The Aesthetic Smile: Diagnosis Treatment: Garber Salama
The Aesthetic Smile: Diagnosis Treatment: Garber Salama
18
~~
Principles of aesthetic diagnosis
pids, in turn, would have the free gingival margin To develop this symmetry, both surgical and
at the same level of the central incisors and match- orthodontic procedures might be used (Table 1).
ing one another. Extending distally, the tissues on
the premolars would be somewhat coronally posi-
tioned (1,9). Surgical techniques
Periodontic plastic procedures, such as the basic
gingivectomy, soft tissue grafting or the apically Additive techniques for augmenting gingiva have
positioned flap, may be used to change the evolved from the early free gingival grafts through
silhouette form of teeth and their relative the many different forms of contiguous grafting.
proportion. This would include pedicle grafts, connective tis-
19
Garber & Snlama
sue grafting, semilunar techniques, coronally posi- The medium lipline in western culture is
tioned grafts and guided tissue regeneration (Fig. 1, deemed to be the most attractive. When the patient
2) (2,3,5 , 7 , 8 , 10, 11, 13, 14). smiles, a nominal exposure of 1 to 3 m m of gingiva
Resective techniques involve both the basic from the most apical extent of the free gingival
gingivectomy with or without gingivoplasty, as well margin to the inferior border of the upper lip is
as the full flap procedure incorporating osseous exposed. Thus the teeth in their entirety are on
removal for crown lengthening of one or more display as well as the interdental gingival tissue
teeth (Fig. 3-5). and the border of free gingiva around the cervical
area of the tooth.
Orthodontic techniques
The great advantage in moving teeth orthodonti- The geometry of harmony
cally is that the entire attachment apparatus, in-
corporating the osseous structure, periodontal lig- Within the confines of the lipline, the remaining
aments and the soft tissue components, moves to- two components of the smile need to be arranged
gether with the tooth. This means that, in health, in such a way as to develop a certain continuity of
during an extrusive movement, the free gingival form, harmony and balance (Fig. 11). Classically,
margin will move coronally at the same distance as the prosthodontist would like to set up a denture
the incisal edge moves (Fig. 6). Concomitantly, the so that the level of the gingival margins of the max-
osseous level will move an identical distance in the illary teeth parallel the form of the upper lip. The
same direction. incisal edges of these maxillary teeth tend to follow
From an aesthetic perspective, this means that the form of the lower lip. In a transverse dimen-
any intrusive or extrusive tooth movement can be sion, the teeth should extend progressively posteri-
used to develop symmetry of the gingival margin in orly and laterally to fill the vestibule extending to
a nonsurgical mode (Fig. 7-9). This is particularly the corners of the smile. In the composition of a
useful when any form of restoration is necessary, as beautiful smile, the form, balance, symmetry and
a surgical procedure invariably exposes root relationship of the elements make it attractive or
structure, where the mesiodistal dimension of the unattractive. An expanse of soft tissue should not
tooth is now considerably narrower (Fig. 10). In be considered to be unaesthetic per se, but the way
attempting to restore this, it becomes necessary to this soft tissue is arranged relative to the teeth and
prepare the tooth and the tissue in such a way that lips is of aesthetic concern. Continuity of linear
an emergence profile can be developed from deep horizontal form between the gingival expanse, the
within the sulcus to avoid lateral horizontal teeth and the upper lip is critical. Any asymmetry
extensions from the preparation line on the in this parallelism disturbs the sense of balance in
narrower root surface to the desired wider form of the composition, disturbing the flow and results in
the restoration. If there is a dramatic diminution of an unaesthetic smile (Fig. 12).
the mesiodistal width of the root at the original By this definition, a high lipline in itself may not
gingival level versus the desired level, then be unaesthetic if these basic rules are followed.
orthodontics may be the treatment of choice. However, in today's mass media-influenced
culture, many people consider eventhe slightest
excessive display of gingival tissue - the "gummy
The lips smile" - unattractive.
The gummy smile or high lipline case with an
The lips form the frame of a smile and as such, de- expanse of soft tissue can result from two basic
fine the aesthetic zone. Liplines have classically problems:
been defined as being high, medium or low (6).
altered passive eruption
In the typical low lipline, only a portion of the
vertical maxillary excess.
teeth are exposed below the inferior border of the
upper lip. The definitive diagnosis of the problem determines
The high lipline shows a large expanse of gingiva the treatment.
extending from the inferior border of the upper lip One of the clinical criteria in determining which
to the free-gingival margin. of these two factors is responsible for a "gummy
20
Primiples of .aesthetic
~-
diagnosis
21
Garber & Salama
Fig. 11. Computer simulation showing a smile with the var- a large dimension between the free gingival margin and the
ious components in harmony. The incisal edge line follows cementoenamel junction, as well as space between cemen-
the form of the lower lip - while the line joining the tops of toenamel junction and the osseous crest for insertion of the
the free gingival margins form the upper lip. The teeth bi- biological width. The green line on the teeth is indicative of
laterally extend to fill the vestibules to the commissures of the preoperative level of the free gingival margin.
the lips. Fig. 14. A gingivectomy was performed to elevate the level
Fig. 12. A preoperative maxillary anterior reconstruction in of the free gingival margin - developing a more proportion-
place showing the lack of harmony between the various ate form for the teeth, as well as removing an excessive dis-
components of the smile, the teeth, the lips, and the gin- play of gingiva below the inferior border of the upper lip.
giva. The gingival line is diametrically opposed before the Fig. 15. Postoperative healing of the gingivectomy as well
maxillary arch. Note the harmony developed in the postop- as orthodontic repositioning of the right central incisor
erative case between the lips, the teeth, and the gingival without closing the diastema provides for bonding in equal
scaffold. amounts between the two central incisor without closing
Fig. 13. Preoperative view showing rather short, squat teeth the diastema.
in which the height is inadequate relative to the width. Peri- Fig. 16. Preoperative view of smile showing short nonpro-
odontal bone-sounding via the sdcus indicates that there is portionate teeth as well as an excessive display of gingiva.
22
Principles of aesthetic diagnosis
smile" relates to the basic shape of the teeth. If the cementoenamel junction of the tooth. In
teeth appear to be somewhat short and squat - subcategory A, the dimension between the level of
meaning that the vertical dimension appears to be the cementoenamel junction and the osseous crest
too short as compared with the horizontal is greater than 1 mm, which is sufficient for the
dimension, the gummy smile is probably due to insertion of the connective tissue fibrous
altered passive eruption. attachment component of the biological width. In
If, however, the silhouette form of the tooth subcategory B, detected by the process of bone
appears to be normal and an expanse of tissue is sounding via the sulcus, the osseous crest occurs in
exposed below the inferior border of the upper lip, close proximity to the cementoenamel junction,
this is probably due to an overgrowth of the maxilla thereby diminishing the space for the insertion of
in a vertical dimension or a vertical maxillary the connective tissue of the biological width.
excess. The biological width, which comprises the
In many situations, the gummy smile may be a junction epithelium, the connective tissue fibrous
combination of these two factors. attachment and the sulcus, is considered to be an
inviolate parameter. This implies that the
biological width should not be impinged upon by
The gummy smile - altered passive restorative endeavors. Based on early necropsy
eruption studies, the average dimensions of the biological
width were considered to be approximately 2.7 mm
Altered passive eruption is an aberration in normal - about 1 mm for the junctional epithelium, 1 mm
development where a large portion of the ana- for the connective tissue attachment and 1 mm for
tomic crown remains covered by the gingiva. This the sulcus. In clinical practice, we have found this
complicates developing dentofacial harmony for to be a more varied dimension often exceeding the
two dominant reasons: 3 mm average.
The tissue being positioned coronally on the
teeth results in a silhouette form that is unattrac- Treatment of type I - altered passive eruption
tive. There is only a nominal degree of scallop to
The typical case of altered passive eruption type I-
the free gingival margin, resulting in a tooth
A exhibits short, square-looking teeth and an ex-
shape that is somewhat square instead of a more
panse of gingiva below the inferior border of the
attractive elliptical or ovoid form.
upper lip. A needle probing of the osseous crest
The excess soft tissue tends to be displayed
through the gingival sulcus detects a distance be-
below the inferior border of the upper lip, com-
tween the cementoenamel junction and the 0s-
plicating the desired relationship in that it makes
seous crest that is sufficient to maintain the biolog-
a potentially medium lipline into a high lipline.
ical width (Fig. 13). A gingivectomy using scalpel,
Altered passive eruption has been classified into electrosurgery or carbon dioxide laser will readily
two distinct types (4). remove this tissue. The tissue should be removed
In type I, there is typically an excessive amount cervically in order not to compromise the inter-
of gingiva, as measured from the free gingival dental papillae. This procedure will result in a re-
margin to the mucogingivaljunction. vised silhouette form for the tooth (Fig. 14) that is
In type 11, there is a normal dimension of gingiva more elliptical and attractive and will resolve the
when measured from the free gingival margin to unwarranted excessive display of gingiva apparent
the mucogingival junction. Although these might during smiling (Fig. 15).
appear to be clinically similar in that there is tissue
extended over the coronal portion of the tooth,
Altered passive eruption - type I-B
therapeutically the diagnosis between the two
types is essential to determine the appropriate Diagnosis is confusing in this subcategory, as the
treatment modality. clinical appearance is similar, with an excessive
Type I can be further subdivided on an amount of gingiva from the free gingival margin to
anatomical histological basis into sub-categories A the mucogingival junction readily shown during
and B. This subclassification depends on the smiling (Fig. 16). On bone sounding via the sulcus,
relationship of the osseous crest to the it would appear that the osseous crest is at the
23
Garber & Salama
Fig. 17. The bone-sounding process viewed by making a ence of interdental papillae and realigning the gingival
submarginal incision, leaving the free gingival margin in margin optimally, not with the cementoenamel junction,
place while elevating mucoperiosteal full-thickness flaps. but with the drape of the upper lip.
With a probe in place, the dimension from the free gingival Fig. 21. Postoperative early healing of the case following
margin to the cementoenamel junction and level of the os- the second stage of electrosurgery. Compare with Fig. 16
seous crest is evident. and note the more proportionate teeth as well as the di-
Fig. 18.The osseous has been redeveloped apicallywith the minished amount of gingival display.
form following and paralleling the rise and fall of the ce- Fig. 22. Lateral oblique view of a patient with vertical max-
mentoenamel junctions typical of this genetic phenotype. illary excess in combination with altered passive eruption.
Fig. 19. The flaps coapted and sutured in position just in- The green line on the gingiva indicates the extent of the re-
cisal to the cementoenamel junction quired gingivectomy to develop gingival harmony as well
Fig. 20. Following initial healing of the flap procedure, a as optimal tooth proportion. The black lines on the incisal
gingivectomylgingivoplasty is performed as part of the edges denote the tooth structure to be removed in cosmetic
two-stage procedure using electrosurgery to fine-tune the contouring to develop ideal embrasure form and incisal
harmony of the free gingival margin, ensuring the pres- edge line.
24
-
Principles_of_aesthetic diagnosis
_ _ _ _ _ ~ ~ ~
Table 3. Treatment of the gummy smile: altered passive eruption or vertical maxillary excess
Condition 'Ikeatment options -
_~ __ __ -.
Altered passive eruption
-
type 1-A Gingivectomy
_ __
Altered passive eruption_type 1-B Flap with osseous resection
- __________-
___
Vertical maxillary excess - degree 1 Orthodontics
Orthodontics and periodontics
Periodonties
- ____
Periodontics
_ _
and restorative dentistry
Vertical maxillary excess - degree 2 Periodontics and restorative dentistry
Orthognathic
__ -
surgery _ _____
_ _ _ _
Vertical maxillary excess - degree 3 Orthognathicsurgery plus periodontics and
restorative dentistry where necessary
25
Garber & Salama
_.__
26
Principles of aesthetic diagnosis
27
Garber & Salama - -- -
28