2QQEvidence

Syllabus SY 2020-2021
Atty. Melissa Romana P. Suarez

Rule 130
Object as Evidence
Section Case Title GR Date
Torralba v. People 153699 Aug 22, 2005
Valeroso v. People 164815 Feb 22, 2008
Carino v. People 178757 Mar 13, 2009
People v. Umanito 172607 Apr 16, 2009
People v. Guiara 186497 Sept 17, 2009
Sec. 1
Cacao v. People 180870 Jan 22, 2010
People v. Kamad 174198 Jan 19, 2010

People v. Olarte 233209 Mar 11, 2019

Documentary Evidence
Section Case Title GR Date
PLDT v. Tiamson 164684-85 Nov 11, 2005
Erasusta v. CA 149231 July 17, 2006
Career v. Godinez 206826 Oct 2, 2017
People v. Mateo 210612 Oct 9, 2017
Sec. 2

Original Document Rule

Section Case Title GR Date
Sec. 3, 4
Consolidated v. Del Monte Motor 143338 Jul 29, 2005
People v. Cayabyab 167147 Aug 3, 2005
People v. Dimaano 168168 Sep 14, 2005
Arceo v. People 14264 July 17, 2006
Citibank v. Sabeniano 156132 Oct 12, 2006
Llemos v. Lemos 150162 Jan 26, 2007
Atlas v. CIR 141104 Jun 8, 2007
Alfaro v. CA 162864 Mar 28, 2007
Chua-Gaw v. Chua 160855 Apr 16, 2008
EDSA Shangri-la v. BF Corporation 145842 Jun 27, 2008
Abadiano v. Martir 156310 July 31, 2008
Manila Mining v. Tan 171702 Feb 12, 2009
People v. Padilla 167955 Sept 30, 2009
Remiendo v. Padilla 184874 Oct 9, 2009
 BPI v. SMP 175466 Dec 23, 2009
Silk Air v. CIR 184398 Feb 25, 2010
Nissan v. United Philippine Scout 179470 Apr 20, 2010
Marquez v. Espejo 168387 Aug 25, 2010
Country Bankers v. Laguna 165487 July 13, 2011
RP v. Imee Marcos-Manotoc 171701 Feb 8, 2012
Bangis v. Heirs of Adolfo 190875 Jun 13, 2012
People v. Lupac 182230 Sep 19, 2012
Heirs of Prodon v. Heirs of Alvarez 170604 Sep 2, 2013
Skunac Corporation v. Sylianteng 205879 Apr 23, 2014
Bognot v. RRI Lending 180144 Sep 24, 2014
Republic v. Gimenez 174673 Jan 11, 2016
People v. Abella 195666 Jan 20, 2016
Gumabon v. PNB 202514 Jul 25, 2016
Capital v. Traveler 200065 Sep 24, 2014
Sps. Tapayan v. Martinez 207786 Jan 30, 2017
Goopio v. Atty. Maglalang AC 10555 Jul 31, 2018
Villas v. Sharp 221548 Oct 3, 2018
Young Builders v. Benson 198998 Jun 19, 2019
Montevilla v. Vallena 234419 Dec 5, 2019

When Original Document is Not Available

Section Case Title GR Date
Estrada v. Desierto 146710 Apr 3, 2001
Sec. 5 Citibank v. Teodoro 150905 Sep 23, 2003
Lee v. People 159288 Oct 19. 2004
Republic v. Masongsong 162846 Sep 22, 2005
Pacasum v. People 180314 Apr 16, 2009
Baguio Trinity v. Heirs of Ramos 188381 Dec 14, 2011
BPI v. Mendoza 198799 Mar 20, 2017
Robinol v. Bassig AC 11836 Nov 21, 2017
Cardenas v. Christian 222614 Mar 20, 2019

When Original is a Public Record

Section Case Title GR Date
Republic v. El Gobierno 142284 June 8, 2005
Sec. 8

Evidence of Written Agreements

Sec. 10 Allied Banking v. Cheng Yong 151040 Oct 6, 2005
Sps. Amoncio v. Benedicto 171707 Jul 28, 2008
Raymundo v. Lunaria 171036 Oct 17, 2008
Estate of Llenado v. Llenado 145736 Mar 4, 2009
Lyn Maagad v. Juanito Maagad 171762 Jun 5, 2009
Norton v. All Asia Bank 162523 Nov 25, 2009
Leighton Contractors v. CNP 160972 Mar 9, 2010
Marquez v. Espejo 168387 Aug 5, 2010
 Financial Building v. Rudlin 164186 Oct 4, 2010
Leoveras v. Valdez 169985 Jun 15, 2011
Ureta v. Ureta 165748 Sep 14, 2011
Paras v. Kimwa 171601 Apr 8, 2013
Mancol, Jr. v. DBP 204289 Nov 22, 2017
Shemberg v. Citibank 216029 Sep 4, 2019

Interpretation According to Circumstance

Sec. Marquez v. Espejo 168387 Aug 5, 2010
14

Disqualification by Reason of Incapacity of Immaturity [deleted]

Marcos v. Heirs of Navarro, Jr. 198240 July 23, 2013
Sec.
People v. Esugon 195244 June 22, 2015
21

Disqualification Confined to Personal Knowledge / Independent Relevant Statement

Republic v. Hanover Worldwide 172102 July 2, 2010
Viloria v. Continental Airways 188288 Jan 16, 2012
Dantis v. Maghinang 191696 Apr 10, 2013
Lea Mer v. Malayan Insurance 161745 Sept 30, 2005
Sec. People v. Gumimba 174056 Feb 27, 2007
22 People v. Malibiran 178301 Apr 24, 2009
Bedol v. COMELEC 179830 Dec 3, 2009
People v. Figueroa 186141 Apr 11, 2012
Espineli v. People 179535 June 9, 2014

Marital Disqualification Rule

Sec. Alvarez v. Ramirez 143439 Oct 14, 2005
23

Privileged Communication
Eagleridge v. Cameron 204700 Nov 24, 2014
Sec. 24

Testimonial Privilege
In Re: Emma Lee v. CA 177861 Jul 13, 2010
Sec. 25
Admission of a Party/Against Interest
Lazaro v. Agustin 152364 Apr 15, 2010
BBB v. AAA 193225 Feb 09, 2015
Sec. Kwong v. Diamond 211353 Jun 10, 2019
27

Offer of Compromise
Tan v. Rodil Enterprises 168071 Dec 18, 2006
People v. Galvez 157221 Mar 30, 2007
People v. de la Cruz 177572 Feb 26, 2008
People v. Españ ol 175603 Feb 13, 2009
Sec. 28
Pentagon v. CA 174141 June 26, 2009
San Miguel Corporation v. Kalalo 185522 June 13, 2012
Goopio v. Atty. Maglalang AC 10555 Jul 31, 2018

Admission by Third Party / Res Inter Alios Acta

Republic v. Kenrick Development 149576 Aug 8, 2006
Cambe v. Ombudsman 212014-15 Dec 06, 2016
Sec. 29 Duque v. Ombudsman 224648 Aug 28, 2019

Admission by Conspirator
Preagido v. Sandiganbayan 52341-46 Nov 25, 2005
Tamargo v. Awingan 177727 Jan 19, 2010
Sec. People v. Bokingo 187536 Aug 10, 2011
31

Admission by Silence
Office v. Cunting AM P-04-1917 Dec 10, 2007
Bughaw, Jr. v. Treasure Island 173151 Mar 28, 2008
People v. Españ ol 175603 Feb 13, 2009
Sec.
Philippines First v. Wallem 165647 Mar 26, 2009
33
Villanueva v. Balaguer 180197 June 23, 2009

Confession
Yapyuco v. People 120744-46 June 25, 2012
Sec. 34
Hearsay
Patula v. People 164457 Apr 11, 2012
Arreza v. Toyo 213198 Jul 1, 2019
Sec. People v. Sultan 225210 Aug 7, 2019
37 People v. Sarabia 243190 Aug 28, 2019

Dying Declaration
Marturillas v. People 163217 Apr 18, 2006
People v. Cerilla 177147 Nov 28, 2007
People v. Tabarnero 168169 Feb 24, 2010
People v. Salcedo 178272 Mar 14, 2011
People v. Salafranca 173476 Feb 22, 2012
Belbis v. People 181052 Nov 14, 2012
People v. Gatarin 198022 Apr 7, 2014
Sec.
People v. Umapas 215742 Mar 22, 2017
38
People v. Macaraig 219848 Jun 7, 2017
People v. Santillan 227878 Aug 09, 2017

Declaration Against Interest

Parel v. Prudencio 146556 Apr 19, 2006
Heirs of Ulep v. Ducat 159284 Jan 27, 2009
Cavile v. Litania-Hong 179540 Mar 13, 2009
Sec. 40

Declaration About Pedigree

Nepomuceno v. Lopez 181258 Mar 18, 2010
Gotardo v. Buling 165166 Aug 15, 2012
Sec. 41

Part of Res Gestae

Sec. 44 Capila v. People 146161 Jul 17, 2006
People v. Cudal 167502 Oct 31, 2006
Talidano v. Falcon Maritime 172031 Jul 14, 2008
Golden Delta v. Pre-Stress International 176768 Jan 12, 2009
Flores v. People 181625 Oct 2, 2009
 People v. Salafranca 173476 Feb 22, 2012
People v. Lupac 182230 Sep 19, 2012
People v. Gatarin 198022 Apr 7, 2014
People v. Estibal 208749 Nov 26, 2014
People v. Calinawan 226145 Feb 13, 2017

Records of Regularly Conducted Business Activity

Security Bank v. Gan 150464 Jun 27, 2006
Aznar v. Citibank, N.A. 164273 Mar 28, 2007
Jose v. Michaelmar 169606 Nov 27, 2009
Sec. 45
Dela Cruz v. Planters Products 158649 Feb 18, 2013

Entries in Official Records

Barcelon v. CIR 157064 Aug 7, 2006
Fullero v. People 170583 Sep 12, 2007
Valeroso v. People 164815 Feb 22, 2008
People v. Quebral 185379 Nov 27, 2009
Alvarez v. v. PICOP 162243 Dec 3, 2009
Sec. 46
Malayan v. Alberto 194320 Feb 1, 2012
Sabili v. COMELEC 193261 Apr 24, 2012
DST Motors v. People’s General Insurance 198627 Jan 13, 2016

Learned Treatises

Arreza v. Toyo 213198 Jul 1, 2019

Sec. 48

Testimony in Former Proceedings

Samalio v. CA 140079 Mar 31, 2005
Manliclic v. Calaunan 150157 Jan 25, 2007
RP v. SB 152375 Dec 16, 2011
Sec.
49
Opinion of Expert Witness
China Banking v. CA 155299 Jul 24, 2007
Padilla-Rumbaua v. Rumbaua 166738 Aug 14, 2009
Tamani v. Salvador 171497 Apr 04, 2011
Dela Llana v. Biong 182356 Dec 4, 2013
Sec. Casumpang v. Cortejo 171127 Mar 11, 2015
52 Tortona v. Gregorio 202612 Jan 17, 2018
Eliscupidez v. Eliscupidez 226907 Jul 22, 2019

Character Evidence
CSC v. Belagan 132164 Oct 19, 2004

Sec. 54