Natwork Management Plan
Natwork Management Plan
Natwork Management Plan
------------------------
D Croft
Chief Executive
th
GD AS G6 003 (Rev. 0) 29 August 2003 – Network Management Plan
Page 1 of 13
Network Management Plan
Table of Contents
1. Introduction...................................................................................................................................... 3
2. Structure of Plan.............................................................................................................................. 3
5. Supplementary Information............................................................................................................ 7
5.1 Reference Maps for the Network .................................................................................................. 7
5.2 Design and Construction Standards ............................................................................................. 7
5.3 Maintenance Standards................................................................................................................ 8
5.4 Operation and Work Procedures .................................................................................................. 8
5.5 Safety Equipment Design, Use and Maintenance ........................................................................ 9
5.6 Description of Engineering Records and Drawings ...................................................................... 9
5.7 Emergencies ............................................................................................................................... 10
5.7.1 Operating Staff.............................................................................................................................. 10
5.7.2 General Emergency Plans............................................................................................................ 10
5.7.3 Testing of the Emergency Procedures ......................................................................................... 10
5.8 Measures to Prevent Hazards to Community and Environment ................................................ 11
5.9 Demand Management ................................................................................................................ 11
5.10 Jurisdictional Planning Requirements ........................................................................................ 12
5.11 Employee Competency System.................................................................................................. 12
5.12 Public Liability Insurance ............................................................................................................ 13
5.13 Superseding of Safety & Operating Plan.................................................................................... 13
6. Schedule of Reports...................................................................................................................... 13
th
GD AS G6 003 (Rev. 0) 29 August 2003 – Network Management Plan
Page 2 of 13
1. Introduction
This Network Management Plan has been prepared in accordance with the Electricity Supply (Safety and
Network Management) Regulation 2002. The object of the Plan is to ensure that TransGrid’s transmission
system provides accessible, efficient, safe and reliable facilities for the transmission of electricity, in an
environmentally and socially responsible manner.
The electricity industry in Australia has undergone significant change with the separation of generation,
transmission and distribution and the establishment of a national electricity market operator. These changes
have been accompanied by the introduction of a national electricity code for market participants and the
involvement of the Australian Consumer and Competition Commission in the setting of income and service
standards for transmission network service providers such as TransGrid.
At State level there has been an increasing focus by shareholders and customers in the performance of
transmission and distribution companies and in particular on reliability and availability of supply. This has
been reinforced through the New South Wales Electricity Supply (Safety and Network Management)
Regulation 2002 that requires Network Operators to develop Network Management Plans and to report
annually on the performance of the network.
Against this backdrop TransGrid has developed this Plan, utilising existing and current corporate documents
and plans. The Plan provides a focus for ongoing analysis within TransGrid and at continually improving the
management of the transmission system. It also provides a formal method for information dissemination to
customers, shareholders and regulators.
TransGrid’s corporate objectives are achieved primarily through the strategies in this Plan. The Plan
describes the model TransGrid uses to manage and develop its assets and the asset management
strategies for network enhancement, maintenance and disposal. These strategies are integrated with non-
asset strategies such as human resources, finance, information technology and procurement.
In many cases and in particular where network additions or augmentation are involved the need for such
work is driven directly by customer needs and requirements. This Plan has been developed in parallel with
an annual planning review conducted by TransGrid as the Jurisdictional Planning Body for New South Wales
and therefore it will by necessity be a living document that will change in response to feedback from
customers and market participants.
2. Structure of Plan
The requirements of the Electricity Supply (Safety and Network Management) Regulation 2002 (the
Regulation) were, prior to this regulation, being met by TransGrid, with minor exceptions, via one major
document, the “Network Management Plan 2001 – 2006.” That document will be attached to this cover
document, and the whole shall constitute the Plan.
Section 4 of this document lists the scheduled requirements from the Regulation and indicates against each
the location of the applicable information.
Section 5 of this document provides the additional information that supplements that provided in the referred
document to meet the full requirements of the Regulation.
3. Referred Documents
3.1 Network Management Plan 2001-2006 (Referred to hereafter as NMP 01/06)
This NMP 01/06 specifically describes and details the planning and service delivery strategies and standards
and the resulting capital investment strategy.
It also details the asset management strategies including the various policies, strategies and standards. It
lists the programs for each of the asset categories detailing specific issues and the strategy for dealing with
the issues. It also details the different measures used to determine the performance of the assets including
technical performance assessments, quarterly asset performance reviews and benchmarking studies.
Asset disposal and waste strategies are also included in this document.
NMP 01/06 covers all assets comprising or relating to the network including:
• Transmission Lines and Cables including easements and access tracks
• Substations and Switching Stations including all associated plant
th
GD AS G6 003 (Rev. 0) 29 August 2003 – Network Management Plan
Page 3 of 13
• Protection, Metering and Communications equipment and associated facilities.
It does not cover non-network assets such as motor vehicles, furniture, non-system related land, buildings
and equipment (eg. corporate computers and business systems).
NMP 01/06 was prepared on the basis that it is an overview document that leads to the preparation of more
detailed working documents identified in the Network Management Process. These include the Annual
Planning Statement, the Asset Management Strategies, the Maintenance Policies and the CAPEX and
MOPEX Resource Plan.
NMP 01/06 includes a Network Management Model which provides a framework for the strategic planning
and management of TransGrid’s physical asset resources and is based on the New South Wales
Government’s Total Asset Management (TAM) Model. The model shows the direct linkages between
TransGrid’s Corporate Plan and its Service Delivery Strategies to the Network Management Plan.
NMP 01/06 also includes details and references to management support systems such as the Quality
System, the Health and Safety Management System, the Environmental Management System and the
Emergency Management System.
6 (2) (a) A commitment by the network operator to ensuring the safe Part 2.2 of NMP
operation of its transmission system, and to giving safety the 01/06
highest priority over all other aspects of network management
6 (2) (b) A description of the transmission system and its design, NMP 01/06 pp7 & 8
construction, operation and maintenance and Part 4.2. Part
5.1-5.6 of this
document
6 (2) (c) A description of the planning process employed for the purpose of Parts 3.1 & 3.2 of
assessing the adequacy of the transmission system and the need NMP 01/06
for development of the transmission system, including if
appropriate:
(ii) system reliability planning standards on a customer class or Part 3.2.8 of NMP
group, or geographical basis, for each distinct voltage level 01/06 and Part 5.10
of this document
6 (2) (d) A description of the asset management strategies employed for the Part 4.2 of NMP
purposes of the design, construction, operation and maintenance of 01/06; Part 5.2 of
the transmission system, including: this document
th
GD AS G6 003 (Rev. 0) 29 August 2003 – Network Management Plan
Page 4 of 13
Regulation Description Location in Plan
Reference
(i) risk management and public liability insurance arrangements Part 4.2.1 (6) of
NMP 01/06
(ii) planned customer technical service standards for quality and Part 3.3 of NMP
reliability of supply 01/06
6 (2) (e) A description of the safety management strategy employed for the Part 2.2 of NMP
purpose of ensuring the safe operation of the transmission system, 01/06
including:
(ii) the procedures to be implemented in the event of an emergency Part 2.2.9 of NMP
01/06 and Part 5.7
of this document
(iii) the procedures and standards designed to ensure that the Part 5.11 of this
network operator’s employees, contractors to the network document
operator and their employees and any other persons working on
or near the system’s electricity works have the competencies
required to undertake the work safely
(iv) a strategy to ensure adherence to safe working procedures Part 2.2.7 of NMP
01/06
6 (2) (f) A description of the plan’s objectives and of appropriate Part 1 of this
performance indicators document & Part
3.3 of NMP 01/06
6 (2) (g) A schedule of reports to be made to the Director-General in relation Part 6 of this
to the management and performance of the transmission system document
6 (2) (h) A description of the codes, standards and guidelines that the Part 5.2-5.4 of this
network operator intends to follow in the design, installation, document
operation and maintenance of the transmission system
(a) References to maps showing the location of the system’s Part 5.1 of this
electricity works and the procedures for gaining access to those document
maps
(b) Design and construction standards and procedures for the Part 5.2 of this
system’s electricity works document
th
GD AS G6 003 (Rev. 0) 29 August 2003 – Network Management Plan
Page 5 of 13
Regulation Description Location in Plan
Reference
(d) Technical customer service standards for quality and reliability Part 3.3 of NMP
of supply 01/06
(e) Maintenance standards and procedures for the system’s Part 5.3 of this
electricity works document
(f) Operation and work procedures for the system (including Part 5.4 of this
procedures for work on or near both de-energised and live document
electricity works)
(g) Safety equipment design, use and maintenance standards and Part 5.5 of this
procedures for the system document
(h) A description of the engineering records, drawings and maps Parts 5.1 and 5.6 of
that the network operator maintains on the system this document
(a) the process used for setting system reliability planning Part 3.1 & 3.2 of
standards and identifying development needs and demand NMP 01/06,
management opportunities TransGrid’s
Corporate Plan
2003/04 and Part
5.9 of this
document
(b) strategies for managing and complying with that process and Part 4.1 of NMP
those standards 01/06
(a) the process used for setting design, construction, operation and Parts 3.3 and 4.2 of
maintenance standards and customer technical service NMP 01/06. Part
standards for quality and reliability of supply 5.3 of this
document
b) strategies for managing and complying with that process and Part 4.2 of NMP
those standards. 01/06
th
GD AS G6 003 (Rev. 0) 29 August 2003 – Network Management Plan
Page 6 of 13
Regulation Description Location in Plan
Reference
(a) systematically identify hazardous events that might be expected Part 2.2.8 of NMP
to occur, and 01/06
(d) specify operational, maintenance and organisational safeguards As above and Part
intended to prevent those events from occurring or, should they 5.8 of this
occur, intended to protect operating personnel, plant, document
equipment, the community and the environment
(2) The operational and maintenance safeguards must include a Part 4.3.2 of NMP
maintenance schedule indicating, among other things, the type 01/06
and frequency of inspections and tests of the transmission
system (including checks on protection devices)
(3) In the case of new transmission systems, an analysis of Part 2.2.8 of NMP
hazardous events should also take into account hazardous 01/06
events occurring during construction
5. Emergencies:
(1) The types of emergencies in respect of which procedures are to Part 2.2.9 of NMP
be implemented include: 01/06 and Part 5.7
of this document
(a) fires, explosions and impacts (with particular reference to those
caused by the activities of other parties), and
5. Supplementary Information
5.1 Reference Maps for the Network
TransGrid has produced an Electricity Supply Network map showing locations of TransGrid Network assets.
This map is available for viewing on TransGrid’s website www.transgrid.com.au. The specific locations of
individual sites are detailed on registered drawings titled 'Site Location Plan' for that site. Access to these
drawings may be requested from the appropriate Regional offices.
th
GD AS G6 003 (Rev. 0) 29 August 2003 – Network Management Plan
Page 8 of 13
Operation Procedures are contained in System Operating Manuals:
• Cable fault alarms - OM 674
• Customer Switching - OM 907
• Emergency Ratings - Main Grid Circuit - OM 302
• Operating Procedures - OM 670
• Removal of Foreign Objects - OM 696
• Reports - HV forced and Emergency Outage Reports - OM 552
• Restoration of Transmission Circuits - OM 686
• System Separation - OM 670, OM 664
• Use of HV Switching Instructions - OM 978
These standards are located on TransNet, TransGrid’s intranet site, or in controlled local folders in the
relevant central or regional office.
In response to natural disasters and disturbances, the operator is required to contact the appropriate
emergency service organisation e.g. Fire Brigade etc. Resources available to Operating staff to address
these emergencies are:
(i) Operating manuals
(ii) Fire Protection Policies and Procedures Manual GD SA G2 001
(iii) Environmental Manual GD EN G2 002 and associated Emergency Response Manuals
(iv) An Emergency Register containing contact names and phone numbers of all relevant emergency
services, including Police, Fire, Ambulance, State Emergency Services, other utilities (Electricity, Water,
Gas) is kept in the Data Acquisition and Control system.
System Operating Manuals address:
Bushfires, floods, storms etc. - OM 686, OM 244
Communications breakdown with the System Control Centre - OM 667
Restart of System - OM 666, Area OM X066
System Control Centre - Emergency Procedures - OM 851
th
GD AS G6 003 (Rev. 0) 29 August 2003 – Network Management Plan
Page 10 of 13
5.8 Measures to Prevent Hazards to Community and Environment
In addition to the steps taken to identify hazardous events, their potential causes and consequences to staff
and contractors, TransGrid through its range of design standards, maintenance policies, plant refurbishment
and replacement strategies and operational work practices undertakes to address all foreseeable events
relating to plant and processes that may cause hazards to the environment and community.
These issues are generally addressed in the parts 5.2 to 5.4 of this document and the NMP 01/06.
Significant examples of these issues are:
(a) Analysis of environmental hazards is contained in TransGrid’s Environmental Management System (Part
2.3 of NMP 01/06) and its Environmental Manual (document GD EN G2 002). These include a
consideration of section 4.3.1 of ISO14001 for environmental aspects and impacts, and are summarised
in an Environmental Risk Register. Relevant substations, transmission line and environmental standards
address the issues raised in this process.
(b) The risks of bushfires associated with the management of transmission lines and their easements are
fully addressed in TransGrid’s Bushfire Risk Management Plan, a requirement of the Electricity Supply
Safety and Network Management) Regulation 2002.
(c) Transformer fires and oil spills are major potential hazards to the community and environment. Should
they happen, TransGrid maintains extensive safeguards to prevent these events from causing damage
to the environment or community.
TransGrid’s document GM EN G8 001 “Guide to Substation Oil Containment Design” sets out items to be
considered in the design of substations with regard to spill containment systems and other places where bulk
oil or liquid hazardous materials are kept.
Other substation and environmental standards, covered by 5.4 above, provide for the regular inspection of
plant oil containment systems and emergency oil spill control equipment. Emergency response to a
transformer fire, or fires of other causes, are managed by the process indicated in 5.7 above.
6. Schedule of Reports
TransGrid will, as required by notice in writing from the Director-General, lodge its Network Management
Plan with the Director-General within such period as may be specified in the notice, to meet the requirements
of Part 2 (Clause 5 [1a]), Part 2 (Clause 6), Part 4 (Clause 15) and Schedule 1 of the Electricity Supply
(Safety and Management) Regulation 2002.
TransGrid will, at times required by the Director-General, provide the Director-General with a report from a
nominated auditor to meet the requirements of Part 3 ( Clauses 10, 11, 12, 13 and 14) of the Regulation
2002.
TransGrid will measure its performance against the Network Management Plan and an annual report will be
provided to the Director-General as set out in Part 4 (Clause 16) of the Regulation 2002. The annual report
will be in the form of the Electricity Network Performance Report submitted annually to the Ministry.
TransGrid will publish its Electricity Network Performance Report in accordance with Part 4 (Clause 16 [2 &
3]).
th
GD AS G6 003 (Rev. 0) 29 August 2003 – Network Management Plan
Page 13 of 13
Network Management Plan 2001-2006
Network Management Plan 2001-2006
1
Contents
Introduction 4
About TransGrid 5
Objectives 6
Mission 6
Values 6
System Description 7
System Map 8
1.1 Introduction 11
1.4 Assets 12
2
Chapter 3: Planning and Service Delivery 25
Appendices 89
A Corporate Policies 91
Environment 92
Quality 93
B Asset Inventory 94
3
Introduction
The electricity industry in Australia has undergone significant change in the last five years with the separation of generation,
transmission and distribution and the establishment of a national electricity market operator. These changes have been accompanied
by the introduction of a national electricity code for market participants and the involvement of the Australian Consumer and
Competition Commission in the setting of income and service standards for transmission network service providers such as TransGrid.
At State level there has been an increasing focus by shareholders and customers in the performance of transmission and
distribution companies and in particular on reliability and availability of supply. This has been reinforced through the New South
Wales Electricity Supply (Safety Plans) Regulation that requires Network Operators to develop Network Management Plans and
to report annually on the performance of the network.
Against this backdrop TransGrid has reviewed and updated its 1998-2003 Network Management Plan to cover the five-year
financial period from 2001 to 2006 inclusive. The Plan provides a focus for ongoing analysis within TransGrid and at continually
improving the management of the transmission system. It also provides a formal method for information dissemination to
customers, shareholders and regulators.
TransGrid’s corporate objectives for electricity supply, safety, quality and the environment are achieved primarily through the
strategies in this Plan. The Plan describes the model TransGrid uses to manage and develop its assets and the asset
management strategies for network enhancement, maintenance and disposal. These strategies are integrated with non-asset
strategies such as human resources, finance, information technology and procurement.
In many cases and in particular where network additions or augmentations are involved the need for such work is driven directly
by customer needs and requirements. This Plan has been developed in parallel with an annual planning review conducted by
TransGrid as the Jurisdictional Planning Body for New South Wales and therefore it will by necessity be a living document that
will change in response to feedback from customers and market participants.
Feedback on this Network Management Plan in regards to either philosophy or detail is most welcome in order that TransGrid is
able to continue to adjust its strategies to meet customer and stakeholder requirements.
D G Croft
Chief Executive
4
A b o u t Tr a n s G r i d
5
A b o u t Tr a n s G r i d
Our Objectives
• To be commercially successful
Our Mission
Values
• Integrity
• Open Communication
• Recognition of contribution
• Competence
6
System Description
TransGrid is the owner, operator and manager of the high voltage transmission capability between generators, distributors and
directly connected end users in New South Wales as well as interconnections with Queensland and Victoria. The system is a
major part of one of the most extensive systems in the world comprising of 76 substations and power station switchyards and
over 12,000 kilometres of transmission lines.
The system, which has a replacement value of more than $4 billion, operates at voltage levels of 500, 330,220 and 132kV. The
substations are located on land owned by TransGrid and the transmission lines of steel tower, concrete or wood pole construction
are generally constructed on easements acquired across private or public land.
TransGrid has staff strategically based at locations throughout NSW in order to meet the day to day operation and maintenance
requirements as well as being able to provide emergency response. The main administrative office is located at the corner of
Park and Elizabeth Street Sydney. Field staff are co-ordinated from major depots located at Wallgrove in western Sydney and at
Newcastle, Tamworth, Orange, Wagga Wagga and Yass.
Lismore
Scale
Dumaresq Tenterfield
0 20 40 60 80 100 km
Moree
Inverell Koolkhan
Glen Innes
Narrabri
Coffs Harbour
Armidale
Keepit
Gunnedah
Tamworth Kempsey
Port Macquarie
Wallerawang Tuggerah
Panorama
A.N.M T1
T2
Albury
Snowy M1
Hume Mtns Cooma
Area M2 Snowy Adit
Munyang
Guthega
7
8
1 Network Management Plan Framework
9
1 Network Management Plan Framework
1.1 Introduction
1.4 Assets
10
1 Network Management Plan Framework
1.1 Introduction
In this latest Plan, TransGrid has moved from a pure asset management model to a broader model which it is believed more
accurately reflects the approach that is to be taken in order for a high voltage transmission network to achieve its objectives. The
intent is to recognise that in the high voltage electrical transmission business, planning of the network in relation to system
augmentations and capacity upgrades plays just as an important role as managing the existing assets.
It also ensures from an organisational perspective that there is a corporate approach towards service standards as distinct from a
pure engineering approach towards managing individual assets or groups of assets. For these reasons TransGrid is now
managing its assets within a broader framework known as the "Network Management Plan".
The Network Management Plan integrates service delivery, planning, capital investment, operations and maintenance,
replacement and disposal strategies. It is prepared to provide corporate direction to the organisation and to demonstrate
responsible management of TransGrid’s assets on behalf of its stakeholders and customers.
The Plan is TransGrid’s statement of the resources and programs required to ensure that:
Within this framework the objective of the Network Management Plan is to provide a systematic approach to planning and
managing assets thus ensuring that the condition and performance of the transmission and associated network assets is being
effectively monitored, maintained and developed to meet customer and stakeholder expectations.
The Plan has a time horizon of five years looking forward initially from the 2001 – 2002 financial year and includes some
tentative or long-term activities which extend beyond the five year planning horizon.
1.2 Customer, Stakeholders and Other Parties for which the Plan is prepared.
• TransGrid’s customers are electricity distributors, retailers, generators, transmission network operators and directly connected
end use customers.
• TransGrid aims to provide customers a safe, adequate and reliable transmission service and to deliver this over the long term,
at minimum cost.
• TransGrid’s stakeholder is the Government of NSW that wishes to ensure, as the ultimate owners of the assets, that their
financial capital is secure.
• Other Parties with a potential interest in this Plan include employees and contractors who physically work on the assets, the
members of the public through whose land the network is built, retailers and energy traders who use the network for trading
and any of the regulatory bodies with which TransGrid comes into contact.
The Plan specifically describes and details the planning and service delivery strategies and standards and the resulting capital
investment strategy.
It also details the asset management strategies including the various policies, strategies and standards. It lists the programs for
each of the asset categories detailing specific issues and the strategy for dealing with the issues. It also details the different
measures used to determine the performance of the assets including technical performance assessments, quarterly asset
performance reviews and benchmarking studies.
Asset disposal and waste strategies are also included in the most recent Network Management Plan.
11
1.4 Assets
The Plan covers all assets comprising or relating to the network including:
The Plan does not cover non-network assets such as motor vehicles, furniture and non-system related land.
• It is an overview document that leads to the preparation of more detailed working documents identified in the Network
Management Process. These include the Annual Planning Statement, Asset Management Strategies, Maintenance Policies and
capital and operating expenditure financial plans.
• It does not represent an authorisation to commit expenditure, nor does it represent a commitment on the part of TransGrid to
proceed with any specific projects or programs - authorisation of expenditure will result from approval of the Annual Budget by
the Board and from other specific expenditure, technical and environmental approvals.
The Model shown on the next page provides a framework for the strategic planning and management of TransGrid’s physical asset
resources and is based on the New South Wales Government’s Total Asset Management (TAM) Model.
The model shows the direct linkages between TransGrid’s Corporate Plan and the components that make up the Network
Management Plan.
12
1.7 Cost Base
The cost base for the Plan is based on Australian dollars as at 1st July 2001. To convert these figures to a projected actual
expenditure for any given year, factors such as CPI and foreign exchange rate movements will need to be considered.
Government Shareholder
Regulator,Customers,
TransGrid Board Community &
Market Participants
Acquire or Build
New Assets
Maintain,
Operate & Dispose
Refurbish of Surplus Assets
Existing Assets
Renew &
Adapt Assets
13
The following table illustrates the relationships and linkages between specific aspects of TransGrid’s Network Management Plan,
associated strategies and related performance indicators. Ultimately, TransGrid’s performance is judged against community,
customer and shareholder expectations and the key performance indicators shown below are the parameters by which this
performance could be assessed.
Output Performance Transgrid’s Customer Service Delivery Standards, Statutory and Business Requirements.
Planning and development processes. Asset management strategies. Asset equipment register to include
materials such as pcbs.
Consultation processes. Maintenance policies.
Key Activities Identification of surplus assets.
Construction of new assets. Outage planning and cordination.
Waste mangement strategies.
Condition monitoring.
Satisfy customer and system Routine maintenance achievement Develop and implement disposal plans
requirements incuding NEMMCO
Planned, forced and emergency Safe and cost effective disposal of
and ACCC.
outages (number and duration) surplus assets.
Network reliability and availability.
Key performance Network reliability and availability Safety & environmental incidents
14
2 Management Support Systems
15
2 Management Support Systems
16
2 Management Support Systems
The key deliverable for TransGrid is to manage its assets and resources in order to meet defined levels of performance in terms of
cost, reliability, availability and quality. However the achievement of these objectives will at all times be performed so as not to
compromise organisational commitments in regards to safety, the community and the environment.
In order to meet these requirements TransGrid’s management plans and strategies are underpinned by the inter-relationships
between TransGrid’s Quality, Safety, Environmental and Emergency Management Systems.
Despite the large geographical distances between the Network Regions and their assets, TransGrid ensures confidence in the
effective application of identical policies and practices across the network through maintaining its certification to AS/NZS
ISO9001 for Quality Management and AS/NZS ISO14001 for Environmental Management Systems. To achieve the maintenance
of both these certifications, TransGrid follows a 3 year cycle consisting of 6 monthly audits and a 3 yearly certification
assessment by an appropriate Certification Body.
The quality system lays the foundation for TransGrid to achieve its objectives. TransGrid’s Quality Policy is included in Appendix A.
TransGrid demonstrates its on-going commitment to quality through its compliance with, and continuing external certification to
ISO9001.
The Chief Executive is the ultimate authority for the Quality System within TransGrid, while direct overall responsibility is
delegated to the General Manager/Commercial & Financial Services, reporting directly to the Chief Executive. Policy decisions
regarding the implementation of a quality approach within TransGrid is determined by TransGrid Management.
Ensuring the flow through all levels of the organisation, Group and Region Managers have responsibility for the implementation
of quality practices within their Group or Region and the quality of products and services provided by contractors.
Further, Team Leaders at all levels are responsible for ensuring that those activities under their control are carried out in
accordance with established procedures.
As a consequence, TransGrid has confidence in the consistent application of quality procedures across its geographically diverse
workforce.
The back-bone of TransGrid’s Quality System is its hierarchy of documentation. This documentation, under regular review to
meet TransGrid’s ongoing business activities, ensures that all the requirements of the elements of ISO9001 are met. The
document hierarchy is as follows:
17
Quality Policy • a statement of TransGrid’s policy and objectives for quality
Project Specific Documents • includes Project Plans, Design Plans, Contract Project Plans.
• other documents for a specific project.
TransGrid’s quality approach provides its workforce with the tools and management support to:
• consistently deliver quality products and services which satisfy the customers’ needs;
• improve organisation performance and eliminate waste by reforming work processes;
• work towards continuous improvement on all fronts; and
• deliver the right result first time.
TransGrid's Health and Safety Policy, GD HS G1 001 (Appendix A) reflects the organisation’s commitment and underpins the
Health and Safety management system.
In addition to the Health and Safety Policy, TransGrid has developed a health and safety commitment and principles. They are as
follows:
18
2.2.3 OH&S Organisational Structure
The Board of TransGrid has the final responsibility for ensuring that the necessary resources and organisational procedures exist
throughout TransGrid. This responsibility is discharged through the Chief Executive and the Executive Occupational Health and
Safety Committee.
Safety policies and procedures are approved by the Chief Executive following review and recommendation by the Executive
Occupational Health and Safety Committee. The Executive Occupational Health and Safety Committee’s charter is the
development of corporate occupational health and safety policy and the promotion and monitoring of health and safety
performance within TransGrid. The committee's goal is the elimination of all workplace injuries and accidents.
The Executive Occupational Health and Safety Committee has a number of subcommittees that report to it. These committees are:
Each of TransGrid’s seven major sites has an established OHS committee. These committees meet every two/three months to
address local issues and discuss endorsed recommendations of the Executive OH&S committee. An integral part of TransGrid's
health and safety management system is the two yearly auditing of safety processes at each of our sites.
TransGrid’s Health and Safety Management System is detailed in the document GD HS G2 020. It outlines TransGrid’s
organisational structure, planning activities, responsibilities, practices, procedures, processes and resources for developing,
implementing, achieving, reviewing and maintaining health and safety systems.
The document provides guidance to managers, team leaders and employees for the effective implementation and maintenance of
health and safety systems and procedures in each of TransGrid’s Business Units.
TransGrid is required to report all fatal and non fatal accidents which involve electric shock, flash or burns or falls from elevated
positions associated with work on electrical apparatus as soon as practicable to the Director-General, Ministry of Energy and
Utilities.
TransGrid is also required to report to the Director-General, Ministry of Energy and Utilities any failure of equipment that could
have consequences regarding the safety of staff, contractors or the public.
All accidents and safety incidents are investigated to ascertain causes and develop corrective and preventive measures to
eliminate future occurrences. Any safety incident involving the general public is viewed as a most serious occurrence that
involves thorough investigation.
Occupational health and safety performance data is provided as required by the Electricity Supply (Safety Plans) Regulation, 1997
in the format of NSW Electricity Network Management Report.
TransGrid's health and safety performance measures together with the previous 5 year trend are included in the annual Electricity
Network Management Report provided to the Director-General.
19
2.2.6 Accident Statistics
TransGrid Staff:
Health and safety performance measures and statistics are recorded and maintained for employees in accordance with Australian
Standard AS 1885. The following safety related statistics are kept and reviewed monthly:
Contractors:
TransGrid requires contractors to provide TransGrid with all details of any accident/incident occurring during the performance of
the contract. In addition, TransGrid seeks periodic reports from contractors of the safety performance indicators as listed above.
A summary of Transgrid’s lost time injury frequency rate is shown in the table below.
Statistics are kept on public accidents and incidents and their causes together with prevention strategies.
Operating and work procedures are contained in TransGrid Safety Rules - GD SA G2 012 which detail the rules for safe work on
the transmission system, and System Control Operating Manuals which provide operation parameters for specific sites and
operating practices and requirements to facilitate safe switching operations.
Safety equipment design, care, use, maintenance and frequency of maintenance, used by TransGrid employees and contractors,
are detailed in TransGrid procedures:
As applicable, relevant Australian Standards and Codes of Practices are used in designing, selecting and maintaining equipment.
A range of Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) is used in TransGrid. PPE is selected with reference to relevant Australian
Standards and Codes of Practice and by consultation with employees in the field.
20
2.2.8 Analysis of Hazards
TransGrid has in place a system to identify hazards and assess the risk of those hazards prior to commencing work on or near
"electricity works". An analysis of hazards is carried out by TransGrid to ensure that protective and preventative measures have
been implemented or are in place and are being followed.
A detailed analysis of hazard types, potential causes, possible consequences and measures implemented to ensure a safe system
of work is provided as an Attachment to TransGrid’s Health and Safety System GD HS G2 020.
Management review and auditing of the work of staff and contractors is carried out to ensure that any new hazards are
appropriately identified and safe processes of work are implemented.
This hazard identification and risk assessment system is regularly audited to ensure compliance.
Major contractors to TransGrid are required to comply with the requirements of New South Wales Government OHS&R
Management Systems Guidelines and to abide by the Codes of Practice and relevant TransGrid Policies and Procedures. The
need to comply with relevant NSW Occupational Health and Safety Act and Regulations and environmental legislation is
included in all contracts and orders.
Contractors, their staff and agents are required to be inducted onto a site and sign a declaration acknowledging that they
have been advised of the relevant OH&S issues associated with the work to be undertaken.
TransGrid competes with external contractors for new construction work both within the organisation and in the external
market. As part of this process, TransGrid will submit an OHS Management Plan for all new contracts as part of the tender
documentation if required.
2.2.9 Emergencies
TransGrid's major Network Control Centres are staffed on a 24 hour basis. Operating staff at these centres are trained to operate
the system in a safe manner in response to emergency conditions of all types, including:
In response to natural disasters and disturbances, the operator is required to contact the appropriate emergency service
organisation e.g. Fire Brigade etc.
21
2.3 Environmental Management System.
TransGrid's Environmental Management System (EMS) is based on its Environmental Policy, a copy of which is in Appendix A.
It is the responsibility of all TransGrid staff to be active in the protection of the environment, to consult with the community as
appropriate and to undertake relevant training.
Regular environmental audits are carried out to ensure the compliance with TransGrid environmental policies and standards.
Reflecting its Policy, TransGrid has developed and implemented an EMS in accordance with the requirements of AS/NZS ISO
14001. TransGrid’s EMS was certified as complying with AS/NZS ISO 14001 in 1996.
The EMS is part of TransGrid's overall business management system. It is a framework within which specific procedures, objectives
and targets are developed, implemented, audited and reviewed. The EMS enables TransGrid to demonstrate its commitment to sound
environmental management, compliance with statutory requirements and to the principle of continual improvement.
The Board of TransGrid has the final responsibility for ensuring that the necessary resources and organisational procedures exist
throughout TransGrid. This responsibility is discharged through the Chief Executive and the Executive Environmental Committee.
Environmental policies and procedures are approved by the Chief Executive following review and recommendation by the
Executive Environmental Committee. The Executive Environmental Committee has as its purpose the development of corporate
environmental policy and the promotion and monitoring of environmental performance within TransGrid.
An integral part of TransGrid's environmental system is the two yearly auditing of related processes at each of our sites.
22
2.3.5 Elements of ISO 14001 and TransGrid’s EMS
The aim of an EMS is to effectively manage the environmental aspects of an organisation’s operations, to ensure minimum
environmental impact.
AS/NZS ISO 14001 "Environmental Management Systems – Specification with guidance for use" describes seventeen elements
that are required in an EMS which are intended to lead to continual improvement in performance. These elements are:
1. Environment Policy
2. Environmental Planning – Aspects and Impacts
3. Environmental Planning - Legal and Other Requirements
4. Environmental Planning - Objectives and Targets
5. Environmental Planning - Environmental Management Program
6. Implementation and Operation - Structure and Responsibilities
7. Implementation and Operation - Training, Awareness and Competence
8. Implementation and Operation – Communication
9. Implementation and Operation - EMS documentation
10. Implementation and Operation - Document control
11. Implementation and Operation - Operational control
12. Implementation and Operation - Emergency Preparedness and Response
13. Checking and Corrective Action - Monitoring and measurement
14. Checking and Corrective Action - Nonconformance and corrective and preventive action
15. Checking and Corrective Action – Records
16. Checking and Corrective Action - Environmental management system audit
17. Management review
TransGrid, in its Environmental Plan GD EN G2 007 sets out its response to each of these seventeen elements of ISO 14001
and also the Business Units responsible for those elements.
23
2.4 Emergency Management System
TransGrid has developed a Corporate Emergency Management Plan (CEMP) to co-ordinate the management measures necessary to
ensure a state of preparedness for emergencies which may impact upon reliability of supply, the safety of staff, members of the public
or the environment. The CEMP is also required to respond to emergencies declared under the NSW State Disaster Plan (Displan).
The CEMP categorises the various levels of emergency and details the specific command structures and responsibilities
associated with each.
Each of TransGrid's Regions have similar Emergency Response Plans detailing the local command structures and
responsibilities. These Plans are tested annually with a simulated emergency carried out in conjunction with other organisations
to ensure they are effective in handling a range of situations.
All the above mentioned plans are reviewed following any significant emergency to ensure that they were applied, that they
worked effectively and noting any areas requiring amendment.
Site Emergency Response Plans are also developed which detail site evacuations and emergency procedures. These plans
comply with Australian Standard - AS 2.5745 Emergency Control Organisation and Procedures for Buildings.
These plans detail the site emergency control personnel, evacuation measures including annual training exercises, debrief session
and the testing of alarms. All visitors to sites are advised of the existence of these procedures as part of their site induction.
24
3 Planning and Service Delivery
25
3 Planning and Service Delivery
26
3 Planning and Service Delivery
The understanding of stakeholder, customers, regulators, market participants and the community is essential in developing a
corporate plan and in turn enabling TransGrid to define the appropriate planning methodology and service standards.
As mentioned in the Introduction there has been an increasing concern by shareholders and customers in the performance of utilities
in terms of service standards, safety and the environment. For TransGrid, as a State owned corporation and a regulated monopoly
provider of transmission services, there is also a range of Acts, Regulations and Codes that impact upon network planning and
therefore service delivery. TransGrid's customers are also able to input into the planning process and to have a direct involvement in
the determination of service standards through regulatory, consultative and Connection Agreement processes.
TransGrid's planning process is subject to several external agencies, that determine the regulatory and planning processes. Consequently
the delivery of service standards is dependent on the planning process as well as the service standards themselves. By way of comparison,
in a competitive environment, service standards or service performance would normally drive planning and capital investment.
Within the National Electricity Market framework, TransGrid’s regulator, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission
and the National Electricity Code have prescribed a set of service standards that are consistent with past practice and
international benchmarked best practice.
Despite not having primary control over the planning process, TransGrid has agreed with its regulator, the Australian Competition and
Consumer Commission, to a set of service standards that are consistent with past practice and international benchmarked best practice.
3.2.1 Objectives
Planning and development of TransGrid’s network is undertaken in accordance with the National Electricity Code. The Code sets
out processes that require TransGrid to consult with Code Participants and interested parties on development options (which
must include consideration of demand side management and local generation options) and apply the ACCC's Regulatory Test to
determine the most economic option.
The Code also specifies performance requirements of the network that form part of TransGrid's service standards.
The main activities that support planning and development of the network include:
• Load forecasting;
• Identification of network constraints;
• Justification and regulatory assessment of development options;
• Joint Planning with electricity distributors and other major customers;
• Annual Planning Review for New South Wales; and
• Input to capital works budget.
27
3.2.3 Load Forecasts
A major input to planning is the forecast of electricity demand and energy consumption.
The overall State demand and energy forecast is developed based on historical demands, economic and demographic scenarios
and temperature variables. The economic scenarios are provided by NEMMCO to all jurisdictions to ensure a common basis for
these forecasts. The State forecast is produced each year in time for inclusion in NEMMCO's annual Statement of Opportunities.
To cater for regional and local needs, a forecast of the demand at each supply point is developed based on forecasts supplied by
the electricity Distributors and major customers. These forecasts thus take account of demand management programs in place or
foreseen by Distributors. Account is taken of load diversity between connection points. The forecasts generally cover both
summer and winter demands and extend over a planning horizon of ten years.
To analyse conditions on the main network a forecast is developed which aligns the local and overall state forecasts to provide a range
of forecast demands at each substation, for both winter and summer. The aligned forecasts apply under the following conditions:
An emerging constraint may be identified during various planning activities such as:
• Connection enquiries
• ongoing network analysis of present and future performance and related activities;
• joint planning with Distributors;
• the impact of prospective generation developments;
• the impact of network developments undertaken by other TNSP's; or
• as a result of a major load development.
Connection enquiries and the formulation of draft connection agreements lead to a preliminary review of the capability of
connections. Further discussions are held with specific customers where there is a need for augmentation or for provision of
new connection points.
The main 500 kV, 330 kV and 220 kV transmission system is developed in response to the overall load growth and generation
requirements and may be influenced by interstate interconnection power transfers. Development includes negotiation with
affected NSW and interstate parties.
2. Inter-regional Planning
The development of interconnectors between regions, and of augmentations within regions that have a material effect on inter-
regional power transfer capability are coordinated, under the National Electricity Code, by the Inter-regional Planning Committee
28
convened by NEMMCO. Network Service Providers may also apply to NEMMCO for interconnection works to be price-regulated.
The IRPC conducts an annual planning review of the inter-regional networks, and assists NEMMCO in assembling the annual
Statement of Opportunities. This document identifies actual and potential constraints on the networks that may be addressed by
transmission augmentations, generation developments or demand management developments. A timetable for addressing inter-
regional constraints follows from this work.
During the initial planning phase a number of options for addressing constraints are developed. In accordance with Code
requirements consultation with interested parties is carried out to determine a range of options including network, local
generation and DSM options and/or refine existing options.
A cost effectiveness analysis is carried out in which the costs and benefits of each option are compared in accordance with the
ACCC's Regulatory Test. In applying this test the cost/benefit factors may include:
• avoiding unserved energy caused by either a generation shortfall or inadequate transmission capability or reliability;
• loss reductions;
• alleviating constraints affecting generation dispatch;
• avoiding the need for generation development;
• fuel cost savings;
• improvement in marginal loss factors;
• deferral of related transmission works; and
• reduction in operation and maintenance costs.
Options with similar Net Present Value would be assessed with respect to factors that may not be able to be quantified and/or
included in the Regulatory Test, but nonetheless may be important from environmental or operational viewpoints, such as:
TransGrid conducts both regular (at least annually) and ad-hoc joint planning activities with all of its major customers, including
Distributors, and requires each Distributor to provide a load forecast covering its franchise service area in time for preparation of
the Annual Planning Statement.
The purpose of these activities is to identify emerging network constraints at points of connection between TransGrid's and the
Distributors' networks and to identify optimum solutions.
The New South Wales Minister for Energy requires that TransGrid, as the Jurisdictional Planning Body for New South Wales,
carry out an Annual Planning Review for New South Wales. The purpose of the Review is to focus on an optimum level of
transmission investment by encouraging interested parties to propose options for the relief of transmission constraints that may
involve components of local generation and DSM. The Review includes a public forum at which the Annual Planning Statement
for New South Wales is presented and discussed.
The first Annual Planning Review was held during 2000 and the Review for 2001 is in progress.
29
3.2.8 Transmission Planning Criteria
3.2.8.1 General
TransGrid's approach to network planning has been formulated to achieve appropriate reliability standards satisfying Code
obligations and Connection Agreement obligations while meeting supply requirements at optimum costs. It is consistent with
both the National Electricity Code (the Code) and its customer service obligations.
In particular, the reliability criteria applied to planning ensure that, for credible system contingencies, there is a high probability that:
• load will not be shed, except for that which may be offered to the market as dispatchable or interruptible;
• the energy market will not be uneconomically constrained;
• the electrical and thermal ratings of equipment will not be exceeded;
• stable control of system voltage will be maintained, with system voltages maintained within acceptable levels;
• stable control of system frequency will be maintained, with frequency within acceptable levels; and
• synchronous stability of the interconnected power system will be maintained.
The development of TransGrid’s network is planned on the basis of the economic evaluation of options to provide a defined level
of supply reliability. This involves the application of a deterministic criterion in conjunction with a probabilistic-based approach
to the analysis of system adequacy and security. This approach is used widely in international practice.
Although there is a high probability that loads will not be shed as a result of system disturbances no power system can be
guaranteed to deliver a firm capability 100% of the time, particularly when subjected to disturbances that are severe or widespread.
In addition extreme loads, above the level allowed for in planning, can also occur, usually under extreme weather conditions.
Thus there is a potential for low probability events to cause localised or widespread disruption to the power system. These
events include the following:
• loss of several transmission lines within a single corridor, as may occur during bushfires;
• loss of a number of cables sharing a common trench;
• loss of more than one busbar within a substation, possibly following a major plant failure;
• loss of a number of generating units; and
• occurrence of three-phase faults, or faults with delayed clearing.
In TransGrid’s network appropriate facilities and mechanisms are frequently put in place to ameliorate the impact of such events.
The decision process considers the underlying economics of facilities or corrective actions, taking account of the low probability
of the occurrence of extreme events.
The assessment of TransGrid’s transmission network is governed by existing or emerging constraints in the areas of:
Appropriate allowance must also be made for sufficient capability in the system to allow components to be maintained in
accordance with TransGrid’s asset management strategies.
Transmission planning seeks to take advantage of the latest proven technologies in electrical plant and control systems where
these are found to be economic. For example, the application of static var compensators has had a considerable impact on the
power transfer capabilities of parts of the main grid and has deferred or removed the need for transmission line development.
30
The broad approach to consideration of these technologies together with related issues of protection facilities, transmission line
design, substation switching arrangements and power system control and communication is set out in the following sections.
This approach is in line with international practice and provides for cost effective means of maintaining a safe, reliable, secure and
economic supply system with a responsible approach to consideration of environmental and social impacts.
The Code specifies requirements relating to planning standards in a range of areas including:
In addition to adherence to Code and regulatory requirements, TransGrid’s transmission planning approach has been developed
taking into account the historical performance of the components of the NSW system, the sensitivity of loads to supply
interruption and state of the art asset maintenance procedures.
A set of deterministic criteria, detailed below, are applied as a point of first review, from which point a detailed assessment of each
individual case is made. Both Monte Carlo-based and analytical methods are applied to assess the adequacy of the transmission system.
Power flows on the main transmission network are subject to overall state load patterns, dispatch of generation within the National
Electricity Market including interstate export and import of power and the availability of Ancillary Services. NEMMCO applies
operational constraints on generator dispatch to maintain power flows within the capability of regional networks. These constraints
are based on the ability of the networks to sustain certain credible contingency events that are defined in the Code. These events
mainly cover forced outages of single generation or transmission elements, but also provide for multiple outages to be redefined
as credible from time to time. Constraints are usually based on short-duration loadings on network elements, on the basis that
generation can be re-dispatched within 15 minutes.
31
The rationale for this approach is that, if operated beyond a defined power transfer level, disturbances could potentially lead to
system wide loss of load with severe social and economic impact.
Following any transmission outage, for example during maintenance or following a forced outage for which reclosure has not
been possible, NEMMCO applies even more severe constraints within a short adjustment period, in anticipation of the impact of a
further contingency event. This may require the re-dispatch of generation and dispatchable loads, the re-distribution of ancillary
services and, where there is no other alternative, the shedding of load. NEMMCO would therefore direct the shedding of customer load,
rather than operate for a sustained period in a manner where overall security would be at risk for a further contingency. The risk is,
however, accepted over a period of up to 30 minutes.
TransGrid’s planning for its main network therefore concentrates in the first instance on the security of supply to its load
connection points under sustained outage conditions, so as to maintain the overall principle that supply to load connection
points must be secure after any single contingency. Although TransGrid performs much of its transmission line maintenance
using live line techniques, provision must be made for outages of line and terminal equipment in accordance with TransGrid’s
asset management plan. In performing its analysis TransGrid must consider the imperative that NEMMCO will operate the
network in a secure manner as described.
The analysis of network adequacy requires the application of probabilistic-based security analysis, taking into account the probable
load patterns, typical dispatch of generators and loads, the availability characteristics of generators as influenced by maintenance and
forced outages, energy limitations and other factors relevant to each case. Options to address an emerging inability to meet all
connection point loads would be considered at or before the planning horizon for a network augmentation solution.
Further consideration may be given before this time to the costs involved in re-dispatch in the energy and ancillary services
markets to manage a single contingency as described above. In situations where these costs appear to exceed the costs of a
network augmentation this will be brought to the attention of network load customers for consideration.
Although the issues of inter-regional transmission, interconnectors and the creation of Regions in the market are beyond the
scope of the Annual Planning Statement, some discussion is warranted because of the need to define the relationship between
jurisdictional and inter-regional planning.
The ability of TransGrid’s network to provide market access to Generators, other than that required to ensure reliable supply to
loads, is not specifically considered in this document because these matters are subject to commercial negotiation in accordance
with clause 5.5 of the Code.
Under the provisions of the Code NEMMCO may recommend the creation of a Region where constraints to generator dispatch are
predicted to occur with reasonable frequency with the network operated in the "system normal" (all significant elements in service)
condition. In making this recommendation the Code currently does not require NEMMCO to consider either the size of the price
difference that is likely to occur, or the consequences to load connection points if there should be a network contingency. In effect the
capacity of interconnectors that is quoted is the short-time capacity determined by the ability to maintain secure operation after a
single contingency in the system normal state. The operation of the interconnector at this capacity must be supported by appropriate
ancillary services, but NEMMCO does not operate on the basis that the contingency may be sustained.
Some parts of TransGrid’s network are primarily concerned with supply to loads, and are not impacted by the marginal dispatch
of generation (although they may contain embedded generators). Further, the loss of a transmission element does not have to be
considered by NEMMCO in determining network constraints, although ancillary services may need to be provided to cover load
rejection in the event of a single contingency.
32
Urban and Suburban Areas Joint Planning
Generally the urban and suburban networks are characterised by a high load density served by high capacity underground cables and
relatively short transmission lines. The connection points to TransGrid’s network are usually the low voltage (generally 132 kV)
busbars of 330 kV substations. There may be multiple connection points and significant capability on the part of the Distributor to
transfer load between connection points, either permanently or to relieve short-time loadings on network elements after a contingency.
The focus of joint planning with the Distributor is the capability of existing connection points to meet expected peak loadings, and the
need for augmentation to TransGrid’s connection point capacity or to provide a new connection point where this is the most economic
overall solution. TransGrid’s aim is to provide a level and reliability of supply at connection points that is complementary to that
provided by the Distributor within its own network.
Consistent with this TransGrid aims to provide ‘n-1’ reliability at the peak demand of the supply point that is forecast to be
exceeded one year in two. It should be noted that 5-10 MW is about the load forecast resolution at a large connection point.
"One year in ten" peak loadings will also be considered, but an augmentation will only be advanced where there is no possibility
of securing the additional load by switching between connection points.
Supply to high-density urban and central business districts requires special consideration in accordance with good international
practice. For example the inner Sydney metropolitan network serves a large and important part of the State load. Supply to this area
via the 330 kV and 132 kV underground cable network is planned to be secure against the outage of a single 330 kV cable or 330/132
kV transformer in TransGrid’s network and a simultaneous outage of the most critical 132 kV cable in the EnergyAustralia's network.
Thus an ‘n-1’ criterion is applied separately to the two networks. This based on consideration of the following factors:
• the importance and sensitivity of the Sydney area load to supply interruptions;
• the high cost of applying a strict 'n-2' criterion to the 330 kV cable network;
• the large number of elements in the 132 kV network;
• the past performance of the cable system; and
• the extensive outage time that can result from a cable failure.
The criterion applied to the Sydney area is consistent with that applied in the electricity supply to major cities throughout the
world. Most countries use an ‘n-2’ criterion. Some countries apply an ‘n-1’ criterion with some selected ‘n-2’ contingencies that
commonly include two cables sharing the one trench or a double circuit line.
Outages of network elements for planned maintenance must also be considered. Generally this will require 75% of the peak load
to be supplied during the outage. While every effort would be made to secure supplies in the event of a further outage, this may
not be always possible. In this case attention would be directed to minimising the duration of the outage.
The focus of joint planning with the Distributor will usually relate to augmentation of connection point capacity, duplication of
radial 132 kV lines, the extension of the 132 kV system to reinforce or replace existing lower voltage systems and to reduce
losses and the overlay of a higher voltage system to provide a major augmentation and to reduce network losses.
Supply to one or more connection points would be considered for augmentation when the firm ‘n-1’ capacity of TransGrid’s
network is forecast to be exceeded at peak load at the planning horizon. Consistent with the lower level of reliability that may be
targeted by the Distributor in a non-urban area the augmentation would be undertaken before more than 3% of the load would be
at risk at the peak period one year in two, or where the period at risk exceeds 1% of the time (88 hours per year).
33
Economics often dictate that an extension of the 132 kV system will not be justified until there are at least two lower voltage lines
(usually 66 kV or 33 kV) to an area, and these subsequently provide backup to the single 132 kV line. An exception would be
made for supply to a new single point load.
An area supplied by a radial 132 kV line backed up by a lower voltage network would be reviewed for duplication when the area
load at risk exceeds about 10 MW.
As a result of the application of these criteria some radial parts of the 330 kV and 220 kV network are not able to withstand the forced
outage of a single circuit line at time of peak load, and in these cases provision has been made for under-voltage load shedding.
Provision is also required for the maintenance of the network. Additional redundancy in the network is required where
maintenance cannot be scheduled without causing load restrictions or an unacceptable level of risk to the security of supply.
Transformer Augmentation
In considering the augmentation of transformers appropriate allowance is made for the transformer cyclic rating and the
practicality for load transfer between connection points. The outage of a single transformer (or single-phase unit) or a
transmission line which supports the load carried by the transformer is allowed for.
Provision is also required for the maintenance of transformers. This has become a critical issue at a number of sites in NSW
where there are multiple transformers in-service. Additional transformer capacity may be required or alternatively a means of
support to the load via the underlying lower voltage network.
Planning activities provide a key input to TransGrid's capital investment strategy by forming the basis of the 5 year capital budget
relating to investment in increased capacity of the network.
Details of capital investment estimates that relate to extensions of TransGrid's network to meet emerging constraints that have
been identified during planning activities, are provided in Section 4.1 of this document.
An individual organisations’ performance in any one of these performance measures is very much dependent on a variety of
factors such as planning criteria, external environment, asset age, funding and technology. Accordingly "best practice" for an
organisation may not necessarily result in the particular organisation being a "best performer" when benchmarked.
Reliability is a measure of the service level of the transmission network as perceived by the customer. It relates to the amount of
Energy Not Supplied resulting from a temporary failure of a component of the network. The measure used to describe Reliability
is System Minutes where
TransGrid’s objective is to use all reasonable and practicable efforts to minimise the number and duration of unplanned
interruptions. Accordingly, TransGrid aims to contain system minutes resulting from the combined number and duration of
interruptions experienced to between 0.5 and 2.0 system minutes per annum, with a rolling 3 year average of less than 1.3
system minutes.
34
Network Reliability
10
09
08
07
SYSTEM MINUTES
06
05
04
03
02
01
0
90-91 91-92 92-93 93-94 94-95 95-96 96-97 97-98 98-99 99-00 00-01
YEAR
Of the 4.23 System Minutes total for 1999/2000, 3.72 System Minutes were a result of two non-typical outages the details of
which are as follows:
i) 1.62 System Minutes that affected the north east of NSW in January 2000, was a result of a forced outage of a transformer at
Armidale substation at the time that other equipment was out of service for major capital works.
ii) 2.1 System Minutes that affected the far south west of Sydney in January 2000, was a result of fire within the roof of the control
building at Ingleburn substation. This was the first such incident within TransGrid’s long history.
Without these two incidents the Network Reliability figure for 1999/2000 would have been 0.51 System Minutes.
The Network Reliability figure for 2000/2001 was 0.67 System Minutes.
In addition, within TransGrid the service standards for Reliability are cascaded down to individual customers and provide further
details of performance at each supply point. A summary of this performance is given in the tables below.
1997/98 0 1 0 1 12 2 1 0 1 0
1998/99 0 1 0 0 5 1 1 0 1 0
1999/00 0 1 0 0 8 0 1 0 0 0
2000/01 0 0 0 0 5 0 1 0 0 2
35
Number of Interruptions per Customer per Year divided by Number of Supply Points to that Customer
ACTEW Australian ANM BHP Country Energy Integral State Rail Tomago Visy
Inland Energy Energy Australia Energy Authority Aluminium Paper
Circuit availability is generally expressed as a percentage of time the transmission system is in an operating state, with 100%
indicating no network outages.
In this calculation the denominator represents the total sum of possible circuit hours available.
TransGrid’s objective is to use all reasonable and practicable efforts to minimise the number and duration of planned and unplanned
interruptions. Accordingly, TransGrid endeavours to provide supply availability values within a band of 99.0% to 99.2%.
The following graph shows TransGrid’s Circuit Availability performance since 1994:
Circuit Availablity
100
99
CIRCUIT AVAILABILITY %
98
97
96
95
94-95 95-96 96-97 97-98 98-99 99-00 00-01
YEAR
This service standard is a measure of the number of unplanned outages occurring on the transmission network. Forced outages are those
outages that automatically take the equipment out of service and includes incidents such as storms, bushfires and equipment failure.
Emergency outages are outages taken on equipment due to condition monitoring or visual inspections identifying that urgent remedial
action is required.
36
Year on year performance of this indicator can very much be influenced by environmental factors.
The trend shows that despite an increase in the average age of the assets there is a continual decrease in the total number of
emergency outages.
The increase in forced outages from 1999-2000 to 2000-2001 was mainly due to overhead mains related issues that involved a variety
of causes including lightning strikes, bushfires, vegetation contact and some unknown factors.
300
250
200
NUMBER
150
100
50
0
94-95 95-96 96-97 97-98 98-99 99-00 00-01
YEAR
Forced Emergency
These are incidents that occur on the network that have significant impact on safety, environment or supply. As mentioned above in
3.3.1, in the year 1999/ 2000 there were a number of incidents which were non-typical that also impacted upon reliability of supply. A
graph of significant substation incidents since 1991 is shown below.
20
18
16
14
NO. OF INCIDENTS
12
10
0
1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 July 01
YEAR
37
3.3.5 Network Maintenance Costs and Asset Replacement Expenditure.
Network maintenance costs have been effectively reduced over the past ten years and more specifically in the last 5 years through the
introduction of improved maintenance practices, the replacement of selected ageing plant and adoption of on-line condition monitoring
techniques. Throughout the period TransGrid has consistently achieved in excess of 95% of its maintenance plan on a year by year basis.
A graph of Network Maintenance Costs and Asset Replacement and Refurbishment Costs since 1994-95 are shown below.
100
80
$M
60
40
20
0
94-95 95-96 96-97 97-98 98-99 99-00 00-01 01-02 02-03 03-04 04-05
YEAR
Note: Future estimates beyond 2002 are preliminary and account for anticipated expansion of TransGrid’s network by the amount
of $1 billion.
40
30
$M
20
10
0
94-95 95-96 96-97 97-98 98-99 99-00 00-01 01-02 02-03 03-04 04-05
YEAR
Note: Expenditure for 98/99 and 99/00 includes Y2K related work and an expedited program of current transformer replacement.
Further performance measures relating to quality of supply have been developed or are in the process of being developed and
include frequency, voltage and harmonics.
38
4 Asset Strategies
39
4 Asset Strategies
40
4 Asset Strategies
The following is a summary of current and emerging constraints (capacity limitations in TransGrid's transmission network) over
an outlook period of 5 years and either committed augmentations (Section 4.1) or indicative network options (Section 4.2) to relieve
them. This defines, in broad terms, TransGrid's capital investment strategies for new regulated work over that period. More details
are given in TransGrid's Annual Planning Statement for 2001.
It should be emphasized that indicative options are subject to economic analysis in accordance with the National Electricity Code
with the ACCC's Regulatory Test being applied to these and other network options and non-network options such as DSM and
embedded generation.
4.1.1.1. Kempsey – Nambucca – Coffs Harbour 132 kV Transmission Line and Substation
The load growth over recent years in the Coffs Harbour, Sawtell, Nambucca Heads, Macksville, Kempsey, Raleigh and Port
Macquarie areas has been relatively high. The existing 132 kV and underlying 66 kV transmission system is not able to support
the full load in the area under line outage conditions.
The works that are being constructed to overcome this constraint include reconstruction of the existing Coffs Harbour to Kempsey
66 kV line to a double circuit 132 kV transmission line and the establishment of a new Nambucca 132/66 kV Substation. The
line and substation are currently under construction.
4.1.1.2. Development of Supply to the Molong, Manildra, Cumnock and Cudal Areas
The Molong, Manildra, Cumnock and Cudal areas are situated about 30 km North West of Orange and are supplied via a radial
66 kV line from Orange 132/66 kV Substation. In the absence of an augmentation to the area the thermal rating of this line would
have been exceeded by summer 2000/2001.
A programme of augmentations has been determined for these areas that includes:
• Establishment by TransGrid of a 132/66 kV Substation near Molong. This was completed in early 2001;
• replacement by Country Energy of its Manildra 66/11 kV Substation by a new 132/11 kV substation by early 2002; and
• construction by TransGrid of a 132 kV line from Molong to Manildra by to match the commissioning of Manildra 132kV Substation.
Supply to the Sydney Central Business District (CBD) and inner suburbs is currently provided by EnergyAustralia's 132kV
network linking TransGrid's 330/132kV Substations at Beaconsfield, Sydney South (Picnic Point), and Sydney North (Dural).
Beaconsfield 330/132kV Substation is supplied via a single 330kV cable from Sydney South.
Failure of the Sydney South - Beaconsfield 330kV cable and any one of thirty other critical circuits or transformers in the Sydney
area would mean that the peak summer load could not be supplied in summer 2003/04 and subsequently.
A programme of augmentations has been determined that includes construction of a 330kV cable from Sydney South to a new
330/132kV Substation at Haymarket. This work is scheduled for completion by October 2003.
Canberra 330/132 kV Substation has two 400 MVA transformers and one 375 MVA transformer. The capacity of these
transformers is expected to be exceeded in winter 2002 based on the expected growth of the Canberra load.
A fourth 330/132 kV transformer will be installed and commissioned at Canberra by winter 2002.
41
4.1.1.5. Koolkhan 132/66 kV Substation Transformer Replacement
The peak load at Koolkhan Substation is expected to exceed the firm rating of the 30 MVA transformers at the site by winter 2002.
Work has commenced on the replacement of the existing 30 MVA units with 60 MVA units and is expected to be completed by April 2002.
Tumut 132/66 kV Substation has two 30 MVA transformers. The capacity of these transformers is expected to be exceeded by winter 2002.
Work has commenced on the replacement of the existing 30 MVA units with 60 MVA units and is expected to be completed by April 2002.
Queanbeyan 132/66 kV Substation has three 30 MVA transformers. The capacity of these transformers is expected to be
exceeded by winter 2002.
One of the 30MVA units released as part of the Tumut transformer replacements will be relocated to Queanbeyan as the fourth
transformer. This work is expected to be completed by June 2002.
Sydney West substation is equipped with four 375MVA transformers, and prior to summer 2000/2001 it was loaded close to its
full capacity. The co-incident maximum demand in western metropolitan area of Sydney increased by 15% during the summer of
2000/2001 when compared to the previous summer, and this increase in demand was substantially driven by an increase in
connected air-conditioning load. Based on a conservative demand forecast, the thermal capacity of Sydney West substation is
expected to be exceeded during the summer of 2002/2003.
The existing 375MVA transformers may be replaced by 600MVA units by April 2005. However, as an interim measure, a fifth
transformer is to be installed by November 2002.
Tamworth 330/132 kV substation has two 150 MVA transformers tail-ended onto 132 kV lines which are directly connected to
Tamworth 132/66 kV substation. The capacity of these transformers is expected to be exceeded by winter 2002.
Augmentation:
A third transformer is to be installed along with the establishment of a 132 kV busbar. This work is expected to be completed by
June 2002.
Based on projected loads in the Albury/Mulwala area, the thermal rating of the Albury - ANM 132 kV transmission line may be
exceeded by summer 2001/2 under line outage conditions.
42
4.1.2. Emerging Constraints and Indicative Network Options
The growth of NSW loads in the Yass - Wagga areas, coupled with a requirement for heavy power transfer from Snowy to
Victoria, will exacerbate the potential overloading of a number of lines and transformers in the area.
At this stage an indicative network option that will address the overloading problems and provide for an increase in the power
transfer capacity to Snowy and Victoria is the development of a 330 kV line between Yass and Wagga by 2004.
Yass 330/132 kV Substation is an essential location on the New South Wales main grid. Most of the interconnecting lines to the
Snowy system are bused at the substation. The substation was established in 1959 and considerable difficulty is now being
experienced in maintaining the substation equipment.
From a system security viewpoint and on an economic basis it is considered necessary to replace the substation 330 kV. The
works are programmed for completion by 2004.
Four 330 kV lines presently extend from Sydney and the south coast to the southwest and Snowy areas. The capability of this
system to transfer power from Snowy to the north or from the Sydney area into the Southwest area of the State is limited.
The transmission system will need to be supported to supply the growing Southwest area load. Reinforcement by transmission
development would also increase the capability for the export of power from NSW to Victoria and possibly from Victoria to NSW.
An indicative network option is the diversion of the Sydney West - Yass 330 kV line into Marulan in 2004.
4.1.2.4. Limitations in the System Supplying the Western Area of New South Wales
The transmission network in the area West of Bathurst has a limited capability. In the near future a number of system limitations
will emerge:
• during outages of the Mount Piper - Wellington 330 kV line adequate voltage levels may not be maintained at Wellington,
Forbes and Parkes;
• 132kV line thermal ratings may be exceeded during 330kV line outages; and
• the loading on the Wallerawang transformers is approaching the transformer rating during 330 kV line outages.
43
4.1.2.5. Limitations in the System Supplying the Greater Sydney Area
Supply to the greater Sydney area is provided by a number of 330 kV substations interconnected with the state's power stations
and power system in the southern area of NSW. Kemps Creek 500/330 kV Substation provides a focal point for the connection of
the 330 kV lines which interconnect the Sydney 330 kV substations. It is also the termination point of the 500 kV double circuit
line from the central coast power stations. The integrity of Kemps Creek Substation and its 330 kV connections are critical to the
supplies to a large portion of the Greater Sydney area load.
The need for reinforcement of supply to this area to meet the growing load arises from the impact of a number of possible main
system contingencies. At this stage, pending more detailed planning and subject to continued load growth, it is necessary to
make plans for a reinforcement of the network in the area between about 2005 and 2010.
An indicative network option that could be developed in an environmentally acceptable manner is the connection of Kemps Creek
to Liverpool 330 kV substation.
Liverpool 330 kV substation is equipped with two 375MVA transformers with some limited load transfer capability to Sydney
West. Due to the higher than expected load growth in the western metropolitan area of Sydney, the ability to transfer any load to
Sydney West is no longer possible, and on a conservative load forecast the capacity of this substation could be exceeded by the
summer of 2003/2004.
The Sydney area load is growing and the reactive power requirements in the area have required the installation of large capacitor
banks at various TransGrid substations in the area annually for many years. There is an emerging need for the installation of
dynamic reactive support in this area:
Ongoing reactive support is also required in other parts of the main transmission system with requirements being determined
with short lead times.
The majority of the Central Coast load area is supplied from Tuggerah 330/132 kV substation and the recently commissioned
Munmorah 330/132 kV substation. Tuggerah 330 kV substation is equipped with a single 375MVA transformer and supplied by
a single 330 kV connection through a tee connection to the Munmorah to Sydney North 330 kV line.
The preferred network option for duplicating the 330 kV supply to Tuggerah involves rebuilding a section of the existing 330 kV
line from the tee point at Sterland to Tuggerah.
4.1.2.9. Limitations in the System Supplying the Greater Newcastle and Lower North Coast
Load in the Newcastle area comprises the metropolitan area load and the smelter loads at Alcan and Tomago. The need for
augmentation to the supply to the area will be driven by the following factors:
An indicative network option is the installation of two 330/132 kV transformers and associated switchgear at Waratah West by
summer 2004/5.
44
4.1.2.10. Limitations in the System Supplying the Lismore Area
The Lismore area is supplied by a single 330 kV line from Armidale and a supporting 132 kV system.
Over recent years the capability of this system to supply the Lismore and far north coast area load has been limited by voltage
control constraints to less than the prevailing peak demand following an outage of the Armidale - Lismore 330 kV line.
System security has been improved by the installation of the Lismore SVC and capacitor banks at Armidale and Coffs Harbour in 1999.
Initially these improvements will enable the full load of the area to be supplied following an outage of the Armidale - Lismore 330 kV line.
However, the load growth in the area is relatively high and the full area load will not be covered beyond about 2003 to 2005 when
132 kV line thermal limits will be reached following an outage of the 330 kV line.
Indicative network options both involve the development of an additional 330 kV line to the area by 2004.
4.1.2.11. Limitations in the System Supplying the Coffs Harbour and Nambucca Coastal Areas
The load growth over recent years in the Coffs Harbour, Sawtell, Nambucca Heads, Macksville, Kempsey, Raleigh and Port
Macquarie coastal areas has been relatively high. The load growth in the area will result in the capability of the 132 kV
transmission system and the rating of the Armidale 330/132 kV transformers being exceeded by winter 2003.
An indicative network augmentation option is the development of a 330 /132 kV substation at Coffs Harbour. This reinforces
supply to the area and enables a reduction in system losses. It also provides a reinforcement of supply to the mid north coast
area via the new 132 kV line to Kempsey.
4.1.2.12. Limitations in the System Supplying the Taree, Port Macquarie and Kempsey Areas
The mid north coast of NSW comprises the load areas supplied from Kempsey, Port Macquarie and Taree substations. The load
in this area is growing steadily.
By the winter of 2003, in the event of an outage of any one of the Armidale - Kempsey, Kempsey - Port Macquarie, Tomago - Taree, or
Kurri - Stroud 132 kV lines, the voltage levels at Port Macquarie and Taree connection points would fall below acceptable levels
This and other limitations are only fully overcome by relatively substantial network support in the area, involving new line
development. Options for this development include the following.
4.1.2.13. Limitations in the System Supplying the Glen Innes and Inverell Areas
Load growth will result in the capacity of the transmission system supplying the Inverell and Glen Innes areas being exceeded by the
mid 2000’s.
An indicative network option is the development of a new 132 kV transmission line between Glen Innes and Inverell by 2006.
4.1.2.14. Limitations in the System Supplying the Gunnedah, Narrabri and Moree Areas
The transmission system supplying the Gunnedah, Narrabri and Moree areas has limited thermal capacity. The system is also limited
by reactive power constraints. There are also constraints on planned maintenance activities on the existing 132 kV transmission
system in the Northwest region of the State. Reinforcement is required to improve the reliability and quality of supply to the area.
An indicative network option is the construction of a 132 kV line from Tamworth to Gunnedah by 2007.
45
4.1.2.15. Limitations in the System Supplying the Parkes, Forbes and Cowra Areas
The Parkes, Forbes and Cowra areas are supplied via a number of 132 kV lines, which interconnect Wellington and Yass 330/132
kV substations. A number of mining and mineral extraction and processing developments have been proposed for this area.
Based on the current load forecast adequate voltage levels may not be able to be maintained in these areas during an outage of
the Wellington to Parkes 132 kV line.
An indicative network option is the construction of a 132 kV line from Manildra to Parkes by about 2004.
Based on the current load forecast, the firm transformer capacity of this substation will be exceeded in the summer of 2003/2004.
At this stage an indicative network option is the development of a new substation at Morven in conjunction with Country Energy
by summer 2003/2004.
4.1.2.17. Limitations in Line Ratings from Wagga 330/132 kV Substation to Wagga 132/66 kV Substation
Wagga 132/66 kV Substation is supplied over two 132 kV lines from Wagga 330/132 kV Substation and a long 132 kV line from
Yass. Based on the current load forecast, the 132 kV transmission line capacity from Wagga 330/132 kV Substation to Wagga
132/66 kV Substation will be exceeded in summer 2004/5.
An indicative network option to overcome this limitation is the establishment of a new 132 kV switching station in the North Wagga area.
These works are estimated to cost $3.5 million. They would be required to be completed by 2004/5 or earlier depending on the
impact of the development of a new 330 kV line to Wagga.
SNI is a proposal by TransGrid to directly interconnect the National Electricity Market regions of New South Wales and South
Australia. The proposal has been developed in response to an acknowledged need for such a connection in the NEM. TransGrid
is in the process of having SNI assessed by NEMMCO as a regulated interconnector.
The project consists of a new 275 kV line from Buronga in New South Wales to Robertstown in south Australia, uprating the
Darlington Point - Buronga line to 275 kV operation and other ancillary works. The total cost of the works is estimated to be
$110 Million and is proposed to be in service by the summer of 2003/4.
Increasing loads in the Newcastle area and increased generation in the Hunter Valley and from northern New South Wales is
likely to be constrained by transmission capacity south from Liddell/Bayswater. Uprating the Bayswater - Mount Piper - Marulan
lines to operate at 500kV provides increased capacity in that part of the network.
46
4.1.3. Summary of Capital Investment Strategy
The table on the following page summarises the above capital investment strategy
4.1.1.1 Kempsey – Nambucca – Coffs Harbour T/Line & Substation New 132 Sub and line 2001
4.1.1.2 Supply to Molong, Manildra, Cumnock & Cudal New 132 Sub and line 2002
4.1.1.8 Sydney West 330 kV Substation Fifth Transformer New Transformer 2002
4.1.1.10 Albury - ANM 132 kV Transmission Line Uprate Uprate Conductors 2002
4.1.2.1 Constraints on Transfer Capability: Snowy to Victoria New 330 kV development 2004 60,000
4.1.2.2 Yass 330 kV Substation Equipment Replacement Equipment Replacement 2004 30,000
4.1.2.3 Limitations in the System Supplying Yass/Canberra 330 kV line works 2004 20,000
4.1.2.4 Limitations in the System Supplying the Western area New 330 kV development 2005 65,000
4.1.2.5 Limitations in the System Supplying Greater Sydney area Reconstruct 330 kV Line 2005 35,000
4.1.2.8 Limitations in the System Supplying the Central Coast 330 kV line works 2004 5,000
4.1.2.9 Limitations in the System Supplying Greater Newcastle 2 New Transformers 2005 12,000
4.1.2.10 Limitations in the System Supplying the Lismore area New 330 kV development 2004 100,000
4.1.2.11 Limitations in the System Supplying Coffs Hrbr, area New 330 Sub 2004 10,000
4.1.2.12 Limitations in the System Supplying Taree, area New 132 kV Lines 2004 30,000
4.1.2.13 Limitations in the System Supplying Glen Innes area New 132 kV Line 2006 8,000
4.1.2.14 Limitations in the System Supplying Gunnedah area New 132 kV Line 2007 7,000
4.1.2.15 Limitations in the System Supplying Parkes area New 132 kV Line 2004 6,000
4.1.2.16 Wagga 132/66 kV Substation Transformer Limitations New 132 kV Sub 2004 3,500
4.1.2.17 Limitations in Line Ratings in Wagga area New 132 kV Sub 2005 3,500
4.1.2.18 South Australia - New South Wales Interconnector (SNI) New NSW - SA 275 kV line 2003 110,000
47
4.2 Asset Maintenance and Operating Strategies
TransGrid uses well-developed and documented processes to ensure that its existing assets are effectively and efficiently managed.
A simple overview of the Asset Management Strategy Process is shown below in Figure 2.
The quality of TransGrid’s asset management process was recognised by the receipt of a National Engineering Excellence Award in 1997.
Refurbishment
Maintenance
or Replacement
Policies
Strategies
Equipment Service
Performance
Co-ordinate Outage
Programme
Works Management
Resource Plan
System
Outage Requests
Work Performed
Maintenance Standards
and Service Instructions
48
Elements of TransGrid’s Asset Maintenance Strategy Process
1. Structure
The development and updating of both the Asset Management Strategies and the Maintenance Policies is carried out by Working
Groups made up of a cross-section of maintenance, design and asset management staff. The Working Groups meet regularly to
discuss issues and resolve problems identified.
The work identified as necessary is categorised as either Capital or Operating for budgetary purposes. The operating work is
further split into two categories.
(i) Maintenance work - which is routine and repetitive in nature and specified by the relevant maintenance policy.
(ii) Major Operating Projects - these are non-repetitive and require the investment of significant resources on a one off basis.
Refurbishment work and some replacements fall into this category. The performance issues and proposed solutions are
detailed in the relevant Asset Management Strategy.
• Substations
• Underground cables
• Transmission lines
• Protection schemes
• Metering installations
• Communications & SCADA
These Strategies are updated annually and detail both the short and medium term strategies used to address issues beyond the
scope of routine maintenance activities.
Information relating to the performance of the assets, including maintenance history and defect history are used in the review
process to determine if any action is required on a specific issue.
Condition monitoring information is used extensively to identify equipment approaching the end of its useful service life thus
allowing for planned replacement or refurbishment programs to be implemented.
The maintenance policies are implemented through a computerised Works Management System (WMS) that schedules, initiates
and records both routine and non-routine maintenance and defect repairs.
49
TransGrid has a policy of minimal intrusive maintenance, preferring instead to carry out diagnostic testing to determine if a need
exists for any further work. Maintenance is generally targeted according to the following criteria:
5. Maintenance Planning
Asset maintenance plans are detailed in a Maintenance Policy and Asset Strategy for each asset category. Each Maintenance Policy
describes the routine maintenance frequency and extent of routine maintenance for each item of plant. The Asset Strategies take a
broader perspective and detail refurbishment / replacement / repair strategies for particular types, makes or categories of equipment.
In planning any routine or non routine work (including new project or construction work), that involves a system outage a
significant effort is made to package as much work as possible to minimise the number and duration of any outages as these may
impact on the Availability of the network.
6. Risk Management
In addition to developing, enhancing and maintaining its transmission network, TransGrid ensures that risks to the system are
understood and quantified.
Both the Maintenance Polices and Asset Strategies are reviewed using risk management principles, considering the criticality and
exposure associated with a particular course of action that could materially affect the network and the quality, availability and
reliability of supply to our customers.
7. Contingency Planning
TransGrid works closely with the civil defence organisations (police, ambulance and fire brigade ) for natural disaster events and is
suitably prepared to manage operations and restorations of supplies. However customer expectations for the security and
reliability of electricity supplies is high as regional and state economies are very dependent on achievement of these expectations.
Contingency planning is an integral part of the risk management process and although it is not realistic to plan for all possible
events there needs to be a common understanding of the extent of anticipated events and the extent of the contingency planning
necessary to cover these events.
A Corporate Emergency Management Plan (CEMP) has been prepared to coordinate the Management measures necessary to
ensure that TransGrid is prepared for emergencies which may impact upon reliability of supply, the safety of staff and the public
or the environment.
A number of Regional Emergency Response Plans support the Corporate Emergency Management Plan, and to ensure effective
operational response to emergencies.
8. Loss of Equipment
The outcome of most risk events will be the temporary or permanent loss of specific network equipment.
TransGrid’s asset procurement policy ensures that, for reasons of economy, there is a reasonable degree of commonality across the
state. There are a number of unique installations where there is only limited opportunity for direct interchange of spare equipment.
In most cases, however, spare equipment can be readily obtained and modified if necessary to effect temporary repairs.
Emergency transmission line structures are held by TransGrid, which can be quickly assembled and erected, in the unlikely event
of major line failures. These are held at key sites throughout the state and are suitable for most tower line locations.
A number of spare transformers are held at strategic locations throughout the state. A formal policy exists defining the number of
spares of a given type to be held based on the size of the transformer population. Other spares such as circuit breakers,
instrument transformers, surge arrestors, protection relays etc. are constantly monitored to ensure optimal levels are held.
50
9. Asset Performance Reviews
The ultimate measure of whether the asset management process is achieving its stated goals is determined by the performance of
the transmission network. Consequently within TransGrid a number of methods are used to objectively measure the outcomes of
the process and these are used to indicate whether:
The actual methods used to perform this function include the following:
Independent auditors with specialist knowledge of the functional area conduct the assessments. A formal report detailing non-
conformances, observations and improvement opportunities is prepared and follow up reports required to ensure that any issues
identified are addressed.
All forced and emergency outages during the period are reviewed in detail and where necessary further action initiated. The
group also reviews the long-term outage/reliability trends to determine issues requiring further investigation.
Issues identified by either a Technical Performance Assessment or the Quarterly Asset Performance Review are passed on to the
relevant Working Group for inclusion in their policy/strategy deliberations.
12. ISO 9001 Quality Audits and ISO 14001 Environmental Audits
Despite the large geographical distances between Regions and their assets, TransGrid ensures confidence in the effective
application of identical policies and practices across the network through maintaining its certification to AS/NZS ISO9001 for
Quality Management and AS/NZS ISO14001 for Environmental Management Systems.
To achieve the maintenance of both these certifications, TransGrid follows a 3 year cycle consisting of 6 monthly audits and a 3
yearly certification assessment by an appropriate Certification Body.
In accordance with the Electricity Supply (Safety Plans) Regulation 1997, under the Electricity Act 1995, TransGrid has prepared a
Safety and Operating Plan which brings together all the documents pertaining to health and safety, maintenance and training
within the organisation.
This Safety and Operating Plan is audited annually by an independent external Auditor to ensure compliance with the Regulation.
51
14. External Benchmarking
Since 1995 TransGrid has been a participant in the International Transmission Operating and Maintenance Study (ITOMS) that
benchmarks maintenance activities performed by high voltage transmission utilities. The study involves some nineteen
transmission organisations from Australia, New Zealand, USA, Europe, Britain and Scandinavia.
The ITOMS results are used by TransGrid as a basis to carry out a detailed review of the various maintenance policies and
strategies being adopted by not only overseas utilities but also most of the Australian utilities. The results from ITOMS99
confirmed the success of TransGrid’s revised policies and provided data for further policy revisions in other maintenance areas.
The impact of these policy revisions and changes in work practices will be assessed in the forthcoming 2001 ITOMS study,
which will review 2000-2001 data.
By internally benchmarking its three Regions, utilising a format similar to ITOMS, TransGrid is able to identify those locations
that impact on TransGrid’s combined performance in specific maintenance activities providing a driver to improve that local
performance.
52
4.2.2 Operation Strategies
1. Operations policies
Policies are developed and reviewed specifying the principles for operating TransGrid’s assets so as to optimise their use while
ensuring equipment and personal safety and security of supply. Reviews are based on statistical performance data, comparison of
practices of other utilities and the introduction of new technologies. The policies are documented in operating manuals which are
used by TransGrid operating staff, network staff and by NEMMCO.
Long-term network augmentation plans are reviewed and improvements are proposed to the network planning group based on
operational experience with the existing network.
The adequacy of TransGrid’s network in the medium term is checked through computer studies to identify if there are any
shortcomings in the planned network augmentations or in the timing of projects. Where potential problems are identified,
corrective action is coordinated with network planning and projects groups to ensure provision of the necessary transmission
assets on time. Where a delay is unavoidable, interim solutions are developed such as special operational strategies and
automatic control schemes to manage the risk of supply interruption.
The capabilities of all transmission elements are determined by System Operations for operational use by TransGrid and by
NEMMCO to ensure the safety of TransGrid’s assets as well as ensuring secure network operation, reliability of supply and safety
to staff and public.
Operating constraints which apply to the transfer of power through TransGrid’s network are determined for transmission outage
conditions. This is carried out to determine optimal arrangements for planned maintenance or for reconstruction work, and to
advise Market Participants of potential impacts of this work on their business processes.
4. Operating manuals
A library of operating manuals is constantly maintained up to date using Quality System principles. The manuals specify
TransGrid’s operating policies, operating procedures, transmission plant capabilities, network operating arrangements, operating
strategies, and operating principles of automatic control systems. These form the basis for operation of the NSW transmission
network by TransGrid operating staff and by NEMMCO.
Courses and presentations are given to relevant staff to maintain competency in and provide familiarisation with operational
procedures and requirements.
5. Operating graphics
A system of operational single line diagrams is maintained to show all network high voltage equipment and relevant associated
low voltage apparatus. Diagrams are instrumental in the operational management of the network and are prepared in differing
formats for use by operators and network personnel and for SCADA displays.
Operating staff are maintained on duty around the clock seven days a week to monitor network conditions and the occurrence of
natural hazards, and to manage abnormal situations. Safe working conditions are arranged for maintenance by TransGrid and
other organisations by the preparation, checking and implementation of approved switching procedures. Liaison is maintained
on and off shift with NEMMCO and other organisations to ensure adequate coordination of equipment outages and appropriate
advice to market participants.
Operations staff are responsible for implementing voltage control on the NSW network. This is done as the agent for NEMMCO,
which has the charter to ensure the National Electricity Code requirements for voltage control are carried out.
53
7. System restart strategy
The main strategy for restoration of the NSW system following a system blackout is developed and regularly updated based on
technical considerations and on restoration priorities. The main aims are to optimise the speed of restoration and to minimise risks to
the community and to critical industries from prolonged interruption to supplies. An assessment is made of the system restart
ancillary services which have been contracted by NEMMCO for this purpose. Training of TransGrid, NEMMCO and general market
participants is carried out on a regular basis to ensure familiarity with restoration requirements and restart principles.
The operational performance of TransGrid’s network is monitored and data collected and analysed in order to identify possible
improvements in operating instructions or in operator performance, or shortcomings in the network or its operational facilities.
Recommendations for system augmentation are prepared when network performance is below adequate operational standards.
System incidents are studied in detail to identify any incorrect performance of plant and possible improvements in operator
response. A database of planned and forced outage details is maintained in order to provide network performance statistics for
policy reviews in planning, operation and maintenance and for benchmarking against other utilities
9. Operating facilities
Operating facilities for the supervision and remote control of TransGrid’s network are regularly reviewed and new requirements
identified to ensure that adequate means are available for optimal utilisation of the transmission assets, both under normal and
emergency conditions. Regular operational testing of facilities is carried out to ensure continued service availability.
Facilities to improve the efficiency of operational processes are investigated, specified, developed and commissioned when appropriate.
Specifications are developed for automatic control schemes that will operate during power system emergencies so as to maintain
a viable grid and minimise the effects of supply disruptions in the event of non-credible contingencies. These schemes are
coordinated where appropriate with network development plans.
Plans for outages of transmission assets for maintenance or for reconstruction are examined to determine the impact on network
operation, reliability of supply and the extent of possible constraints imposed on the market. This information is provided to
affected market participants and is used to facilitate coordination of work by TransGrid’s maintenance and project groups and staff
of other organisations.
Outage schedules for all work on TransGrid equipment and that of other organisations connected to TransGrid assets are prepared
for up to 24 months ahead and refined as necessary to suit changing network conditions and customer requirements while
maintaining security and reliability of supply. Details of outages that might have an impact on the operation of the National
Electricity Market are submitted to NEMMCO for additional assessment and final approval.
Emergency operational procedures are prepared in advance to ensure effective response in abnormal conditions that might arise
from foreseeable contingencies. Procedures are also prepared to enable effective commissioning of new plant, including testing
in situ by energising from the main system when required.
54
4.3 Specific Asset Profiles & Strategies
Introduction
This section details some technical data of the numbers and age profiles of the existing assets within TransGrid’s network as at 30 June 2001.
• Substations
• Transmission Lines
• Underground Cables
• Protection Schemes
• Metering Installations
• Communications and SCADA
1. Substations
Introduction
TransGrid has a total of 76 substations and switching stations within its network ranging in voltage from 132kV, 220kV, 330kV to 500kV.
Their locations vary from coastal to rural, sub-tropical to dry-desert, sea level to high altitude, corrosive locations to stable atmospheres.
Each substation or switching station may comprise high voltage circuit breakers, power transformers, instrument transformers,
synchronous condensers, reactors, static var compensators, capacitor banks, control and protection schemes, property and
buildings, switchyard structures and hardware, buffer zones, and a multitude of other associated power supplies, cabling and
ancillary equipment.
As shown from the age profiles below, approximately one third of substations and switching stations were commissioned before
1970, with the oldest being Burrinjuck commissioned in 1950 and the most recent Balranald and Molong in 2001.
20
15
NO.
10
05
0
1950-1959 1960-1969 1970-1979 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009
YEAR COMMISSIONED
55
Power Transformers
TransGrid’s power transformer population comprises of 203 individual units and of these 56% are rated above 100MVA with a primary
voltage of 132kV or higher. Also 38% of this population comprises single-phase units and 92% have on-load tapchangers.
The power transformer age profile shown below indicates that 46% were commissioned before 1970, and some of the oldest
units were manufactured pre 1952.
80
60
NUMBER
40
20
0
1950-1959 1960-1969 1970-1979 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009
The age profile shown below indicates that 33% of the installed units were commissioned before 1980 and some of the oldest
units were manufactured in 1970.
10
08
NUMBER
06
04
02
0
1960-1969 1970-1979 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009
YEAR COMMISSIONED
56
Circuit Breakers
TransGrid’s circuit breaker population comprises 1226 units in the voltage range from 11kV to 500kV. The types of circuit
breakers used include Air Blast (AB), Bulk Oil (BO), Small Oil Volume (SOV), Vacuum and SF6.
400
300
NUMBER
200
100
0
1950-1959 1960-1969 1970-1979 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009
All recent circuit breaker purchases at 132kV and above are of the SF6 type with a preference for spring operating mechanism. The
type and age profiles given above reflect the various numbers and types of circuit breakers installed on the network as at June 2001.
Instrument Transformers
TransGrid manages a total instrument transformer population of approximately 5750 units ranging in voltage from 11kV to 500kV, comprising:
• Current Transformers (approximately 66.5% of population) ,
• 670 Magnetic Voltage Transformers (approximately 12% of population) ,
• 1220 Capacitor Voltage Transformers (approximately 21.5% of population).
The age profile shows that 27% of these units were manufactured before 1970 and some of the oldest units before 1957. All of
the above units are of the post freestanding type and any instrument transformers contained within metal clad switchgear, gas
insulated switchgear, power transformers and oil filled reactors are not included in the above statistics.
1000
NUMBER OF UNITS
500
0
1956-1960 1961-1965 1966-1970 1971-1975 1976-1980 1981-1985 1986-1990 1991-1995 1996-2000
57
Synchronous Condensers
TransGrid has two synchronous condensers each rated at 16kV +/- 75 MVAr located at Sydney South Substation. Both units
were commissioned in 1962 and are approching the end of their economic life.
Shunt Capacitors
TransGrid has a total of 77 shunt capacitor banks in-service within the network with an installed capacity of 3430 MVArs ranging
in voltage from 11kV to 330kV. Of this population 54% are rated at 132kV, 60% were manufactured between 1981 and 1985, and
85% have been manufactured and installed since 1980.
The majority of the capacitor units installed are of the internal fuse type but some externally fused units have also been used. All
units are PCB free but some (approximately 985MVAr) contain the fluid Dow C4.
Surge Arresters
Surge Arresters are used to protect expensive items of plant such as transformers from failure due to transient voltage surges.
There are 1347 arresters installed within TransGrid’s system.
Bushings
TransGrid’s transformers and reactors contain some 1685 bushings ranging in voltage from 500kV to 11kV. In general the age
profile would follow closely that of the transformers and reactors. These indicate that approximately half of the transformer
bushings are more than 30 years old and approximately half of the reactor bushings are over 10 years of age.
Ancillary Equipment
All substation and switching stations also contain ancillary equipment such as disconnectors, earth switches, surge arresters,
busbars, batteries and battery chargers, control and protection cabling, security systems, fire protection equipment, air
conditioning, light and power.
Sites also may contain fencing, roads, drainage systems, landscaping, environmental buffer zones and other services, which need
to be kept in good order.
The age profile for these sites is normally the same as the substation and the style and construction methods vary due to the
location, environmental issues and the era built.
58
2. Transmission Lines
TransGrid has a total of 10,696 route km and 12,152 circuit km of transmission line with details of constructed and operating
voltage given in the following table:
These lines are of steel lattice tower, steel pole, concrete pole and wood pole construction. The construction line type and age
profiles are shown below:
59
Transmission Line Age Profile
2000
1750
1500
1250
CIRCUIT km
1000
750
500
250
0
1956-1960 1961-1965 1966-1970 1971-1975 1976-1980 1981-1985 1986-1990 1991-2000
YEAR OF CONSTRUCTION
132kV Wood Pole 66kV Wood Pole 330kV Steel Tower 330kV Wood Pole 132kV Steel Tower
132kV Concrete Pole 500kV Steel Tower 330kV Steel Pole 330kV Underground Cable 220kV Steel Tower
3. Underground Cables
The primary cable asset owned by TransGrid is the 19.7km 330kV cable 41 between Beaconsfield and Sydney South. This is a
paper-oil cable system which was placed into service in 1979. Associated with 41 cable is the pilot cable 160.
TransGrid also has short lengths of cable energised at 132kV, 66kV, 33kV and 11kV which in general, though not exclusively, run
within the confines of our substation boundaries.
4. Protection Relays
Introduction
Protection equipment at TransGrid sites can be grouped into a number of broad categories. These include :
• Line Protection Relays
• Transformer Differential Relays
• Busbar Protection Relays
• Overcurrent Relays (Instantaneous and IDMT)
• Auxiliary Relays (timers, multitrips, followers etc)
60
Relay Profile
Line 20%
Transformer Differential 8%
Busbar 8%
Overcurrent 20%
Auxiliary 44%
Auxiliary relays represent the largest category and whilst installed in all protection schemes can be considered as secondary
components. It is, however, the remaining four categories that comprise the primary components of any protection scheme.
The population, age and performance of this equipment represent some of the factors that need to be considered when
determining a 30 year replacement program. The replacement program would also need to include the upgrading of auxiliary
relays as a natural consequence of any primary relay change.
It is recognised that most primary relays currently installed on TransGrid’s system will need to be replaced. The population and
age of the primary protection equipment installed on TransGrid’s network is set out in the following pages.
450
400
350
300
250
NUMBER
200
150
100
50
0
1960-1969 1970-1979 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009
YEAR INSTALLED
61
Transformer Differential Relays
TransGrid’s transformer differential relay population comprises 378 individual schemes ranging in age from 0 to 30+ years. The
age profile shown below indicates that 64% of TransGrid’s distance relay population was commissioned before 1980, some of the
oldest schemes were manufactured in the 1960s.
140
120
100
80
NUMBER
60
40
20
0
1960-1969 1970-1979 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009
YEAR INSTALLED
250
200
NUMBER
150
100
50
0
1960-1969 1970-1979 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009
YEAR INSTALLED
62
Overcurrent Protection Relays
TransGrid’s overcurrent protection relay population comprises approximately 1,799 individual relays ranging in age from 0 to 30+
years. The age profile shown below indicates that 23% of TransGrid’s overcurrent protection relay population was commissioned
before 1970, some of the oldest schemes were manufactured in the 1960s
900
800
700
600
NUMBER
500
400
300
200
100
0
1960-1969 1970-1979 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009
YEAR INSTALLED
5. Metering
Metering equipment at TransGrid sites can be grouped into a number of broad categories. These include :
• Energy Meters
• Remote Interrogation Meters
• Auxiliary Devices (voltage selection relays, transformers etc)
• Transducers
Auxiliary Devices 6%
Transducers 21%
RIMs 11%
63
Energy Meters represent the largest category and when combined with Remote Interrogation Meters (RIMs) and Auxiliary Devices
form the essential components of any Revenue or Backup metering scheme. Transducers form the second largest category and
provide an important function in relation to system operations.
A replacement program would include the upgrading of selected auxiliary devices as a consequence of any Revenue or Backup
metering scheme review. For example, the voltage selection relay may be changed, but the 110V/240V auxiliary supply
transformer would not generally require replacement.
It is recognised that most energy meters, RIMs and transducers currently installed on TransGrid’s system will need to be replaced.
The population and age of the primary metering equipment installed on TransGrid’s network is set out in the following pages.
Energy Meters
TransGrid’s energy meter population comprises 1,524 individual units ranging in age from 0 to 30+ years. The age profile shown
below indicates that 46% of TransGrid’s energy meter population was commissioned before 1980.
800
700
600
500
NUMBER
400
300
200
100
0
1970-1979 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009
YEAR INSTALLED
64
Age Profile of RIM Devices
250
200
150
NUMBER
100
50
0
1970-1979 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009
YEAR INSTALLED
Transducers
TransGrid’s transducer population comprises 726 individual units ranging in age from 0 to 30 years. The age profile shown below
indicates that 60% of TransGrid’s transducer population was commissioned before 1980.
450
400
350
300
250
NUMBER
200
150
100
50
0
1970-1979 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009
YEAR INSTALLED
Power Meter (Hung Chung) Watts/Vars (L & G, DWR) Watts (L & G, DWR, Carrel & Carrel) Current (L & G, PTN)
Frequency (L & G, PTN) Var (L & G, DWR, Carrel & Carrel) Volts (L & G, Carrel & Carrell)
6. Communications
TransGrid owns 66 communication rooms located within substations, Regional Centres and TransGrid’s head office.
Each communication room provides voice, data and protection services to the equipment and staff on site. Being part of the site
the communication room utilises the ancillary equipment installed.
TransGrid own 62 microwave and VHF radio repeater sites located across NSW.
65
All Repeater sites are stand-alone and have individual ancillary equipment. These include power and lighting, battery and
chargers, air conditioning, access roads, security fencing and radio towers, poles or structures.
CAS (10)
TransGrid Smart
EC NSW 3 Rate
EC NSW 5 Rate
66
Power Line Carrier
TransGrid owns 258 Power Line Carrier systems that provide communication services between substations. These systems carry
Voice, SCADA and Backup alarm systems.
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
1966 1974 1976 1978 1981 1982 1984 1987 2000
250
200
150
100
50
0
1975 1976 1982
67
VF Intertrips Installed
100
80
60
40
20
0
1970 1979 1980 1981 1987 1997
Telephone Equipment
TransGrid owns and operates 64 networked telephone exchanges. These exchanges provide voice communications to all major
sites and substations. The exchanges operate using 4 different versions of software (BC6, BC6.3, BC7and BC9). The 64
exchanges were installed between 1990 and 1991 with the 4 versions of software being installed and upgraded at selected sites
from 1990 to 1997. The entire TransGrid Corporate Telephone Network will be upgraded to BC10 in the Financial Year 2001/02.
Exchange Types
MD 110/50
MD 110/10
68
Microwave Radio Types
SAIE (2)
Siemens (2)
Harris Farinon (2)
AWA MW (13)
NEC MW MUX (234)
Philips (209)
TAIT (52)
Exicom (8)
69
4.3.2 Specific Asset Maintenance Strategies
Introduction
This section describes the specific maintenance policies and refurbishment and replacement strategies that have been developed to
ensure the continued performance of the existing network assets. Staff carrying out inspection of equipment constantly monitor the
condition of the assets and data is analysed to determine the appropriate course of action.
1. Substations
Routine Maintenance
Routine maintenance is carried out in accordance with the TransGrid Substation Maintenance Policy. The principles employed include
the following:
Circuit Breakers - Circuit breakers are maintained on either time or operational basis. The table below summarises the different
maintenance types and frequencies.
In addition the duration of the maintenance also depends on circuit breaker type. For example on air blast 330kV circuit breakers
there can be up to 24 interrupting heads, while a modern SF6 330kV unit for the same duty has only 6 heads.
Types of diagnostic testing carried out on circuit breakers include: measurement of contact resistance, speed of operation of contact
opening and closing, insulation medium tests, checks on operating mechanisms etc.
Power Transformers and Oil Filled Reactors - power transformers have four main components (tapchanger, bushings, windings and
oil) that require routine maintenance on either time or operational basis. The table below summarises the different maintenance types
and frequencies.
The frequency of maintenance also depends on transformer / reactor condition and to some degree on its type. Oil samples are taken
for Dissolved Gas Analysis (DGA), Furans and Oil Quality tests.
More recently, on-line condition monitoring facilities are being developed and installed on selected power transformers and oil filled
reactors. These devices provide continuous monitoring of the condition of the equipment while they remain in service and include
early warning of any internal problems that could reduce the incidence of unexpected major failures.
70
Instrument Transformers - Instrument transformers include current transformers and voltage transformers. Most voltage transformers
are of the capacitive type and a purpose built on-line voltage unbalance system developed by TransGrid is used to monitor their
internal condition.
All current transformers are tested externally by measuring dielectric dissipation factor (DDF) and oil sampled. Oil tests include
dielectric measurements and dissolved gas analysis (DGA) tests. Normal method of testing is a 4-yearly cycle with more frequent
tests if results indicate a need.
Similar to power transformers, on-line condition monitoring facilities are also being developed and installed on selected current
transformers to detect internal problems that could reduce the incidence of unexpected major failures.
Other Plant - Other plant such as disconnectors, surges arrestors, capacitor banks etc. are maintained at service intervals the same as
the main plant. Batteries are maintained in accordance with our service experience, basically at 2 yearly intervals.
Non-Routine Maintenance
Non-routine maintenance covers breakdown repairs, defect repairs, plant modifications and other work not covered by routine
maintenance.
The following factors are used to identify, analyse and substantiate any new major operating project:
• Need for work based on issues such as performance, maintenance needs, safety, lack of spare parts, environmental factors, type
faults etc;
• Risk assessment analysis associated with continued repairs, future reliability, system security;
• Total quantity and costs which may consider either refurbishment or replacement options;
• Time period over which the work has to be done; and
• Priority factor giving importance relative to other projects.
In general all replacement programs are determined by condition, economic, safety or environmental considerations rather than
by age alone.
Increasing use of condition monitoring is being made to substantiate equipment replacement and refurbishment. On-line continuous
condition monitoring systems are becoming available for a wide variety of substation plant such as power transformers and oil filled
reactors, bushings, on-load tapchangers, circuit breakers, instrument transformers and protection relays.
TransGrid has implemented a strategy to purchase a range of these on-line monitoring systems for installation at selected
locations initially, and then to include other sites as considered appropriate.
Existing condition monitoring and maintenance practices such as regular visual inspections, oil sampling and major maintenance of
transformers and oil filled reactors identify those issues that require oil treatment, refurbishment or repair.
71
The types of refurbishment programs applicable to most power transformers and oil filled reactors include the following work:
Depending on local operating conditions, most transformers and reactors over 30 years old are subjected to refurbishment programs
that are repeated every 20 years.
In addition, TransGrid implements projects on specific transformers or reactors to maximise the useful service life of the units.
Some of these projects include:
• Fitting of oil conservator bags to minimise oxidation and moisture ingress initially on all transformers less than 20 years old;
• Fitting of filters and dehumidifier units to on-load tapchangers that are subject to more than 15,000 operations per year;
• Fitting of on-line continuous monitoring systems to the on-load tapchanger, high voltage bushings, transformer oil and
thermal systems on all critical transformers; and
• Relocation of transformers or reactors to other substations within TransGrid’s network to better utilise or match their design
ratings against the substation loadings and to defer expenditure on new transformers and reactors.
Once a transformer or reactor is assessed to have reached the end of its reliable service life a replacement unit is installed. Normal
procedures require that before any replacement unit is procured a review is performed to determine the optimum rating required.
Also, contained within the NSW Annual Planning Statement any specific network constraints are identified where existing substation
transformer thermal capacities are not able to meet the required loads. For these situations the two normal options considered include
the installation of extra transformers into the substation or the replacement of the existing transformers with higher rated units.
Depending on the condition of the units replaced they are either refurbished and relocated to another site or stored as spare units.
Circuit Breakers
There are three main types of high voltage circuit breakers in use on TransGrid’s network, air blast, small oil volume and SF6.
Both the air blast and small oil volume circuit breakers are now considered to be obsolete technology due to their complicated design
and the large numbers of parts that are no longer available. Maintenance costs for these two types of circuit breakers (including air
systems for air blast type) are high, and a substantial level of maintenance knowledge and effort are required to ensure continued
reliability of the circuit breakers.
Poor performance on air blast and small oil volume circuit breakers usually relates to timing problems with the breakers operating
either slowly or with greater than acceptable phase discrepancies. CIGRE statistics indicate an expected economic life of circuit
breakers to be within the range 25 to 35 years and this is consistent with TransGrid’s service experience.
Subject to an economic evaluation in each case, a program of phasing out of air blast and small oil volume (SOV) circuit breakers
within TransGrid commenced in 1995. In particular there are specific strategies for replacement of the following circuit breakers.
72
Type and make of Circuit Breaker Voltage Project Time Frame
Although modern SF6 circuit breakers have proven to be reliable and need minimum maintenance, early generation SF6 circuit
breakers supplied between 1975 and 1987 suffer from type faults leading to corrosion and SF6 gas leaks. Refurbishment programs
have commenced to rectify these problems.
Switching of large shunt capacitor banks can result in transient voltage disturbances that impact on the performance of end use
customer equipment. To minimise voltage disturbances point-on-wave switching technology is to be incorporated into the circuit
breaker design at a number of locations.
On-line continuous condition monitoring systems have recently become available to monitor circuit breakers and a program has
commenced to assess the effectiveness of these different systems.
Instrument Transformers
TransGrid’s instrument transformer maintenance policy provides for regular inspection and testing to detect any units that may need
specific attention.
Replacement of instrument transformers is generally carried out based on condition monitoring results of the insulation system. For
current transformers oil samples and dissolved gas analysis has been the most commonly used monitoring method.
On-line condition monitoring devices have been used by TransGrid on capacitor voltage transformers for some time, where a voltage
unbalance alarm indicates a potentially faulty unit and, if confirmed, the unit is replaced. Similar devices are now being considered to
continuously monitor current transformers within a switchyard.
Synchronous Condensers
The two Synchronous Condensers at Sydney South substation have been in service since 1962 and have progressively undergone
major refurbishment. Both units require extensive maintenance to keep them operational and both units will require further major
refurbishment work over the five years in order to maintain acceptable levels of operational performance.
Details of the proposed work to be performed on both units are summarised in the following table.
Refurbish Starting Transformer, Phase Isolated Bus and Hydrogen Storage Facilities 2002-2003
73
However, the recent decision to replace both of these synchronous condensers with the modern alternative of Static Var
Compensators by 2003 will significantly affect and possibly cancel any proposed refurbishment work unless considered urgent.
Issues relating to the electronic control systems in the Kemps Creek SVCs have resulted in a shortage of available spare parts
that restrict the full operation of both units. The manufacturer has indicated that the control technology used on these SVCs is
now outdated and future availability of spare parts is not assured. Consequently proposed upgrading of the Kemps Creek SVCs’
Control Systems is scheduled from 2002.
Detailed investigations during 1995/96, involving the manufacturer confirmed that the condition of the equipment is quite good.
An assessment of spare parts required to ensure the long term performance of this equipment up to 2006 has been performed
and procurement action initiated. Refurbishment of existing Circuit Breakers and Gas Chambers is scheduled for 2003–2006 after
the commissioning of the new substation at Haymarket.
Shunt Capacitors
TransGrid has 77 shunt capacitor bank installations of various configurations ranging in voltage from 11kV to 330kV. All PCB
filled capacitors have been replaced and it is for this reason that the majority (90%) of existing capacitors have been
manufactured and installed since 1980.
Unlike most other items of electrical equipment the condition of power capacitors cannot be monitored and hence the estimated life of
these capacitors is expected to be between 25 to 35 years. Therefore existing capacitor banks are expected to be replaced because of
normal ageing factors from about 2010 at the rate of 100MVAr per year. This does not impact on the period of this Plan.
One of the Non-PCB fluids introduced in 1980 was the chemical "Dow C4" and at present 24 capacitor banks contain this fluid (total of
985MVAr). Environmental regulations are now becoming apparent that this fluid requires similar handling and disposal methods as that
developed for PCB. Hence significant expenditure is required to dispose of any failed Dow C4 capacitors. A major replacement / disposal
program for these Dow C4 capacitor banks may commence from approximately 2010 and could take up to ten years to complete.
All of TransGrid’s batteries except at two sites are of the Nickel Cadmium type. The two exceptions are presently Lead Acid type
and are due for replacement within the next 5 years.
All existing batteries are in good condition with regular maintenance and condition checks being carried out. The batteries are
replaced when their capacity drops below 70% and this generally occurs after 20 years into their life. Battery chargers are
normally replaced when spare parts are no longer available.
Surge Arresters
The maintenance of surge arresters is usually carried out when the associated equipment is removed from service which is
generally a 4 yearly cycle. Whilst testing for moisture ingress can be carried out economically, testing for block deterioration can
prove to be expensive.
Due to the possibility of the older surge arresters requiring more frequent testing and the impact that such a program would have
both economically and in terms of availability, a replacement program for arresters over 35 years of age has been initiated. This
program will commence with the replacement of all "gapped" silicon carbide units still in service.
74
Bushings
TransGrid has a bushing population of approximately 1685 bushings. They are predominantly installed in transformers and
reactors and are the means by which a HV conductor passes through earthed metal work. All HV bushings are of a condenser
construction and generally take one of the following forms: Oil impregnated paper; Resin bonded paper (SRBP); Resin
impregnated paper.
As is the case with any solid or liquid insulation, aging and degradation of insulating properties will occur as a result of
prolonged electrical, thermal and mechanical stresses and it is these factors that will generally determine the life expectancy of
bushings. Generally a service life of 30 years could be expected from bushings provided other factors do not come into play.
SRBP bushings by the nature of their manufacture have a much higher level of failure than the other types as a result of
delamination of the layers and void formation.
Bushing failures often have far reaching effects that extend beyond the loss of bushing itself as often a failure may lead to the
loss of a transformer through fire.
Maintenance on bushings is generally integrated into the transformer maintenance and involves the measurement of DDF via a
test point located on the flange. Where no such test point exists assessment of the bushings condition becomes difficult unless it
is removed from the transformer.
Control Systems
By 2002-3, the Yass 330kV substation will need to undergo a major refurbishment of its control and alarm schemes including the
replacement of most of its switchyard cabling. Depending on the technology adopted, this replacement work may also include all
the protection and metering schemes. However, more recent plans for Yass now indicate that the complete substation may need
to be replaced by 2004-2005 and therefore any proposed refurbishing work will be cancelled.
The techniques and refurbishing methods proposed for Yass will now be considered for other 330kV substations such as Sydney
South by 2004 and Sydney West, Sydney North, Canberra and Dapto in future years.
2. Transmission Lines
Routine Maintenance
A routine maintenance strategy is in place to ensure that all transmission line structures are regularly inspected. The inspections
aim to detect likely component aging or defects such that remedial work can be undertaken to ensure no loss of supply will
occur. The location of the assets, past performance and the material or form of construction determines the inspection intervals.
Inspection cycles have been reviewed and categorised into maintenance regimes based on past performance, current condition
and line importance. All transmission lines are visually inspected at least once per year.
75
A summary of maintenance requirements is shown in the table below:
Steel Tower, Steel Pole & Concrete Pole High Annual Ground Patrol
Annual Aerial Patrol
10 yearly Detailed Aerial Patrol
Non-Routine Maintenance
A major facet of the non-routine maintenance is easement vegetation control where growth rates of plants and trees are largely a
function of climatic conditions and as such cannot be predicted very far in advance. Where necessary suitable access to the lines
is provided and maintained.
In some instances type defects, such as insulator degradation, can be identified and extra resources channelled to determine the
extent of the problem or to apply corrective action.
A number of current minor issues and their strategies are shown below.
Insulators
Where problems are identified with insulators, or where insulators are in excess of 25 years old, batches of that type of insulator
are taken out of service for testing. Should testing confirm a type problem then a strategy is developed to deal with it. Conversely,
if the problem is an isolated one, then a watching brief will be maintained on that type of equipment.
Galvanised steel earthwire close to marine or industrial environments suffers from accelerated corrosion. Amongst the most
susceptible are the lines between Sydney and Dapto, which are showing significant, pitting of the steel strands. Replacement is
programmed for completion by the end of 2001.
76
Vibration Dampers
Some 132 kV lines were originally installed without vibration dampers. Fatigue of strands has occurred due to the lack of
damping capability on the spans, which in some cases has lead to the conductor failure. A strategy has been developed whereby
all remaining undamped lines are fitted with dampers in accordance with current design practice.
Wood Poles
Wood poles are generally replaced following detection of significant defects during routine maintenance. In the past less than 1%
of the pole population has been replaced each year. However, the defect rate is anticipated to increase to 4% over the next ten
years as the wood poles reach their average life expectancy. A strategy has been established to replace wood poles with steel or
concrete poles which will reduce the anticipated ‘peak’ in replacement rates and provide infrastructure with low maintenance and
long life. Significant rot has been identified in poles on several lines requiring considerably higher replacement rates and these
lines are programmed to be the first in the replacement strategy.
A number of issues have arisen with respect to these structures including pole rot occurring behind the jointing cylinder. A
strategy has been implemented to replace these structures at high-risk locations. A progressive program is to be undertaken to
rebuild these lines to steel or concrete construction as their condition warrants.
Grillage Foundations
Early practice in steel tower construction, particularly where access was difficult, was to place a steel quadraped on the bottom of
each tower leg and back fill with earth. Over time the reaction of the acids in the soil have slowly corroded the zinc coating and
now the steel of many towers. Early strategies here have focussed on encasing the leg with concrete to prevent further corrosion.
A more cost effective and quicker method using sacrificial anodes has been developed to protect the remaining steel of the tower
foundations. All applicable steel towers are expected to be treated by 2003.
Concrete Poles
Corrosion of the steel reinforcing in concrete poles has been noticed in areas with high water tables of high saline content.
A small number of existing poles will need to be replaced within the next 10 years.
3. Underground Cables
The 330kV Sydney South – Beaconsfield West Cable 41 circuit was commissioned in 1979. The cable and cable accessories
were manufactured and installed by Sumitomo/Japan under Contract 2609 (Mitsui). This is currently TransGrid’s only high
voltage cable (outside substation boundaries), until the commissioning of the next 330kV cable 42 from Sydney South to the new
substation at Haymarket in late 2003.
Routine Maintenance
Routine maintenance is carried out in accordance with the TransGrid Underground Cable Maintenance Policy. The principles
involved include:
77
The frequencies of these activities are set out in the Policy.
Non-Routine Maintenance
Due to the nature and location of the underground cable in public roads and footways, various defect repairs and modifications
not covered by Routine Maintenance are carried out. These need to be assessed on a case-by-case basis.
• Increased loading, particularly during summer days, has meant that currently applied cyclic ratings are being reached on a
number of occasions. In addition, contingency considerations mean that the ability to obtain outages on other critical items of
plant in the Sydney area is becoming increasingly limited;
• Investigations by TransGrid have identified the capacity for safely increasing the rating of the cable under a number of
operating conditions; and
• Recent information on the thermal impact of deeply buried sections of cable has identified the potential for "hot spots" in the
cable that could accelerate cable paper deterioration at these locations and affect long-term cable reliability.
Preliminary assessments have indicated that the maximum operational benefit and risk control will be obtained by the
implementation of a real-time cable rating system. This system is designed to measure cable sheath and soil temperatures at a
number of critical locations and to compute normal and emergency cable ratings available in real time. This work is expected to
be completed by 2003.
• Increase the surplus oil volume in the cable oil system to improve cable security;
• Replace or refurbish oil pressure gauges;
• Evaluate differential pressure gauges, and if successful implement a differential (phase to phase comparison) pressure alarm
system which is expected to be considerably more sensitive than the current system;
• Overhaul pressure alarm switches.
Civil Works
The civil structures associated with the Cable 41 circuit are beginning to deteriorate. Remedial work is necessary to prevent more
extensive damage resulting from the problems being neglected.
78
4. Protection Schemes
Routine Maintenance
The routine maintenance policy determines the frequency and extent of maintenance required for a given relay type. A summary
is given in the table below.
Distance System critical and relay not self-checking 6 yearly full routine maintenance
3 yearly performance check
Annual in-service auto-reclose checks (for circuits with intertrips)
Non-Routine Maintenance
Relays used for the protection system are inspected and tested on a routine basis and where failures or problems are found an
investigation is carried out. Subject to the results of such investigations, relays are either replaced, modified or placed under a
"watching brief".
In the short term (five years), the above programs form the initial steps in the replacement of selected relay types on the Network.
These programs will be supplemented by relay replacements using the criteria for selection as detailed in the 30 year strategy.
In the long term (five to thirty years) relay performance will need to be assessed using certain criteria before being considered
suitable for replacement. Such criteria will include on a priority basis :
1) Relay age.
2) Relay failure rates – includes history of particular relay maloperations and the impact on system performance.
3) Relay location and criticality in the Network – includes speed and performance of relays and their "fitness for purpose".
4) The ability to repair a relay and the cost of repair.
5) Relay routine and fault maintenance costs.
To allow a projection for the number of replacement schemes to be developed, the following assumptions have been made:
• All main protection relays will be progressively replaced over a 20 year period.
(The main reasons being to improve the reliability of protection relays, the ability to remotely interrogate relays as to their
status and reduced maintenance requirements)
• The relays would be replaced on a priority basis according to the five criteria identified above.
• Existing relays not targeted for replacement in the period 2000 to 2010 continue to perform satisfactorily.
• Appropriate resources are available to perform replacement programs.
• The expected life of new relays is estimated at between 15-20 years.
• Repair is possible of these new relays during their 15 to 20 year lifetime.
79
With consideration given to these assumptions and TransGrid’s existing relay population, estimates for the replacement program
have been developed. These estimates are based on the following action plan:
• Relays currently 20 years of age and older will be progressively replaced in the period 2000-2010.
• Relays currently younger than 20 years of age will be replaced during the period 2010-2020.
• These new relays will themselves need replacement from about 15 years of age.
• Overcurrent relays are included in primary relay replacement.
• To improve fault recorder data, a trial of GPS equipment has commenced to provide a synchronised time base;
• Trial remote interrogation of some modern types of protection relays;
• Installation of a modern fault location unit which uses the travelling wave principle;
• Further development of newer testing methods, which incorporate scheme testing rather than individual relay tests, will
improve maintenance techniques and reduce operating costs.
5. Metering Installations
Routine Maintenance
TransGrid is a registered Metering Provider under the National Electricity Market Code of Conduct, qualified to design, install,
maintain and repair revenue metering. All metering at transmission network connection points is installed and maintained to
Code requirements.
Non-Routine Maintenance
Metering installations are under constant performance review to ensure their compliance with the accuracy requirements of the
Code. As problems are identified they are promptly fixed to ensure accurate metering is always available to both the National
Electricity Market Management Company and to Customers.
Regulated metering equipment will typically include transducers and statistical meters providing operational and network
planning data. Unregulated metering equipment generally includes revenue (including check) meters and RIMs used to collect
metering data for the settlement of the National Electricity Market.
Strategies for replacing unregulated metering equipment will largely be determined by the financially responsible customer and
are therefore beyond the scope of this document.
Traditionally, the replacement of metering equipment has largely been driven by two main criteria :
1) The inability to repair ageing equipment that has failed in service due to lack of spares and support from the manufacturer.
2) The need to keep up to date with technological developments and the utilisation of these advances in the most efficient manner.
In the short term (five years) a replacement program for regulated metering equipment should be implemented with age being the
primary factor in deciding what equipment is to be changed.
80
In the long term (five to thirty years) equipment performance will need to be assessed before a decision can be made on
replacement strategies. Such criteria for assessment will include:
1) Age.
2) Failure rates.
3) The ability to repair the equipment and the cost of repair. (Dependent upon the availability of spares and manufacturer support).
4) Suitability of existing metering equipment to system requirements.
• All main meter types will be progressively replaced over a 20 year period.
• The meters will be replaced on a priority basis according to the four criteria identified above.
• Existing meters not targeted for replacement in the period 2000 to 2010 will continue to perform satisfactorily for their intended purpose.
• Appropriate resources are available to perform replacement programs.
• The expected life of new meters and their suitability (fitness for purpose) is estimated at between 15-20 years.
With consideration given to these assumptions and TransGrid’s existing metering population, estimates for the replacement
program have been developed. These estimates are based on the following action plan:
• Meters currently 20 years of age and older will be progressively replaced in the period 2000-2010.
• Meters currently younger than 20 years of age will be replaced during the period 2010-2020.
• These new meters will themselves need replacement from about 15 years of age.
The estimated number of replacements shown above should only serve as a guide as the actual replacement of meters is the
prerogative of TransGrid's customers and not subject to TransGrid determination. It should also be noted that the RIM and
transducer replacements may not eventuate as these functions may become integrated into replacement meter and protection
relay devices.
6. Communications
Routine Maintenance
Routine maintenance is carried out where appropriate to ensure reliable performance of communication systems.
A summary of some of the key routine maintenance periods is shown in the table below:
VF Intertrips 3 yearly
81
Non-Routine Maintenance
Non-routine maintenance is carried out as required in order to achieve a communication systems availability target of 99.5%.
Fault repair and equipment and replacement is priorities with regard to the severity and impact of the fault.
Bay Alarms
A replacement program is currently under way to provide improved performance on Bay Alarm Systems. The replacement system
is designed to increase performance and provide remote interrogation facilities.
The current systems have a high failure rate, insufficient spare parts and is obsolete technology
A new system has been developed and replacement for 20 sites will be complete at the end of 2000 – 2001 financial year. All
remaining Bay Alarm Systems are to be replaced from 2001 - 2004 at the rate of 40 per year and again from 2020 – 2025. Due to
changes in technology the initial replacement system is to be a microprocessor-based system that provides remote interrogation
and control facilities.
All 3 Rate and 5 Rate Alarm Systems have been identified for replacement. The main reasons for replacement are deteriorating
performance, reliability with age, the inability to obtain suitable spare parts and the limited capacity of the systems.
A new system has been developed named SMART Alarm that will provide a 10-function alarm service in both transmit and
receive directions. This system has an expected life of 20 years. The replacement of existing alarm equipment has commenced
and is expected to be complete by 2005, at the rate of 30 per year.
The total population of Power Line Carrier Systems were manufactured by Fujitsu Denso prior to 1985 and are no longer
supported or built.
With several new substations being built new suppliers are being evaluated to provide systems for current and future needs. A
program is currently being developed to utilise the systems for new installations.
Existing PLC are expected to be replaced because of normal ageing factors from about 2001 at the rate of 10 to 15 systems per year.
All existing PLC equipment was manufactured by Fujitsu Denso and is no longer supported by the supplier.
With several new substations being built new suppliers are being evaluated to provide systems for current and future needs. A
program is currently being developed to utilise the systems for new installations.
At present there is no evidence that existing PLC Intertrip systems will experience failures and there is adequate spares to
maintain all systems. Without the support of the manufacturer these systems are expected to be replaced from about 2003 at the
rate of 5 systems per year.
82
VF Protection Intertrip Systems
There are two main types of Voice Frequency Protection Intertrip Systems in use on TransGrid’s network, Fuji VF Intertrip
Systems and Dewar VF Intertrip Systems.
The Fuji VF systems were manufactured prior to 1987 and are no longer supported by the supplier.
Dewar VF Intertrip Systems have replaced Fuji System over the past 5 years. A replacement program for the 16 Fuji TFCRE1
systems has been developed and will be complete by 2003 at a cost of $200,000.
At present there is no evidence that existing Fuji VF Intertrip systems will experience failures and there is adequate spares to
maintain all systems. Without the support of the manufacturer these systems are expected to be replaced from about 2004 – 2020
at the rate of 20 systems per year, which will cost approximately $200,000 per year.
Dewar VF systems are currently supported by the manufacturer with an expected life of 25 years. These systems are expected to
be replaced from about 2020 – 2025 at the rate of 6 systems per year.
Telephone Equipment
The telephone network was installed in two parts. In 1990-1992 the major sites were completed and in 1994 exchanges in the 330kv
substations were installed. Ericsson manufactured the entire network with software upgrades to selected sites occurring in the late 1990’s.
The large network requires constant maintenance to achieve a reliable system performance.
The manufacturer no longer supports the software versions that enable the exchanges to function and an evaluation has
determined that a system software upgrade to BC10 is the most effective action. This uograde will take place in FY 2001/02.
AWA 6 ends. No longer supported by the manufacturer, minimal spares, 1.5 to 2Ghz band
NEC500 4 ends. Minimal spares, no manufacturer support and outdated technology.
NEC 600 6 ends. spares, no manufacturer support and limited bandwidth.
SAIE 2 ends. Minimal spares and manufacturer support
Harris Farinon 2 ends. Adequate spares but no manufacturer support
Seimens 2 ends. Adequate spares and manufacturer support
This equipment is to be purchased and installed by December 2001. The expected life of the equipment is 20 to 25 years. This
life cycle is determined by technological changes.
83
The fixed repeaters and links consist of
1. Philips 814 Tranceivers. This equipment was manufactured in the early 1980s and is no longer supported by the manufacturer.
Current spares are at minimal levels and will be depleted by 2002.
2. Midland Tranceivers. This equipment was manufactured in 1997 and is supported by Exicom and is expected to provide
service till the year 2020.
The mobile fleet and desk base stations are Tait 2000 series transceivers. This equipment was manufactured in the early 1990s is
supported by Tait. Current spares are adequate to continue services till 2015.
The Philips FM814s will be replaced progressively with TAIT 2000 series equipment, commencing in 2001 and proceding at the
rate of 10 per year.
• Batteries: Batteries at each site have a life of approximately 20 years and are replaced as and when
required.
• Battery Chargers: Chargers at each site range between 12v, 24v or 50v. They have a life of approximately 30
years and are replaced as and when required.
• Air Conditioners: Air Conditioners at each site are either wall mount or split unit. These units run continuous for
24 hours a day. The life cycle is 5 to 10 years determined by location. They are replaced as and
when required.
• Aerial Feeders and Antennae: Feeders and antennae provide transmission medium for Microwave and VHF services. The life
cycle is 10 to 20 years determined by location. They are replaced as and when required or
when systems are replaced.
• Cabling: Cabling consists of power, alarm and service wiring. Location and possible rodent damage
determine the cabling life cycle. They are replaced as and when required
SCADA Outstations
TransGrid’s current DAC outstations provide the local interface at each substation to the SCADA network. These outstations are
not being replaced under the ABB SCADA replacement contract.
The outstations were manufactured in the early 1980s and are approximately 20 years old. The manufacturer no longer supports
this equipment. Sufficient spare cards exist but individual components are no longer manufactured.
There are 46 TransGrid Toshiba outstations, 21 TransGrid MITS outstations, 19 Customer Toshiba outstations and 3 Customer
MITS outstations. All of these outstations will be replaced over the next 5 year at the rate of 15 per year, after an initial trial to
confirm the process and materials..
84
7. Environmental Strategies
TransGrid’s Environmental Plan describes the elements of its Environmental Management System and the Business Units
responsible for those elements, while TransGrid’s Environmental Manual describes the procedures and practices involved.
Native trees and shrubs are planted around substations, to promote native species and reduce the visual impact of substations.
Noise emissions from transformers are reduced by construction of suitable enclosures or walls where necessary. A program for
replacing air-blast circuit breakers with quieter SF6 circuit breakers is in place.
TransGrid substations are designed and sited to minimise their impact on the environment. All sites have environmental
response systems designed to ensure that, in the event of equipment failure, the surrounding environment is unaffected. Major
oil-filled plant, such as transformers, is located within bunds. Secondary, and on some sites tertiary oil containment systems are
installed, to prevent the escape of oil from the substation to the surrounding environment.
An environmental impact statement is prepared, which assesses all the known possible environmental impacts of the construction
and the operation of the line following construction. The statement is publicly exhibited and submissions from interested parties
are encouraged. A program for managing construction and maintenance of the line following construction is then implemented,
based on the findings of the Environmental Impact Statement and submissions received.
Procedures for maintenance of transmission line easements have been developed with the aim of minimising environmental
impacts. Low growing native shrubs and trees are encouraged on easements.
A database is used to assist with easement maintenance. It contains all relevant environmental information about each easement,
including the location of rare and threatened flora and fauna species and habitats, protected lands and rivers, archaeological
relics, heritage sites and property owner requirements.
Environmental Initiatives
TransGrid is involved in a number of environmental projects.
TransGrid sponsors nine shade-houses throughout NSW, as part of Rotary’s "Trees for 2000" program. Local school children
raise native seedling in the shade-houses. Landcare groups plant the seedling in places needing vegetation.
TransGrid is also providing sponsorship for Greening Australia’s "Corridors of Green" and "Greengird" projects. TransGrid’s
contribution has helped provide 1,000 trees for planting by school children along the Barton Highway between Yass and
Canberra. Property owners, local Landcare and community groups in Yass area are involved in the "Greengrid" project, planting
trees and shrubs to enhance the local environment and augment the habitat of the Superb Parrot.
The Illawarra Greenhood Orchid, Pterostylis gibbosa, is a rare and endangered species of plant, found near Lake Illawarra.
TransGrid, together with the National Parks and Wildlife Service, the University of Wollongong and the Wollongong Native Orchid
Society, is protecting and preserving the Orchid and its habitat.
TransGrid is the sponsor of the Kooragang Wetlands Rehabilitation Project, in the Newcastle area. A new visitors centre shows
the importance of Coastal Wetlands to the local environment.
TransGrid has joined the Greenhouse Challenge, a joint initiative developed by industry and the Federal Government, to
encourage organisations to reduce emission of greenhouse gasses. TransGrid has identified a number initiatives that will be
undertaken as part of the program, including reducing usage of paper products, minimising energy use where possible and
promoting tree-planting. A co-operative agreement will detail TransGrid’s commitment to implementing the initiative. Each year,
TransGrid will report its progress to the Australian Greenhouse Office.
85
4.4 Asset Disposal Strategies
4.4.1 Introduction
Assets are of value to TransGrid only in so much as they continue to cost effectively support the delivery of the required service. Once
these assets no longer provide the required level of service their worth lies only in the benefits to be gained from their disposal.
Asset disposal is therefore the final stage in the asset life cycle and its proper planning and management is an integral part of
TransGrid’s Network Management Plan.
TransGrid’s Asset Disposal Strategies mainly encompass two broad types of assets. The first involves real property holdings and
the second involves general assets such as buildings, structures, plant and equipment.
Although real property assets normally have high values and their disposal often involves more complex planning and financial
issues, the general disposal processes followed within TransGrid are very similar to the disposal of all other types assets.
Therefore this Section of the Asset Management Plan outlines these general disposal strategies.
TransGrid’s Asset Disposal Planning involves a detailed assessment of those assets identified in the Planning/Capital Investment
Strategies and Asset Management Strategies that are no longer required, or no longer effectively meet their service delivery
outputs at the lowest long term cost to TransGrid. This allows TransGrid to cull redundant assets that might otherwise reduce
efficient and effective service delivery.
Once an asset is identified as surplus, its physical disposal will depend on one or more of the following:
• whether or not there are net disposal benefits to TransGrid, either in financial or other terms such as management, supervision
and storage,
• whether or not there are secondary (non core) service obligations associated with the asset which dictate its retention, for
example heritage, open space or other social environmental considerations,
• whether or not disposal can be carried out without adverse impacts on the physical environment,
• compliance with any Legislative requirements such as for Asbestos and Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCBs),
• whenever considered likely that some under-utilised or surplus assets may be of significant value to other agencies such as
NSW Electrical Distributors, such agencies are advised of the asset’s availability.
TransGrid’s Asset Disposal Strategy Process is a structured and systematic process aimed at ensuring the asset portfolio
comprises only of assets that effectively meet their service delivery requirements at the lowest long term cost. The processes
involved are therefore directly linked with TransGrid’s Service Delivery Strategies, TransGrid’s Planning/Capital Investment
Strategies and TransGrid’s Asset Management Strategies.
86
The Disposal Strategy has five discrete stages, the main aspects of which as are follows:
Stage 1 - Assess in detail those assets identified by the Planning/Capital Investment and Asset Management Strategies as being
Surplus to service delivery requirements.
Stage 2 - Assess the advantages or otherwise to TransGrid, TransGrid’s Shareholders or the Community in divesting the Surplus assets.
Stage 4 - Identify related disposal requirements (auction, tender, private treaty or scrap) and processes including probity requirements.
Stage 5 - Prepare and implement appropriate Disposal Plan that satisfies all safety and environmental requirements.
The majority of TransGrid’s aged Surplus assets are normally scrapped or sold for material salvage and depending on the
materials used in the design and construction of the assets a number of procedures have been established to facilitate this
process. Many of these processes are contained within TransGrid’s Waste Management standard.
TransGrid’s waste management procedures have been established in accordance with both NSW and Australian legislation
requirements including the NSW Protection of the Environment (Operations) Act 1997 and the Waste Minimisation and
Management Act, 1995. This involves the appropriate disposal methods for various waste and materials, the licensing of
TransGrid sites and facilities and direct dealings with the Environmental Protection Authority.
Within TransGrid, specific asset disposal strategies concerning certain types of materials include the following:
i) Owners of PCB contaminated materials must carry out a survey by 1st January 1999 to identify items of equipment and
articles containing PCB. TransGrid has basically completed this task.
ii) Concentrated PCB material (i.e. PCB greater than 10%) must be removed from priority areas within 2 years of completing the
survey, and from other than priority areas within 5 years of completing the survey. TransGrid completed the removal and
destruction of all concentrated PCB materials (1,155 tonnes) by January 1999 at a cost of $5.7M.
iii) Scheduled PCB material (i.e. PCB greater than 50 ppm) must be removed from service, or processed in-situ to reduce the
PCB concentration below 50 ppm, within 5 years of identification. For TransGrid, this requires that scheduled PCBs must be
either removed from service or processed by 2004 and strategies are in place to replace meet this requirement.
iv) Non-scheduled PCB materials (i.e. PCB less than 50 ppm) are not required to be removed from service within any legislative
time-frame, however once removed from service appropriate disposal methods are required. Since 1999 TransGrid has
disposed of 211 tonnes of non-scheduled material at a cost of $626,000
Disposal of Chemical Fluid Dow C4
One of the Non-PCB fluids introduced for Power Capacitors in 1980 was the chemical "Dow C4" and within TransGrid 24
capacitor banks contain this fluid (total of 985MVAr). This fluid requires special precautions for safe handling and paper
disposal. Hence significant expenditure is being incurred at the moment to dispose of any failed Dow C4 capacitors.
However, from approximately 2010 a number of these Dow C4 filled capacitor banks will be approaching the end of their expected
life span. A Disposal Strategy will need to be developed as the replacement program could take up to ten years to complete and
require significant resources. This aspect does not impact on the period of this Plan.
87
Disposal of Batteries
TransGrid has quantities of large station and communication batteries that comprise of Lead Acid or Ni-Cad. These batteries
have a normal life span of approximately 20 years and their retirement is determined by the Maintenance Battery Policy and
Battery Maintenance Procedures.
Disposal of Ni-Cad and Lead Acid batteries is a requirement of TransGrid’s Procurement Specification for Batteries and thus
forms part of the contract. The old Ni-Cad cells are returned to Australian manufacturer’s works for shipment overseas for
recycling while the Lead Acid units are recycled within Australia. The whole operation is carried out in accordance with the
relevant dangerous goods and environmental regulations.
88
Appendices
89
Appendices
A Corporate Policies
Environment
Total Quality
B Asset Inventory
C Resource Plans
90
Appendix A - Corporate Policies
Demonstration of our on-going commitment to the health and safety of employees, contractors and visitors is through
compliance with and external certification to AS 4801. TransGrid will consult with elected employee health and safety
representatives and employees in any workplace change that will affect the health and safety of employees, and to ensure
continuous improvement in all areas of our work.
RESPONSIBILITY: TransGrid’s Board and Executive are ultimately accountable and responsible for the Health and Safety of employees,
visitors, contractors and the public, and for legislative OHS compliance. In particular, the following responsibilities apply:
• Provision of information, training and supervision to ensure employees and contractors are able to carry out their work safely
• Implementation of relevant actions from their business unit Health and Safety Plan to meet agreed performance targets
• Ensuring their own safety and the safety of others in the workplace by following defined occupational health and safety policies
and procedures and avoiding "at risk" behaviour in all activities
• Working with Management to prevent injury and illness
• Reporting all accidents, incidents and potential hazardous conditions to their Team
• Leader immediately they become aware of them.
GD HS G1 001
91
Environment Policy
The Protection of our environment is one of the fundamental values associated with all TransGrid activities. The TransGrid
Environmental Policy applies to both the natural environment and items of Environmental Heritage. This includes those
buildings, works, relics or places of historical, scientific, cultural, social, archeological, natural or aesthetic significance.
The policy applies to the design, siting, construction, maintenance, operation, decommissioning and disposal of all buildings,
plant and equipment, including transmission lines and cable easements.
TransGrid teams:
• Take active measures to protect the environment during all work activities;
• Consult with appropriate community organisations and government departments; and
• Are trained and regularly updated on environmental issues relating to their particular work requirements.
Protection of the environment is the responsibility of all TransGrid staff. TransGrid will continually improve environmental
performance through the setting of targets and regular environmental auditing.
92
Total Quality Policy
TransGrid's objectives are to provide a safe, reliable, environmentally effective and economic bulk electricity network service to
our customers and the community. To achieve these objectives we will:
Leadership at all levels is critical to our success; as is the fundamental concept of continual improvement in all products,
processes and systems.
Demonstration of our on-going commitment to quality is through compliance with, and external certification to ISO9001.
GD QA G1 002 Revision 2
93
Appendix B - Asset Inventory
94
Transgrid System Transformers
95
Substation Volts MVA Phases Manufacturer Contract Date Qty
96
Circuit Breakers
Type Manufacturer Type Voltage (kV) Quantity First Install date Last Install Date
Total 498
Type Manufacturer Type Voltage (kV) Quantity First Install date Last Install Date
TOTAL 49
97
Type Manufacturer Type Voltage (kV) Quantity First Install date Last Install Date
TOTAL 566
Type Manufacturer Type Voltage (kV) Quantity First Install date Last Install Date
TOTAL 63
Type Manufacturer Type Voltage (kV) Quantity First Install date Last Install Date
TOTAL 4
98
Transmission Lines and Underground Cables
99
Circuit No. From (Site 1) To (site 2) Length (km) Predominant Construction
100
Circuit No. From (Site 1) To (site 2) Length (km) Predominant Construction
In Service at 66 kV:
81Y MT PIPER MT PIPER 132 1.06
875 GUNNEDAH TAMWORTH 132 64.9 Single Circuit Wood Pole
102
Appendix C
103