Proposed Posture Improvement For Tile Workers Using The REBA Method
Proposed Posture Improvement For Tile Workers Using The REBA Method
Proposed Posture Improvement For Tile Workers Using The REBA Method
2: 31-12-2021
(The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic) ISSN Print: 1411 – 951 X, ISSN Online: 2503-1716
Abstract
Sokka Super Sid Tile SMEs (Small and Medium Enterprises) is one of the SMEs that produce
roof tiles in the Godean area. This SMEs has problems regarding workers' body positions that are not
ergonomic and are carried out for a long period of time (around 7-8 hours / day) and are repeated for
days, resulting in bad effects that are often felt by workers when doing their work such as when
bending over, back pain, cramps in muscles and decreased ability to move. This posture issue will
cause pain in the joints, muscles and ligaments, and therefore will have an impact on discomfort while
working. This study aims to determine body posture in the working position after improvements have
been made and provide recommendations for improvements to reduce pain felt by the workers by
proposing an ergonomic work tool design. The Rapid Entire Body Assessment (REBA) method is
used to determine the risk of injury to the posture of workers at each work station. Data were collected
through observation, interviews and taking photo documentation at each work station. Prior to the
improvement, activities that have a risk level of 2 are at the work stations of refining, pressing, and
drying. Risk level 3 is at the milling, burning, and mixing work stations. Risk level 4 is at the sun-
drying work station. Improvements given to the UKM are desk facilities to make their work easier and
to reduce the risk of injury to workers' bodies. After improvements are implemented, the results
obtained show risk level 1 is at the work station of milling, drying, refining, and burning. Risk level 2
is at the mixing, pressing and sun-drying work stations. It is concluded that the improvement of body
posture in drying workers is in accordance with the ideal work posture.
Abstrak
UKM Genteng Sokka Super Sid merupakan salah satu UKM yang memproduksi genteng di
daerah Godean. UKM ini memiliki permasalahan pada posisi tubuh pekerja yang tidak ergonomis dan
dilakukan dalam jangka waktu yang lama sekitar 7-8 jam/hari dan diulang berhari-hari, dampak buruk
yang sering dirasakan oleh pekerja saat melakukan pekerjaan nya seperti membungkuk, nyeri
punggung, kram pada otot dan penurunand anggota gerak. Hal tersebut akan menimbulkan keluhan
pada persendian, otot dan ligamen dengan adanya hal tersebut akan berdampak pada
ketidaknyamanan saat bekerja. Penelitian bertujuan mengetahui postur tubuh pada posisi kerja setelah
dilakukan perbaikan dan memberikan rekomendasi perbaikan untuk mengurangi keluhan pada pekerja
dengan usulan desain alat kerja yang ergonomis. Metode Rapid Entire Body Assessment (REBA)
digunakan untuk mengetahui resiko cedera pada postur tubuh pekerja di setiap stasiun kerja.
154
Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia Vol.7, No.2: 31-12-2021
(The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic) ISSN Print: 1411 – 951 X, ISSN Online: 2503-1716
Pengambilan data dilakukan melalui observasi, wawancara dan mengambil dokumentasi foto di setiap
stasiun kerja. Sebelum dilakukan perbaikan aktivitas yang memiliki level resiko 2 yaitu pada stasiun
kerja penghalusan, pengepresan, pengeringan. Level resiko 3 yaitu pada stasiun kerja penggilingan,
pembakaran, pencampuran. Level resiko 4 yaitu pada stasiun kerja penjemuran. Perbaikan yang
diberikan kepada UKM yaitu fasilitas meja untuk mempermudah pekerjaan dan mengurangi
terjadinya resiko cedera pada tubuh pekerja. Setelah dilakukan perbaikan diperoleh hasil berupa level
resiko 1 yaitu pada stasiun kerja penggilingan, pengeringan, penghalusan, pembakaran. Level resiko 2
yaitu pada stasiun kerja pencampuran, pengepresan, penjemuran. Disimpulkan bahwa perbaikan
postur tubuh pada pekerja penjemuran sesuai dengan postur kerja yang ideal.
INTRODUCTION
Transporting and moving materials manually in the production process requires the
human resources and it is needed by SMEs (Small and Medium Enterprises) in Indonesia.
Traditional material transportation can be done easily and does not require too much handling
costs. Some UKMs ignore the consequences of manually transporting material loads,
especially at the cost of comfort and health of the workers (Herdiana, 2012).
The way of moving by relying on human power without using a machine is called
Manual Material Handling (MMH). One of the effects caused by improper MMH activities is
pain that occurs in the musculoskeletal system. Musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs) are
disorders that attack the muscles, nerves, tendons, ligaments, joints, cartilage, and spinal
nerves. Complaints occurring in the musculoskeletal system are pains in parts of the skeletal
muscles that are felt by a person ranging from very mild pain to very painful. If the muscle
receives a static load repeatedly and for a long time, it can cause pain in the joints, ligaments
and tendons (Rahayu, 2012).
Posture is a geometric arrangement of body parts that are closely related to other body
organs. Posture consists of joints, tendons, ligaments and muscles. If the good posture can be
used correctly then there is a balance in doing activities (Ristanto & Uswatun Insani, 2014).
Work postures that cause complaints or irregularities in body positions include reaching back,
turning in the wrong direction, working at a height above the head, bending wrists for too
long, kneeling, bending, and squatting. Risks that can occur if incorrect posture is done long-
term and unnoticed for some time can cause workers to experience complaints such as pain,
numbness, swelling, and stiffness, which can directly affect the productivity of workers (Nur
et al., 2016).
The results of the production can be sold at a price that is able to compete in the
market. The problem that usually occurs in SMEs is the lack of work facilities that can assist
workers in carrying out production activities. The need for training on how to manufacture
products must be designed in such a way that workers can better understand and know about
the risks that can occur to workers during production activities. Reduction of risks or dangers
to workers is carried out by using complete personal protective equipments when doing their
work, knowing standard procedures in the event of an emergency and conducting training
according to the needs of SMEs.
Sokka Super Sid SMEs is engaged in the production of roof tiles and it is located at
Klangkalan I Rt 01 Rw 03 Godean, Sleman, DIY. The number of workers in this study were
7 people and there were 7 work stations, namely mixing, pressing, drying, refining, milling,
sun-drying and burning. There are tile SMEs that are still using traditional tools without using
automatic machines. All production departments are deemed to be lacking in ergonomics
when doing their work. At the mixing work station there is a hoe to mix raw materials, but it
is deemed not effective because the handle is too short, and so it forces the worker’s body to
155
Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia Vol.7, No.2: 31-12-2021
(The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic) ISSN Print: 1411 – 951 X, ISSN Online: 2503-1716
bend more when using the hoe. The milling work station has a milling tool that is too high so
workers would need to stand on tiptoe to pour clay into the milling tool. The pressing work
station has a pressing tool by rotation but the tool is too heavy to use. The drying rack used
by drying work station is too high so workers would need to stand on tiptoe. The worker at
the refining work station uses feet to support the roof tiles in production process. The worker
at the drying work station does not use tools when carrying the tiles so that his waist and
hands are often under heavy loads. Workers at the burning work station often arrange roof
tiles with tilted body positions.
The positions of the workers' body that are not ergonomic and are carried out for a
long period of time (around 7-8 hours / day) and repeated for days, can cause bad effects such
as hunching back, back pain, muscle cramps and decreased ability to move. This can lead to a
decrease in work productivity as a result of complaints associated with Musculoskeletal
Disorders felt by workers. An ergonomic approach can increase the effectiveness and
efficiency of workers and other activities, as well as improve safety, reduce fatigue and
injury, increase comfort and increase job satisfaction.
Problems or impacts on working conditions experienced by workers in tile-producing
SMEs certainly involve the need of physical activities that can drain a lot of energy in doing
work, particularly if workers do it continuously without sufficient rest time. Workers are only
given 1 hour of rest during their work and sometimes they ignore this break in order to meet
production targets due to high consumer demand, thus causing pressure felt by workers in
doing their work.
High physical activity and irregular rest periods can cause workers to feel tired easily.
In addition, almost all workers are dominated by a standing work attitude in addition to lack
of concentration. This can cause the workers' posture while doing their job to be susceptible
to injury.
Length of work is the amount of time to do a job, which can cause a risk factor the
longer that job is being carried out. The length of work can be seen from how many hours
worked / day. In tile-producing SMEs the working hours is typically 8 hours per day.
Burdens that arise from working can be in the form of physical, mental or social burdens
experienced by workers. A worker who physically works hard, such as loading and unloading
goods at a port, bears more physical burdens than mental or social burdens. Meanwhile, the
workload of an entrepreneur or manager, his responsibility is a mental burden that is
relatively larger than the physical burden that is demanded by his job (Utami, 2017).
From information obtained from observations and interviews in trying to identify
problems, workers must perform some stages when producing roof tiles, workers lack of
understanding of the risks when carrying out production activities, improvements are needed
to reduce complaints to workers during the tile production process and suggestions for
ergonomic work facilities.
The purpose of this study is to determine body posture in the working position after
improvementss were made, to provide recommendations for improvements to reduce the
occurrence of complaints to workers and to provide design proposals for ergonomic work
facilities. The benefits obtained from this study are: knowing the risk of injury when making
roof tiles, providing ergonomic recommendations to reduce injuries or worker complaints,
and improving body posture when doing work.
To make improvements, the REBA method is needed to analyze the worker's posture.
Some parts of the body can be used in analyzing work postures to reduce the occurrence of
joint injuries in the body such as the neck, back, arms, wrists, feet and fingers. So we need a
study to make it easier to analyze and find out posture that can cause injury to the joints.
Rapid Entire Body Assessment (REBA) is a method in the field of ergonomics that is
used to quickly assess the posture of a worker's neck, back, arms, wrists and legs
156
Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia Vol.7, No.2: 31-12-2021
(The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic) ISSN Print: 1411 – 951 X, ISSN Online: 2503-1716
(Middlesworth, 2014). Assessment of upper limbs and lower limbs with muscle function and
external loads experienced by the body. The coding system is used to generate a list of
actions that indicate the level of intervention needed to reduce the risk of physical injury to
the operator (Sulaiman & Sari, 2018).
Solidworks is a design program that is widely used to work on product design,
machine design, mold design, construction design or other engineering needs. Solidworks can
be equipped with tools that are often used to calculate and analyze design results such as
stress and strain, so that they can find out whether the component to be designed is reliable or
not (Alejandro Reyes, 2014).
METHOD
The research methodology uses the Rapid Entire Body Assessment (REBA) method.
The object of this research is SMEs producing Sokka Super Sid roof tiles located at
Klangkalan I Rt 01 Rw 03 Godean, Sleman, DIY. The total population in this study are 7
people. The REBA method is equipped with an external load of work activities, in the REBA
method the body parts are divided into two groups, namely group A consisting of the back
(torso), neck, and legs, and group B consisting of the upper arms, forearms, and wrists, while
group C consists of combined score between group A and group B. The method of collecting
data is by means of observation, interviews and documentation (Middlesworth, 2014).
Based on the percentage of the largest complaints experienced by workers, namely the
sun-drying work station. Documentation of body posture by tile production workers is then
processed using the REBA method as shown in Figure 1.
157
Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia Vol.7, No.2: 31-12-2021
(The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic) ISSN Print: 1411 – 951 X, ISSN Online: 2503-1716
Worker has body posture as shown in Figure 1. The body posture score of the tile
drying process can be seen in Table 2.
The posture of the worker in tile production at a drying work station shows that the
neck posture is given a score of 2 because the angle is 23o forward, the torso is given a score
of 4 because it is 92o forward, and the legs are given a score of 1 because the position of the
feet is not balanced and given +2 because the legs form 156o angle as can be seen in table 1,
so the final foot score is 4. The results of observations on the posture of the neck, torso and
legs when working the score is entered into table A, the score is 7 which can be seen in Table
3.
Neck
Table A 1 2 3
Legs 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
1 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 3 3 5 6
2 2 3 4 5 3 4 5 6 4 5 6 7
Torso 3 2 4 5 6 4 5 6 7 5 6 7 8
4 3 5 6 7 5 6 7 8 6 7 8 9
5 4 6 7 8 6 7 8 9 7 8 9 9
158
Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia Vol.7, No.2: 31-12-2021
(The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic) ISSN Print: 1411 – 951 X, ISSN Online: 2503-1716
After obtaining a score in table A, it is continued with scoring in table B. The posture of
the tile production worker shows that the upper arm is given a score of 3 because of the large
70o forward angle, the forearm is given a score of 2 because of the 156o forward angle, the
wrist is given a score of 2 because the angle of 28o down can be seen in Table 4.
The score obtained from the results of observing the posture of the upper arm, forearm
and wrist while working the score is entered into table B and a score of 5 is obtained and
there is no additional grip score, because when working, holding the tool properly can be
seen in table 5.
Upper Arms
Table B 1 2
Wrists 1 2 3 1 2 3
1 1 2 2 1 2 3
2 1 2 3 2 4 4
Upper 3 3 4 5 4 5 5
Arms 4 4 5 5 5 6 7
5 6 7 8 7 8 8
6 7 8 8 8 9 9
The results of the analysis showed that the score in table A was 8 while B in table C, so
a score of 10 was obtained for the tile production process as seen in Table 6.
159
Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia Vol.7, No.2: 31-12-2021
(The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic) ISSN Print: 1411 – 951 X, ISSN Online: 2503-1716
The recapitulation of the body posture score of the tile production process is shown in
Table 7.
Table 7. Recapitulation of REBA Scores for Tile Production Process Work Posture
Work Station Table A Score Table B Score Table C Score REBA Score
Refining 3 1 3 4
Pressing 4 4 5 6
Drying 5 3 6 7
Milling 4 3 7 8
Burning 7 2 8 9
Ingredients Mixing 6 5 9 10
Sun-drying 7 5 10 11
Based on the REBA score, the categorization and corrective actions can be seen in
Table 8.
After knowing the level of risk from the work posture of the tile production process, the
results can be categorized according to the REBA score. REBA Score Categorization can be
seen in Table 9.
Based on Table 8, there are 3 postures with a moderate level of risk and need
improvement, there are 3 postures with a high risk that need immediate improvement, there is
1 posture with a very high risk and currently need to get an improvement process. The entire
body posture of workers in the tile production process in SMEs requires corrective action.
The results of the analysis of body postures at the tile-producing SMEs show many
work postures that can pose a risk of injury. This can be seen in the category value of the
REBA method. The results of the categorization obtained medium, high and very high
categories. A solution to reduce the risk of injury is to improve work postures for all tile
160
Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia Vol.7, No.2: 31-12-2021
(The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic) ISSN Print: 1411 – 951 X, ISSN Online: 2503-1716
production processes. After calculating the score, the corrected score can be seen in Table 10.
Table 10. REBA score results after improving all work stations
The suggestion to improve posture for tile drying workers is because the results of the
REBA score before improvements are categorized as very high risk levels, so that body
posture improvements can be seen in Figure 2.
The posture of the workers carried out is as shown in Figure 2. The body posture score
of the drying process of the tile can be seen in Table 11.
The posture of the workers in the tile production at the drying work station shows that
the neck is given a score of 1 because the angle is 14o forward, the torso is given a score of 1
because it is 0o balanced, and the legs are given a score of 1 balanced leg as seen in table 1,
so the final foot score is 1. Results Observing the posture of the neck, torso and legs while
161
Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia Vol.7, No.2: 31-12-2021
(The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic) ISSN Print: 1411 – 951 X, ISSN Online: 2503-1716
working, the scores are entered into table A, the score is 1, which can be seen in Table 12.
Neck
Table
1 2 3
A
Legs 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
1 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 3 3 5 6
2 2 3 4 5 3 4 5 6 4 5 6 7
Torso 3 2 4 5 6 4 5 6 7 5 6 7 8
4 3 5 6 7 5 6 7 8 6 7 8 9
5 4 6 7 8 6 7 8 9 7 8 9 9
The posture of the tile production workers shows that the upper arm is given a score of
2 because of the large angle of 35o forward, the forearm is given a score of 2 because of the
angle of 122o forward, the wrist is given a score of 1 because the angle of 0o down can be
seen in Table 13.
With the scores obtained from the results of observing the posture of the upper arms,
forearms and wrists while working, the scores are entered into table B and a score of 2 is
obtained and there is no additional grip score, because when working, you are already
holding the tool according to Table 14.
Lower Arms
Table B 1 2
Wrists 1 2 3 1 2 3
1 1 2 2 1 2 3
2 1 2 3 2 4 4
Upper 3 3 4 5 4 5 5
Arms 4 4 5 5 5 6 7
5 6 7 8 7 8 8
6 7 8 8 8 9 9
After entering the final scores of tables A & B in table C, a score of 3 tile production
processes is obtained as seen in Table 15.
162
Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia Vol.7, No.2: 31-12-2021
(The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic) ISSN Print: 1411 – 951 X, ISSN Online: 2503-1716
The recapitulation of the body posture score for the tile production process is shown in
Table 16.
Table 16. REBA Score Recapitulation of Work Posture in the Tile Production Process
Based on the REBA score, the categorization and corrective actions can be seen in
Table 17.
After knowing the level of risk from the work posture of the tile production process, the
results obtained are in accordance with the REBA Score categorization. REBA Score
Categorization can be seen in Table 18.
163
Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia Vol.7, No.2: 31-12-2021
(The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic) ISSN Print: 1411 – 951 X, ISSN Online: 2503-1716
Improvement Working
REBA Score Risk Level
Actions Station
Milling
Might be Drying
2-3 Low
Necessary Refining
Burning
Mixing
4-7 Medium Necessary Pressing
Sun-drying
Based on Table 18, there are 3 postures with low risk levels that may need
improvement and there are 4 postures with moderate risk that need improvement. The entire
body postures of workers in the tile production process in SMEs require a tool design to help
their work so that it would be easier and could reduce the risk of injury.
Proposed work tools is also useful for reducing the occurrence of injuries to workers
and so it could facilitate work. Tool design was done using Solidworks software. The design
of this tool is used to help workers do their jobs easily and reduce the risk of injury. The size
of this table is 400 cm long, 200 cm wide, 100 cm high. The reason is because they can put
the roof tiles when drying so that workers would not have to bend over. Design can be seen in
Figure 3.
CONCLUSION
The results of the workers' posture scores at the work station and the level of risk using
the Rapid Entire Body Assessment (REBA) method before improvements were 4 for
smoothing, 6 for pressing, 7 for drying, 8 for grinding, 9 for burning, 10 for mixing, and 11
for sun-drying. The results of the worker's posture score while working and the level of risk
using the Rapid Entire Body Assessment (REBA) method after improvements is 3 for
grinding, 3 for drying, 3 for refining, 3 for burning, 4 for mixing, 4 for pressing, and 4 for
sun-drying.
Proposed improvements are given to help change the worker's body posture according
to the ideal posture in order to avoid injury to the body. With the addition of a desk, it can
164
Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia Vol.7, No.2: 31-12-2021
(The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic) ISSN Print: 1411 – 951 X, ISSN Online: 2503-1716
help the workers do their jobs easier. The design of the table facility is adjusted to the size of
the worker's posture so that workers are more comfortable when using it.
REFERENCES
Alejandro Reyes. (2014). Beginner’s Guide to SolidWorks 2014 - Level I - Alejandro Reyes -
Google Buku. Beginner’s Guide to SolidWorks 2014.
https://books.google.co.id/books?id=MFS5AgAAQBAJ&printsec=frontcover&dq
=solidworks+2014&hl=id&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi46Inhu-
LmAhWkguYKHcDICY8Q6AEIKTAA#v=onepage&q=solidworks 2014&f=false
Herdiana, D. (2012). Analisis Pemindahan Material Secara Manual Pekerja Pengangkut
Genteng Ud. Sinar Mas Dengan Menggunakan Metode Rapid Entire Body
Assessment (Reba).
Middlesworth, M. (2014). A Step-by-Step Guide Rapid Entire Body Assessment ( REBA ).
Ergonomics Plus Inc, 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0003-6870(99)00039-3
Nur, R. F., Lestari, E. R., & Mustaniroh, S. A. (2016). Analisis Postur Kerja pada Stasiun
Pemanenan Tebu dengan Metode OWAS dan REBA, Studi Kasus di PG Kebon
Agung, Malang. Teknologi Dan Manajemen Agroindustri, 5(1), 39–45.
Rahayu, W. (2012). Faktor-faktor yang Berhubungan dengan Keluhan Muskuloskeletal pada
Pekerja Angkat-angkut Industri Pemecahan Batu di Kecamatan Karangnongko
Kabupaten Klaten. Jurnal Kesehatan Masyarakat Universitas Diponegoro, 1(2),
18728.
Ristanto & Uswatun Insani. (2014). Buku Ajar Asuhan Keperawatan Medikal Bedah: Sistem
Muskuloskeletal - Risnanto dan Uswatun Insani - Google Buku. Buku Ajaran
Asuhan Keperawatan Medikal Bedah.
https://books.google.co.id/books?id=Si88DAAAQBAJ&pg=PA21&dq=postur+tub
uh+adalah&hl=id&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj14JeI0LTlAhVXT30KHYlwAMgQ6A
EIKDAA#v=onepage&q=postur tubuh adalah&f=false
Sulaiman, F., & Sari, Y. P. (2018). Analisis Postur Kerja Pekerja Proses Pengeasahan Batu
Akik Dengan Menggunakan Metode Reba. Jurnal Optimalisasi, 1(1), 16–25.
https://doi.org/10.35308/jopt.v1i1.167
Utami, U. (2017). Hubungan Lama Kerja, Sikap Kerja dan Beban Kerja Dengan
Muskuloskeletal Disorders (MSDs) Pada Petani Padi di Desa Ahuhu Kecamatan
Meluhu Kabupaten Konawe Tahun 2017. Jurnal Ilmiah Mahasiswa Kesehatan
Masyarakat Unsyiah, 2(6), 198186.
165