Critique Paper Rubric
Critique Paper Rubric
Critique Paper Rubric
Name: _________________________________________
weight
Criteria Exemplary (10 Effective (8 Minimal (6 Unsatisfactory (4 Obtained
points) points) points) points) Score
In depth and well- Content is Content is Content is not
organized content adequately minimally organized
Clearly states the organized and organized No main
main impression and comprehensive Vaguely states impression is
properly supports it with Clearly states the the main given, and details
Content of
50% observation main impression impression are very scarce
Review
Excellent review although it lacks and many Poor review
some important important
details in the body details are not
Adequate review present
Basic review
Ideas are presented Ideas are Ideas are Ideas are vague
logically presented presented Doesn’t have
Claims are balanced; unreasonably illogically claims
pointed weaknesses and Claims are not Claims are Random, no
recognizes strong points balanced; pointed based on mere evidence of
Order of paragraph weaknesses based opinion paragraph
contributes to an on insensible Ineffective or structure. Illogical
effective argument, reason. inconsistent organization of
Coherence 30% reinforces content, Order follows paragraph ideas
unified and coherent, position, shows order, not
paper flows smoothly clear plan, but not fully
perfected developed