Learning Metaphors: by James Lawley and Penny Tompkins
Learning Metaphors: by James Lawley and Penny Tompkins
Learning Metaphors: by James Lawley and Penny Tompkins
by James Lawley and Penny Tompkins In addition there is a fourth property, and it is the one
which most impacts the way students learn. Because
Learning is a highly complex process about which we metaphors describe one experience in terms of another,
know very little. But one thing we know for sure is that they specify and constrain our ways of thinking about
people learn in different ways. How can we have a sense the original experience. This influences the meaning and
of the way our students learn -- just by listening to what importance we attach to the original experience, the way
they say? A very practical approach is to take note of the it fits with other experiences, and the actions we take as
metaphors in their language. a result.
In the innovative and mind-expanding book Metaphors There is a very simple way to discover your student's
We Live By, linguist George Lakoff and philosopher metaphors for learning -- just ask them:
Mark Johnson say:
And when you're learning, that's learning like what?
The essence of metaphor is understanding and
experiencing one kind of thing in terms of another. [Note Whatever answer they give can be further developed by
1] asking:
We like this definition for a number of reasons. First, it And is there anything else about that 'X'?
recognises that metaphor is about capturing the essential And what kind of 'X' is that 'X'?
nature of an experience. For instance, when a student of
ours described his situation as "It's like I'm banging my [Where X' is the metaphorical or symbolic part of the
head against a brick wall." the sense of the repetitive, answer to the original question.]
painful and self-defeating nature of his experience was
instantly apparent. Second, the definition acknowledges These 'Clean' Language questions are taken from a
that metaphor is an active process which is at the very method of exploring a person's metaphors devised by
heart of understanding ourselves, others and the world David Grove, and are fully explained in our
about us. Third, metaphor need not be limited to verbal book Metaphors in Mind: Transformation through
expressions. For us, a metaphor can Symbolic Modelling. [Note 4]
include any expression or thing that is symbolic for a
person, be that nonverbal behaviour, self-produced art,
In the 1980s, psychotherapist David Grove realised that
an item in the environment, or an imaginative
many of his clients naturally described their symptoms
representation. In other words, whatever a person says,
and outcomes in metaphor. He discovered that when he
sees, hears, feels or does, as well as what they imagine,
enquired about these metaphors using the
can be used to produce, comprehend and reason through
client's exact words, their perception of their problems
metaphor.
began to change. This led him to create Clean Language,
a method of asking simple questions of clients'
Metaphor is not an occasional foray into the world of metaphors which neither contaminate nor distort them.
figurative language, but the fundamental basis for
everyday cognition. Lakoff and Johnson state:
Metaphors for Learning
In all aspects of life, ... we define our reality in terms of
Using the above clean questions, we elicited a metaphor
metaphors and then proceed to act on the basis of the
for learning from ten adult students:
metaphors. We draw inferences, set goals, make
commitments, and execute plans, all on the basis of how
we in part structure our experience, consciously and 1. Planting flowers -- A seed is planted in my mind
unconsciously, by means of metaphor. [Note 2] which I nurture with water and sun in the faith that it
will sprout and grow.
Andrew Ortony has identified three characteristics of
metaphors that account for their utility: vividness, 2. Playing cards -- I divide things into four categories
compactness and expressibility. [Note 3] In short, and look for patterns across the suits until the logic and
meaning emerges and I know which card to play.
3. Savings account -- I invest the time to accumulate d. It's got me beat.
data and information until there is enough interest that I e. Just when I think I understand, it all gets shuffled
can roll it over into the next idea. around.
f. I can't make anything out of this.
4. Switching on a light bulb -- It's not until the light g. It makes me want to weep.
switches on that I have an insight or an 'ah ha'. h. I'm clueless.
i. I'm wandering around in the dark.
5. Eating -- You need to take in the basic meat and j. We can't learn in these conditions.
potatoes before you get to the mouth-watering dessert.
It's easy to find the correspondence, isn't it? [Note 6] Why?
6. Being a detective -- It's all about uncovering the facts, For two reasons: first, we generally use common and
looking for clues and asking the right questions until the well understood experiences as the metaphorical basis
whole mystery makes sense. for complex and abstract information; and second, there
is a consistency and logic to the metaphors each of us
7. Peeling an onion -- I peel off a layer which reveals uses.
the next layer to be peeled off. Each time something teIls
me I'm get closer to the core of the matter. You can see that if you want to teach in a way that
corresponds to the metaphors of a group of students, you
8. A quest -- I'm searching for that illusive something will need a highly flexible approach.
and every step I take brings me closer to what I need to
know, but I never get there ... it's a continuous journey. Using Multiple Metaphors
9. Sculpting -- You start with the raw material and shape One way to appeal to a wide range of learning styles is
it into a form that's pleasing to the eye. to make sure that you use a variety of metaphors. These
should have as diverse a structure as possible. For
10. Wrestling -- I struggle with the ideas until they're instance, in addition to saying to the class "Can you
pinned down and I've captured them. figure this out?" and leaving it at that, you might also
offer a few other metaphorical alternatives, such as:
These metaphors reveal the diversity of student's
symbolic representations for how they learn. They also Who can solve this?
suggest some interesting contrasts. For example the See what you make of this.
'savings account' student steadily accumulates What conclusions do you draw?
knowledge, whereas no learning will appear to be Who feels they can work this out?
happening for the 'light bulb' student until the light is Tell me when you get somewhere.
switched on. The 'playing cards' student presumably What can you construct out of this?
wants all the cards dealt so they can start looking for Take your time and see what emerges.
patterns, but giving the 'detective' student all the relevant Tell me when you've come up with an answer.
information in advance will probably take the fun out of Play around with the ideas and see where you get to.
their investigation. The student on a 'quest' needs to Chew over the information until you've digested the
discover new things at each step of their journey, while ideas .
the 'planting flowers' student will want to stay with and Spend some time considering this and it will all become
continually tend the seed of an idea. clear.
You'll need to dig below the surface to get the nub of the
Although we obtained the metaphors for learning issue.
through asking Clean Language questions, students are
speaking in metaphor all the time. Research shows that In conclusion...
everyday conversation makes use of at least four
metaphors per minute. [Note 5] Below are examples of Metaphors embody and define the intangible and
metaphorical expressions which are 'hidden' or abstract, but this process inevitably constrains
'embedded' in language. Can you match the above ten perceptions and actions to those which make sense
students to the following problems with learning? within the logic of the metaphor. Metaphors are
therefore both descriptive and prescriptive. As students
a. I've lost my way. become aware of their own metaphors for learning they
b. I can't digest all this information. can recognise how these limit or liberate them. In this
c. There's not enough in the bank. way they can learn from their own learning process!
It also pays to know your own preferred metaphors
because they have such an influence on the way you It is important to understand how a metaphor works and know when
teach. Once you are familiar with your preferences you
you have heard one. They are meant to create a vivid picture, or be a
can begin to stretch yourself by employing new
metaphors. For some students your new metaphors will profound saying. The stronger the metaphor is, the better your intent
say the same thing in a different way -- but other
students will need to engage in a different class of will be received. Using metaphors to explain something to a child
mindbody processing. In addition to teaching the subject
matter you will be training your students to process helps them by giving them a more visual picture.
information via a variety of metaphors. The result will
be an enhanced ability to think more creatively. Simple Metaphor Examples For Kids
What is a Metaphor?
Here is a list of simple metaphor examples you can use to help teach
A metaphor is a comparison between two things that share a 1. Max is a pig when he eats.
2. You are my sunshine.
common characteristic. One thing is equal to another because it has 3. It’s raining cats and dogs.
4. Even a child could carry my dog around for
this characteristic. For example, “You are my sunshine,” just like the hours. He is a feather.
5. He is the Tiger Woods of his golf team.
sun brings warmth and happiness to someone’s day; you do the 6. Mary’s hair was a fierce lion’s main; always
sticking out in wild directions.
same, by bringing happiness to someone’s day. You are sunshine 7. He tried to help but his legs were rubber.
8. Her eyes were fireflies.
because you share the characteristic of making someone happy. A 9. I was lost in a sea of nameless faces.
10. My teacher is a dragon.
metaphor is a stronger image than a simile; and makes the reader 11. Their home was a prison.
12. Life is a rollercoaster.
feel or see something to help them understand it. It states that 13. America is a melting pot.
14. His eyes were ice.
something is equal to something else; it is not just a comparison 15. The world is a stage.
16. Life is a fashion show.
between two things. 17. My kid’s room is a disaster.
18. The alligator’s teeth are white daggers.
The Purpose of Metaphors 19. Time is money.
20. The wheels of justice turn slowly.
21. She cut him down with her words.
Metaphors should create an impact on the reader. They are used to
22. The teacher planted the seed of wisdom.
23. The clouds sailed across the sky.
inspire and help people understand the importance of something. For 24. Laughter is the music of the soul.
25. He is a chicken.
example, “Max is a pig when he eats,” gives the reader a strong visual 26. The peaceful lake was a mirror.
27. Your brain is a computer.
of how messy Max is when he eats. This is very important not only in 28. He is a night owl.
29. The car was a furnace in the son.
a story or poem, but in everyday conversation. If someone says that 30. A blanket of snow covered the ground.
31. The park was a lake after the rain.
his stomach is a black hole you know it is important to have plenty of 32. The lawn is a green carpet.
33. The kids were monkeys on the jungle gym.
food at your event. If he had just said that his stomach is big or can 34. The stars are sparkling diamonds.
35. My brother is a couch potato.
hold a lot you wouldn’t think you needed as much food. If his 36. The clouds are balls of cotton.
37. His stomach is a black hole.
stomach truly were a black hole you would need a never ending 38. His heart is a rock.
39. She is fishing for more.
supply of food. 40. He was feeling blue.
41. She is on a rollercoaster of emotions.
42. He has a broken heart.
43. She has a bubbly personality.
British school story (which includes elements
44. She is a shining star.
45. The interstate was a parking lot at rush hour. of mystery, thriller, adventure, horror and romance), it
46. Books are the keys to your imagination. has many cultural meanings and references.
47. The ballerina was a swan, gliding across the
stage. [5]
According to Rowling, the main theme is death.
48. Her angry words were bullets to him. [6]
There are also many other themes in the series,
49. The thunder was a lion.
50. The road was a ribbon stretching across the such as prejudice, corruption, and madness.[7]
desert.
The series was originally printed in English by two
Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious- wonderful major publishers, Bloomsbury in the United Kingdom
andScholastic Press in the United States. The seven
or fantastic
books were adapted into an eight-part film
series by Warner Bros. Pictures, which is the
second highest-grossing film series of all time as of
Harry Potter is a series of seven fantasy August 2015. The series also originated much tie-
novels written by British author J. K. Rowling. The in merchandise, making the Harry Potter brand worth
series chronicles the life of a young wizard, Harry in excess of $15 billion.[8]
Potter, and his friends Hermione Granger and Ron
Because of the success of the books and films, Harry
Weasley, all of whom are students atHogwarts School
Potter-themed areas, known as The Wizarding World
of Witchcraft and Wizardry. The main story
of Harry Potter, have been created at
arc concerns Harry's struggle against the Dark
several Universal Parks & Resorts theme parks
wizardLord Voldemort, who aims to become immortal,
around the world. The franchise continues to expand,
overthrow the Ministry of Magic, subjugate non-magic
with numerous supplemental books to accompany the
people and destroy anyone who stands in his way.
films and the original novels, a studio tour in London
Since the release of the first novel, Harry Potter and that opened in 2012, a traveling exhibition that
the Philosopher's Stone, on 30 June 1997, the books premiered in Chicago in 2009, a digital platform
have gained immense popularity, critical acclaim and entitled Pottermore, on which J.K. Rowling updates
commercial success worldwide. They attracted a wide the series with new information and insight, a sequel
adult audience, and have remained one of the in the form of a stage play, and a trilogy of spin-off
preeminent cornerstones of young adult literature. films premiering in 2016, amongst many other
[2]
The series has also had some share of criticism, developments.
including concern about the increasingly dark tone as
the series progressed, as well as the often gruesome Plot[edit]
and graphic violence depicted in the series. As of July Further information: Harry Potter universe
2013, the books have sold more than 450 million
The novels revolve around Harry Potter, an orphan
copies worldwide, making the series the best-selling
who discovers at the age of 11 that he is a wizard,
book series in history, and have been translated into
though he lives within the ordinary world of non-
73 languages.[3][4] The last four books consecutively set
magical people known as Muggles.[9] The wizarding
records as the fastest-selling books in history, with the
world has hidden itself from the Muggle world,
final instalment selling roughly 11 million copies in the
presumably to avoid persecution of witches and
United States within the first 24 hours of its release.
wizards, which had occurred to a great extent several
A series of many genres, centuries before. His magical ability is inborn, and
including fantasy, drama, coming of age and the children with such abilties are invited to attend an
exclusive magic school that teaches the necessary When the first novel of the series, Harry Potter and
skills to succeed in the wizarding world. Harry
[10]
the Philosopher's Stone (published in some countries
becomes a student at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft as Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone) opens, it is
and Wizardry, and it is here where most of the events apparent that some significant event has taken place
in the series take place. As Harry develops through in the wizarding world – an event so very remarkable,
his adolescence, he learns to overcome the problems even the Muggles (non-magical people) notice signs
that face him: magical, social and emotional, including of it. The full background to this event and Harry
ordinary teenage challenges such as friendships, Potter's past is revealed gradually through the series.
infatuation, romantic relationships, schoolwork and After the introductory chapter, the book leaps forward
exams, anxiety, depression, stress, and the greater to a time shortly before Harry Potter's eleventh
test of preparing himself for the confrontation in the birthday, and it is at this point that his magical
real world that lies ahead, in wizarding Britain's background begins to be revealed.
increasingly-violent second wizarding war.[11]
Harry's first contact with the wizarding world is
Each book chronicles one year in Harry's life with [12]
through a half-giant, Rubeus Hagrid, keeper of
the main narrative being set in the years 1991–98. grounds and keys at Hogwarts. Hagrid reveals some
[13]
The books also contain many flashbacks, which are of Harry's history.[15] Harry learns that, as a baby, he
frequently experienced by Harry viewing the witnessed his parents' murder by the power-obsessed
memories of other characters in a device called Dark wizard Lord Voldemort, who subsequently
a Pensieve. attempted to kill him as well.[15] For reasons not
immediately revealed, the spell with which Voldemort
The environment Rowling created is intimately
tried to kill Harry rebounded. Harry survived with only
connected to reality. The British magical community of
a lightning-shaped scar on his forehead as a
the Harry Potter books is inspired by 1990's British
memento of the attack, and Voldemort disappeared
culture, European folklore, classical mythology
afterwards. As its inadvertent saviour from
and alchemy, incorporating objects and wildlife such
Voldemort's reign of terror, Harry has become a living
as magic wands, magic plants, potions, and spells,
legend in the wizarding world. However, at the orders
flying broomsticks,centaurs and other magical
of the venerable and well-known wizard Albus
creatures, the deathly hallows, and the Philosopher's
Dumbledore, the orphaned Harry had been placed in
Stone, beside others invented by Rowling. While
the home of his unpleasant Muggle relatives, the
the fantasy land of Narnia is analternative
Dursleys, who kept him safe, but treated him poorly,
universe and the Lord of the Rings' Middle-earth a
having him live in a cupboard and do many more
mythic past, the wizarding world of Harry Potter exists
chores than their son Dudley, whom they spoiled.
in parallel within the real world and contains magical
Petunia Dursley was jealous of her sister's magical
versions of the ordinary elements of everyday life,
abilities as a child, and therefore hated wizards, so
with the books being mostly set in Scotland
the Dursleys hid Harry's true heritage from him,
(Hogwarts), the West Country, Devon, London and
saying his parents died in a car crash in hopes that he
Surrey in south-east England.[14] The world only
would grow up "normal".[15]
accessible to wizards and magical beings comprises
a fragmented collection of overlooked hidden streets, With Hagrid's help, Harry prepares for and undertakes
ancient pubs, lonely country manors and secluded his first year of study at Hogwarts. As Harry begins to
castles invisible to the Muggle population. [10]
explore the magical world, the reader is introduced to
(Expelliarmus) killing Voldemort. Also, as most overhauled and most of the features were removed.
viewers saw coming, Harry Potter marries and has The site has been redesigned and it mainly focuses
children with Ginny Weasley and Hermione Granger on the informations already available, rather than
6. Rhythm Race
This is a race between 2 students. The
teacher claps out a rhythm using some
common patterns, such as ti-ti, ti-ti, ti-ti, ta.
Students run to the board and then write the
rhythm clapped by the teacher. The first
student to write the correct pattern is the