Trincomalee EIA English Volume-I
Trincomalee EIA English Volume-I
Trincomalee EIA English Volume-I
for
(January, 2015)
Consultant:
Mantec Consultants (Pvt.) Ltd., New Delhi
(An ISO 9001-2008 Certified Company)
Project Proponent:
Environmental Impact Assessment Report for Trincomalee Thermal
Power Project (2x250 MW)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Table of Contents i
List of Tables ix
List of Figures xiv
List of Annexures xx
List of Abbreviations xxi
CHAPTER - 1: INTRODUCTION
Section Title Page
No.
1.1 Background of the Project 1-1
1.2 Objective and Justification of the Project 1-11
1.3 Objective of the EIA Report 1-13
1.4 Extent and Scope of the EIA Study 1-15
1.5 Brief Outline of the Methodologies Adopted in the EIA Report 1-17
1.6 Government Policy regarding related Sectoral Development 1-17
1.7 Compliance with Existing Plans 1-19
1.8 Approvals/ Permits Needed and Any Conditions Already Laid 1-19
Down for the Implementation of the Proposed Project by
State Agencies
1.9 Conformity with International Conventions/ Protocols 1-25
List of Tables
LIST OF FIGURES
3.3 Annual wind rose diagram at Sampoor site based on data 3-7
recorded by CEB
3.4 Surface Water Sampling Location 3-11
3.5 Ground Water Sampling Location 3-20
3.6 Locations for Ground Water Sampling by LHI (2012) 3-25
3.7 Areas covered under the LHI bathymetric surveys 3-27
3.8 Bathymetry of the project area 3-28
3.9 Locations for water level and current measurements 3-29
3.10 Seasonal Wave Rose Diagrams (2007 - 2012) _ Offshore _ 3-34
Overall Waves(a) SW Monsoon (May to Sep) (b) NE
Monsoon (Dec to Feb)
3.11 Vector Plot for Current Flow around Proposed Plant Area: NE 3-38
Monsoon, Spring Tide & Peak Conditions (Wind & Wave) a)
Existing Environment (b) With Proposed Inflow and Outflow
3.12 Vector Plot for Current Flow around Proposed Plant Area: SW 3-39
Monsoon, Spring Tide & Peak Conditions (Wind & Wave) (a)
Existing Environment (b) With Proposed Inflow and Outflow
3.13 Vector Plot for Current Flow around Proposed Plant Area SW 3-40
Monsoon, Spring Tide & Peak Conditions (Wind & Wave) (a)
With Proposed Intake Structure (Option 1) and outfall (b)
With Proposed Intake Structure (Option 2) and outfall
3.14 Locations of sea bed sampling 3-41
3.15 Locations of sampling for suspended sediment 3-42
concentrations
3.16 Vector Plot for Sediment Transport Field around Proposed 3-44
Plant Area: NE Monsoon, Spring Tide & Peak Conditions
(Wind & Wave) (a) Existing Environment (b) With Proposed
Inflow and Outflow
3.17 Vector Plot for Sediment Transport Field around Proposed 3-45
Plant Area: SW Monsoon, Spring Tide & Peak Conditions
(Wind & Wave) (a) Existing Environment (b) With Proposed
Inflow and Outflow
3.18 Vector Plot for Sediment Transport Field around Proposed 3-46
Plant Area: SW Monsoon, Spring Tide & Peak Conditions
(Wind & Wave) (a) With Proposed Intake Structure (Option
1) and outfall (b) With Proposed Intake Structure (Option 2)
and outfall
3.19 Sea Water Quality Sampling Locations 3-49
3.20 Geology of Trincomalee (Modified after Cooray, 1982) 3-52
3.21 Soil Sampling Location in study area 3-54
3.22 Air monitoring Location 3-58
3.23 Noise Level Monitoring Stations in the Study Area 3-70
3.24 Habitat Map of the Study Area 3-73
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
DD Data Deficient
DE/DS Dust Extraction and Dust Suppression
Deg C/ oC Degree Celsius
DFC Department of Forest Conservation
DG Diesel Generator, Director General
DHI Danish Hydraulic Institute
DM Plant De-mineralization Plant
DMP Disaster Management Plan
DO Dissolved Oxygen
DS Divisional Secretariat
DSD Divisional Secretariat Division
DWLC Department of Wildlife Conservation
E Endemic
ECC Emergency Control Centre
EIA Environment Impact Assessment
EMC Environmental Monitoring Committee
EMP Environment Management Plan
EN Endangered
EOI Expression of Interest
Ep Epiphyte
EPC Engineering, Procurement, Construction
EPL Environmental Protection License
ESP Electrostatic Precipitator
FBC Fluidized bed combustion
FGD Flue Gas Desulphurization
FM Flexible Mesh
FTMA Fly Ash and Technology Management Associates, Noida
(India)
FW Fresh Water
G&D Gauge and Discharge
g/s, g/sec Gram per second
GCE A/L General Certificate of Education- Advance Level
GCE O/L General Certificate of Education- Ordinary Level
GCV Gross Calorific Value
GD Group Discussion
GGH Gas-Gas Heater
GHG Greenhouse Gas
GIS Gas Insulated System
GJ Giga Joules
GLC Ground Level Concentration
GN Grama Niladari
GNDs Grama Niladari Divisions
GoSL, GOSL Government of Sri Lanka
GPS Global Positioning System
GRP Glass Reinforced Plastic
GW Ground Water
GWh Giga Watt Hour
H Hydrogen
H Herbaceous
H2S Hydrogen Sulphide
Ha Hectare
HA Habit
HBFC Hydro-bromo-fluoro-carbon
HCFC Hydro-chloro-fluoro-carbon
HCSD High Concentration Slurry Disposal
HDPE High Density Poly Ethylene
MANTEC CONSULTANTS (P) LTD., NEW DELHI Table of Contents, Page-xxii
Environmental Impact Assessment Report for Trincomalee Thermal
Power Project (2x250 MW)
HFC Hydro-Fluoro-Carbon
HFL High Flood Level
HNB Hatton National Bank
HRSG Heat Recovery Steam Generator
HT High Tension
HVAC Heating Ventilation and Air Conditioning
ID Fan Induced Draft Fan
IDCT Induced Draft Cooling Towers
IEA International Energy Agency
IEC International Electro-Technical Commission
IEE Initial Environmental Examination
IGCC Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle
ISCST3 Industrial Source Complex Simple Terrain Rev. 3
ITI Industrial Technology Institute
IUCN International Union for Conservation of Nature
JV Joint Venture
JVC Joint Venture Company
JVSHA Joint Venture and Share Holding Agreement
Kcal/kg Kilo Calorie per Kilogram
Kcal/kWh Kilocalorie per kilowatt hour
kg/cm2 Kilogram per Square Centimeter
kg/h, kg/hr Kilogram per Hour
Kl, KL Kilolitre
Km Kilometre
Km/h, km/hr Kilometre per hour
kPa Kilo Pascal
kTOE kilo Tonne of Oil Equivalent
kV Kilo Volt
kWh Kilo Watt Hour
LA Local Authority
LAD Lanka Auto Diesel
LC Least Concern
LCCL Lanka Coal Company (Private) Limited, Sri Lanka
Ld Daytime Leq that has computed from 6.00 am to 18.00 pm
Leq 24 hourly equivalent continuous noise level
LHI Lanka Hydraulic Institute Limited, Sri Lanka
LIT Line Intercept Transect
Ln Night time Leq that is computed from 18.00 pm to 6.00 am
LNG Liquefied Natural Gas
LOI Loss on Ignition
LPCD Liters per capita per day
LSI Langelier Saturation Index
LT Low Tension
LTGEP Long Term Generation Expansion Plan
LUCF Land-use Change and Forestry
m Meter
m/s, m/sec Meter per second
m3/day Cubic Meter per Day
m3/h, m3/hr Cubic Meter per Hour
Mantec Mantec Consultants (Pvt.) Limited
Max. Maximum
MB Mixed Bed
mbar milli Bar
MCC Motor Control Centre
MCM Million Cubic Meter
MEA Multilateral Environmental Agreements
MANTEC CONSULTANTS (P) LTD., NEW DELHI Table of Contents, Page-xxiii
Environmental Impact Assessment Report for Trincomalee Thermal
Power Project (2x250 MW)
Executive Summary
1. Introduction
1.1 Trincomalee Thermal Power Plant (TTPP) (2x250 Mega Watts (MW)) will be
implemented by Trincomalee Power Company Limited (TPCL), a Joint Venture
Company (JVC) of Ceylon Electricity Board (CEB) and NTPC Limited (NTPC) with
equal (50:50) partnership. The proposed site for the project is located near
Sampoor village in Koddiyar Pattu of the Divisional Secretariat (DS) Division of
Mutur, in District Trincomalee in Eastern Province of Sri Lanka was identified for
the project. The site is bounded by villages named Soodaikuda, Sampukkali,
Kadatkaraichenai and Koonithivu and situated at 08°29′10″N Latitude and
81°18′00″E Longitude at about 35 km from the Trincomalee by road. Vicinity map
of the project is presented at Figure-1.1. The project site can be approached from
Trincomalee –Batticaloa state highway.
1.2 Implementation of Trincomalee Thermal Power Project is in line with the National
Energy Policy and Strategies of Sri Lanka, Trincomalee Metro Urban Area
Development Plan (2007) prepared by Urban Development Authority of the Govt.
of Sri Lanka as well as Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) Study (2008)
undertaken by Central Environmental Authority (CEA).
1.3 The present Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) report has been prepared
by M/s Mantec Consultants (Pvt.) Limited, New Delhi with inputs from local
experts in the areas of oceanography, terrestrial ecology, marine ecology and
social environment, Lanka Hydraulic Institute and Industrial Technology Institute
as per the Terms of Reference (TOR) approved by CEA of Sri Lanka.
1.4 The geographical extent of the study area for the purpose of EIA Study has been
defined by CEA as: 20km for the air quality assessment and 2 km for all other
aspects; 500m from the boundaries of offshore/onshore structures or area of
maximum risk; 100m on either side of proposed pipeline routes or area of
maximum risk.
mention here that this requirement is not on a continuous basis, but for short
durations of initial start-up and flame stabilization.
2.3 During operation phase, the entire water requirement of the project shall be met
from the sea water to be drawn from Koddiyar Bay (at a location 700 m from
shore and at a depth of 7 m). The total water requirement for the Project is
estimated to be 93,120 m3/hr. Sea water shall be used for cooling and flue gas
desulphurization. A desalination plant shall be established to meet the sweet
water requirement of the project. However, during construction phase of the
project, ground water is proposed to be extracted to meet the water requirement
of the project (peak requirement 350 m3/day).
2.4 Major components of the power project are Coal Handling and Storage Plant, Fuel
Oil Handling and Storage Plant, Water Intake and Treatment Systems, Steam
Generator and its auxiliaries, Steam Turbine and its auxiliaries, Condenser and
auxiliary cooling system, ash handling plant, Electrical Generators, Transformers
and Switchyard, various control and instrumentation systems etc. Construction of
project shall involve various site development activities such as site clearance,
leveling and fencing, boundary wall and approach roads/ internal roads, storm
water drains & sewer lines, domestic water supply system, sewage treatment
plant, development of green belt, afforestation and landscaping activities etc. A
township with various residential and non-residential facilities is proposed to be
constructed adjacent to the project to house the staff of TPCL, Security Forces.
2.5 Trincomalee Thermal Power Project shall be provided with the following facilities:
a. Well equipped security system.
b. Facilities for fire fighting, communication, emergency power supply,
emergency safety equipment, alarms etc.
c. Comprehensive fire detection and protection system.
d. A township comprising of various residential buildings for Staff of TPCL and
Security Persons and non-residential buildings (such as Field Hostel, Guest
House, Hospital, Commercial facilities, School, Security related facilities etc.)
as well as infrastructural facilities.
2.6 The Transmission (Power evacuation) system for the project shall be provided by
CEB, for which environmental clearance has already been accorded. The
construction power and startup power for the project shall also be provided by
CEB.
February. The winds are generally light to moderate. The predominant wind
direction is from South West followed by South East, West, West South West,
North West and East.
3.3 Mahaweli Ganga is the main river in the region, which falls in Koddiyar Bay at a
distance of about 7 km. from the project. Besides Koddiyar bay on the north-west
and Indian ocean on the east, there are lagoons and numerous kulam in the
study area. The biggest lagoon is Ullacklie located on the south-east of the study
area followed by Kaddaiparichan lagoon. Ilakkantai, Ullai and Kayiavandan are
the major kulam in the study area.
3.4 Surface and ground water quality monitoring indicate that the physio-chemical
characteristics of Ilakkantai kulam and Mahaweli are very good, conforming to
drinking water standards of Sri Lanka. However, bacteriological contamination
has been observed in the water samples taken from the Villu kulam and
Ilakkantai kulam. The physio-chemical characteristics of ground water from all
the four locations monitored are found to be well within the prescribed limits. No
bacterial contamination has been found.
3.5 The construction and operation activities of the project will generate various types
of effluents, which may alter the water quality and ecology of the receiving water
body, if not managed properly. In order to control the quality of the effluent and
minimize the impacts on water bodies, the following are proposed
3.5.1 During construction phase, the effluents from construction site and
labour colonies shall be treated separately in settling tanks and package
type sewage treatment plants respectively and treated effluents shall be
used for horticulture, dust suppression etc. Unutilised part of the
treated effluents shall be discharged in Koddiyar Bay. The effluents shall
conform to the ‘Tolerance Limits for Discharge of Industrial and
Domestic Waste Water into Inland Surface Waters’ published under
National Environmental Act of Sri Lanka
3.5.2 During operation phase, the warm cooling water along with the effluents
from flue gas desulphurization and other treated effluents, conforming
to the ‘Tolerance Limits for Discharge of Industrial and Domestic Waste
Water into Marine Coastal Areas’ published under National
Environmental Act of Sri Lanka shall be discharged into Shell Bay
through a well designed outfall structure. The combined effect of
vertical rise and mixing due to buoyancy and lateral dispersion and
movements due to currents shall minimize the impacts of disposal of
waste water on the temperature and water quality of sea. It has already
been established through detailed thermal dispersion modeling studies
undertaken through Lanka Hydraulic Institute. Results of modeling are
discussed in detail in the Para 3.40 and 3.41.
3.5.3 Coal pile areas and Oil storage areas shall be provided with
impermeable surface and garland drains/ dykes to collect and treat the
effluents from these areas, so that these effluents do not contaminate
the surface/ ground water. Treated supernatant shall be recycled back
into the system.
3.6 The area consists of non-lateritic loamy soils. Among the other important soil
types are the alluvial that occur along the lower courses of rivers and the regosols
(sandy soils) of the coastal tracts. The soil is sandy loam in texture at most of the
locations.
3.7 Ambient air quality was monitored at five locations around the project. The area
observes Particulate Matter less than 10 micrometer in size (PM10) in the range of
56- 88µg/m3; Particulate Matter less than 2.5 micrometer in size (PM2.5) in the
range of 20- 38µg/m3; Sulphur Dioxide (SO2) in the range of 6-13 µg/m3;
Nitrogen Oxide (NO2) in the range of 10-24 µg/m3; Ozone (O3) in the range of
20-39.0 µg/m3; and Carbon Mono-oxide (CO) in the range of 100-900 µg/m3. All
the parameters are well within the National Ambient Air Quality Standards
(NAAQS) of Sri Lanka.
3.8 The construction and operation activities of the project will generate various types
of air emissions, which may alter the air quality of the surrounding, if not
controlled properly. In order to control the air emissions and minimize the
impacts on environment, the following are proposed
3.8.1 During construction phase, there will be increased vehicular movement
for transportation of various construction materials to the project site
and disposal of construction waste at the dumping site. The movement
of vehicles may lead to dust emissions and marginal increase in
Hydrocarbons, SO2 and NOx levels. However, the ground level
emissions do not travel for long distances and hence these impacts shall
be localized and temporary in nature. Suitable mitigation measures shall
be taken to prevent the dust emissions due to vehicular movement;
transport, handling and storage of construction materials like sand, fine
aggregate and transport, handling and storage of excavated earth and
construction wastes. The measures include water sprinkling in
vulnerable areas, transportation of construction material in covered
trucks, wherever possible, proper maintenance of vehicles and haulage
roads etc.
3.8.2 During operation phase, the emission of flue gas from stack generated
due to combustion of coal shall be the main source of pollution. Air
pollution control measures such as high efficiency Electro Static
Precipitators (ESPs) to limit the particulate emission in flue gas to 100
mg/Nm3, Design of furnace to control the formation of oxides of
nitrogen, Sea water Flue Gas Desulphurisation system to limit the
emission of SO2 in the flue gases, 135 m high twin flue stack to
facilitate wider dispersion of flue gases are proposed to be installed.
3.9 The impacts of flue gas emission on the ambient air quality were predicted using
computer based mathematical models and meteorological data. The results of the
analysis indicate that the resultant maximum 24 hourly average ground level
concentrations of SO2 and NOx after operation of the project shall be about 35
and 50 µg/m3, against National Ambient Air Quality Standards of 80 and 100
µg/m3 for SO2 and NOx respectively. Thus there will be enough margins for future
development of industries in the area. The results of the predictions were
validated by Industrial Technology Institute (ITI), Colombo using a different
model and it was confirmed that the proposed power plant, operating with the
designed parameters and pollution control systems, shall conform to the National
Ambient Air Quality Standards.
3.10 Handling of coal and ash during operation phase of the project may result in
emission of fugitive dust. Dust extraction/ dust suppression (DE/ DS) systems
shall be provided in coal handling plant (CHP) and coal stock yard for control of
fugitive dust emissions. Ash handling and storage areas shall also be provided
with suitable measures for control of fugitive emissions. The provision of green
belt around the project shall further help in controlling the fugitive emissions.
3.11 A Plan has been prepared to utilize the entire ash generated in the project due to
combustion of coal. Fly ash (fine ash) is proposed to be used for manufacture of
cement and ready mix concrete while bottom ash (coarse ash) is proposed to be
used in construction of roads and embankments. Market surveys and call for
expression of interest indicate that the potential for ash utilization is very high in
Sri Lanka. The systems for supply of ash, such as dry extraction, storage silos
and unloading system have already been included in the project.
3.12 Unutilised quantity of ash during short periods of interruptions in demand/ supply
shall be disposed off in a well designed ash dyke located adjacent to the project
area using High Concentration Slurry Disposal (HCSD) system. In HCSD system,
a thick slurry (concentration 50-65% by weight) of ash with water is made, which
will be pumped into the dyke, where it will get solidified within 1-2 days leaving
no free water as supernatant or leachate. The ash disposal area shall be provided
with an earthen dyke all around and impermeable High Density Poly-Ethylene
(HDPE) liner. The water collected from the ash dyke area shall be recycled back
to the ash handling system for re-use. Further, the ash stored in the ash dyke
shall also be used at later stage.
3.13 The workers shall be provided with proper facilities including housing, drinking
water supply and sanitation. In addition, the construction activity will also benefit
the local population through tertiary sector employment and provision of goods
and services for daily needs including transport.
3.14 A noise survey was undertaken at 10 locations during the month of October,
2011. The noise level varied between 45.3 to 54.3 decibel A-weightage (dB (A))
during daytime and 40.1 to 52.7 dB(A) during night time. Typical noise levels
from construction activities and equipment vary from 75-90 dB(A) while
occasionally it may go up to 100 dB(A) during very short periods of time.
Therefore, there could be increase in noise levels during construction phase.
Drilling and blasting operations during construction phase may result in
vibrations. This impact shall be mitigated by adopting controlled blasting and
strict surveillance regime. Noise from the turbines, compressors, pumps, fans,
coal handling plant etc. shall be controlled through the design of the machines,
provision of acoustic enclosures over the sources of noise and provision of
barriers in the form of buildings. Further, provision of green belts around the
plant area shall also help in absorbing the noise generated. Wherever required,
the workers shall be provided with protective equipments such as ear plugs and
ear muffs. Noise levels at the boundary of the project and beyond shall be
maintained within the national standards.
3.15 Access routes to construction sites as well as stretches of roads shall be widened/
strengthened. Necessary manpower and equipment shall be deployed for traffic
management at the identified sites as well as parking space for vehicles. The
vehicles and construction equipment shall be maintained so that their noise and
exhaust emissions do not cause nuisance to the workers and general public.
3.16 Natural drains carrying the storm water runoff from the project area as well as
the surrounding area shall be diverted/ strengthened to mitigate the adverse
impacts.
Terrestrial Environment
3.17 Biogeographically, the proposed project area lies within the low country Dry Zone.
Floristically it is classified under the Dry and Arid Lowlands Floristic Zone and
Coastal and Marine Belt Floristic Zone. Tropical Dry Mixed Evergreen Forests
{Manilkara Community, Mixed community (Chloroxylon-Vitex-Berrya-Schleichera
3.24 The site selected for the project is under high human influence even at present.
During the sampling period it was observed that people in the area are engaged
in fuel wood extraction at the site on a commercial scale. Further, there is illegal
quarrying of the rock outcrops within the project site for extraction of metal.
Further, those who are involved in these activities also hunt animals as was
indicated by the presence of remains of such hunted animals throughout the
project site.
3.25 The construction of the project will result in the loss of approximately 375 acres
(150 ha) scrubland. Based on the species observed at the site, it can be
concluded that the site does not function as a critical habitat or habitat of any
critical species. Further it will not result in fragmentation of habitat or obstruction
of a known migratory pathway of terrestrial species. Therefore, even though the
project will result in the loss of habitat of terrestrial species, it will not have a
significant impact on habitats or species present in the project area.
3.26 As the project will not result in a significant impact on the terrestrial habitats, no
major mitigation measures are recommended. It is recommended that project
proponent establish a green belt around the project (50-100 m in width
depending on the lay out of the project site with an estimated extent of 100
acres) except around the switchyard. The balance empty areas should also be
vegetated with native species.
3.27 Project proponent shall take all steps not to cause any disturbance to the
adjacent wetland (Sampu Kulam) to the project site or carry out any activities
around Foul Point which supports an unique vegetation.
Marine Environment
Koddiyar Bay
3.28 Water for the project (93,120 m3/hour) is proposed to be drawn from Koddiyar
Bay through an Intake Well, Pump House and two pipelines of diameter 2.6 m
each. Construction of these facilities and continuous drawl of water may affect the
ecology of the Koddiyar Bay. Therefore, the ecology of the Koddiyar Bay was
studied in detail.
3.29 Koddiyar Bay comprises of sandy beaches, mangrove patches and estuaries. The
shoreline is fringed with numerous coastal plants and the sandy shore is dwelt by
various burrowing forms of organisms. Squilla, bivalves, ghost crabs and hermit
crabs are the major types of organisms observed in this environment. Part of the
coastline is prone to some erosion/accretion during monsoon periods. The bay is
connected to two main estuaries namely; Mahaweli and Kaddaiparichan Aru.
3.30 Coastal waters of the Koddiyar Bay are extremely turbid throughout the year.
Therefore the bottom of the bay does not get enough sunlight to create a well-
diversified ecosystem. As a result the bottom is covered with very fine clay-sand
mixture with intermittent clumps of unidentified sponges and rare sightings of
worm species. Ray species, demersal fish species, and some molluscs were found
very rarely during the underwater survey. Turbidity is extremely high to the
extent that one cannot see its palm when the hand is fully extended in the water.
Almost all the fish species observed in the Koddiyar bay were small pelagic
species, rare catches of bottom dwelling elasmobranch species and few crab
species.
3.31 Koddiyar bay near Kaddaiparichan is occupied by traditional fishermen and
fiberglass boat fishermen and they engage in gill net fishery. In addition to that,
some parts of the shallow area are occupied by kraal fishing gears. However the
bay is not used for high ended traditional fishing activities, but very much
primitive fishing activities aiming small pelagic fish species.
3.32 During construction activities for pipeline and intake well, temporary increase of
turbidity, re-suspension fine sediments is expected in Koddiyar Bay. Considering
the naturally high turbidity levels prevailing in the Koddiyar Bay, the induced
sedimentation conditions do not cause a significant change in the sediment load
in the water column. Release of trapped toxicants such as H2S can be expected
until the pipe laying process is completed. These conditions may cause some
impacts on biota living in the area of development and in the vicinity. Larger
vertebrates such as fishes are less impacted due to their movability from
hazardous environments. The sustainability of corals in Koddiyar bay seems to be
extremely low due to the high sedimentation regime and salinity changes. Under
water survey and observations confirmed that the coral diversity is very low in
Koddiyar bay, except some coral colonies in remote isolates corners. Therefore,
no impacts on corals are anticipated.
3.33 Koddiyar Bay will be used only for the intake and hence no impacts are envisaged
during operation phase. However, there could be changes in the current patterns
around the intake. Detailed modelling studies carried out by Lanka Hydraulic
Institute indicate that the increase in current velocities drops below 0.1 m/s
within the 10m from the intake. Hence the impacts are local and there will not be
any changes to the macro faunal diversity. Microfaunal diversity may affect
slightly as they are sucked with the inlet current. However the damage seems
minimal due to the low microfaunal (plankton) abundance and diversity in the
water column.
Shell Bay
3.34 Warm cooling water from the project along with effluents from flue gas
desulphurization system and other treated effluents (92,710 m3/hour) is proposed
to be discharged into Shell Bay through a pipeline and an Outfall Structure.
Construction of these facilities and continuous discharge of warm water may
affect the ecology of the Shell Bay. Therefore, the ecology of the Shell Bay was
studied in detail.
3.35 Shell Bay area is covered by a sandy beach that fringes to a dense coastal shrub
and woody vegetation. The sandy beach is relatively less diverse with some
hermit crabs and ghost crabs. Sea bed shows a gradual slope from the coast up
to 15 m and then the slope increases and finally reaches areas deeper than
500m. The bottom surface of the shallow coastal water is covered with scattered
rocks and sandstone boulders. The upper intertidal surfaces of these rocky
boulders are found covered with barnacles (Balanus sp.) and algae species such
as Ulva, Jania, Caulerpa and some filamentous green algae. In addition to that
Littorina, Nodilittorina, Trochus and Chiton sp were found. Sea cucumber species,
Holothuria atra, Holothuria scabra, Unidentified heart urchin and broken thallus of
red algae were found on the sandy substrate where the sand particle sizes
changed from fine to course. Annelid worms, giant clams (Tridacna), pen shell
(Pinna), Spider shell (Lambis lambis) and cushion stars (Culcita sp.) were found
rarely within the bay area.
3.36 Very few fishermen fish in the Shell bay use Hook and line method and crab trap
methods. They use FRP boats during these fishing activities from Soodaikuda
landing site. Crab pots are laid closer to rocky/coral outcrops and leave it
overnight until it trap crab species (including lobsters). Fishermen fix a half rotten
clump of fish at the center of the trap in order to attract fish. However the
damage caused to the environment from these two fishing methods are very low.
3.37 The coral and substrate cover in the Shell bay has not showed even distribution
and the sea bottom of the bays covered by rocky and limestone outcrops. Some
areas were densely populated with corals and some areas were not covered with
corals and other marine invertebrate life even though the bottom is hard. The
average height of these protrusions ranges 0.5 to 1 meters with occasional
boulders that extends up to 3 meters. These surfaces are covered with coralline
algae and red, brown and green encrusting and filamentous algae. Main sticking
feature of the area is the abundance of soft corals of different densities. In these
areas higher sedimentation evidence was shown. Some parts of the bay were
covered with sandy bottom where the size of the sand particles was fine. Number
of organic and solid debris was found accumulated in these sandy patches.
3.38 Corals located in the surrounding areas of the construction sites may undergo
several impacts, such as temporary increase in turbidity, re-suspension of fine
sediments, release of any trapped toxicants such as H2S. These conditions may
cause some impacts on coral and soft coral species. In view of the coral density
and coral cover in the location originally envisaged for outfall in Shell Bay, six
alternate locations were surveyed and the location with lowest coral diversity and
cover was finally selected.
3.39 During the laying of the pipeline in Shell Bay, the bottom substrate along the pipe
line corridors will be impacted. It is expected that a maximum width of 50m along
pipe line traces will be disturbed for actual pipe laying and as a working area.
Corals and marine biodiversity along pipe line traces will be subjected to dredging
and on either side of the trace in the working area may be exposed to some
damages. However the area impacted will be comparatively very small and
mitigation measures are proposed to be taken to reduce these impacts. Further,
animals such as fish, turtles and crabs sp. can disperse to safer areas when they
got stressed. Therefore the impact can be considered extremely small. Effects of
sound pollution could be expected in the vicinity of the construction site. Soft
bodied marine invertebrates, marine algae and eggs may expose partially to
these conditions. However the damage is considered to be very low.
3.40 All larger adult coral boulders of the proposed area, if any, will be transplanted to
a suitable location before commencement of construction. The species will be
selected for this initial transplant from the area where the outlet pipes will be
located, 50 m either sides of the outlet pipe lines and a 50 meter radius at the
outlet structure.
3.41 The impact of construction of pipeline and outfall structure on corals was a major
area of concern. Therefore, the final location of outfall was decided after a series
of thermal modeling by Lanka Hydraulic Institute (LHI) and underwater survey of
a series of locations in Shell Bay. The final location recommended for outfall has a
low coral diversity and low cover. By moving the outfall to the new location
possible impact during the construction has been minimized and could be
considered as extremely low.
3.42 During operation phase, the temperature of the discharged water at the outlet
point will be 70 C higher as compared to the ambient sea water temperature. Due
to the lesser density of the warm water, the discharged water will naturally flow
towards the surface directly from the outlet point. The resulting stratification of
the density and temperature driven water masses are expected to be higher
sustaining the warmer water masses on the surface of the water column at most
of the times. Therefore the bathing of corals and benthic organisms from the
warmer water becomes very low.
3.43 Thermal dispersion was studies in detail by Lanka Hydraulic Institute (LHI). The
results of near field modeling indicate that near field influence zone with excess
temperatures +7oC (at point of discharge) to +2 oC to +4oC (at outer boundary
of influence zone) above ambient is limited to 20m radius from the discharge
point. The results of far field modeling indicate that the far field influence zone
with excess temperature of +2oC is limited to 100m of radius (about 3.14 Ha) for
most of the time. However, an excess temperature of +2oC may exist up to the
180m in one direction (in South West (SW) monsoon considered as worst case) at
one instance from outfall. Influence zone for an excess temperature of +1oC is
limited to 300m-400m of radius (about 50 Ha) for most of the time. However, an
excess temperature of +1oC may exist up to around 500m in one direction (in SW
monsoon considered as worst case) at one instance from outfall. These conditions
would not overlap with whale territories and in any case would not cause any
physiological or behavioral changes even if they migrate into these marginally
warm waters.
3.44 Surface dispersion may not affect corals in sea bottom. There may be positive
and negative impacts on coral sperm, eggs and larvae and their distribution
pattern. However these impacts (either positive or negative) are considered to be
minimal due to the low temperature increase.
3.45 On the other hand, these upward water movements may bring bottom nutrients
to the surface by locally and artificially created upwelling system and the warmer
waters may influence the productivity of the area coupled with higher nutrient
levels. This may induce some positive impacts to the area by increasing the
primary productivity followed by the diversification of the food chains and food
webs in the area.
3.46 Increase of sea water temperature may cause minor impacts to plankton, fish,
molluscs, crustaceans, reptiles and mammals which can tolerate much wider
fluctuations. Further, Tropical members of the latter groups can tolerate
temperatures of about 35° C, without showing sub-lethal symptoms. Therefore it
is expected that this temperature increase do not cause any significant damage to
benthic organisms and even the pelagic organisms are slightly affected from this
less warm water mass due to their ability to move from unfavorable waters only if
the warmer water cause any impact on them.
3.47 Electro chlorination will be used (Hypochlorite) to reduce bio fouling in pipelines
and other surfaces. A de-chlorination plant shall be provided. However, a slightly
elevated residual chlorine levels could be expected in discharged waters. Chlorine
concentration of the discharged water will be maximum 0.2 ppm higher than the
intake water. However, these excess concentrations are well within the standards
given under World Bank guidelines and hence, the impacts are considered to be
low.
3.48 SO4 is added to the discharged water as a result of using Flue Gas
Desulphurisation (FGD) process. In normal sea water, SO4 concentration ranges
from 2300-3000 mg/l. The increase in SO4 concentration of sea water due to FGD
process is expected to be around 33–40 mg/l. The increase in SO4 concentrations
is within the natural range of SO4 concentrations in ambient sea water. Therefore,
the impacts are considered to be low and no mitigation actions are proposed for
SO4 in the effluents.
3.49 There were no rare or threatened species found in the sampling sites. However in
some places, 20-30% of the bottom surface and the species found were Sinularia,
Sarcophyton, and Lobophytum sp. Occasionalcushion stars, Sea cucumbers,
Euphillia corals, Giant clams were recorded but are not considered to be
rare/threatened and endemic.
3.50 The intake and outfall locations are located approximately 25km from the Pigeon
Islands Marine National Park in Sri Lanka with its unique terrestrial and marine
ecosystems. The island is important breeding ground for Rock Pigeon, which is
assigned as critically endangered under International Union for Conservation of
Nature (IUCN) nationally threatened bird list. However the distance to the outlet
and the inlet point are such that they do not have any chance of a negative
impact on its marine bio diversity.
3.51 Trincomalee area is known for Dolphins, whales, especially Blue whale and sperm
whales. However, almost all these sightings are well away from the beaches and
beyond 100m depth contour line. The main areas popular among whale watchers
are closer to Swami Rock area and deeper sites in front of the harbor mouth.
However, research findings indicates that more whales are roaming in area north
of Trincomalee closer to Mulathivu than the southern areas of Trincomalee. The
influence zones of thermal dispersion (as described in Para 3.38 above) would not
overlap with whale territories and in any case would not cause any physiological
or behavioral changes even if they migrate into these marginally warm waters.
3.52 Five species of turtles, namely; Loggerhead (Caretta caretta), Green turtle
(Chelonia mydas), Olive Ridley (Lepidochelys olivacea), Leatherback
(Dermochelys coriacea) and Hawksbill turtle (Eretmochelys imbricata) are
reported to nest along the beaches of Trincomalee. However there are no
published data on the presence and nesting of turtles in Koddiyar and Shell bay
areas.
3.53 In both Koddiyar Bay and Shell Bay some disturbances to the movement of
fishing vessels and fishing activities will occur in areas in close proximity to the
construction sites. However once the construction phase is over, there will not be
any disturbance to the fisheries activities except declaration of a small restricted
areas around intake and outfall structures due to security and safety reasons.
However, no commercial fishery activities have been observed in the vicinity of
intake and outfall of Koddiyar and Shell Bay.
3.54 Proper maintenance and operation of construction equipment are needed to avoid
any possible oil leakages into the waters.
Socio-economic Environment
3.55 The land for the project has already been transferred on lease to TPCL by Govt. of
Sri Lanka. The land is free from human settlements or any other livelihood related
activities except 10 families living beyond 250m distance from the boundary.
There are no other socio economic infrastructure facilities established in the
vicinity of the land. Fisheries and agriculture are the main livelihood activities in
the area. The agriculture is mainly concentrated on shifting cultivation (chena)
and paddy cultivation during Maha seasons under small tanks. The fishing
activities are performed beyond the project facilities in the Koddiyar Bay & Shell
Bay. The main boat landing sites (Kaddaiparichan in Koddiyar Bay and
Soodaikuda in Shell Bay) are located little more than 1 km distance from the
intake and outfall points of the sea.
3.56 The project land is located far from urban centers and also other public and
private institutions in Mutur divisional secretariat. Only a junior school, Sivasakthi
is found in an area within 250m radius from the boundary of project. This place
may have some disturbances during construction and operation phases.
3.57 Even though possible social impacts are not significant, the stakeholders
(communities as well as other agency personnel) perceived different positive and
negative impacts on communities and their livelihood activities. The consultants
observed most of these perceived negative impacts may not be obvious but, need
attention of the project proponent and use modern technology and other
management measures to ensure project implementation without creating
negative impacts on the communities. There will be significant job opportunities
and other indirect sources for income generations for local people. The project
developer will explore all the possible efforts to improve the skill of the local
community and provide job opportunities to the local communities depending on
their suitability.
3.58 The proposed project will be the first large scale development project in Mutur
Divisional secretariat division and it will significantly influence the existing
condition of local economy. The present small urban centers in the vicinity of the
project boundary will get improved. The local community members may explore
possibilities to invest in small and medium scale income generation activities
and even some families may attempt at providing higher education to their
children expecting to reap the opportunities created by the project.
3.59 Significant impacts and their mitigation measures for construction and operation
phases are summarized in Table 1. Adequate financial provisions have been made
in the Project for implementation of various mitigation measures.
Severity of
Impacts
Discipline Impacts Mitigation
Before
Mitigation
Pollution due to Dust and M(-) Sprinkling of water,
vehicular exhausts during Maintenance of Roads and
construction phase Vehicles
Change in air quality due H(-) Selection of coal, Efficiency of
Air Quality
to stack emissions plant, Furnace Design, ESP,
FGD, Tall Stack
Change in air quality due L(-) DE/DS systems, wind
to Fugitive emissions barriers, water sprinkling
Increase in Noise due to M(-) Maintenance of Vehicles and
construction activities Equipment, Regulating
activities, Use of PPE
Noise and Vibrations due to L(-) Control and Surveillance,
Vibrations construction activities Regulating activities
Increase in Noise due to L(-) Design of equipment and
operation activities acoustic covers, PPE, Design
of Buildings, Green Belt
Coastal Change in coast line due to L(-) Proper design of structures
Stability and construction
Sedimen- Change in coast line due to L(-) Proper design of structures
tation operation
Coastal and Destruction of habitats due M(-) Proper location and design of
Marine to offshore structure structures
Environment Local increase in turbidity H(-) Silt screens
Severity of
Impacts
Discipline Impacts Mitigation
Before
Mitigation
Loss of Fauna, Flora and L(-) Proper location of structures
Sensitive Eco-Systems
Impacts of water L(-) Proper location and design of
extraction (current/ structures with screens
impingement)
Impacts of warm water M(-) Proper location and design of
discharge structures
Impacts of Discharge of L(-) Treatment, Dilution with
effluents Cooling water
Impacts of Oil spills/ coal L(-) Containment and Treatment
pile run-off
Overall Impacts on coral L(-) Proper location and design of
reefs, marine organisms structures
and marine mammals
Loss of Habitat L(-) Retention of scrub land to the
extent possible, Development
of Green Belt and
Terrestrial
Afforestation within and
Ecosystems
around project area
Loss of Fauna, Flora and L(-) Plantation of vulnerable plant
Sensitive Eco-Systems species in green belt
Obstructions to drainage/ L(-) Improvement in drainage
Flooding channel from Sampukkali to
Hydrological
Kaddaiparichan lagoon
& drainage
Change in Surface and L(-) Treatment, recycle and reuse
pattern,
Ground Water Quality of effluents, Disposal in sea
Water
along with warm water
Bodies
Soil erosion and Siltation M(-) Peripheral drains with settling
during construction basins
Loss of land/ home/ L(-) Preference to local people in
livelihood employment
Public safety/ security M(-) Traffic management,
Deployment of security
agencies/ systems, Disaster
Management
Impacts on fishing due to L(-) Cordoning off the area,
construction activities Proper signage (No fishing
activity in construction
areas).
Impacts on fishing due to L(-) Cordoning off the area,
operation activities Proper signage (No fishing
Social activity in construction
Environment areas).
Employment and Income H(+) Preference to local people in
employment, Capacity
Building
Conflicts between locals L(-) Engagement of local persons
and migrant population in project activities and
social-cultural programmes,
Awareness about the project
activities, Deployment of
security systems
Health L(-) Extension of health care to
locals through dispensary and
health camps
After the successful implementation of mitigation, it is expected that all the impacts
will reduce to acceptable limits.
4. Contingency Plans
4.1 As per the requirements of Sri Lanka Disaster Management Act (Act No. 13 of
2005), a generic On-site Disaster Management Plan (DMP) for Trincomalee Thermal
Power Project has been prepared. At the time of commissioning of the project, a
detailed and site specific Disaster Management Plan shall be prepared and
submitted to National Council for Disaster Management for approval and the same
shall be implemented at site. Being a coastal project, Trincomalee Thermal Power
Project also needs to be geared up for any occurrence of tsunami. The project shall
have linkage with the Indian Ocean Tsunami Warning System and other tsunami
warning systems of Sri Lanka. The risks of tsunami shall be kept in consideration
during detailed design and construction of the project and systems for emergency
preparedness in case of tsunami shall be provided.
4.2 The responsibility for establishing and maintaining a safe working environment for
all its employees and people in the surrounding area rests with TPCL, which will
take all such steps which are reasonably practicable to ensure best possible
conditions of work.
5. Monitoring Programme
5.1 There are two principal types of monitoring, namely:
Compliance Monitoring to confirm the effective implementation of
mitigation measures and
Impact Confirmation Monitoring to confirm the assumptions made in the
EIA process.
5.2 A well structured monitoring programme has been proposed to ensure both
Compliance and Impact Confirmation Monitoring to high degree of efficiency.
However, the programme shall be further strengthened after accord on
environmental clearance to the project, to include project specific stipulations, if
any and also, during the course of construction and operation of the project,
based on actual experience/ impacts.
5.3 It is recommended that an Environmental Monitoring Committee (EMC) be
appointed to oversee the implementation of the Monitoring Plan. The EMC shall be
chaired by a representative from the Central Environmental Authority (CEA) or
the Coast Conservation and Coastal Resource Management Department
(CC&CRMD), in view of the fact the project’s interaction with the coastal zone.
Appointees to the EMC shall be approved by the Central Environmental Authority
and include representatives from key stakeholders.
5.4 The EMC will have regular meetings, once in every three months during
construction phase and once in very six months during operation phase, in order
to review the monitoring. In areas of potential conflict, the EMC will have
responsibility to resolve such issues.
5.5 The EMC in consultation with the Project Proponent shall develop a mechanism to
manage, investigate, respond and act upon, any issues raised by the public
during construction.
Sri Lanka
1. Introduction
Selection of Site
CEB and NTPC jointly explored several sites for setting up the proposed power
project in Trincomalee region and a site near Sampoor village in Trincomalee
district was identified for Feasibility Study. This site is one of the sites identified
and assessed by the Central Environmental Authority (CEA) during Strategic
Environmental Assessment undertaken by them through University of Moratuwa
(UOM) in 2008 (SEA, 2008). Alternate sites identified in the SEA Report for
Thermal Power Project are presented in Figure 1.1. Based on various techno-
economical and environmental considerations, two alternatives - Sampoor and
Sampalthive areas were selected for detailed analysis. These alternatives were
also included in Trincomalee Metro Urban Area Development Plan (2007)
prepared by Urban Development Authority of the Govt. of Sri Lanka and their
relative merits and demerits were studied under SEA (2008).
SEA (2008) recommends Sampoor area for power development over Sampalthive
area, because of inherent advantages of Sampoor Site including the fact that
deep water of Koddiyar Bay will be an asset when considering the transport of
coal and minimizing the adverse impacts caused by thermal stress and damage to
marine environment. A comparison of the two sites, as covered in SEA (2008) is
presented in Table 1.1.
Table 1.1: Comparison of Alternate Sites by Central Environmental
Authority (SEA, 2008)
Factor Sampoor Site Sampalthive Site
Land area available Large space available Restricted space, limited
room for expansion
Need for Already evacuated and Resettlement plans needed
resettlement of resettlement in progress
people
Access for coal Conventional sea access No suitable site for jetty
unloading with appropriate depths for nearby, as the sea is
coal imports. Site for jetty shallow and the marine
already identified ecosystem is vulnerable.
Environmental Risk Protection for any hazards Limited area would be a
Management could be included due to the constraint
relatively large land area
available.
Discharge of The site does not contain Site is very close to the
Cooling Water large coral reefs. However, Pigeon Island National Park.
discharge of cooling water Discharge of cooling water
has to be done after careful will be a major problem, as
planning. The added this area contains extensive
advantage of this site will reef habitats. Migration of
be the deep water trench, species and requirement of
where the cooling water organisms to maintain
outfall can be placed to viable population for
achieve a much higher breeding colonies may be
initial dilution, thus affected if shallow water
minimizing the impacts on reef habitats are destroyed
marine ecosystem. due to temperature changes
caused by cooling water
discharge
The final site for the proposed power plant is situated at 08°29′10″N Latitude
and 81°18′00″E Longitude near Sampoor village of Trincomalee district of Eastern
Province of Sri Lanka. The site is about 35 km from the Trincomalee by road. The
vicinity map is placed as Figure - 1.2.
Alternate Sites
The major findings of the Long Term Generation Expansion Plan can be
summarized as follows:
Biomass or fuel wood, petroleum and hydro are the major primary energy
supply sources, which cater to the energy demand of Sri Lanka.
Biomass or fuel wood, which is mainly a non-commercial fuel provides close to
46 percent of the country’s total energy requirement.
Petroleum is the major source of commercial energy, which covers more than
42 percent of the energy demand.
Hydropower is the main indigenous source of primary commercial electrical
energy in Sri Lanka with an estimated potential of about 2000 MW, of which
more than half has already been harnessed. Further exploitation of hydro
resources is becoming increasingly difficult owing to social and/or
environmental impacts associated with large-scale developments as well as
the cost factor.
As at present, Sri Lanka has no proven resources of fossil fuels and the total
fossil fuel requirement of the country is imported either as crude oil or as
refined products. A small quantity of Peat has been located in the extent of
marshy lands to the North of Colombo. However, the quality and extent of the
reserve would not prove to be commercially viable for extraction and use as a
source in power generation.
Apart from these, there is a possibility of developing wind resources to some
extent for power generation.
By the end of 2012, about 93% of the population had access to electricity
from the national electricity grid. When the planned electrification schemes
are implemented it is expected to increase further.
The average per capita electricity consumption in Sri Lanka was 480 Kilo Watt
Hour (kWh)/ person in 2011 and generally it has been rising steadily with an
average growth rate of 6.9% during 2001-07. However, during 2007-08, with
the slowing of electricity growth, the per capita consumption stagnated but
the increase was observed again during 2009-11.
In early stages, the electricity demand of the country was mainly supplied by
the hydro generation and the contribution from thermal power generation was
minimal. However, at present the thermal generation is much higher than that
of hydro.
The statistics of power generation in Sri Lanka for 2012 and 2013 is
summarized in Table 1.2:
Table 1.2: Statistics of Power Generation in Sri Lanka for 2012 and 2013
OWNERSHIP & NO. OF INSTALLED Gross
SOURCE POWER CAPACITY IN Generation
STATIONS MW in Giga Watt
Hour (GWh)
2012 2013 2012 2013 2012 2013
CEB Total 25 25 2214 2228 6162 8808
Hydro 17 17 1357 1361 2727 6010
Thermal 7 7 854 864 3433 2795
Wind 1 1 3 3 2 2
PPP Total 134 155 1098 1134 5640 3154
Hydro-Small 109 131 227 267 565 916
Thermal 8 7 784 771 4906 1977
NCRE 17 17 87 96 169 260
Total 159 180 3312 3362 11801 11962
(Source: Statistical Digest (2013) of Ceylon Electricity Board)
CEB considered hydro power, fossil fuel based thermal power and nuclear
based thermal power generation options as primary energy options to meet
the future electricity demand. A large no. of factors including cost of
development, operation and maintenance costs and environmental effects
were evaluated in order to consider the suitability of the primary options.
Due to high specific cost and low plant load factors, the hydro projects were
not found to be competitive with coal based thermal power plants. It was
recommended that hydro power projects will have to perform peaking duty
and Sri Lankan power system will have to gradually transform into thermal
based system in future.
The screening of thermal power generation options (coal fired steam plants,
oil fired steam plants, oil fired gas turbine plants and oil fired combined cycle
power plants) establishes coal as an economically attractive fuel option for
power generation for higher plant factor operation.
In view of above, establishing 2x250MW Trincomalee coal based power project at
Sampoor, scheduled to be commissioned in 2018 is justified. The main objective
of Trincomalee Power Project is to meet the growing electricity demand of the Sri
Lanka, to improve system reliability, to reduce load shedding and to provide
economical power.
10 km. Radius
sectors are likely to record higher annual growth rates of about 7-8%. Hydro
electricity production and biomass-based energy supplies, which are the only
large-scale indigenous primary energy resources available in Sri Lanka, are
expected to increase only marginally in the near future. This is mainly due to
limitations in further hydropower development owing to lower economic viability
of exploiting the remaining large hydropower sites and limited use of biomass
with gradually increasing standard of living of the population. This means that the
country’s incremental primary energy requirements need to be supplied mainly by
imported fossil fuels in the medium term. In the longer term, possible
development of indigenous petroleum resources and accelerated development of
non-conventional renewable energy are likely to make a significant change in Sri
Lanka’s mix of primary energy resources.
One of the Energy Policy Elements states that the energy resources used in the
country will be diversified and the future energy mix will be rationalized,
considering important factors such as the economic cost, environmental impacts
(including those on existing hydropower project catchment areas), reliability of
supplies, convenience to consumers and strategic independence.
Ensuring the fuel diversity in electricity generation through diversifying into
generation technologies that do not use oil or fuels of which the price is indexed
to oil prices is one of the key implementation strategies.
Under Fuel Diversity and Security section of the Specific Targets, Milestones and
Institutional Responsibilities, it is stated that the electricity sub-sector shall
rapidly move from the present two-energy resource (hydropower and oil) status
to a multiple resource status. The Government shall not initiate or entertain any
proposal either by the electricity utilities or private developers to build power
plants that will use oil, oil-based products or fuels of which the price is indexed to
the oil price, unless they are required to be included in the generation expansion
plan due to technical limitations in other plant types. This moratorium on oil-
based power plants shall be factored into the Long Term Generation Expansion
Plan (LTGEP) and shall remain in force until 80% of Sri Lanka’s electrical energy
supplied to the national grid is from non-oil based fuels.
The strategy of the Government shall be immediately diversified into a third fuel.
To ensure maximum possible security against price and supply fluctuations, and
to ensure the growing demand is reliably met, this third fuel shall be coal. The
LTGEP studies confirm the viability of this strategy. Non-conventional Renewable
Energy (NRE) shall be the fourth resource in this diversification and security
strategy. The electricity generation targets envisaged with NRE and coal
resources are presented in Table 1.3.
Table 1.3: Electricity Generation Targets envisaged in National Energy
Policy & Strategies of Sri Lanka with NRE and Coal Resources
Electrical Energy Supplied to the Grid ad a
Share of the Total
Year Minimum Comments
Conventional Maximum
Coal from
Hydroelectric from oil
NRE
1995 94% 6% 0% Actual
2000 45% 54% 0% 1% Actual
2005 36% 61% 0% 3% Actual. Moratorium on
power plants burning oil or
similarly priced oil/gas
products becomes
effective in 2006.
2010 42% 31% 20% 7% Progressive diversification
into coal and NRE.
Moratorium remains in
place.
2015 28% 8% 54% 10% Moratorium on power
plants burning oil or
similarly priced oil/ gas
products may be lifted.
(Source: National Energy Policy & Strategies of Sri Lanka (Gazette No. 1553/10
dated 10.06.2008, published by Ministry of Power and Energy, Govt. of Sri Lanka)
Another important element of implementation strategy is the protection from
adverse environmental impacts of energy facilities.
o Energy sector utilities will be compelled to comply with safety standards
issued by Public Utilities Commission of Sri Lanka (PUCSL) as well as
environmental standards stipulated by the state.
o A scheme of compensation to victims of accidents and hazards attributed to
energy sector utilities will be established with the participation of all
stakeholders.
o Every energy sector utility will establish an environmental division with staff
qualified to conduct environmental safety audits of existing and new facilities
to comply with the standards and regulations under the National Environment
Act.
In view of the above, development of Trincomalee Thermal Power Project with
appropriate environmental pollution control measures and environment division is
in line with National Energy Policy & Strategies of Sri Lanka
1.8 Approvals/ Permits Needed and Any Conditions Already Laid Down
for the Implementation of the Proposed Project by State Agencies
The list of approvals required for commissioning of a thermal Power Project is
presented in Table 1.4.
TPCL with assistance from CEB or the construction contractor as appropriate shall
obtain all necessary clearances for the operation of the power project.
Table 1.4: List of Approvals required for Commissioning of a Thermal Power Project
Permit/ Clearance/ Approval Description/ Salient Features Required for the Remarks
Approval Required Authority Project?
Environmental Approval CEA or The requirement for environmental Trincomalee TPP falls This EIA report fulfills
under Part IVC of National appropriate assessment is established by the within the Projects and the requirement
Environment Act No. 47 of PAA. National Environment Act and the Undertakings for which
1980 and its amendments procedures are defined in the approval under the EIA
after carrying out an Environmental Impact Assessment regulations are
Environmental Impact Regulations (1993). The regulations required.
Assessment (EIA) or Initial specify activities for which
Environmental Examination environmental assessment is
(IEE) mandatory.
Environmental Approval CEA If any alterations are being made to As decided by the PAA. TPCL shall inform
under Section 23EE of NEA any prescribed project for which CEA of the
for alteration of approved approval had been granted alternations (If any)
prescribed project. Under part IVC of NEA, the project made to the
proponent shall inform the approved project.
appropriate project approving
agency of such alterations and
where necessary obtain fresh
approval in respect of any
alterations that are made to the
prescribed project for which approval
had already been granted.
Environmental Protection CEA or Local Applicable for industries /activities Applicable to certain Construction
License (EPL) from Central Authority (LA) potential to discharge effluents, activities of Contractor shall
Environmental Authority or deposit wastes, emit smoke /gases Trincomalee TPP obtain EPL from CEA
Local Authority under the /fumes /vapor or excessive noise during construction. or LA as appropriate.
National Environment Act No. /vibration into the environment.
47 of 1980 and its Gazette Notification No: 1533/16 TPCL to apply one
amendments; Gazette dated January 25, 2008 prescribes Applicable to operate month prior to
Notification No: 1533/16 the industries /activities required to the coal power plant. commencement of
dated January 25, 2008. obtain an Environmental Protection operations of the
License (EPL). power plant
Permit/ Clearance/ Approval Description/ Salient Features Required for the Remarks
Approval Required Authority Project?
Clearance under the Fauna Department of Five categories of protected areas The project Not required
and Flora Protection Wildlife are established: (i) strict nature components are not
Ordinance Act No. 49 of 1993 Conservation reserves, (ii) national parks, (iii) located within a
and its amendments (DWLC) nature reserves, (iv) jungle national reserve or
corridors, and (v) intermediate within one mile from
zones including sanctuaries. Any the boundary of any
development activity within one mile national reserve
from the boundary of any national
reserve is required to be subjected Not required.
to EIA/IEE, and written approval
shall be obtained from the Director
General, Department of Wildlife
Conservation prior to project
implementation.
Permit under the Mines and Geological Mining and exploitation for minerals, Required. Construction
Mineral Act No. 33 of 1992 Survey and including sand and aggregate must contractors are
Mines Bureau be licensed under the act by the required to obtain
Geological Survey and Mines Bureau. permit from the
Permit is required for earth and Geological Survey and
quarry material extraction for Mines Bureau and/or
construction of buildings etc either procure materials from
directly or through contractors. licensed
Alternatively, project contractors can sources/traders.
procure the material from open
market but they will have to make
sure that such sources/traders are
operating with valid licenses.
Approval under Gazette No. Permit from the Written permission from the Required. The Construction
1152/14 dated October 04, department of Department of Archaeology must be Approval of the Contractor shall
2000 to be read with the Archaeology obtained before commencement of Department of inform the
Section 43(b) of the excavations for: generation and Archaeology is granted Consultant and the
Antiquities (Amendment) Act transmission of electricity; Re- with conditions (see Director General of
No. 24 of 1998. settlement of families; Reclamation Annexure-VII). Department of
Permit/ Clearance/ Approval Description/ Salient Features Required for the Remarks
Approval Required Authority Project?
of lands and wetland; Clearing of all Archaeology of any
These orders are called lands exceeding 2 hectares on Chance found
procedural orders No. 01 extent so that such lands and wet Archaeological
Projects of 2000 lands will be inundated with water property.
etc.
Approval for Felling of Jack, From the To control removal of certain types Jack and Bread Fruit The Construction
Bread Fruit and female Divisional of trees. Permits should be obtained trees are not found Contractor shall
Palmyra trees under the Secretary For for falling of Jack, Bread Fruit and within the project obtain the approval
Felling of Trees Control Act falling up to 03 female Palmyra trees because yield footprint. But felling of from the relevant
No 1 of 2000 trees; (nuts) of those trees are used as female Palmyrah trees authority.
the District daily food of human being. if required) need the
Secretary to fall approval
3 to 15 of those
trees;
If the numbers
of those trees
are above 15
the Secretary of
the Ministry of
Agriculture.
Permit under the Coast Department of Carrying out an EIA is not Required to obtain This EIA report fulfills
Conservation Act No. 57 of Coast mandatory. The Director General permit from CC&CRM the requirement.
1981 and its amendments; Conservation (DG) of CC&CRM has the decretory to construct sea water
Coast Conservation and Coastal power to request a developer intake, cooling water
(Amendment) Act, No. 64 of Recourse applying for a permit (to engage in a discharge and other
1988 and Coast Conservation Management development activity within the ancillary facilities
(Amendment) Act, No. 49 of (CC&CRM) Coastal Zone) to furnish an Initial within the coastal
2011 is required. Environmental Examination, zone.
Environmental Impact Assessment
or both relating to the proposed
development activity.
Permit/ Clearance/ Approval Description/ Salient Features Required for the Remarks
Approval Required Authority Project?
Approval under Marine Marine Pollution Discharge any material which can Permit is required from
Pollution Prevention Act, No. Prevention pollute the territorial waters of Sri MPPA to discharge
35 of 2008. Authority Lanka or any other maritime zone, cooling water and any
(MPPA) its fore shore and the coastal zone of other material into the
Sri Lanka, is prohibited except under sea.
the authority of permit issued by the
MPPA under the Marine
Environmental Protection (issuance
of permits for dumping at sea)
Regulations published in the
Government gazette Notification No.
1816/37 dated June 28, 2013
Approval under Civil Aviation Civil Aviation Approval under the regulations Already obtained.
Act No 14 of 2010 for the Authority published under section 23 of the (copy attached
construction or alternation of act. Annexure-VII)
buildings or other structures
(section 23 -4) within
declared protected areas
Public Utilities Commission of Public Utilities Generation License Already obtained –
Sri Lanka Act No 35 of 2002. Commission of copy attached see
Sri Lanka Annexure-VII)
(PUCSL)
Construction of houses and LA Permission from the LA is required Required.
other infrastructure facilities. for any physical construction activity TPCL to submit the
within the LA area. application along with
drawings of the
facilities to be
constructed.
Widening, rehabilitation or Road Permission from the RDA/ PRDA/ LA TPCL to submit the
construction of roads for the Development as appropriate is required. application along with
construction sites. Authority (RDA) drawings of the roads
/ Provincial to be Widened,
Road rehabilitee or
Permit/ Clearance/ Approval Description/ Salient Features Required for the Remarks
Approval Required Authority Project?
Development constructed.
Authority
(PRDA)/LA
Transportation of heavy RDA/ PRDA/LA Permission from the RDA/ PRDA as TPCL to submit the
equipment by road appropriate is required application along with
details of the heavy
equipment to be
transported.
Atmosphere
Vienna Convention for the Protection of the Ozone Layer (1985)
Date of Ratification by Sri Lanka: December 15, 1989.
Protection of the Ozone Layer through international cooperation in the areas
of scientific research, monitoring and of information exchange.
Montreal Protocol on Substances That Deplete the Ozone Layer
(1987)
Date of Ratification by Sri Lanka: December 12, 1989.
Reduction and the eventual elimination of consumption and production of Un-
anthropogenic Ozone Depleting Substances.
Ozone depleting substances (ODS) are those substances which deplete the
ozone layer and are widely used in refrigerators, air-conditioners, fire
extinguishers, in dry cleaning, as solvents for cleaning, electronic equipment
and as agricultural fumigants. Ozone depleting substances include:
Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), Halon, Carbon tetrachloride, Methyl chloroform,
Hydro-bromo-fluoro-carbons (HBFCs), hydro-chloro-fluoro-carbons (HCFCs),
Methyl bromide & Bromo-chloro-methane.
United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC-
1992)
Date of Ratification by Sri Lanka: November 23, 1993.
Stabilization of greenhouse gas (GHG) (Carbon dioxide-CO2, Methane-CH4,
Nitrous Oxide-NO2, Per-Fluoro-Carbon (PFCs), Hydro-Fluoro-Carbons (HFCs),
Sulphur hexa-Fluoride (SF6) concentrations in the atmosphere at a level that
would prevent dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climatic
systems.
Greenhouse Gases are components of the atmosphere that contribute to the
greenhouse effects. Greenhouse gases include water vapour, Carbon dioxide,
Methane, Nitrous oxide, Per-fluro-carbon (PFCs), Hydro-fluoro-carbon (HFCs)
and Sulphur hexafluoride.
Kyoto Protocol (1997)
Ratification by Sri Lanka: October 03, 2002.
The Annex 1 parties (Developed Countries) to reduce their collective
emissions of greenhouse gases by at least 5% of the 1990 level by the period
2008 –2012.
Bio Diversity
International Plant Protection Convention (1951)
Date of Ratification by Sri Lanka: February 12, 1952.
Land
United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification (UNCCD- 1994)
Date of Ratification by Sri Lanka: December 09, 1998.
To combat desertification and to mitigate the effects of drought in countries
experiencing serious droughts and/ or desertification with the final aim being
to prevent land degradation in the hyper arid, arid, and semi arid, dry sub
humid areas in the countries that are parties of the Convention.
Chemical
Basel Convention on the Control of Trans-boundary Movements of
Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal (1989)
Date of Ratification by Sri Lanka: August 28, 1992.
To reduce trans-boundary movements of hazardous waste and other waste,
subject to the Basel Convention to a minimum consistent with their
environmentally sound management; To ensure strict control over the
movements of hazardous waste across the boarders as well; as the prevention
of illegal traffic; To dispose of the hazardous waste and other waste
generated, as close as possible to their source of generation; To minimize the
generation of hazardous waste in terms of quality and hazardousness; To
prohibit shipments of hazardous waste to countries lacking the legal,
administrative and technical capacity to manage and dispose of them in an
environmentally sound manner; To assist developing countries and countries
with economies in transition in environmentally sound management of the
hazardous waste they generate.
Rotterdam Convention (1998)
Date of Ratification by Sri Lanka: January 19, 2006.
To promote shared responsibility and cooperative efforts among Parties in the
international trade of certain hazardous chemicals in order to protect human
health and the environment from potential harm; to contribute to the
environmentally sound use of those hazardous chemicals, by facilitating
information exchange about their characteristics, by providing for a national
decision-making process on their import and export and by disseminating
these decisions to Parties.
Stockholm Convention on Persistence Organic Pollutants (POPs -
2001)
Date of Ratification by Sri Lanka: December 22, 2005.
To protect human health and the environment from persistent organic
pollutants (POPs).
TPCL will comply with the national directives/ policies/ standards related to the
relevant conventions/ protocols.
Figure 2.1: General Layout Plan for Trincomalee Thermal Power Project
The photographs of the project and surrounding area are presented in Figures
2.4 and 2.5.
(1) The coal is transferred from the coal handling plant by conveyor belt to the
coal bunkers, from where it is fed to the pulverizing mills, which grind it to
fine powder. The finely powdered coal, mixed with air is then blown into the
boiler by a fan where it burns like a gas.
(2) The process of combustion releases thermal energy from coal. The boiler walls
are lined with boiler tubes containing high quality de-mineralized water
(known as boiler feed water). The combustion heat is absorbed by the boiler
tubes and the heat converts the boiler feed water into steam at high pressure
and temperature. The steam, discharged through nozzles on the turbine
blades, makes the turbine to rotate, which in turn rotates the generator
coupled to the end of the turbine. Rotation of generator produces electricity,
which is passed to the step-up transformer to increase its voltage so that it
can be transmitted efficiently. The power is evacuated via switchyard through
a Transmission System.
(3) The combustion of coal oxidizes the combustible matter present in coal and
the flue gases contain the oxides of carbon, sulphur and nitrogen apart from
the fine ash particles. The formation of oxides of nitrogen shall be controlled
through the design of furnace. The flue gases after heat recovery shall be first
passed through the electrostatic precipitators (ESP), where the fine ash
particles shall be removed. Thereafter it shall pass through a flue gas
desulphurization system where the SO2 in flue gases shall be absorbed. The
clean flue gases after ESP and FGD systems shall be discharged through a tall
chimney for wider dispersal of remaining pollutants.
(4) During combustion, the non-combustible part of coal is converted into ash.
Major part of the ash (about 80%) is in fine powder form, known as Fly Ash,
and is carried out of the boiler along with the flue gas. The fly ash is removed
through electrostatic precipitators and the ash collected in the ESP hoppers is
extracted in dry form and conveyed to dry ash storage silos from where it is
supplied to user industries or taken to ash dyke for controlled storage using
High Concentration Slurry Disposal (HCSD) system till the ash is supplied to
the end users. A small part of ash (about 20%) binds together to form lumps,
which fall into the ash pits at the bottom of the furnace. This part of ash is
known as bottom ash.
(5) The steam, after passing through the turbines, is condensed back into water
in condensers and the same is re-used as a boiler feed water for making
steam. The reasons for condensing and reusing the steam are following:
The cost of boiler feed water is very high as it is very pure de-mineralized
water hence reuse is economical.
The condenser serves as the thermodynamically essential sink, rejecting
the heat to atmosphere and condensing the steam to saturated water.
Blow down
6. Transformer
Warm Water
7. Transmission
Towers
(6) The condenser contains tubes through which cold water is constantly pumped.
The steam passing around the tubes of condenser looses heat and condenses
as water. During this process, the steam gets cooled while cooling water gets
heated up. This warm water can be discharged into a natural water body for
cooling (Once Through Cooling System) or it may be cooled in a cooling tower
and recycled for cooling (Closed Cycle Cooling System).
(7) In case of Trincomalee Thermal Power project, once through cooling system is
proposed to be adopted. The cooling water shall be drawn from Koddiyar Bay
and discharged into the sea (Shell Bay) where it shall get cooled through the
natural processes of mixing and heat dissipation.
The typical characteristics of coal being imported and used at Lakvijaya Power
Station are given in Table 2.2.
Coal shall be imported, transported through sea route and supplied by M/s Lanka
Coal Company (Private) Limited (LCCL) through a Coal Supply Agreement (CSA)
between Trincomalee Power Company Limited (TPCL) and LCCL. The location for
developing port/jetty for coal / equipment unloading has been finalized by GOSL
near Sampoor from where it shall be conveyed to the TPCL. LCCL shall arrange
for shipment and unloading of Coal at the Jetty near Sampoor site (Project Site),
from where it shall be conveyed to the terminal point of TPCL. LCCL shall make
arrangements for loading of Coal on to their stream conveyor on which suitable
systems will be installed by Supplier to segregate foreign material like stones,
iron, odd sized Coal lump etc. Supplier shall make available Coal through
conveyor at Delivery Point, Surge hopper(s). As received, coal shall be of less
than 50mm size and hence no crushers have been envisaged in Trincomalee TPP.
At Trincomalee TPP, an independent coal handling plant with 500 tonnes per hour
(TPH) capacity is proposed to be provided to cater to the peak daily requirement
of coal for all units in two bunker filling cycles in 12 hrs effective operation. The
coal may be conveyed directly to the bunkers through belt conveyors of capacity
500 TPH each or to the stock yard through single yard conveyor. As the plant will
be receiving coal straight from port and in order to evacuate coal from ship, coal
conveyor from plant boundary (terminal point) to stacking including yard
conveyor shall be of 2000 TPH. Accordingly, the stacker shall be able to stack coal
at 2000 TPH and the reclaiming path shall be of 500 TPH. Belt conveyor feeding
coal to the main plant shall have belt weighers, metal detectors. Coal sampling
shall be provided at main plant transfer point to sample coal as “As fired basis”.
The overall operating hours of the coal handling plant shall be 16 hours spread
over two shifts per day leaving third shift exclusively for routine inspection and
maintenance.
Proposed Coal stockyards shall have coal storage capacity equivalent to two (2)
months coal consumption for 2 x 250 MW units.
Dust suppression, potable water, cooling water (if any) and service water system
shall be provided throughout the coal handling plant for which Pump House shall
be provided. The effluents from the coal handling plant including coal stock yard
shall be led to a coal settling pond, where the suspended coal particles shall be
removed and the decanted water shall be recycled for further use in dust
suppression. Wind barrier of adequate height shall be provided on outside of
stockpile to prevent dust emission.
A centralized main Coal Handling Plant (CHP) control room shall be provided to
control and monitor the operations of the entire coal handling system.
The fuel oil storage area shall have safety arrangements for fire detection and
protection, as per regulatory requirements in Sri Lanka. In addition, the fuel oil
storage area shall be provided with a dyke all around to contain effluents/ run off.
The effluents from fuel oil storage area shall be treated in oil water separator and
then sent to service water system for further treatment and recycle.
A central chilled water type air conditioning plant shall be provided for air -
conditioning in main plant area and ESP control rooms of all the units. Chilled
water shall be pumped to each area and each area shall be air-conditioned
through dedicated air handling units located locally. All air conditioned space shall
be maintained at 24°C +/- (plus or minus) 1° C and 50% +/- (plus or minus)
5% Relative Humidity (RH). All air conditioned areas shall be supplied with
filtered air. Both re-circulated and fresh air shall be filtered separately.
Further critical areas like Control room, Programmer room, etc. which are
required to be air conditioned even during failure of normal power supply shall be
air conditioned whose drives along with applicable fresh air fans, chilled water
pumps, condenser water pumps, cooling tower and Air Handling Unit (AHU) shall
operate on emergency Diesel Generator (DG) sets.
Ventilation System
The ventilation system for various buildings/rooms shall be designed to effectively
remove the internal heat generated, fumes/gas, etc. from plant and equipment
and provide a comfortable working environment in various areas of the plant.
The areas, which will require ventilation, are as follows:
a) The turbine generator hall for each unit including cable galleries, switchgear
rooms etc.
b) ESP control room (non a/c areas) for each unit
c) Battery rooms in main plant area
d) C.W. pump house.
e) Work shop and store areas.
f) Fuel oil unloading and forwarding pump house
g) Fuel oil-pressurizing house
h) Toilets, pantry, canteen etc.
i) Compressor house
j) Fire water pump house
k) Non-ac areas of Service and Administrative Building.
l) Ash handling Plant buildings
m) Stores
n) Any other area which may require ventilation.
Mechanically ventilated areas shall be designed to 20 air change rate per hour
(for general area) and 30 air changes rate per hour for Motor Control Center
(MCC)/switchgear rooms, battery room, etc. All ventilation system shall work on
100% fresh filtered air.
Turbine hall and electrical switchgear / MCC rooms/Cable Galleries, etc. shall be
designed for positive pressure ventilation, which shall be achieved by sizing the
exhausters to extract 60-70% of total air delivered by supply air fans. All fuel oil
pump houses, battery rooms, kitchens; toilets shall be designed for negative
pressure ventilation.
For battery rooms, fuel oil rooms/pump houses, spark proof fan with flame proof
motor shall be used.
Non-Residential Buildings
1. Auditorium (Seating Capacity 500) with a Built-up Area 1800 sq.m.
2. Utility Complex (11 Shops, Bank, Post Office, Township Maintenance Office,
Telephone Exchange and Cafeteria) with a Built-up Area 1700 sq.m.
3. Hospital (Ten Beds) with a Built-up Area 3000 sq.m.
4. Club, Multipurpose Hall and Swimming Pool with a Built-up Area 1500 sq.m.
5. Community Center with a Built-up Area 1000 sq.m.
6. Guest House with a Built-up Area 1000 sq.m.
7. Common Facilities like Nursery School, Creche (day care), Ladies Club etc.
8. Sewage Treatment Plant
locations of these structures are shown in Figure 1.3. The intake and outfall
locations as well as corridors are already marked in Layout Plan.
It is proposed to draw water from a depth of 7 m below the surface of sea at a
location 700 m from the shore in Koddiyar Bay and discharge the warm water
into Shell Bay (at a location 480 m from shore, at a depth of 7 m).
The length of intake water corridor is about 3 km. Two routes have been
identified for discharge water corridor, as shown in Figure 1.3 - Alternate-I (3.7
km) and Alternate-II (6.5 km). Baseline environmental surveys including
Terrestrial Ecology were carried out for both the routes. Alternate-I is preferred,
as it is the shortest route. It is proposed to use Glass Fiber Reinforced Polyester
(GRP) Pipes of diameter 2600 mm with 300 mm sand casing all around for intake
and discharge ducts. Ducts outside plant boundary shall be laid below ground
level.
The water drawl system shall be either Off-shore Intake well and CW pump house
or On-shore CW Pump House. The final choice of options shall be made after
detailed studies of the site specific conditions. However impact of any of these
options will not be significantly different (under construction)
In case of Off-shore Intake well, CW pump house in RCC construction shall be
provided at the intake well itself. Opening of requisite size at suitable level (-7.0
m from MSL) shall be made in the well for water intake and subsequent drawl
through pumps. Opening in the well are proposed to restrict the flow velocity of
about 0.5 m/sec. Suitable wire mesh / travelling water screen & vertical trash
rack shall be provided in the opening to stop entering of any logs/ big fishes into
the well. Water shall be transported through GRP pipes up to plant. Jetty/bridge
in RCC construction with suitable pile or open foundation shall be constructed for
carrying water pipes and for approach to pump house for operation and
maintenance purposes. From shore to plant the GRP pipes shall be buried under
ground with earth/sand cover of minimum two meters. The size, location and
structural details of well, platform for pumps, jetty / bridge, piers of jetty and
associated foundation details etc. shall be as per detailed analysis and design of
intake system to be carried out by an expert agency. Sketch showing the
arrangement is enclosed at Figure 2.9.
In case of On-shore CW pump house, the water shall be drawn from drawl
location to the shore either through RCC Pre-cast Duct or Pipes of suitable
material and laid under the sea bed. At the point of drawl, RCC Pre-cast Duct or
Pipe shall be provided with an intake structure and suitable openings shall be
provided at desired level (-7.0 m from MSL). RCC intake structure shall be
provided at the drawl point to provide support/ stability to the RCC Pre-cast Duct
or Pipe and to restrict the flow velocity of about 0.5 m/sec by providing suitable
openings. A platform over the structure shall be provided for maintenance
purposes. Suitable wire mesh / travelling water screen & vertical trash rack shall
be provided in the openings to stop entering of any logs/ big fishes into the duct/
pipe. A sump/fore-bay shall be provided on shore with CW pump house in RCC
construction. From on-shore CW pump house to plant water shall flow through
GRP pipes buried under ground with earth/sand cover of minimum two meters.
The size, location and details of under sea bed pipes/RCC pre-cast ducts and
construction methodology shall be as per detailed analysis and design of intake
system to be carried out by an expert agency. Sketch showing the both the
arrangements is enclosed at Figure 2.10 and 2.11.
Individual intake ducts from the C.W. pumps to the condenser and from
condenser to downstream of sea shall be provided for each of 250 MW units.
However, the ducts of all 250 MW units shall be interconnected so that in the
event of one pump being out for maintenance, the discharge of remaining pumps
will be equally distributed to both the units.
Figure 2.9: Typical Arrangement of Off-shore Intake Well and CW Pump House
Figure 2.10: Typical Arrangement of On-shore Intake Well and CW Pump House
(Option-I)
Figure 2.11: Typical Arrangement of On-shore Intake Well and CW Pump House
(Option-II)
The pump house bay shall be designed for a flow of 93120 m3/hr. The pump
house shall have five (5) C.W. pump bays. Each bay shall be designed for a flow
of 23280 m3/hr. The hydraulic structure in general is designed in accordance with
the recommendations of the Hydraulic Institute of U.S.A. Traveling water screen
(TWS) with Vertical trash racks on the upstream shall be provided at the inlet to
the pump suction chamber to prevent entrance of large sized debris. This shall be
followed by a stop log arrangement for pump bay isolation.
Discharge of return warm water shall be through GRP pipes buried under ground
up to the sea shore. On the shore a sump / seal pit shall be provided. From sump
to discharge location in the sea, water shall flow through two or more pipes. As
per Lanka Hydraulic Institute report, point of discharge (L0) is about 480 m from
the sea coast at a depth of about 7 m in the Shell Bay area.
2.3.2.1 Sources, intake points, quality and quantity to be used by the project
Sea water shall be drawn from Koddiyar Bay through an intake well, proposed to
be located at 700 m inside the Bay from a drawl level of 7 meters below mean
sea level (MSL). The intake location is shown in Figure 1.3.
The total sea water requirement is estimated to be about 93,120 m3/hr, out of
which 92,000 m3/hr shall be used for condenser and auxiliary cooling and flue gas
desulphurization while 1120 m3/hr shall be used in desalination plant for
generation of fresh water. The total fresh water requirement is estimated to be
440 m3/hr.
Water quality parameters for various water streams are as follows:
b) First Stage Sea Water Reverse Osmosis (SWRO) System: The purpose of
SWRO System is to remove the dissolved solids from the filtered sea water and to
produce specified quantity of sweet water for plant use and as well to supply feed
water for second stage RO units. Chemicals shall be dosed in SWRO plant for
effective treatment as described in Chemical Storage and Dosing System.
c) Post treatment and Treated Water Storage system: Permeate from the SWRO
trains shall be treated to correct pH by chemical dosing. For removal of dissolved
Carbon di-Oxide (CO2), a set of Degassers shall be provided. Water delivered out
of Degassers shall be led to Degassed water storage tanks. Re-mineralization of
permeate water shall be achieved by pH (alkali dosing) correction, increase of
alkalinity (by dosing food grade CO2 gas), passing through lime beds before being
pumped to a set of Sweet (Permeate) water storage tanks for plant use. Portion
of Sweet (Permeate) water (from degassed water storage tanks) shall be pumped
for treatment to produce water suitable for potable water system. Potable water
quality shall be achieved by pH (alkali dosing) correction, increase of alkalinity
(by dosing food grade CO2 gas), passing through a lime bed and blending of
required quantity of permeate from second stage RO unit. From degassed water
storage tanks, RO feed pumps shall pump water to 2nd stage RO System.
d) Reverse Osmosis (RO) & Mixed Bed Ion exchangers for DM water System: The
purpose of second stage RO System and associated Polisher Ion exchanger units
is to remove dissolved solids from raw water produced from SWRO Plant to
produce De-mineralized water. Ion exchange resins i.e. Cation and Anion resins
shall be regenerated with Hydrochloric acid and Sodium hydroxide respectively.
Regeneration facility shall comprise of DM Regeneration pumps (which shall draw
water from DM water storage tanks), Alkali & Acid Storage facility, Chemical
unloading pumps, Alkali & Acid preparation/measuring tanks, Chemical Dosing
system etc.
Hydrochloric acid shall be used for pH control of RO feed water and Citric
acid (C6H8O7) for preparation of cleaning solution of RO modules.
Hydrochloric acid shall also be used for regeneration of cation resin of
Mixed Bed ion exchanger vessels.
Sodium hydroxide shall be used for pH control of permeate water of
SWRO/RO plant and for regeneration of anion resin of Mixed Bed ion
exchanger vessels.
Electro-chlorination shall be envisaged along with all accessories.
Dechlorination facilities shall also be provided at the disposal point to meet
the statutory norms. Emergency safety showers with eye wash units shall
be provided in the Chemical Storage Handling facility at strategic locations
such as Acid/Alkali Storage area, outdoor Chemical storage area,
Chlorination plant area and Chemical preparation & dosing equipment
area.
Chemical storage facilities described above for various systems shall generally be
designed to hold one (1) month requirements, chemical dosing tanks to hold one
(1) day requirement (at least two (2) tanks). Various chemical dosage rates shall
be as per the system design requirement.
Figure 2.12: Water Balance Diagram for Trincomalee Thermal Power Project
2.3.3.2 Quantity and Quality of Cooling Water to be Used and Rate of Use Under
all Modes of Plant Operation and Capacity
The water requirement for the condenser & auxiliary cooling is estimated to be
92,000 m3/hr (for 2X250 MW units) and the maximum temperature rise across
the condenser shall be 7oC. An additional 1120 m3/hr is required for desalination
plant.
take place in the coming years (over 5-10 years) and hence about 8-10 RMC
units may be set-up in the next 2-3 years. As such, there may be a
requirement of about 50,000 tonne fly ash per year.
c) At present, there is no unit in Sri Lanka to manufacture fly ash brick/ block,
as fly ash generation in Sri Lanka has started recently in April 2011.
Moreover, all the dry fly ash being generated by the Lakvijaya Power Station
is being used by the cement units for production of PPC. Ceylon Electricity
Board (CEB) has floated a subsidiary company namely ‘Sri Lanka Energies
Private Ltd’ (SLEPL) with an objective of managing fly ash (especially
bricks/blocks, etc.) and explore options of Non-conventional energy sources
in Sri Lanka. The subsidiary has tied-up with another company namely
‘Amtrad Limited’ for making Light weight cement concrete blocks and fly ash
bricks / blocks using fly ash. Amtrad Limited, Sri Lanka is a manufacturer of
concrete blocks and pavers since 1980.
d) Considering the present scenario of brick making in Sri Lanka and also the
efforts being made by CEB/ Sri Lanka Energies Private Ltd., it is estimated
that many entrepreneurs (about 20) may come up in Trincomalee region in
near future to set-up fly ash brick/ block manufacturing units with a capacity
of 10,000 – 12,000 bricks per day. The annual requirement of fly ash in this
sector is expected to be about 60,000 tonne per year.
e) As the fly ash/ bottom ash has not been available in Sri Lanka, it has not
been used in construction of road and embankment so far and no code of
practice is available in Sri Lanka. However, Road Development Authority
(RDA) may undertake some Research and Development (R&D) project in Sri
Lanka on use of fly ash/ bottom ash as a part substitute of soil and as a part
substitute of cement for construction of concrete roads and develop suitable
code of practice in this regard. The Director (Planning), RDA showed keen
interest to have a collaborative project for preparation of manual/guidelines/
code of practice.
f) Based on the market survey carried out by Fly Ash and Technology
Management Associates (FTMA), Noida, the fly ash to be generated from
Trincomalee TPP can be gainfully utilized in following areas on sustainable
basis:
i. Use of fly ash in production of PPC and cement-concrete works/ RMC
ii. Use of fly ash/ bottom ash in fly ash bricks/ blocks making
iii. Use of fly ash / pond ash in construction of roads and
embankments
g) Based on the various inputs received from various sectors of industry /
agencies, the estimates on the use/ requirement of fly ash and bottom in
Trincomalee region are summarized below:
h) In line with the above estimates, the total ash (0.30 MTPA) to be generated
from the Trincomalee TPP, is proposed to be utilized (100%) since the start/
commissioning of its first unit. The fly ash and the bottom ash utilization
plan are summarized below:
Fly Ash Utilization Plan:
The fly ash (0.26 MTPA) to be generated from Trincomalee TPP will
be utilized 100% by the cement industry in Sri Lanka every year.
The demand of fly ash for cement manufacture is expected to be
much more (1.10 MTPA) than the generation for years to come.
Trincomalee Power Company Limited shall take necessary action for
signing of Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the cement
company(ies).
Bottom Ash Utilization Plan:
The bottom ash (0.06 MTPA) to be generated from the Trincomalee
TPP can be utilized 100% in construction of road & embankment,
subject to the formulation of suitable standards / guidelines / codes
of practice for its use in this area. Bottom ash being coarser than
fly ash has better drainage properties, better shear strength and
better CBR (California Bearing Ratio) as compared to fly ash and
conforms to the characteristics specified by Indian Road Congress
for construction of road embankments. It is being used in India for
construction of roads and embankments. It is also being used as a
substitute for sand in sand chimney/ sand blanket of ash dykes,
stowing of mines and part replacement of sand/ stone dust in
cement concrete and fly ash bricks. Based on the market survey,
the potential of use of bottom ash in construction of road and
embankment is 0.14 MTPA, which is much more than the annual
generation of bottom ash (0.06 MTPA).
On the downstream slope of starter dyke 300 mm thick rip rap with 300 mm thick
aggregate and 300 mm thick sand filters shall be provided below High Flood Level
(HFL). Above HFL, the d/s slope shall be protected by turfing. During the raisings
also, the outer slopes shall be protected with turfing. On the upstream slope, the
slope protection shall be confined within brick / Random Rubble (RR) masonry
panel walls. For the starter dyke, the protection shall be for top 3 M height and
for entire height of raisings. At the location of slurry discharge points, lining with
RR masonry or any other suitable energy dissipating arrangements shall be
provided to protect the slopes of dyke from erosion due to falling jets of slurry or
alternatively the pipe discharge ends shall be extended to be clear of the toe of
dyke.
The decanted water as well as the rain water collected within the storage pond
shall be spilled out through the periphery of water escape tower into the over flow
lagoon and re-circulated back to the main plant for reuse in ash handling. The
level of water escape tower shall be at 1.5 metre below the dyke top in each
phase. However provisions shall be made for lowering the water level during
emergencies. Shaft like structures are proposed for decanted water escape. The
diameter and number of wells in each lagoon are fixed in such a way that the
velocity of spilling water shall always be maintained very low so that the
carryover of solids will be limited (less than 0.5 m/sec during normal conditions).
During heavy rains these wells shall be capable of discharging flood water also
without heading up-to more than 0.5 metre. The shaft shall be made of RCC.
Access dykes/bridges shall be provided to the decant tower from the top of dykes
in various phases.
The requirement of Wind barriers shall be worked out at detailed engineering
stage and the same shall be provided for prevention of fugitive dust.
Inspection road all along the periphery of dyke and along the ash pipe corridor
from plant boundary to ash pond shall be provided for maintenance of ash pipes.
Same shall be used for approach to ash pond.
Layout and Typical Section of Ash Dyke is shown in Figure 2.13.
In reaction (1), is SO2 is absorbed in sea water and creates sulphite ions (SO32-)
and hydrogen ions. SO32- ions react with oxygen to form sulphate thereby
consuming the dissolved oxygen of sea water and creating a chemical oxygen
demand. On the other hand, hydrogen ions decrease the pH of the water during
the process. Aeration of absorber liquid after absorption, oxidises the SO32- ions
and raise the level of dissolved oxygen (reaction (2). Bi-carbonate ions present in
sea water neutralize the hydrogen ions and raise the pH.
The key advantages of the sea water FGD system over traditional FGD system are
as follows:
i. No chemical/ reagent is required. Only sea water and air are used.
ii. No by-product is generated, which needs to be handled/ disposed off. End
product, sulphate is a natural component of sea water and the increase in
concentration is small as compared to normal concentration in sea water.
iii. Sea water FGD can be designed as fully automated plant, which can be
normally controlled and monitored from a centralized control room. Hence,
it requires no additional manpower.
iv. The process has few rotating equipment resulting in low power
consumption and low maintenance cost.
At Trincomalee TPP, the FGD plants shall be fully automated and the operation of
the plant shall be monitored and controlled from the Central Control Room. There
will be two separate Seawater FGD plants, one for each unit. Each plant shall
consist of one absorber unit and one Gas-Gas Heater (GGH) unit to raise the gas
temperature before emission through the stack. After passing through the
absorber, the SO2-rich seawater shall flow by gravity to the Sea Water Treatment
Plant (hereafter called SWTP), where it shall be mixed with the seawater coming
from discharge of condenser and aerated.
A large no. of sea water FGD plants are working world over even though the
technology has limitation of being deployed only in the coastal plant. Just to have
an idea of extent of use of sea water based FGD system, one of the leading
supplier of sea water based FGD system, M/s ALSTOM up till now have already
supplied these units for about 42,000 MW capacity power plants.
In order to take care of the natural variations in the alkalinity of sea water, the
plant will be designed with sufficient margin and efficiency shall be maintained by
regulating the flow of sea water through the system. Therefore, SO2 emission
norms will be met in all conditions of operations.
The details of ash handling, utilization and disposal have already been covered in
Section 2.3.4.
For hazardous wastes (like used oil, oil sludge, batteries containing lead and acid
etc.), Secured stores shall be constructed for storage and the same shall be
recycled/ disposed off through authorized agencies.
The production process and the waste treatment processes described above are
summarized in Table 2.6.
TABLE 2.6: List of Production and Waste Treatment Processes for 2x250 MW Plant
1. Production Processes
Production Process Capacity/ Rate of Remark
Operation
1. Coal Handing and Firing Systems
Coal Handling Plant 500 Tonnes per Hour A complete system for receiving, storing, processing and feeding coal.
Coal Burning System 214.5 Tonnes per Shall consist of coal feeders, coal mills and Primary Air (PA) fans to
Hour transport pulverized coal from mill to burners.
Generation of Flue Gas 539.44 Nm3/sec Flue gas is generated as a result of coal burning in the furnace.
Notes:
1. The data indicated above is based on the boundary conditions agreed in coal supply agreement entered into with Lanka Coal
Company Private Limited.
2. Data indicated above is for design coal characteristic arrived at as per 1 above.
3. For ash production, the value of ash constituent has been considered as 15 %, which is near to limiting value of 16%.
2. Fuel Oil Handing Systems
LAD Storage Tanks 2x700 m3 Fuel oil unloading and handling systems shall be designed to handle
Lanka Auto Diesel (LAD), to be used for cold start-up and part load
operations of the steam generator while firing coal.
The system shall be complete with all pumps, tanks and instruments and
accessories.
Day Oil Tank 1x100 m3 Drain oil tanks and pumps and oil separators shall be provided for
collection and treatment of oily waste water.
Extraction of Raw Water 93120 m3/hr It shall consist of intake pump house including Glass Fiber Reinforced
supply and discharge pipes.
Water shall be drawn from sea from a depth of 7.5 m below the surface of
sea at a location 200 m from the shore in Koddiyar Bay.
Chlorination Plant 3x50 Kg/Hr It shall be an indoor plant and consist of electro-chlorinator sets for
chlorine dosing to prevent the growth of algae and bacteria in cooling
water system.
Generation of Fresh Water 390 m3/hr A desalination plant based on sea water reverse osmosis (SWRO) shall be
used for generation of fresh water to meet various plant requirements
including potable water.
Both the types of ash shall be utilized for various purposes. However, for
disposal of ash during periods on non-utilization, high concentration slurry
disposal system shall be provided.
Flue Gas De-sulphurisation For a brief write up, please refer Para A of Explanatory Notes given
System at the end.
Coal Settling Ponds To treat and recycle the effluent from coal handling plant area.
Sewage Treatment Plant Biological treatment system with adequate capacity to treat the
sanitary waste generated in the plant area.
is operating at its maximum continuous rating, firing worst coal having maximum ash content. A brief description of the functional
needs of ESP, as also given in the FR, is brought out below.
The electrostatic precipitators will have four (4) parallel gas streams, isolated from each other on the electrical as well as gas side
and will be provided with gas tight dampers at inlets and outlets of each stream, so as to allow maintenance to be carried out
safely on the faulty stream, while the unit is working. ESP specific collection area shall not be less than 135 m2/ m3/sec at 100%
TMCR. Electrostatic precipitator will be provided with microprocessor based programmable type rapper control system and ESP
management system to ensure safe and optimum operation of ESP.
ESP transformer rectifier sets will use high flash point oil as the cooling medium. The dust collection hoppers at all strategic
locations will have a minimum storage capacity of eight (8) hours. The hoppers will have heating arrangements to prevent ash
sticking to the sloping sides and down pipes. Level indicators to indicate ash levels in the hoppers and trip the corresponding field
of ESP in case of high ash levels in the ash hoppers are also envisaged to ensure safety of ESP.
Safety Policy
Trincomalee Power Company shall adopt a safety policy with the following broad
objectives:
To allocate sufficient resources to maintain safe and healthy conditions of
work.
To take steps to ensure that all known safety factors are taken into account in
the design, construction, operation and maintenance of plants, machinery and
equipment.
To ensure that adequate safety instructions are displayed at all appropriate
places and explained to all employees in Sinhala, Tamil and English
languages.
To provide wherever necessary protective equipment, safety appliances and
clothing, and to ensure their proper use.
To inform employees about materials, equipments or processes used in their
work, which are known to be potentially hazardous to health or safety.
To keep all operations and methods of work under regular review for making
necessary changes from the point of view of safety in the light of experience
and aptitude knowledge.
To provide appropriate facilities for first aid and prompt treatment of injuries
and illness at work.
To provide appropriate instruction, training, retraining and supervision to
employees in health & safety, first aid and to ensure that adequate publicity is
given to these matters.
Medical Facilities
Medical facilities shall be made available round the clock for attending any
medical emergency during construction & operation phases.
Pre-employment Training
Pre-employment training aims at providing requisite skills and confidence to the
personnel who enter the company as fresh trainees at different induction levels.
Four types of long-duration training schemes are proposed, to take care of this
aspect of training.
Name of Scheme Duration
1) Engineering Executive Training Scheme 1-year
2) Finance & HR Executive Training Scheme 1-year
3) Executive Training Scheme (Chemistry) 1-year
4) Diploma/ Technical Trainees Scheme 1-year
Post-Employment Training
Post-employment training provides opportunities to personnel at various levels of
the organization hierarchy to take up higher responsibility and skills and also to
reorient them to keep pace with the advancement in thermal power technology.
This package basically has three components viz. Management Development,
Specialized Training and Employee Development.
Management Development shall offer general management programme,
programme for developing functional knowledge, induction and familiarization
courses and discussions on subjects of topical interest.
The specialized training activities, besides providing special skills, also strive
to acquaint the employees with the latest technology available the world over.
Short duration programmes aim to develop and upgrade specific skills of the
employees.
Various options under specialized training activities may be further classified as
Induction Programmes for personnel inducted in the various areas of O&M
have to orient the same in the operation & maintenance of units. These
programmes shall include in plant operations training in the power stations
and study visits to manufacturers works.
Training of the Company’s personnel by the suppliers is generally provided for
under different contractual agreements. Executives may be trained under this
scheme to assimilate and build up in-house expertise in the contemporary
technology intensive areas.
Towards the end of the construction and erection phase, erection manpower
may be given appropriate training for their placement in the O&M position and
switched over to operation and maintenance as and when the units come into
the operation. The training apart from providing opportunities for career
growth to individuals will go a long way involving the problem of erection
personnel being rendered surplus, when project activities come to an end.
To provide necessary exposure on new developments in engineering and
management fields, arrangements shall be made for imparting specific need
based training in operations and maintenance personnel down the line.
Based on the coal characteristics, i.e. proximate and ultimate analysis of coal the
combustion properties of the coal will vary. Further, based on the ash quantity
and characteristics, the steam generator heating surfaces will be designed. The
major coal types and their characteristics are as follows:
1. Lignite: Lignite, also known as brown coal, has high moisture and high
volatile matter. The furnace sizing and arrangement of various heat
transfer surfaces cater to the high flue gas volume. Lignitic coals are soft
coals, and coal preparation and firing system has to be appropriately
selected and designed to ensure adequate coal drying and to avoid mill
fires. Fluidized bed combustion is found suitable for Lignite coal with high
sulphur content.
2. Bituminous/ Sub-bituminous: These coals generally have higher calorific
value and lower moisture % and volatile matter than lignitic coals. Mostly,
pulverized coal combustion is used for burning bituminous coals.
3. Anthracite: Anthracite coal has high fixed carbon and low volatile matter
and thus is difficult to burn even though calorific value is relatively high.
They require a different combustion system to ensure proper and complete
combustion. Anthracite coals are usually used in downshot boilers having
downshot burners to cater to coal combustion properties.
Some other power generation technologies are as follows:
i) Fluidized bed combustion (FBC)
In FBC, the fuel is placed on a bed along with bed material (sand, ash
etc.) and air or other gas flows upward through the bed, fluidizing the bed.
FBC is used when the boiler has to cater to a large range of varying coal
properties. This technology has been adopted for comparatively smaller
unit sizes than pulverized coal fired units, is comparatively less efficient
and more expensive.
STUDY AREA
The geographical extent of the study area for EIA Study, as specified in the Terms
of Reference (TOR) for Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Study approved
by Central Environmental Authority (Annexure-I) is as follows:
Project site and 20 km from the boundary of project site for the air
quality assessment and 2 km from the boundary of project site for all
other studies or the area of maximum risk;
The locations of the offshore/ onshore structures and 500m from the
boundaries of these structures or area of maximum risk;
Pipeline routes and 100m on either side of proposed pipeline routes or
area of maximum risk.
Transmission line routes and 50 m on either side of the transmission line
(However, CEB has already obtained environmental clearance for
transmission line separately)
These study areas marked on the vicinity map of the project are presented at
Figure 1.9.
The scope of the present EIA includes the power plants and its components
including cooling water intake and outfall system but excludes the facilities for
import, storage and supply of coal and transmission lines to be commissioned by
Ceylon Electricity Board. In brief, these are summarized as:
Inclusions Exclusions
Steam Generator, Turbine Generator Jetty for coal / equipment
and their Auxiliaries, unloading at Sampoor site
Coal Handling System including Dust Shipment and unloading of Coal
Extraction and Suppression System, at the Jetty
Sea water intake and effluent Transmission lines beyond the
discharge system, Switch Yard of Trincomalee
Once Through Cooling System, Thermal Power project
Water treatment system including
desalination, effluent treatment,
recycle, reuse and disposal System,
Fire Protection System,
Air Conditioning & Ventilation System,
Air pollution control systems like
Electrostatic Precipitators, Flue Gas
Desulphurization and Chimney;
Ash Handling System with Dry Ash
Extraction, Storage and High
Concentration Slurry Disposal System;
Electrical Systems such as Generator
Bus Duct, Transformers, Switchgears,
Switch Yard
Township and other off site facilities
Rainfall
The brief details of instruments, parameter and frequency are presented in
Table 3.1.
1 Wind Speed
2 Wind Direction Automatic Weather Continuous
station (Envirotech Automatic 1 hourly
Ambient Temperature at WM 251) Average
3
Two Heights 2m & 10m
NORTH
35%
28%
21%
14%
7%
WEST EAST
WIND SPEED
(m/s)
>= 11.1
8.8 - 11.1
5.7 - 8.8
SOUTH
3.6 - 5.7
2.1 - 3.6
0.5 - 2.1
Calms: 5.24%
Figure 3.1: Wind rose at Mutur (28th September to 28th October, 2011)
Figure 3.3: Annual wind rose diagram at Sampoor site based on data
recorded by CEB
3.1.3 HYDROLOGY
3.1.3.1 Surface Drainage pattern and
3.1.3.2 Vulnerability to Floods
In the study area, Mahaweli Ganga is the main river which flows to the west of
Mutur west before falling into the sea near Navaladi. Koddiyar Aru is an
interlacing of the Mahaweli river and flows through the study area in a circuitous
path and falls into the sea near Navaladi Mulkattuvarmin on the west of Mutur
east. Besides Koddiyar bay on the north-west and Indian Ocean on the east,
there are lagoons and numerous kulam in the study area. The biggest lagoon is
Ullacklie located on the south-east of the study area followed by Kaddaiparichan
lagoon. Ilakkantai, Ullai and Kayiavandan are the major kulam in the study area,
which are meant for paddy cultivation. There are also a few dug wells in the study
area, some of which appears to be redundant. Apart from these, there are water
holes / tanks in the area which are used for irrigation and domestic purposes.
Even during the iconic, massive flood event in Trincomalee district in Jan.-Feb.,
2011 when outflow of Mahaweli river and other adjacent catchments inundated
most part of Mutur (more than 70% of land area) and Kinniya Divisional
Secretariat, the project area in Sampoor was least affected.
The significant stream in the study area is Kaddaiparichan Aru, which flows South
of Sampoor. Majority of the surface is drained through it, while the area North of
Sampoor is drained by a small water path called Villu Kulam Aru.
Currently, no demarcated and developed drains exist in the project area although
the area contains few small streams of shallow depth and wide foot print. Owing
to sandy geological formation, infiltration remains high and no strong surface run-
off currents exist for natural creation of ditches and drains. Shrubs and bushes
roughen the existing land terrain disturbing the smooth surface run-off.
The salient findings of the study by LHI are as follows:
1. The hydrological analyses of the project area and related catchments reveal
that the drainage of the project area is satisfactory and no complete
inundation of the project area is expected even for the 100 year flood. Unique
topographical orientation of the project area with two ridges prevents major
floods from Mahaweli River entering into Sampoor.
2. Safe minimal ground elevation is recommended as 2.5 m above mean sea
level.
3. Entire project area is not prone to significant flood accumulation and all
access paths and intake and discharge pipeline corridors are considered flood
safe.
4. Main access road (starting from Ring Road, which provides direct access to
the project site) is safe for most of its span except from Patchannoor to a
point about 6 km. west of Kinniya. Floods of return period 5 year and 100
year inundate this road stretch to a length of 4 km. and 6 km. respectively.
However, as Patchannoor junction can also be accessed via south by
Batticaloa – Trincomalee highway, an uninterrupted access to the project site
under any flood situation exists.
5. Mutur Sampoor road is flood prone and must be avoided during high flood
events.
6. The project area contains Sampukkali Kulam in its South West corner while
Villu Kulam is located just north of the project area. Sampukkali Kulam is
dried up during most of the year and is planned to be preserved as green
area. It discharges to Kaddaiparichan lagoon which is connected to the sea via
Kaddaiparichan Aru. Villu Kulam is drained directly to the sea. Therefore, local
accumulation of rainfall within the project area could be directed to any of the
prominent drainage direction.
7. As a ridge that exists close to the north boundary of the project area diverts
most of the accumulated run-off to the south, the proposed green area is
recommended to be developed with adequate drainage path. Planned corridor
for the discharge duct must facilitate the surface run-off across it my means
of suitable small drains. In addition, the passage that connects Sampukkali
Kulam to Kaddaiparichan Lagoon must also be developed to facilitate rapid
run-off dispersion.
15 Potassium as K (mg/l) - 19 6 20 40 4
* - CEA (2001), Interim Ambient Water Quality Standards for Class-III Waters (General Use)
(Source: Monitoring Data by Mantec Consultants)
Following conclusions can be drawn for the surface water quality results
mentioned in the above table:
The pH varies from 6.7 to 7.74
Conductivity varies from 263 µmho/cm to 4000 µmho/cm
Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) and Total Suspended Solids (TSS) vary from 170
mg/l to 2548 mg/l and 28 mg/l to 194 mg/l respectively
Sodium varies from 32 mg/l to 920 mg/l
Chloride varies from 37 mg/l to 274 mg/l
Total coliform varies from Absent to 179 Maximum Probable Number
(MPN)/100 ml
Minimum
Discharge
10- 2003- 2004- 2005- 2006- 2007- 2008- During
Year
Daily 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Oct. 2003
to Sep.
2009
I 10.9 10.9 6.0 23.3 8.6 12.2 6.0
Oct.
II 12.3 18.5 3.9 15.6 8.1 37.2 3.9
2003
III 13.6 23.3 21.6 42.9 8.0 42.7 8.0
I 13.6 50.4 26.0 73.6 21.6 34.5 13.6
Nov.
II 47.8 68.7 55.8 279.3 27.8 59.2 27.8
2003
III 88.6 99.5 67.4 254.8 27.8 62.5 27.8
I 60.0 107.0 61.4 201.1 26.9 59.2 26.9
Dec.
II 41.7 146.9 50.4 282.4 53.1 101.0 41.7
2003
III 33.9 92.2 37.1 245.9 58.6 59.2 33.9
I 42.9 38.2 49.1 94.0 49.1 54.5 38.2
Jan.
II 51.7 53.1 110.9 237.1 85.2 57.6 51.7
2004
III 40.5 105.1 40.5 125.1 50.4 51.4 40.5
I 42.9 76.8 64.4 80.1 33.9 42.7 33.9
Feb.
II 36.0 39.4 107.0 37.1 27.8 34.5 27.8
2004
III 31.8 31.8 44.2 34.9 16.3 23.6 16.3
I 27.8 26.9 49.1 17.7 45.3 29.5 17.7
March
II 26.0 46.6 42.9 23.3 366.9 24.7 23.3
2004
III 22.5 40.5 25.1 12.8 170.4 18.1 12.8
I 27.8 38.2 22.5 14.3 153.8 17.1 14.3
Apr.
II 28.8 27.8 30.8 13.6 107.0 28.3 13.6
2004
III 17.7 27.8 29.8 13.6 99.5 15.1 13.6
I 20.0 40.5 31.8 19.2 94.0 12.2 12.2
May
II 15.6 33.9 49.1 20.0 44.1 9.5 9.5
2004
III 17.0 37.1 26.9 19.2 20.0 7.7 7.7
I 27.8 26.0 28.8 20.0 NA 5.3 5.3
June
II 20.8 23.3 20.8 14.9 NA 17.1 14.9
2004
III 19.2 21.6 20.0 16.3 NA 12.2 12.2
I 16.3 21.6 20.0 15.6 16.3 11.3 11.3
Jul-04 II 22.5 25.1 28.8 14.3 13.6 18.1 13.6
III 20.8 21.6 26.0 10.9 17.0 18.1 10.9
I 20.8 21.6 19.2 8.0 21.6 18.1 8.0
Aug.
II 21.6 19.2 20.0 7.7 25.1 17.1 7.7
2004
III 21.6 19.2 21.6 8.1 31.8 13.1 8.1
I 21.6 18.5 22.5 7.7 15.6 10.3 7.7
Sep.
II 16.3 9.5 31.8 6.7 7.0 10.3 6.7
2004
III 16.3 8.8 32.8 5.4 7.0 6.1 5.4
(Source: Hydrology Division of Irrigation Dept. Sri Lanka)
3.1.3.4 Downstream Uses with respect to the Intake Point and Waste Water
Disposal Points
Water is proposed to be drawn from Koddiyar Bay and discharged in Shell Bay.
The waters in these areas are used for navigation, fishing, supporting marine life
etc. At present, there is no other industrial use of water from these Bays.
14 Sodium as Na(mg/l) - 34 24 78 43
15 Potassium as K(mg/l) - 10 24 3 5
Following conclusions can be drawn for the ground water quality results
mentioned in Table 3.10:
The pH varies from 7.51 to 8.15
Conductivity varies from 500µmho/cm to 1161 µmho/cm
TDS and TSS vary from 316mg/l to 754mg/l and 6mg/l to 202mg/l
Sodium varies from 24 mg/l to 78 mg/l
Chloride varies from 4 mg/l to 99mg/l
No bacterial contamination.
The physico-chemical characteristics of ground water are good, confirming to
drinking water standards of Sri Lanka (SLS 614 PART1:1, 1983). No bacterial
contamination has been found.
3.1.3.8 Highest Ground Water Level and Lower Ground Water Level
The lowest ground water level purported to have observed, as per local enquiry,
is 1.5 m. The depths to the ground water level in wells from where the ground
water samples were taken during September, 2011, are shown in Table-3.11.
Table-3.11: Depth of Ground Water Level in the Study Area
S. No. Location of Well Depth to Ground Water during
September- 2011, (in meter)
1. Sampoor Village 5.0 m below ground
2. Kaddaiparichan 3.0
3. Illakkantai 4.5
4. Pallikudiyeruppu 4.0
5. Sampu kulam (Near 6.0
compound of govt.
building)
(Source: Measurements by Mantec)
The measurements of ground water levels were also carried out by LHI in 2012 as a
part of ground water studies. The locations for ground water sampling are presented
in Figure 3.6 while the ground water levels observed during the study are presented
in Table-3.12.
3.1.4 Oceanography
3.1.4.1 Coastal & offshore topography of the study area with special
reference attention to sand dunes, coral reefs etc.
Options for the intake structure was considered in the Koddiyar Bay whereas
options for the outfall structure were considered both in Shell bay or in Koddiyar
bay. Shell Bay is exposed to direct waves mainly during the North East Monsoon
Period. Near shore area and the coastline of the project area located in the
Koddiyar Bay are partially protected from direct waves due to the presence of a
headland. Studies related to oceanographic aspects of the project were
undertaken by Lanka Hydraulic Institute. Summary of the studies are provided in
Annexure-XI and XV.
Lanka Hydraulic Institute (LHI) carried out 2 bathymetric surveys (2012 and
2014) of the project area. Figure 3.7 shows the areas covered in the LHI
bathymetric surveys. Figure 3.8 shows the bathymetry of the project area.
Coastline of the project area is stable not being subjected to extensive seasonal
changes. Main features are the natural headland – north of the project site and
river outfalls south of the project site.
The current measurements have been carried out by LHI for a period of two
weeks using the SONTEK Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP). The
instrument is designed to measure current speed and direction through the water
column. The instrument (ADCP) has been deployed at 15m depth and
measurements have taken during the period of 28/8/2014 to 17/9/2014 at the
location shown in Figure 3.9. Current speed and direction have observed
approximately at 1m interval across the water column and the measurements
have carried out at 10 min intervals. Table 3.13 gives the summary of current
speeds and directions. Current speeds in the area are quite small with average
values varying from 0.05 m/s to 0.16 m/s. Maximum currents recorded are in the
range of 0.3 m/s to 0.5 m/s. Current speeds during the North East Monsoon will
be comparatively high due to the influence of NE wind and wave fields. Further
details of water level and current measurements are available in the Final Report
– Trincomalee Thermal Power Project: Additional Field & Modelling Investigations
(LHI – October 2014).
Table 3.13: Summary of Measured Currents
10 -- 12
12 -- 14
14 -- 16
8 -- 10
4 -- 6
6 -- 8
Total
Hs (m)
0 -- 0.1 1.43 3.57 2.86 7.86
0.1 -- 0.2 2.14 25.00 15.00 2.86 0.71 45.71
0.2 -- 0.3 5.00 2.86 7.86
0.3 -- 0.4 1.43 1.43
0.4 -- 0.5 2.86 3.57 6.43
0.5 -- 0.6 1.43 6.43 7.86
0.6 -- 0.7 0.71 7.86 8.57
0.7 -- 0.8 2.86 2.86
0.8 -- 0.9 7.14 7.14
0.9 -- 1 1.43 1.43
1 -- 1.1
1.1 -- 1.2 0.71 1.43 2.14
1.2 -- 1.3 0.71 0.71
Total 5.71 40.00 29.29 18.57 5.71 0.71 100.00
2 -- 4
4 -- 6
Total
Hs (m)
0.2 -- 0.3 0.71 0.71
0.3 -- 0.4 2.86 2.86
0.4 -- 0.5 7.14 7.14
0.5 -- 0.6 10.00 10.00
0.6 -- 0.7 15.71 15.71
0.7 -- 0.8 12.14 12.14
0.8 -- 0.9 12.14 12.14
0.9 -- 1 10.00 10.00
1 -- 1.1 0.71 5.71 6.43
1.1 -- 1.2 10.00 10.00
1.2 -- 1.3 5.00 5.00
1.3 -- 1.4 2.86 2.86
1.4 -- 1.5 2.14 2.14
1.5 -- 1.6 1.43 1.43
1.6 -- 1.7 1.43 1.43
Total 0.71 99.29 100.00
12 -- 14
14 -- 16
8 -- 10
6 -- 8
Total
Hs/(m)
0 -- 0.1 5.36 21.43 23.21 9.38 0.89 60.27
0.1 -- 0.2 4.46 12.05 4.46 1.34 22.32
0.2 -- 0.3 4.91 3.13 8.04
0.3 -- 0.4 4.46 4.46
0.4 -- 0.5 4.02 4.02
0.5 -- 0.6
0.6 -- 0.7 0.89 0.89
Total 24.11 36.61 27.68 10.71 0.89 100.00
2 -- 4
4 -- 6
6 -- 8
Total
Hs (m)
0 -- 0.1 1.34 1.34
0.1 -- 0.2 0.45 13.84 14.29
0.2 -- 0.3 2.23 12.95 15.18
0.3 -- 0.4 0.45 12.05 12.50
0.4 -- 0.5 8.04 8.04
0.5 -- 0.6 6.70 6.70
0.6 -- 0.7 4.02 4.02
0.7 -- 0.8 5.36 5.36
0.8 -- 0.9 4.46 4.46
0.9 -- 1 10.27 10.27
1 -- 1.1 5.80 5.80
1.1 -- 1.2 0.45 5.36 5.80
1.2 -- 1.3 2.68 2.68
1.3 -- 1.4 2.68 2.68
1.4 -- 1.5 0.45 0.45
1.5 -- 1.6 0.45 0.45
Total 3.57 96.43 100.00
12 -- 14
14 -- 16
16 -- 18
18 -- 20
8 -- 10
6 -- 8
Total
Hs (m)
0 -- 0.1 0.81 13.71 31.45 25.40 2.02 73.39
0.1 -- 0.2 0.81 16.13 8.87 0.81 26.61
Total 1.61 29.84 40.32 26.21 2.02 100.00
8 -- 10
2 -- 4
4 -- 6
6 -- 8
Total
Hs/(m)
0 -- 0.1 12.50 26.61 0.81 39.92
0.1 -- 0.2 0.40 26.21 2.02 0.40 29.03
0.2 -- 0.3 0.40 4.84 5.24
0.3 -- 0.4 0.81 5.24 6.05
0.4 -- 0.5 6.05 6.05
0.5 -- 0.6 0.81 5.65 6.45
0.6 -- 0.7 0.40 4.44 4.84
0.7 -- 0.8 1.61 1.61
0.8 -- 0.9 0.81 0.81
Total 2.82 67.34 28.63 1.21 100.00
period. Figure 3.10 gives Seasonal Wave Rose Diagrams (2007 - 2012) for
Offshore_ Overall Waves.
The MIKE 21 Flow Model FM (Flexible mesh) has been used for the hydrodynamic
modeling. Model has setup by using the unstructured mesh generated with water
depths and contour maps for proposed area. The unstructured mesh has been
selected as it is appropriate to model a large area at once considering different
resolutions. With the use of unstructured mesh, interested areas can be defined
with high resolution giving all the required details where as the other areas could
be represented with reasonable resolution maintaining the total number of nodes
in the domain at a manageable level. Structures and other special features can
also be easily represented by using the flexible mesh.
The simulations of hydrodynamic model has been performed for the forcing of
different tide, wind, wave conditions and the sources from the surrounding water
bodies during different seasonal periods. Time series of water levels based on the
tidal constituents of Point Pedro and Oluvil have been used as the Northern and
Southern boundaries of the model.
MIKE 21 Spectral Wave Model (SW) has been used to transfer the available UKMO
wave data (at 4000m depth and 70km away from the interest area) to the area of
interest and corresponding wave radiation stresses together with wind fields of
the area have been used for the prediction of wave induced currents. The model
has been calibrated and verified with available data of water level and current.
Based on the wind conditions observed within the local model area, two scenarios
have been selected to represent average (1.8 m/s, 450) and high (5.1 m/s, 450)
wind conditions. In both cases the wind was assumed to be constant in time and
space. Based on offshore wave data two scenarios have been selected to
represent average (1.28 m, 5.6 seconds, 72.50) and high (3.11 m, 7.9 seconds,
47.00) wave conditions. Total number of scenarios modeled based on different
wind, wave and tide conditions are given in Table 3.20.
Simulations S1 to S24 in Table 3.20 have used to compare the current and
sediment transport patterns around the area of interest covering NE, SW and
inter monsoon periods. SW monsoon period has identified as the most critical
period and hence additional modeling (S25 to S32) scenarios have been carried
out only for this period. This additional modeling includes the structural
configurations of the proposed intake and outfall structures.
Further modeling runs have been carried out for a one year period incorporating
all seasons to assess the long-term changes. Table 3.21 gives the model
scenarios for long-term modeling.
Selected two dimensional vector plots of current speeds are given in Figure 3.11
to Figure 3.13. Figure 3.11 represents the Spring Tide together with peak wind
& wave conditions of NE monsoon period whereas Figure 3.12 and Figure 3.13
represent the Spring Tide together with peak wind & wave conditions of SW
monsoon period. Figure 3.13 include proposed intake and outfall structures in
addition to the intake and outflows.
Corresponding figures during Neap Tide together with peak wind & wave
conditions are very similar to Spring Tide indicating a lesser influence of tidal
dynamics. On the other hand, figures with average wind & wave conditions,
during both spring and neap periods show comparatively small current fields,
showing the influence of wind & wave conditions on current fields of the area.
Figure 3.11: Vector Plot for Current Flow around Proposed Plant Area
NE Monsoon, Spring Tide & Peak Conditions (Wind & Wave)
Figure 3.12: Vector Plot for Current Flow around Proposed Plant Area
SW Monsoon, Spring Tide & Peak Conditions (Wind & Wave)
(a) With Proposed Intake Structure (Option 1) (b) With Proposed Intake Structure (Option 2)
and outfall and outfall
Figure 3.13: Vector Plot for Current Flow around Proposed Plant Area
SW Monsoon, Spring Tide & Peak Conditions (Wind & Wave)
All the collected samples have been analyzed for particle size distribution and the
summary of the results are given in Table 3.22 and 3.23. Further details of
sediment sampling are available in the Final Report – Trincomalee Thermal Power
Project: Additional Field & Modelling Investigations (LHI – October 2014).
Sediment transport study has been carried out using the results of hydrodynamic
and wave transformation modeling. Representative environmental scenarios have
been formulated based on the annual wave climate and current patterns. The
sediment data for the model study have been selected based on the results of
bed sediment analysis of the project area. The wave/current induced sediment
transport and the associated morphological evolution in the study area have
modeled using MIKE 21 ST module.
Figure 3.16: Vector Plot for Sediment Transport Field around Proposed Plant Area
NE Monsoon, Spring Tide & Peak Conditions (Wind & Wave)
Figure 3.17: Vector Plot for Sediment Transport Field around Proposed Plant Area
SW Monsoon, Spring Tide & Peak Conditions (Wind & Wave)
(a) With Proposed Intake Structure (Option 1) (b) With Proposed Intake Structure (Option 2)
and outfall and outfall
Figure 3.18: Vector Plot for Sediment Transport Field around Proposed Plant Area
SW Monsoon, Spring Tide & Peak Conditions (Wind & Wave)
Table 3.24: Sea water quality in close proximity to proposed Intake and
Outfall structures
Intake Outfall
Top Middle Botto Top Middl Botto
m e m
pH - 8.0 (at 8.1 (at 8.1 (at 8.1 (at 8.1 (at 8.1
250C) 250C) 250C) 250C) 250C) (at
250C)
TSS mg/l 5 3 6 4 3 2
Conductivity mS/cm 32.4 (at 39.1 39.3 (at 39.8 40.7 41.2
250C) (at 250C) (at (at (at
250C) 250C) 250C) 250C)
Alkalinity (as CaCo3) mg/l 116 118 118 120 118 121
Total Dissolved mg/l 30750 37814 35655 35824 35488 35190
Solids
Total Hardness (as - 6130 6032 6179 6179 5934 6228
CaCo3)
Calcium (as Ca) mg/l 814 1596 17.7 18 17.8 2022
Magnesium (as Mg) mg/l 1528 1623 13.3 13 13.2 1693
Chloride (as Cl) mg/l 18212 17970 18212 17921 18164 17921
Phosphate (as PO4) - ND ND ND ND ND ND
Nitrate (NO3) mg/l 2 1.9 1.8 1.8 1.7 1.7
Oil and Grease mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND
Sulphate (as SO4) mg/l 2076 2122 1864 2222 2238 3064
Sodium (as Na) mg/l 15680 17358 351 388 343 15648
Potassium (as K) mg/l 798 853 357 37 34 860
BOD5 mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND
COD mg/l - - - ND ND ND
Phenolic compounds mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND
Copper (as Cu) mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND
Silica (as Si) mg/l 3 0.8 0.5 0.9 2 0.6
Mercury (as Hg) mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND
Cadmium (as Cd) mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND
Selenium (as Se) mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND
Arsenic (as As) mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND
Lead (as Pb) mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND
Zinc (as Zn) mg/l ND ND ND ND ND 0.17
Chromium (as Cr) mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND
Chromium (as Cr64) mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND
Iron Total (as Fe) mg/l ND ND ND ND ND ND
Total Coliform MPN/100 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2
ml
Fecal Coliform MPN/100 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 <2
ml
Note: ND – Not detected
(Source: LHI and SGS)
Abbreviations:
ND- Not Detectable
NA-Below level causing algae bloom (to be established)
NO-Not Objectionable
Methodology
The samples collected from the all locations are homogeneous representative of
each location. At random 10 sub locations were identified at each location and soil
was dug from 30 cm below the surface. It was uniformly mixed before
homogenizing the soil samples. The samples were filled in polythene bags,
labeled in the field with number and site name and sent to Mantec Laboratory for
analysis.
Table 3.27: Soil Sampling Location of the Study Area
*Station Stations Distance(Km) Direction Type
Code w.r.t. project w.r.t.
site project site
SQ1 Coal stocking Yard 0.0 km - Project site
SQ2 Switch Yard 0.0 km - Project site
SQ3 Ash pond Area 0.0 km - Ash Pond Site
SQ4 Sampoor West 2.0km NW Agriculture land
village
SQ5 Foul Point 5.0 km E Scrub forest -
coastal area
SQ6 Sunkakuli 1.0 km S Agricultural land
SQ7 Kaddaiparichan 3.0 km SW Scrub forest land
SQ8 Navrendanpuram 3.0km SE Agriculture land
SQ9 Ilakantai 5.0km E Scrubs/
Agriculture land
SQ10 Koonithivu 4.0km N Village land
*SQ -Soil Quality
*w.r.t.-with respect to
Chemical Properties
The results of chemical analysis of the soil samples are presented in Table 3.29.
The analysis of the samples represents that the pH varies from 6.74 to 8.4 i.e.
from neutral to slightly alkaline. The N, P, K values varies from 1.37 to 8.4
mg/100g, 31.33 to 631.6 mg/100g and 0.6 to 14 mg/100g respectively.
Conductivity varies from 5.0 to 7709.82µmho/cm with a bulk density from 1.48
to 1.64 gm/cm3
Coal stocking Yard 7.33 8.87 34.2 1.54 1614 6.2 0.75 0.43 1.06 0.28 3.14 33.7 2.9 16.4 10.68
Switch Yard 6.74 0.61 38.3 1.57 138 0.62 0.32 0.16 1.10 0.87 5.14 34.6 0.6 2 1.30
Ash pond Area 6.98 ND 39.1 1.59 152 0.54 0.43 0.25 3.22 3.66 2.86 55.87 0.9 3.3 2.14
Sampoor West
8.0 2.65 40.2 1.48 371 0.45 2.01 1.16 5.80 0.53 2.57 272.3 1.0 2.6 1.69
village
Foul Point 7.2 3.05 38.2 1.48 141 0.38 2.08 1.21 4.78 2.17 2.86 34.46 0.6 2.3 1.50
Sunkakuli 7.99 10.12 39.1 1.57 586 2.11 0.91 0.53 3.15 2.24 2.57 123.7 0.8 11.3 7.36
Kaddaiparichan 8.10 10.2 38.2 1.47 316 0.89 0.48 0.28 5.32 1.2 3.7 199.6 1.1 3.7 2.4
Navrendanpuram 8.41 7.35 40.1 1.49 5.0 1.0 1.17 0.68 3.46 3.66 3.14 46.59 0.6 6.1 3.97
Ilakantai 8.20 4.05 38.2 1.49 335 0.53 0.85 0.49 3.89 1.22 2.28 31.33 1.6 2.8 1.82
Koonithivu 7.60 5.8 39.2 1.53 407.1 1.09 1.43 0.82 5.24 1.14 3.08 631.7 2.5 4.5 2.92
(Source: Monitoring by Mantec Consultants)
The location of the monitoring stations with reference to the proposed plant site is
given in Table 3.30 and shown in Figure 3.22.
Ambient air quality monitoring was carried out with a frequency of one hourly for
seven days at all five locations for SO2, NOx, CO and O3 and 24 hourly for PM10
and PM2.5.
PM2.5:
A PM2.5 air sampler (Win-impact) draws ambient air at a constant volumetric flow
rate maintained by a mass flow/ volumetric flow controller coupled to a
microprocessor into specially designed inertial particle-size separator where the
suspended particulate matter in the PM2.5 size ranges is separated for collection
on a 47 mm Poly Tetra Fluoro Ethylene (PTFE) filter over a specified sampling
period. Each filter is weighed before and after sample collection to determine the
net gain due to the particulate matter. The mass concentration in the ambient air
is computed as the total mass of collected particles in the PM2.5 size ranges
divided by the actual volume of air sampled, and is expressed in μg/m3.
Nitrogen Oxides
Sampling and analysis of ambient NOx was performed by adopting the 'Jacob
Hochheister Modified (Na arsenite)' method. Ambient air is drawn through an
impinger at a pre determined flow rate of 1 ppm. The impinger contains known
volume of absorbing solution of sodium arsenite and sodium hydroxide. Oxides of
nitrogen react with the absorbing reagent to form a stable solution of sodium
nitrite. The nitrate ion produced during the sampling is estimated calorimetrically,
after reacting with phosphoric acid, sulphanilamide and naphthyl ethylenediamine
dihydrochloride (NEDA), using spectrophotometer at 540 nm wavelength. The
measured Optical Density is used to determine the concentration of NOx from the
calibration curve already prepared against known concentrations of nitrite ion.
The mass of NOx in the absorbing reagent, divided by the volume of sampled air
provides the concentration of NOx, which is expressed as μg/m3.
Carbon Monoxide
An atmospheric sample is introduced into a sample conditioning system and then
into a non-dispersive infrared spectrometer (NDIR). The spectrometer measures
the absorption by CO at 4.7 μm using two parallel infrared beams through a
sample cell, a reference cell and a selective detector. The detector signal is led to
an amplifier control section and the analyzer output measured on a meter and
recording system.
Ozone
Micro-amounts of ozone and the oxidants liberate iodine when absorbed in a 1%
solution of potassium iodine buffered at pH 6.8 0.2. The iodine is determined
spectrophotometrically by measuring the absorption of tri-iodine ion at 352nm.
The stoichiometry is approximated by the following reaction:
O3 + 3Kl+ H2O KI3 + 2 KOH + O3
This method covers the manual determination of oxidant concentrations between
0.01 to 10 ppm (19.6 to 19620μg/m3) as ozone.
When 10ml of absorbing solution is used, between 1 and 10 μl of ozone,
corresponding to absorbance between 0.1 and 1 in a 1 cm cell, are collected.
The precision of the method within the recommended range is about +/- 5%
deviation from the mean. The major error is from loss of iodine during sampling
periods; this can be reduced by using a second impinger.
The method was compared against an absolute ultraviolet photometer. In the
range of 40-60% relative humidity the ozone- iodine stoichiometry was 1.25 and
not 1.00 as suggested by the above equation.
Calculations
Standard conditions are taken as 101.3 kilo Pascal (kPa) and 25ºC, at
which the molar gas volume is 24.47 liters.
The volume of sample collected is recorded in liters.
The total µl of O3 / 10ml of reagent are read from the calibration curve.
The concentration of O3 in the gas phase in µl/ l or parts per million (ppm)
is given by:
O3 ppm = total µl ozone per 10ml
Volume of air sample, L
Presentation of Results
The results of ambient air quality monitoring for the period of one month are
presented in Table 3.33 to Table 3.37 and its summary in Table 3.48. Various
parameters were monitored during the study and the hourly average values have
been computed from the monitored data for all the locations.
Particulate Matter (PM10): The maximum value for PM10 is observed, as
88µg/m3 at Trincomalee while 24 hours applicable limit is 100µg/m3. The area
observes PM10 in the range of 56- 88µg/m3 with the lowest concentration recorded
in Sampoor.
Particulate Matter (PM2.5): The maximum value for PM2.5 is observed, as
38µg/m3 at Trincomalee while 24 hours applicable limit is 50µg/m3. The area
observes PM2.5 in the range of 20- 38µg/m3 with the lowest concentration
recorded in Sampoor.
SO2: The maximum value for SO2 is observed, as 13.0µg/m3 at Mutur town while
1 hourly applicable limit is of 200 µg/m3. The area observes SO2 in the range of
6-13 µg/m3 with the lowest concentration recorded in all the other villages except
Mutur town and Toppur.
NOx: The maximum value for NO2 is observed at, as 24.0µg/m3 at Mutur town
and Santoshpuram while 1 hourly applicable limit is of 250 µg/m3. The area
observes NO2 in the range of 10-24 µg/m3 with the lowest concentration recorded
in Toppur.
O3: The maximum value for O3 is observed at, as 39.0µg/m3 at Mutur town while
1 hour applicable limit is of 200 µg/m3. The area observes O3 in the range of 20-
39.0 µg/m3 with the lowest concentration recorded in Sampoor.
CO: The maximum value for CO is observed at, as 900µg/m3 at Trincomalee while
1 hour applicable limit is of 30000 µg/m3. The area observes CO in the range of
100-900 µg/m3 with the lowest concentration recorded in Santosh puram.
Date Location PM10 PM2.5 CO (1 Hourly, O3 (1 Hourly, SO2 (1 Hourly, NOx (1 Hourly, g/m3)
(24 (24 g/m3) g/m3) g/m3)
Hourly, Hourly,
g/m3) g/m3)
1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th
8/09/2011 56 23 160 180 220 215 20 24 20 20 10 11 8 12 14 22 20 16
29/09/2011 62 25 175 200 210 220 24 26 28 22 10 7 8 11 22 16 18 14
30/09/2011 56 20 165 185 210 225 22 28 25 24 7 11 10 12 22 18 18 18
Sampoor
01/10/2011 64 22 170 190 200 215 24 26 30 28 6 8 11 9 18 16 19 18
02/10/2011 60 24 185 190 210 220 29 21 28 24 10 6 7 11 18 20 18 14
03/10/2011 68 27 165 210 220 185 26 24 30 26 10 11 8 6 22 14 12 15
04/10/2011 64 24 190 165 200 180 29 29 24 29 12 9 8 7 19 23 18 11
Date Location PM10 PM2.5 CO (1 Hourly, O3 (1 Hourly, SO2 (1 Hourly, NOx (1 Hourly, g/m3)
(24 (24 g/m3) g/m3) g/m3)
Hourly, Hourly,
g/m3) g/m3)
1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th
28/09/2011 50 21 100 130 150 180 24 30 28 24 10 8 9 7 20 24 22 20
29/09/2011 54 23 110 125 140 150 27 34 26 25 11 10 9 8 15 20 18 16
Santosh
30/09/2011 58 25 125 150 180 170 28 36 25 27 6 8 10 12 13 12 17 15
Puram
01/10/2011 68 29 120 140 130 150 24 32 28 29 8 12 11 8 22 20 23 22
02/10/2011 64 26 100 150 140 130 26 34 30 32 9 8 7 9 19 23 20 17
03/10/2011 62 25 115 130 140 150 32 37 31 32 7 11 9 10 13 22 17 21
04/10/2011 70 28 150 160 140 155 28 32 34 35 9 12 10 7 13 19 18 12
Date Location PM10 PM2.5 CO (1 Hourly, O3 (1 Hourly, SO2 (1 Hourly, NOx (1 Hourly, g/m3)
(24 (24 g/m3) g/m3) g/m3)
Hourly, Hourly,
g/m3) g/m3)
1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th
05/10/2011 74 30 320 400 440 460 24 27 34 30 12 10 9 12 18 21 14 22
06/10/2011 68 28 340 350 370 430 27 30 32 28 9 11 10 11 16 20 15 20
Mutur
07/10/2011 66 26 330 400 430 440 29 32 30 26 8 7 8 10 16 12 18 24
Town
08/10/2011 72 29 325 350 380 390 26 29 28 27 10 9 8 7 16 22 20 16
09/10/2011 78 31 350 400 430 440 32 28 29 30 11 8 7 10 24 20 19 16
10/10/2011 65 26 400 430 440 360 39 26 27 34 7 10 12 8 14 22 20 17
11/10/2011 68 24 430 400 450 460 37 25 26 32 7 13 8 7 16 20 12 14
Date Location PM10 PM2.5 CO (1 Hourly, O3 (1 Hourly, SO2 (1 Hourly, NOx (1 Hourly, g/m3)
(24 (24 g/m3) g/m3) g/m3)
Hourly, Hourly,
g/m3) g/m3)
1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th
05/10/2011 76 32 220 300 380 340 22 25 28 26 8 7 10 12 12 19 16 18
06/10/2011 70 28 240 280 340 350 24 24 25 24 9 10 11 9 10 16 14 16
07/10/2011 65 26 230 300 350 380 26 30 24 23 11 7 9 8 10 15 20 22
Toppur
08/10/2011 68 27 280 350 300 300 27 27 22 22 8 9 7 10 19 22 13 18
09/10/2011 74 30 300 340 280 300 30 26 28 27 8 10 8 10 18 22 16 17
10/10/2011 76 31 340 300 350 280 28 29 30 29 10 12 8 10 23 12 12 20
11/10/2011 72 28 350 300 360 300 26 24 27 28 9 12 10 9 17 22 16 23
Date Location PM10 PM2.5 CO (1 Hourly, O3 (1 Hourly, SO2 (1 Hourly, NOx (1 Hourly, g/m3)
(24 (24 g/m3) g/m3) g/m3)
Hourly, Hourly,
g/m3) g/m3)
1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 1st 2nd 3rd 4th
12/10/2011 78 31 450 500 800 700 22 24 30 28 8 6 10 8 14 12 16 20
13/10/2011 85 35 500 700 600 800 28 26 28 25 11 8 10 7 20 19 14 19
14/10/2011 82 34 600 900 800 700 30 28 26 24 9 12 8 10 17 20 18 16
Trincomalee
15/10/2011 80 30 540 650 840 680 26 28 30 22 11 9 10 10 20 22 18 14
16/10/2011 82 33 640 700 580 640 32 30 26 28 8 7 11 10 19 17 23 20
17/10/2011 86 36 540 700 750 880 30 26 24 24 8 7 9 10 16 19 22 21
18/10/2011 88 38 650 800 900 850 24 28 26 26 9 8 10 11 17 18 20 19
Table 3.38: Summary of Ambient Air Quality in Study Area (28.09.11 to 18.10.2011)
Location PM10 (24 PM2.5 (24 CO (1 Hourly, O3 (1 Hourly, SO2 (1 Hourly, NOx (1 Hourly, g/m3)
Hourly, Hourly, g/m3) g/m3) g/m3)
g/m3) g/m3)
Range Avg. Range Avg. Range Avg. Range Avg. Range Avg. Range Avg.
3.1.7 NOISE
Noise is said to be defined as an unwanted sound. It is, therefore, necessary to
measure both the quality as well as the quantity of environment noise in and
around the power plant.
LAeq T, dB (A)
Category of Area Daytime Nighttime
(6.00 AM to (18.00 PM to
18.00 PM) 6.00 AM)
Low Noise Area1 55 45
Medium Noise Area2 63* 50
High Noise Area3 70 60
Silent Zone4 50 45
Note:
LAeq T- Maximum permissible noise levels
1. area located within any Pradeshiya Sabha
2. area located within any Municipal Council or Urban Council area
3. any export processing zone established by Board of Investment or industrial
estates approved under Part-IVC of the National Environmental Act
4. area covered by a distance of 100 m from the boundary of the court house,
hospital, public library, school, zoo, sacred areas and areas set apart for
recreational or environmental purposes
* - Provided that the noise level should not exceed 60 dB (A) inside existing
houses, during day time.
influence for many decades. Specifically, Tropical Dry Mixed Evergreen Forests,
Tropical Thorn Forests, Damana and Villu Grasslands, Riverine and Gallery
Forests, Salt Marshes do not exist in the study area. Forests that exist within the
study area had grown after the disappearance of the ancient hydraulic civilization
that persisted over much of the dry zone of Sri Lanka for centuries and therefore,
are secondary in origin. Repeated disturbances in such secondary forests due to
human activities such as agriculture, timber logging and frequent shifting
cultivation etc., and lack of regeneration of high value forest species has resulted
in the formation of scrub forests or scrublands. This is not a true climax
vegetation type even though it is present throughout the dry zone of Sri Lanka.
Therefore, the secondary forests that exist in the study area can be classified as
Scrublands.
Sand Dunes and Strand Vegetation occur along the coastal zone of the study
area. However, those sand dunes are not extensive and the vegetation observed
on the sand dunes is highly disturbed.
Few rock outcrops were observed in the study area during the study and they
contain rock outcrop associated vegetation.
In addition to these terrestrial habitats several aquatic habitats such as lagoons,
estuaries and flood-plain wetlands are present in the area. Further, few small
(small in width and short in length) seasonal streams were observed to drain
through the study area and release in to the sea at Koddiyar Bay. Mangroves
were observed at the edges of the lagoons and estuaries while the flood-plain
wetlands supported fresh water plant communities. On the banks of the seasonal
streams, disturbed mixed riparian vegetation was observed.
In addition to above natural habitats, several non natural and semi natural such
as, tanks, abandoned lands, abandoned paddy lands, agricultural lands and home
gardens were observed in the area. Habitat map of the study area is presented in
Figure 3.24.
Based on the habitat map developed species sampling locations were identified
and Point samples or line transects surveys were conducted at each of the
sampling locations identified. Both direct observations as well as verifiable
indirect observations such as nests, droppings, footprints, and calls were recorded
in the case of animals. When direct observation is possible the identity and
number of individuals were recorded. Location of each sampling point was geo-
referenced for future monitoring purposes (Table 3.42).
WA
SC
SD
SC
SC
SD AP
AB
WA
SC
SC
MG
MG
MG
Table 3.42:. The coordinates of the sampling locations, the type of habitat
present and the season during which sampling was carried out at the location.
Shaded rows indicate sites that are outside the direct impact zone. Locations
16 and 17 are at the intake and pipe line path. Locations 18 and 19 are at the
out fall and pipeline path.
Altogether 25 locations were sampled (12 locations inside the project affected
area and 13 locations within the 2 km boundary of the project affected area.
Sampling was carried out both during the dry season and wet season as indicated
in Table 3.42.
Aquatic fauna were surveyed using sampling gears such as cast nets, fine meshed
drag nets, hand nets and scoop nets. Furthermore, interviews were conducted
with the fishermen in the area in order to collect information on the species
present. Aquatic amphibians and reptiles were recorded by direct observations.
The amphibians usually occupy the surface layer of the water and also inhabit the
area closer to the shore and therefore easy to spot from the edge of the water
body. Aquatic birds were sampled from the shore line and birds observed were
recorded. Both direct observations and indirect observations such as existence of
nests, droppings and calls were recorded.
Within each sampling site, the flowering plants observed were identified to their
families, genera and species. Specimens of unidentified species were collected
and numbered for subsequent identification at the National Herbarium.
Determination of conservation and taxonomic status
The animal classification, nomenclature, endemism and local names are in
accordance with Bedjanic et al., (2007), D’abrera (1998), das & de Silva (2005),
Goonatilake (2007), Harrison (1999), Manamendra-Arachchi & Pethiyagoda
(2006), Phillips (1935).
The plant classification, nomenclature, endemism and local names are in
accordance with Dassanayake (1980-2000) and Senaratne (2001). The life form
for each species (tree, shrub and herb etc.) was obtained based on field
observations and literature (Dassanayake 1980-2000).
The national conservation status of the species was determined according to the
Ministry of Environment (MOE, 2012) and the global conservation status was
based on latest global listing International Union for Conservation of Nature
(IUCN, 2014). The endemism and commercial importance was determined based
on the published information on these species.
Detailed descriptions of the natural habitats observed in the project area are
given below.
Scrublands
Scrublands are the dominant vegetation type observed in the proposed site for
the establishment of the coal power plant, proposed water intake path and the
water outfall path. It is also common in the area surrounding the site selected for
the proposed project (Figure 3.25).
These scrublands have resulted due to repeated disturbances to forests due to
human activities such as timber logging, fuel wood extraction and shifting
cultivation. Therefore, scrublands present in the study area can be considered as
a late seral stage in the ecological succession towards the typical climax state
present in the area, the dry mixed evergreen forests that have been prevented
from reaching a climax stage due to high human influence on these habitats.
Two types of scrublands can be identified in the area. One is open scrublands and
other one is the thick scrublands. Open scrublands are characterized by thick
scrub patches separated by open grass or forb lands (Figure 3.25) whereas thick
scrublands does not contain any open grass or forb lands (Figure 3.26).
Floristically, thick scrublands and open scrublands do not differ from each other.
Further, plant species assemblage of scrublands present within the proposed
project site did not show any difference with that of the scrublands observed in
the area surrounding the proposed project site (see Annexure-XII)
Derris parviflora (Kala Wel), Eugenia willdenowii, Vernonia zeylanica (Pupula),
Cassine glauca (Neralu) and Premna alstoni (Gal Kera) are the recorded endemic
plant species within the scrublands present within and the area surrounding the
proposed project site.
Manilkara hexandra (Palu), Tinospora cordifolia (Rasakinda), Chloroxylon
swietenia (Buruta), Margaritaria indicus (Karawu), Strychnos nux-vomica
(Godakaduru), Pachygone ovata are the recorded nationally vulnerable (VU) plant
species and Vitex altissima (Milla), Salvadora persica (Maliththan), Diospyros
montana, Erythroxylum monogynum (Devadaram) are the recorded nationally
near threatened (NT) plant species within the scrublands present within and area
surrounding the proposed project site. A detailed list of plant species observed in
the scrubland vegetation found within and around the proposed project area is
given in Table 1 and 2 of Annexure-XII.
Figure 3.27: Typical sand dune vegetation that can be seen in the study area
Figure 3.28. Rock outcrop present within the land selcted for the
establishment of the proposed coal power plant
Figure 3.29. Rock outcrop present in outside the project area showing the
vegetation associated with the rock outcrop habitat
Two endemic plant species Derris parviflora (Kala Wel) and Vernonia zeylanica
(Pupula) was recorded within the rock outcrop vegetation present both within and
the area surrounding the proposed project site. Further, two Nationally Vulnerable
(VU) plant species, Manilkara hexandra (Palu), Strychnos nux-vomica
(Godakaduru) and four Nationally Near Threatened (NT) plant species, Dioscorea
oppositifolia (Gonala), Salvadora persica (Maliththan), Sansevieria zeylanica
(Niyanda), Vitex altissima (Milla) were recorded in this habitat. Also one species,
Tinospora sinensis (Bu Kinda) listed as Nationally Data Deficient (DD) was
observed among the vegetation associated with rock outcrops both within and the
area surrounding the proposed project site. A detailed list of plant species
observed in the rock outcrop vegetation in and around the proposed project area
is given in Table 1 and 2 of Annexure-XII.
Mangroves
Mangrove vegetation was observed on the edges of the lagoons and estuaries in
the area surrounding the proposed project site and at Foul Point (Figure 3.30
and 3.31).
Figure 3.30: Typical mangrove vegetation observed along the edges of lagoons
and estuaries
Wetlands
Several flood-plain wetlands exist (Sambu Kulam, Villu Kulam, etc.) in the area
that surrounds the site selcted for the project. Fresh water plant communities
were observed in such flood-plain wetlands. The vegetation comprised of aquatic
and semi aquatic plant species such as Ceratophyllum demersum, Nelumbo
nucifera (Nelum), Fimbristylis spp., Cyperus spp., Ludwigia adscendens (Beru
Sampu Kulam
Villu Kulam
Figure 3.32: The two main flood-plain wetlands observed outside the direct
impact zone of the proposed project site.
Villu Kulam
Tanks
Many small manmade tanks are present in the study area (both within and in the
area surrounding the proposed project site).
Neptunia oleracea (Diya Nidikumba), Marsilea minuta (Hathara pethiya),
Limnophila sp., Aponogeton natans (Kekatiya) are the aquatic plant species
observed in such tanks. The water level in these seasonal tanks progressively
recede with the onset of the dry season and the exposed tank bed becomes
colonized by plant species such as Cyperus spp., Fimbristylis spp., Desmodium
triflorum (Undupiyaliya), Mimosa pudica (Nidikumba), Chrysopogon aciculatus
(Tuttiri), Tephrosia purpurea (Pila), Melochia corchorifolia (Gal Kura), Coldenia
procumbens, Cynodon dactylon, Cassia occidentalis (Peni Tora), Cassia tora (Peti
Tora), Glinus oppositifolia (Heen Ala), Heliotropium indicum (Et Honda), Marsilea
minuta (Hathara pethiya), Alternanthera sessilis (Mugunuwenna), Phyla nodiflora
(Hiramanadetta), Schoenoplectus articulatus (Maha Geta Pan), Croton
bonplandianus, Evolvulus nummularius, Hygrophila schulli (Niramulliya), Neptunia
oleracea (Diya Nidikumba), Sphaeranthus africanus (Velmudda), Xanthium
indicum (Urukossa).
The riparian zone of the tanks are inhabited by plant species such as Mitragyna
parvifolia (Helamba), Madhuca longifolia (Mi), Diospyros malabarica (Timbiri),
Syzygium cumini (Madan) while epiphytic orchid species such as Acampe
praemorsa and Vanda tessellata were observed on Madhuca longifolia (Mi) trees
present in the riparian zone.
Aponogeton natans (Kekatiya) and Vanda tessellata observed in this habitats are
listed as nationally vulnerable (VU) species while Madhuca longifolia (Mi) is listed
as a nationally near threatened plant species.
A rare coastal plant species, Euphorbia atoto was recorded among the beach
vegetation of the Foul Point. This plant has not been recorded for many years and
therefore, in the 2012 national red data book, it was listed under the critically
endangered possibly extinct {CR (PE)} category. Another rare plant species,
Cordia subcordata listed as nationally endangered (EN) was also recorded in this
habitat. In addition, four plant species, Crinum zeylanicum, Ipomoea stolonifera,
Manilkara hexandra (Palu), Guettarda speciosa (Nil Pichcha), listed as nationally
vulnerable (VU) and five plant species, Aristolochia bracteolata (Sapsanda),
Erythroxylum monogynum (Agil), Pemphis acidula (Kiri Maram), Salvadora
persica (Maliththan), Vitex trifolia listed as nationally near threatened (NT) were
recorded in the beach and sand dune vegetation of the Foul point area. A
detailed list of plant species recorded in the beach, sand dunes and mangroves of
the Foul point area listed in Table 2 of Annexure-XII.
Table 3.43: Summary of the plant species recorded during the study
Threatened and
Total Near Threatened
Plant Type DD Endemic Native Exotic
Species CR
CR EN VU NT
(PE)
Tree 92 0 1 1 7 11 0 2 81 9
Shrub 33 1 0 0 1 0 1 26 6
Herb 70 0 0 0 2 2 0 0 61 9
Epiphyte 4 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 4 0
Climbers 44 0 0 0 3 2 1 2 41 1
Total 243 1 1 1 13 16 1 5 213 25
% 2% 88% 10%
Abbreviations: CR (PE) - Critically Endangered (Possibly Extinct), CR - Critically
Endangered, EN - Endangered, VU - Vulnerable, NT - Near Threatened, DD - Data
Deficient
Table 3.45: Endemic, rare, threatened and near threatened plant species
observed in and around the proposed project site.
Fauna:
The 285 faunal species recorded in the project area included 14 species that are
endemic to Sri Lanka (Table 3.46) and 13 species that are listed as Nationally
Threatened (three Nationally Critically Endangered species, four Nationally
Endangered species and six Nationally Vulnerable species). A further nine species
that are listed as Nationally Near Threatened was also observed in the study area
(MOE, 2012). The faunal assemblage also included six species that are listed as
Globally Threatened (one Critically Endangered species, one Endangered species
and four Vulnerable species) and three species that are listed as Globally Near
Threatened (IUCN, 2014).
Table 3.46: Endemic, rare, threatened and near threatened animal species
observed in and around the proposed project site.
Family Scientific Local Name TS NCS GCS In- Out-
Name side side
Ariophantidae Euplecta layardi E EN NE +
Macrachlamys
Ariophantidae vilipensa N DD NE +
Cyc!ophorus
Cyclophoridae menkeanus E VU NE + +
Pterocyclus
Cyclophoridae cumingi N NT NE + +
Theobaldius
Cyclophoridae cratera E DD NE + +
Lathrecista
Libellulidae asiatica N NT LC + +
Tirumala Anduruwan nil-
Nymphalidae septentrionis kotithiya N NT NE +
Papilionidae Papilio crino Mayurabada N VU NE +
Thundu Digapath
Pieridae Appias galene Samanalaya E LC NE + +
Podu tembiliwan
Pieridae Colotis aurora sudana N VU NE +
Anabas
Anabantidae testudineus Kavaiya N LC DD +
Calotes Thola-visituru
Agamidae ceylonensis katussa E NT NE +
Eretmochelys
Cheloniidae imbricata Pothu kasbaeva N EN CR +
Crocodylus
Crocodylidae palustris Hala kimbula N NT VU +
Hemidactylus
Gekkonidae depressus Hali gehuna E LC LC +
Xenochrophis
Natricidae asperrimus Diya polonga E LC NE +
Pythonidae Python molurus Pimbura N LC VU +
Geochelone
Testudinidae elegans Taraka ibba N NT LC + +
Lissemys
Trionychidae ceylonensis Kiri ibba E LC NE +
Rhinophis
Uropeltidae oxyrynchus Ul thudulla E LC NE +
4
CR status applies only to the small breeding colony present in the coastal sand
dunes south of Panama and the winter visitor population which is present at the
study site should be designated as Not Evaluated (NE).
Figure 3.34: Protected areas and forest reserves found in the vicinity of the
project area (source: Environmental Sensitive Area map prepared by the central
Environmental Authority)
Coastal waters of the area are extremely turbid throughout the year. Therefore
the bottom of the bay does not get enough sunlight to create a well-diversified
ecosystem. As a result the bottom is covered with very fine clay-sand mixture
with intermittent clumps of unidentified sponges and rare sightings of worm
species (Figure 3.37 and 3.38). Ray species, demersal fish species, and some
molluscs were found very rarely during the underwater survey. Turbidity is
extremely high to the extent that one cannot see its palm when the hand is fully
extended in the water.
The fish species in the Koddiyar bay was determined by the catch compositions
obtained from the landing sites. Almost all the fish were small pelagic species,
rare catches of bottom dwelling elasmobranch species and few crab species.
Littorina, Nodilittorina, Trochus and Chiton sp were found. Sea cucumber species,
Holothuria atra, Holothuria scabra, Unidentified heart urchin and broken thallus of
red algae were found on the sandy substrate where the sand particle sizes
changed from fine to course. Annelid worms, giant clams(Tridacna), pen shell
(Pinna), Spider shell (Lambis lambis) and cushion stars ( Culcita sp.) were found
rarely within the bay area.
A detailed Marine Ecological Survey was carried out in Shell Bay in the
vicinity of the originally proposed outfall location (L8). The survey covered
an area of approximately 1.5 km along the coastline. Sub sites selected
for the surveys are shown in Figure 3.40 (Site A – F).
recent colonization.
E The live coral cover was extremely low
and the area was found covered with
scattered granite boulders. High
sediment loads were evident. Very few
larger hard coral colonies were observed
at this site. The fish diversity was
comparatively lower than in site D.
Based on the coral and marine diversity distribution pattern of the area, Site E
has been recommended as the most suitable location for the outfall, which is
approximately 1 km away from the original location (L8). New location, named as
L0 in the report (810 18’ 2.49’’ E, 80 30’ 50.60’’ N) is at 7m depth and a mínimum
distance (perpendicular distance) of 480m away from the shoreline.
The coral and substrate cover in the Shell bay was not showed even distribution
and the sea bottom of the bays covered by rocky and limestone outcrops. Some
areas were densely populated with corals and some areas were not covered with
corals and other marine invertebrate life even though the bottom is hard. The
average height of these protrusions ranges 0.5 to 1 meters with occasional
boulders that extends up to 3 meters. These surfaces are covered with coralline
algae and red, brown and green encrusting and filamentous algae. Main sticking
feature of the area is the abundance of soft corals of different densities. In these
areas higher sedimentation evidence was shown. Some parts of the bay were
covered with sandy bottom where the size of the sand particles was fine. Number
of organic and solid debris was found accumulated in these sandy patches.
Detailed list of identified marine species are presented in Annexure-XIII as
follows,
Coral species found in the Bay area (Table 1 of Annexure-XIII)
Algae species found from the area (Table 2 of Annexure-XIII)
Marine Invertebrate species (Table 3 of Annexure-XIII)
Coastal Fish species (Table 4 of Annexure-XIII)
Plankton list (Table 5 of Annexure-XIII)
Marine Mammal list (Table 6 of Annexure-XIII).
Koddiyar Bay species list (Table 7 of Annexure-XIII)
Figure 3.45: Trincomalee Thermal Power Project and Important Places in the Surrounding Area
Final Intake
LocationP0
Figure 3.46: GN Divisions located in the 2 KM radius of the Trincomalee Thermal Power Project
The land right in the project land: The government has assigned 1368 acres
of land for industries in greater Trincomalee area. The allocation of 1368 acres of
land include, 818 acres for BOI (Board of Investment), 20 acres for CEB (Ceylon
Electricity Board for Switch Yard), and 25 acres for CEB for future activities and
505 acres for proposed Coal power plant.
Disabled persons: There are 2 (6%) persons among 35 people residing in the
area within 250m radius of the project land (in 10 families). Similarly, every GND
located within 2 km radius of the project land has certain number of disabled
persons. The number of disabled persons in each GND studied is mentioned
below:
221 Koonithivu GND- 8 ( 2% of total population )
221 A Navaratnapuram GND-14 (3% of total population )
Land availability for the families in the studied area: The people were
resettled in new houses constructed in 15 perch lands in resettlement villages.
The resettled farmers are in the process of developing land for cultivation with
the help of relevant govt. organizations.
The families living in the vicinity of the project land have accessed to at least 1 to
5 acres of irrigated land and 0.5 to 2 acres of highland. Therefore, the
communities residing in the vicinity of project land are considered as moderately
rich community in terms of access to land. This situation is observed outside of
the land area demarcated as industrial zone by the Urban Development Authority
(UDA).
No % No % No % No % No % No %
250m radius 10 28 2 6 6 17 16 46 1 3 0 0
221 Koonithivu 0 0 82 63 18 14 20 15 11 8 0 0
GND
221 A 0 0 62 73 3 4 12 14 8 9 0 0
Navaratnapuram
GND
222 A Chenaiur 0 0 452 72 80 13 59 9 29 5 5 1
GND
222 B 0 0 249 68 21 6 21 6 24 7 46 13
Kaddaiparichan
GND
222 C 0 0 355 86 35 8 9 2 11 3 2 1
Kadatkaraichenai
GND
Entire Mutur DSD 0 0 14174 71 2580 13 1810 9 889 4 574 3
Employment: most of the persons within employable age are involved in labor
related income generation activities. The second highest category of income
generation is agriculture activities such as paddy cultivation and Chena farming in
Maha seasons. The information on distribution of employments of the people
within employable age is included in Table 3.53.
Geographical Labor Govt. Job Pvt. Job Fishery Agriculture Self- Business
units employment
No % No % No % No % No % No % No %
250m radius 1 8 0 0 3 21 3 21 0 0 7 50 0 0
221 Koonithivu 57 27 31 14 11 5 44 21 33 15 27 13 11 5
GND
221 A 102 51 13 7 0 0 12 6 40 20 30 15 3 1
Navaratnapuram
GND
222 A Chenaiur 235 13 45 3 1084 62 186 11 143 8 38 2 20 1
GND
222 B 50 6 97 11 509 60 24 3 105 13 37 4 23 3
Kaddaiparichan
GND
222 C 375 34 20 2 8 1 183 17 475 43 12 1 25 2
Kadatkaraichenai
GND
Entire Mutur DSD 6136 27 2630 12 2005 9 3642 16 4731 21 1842 8 1773 7
Income distribution: The data available in DS and GN offices does not indicate
the accurate picture of the income levels of families in their jurisdictions. But, it is
a common trend observed in official data on income available in most of the DS
and GN offices in the country. The Chief householder reported data is recorded by
GNs as the income of families and this is the main reason for recording under
value figures as incomes. The data on income levels of 10 families residing in the
250 m radius was obtained by the SIA team and it was found that most of the
families are earning more than Rs 10,000 a month (Annexure-XIV). Similar
situation can be found on the income of other families living in the GN divisions
(although low figures are available in GN offices). Whatever, low figures recorded
in GNs and DS offices of Mutur they indicate the general trend of income levels of
the recently resettled families. Most of them depend on government subsidies yet
and they are in the process of reestablishment of their lost livelihood systems.
The income related information available in GN divisions and SIA team collected
information from 10 families are shown in Table 3.54.
Table 3.54: Income Levels of Families in the Study Areas
No. and Percentage of Families with Different Levels of
Monthly Income
Geographical Less than Rs 1001- Rs 5001- Rs 10001- More than
units Rs 1000 5000 10,000 15,000 Rs 15,000
No % No % No % No % No %
250m radius 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 40 6 60
221 Koonithivu 29 16 96 54 23 14 6 3 24 13
GND
221 A 43 29 27 18 61 42 5 3 13 8
Navaratnapuram
GND
222 A Chenaiur 151 28 166 32 150 28 24 4 45 8
GND
222 B 21 5 91 23 87 21 111 28 93 23
Kaddaiparichan
GND
222 C 72 14 425 80 10 2 14 3 2 1
Kadatkaraichenai
GND
Entire Mutur DSD 2735 15 7808 42 4036 22 1639 924 2428 12
Source- : DSD Mutur, relevant GNDs and findings of SIA team
In order to obtain the view of different groups of population, three focused group
discussions (GDs) were held as follows:
Focused Target Population Date of Location
Group GD
Discussions
Focused group Fisherman 01.10.2014 Soodaikuda
discussion – 1 fisheries landing
site
Focused group Community and religious 01.10.2014 Kaliamman Kovil
discussion – 2 leaders in Sampoor area – Sampoor
Focused group Community leaders 03.10.2014 Soodaikuda
discussion – 3 residing in 3 land belts fisheries landing
from the boundary of the site
proposed project land
The details of the discussions are presented in Annexure-XIV and summarized
in the following sections along with the other findings of the SIA Study.
The fishery has been found as one of the main livelihood activities of the
population in 250 m radius and the 5 GN divisions located within 2 km radius. The
same situation is reported from Mutur DSD as whole. This section discusses on
families and population involved in fishing activities, fishing equipment they
posses, launching points to the sea, fishing area in the sea, type of fish caught
and marketing arrangement. The details of 2 representative fishermen are
documented as 2 case studies to explain the livelihood system of fishermen in the
project area. The main boat landing sites of the fishermen have been marked in a
sketched map (Figure 3.45).
The information on families involved in fishery activities and the population in
fishery families are included in in Table 3.55.
The situation in 250 m radius: 3 families of 10 residing in this land belt are
involved in fishery activities. They perform artisanal fishing in shallow sea using
traditional methods such as "Belibama", "manual catching", and "collecting
Bellan" etc. The small fish caught are sold to the local community in the villages.
This type of fisherman can earn about Rs 500 to 700 a day.
The situation in 2 km radius: Every GN division located in the vicinity of the
project land has certain number of fishing families. Most of these fishermen use
Soodaikuda and Kadatkaraichenai boat landing places to park and launch their
fishing boats.
The intake and the out fall areas identified for the project are not used by
fishermen for launching their fishing vessels. These locations are situated in high
security zone. Soodaikuda boat landing site is located about 1 km distance from
the out fall point of the project. Kadatkaraichenai boat landing site is also more
than 1 km far from the proposed intake for the project.
Soodaikuda boat landing site is managed by Soodaikuda fish cooperative and
there are 6 boats and 20 rafts landed in this location. About 40 fishermen operate
from Soodaikuda boat landing site. Kadatkaraichenai boat landing site is also
managed by a cooperative established by the fishermen as community based
organization and there are about 40 boats and 15 rafts operated from this landing
site by 60 fishermen.
The shallow sea used for fishing by these communities is well endowed sea area
with fish population. The fish varieties such as ‘various types of Galmalu’ and
tuna are densely available.
A large number of fishermen from Soodaikuda and Kadatkaraichenai boat landing
sites and also from other areas such as Mutur, Kinniya and even Trincomalee
reach this shallow sea belt for fishing (about 400-500 fishermen). These
fishermen do not fish in the areas located for intake and out fall and also in the
vicinity of these 2 points. The fish catch in these areas are sold in Mutur, Kinniya
and also in fish markets in Trincomalee. Two fishermen were studied including
their production details as case studies and these 2 cases are generic and
representative of the other fishermen in general. The 2 case studies are shown
below:
Details Fisherman 1 Fishermen 2
Name A. Ravindramurthi J. Sudarshana
Address Kadatkaraichenai, 1 Soodaikuda, Koonithivu
Sampoor, Mutur
Fisheries Kadatkaraichenai, Rural Soodaikuda, corporative
Association fishery association fisheries association
Position Chairman in the fishing Chairman in the fishing
society society
Boat landing site Kadatkaraichenai Soodaikuda
Fishing Areas Kadatkaraichenai shallow Soodaikuda shallow sea
sea
Possess of fishing Engine boat and other Engine Boat, raft and other
equipment equipment equipment
Type of fish Gal Malu, Prawn, Cuttle fish, Same as fisherman 1
caught Tuna, Salaya, paraw and
Bollu
Daily catch 200 to 250kg 150 to 200kg
Net income per Rs 5000/- Rs. 5000/-
day
No of days of 20 20
fishing
No of months 8 to 9 8 to 9
involved in
fishing
Other views We have not been Same as Fisherman 1
expressed involved in fishing for
about 6 years during
civil conflict
Operation started only in
the beginning of 2014
The area we fished is
very rich in fish
population
Our fishing area is about
0.750km to 1.00km far
from the intake,
Note: The Rs.5000/= daily net income is shared with 2 assistants (called
Ganiyans in local language) operate in the boat.
Sampoor area as whole was famous for fishing prior to civil conflict. The fishing
activities have commenced about 6 months ago with the permission from the
security forces. The sea area in the vicinity of outfall and intake of the proposed
project has been declared as high security zone. The fishermen go for fishing to
the sea areas beyond security zone. Therefore, limited activities carried out
during construction phase of intake and out fall will not create any negative
impacts on fishing activities.
Crops grown and cropping intensity: The project land is a scrub jungle at
present due to long term negligence. Grains such as cowpea, green gram,
ground nuts were grown prior to civil conflict. This is same in the 50 m radius
land belt. In the 250m land about 10% is used for homesteads at present and it
was also grown with Chena at that time. The land within 2 km radius was
intensively cultivated prior to civil conflict with grains and paddy under small
tanks. The cultivation was limited to Maha seasons due to water reasons. In
general the land available in this area is not yet utilized properly.
Yield and income : At present there are no cultivation in the project land or its
immediate vicinity but, the land in the 2km radius are cultivated with paddy and
non rice crops but, the yield is much low compared to other areas of the country
(3 tonnes per hectare of paddy). To explain the present agriculture behavior of
farmers’ specific details were obtained from a farmer as case study and this case
study is generic and represents the other farmers in the area. The details of the
case study are shown below:
Case study on agriculture
Name of the farmer: S Carl Raja
Address: No 6, Sampoor, Mutur
Agriculture area: Sampoor
Type of Agriculture: Rain fed farming during Maha seasons
Type of crops grown: Green gram, cowpea and ground nuts mostly and some
vegetables too.
Income from agriculture: at present cultivate only for domestic consumption
The views expressed:
Prior to civil conflict I used to cultivate paddy also in the land (2 to 3
acres) during Maha seasons and obtained about 1500 to 2000kgs of
paddy per acre
My land has got into the area demarcated as high security zone
I was able to cultivate non rice crops during Maha season and obtained
about Rs. 30,000 to 40,000 per year
Other economic activities: Other than fisheries and agriculture that are
performed by people there are some other income generation activities such as
self-employment activities carried out by the community in the 2km radius. Since
the project land and its immediate vicinity (50m radius) are free from human
settlements these issues are not relevant to these 2 geographical areas.
Although the main livelihood activities of the community members in 2km radius
prior to civil conflict were concentrated on agriculture and fishery, these two
activities have not yet become fully operated even at present. Therefore, the
limited number of householders resettled is mainly involved in non agriculture
income generation activities such as collecting firewood. Firewood collection is the
principle income generation activity of about 50 persons residing in 2km radius.
Firewood collection is carried out in the land allocated for industrial activities
(entire land including the 500 acre portion for proposed coal power project). In
addition to firewood collection animal husbandry is becoming popular among
people living in villages such as Santhoshapuram, Wallikurny in Kaddaiparichan
GND. About 10-12 persons are involved in animal husbandry in this area and also
another 15 involved in collecting bee honey.
To explain the nature of other income generation activities a case study on a
person involved in firewood collection was prepared and the details are given
below:
VIEWS EXPRESSED:
My main income generation activity prior to civil conflict was agriculture
but, there is no land to cultivate at present.
We collected firewood mostly from the land presently fenced and
separated for industrial activity purpose.
The number of families depending on firewood collections has increased
in my community due to limited land available for agriculture (there
were 5 to 6 families at that time but, it has gone up to 20 to 25 at
present.)
This section includes, Access roads linked to project land also to the other main
roads and also the distance to main roads from the project land, Availability of
telephone systems in the area, Sources of drinking water, Availability of
electricity , Sanitary latrines, Schools, hospitals, Urban centers and other service
delivery centers such as banks, police, DS office, GN office etc.
Access roads: the main road available to access the project land is Mutur-Lanka
patuna road. At present it is a well improved main road. From Mutur to
Lankapatuna road there is a sub road to reach the project land and this sub- road
is dilapidated. It is a gravel road with lot of potholes. There is another road from
Mutur to Lanka patuna road falling near Santhoshapuram Sivasakthi School to
reach the project land but, it is also a gravel road which is dilapidated.
Telephone: cable based telephone system has not yet been established in this
area but, every family irrespective of their economic status has cellular phones
therefore, communication is not a constraint in the area.
Drinking water facilities: there is no pipe borne water system established in
the 2km radius area of the project land. Even the shallow wells are limited in
villages. In most of the villages only about 2-3 shallow wells are available in some
home gardens to share water among villagers. In this context, Sampoor
Pradeshiya Sabha distributes drinking water through bowsers in some areas that
are very critical in water availability for drinking purposes (Koonithivu and
Navaratnapuram).
Electricity facilities: disturbed power connection due to civil conflict has been
reestablished in all the areas studied. Power supply is available even for the area
located within 250m radius of the project land. Significant percentages of
householders have obtained connections and the balance has not yet obtained
house connections due to economic reasons. The information on availability of
electricity in the households of studied areas is shown in Table 3.58.
Table 3.58: Availability of Electricity
Geographical units studied Total No. and Percentage of
families Households to whom
Electricity is
Available Unavailable
No % No %
250m radius 10 8 80 2 20
221 Koonithivu GND 178 69 39 109 61
221 A Navaratnapuram GND 149 12 8 137 92
222 A Chenaiur GND 536 446 83 90 17
222 B Kaddaiparichan GND 403 344 85 59 15
222 C Kadatkaraichenai GND 523 123 24 400 76
Mutur DSD 18646 11782 63 6864 37
(Source- : DSD Mutur, relevant GNDs and findings of SIA team)
Note: high tension line is available on Lankapatuna road which is located about
300m from the boundary of the project land.
Toilet facilities: Some of the houses do not have toilet facilities yet in the area
studied. The householders who do not have toilets at homes used to share the
toilet with others or use the nearby scrub lands for the purpose. The information
in Table 3.59 indicates that percentages of households with and without latrine
facilities.
Table 3.59: Availability of Latrines at Households
Geographical units studied Total No. and Percentage of
families Households to whom
Latrines are
Available Unavailable
No. % No. %
250m radius 10 8 80 2 10
221 Koonithivu GND 178 91 51 87 49
221 A Navaratnapuram GND 149 136 91 13 9
222 A Chenaiur GND 536 90 17 446 83
222 B Kaddaiparichan GND 403 353 88 50 12
222 C Kadatkaraichenai GND 523 307 59 216 41
Mutur DSD 18646 12535 67 6111 33
(Source- : DSD Mutur, relevant GNDs and findings of SIA team)
Schools: There are no schools in the 50 m land belt adjacent to the project land.
Santoshpuram Shivasakthi School is available in 250 m distance from the boundary
of project land. This is the nearest school to the project land and it is a junior
school with 7 teachers and 105 student population.
Situation 2 km radius area: Seven schools are available in the GN divisions
located in 2 km radius of the project land. The information on the school available
in this area is included in Table 3.60.
Hospitals : There are no Hospitals available in the close proximity of the project
land (in 50 m or 250 m radiuses) but, there is 1 Dispensary in Kaddaiparichan
and it is located about 3km distance from the project land. All other hospitals are
available in more than 8km distance from the project land as shown below:
Mutur Base Hospital- 8 km
Toppur District Hospital- 10 km
Kiliwatti Rural Hospital- 12 km
Urban Centers: Mutur town is the only urban center close to the project land
and it is located about 8 km distance from the boundary of the project land.
Mutur is the main township where most of the service delivery institutions are
located. This township is about 8 km far from the project land. The main service
delivery centers found in Mutur Township are mentioned below:
DS Office
Pradeshiya sabha
Agrarian development center
Fisheries inspectors office
Police
Main post office
District health service office
Peoples bank, Bank of Ceylon, HNB (Hatton National Bank), RDB (Regional
Development Bank) , Sampath Bank, Sanasa Bank
CEB (Ceylon Electricity Board) office
RDA (Road Development Authority) office
CTB (Ceylon Transport Board) Depot
4.1.1.4 Impacts on Fauna, Flora and on Sensitive and Fragile Eco-Systems due to
Turbidity Changes and Re-deposition of Sediments etc.
The environmentally sensitive areas (as mentioned in Strategic Environmental
Assessment Report, 2008 for Trincomalee Metropolitan Area Development Plan)
around proposed Trincomalee Thermal Power Project are shown in Figure 4.4.
These include wildlife declared areas at Trincomalee Naval Head Works, Pigeon
Island, Great Sober Island and Seruvilla wildlife sanctuaries, Mammal Hotspots in
Trincomalee Bay, coral reefs along the sea shore from Norway Point to Foul Point
and towards the Indian Ocean side. Figure 4.4 also shows the location of project
site along with the proposed locations of intake and discharge points for cooling
water system. It is evident from Figure 4.4 that the project and its components,
specially the intake and discharge locations are neither located in the protected
area nor too close to the protected areas.
The impacts on flora-fauna and ecosystems could be in the form of loss of
habitats, degradation of the conditions and the quality of habitat and loss of
species.
Impact on coral during construction period
Corals located in the surrounding areas of the pipeline would undergo several
impacts. Temporary increase in turbidity, re-suspension of fine sediments and
any trapped toxicants such as H2S can be expected until the pipe laying process is
completed. These conditions may cause some impacts on coral and soft coral
species. Temporary changes in pH, DO, BOD, COD, Conductivity and
salinity/density of the water, dissolution of leached pollutants is expected. This
situation may cause some stress conditions to corals in the vicinity. Temporary
increase in turbid levels and smothering conditions may affect corals negatively
by stressing them, excess slime secretions and decolouration.
Further, the marine biodiversity in the vicinity of the developing area become
vulnerable to the sedimentation, changes in the water parameters and slight
toxicity may cause corals, soft corals, other marine invertebrates (sessile and
sentary) impacts for their survival by smothering.
Bottom substrate along the pipe line corridors will be totally impacted. It is
expected that a maximum width of 50m along pipe line traces will be disturbed
for actual pipe laying and as a working area (Outfall - Shell Bay: 480x50 m2 and
Inlet - Koddiyar Bay: 700x50 m2). Corals and marine biodiversity along pipe line
traces will be subjected to dredging and on either side of the trace in the working
area may be exposed to some damages. However the area impacted will be
comparatively very small and mitigation measures are proposed to be taken to
reduce these impacts.
The coral sustainability of corals in Koddiyar bay seems extremely low due to the
high sedimentation regime and salinity changes. Under water survey and
observations confirmed that the coral diversity is very low in Koddiyar bay, except
some coral colonies in remote isolates corners.
Out of six alternate locations surveyed, the location having a low coral cover has
been recommended as the most suitable location for the outfall. The coral
diversity and cover at this location is very low compared to the previously
selected site for the outfall in Shell bay. By moving the outfall to the new location
possible impact during the construction has been minimized and could be
considered as extremely low.
4.1.2.3 Siltation and soil erosion effects to waterways and adjacent areas
including minor irrigation tanks in the vicinity
The effluents from construction site, if not treated properly, may carry large
sediment loads of excavated materials as well as construction materials and may
lead to siltation of the drainage channels and the receiving water bodies. It may
also lead to reduction in light penetration, which in turn could reduce the
photosynthetic activity to some extent of the aquatic plants as it depends directly
on sunlight. This change is likely to have an adverse impact on the primary
biological productivity of the receiving water bodies. Suitable mitigation measures
for drainage management as well as water pollution control, such as construction
of peripheral drains and sedimentation basins shall be provided. However, during
the periods of heavy rains, the erosion and siltation cannot be avoided.
ground water quality. Various mitigation measures are proposed to control the
impacts of the same on surface water quality as well as ground water quality. In
addition to the measures described above, the following additional measure shall
be taken for protection of ground water
Storage of fuel oil, lubricants and grease etc. in closed containers in
covered storage areas with impermeable floors.
Containment, recovery & recycle and controlled combustion of any spillage
of oily substances.
pneumatic tools,
vibrators etc.
The operation of these equipments will generate noise ranging between 75–90
dB(A), while occasionally it may go up to 100 dB(A) during very short periods of
time. Operation of these vehicles/ equipment may temporarily increase the noise
level near the instrument. However, the noise levels at the boundary shall be
reduced due to natural attenuation.
Drilling and blasting operations during construction phase may result in
vibrations. This impact shall be mitigated by adopting controlled blasting and
strict surveillance regime.
Figure 4.6: Study Areas for Water Drawl System and Thermal Dispersion
The alternate locations considered during LHI study for intake and discharge
points are given in Table 4.1 and shown in Figure 4.7(a) and (b).
L1 10 350
L2 15 475
Koddiyar bay Outfall
L3 15 580
L9 13 400
L5 15 1200
L6 13 950
L7 10 750
L8 6 420
L0 7 480
* - The distance from P0 to intake water pump house is 700 m.
However, the perpendicular distance of P0 from shore is 610 m.
Field measurements carried out indicate that the average ambient bottom current
is around 0.1m/s. Modelling carried out indicate that velocity drops down
exponentially with the distance from the intake and reaches the average ambient
velocity of 0.1 m/s within 10 m from the intake. This clearly shows that the
impact is limited to a small local area. Figure 4.9 shows the velocity distribution
of intake with the distance.
It can be concluded that the increase in current fields due to water intake is small
and limited to a highly localized area. The primary impacts of concern are
impingement of marine life on the intake screens and entrainment of marine
species into the cooling water system. An intake screen should be used to prevent
large fish from being entrained into the intake channel. Water intake will be
operated continuously, at more or less regular flow discharges, avoiding sudden
changes in velocity fields which are considered not reliable. Impacts could
therefore be considered as low.
Residual Chlorine (Max. Disposal into sea through a well designed out
0.2 mg/l) fall to ensure proper mixing and dilution.
SO4 concentration
higher (by 33-40 mg/l)
than in incoming sea
water (2300-3000
mg/l).
2. Sludge from Desalination Plant 15 High in Suspended
Solids (150-500 mg/l)
3. Reject from Sea Water Reverse 675 High in Dissolved
Osmosis Plant and Second Solids (48,000-62,000
Stage Reverse Osmosis Plant of mg/l)
Demineralisation System
Effluents from Sweet Water Systems
1. Sludge from service water 2 High in Suspended Disposal into sea through a well designed out
treatment systems Solids (1% or 10,000 fall to ensure proper mixing and dilution.
mg/l)
2. Neutralised DM Plant <1 Dissolved Solids (150- Disposal into sea through a well designed out
Regeneration Waste 200 mg/l) fall to ensure proper mixing and dilution.
3. Boiler Blow down 10 Variation in pH Recycle to Service Water Inlet
4. Sanitary waste from plant and 10.5 High in Organic Matter Treatment in Sewage Treatment Plant and
township areas and Suspended Solids, Reuse in Horticulture.
Bacteriological Disposal of unused quantity in sea along with
Contamination discharge from cooling system.
Near-field modelling
CORMIX1 has been used in the present study for the analysis of submerged single
port discharges. To finalize the optimum location for an outfall, three different
water depths; 15m, 10m and 6m have been considered. Temperature of
discharge water is taken 70C above the ambient conditions. Results of the
modelling carried out shows that the plume reaches the sea surface within a
distance of 15-20m from the outfall (Figure 4.10). Deeper the outfall location,
plume travels a comparatively longer distance before reaching the water surface
but dissipates more temperature during this process.
For a discharge point located at 6m water depth, Figure 4.11 shows the
variation of dilution with downstream distance whereas Figure 4.12 shows the
variation of excess temperature with downstream distance within the near-field
region. It is clear from the figures that discharged water undergoes a dilution of
around 5 leading to a temperature of 1.40C at the edge of the near-field region.
Near-field region is approximately 15-20m from the discharge location.
The modelling confirms that the discharge water reaches the World Bank
guidelines (maximum of 3°C) and guideline adopted by some countries (2°C)
within the near-field region of 20 m radius. Under the assumption that ambient
water temperature in Trincomalee bay is less than 30°C, it can also concluded
that proposed quality standards for all four use classes of coastal water in Sri
Lanka (less than 32°C) will also be achieved within the region.
As described earlier far field modelling has been repeated using dynamic MIKE 21
Advection Dispersion Model to simulate dynamic environmental conditions.
MIKE21 AD model is a depth average model. Hence the excess temperature at
the average water depth (from near field model) has been used as the input
boundary condition for the far field model.
Figure 4.13 and Figure 4.14 show the Thermal Plume Dispersion at outfall
location L8 in Shell bay and outfall location L9 Koddiyar bay. It is clear from the
figures that the Thermal Plume having a temperature increase greater than 1°C is
limited to a very small area around the discharge point.
Figure 4.14 which correspond to the outfall location L9 in Koddiyar Bays clearly
shows the re-circulation during SW monsoon period.
Figure 4.15 shows the variation of dilution with downstream distance whereas
Figure 4.16 shows the variation of excess temperature with downstream
distance in the far-field region. These figures correspond to discharge point
located at 6m water depth. It is clear from the figures that discharged water
undergoes a dilution of 8 (specified in the MEPA regulations) approximately 500m
from the discharge point. Stringent 1°C criterion adopted by some countries is
also achieved within this 500 m distance.
It has been estimated that sludge at the rate of 15 m3/hr and Reverse Osmosis
rejects at the rate of 675 m3/hr will be connected to the cooling water return duct
resulting a change in water quality parameters. Tolerance Limits for Industrial
and Domestic Waste Discharged into Marine Coastal Areas specified by CEA/
MEPA (Annexure-IX) has to be satisfied before discharge in all times of
operation.
Modelling carried out for other scenarios of south west monsoon peak, north east
monsoon average and north east monsoon peak conditions show similar results.
Figure 4.17: Original (L8) and New (L0) outfall locations together with
Ecological survey sites
Figure 4.18: Cross sectional view of near field dispersion (SW Monsoon –
Average condition)
Figure 4.19: Plan view of the temperature iso-lines of near field dispersion
(SW Monsoon – Average condition)
Figure 4.20: Cross sectional view of far field dispersion (SW Monsoon – Average
condition)
Figure 4.21: Plan view of the temperature iso-lines of far field dispersion
(SW Monsoon – Average condition)
Figure 4.22 and Figure 4.23 show vector plots of current flow around the outfall
(L0) for SW and NE Monsoon conditions respectively. Outfall location in the Shell
Bay is open to NE monsoon conditions without any disturbance, resulting a very
uniform flow towards the west. However, during the SW monsoon conditions flow
is disturbed by the headland located to the west of the outfall resulting a more
circular movement of flow in the vicinity of the outfall. Thermal plume, which
moves together with the ambient flow field in the far field region show similar
behaviour during SW and NE Monsoon conditions.
Figure 4.24 shows Thermal Plume Dispersion under average environmental
conditions during SW Monsoon period together with Spring Tidal conditions.
Figure 4.24 (a) and (b) show the overall and close-up view of the thermal
plume 37 hours after initiation. Figure 4.24 (c) and (d) show the close-up view
of the thermal plume 71 and 88:45 hours after initiation.
Figure 4.25 shows Thermal Plume Dispersion under peak environmental
conditions during SW Monsoon period together with Spring Tidal conditions.
Figure 4.25 (a) and (b) show the overall and close-up view of the thermal
plume 32 hours after initiation. Figure 4.25 (c) and (d) show the close-up view
of the thermal plume 27 and 40:45 hours after initiation.
Only few selected plots are included here. LHI Report “Sampur Thermal Power
Plant Project: Additional Thermal Dispersion Study – Addendum to Final Report,
December 2014” includes plots corresponding to number of model time steps
covering all model scenarios. Modelling results indicate that thermal plume
reaches the internationally acceptable condition of +20C temperature within 100
m radius (about 3.14 Ha) from the outfall during most of the time. Only at few
instances, plume travels approximately 180 m in one direction (in SW monsoon
considered as worst case) at one instance from outfall.
Plume generally reaches +10C temperature, approximately 300-400 m from the
outfall and only during few instances plume travels approximately 500 m from the
outfall in one direction (in SW monsoon considered as worst case) at one instance
from outfall.
Thermal Plume Dispersion under average and peak environmental conditions
during SW Monsoon period together with Neap Tidal conditions also shows very
similar results and hence not included here.
Figure 4.26 and Figure 4.27 show Thermal Plume Dispersion under average
and peak environmental conditions during NE Monsoon period together with
Spring Tidal conditions. Modelling results indicate that thermal plume reaches the
internationally acceptable condition of +20C temperature within 50 m from the
outfall and reaches +10C level within 180 m from the outfall. Plume dispersion
during the NE Monsoon is very limited in comparison to the SW Monsoon period
during the presence of strong directional currents as described earlier.
Thermal Plume Dispersion under average and peak environmental conditions
during NE Monsoon period together with Neap Tidal conditions also shows very
similar results and hence not included here.
In general 1°C or 2°C increase in temperature is considered as the standard by
most countries. The World Bank uses a maximum of 3°C increase in temperature
at the edge of the mixing zone as their guideline.
Figure 4.22: Vector Plot for Current Flow around the Outfall (L0)
SW Monsoon _ Spring Tide _ Peak Condition
Figure 4.23: Vector Plot for Current Flow around the Outfall (L0)
NE Monsoon _ Spring Tide _ Peak Condition
500m
200m
100m
Figure 4.29 shows the coal unloading jetty of Lakvijaya Power Station whereas
Figure 4.30 shows the shoreline behaviour in the vicinity. Red line indicates the
shoreline position in December 2005. In spite of being a very dynamic coastline
experiencing relative high northward sediment movement, no appreciable
changes could be seen over this 09 year period. Only marginal adjustment of the
coastline near the structure has been report soon after the construction.
In conclusion, some local changes near the structures could be expected.
Monitoring of the coastline needs to be carried out and proper remedial measures
(if required) have to be taken. Prior approval from Coast Conservation and
Coastal Resource Management Department (CC & CRMD) should be obtained
before any intervention. Overall impacts could be considered as low.
(a) before construction (b) during construction (c) 4 years after construction
December, 2005 October, 2009 February, 2014
Figure 4.30: Shoreline behaviour in the vicinity of Lakvijaya Power Station
4.2.2.3 Impacts of Oil Spills/ Coal Pile Leachate and Surface Run Offs
Coal pile areas shall be provided with impermeable base and garland drains/
dykes to collect the effluents from these areas and coal settling ponds for removal
of coal particles. Treated supernatant shall be recycled back into the dust
extraction/ suppression system while the settled coal sludge shall be sent back to
the coal pile. The capacity of settling tanks shall be sufficient to accommodate the
surface run-off from these areas.
Oil storage areas shall also be provided with impermeable base and garland
drains/ dykes to collect the oil spillage/ surface run-off from these areas and
treatment systems for the same. Oil separators shall be provided in the oil
handling and storage area for removal of oil. Treated effluents conforming to the
Tolerance Limits of Industrial and Domestic Waste Discharged in Marine Coastal
Area specified under National Environment (Protection and Quality) Regulations
(Annexure-IX) shall be recycled/ discharged.
The ships and barges which supply equipment and machinery for the proposed
project shall comply with the provisions of the Marine Pollution Prevention Act 59
of 1981. In order to minimize the risks posed by operational oil spillages, the
shipping company should adopt good operating practice, ensure the adoption of
principles of safety for the operation of vessels and operate an Oil Spill
Contingency Management Plan (OSCMP), in accordance to the guidelines provided
by Marine Environmental Prevention Authority (MEPA) and obtain prior approval
from MEPA.
In order to take care of excess rain water during rainy season, ash dyke
embankment of suitable height has been proposed. Further, in some stretches no
ash dyke boundaries have been shown in the layout, as the ground level for these
stretches is higher than the proposed dyke top level. Further, a free board of
1.5m has also been provided to take care of the extra water during monsoon. On
higher ground where no dyke is shown, a 1.5m high bund will be constructed to
stop entry of storm water from outside, into dyke area. RCC decantation well and
sedimentation basin are envisaged for proper decantation of excess water from
pond. In addition to RCC decantation well, RCC spillway is envisaged to allow safe
passage of extra water avoiding any chance of overtopping. RCC peripheral drain
is envisaged to collect the seepage water & excess water from the lagoon through
spillways, into RCC sump and the same will be re-circulated to the plant for
reuse. High Density PolyEthylene (HDPE) lining shall be provided on upstream
slope of dyke embankment & base of the storage lagoon, to prevent any risk of
ground water contamination.
November)
(October -
Monsoon
February)
Monsoon
The resultant maximum GLCs for SO2, NOx, and PM from the project with FGD
unit were estimated to be well within the National Ambient Air Quality Standards
(NAAQS) of Sri Lanka, with enough margins for future development of power
projects and other industries in Sampoor area.
It may be noted that the values predicted for ground level concentrations after
operation of the project are calculated using ISCST3 Model based on Gaussian
Plume Model for a worst case scenario, i.e.
a) firing such a coal so as to generated maximum quantity of SO2,
b) worst meteorological conditions (wind speed, direction and atmospheric
stability) to cause maximum ground level concentration
c) the point of maximum predicted ground level concentration coinciding with
the point of maximum measured ground level concentration.
In reality, such conditions rarely exist. It may further be appreciated that there
are several uncertainties associated with the Gaussian Plume Model, due to
simplifying assumptions made in its derivation and input data used for
predictions. Some of these are summarized below:
1. The model assumes a steady-state condition with respect to flow and
meteorological conditions, at least for a time period equal to or greater
than the time of travel from tip of stack to the receptor location. For most
situations such conditions are never true and they may be approached
over short time periods only (say 1 hour or less).
2. Wind blows in x-direction and is constant in both speed and direction.
3. Transport by mean wind is much higher than turbulent transport in x-
direction.
4. Eddy diffusion coefficients are constant in both time and space.
5. Mass of pollutants is conserved across a plume cross-section and the
effects of chemical transformation, atmospheric washout/ fallout during
the travel of plume are not considered.
6. The wind speed and directions at the point of release of emission (135 m
above ground) is calculated on the basis of measurements of wind speed
and direction at 10 m height. However, it may be different.
7. There are uncertainties associated with the horizontal and vertical
dispersion coefficients, used in the calculations.
Table 4.9: Predicted GLC at Ambient Air Quality stations during the Plume
Fumigation
Incremental Concentration
Station (g/m3)
Stations
Code
1 hour 24 hours
1 Santhosapuram 79.6 11.1
2 Sampoor 84.7 6.8
3 Mutur town 74.6 14.1
4 Thoppur 58.9 9.7
Trincomalee
5 36.3 7.8
town
The episodic increase during the plume fumigation is clearly indicated in one hour
average concentration; whereas 24hrs concentration predicated by SDM is
comparatively in the acceptable range of concentration. While interpreting the SDM
results, readers are advised to consider that the fumigation sub-model of SDM is
generally applicable to a relatively smooth shoreline – in case of irregular shoreline
like narrow bays and peninsulas thermal internal boundary layer (TIBL) may or may
not be formed(a prerequisite for plume fumigation).
4.2.4.3 Dispersion Model Input Data and Model Results including Determination
of Stack Height
Meteorological Data
The onsite meteorological data recorded at Sampoor site by CEB during Dec., 2012
to Nov., 2013 was used for dispersion modeling. The Pasquill-Gifford (P-G) stability
classes were derived and the missing data were treated in compliance with the EPA-
450/4-87-0131.
1
Meteorological Monitoring Guidance for Regulatory Modeling Applications
Mixing Depth
The seasonal mixing height data were considered similar to the Chennai – the
closest available data - from the Atlas of Hourly Mixing Height and Assimilative
Capacity of Atmosphere in India, published in 2008 by the India Meteorological
Department.
Model Results
Results of the model are summarized in Tables 4.7 to 4.9 and presented
graphically in Figures 4.31 to 4.50. Model outputs are enclosed in Annexure-
XVI.
Figure 4.31: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of NOx (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) for Northeast Monsoon
Figure 4.32: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of SO2 (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) without FGD for Northeast Monsoon
Figure 4.33: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of SO2 (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) with FGD for Northeast Monsoon
Figure 4.34: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of Particulate Matter (µg/m3) due to Operation
of Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) for Northeast Monsoon
Figure 4.35: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of NOx (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) for First Intermonsoon Monsoon
Figure 4.36: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of SO2 (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) without FGD for First InterMonsoon Season
Figure 4.37: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of SO2 (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) with FGD for First InterMonsoon Season
Figure 4.38: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of Particulate Matter (µg/m3) due to Operation
of Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) for First InterMonsoon Season
Figure 4.39: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of NOx (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) for South West Monsoon Season
Figure 4.40 Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of SO2 (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) without FGD for Southwest Monsoon
Figure 4.41: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of SO2 (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) with FGD for Southwest Monsoon
Figure 4.42: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of Particulate Matter (µg/m3) due to Operation
of Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) for Southwest Monsoon
Figure 4.43: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of NOx (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) for Second Intermonsoon Season
Figure 4.44: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of SO2 (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) without FGD for Second Intermonsoon Season
Figure 4.45: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of SO2 (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) with FGD for Second Intermonsoon Season
Figure 4.46: Isopleths for Maximum Incremental Concentration of Particulate Matter (µg/m3) due to Operation
of Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) for Second Intermonsoon Season
Figure 4.47: Isopleths for Annual Average Incremental Concentration of NOx (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW)
Figure 4.48: Isopleths for Annual Average Incremental Concentration of SO2 (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) without FGD
Figure 4.49: Isopleths for Annual Average Incremental Concentration of SO2 (µg/m3) due to Operation of
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW) with FGD
Figure 4.50: Isopleths for Annual Average Incremental Concentration of Particulate Matter (µg/m3) due to
Operation of Trincomalee Thermal Power Project (2x250 MW)
SO2 [mg/Nm3], 538 (145.05 g/s) 524 (144.96 g/s) 850 (226.80
with FGD g/s)
*The minimum gas exit velocity in Scenario B was considered as 22.00 m/s
# Global Positioning System
Table 4.12: Summary of the Results Predicted by the Air Dispersion Modelling
Study by ITI
Air Quality Predicted Maximum SO2 Predicted Maximum NOX Predicted
Parameter Concentration Concentration Maximum PM
[µg/m3] [µg/m3] Concentration
[µg/m3]
Averaging
1-hr 8-hr 24-hr 1-hr 8-hr 24-hr 24-hr Annual
Period
AAQ
200 120 80 250 150 100 100 50
Standard
Case 1 117.54 43.30 21.36 137.05 50.45 24.88 3.97 0.48
Case 2 342.15 126.04 62.16 - - - - -
Case 3 116.39 42.62 21.01 136.71 50.06 24.68 4.01 0.49
Case 4 550.61 201.63 99.40 - - - - -
Note: Predicted Values which do not comply with the respective AAQ
Standard are indicated in Bold.
Scenario B
Referring to the model output of Case 5 presented in Table 4.12, all time
averaged SO2, NOX and PM emission concentrations in the ambient air would
comply with the respective AAQ standards, if the proposed coal power plant
would conform the National Environmental (Stationary Source Emission Control)
Regulation (Interim Standards).
Table 4.13(a): Typical analysis of heavy metals in coal, fly ash and bottom ash
samples of Lakvijaya Power Station
Parameter Test Method Test Values (mg/kg) Limits of
Coal Fly Ash Bottom Detection
Ash (mg/kg)
Lead (as Pb) Atomic Absorption ND 1.1 ND 0.5
Cadmium (as Cd) Spectrophotometry/ ND ND ND 0.1
Flame
Chromium (as Cr) 0.8 5.5 1.0 -
Mercury (as Hg) Atomic Absorption ND ND ND 0.05
Arsenic (as As) Spectrophotometry/ 0.17 ND ND 0.05
Vapour Generation
Assembly
ND - Not Detected
(Source: Sampling and Analysis Done by ITI, Colombo from Lakvijaya Power Station)
Table 4.13(b): Typical analysis of heavy metals in sea water (at intake and
outlet) of Lakvijaya Power Station
Parameter Test Method Test Values (mg/kg) Limits of
Sea Water Sea Water Detection
at Intake at Outlet (mg/kg)
Lead (as Pb) APHA 3111 B ND ND 0.1
Cadmium (as Cd) ND ND 0.02
Chromium (as Cr) ND ND 0.05
Mercury (as Hg) CML 33 ND ND 0.001
Arsenic (as As) APHA 3114 C 0.007 0.006 -
ND - Not Detected
(Source: Sampling and Analysis Done by ITI, Colombo from Lakvijaya Power Station)
The results presented above indicate that the heavy metals in coal are very low.
Further, the metals present, if any shall be retained in ash and shall be fixed in
cement/ concrete products without having any significant impact on environment.
The low levels (mostly below detection limit) of the elements in sea water at
outlet further confirm that the impacts will be very low. Considering that
Trincomalee Thermal Power Project is the only coal based thermal power project
in the east coast of Sri Lanka, the overall impacts of trace metals may be
considered as very low.
from Sri Lanka was 0.640 Tonne CO2 per capita per year in year 2012 against a
world average of 4.44 Tonne CO2 per capita per year (Table 4.14).
Table 4.14: Comparison of CO2 Emissions from Fuel Combustion
The estimated emissions from Trincomalee Thermal Power Plant would be 4135.4
GgCO2 per annum from the entire plant. Compared to global emission inventory
this emission is negligibly small (less than 0.02% of total emission of CO2 from
Annex-I countries in 2012 and less than 0.06% of total emission of CO2 from
Non-Annex-I countries in 1994, the last reported year).
The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) was
ratified by Sri Lanka on 23 November 1993 and entered into force on 21 March
1994. Sri Lanka became a party to Kyoto Protocol in 2002. Sri Lanka, being a
developing country and a Non-annex-1 country party to the UNFCCC, has no
quantified emission reduction targets for CO2.
Sri Lanka’s contribution to the emission of green house gases is negligible as
compared to the rest of the world. However, being an island country, the adverse
impacts of the anticipated changes arising out of global warming due to the rest
of the world are likely to be significant.
TPCL will comply with the national directives/ policies/ standards related to the
emission of Green House Gases and Climate Change.
Where,
Sound Lp2 and L p1 are the Sound Pressure Levels (SPL) at points located at a
distances of r2 and r1 from the source. AE & AM are attenuations due to
Environmental conditions (E) and Machine correction (M). The combined effect of
all the sources can be determined at various locations by the following equation.
(Pa)/10
Lp(total)= 10Log (10 + 10(Pb)/10 + 10 (Pc)/10
+. . ………….) ......... (2)
Where Lpa, Lpb, Lpc are noise pressure levels at a point due to different sources.
Machine Correction (AM): The background noise level, when the machine is not
in operation should be determined at one or more locations while conducting the
test. The readings at each location, with the machine in operation should exceed
the background levels by at least 10 dB in each pressure level of interest. If the
difference is less than 10 dB, correction should be applied. If the difference
between the measured sound and the background sound in any sound pressure
level is less than 3 dB a valid measurement of the machine cannot be made. In
order to reduce background noise to acceptable levels, it may be necessary to
acoustically treat the equipment.
Based on the above equation user friendly model has been developed. The details
of the model are as follows:
The site selected for the project is under high human influence even at present.
During the sampling period it has been observed that people in the area is
engaged in fuel wood extraction at the site at a commercial scale. Further, there
is illegal quarrying of the rock outcrops within the project site for extraction of
metal. Further, those who are involved in these activities also hunt animals as
was indicated by the presence of remains of such hunted animals throughout the
project site.
The project will result in the loss of approximately 150 ha scrubland present in
the site selected for the project. Based on the species observed at the site it can
be concluded that the site does not function as a critical habitat or habitat of a
critical species. Further it will not result in fragmentation of habitat or obstruction
of a known migratory pathway of terrestrial species. Therefore, even though the
project will result in the loss of habitat of terrestrial species it will not have a
significant impact on habitats or species present in the project area.
Shell Bay
Impact is similar to coral species.
Increase of sea water temperature may cause minor impacts to plankton, fish,
molluscs, crustaceans, reptiles and mammals which can tolerate much wider
fluctuations. Further, Tropical members of the latter groups can tolerate
temperatures of about 35° C, without showing sub-lethal symptoms. Therefore it
is expected that this temperature increase do not cause any significant damage to
benthic organisms and even the pelagic organisms are slightly affected from this
less warm water mass due to their ability to move from unfavorable waters only if
the warmer water cause any impact on them.
The local communities expect significant indirect benefits during operation phase
of the coal power plant. The positive and negative impacts perceived during
operation phase are summarized in Table 4.19.
Table 4.19: Impacts on General Community in the Area during Operation
Phase
Positive Impacts (Perceived) Negative Impacts (Perceived)
250 M radius
There can be occasional The school community of Sivashakthi Junior
assistance to the Sivashakthi School (parents, and teachers) perceives that
Junior school for its students there can be some disturbances to the
and also for some facilities children due to noise, dust due to coal based
operations of the power plant; At the same
time they expressed their opinion that they
do not have previous experience on the
impacts of a coal power plant. Although the
school is located about 250m from the
boundary of the land, the negative impacts
will not be significant as there will be tree
plantation between boundary and school.
The members in the 10 families residing in
the 250 m radius but, beyond 50m distance
from the project boundary also perceive
some negative implications on their routine
lives due to dust, noise and increased
temperature in the local area. The school
children may have some difficulties to do
their home works during nights due to day
and night operations of the power plant in the
vicinity.
2 km Radius
There can be some assistance The community members perceive that there
to the 7 schools located in 2km can be danger if waste water pipe lines get
radius of the project boundary. damaged due to some problems (waste water
The project developer may has high temperature). According to the
provide some supports to technical experts of the EIA team, the
renovate the buildings and also temperature of discharged cooling water is
to establish drinking water not so high to create dangerous negative
facilities to the school impacts.
population.
It is expected that the project Communities are also having fear about
developer will establish reliable possible polluted air spreading from the plant
drinking water system under the due to some accident. If such incident takes
project facilities. If so, the place, it might create some negative impact
neighbouring communities can on the communities in the vicinity (this may
also benefit from such facilities be highly unlikely, but it is a perception of
(the area does not have access the community leaders)
to reliable and clean drinking
water facility)
The youths in the neighboring There can be tendency to have conflicts
communities will get motivated between local community members and the
4.2.7.7 Health
Community members are not familiar with the possible implications of coal power
plants and therefore, they perceive possible negative impacts as they understand.
The different negative impacts perceived by the stakeholders including local
communities residing in the vicinity of project lands are mentioned below.
There can be some negative impact due to dust and noise generated by
the project on the children studying in Sivashakthi junior school which is
located in the vicinity of the project land. (250m distance from the project
land)
The members in the ten families located in 250m radius may also have
health implications due to dust and noise generated in the plant. The
community members are critical on potential dust from the coal power
plant.
There can be temporary health related implications on the communities
during land preparation period of the project (dust, noise and other
problems due to heavy vehicles roaming in the local area).
Some community members perceive possible spreading of dust and smoke
from the coal power plant up to the area about 1km or 2 km.
In general, the stakeholders are of the opinion that respiratory diseases
may get increased among community members specially the children
residing in the vicinity of power plant.
The local people also point out the likelihood vulnerability of damages to
the waste water pipe lines in the project. If such incident takes place there
can be some negative impact on the people (unlikely impact).
The project developer may tend to establish a separate medical center for
its employees and if so, community members living in the 2km radius
expect to have opportunity to reach this center for treatments.
4.2.7.8 Tourism
The coastal area near the project land is not popular for local or foreign tourists
and therefore, there will not be positive or negative impacts on tourism.
5. Mitigation Actions
Chapter-4 of the EIA report identified potential environmental impacts associated
with the construction and operation of the Coal Power Plant and this chapter
refers to mitigation measures. There are three important areas to be considered
with respect to mitigation measures and its applications, namely,
(1) To review and report specific features in identifying potential environmental
issues at the planning and preliminary design stages and their incorporation at
the relevant stages. If necessary make further recommendations to amend
the design.
Mitigation Measures adopted in the Design Phase (Mitigation by
Design)
The approach to the EIA and the associated engineering process includes
‘Mitigation by Planning and Design’. Therefore some of the potential
environmental impacts on the coastal zone, the zone of major environmental
concern due to intake and outfall structures, have been reduced to an extent
within practical limits through iterative planning and design processes,
incorporating state of the art mathematical modeling carried out by LHI,
Moratuwa in consultation with the University of Moratuwa. This approach has
reduced the need to apply mitigation measures.
The objective of modeling a wide range of scenarios (covering varying incident
conditions), to examine critical environmental issues (e.g. coral reef systems
and their locations) and project induced development (e.g. potential
recirculation from close proximity of intake and outfall structures) is to enable
designers to adopt designs, as far as possible, which mitigate critical issues.
This approach minimizes impacts by design itself, rather than adopting
specific mitigation measures to an environmentally unfriendly design.
Modelling done on a very extensive scale has therefore achieved this objective
at its very best.
(2) To identify mitigation and best practice measures that should be developed in
order to avoid or minimize any such adverse impacts during construction and
operation stages. In doing so attention has to be focused on the mechanism
required to ensure the implementation of the mitigation measures. This forms
part of the Environmental Monitoring Programme.
(3) Some of the impacts may be of severe magnitude though effective over a
short period of time (such as those caused due to earthquake, cyclone,
tsunami etc) and may lead to disaster situations. These shall be reviewed
under Risk Management and Disaster Mitigation Plan shall be prepared as a
part of EMP. Further, all the structures and facilities shall be designed based
on the worst case scenario experienced so far.
drainage study for the project site has been undertaken separately through Lanka
Hydraulic Institute (LHI) to study the drainage pattern of the area in detail and
recommend suitable drainage management plan.
The drainage system shall be designed such that the plant storm water flows by
gravity and meets the final discharge point. As per LHI report of “Area Drainage
Study” plant drainage is to be connected to Sampukkali Kulam. The Sampukkali
Kulam is inter-connected to Kaddaiparichan lagoon, which ultimately meets Sea.
As recommended in “Area Drainage Study” report, the existing connection/
drainage path between Sampukkali Kulam and Kaddaiparichan lagoon to be
further developed/ improved.
and sea water FGD effluents. The final quality of the effluents discharged through
outfall structures shall conform to ‘Tolerance Limits for Discharge of Industrial
and Domestic Waste Water into Marine Coastal Areas’ published in Gazette No.
1534/8 dated 01.02.2008 under National Environmental Act of Sri Lanka (Copy
enclosed at Annexure-IX).
The sewage from plant and township shall be treated in a sewage treatment
plant. The treated sewage, conforming to ‘Tolerance Limits for Discharge of
Industrial and Domestic Waste Water into Inland Surface Waters’ published in
Gazette No. 1534/8 dated 01.02.2008 under National Environmental Act of Sri
Lanka (Copy enclosed at Annexure-IX), shall be utilized for plantation to the
extent possible. The unused part of treated sewage shall be discharged into Shell
Bay along with cooling water and sea water FGD effluents.
3. Long term tie ups with cement and other interest agencies.
4. Efforts to motivate and encourage entrepreneurs to set up ash based building
products such as fly ash bricks/ blocks/ tiles etc.
5. Setting up in-house fly ash brick / block manufacturing plant at Trincomalee
Project and use of bricks/ blocks to meet in–house construction requirement.
6. Use of ash filling purposes for in-house construction works and ash dyke
raising work.
The unused fly ash, economizer ash and bottom ash shall be mixed with water in
an agitator tank at controlled rate to obtain the desired concentration of slurry.
This high concentration slurry shall be further pumped to Contingency Ash dyke
approximately 0.5 Km from the plant by High Concentration Slurry Disposal
(HCSD) pumps. HCSD System utilizes a high ash-water ratio to create a viscous
slurry, which gets hardened in 1-2 days time. The hardened slurry itself acts as
impermeable layer. However, the ash disposal area shall be provided with an
earthen dyke all around and impermeable High Density Poly-Ethylene (HDPE)
liner. Hence, there is no significant risk of leachate from the ash disposal area.
For hazardous wastes (like used oil, oil sludge, batteries containing lead and acid
etc.), Secured stores shall be constructed for storage and the same shall be
recycled/ disposed off through authorized agencies.
The noise shall be controlled through the design of the machines, provision of
acoustic enclosures over the sources of noise and provision of barriers in the form
of buildings. Further, provision of green belts around the plant area shall also help
in absorbing the noise generated, so that the population outside the plant
boundary is not affected. Wherever required, the workers shall be provided with
protective equipments such as ear plugs and ear muffs.
4. In selecting the plant species for the green belt priority was given to select
plants that can function as food plants for animals so that the green belt
will support a higher species richness.
It is recommended that the vegetation removal in the area identified for the
establishment of green belt should be kept to a minimal level as possible.
Introduced species present in the green belt and other shrub species should be
replaced gradually with the recommended plant list so that these plants will
establish easily. Further, the services of a botanist is obtained by the project
proponent to provide technical support for the establishment of the green belt
and the project proponent may establish a nursery to collect planting material
necessary to establish the green belt.
It is further recommended that project proponent should take all steps not to
cause any disturbance to the adjacent wetland (Sampu Kulam) to the project site
or carry out any activities around Foul Point which supports a unique vegetation.
Finally, it is also recommended that the intake and out fall paths for the pipeline
are either properly compacted or turfed after burying the pipes to avoid erosion.
Charge of Auto Base; Public Relation Officer etc.). The plan shall also specify the
responsibilities of these personnel in case of a disaster and draw an action plan to
be followed. It shall also specify the responsibilities for Declaration of Emergency
and giving All Clear Signal. The list of key personnel and their phone numbers
shall be informed to all concerned suitably.
Chief Incident Controller and Works Incident Controller may decide the actions
needed to shut down plants, evacuate personnel, carry out emergency repair
works, arrange of supplies of equipment, personnel etc. Carry out atmosphere
tests, provide catering facilities, liaison with police, informing relative of the
victims, press media etc. Chief Incident Controller and Works Incident Controller
shall be assisted by two support teams as described in Table 6.2.
Table 6.2: Support Teams for Chief Incident Controller and Works
Incident Controller
Support Team to Consisting of Heads of Personnel, Materials and Finance
Chief Incident Divisions; to function in consultation with CIC for the
Controller (CIC) following
Contacting statutory authorities.
Arranging for relievers and catering facilities.
Giving information to media.
Contacting medical centers and nursing homes.
Providing all other support, as necessary.
Arranging for urgently required materials through
cash purchase or whatever means.
Arranging funds for various relief measures as well
as emergency purchase of materials, sending his
representative for emergency purchase.
Support Team to Work Consisting of Heads of Administration, Operation,
Incident Controller Electrical Maintenance, Mechanical Maintenance and
(WIC) any more persons depending upon the need to assist
the WIC in manning communication and passing
instructions to the teams. One Steno Secretary shall
also be available with WIC for recording all information
coming in and instructions going out.
In addition to the support teams mentioned above, there will be a team for each
functional area, as described in Table 6.3.
6.4.6 Alarm
The project shall have various alarm systems to denote different kinds of
emergencies and restoration of normalcy. Chlorine handling area shall be
provided with automatic emergency alarm. The purpose of the alarm is to advice
all persons on the outburst of major emergency. As a general practice, all
employees will be able to raise an emergency alarm so that the earliest possible
action can be taken to control the situation. There will be an adequate number of
points from where the alarm can be raised either directly by activating an audible
warning or indirectly, viz. a signal or message to the permanently manned
location. The emergency alarm shall also be located at central place with the
control and operation switch under fire station control room in-charge. A separate
Siren audible to a distance of 5 Km range shall also be provided to denote major
leak of chlorine or major outbreak of fire. The alarm code shall be such that the
nature of emergency can be distinguished as a chlorine release or major fire.
storm surges and the intake and outfall structures would be designed giving due
considerations to the expected wave heights and currents.
o To take steps to ensure that all known safety factors are taken into account in
the design, construction, operation and maintenance of plants, machinery and
equipment.
o To ensure that adequate safety instructions are given to all employees.
o To provide wherever necessary protective equipment, safety appliances and
clothing, and to ensure their proper use.
o To inform employees about materials, equipment or processes used in their
work which are known to be potentially hazardous to health or safety.
o To keep all operations and methods of work under regular review for making
necessary changes from the point of view of safety in the light of experience
and up to date knowledge.
o To provide appropriate facilities for first aid prompt treatment of injuries and
illness at work.
o To provide appropriate instruction, training, retraining and supervision in
health and safety and first aid and ensure that adequate publicity is given to
these matters.
o To ensure proper implementation of fire prevention and an appropriate fire
fighting service, together with training facilities for personnel involved in this
service.
o To ensure that professional advice is made available wherever potentially
hazardous situations exist or might arise.
o To organize collection, analysis and presentation of data on accident, sickness
and incident involving personal injury or injury to health with a view to taking
corrective, remedial and preventive action.
o To promote through the established machinery, joint consultation in health
and safety matters to ensure effective participation by all employees.
o To publish/notify regulations, instructions and notices in the common
language of employees.
o To prepare separate safety rules for each type of occupation/process involved
in a project.
o To ensure regular safety inspection by a competent person at suitable
intervals of all buildings, equipments, work places and operations.
o To co-ordinate the activities of the company and of its contractors working on
the Company’s premises for the implementation and maintenance of safe
systems of work, to comply with their legal obligations with regard to the
health, safety and welfare of their employees.
7. Monitoring Programme
7.1 General
This Chapter outlines the monitoring to be carried out during the Construction
and Operation phases of the Project. A Monitoring Plan has been developed on
the basis of the recommendations of this chapter, which shall be a part of the
wider Environmental Management Plan (EMP).
Public Concern
It is recognised that Compliance Monitoring and Impact Confirmation Monitoring
are required to ensure that the project includes the satisfactory implementation
of the EIA recommendations and to confirm that no potential adverse impacts
have been excluded from the assessment process. The EIA team believes that the
MANTEC CONSULTANTS (P) LTD., NEW DELHI Chapter-7, Page-2
Environmental Impact Assessment Report for Trincomalee Thermal
Power Project (2x250 MW)
As the EMP will form part of the contract, there will be provisions to ensure that
TPCL fulfils his obligations regarding the implementation mitigation measures. It
is recommended that the CEA appoints specialist(s) from the EMC to
independently verify that the measures are implemented correctly and efficiently
as part of third party verification. This arrangement will fully satisfy the
requirement of Compliance Monitoring.
Table: 7.1(a): Proposed Environmental Monitoring Programme (Construction Phase) for Physical Environment
Meteorology One Continuous/ Daily Wind speed and direction, Max. and Min. -
(Inside the Project Area) Temperature, Humidity, Solar radiation,
Atmospheric Pressure, Rainfall
Ambient Air 5 Stations 8 Hourly, 3 Samples SO2:120µg/m3
Quality at each location Once SO2, NOx, CO and O3 Measure- NOx:150µgm3
Sensitive locations around a week ments by CO:10,000µg/m3
the construction site 1 Sample, 24 hourly External O3: 200 µg/m3
Once a week PM10 and PM2.5 Agency PM10 : 100 µg/m3
Engaged by PM2.5: 50 µg/m3
Noise 10 locations within the Once a month for 8 TPCL and Night 60 dB(A)
Equivalent continuous Sound Pressure approved by
project area (High Noise hours Day 75 dB(A)
Levels (Leq) CEA
Areas)
5 locations outside project Once a month for 24 Night 56 dB(A)
boundary hours Ambient Equivalent continuous Sound Review by Day 65 dB(A)
Pressure Levels (Leq) at day and Night CEA/ EMC
Sensitive locations around time.
the construction site
Ambient Surface Water: 2 Locations Monthly pH, Temperature, Conductivity, Dissolved -
Water (Sampu Kulam and Oxygen, Total Suspended Solids, Total
Quality Kaddaiparichan Lagoon) Dissolved Solids, Sulphates, Phosphates,
Oil & Grease, Phenolics
Ground Water: 2 locations Quarterly Heavy Metals (Mercury, Cadmium, Lead, -
(near construction camp Iron, Manganese, Copper, Zinc, Total
and Santhoshpuram) Chromium)
Effluents Treated Effluents from Monthly pH, Conductivity, Dissolved Oxygen, Tolerance Limits
Construction Activities Biochemical Oxygen Demand, Chemical for Discharge of
Oxygen Demand, Total Suspended Solids, Industrial and
Total Dissolved Solids, Sulphates, Domestic Waste
Phosphates, Chlorides, Oil & Grease, Water into Inland
Phenolics, Total Coliform, Faecal Coliform Same as Surface Waters’
above published under
Treated Sanitary Effluents Monthly pH, Conductivity, Dissolved Oxygen, National
(Construction camp) Biochemical Oxygen Demand, Chemical Environmental
Oxygen Demand, Total Suspended Solids, Act of Sri Lanka
Total Dissolved Solids, Sulphates,
Phosphates, Chlorides, Oil & Grease,
Phenolics, Total Coliform, Faecal Coliform
Table 7.1(b): Proposed Environmental Monitoring Programme (Operational Phase) for Physical Environment
Note 1: Measurements by External Agency Engaged by TPCL and approved by CEA and Review by CEA/ EMC
Note 2: Measurements by TPCL and approved by CEA and Review by CEA/ EMC
Note 1: Measurements by External Agency Engaged by TPCL and approved by CEA and Review by CEA/ EMC
Note 2: Measurements by TPCL and approved by CEA and Review by CEA/ EMC
Note-3: Tolerance Limits for Discharge of Industrial and Domestic Waste Water into Marine Coastal Areas published under National
Environmental Act of Sri Lanka
Note-4: Tolerance Limits for Discharge of Industrial and Domestic Waste Water into Inland Surface Waters’ published under National
Environmental Act of Sri Lanka
Table: 7.2: Proposed Environmental Monitoring Programme (Construction and Operation Phases) for Terrestrial,
Coastal and Marine Environments
A) Terrestrial Environment
Criteria Indicators Frequency Responsibility
Construction Phase
Tree Plantation No. Of Trees Planted and Survived (No.) Once in six months TPCL
Species composition of plants (List)
Area covered under greenbelt (No.)
Impact on Water Any sign of disturbance, waste disposal, Once a month TPCL
Body (Sampu sedimentation beyond the boundary of TTPP
Kulam) due to TPCL (Digital Photographs)
Operation Phase
Biodiversity Species composition of flora and fauna (List) Once in a three years TPCL through an independent
Ecologist approved by CEA
Biodiversity Selected sites Once Before Bottom and pelagic bio biodiversity,
Construction Species for transplantation, location for TPCL through an
transplantation and method. independent Ecologist
approved by CEA
Operation Phase
Thermal regime Four locations at 200 Monthly for one year. Temperature Measurements by
(Spread and m and four locations Frequency/ locations Water quality analysis (TSS, Salinity, External Agency
temperature at 500 m in all four may be reviewed after Residual Chlorine, Oil and Grease, Engaged by TPCL and
pattern of the directions from the one year. Sulphate, E-coli) approved by CEA
outlet water) point of outfall
Beach profile of at 100 m intervals in a Bi Annual (before and Measurements by
Koddiyar and 3 km coastal stretch after monsoon External Agency
Shell Bays (1.5 km to the south Engaged by TPCL and
and 1.5 km to the Beach Profile Survey approved by CEA
north of the shoreline
location of the intake/
outfall structures
Biodiversity Selected sites along Annually Bottom and pelagic bio biodiversity TPCL through an
the Pipeline Route and independent Ecologist
Intake/ Outfall approved by CEA
Structures 100 m on
both the sides for pipe
corridor and 500 m
from the boundary of
intake/outfall
structure.
Table 7.3: Proposed Monitoring Programme for Construction and Operation Phases for
Socio-economic Environment
Criteria Indicators Data Responsibility
Construction Phase
Human No. of complaints received about construction related Data from the Grievance Redress
settlements disturbances, construction site and Mechanism Reporting to
No. and % of complaints attended /unattended, also from the local EMC for monitoring
community to have
Reasons for not attending the complaints
values for the indicators
No. of local persons requested for employments and
no. of employments offered
No of requests rejected and the reasons for rejection,
No. of persons able to initiate indirect income
generation activities due to project,
Fisheries activities No. and nature of complaints received from fishermen Documented cases on Fisheries community
on any type of disturbances induced due to project incidents leaders, Fisheries
construction activities in the sea area Inspector in the areas.
No. and % of complaints attended /unattended, Grievance Redress
Reasons for not attending the complaints Mechanism Reporting to
EMC for monitoring
Other likelihood No. and nature of complaints received from other Data on the details of Grievance Redress
disturbances institutions (religious institutions, schools etc.), the complaints and their Mechanism Reporting to
No. and % of complaints attended /unattended, relevance to the project EMC for monitoring
activities
Reasons for not attending the complaints
Other benefits No. and nature of requests received from the Data on the cost of Grievance Redress
community to improve local infrastructure attending the requests Mechanism Reporting to
No. and % of requests attended /unattended to the project and the EMC for monitoring
benefits for the local
Reasons for not attending the requests
community
Operation Phase
Local communities No. and nature of complaints received against project Detailed data on the Grievance Redress
induced disturbances (dust, smoke and other), complaints and Mechanism Reporting to
No. and % of complaints attended /unattended, employment, income EMC for monitoring
generated through
Reasons for not attending the complaints
project assisted sources
No. of employment generated in the project
No. of employment offered to the local communities,
Indirect income generation opportunities and their
nature,
Income generated to the local economy
Other sensitive No. and nature of complaints received from religious Details on the Grievance Redress
institutions centres about project induced impacts, complaints and the Mechanism Reporting to
No. and % of requests attended /unattended solutions offered EMC for monitoring
Reasons for not attending the requests
Other project No. and nature of complaints (disturbances to the Details on the Grievance Redress
induced access roads etc.) and requests for benefits complaints and the Mechanism Reporting to
implications (assistance to religious centres, schools etc.) solutions offered EMC for monitoring
received.
No. and % of complaints/ requests attended
/unattended along with reasons for not attending
Overall socio- Indicators on Health, Education, Sanitation and Periodic Survey (every 3 TPCL through a reputed
economic Hygiene, Income level, etc. years) institution under the
development overall guidance of EMC.
Capacity building No. of Persons with additional Educational/ Technical/ Periodic Survey (every 3 TPCL through a reputed
and skill Professional Skills Acquired years) institution under the
upgradation No. of Persons with additional Employment/ Improved overall guidance of EMC.
Status of Employment as a result of above and
Role of TPCL in facilitating the skill upgradation (such
as organising the training, sponsoring the candidates,
providing financial incentives etc.). if any.
8.3 RECOMMENDATIONS
Execution of the project is recommended with the proposed mitigation measures
and monitoring requirements. All necessary contractual provisions and
stipulations regarding mitigation measures shall be included in the contract
documents. An Environmental Management Plan shall be prepared based on
proposed environmental mitigation and monitoring plans and the conditions
stipulated in environmental clearance. Additional cost items for these shall be
specified in the bill of quantities for construction works. This EMP shall be an
integral part of the contract. The EMP shall also include programmes for
environmental awareness of workers and training on environmental related
matters.
It is recommended that environmental monitoring be undertaken by an
Environmental Monitoring Committee with representatives from different
agencies/ stakeholders. This monitoring Committee shall be put in place prior to
commencement of the construction works of the project.