Kachru's Model Reflection

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 2

Name: Herford Rei B.

Guibangguibang February 22, 2020


MAELS REFLECTION PAPER

Topic: Kachru’s Three Circles Model of World Englishes

Based on my reading, Kachru’s model in World Englishes was formulated in the early
1980’s which became the pioneering model: concentric circles. These circles represent “the
type of spread, the patterns of acquisition and the functional domains in which English is
used across cultures and languages. The Concentric circles model presents three concepts:
First, the inner circle, where the language functions as an L1 (or the native language),
among speakers are from Great Britain, the USA; secondly, the outer circle, where the
language was forced upon the subjugated people by Britain, among speakers are from India
and Nigeria; third, the expanding circle where English is studied as a foreign language,
among speakers are from China and Brazil which is being critically explained that speakers
in the three circles perform in English in different ways according to the contexts in which
English is employed.

The inner circle or the so-called native speakers refers to the traditional bases of
English, dominated by the mother-tongue varieties, where English acts as a first language.
The varieties of English used here are said to be ‘norm providing’. Norm provider in the
sense that they are the one who were known to have the standard rules that is why they are
presumed to be the provider of the sets.   Meanwhile, the Outer Circle consists of the
earlier phases of the spread of English in non-native settings, where the language has
become part of a country’s chief institutions, and plays an important ‘second language’
role in a multilingual setting. The English used in the outer circle is considered as ‘norm-
developing’. Lastly,  the Expanding Circle refers to the territories where English is learnt
as a foreign language. English is taught as a ‘foreign’ language as the most useful
vehicle of international communication. The English used in the Expanding Circle is
regarded as ‘norm dependent’.

This model creates the classification of speakers as to ENL (English as a native


language, there are native speakers born in a English-speaking country, having then this
language as their mother tongue. The other one, ESL (English as a second language,
these are the non-native speakers who have learnt English almost at the same time as
their mother tongue. Third, EFL, English as a foreign language, these are the non-native
speakers who learnt English in a country where English is not usually spoken.

Braj Kachru’s model brings intertwined effects - ecstasy and agony. English is
everywhere and bestows privileges on those who acquired the language at an early age or
have learned it formally in schools – emphasizing that English brings ecstasy. On the other
hand, notions speaks that there are people who have not given or do not have really
opportunities to learn English – highlighting the agony effect. Moreover, there are speakers
who use English but have deviating features as to what function of English in the inner circle
speakers used, as result, this gives the agony of prejudice and discrimination to the
speakers. Even the point of trying to become a native speaker because as said people who
speak and write it appropriately have varied roles in the large number of communities of
practice.

In the article, it pointed out that, Kachru’s three circles construct or model of English
brings a notion that the world is multilingual: multilingualism is the rule, and monolingualism
is the exception. In lieu, we tend to view native speakers as almost god-like creatures with
reverence since native speakers are the creator or the English, and
Name: Herford Rei B. Guibangguibang February 22, 2020
MAELS REFLECTION PAPER

You might also like