KNIVES OUT Plot M Questions1
KNIVES OUT Plot M Questions1
KNIVES OUT Plot M Questions1
The family of Harlan Thrombey, a wealthy mystery novelist, attends his 85th birthday party at
his Massachusetts mansion. The next morning, Harlan's housekeeper, Fran, finds him dead
with his throat slit. The police believe Harlan's death to be suicide, but private detective Benoit
Blanc is anonymously paid to investigate. Blanc learns Harlan's relationships with his various
family members were strained: on the day of his death, Harlan threatened to expose his son-
in-law Richard for cheating on his daughter Linda; cut off his daughter-in-law Joni's allowance
for stealing from him; fired his son Walt from his publishing company; and had an altercation
with his grandson Ransom.
Unknown to Blanc, Harlan's nurse, Marta Cabrera, accidentally mixed up his medications; she
apparently overdosed him with morphine and could not find the antidote, leaving Harlan only
minutes to live. Wanting to save Marta's family from scrutiny (her mother is an undocumented
immigrant), Harlan gave her instructions to create a false alibi, then slit his own throat.
Harlan's very elderly mother saw Marta carrying out his instructions, but mistook her for
Ransom. Marta cannot lie without vomiting, so she gives true but incomplete answers when
questioned. She agrees to assist in Blanc's investigation, and conceals evidence of her actions
as they search the property. When Harlan's will is read, to everyone's shock, Marta is the sole
beneficiary. Ransom helps her escape the family's wrath, but manipulates her into confessing
to him; he offers his help in exchange for a share of the inheritance. The other Thrombeys try
to persuade Marta to renounce the inheritance; Walt threatens to expose her mother's
immigration status.
Marta receives a blackmail note with a partial photocopy of Harlan's toxicology report. She and
Ransom drive to the medical examiner's office, but it has burned down. Marta receives an
email proposing a rendezvous with the blackmailer. Blanc and the police spot them, and, after
a brief car chase, Ransom is arrested; Blanc explains Harlan's mother saw Ransom climbing
down from Harlan's room the night he died. At the rendezvous, Marta finds Fran, drugged. She
performs CPR and calls an ambulance. She confesses to Blanc, though Ransom has already
informed on her, and decides to tell the family she caused Harlan's death, which would
invalidate the will under the slayer rule. At the house, she finds a copy of the full toxicology
report in Fran's cannabis stash. She gives it to Blanc without reading it herself. Reading it, Blanc
sees it showed little morphine in Harlan's system, and interrupts Marta before she can confess.