Seri Konferensi IOP: Ilmu Bumi dan Lingkungan

KERTAS • AKSES TERBUKA

Pengaruh karakteristik permukiman bantaran sungai terhadap keberlanjutan Kali

Pepe Surakarta

Mengutip artikel ini: S Setyowati dkk 2020 IOP Conf. Ser .: Lingkungan Bumi. Sci. 447 012054

Lihat artikel online untuk pembaruan dan peningkatan.

Konten ini diunduh dari alamat IP 36.83.66.101 pada 27/02/2021 pukul 12:48
ICoPS2019 IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Seri: Ilmu Bumi dan Lingkungan 447 ( 2020) 012054 doi: 10.1088 / 1755-1315 / 447/1/012054

Pengaruh karakteristik permukiman bantaran sungai terhadap

keberlanjutan Kali Pepe Surakarta

S Setyowati 1, A Djunaedi 2, D Pramitasari 2 dan A Sarwadi 2

1 Jurusan Arsitektur Fakultas Teknik

Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta, Jl. Garuda Mas No.6 Pabelan, Kartasura, Sukoharjo, Jawa
Tengah, Indonesia
2 Department of Architecture and Planning, Faculty of Engineering Universitas Gadjah Mada, Jl.

Grafika No.2, Mlati, Sleman, Daerah Istimewa Yogyakarta, Indonesia

Corresponding author’s e-mail: [email protected]

Abstract. Surakarta City is one of the cities in Indonesia that has experienced the effects of urbanization and rapid
development. This is evident from the slums along the banks of the Kali Pepe. This river intersects the city of Solo and
stretches for about five kilometers from Sangkrah Village to Gilingan Village. This river used to have an important role in
accommodating urban mobility. In 2016, Kali Pepe received attention for its pedestrian segments, parks, and riverbank
development. This study describes the settlement characteristics along the riverbanks in relation to the sustainability of
the Kali Pepe. Descriptive-qualitative methods accompanied by in-depth interviews were used to collect data. Moreover,
the study exploration of field conditions was recorded in the form of sketches and photographs. The results of the study
show two prominent potentials from the characteristics of the Kali Pepe riverbanks in relation to its sustainability, i.e., (1)
nature characteristics that can be developed through integrated water transportation tourism; (2) The emergence of
homeindustry that is backed by the potential of employment in the informal sector and accommodated riverbank tourism.

1. Introduction
One impact of the current high rate of urbanization is the increase in the need for human settlements. This leads to the
formation of unplanned settlements and slums. Population growth can cause social, economic, and cultural changes in cities.
Such conditions can lead to a competition for land, causing the formation of slums on the remaining pieces of land in urban
areas. Slum settlements are not only caused by newcomers who cannot afford the price of urban land. It is also caused by the
deterioration of old settlements into slums.

Slum settlements are settlements that are not suitable for habitation due to the high building density and the low quality
of buildings as well as facilities and infrastructure that do not meet minimum standards. Some other the characteristics of
the slum settlements are that majority of the inhabitants are low-income households; the livelihoods of slum dwellers are in
the informal sector; the environment, settlements, houses, facilities, and infrastructure are sub-standard; the public facilities
are inadequate, flood-prone, and the environment can pose physical and non-physical threats for the inhabitants.

Content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence . Any further distribution of this work must maintain attribution
to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.
Published under licence by IOP Publishing Ltd 1
ICoPS2019 IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 447 ( 2020) 012054 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/447/1/012054

The largest slum settlement in the city of Surakarta is located along the banks of the Kali Pepe, which spans
approximately five kilometers from Sangkrah Urban Village to Gilingan Urban Village. Kali Pepe is a meeting point of two
rivers; Kali Pepe and Bengawan Solo. The river plays a big role in the city’s mobility for transporting goods that supply
markets and for human transportation. It is the main trade artery for various ethnicities. In 2016, a restructuring program for
the pedestrian walks, parks and the construction of a concrete canal lining for the Kali Pepe were planned. Kali Pepe has an
interesting dynamic development environment after the waterfront environmental arrangement which began in 2016 and is
planned to be completed in 2018 in line with the government's efforts to restore the image of the city in this case to
accommodate waterfront city tourism.

Research related to settlements built in urban areas that are normally illegal for development has mushroomed. Areas
along riverbanks are normally prohibited for development. Research on riverbanks identified the problem of settlements in
the city of Bandung. These areas do not fulfill the need for adequate housing; low-income communities have limited access
to housing; the quality of housing and settlements is declining; and there is no integrated development of facilities and
utilities in the area. This research aimed to find out the quality of the slums and provide recommendations for the
improvement of the settlements along the Cikapundung [1]. This was reaffirmed by Bintarsih's research on the development
of waste banks for communities in the Cikapundung River [2]. This research recommended governments and
institutions/social organizations to implement a continuous program that increases the awareness of local communities of
effective waste management. Both studies complement each other in providing solutions for settlement improvement on the
riverbanks [2].

Another study that has been carried out on riverbank settlements is the study on the characteristics of Kampung Beting in
Pontianak [3]. Kampung Beting was formed spontaneously due to the socioeconomic conditions of the area. The area is
characterized by ethnic plurality, which is the absence of customary rules that generally shape the social environment of
traditional settlements. Changes in settlements occur under the influence of changes in networks, lifestyles, which ultimately
changes the overall ecological elements of settlements. Another study was conducted that analyzed the sustainability of
riverbank settlements of the Kahayan River in Palangkaraya City. The research discovered that Ada dua jenis permukiman,
yaitu: (1) Rumah Lanting (permukiman informal) dan (2) Rumah panggung, yang merupakan permukiman formal dengan
sertifikat tanah [4].

A study on the characteristics of slum areas in Semarang found that the environmental conditions were unsuitable for
living and did not meet the standards for settlements [5]. Furthermore, research on the banks of the Palembang Musi River
identified the spontaneous settlement process in the area. The study identified the legality of settlements in terms of the place
of origin of the residents, the process of acquiring land, the house construction activities, the characteristics of activities, and
the tendency of displacement of habitable places [6]. The various studies mentioned above highlighted that the
characteristics of riverbank settlements are influenced by several factors, which are, among others, by nature, the origin of
residents, the behavior of people, occupancy and condition of facilities and infrastructure. In contrast to the before mentioned
studies, this study examines the characteristics of the settlements in the Kali Pepe using the Doxiadis’ five elements of the
settlement in order to determine its sustainability.

1.1. Elements of settlements

The term settlement refers to dwellings intended for humans. As such, settlements are built with the purpose of meeting
humans’ needs for living space. Broadly speaking, the term settlement also implies an understanding of human interactions
and interactions between humans and society as well as human-nature interactions. A settlement comprises two elements [7]:

• The content: humans who live in the settlement (individuals and social groups);
• The container: the physical place where humans live which includes natural and man-made elements.

2
ICoPS2019 IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 447 ( 2020) 012054 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/447/1/012054

Figure 1. Individuals (left), Social Groups (right) Figure 2. Natural environment (left), man-
made environment (right)

1.2. Settlement systems by Doxiadis

A system is used to show a "phenomenon" that has a clear and well-known structure. The system is defined as a collection of
elements that mutually interact and collaborate to achieve certain goals in a complex environment. The settlement system is
made up of five elements, i.e., nature, Anthropos, society, shells, and networks. These elements are a comprehensive unit
rather than a collection of parts.

Good settlements can provide happiness and safety and vice versa, a settlement is considered bad if it can no longer fulfill
human needs. The settlement system includes [7]:
• Nature; sub-elements of the natural environment include geography, topography, land, water, plants, animals,
climate/weather, wind, and sun.
• Anthropos; human needs must be well-considered, among others, biological needs (space, air, food); sensory
regulation; stimulus from the environment through the senses and the need for the perception of the environment;
and emotional needs. Physical development marginalizes moral values and there are reciprocal links between
quality of life and quality of the environment (Figure 3).

• Society; elements of the society include composition and population density, social stratification and cultural
patterns, economic development, education, health, law and administration (Figure 4).

• Shells; covers housing, social facilities, economic facilities, government facilities, industry, and transportation
centers.
• Networks; this element includes water and power supply systems, transportation, communication, and
wastewater disposal.

Figure 3. Space requirements Figure 4. Society.

for children.

Human needs for space receive the most attention in ekistics. Spatial requirements include individual space for
various activities and functions as well as more complex spaces for socioeconomic activities. Doxiadis argued that
space is needed to provide the possibility of interaction between humans and regions.

3
ICoPS2019 IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 447 ( 2020) 012054 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/447/1/012054

1.3. Sustainable development

The Minister of Population and the Environment in the year 2010 has outlined several environmental policies in relation to
sustainable development as follows.
• Reviving economic growth, which has a direct relationship with community welfare. The indicator of community
welfare is income per capita. In developing countries, the minimum growth of national income is 5% per year.

• Changing the quality of growth. This is associated with conserving natural resources, improving income
distribution, and resilience to various economic crises.
• Meeting basic human needs. This includes food, shelter, clothing, energy, water, and sanitation, which must be able
to meet minimum standards for economically weak groups. Ensuring a sustainable population. A population that can
• support sustainable development is stable and in accordance with the carrying capacity of its environment. To
ensure a sustainable population, high population growth rates (> 2% per year), as is the case in most developing
countries, must decline towards a growth rate of zero.

Sustainable development refers to actions that can preserve their natural environment. Sustainable development has the
following characteristics.
• It preserves the functions and capabilities of ecosystems, directly as well as indirectly.
• It utilizes natural resources through technology that does not damage the environment.
• It provides opportunities for other sectors and activities to develop in each region, within the same timeframe and at
different time periods on an ongoing basis.
• It enhances and preserves ecosystem functions to supply, protect, and support natural resources in a
sustainable manner.
• It uses procedures that pay attention to the sustainability of ecosystems’ functions and abilities to support life in the
present and the future.

2. Research methods
The research used a mixed-method approach that combines descriptive methods and qualitative exploratory methods
based on field data to discover the characteristics of settlements located along the Kali Pepe in Surakarta. Data collection
commenced with a general survey of the study locations to determine the physical boundaries of the study area. The study
focuses specifically on the Kestalan Urban Village (RW1), Keprabon Urban Village (RW 5), Ketelan Urban Village (RW
4-5), and Setabelan Urban Village (RW 7-9). The survey results are presented using descriptive methods and analyzed
qualitatively to identify settlement characteristics on the banks of the Kali Pepe. The settlement variables refer to the five
elements of settlements, i.e., nature, humans, society, shell, networks [7].

3. Results
The results and discussion refers to the five elements that influence the formation of a settlement, i.e., (1) Nature, the land
that is used and utilized to build a residence and for other functions; (2) Humans, individuals or groups who occupy the land;
(3) Society, referring to the interactions and social relations; (4) Shells, a shelter for human life; (5) Networks, the
infrastructure used to support human livelihood activities. Based on this theory, the characteristics of slums along the Kali
Pepe can be identified as follows.

3.1. Nature characteristics

The Kali Pepe River is in a flood-prone area with inadequate drainage facilities, which causes flooding when it rains. In
2016, the government started making concrete canal lining and dredging along the riverbanks, stopping flooding until now.
Access to water for the community can be classified as good and is supplied by using shallow well water, rainwater, or by
purchasing canned water. Judging from the survival of animals and plants, the climate conditions are also favorable.
Currently, the

4
ICoPS2019 IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 447 ( 2020) 012054 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/447/1/012054

government has initiated a program to develop river tourism along the Kali Pepe, which is expected to restore the historical
function as a water transportation route.

Figure 5. Concrete canal lining along the Riverbank of Kali Pepe

3.2. Human characteristics

The characteristics of the residents can be identified from the social and economic conditions of the community. This can be
viewed from the source of livelihoods that affect the environmental conditions and the type of shelter in the area. The
majority of people who live in slums work in the informal sector. Along the riverbank, garbage is dumped in allocated space
along the pedestrian even though the garbage collection system is inadequate as the garbage is collected only twice a
week. In the neighborhood along the Kali Pepe riverbank, there is a 1-2 meter wide road that serves multiple functions, i.e.,
as a public space, a place for cooking, washing & drying laundry, and parking (Figure

6).

3.3. Characteristics of society

Kepadatan penduduk, stratifikasi sosial, dan pola budaya tidak berubah di kawasan sepanjang bantaran Kali Pepe. Luas
rata-rata rumah adalah 12 m 2 and occupied by one household comprising 4-5 people. The houses consist of 1-2 floors of
multifunctional space, yet toilets and kitchen are still outside the house. This causes the 1-2 meters wide neighborhood
road to have multiple functions and be characterized by sharing of space. There are various social activities in the Ketelan
RW 05 area, these include efforts to mobilize the youth to be active in the community, there are routine meetings of
fathers, as well as welfare empowerment gatherings. Most residents of this urban village have inhabited this area since
1998. Around 50 families live in the Keprabon area. The shared communal space is frequently used for meetings of men
and women and sometimes services are provided.

Figure 6. Public spaces on the Kali Pepe’s Riverbanks Figure 7. Public spaces along the Kali Pepe

5
ICoPS2019 IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 447 ( 2020) 012054 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/447/1/012054

3.4. Shell characteristics

Building irregularities can be seen from the orientation, size, and shape. In general, buildings are semipermanent and
unregulated. The roofs, floors, and wall material does not meet the minimum health standards. For instance, many houses still
have dirt floors, or the wall is made of makeshift material, which causes unhealthy air circulation. On Jl. R.M. Said and
Keprabon there is an apartment building. This development involved various stages including (1) initial socialization, (2)
mapping of physical, environmental and social aspects, (3) socialization of mapping results (Figure 8).

Along the Kali Pepe, row houses have been constructed in Pringgading Village, Stabelan Village (see Figure 9). These row
houses were built in collaboration with non-governmental organizations and are occupied by low-income households, who can
get building permits and construction funding from the government. These houses provide sanitation facilities. The average
house along the riverbank of the Kali Pepe has an area of 3x4 meters and is inhabited by one household (4-5 people). These
houses do not have a private toilet and the kitchen of some houses is situated outside the house. Figure 10 shows the location
of the flats and row houses after the restructuring program from the Surakarta City Government (Figure 10).

Figure 8. Kali Pepe Flats Figure 9. Kali Pepe Row Houses

3.5. Network characteristics

The range of services can be seen from the road network in the area along the Kali Pepe, which is identified as adequate.
Accessibility to residential roads along the banks gives a sense of security ad comfort and facilitates the movement of
pedestrians, cyclists, and motorbikes. The road infrastructure that connects houses within settlements also supports the
creation of more suitable and comfortable settlements on the banks of the Kali Pepe. Similar infrastructure development is
carried out in all residential areas along the banks of the Kali Pepe. Some of the infrastructures that have been constructed
include communal toilets, well pumps, wastewater installations, and repair of road paving for pedestrians (Figure 11).

6
ICoPS2019 IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 447 ( 2020) 012054 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/447/1/012054

SEGMEN 1 SEGMEN 3

SEGMEN 2

Information:

: Settlements

: Flats

: Row Houses

Figure 10. Mapping of flats and row houses location

Figure 11. One of the paved roads along the Kali Pepe Figure 12. Well pumps are found at several
points along the Kali Pepe.

Based on the five elements by Doxiadis, the residential characteristics of the settlements on Kali Pepe's riverbanks are as
follows:
• Nature characteristics: The Kali Pepe offers great natural potential. For instance, it offers the possibility of river
tourism while restoring the function of rivers as a historical water transportation route. This is expected to have
a long-term impact on the socio-economic conditions of the community.

• Human characteristics: The optimization of various river potentials can lead to an increase in the standard of living for
the people who live along the banks of the Kali Pepe.
• The characteristics of society: The composition remains unchanged in terms of population density, social
stratification, and cultural patterns. However, lately, significant changes felt were in terms of increasing sources of
livelihood along the riverbanks.

7
ICoPS2019 IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 447 ( 2020) 012054 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/447/1/012054

• Shell characteristics: Apartments were constructed in the form of in-situ handling whereas another protection
program is the construction of row houses in Pringgading Village, Stabelan Village. These were built independently,
where occupying residents are from low-income groups and can have access to building permits, construction
financing from the government, and sanitation.

• (e) Network characteristics: The road infrastructure that connects houses within the settlement unit also supports the
creation of settlements along the riverbanks that are livable, healthy, safe, and comfortable. The infrastructure that
has been constructed in all settlements along the Kali Pepe are communal toilets, wells pumps, waste treatment, and
repair of road paving.

4. Discussion
Bagian ini membahas hubungan antara karakteristik permukiman dan keberlanjutan Kali Pepe dengan membahas
unsur-unsur permukiman oleh Doxiadis yang terkait dengan konsep pembangunan berkelanjutan. Ciri pertama
pembangunan berkelanjutan adalah terpeliharanya fungsi dan kemampuan ekosistem, baik secara langsung maupun
tidak langsung. Berdasarkan karakteristik alamnya, Kali Pepe memiliki potensi alam untuk wisata sungai sekaligus
mengembalikan fungsi sungai sebagai jalur transportasi air yang memiliki nilai sejarah. Hal ini diharapkan berdampak
jangka panjang terhadap kondisi sosial ekonomi masyarakat. Temuan ini menunjukkan bahwa penataan ulang Kali Pepe
berdampak baik pada perbaikan kondisi alam sekitarnya.

The second feature is utilizing natural resources and technologies that will minimize harm to the environment. This can be
viewed from the shell and network characteristics of the settlements along the river. This is indicated by the construction of
in-situ buildings and self-help programs targeted at low-income people. Road infrastructure that connects houses within
settlement units facilitates the creation of a decent settlement that is healthy, safe and comfortable. The infrastructure
improvements that have been implemented along the riverbanks include the construction of communal sanitation, well pumps,
wastewater treatment facilities, and paved roads and pedestrian paths. Furthermore, the government has carried out the
normalization of the river by dredging and constructing concrete canal lining.

The third element is the natural characteristics that affect the long-term socio-economic condition of the community due to
the potential of water transportation tourism and human characteristics of residents working in the informal sector such as
traders and tailors. These community members make use of pedestrian paths in a comfortable public space because of the
clean river conditions. The fourth characteristic can be seen from the 5 km long concrete canal lining and the planting of
vegetations on both sides of the river embankments to maintain a comfortable climate and protect the ecosystems along the
riverbanks.

The fifth characteristic of sustainable development is the use of procedures that observe the sustainability of the
functions and capabilities of the ecosystem to support life, both the present and the future. This includes all of the
rearrangement of Kali Pepe, which is done according to the correct procedures and regulated by the government. This
program started with a government plan to improve slums in the center of the city. On 12 December 2014, the plan was
ratified by the Decree of the Mayor of Surakarta No: 032/97-C/1/2014 on the Determination of Residential and Slum
Locations in Surakarta. This regulation has been the basis for the planning and implementation of urban slum handling in
Surakarta. These efforts aim to achieve the goals of the National Medium-Term Development Plan 2015-2019.

The government of Surakarta has a major aim in the optimization of Kali Pepe to turn the river into a great potential of
Surakarta City. The river's strategic location shows its strategic potential as a tourist location that is expected to bring
positive change for the city of Surakarta and for its inhabitants [8]. Surakarta’s development program for Kali Pepe
commenced with a participatory review of the environment of the river by the Surakarta Department of Housing, Settlements
and Land Affairs in
2017. Then, the area was divided into three zones that were redeveloped in 11 development phases from Gilingan Urban
Village up to Sangkrah Urban Village. The waterfront rearrangement began in

8
ICoPS2019 IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 447 ( 2020) 012054 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/447/1/012054

2016 and was completed in 2018 as part of a government effort to rebrand Surakarta as a waterfront city.

The discussion indicates a connection between the characteristics of Kali Pepe and the features of sustainable
development. In fact, all characteristics of the settlements along the Kali Pepe in terms of nature, human, society, shells, and
networks fit the characteristics of sustainable development. These results can be used as a recommendation for the
improvement of environmental problems of rivers in other cities to add to previous research on the Cikapundung River in
Bandung. In addition, the paper can provide input on the structured method of identifying river characteristics or other
residential neighborhoods using the 5 elements of settlements of Doxiadis.

5. Conclusion
Based on the discussion above, it can be concluded that the restructuring of the Kali Pepe has a good impact on its
sustainability. The findings are also evidence of Doxiadis’ principles of a balance between the elements of settlements. These
are all interconnected and changes in one or several elements will influence the others. This paper aimed to provide a
comprehensive presentation of the characteristics of the Kali Pepe's riverbank, although characteristics are different in each
region. Based on the characteristics along the Kali Pepe, two major potentials are evident: (1) nature characteristic that can be
developed through an integrated program of water transportation and tourism; and (2) The emergence of the home-industry
that is backed by the potential of employment in the informal sector and accommodates riverbank tourism.

Acknowledgments
This research was supported by the Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta. We are grateful to our advisors for providing
insights and expertise that have greatly helped the research. However, all interpretations and conclusions from this paper
were ours alone.

References
[1] Wijaya K, Permana A Y and Suwanto N 2017 Cikapundung riverbanks area as low-income
community settlements in the city of Bandung J Arcade 1 57- 68 DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31848/arcade.v1i2.7
[2] Bintarsih S, Desi Y and Sri S 2017 Development of a garbage bank in the community on the
banks of the Cikapundung river J. Pengabdian Kepada Masyarakat 1 292-298 Available at
http://jurnal.unpad.ac.id/pkm/article/view/16414/8010 accessed 19-01-2020
[3] Khaliesh H, Widiastuti I and Budi B S 2012 Characteristics of Kampung Beting Riverbank
settlements in Pontianak Proc.of the IPLBI Scientific Meeting (Bandung) 69-72 Available at
https://temuilmiah.iplbi.or.id/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/TI2012-05-p069-072Karakteristik-Permukiman-Tepian-Sungai-Kampung-Be
accessed 1901-2020

[4] Hamidah N, Rijanta R, Setiawan B and Marfai M A 2016 Analysis of sustainable riverbank
settlements the case of the Kahayan river settlement in Palangkaraya City INERSIA 12 13-24 DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21831/inersia.v12i1.10343
[5] Nursyahbani R and Pigawati B 2015 Study on the characteristics of slum areas in kampung kota
(Case study: Kampung Gandekan Semarang) J. Teknik PWK 4 267-281 Available at
https://ejournal3.undip.ac.id/index.php/pwk/article/download/8463/8228 accessed 19-012020

[6] Sarwadi A, Tohiguchi M and Hashimoto S 2001 Inhabitation process and spatial order of living space in the urban
riverside area, A case study in the Musi urban riverside settlement, Palembang City, Sumatra, Indonesia J. of
Archit and Plann. (Transactions of AIJ) 556 297304 DOI: https://doi.org/10.3130/aija.67.297_4

[7] Doxiadis C A 1967 Ekistics: An introduction to the science of human settlements ( London:
Hutchinson of London)

9
ICoPS2019 IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 447 ( 2020) 012054 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/447/1/012054

[8] Purnamasari L S 2015 Laporan kegiatan kerja praktek DED penataan bantaran Kali Pepe
Program Studi Perencanaan Wilayah dan Kota (Surakarta: UNS)

10