Pioneer Shipping LTD V BTP Tioxide LTD (1982
Pioneer Shipping LTD V BTP Tioxide LTD (1982
Pioneer Shipping LTD V BTP Tioxide LTD (1982
Court: HL
obviously wrong, the judge had been wrong to grant leave to appeal. (ii) On the true construction of the
charterparty as varied by the addenda, the voyages for the 1979 and 1980 seasons were separate and
distinct adventures, since the performance of the one was not dependent on the performance of the other.
Treating the voyages for the 1979 season as a separate adventure, the arbitrator was justified on the facts
and correct in law in holding that the 1979 adventure was frustrated. The appeal would be dismissed.
Case History
Annotations Case Name Citations Court Date
[1982] AC 724, [1981]
2 All ER 1030, [1981] 3
WLR 292, [1980-84]
Pioneer Shipping Ltd CaseSearch
— LRC (Comm) 391, HL 16/07/1981
v BTP Tioxide Ltd Entry
[1981] 2 Lloyd's Rep
239, [1981] Com LR
197, 125 Sol Jo 542
[1980] QB 547, [1980]
3 All ER 117, [1980] 3
Pioneer Shipping Ltd CaseSearch
Affirming WLR 326, [1980] 2 CACivD 22/05/1980
v BTP Tioxide Ltd Entry
Lloyd's Rep 339, 124
Sol Jo 428
BTP Tioxide Ltd v
Pioneer Shipping Ltd CaseSearch
Reversing [1980] 2 Lloyd's Rep 83 QBD circa 1980
and Armada Marine Entry
SA, The Nema
(Nov)
[2010] EWHC 3302
(Comm), [2011] 2 All
ER (Comm) 935, [2011]
A v B (Arbitration: Comml CaseSearch
Considered Bus LR 1020, [2011] 1 16/12/2010
Security) Ct Entry
Lloyd's Rep 363, [2011]
NLJR 174, [2011] All
ER (D) 184 (Jan)
Sylvia Shipping Co [2010] EWHC 542
Ltd v Progress Bulk (Comm), [2010] 2 Comml CaseSearch
Considered 18/03/2010
Carriers Ltd (The Lloyd's Rep 81, [2010] Ct Entry
Sylvia) All ER (D) 184 (Mar)
[1991] 2 QB 139,
[1991] 2 All ER 110,
Geogas SA v Trammo [1991] 2 WLR 794, CaseSearch
Considered CACivD 14/11/1990
Gas Ltd, The Baleares [1991] 1 Lloyd's Rep Entry
349, (1990) Times, 26
November
[1990] Ch 709, [1990] 1
All ER 730, [1990] 2
WLR 108, 134 Sol Jo
Ipswich Borough CaseSearch
Applied 517, [1990] 1 EGLR 17, CACivD 24/11/1989
Council v Fisons plc Entry
[1990] 04 EG 127,
(1989) Times, 13
December
[1987] QB 650, [1986]
3 All ER 737, [1986] 3
Aden Refinery Co Ltd
WLR 949, [1986] 2
v Ugland Management CaseSearch
Considered Lloyd's Rep 336, 130 CACivD 31/07/1986
Co Ltd, The Ugland Entry
Sol Jo 861, [1986] LS
Obo One
Gaz R 1089, [1986]
NLJ Rep 1089
[1986] Ch 500, [1986] 2
All ER 858, [1986] 3
WLR 80, 53 P & CR
Lucas Industries plc v 198, 130 Sol Jo 483,
CaseSearch
Distinguished Welsh Development [1986] 1 EGLR 147, ChD 21/03/1986
Entry
Agency [1986] LS Gaz R 1902,
[1986] NLJ Rep 560,
278 Estates Gazette
878
[1986] Ch 500, [1986] 2
All ER 858, [1986] 3
WLR 80, 53 P & CR
Lucas Industries plc v 198, 130 Sol Jo 483,
CaseSearch
Considered Welsh Development [1986] 1 EGLR 147, ChD 21/03/1986
Entry
Agency [1986] LS Gaz R 1902,
[1986] NLJ Rep 560,
278 Estates Gazette
878
[1985] 2 All ER 817,
National Westminster
[1985] 1 WLR 1123n,
Bank plc v Arthur CaseSearch
Distinguished 129 Sol Jo 638, [1985] CACivD 13/06/1985
Young McClelland Entry
2 EGLR 13, 275
Moores & Co (a firm)
Estates Gazette 717
Page 4
Document information
Court
House of Lords
Judgment date
16/07/1981