Understanding The Self
Understanding The Self
Understanding The Self
PHILOSOPHERS
Gilbert
Ryle
• The self is the way people behave.
• What truly matters is the behavior that a
person manifest in his day to day life.
• British philosopher Ryle believes that
the self is best understood as a pattern
of behavior, the tendency or disposition
of a person to behave in a certain way
in certain circumstances.
• Philosophers principle “I act therefore I
am”
• Mind and body are intrinsically linked
in complex and intimate ways.
• The self is the same as bodily behavior.
Mind is the totality of human
dispositions that is known through the
very way people behave.
• Convinced that the mind expresses the
entire system of thought emotions and
actions that make up the human self.
• The workings of the mind are not
distinct from the actions of the body but
are one and the same.
• The mind is a set of capacities and
abilities belonging to the body. It is a
mysterious entity that controls the
mechanical workings of the body.
• The mind should be seen as an organizing
principle of the body.
• Teaches the distinction among:
- knowing how – (technical ability)
- knowing that – (facts and proposition)
- knowing what – (acquaintance with
things and persons)
Maurice
merleau ponty
(1908-1961)
• French philosopher. All knowledge about
self is based on the phenomena of
experience.
• The “I” is a single integrated core identity, a
combination of the mental, physical and
emotional structures around a core identity
of the self.
• The mind and body are unified, not
separate.
• A phenomenologist, says the mind and body are
so intertwined that they cannot be separated
from each other.
• One cannot find any experience that is not an
embodied experience. All experience is
embodied. One’s body is his opening toward his
existence to the world. Because of these bodies,
men are in the world.
• For him, the living body, his thoughts, emotions
and experiences are all one.
• There is no experience that is not an embodied
experience.
• “Everything that we experience in this world –
experiences of joy, sadness, love, remorse –
happens with our bodies. There is never a
moment in which we are separated from our
bodies as if it is a clothing that we can shed off”
(Corpuz et al, 2019)
• Refers to this oneness or harmony between the
body and the world as our “being in the world.”
• Everything that people are aware of is
contained within the consciousness.
• Consciousness is a dynamic form
responsible for actively structuring
conscious ideas and physical behavior.
• Convinced that consciousness, the world
and the human body are intricately
intertwined in perceiving the world.
•Perception it is a conscious
experience, thus the self is
embodied subjectivity.
PAUL
CHURCHLAND
The Self is the Brain
• Canadian philosopher – advocates the idea of
eliminative materialism or the idea that the self is
inseparable from the brain and physiology of the
body.
• Adheres to materialism, the belief that nothing
except matter exists. If a thing cannot be recognized
by the senses then it is not real .
• Asserts that since the mind cannot be experienced
by our senses then the mind does not really exist. It
is the physical brain and not the mind that gives our
sense of self.
•All the person has is the brain, so if
the brain is gone, there is no self.
•The physical brain gives people the
sense of self. The mind does not
really exist because it cannot be
experienced by the senses.
• Decision making and moral behavior are
a biological phenomena. Human
behavior must be explained rather by a
mature cognitive neuroscience.
• Churchland speaks of neuro – conscience.
MEDIEVAL
PHILOSOPHERS
•St. Augustine. The self has an
Immortal Soul.
•Combined Greek Philosophy
and truths contained in the
scriptures.
•Integrated the ideas of Plato
and teaching of Christianity.
•The physical body is radically
different from and inferior to its
inhabitant, the immortal soul.
•Ultimately came to view the body as
“spouse” of the soul, both attached to
one another by a “natural appetite”.
• The self is made up of a body and a soul, “a soul in possession of a
body which does not constitute two persons but one man”. His
concept of self is in the context of his relation to God. Every human
person is created into the image and the likeness of God, Every
human person is made for God. It is only upon one’s recognition of
God’s love and one’s response to the invitation to love that one
finds inner peace.
• Happiness is the end all and be all of human living and this
happiness can be found in God alone.
•Believes that the body is united with the soul so
that man may be entire and complete. As a
religious philosopher he contemplates on the
nature of man with emphasis on the soul as an
important element of man.
•Believes that the soul is what governs and
defines man.
•Humankind is created in the image and likeness of
God. Everything created by God who is all good is
good; Therefore, the human person being a
creation of God is always geared towards the
good.
•Self knowledge is a consequence of knowledge of
God.
•Espouses the significance of reflection as well
as the importance of prayers and confessions to
arrive at a justification for the existence of God.
“Knowledge come by seeing the truth that dwells
within us”
•Truth – refers to the truth of knowing God.
•Believes that a virtuous life is a
dynamism of love.
•Loving God means loving one’s
fellowmen, and loving one’s fellowmen
denotes never doing any harm to another.
•Goal of every human person; to attain
this communion and bliss with the Divine
by living his life on earth in virtue.
•Virtue is “the order of love”. To love God means
necessarily to love one’s fellowmen never to do
any harm to another as you would not others to
do unto you. This is Aristotle’s Golden mean.
•Man craves for something perfect immutable
and enduring, Possession of the goods such as
health, beauty, power, honor, fame can never
give to a human person what one is truly looking
for, these goods are finite, unstable and
ephemeral.
THOMAS AQUINAS
• Most eminent 13 century scholar and stalwart
th
• Identity (noun) –
qualities, beliefs etc, which makes a particular person or group different from
others.
• Self (noun) –
The person that someone normally or truly is---entirety of an individual.
Identity – distinguishes/compares one from another
Self – refers to the total characteristics or qualities of a person both known and
unknown to others (but known to oneself)
• A person’s identity is highlighted by a dominant trait
which makes one distinguishable from others.
Communal – expectations
norms
HEREDITARY FACTOR
Kant – the self constructs its own reality, actively creating a world
that is familiar and predictable.
- Relationship with
siblings harness one’s
socialization skills.
Schools and general academic
environments
World views expand as one gets exposed to more people
Knowledge and social skills gained from mentors, relatives and peers
contribute to how the social self is harnessed.
Information gleaned from books, lectures and insights from classmates –
assimilated and imbibed in the inner recesses of the self.
Knowledge of the world is shaped by collaborative learning.
Values of social harmony emotional sensitivity to the needs of others and
behavior to personal spaces of others etc are learning insights inculcated in
oneself.
Culture
Complex whole which includes knowledge,
beliefs, law art, moral, custom, and other
capabilities and habits acquired by man as a
member of society, (Edward Tylor, 1871).
Key words