St. Mary'S University School of Graduate Studies
St. Mary'S University School of Graduate Studies
MARY’S UNIVERSITY
SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES
BY
HENOK TILAHUN
ENROLMENT No: SGS/0016/2008A
JUNE, 2018
ADDIS ABABA,
ETHIOPIA
FACTORS AFFECTING EMPLOYEE TURNOVER INTENTION IN
DEVELOPMENT BANK OF ETHIOPIA
BY
HENOK TILAHUN
ENROLMENT No: SGS/0016/2008A
JUNE, 2018
ADDIS ABABA,
ETHIOPIA
ST. MARY’S UNIVERSITY
SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES
FACULTY OF BUSINESS
BY
HENOK TILAHUN
______________________________ ________________________
______________________________ ________________________
Advisor Signature
______________________________ ________________________
______________________________ ________________________
I, the undersigned, declare that this research paper is my original work, prepared under the
guidance and supervision of my advisor Abrarawu Chane (Phd.). All sources of materials used
for the thesis have been duly acknowledge .i further confirm that the thesis has not submitted
either in part or in full to any other higher learning institution for the purpose of earning any
degree.
I|P age
Endorsement
This thesis has been submitted to St. Mary’s University, School of Graduate Studies for
examination with my approval as a university advisor.
_________________________ ______________________
Advisor Signature
II | P a g e
Acknowledgements
First and foremost, I would like to express my highest gratitude to GOD for the blessing, love, -
opportunity, health and mercy for me to complete this thesis. In this valuable chance, I personally
would like to express my gratitude and appreciation to my advisor Abrarawu Chane (Phd.) for his
motivation, advice, support, and even remark that he had contributed towards the completion of
my paper. My special appreciation and heartily thankful to my wife, Biscut Tefferi, for her
support, insightful suggestions, and endless patience from the beginning of my paper towards the
end.
Lastly, I offer my regards and appreciation to all of those who supported me in any respect during
the completion of the project.
III | P a g e
Acronyms
IV | P a g e
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to identify factors contributing towards turnover intention in existing
employees of Development bank of Ethiopia. The turnover intention can be measured in the
aspect of personal factor, social and economic factor, job stress, working environment,
compensation salary Employee relationship with management and career growth. Primary data
were collected through the use of questionnaire to the bank employees. Around 264
questionnaires were distributed and almost all questionnaires were successfully collected from
the respondents. All the data was gathered from the respondents were analyzed using Statistical
Package for Social Science (SPSS) versions 20.0. Descriptive analysis technique is used to
identify the background of respondents in the aspect of age, gender, marital status, years of
experience, and qualification. The result of the study shows that there is a high dissatisfaction
with working environment and employee relationship with management compared to other
variables such as job stress, compensation salary and career growth. This study has played an
important role to identify variables or factors contributing towards employees’ turnover intention
in Development bank of Ethiopia and also identified few steps to reduce the problem of turnover
intention.
Key words
V|Page
Table of Contents
Declaration ....................................................................................................................................... I
Endorsement .................................................................................................................................... II
Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................................ III
Acronyms ...................................................................................................................................... IV
Abstract ........................................................................................................................................... V
Table of Contents .......................................................................................................................... VI
CHAPTER ONE .............................................................................................................................. 1
INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................ 1
1. Background of the study ........................................................................................................... 1
2. Statement of the Problem .......................................................................................................... 3
3. Basic Questions ......................................................................................................................... 4
4. Objectives of the Study ............................................................................................................. 4
5. Significance of the Study ............................................................................................................ 4
6. Scope of the Study (delimitation)................................................................................................ 5
7. Limitations ................................................................................................................................... 5
8. Definition of term ......................................................................................................................... 5
CHAPTER TWO.............................................................................................................................. 6
REVIEW OF RELATED LIRATURE ............................................................................................ 6
2.1 Empirical review ........................................................................................................................ 6
2.2 Theoretical review ...................................................................................................................... 7
2.2.1 Definitions of Turnover .............................................................................................. 7
2.2.1.1 Voluntary and involuntary employee turnover ............................................................. 7
2.2.2 Influencing Factors of Employee Turnover intention ................................................ 9
2.2.2.1 Personal Factors ............................................................................................................ 9
2.2.2.2 Organization and Work Factors .................................................................................... 9
2.2.2.3 Social and Economic Factors ........................................................................................ 9
2.2.2.4 Job Stress .................................................................................................................... 10
2.2.2.5 Compensation (Salary) ................................................................................................ 10
2.2.2.6 Employee relationship with management ................................................................... 11
VI | P a g e
2.2.2.7Career Growth .............................................................................................................. 11
2.2.2.8 Work Environment ...................................................................................................... 12
2.2.3 Measuring Turnover ................................................................................................. 12
2.2.4 Conceptual frame work of employee Turnover ....................................................... 12
2.2.5 Benefits of Turnover ................................................................................................ 14
2.2.6 Consequences of Turnover ....................................................................................... 14
CHAPTER THREE ........................................................................................................................ 15
RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY .......................................................................... 15
3.1 Research Design ....................................................................................................................... 15
3.2 Data Sources ............................................................................................................................. 15
3.3 Instruments of primary Data Collection ................................................................................... 15
3.3.1 Questionnaire survey ................................................................................................ 15
3.4 Population................................................................................................................................. 16
3.5 Sampling Techniques ............................................................................................................... 16
3.6 Method of Data analysis and instruments ................................................................................ 16
3.7 Ethical considerations .............................................................................................................. 17
CHAPTER FOUR .......................................................................................................................... 18
DATA PRESENTATION, ALYISIS, AND INTERPERETATION ............................................. 18
4.1 Demographic Characteristics of the respondents ..................................................................... 18
4.2 Data Analysis ........................................................................................................................... 20
CHAPTER FIVE ............................................................................................................................ 28
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMENDATION .......................................................... 28
5.3 Recommendations .................................................................................................................... 30
References ...................................................................................................................................... 32
Annex ............................................................................................................................................. 35
QUESTIONNAIRE ........................................................................................................................ 37
VII | P a g e
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
Employees are great assets for any service giving company in this world. Especially in a banking
sector it is impossible to meet company’s objective without retaining employees. In this context,
it is important to cite Andrew Carnegie, the famous industrialist of the 19th century, who
mentioned: “Take away my factories, my plants; take away my railroads, my ships, my
transportation, take away my money; strip me of all of these but leave me my key employees, and
in two or three years, I will have them all again” (Alkahtani, 2015).
The attraction and retention of high-quality employees is more important today than ever before.
A number of trends (globalization, increase in knowledge of the workers, accelerating rate of
technological advancement) make it vital that firms acquire and retain human capital. In human
resources context, turnover can be viewed as the rate at which an employer gains and misplaces
employees or how long employees tend to stay in a particular organization (Turner, 2010).
According to (Alkahtani , 2015), there are a number of reasons why turnover takes place. These
reasons may range from external environmental variables such as economy that affects the
business that in turn shapes the employment levels to organizational factors including types of
industry, types of occupation, size of organization, payment, supervisory levels, locations,
selection processes, work environment, work assignments, benefits, and promotions .The other
variables that affect employee turnover in organizations involve the individual’s work variables
such as , integrative variables like job satisfaction, pay, promotion and working condition and the
individual’s non-working factors such as family related factors.
In addition, demographic variables cannot be disregarded. Age, tenure, level of education, level
of income, job category, and gender have been proven to affect employee retention and have been
discovered to have established relationship with turnover. Among the above demographic factors,
age, tenure and income level were discovered to be negatively associated with turnover;
Page | 1
Level of education is positively related to turnover as employees with higher education levels
have higher tendency to quit. With regard to job category, non-managerial employees have higher
tendency to quit than managerial employees.
Furthermore, turnover of any company’s employees (especially key employees) comes with a
considerable yet underestimated cost. There are two kinds of costs associated with turnover,
visible and invisible costs.
Visible turnover costs include leave capitalization, recruitment costs, security clearance,
temporary worker costs, relocation costs, formal training costs and induction expenses.
In this study the researcher tried to address the issue of the current turn over intention challenge.
I.e. Development Bank of Ethiopia is losing its employees Due to the high expansion of banks
throughout the country; there is high demand in the market for those who have abundant skill.
The need of employees for better pay off also contributes for such challenges. This paper was
conducted in development bank of Ethiopia to investigate on the factors that affect employee
turnover intention.
Page | 2
2. Statement of the Problem
Labor turnover is threat to many organizations. Today, it has become a very serious issue for any
organization due to its negative effects on operation and performance of organizations. Therefore
labor turnover needs to be controlled basing to its malfunction cause factors. (Bangi, 2014).
Development Bank of Ethiopia is faced with a high rate of staff turnover each year and this leads
to poor employee performance which in turn has impact on organizational effectiveness. When
an employee leaves the organization the present employees have to fill the gap until a new
employee is appointed. Moreover, the bank spends lot of money on the recruitment and training
of new staff members each year due to high turnover rates.
A number of factors could contribute to the bank’s high employee turnover rate. To mention a
few, personal factors, social and economic factors, job stress, organization and work factors,
employee relationship with management, career Growth, and Compensation (salary),
Therefore this study was motivated by these factors to find out the reasons for employee turnover
in the bank.
Page | 3
3. Basic Questions
To find out the various variables affecting employee turnover intention in the bank.
To measure the impact of various independent variables (major determinants) on
employee turnover intention in the bank.
The results and findings of this research through the designated questionnaire will have the
following significance;
The study will help the management of the bank to see the major area that’s causing
turnover intention in the organization and make appropriate decision to address the
problems.
The study will create insights to the readers on the factors that affect employee turnover
intention in the bank
It would ease future researchers to identify in detail the employees’ perspective on
turnover intention.
It will help improve the benefits and welfare of the bank and hence further supports the
banking industry to revitalize their retention program.
Page | 4
6. Scope of the Study (delimitation)
Even though Development Bank of Ethiopia has many branches, the research has only been
conducted on the head office of the bank considering majority of the employees are located there.
Moreover, due to time and cost constraint, the research only covers voluntary turnover rather than
involuntary turnover.
7. Limitations
The assumptions of this study are based on the truthful responses of the participants to
the survey questions, as well as the accuracy of the information provided.
8. Definition of term
For clarity and understanding throughout this study the following term is defined.
Employee turnover: this term is used to describe the ending of a relationship between an
organization and a person who received monetary compensation from the organization.
Turnover intention: Turnover intention is defined as "a conscious and deliberate willingness to
leave the organization".
Page | 5
CHAPTER TWO
According to (Huselid, 1995) ,prior work has observed the determinants of both individual
employees’ departures and collective organizational turnover ,although most of the previous
work has focused on the former. For example perception of organizational culture, perception of
job security,the occurrenceof a union ,copmensation level,job satisfaction, organizational
tenure,demographic variable such as age,gender,education,organizational commitement,whether
a job meets an individual’s expectation or not were all predictive of employees’ turnover
Studying about factors affecting rate of turnover of MPOs (Medical promotion officer) Tanuir,
Shahind (2012) established that most of the employees are not satisfied with their jobs and not
motivated and for this turnover tendency is high. The MPOs are dissatisfied with their job
security, social status, work load, visit to retailers’ shop, sales target, no room for family, not
getting the retirement benefit and not getting the family insurance support.
A study by Asimah (2001) shows 70.8 % of the respondents said they were not satisfied with
their present motivation packages. Respondents strongly agreed that good manager-employee
relationship can cause core employee to be retained. About 81.2% of the respondents were not
satisfied with the mode of selection for training and development and has led to feeling of
inequity, de-motivation and labor turnover.
When looking at the study made by Asmamaw (2011) at MOFED, management of the
organization is not committed to provide everything that employees’ need for work. The study
shows that un attractive financial issues, poor management regarding performance based
promotion un-satisfying terminal and pension benefits and problem of the management in
providing clear path for employees to advance their career where highlighted as major factors
affecting employees’ turnover in the company. Given all the problems, employees stayed in the
organization because they do not have other alternative job and they clearly identify a mismatch
between the positions they hold and the skill and knowledge they have. Most employees of the
Page | 6
organization have no sense of belongingness to the organization so interpersonal relationship is
not healthy. Disciplinary measures of the organization are not properly laid-dawn. Supervision of
employees has not arranged flexible working condition. As the Ex-employees gained nothing
while they were in MOFED and most ex-employees believe in conducive working environment
of the organization. Thus most Ex-employees left the organization because of low salary scale
and other benefit packages.
Filipe F & Luis Borges (2012) defined turnover as the rotation of workers around the labor
markets; between firms, jobs and occupations; and between the states of employment.
According to Robbins (2003) turnover refers to the voluntary and involuntary permanent
withdrawal from an organization. Rion (2009) also defined employee turnover as a ratio
comparison of the number of employees an organization must replace in a given time period to
average number of total employees More over employee turnover does not only include the
voluntary termination of employment but also the involuntary termination of membership of an
organization .The researcher focused on voluntary turnover.
(Pietersen, 2014) Human capital has more mobility than any other asset. An organization will
only be able to sustain a competitive advantage if it manages employee mobility effectively.
Unfortunately, employee mobility cannot always be controlled by an organization. In this regards
employee turnover – (the voluntary or involuntary movement employees in an out of work
organizations) - is of key importance in talent management. It is therefore not surprising that the
management of employee turnover (voluntary as well as involuntary turnover) continues to be a
central concern in the management literature. It is a key concern for both profit and non-profit
organizations.
Page | 7
Voluntary employee turnover occurs when an employee leaves the organization with his own
will (due to job satisfaction, bad working condition etc.) when a better job opportunity presents
itself. It is true that high level of voluntary turnover is to be negative for the organizational
development .Some Scholars have identified that the major factors for voluntary turnover is job
satisfaction.
Voluntary turn over occurs when employees choose to leave his/her organization for whatever
reason at his /her own will (Dess and Shaw, 2001:446).If employees become dissatisfied with
their job, they can be motivated to search for another organization with better situation. The labor
market is also another factor for voluntary turnover to motivate employees and to find alternative
employment opportunities. If the labor market situation is not favorable, however, even if they
are dissatisfied with their jobs, they remain until another job is available (Meshane and Glinow,
2000).
Voluntary turnover is initiated by an employee and involuntary turnover by an employer.
Involuntary turnover also result from uncontrollable factors such as death and ill health.
Functional voluntary and involuntary turnover could benefit an organization. For example
employee turnover at subordinate organizational levels could be beneficial to banks because
advances in technology continue to reduce the need for lower level skills in the banking sector.
On the other hand, the need for non-manual, intermediate and high level skills as well as value-
adding competencies such as autonomy and discretion are on the rise in the banking sector.
Therefore, both voluntary and involuntary turnover could be dysfunctional if the result is a loss of
human capital. (Pietersen, 2014). Voluntary turnover could be either avoidable or unavoidable;
a. Avoidable Turnover
Avoidable turnover is something organiations can prevent by hiring ,evaluating and
motivating their employees more effctively (Sandra 2012).
b. Unavoidable Turnover
Unavoidable turnover resuls from life decisions that extend beyond an employer’s
control,such as decision to move to a new area or job transfer for a spouse (Sandra 2012).
Page | 8
2.2.2 Influencing Factors of Employee Turnover intention
The topic employee’s turnover is extensively studied with multiple perspectives and suggested a
variety of factors are the causes of turnover of an employee in an organization. Some factors are
demographics and some are biographic e.g. financial rewards, work environment, promotion,
emotion of employee’s self-accomplishment and self-recognition, over stress of employees etc.
nobody can deny the fact that demographic variables have constant positive or negative links
with turnover ratio like tenure, educational level, age, etc. (Ali , 2014)
Page | 9
2.2.2.4 Job Stress
High rates of mergers, acquisitions, increasing economic interdependence among countries due to
globalization, technological development, and restructuring have changed the organizational
work over the last few decades have resulted in time pressure, excessive work demand, role
conflicts, ergonomic insufficiencies and problematic customer relationship are causes of stress.
Also to be consider stress as an environmental stimulus to a person, or an oddity between
individual and environment. The experience of job related stress (job stress), the range factors
that lead to job related stress (stressors), lack of commitment in the organization; and job
dissatisfaction make employees to quit .(Shukla & Sinha,2013)
Page | 10
Flexibility in benefits package can enhance retention retention, as it creates responsivness to the
specific needs and circumstances of individual employees (Rampur,2009).
Employees always search for organizations that provide more benefits and compensation
package. Besides, compensation and lack of challenge and opportunity were the most common
factors in contemplating leaving the organization (Ramlall,2003). It also found that, unequal or
substandard wage structures that fall under salary and benefits category as a factor to leave the
organization .
In line with salary and benefit packages, assistance or voluntary benefits provided by the
organizations encourage employees to stay in the company (Rion,2009). Organizations also used
such assistance for creating good relationship in the organization with employees .
2.2.2.7Career Growth
Career progress creates stress on employee’s understanding of the worth of his or her career
prospects. Obstacles in career development can appear at any time during an employee’s
employment period which serves as source of stress for them. These stressing factors can include
an array of problems like being stuck at a position without any hopes of progress or threats of
downsizing. Career growth is much more important than salary in Europe or America but it is
counted equivalent to salary in Asian context. “Moving Up or Moving Out” counts career growth
as basic for turnover. High employee turnover could also be due to no potential opportunity for
advancements or promotions. Employees prefer other companies which may provide them with
higher posts and increased compensation packages. (Shukla & Sinha, 2013)
Page | 11
2.2.2.8 Work Environment
If working conditions are substandard or the workplace lacks important facilities such as proper
lighting, furniture, restrooms and other health and safety provisions, employees will not be
willing to put up with the inconvenience for long time. Organizational instability has been shown
to have a high degree of high turnover. Indications are that employees are more likely to stay
when there is a predictable work environment and vice versa. In organizations where there was a
high level of inefficiency there was also a high level of staff turnover. For employer losing a
single key worker the like hood of project success and investor confidence may significantly
reduce. Main causes of turnover are salary, working environment and security of job. Turnover
particularly arises from unhappiness from job place. In contrary employees are also pushed to
leave their current job due to the dissatisfaction in their present workplace.
Page | 12
Personal Factors
Social and
Economic
Factors
Job Stress
Organization and
Work environment
Factors
Turnover
Employee Intention Turnover
relationship with
management
Career
Growth
Compensation
(Salary)
Page | 13
2.2.5 Benefits of Turnover
According to Shumon (2012) ,”Sometimes employee turnover benefits organizations positively”.
This might happen when a poor performer is replaced by a more skilled employee and when a
retired employee replaced by a younger one.
He further said that labor turnover acts as an obstacle to increased productivity and efficiency, a
view maintained in more recent literature. For example, the issue of quality cannot be ignored
when dealing with employee turnover. Curtis and Wright (2001) stated that “high turnover can
damage factors such as quality and customer service which provide competitive advantage,
thereby inhibiting business growth or even causing a decline in the level of business”. It is often
said that the people who leave are those who are most talented (Hinkin & Tracey, 2000). The
issue of quality is highlighted when someone unfamiliar with the tasks takes on the vacant
position. It takes a long time to learn a new job and ranges from 54 to 80 days to reach an
acceptable level of competence (Hinkin& Tracey, 2000).
Page | 14
CHAPTER THREE
In general when we say research design and methodology, it means that the strategic decision
applied in designing and conducting the research study.
In order to obtain relevant data for this study, both primary and secondary source of data will be
considered. The researcher used secondary data sources to supplement data that are obtained
from primary data source. Secondary data sources are be collected from books, brushers, reports,
journals (articles) and internet. This data used to establish the theoretical framework and to
design questionnaire.
After ascertaining the reliability of the instruments, the researcher has proceed to administer the
area of the study. The questionnaires are collected by the researcher .the data collected are
computed with the use of computer, edited to minimize errors. Then data are grouped in to tables
and graphs.
In this study, structured and unstructured questionnaires has been used in data collection of the
researcher’s question. Most importantly; the questionnaires were carefully designed to avoid
responses that might be biased in favor of the study objectives. They were also prepared
according to the status of the targeted group. Questionnaire was chosen by the researcher because
of the following reasons: - it encouraged great honest, possibilities of enquiring absent attitude
Page | 15
and opinions; they could be written for specific purpose, within a short time, one could collect a
lot of information.
3.4 Population
The population of the study included the employees of Development Bank of Ethiopia in Head
office which count 782, the researcher choose head office because majority of the employees of
the bank are found at Head office. Also because of limitation on time and other resources
including finance.
A simple random sampling technique has been applied to obtain a representative sample of
respondents. In addition samples from the population are collected by applying lottery method.
The sample size is determined by using the formula developed by Yemane (1967) at a confidence
of 95%. The researcher used this formula because it is easily understandable and widely applied.
N=population size
E= level of precision
Both qualitative and quantitative approaches are used during the data analysis. Statistical Package
for Social Sciences (SPSS) is used in data analysis. In order to analyze the quantitative data
obtained through Questionnaire (Likert scale technique).
In addition the researcher used both quantitative qualitative research design using Descriptive
statics such as frequency counts , percentage charts and averages for structured item meaning are
contextualized ,interpreted and organized according to their sources .the collected data are
analyzed and discussed .
Page | 16
Descriptive statics analysis is applied for the presentation, interpretation and discussion parts on
various dimensions of the evaluation system. Frequency, tables, charts, graphs, figures and
percentages are used as appropriate to analyze, interpret, tabulate and present the results of the
study. The data that are gathered through and questionnaire are coded, entered in to computer and
are analyzed and presented in the form of charts, diagrams, and tables by using SPSS version 20.
In addition, questionnaires which are collected, they are checked for completeness.
Questionnaires which were blank or extensively incomplete are barred from processing. Then
later the gathered questionnaires are analyzed for validity and completeness
Concerning ethical consideration, an attempt are made to ensure all respondents to keep their
identity and respondents as confidential in order for all the information to be given with complete
confidence .The questionnaire are dispersed based on willingness of each respondents. In
addition, the purpose of the questionnaire and interview was clearly revealed.
Page | 17
CHAPTER FOUR
This chapter deals with data presentation ,analysis and interpretations of the analyzed data .It
includes two major analysis techniques .The first section presents demographic features of
respondents which are the subject of the study and the second section of the chapter discusses the
results and implications of the findings .
The demographic characteristics part of the questionnaire includes the personal futures like Age,
gender ,Educational qualifications ,working experience and marital status .The detail are as
follows ;
Widowed 2 0.8%
Total
Page | 18
4 Educational Certificate 0 0.0%
Qualification Diploma 6 2.3%
Degree 214 81.1%
Masters 44 16.7%
Degree
Above 0 0.0%
Masters
Degree
Total
5 Working Less than 1 0 0.0%
Experience year
1-2 years 61 23.1%
3-5 years 50 18.9%
6 years and 153 58.0%
above
Total
Item-1 demonstrations the respondents age and out of 265 respondents 54.9% fall under the age
26-35 followed by 18.6% within the age group of 18-25 with a percentage of 18.6%, then 12.1%
within the age group of 36-45, 9.1% within the age group of 46-55, and 5.3% above the age of
55. From this one can conclude that majority of the company’s employees are within the younger
age group this could be taken as an advantage of the company if managed well.
Item-2 shows gender arrangement and 52.3% of sampled employees are male and 47.7% are
female. From this, it’s possible to conclude that the outcome of the research fairly represents the
employees’ view.
Item-3 of the table points out the marital status of the respondents. Accordingly, 65.2% of the
respondents are single and 31.1%.
Item-4 of the table is about the educational qualification of the respondents .Based on the data,
majority of the respondents, which is 81.1% are first degree holders followed by 16.7% second
degree holders and 2.3% are diploma holders .There were no respondents who are PhD holders.
Page | 19
Based on the evidence provided, it could be inferred that majority of the company’s labor force
are well educated.
Item-5 of the table is concerning the service year of the respondents in the organization. The table
shows that 58.0% of the respondents have been working in the organization for 6 years and
above, 23.1% respondents for 1-2 years, 18.9% respondents for 3-5 years. Based on this figure,
it’s possible to conclude that majority of the employees are fairly stable.
In this section the data obtained on employee turnover are from the organization report and data
collection through questionnaires from professional employees currently working at
Development Bank of Ethiopia and are analyzed, presented and interpreted by using, mean,
percentage, count and standard deviation.
The responses from every respondent for each determinant are scored on a five points scale i.e.
strongly agree, agree, Neutral, disagree and strongly disagree.
Page | 20
Table 2 Respondents analysis
Item 1 of the above table shows feedback provided by the respondents on whether the
organization and work factors are conducive enough for them to stay in the organization.
Majority of the respondents, which is 43% neither agreed nor disagreed to this point (neutral)
followed by 29.1% who agrees to this statement, 18% did not agree to this statement and the rest
2.9% strongly agrees. Based on this result, it’s fair to conclude that considerable number of
respondents believes that the there’s a favorable organization and work factor for them to stay
longer in the company.
Page | 21
Item 2 of the above table demonstrates responses given to availability of social and economic
factors in the company i.e. better benefit and compensation; level of educational facilities
provided; level of health care facilities provided by the company. Based on the responses given,
37.9% neither agrees nor disagrees as to the availability of this factor; 33.3% disagrees to this
statement; 22.3% agrees to this statement, whereas the rest 2.7% strongly disagrees. Based on the
response rate (excluding the neutrals) it’s possible to conclude that employees of the organization
believes that they’re not being compensated well for the work they’re doing and the benefit
package is not competitive enough to address their needs.
Item 3 of the above table depicts responses given in connection with the presence of job stress in
the work place. Accordingly, 43.6% of the respondents are neutral, followed by 25.8% disagrees
with its existence, and 22.7% agrees that it does exist in the work place, and the rest 4.9% and
3% strongly agrees and strongly disagrees respectively. Notwithstanding those who were neutral
with this statement, it’s possible to infer that employees believe that their work environment is
stress free which intern will play a big role in staff retention.
Item 4 shows the respondents result regarding personal factors, i.e. correlation of their
educational background with the job that they’re doing; recognition received for a job well done;
company’s recognition of gender equality. As it can be referred from the above table, 40% of the
respondents are neutral, 26.9% disagrees, 15.9% strongly disagrees, while 13.6% agrees and
2.7% strongly agrees respectively. Not considering the neutral ones, it’s possible to conclude that
considerable number of respondents disagrees with the fact that the company takes into
consideration personal factors as part of keeping employees motivated/retaining its employees.
Item 5 shows responses regarding the availability of a conducive work environment for
employees to do their jobs. Accordingly, majority of the respondents (50%) disagrees with the
availability, followed by 20.8% who strongly disagree with its existence, 11.7% who do agree
with the statement, while 9.8% are neutral and 7.6% strongly agrees that there is suitable work
environment. Looking into majority of the responses given, it’s possible to conclude that the
company has poor work environment which could result in low employee motivation and high
turnover.
Page | 22
Item 6 shows respondents observation of the availability of career growth in the company. As
per the feedback collected, 47.3% of the respondents neither agrees or disagrees to this statement,
while 37.5% disagrees, followed by 12.5% who agrees with the availability of career opportunity,
and 2.7% strongly disagrees with its existence. Aside from those who are neutral and referring to
the second largest response given, it’s possible to infer that employees do not feel that there’s a
career growth opportunity within the organization.
Item 8 describes employee relationship with management and the result shows that majority of
the respondents i.e. 32% disagrees with the statement, where as 30.7% agrees that there is a good
relationship with management, followed by 21.6% are neutral while 8% and 7% strongly
disagrees respectively. Based on the feedback given, it’s possible to conclude that majority of the
employees disagrees with the fact that a harmonious relationship between the employees and the
management exists within the organization.
Page | 23
Table3 Labor turnover factors
Standard
Item Factors Mean
Deviation
Employee relationship
7 3.01 1.14
with Management
Item 1 concludes that the respondents result on a matter of work environment i.e. mean 2.25 and
SD 1.13, and the result explains that the employees of the bank are dissatisfied by the work
environment which is one means to see this factor that affect the employee turnover.
Item2 which is personal factor respondents resulted 2.51 mean and 0.90 standard deviation.
Based on the result findings the respondents dissatisfied on the matter.
On table 3 item 1 shows organization and work factor with a 3.02 mean and 0.88 SD in five point
Likert measurement scale. These explains the majority of respondents fall under the category of
neutral or indifferent .In additions as can be observed by table 3 this factor has a neutral effect on
the respondents .
In item 2 table 3 clarifies Social and Economic factors ,based on the result the respondents mean
is 2.79 and 0.88 standard deviation .This infers that ,the respondents are neutral on the factors .
Page | 24
On item 3 table 3 explains respondents mean (2.85) and standard deviation (.82) on regarding job
stress factors .Based on the result, respondents are indifferent on the matter of job stress in the
bank.
Item 6 category on table 1 shows the respondents result which shows a mean 2.71 and SD .68
In addition this result explains that respondents are indifferent on the matter.
On item 7 of table 1 found compensation and salary which respondent’s response is mean 2.88
and SD 1.15.this result explains that respondents are indifferent on the factor mentioned.
Item 8 on table 1 shows the respondents answer on the factor of Employee relationship with
Management and explains with a mean 3.01 and SD 1.14 .in addition the result explains that the
respondents are indifferent with factor.
Page | 25
Graph 1
The above graph shows the correlation between the educational background of the respondents
and the factors affecting turnover. Accordingly, one can infer from the above graph that though
there are few differences between the level of agreement and disagreement with the factors under
consideration, their responses were skewed towards the same direction. Hence, it’s possible to
conclude that the two does not have any correlation.
Page | 26
Graph 2
The above graph shows the correlation between the gender of the respondents and the factors
affecting turnover. Accordingly, one can infer from the above graph that though there are very
few differences between the level of agreement and disagreement with the factors under
consideration, their responses were skewed towards the same direction. Hence, it’s possible to
conclude that the responses given where not influenced by the gender of the respondents.
Page | 27
CHAPTER FIVE
This chapter presents summary conclusion and recommendation based on the data collection,
analysis.
This study attempted to investigate the factors that affect employee’s turnover on the organization
on the current employees of DBE. From the analysis made the reason for the high turnover are
highly dissatisfied employees due to work environment and employee relationship with
management.
The study revealed that the highest average response rate for organization and work related factor
went for neutral with standard Mean 1 . This indicates that the respondents were not sure of all
the statement under turnover factor in organizational and work factor at Development Bank of
Ethiopia. The bank could surely benefit from giving attention to the statements in this section
since workers have not taken a stand in the factor and don’t believe that it will in any way impact
their stay in the organization. In addition the study established that the highest response rate for
social and economic and factor went for neutral. This indicates that respondents are either unsure
of all the statement under social or economic factor or they don’t consider it as a factor that could
influence their stay in the organization. The findings under job stress factor reveals that most of
the respondents are neutral also. This indicates that the respondents are either unsure of all the
statement under this factor or they don’t consider it as a defining factor on whether they would
consider staying in or leaving the company.
Page | 28
Furthermore, the study established that working environment is very important factors that
employees consider at work place. A poor work environment may cause discomfort to some
employees who may end up being attracted to other organizations with better working conditions.
Flexible work-schedules lead to greater work-life balance and can offset work stress. The study
revealed that if the workplace lacks important facilities, such as proper lighting, furniture, clean
restrooms, and other health and safety provisions, employees will not be willing to put up with
the inconvenience for long. It further established that the environment in which an employee
works should be considered safe, and abide by health and safety standards.
Further the results suggest that the respondents are satisfied with the existing compensation
(salary) of the company. It could therefore be said that Compensation (salary) factors have helped
retain employees hence could not be considered as a factor for high employee turnover faced by
the bank. Under employee relationship with management, the study revealed that majority of the
respondents feels that there is no harmonious relationship between the management and the
employees within the organization.
5.2 Conclusion
High employee turnover can be caused by a lot of factors, such as organization and work, Social
and economic, job stress, Personal factor, works Environment, Career Growth, Employee
relationship with m management etc.
The company under the study recorded high employee turnover in the last few years. This study
has identified factors that affect the turnover in the Bank, in doing so, the researcher used both
primary and secondary data sources. Regarding the analysis, interpretation, tabulation, and
presentation of the data, the researcher made use of different tools such as mean, frequency,
tables, charts, graphs, figures and percentages.
The conclusion of the study reveals that, the current employees of Development Bank of Ethiopia
thinks that the organization and the work factor, social and economic, job stress, personal factor,
Page | 29
career growth and compensation and salary are adequate and these can’t be the reason to leave
the organization.
From the analysis made one can conclude that the main reasons of the high employee turnover
that are found in the organization are: Highly dissatisfaction with the working environment and
also dissatisfaction with employee relationship with the management.
The company under the study is losing young and mature professionals and this in turn affects the
performance of the organization.
5.3 Recommendations
Grounded by the findings and conclusion, the next recommendation are made to allow the liable
authority’s to retain the current employees and decrease the factors for the high employee
turnover faced by the organization.
Compensation and benefit- referring to the responses given by the employees, the
company seems in good space in this regards. However, the company should not take this
for granted as the external environment is every changing and a need to revise its benefit
package could be a necessity. For this, the company should always stay alert of what’s
happening the external environment and make sure it’s package is competitive and
sufficient enough to retain its talents.
Create a conducive working environment where employees feel recognized for a job well
done and are well motivated to excel on their responsibility. Furthermore, the company
needs to conduct a pulse survey and understand what led employees to believe that gender
equality is not recognized in the company (e.g. equal pay, career advancement…). Gender
diversity should be given due attention by the management as a diverse workforce proved
to bring different ideas to the table and drive company’s performance. The impact of
availing all the appropriate tools of trade for employees on employees moral and job
satisfaction should also not be over looked by the organization.
Career progress within a particular company plays a critical role in the retention of top
talents. Furthermore, it is considered as a wise way of building the succession pool of the
Page | 30
company where by talents are groomed to assume a senior role when the need arises. Even
though the employees seems satisfied (based on the response given) with the career
progress opportunity that exists within the organization, the company should always stay
abreast of new developments and strive to bring about a more effective career
opportunities/path that are appealing for the talents’ generation as what worked well for
the existing employees may not be acceptable by the new talents that the company will be
recruiting for the years to come. Therefore, the company should consider designing a clear
career road map for its employees with appropriate capability plan not only to support the
employees but also to ensure that the company achieves its target year on year.
A harmonious relationship with the employees and the management is very critical to the
very existence of any organization because more engaged employees are believed to be
more productive. For this reason, the company needs to conduct a value survey/pulse
survey for the following reasons;
o Whether the employees value aligns with that of the company
o To identify how they feel about the organization and the management as a whole
o To identify the root cause of this dissonance
o To collectively identify area of improvements
Furthermore, employees should be fully engaged in important matters (policy changes
before it takes effect for example) so that they feel valued and they’re important members
of the organization. This will intern not only improves the employee-management
relationship but also creates a sense of ownership within the employees which will result in
a better company performance.
The company should continue to provide a stress free environment for its employees as it
plays a critical role in enhancing employees’ performance .
Page | 31
References
Ali Khan, S. (2014). The factors affecting employee turnover in an. African Journal of
Shukla, S., & Dr.Sinha, A. (2013). Employee Turnover in banking sector: Empirical evidence.
Shumon, R. (n.d.). (2012) Employee Turnover-a Study of its Causes and Effects.
Turner. (2010). The influence of empowerment and engagement on affective (Vol. 24)
Filpe F. & Luis Borges. (2012). Scientific Papers: Journal of Knowledge Management,
Economics and Information Technology, Vol: II, Issue 2, and April 2012
Page | 32
Juliet Candle (2004).Factors affecting teacher’s turnover. Human Resource Management.
Kampala.
Robbins, S.P. (2003). Organizational behavior. Upper, 10thedition, New Jersey: Presntice
Hall.
http//researchpro.seals.ac.Za
G. D., & Shaw, J. D. (2001). Voluntary turnover, social capital and organizational
Inc.
Sandra R.C. (2012). Assessing employee turnover. Faculty of Economics and Management
Lockhead. C and Stephens, A. (2004), “Employee Retention, Labor Turnover and knowledge
transfer”.
http://WWW.buzzle.com/Articles/cause-of-employee-turnover.html
http:researchpro.seals.ac.za.
Page | 33
Asmamaw. (2011).Professional Employees Turnover and retention practices of Ethiopian
Addis Ababa.
Page | 34
Annex
Time Frame
List of activity Jan. Feb. Mar. April. May. Remark
1 Preparation of the draft
proposal
2 Submission of 1st draft
3 Feedback from advisor
4 Designing of questionnaire
5 Review literature/ further
discussion
6 Distribution of questionnaire
and interview
7 Collection of interview
questionnaire
8 Compilation and edition of
the final paper
9 Submission of the first
thesis draft
10 Correction /feedback from
the advisor
11 Final edition and correction
of the draft thesis paper
12 Submission of the final
paper
Page | 35
Budget Allocation
Page | 36
QUESTIONNAIRE
Dear Sir/Madam, I am a graduate student undertaking Masters of General Management at the Saint’s
Marry University College. I am conducting a research study entitled “FACTORS AFEECTING
EMPLOYEE TURNOVER: IN THE CASE OF DEVELOPMENT BANK OF ETHIOPIA”. You have
been selected to assist in providing the required information because your views are considered important
to this study. I am therefore kindly requesting you to fill this questionnaire. Please note that any
information given will be treated with utmost confidentiality and will only be used for the purpose of this
study. Thank You.
Yours faithfully,
Henok Tilahun
_________________________________________________________________________
Instructions
Kindly tick (√) the appropriate choice or fill the following questions in the appropriate spaces provided
5. How many years have you worked for Development Bank of Ethiopia?
2) 1-2 years________
3) 3-5 years________
Page | 37
1= Strongly Disagree; 2= Disagree; 3= Neutral; 4=Agree; 5=Strongly Agree
PART 2 –LABOUR TURNOVER FACTORS (Please tick (√) the appropriate choice)
Page | 39
PART 3
1) In your view what should be done to reduce the labor turnover patterns that are being
experienced? Please tick (√) the appropriate by ranking.
_________________________________________________
__________________________________________________
_________________________________________________
2) What is the Company doing to reduce the labor turnover patterns being experienced?
1) Nothing____
_________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________
__________________________________
Page | 40