Review de Walter Cahn

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 2
 
7?<
 Tovcows
BVVB \IK@V,
 Dbba Ceeujchitcbh ch t`o Jcffeo Igos= Ih Chtrbfuktcbh
Vrihs. Aiy Fivoh-
pbrt. \roniko
 dy
 M. M. G. Ieoxihfor. Ebhfbh= @irvoy Jceeor1 How Sbra ihf Bxnbrf=Bxnbrf _hcvorscty \ross, 930>. \p. 44;1 ;4 kbebr peitos, 49< deika-ihf-w`cto ceeus-tritcbhs. Brcgchieey pudecs`of ch Gorjih dy \rostoe ch Juhck`, 9306.Ch `cs chtrbfuktcbh tb t`cs ittriktcvo vbeujo, t`o iut`br rojiras t`it furchg `csstufoht fiys, ch t`o oirey fokifos bn t`cs kohtury, t`o stufy bn jihuskrcpt ceeujchitcbhwis gohorieey rogirfof is i jchbr drihk` bn sk`beirs`cp priktckof dy t`o ikifojckieeyuhijdctcbus ihf wis bntoh kirrcof bh is i joro ifmuhkt tb t`o chvostcgitcbh bn t`ojbro nivbrof jbhujohtie irts. V`it t`cs wbuef `irfey do i nicr mufgjoht hbw csfuo ch hb sjiee pirt tb \ik`t's bwh nuhfijohtie kbhtrcdutcbhs tb t`cs kiuso, bn w`ck`i ecst bn wrctchgs chkeufof it t`o ohf bn t`o vbeujo, spihhchg t`o yoirs nrbj 93;0 tb
930;,
 prbvcfos ih bvorvcow (pp. 49;‖96). V`o dbba `oro rovcowof cs foskrcdof is t`orokbrf bn i sorcos bn eokturos foecvorof it t`o _hcvorscty bn ^cohhi ch t`o wchtor torj93>7‖>0, nbr w`ck` hbtos ihf i sujjiry dcdecbgrip`y `ivo dooh prbvcfof dy t`oofctbrs bn t`o brcgchie Gorjih ofctcbh, pudecs`of ch 9306. Dut cts ipprbik` ihfchscg`ts `ivo juk` befor rbbts, ihf w`it wo iro bnnorof jcg`t do sicf tb kbhstctutoi achf bn fcstceeitcbh bn i ecnotcjo's wbra ch t`o ncoef bn jihuskrcpt stufcos.
Dbba Ceeujchitcbh
 ch
 t`o
 Jcffeo gos
 kbhscsts bn ih chtrbfuktcbh ihf sovoh k`iptors,w`ck` iro ohtcteof is nbeebws= \cktbrcie Fokbritcbh ch t`o Brgihck [trukturo bn t`oDbba, V`o Chctcie, Dcdeo Ceeustritcbh, Fcfiktck Jchcituros, Ceeustritcbh bn t`oIpbkieypso, Ceeustritcbh bn t`o \sietor, ihf V`o Kbhneckt bn [urniko ihf [piko=Ih Bhgbchg \rbkoss. Is doncts i toxt kbhkocvof is i gohorie chctcitcbh, t`o iut`brrihgos nir ihf wcfo, t`bug` `o fbos hbt foie it iee wct` ispokts bn jofcovie dbbaceeujchitcbh t`it bho jcg`t woee oxpokt tb do troitof ch i wbra bn t`cs achf= t`oceeustritcbh bn vorhikueir ectorituro bn t`o `cg` ihf eitor Jcffeo Igos, nbr oxijpeo,ihf t`o ceeujchitcbh bn jusck jihuskrcpts br bn eogie ihf skcohtcnck wrctchgs. Dut cts`buef do sicf t`it \ik`t's chtohtcbh cs hbt sb juk` tb prbvcfo i kbjpro`ohscvo ihfnicr-jchfof niktuie survoy t`ih tb ohuhkcito disck prchkcpeos. @o cs porsuifof t`itt`o prbfuktcbh bn ih ceeujchitof dbba gohoritos nbrjie ihf strukturie kbhkorhs t`itiro uhcquoey k`iriktorcstck bn ih chtorpeiy bn skrcpt, fokbritcbh, ihf pckturo (p.6?) ihf t`oronbro kihhbt do prbporey uhforstbbf cn mufgof wct`ch i nrijo bn ronor-ohko ippeckideo tb bt`or irtcstck gohros. Is Mbhit`ih Ieoxihfor mustey bdsorvos ch `csproniko tb t`o prosoht vbeujo, t`o achf bn p`ohbjohbebgy bn t`o fokbritof dbbat`it \ik`t t`us sbug`t tb kbhstrukt cs rbbtof ch kbhkorhs bn t`o ^cohhi [k`bbe ihfducefs bh t`o wbra bn scghcnckiht oirecor ncguros bn t`it chtoeeoktuie sp`oro, hbtideyNrihz Wcka`bnn ihf Iebcs Tcoge.\ik`t's chtorost ch t`o ihieyscs bn prbdeojs t`it kbuef do rogirfof is chtrchsck tbdbba ceeujchitcbh cs drceecihtey fcspeiyof ch t`oso eokturos. @o `is vieuideo t`chgs tbsiy idbut t`o quostcbh bn hirritcvo tok`hcquo ch dbbas, ih cssuo tb w`ck` `o `ifoirecor fovbtof i pcbhoorchg stufy. V`o `cstbry ihf porjutitcbhs bn t`o chctcie, chw`ck` idstrikt scgh ihf pcktbrcie jbtcn kbhvorgo, rokocvo ih idsbrdchg fcskusscbh.V`oso iro, bn kburso, hbw nijcecir tbpcks. Dut bt`ors, bh w`ck` t`o sijo ikuto nbrjieporkoptcbhs iro drbug`t tb doir, iro oxpebritbry nbriys ch t`o ^cohhoso styeo t`it`ivo hbt yot `if t`o sijo ittohtcbh nrbj stufohts, hbw, bh t`o w`beo, friwh tbfcnnoroht achfs bn cssuos. C t`cha ch pirtckueir bn t`o iut`br's rojiras bh t`o rbeo bnt`o nrijo ch oirey-jofcovie ceeujchitcbh ihf bh fcnnoroht ipprbik`os tb surnikopittorh (pp. 977 nn.). \ik`t's irt `cstbry cs eirgoey fcroktof dy cjjihoht niktbrs ihftohfohkcos. Oik` typo bn 'dbba,' `o k`iriktorcstckieey wrctos, ippoirs tb kiee nbrt`nrbj wct`ch hbt bhey pcktbrcie nbrjits suctideo tb cts sbeo hoofs iebho dut iesb i systojbn fokbritcbh kbhgohcie sbeoey tb ctsoen ... (p. 4?). V`o idsohko bn `ujih igohts,
5
 
Tovcows
 7?9
br bn i keoirey foechoitof sbkcie sottchg ch w`ck` t`o nbrjie trihsiktcbhs drbug`t tbecg`t dy t`o iut`br's pichstiachg ihieyscs jcg`t do grbuhfof, jiy strcao sbjo roiforsis i s`brtkbjchg bn `cs jot`bf. Dut it i tcjo w`oh dbba ceeujchitcbh jiy do stufcofis p`cebebgy, is sbkcie `cstbry, br is ectoriry krctckcsj, i fonohso bn cts keicjs is irt `isjuk` tb rokbjjohf ct.\ik`t's dbba `is dooh `ihfsbjoey prbfukof ch i nbrjit cfohtckie tb t`o Gorjihofctcbh. Dut i hujdor bn orrbrs, sbjo bn t`oj kirrcof bvor nrbj t`o Gorjih toxt,bug`t tb do kbrroktof ch ihy nuturo ropudeckitcbh. W`oh t`o iut`br johtcbhs t`obwhors`cp dy K`rcstcih kbjjuhctcos bn kbfckos bh pipor is oirey is t`o sokbhfkohtury, `o suroey joiht tb wrcto pipyrus (p. 96). V`o fcskusscbh kbhkorhchg t`obrcgch bn zbbjbrp`ck chctcies jystorcbusey ieeufos tb oxijpeos ch @odrow jihuskrcptst`it iro sicf tb do juk` befor t`ih t`o toht` kohtury, dut t`o dbbas kctof ch t`oikkbjpihychg hbto iro i gbbf foie eitor ch fito (p. ?<). V`o kipctie roprbfukof bhpigo 06 (ncg. 990) stojs nrbj t`o kebcstor bn Ei Fiurifo ch Vbuebuso ihf cs prosorvofch t`o Jusoo fos Iugustchs. V`o prbvohihko bn t`o Jbsih (2) jihuskrcpt bn @bhbrcusIugustbfuhohscs's
 Keivcs p`ysckio
 (\ircs, Dcdecbt`oquo Hitcbhieo, J[ eit. >7;6), gcvohis Jck`oesdorg ch Nrihkbhci, s`buef do stitof ch jbro `ypbt`otckie nis`cbh (p. 9?0),ihf t`o brcgch bn t`o Chgodbrg \sietor, sicf tb `ivo dooh ceeujchitof it Vburhic (pp.36-3?), rojichs ih bpoh quostcbh. V`o tcteo bn t`o [wofcs` ox`cdctcbh kitiebguo
Gyeeoho Dbbaor
 `is dooh trihsjbgrcncof chtb ih iut`br's hijo (p. 4<6, h. ;;).
WIEVOT KI@H
Sieo _hcvorscty
EOO
 \IVVOT[BH,
 Hogbtcitchg t`o \ist= V`o @cstbrckie _hforstihfchg bn Jofcovie Ectorituro
Jifcsbh, Wcso= _hcvorscty bn Wcskbhsch \ross, 9307. \p. xcv, 4;3. $;? (kebt`)1$9?.3? (pipor).@bw kih wo gohuchoey ahbw t`o pist ‖ spokcnckieey t`o ectorituro bn t`o pist2 Fb wohbt joroey prbmokt bur bwh bntoh uhkbhskcbus issujptcbhs upbh toxts bn uhkortichbhtbebgckie stitus2 W`it cs `cstbrckie kbhskcbushoss2 @is ct i `cstbry bn cts bwh2 Cs ctbdmoktcvoey pbsscdeo br foscrideo2 W`it cs t`o roeitcbh bn i toxt tb cts kbhtoxt, ihf w`it
cs
 cts kbhtoxt2 Kih wo kbhstrukt ih ikkurito toxt but bn ih bdskurchg kebuf bn wcthossosw`ck` cs ctsoen t`o toxt 2 @bw fb wo ebkito bursoevos `cstbrckieey, grihtof t`it iee burvieuos iro hbw roeitcvcstck, puroey kbhtchgoht, ihf wo bursoevos t`o prbfukt bn iprbdidey uhahbwideo `cstbry2 V`oso ihf i hujdor bn bt`or prbdeojs iro kbhnrbhtofdy Eoo \ittorsbh wct` i woiet` bn eoirhchg ihf bn spokcnck ectoriry chstihkos. @o oxkoesospokcieey ch oxtriktchg t`o uhforeychg frcnt br cjpueso bn kbjpeox krctckie nbrjuei-tcbhs ihf ittctufos. Ch iffctcbh `o issorts t`it iee ikifojck wbra cs pbectckie, t`bug``o cs viguo idbut t`o pbeckcos t`ojsoevos. V`oso kih do sujjof up is kbhsorvitcvo(dif) br `bstceo tb t`o fbjchitchg cfobebgy (gbbf).@o dogchs wct` i pohotritchg ikkbuht bn t`o jich stroijs bn K`iukor krctckcsj cht`o _hctof [titos ch t`o twohtcot` kohtury. Ncrst, `o soos drceeciht `cstbrckie sk`beirs`cpuhideo uetcjitoey tb kbhhokt wct` t`o chtorprotitcbh ihf oxpeihitcbh bn toxts, t`usrosuetchg ch i jcxturo bn `cstbrckie pbsctcvcsj ihf joro ipprokcitcbh. Ch roiktcbh `osoos t`o How Krctckcsj, disof bh i trihs`cstbrckie, bntoh i`cstbrckie ihieyscs bn t`o toxtbh t`o pigo, kbhnrbhtchg Tbdortsbhcih Oxogoscs. Viedbt Fbhiefsbh's drceeciht wbra csbho roprosohtitcvo bn How Krctckcsj. Fbhiefsbh's ik`covojoht wis tb oxtohf t`ohchotooht`-kohtury hbtcbh t`it iutbhbjbus k`iriktor gohoritos spook` tb t`o w`beobn K`iukor's wrctchg, t`rbug` t`o fovcko bn t`o Hirritbr. V`cs frijitczos t`o pbotryihf bpohs i gip dotwooh Iut`br ihf Hirritbr w`ck` ieebws nbr t`o chsortcbh bn t`itchfcspohsideo How Krctckie tbbe, crbhy. K`ireos Juskitcho dy `cs kbhkopt bn t`o eirgoey
5

Reward Your Curiosity

Everything you want to read.
Anytime. Anywhere. Any device.
No Commitment. Cancel anytime.
576648e32a3d8b82ca71961b7a986505