Field Research (Cafe+)
Field Research (Cafe+)
Field Research (Cafe+)
Final Requirement in
DBAORDEVHOS (Organizational Development
in Hospitality and Tourism Industry)
Presented by:
MARY PAULINE M. ALINCASTRE
Presented to:
DR. ANTONINO F. ALEJANDRO
1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The researcher strongly suggests the implementation process for the coffee
shop to retain its market share and survive in the competition. Related studies shows
the importance of adapting to change and the importance of the manager’s initiative.
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Executive Summary…………………………………………………………………………….2
Table of Contents……………………………………………………………………………….3
Introduction…………………………………………………………………………………...….4
Organizational Background…………………………………………………………………….6
Literature Review………………………………………………………………………………..8
Application of Methods…………………………………………………………………….….14
Problem Definition……………………………………………………………………………..16
Prioritization…………………………………………………………………………………….18
Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………………...19
Recommendation………………………………………………………………………………19
References ……………………………………………………………………………………..20
Appendices……………………………………………………………………………………..22
3
INTRODUCTION
Every organization, whether big or small needs to assess their internal and
external performance in order to sustain and improve their business status. As defined
by Beckhard (1969) “Organization Development is an effort planned, organization-wide,
and managed from the top, to increase organization effectiveness and health through
planned interventions in the organization's 'processes,' using behavioral-science
knowledge.” Planning is a must and an organizational team effort is required to
effectively implement the needed changes. An effective organization can also boost
employee morale because workers can feel more empowered and valued when your
company is well structured.
4
development theories can help strengthen, sustain and improve further in the
competition especially that there is a struggle in MSMEs life cycle.
In the words of John P. Kotter: “The rate of change is not going to slow down
anytime soon. If anything, competition in most industries will probably speed up even
more in the next few decades.” Businesses should conduct preventive measures rather
than coping up to the damages brought about by changes in the competition. If there
are arising problems in the organization, changes should be treated as anticipatory
measures in preparation for bigger leap of development and improvement.
From Lewin’s model, John P. Kotter drafted his Eight Steps to Successful
Change. He is a professor in Harvard Business School concentrating on leadership and
change management. In 1995, he conceptualized the suggested change model
published in his book “Leading Change”. The Eight Steps are as follows: (1) create a
sense of urgency, (2) forming powerful guiding coalition, (3) developing a vision and a
strategy, (4) communicating the vision, (5) removing obstacles, (6) creating short-term
wins, (7) consolidating gains and (7) anchoring change in the corporate culture.
This field research will focus on the application of Kotter’s Eight Step Model of
Change applied in the chosen establishment under study – Café+
Coffee.Brunch.Dessert. The detailed discussion of the organization and the
organizational development model that will be applied will be further discussed in the
succeeding parts of the study.
5
ORGANIZATIONAL BACKGROUND
The coffee shop, in its first years have gained positive feedbacks from its
customers. Through social media comments and first hand customer experiences,
guests of the shop commends good drinks, food and ambiance and mentioned that they
frequently comes back to the store. The regular customers of Café+ is the main strength
of the operation. As John Rampton said: “Customers are the lifeblood of your business”,
the management has established its customer loyalty by providing quality products and
a good place to stay, relax and establish connections. This could also be the reason
why the company stayed through the years and survived the tight competition with other
rising coffee shops in the previous years. The company also takes pride in its
employees in delivering good customer service and in being all-around and multi-tasker
employees.
In the quest of competing with other MSMEs in the area, Café+, however, lacks
in its marketing strategies. There were only few marketing ads and paraphernalia to
6
boost its market share. In an interview conducted with two of its long-time employees,
they noticed a problem in the implementation of job positions in the organizational
structure. The organizational structure of Café+ (see Appendix A) is very simple but
according to its staff, is not properly implemented and the tasks assigned to them were
not clearly stated. There were times when they are asked to do tasks that are not part of
their work (e.g. working as barista then suddenly be asked to help in the kitchen). In the
organizational structure, the owner is also the manager who solely overlooks in the
operation. In some instances that the owner needs to attend other activities and errands
outside the store, the senior employees usually takes over without proper hand over of
tasks and responsibilities. These employees also handles customer complaints in times
like this.
In August 2018, Café+ opens its doors to Central Luzon State University (CLSU)
in Nueva Ecija but unfortunately closed also after a year. According to the staff assigned
to open the store in the area, there is a good customer turnover in the daytime –
because it is a university, but after 6:00pm and during weekends it is like an isolated
one. Since there is a good acceptance in the products of the store, there is an
opportunity outside its main branch if given the proper planning and strategies before
opening. The company needs also to prepare in the changing demographics and
changing trends as it might affect the preferences of their customers. The product line of
Café+ is very stationary and they only stick to their classic menus.
Every MSME needs to prepare for anything that could disturb the harmony of its
operations – threats. Any company is afraid of this, thus preparation makes it easier to
cope up in these unplanned external changes. The booming industry of milk tea shops
is one of those that could harm the sales of Café+, giving an option to other customers.
It was year 2018 when Starbucks Pulilan opened its doors to the people in the area,
which makes it a competitor in the nearby place. The stated challenges and threats to
the operation of Café+ should be an eye opener to the owners in being very complacent
in the competition.
7
Café+ is commendable in its regular customers, but preparation for the
opportunities and threats should also be a consideration in their organizational
development. Highlighting the problem in its organizational structure and
implementation is a considered area for attention. (see Appendix C for the Summary of
SWOT Analysis)
LITERATURE REVIEW
8
for change, support will be created. This requires and open, honest and
convincing dialogue. This convinces employees of the importance of taking
action. This could be accomplished by talking with them about potential threats or
by discussing possible solutions.
9
The most important objective of step 4 of Kotter’s 8 Step Change Model is
to create support and acceptance among the employees. This can only be
achieved by talking about the new vision with the employees at every chance you
get and by taking their opinions, concerns and anxieties seriously. The new
vision must be fully adopted across the entire organization.
5. REMOVE OBSTACLES
(Remove obstacles, enable constructive feedback and lots of support from
leaders – reward and recognize progress and achievements.)
Before change is accepted at all levels, it is crucial to change or, if
necessary, remove obstacles that could undermine the vision. By entering into
dialogue with all employees, it will become clear who are resisting the change.
To encourage acceptance of the vision by the employees, it helps when their
ideas are incorporated and implemented in the change process.
7. CONSOLIDATE IMPROVEMENTS
(Foster and encourage determination and persistence - ongoing change –
encourage ongoing progress reporting highlight achieved and future milestones)
According to John Kotter many change trajectories fail because victory is
declared too early. However, change is a slow-going process and it must be
driven into the overall corporate culture. Quick wins are only the beginning of
10
long-term change. An organization therefore needs to keep looking for
improvements. Only after multiple successes have been achieved, it can be
established that the change is paying off.
When all steps of Kotter’s 8 Step Change Model have been followed, John Kotter
recommends taking the new vision as a starting point when recruiting and hiring new
staff. This also applies to the training of (current) staff. The new vision and the changes
must be given a solid place in the organization. Employees who have actively
contributed to the change must receive public recognition. Their support is enormous
and therefore they will be asked again for their support and help when another change
needs to be brought about.
Below is a list of advantages and disadvantages of the model from an article
written by Prachi Juneja (2000).
11
Disadvantages of Kotter’s Model
Since it is a step by step model, skipping even a single step might result in
serious problems.
The process is quite time consuming (Rose 2002).
The model is essentially top-down and discourages any scope for participation or
co-creation.
Can build frustration and dissatisfaction among the employees if the individual
requirements are given due attention.
Coffee plays a vital role in one’s life. It is more than a drink. According to a study
conducted by Kantar Worldpanel Philippines, Filipinos shifted from being moderate to
heavy coffee drinkers. Heavy drinkers are those who purchase and consume coffee
products thrice a week or 126 times a year. For the past years, this growth has been
consistent. Another study conducted by Barlan in 2013, stated that as for the managers
and employees assessment on their business for the future, they see the coffee shop
business in the next five years positively. They are expecting a reasonable growth in
their business because of the innovation that they will continue to offer to their
customers, and with the positive feedbacks and overwhelming response they are
gaining from them there will be expanding greatly in the market. Thus, leading to the
importance of change and innovation in sustaining your share in the competition.
Another related study addresses the determinants of survival that exist in the
family-run local coffee shop business in Malaysia which are not readily apparent in the
study of larger food service players or in manufacturing firms and other family
businesses. These determinants are ownership transition to next generation,
competitive advantage, location and branding. With regards to branding strategy -
marketing skills is the one of the requirements for local food operators to compete with
modern food chains. Most of the SME have less well-recognized brands because of
less marketing strategies. (Foo, et.al. 2013)
12
Café+ is also considered as an independent coffee shop. To survive beyond five
years, a study with the following conclusion can be considered to remain strong in the
competition giving emphasis to being adaptive to market changes and sustainability and
the importance of proper planning. Independent coffee shops are vulnerable to market
changes and sustainability. Independent coffee shop owners may be unsure as to what
strategies survived through community involvement. Community involvement was
critical to business sustainability for independent coffee shops. Capturing customer
loyalty to generate enough profits to sustain the business was a challenge facing
independent coffee shops. The business owner must develop a plan and communicate
its purpose to the community to benefit economically. (Higdon, 2016)
Running a café / coffee shop is a high risk business, giving importance to the role
of the owners/managers as catalyst in the success of the organization. It was
highlighted in a study conducted by Douglas, et.al. (2018) that in order to succeed,
coffee shop owners need good coffee and good food delivered by customer-friendly
staff in a clean environment. To make a success of their business, owners need a range
of business skills covering such areas as operations management, marketing, human
resources management and financial management. They also need good interpersonal
skills and good leadership skills.
13
complex dynamic within which employee attitudes and future expectations will be
shaped.
APPLICATION OF METHODS
14
The organizational structure should also be revised to meet the needs of the
operation. During the interview, it was mentioned that employees doesn’t have a
clear understanding of the structure since the manager/owner doesn’t use it and
almost everyone has the same level of responsibility. Thus, resulting to some
problems in those times when the manager is not around.
5. Remove Obstacles
The manager’s attitude towards change should be the first obstacle to be
removed. Based from the observations of the interviewee, the manager is the
one who resists change. She is afraid of trying and innovating. With this, she
must realize the possible advantages of organizational development and the
preparation for the future competition. After which, the implementation will
successfully follow.
Other employees are also afraid of changes and innovation. Given the
proper training and operation mindset, the other employees may divert this
attitude into positive initiatives in the planned change.
15
6. Create Short-Term Wins
In an organization that is very complacent, celebration of short-term
achievements are considered accomplishments already. Step-by-step, little-by-
little, the changes achieved and accomplished must be accompanied by rewards
to motivate more the employees.
7. Consolidate Improvements
The organization should conduct a regular check on the progress of the
targets. This will further help the organization in monitoring the effectiveness of
the plans.
8. Anchor The Changes
Change should be incorporated in the organizational culture of the
organization. Organizational culture is based on shared attitudes, beliefs,
customs, and written and unwritten rules that have been developed over time
and are considered valid (The Business Dictionary).
Employees should get used to be part of the change in the organization.
They should not be afraid of being innovative and active part of the development.
With this, the organization as a whole will benefit and will rapidly adapt to
external challenges and opportunities.
PROBLEM DEFINITION
The researcher interviewed two (2) senior employees in the organization and
from the conducted interview, the following problems were identified and clustered
depending on its areas of concern:
16
There is no clear organizational structure defining the division of tasks and
scope or assignment between employees;
Employees are unintentionally tasked to take over on areas needing attention
even if they are not the focal person assigned;
Inconsistencies with employee salary and benefits compared in different
years and instances (e.g. holiday pay);
Not all employees are delivering the same customer service;
o There are noticed inconsistencies in the manner of customer service
delivery amongst employees.
Based on the gathered data regarding the concerns of the organization, the
researcher has concluded that the main problem is the absence of a clear
organizational structure and non-implementation and the problem wih the
manager’s initiative to development. The researcher believes that the main problem
has resulted to different concerns and conflicts in the organization (as detailed above).
17
ORGANIZATION AND DESCRIPTION OF ISSUES
PRIORITIZATION
Based from the conducted field research, the researcher has crafted an
implementation process to help the organization move forward and improve through
organizational development.
18
wins. This phase will also help increase the proactivity rate of employees in the
process.
Step 4: The last phase of Kotter’s change model includes the two steps:
consolidating improvements and anchoring of changes. The last phase is a signal
that the organization has adapted to change and that the members of the
organization has contributed already to the development and improvement.
Step 5: After having completed the eight-step change model, proper check and
monitoring should be thoroughly conducted to fully implement the changes.
The suggested process prioritizes the need for the owner/manager to be open to
changes giving emphasis on the way she is managing the organization. Without the
success of the first stage, other suggested stages cannot be executed and taken into
action.
CONCLUSION
MSMEs like Café+ should take into consideration the positive effects of adapting
into organizational change and development. It is evident in the conducted field
research that the management of the store under investigation is very relaxed and
complacent in terms of managing and operating her business, thus, resulting to
problems noticed by its employees. Organizational development suggests that every
company should prepare for the challenges of trends and emerging innovation.
Concluded from the conducted investigation were the problems that contributed
to the definition of the main need for concern which is the manager’s willingness to
adapt to change. There is also an evident need for re-organizing the organizational
structure of the coffee shop to create a clear understanding of the job tasks and division
amongst employees. It is also determined by the researcher that the John P. Kotter’s
eight-step change model could be of great help in the change process recommended
for the organization to survive in the business world.
19
RECOMMENDATION
This field research urges the coffee shop under investigation to consider the
suggested implementation process anchored by John P. Kotter’s eight-step change
model for re-organizing and further develop their current business status. There are four
suggested steps for the implementation giving priority to the individual change initiative
on that of the owner/manager of the organization. A re-organization of the structure in
the organization is strongly suggested also likewise with the monitored implementation.
After successfully dwelling in the changes is the application of Kotter’s eight-step
change model with three stages: (1) creating the right climate for change to the
organization, (2) link the change to the organization and (3) consolidating improvements
and anchoring of changes.
REFERENCES
20
Juneja, Prachi (2000). Kotter’s 8 step Model of Change. Retrieved from Management
Study Guide: https://www.managementstudyguide.com/kotters-8-step-model-of-
change.htm
Mulder, P. (2012). Kotter’s 8 Step Change Model. Retrieved [insert date] from
ToolsHero: https://www.toolshero.com/change-management/8-step-change-
model-kotter/
Barlan, Leoncio (2013) Status of Coffee Shop Business in Batangas City: Basis for
Business Operation Initiatives. International Journal of Academic Research in
Business and Social Sciences, August 2013, Vol. 3, No. 8 (ISSN: 2222-6990)
Foo, W. C., Bajuri, N. H., and Wong K. Y. (2013) Overview on SMEs Family-run Local
Coffee Shop in Malaysia: Challenges and Determinants of Survival. Jurnal
Teknologi (Social Sciences) 64:2 (2013), 103–107
Higdon, Bruce (2016). Strategies Independent Coffee Shop Owners Require to Survive
Beyond Five Years. Walden University Scholar Works – Dissertation and
Doctoral Studies Collection.
Douglas, J., Douglas, A., Cano, M., and Moyes, D. (2018) Investigating the Success of
Independent Coffee Shops and Cafes in the UK: Findings from a Pilot Study.
Excellence in Services, 21th International Conference (Paris, France)
Conference Proceedings ISBN 9788890432781
Wiesner, Retha and Banham, Heather C. and Poole, Nicole Lesley (2004)
Organisational change in small and medium enterprises (SMEs). In: 21st
CCSBE-CCPME Conference: Entrepreneurship and Economic Development:
Innovation, Opportunity and Capacity, 12-13 Nov 2004, Regina, Saskatchewan.
21
APPENDICES
APPENDIX A
Organizational Structure of Café+
OWNER/MANAGER
Steward (2)
APPENDIX B
22
Menu Offerings of Café+
APPENDIX C
JOHN P. KOTTER’S EIGHT-STEP CHANGE MODEL
23
APPENDIX D
SWOT ANALYSIS SUMMARY
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
• Strategically located in Plaridel Highway (near • Poor marketing strategies to gain more
establishments and NLEX) customers
• Good customer loyalty • Job positions of employees is not implemented
• Good customer feedback on tastes of product properly
offerings • Load of works of employees is not monitored
• Strong employee attitude (loyal, hardworking properly
and good at multi-tasking) • The owner is the manager and when she is not
around employees are tasked to take over
OPPORTUNITIES THREATS
• Trends in changing taste that can make the • Becoming very complacent with the current
service product more desirable status of the shop
• New geographic shift in the target market, • Arrival of a branded coffee shop in Pulilan area
creating new prospects • Arising of Milk Tea shops near the area,
• New product and services that can be offered offering another option for customers
• Option of expanding the business
24