Lecture Notes - Structured Problem Solving Using Frameworks - II
Lecture Notes - Structured Problem Solving Using Frameworks - II
Lecture Notes - Structured Problem Solving Using Frameworks - II
In the previous module, you learnt how to approach a problem statement, right from
understanding the business problem, asking the right questions and then determining the root
cause of the problem and the implications associated with it. In this module, you will learn about
some more frameworks that you can use in a structured problem-solving approach. These are
called issue tree frameworks, specialised frameworks and some consulting frameworks such as
7Ps and 5Cs.
In this module, you will also understand the application of the issue tree framework in the
business problems that were discussed in the previous module. Finally, you will see the solution
and summarise those business problems.
While you are in the process of understanding a certain problem, you need to explore the
reasons for it, i.e., you first need to break down the business problem into possible causes and
then convert the causes into testable hypotheses.
For example, some people still do not prefer to buy electronic goods online from e-commerce
giants such as Amazon, Flipkart and eBay. What, according to you, could be the possible
reasons for this?
After performing some analyses, you came to the conclusion that (using the 5 WHYs
framework) you can check the reliability and revise the customer trust policies of these
e-commerce companies. Do you think this is the only reason that you have identified the
problem? Well, the answer is no. There could be multiple reasons as to why some customers do
not buy electronic goods online. In the working industry, the 5 whys framework is often applied
along with a structured approach known as the issue tree framework.
It covers multiple domains of the business in a simple and efficient manner. At the end of the
model, you are aware of the firm's or product's value proposition, infrastructure, customers, and
finances.
Your business understanding increases at an accelerated pace because multiple areas of the
business are covered in a very short span.
This model is adaptive to all businesses. Whether it is a multinational company or a startup, this
model can be applied to all of them.
Finally, all you have at the end is just a piece of paper. It is an advantage as you can easily
carry your entire research in the interviews for your reference.
1. Value propositions - What are your products and services? What is the job that you get
done for your customer?
2. Customer segments - What are the different customer groups with which the company
interacts? Who is/are your most important customer(s)?
3. Channels - How do you communicate with your customers? How do you deliver your
value proposition?
4. Customer relationships - How does the business maintain its relationship with its
customers?
5. Revenue streams - What price are the customers willing to pay for your products? How
would they prefer to pay? How much does each stream’s revenue contribution to the
overall revenue?
6. Key resources - Assets that are required to operate and deliver your company’s value
proposition.
7. Key activities - The main business activities that are performed in order to run your
daily business model. What are the key activities that your value proposition requires?
8. Key partners - Who are your key partners/suppliers, and what are the motivations for
the partnerships?
9. Cost structure - What are the top costs of the company taking into account activities
and resources?
Until now, you have looked at the first part. Now, once the interview is done, you will come
across several causes of the problem that e-commerce companies face. These causes are
termed as hypotheses. In this part, you will understand the process of formulating a hypothesis
using multiple frameworks.
The issue tree framework is one of the most comprehensive frameworks because of the way it
helps in approaching a problem. With the help of this framework, a problem can be disintegrated
into multiple components and each component can be further broken down into
Any large business problem can be broken down to smaller issues/problems, which results in a
number of hypotheses. Let’s take a look at the image below to understand the concept better.
An important point to note here is that every hypothesis cannot be tested. As you proceed, after
you get a set of hypotheses, you should always prioritise the hypothesis based on the impact
that it has on the problem. One rule that can be followed here is the ‘Pareto Rule’ or the ‘80:20’
rule, where 80% of the effects come from 20% of the causes. Hence, you can try and identify
these hypotheses and prioritise them accordingly.
A tool called Coggle is often used in the industry to identify the different branches and structure
the issue tree charts. Thus, Coggle can be used to build an issue tree comprehensively and
easily.
The profitability problem is divided into two components: revenue and cost. While covering the
revenue part of the issue, you can see that the question 'How' is raised at each level. Based on
the responses that you receive in the interview, you first have to dig deeper into a particular
component and then proceed in further in the branch.
Another way to check whether or not the problem lies in a particular component is by deriving its
past trends. Let's consider the elements given in the revenue part. You want to know which
among the three components (alternate revenue paths/number of units sold/price per unit). If
the past data suggests that the alternate revenues and the number of units sold have been
increasing and the prices have been falling over the past years, then you would also want to
check the branch for 'price per unit'. Therefore, past trends can sometimes be beneficial to
prioritise the faulty areas over the good areas.
After applying the 5 whys framework and the issue tree technique to the problem, it was found
that the main cause of the problem was that the third-party agency spent more time in document
verification and background check of non-salaried professionals.
So, Bank A asked its analytics team to build an ‘Income Estimation Linear Regression Model’
using the historical inflow and outflow of the data for the non-salaried people using some filters
and exclusions, thereby removing the main existing problem. Along with this short-term
streamlining, Bank A made its process competitive enough for its existing customers and helped
maintain the growth of its home loan portfolio and got back the market leader in the home loan
business.
In the previous module, you applied the 5 whys framework and understood the ‘why’ questions,
which could be explored at each level in the problem statement.
Later, you also found out that the final root cause in the business problem was that the average
cost per claim for diagnostic services was found to be high in the region.
Now, let’s apply in this problem the issue tree framework and understand how each ‘why’ can
be split into root causes.
The company filed a case against the third-party lab agencies for fraudulent claims, which led to
the prosecution of the owners of the lab agencies.
The company also launched an exercise on accrediting labs and asking its insurance
policyholders to get their diagnostic tests done only from the accredited labs.
The Data Science team was requested to build an Anomaly Detection System that could detect
anomalies in false claims.
In this part, you will learn how an issue tree along with the SPIN selling framework can help in
solving a problem. Recall that the head of marketing at bank XYZ was not happy with the bank’s
revenue growth and other issues such as low customer satisfaction and high employee attrition
owing to the cross-selling of the bank’s products.
In the situation part of the SPIN selling framework, the problem of revenue growth of bank XYZ
is broken down into different factors.
Using the 5Ws and How framework, you can ask certain questions to understand the existing
situation and gather important facts and data.
In the problem part of the SPIN selling framework, the issue regarding revenue growth is broken
down into two parts: new customers, i.e., the strategy for acquiring new customers and existing
customers who are already a part of the bank .
Since the problem is related to the existing customers, it is broken down further into up-selling
(selling a higher variant of the same product) and cross-selling (selling a different type of
product).
In the implication part of the SPIN selling framework, we examine the product-centric mindset
through three factors: customers, sales and products.
Various implications for customers are Lower satisfaction score, a higher rate of churn, poor
perception of the bank etc. Similarly for sales are: employee satisfaction score, Higher
employee attrition, Higher training cost and for the products are: No trust among product teams,
hesitant in higher cross-sell targets etc.
In the need/pay-off part of the SPIN selling framework, once you have identified the
implications, as a consultant, analyst or data scientist, you can present your solution to the
customer by articulating its benefits and focussing on questions related to implications of the
problem and the need/pay-off.
7P's Framework
The 7Ps is a powerful tool used for marketing strategy. The framework consists of seven
different matrices: product, price, place, promotion, people, process and physical evidence.
Let’s quickly go through them one by one.
1. Product: This involves the product that is being offered to the customers and the
expected standard quality that is to be met.
2. Price: This refers to the price of the product and how it is going to affect customer
sentiments and whether or not they are satisfied with it.
3. Place: This includes the distribution locations that are available. In simple terms, this
matrix will help you check whether or not the product is available at a particular
customer’s location.
4. Promotion: This matrix refers to the marketing and branding of the product.
5. People: The people in the framework refer/represent the employees, consultants and
freelancers that represent the organisation and deliver the products or services.
6. Process: This matrix refers to the steps involved in delivering a certain product to the
end user.
7. Physical evidence: This is a combination of the environment in which a product or
service is provided and the branding of the product.
Different companies use different Ps frameworks based on their business requirement and
needs.
The 5C analysis is considered the most useful and common way to analyse the market
environment because of the extensive information that it provides. Now that you are aware of
the framework, the only thing that you need to do is restructure your interview to incorporate this
framework. You should be able to find the answers that will help you attain the end goal, i.e., a
hypothesis.
Let’s put the 5C framework to work now. One thing that you should understand is that the result
of using the framework will highly depend on the flow of questions that you ask because those
answers will form the basis for the hypothesis. Hence, you need to blend the framework in the
interview in a structured and planned manner.
When you are using the 5C framework, you aim to understand the 5 Cs around the company.
You need to list down all the questions that will help you understand a particular C.
Also, one person will not be able to answer all the questions. You should map the set of
questions to different teams who will provide you with the answers and cover all the Cs of the
framework.
Customer
● Who are the customers that the firm caters to?
● What is the size of the market in which the firm operates?
● Are the customers satisfied with the final products or the services that they receive?
Company
● What are the products and services that the firm provides to the customers?
● How much time is allotted for the team to complete a project?
● What is the reputation of the firm in the market?
Collaboration
● Does the IT firm have partnerships with any other firm?
● Who are the suppliers that provide the raw materials for the final product?
● Are there any promoters that help you market your product?
Competition
● Who are the competitors in the market?
● What is the market share of each competitor?
● What is the price that they charge their customers?
Context
● How is the industry performing over the past years?
● Have there been any technical developments in the industry?
● Are there any regulations in the market that have affected the operations at the firm?
The interview will flow in a particular direction based on the answers that you receive for the
questions asked. Once you have an answer to a specific question, multiple follow-up questions
will help you reach a final point, which will form the basis for a hypothesis.
The main aim of interviewing any person is that you have a hypothesis at the end of the
interview. As you interact with multiple members of different teams, you will end up with multiple
hypotheses for the same problem. They will be termed as a hypothesis until you have validated
them using some data.
Specialized Frameworks - I
© Copyright 2020. UpGrad Education Pvt. Ltd. All rights reserved
In the previous part, you learnt how effective the different frameworks are in their approach of
covering all the domains of a particular problem/business and provide a set of hypotheses to
test.
However, one issue that you may face is that the issue tree framework requires a thorough
knowledge of the firm and the industry. You have to know all the factors that can have an
impact.
You need to use the issue tree framework along with different frameworks to gain a complete
overview of the problem. Based on the domain of the problem that you want to solve, there are
multiple frameworks available. For example, if a company is trying to create awareness in the
market, then the problem is a marketing problem; if the company wants to optimise the process
of manufacturing, then the problem is an operational problem; and if the company is dealing
with declining sales, then the problem is a sales problem. These cases are different in nature
and, hence, should be handled differently.
Over the years, many individuals have used their expertise and developed various frameworks
that are relevant to their own fields. Your job is to find a framework that fits your problem and
use it in conjugation with the issue tree framework to form hypotheses. In the next part, you will
learn about multiple frameworks that will help you explore any business problem.
Specialized Frameworks - II
By now, you must have realised that frameworks are effective tools for solving a business
problem. As a wide range of issues can occur at different phases of business, companies might
need help in the following functions:
Based on the problem your company or the client is facing, you need to select a relevant
framework and try to solve the problem as early as possible. Here, you are provided with some
useful frameworks based on different issues that you may get in your job roles.
Business partation
This framework is useful when a company or a client has multiple businesses. As in the case of
the issue tree framework, you will be required to break down the company into the respective
businesses in which it operates. For example, e-commerce giants, such as Amazon and
Flipkart, provide a wide range of products, including apparel and electronics. If the company is
facing any problems, you will analyse these parts separately because the characteristics of
each business can be different from the other.
Frameworks: Operations
SWOT Analysis
The SWOT analysis helps you part the processes in the company based on the capabilities and
points out the critical concern areas for the company. The four branches in SWOT analysis are:
1. Strengths
2. Weaknesses
3. Opportunities
4. Threats
All the points that fall under "weakness" and "threats" will help you to figure out the problem that
is being faced by the company. You can build multiple hypotheses around the points in these
quadrants and test them later. On the other hand, you can explore the opportunities branch for
coming up with expansion plans etc.
Frameworks: Sales
BANT Framework
The BANT framework helps you identify good leads from the customer pool. It stands for
budget, authority, need and timeframe, which can be summarised as follows:
● Budget: This helps you understand whether or not the person can afford the
products/services offered.
● Authority: This helps you identify whether the authority to make the buying decision lies
with the customers.
● Need: This helps to understand the pain points that the lead is facing.
● Timeframe: This helps you understand how early the person wants to have your
products/services delivered to them.
The framework helps you measure the quality of sales prospects and analyse their likelihood of
converting into successful customers.
Market partation: Dividing customers based on demographics (geography, age, gender, income,
education, ethnicity, marital status, profession or occupation), lifestyle, behaviour, consumption
levels, etc.
Market Targeting: Evaluating the created parts and selecting the target customers.
Product Positioning: Selects the value proposition of product or service you want to offer to the
parts. The part that you have chosen may have one of these priorities in their mind: the utility of
the product, the market reputation of the brand or product, the experience of the product.
The framework helps you validate whether the product/service offered to the customer matches
the respective part. You will end with multiple hypotheses when the customers are not mapped
to the section you believe they should be.
● You can download this document from the website for self-use only.
● Any copies of this document, in part or full, saved to disc or to any other storage medium may
only be used for subsequent, self-viewing purposes or to print an individual extract or copy for
non-commercial personal use only.
● Any further dissemination, distribution, reproduction, copying of the content of the document
herein or the uploading thereof on other websites or use of content for any other
commercial/unauthorized purposes in any way which could infringe the intellectual property
rights of UpGrad or its contributors, is strictly prohibited.
● No graphics, images or photographs from any accompanying text in this document will be
used separately for unauthorised purposes.
● No material in this document will be modified, adapted or altered in any way.
● No part of this document or UpGrad content may be reproduced or stored in any other web
site or included in any public or private electronic retrieval system or service without UpGrad’s
prior written permission.
● Any rights not expressly granted in these terms are reserved.