C B T P C B B: Tamford Niversity Anglades H
C B T P C B B: Tamford Niversity Anglades H
C B T P C B B: Tamford Niversity Anglades H
LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL
December, 2012
Assistant Professor, Dept. of Business Administration
Stamford University Bangladesh
Finally I assure you that I have tried my best to make a systematic and informative
summary based on my practical work. If you need further clarification, I am always
ready to answer your questions.
Thanking You
Yours Sincerely
_______________
Department of Business Administration
_______________
Supervisor’s Declaration
STAMFORD UNIVERSITY BANGLADESH
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all I would like to thanks all mighty Allah for giving me the patience
and proper time to complete the Thesis Paper study successfully. It is pleasure
to take this occasion to thank a few people who have, assisted, encouraged,
directed and supported throughout completed to the program.
EXECUTIVE SUMMERY
Capital budgeting is one of the most important areas of financial management. There
are several techniques commonly used to evaluate capital budgeting projects namely
the payback period, accounting rate of return, present value and internal rate of return
and profitability index. Recent studies highlight that financial managers worldwide
favor methods such as the internal rate of return (IRR) or non-discounted payback
period (PP) models over the net present value (NPV), which is the model academics
consider superior. In particular this research focused on small, medium and large
businesses and investigated a number of variables and associations relating to capital
budgeting practices in businesses in the Bank of Bangladesh.
The results revealed that payback period, followed by net present value, appears to be
the most used method across the different sizes and sectors of business. It was also
found that 64% of businesses surveyed used only one technique, while 32% of the
respondents used between two to three different types of techniques to evaluate
capital budgeting decisions. The findings show that the more complicated methods
such as IRR and NPV are most favored by the large businesses as compared to the
small businesses. The majority of the respondents believed that project definition was
the most important stage in the capital budgeting process. Implementation stage
appeared to be the most difficult stage for the manufacturing sector whereas Project
definition, Analysis and selection and Implementation were generally rated as being
the difficult stages by the retail sector. Project definition and Analysis and selection
were found to be the most difficult stages by the service sector. Most businesses used
the cost of bank loan as a basis in capital budgeting and more than two thirds of
respondents used non-quantitative techniques to consider risk when making a decision
on investing in fixed assets.
Table of Content
Headings Page
Chapter-1: Introduction
1.1 Rationale of the study
1.2 Objectives of the report
1.3 Scope of the report
1.4 Methodology
1.5 Limitation of the repot
This is the thesis paper based on the thesis program. The topic covers mainly
the Capital Budgeting Technique of Private Commercial Bank of Bangladesh and
its different types of Technique use by among the fifteen Private Commercial
Bank of Bangladesh. This is divided paper into seven chapters. The first chapter
is comprised by introduction, origin of the report, scope, objectives,
methodology and limitations of the report. The second chapter includes
Overview of Banking System, Bangladesh Scenario, The implications for the banking
system, Mitigating actions, History of Banking Industry in Bangladesh, List of banks
in Bangladesh. The third chapter focuses Article on Capital budgeting technique,
Literature review of article. The fourth chapter mentions overview of the
sampling 15 commercial bank of Bangladesh. The fifth chapter contains
overview of the topics, nature of the investment decision, and importance of the
investment decision. The sixth chapter includes findings and analysis of capital
budgeting technique of the sampling bank. And the final chapter includes
conclusion, recommendation of the report.
1.4: Methodology
Research design
This study aims to “Practice of Capital Budgeting Techniques in Banks of
Bangladesh” To gather the information, we have done the interview and the
questionnaire. The interview is taken from the respected authorities of three banks of
Bangladesh- IFIC Bank Limited, Datch Bangla Bank Limited, and National Bank
Limited. Thorpe and Lowe (1993) argued that questionnaires are a useful tool for
investigating patterns in data and are frequently used with success in management,
marketing and research. As it is a descriptive study on management, the questionnaire
will be better fitted according the stated researchers.
Data collection
For preparation of a comprehensive report on any articles the procurement of data and
the sources of data are very important. Duration preparation of this research paper we
have gone through the different booklets, use different mechanics utilize different
techniques which are offended below shortly. We are taken fifteen commercial bank
as our field to find out the necessary information for this report. But there were a hard
work for us because we could not go every institution to collect the primary data. As
the limitation of the resource we collected our data from two sources .These are-
1. Primary Data.
2. Secondary data.
1.5: Limitation
2. Export growth in the first quarter of the current fiscal year turned substantially
negative.
3. Even the exports of ready made garments sector which showed tremendous
resilience against global recession experienced negative growth of about 5 per
cent in the first quarter of the current fiscal year. This sector accounts for over
three-fourths of our total exports and a large part of our industrial output.
4. Parallel, the growth of imports has also turned negative encompassing all
categories – raw materials, intermediate goods, capital goods as well as
consumption goods.
1. The banks should make determined efforts to increase income. They can do so
by diversifying their asset base. In this context, they should consider
expansion of loan to the un-banked or under banked sectors such as
agriculture, small and medium industries and small scale domestic traders.
2. With a view to diversifying asset base as suggested above, the banks must
depart from the traditional practice of collateral-based lending. They should
aggressively seek out new borrowers with high income potentials and viable
project proposals.
3. Banks should also consider offering new products such as swaps, options and
derivative products. However, they must make sure that they do not assume
unsustainable risk from such operations. The Central Bank needs to issue
guidelines in this regard.
4. All out efforts should be made to recover non-performing loans (NPL). It is
understood that the state-owned banks have been able to reduce their NPL to
total loan ratio, but mostly by rescheduling rather than cash recovery. On the
other hand, NPL ratios of the privately owned banks have recently gone up.
6. The banks should also look at their expenditure side to improve income-
expenditure ratios. In particular, salaries and perks of employees and directors
and ostentatious expenses on branch decorations should be reduced.
7. Finally, banks should strengthen their risk management and early warning
systems so that they are not caught off-guard by developments in the real
economy
During the Mughal period, there were different types of gold coins in circulation that
encouraged people to engage in monetary transactions and profit-motivated financial
activities. Many individuals and some families attained special reputation in trading
and in finance. One such family, that of jagat sheth, had branches of its monetary
business in dhaka, Hughli and murshidabad. Mughal rulers patronised the banking
business of Jagat Sheth family and others, and also used to borrow money from them
when needed. People could convert their valuables, mostly gold and silver, into
currency with minimum cost at Mughal mints. Monetary transactions and transfer
through hundi, along with cash transaction, was in vogue during the Mughal period.
The revenue received from zamindars and dues there from were sent to the
government treasury through family-based financial or banking institutions. People
from different classes were also involved in monetary trading which helped the
evolution of banking in that period. A major landmark was the establishment of the
Hindustan Bank in 1700 AD at Calcutta. After the stewardship of Bengal, Bihar and
Urissha was assumed by the east India company, Jagat Sheth's family and other
traders in money and finance suffered great losses in their business because of the
activities of a new elite subservient to British rulers. The decline in banking brought
some instability in the economy of that time and, upon quick realisation of the fact,
the British set up the English Agency House.
Established in 1784, the Bengal Bank was the first British-patronised modern bank in
India. Dhaka Bank started to operate as a commercial bank in 1806. The Bengal Bank
opened its first branch in Dhaka by purchasing Dhaka Bank in 1862. In 1873, it
opened its two branches in sirajganj and Chittagong. Another branch of Bengal Bank
was opened in chandpur in 1900. Six branches of Bengal Bank were in operation in
the Bangladesh region until the partition of Bengal in 1947 and these branches were
located at Dhaka, Chittagong, mymensingh, rangpur, Chandpur and narayanganj.
The three Presidential banks that followed the establishment of the Bengal Bank were
the Bank of Calcutta (1806), Bank of Bombay (1840) and Bank of Madras (1843).
Combining these three banks, the Imperial Bank of India was set up in 1921. The
Reserve Bank of India came into being in 1935.
In addition to the above, there were other banking and financial institutions
throughout British India, including the territory of Bengal. Other banking institutions
established in East Bengal during the British period were the loan offices at
faridpur(1865), bogra (1872), barisal (1873), Mymensingh (1873), Nasirabad (1875),
jessore (1876), munshiganj (1876), Dhaka (1878), sylhet (1881), pabna (1882),
kishoreganj (1883), noakhali (1885), khulna (1887), madaripur (1887), tangail (1887),
nilphamari (1894) and Rangpur (1894). Banks established in this period included the
Kurigram Bank (1887), Kumarkhali Bank (1896), Mahaluxmi Bank, Chittagong
(1910), Dinajpur Bank (1914), Comilla Banking Corporation (1914) and Comilla
Union Bank (1922). Major Indian banks of the period having branches in the territory
were the National Bank of India (1864), Bengal Central Bank (1918), New Standard
Bank (1920), Imperial Bank of India (1921), Pioneer Bank (1923), Bank of
Commerce (1929), United Industrial Bank (1940), Habib Bank (1941) and United
Commercial Bank (1942).
After the birth of Pakistan in 1947, the State Bank of Pakistan, the central bank of the
country, came into being in 1948. Later, the National Bank of Pakistan, a commercial
bank was set up in 1949. In all, 36 scheduled commercial banks were in operation
throughout Pakistan. Most of these banks were owned by Pakistanis.
Only three of them, namely, National Bank of Pakistan, Habib Bank, and the
Australasia Bank had a branch in East Pakistan in 1949. During 1950-58, three other
Pakistani-owned banks, the Premier Bank, Bank of Bawalpur and Muslim
Commercial Bank had opened branch offices in East Pakistan. Four Pakistani-owned
banks, the United Bank, Union Bank, Standard Bank and Commerce Bank conducted
business in the province during 1959 - 1965. The province had only two banks owned
by local business groups and with headquarters at Dhaka, the Eastern Mercantile
Bank and Eastern Banking Corporation (now uttara bank), established in 1959 and
1965 respectively.
The banking system in the territory of Bangladesh grew slowly during the British and
Pakistan periods. There were only 25 bank branches in 1901 and the number grew to
668 in 1946. Creation of Pakistan was a deterrent in the sector as was evidenced by
the closure of bank branches, which came down to 148 in 1950. In 1965, the number
rose again to 545. Subsequent years, however, showed dramatic changes in the
situation and the number of bank branches increased to 1,025 in 1970.
Bangladesh bank, the central bank of the country, was set up on 16 December 1971
by the Bangladesh Bank Order 1972. The government accepted the assets and
liabilities of the Deputy Governor's office of the State Bank of Pakistan in Dhaka and
declared the Bangladesh Bank as a fully effective and permanent central bank.
The bank has the responsibility of overseeing and regulating the country's banking
system. In addition, the head office at Dhaka, Bangladesh Bank has nine branch
offices, two in Dhaka city (Motijheel and Sadarghat) and one each in Chittagong,
Khulna, rajshahi, Sylhet, Bogra, Rangpur and Barisal. The paid up capital of
Bangladesh Bank is Tk 30 million divided into 300,000 shares of Tk 100 each. The
total share capital is fully paid by the government. A nine-member board of directors
headed by a Governor as the chief executive oversees the affairs of the bank. To
conduct banking in Bangladesh, all banks have to have licenses from the Bangladesh
Bank under the Bank Companies Act 1991. To be able to get a license, all intending
banks have to be registered with the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies under the
company’s act 1994, and collect Certificate of Incorporation. Moreover, to collect
capital through public offerings of shares, intending banks have to obtain permission
from the country's Securities and Exchange Commission.
Domestic private banks are the International Finance and Investment Bank (ific bank,
estd. 1976), Islamic bank Bangladesh (1983), united commercial bank (1983), city
bank (1983), national bank (1983), Arab Bangladesh bank (1985), al Baraka bank
(1987), eastern bank (1992), national credit and commerce bank (1993), prime bank
(1995), south-east bank (1995), Dhaka bank (1995), al-arafah Islamic bank (1995),
social investment bank 1995), premier bank (1996), dutch-bangla bank (1996),
mercantile bank (1999), standard bank (1999), one bank (1999), export import bank
(1999), Bangladesh commerce bank (1999), mutual trust bank (1999), trust bank
(1999), bank Asia (1999) and first security bank (1999).
The three NCBs now operating in the country are the Sonali Bank, Janata Bank and
Agrani Bank. There is a special group of nationalised banks known as specialized or
development financial institutions to support specific economic purposes of the
country. These include two for agricultural development, the Bangladesh krishi bank
(estd. 1973) and rajshahi krishi unnayan bank (estd. in 1987 with branches of
Bangladesh Krishi Bank in Rajshahi division), one for industrial development, the
bangladesh shilpa bank (estd. 1972) and one for supporting unemployed youths in
their self-employment activities, the employment bank (estd.1997). The country has a
Co-operative Bank established in 1948, as the apex institution of all co-operative
societies in Bangladesh. The main function of this bank is to mobilise small savings
and assist members of co-operative societies to build up capital and provide them with
loan/financial assistance for the development of agriculture, commerce, fisheries,
urban and rural cottage industries, etc. It also provides loan to promote other income
generating activities in the society.
Foreign private banks which have branches in Bangladesh are the, standard chartered
bank, state bank of India, credit Agricola indosuez, Hong Kong and Shanghai
Banking Corporation (hsbc), national bank of Pakistan, habib bank, and hanvit bank.
Depending upon the relationship with and the degree of control of the Bangladesh
Bank banks in Bangladesh are divided into scheduled and non-scheduled banks.
Scheduled banks are enlisted by the Bangladesh Bank under the provisions of section
37 of the Bangladesh Bank Order 1972. They are promise bound to obey central bank
instructions, rules and regulations especially, those relating to required capital and
provisions, statutory liquidity reserves, audited returns etc. Through scheduling, banks
gain special status and enjoy some special facilities from the central bank such as re-
discounting, participation in the money market, membership of the clearing house and
deposit insurance scheme. Non-scheduled banks do not enjoy such privilege. The list
of non-scheduled banks in Bangladesh includes the Eden Bank, Saidpur Commercial
Bank, Comilla Co-operative Bank, Dinajpur Industrial Bank, Rajshahi Bank, Shankar
Bank, Faridpur Banking Corporation and Madaripur Commercial Bank.
During the Mughal period, there were different types of gold coins in circulation that
encouraged people to engage in monetary transactions and profit-motivated financial
activities. Many individuals and some families attained special reputation in trading
and in finance. One such family, that of jagat sheth, had branches of its monetary
business in dhaka, Hughli and murshidabad. Mughal rulers patronised the banking
business of Jagat Sheth family and others, and also used to borrow money from them
when needed. People could convert their valuables, mostly gold and silver, into
currency with minimum cost at Mughal mints. Monetary transactions and transfer
through hundi, along with cash transaction, was in vogue during the Mughal period.
The revenue received from zamindars and dues there from were sent to the
government treasury through family-based financial or banking institutions. People
from different classes were also involved in monetary trading which helped the
evolution of banking in that period. A major landmark was the establishment of the
Hindustan Bank in 1700 AD at Calcutta. After the stewardship of Bengal, Bihar and
Urissha was assumed by the east India company, Jagat Sheth's family and other
traders in money and finance suffered great losses in their business because of the
activities of a new elite subservient to British rulers. The decline in banking brought
some instability in the economy of that time and, upon quick realisation of the fact,
the British set up the English Agency House.
Established in 1784, the Bengal Bank was the first British-patronised modern bank in
India. Dhaka Bank started to operate as a commercial bank in 1806. The Bengal Bank
opened its first branch in Dhaka by purchasing Dhaka Bank in 1862. In 1873, it
opened its two branches in sirajganj and Chittagong. Another branch of Bengal Bank
was opened in chandpur in 1900. Six branches of Bengal Bank were in operation in
the Bangladesh region until the partition of Bengal in 1947 and these branches were
located at Dhaka, Chittagong, mymensingh, rangpur, Chandpur and narayanganj.
The three Presidential banks that followed the establishment of the Bengal Bank were
the Bank of Calcutta (1806), Bank of Bombay (1840) and Bank of Madras (1843).
Combining these three banks, the Imperial Bank of India was set up in 1921. The
Reserve Bank of India came into being in 1935.
In addition to the above, there were other banking and financial institutions
throughout British India, including the territory of Bengal. Other banking institutions
established in East Bengal during the British period were the loan offices at
faridpur(1865), bogra (1872), barisal (1873), Mymensingh (1873), Nasirabad (1875),
jessore (1876), munshiganj (1876), Dhaka (1878), sylhet (1881), pabna (1882),
kishoreganj (1883), noakhali (1885), khulna (1887), madaripur (1887), tangail (1887),
nilphamari (1894) and Rangpur (1894). Banks established in this period included the
Kurigram Bank (1887), Kumarkhali Bank (1896), Mahaluxmi Bank, Chittagong
(1910), Dinajpur Bank (1914), Comilla Banking Corporation (1914) and Comilla
Union Bank (1922). Major Indian banks of the period having branches in the territory
were the National Bank of India (1864), Bengal Central Bank (1918), New Standard
Bank (1920), Imperial Bank of India (1921), Pioneer Bank (1923), Bank of
Commerce (1929), United Industrial Bank (1940), Habib Bank (1941) and United
Commercial Bank (1942).
After the birth of Pakistan in 1947, the State Bank of Pakistan, the central bank of the
country, came into being in 1948. Later, the National Bank of Pakistan, a commercial
bank was set up in 1949. In all, 36 scheduled commercial banks were in operation
throughout Pakistan. Most of these banks were owned by Pakistanis.
Only three of them, namely, National Bank of Pakistan, Habib Bank, and the
Australasia Bank had a branch in East Pakistan in 1949. During 1950-58, three other
Pakistani-owned banks, the Premier Bank, Bank of Bawalpur and Muslim
Commercial Bank had opened branch offices in East Pakistan. Four Pakistani-owned
banks, the United Bank, Union Bank, Standard Bank and Commerce Bank conducted
business in the province during 1959 - 1965. The province had only two banks owned
by local business groups and with headquarters at Dhaka, the Eastern Mercantile
Bank and Eastern Banking Corporation (now uttara bank), established in 1959 and
1965 respectively.
The banking system in the territory of Bangladesh grew slowly during the British and
Pakistan periods. There were only 25 bank branches in 1901 and the number grew to
668 in 1946. Creation of Pakistan was a deterrent in the sector as was evidenced by
the closure of bank branches, which came down to 148 in 1950. In 1965, the number
rose again to 545. Subsequent years, however, showed dramatic changes in the
situation and the number of bank branches increased to 1,025 in 1970.
The bank has the responsibility of overseeing and regulating the country's banking
system. In addition, the head office at Dhaka, Bangladesh Bank has nine branch
offices, two in Dhaka city (Motijheel and Sadarghat) and one each in Chittagong,
Khulna, rajshahi, Sylhet, Bogra, Rangpur and Barisal. The paid up capital of
Bangladesh Bank is Tk 30 million divided into 300,000 shares of Tk
100 each. The total share capital is fully paid by the government. A nine-member
board of directors headed by a Governor as the chief executive oversees the affairs of
the bank. To conduct banking in Bangladesh, all banks have to have licenses from the
Bangladesh Bank under the Bank Companies Act 1991. To be able to get a license, all
intending banks have to be registered with the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies
under the companies act 1994, and collect Certificate of Incorporation. Moreover, to
collect capital through public offerings of shares, intending banks have to obtain
permission from the country's securities and exchange commission.
Domestic private banks are the International Finance and Investment Bank (ific bank,
estd. 1976), Islamic bank Bangladesh (1983), united commercial bank (1983), city
bank (1983), national bank (1983), Arab Bangladesh bank (1985), al Baraka bank
(1987), eastern bank (1992), national credit and commerce bank (1993), prime bank
(1995), south-east bank (1995), Dhaka bank (1995), al-arafah Islamic bank (1995),
social investment bank 1995), premier bank (1996), dutch-bangla bank (1996),
mercantile bank (1999), standard bank (1999), one bank (1999), export import bank
(1999), Bangladesh commerce bank (1999), mutual trust bank (1999), trust bank
(1999), bank Asia (1999) and first security bank (1999).
The three NCBs now operating in the country are the Sonali Bank, Janata Bank and
Agrani Bank. There is a special group of nationalised banks known as specialized or
development financial institutions to support specific economic purposes of the
country. These include two for agricultural development, the Bangladesh krishi bank
(estd. 1973) and rajshahi krishi unnayan bank (estd. in 1987 with branches of
Bangladesh Krishi Bank in Rajshahi division), one for industrial development, the
bangladesh shilpa bank (estd. 1972) and one for supporting unemployed youths in
their self-employment activities, the employment bank (estd.1997). The country has a
Co-operative Bank established in 1948, as the apex institution of all co-operative
societies in Bangladesh. The main function of this bank is to mobilise small savings
and assist members of co-operative societies to build up capital and provide them with
loan/financial assistance for the development of agriculture, commerce, fisheries,
urban and rural cottage industries, etc. It also provides loan to promote other income
generating activities in the society.
Foreign private banks which have branches in Bangladesh are the, standard chartered
bank, state bank of India, credit Agricola indosuez, Hong Kong and Shanghai
Banking Corporation (hsbc), national bank of Pakistan, habib bank, and hanvit bank.
Depending upon the relationship with and the degree of control of the Bangladesh
Bank banks in Bangladesh are divided into scheduled and non-scheduled banks.
Scheduled banks are enlisted by the Bangladesh Bank under the provisions of section
37 of the Bangladesh Bank Order 1972. They are promise bound to obey central bank
instructions, rules and regulations especially, those relating to required capital and
provisions, statutory liquidity
Central Bank:
1. Bangladesh Bank
The results revealed that payback period, followed by net present value, appears to be
the most used method across the different sizes and sectors of business. It was also
found that 64% of businesses surveyed used only one technique, while 32% of the
respondents used between two to three different types of techniques to evaluate
capital budgeting decisions. The findings show that the more complicated methods
such as IRR and NPV are most favored by the large businesses as compared to the
small businesses. The majority of the respondents believed that project definition was
the most important stage in the capital budgeting process.
Implementation stage appeared to be the most difficult stage for the manufacturing
sector whereas Project definition, Analysis and selection and Implementation were
generally rated as being the difficult stages by the retail sector. Project definition and
Analysis and selection were found to be the most difficult stages by the service sector.
Most businesses used the cost of bank loan as a basis in capital budgeting and more
than two thirds of respondents used non-quantitative techniques to consider risk when
making a decision on investing in fixed assets.
Capital budgeting is one of the most important areas of financial management. There
are several techniques commonly used to evaluate capital budgeting projects namely
the payback period, accounting rate of return, present value and internal rate of return
and profitability index. Recent studies highlight that financial managers worldwide
favor methods such as the internal rate of return (IRR) or non-discounted payback
period (PP) models over the net present value (NPV), which is the model academics
consider superior. In particular this research focused on small, medium and large
businesses and investigated a number of variables and associations relating to capital
budgeting practices in businesses in the Bank of Bangladesh.
The results revealed that payback period, followed by net present value, appears to be
the most used method across the different sizes and sectors of business. It was also
found that 64% of businesses surveyed used only one technique, while 32% of the
respondents used between two to three different types of techniques to evaluate
capital budgeting decisions. The findings show that the more complicated methods
such as IRR and NPV are most favored by the large businesses as compared to the
small businesses. The majority of the respondents believed that project definition was
the most important stage in the capital budgeting process. Implementation stage
appeared to be the most difficult stage for the manufacturing sector whereas Project
definition, Analysis and selection and Implementation were generally rated as being
the difficult stages by the retail sector. Project definition and Analysis and selection
were found to be the most difficult stages by the service sector. Most businesses used
the cost of bank loan as a basis in capital budgeting and more than two thirds of
respondents used non-quantitative techniques to consider risk when making a decision
on investing in fixed assets.
Many scholars and researchers agree that capital budgeting decisions are crucial to a
business’s performance (Swain & Haka, 2000; Arya, Fellingham & Glover, 1998).
Capital budgeting plays a crucial role in a business’s competitive model. This
explains why Kwak, Shi, Lee & Lee (1996) state that capital budgeting is not a trivial
task. A business whose ability to effectively develop a feasible mechanism for capital
budgeting may gain a better competitive advantage to its rivalries in an environment
characterized by change and volatility (Louw, 2007; Lazaridis, 2004).
In the last three decades, empirical research involving Bank has been conducted
extensively on the use of capital budgeting techniques. Hermes, Smid & Yao (2007);
Lazaridis (2004); Sandahl & Sjogren (2002); George & Chong (2001); Kester &
Chong (1999); Drury & Tayles (1996) and Jog & Srivastava (1995) provide details of
empirical studies on capital budgeting practices in Asia, Cyprus, Netherlands &
China, Sweden, Canada, Singapore and the UK respectively.
These surveys, which have focused on methods of evaluating project profitability and
risk, have shown that the sophistication of the analytical techniques used by United
States executives has increased over time. Discounted cash flow (DCF) techniques,
such as Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Retum (IRR), have become the
dominant method of evaluating and ranking proposed capital investment (Kester et al
(1999).
Hatfield, Horvath, and Webster (1998) as cited by Lazaridus (2004) investigated the
importance of payback period (PP), average rate of return (ARR), internal rate of
return (IRR) and net present value (NPV) capital budgeting techniques on the
performance and value measures of businesses. They found out that businesses
analyzing all projects had higher share prices on average as compared to those that did
not. In addition to this, they also found, in contrast to the theory of finance, that the
NPV technique did not maximize the value of the business. Their results thus
suggested that businesses should not use single capital budgeting technique but
instead should apply as many methods as possible for a project evaluation.
Chapter: 04
Profile of the Private Commercial Banks
Background of Private Commercial Bank:
4.1:
Dutch-Bangla Bank Limited (the Bank, DBBL) is a scheduled joint venture
commercial bank between local Bangladeshi parties spearheaded by M Sahabuddin
Ahmed (Founder & Chairman) and the Dutch company FMO. DBBL was established
under the Bank Companies Act 1991 and incorporated as a public limited company
under the Companies Act 1994 in Bangladesh with the primary objective to carry on
all kinds of banking business in Bangladesh. DBBL commenced formal operation
from June 3, 1996. The Bank is listed with the Dhaka Stock Exchange Limited and
Chittagong Stock Exchange Limited.
IFIC Bank
Founded 1977
Headquarters Dhaka, Bangladesh
Paid –Up- capital Tk.1744 million
Authorized capital Tk. 5350 million
Branches 82
Employees 2193
M. J. Abedin & co.
Auditors
Chartered Accountants
Website www.ificbankbd.com
4.3:
National Bank Limited (NBL) established in 1983 with an authorized capital of Tk
100 million and paid up capital of Tk 44 million. It started banking operations on 23
March 1983. On 31 December 2000, the bank's authorized and paid up capital were
Tk 1,000 million and Tk 430 million respectively. The bank conducts commercial
banking activities including deposit mobilization, lending, servicing domestic and
foreign trade and remittance services. The bank introduced credit card and master
card for both internal and international use. It has a deposit insurance scheme and a
monthly deposit project to encourage the public to save more. The bank has a huge
amount of non-performing loans and advances and the total amount of classified loans
stood at Tk 5,796.2 million in 2000. The bank has to maintain large amount of
provision for the classified loans from its profits. On the other hand, non-recovery of
stuck-up loans and interest thereon inflated the interest suspense account of the bank.
Thus the interest income of the bank from loans and advances was largely squeezed to
affect the overall profitability of the bank.
4.4:
AB Bank Limited, the first private sector bank was incorporated in Bangladesh on
31st December 1981 as Arab Bangladesh Bank Limited and started its operation with
effect from April 12, 1982. AB Bank is known as one of leading bank of the country
since its commencement 28 years ago. It continues to remain updated with the latest
products and services, considering consumer and client perspectives. AB Bank has
thus been able to keep their consumer’s and client’s trust while upholding their
reliability, across time. During the last 28 years, AB Bank Limited has opened 77
Branches in different Business Centers of the country, one foreign Branch in Mumbai,
India and also established a wholly owned Subsidiary Finance Company in Hong
Kong in the name of AB International Finance Limited. To facilitate cross border
trade and payment related services, the Bank has correspondent relationship with over
220 international banks of repute across 58 countries of the World.
AB Bank Ltd
Type Private
Founded 1981
Headquarters Dhaka, Bangladesh
M.WahidulHaque
Key people
Chairman
Authorized capital in BDT*
6,000
(mn)
Branches 77
Paid-up Capital in BDT*
3205.32
(mn)
Website www.abbank.com.bd
4.5:
BRAC Bank (BRAC) is a commercial bank that was founded in 2001 by BRAC
NGO, one of the largest development finance institutions in the world. The bank’s
objectives include providing comprehensive commercial banking services, building a
profitable and modern, full-service financial institution, and pursuing profitable
market niches in the Small and Medium Enterprise (SME) business sector not
traditionally met by conventional banks.
The bank’s main portfolio products include loans for small and medium sized
entrepreneurs; personal loans, credit cards and multiple deposit accounts for retail
customers; and specialized retail products tailored to religious restrictions. The bank
also provides corporate deposit and loan products as well as non-resident Bangladeshi
remittance services. BRAC’s distribution network of 22 branches, 350 small and
medium enterprise unit offices, and 19 ATM sites span across Bangladesh and reach
more than 40,000 borrowers.
BRAC Bank Ltd
Founded 2001
Headquarters Dhaka, Bangladesh
Paid-up Capital in
2677.0
BDT* (mn)
Authorized capital in
4800.0
BDT* (mn)
Share Market Category A
Dr.Mohammad A (Rumme) Ali,
Key people
Chairman
Website www.bracbank.com
4.6:
Eastern Bank Limited (EBL) is one of the modern, fully online and technologically
superior private commercial Banks in Bangladesh. Eastern Bank markets a wide range
of depository, loan & card products. Eastern Bank Limited provides commercial
banking products and services to the corporate, mid-market, and retail segment in
Bangladesh and internationally. Its deposit products include savings deposit, EBL SB
insurance account, deposit–retail, EBL campus account, EBL interesting account,
EBL confidence, salary account deposits, monthly deposit plan, bearer certificate of
deposits, bills payable and fixed deposits comprising short term deposits, term
deposits, and non resident foreign currency deposits.. It also provides financial
products and services, including corporate deposit accounts, syndicated financing,
trustee and agency services, term loan, project finance, export-import financing,
working capital and other finance, bonds and guarantees, investment and business
counseling, infrastructure finance, and cash management services, as well as treasury,
syndication, securities, and custody services..
4.7:
Dhaka Bank Limited a private sector commercial bank. It was incorporated as a
public limited company on 6 April 1995 under the companies Act1994. It started
commercial banking operations on 5 July 1995 with an authorized capital of Tk 1000
million, divided into 10 million ordinary shares of Tk 100 each. The issued,
subscribed, and paid up capital of the bank in 1995 was Tk 100 million, which was
paid fully by the sponsors. In addition to all sorts of traditional banking activities,
Dhaka Bank provides on-line tele-banking services and a comprehensive range of
financial services to national and multinational companies in the country. It also
underwrites shares and debentures, works as issue manager, and participates in other
operations in money Market and Capital Market.
As a member of the Dhaka and Chittagong stock exchanges, the bank participates in
the day-to-day transactions of the stock exchanges. The bank has established a large
network of foreign correspondents covering important business centres in 107
countries around the world and now has 325 foreign correspondents in these
countries. The bank introduced Reuter's screen since 1998, which has accelerated its
foreign exchange dealings. Of its 12 branches, 10 are authorized to deal in foreign
exchange. The aggregate quantum of import business handled by the bank in 1999
stood at Tk 9,075 million while the export business handled by the bank that year was
worth Tk 3,299.30 million.
4.8:
Pubali Bank Limited was initially established in East Pakistan as Eastern
Mercantile Bank Limited in 1959, under the Bank Companies Act of 1913.
Bangladesh became independent in 1972 Eastern Mercantile Bank Limited was
nationalized and renamed as Pubali Bank. The bank was denationalized in 1983, and
was renamed as Pubali Bank Limited. The People's Republic of Bangladesh handed
over all assets and liabilities of Pubali Bank to Pubali Bank Limited. Since then
Pubali Bank Limited has been involved in Commercial Banking services as the largest
bank in the private sector of Bangladesh. The functions of the bank include deposit
mobilisation, financing productive activities, conducting foreign exchange business
and providing various types of banking services to the customers. Total deposits of
the bank on 31 December 1972 were Tk 767.98 million, which rose to Tk 5,409.11
million in December 1984.
Total loans and advances of the bank during these two reference periods were Tk
471.64 million and Tk 4,333.46 million respectively. Total liabilities (assets) of bank
were valued at Tk 7,233.64 million on 31 December 1984. Compared to these, the
value of total deposits, total loans and advances, and total liabilities (assets) on 31
December 2000 was Tk 29,590.1 million, Tk 21,572.2 million and Tk 33,436.9
million respectively. The deposits comprised savings deposits Tk 11,608.6 million,
fixed deposits Tk 5,557.3 million, current deposits Tk 3,933.1 million, and other
deposits Tk 8491.1 million.
4.9:
Uttara Bank formed in 1972 as a scheduled bank with assets and liabilities of the
Eastern Banking Corporation set up in East Pakistan on 28 January 1965. It started
banking business 22 June 1965 and became a member of the Dhaka Clearing House
on 17 September 1965. At the time of establishment, Eastern Banking Corporation
had a paid up capital of Tk 1.42 million and deposit resources of about Tk 10 million.
It was the only scheduled bank formed with capital raised entirely from the small
income group of people of East Pakistan.
Eastern Banking Corporation was nationalised under the Bangladesh Banks
Nationalisation Order 1972 and its name was changed to Uttara Bank. At that time,
the bank had 182 branches. The government retracted 95% of its share capital and
allowed it to operate as a private bank. It was transformed into a limited company on
15 September 1983. On 31 December 2000, the authorised capital of the bank was Tk
200 million divided into 2 million ordinary shares of Tk 100 each. Its issued and paid
up capital was Tk 100 million, of which Tk 5 million is subscribed by the
government. The bank is listed with both Dhaka and Chittagong Stock Exchanges.
The bank performs all traditional commercial banking functions. It renders agency
services to the government in food procurement and collection of government revenue
through the network of its branches all over the country. The total volume of foreign
exchange business handled by the bank during 1998-99 amounted to Tk 16,600
million which comprised exports servicing Tk 4,450 million, imports financing Tk
10,560 million and remittances facilities Tk 1,590 million. The bank has
correspondent relationships with 300 foreign banks/bank offices and exchange houses
in 72 countries. The bank had 198 branches (150 urban and 48 rural) and the number
of employees in all its branches 2,822 including 84 executives, 1,756 officers, 326
assistant officers, and 656 employees of non-officer grades. The bank's branch
banking is supervised through its 12 zonal offices in different parts of the country
4.11:
ONE Bank Limited was incorporated in May, 1999 With the Registrar of Joint Stock
Companies under the Companies Act. 1994, as a commercial bank in the private
sector. The Bank is pledge-bound to serve the customers and the community with
utmost dedication. The prime focus is on efficiency, transparency, precision and
motivation with the spirit and conviction to excel as ONE Bank in both value and
image. The name 'ONE Bank' is derived from the insight and long nourished feelings
of the promoters to reach out to the people of all walks of life and progress together
towards prosperity in a spirit of oneness.OBL is a private sector commercial bank
dedicated in the business line of taking deposits from public through its various
saving schemes and lending the fund in various sectors at a higher margin.. OBL also
involved in cement construction and transport sector financing. In the investment
portfolio, OBL have substantial investment in quoted and non-quoted shares of
different organization including some very prospective financial institutions. The
bank has shown its acumen in reducing its exposure from ship scrapping sector, steel
re-rolling where the bank had investment earlier. With the increase in exposure to
RMG, the bank has increased its non-funded business income substantially. With an
age of only 8 years, the OBL has taken initiative to launch IT based banking products
like ATM facilities, E-banking etc that are praiseworthy.
4.12:
National Credit and Commerce Bank Ltd. bears a unique history of its own. The
organization started its journey in the financial sector of the country as an investment
company back in 1985. The aim of the company was to mobilize resources from
within and invest them in such way so as to develop country's Industrial and Trade
Sector and playing a catalyst role in the formation of capital market as well. Its
membership with the browse helped the company to a great extent in this regard. The
company operated upto 1992 with 16 branches and thereafter with the permission of
the Central Bank converted in to a full fledged private commercial Bank in 1993 with
paid up capital of Tk. 39.00 corore to serve the nation from a broader platform.
4.13:
It was reported that Citigroup executives were pleased with the performance of the
Boston branches, but were less impressed with the Philadelphia experiment, according
to a person familiar with the situation.. The article also noted that Citi could abandon
or scale back where it is an also-ran, including Boston, Philadelphia and parts of
Texas, according to people with knowledge of the discussions.
Citibank
Type Private Commercial Bank
Founded 1983
Total Asset Tk-764.66 core
Paid-up Capital Tk-157.12 core
SME Branches 14
Branches 87
Number of ATM 46
Website www.thecitybank.com
4.14:
HSBC Holdings was established in 1990 and became the parent company to The
Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation in preparation for its purchase of
Midland Bank and a change of domicile for the transfer of sovereignty of Hong Kong.
Shares in HSBC Holdings, which gave HSBC a substantial presence in the UK, was
completed in 1992. HSBC then moved the headquarters of HSBC Holdings from
1Queens Road Central, Hong Kong to 10 Lower Thames Street, London in 1993.
Major acquisitions in South America started with the purchase of Banco Bamerindus
of Brazil for $1bn in March 1997 and the acquisition of Roberts SA de Inversiones of
Argentina for $600m in May 1997.In May 1999 HSBC embarked on a major
acquisition in the United States with the purchase of Republic National Bank of New
York for $10.3bn.[9] Expansion into Continental Europe took place in April 2000 with
the acquisition of Credits Commercial de France, a large French bank for £6.6bn.]
In July 2001 HSBC bought Demirbank, an insolvent Turkish bank. Then in August
2002 HSBC acquired Grupo Financiero Bital, SA de CV, Mexico's largest retail bank
for $1.1bn .The new headquarters of HSBC Holdings at 8 Canada Square, London
officially opened in April 2003.Then in September 2003 HSBC bought Polski Kredyt
Bank SA of Poland for $7.8m.[14] A terrorist attack took place in November 2003: a
bomb blast in Istanbul damaged the bank's head office in Turkey, causing several
deaths and hundreds of injuries.
HSBC
Type World Class Local Bank
Founded 1990
Headquarters Canada Squire in London
Number of ATM 27
Branches 09
Employees 830
Website www.hsbc.bd.com
4.15:
EXIM Bank Limited was established in 1999 under the leadership of Late Mr.
Shahjahan Kabir, founder chairman who had a long dream of floating a commercial
bank which would contribute to the socio-economic development of our country. He
had a long experience as a good banker. A group of highly qualified and successful
entrepreneurs joined their hands with the founder chairman to materialize his dream.
In deed, all of them proved themselves in their respective business as most successful
star with their endeavor, intelligence, hard working and talent entrepreneurship.
Among them, Mr. Nazrul Islam Mazumder became the honorable chairman This
bank starts functioning from 3rd August, 1999 with Mr. Alamgir Kabir, FCA as the
advisor and Mr. Mohammad Lakiotullah as the Managing Director. Both of them
have long experience in the financial sector of our country. By their pragmatic
decision and management directives in the operational activities, this bank has earned
a secured and distinctive position in the banking industry in terms of performance,
growth, and excellent management. The authorized capital and paid up capital of the
bank are Tk. 3500.00 million and Tk2677.80million respectively.
Number of branches 52
Proposed branches 10
CREDIT RATING
Long Term ‘AA’
Short Term ‘ST-2’
Shareholders Equity 6717.21
Chapter: 05
Back Ground of Capital Budgeting Technique
Background of Capital Budgeting Technique:
Non-discounted Cash flow criteria: These techniques do not employ the time
value of money concepts.
Accounting Rate of Return (ARR): The accounting rate of return, also known as
the return on investment, uses accounting information, as revealed by financial
statements, to measure the profitability of an investment. The accounting rate of
return is found out by dividing the average after-tax profit by the average investment.
The average investment would be equal to half of the original investment if it is
depreciated constantly. Alternatively, it can be found out dividing the total of the
investment’s book values after depreciation by the life of the project.
Net Present Value (NPV): Under the net present value method, the present value
of a project’s cash inflows is compared to the present value of the project’s cash
outflows. The difference between the present values of these cash flows, called the net
present value, determines whether or not the project is an acceptable investment. The
NPV acceptance rules are:
Accept if NPV> 0.
Reject if NPV< 0.
May accept if NPV 0.
Internal Rate of Return (IRR): The internal rate of return is the rate of return
promised by an investment project over its useful life. It is sometimes referred to
simply as the yield on a project. The internal rate of return is computed by finding the
discount rate that equates the present value of a project’s cash outflows with the
present value of its cash inflows. In other words, the internal rate of return is that
discount rate that will cause the present value of a project to be equal to zero.
Profitability Index (P1): Profitability index is the ratio of the present value of
cash inflows, at the required rate of return, to the initial cash outflow of the
investment. The P1 acceptance rules are:
Accept if P I>1.
Reject if PI<1.
May accept if PI= 1.
Where P1 is greater than 1, the project will have positive net present value.
Modified Internal Rate of Return (MIRR): MIRR - Is basically the same as the
IRR, except it assumes that the revenue (cash flows) from the project are reinvested
back into the company, and are compounded by the company's cost of capital, but are
not directly invested back into the project from which they came.
Expansion: a company may add capacity to its existing product lines to expand
existing operation. A firm may expand its activities in a new business.
Cost reduction: Reduce cost by improving productivity. Cost is the main fact for
profit, if the firm able to reduce the cost the able to get more profit.
Replacement: replace means, change the existence fixed assets for improving the
efficiency and cost reduction.
Lease or Buy: The decisions in which the capital will be acquired that is are they
buy or lease the capital assets?
Modernization: modernization means, improve the existence fixed assets for
improving the efficiency and get more profits.
Mutual exclusive: mutual exclusive investments serve the same purpose and
compete with each other. If one investment decision will take another will be
excluded.
Growth The effects of investment decisions extend into the future and have to be
endured for a longer period than the Consequences of the current operation
expenditure. A firm’s decision to invest in loin-term assets has a decisive influence on
the rate and direction of its growth. A wrong decision can prove disastrous for the
continued survival of the firm’s unexpected or unprofitable expansion of assets will
result in heavy operating costs to the firm. On the other hand, inadequate investment
in assets would make it difficult for the firm to compete successfully and maintain its
market share
Risk A long-term commitment of fund may also change the risk complexity of fire
firm. If the adoption of an investment increases average gain but causes frequent
fluctuations in its earning the firm will become more risky Thus, investment decisions
shape the basic character of a firm.
Funding Investment decisions generally involve large amount of funds, which make
it imperative for the firms to plan its investment program carefully and make an
advance arrangement for procuring finances internally or externally
Irreversibility Most investment decisions are irreversible It is difficult to find a
marker for such capital items once they have been acquired The firm will incurred
heavy losses if such assets are scrapped
Complexity Investment decisions are among firms most difficult decision. They are
an assessment of future events, which are difficult to predict. It is really a complex
problem to correctly estimate the future cash flows of an investment Economic,
political, social and technological forces cause the uncertainty in cash floss
estimation.
Chapter: 06
Problem
implementing of Absence of relevant Lack of skilled Arbitrary capital Too much cost
and realize data
Capital Budgeting manpower budgeting decision concern
Decision
DBBL Moderate Slightly Important Neutral Moderate
Important Important
IFIC Neutral Highly Important Slightly Important Neutral
NBL Moderate Slightly Important Highly Important Neutral
Important
AB BANK Moderate Slightly Important Moderate Neutral
Important Important
BRAC Slightly Important Neutral Slightly Important Moderate
Important
EBL Moderate Slightly Important Neutral Moderate
Important Important
DBL Neutral Highly Important Slightly Important Neutral
PBL Moderate Slightly Important Highly Important Neutral
Important
UBL Moderate Highly Important Moderate Neutral
Important Important
UCBL Moderate Highly Important Neutral Neutral
Important
NCC Moderate Moderate Slightly Important Neutral
Important Important
OBL Slightly Important Highly Important Moderate Slightly Important
Important
HSBC Moderate Highly Important Moderate Neutral
Important Important
EXIM Moderate Highly Important Neutral Neutral
Important
CBL Moderate Moderate Slightly Important Neutral
Important Important
GRAFICAL PRESENTATION
In the capital decision NPV is best among the three banks that is Datch Bangla Bank
Limited, IFIC Bank Limited, and National Bank Limited they always use NPV
technique but the budgeting technique like IRR are frequently used by DBBL, and
IFIC. And NBL always use this technique. Non-discounted cash flow criteria like
Payback period, Discounted Payback period, and Accounting rate of return which do
not consider the time value of money are always used by IFIC and NBL. So it is not
correct technique for bank for capital investment. For solving this problem the
authority should give emphasis on this matter.
On the satisfaction of this technique we can see that both NBL and IFIC are highly
satisfied in most of the technique. The DBBL, they are highly satisfied only by using
NPV some of the techniques they do not use, so they result those technique as neutral.
In our Analysis we find that 53% bank always used NPV, 40% frequently used NPV,
7% sometime used NPV, rarely and never used 0%.
In our analysis we find that 20% bank always used IRR, 67% frequently used IRR,
and 13% sometime used IRR, rarely and never used 0%.
In our analysis we find that 13% bank always used MIRR, 33% frequently used
MIRR, 47% sometime used MIRR, 7% sometime used rarely MIRR and MIRR 0%
used in never.
In our analysis we find that 7% bank always used PI, 33% frequently used PI, 33%
sometime used PI, 20% sometime used rarely PI and 7% used in never.
In our Analysis we find that 0% bank always used discounted payback period, 0%
frequently used discounted payback period, 0% sometime used discounted payback
period, 27% rarely and never used 73%.
In our Analysis we find that 0% bank always used discounted payback period, 0%
frequently used discounted payback period, 0% sometime used discounted payback
period, 27% rarely and never used 73%.
In our Analysis we find that 0% bank always used discounted payback period, 0%
frequently used discounted payback period, 7% sometime used discounted payback
period, 40% rarely and never used 53%.
Chapter: 07
Comparession, Recommendation&Conclusion
7.1: Comparession
7.2: Recommendation:
Businesses look for opportunities that increase their share holders’ value. In capital
budgeting, the managers try to figure out investment opportunities that are worth
more to the business than they cost to acquire. Ideally, firms should peruse all such
projects that have good potential to increase the business worth. Since the available
amount of capital at any given time is limited; therefore, it restricts the management
to pick out only certain projects by using capital budgeting techniques in order to
determine which project has potential to yield the most return over an applicable
period of time. Capital budgeting is the process which enables the management to
decide which, when and where to make long-term investments. With the help of
Capital Budgeting Techniques, management decide whether to accept or reject a
particular project by making analysis of the cash flows generated by the project over a
period of time and its cost. Management decides in favor of project if the value of
cash flows generated by the project exceeds the cost of undertaking that project.
According my opinion every manager should to maintain the following criteria in
Capital Budgeting Decision to ensure their proper capital uses.
7.3: Conclusion:
Capital budjeting is an outline of planned investments in fixed assets and it is the
whole process of analyzing projects and deciding which ones to include in the capital
budjet. Businesses look for opportunities that increase their share holders’ value. In
capital budgeting,the managers try to figure out investment opportunities that are
worth more to the business than they cost to acquire. Ideally, firms should peruse all
such projects that have good potential to increase the business worth. Since the
available amount of capital at any given time is limited; therefore,it restricts the
management to pick out only certain projects by using capital budgeting techniques in
order to determine which project has potential to yield the most return over an
applicable period of time.An efficient allocation of capital is the most important
finance function in the modern times. It involves decision to commit the firm’s funds
to the long-term assets. Capital budgeting or investment decisions are of considerable
importance to the firm since they tend to determine its value by influencing its
growth, profitability and risk.
Reference:
1. www.gogle.com
2. www.banglapedia.com
3. www.dbbl.com.bd
4. www.ificbankbd.com
5. www.nblbd.com
6. www.abbank.com.bd
7. www.bracbank.com
8. www.bracbank.com
9. www.primebank.com
10. www.pubalibank.com
11. www.ebl-bd.com
12. www.hsbc.bd.com
13. www.ucbl.com
Appendix:
Appendix:
Survey Questionnaire
Dear Sir/ Madam
This is to inform you that Golam Sarwar Hossain Khan Assistance professor
Department of business administration, Stamford University Bangladeshis requesting
you to answer the following questions related to “Capital Budgeting Technique in
Private Commercial Bank of Bangladesh”. This thesis paper is a partial requirement
to complete his MBA degree.