Topic-3-Price Determination Under Perfect Competition
Topic-3-Price Determination Under Perfect Competition
Topic-3-Price Determination Under Perfect Competition
Table of Contents
2
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
Introduction
In the previous topic, we studied revenue analysis and pricing policies. We saw how costs can
influence the pricing behaviour of a firm. In recent years, where firms are finding it difficult to
differentiate themselves from their competitors, the price fixed by a firm is highly influenced
by the pricing behaviour of its competitors. Effectiveness of a firm’s management lies in its
capacity to analyse the market. Knowledge of market structure and different kinds of markets
is of utmost importance to a business manager in taking right pricing decisions and planning
business activities efficiently. In this topic, we will be studying price determination under
perfect competition.
Learning Objectives
• explain how firms under perfectly competitive markets maximise their output
3
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
4
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
market for a good or service”. It indicates a set of market characteristics that determine the
nature of market in which a firm operates. Different market structures affect the behaviour of
sellers and buyers in different ways.
The primary characteristics of markets are as follows:
• The number and size distribution of sellers
• The number and size distribution of buyers
• Product differentiation
• Conditions of entry and exit
The number and size distribution of sellers
A market may consist of many, few or very few sellers. There may be a few big firms with huge
investments or a large number of small firms with limited investments. Thus, the operating size
of the firm may be large or small in a market. The number and size of sellers influence the
working of a market.
The number and size distribution of buyers
In a market, there may be large number of buyers. Similarly, a market may consist of many
small buyers or only a few buyers. The total number of buyers influences the nature of
transactions in the market.
Product differentiation
Products sold in the market may be homogeneous, or have substitutes, close substitutes or
remote substitutes. A firm may deliberately differentiate its product with that of the products
of other firms by adopting several techniques.
Conditions of entry and exit
In a few market situations, new firms may enter the industry or, old firms may leave the
industry at their own free will. In case of other market situations, there will be deliberate entry
barriers.
Thus, the characteristics of market structure give us information about the nature of working
of different markets.
Among the different market situations, perfect competition and monopoly form the two
extremes. In between these two market situations, we come across a number of market
situations which may be collectively termed as imperfect markets. In these imperfect markets,
we notice the elements of competition as well as monopoly. They are bi-lateral monopoly,
5
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
monopsony (one buyer), duopoly (two sellers) duopsony (two buyers), oligopoly (few
sellers), oligopsony (few buyers) and monopolistic competition (many sellers). Figure 1
shows the types of competition.
2. Perfect Competition
Perfect competition is a comprehensive term which includes pure competition too. Before we
discuss the details of perfect competition, it is necessary to have a clear idea regarding the
nature and characteristics of pure competition.
Pure Competition is a part of perfect competition. Competition in the market is said to be pure
when the following conditions are satisfied:
• Prevalence of a large number of buyers and sellers.
• The commodity supplied by each firm is homogeneous.
• Free entry and exit of firms.
• Absence of any kind of monopoly element.
Under these conditions, no individual producer is in a position to influence the market price of
the product. According to Prof. E.H. Chamberlin – “Under Pure Competition, as the individual
seller’s market is completely merged with the general one, he can sell as much as he pleases at
the going price”. Further, he remarks, “Pure competition means unalloyed by monopoly
elements. It is a much simpler and less exclusive concept than perfect competition”.
6
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
Prof. Joel Dean, after going through the features of pure competition, observes that, “Pure
competition does exist in reality, but it is a rare phenomenon”. Hence, it is stated that it is
possible to come across pure competition in our life, for example, in the markets for rice,
wheat, cotton, jowar, fruits, vegetables, eggs, etc., where there are a large number of sellers
and buyers and practically all goods are identical. If we look at the present market, we notice
that even in these cases, there is a possibility of forming cartels by sellers to influence the
market price. Now, we shall turn our attention to perfect competition.
Meaning and definition of perfect competition
A perfectly competitive market is one in which the number of buyers and sellers are large, all
engaged in buying and selling a homogeneous product without any artificial restriction and,
possessing perfect knowledge of the market at a time. According to Bilas, “the perfect
competition is characterised by the presence of many firms; they all sell the same product
which is identical. The seller is the price-taker”. According to Prof. F. Knight, perfect
competition entails “Rational conduct on the part of buyers and sellers, full knowledge,
absence of friction, perfect mobility and perfect divisibility of factors of production and
completely static conditions”.
Features of perfect competition
1. Existence of a large number of buyers and sellers
A perfectly competitive market will have large number of sellers and buyers. Output of a seller
(firm) will be so small that it is a negligible fraction of the output of the industry. Hence,
changes in supply made by a particular firm will not affect the total output and price. Similarly,
no single buyer can influence the price of the commodity because the quantity purchased by
him is a small fraction of the total quantity.
2. Homogenous products
Different firms constituting the industry produce homogenous goods. They are identical in
character. Hence, no firm can raise its price above the general level.
3. Free entry and exit of firms
There is absolute freedom for firms to get in or get out of the industry. If the industry is making
profits, new firms are attracted into the industry. Conversely, firms will quit the industry if
there are losses. This results in the realisation of normal profits by all the firms in the long run.
4. Existence of single price
7
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
Each unit bought and sold in the market commands the same price since products are
homogeneous.
5. Perfect knowledge of the market
All sellers and buyers will have perfect knowledge of the market. Sellers cannot influence
buyers and, vice versa.
6. Perfect mobility of factors of production
Factors of production are free to move into any industry or occupation in order to earn higher
rewards. Similarly, they are also free to come out of the occupation or industry if they feel that
they are under remunerated.
7. Full and unrestricted competition
Perfectly competitive market is free from all sorts of monopoly and oligopoly conditions. Since
there are a large number of buyers and sellers, it is difficult for them to join together and form
cartels or form organisations. Hence, each firm acts independently.
8. Absence of transport cost
All firms will have equal access to the market. Market price charged by the sellers should not
vary because of the difference in the cost of transportation.
9. Absence of artificial government controls
The government should not interfere in matters pertaining to supply and price. It should not
place any barriers in the way of smooth exchange. Price of a commodity must be determined
only by the interaction of supply and demand forces.
10. The market price is flexible over a period of time
Market price changes only because of changes in either demand or supply force or both. Thus,
price is not affected by the sellers, buyers, firm, industry or the government.
11. Normal profit
As the market price is equal to the cost of production, firms in perfectly competitive markets
can earn only normal profits. Normal profits are those which are just sufficient to ensure the
firms stay in business. It is the minimum reasonable level of profit which the entrepreneur
must get in the long run. It is a part of the total cost of production because it is the price paid
for the services of the entrepreneur, i.e., profit is an item of expenditure for a firm.
Special features of perfect competition
i) It is an extreme form of market situation rarely found in the real world.
8
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
9
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
From the table, it is clear that equilibrium price is determined at Rs. 6.00 where demanded
quantity is exactly equal to quantity supplied i.e., 5000 units. Figure 2 shows the equilibrium
output.
10
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
The lower limit of the price is determined by the production cost. In the long run, the price
should not fall below production costs of making and distributing the product / service. With
reference to the industry, the point P can be regarded as the position of stable equilibrium.
Even if there are changes in the price, there will be automatic adjustments in supply and
demand, restoring the original equilibrium position. When the price rises from OR to OR1
supply exceeds demand, there will be excess supply over demand. The excess supply of goods
pushes down the price from OR1 to OR, the original price.
Similarly, when price falls from OR to OR2, demand exceeds supply, excess demand over
supply in its turn pushes up the prices from OR2 to OR - the original price. Thus, interaction
between demand and supply determines the market price.
Under perfect competition, a firm will not have any independence to fix the price of its own
product. The industry is the price - maker or giver and a firm is a price - taker or price acceptor
and quantity adjuster. As a part of the industry, it has to simply charge the price which is
determined by the industry. If it charges a higher price it will lose its sales and, if it charges a
lesser price, it will incur losses.
In case of a firm, the price line which is equal to AR and MR, will be horizontal and parallel to
OX - axis. This is because; the same price has to be charged by the firm for all the units
supplied, irrespective of changes in the demand. Hence,
Equilibrium or Market Price = AR = MR
11
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
Profit making is the basic objective of a firm. The traditional and conventional objective of a
firm was profit maximisation and now, the main objective is profit optimisation.
A business firm is a legal entity on the basis of ownership and contractual relationship
organised for the production and for the sale of goods and services.
Many firms producing similar or homogeneous goods or services collectively make an industry.
The term industry refers to a set or group of firms engaged in the production of a particular
product or a service. For example, Reid and Taylor, Digjam, Reliance Industries, Raymond Ltd.,
etc are all firms producing textiles. Such firms put together constitute the textile industry in
India. Thus, an industry is engaged in the production of homogeneous goods that are
substitutes for each other, use common raw materials, have similar processes, etc. All firms
engaged in providing the same kind of services or doing a common trade or business constitute
an industry, for example, banks, hotels, etc. An industry is a particular line of productive activity
in which many firms are engaged, each adopting its own production and pricing policies to its
best advantage.
12
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
price maker. On the basis of this price, a firm adjusts its output depending on the cost
conditions.
An industry under perfect competition in the short run, reaches the position of equilibrium
when the following conditions are fulfilled:
1. There is no scope for either expansion or contraction of the output in the entire industry.
This is possible when all firms in the industry are producing an equilibrium level of output
at which MR = MC. In brief, the total output remains constant in the short run at the
equilibrium point. Thus, a firm in the short run has only temporary equilibrium.
2. There is no scope for the new firms to enter the industry or existing firms to leave the
industry.
3. Short run demand should be equal to short run supply. The price so determined is called as
‘subnormal price’. Normal price is determined only in the long run. Hence, short run price
is not a stable price.
13
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
14
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
If price is above the AVC and below the AC, it is called as “Loss minimisation” zone. If the price
is lower than AVC, the firm is compelled to stop production altogether.
While analysing short term equilibrium output and price, apart from making reference to SMC
and AVC, we have to consider AC also. If AC = price, there will be normal profits. If AC is greater
than price, there will be losses and, if AC is lower than price, then there will be supernormal
profits.
In the short run, a competitive firm can be in equilibrium at various points E1, E2 and E3
depending upon cost conditions and market price. At these various unstable equilibrium
points, though MR = MC, the firm will be earning either supernormal profits or incurring losses
or earning normal profits.
In the case of the firm:
1. At OP4 price, the firm will neither cover AFC nor AVC and hence it has to wind up its
operations. It is regarded as shut-down point.
2. At OP1 price, OQ1 is the equilibrium output. E1 indicates the price or AR = AVC only. It
does not cover fixed costs. The firm is ready to suffer this loss and continue in business with
the hope that the price may go up in the future.
3. At OP2 price, OQ2 is the equilibrium output. E2 indicates the price = AR = AC. At
this point MR is also equal to MC. At this level of output, total average revenue = total average
cost. Hence, the firm is earning only normal profits. It is also known as Break - even point of the
firm, a zone of no loss or no profit. The distance between two equilibrium points E2 and E1
indicates loss-minimisation zone.
4. At OP3 price, OQ3 is the output produced by the firm. At E3, MR = MC. But AR is
greater than AC. For OQ3 output, the total cost is OQ3AB. The total revenue is OQ3E3P3.
Hence, P3E3AB is the total supernormal profits.
Thus, in the short run, a firm can either incur losses or earn supernormal profits. The main
reason for this is that the producer does not have adequate time to make all kinds of
adjustments to avoid losses in the short run.
In case of the industry, E indicates the position of equilibrium where short run demand is equal
to short run supply. OR indicates short run price and OQ indicates short run demand and
supply.
15
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
16
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
2. The firm in the long run must cover its full costs and should earn only normal profits.
This is possible when long run normal price is equal to long run average cost of production.
Hence,
Price = AR = AC
3. When AR is greater than AC, supernormal profits are earned. This leads to the entry of
new firms, increase in the total number of firms, expansion in the output, increase in the
supply, fall in the price and fall in the ratio of profits. This process will continue till supernormal
profits are reduced to zero. On the other hand, when AC is greater than AR, the industry will be
incurring losses. This leads to the exit of old firms, decrease in the number of firms, contraction
in output, rise in price, and rise in the ratio of profits. Thus, losses are avoided by automatic
adjustments. Such adjustments will continue till the firm reaches the position of equilibrium
when AC becomes equal to AR. Thus, losses and profits are incompatible with the position of
equilibrium. Hence,
Price = MR = MC = AR = AC
4. The firm is operating at its minimum AC making optimum use of available resources.
17
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
In case of the firm, P indicates the position of equilibrium. At P, LMR = LMC and LMC curve cuts
LMR curve from below. At the same point P, the minimum point of LAC is tangent to LAR curve.
Hence,
LAR = LAC
A competitive firm in the long run must operate at the minimum point of the LAC curve. It
cannot afford to operate at any other point on the LAC curve. Otherwise, it cannot produce the
optimum output or, it will incur losses.
Time plays an important role in determining the price of a product in the market. As the time
under consideration is short, demand will have a more decisive role than supply in the
determination of price. Longer the time under consideration, supply becomes more important
than demand in the determination of price.
The price determined in the long run is called as normal price and it remains stable.
Market price
Market price refers to that price which is determined by the forces of demand and supply in a
short period where demand plays a major role and supply plays a passive role. Market price is
unstable.
Normal price
Normal price is determined by demand and supply forces in the long period. It includes normal
profits also and it is stable in nature.
8. Summary
Here is a quick recap of what we have learnt so far:
• The organisation and functioning of a firm is determined by the type of market in which it is
operating.
• A market structure is characterised by the number of buyers and sellers, nature of the
commodity dealt with, the scope for entry and exit of firms and the determination of price.
• Perfect competition exhibits an ideal market situation, where there are a large number of
buyers and sellers, the commodity dealt with is homogeneous, there is free entry and exit
of firms into and out of the industry, and a uniform price prevails in the market.
• In the long run Price is equal to MR=AR=MC=AC. The firms can make normal profit only in
the long run.
18
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION
MBO103 – Managerial Economics
9. Glossary
Firm A single manufacturing unit producing and selling either a commodity
or service.
Industry All firms engaged in providing the same kind of service or doing a
common trade or business.
Market A commodity and buyers and sellers of that commodity who are in
competition with one another.
Market structure Economically significant features of a market, which affect the
behaviour, and working of firms in the industry.
Normal profits Profits which are just sufficient to ensure the firms stay in business.
Perfectly Market in which the number of buyers and sellers are large, all
competitive market engaged in buying and selling a homogeneous product without any
artificial restriction and, possessing a perfect knowledge of the
market at a time.
19
©COPYRIGHT 2019, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MANIPAL ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION