A Population Based Analysis of Children With Pneumonia Among Intensive Care Units in Taiwan
A Population Based Analysis of Children With Pneumonia Among Intensive Care Units in Taiwan
A Population Based Analysis of Children With Pneumonia Among Intensive Care Units in Taiwan
ScienceDirect
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
a
Division of Infectious Diseases, Department of Pediatrics, Taipei Veterans General Hospital and
National Yang-Ming University, Taipei, Taiwan
b
Division of General Pediatrics, Department of Pediatrics, Taipei Veterans General Hospital and
National Yang-Ming University, Taipei, Taiwan
c
Institute of Emergency and Critical Care Medicine, School of Medicine, National Yang-Ming University,
Taipei, Taiwan
Received 30 April 2013; received in revised form 27 June 2013; accepted 19 July 2013
Available online 21 September 2013
KEYWORDS Background: Pneumonia is a major diagnosis in children that requires intensive care and is a
Children; major cause of mortality in critically ill children. A survey on current epidemiology and case
Intensive care unit; fatalityeassociated conditions is crucial for the care of critically ill children with pneumonia
National Health in an intensive care unit (ICU).
Insurance Research Methods: The sex, age, seasonality of admission, area of distribution, and case fatality rate of
Database; children younger than 18 years who had pneumonia and were admitted to an ICU during the
Pneumonia period 2006e2010 were obtained from the National Health Insurance Research Database
(NHIRD) of Taiwan. The enrolled children were grouped by age (0e2 years, 3e5 years, 6e11
years, and 12e17 years). The need for invasive procedures such as endotracheal tube (ET)
insertion, mechanical ventilation (MV), tracheostomy, central venous catheter (CVC) insertion,
chest tube insertion/drainage, chest surgery, and extracorporeal membranous oxygenation
(ECMO) were analyzed to clarify their association with case fatality in critically ill children with
pneumonia.
Results: Of the 12,577 children enrolled, 7131 (56.7%) were boys and 5446 (43.3%) were girls.
The younger age groups had more cases of pneumonia, but less often required invasive proce-
dures. Children 0e2 years old (n Z 6083) accounted for approximately one-half (48.4%) of all
* Corresponding authors. Department of Pediatrics, Taipei Veterans General Hospital, 201, Section 2, Shih-Pai Road, Taipei 112, Taiwan.
E-mail addresses: [email protected] (M.-J. Jeng), [email protected] (K.-G. Wu).
1684-1182/$36 Copyright ª 2013, Taiwan Society of Microbiology. Published by Elsevier Taiwan LLC. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jmii.2013.07.007
154 C.-L. Hsu et al.
enrolled children. This group had the lowest case fatality rate (3.1%; 187/6083 children) and
lowest need for invasive procedures (31.1%; 1892/6083 children), whereas children in the 12
e17 year-old group had the highest case fatality rate (9.9%; 140/1417 children) and the highest
need for invasive procedures (59.8%; 847/1417 children) (p < 0.001). The percentage of pneu-
monia cases was highest in the spring (30.1%) and lowest in the summer (21.7%). The invasive
procedures associated with case fatality were ET/MV (OR, 14.31; p < 0.001), CVC insertion
(OR, 7.46; p < 0.001), ECMO intervention (OR, 4.59; p < 0.001), and chest tube insertion/
drainage (OR, 1.87; p < 0.001).
Conclusion: The number of cases of pneumonia that required ICU admission was greater among
younger children than among older children. Factors associated with the higher case fatality
rate included older age at presentation, the need for invasive procedures (e.g., ET/MV, CVC
insertion, chest tube insertion/drainage, and ECMO), underlying comorbidities and complica-
tions.
Copyright ª 2013, Taiwan Society of Microbiology. Published by Elsevier Taiwan LLC. All rights
reserved.
Table 1 Demographic characteristics, percentage of patients undergoing invasive procedures, and the case fatality rate
among critically ill children with pneumonia who were admitted to an ICU in Taiwan (in 2006e2010)
Variable No. of patients Invasive procedures, p (c2 test) Case fatality p (c2 test)
Total 12,577 (100) 4702 (37.4) 522 (4.2)
Sex
Male 7131 (56.7) 2639 (37.0) 0.324 308 (4.3) 0.299
Female 5446 (43.3) 2063 (37.9) 214 (3.9)
Age (y)
0e2 6083 (48.4) 1892 (31.1) <0.001* 187 (3.1) <0.001*
3e5 2906 (23.1) 1047 (36.0) 66 (2.3)
6e11 2171 (17.3) 916 (42.2) 129 (5.9)
12e17 1417 (11.3) 847 (59.8) 140 (9.9)
Area of Taiwan
North 4589 (36.5) 2185 (47.6) <0.001* 218 (4.8) 0.082
Middle 3548 (28.2) 1088 (30.7) 138 (3.9)
South 4128 (32.8) 1302 (31.5) 155 (3.8)
East 312 (2.5) 127 (40.7) 11 (3.5)
Season
Spring 3786 (30.1) 1301 (34.4) <0.001* 136 (3.6) 0.231
Summer 2725 (21.7) 1043 (38.3) 121 (4.4)
Autumn 2924 (23.2) 1155 (39.5) 129 (4.4)
Winter 3142 (25.0) 1203 (38.3) 136 (4.3)
Data are presented as n (%).
* Indicates a statistical significance (p < 0.05).
ICU Z intensive care unit.
However, the percentage of invasive procedures and the The use of invasive procedures in critically ill children
case fatality rate in each age group were higher among the with pneumonia in an ICU is much higher in younger chil-
older age groups. The need for invasive procedures was dren than in older children. This is consistent with the total
furthermore associated with a higher ratio of case fatality case numbers of each age group (Table 1). Of the enrolled
in critically ill children. patients, 37.4% (4702/12,577 children) of the patients
The present study focuses on critically ill children who required one or more invasive procedures during their ICU
were diagnosed with pneumonia and admitted to an ICU stay. Furthermore, 2939 children (62.5% of all enrolled
during the period 2006e2010. This is the first report to use children) who were aged 0e5 years required invasive pro-
the nationwide population-based NHI database to investi- cedures. This was much higher than the total number of
gate critically ill pediatric patients admitted to an ICU for pneumonia cases among children aged 6e17 years old (1763
pneumonia. The present study reveals that the incidence of patients; 37.5% of all enrolled cases). However, the ratio of
pneumonia in ICU-admitted children is higher in boys than children requiring invasive procedures and the case fatality
in girls and is higher in younger children (especially children rate were higher in the 6e17 year-old children than in the
who are 0e2 years old) than in older children (Fig. 1). These 0e5 year-old children. These results are compatible with
findings are consistent with a previous report by Lin et al17 previous investigations11,17,21 and imply that, even though
that was performed in a single center in the middle part of fewer older critically ill children are admitted to an ICU for
Taiwan and covered the period of 2002e2005, and reports pneumonia, their disease severity may be worse in com-
by Wu et al,11,12 who used the NHI database that covered parison to the disease severity in younger children.
the period of 1997e2004. However, these three studies The critical pneumonia-related case fatality rate is
investigated all hospitalized children and did not focus on highest in the children aged 12e17 years. In a report of
critically ill patients. A European study examining the Wu et al11 on children hospitalized with pneumonia in the
period of 1981e1982 also reported that the incidence of period of 1997e2004, the population-based mortality
pneumonia was significantly higher in children younger than rate was much higher in children younger than 5 years
5 years.18 Thus, young children are the most vulnerable than in older children. The biphasic pneumonia-related
population for pneumonia. This remains true for critically case fatality rate was also markedly high in children
ill children who are admitted to an ICU. aged 12e17 years.11 Therefore, the high pneumonia-
The most common causes of pneumoniadother than related case fatality rate in 12e17 year-old children
virusesdin children younger than 5 years is bacterial was consistent prior to and after 2005. Clinicians should
pneumonia.1,2,4,6 Streptococcus pneumoniae, Haemophilus pay more attention to older children who are admitted to
influenzae, Streptococcus pyogenes, and Staphylococcus an ICU for pneumonia, especially children with critically
aureus are the primary causes of pneumonia.1,4 In older ill presentations.
children and adolescents, Mycoplasma pneumoniae is the It is generally believed that younger children are more
most frequent cause.5,19,20 likely to get sick and are more vulnerable to more severe
Analysis of children with pneumonia in ICU 157
Table 3 The top 10 associated diagnoses and odds ratios for case fatality among children with pneumonia who were admitted
to an ICU in Taiwan (2006e2010)
Diagnosis ICD-9-CM code Total cases (n) Case fatality (n) OR 95% CI p
Respiratory failure 518.8x 2296 304 7.04 5.87e8.46 <0.001
Cerebral palsy 343.x 2075 91 2.37 1.86e3.01 <0.001
Epilepsy 345.xx 1756 74 1.49 1.16e1.93 0.002
Septicemia 038.xx 1348 248 7.07 5.88e8.50 <0.001
Asthma 493.xx 1107 11 0.17 0.09e0.31 <0.001
Convulsions 780.3x 830 38 0.88 0.63e1.24 0.478
Pleural effusion 511.x 812 32 0.67 0.47e0.97 0.033
Congenital heart disease 745.xx 756 43 1.46 1.05e2.02 0.023
Volume depletion 276.5x 745 10 0.23 0.12e0.42 <0.001
Gastrointestinal hemorrhage 578.9 607 61 2.96 2.23e3.95 <0.001
CI Z confidence interval; ICD-9-CM Z International Classification of Diseases, 9th Revision, Clinical Modification; ICU Z intensive care
unit; OR Z odds ratio.
Analysis of children with pneumonia in ICU 159