Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
GOVERNMENT OF KERALA |
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
Table of Contents
Glossary 2
Introduction 3
Global Scenario 4
Kerala Scenario 5
Goal 6
Guiding Values and Principles 6
Objectives 8
Palliative Care at the Primary Level 9
Palliative Care at the Secondary Level 9
Palliative Care at the Tertiary Level 9
Training and Capacity Building 10
Citizen Education 10
Access to opioids and other essential medicines and supplies relevant to Palliative
Care 11
Role of Non-Governmental Organizations and Community Based Organizations. 11
Role of Local Governments 12
Role of Private Hospitals 12
Role of AYUSH 12
Special focus on Vulnerable Population 13
Livelihoods. 13
Documentation and Research 13
Monitoring and Evaluation 14
Specialization in Palliative Care 14
Institution of Excellence in Palliative Care 14
Palliative Care Grid 15
Targets 15
Financing 22
Implementation of the policy 22
1
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
Glossary
AYUSH Ayurveda, Yoga, Unani, Siddha and Homeopathy
2
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
Introduction
In much of history, the reduction of suffering was at the core of medicine. As medical
science evolved and better diagnostic and treatment modalities became available, the
focus shifted to successful treatment and cure of diseases and illnesses. While this
benefitted humankind in countless ways, paradoxically, there has been unintended
neglect and marginalization of palliating health-related suffering 1. In order to
address this, now there is a need for special attention and action.
The World Health Organization (WHO), in 2002, defined Palliative Care as “an
approach that improves the quality of life of patients and their families facing
the problems associated with life-threatening illness, through the prevention and
relief of suffering by means of early identification and impeccable assessment and
treatment of pain and other problems, physical, psychosocial and spiritual” 2.
The Lancet Commission Report on Palliative Care (2017) has widened the scope and
considers Palliative Care as “an essential component of comprehensive care for
persons with complex chronic or acute, life-threatening, or life-limiting health
conditions that should be practiced by all health-care and social care providers and
by palliative care specialists, and that can be provided in any health-care setting,
including patients’ own homes” 3. The Commission particularly highlights the
special needs and requirements of children who are in need of Palliative Care.
Palliative Care aims at reducing Serious Health-related Suffering that is, suffering
associated with illness or injury of any kind and which cannot be relieved without
special interventions failing which it impairs physical, social and emotional
1
Krakauer, To Be Freed from the Infirmities of Age.Subjectivity, Life-Sustaining Treatment and Pallaitive
Medicine.; Gawande, Being Mortal. Medicine and What Matters in the End.
2
“WHO | WHO Definition of Palliative Care.”
3
Knaul et al., “Alleviating the Access Abyss in Palliative Care and Pain Relief—an Imperative of Universal Health
Coverage.”
3
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
Palliative Care is now seen from a human rights perspective as an integral part of the
right to enjoy the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health4 . The
UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights states that it is critical to
provide “attention and care for chronically and terminally ill persons, sparing them
avoidable pain and enabling them to die with dignity”.
Global Scenario
Goal No. 3 of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) calls for the attainment of
Universal Health Coverage (UHC) 5. UHC by definition is about providing access to
all people to promotive, preventive, curative, rehabilitative and palliative health
care as per need and of sufficient quality to be effective, while also guaranteeing that
the use of these services does not expose them or their families to financial
hardships6. This makes Palliative Care an integral part of Universal Health Coverage
without which the goal of Universal Health Coverage cannot be attained.
The Astana Declaration of 2018 reiterates this by stating that it aims to “prioritize
disease prevention and health promotion and will aim to meet all people’s health
needs across the life course through comprehensive preventive, promotive,
curative, rehabilitative services and palliative care” 7.
The global community has the responsibility to “close the abyss in the relief of pain
and other types of suffering throughout the life course and at end-of-life, caused by
4
Brennen, “Palliative Care as an International Human Right”; United Nations, “International Covenant on
Economic, Social and Cultuural Rights.”
5
“The Sustainable Development Agenda - United Nations Sustainable Development.”
6
WHO, “What Is Universal Coverage?”
7
WHO, Declaration of Astana.
4
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
life-limiting and life-threatening health conditions” 8. Barriers that exist to the access
of palliative care include the focus on cure and extending life, opiophobia, limited
patient advocacy and the focus on existing measures of health outcomes that give
little weight to interventions that alleviate suffering and increase dignity particularly
at the end of life 9.
In 2015, 45% of all global deaths (25.5 million of 56.2 million deaths) involved
serious health related suffering. 80% of all deaths with serious health related
suffering were from developing countries and the vast majority of these countries
lacked access to palliative care services. 2.5 million children died with SHS in 2015
and 98% of these deaths were from developing countries. In high-income countries,
children account for only 1% of all deaths with SHS whereas in developing countries
children form 30% of deaths with SHS 10.
Diseases that cause SHS in the developing world include malignant neoplasm’s(26%),
cerebrovascular diseases(17%), lung diseases (11%), Injuries (6%), Tuberculosis (6%),
premature birth and trauma (5%), HIV (5%), Liver disease (5%), Non Ischemic Heart
Disease (4%), Dementia (4%). 11% of the SHS were from other diseases 11.
Kerala Scenario
Kerala has been acknowledged as a successful model, not only in India but in the
entire developing world, through its path-breaking work in Community Based
Palliative Care 12. The ‘Quality of Death’ study by Economist Intelligence Unit states
8
Knaul et al., “Alleviating the Access Abyss in Palliative Care and Pain Relief—an Imperative of Universal Health
Coverage.”
9
MD Magazine, “Why Are We Still Talking about Opiophobia?”
10
Knaul et al., “Alleviating the Access Abyss in Palliative Care and Pain Relief—an Imperative of Universal
Health Coverage.”
11
Knaul et al.
12
Hockley, Froggatt, and Heirmerl, Participatory Research in Palliative Care: Actions and Reflections - Oxford
Scholarship; Bollini, Venkateshwaran, and Sureshkumar, “(18) (PDF) Palliative Care in Kerala, India.”
5
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
that ‘amid the lamentably poor access to palliative care across India, the southern
state of Kerala stands out as a beacon of hope 13. The Palliative Care movement in
Kerala began with the Pain and Palliative Care Society in Kerala and quickly grew
with the formation of the Neighbourhood Networks in Palliative Care (NNPCs) 14
providing home-based palliative care. NNPC is aimed at motivating and capacitating
local communities to look after chronically ill and dying patients in their
neighbourhoods.
The Palliative Care movement in Kerala which had its roots in NGO action soon
attracted a high level of political ownership. Kerala declared Palliative Care Policy in 2008.
Realizing the necessity to modify the Palliative Care Policy incorporating the existing
situation, discussions was held among the experts from different sectors and a new
comprehensive Palliative Care Policy is being formulated. Local governments and over
350 non-government and community-based organizations are now providing
Palliative Care services, largely home-based. The Kerala Model places a strong
emphasis on community participation and volunteerism integrated with Primary
Health Care system especially through dedicated nurses under the overall leadership
of local governments.
Goal
The Goal of the Policy is to ensure that every person in Kerala has access to effective
palliative care services of good quality with a focus on community-supported home-
based care without getting exposed to hardships- financial, social or personal.
13
The Economist, “The Quality of Death-Ranking End of Life Care across the World.”
14
Kumar and Numpeli, “Neighborhood Network in Palliative Care.”
6
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
2. Universality
No one who requires palliative care would be left behind. The Antyodaya approach
would be followed to ensure the poorest and weakest person is reached first.
3. Integration
Palliative Care would be mainstreamed in all disciplines of medicine. It will be fully
integrated into the health care system and will not be seen as a standalone activity.
4. Multi-Sectoral Approach
The multi-sectoral approach would be followed to converge different services and
resources of palliative care involving the relevant departments especially Health and
Family Welfare, AYUSH, Education, Local Self Government, Social Justice, Youth
Affairs, Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe Development, Revenue and Home,
coordinated by the local governments at the field level.The government will involve
private, not-for-profit and NGOs and CBOs in ensuring palliative care services to the
community
7. Ethics
Highest standards of ethics would be ensured in the field of Palliative Care with a
published Code.
10
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
8. Accountability
A bouquet of accountability measures would be put in place to ensure total
transparency. Accountability to the community will be promoted through community
involvement and ownership in the program.
9. Continuum of Care
Palliative care will be provided across the course of the suffering with definite roles
for all levels of healthcare – community-based, primary, secondary and tertiary-
public and private.
11. Convergence
All relevant programmes of the central, state and local governments would be
converged to enhance the coverage and quality of palliative care.
10
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
Objectives
1. To ensure that every needy patient gets the required palliative care in
appropriate quantity and quality within a reasonable time with an emphasis on
home-based care with no one left behind.
2. To enhance the capability of the health system to meet the palliative care
requirements of the state.
3. To build the capacity of all the stakeholders to equip them to perform the tasks
required to achieve universal palliative care.
4. To improve access to essential medicines needed for pain and palliative care
including the required controlled medicines while putting in place strict
measures to prevent inappropriate and non-medical use.
5. To develop a functional partnership with NGOs and CBOs and also hospitals
outside the government sector to expand the service provision in palliative care
6. To develop capacity for documentation, research and development.
7. To develop medical colleges as centers of excellence in palliative care.
8. To put in place support systems to achieve the above objectives to ensure
sustainability.
10
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
10
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
training for various stakeholders. Doctors and other health personnel working in
primary, secondary and tertiary levels would be given mandatory training according
to a training calendar for which they would be deputed before the start of the
financial year. Refresher courses would be regularly conducted at periodic intervals
for those who have been trained. All elected heads of local governments and
members of the health standing committees would be trained on different aspects of
Palliative Care. Similarly, training would be conducted for NGOs and CBOs working
in the area to develop their capacity for service delivery and training. The
Government would also provide training free of cost to the staff of the hospitals in
the private sector which volunteer to join the Palliative Care programme.
Sensitization training would be organized for students in schools and colleges and for
interested citizens.
High-quality handbooks would be prepared for different stakeholders. Also, distance
learning would be facilitated through Certificate and Diploma courses. A knowledge
portal would be developed.
Citizen Education
In order to sensitize citizens, the following steps would be taken
1. Training sessions for High School and Higher Secondary School and colleges
including professional colleges students with home visits as part of
community outreach.
2. Practical training for National Cadet Corps (NCC), and Student Police Cadets
and all NSS volunteers.
3. Promotion of students palliative care Units in all educational institutions.
4. Sensitization training for all Neighbourhood Groups of Kudumbasree, other
Self Help Groups and Residents Associations.
5. Introduction of a module in all programmes of the State Literacy Mission.
6. Sensitization training for Youth Clubs, village libraries and other social
groups.
In addition, conventional and social media would be widely utilized to highlight the
importance of Palliative Care.
11
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
The government would facilitate the development of capacity of NGOs and CBOs to
initiate and upgrade primary, secondary and tertiary programmes.
12
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
Role of AYUSH
The Department of AYUSH would come out with a plan of action for providing
palliative care through their institutions in consonance with the general parameters
of this policy including quality assurance, procurement and distribution of medicine.
be emphasized.
Livelihoods.
Efforts would be taken to ensure the socio-economic rehabilitation and promotion of
livelihoods of people with debilitating illnesses. Such persons will be provided the
requisite skills and raw materials for taking up livelihood related activities. Local
governments would provide avenues for marketing the products of such enterprises
including quality assurance and branding in association with Kudumbasree, NGOs
and CBOs with such competence. Appropriate support systems will be developed at
local level to take care of the well-being of dependents of those persons who are on
palliative care.
14
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
15
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
advocacy agent for mainstreaming palliative care in the health system all over. It will
also identify national and international practices for suitable adaptation.
Palliative care grid will enable the continuum of care of patients across various levels
of the health system. The Grid will exist as an omnichannel portal being largely
hosted online while ensuring that measures are in place to ensure that people who do
not have access to the internet are included in the network.
Targets
By the end of the First year
1. To develop training facilities in the state so as to provide high-quality
training in palliative care across the state.
1.1. To accredit and recognize existing training centres based on common
standards.
1.2. To develop at least one government training centre in each district in
the state for advanced training in palliative medicine and nursing
satisfying minimum standards covering doctors, nurses and other
health professionals.
16
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
17
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
18
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
3.3. Ensuring at least 10-day training for a minimum of one doctor and
ensure the access of morphine and other essential drugs in all major
hospitals, all Community Health Centres (CHCs)
3.4. Ensure the access of morphine and other essential drugs in all Primary
Health Centres/ Family Health Centres where a trained doctor is
available.
3.5. Ensuring proper documentation is kept in accordance with the
Narcotics Amendment Act 2014 when morphine or opioids are stocked
by issuing a clear set of instructions.
4. To develop palliative care services at the tertiary care level both within the
government sector as well as the private sector as detailed below.
4.1. Establishment of Division of Palliative Care in all Government Medical
Colleges and 25% private medical colleges consisting of existing staff
including for one doctor each from as many of the following
departments preferably on a voluntary basis. (Anesthesia, Internal
Medicine, Community Medicine, Radiation Oncology, PMR,
Gynecology, Pediatrics, General Surgery, Family Medicine and any
other relevant clinical departments)
4.2. In-Hospital Consultation facilities by the Division of Palliative Care in
the current ward of the patient.
4.3. Palliative Care Out-patient Departments to be set up by the Division of
Palliative Care at a site preferably outside the Department of Oncology
to facilitate the access by non-cancer patients with Serious Health-
Related Suffering.
4.4. Palliative Care Home Visits on a regular basis with the objective of
improving patient care and to improve medical and nursing student
learning outcomes.
4.5. Effective follow-up post-discharge of the patient needing palliative care
services, integrating with the existing primary palliative care system
including home visits.
19
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
20
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
21
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
9. To develop palliative care services at the tertiary care level both within the
government sector as well as the private sector as detailed below.
9.1. Strengthening Palliative Care divisions in Medical colleges
9.2. To develop dedicated beds for patients with serious illness related
suffering in all wards of medical colleges, general hospitals, district and
taluk hospitals with attendant facilities with privacy, provision for
family support and appropriate furniture andequipment.
9.3. To develop management protocols for serious health-related suffering
in the emergency department / Intensive Care Unit and any other
areas.
10. To facilitate socio-economic rehabilitation of patients with a debilitating
illness
10.1. To create a registration system to identify all patients who require
rehabilitation support eg patients with hemiplegia, quadriplegia and
other debilitating conditions.
10.2. To provide skill development of such patients or immediate caregivers
of such patients.
10.3. To provide a consistent supply of quality raw materials that are needed
for producing goods.
10.4. To create a common branding for goods made by disabled persons/
caregivers and set mechanisms for quality check of those goods
10.5. To provide avenues for the sale of goods made by disabled persons/
caregivers.
10.6. To facilitate tie-up with corporates/marketing agencies for
marketing/promotion of these goods.
10.7. To promote the use of such quality tested goods at government
institutions through appropriate purchase preference.
22
Kerala State Palliative Care Policy 2019
11. To set up monitoring committees to oversee activities and ensure compliance
to policy
11.1. Creation of common online reporting system for activities conducted by
primary, secondary and tertiary hospital level – public and private.
11.2. The regular meeting of the local government level monitoring committee
once every month with the presentation of indicators.
11.3. The regular meeting of the District level monitoring committee once in
three months with the presentation of indicators.
11.4. Regular meeting of the State level monitoring committee once in six
months with the presentation of indicators.
11.5. To create provisions for external evaluation of the model by a top institute
in the country.
11.6. Regular Social Audits once a year at the local government
11.7. External general Social Audit once in five years by renowned social
auditors using rigorous methodology suitable for large scale Social Audits.
Financing
Palliative care services should be financed as follows: one-third of the recurring cost
through state government and local governments, one-third through contributions
from corporates & philanthropists, and remaining one-third by way of voluntary
service. There shall be a definite budget item for the programme in the state budget.
Local governments should pool resources from various sources to finance palliative
care services.
23