FENET
FENET
Mekonnen Mehertu
ID No. GSE/398/12
An individual investor has Birr 70,000 to divide among several investments. The alternative investments
are municipal bonds with an 8.5% return, certificates of deposits with a 10% return, Treasury bill with a
6.5% return, and income bonds with a 13% return. The amount of time until maturity is the same for
each alternative. However, each investment alternative has a different perceived risk to the investor;
thus it is advisable to diversify. The investor wants to know how much to invest in each alternative in
order to maximize the return. The following guidelines have been established for diversifying the
investment and lessening the risk perceived by the investor.
2. The amount invested in certificates of deposit should not exceed the amount invested in other three
alternatives.
3. At least 30% of the investment should be in treasury bills and certificates of deposits.
4. The ratio of the amount invested in municipal bonds to the amount invested in treasury bills should
not exceed one to three.
Required:
A sale manager has to assign salesmen to four territories. He has four candidates of varying
experience and capabilities and assesses the possible profit for each salesman in each territory
as given below. Find the assignment which maximizes profit?
Salesmen Territories
A B C D
1 35 27 28 37
2 28 34 29 40
3 35 24 32 33
4 24 32 25 82
Solution since it is a maximization problem we first subtract each of the entries in the table from the
latgest one which equals 82 here
A B C D
1 47 55 54 45 45
2 54 48 53 42 42
3 47 58 50 49 47
4 58 50 57 0 0
Now we proceed as
Subtract value in each raw from every value in the raw. So the result will be
salesman Territory
A B C D
1 2 10 9 0
2 12 6 11 0
3 0 11 3 2
4 58 50 57 0
Column mini 0 6 3 0
Next subtract minimum value in each column in reduced cost from the above table then ew get
salesman Territories
A B C D
1 2 4 6 0
2 12 0 8 0
3 0 5 0 2
4 58 44 54 0
Since the number of aligned line raw and column are not we drew another ratable by finding unoccupied
column and from this column takes the list valued and ad to the intersection number and subtract from
unoccupied one. Finally we gate
salesman Territories
A B C D
1 2 4 0 0
2 12 0 2 0
3 0 11 0 8
4 58 44 48 0
Hence territories have been on zero elements C1,B2,A3 D4
Question 4
Peniel House and Furniture manufacturer produces two products: Beds and Chairs. Each unit of
Bed requires 3 hrs in molding unit, 4hrs in painting unit, and 1 hr in finishing. On the other hand,
each unit of Chair requires 3 hrs in molding unit, 2 hrs in the paint shop and 2 hours in finishing.
Each week, there are 210 hrs available in molding, 200hrs in painting, and 120 hrs in finishing
unit. The demand for Beds cannot exceed 40 units per week. Each unit of Bed contributes Birr
20 to profit, while each unit of chair contributes Birr 30. Determine the number of units of each
product per week to maximize the profit? (Use Graphic Method to solve the given LP problem).
Solution
Resource Beds Chair Maximum Available
Molding Unit 3 3 210
Painting Unit 4 2 200
Finishing Unit 1 2 120
Maximum Demand 40 Unlimited
Profit for each products 20 30
LP Model
Let X1 and X2 be the number of Beds and Chairs Respectively
Let the weekly profit be Z. Then. we must
MaxZ=20X1+30X2
Subject to
3X1+3X2≤210Molding Constraint
4X1+2X2≤200painting Constraint
X1+2X2≤120 Finishing Constraint
X1≤40 Demand Constraint
Plot the constraints (0.100) x2
3x1+3x2≤210 molding constraint (0.70)
3x1+3x2=210
If x1=0 D(0.60)
⇒3x1+3x2=210 C(80/3,140/3)
⇒3(0)+3x2=210
⇒x2=7 B(40,20)
The coordinates (0,70) FEASIBL x1+2x2≤120
If x2=0 REGION
⇒3x1+3(0)=210
⇒x1=70 (40,0) A (50,0) (70,0) (120,0) x1
The coordinates (70,0)
X1≤40
⇒painting constraint 4x1+2x2≤200 4x1+2x2≤200 3x1+3x2≤210
4x1+2x2=200
If x1=0
⇒x2=100, the coordinates (0,100) and if x2=0 ⇒x1=50, the coordinates (50,0)
⇒finishing constraint
X4+2x2≤120
X1+2x2=120 if x1=0⇒x2=60, the coordinates (60,0) And if
x2=0⇒x1=120,
x1=120, the coordinates (120,0)
1 2 3 4 5
corner Constraints Coordinates Objective function
points intersected X1 X2 20x1+30x2
A Demand 40 0 800
B Demand and painting 40 20 1400
C Painting and finishing 80/3 140/3 5800/3
D Finishing 0 60 1800
The maximum value of the objective function is 5800/3. Therefor the optimum solution is found
at the corner point C, where constraint painting and finishing are intersected. Hence optimal
solution x1=80/3, x2=140/3
Question 5
Construct the CPM network described by the following set of activities, compute the length of each path
in the network, and indicate the critical path.
1–2 4
1–3 7
2–4 8
2–5 3
3–5 9
4–5 5
4–6 2
5–6 6
3–6 5
Answer
Construct the CPM network described by the following set of activities
4 3
2
8 5 5 6
1 4 2
7 3 9 6
5
Question 6
A firm plans to purchase at least 200 quintals of scrap containing high metal quality metal X and
low quality metal Y. It decides that the scrap to be purchased must contain at least 100 quintals
of X-metal and not more than 35 quintals of Y-metal. The firm can purchase the scrap from two
suppliers ( A and B) in unlimited quantities. The percentage of X and Y metals in terms of weight
in the scrap supplied by A and B is given below.
Metals Supplier A Supplier B
X 25% 75%
Y 10% 20%
The price of A’s scrap is Birr 200 per quintal and that of B is Birr 400 per quintal. The firm wants to
determine the quantities that it should buy from the two suppliers so that total cost is minimized? (Use
graphic approach)
Solution
LP Model
Let x3 and x2 be the number if high metal quality and low metal quality respecti
respectively.
vely.
Let the minimum cost be Z. then, we must
minZ=200x1+400x2
subject to
10%x1+20%x2≤35 quintal of metal y 25%
+75%x2≥100 quintal of metal B X1+x2≥200
quintals of metal Y and metal X
X1.x2≥0
(0,200)
X2
Plot the constraints
X1+x2≥200 quintals of metal Y&B (0,175)
X1+x2=200 C(50,150)
If x1=0
Feasible region
⇒(0)+x2=200
⇒x2=200 (0,400/3 25% x1+75%x2 ≥100
The coordinates (0,200) B(100,100)
If x=0 A(250,50)
⇒x-3(0)0200⇒x=200 A(200,0) (350,0) (400,0) x1
The coordinates (200,0) L2
L3 L1
1 2 3 4 5
corner Constraints Coordinates Objective function
points intersected X1 X2 200x1+400x2
A L1 AND L3 325 25 75000
B L1 AND L3 100 100 60000
C L1 AND L2 50 150 70000
The minimum value of the object function is 60000. therefore, the optimum solution is found at the
corner point B , where constraint L1 and L3 are intersected. Hence, optimal solution: x1=100,x2=100.
Question 7
Six salesmen are to be allocated to six sales regions so that the cost of allocati
allocation
on of the job will be
minimum. Each salesman is cable of doing the job at different
different costs in each region. The cost (in birr)
matrix is given below.
Region Salesmen
I II III IV V VI
A 15 35 0 25 10 45
B 40 5 45 20 15 20
C 25 60 10 65 25 10
D 25 20 35 10 25 60
E 30 70 40 5 40 50
F 10 25 30 40 50 15
The minimum value of each row is subtracted from elments in the row and show reduced
table as follows as below
Region Salesmen
I II III IV V VI
A 25 35 0 25 10 45
B 35 0 40 15 10 15
C 25 50 0 55 15 0
D 25 10 25 15 0 50
E 25 65 35 0 35 45
F 0 15 20 30 40 5
A. The minimum value of each column is subtracts from all elements in the columns an
d show reduced table as follows as below
Region Salesmen
I II III IV V VI
A 15 355 0 25 10 45
B 35 0 40 15 10 15
C 15 50 0 55 15 0
D 15 10 25 25 0 50
E 25 65 35 0 35 45
F 0 15 20 30 40 5
Since the number of lines covering all zeros 6 equal to the number of columns or rows, then the
allocation to give minimum cost are aiii, Bii,Ciii and Civ, Dv, Eiv, Fi
Then the minimum cost is 0+5+10+10+25+5+10=65
B.
Region Salesmen
I II III IV V VI
A 15 35 0 25 10 45
B 40 5 45 20 15 20
C 25 60 10 65 25 10
D 25 20 35 10 25 60
E 30 70 40 5 40 50
F 10 25 30 40 50 15
Since it is maximization problem we would first subtract each of the entries in the table
from the largest one which equals to 70. The result data are given below
Region Salesmen
I II III IV V VI
A 55 35 70 45 60 25
B 30 65 25 50 55 50
C 45 10 60 5 45 60
D 45 50 35 60 45 10
E 40 10 30 65 30 20
F 60 45 40 30 20 55
We will use the minimum value process subtract the least value in each row and column.
The reduced table as follows.
Region Salesmen
I II III IV V VI
A 30 10 45 20 35 0
B 5 40 0 25 30 25
C 40 50 55 0 40 55
D 35 40 25 50 40 0
E 30 0 20 55 20 10
F 40 25 20 10 0 35
The least value of the columns are all zero then the reduced table is the same as the
above table
Since the number of lines covering all zeros is equal to the number of columns or rows,
then the allocation to give earning are AVI, BIII, CVI, DVI, EII, FV
The maximum possible earning is 45+20+65+60+70=310 birr
Then the minimum cost is 0+5+10+10+25+5+10=65
Question 14
The owner of the Burger Doodle Restaurant is considering two ways to expand operations:
opening a drive-up window or serving breakfast. The increase in profits resulting from these
proposed expansions depends on whether a competitor opens a franchise down the street. The
possible Profits from each expansion in operations given both future competitive situations are
shown in the following payoff table.
Competitor
Decision Open Not Open
Drive-up window $-6,000 $20,000
Breakfast 4,000 8,000
Select the best decision using the following decision criteria.
a. Maximax
b. Maximin
c. Equally likely
d. Minimax regret
solution
A. The decision maker selects the decision that will result in the maximum from each rows
.
Decision Competitor
Open Not open Maximum row
The maximum of maximum row is 20000. Then the best decision from the above table is
drive up window
Decision Competitor
Decision Competitor
Open Not open average row
D..
Decision Competitor
Open Not open average row
Identify the best payoff in column and then subtracting each of the other values in the column from that
payoff. That is
Decision Competitor
Open Not open Maximum row
There for the minimum of maximum row is 0. Then the best decision is drive-up window
Question 15
Subject to:
5x1+ x2 > 10
X1, x2 > 0
Solution
The dual of a normal max problem is a normal min problem and vice versa. Then, yje dual of minimum is
the maximum. There for yhr dual of
Min Z=2x1+8x2 subject to; 5x1+x2≥ 10
2x1+2x2≥ 14
X1+4x2≥ 14
X1,x2≥ 0
X1+2x2+4x3≤ 8
X1.x2.x3≥ 0
X1+2x2+4x3+s2=8
X1.x2.x3≥ 0
Initial feasible solution if x1=0,x2=0,x3=0 then s2=2 and ifx1=0,x2=0,x3=0 then s2=8
Basic Cj 10 14 14 0 0 quantity
variable X1 X2 X3 S1 S2
S1 0 5 2 1 1 0 2/2=1
S2 0 1 2 4 0 1 8/2=4
Zj 0 0 0 0 0 0
Cj-zj 10 14 11 0 0 0
Pivot element pivot column pivot row
The row cj-zj the largest value is 14 at the column of x2 and x3. Then we take at a column of x2 and the
smallest rati
ratio
o1
Table
Table 1
Divided all element of R1 by 2 to change pivot element into one and R2=R2-2R1 we get the following
table
Basic Cj 10 14 14 0 0 quantity
variable
X1 X2 X3 S1 S2
X2 14 5/2 1 1/2 ½ 0 1/1/2=2
S2 0 -4 0 3 -1 1 6/3=2
Zj 35 14 7 7 0 14
Cj-zj 25 0 7 -7 0 14
pivot column Pivot element pivot row
Divide all elements of pivot row by 3 to change pivot element into one and R1=R1-1/2R2 then, we get
the following table
Basic Cj 10 14 14 0 0 quantity
variable
X1 X2 X3 S1 S2
From the above table the cj-zj row elements are negati
negative
ve and zero then, minimum value at x1=0, x2=0
and x3=2 is 28
Question 18
An investor is considering investing in stock, real estate, or bonds under uncertain economic
conditions. The payoff table of returns for the investor’s decision situation is shown below
Economic Conditions
Investment Good Stable Poor
Solution
B. the maximum van be calculated from the given alternatives be finding maximum of
elements of each row from minimum of each element
From the minimum row column the maximum value is 4000, then the investment decided the best
decision is bond
C. the maximum decision states that the maximum value of each row
The maximum of maximum row from the above table is 10000. Thre for the best decision of the
investment is real state
D.
If a=0.3 then the optimism is 0.3 and 0.7 is pessimism, there for Hurwitz decision for each
investment can be calculated as follows
Stocks=0.3x7000+0.7x3000=4200
Bonds =0.3x4000+4000x0.7=4000
The maximum value of the result is 4200, then the best decision of the investment is stocks.
Second find the maximum value of each row and then finally find minimum of each maximum row. That
means the maximum value of each column respectively are 5000,10000,6000
The diff
difference
erence between the maximum value and each elements of columns are as follows
Question 26
A large steel manufacturing company has three options with regard to production. (i) Produce
commercially (ii) build pilot plant (iii) stop producing steel. The management has estimated that
their pilot plant, if built, has 0.8 chance of high yield and 0.2 chance of low-yield . if the pilot
plant does show a high yield , management assigns a probability of 0.75 that the commercial
plant will also have a high yield. If the pilot plant shows a low yield, there is only a 0.1 chance
that the commercial plant will show a high yield. Finally management best assessment of the
yield on a commercial-size plant without building a pilot plant first has a 0.6 chance of high
yield. A pilot plant will cost birr 300,000. The profit earned under high and low yield conditions
are birr 12000,000 and birr 1200,000 respectively. Find the optimum decision for the company?
Answer
EMV at Decision Node 1 = max (75,96,000, 76,80,000, 0)
Question 27
What is the role of decision making in operation research? Define scientific decision-making and
explain it affects
ffects operation research decisions.
Answer
Diff
Different
erent methods such as stimulation, queuing theory, game theory, mathematical &
network analysis which are part of operati
operation
on research are considered as major helpers
in the decision-
decision-making process. ... Effective
ffective Decisions Operati
Operation
on Research helps the
managers to make well-informed and effective
ffective decisions.
decisions.
Explain how and why operation research methods have been valuable in aiding executive
decision?
Operation research is an aid for the executive in making his/her decision bt
providing the needed quantitative information, based on scientific method
analysis.
Question 29
Explain approximation in operation research model. What are advantage and characteristics of a
good model?
A model in the sense used in OR is defined as representation of an actual or
situation
A model is constructed to analyze and understand the give system for the
purpose of improving its performance. The reliability of the solution obtained
from a model depends on the validity of the model in representing the system
under study. A model, allows the opportunity to examine the behavioral changes
of a system without disturbing the on-going operations
Advantages of model
Models in general are used as an aid for analyzing complex problem. However a
model can also serve other purposes as
Question 30
26. What are the situations where operation research techniques will be applicable?
Answer
Today,
Today, almost all fields of business and government utilizing the benefits of Operations
Research. There are voluminous of applications of Operations Research. Although it is
not feasible to cover all applications of O.R. in brie
brief. The following are the abbreviated
set of typical operations research applications to show how widely these techniques are
used today:
Accounting: Assigning audit teams effectively
ffectively Credit policy analysis Cash flow
planning Developing standard costs Establishing costs for by products Planning of
delinquent account strategy
Construction: Project scheduling, monitoring and control Determination of proper
work force Deployment of work force Allocation of resources to projects Facilities
Planning: Factory location and size decision Estimation of number of facilities
required Hospital planning Quantitative Techniques for Managers International
logistic system design Transportation loading and unloading Warehouse location
decision
Finance: Building cash management models Allocating capital among various
alternatives Building financial planning models Investment analysis Portf
Portfolio
olio analysis
Dividend policy making Manufacturing: Inventory control Marketing balance
projection Production scheduling Production smoothing
Marketing: Advertising budget allocation Product introduction timing Selection of
Product mix Deciding most effective
ffective packaging alternative Organizational Behavior /
Human Resources: Personnel planning Recruitment of employees Skill balancing
Training program scheduling Designing organizational structure more effectively
ffectively
Purchasing: Optimal buying Optimal reordering Materials transfer Research and
Question 31 For what type of business problems might game theory helpful?
A player is called a competitor. A strategy for a player is a plan which specifies his action
for every possible action of his opponent. In a two person game if player I has 'm'
strategies and player II has 'n' strategies then the game is said to be a m x n game. If the
number of strategies of the players is finite then the game is said to be a finite game. If
at least one of the players has in finite number of strategies, the game is said to be
infinite.
A game with two players wherein one person's gain is the loss of the other is call two
person zero sum game. The pay offs corresponding to various strategies of the players
are presented in a matrix called the game matrix.