Euthyphro Edited
Euthyphro Edited
Euthyphro Edited
Name
Course
Professor
Due Date
A Summary of Euthyphro
The text is a dialogue between Socrates and Euthyphro in The Porch of the King Archon.
In the text, Socrates is getting ready for a court in which Euthyphro is acting as the prosecutor
against his father. As they are on their way to the court, Euthyphro informs Socrates about his
father, who is on trial for homicide and that his family is upset about his position as the
prosecutor despite the victim being his father and questions why he decided to do so.
Euthyphro then defends himself, claiming that he is acting with piety to mean that he judges
with what all the gods have approved and that it is the most honorable and holy thing to do.
The dialogue continued when Socrates got interested in knowing more about the nature
of holiness. He tries to disclose the true nature of noble and holiness by asking Euthyphro to
define righteousness. Despite Euthyphro's several attempts to define what piety is, he fails
each time since his responses disclaim Socrates definition of piety. Euthyphro makes the
religious assertion that his father committed sin because his claims and opinions are founded
on knowledge of what the Gods think about piety and impiety. He further argues that the
Gods gave him the instruction to prosecute his father's case of murder. Socrates, who believes
The arguments between Socrates and Euthyphro show that each definition of piety raises
more questions than answers forcing Socrates to push for a clear answer. Through their
Surname2
discussion, it is clear that it is impossible to identify what is truly holy without an explanation
from the gods. Euthyphro might be pleasing and holy to one god but unholy to other gods
thus, the situation should be agreed by all gods. The dialogue serves as an exploration of the
text, universalism is a conviction that moral principles apply to all persons and societies, and
thus should be followed. Whether something is pious because the gods love it or the gods
3. “The point which I should first wish to understand is whether the pious or holy is beloved
by the gods because it is holy, or holy because it is beloved of the gods.” “Is all the pious just?
4. In the dialogue, Socrates poses the question whether it is the gods who make something
pious, or whether it is piety that makes something beloved of the gods to get more
clarification and understanding of Euthyphro. He then asks whether if all the pious is just, and
if all the just is pious in an attempt to isolate the essential element of justice which makes it
pious.
The quote is included in the text to illustrate Socrates' beliefs on the relationship between
justice and piety, as well as to invite readers to think deeply about the nature and significance
which challenges the concepts of piety and justice and forces the reader to confront their own