Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2(1), 2019.

ISSN 2644-4542

Anyakoha, C. (2019). Job analysis as a tool for improved organizational performance of SMEs in Lagos, Nigeria.
Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2 (1), 7-16. doi:
10.33382/cejllpm.2019.02.01

JOB ANALYSIS AS A TOOL FOR IMPROVED

ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE OF SMEs IN LAGOS,
NIGERIA
Chukwunonye Anyakoha 1
1
Faculty of Vocational Technical Education, University of Nigeria, Nsukka, Enugu State

Received: 30. March 2019, Reviewed: 26. April 2019, Accepted 19. May 2019

Abstract
This study explored the influence of job analysis on organizational performance among 180
small and medium scale enterprises in Lagos, Nigeria. Data was obtained using structured
questionnaires and analysis of company financial statements. The analysis was done using
statistical package for social science (SPSS) version 20 and the results obtained showed that
proper job analysis improves productivity at work, efficiency and organizational profitability.
Findings also showed that there are significant challenges that hamper the effective
implementation of job analysis in SMEs in Lagos. The study thus recommended that
entrenching a company policy of robust talent management and job analysis in order to bring
about continuous improvement of staff performance and organizational efficiency.

Key words
Job analysis, human resource management, small and medium scale enterprises,
organizational performance

DOI:10.33382/cejllpm.2019.02.01

JEL classification: D21, D23, J08

Introduction
Job analysis involves the process of understanding the jobs that need to be filled in an
organization, the specific tasks that are supposed to be accomplished by individuals doing
these jobs, the human traits and characteristics needed in order to do these jobs and the
parameters that can be used to evaluate the successful and effective execution of these jobs.
According to Dessler (2013), job analysis could be defined as the procedure determining the
duties and skill requirements of a job and the kind of individual or individuals who should be
hired.
Business organizations in recent times have adopted job analysis as a very important human
resource planning strategy. This is due to the fact that the human resource is the most
important resource of every business organization. According to Sackett and Laczo (2003),
proper human resource management practice has a direct positive effect on organizational
performance. The study further mentioned that business organizations that pursue job analysis

7
 Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2(1), 2019. ISSN 2644-4542

as a planning strategy for human resource management tend to have competitive advantage
over organizations that do not make such provisions.
Previous research work done on job analysis focused on the methodological aspects of the
topic, thus making significant contributions to the field of human resource management by
developing procedures and techniques for generating job-related data. This has enabled
experts to effectively apply the procedures of job analysis in various organizations.
Furthermore, Osibanjo, Kehinde and Abiodun (2012) opined that job analysis information and
procedures have effectively been used to provide information about jobs and also
characteristics for jobs, thus helping recruiters to know the features they are looking out for in
prospective employees and also for job seekers to ascertain if they are qualified for the job
that they seek.
The importance of job analysis cannot be over-emphasized. According to Fine and Cronshaw
(2009), job analysis is the backbone of nearly all human resource management activities. He
further mentioned that it provides information about jobs and job holders, utilized by human
resource professionals to develop job descriptions as well as design performance evaluation
standards that will be used for staff appraisal. In addition, Adegbami (2013) also mentioned
that job analysis helps management in preparing appropriate recruitment strategies, training
and development, compensation packages as well as health and safety requirements that are
designed around the demands and characteristics of the job. He further mentioned that this
information is vital to the job seekers as they adequately prepare themselves to be qualified
for the jobs that they seek and know areas where they are deficient in order to develop
themselves.. Effective human resource practice requires a clear understanding of the details of
jobs on the part of the organization and employees, thus making it intuitively imperative that
there is a relationship between job analysis and company performance.
Despite the increased importance of job analysis, there has not been enough empirical
research done , especially linking it organizational performance in African countries. It is
based on this gap that this study is carried out and is aimed at examining this link between job
analysis and organizational performance, and test it with empirical data obtained from 160
SMEs in Nigeria.

Theoretical background
Over the years, management experts have been of the view that sound human resource
practices significantly help in improving organizational productivity and financial
performance. The advantages of job analysis go beyond business organizations, but also for
public sector enterprises and non-profit organization. However, this study focuses on the role
of job analysis for business organizations. One of the theoretical designs adopted in job
analysis is the Hackman and Oldham job characteristics model, as described by Anyadike
(2013). This model postulates that desirable job outcomes are cultivated in response to the
task itself. This model, postulated by Hackman and Oldham (1980) further postulated that in
order for motivation to prevail among workers, the tasks being assigned must stimulate
satisfaction within their own specific context. Tasks should be identifiable and there should
also be a tangible outcome, while significantly impacting the organization and the individuals
working in the organization. The theory of the job characteristics model, according to

8
 Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2(1), 2019. ISSN 2644-4542

Bohlander and Snell (2009) relies on stretching the capabilities of individual workers by
creating a challenging work environment by giving workers greater autonomy, responsibility,
rotation and job enrichment. In another related study, Wilson (2004) also mentioned that it is
important to periodically administer periodic surveys in order to ensure that workers are
continually motivated and improved in their work environment and measures be taken in
order to improve upon identified deficiencies.
In order to ensure the success of administrative decisions in business organizations, it is
important to ensure that workers participate in the decision making process of the
organization. According to Robinson (2012) when workers have a say in decisions made by
the management of the organization, these workers perceive the procedures within the
organization more favourably as opposed to situations when they are not given a voice in
managerial decisions.
Another theory of job analysis is the Job Embeddedness Theory. This theory postulates that if
employees are embedded to their job, it is unlikely that they will leave (Rogelberg, 2007).
Job Embeddedness is measured with the relationship of an employee’s fit with the
organization and the individual’s social links to the workplace and the community. However,
Schmitt and Fine (2003) mentioned that a significant limitation of the job Embeddedness
theory is that it places heavy emphasis on factors such as marital status the workers’
connection to the community and many of these are outside the jurisdiction of the manager.
The Human Capital Theory of job analysis postulates that human workers within an
organization may be used interchangeably, and that human workers bring a tangible asset
within an organization in the form of their learned skills, innate talent and relationships
(Schneider and Konz, 1999). This theory thus views the individual worker as an asset or a
liability to the organization, thus this makes it imperative that business firms employ
individuals who have the aptitudes and capabilities that are contained in the job description.
Job analysis is vital in order to achieve the strategic plans and objectives of a business firm.
According to Anyim, Ikemefuna and Mbah (2011), job analysis information helps in
identifying key employee competencies required in different work positions as well as
training needs that to be met, thus consistently equipping workers with the needed skills for
doing the job effectively. Furthermore, the organizational tradition also helps in determining
the key traits that are needed by employees. For instance, according to Edien (2015), a
business organization that thrives on creativity and constant improvement will not limit its
workers to being “pigeon-holed” at their position, but look beyond their own jobs and
constantly seek for ways to improve things in their organization. The study thus
recommended that competency–based job analysis be used by business organizations and the
traditions and strategic plan of an organization should be considered in every decision
pertaining to staff recruitment and training in order to effectively organize work around the
employees competencies in order to bring about continuous improvement.
Companies that conduct regular job analysis are more able to get the best from their
employees than those that do not apply job analysis. According to Fine and Cronshaw (2009),
this is due to the fact that organizations that carry out job analysis set minimum required
performance benchmarks for their employees and also bring about proper evaluation
benchmarks that will be used to for effective employee performance appraisal. In another
related study, Franklin (2005) also opined that proper job analysis information helps business

9
 Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2(1), 2019. ISSN 2644-4542

firms in making decision about the right compensation package that is suitable for the job
position; decision about training needs required for the job, and also helps ensuring that the
organization complies with existing employment laws that exist in the country or community,
where the enterprise is based in. Furthermore, Bannick, Levine and Morgeso (2007) were of
the view that proper job analysis helps organizations to set up human resource management
systems in place that will not be too difficult for new entrants to understand, thus creating an
atmosphere of stability and sustainability.
The most important aspect of job analysis is designing the job description. The job description
is a written statement of what the worker does, how he/she ought to do it and the working
conditions under which the work shall be done. According to Cascio and Aguinus (2005), the
information contained in the job description helps inform the job seeker the role his job plays
in the organization achieving its goals and objectives. He further mentioned that job
description information clearly highlights the chain of command of the organization, the
authorities as well as responsibility due to the job seeker. Harley (1999) mentioned that proper
job analysis, description and design promotes employee productivity as individuals specialize
on tasks that they are qualified and have the skill for. The study further mentioned that a
continuous repetition of tasks leads to expertise and dexterity.
The human resource department of every organization plays a key role in its development. In
his study, Franklin (2005) mentioned that the human resource departments play important
management roles in organizations as they ensure that there is proper staffing of different
departments in the organization. In another related study, Muchinky (2012) mentioned that
the consequences of filling job positions with the wrong people cannot be exaggerated. The
study mentioned that an organization’s success is highly dependent on the quality of its
human resources, thus with increased competition amongst businesses and the need to
continually keep abreast with changing dynamics of the modern day business world, it is
imperative that competent individuals are put in various positions.
Some business organizations make use of competency-based job analysis to create employee
profiles for various positions in their organization. According to Okoye and Ezejiofor (2013),
competencies are observable and measurable behaviours of an individual that make the
performance of job tasks possible. Competency based job analysis involves describing the job
in terms of measurable and observable behavioural competencies (knowledge, skills and
behaviours) that an employee doing a job must exhibit. Furthermore, Siddique (2007)
mentioned that unlike the traditional job analysis that is job-focused, competency based
analysis is worker-focused, as it concentrates on the fact that the worker must be competent
enough to perform all the tasks inherent in the job. The study further mentioned that managers
usually group competencies into three broad parts namely general competencies, leadership
competencies and technical competencies. General competencies are described as skills that
are general in nature for instance writing, reading and language skills. Leadership
competencies on the other hand are skills that measure leadership ability of the individual
such as strategic thinking and planning ability, while technical competencies are specific
skills needed for the job, for instance, for a systems engineer position, the individual should
have the ability to create and design software applications.

10
 Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2(1), 2019. ISSN 2644-4542

In studying the behavioural aspect of job analysis, Wilson (2004) opined that one of the fears
employees have about job analysis is that a clear and concise definition of their work means
limiting their creativity and flexibility. The study further mentioned that employees are also
afraid about the purpose of elaborate examination of the workplace. In order to ameliorate this
fear , the study recommended that employees must be properly educated why job analysis is
done and also make an input on how they think the job can be done better. In another related
study, Rogelberg (2007) also mentioned that giving employees increased responsibility
improves their confidence level at work and also their level of contribution to the
organization. The study further mentioned that increased responsibility helps in improving the
leadership abilities of these employees as they are able to take on new tasks and lead new
projects.
Small and medium scale enterprises (SMEs) constitute a major bedrock of the Nigerian
economy. They contribute significantly to gross domestic product, tax revenue for the
government and also help in capacity utilization as well as giving new and prospective
entrepreneurs the opportunity to venture into entrepreneurship. Furthermore, according to
Anyakoha and Nwolisa (2017), SMEs help in creating employment for the society, especially
for fresh graduates, as they gain working experience in these organizations. It is therefore
critical that these organizations do well financially in order to achieve economic balance in
the country. For these SMEs, the human resource is their most important asset. This makes
human resource management an integral part of the management decisions in the
organization.
The Nigerian economy has been classified as a fast growing one, driven by private sector
growth, foreign investment and a surge of afri-capitalism. Furthermore, with a population of
more than 90 million individuals, there is available a dynamic workforce that if properly
harnessed, is capable of positioning the country’s economy into the best in Africa. Lagos state
on its own is the biggest economic hub of the country, with a large concentration of SMEs
that are championing innovation and commerce. The influx of foreign direct investment (FDI)
has created an impressive mix of domestic and foreign companies. This has created an
atmosphere of competition making it imperative that companies become productivity and
efficiency conscious. This in turn has made business organizations especially SMEs to search
for strong management practices, especially in the area of human resource management. Job
analysis provides a veritable human resource management tool for SMEs in achieving their
strategic objectives as it helps to clearly outline performance targets for employees of an
organization.
It is on the backdrop of this that this study is conducted and is aimed at exploring the
influence of job analysis on organizational performance of selected SMEs in Lagos State,
Nigeria. Financial performance (earnings, profitability and liquidity) as well as employee
satisfaction and staff turnover were used to ascertain the organizational performance.

11
 Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2(1), 2019. ISSN 2644-4542

Material and methods

A sample of 180 SMEs was randomly selected for this study, and these organizations were
distributed across the various local government areas in Lagos State. Structured
questionnaires were distributed to the managers of the various businesses, and 172, indicating
a return rate of 95.5%. Furthermore, the audited financial statements of the companies were
also used to ascertain profitability and earnings figures. SMEs were used for this study based
on the fact that they constitute more than 65% of the business organizations in Nigeria
(Anyakoha and Nwolisa, 2017). Furthermore, they also constitute 59% of total private sector
employment in the country.
The SMEs used for this study are based in Lagos state of Nigeria and are engaged in different
sectors of the Nigerian economy. The sectors of the economy that SMEs for this study are
engaged in include agriculture, oil and gas, extractive industry (mining industry), education,
non-professional services, fast moving consumer goods (FMCG), telecommunication and
information and communication technology (ICT). The justification for using Lagos State for
this study is based on the fact that Lagos has the highest concentration of SMEs in Nigeria
and also these SMEs cover almost all the sectors of the Nigerian economy. Also, a 5 point
Likert scale was used to measure the times that described the effect of job analysis on
organizational performance.
Results and discussion
Demographic Characteristics of the Sample
The results of data analysis are presented in the following section. Demographic
characteristics of the sample, outlining the sectors of the economy in which the SMEs are
engaged in are shown in Table 1.
Table 1: Sector Breakdown of Respondents for the Study
Sector Frequency Percent
Agriculture 19 11.05%
Oil and Gas 24 13.95%
Extractive Industry 21 12.21%
Education 17 9.88%
Non-professional services 28 16.28%
Fast Moving Consumer Goods 34 19.77%
Telecommunication 8 4.65%
ICT 21 12.21%
Source: Computed field data 2019

There was a fairly even distribution of respondents amongst different sectors of the economy,
with Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) sector having a slightly higher population than
the rest due to their prevalence in terms of population in SME sector. However, most of the
productive sectors of the economy were captured in the study.
Descriptive Statistics of Use of Job Analysis
Table 2 shows the descriptive statistics of the effect of job analysis on organizational
profitability of SMEs in Lagos, Nigeria
12
 Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2(1), 2019. ISSN 2644-4542

Table 2: Descriptive statistics of effect of job analysis on profitability

Variable Mean Standard Variance
Deviation
Less resources spent on correcting mistakes 4.13 1.05 1.71
Reduced wastage of production inputs 3.99 1.26 1.87
Proactive in anticipating problems before 3.71 0.89 2.42
they occur
Recruitment of skilled and qualified 4.01 0.97 2.39
manpower thus reduced training costs
Source: Analysis of field data 2019

The findings in Table 2 indicate that job analysis leads to fewer resources spent on correcting
mistakes. This is due to the fact that job tasks are properly outlined, thus enabling employees
to be methodical in accomplishing job tasks. In addition, the findings also show that job
analysis brings about a reduction in wastage during the production process. This could be
attributed to the fact that qualified and skilled workers are more efficient in carrying out their
tasks thus reducing mistakes and wastages. This is in agreement with the postulations of
Anyadike (2013), who mentioned that clearly specifying tasks for a given job helps human
resources departments to hire the best qualified staff and also makes employees to grasp the
rudiments of the job faster. Furthermore, Fine and Cronshaw (2009) also opined that
repetition of tasks leads to specialization, thus making for improved output at work.

Descriptive statistics on the effect of job analysis on employee productivity

Table 3 shows the descriptive statistics of the effects of job analysis on employee
productivity.

Table 3: Descriptive statistics on effect of job analysis on productivity

Variable Mean Standard Variance
deviation
Jobs are done efficiently 3.84 1.05 1.86
Minimal down-time between performing tasks 3.91 0.97 1.81
Rudiments of the job are mastered faster and 4.01 0.87 2.31
improved upon within a short time
Multi-tasking is done to more effect 3.84 0.91 2.42
Source: Analysis of field data, 2019

The findings in Table 3 shows that job analysis makes it possible for jobs to be done more
efficiently, thus using fewer resources to accomplish more objectives. Furthermore, the
findings also show that job analysis brings about minimal down-time between performing
different tasks. These are in agreement with the postulation of Okoye and Ezejiofor (2013)
who mentioned that job analysis leads to specialization and accomplishment of tasks in a

13
 Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2(1), 2019. ISSN 2644-4542

more efficient and effective manner. The findings from this study also show that job analysis
enables employees to master the rudiments the job faster, thus reducing mistakes and costs in
the medium and long run. This is in agreement with the findings of Osibanjo, Kehinde and
Abiodun (2012) who mentioned that faster understanding of the rudiments of a job reduces
training costs for the organization, increases efficiency and leads to more productivity, thus
giving the organization an edge over its competitors.
Descriptive Statistics on the Challenges of Implementing Job Analysis in SMEs
Table 4 shows the challenges that are faced by SMEs in implementing job analysis
Variable Mean Standard Variance
deviation
Lack of management support 3.71 0.91 1.81
Lack of support by employees 3.87 0.97 1.76
Bias on the part of the job analyst 4.01 1.09 2.04
Using single data source 3.61 0.76 2.03
Inability to identify the need for job analysis 3.92 0.85 2.30
Source: Data analysis 2019
The findings in Table 4 show that lack of management support significantly hampers the
effective implementation of job analysis in SMEs. In order to inculcate such an important
policy in an enterprise, there is a need for top management not only support but work in
tandem with human resource departments in order to promulgate optimal polices on staffing,
employee training and job analysis. Furthermore, lack of support on the part of employees
significantly hampers the implementation of job analysis. These findings are in agreement
with the postulations of Schmitt and Foe (2003) who mentioned that the use of single source
of data for job descriptions does not give an accurate and complete description of what is
expected for different jobs. They further mentioned that it is imperative for the job analyst to
be objective in order to properly itemize and describe what is expected from an employee in a
given position. The findings are also in agreement with the postulations of Anyadike (2013)
who mentioned that there is a need to properly educate employees on the value and need for
job analysis in order for it to be implemented effectively. The study further opined that
employees should also be involved in the job analysis process so as to make it more dynamic
and effective.

Conclusion
The findings from this study have shown that job analysis contributes significantly to
organizational performance. Furthermore, the findings from this study also buttress the fact
that job analysis is an important strategic management decision for business organizations.
Human resource departments play a key role in organizational development by ensuring that
only skilled and qualified candidates are recommended for job positions. Furthermore,
staffing constitutes very important management decision, thus the strategic plan of an
organization must include staffing and how the staff employed will help the organization to
attain its strategic objectives. This study thus recommends that SMEs should inculcate a
culture of job analysis in their operations and use it as a framework in making recruitment
decisions, drawing staff training curriculum and also making promotion and appraisal
decisions. Furthermore, job seekers should also study the requirements, rudiments and

14
 Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2(1), 2019. ISSN 2644-4542

responsibilities pertaining to the jobs they want to apply for in order to ensure that they
possess the needed aptitudes, attitudes, qualifications and experience needed for the job.
The findings of this study are relevant for human resource professionals as it helps them to
initiate workable human resource management principles and activities that will help their
organizations to achieve strategic goals. Furthermore, findings from this study are also
important for management decisions of SMEs as they employ the specific type of job analysis
most suitable for them.

Acknowledgement

This study was supported by the Department of Business Education, University of Nigeria
Nsukka and the Small Medium Scale Enterprise Development Agency of Nigeria.

References

1. Adegbami, A. (2013). Effect of Underemployment on Human Resources Efficiency

and
2. Wellbeing in Nigeria. The African Symposium 13(2), 14-27.
3. Anyadike, N. (2013). Human Resource Planning and Employee Productivity in
Nigeria Public Organization. Global Journal of Human Resource Management, 1(4),
56-68.
4. Anyakoha, C. and Nwolisa, C. (2017). Financial Innovation and Entrepreneurship
Development in Lagos State of Nigeria: Challenges and Prospects for Small and
Medium Scale Enterprises. Innovation Management, Entrepreneurship and
Sustainability 2017 Conference Proceedings Citation Index, Prague Economic Papers
pp. 16-27
5. Anyim, F, Ikemefuna, C. And Mbah, S. (2011). Human Resource Management
Challenges in Nigeria Under a Globalized Economy. International Journal of
Economics and Management Sciences 1(4), 1-11.
6. Bannick, M.; Levine, E.L. and Morgeso, F.P. (2007). Job and Work Analysis:
Methods,
Research and Applications for Human Resource Management. California. Thousand
Oaks.
7. Bohlander, G. And Snell, S. (2009). Managing Human Resources. London. Cengage
Learning.
8. Cascio, W. and Aguinis, F. (2005). Applied Psychology in Human Resource
Management. New York. Penguin Books.
9. Dessler, G. (2013). Human Resource Management. London. Pearson Publishers.
10. Edien, A. (2015). Effects of Job Analysis on Personnel Innovation. International
Journal of Business Management Invention 4 (10), 9 – 18.
11. Fine, S. and Cronshaw, S. (2009). Functional Job Analysis: A Foundation for Human
Resources Management. New Jersey. Erlbaum Publishers.
12. Franklin, M. (2005). Guide to Job Analysis. American Society for Training and
Development.
13. Hartley, D. (1999). Job Analysis at the Speed of Reality. Amhers, Massachusetts. HRD
Press.
14. Muchinsky, P. (2012). Psychology Applied to Work. Summerfield. Hypergraphic
Press.

15
 Central European Journal of Labour Law and Personnel Management, 2(1), 2019. ISSN 2644-4542

15. Okoye, P. And Ezejiofor, R. (2013). The Effect of Human Resources Development on
Organizational Productivity. International Journal of Academic Research, Business
and
Social Sciences, 3(10), 25-268.
16. Osibanjo, A; Kehinde, J.,Abiodun, A. (2012). Human Resource Management and
Employee Job Satisfaction: Evidence from the Nigerian Banking Industry. Journal of
Economics and Business Research. 38(1), 17-32.
17. Robinson, M. (2012). What is Job Analysis? Institute of Psychology. April 18th.
18. Rogelberg, S. (2007). Encyclopaedia of Industrial and Organizational Psychology.
California. Thousand Oaks.
19. Sackett, P. and Laczo, R. (2003). Handbook on Psychology. New York. Forbes
Publishing
20. Schmitt, N and Fine, S. (2003). Inter-Rater Reliability of Judgements of Functional
Levels
21. and Skill Requirements of Jobs Based on Written Task Statements. Journal of
Occupational Psychology, 56 (2), 121-127.
22. Schneider, B and Konz, A. (1999). Strategic Job Analysis. Human Resource Manager,
28, 51-63.
23. Siddique, C. (2007). Job Analysis: A Strategic Human Resource Management
Practice. International Journal of Human Resource Management. 15 (1), 219 –
244.
24. Wilson, M. (2004). A History of Job Analysis. In L.Koppes, Historical Perspectives in
Industrial and Organizational Psychology. Lawrence Erbaum Associates.

Author contact
Chukwunonye Anyakoha. University of Nigeria, Nsukka, Enugu State, Faculty of Vocational
Technical Education, Department of Business Education. P.O. Box 3219, Nuskka, Enugu
State. Nigeria. E-mail: [email protected]
Authors´ ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1907-9295

16