Appendix “B” – Certificate of Police Blotter Excerpt

Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
NAGA CITY POLICE OFFICE
City of Naga

TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:

THIS IS TO CERTIFY that the following is an excerpt from the Police Blotter
of this Police Unit dated May 3, 2013, wit:
2013-45, 03 May 13, 8:10AM

Robbery

Juanita De Guzman, 34 years old, married of No. 345 Abella Street, Brgy. Abella,
Naga City, reported to this Police Office that on or about 2:00AM of May 2, 2013,
she was awaken with a noise from their kitchen and when she cracked it, she saw
the person of Aldrin Dimayuga, of minor age, also resident of their barangay,
trying to escape in an open outlet in the comfort room with the laptop and when
she shouted for help, subject person assaulted her with a bladed weapon but
fortunately her father was awaken also and successfully subdued the suspect.

Office-on-Case: SPO1 Jose C. Manzanero

Disposition: This case was filed in the court with CC No. 2013-0056, Branch 15,
RTC, Naga City

Given this 8th day of May 2013 at Naga City, Philippines.

FOR THE CITY DIRECTOR:

DANILO S. MAGBANUA
-Police Superintendent
Chief, Admin Section
Appendix “C” – Memorandum

Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
NAGA CITY POLICE OFFICE
City of Naga
NCPO-Inves

MEMORANDUM

FOR : The City of Director

Attn: The Chief, Administrative Section

THRU : The Chief, Operations Section

FROM : The Chief Investigation Section

SUBJECT : Augmentation Personnel, Request for –

DATE : May 8, 2013

1. Reference: Memorandum from R7, PRO5, re-submission of Daily Records of

Events, dated May 2, 2013.

2. Request be informed that the Investigation Section has only seven (7)
personnel while on the other hand, the R7 of PRO5 requires this Section to submit
daily the records of events.

3. In this connection, respectfully request additional personnel to this Section to

do the following tasks:

a. to encode, print and maintain the daily record of events;

b. to submit daily through e-mail the encoded daily records of events.

4. Further request favorable action.

FOR THE CHIEF, INVESTIGATION SECTION:

ERNISTO G CASTILLO
Police Inspector
Asst. Chief, Inves Section
IncI:
Memo from R7, PRO5
Appendix “D” – Radio Message Form

PNP RADIO MESSAGE FORM

INSTRUCTION (ORIGINAL FILLS UP BOXES INSIDE DOUBLE LINE ONLY)

FOR COMCEN SIGNAL USE SECURITY CLASSIFICATION
Line 1
Line 2
Line 3
Line 4
PRECEDENCE ACTON PRECEDENCE INFO TIME/DATE MESSAGE
P 1000H 05 JAN 13 INSTRUCTION

ROUTING
FROM: CD NCPO CITE NO: NCPO-130105
INDICATOR

OOA 0900H O5 JAN 13 CMA A STABBING INCIDENT TRANSPIRED ALONG

PANGANIBAN DRIVE CMA NAGA CITY CMA INFRONT OF IGLESIA NI KRISTO
CHURCH CMA WHEREIN THE VICTIM ONE CMA JOSE DELA CRUZ Y CRUZ CMA
30 YEARS OLD CMA MARRIED CMA JOBLESS AND A RESIDENT OF NO 34 BRGY
LERMA CMA NAGA CITY CMA WAS STABBED BY SUSPECT ONE CMA MARIO
EVANGELISTA Y MARCELINO CMA 28 YEARS OLD CMA SINGLE CMA JOBLESS
ALSO AND A RESIDENT OF BRGY MABOLO CMA ALSO OF NAGA CITY PD AS A
CONSEQUENCE THEREOF CMA THE VICTIM SUSTAINED MULTIPLE STAB WOUND
IN THE DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE BODY AND WAS RUSHED TO ST JOHN HOSPITAL
FOR MEDICAL TREATMENT BUT WAS PRONOUNCED DEAD ON ARRIVAL OPEN
PAREN DOA CLOSE PAREN BY THE ATTENDING PHYSICIAN THEREAT PD THE
SUSPECT WAS ARRESTED AFTER THE INCIDENT BUT THE WEAPON USED WAS NOT
RECOVERED AND HE IS NOW UNDER THE CUSTODY OF THE POLICE OFFICE FOR
INVESTIGATION AND PROPER DISPOSITION PD THE CADAVER WAS MOVED TO
THE PNP CRIME LABORATORY SERVICE CMA CAM SUR PRO CMA NAGA CITY
CMA FOR AUTOPSY EXAMINATION PD THE MOTIVE OF THE INCIDENT IS
UNDETERMINED AND THE CASE IS STILL UNDER INVESTIGATION PD PROGRESS
REPORT WILL FOLLOW PD BT

DRAFTER’S NAME AND TITLE TELEPHONE NUMBER

SPO1 Melvin D. delaJusta Clerk, Inves Section 09284416591

CLASSIFIED NUMBER RELEASER’S NAME AND TITLE SIGNATURE
NO OF PAGES
1 PINSP ERNISTO G CASTILLO
Asst Chief, Inves Section
FOR DATE SYSTEM OPTR DATE SYSTEM DATE SECURITY
OPTR USE CLASSIFICATION
SISON 05 R
JAN
13
Appendix “E” – Spot Report (Sent through Radiographic Message)

PNP RADIO MESSAGE FORM

INSTRUCTION (ORIGINAL FILLS UP BOXES INSIDE DOUBLE LINE ONLY)

FOR COMCEN SIGNAL USE SECURITY CLASSIFICATION
Line 1
Line 2
Line 3
Line 4
PRECEDENCE PRECEDENCE TIME/DATE MESSAGE INSTRUCTION
ACTON INFO 1000H 05 JAN 13
P
ROUTING
FROM: CD NCPO CITE NO: NCPO-130105
INDICATOR

OOA 0900H O5 JAN 13 CMA A STABBING INCIDENT TRANSPIRED ALONG

PANGANIBAN DRIVE CMA NAGA CITY CMA INFRONT OF IGLESIA NI KRISTO
CHURCH CMA WHEREIN THE VICTIM ONE CMA JOSE DELA CRUZ Y CRUZ CMA
30 YEARS OLD CMA MARRIED CMA JOBLESS AND A RESIDENT OF NO 34 BRGY
LERMA CMA NAGA CITY CMA WAS STABBED BY SUSPECT ONE CMA MARIO
EVANGELISTA Y MARCELINO CMA 28 YEARS OLD CMA SINGLE CMA JOBLESS
ALSO AND A RESIDENT OF BRGY MABOLO CMA ALSO OF NAGA CITY PD AS A
CONSEQUENCE THEREOF CMA THE VICTIM SUSTAINED MULTIPLE STAB WOUND
IN THE DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE BODY AND WAS RUSHED TO ST JOHN HOSPITAL
FOR MEDICAL TREATMENT BUT WAS PRONOUNCED DEAD ON ARRIVAL OPEN
PAREN DOA CLOSE PAREN BY THE ATTENDING PHYSICIAN THEREAT PD THE
SUSPECT WAS ARRESTED AFTER THE INCIDENT BUT THE WEAPON USED WAS NOT
RECOVERED AND HE IS NOW UNDER THE CUSTODY OF THE POLICE OFFICE FOR
INVESTIGATION AND PROPER DISPOSITION PD THE CADAVER WAS MOVED TO
THE PNP CRIME LABORATORY SERVICE CMA CAM SUR PRO CMA NAGA CITY
CMA FOR AUTOPSY EXAMINATION PD THE MOTIVE OF THE INCIDENT IS
UNDETERMINED AND THE CASE IS STILL UNDER INVESTIGATION PD PROGRESS
REPORT WILL FOLLOW PD BT

DRAFTER’S NAME AND TITLE TELEPHONE NUMBER

SPO1 Melvin D. delaJusta Clerk, Inves Section 09284416591

CLASSIFIED NUMBER RELEASER’S NAME AND TITLE SIGNATURE
NO OF PAGES
1 PINSP ERNISTO G CASTILLO
Asst Chief, Inves Section
FOR DATE SYSTEM OPTR DATE SYSTEM DATE SECURITY
OPTR USE CLASSIFICATION
SISON 05 R
JAN
13
Appendix “E” –Spot Report (Sent through Memorandum)

Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
NAGA CITY POLICE OFFICE
City of Naga
NCPO

MEMORANDUM

FOR : The Regional Director

Attn: The Chief, R7

FROM : The City Director

SUBJECT : Spot Report, re – Stabbing Incident

DATE : January 5, 2013

1. On or about 9:00AM of January 5, 2013, a stabbing incident

transpired along Panganiban Drive, Naga City, infront of Iglesia ni Kristo Church,
wherein the victim one, Lerma, Naga City, was stabbed by suspect one, MARIO
EVANGELISTA y Marcelino, 28 years old, single, jobless also and a resident of Brgy.
Mabolo, also of Naga City.

2. As a consequence thereof, the victim sustained multiple stab

wounds in the different parts of the body and was rushed to St. John Hospital for
medical treatment but was pronounced dead on arrival (DOA) by the attending
physician thereat.

3. The suspect was arrested after the incident but the weapon used
was not recovered and he is now under the custody of the Police Office for
investigation and proper disposition. The cadaver was moved to the PNP Crime
Laboratory Service, Cam Sur PPO, Naga City, for autopsy examination.

4. The motive of the incident is undetermined and the case is still

under investigation.

5. Progress report will follow.

RICARDO HABALA SALDIVAR

Police Senior Superintendent
Appendix “F” –Incident Report

Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
NAGA CITY POLICE OFFICE
City of Naga
NCPO-Patrol

MEMORANDUM

FOR : The Chief, Operation Section

FROM : The Chief, Patrol Section

SUBJECT : Incident Report

DATE : April 4, 2013

1. Reference: Incident recorded in Patrol Section Incident Logbook

with Entry No. 2013-25, dated April 3, 2013

2. Request be informed that on or about 9:00AM of April 3, 2013, the

car of Senator Juan De la Cruz, XUV, bearing Plate No. ABC 123, colored black,
while parked inside the parking area of Avenue Plaza Hotel, its windshield, for
unknown reason, was smashed with stone by two unidentified persons causing it
to be broken. The two suspects were chased by Security Guards but they made
good of their escape and were never identified.

3. For your information and reference.

RAMON E VELITARIO
Police Chief Inspector

IncI:
Copy of Blotter Excerpt
Appendix “G” –Initial Investigation Report

Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
NAGA CITY POLICE OFFICE
City of Naga
NCPO-Inves

MEMORANDUM

FOR : The Chief, Investigation Section

FROM : The Officer-On-Case

SUBJECT : Initial Investigation Report, re – Malicious Mischief

DATE : April 5, 2013

I. AUTHORITY:

1. Standard Operating Procedures of this Police Unit with reference

to incident recorded in [Patrol Section Incident Logbook, Entry No. 2013-25, dated
April 3, 2013.

II. DETAIL:

2. Upon receipt of the report of the Chief of the Patrol Section, the
herein investigator was dispatched by the duty Desk Officer, SPO4 Elmer O.
Bilarmino to conduct investigation on the alleged malicious being done to the car
of Senator Juan dela Cruz.

3. At the scene, the undersigned investigator observed . . . . .

4. Other details of the incident were . . . . .

III. RECOMMENDATION:

5. It is respectfully recommended that . . . . . . .

Eduardo G Crisostomo
Senior Police Officer1
Appendix “H” –Progress Report

Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
NAGA CITY POLICE OFFICE
City of Naga
NCPO-Inves

MEMORANDUM

FOR : The Chief, Investigation Section

FROM : The Officer-On-Case

SUBJECT : Progress Report No. 1, re – Malicious Mischief

DATE : April 10, 2013

I. AUTHORITY:

1. Progress Report to the investigation conducted on the incident

recorded in Patrol Section Incident Logbook, Entry No. 2013-25, dated April 3,
2013.

II. DETAIL:

2. Continuous follow investigation result to . . . . .

3. This report was confirmed by . . . . .

4. Further, document revealed that . . . . .

III. RECOMMENDATION:

5. It is respectfully recommended that . . . . . . .

Eduardo G Crisostomo
Senior Police Officer 1
Appendix “I” –Final Investigation Report

Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
NAGA CITY POLICE OFFICE
City of Naga
NCPO-Inves

MEMORANDUM

FOR : The Chief, Investigation Section

FROM : The Officer-On-Case

SUBJECT : Final Investigation Report, re – Malicious Mischief

DATE : April 20, 2013

I. AUTHORITY:

1. This section should contain a brief statement of when, where and

by whom the investigation was made on the basis of oral order, this fact should
be stated, naming the individual issuing the order and the date thereof. If it was
made pursuant to the document, stating the date and the original directing
authority, whether local or chief of higher PNP Office, is necessary.

II. MATTERS INVESTIGATED:

2. This section of the report represents the mission of the

investigator/investigating officer. In order words, “What is the investigation
about?” Most of these reports are written complaints, alleging that some persons
have committed some crimes or unjust treatments. If the allegations are too long
to cite, a synopsis is in order. Approximate reference maybe made to the copy of
the papers in the appendix upon which the investigation was based.

III. FACTS OF THE CASE:

3. This section presents the real truth respecting the matters

investigated. Clear and complete descriptions should be applied here.
Presentation of facts should be conherent, unbiased, and fully supported by
evidence.
 The facts regarding the several matters at issue should be presented in the same
manner as that which the allegations are presented in the preceding section, If
there are several allegations to be handled, the presentation should be such that
the reader will know at all times which allegation is being considered. The facts of
each allegation should be put together to tell the story, especially if the
investigating officer is reporting orally. Brevity is not permissible, if it involves the
omiision of a single fact necessary to the only evidence procurable concerning an
element of the case. If there is the conflicting statement of two witnesses from
both in lieu of making a determination of the facts based on a study, analysis and
weighting the evidence.

IV. DISCUSSION:

4. This section should indicate the presumption and inference from

all the circumstances in the case to give the directing authority the clearest
possible picture. It should contain such related factual matter of argument as may
be necessary, in addition to facts presented to establish the conclusions and
recommendations based thereon. On simple case requiring circumstances, this
section maybe avoided and indicated or worded: “This case possesses no aspects
or conditions requiring especial discussion; and there are no mitigating or
extenuating circumstances.” Frequently, however, the evidence is so evenly
divided, pro and co, or the attending circumstances are so unusual that some
explanatory justifying conclusions reached are necessary. In the event acts of
irregularity or misconduct are established in the case of a person whose part
record has otherwise been of such excellence, justice requires that it should be
included in the discussion. When the only obtainable evidence is that contained in
the testimony of the informant and of the person accused, the facts cannot
positively be established. However, the records and character of the accuser may
be used to assist in determining the appropriate action. In such cases, the
investigating officer’s observation and opinions may appropriately be presented
in this section of the report. Whenever the available evidence is scanty and
conflicting but the investigating officer has strong and well-supported convictions
of the matter, the basis for the conclusions he reaches should be presented in the
discussion.

V. CONCLUSSION:

5. This section represents concise summary of the results of

investigation directly consequent from and supported by the facts. This
should logically follow from the facts the case as found and set forth in the
report, and should contain no item not supported by the facts contained in
the preceding parts of the report.
They are usually stated in the order naturally suggested by the statements of the
allegations or facts. Conclusions should not be a repetition of the facts, merely
worded differently. Since the facts upon which they are based will have preceded
this section, no further statement of facts or repetition is necessary or desirable in
the conclusions. They should represent the investigating officer’s honest, well-
studied opinion as to the real truth of each of the matters at issue. As such, they
should contain no apology, or qualifications such as: “it appears,” “it believed,” or
“it seems probable.”

VI. RECOMMENDATION:

6. This section should contain the practical suggestions as to

appropriate action to be taken to make sure suitable disposition of all case. They
should follow, as far as practicable, the same sequence as was used in the
presentation of the conclusions. Recommendations should be consistent with and
appropriate to the conclusions. They constitute the investigating officer’s
authority should take. They should stipulate the proper action in the case of a
wrong committed or the remedy for an unsatisfactory situation or condition
found to exist. If the facts and conclusions disclose that no wrong was committed
nor was there a condition requiring correction, the recommendation may be that
the case be closed.

Investigating Officer

IncI:
*Necessary documents required
Appendix “I-A”- Final Investigation Report

Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
NAGA CITY POLICE OFFICE
City of Naga

NCPO-Inves

MEMORANDUM

FOR : The Chief, Investigation Section

FROM : The Officer-On-Case

SUBJECT : Final Investigation Report, re – Stabbing Incident that

Resulted to the Death of JOSE DELA CRUZ y Cruz

DATE : January 7, 2013

I. AUTHORITY:

1. Verbal Instructions of _________________________________;

2. Complaint Sheet of _____________________dated (Tab “A”); and

3. Memo from ________dated ______ subject _________(Tab “B”).

II. MATTERS INVESTIGATED:

4. A stabbing incident that transpired on or about 9:00AM of January

5, 2013, along Panganiban Drive, Naga City, infront of Iglesia ni KristoChurch; and

5. To determine the criminal liabilities of the suspect and to know the

premises surrounding this particular incident.

III. FACTS OF THE CASE:

6. That on or about 9:00AM of January 5, 2013, a stabbing incident

transpired along Panganiban Drive, Naga City, infront of Iglesia ni Kristo Church,
wherein the victim one, JOSE DELA CRUZ y Cruz, 30 years old, married, jobless and
a resident of No. 34 Brgy. Lerma, Naga City, was stabbed by suspect one, MARIO
EVANGELISTA y Marcelino, 28 years old, single, jobless also and a resident of Brgy.
Mabolo, also of Naga City. As a consequence thereof, the victim sustained
multiple stab wounds in the different parts of the body and was rushed to St. John
Hospital for medical treatment but was pronounced dead on arrival (DOA) by the
attending physician thereat. The suspect was arrested after the incident but the
weapon used was not recovered and he is now under the custody of this Police
Office for investigating and proper disposition. The cadaver was moved to the
PNP Crime Laboratory Service, Cam Sur PPO, Naga City, for autopsy examination.

7. Investigation conducted by this Office disclosed that the motive of

the incident emanated from an old grudge/misunderstanding between them
wherein the victim was threatened to kill by the suspect at any opportune time.
This Office invited three (3) vital witnesses to shed light to this particular incident.

8. In the sworn statement of one EDNA DELA CRUZ – Marciano of

Brgy. Lerma , Naga City dated January 5, 2013, she averred that is the wife of the
victim and that while she together with her friend were waiting for a tricycle on or
about 9:00AM of January 5, 2013 along Panganiban Drive, she saw her husband
being attacked and repeatedly stabbed by one MARIO EVANGELISTA, alias Mar
(suspect), with the use of a bladed weapon. She further averred that after the
incident, they rushed her husband to St. John Hospital for medical treatment but
was declared dead on arrival (DOA) by the attending physician thereat. She
likewise averred that the cause/motive of the incident might be due to an old
grudge/ misunderstanding between them wherein the victim was threatened to
kill by the suspect if he be given a chance or an opportunity to do it (Tab “C”).

9. In the sworn statement of one DANTE DE LEON y Sta Cruz of Brgy.

San Felipe, Naga City, dated January 6, 2013, he stated that while he was on duty
as security guard at the gate of Iglesia ni Kristo Church on or about 9:00AM of
January 5, 2013, he saw a man being attacked and stabbed by his attacker who
was then armed with a bladed weapon (balisong). He further stated that he
immediately reported the incident to the barangay tanod who were conducting
patrol at the vicinity of the said place that resulted to the resulted to the arrest of
the suspect, wherein through the investigation conducted by the police, he
identified as one MARIO EVANGELISTA alias Mar of Pasig City (Tab “D”).

10. In the sworn statement of one PACIFICO DE JESUS y Sta Maria of

Brgy. Lerma, Naga City dated January 6, 2013. He said that while he was tending
his merchandizes along Panganiban Drive, Naga City on or about 9:00AM of
January 5, 2013 he saw a man being attacked and stabbed by his attacker who
was then armed with a bladed weapon (balisong). He further said that after the
 Incident, he helped other bystanders to rush the victim to St. John Hospital
where he succumbed to his death while undergoing medical attention thereat. He
likewise identified the suspect during the investigation conducted by the police as
one MARIO EVANGELISTA alias Mar of Pasig City (Tab “E”).

11. In the Joint Affidavit of Arrest of FRANCISCO STA MARIA y De

Leon and DANILO CASTRO y Bernardo, both of Brgy. Lerma, Naga City, dated
January 6, 2013, they said that they are duly appointed barangay tanod of Brgy.
Lerma and that while they were conducting patrol on or about 9:00AM of January
5, 2013 along Panganiban Drive, they were summoned and responded to a
stabbing incident at the said place wherein they were able to arrest the suspect
through positive identification given by the witness and they further turned-over
him to the police station for investigation. They identified the arrested suspect,
through the investigation conducted by the police, as one MARIO EVANGELISTA
alias Mar of Pasig City and temporarily residing at Brgy. Mabolo, Naga City (Tab
“F”.

12. Based on the Medical Certificate issued by the attending

physician at St. John Hospital, the herein victim sustained multiple stab wounds in
the different parts of the body that caused of his death (Tab “G”). Likewise,
attached are copies of the Autopsy/Necropsy Report and the Death Certificate of
the victim for perusal and ready reference (Tab “H”).

13. On January 6, 2013, a case of Murder against the suspect was

referred to the Office of the City Prosecutor, Naga City and docked under I.S.
Number 13-0015 for final disposition (Tab “I”). Commitment Order was issued by
the court and the suspect was subsequently transferred to the BJMP District Jail,
Brgy. Del Rosario, Naga City. The court recommended no bail bond for the
temporary liberty of the suspect (Tab “J”).

IV. DISCUSSION:

14. The victim and the suspect had personal

differences/misunderstanding before the incident. The herein suspect, with
treachery, evident premeditation and with intent to kill, stabbed the herein victim
several times with the use of a bladed weapon (balisong) that resulted to his
untimely death.

V. CONCLUSION:

15. After a careful perusal surrounding this particular incident,

probable cause exists that the herein suspect is criminally liable, hence, the filling
of a murder case against him is necessary.
VI. RECOMMENDAION:

16. WHEREFORE, in view of the foregoing, the undersigned

respectfully recommends that this case be considered solve and close.

Office-On-Case

List of Exhibits/Annexes to IR
“A” - Complaint Slip/Sheet
“B” – Authority to Investigate
“C1” – SS of Witness 1
“C2” – SS of Witness 2
“D3” – SS of Suspect 1
“D4” – SS of Suspect 2
“E1” – Arrest Booking Sheet
“E2” – Laboratory Reports
“E3” – Photographs
“E4” – Other Documentary Evidence

(NOTE: List Exhibits/Annexes – Only five (5) letters are used. In case of additional
SS, add annexes “C3”, etc. and “D3”, etc.).
Appendix “J”- After Operations Report

Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
NAGA CITY POLICE OFFICE
City of Naga

NCPO-Opns

MEMORANDUM

FOR : The Chief, Investigation Section

FROM : The Team Leader

SUBJECT : After Operations Report

DATE : February 21, 2013

A. References:

a. HWI OF THE Chief, Operations Section to the undersigned to

provide police assistance and conduct rescue operations at Brgy. Carolina, Naga
City.
b. OPLAN “Sagip Nene”

B. On February 20, 2013, the undersigned was directed to lead the team to
rescue Annabel de Ramos, 14 years old, minor, a resident of Brgy. Mabolo, Naga
City, who was reportedly working as Guest Relation Officer (GRO) at one of the
beer houses at Brgy. Carolina, Naga City, particularly at Sweet Rose Beer House
along Km. 14, Brgy. Carolina, Naga City. The team was composed of seven (7) PNP
members and three (3) personnel from CSWD.

C. On or about 9:00AM of February 21, 2013, the team met the parents of
Annabel de Ramos, Jose and Perlita de Ramos, who earlier reported that their
daughter is being forced against her will to work as entertainer at said beerhouse.
At about 9:30AM of even date, the team proceeded to Brgy. Carolina and
coordinated first the Barangay Chairman, then together with some barangay
tanods, the team proceeded to Sweet Rose Beer House.
 D. At the scene, there were several male persons who seemed to be guards
of the place but they did not show of resistance when the team broke into the
said beer house. At said place, the team found the victim, Annabel de Ramos
together with five (5) more minors from different provinces in Bicol Region.

E. The maintainer, Juanita Hernandez y Cruz, 35 years old, widower, a

resident of Manito, Albay, was arrested and brought to this police office together
with Annabel de Ramos and other five minor girls.

F. Appropriate changes is about to file now with the office of the City
Prosecution.

G. For your information and reference.

ANACLETO PENERO TENORIO

Police Senior Inspector

IncI:

 List of participating personnel

 Summary of resources consumed
 Coordination forms (CSWD, Barangay Officials, other agencies)
 Photographs
 Other necessary documents
Appendix “K”- After Encounter Report

Republic of the Philippines

NATIONAL POLICE COMMISSION
PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE
NAGA CITY POLICE OFFICE
City of Naga

NCPO-Opns

MEMORANDUM

FOR : The Chief, Investigation Section

FROM : The Team Leader

SUBJECT : After Encounter Report

DATE : March 15, 2012

I. AUTHORITY: OPLAN No. 30-15 (Palakol)Hqs City Police Office dated February 24,
2012.

II. PERIOD COVERED: March 13 to 14, 2012

III. AREA COVERED: Sitio Caromatig, brgy. Carolina, Naga City.

IV. PARTICIPATING TROOPS: PSINSP AMBROSIO D PONTILLO and twenty-one (21)

others.

V. NARRATIVE:

1. On March 13, 2012 at about 9:00AM, this station received a reliable

information from an asset that an undetermined number of CPP/NPA/NDF (CNN)
led by Anselmo Dimayao, alias “Ka Sel” were planning to collect food stuffs and
conduct teach-ins to the barangay folks in Sitio Caromatig, Brgy. Carolina, Naga
City.

1. Acting on the information, the undersigned immediately organized two

police teams with the mission to seek, engage and neutralize the reported CNNs.
An 11-man PNP team from the City Mobile Group led by PSINSP AMBROSIO D
PONTILLO and an equal number of PNP elements from Patrol Section under this
reporting officer simultaneously jumped off on March 14, 2012 at about 6:00AM
passing through Brgy. San Isidro and subsequently maneuvered to ambush
position at the probable enemy route in the morning of March 14, 2012. Hours of
long wait, however, proved futile as the expected enemy failed to show up.

2. Realizing the futility of waiting any further, the team tactically moved
towards Brgy. Carolina at about 2:00PM, passing through the thick forested area
along Sitio Caromatig of same barangay. While the government troops were
maneuvering in the vicinity of Sitio Caromatig, they were met by a heavy burst of
gunfire from different directions prompting them to seek cover and return fire
toward the direction of the enemy.

3. Heavy firefight ensued. Using firepower, the government troops valiantly

engaged the CNNs in a heated gun battle. In a determined effort to seize the
initiative and gain tactical advantage, the team of PINSP PONTILLO, in utter
disregard of their safety, courageously maneuvered towards the hilly portion of a
terrain while the team of the undersigned provided cover fire. The tactics paid-off
as they were able to inflict heavy casualties on the enemies who were
overwhelmed by the aggressiveness and ferocity of the government troops.

4. Sensing possible annihilation, the enemy frantically withdraw towards

the forested area but an alert team lead by SPO4 Armando D Dimas, cut them
with automatic gunfire and thunderous explosion from their M-203 grenade
launchers, Others, however, managed to escape bringing along with them their
wounded comrades as evidenced by the bloodstain in the route of withdrawal.

5. When the smoke of gun battle subsided, about thirty minutes later,
fourteen (14) CNNS lay dead. Anselmo Dimayao, alias “Ka Sel”, who was seriously
wounded in the initial exchange of gunfire, was captured. There was no casualty
on the government side.

6. After securing the area and vicinity from possible enemy counterattack.
The troops started recovering the items left behind by the enemy, to include
firearms and ammunition. Four (4) dead CNNS were later identified as Ulopiano
de Castro alias “Ka Ulo”, Rodolfo Demetrio, alias “Ka Dolfo”, Igmedio Remedios
alias “Ka Igme” and Rodrigo Saysay “alyas Ka Rod”. While the rest remainded
unidentified.

7. After clearing the area, the team of undersigned conducted pursuit

operations on the CNNs who were able to escape. Following the trails and
bloodstains, the pursuing elements caught up with the enemy about two
kilometers north of encounter scene on March 14, 2012, at about 3:30PM.
 The troops engaged about ten (10) CNNs for about 15 minutes, after which the
enemy withdrew. As a result, two more CNNs were killed. Recovered from their
possession were two (2) high powered firearms (1 M16 and 1 AK-47) and
subversive documents. Again, there was no casualty on the government side.

VI. RESULTS OF OPERATIONS:

1. Enemy Side:
a. Personnel Losses
1. Killed – Fourteen (14)
2. Wounded – Undetermined
3. Captured – Anselmo Dimayao, alias “Ka Sel”

b. Material Losses
1. Firearms
a. Five (5) M16 Cal 5.56mm
b. Three (3) M14 Cal 7.62mm
c. Four (4) AK 47 Cal 5.56mm
d. Two (2) M203 GL

2. Others
a. Two (2) pairs of tropical combat shoes
b. One (1) knapsack with voluminous subversive documents
c. Assorted ammos and magazines for M16, M15 and AK47 rifles

2. Government Side
a. Personnel Losses
1. KIA – None
2. WIA – None
3. Capture – None
4. Material Losses – None

VII. LESSONS LEARNED

1. Good and timely intelligence, bold and exploitation of enemy weakness

are vital to the success of any internal security operation.

2. The 30 – minute firefight showed that the CNNs have already developed
the capacity to engage the government troops in a sustained gun battle. However,
security forces with sufficient strength/firepower, determination and strong will
to fight and stability under pressure have a higher survivability during an
encounter even with a superior enemy force.
 3. In any armed encounter, tactical edge is the key to increasing one’s
survival advantage. Flexibility and initiative of the maneuver team to counter
attack immediately contributed to the success of the internal security operations.

4. Speedy reinforcement of troops from Headquarters and other police

units is severely hampered by the lack of modern transportation and
communication equipment.

VIII. RECOMMENDATIONS:

1. Awarding of Medalya ng Kagitingan (PNP Medal of Merit) to the

participating PNP troops for their courage and combat skills against a superior
number of CNNs.

2. Immediate replenishment of ammunition expended.

3. Issuance of vehicle and communication equipment to further enhance

the unit’s operational efficiency and effectiveness.

TOMAS G BRILLANTE
Police Inspector

IncI:
1. List of participating troops
2. Sketch of the encounter scene
3. Summary of ammunition expended
4. Summary of Ammo Stock Status
5. Recommendation for Award
6. Proposed Citation
7. Pictures
Appendix “L” – Police Operational Plan (OPLAN)

Copy No. ___of ___copies

Naga City Police Office
City of Naga
January 8, 2010
OPLAN “DISASTER”

Reference: Situation Map

Task Organization (Annex “A”)

I – SITUATION:

Naga City is located in the floodplains of Camarines Sur and its urban area
was said to be part of San Miguel Bay itself thousand years ago. The city
topographic clearly shows that its urban core is in the lowest lying end of cities
land area. All of the build-up area in the city is within the 0 to less than 5-
meterelevation, making the present urbanized area prone to flooding. Based on
the flood hazard map, the flood prone area of Naga City covers about 800
hectares, speed over the 17 out of 27 barangays of the city. The area affected
may appear small relative to the total land area of the city (10% of the total), but
this area is inhabited by 85% of the city’s aggregate population and the site of
most of the main economic activities, thereby the impact of flooding hazards
becomes highly significant. For all the flood-return periods analyzed, the extent of
flooding is widespread and disastrous. Most of the flood areas are located in the
vicinity of the Bicol and Naga Rivers on the western side of Naga City.

The depth of flooding varies from less than a meter to more than two
meters which was recorded in the barangays of Triangulo, Sabang and Mabolo.
The ten (10) remaining barangays are prone to wind hazard. They are categorized
as high hazard areas in view of their location and relatively open as well as
dispersed settlements. Overall, about 24% of houses or 7,270 out of 29,208
houses are at risk due to wind hazard at various return periods.

a. Enemy Forces: Current INTSUM (Omitted)

b. Friendly Forces:

1. Camarines Police Provincial Office

2. 504th PNP Provincial Mobile Groups
3. High Patrol Group, Camarines Sur Office
 4. Bureau of Fire Protection
5. Bureau of Jail Management and Penology
6. Criminal Investigation & Detection Group
7. 5th PNP Maritime Group, Naga City
8. Neighboring Municipal Police Stations
9. National Bureau of Investigation
10. 9th ID, Camp Elias Angeles, Tinangis, Pili, Cam Sur
11. All Intelligence Units within AOR
12. Reservist and Reserved Officers
13.Government & Private Security Agencies
14. Barangay Tanods
15. Naga City Public Safety Office

c. Attachments/Detachments: None

d. Assumptions:

1. A tropical cyclone alert hosted over Bicol Region and this developed into
typhoon unit Public Storm No. 4 raised over the province of Camarines Sur
including Naga City.

2. Due to heavy rains, water level continue to rise until flood warning level
reached to level 3 affecting the low lying areas of Naga City, compromising mostly
of residential houses and commercial establishments, resulting to mass
evacuation.

3. While in the upper portion of Naga City, due to strong winds brought
about by typhoon, major crops destroyed, trees unrooted and houses unroofted,
resulting to more disastrous of the residents.

4. There would be having shortage and high prices of prime commodities

due to hoarding by unscrupulous businessmwen.

II. MISSION:

The Naga City Police Station, concurrent with its mission and functions shall
exert effort in minimizing the damage to properties and harm to the citizens
brought about disaster by adopting a preparedness plan.
III. EXECUTION:

A. Concept of Operation:

 Pre – Disaster
 Identify and pre-position manpower, vehicles, communication
equipment to augment resources in vulnerable areas.
 Provides support to warning and information task unit.
 Performs such other functions that may be assigned by CDCC
Chairman from time to time.

 Disaster Phase
 Initiates security measures to protect the evacuation operations and
the evacuation centers.
 Provides security support over movement of relief assistance and
personnel.
 Documents all disaster victims for legal basis in providing assistance
from higher DCC.
 Performs such other functions that may be assigned by DCC chairman
from time to time.

 Post – Disaster Phase

 Assists the registration of the disaster victims for security purposes
 Assists in the clearing operations
 Assists in the conduct of damage assessment and reporting.
 Provides other assistance to the CDCC’s concerns when required
 Performs such other functions that may be assigned by DCC chairman
from time to time

B. Tasking:

1. Operations and Plans Section:

a. OPR of this OPLAN.

b. Compose and supervise the Crises Management Team and Search and
Rescue Operation Team.

c. Make an inventory of equipment and other resources needed when

disaster occurred.

d. Coordinate with CDCC and other line agencies in the time of disaster.
 e. Provide security personnel to all places needing protection during
disaster until after the restoration of all basic facilities.

f. Other tasks as directed.

2. Admin Section:

a. Provide administrative support in the implementation of this OPLAN;

b. Issue order for the detail of personnel to special assignments;

c. Performs other tasks as directed.

3. Intel Section:

a. Monitor group lawless elements that may take advantage of the

situation;

b. Perform other tasks as directed.

4. Logistic/Finance Section:

a. Prepare necessary equipment during disaster particularly in search and

rescue operations;

b. Seek the assistance of LGU and higher police for logistical requirements
not available in CPO;

c. Perform other tasks as directed.

5. PCR Section:

a. Conduct seminars or provide information through leaflets to barangay

residents the things to be done in case of disaster;

b. Provide proper information to the relatives of the victims and the public
in general;

c. Give advisory about the incident;

d. Perform other tasks as directed.

6. Investigation Section:

a. Conduct investigation of cases relative to the disaster.

b. Perform other tasks as directed.

7. PCMG:

a. Provide personnel for evacuation and rescue operations;

b. Secure places of evacuation and the affected building;

c. Perform other tasks as directed.

8. Precincts:

a. Provide assistance to NCPO in terms of personnel and equipment;

b. Assist in evacuation and rescue operations.

c. Perform other tasks as directed.

C. Coordinating Instructions:

1. Lateral coordination with CDCC/AFP and other agencies is highly

encouraged;

2. Prime and foremost the safety of lives and properties is paramount;

3. Strict adherence to Rules of PNP Operational Procedures shall be

adopted in any given situation.

4. Radio discipline shall be observed at all times.

IV. ADMINISTRATIVE AND LOGISTICS:

1. One (1) basic load per weapon.

2. Evacuation – Bicol Medical Center, Naga City Hospital or the nearest

government of private hospitals.
 3. Logistical requirements beyond the capability of this Station shall be
coursed through to the LGU and higher police offices.

V – COMMAND AND SIGNAL:

1. Signal: Current CEIO/Call words in effect.

2. Command Post: Naga City Police Central Station

Temporary Command Post: At any designated place

Acknowledge:

SISON
Pol Sr Supt

Official:

PSI NICASIO LANITE GARCIA

Chief, Operations and Plan Section

Annexes: Distribution:
“A” – Task Organization - A – All Units, CPO
“B” – Map of Naga City - B – Chief of Police
“C” – Detail of Personnel - C - File
“D” – Radio Net
Appendix “M” – Sample Format of Sworn Statement (Question and Answer)

MALAYA AT KUSANG LOOB NA SALAYSAY NI (Name and address of the Affiant) NA

IBINIGAY SA PAGSISIYASAT NI (Name of the Investigator), DITO SA TANGGAPAN
NG Name and address of the Office, NGAYON IKA – (Month, Date and Year), SA
GANAP NA IKA – (Time) NG UMAGA/HAPON/GABI, SA HARAP NINA (Name of
Witnesses at least 2), SA PAMAMAGITAN NG MGA TANONG AT SAGOT.

===================================================================

(Ang nagsasalaysay ay pinahiwatigan o pinaalalahanan ng lahat ng kanyang mga

karapatan alinsiunod sa itinadhanana ng ating Bagong Saligang Batas).

MGA TANONGA AT SAGOT

01. Tanong Ginoong/Ginang , ikaw ba ay magsasabi ng boung

katotohanan at pawing katotohanan lamang sa
pagsisiyasat na
Ito?
Sagot

02. Tanong Ikaw ba ay handang magbigay ng iyong Malaya at kusang loob

na salaysay?
Sagot

03. Tanong Maari mo bang sabihin sa pagsisiyasat na ito ang iyong tunay
na pangalan at iba pang mapagkakakilanlan sa iyong
tunay na pagkatao?
Sagot

04. Tanong Ano naman and dahilan at ikaw ay naririto sa aming tanggapan
at nagbibigay ng iyong malaya at kusang loob na salaysay?
Sagot

05. Tanong Saan at kalian nangyari ang naturang insidente?

Sagot

06. Tanong Sino ang may kinalaman sa naganap na ?

Sagot

07. Tanong Paano naman nangyari ang ?

08. Tanong Kilala mo ba itong biktima?
Sagot

09. Tanong Sa ikaliliwanag ng pagsisiyasat na ito, maaari mo bang isalaysay

o sabihin kung ano ang tunay na nagyayari sa naganap na ?
Sagot

10. Tanong Sa iyong pagkakaalam, ilan sa mga ang may mga dalag baril
at anu-anu ang mga kalibre nito?
Sagot

11. Tanong Bukod sayo, may alam ka bang mga taong nakakita sa naturang
pangyayari?
Sagot

12. Tanong Ano naman ang iyong ginawa matapos mong masaksihan ang
naturang pangyayari?
Sagot

13. Tanong Kung muli mo silang makikita at makaharap, makikilala mo ba

ang mga ito?
Sagot

14. Tanong Pansamantala ay wala na akong itatanong saiyo, mayroon

kabang ibang ibig idagdag o bawasin sa salaysay mong
ito?
Sagot

15. Tanong Ikaw ba ay tinakot, pinangakuan, o binigyan ng pabuya sa

pagbibigay mo ng salaysay na ito?
Sagot

16. Tanong Handa mo bang lagdaan ang salaysay mong ito na binubuo ng
(bilang ng pahina) pahina?

WAKAS NG SALAYSAY: (Date and Time)

Nagsalaysay
SUBSCRIBE AND SWORN TO before me this (DATE) at (PLACE)

Administering Officer

CERTIFICATION

I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I have personally examined the herein affiant under
oath and that I am fully satisfied that he/she voluntarily executed and understood
his/her statement.

Administering Officer
Appendix “M.1” – Sample Format of Sworn Statement (Narrative)

Republika ng Pilipinas)
Lungsod ng Quezon. .) S.S
x- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - x

SINUMPAANG SALAYSAY

Ako, si , Filipino, taong gulang,

walang asawa/may asawa, naninirahan sa ,
matapos na makapanumpa nang naaayon sa saligang batas ng Pilipinas ay
nagsasaad ng mga sumusunod:

Na, noong , isang nagngangalang na

taga at/o may Agency na
Na matatagpuan sa ay
nagpakilala sa akin na may kakayahan na mangalap ng mga manggagawa para sa
ibang bansa partikularmente sa bansang sa pamamagitan ng ;

Na ako, sa boung pagtitiwala ay nag – aplay sa taong naturan bilang isang

;

Na, ang taong nabanggit ay pinangakuan ako ng trabaho sa ibang bansa na

bilang kapalit ako ay pinagbibigay/pinagbabayad na aking naman
ibinigay/ibinayad ang mga sumusunod:

HALAGA/BAGAY PETSA LUGAR/TUMANGGAP

Na ang nasabing mga halaga/bagay ay tinanggap ni ,

at nagsabing tao ( ) NAGBIGAY ( ) HINDI NAGBIGAY ng kaukulang resibo;

Na sa kabuuan halaga ako ay nahingian at/o nagbigay ng pera sa taong

naturan na umabot sa halagang humigit kumulang sa ()
kasama na ang aking mga nagastos habang ako ay nag – aaplay ( ) hindi pa
kasama ang aking mga nagastos habang ako ay nag – aaplay sa kanya.
 Na, noon , ako ay lumuwas patungong Maynila sakay ng at
ako ay dumiretso sa bahay/agency na matatagpuan sa ;

Na, habang ako ay nag – aantay ng aking pag – alis, ako ay pansamantalang
pinatira ng taong naturan sa kanyang bahay na matatagpuan sa .
Ako tumuloy sa nasabing bahay sa loob ng . Habang ako ay
nanunuluyan sa nasabing bahay ako ay pinagbabayad ng halagang bawat
araw/buwan para sa aking pagkain at iba pang gastusin para sa aking
pansamantalang panunuliyan;

Na, habang ako ay pansamantalang nanunuluyan sa nasabing bahay, ako ay

kanyang pinagawa ng mga gawaing bahay tulad ng
Ito raw umanoy parte ng aking training bilang
isang ;

Na, ang taong nabanggit ( ) ay nabigo na maipadala ako sa ibang bansa ( )

ako’y nakaalis papunta sa nasabing bansa bilang isang upang
magtrabaho noong at bumalik noong sa kadahilanang
.

Na, ang taong nabanggit ay nabigo at/o ayaw ibalik ang aking pera/papeles
sa kabila ng aking paulit – ulit na kahilingan;

Na, aking natuklasan na ang taong naturan ay walang lisensya o karapatan

na mangalap at magpadala ng mga manggagawa sa ibang bansa;

Na, hanggang sa ngayon ang taong nabanggit ay pinapangakuan ako na

matutuloy nmaka – alis patungong ibang bansa at ako ay kanyang hinihingian ng
dagdag na bayad na nagkakahalaga sa kapalit ng aking diumano’y pag
– alis;

Na, ang taong naturan ay naninirahan at/o maaaring mapasabihan sa

.

Na, ginawa ko ang Sinumpaang Salaysay na ito upang ihabla si/sina

ng illegal recruitment at/o estafa at/o
Human Trafficking;
 Na, aking pinatutunayan na ako ay hindi naghain ng reklamong katulad nito
sa mga taong nabanggit sa iba pang ahensya o sangay ng pamahalaan maliban
dito.
BILANG PATUNAY, ako ay lumagda sa ibabaw ng aking pangalan ngayon ika
- ng , .

Lagda

SINUMPAAN AT PINATOTOHANAN sa harap ko ngayon ika ng ,

. Pinatutunayan ko na ang nagsalaysay ay aking nasiyasat at ako ay may
sapat na napaniniwala na siya ay kusa at malayang nagsalaysay.

Administering Officer
Appendix “M-2” – Affidavit

Republic of the Philippines)

City of Naga . . . . . . . . . . . . .) S.S.
X-------------------- x
AFFIDAVIT

I, Juanito Benito y de Guzman, 29 years old, single and a resident od No. 12 Sto Niño
Street, Brgy. Abella, Naga City, after having been duly sworn to in accordance with the law do
hereby depose and say:

That I know personally Benjamin Crisostomo y Clerigo because we are living in same
barangay and I am aware as well of his illegal drugs operations as he usually uses me as delivery
boy of illegal drugs to those wealthy buyers who are afraid of going to his residence;

That we usually repacked Methamphetamine Hydrochloride (shabu) into small plastic

bags for P500 pesos using a weighing scale in order to dispose them easily to small – time
buyers in the streets;

That aside from selling shabu, he also allows some persons to use his bedrooms for pot
sessions because he is complete with illegal drugs accessories/paraphernalia such as aluminum
foils, disposable lighters, candles, forceps, scissors, and tooter;

That some of his illegal drugs are placed under the cushion sofa in the receiving room
while others are placed in a bottle of bread spread inside the hanging cabinet in the kitchen.

That on June 2, 2008, I decided to end this illegal activities by reporting it to PSINSP
NICASIO L GARCIA, because I cannot bear anymore the consequences our family had suffered
when one of my brothers became heavily addicted that resulted to his confinement at mental
hospital;

That I am executing this affidavit to attest the veracity of the facts herein declared to the
best of my knowledge and belief.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand this day of June 2008, City of
Naga, Philippines.

Juanito G Benito
Affiant

SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN to before me this day of June 2008, at Naga City,
Philippines.

DIOSDADO G. MACALINTAL
Presiding Judge