Swann and Skelly-2016-Veterinary Medicine Research and Reports-AM
Swann and Skelly-2016-Veterinary Medicine Research and Reports-AM
Swann and Skelly-2016-Veterinary Medicine Research and Reports-AM
Barbara J Skelly:
Department of Veterinary Medicine
University of Cambridge
Madingley Road
Cambridge CB3 0ES
United Kingdom
+44 1223 337649
[email protected]
James Swann:
Queen Mother Hospital for Animals
The Royal Veterinary College
Hawkshead Lane
Hatfield
Hertfordshire
AL9 7TA
United Kingdom
+44 1707 666366
[email protected]
“Canine autoimmune hemolytic anemia: management challenges”.
• Opportunistic infections
• Non-regenerative disease
• Thromboembolic complications
• Kernicterus
Immune mediated haemolytic anaemia is one of the most common manifestations of canine immune
mediated disease yet treatment regimens remain non-standardised and, in some cases, controversial.
The main reason for this, as for most diseases in veterinary medicine, is the lack of large scale
placebo-controlled trials so that the efficacy of one treatment over another can be established. Most of
the evidence used for treatment comes from retrospective studies and personal preference and
experience and because of this treatment regimens tend to vary between institutions and between
individual clinicians.
Keywords
Conflict of interest:
disease of dogs1 and is encountered in first opinion and specialist practices in North America and
Europe. Clinical features of the disease are the result of a spontaneous autoimmune response directed
against normal glycoprotein molecules on the surface of the erythrocyte.2 Production of autoreactive
lysis (so called intravascular hemolysis) or due to phagocytosis by cells of the monocyte-phagocyte
system in the liver and spleen (extravascular hemolysis). These processes result in anemia and, in
Following diagnosis, many dogs with IMHA receive blood products, which are intended to achieve
clinical parameters, grouped together as the Anemic Dog Clinical Assessment Score (ADCAS), have
been evaluated as guides for administration of transfusions,3 but there is currently no consensus
regarding the optimal trigger for this procedure in dogs. The availability of blood products varies
according to geographical location and type of veterinary practice, with some institutions maintaining
colonies of donor animals and others relying on client-owned dogs or on charitable blood donation
Glucocorticoid products are commonly used for treatment of IMHA in dogs; in a recent systematic
review of studies produced at tertiary referral institutions, we found that these drugs had been
administered to all of the dogs included in the review5. Several other immunosuppressive drugs also
have been used to treat the disease, including azathioprine,6,7 leflunomide,8 ciclosporin9,10 and
optimal immunosuppressive regimen that should be employed after a dog has been diagnosed with
IMHA, and there has been considerable variation in the choice, dosage, duration and rate of reduction
rates of 50-70% reported in older studies,6,13 and rates of approximately 30-40% in more recent
availability of supportive care and blood products. A number of previous studies have investigated
associations between survival and biochemical, hematologic or clinical parameters that can be
measured at presentation to determine if these might have prognostic value. Review of the studies that
assessed prognostic factors using a multivariable statistical model revealed that serum bilirubin and
urea concentrations had each been significantly associated with survival in more than one previous
study,15 suggesting that these variables might be helpful in guiding clinical decisions in future.
A paragraph duplicating predicting disease outcome using scoring systems has been deleted here
Because clinical presentation and response treatment are so variable in dogs with IMHA, a number of
scoring systems have been developed to estimate the severity of disease and prognosis for dogs when
they are diagnosed. These scores have been generated by investigating associations between
individual clinicopathological variables and outcome, measured as survival time after diagnosis or
percentage mortality at a defined time point. Summaries of two different prognostic scores are
presented in Table 1. In a recent study, Goggs et al.,14 found that a combination of the American
Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) clinical grade and serum concentrations of bilirubin and urea or
creatinine predicted mortality with greater accuracy than either of the scores described by Whelan et
al.,16 or Ishihara et al.,17 in a sample of 276 dogs in the British Isles, but the authors unfortunately did
not present their own model in the same form of a user-friendly score. An additional study revealed
that the score developed in Japan did not predict survival in dogs with IMHA in Australia,18
highlighting the importance of using prognostic tools in a population for which they have been
validated.
of haemoglobinuria, haemolysed plasma and presence of persistent agglutination of red blood cells,
has traditionally been considered an indicator of a poor prognosis in dogs with IMHA. However, this
perception is not supported by the majority of clinical studies of factors associated with survival: only
two studies indicated that autoagglutination was associated with decreased survival using univariable
analyses. One of these studies subsequently showed no difference between cases that did or did not
have undefined ‘intravascular haemolysis’19 while the other demonstrated that agglutination was
associated with survival to discharge but not to one year after diagnosis.20 In contrast, serum total
haemolysis, has been associated consistently with survival in several previous studies that utilised
either univariable or multivariable analyses, albeit with considerable variation in the apparent size of
the effect.15, 19, 21, 13, 22, 10, 23, 24, 14 Consequently, we believe that this variable is likely to be the most
useful for the clinician in guiding therapy and estimating prognosis, particularly since it is easily
Corticosteroids, mainly the glucocorticoid, prednisolone, have been the mainstay of treatment for
many years. No protocols are described that do not include corticosteroids, probably because many
would consider it unethical to conduct a treatment trial that withholds this class of drugs.25 When other
drugs are assessed for their usefulness in IMHA they are given in conjunction with corticosteroids and
compared to steroids alone. There have been no known, multiple patient, published trials that have
shown that any other immunosuppressive drug can be used alone in the management of IMHA though
anecdotal reports have suggested that this may be possible and ciclosporin has been used for this
purpose by these authors in circumstances when owners have refused to use steroid therapy due to the
inflammatory responses. Chronic auto-immune and inflammatory diseases develop when the stimuli to
perpetuate the immune response outweigh the ability of endogenous glucocorticoids to suppress the
response. This results in the hyper-activation of the immune system characteristic of these diseases.
Although steroids are undeniably effective at treating IMHA they do so with a number of potentially
severe side effects that often have an impact on an owner’s willingness to continue with treatment.
Steroids cause polydipsia and polyuria through their interference with ADH function, polyphagia,
panting, restlessness, muscle weakness and wasting, thromboembolic disease and proteinuria. These
people, steroid use is much more restricted by side effects and hypertension and osteoporosis are
commonly seen. For this reason it is rare that immune-mediated diseases in humans are managed with
steroids alone and other drugs, splenectomy and monoclonal antibody treatments are used both for
Steroids have the ability to worsen the clinical signs in an animal that already has signs of disease in
another body system. An example of this would be the ability of steroid therapy to induce or worsen
congestive heart failure in a dog with pre-existing heart disease (e.g. mitral valve endocardiosis or
glucocorticoid administration in patients with heart failure due to the sodium and water retention they
induce. More latterly, it has been suggested that glucocorticoids may actually act synergistically with
diuretics in some patients to improve diuresis and therefore clinical wellbeing. This area has not been
The drugs and their dosing regimens commonly used for the management of IMHA along with other
in combinations, and a number of different infectious complications have been reported with the use of
induced lesions,38 but there is little evidence available in dogs to indicate how often these
complications arise.
number of different autoimmune diseases and following transplantation.39,40 These appear to affect the
respiratory tract most commonly, resulting in pneumonia with or without the involvement of the
opportunistic organism Pneumocystis jirovecii. The latter organism could present a theoretical risk to
dogs receiving immunosuppressive therapy but has been reported only in dogs with immunoglobulin
deficiency, with or without B cell hypoplasia.41,42,43 Immunocompromised people are also predisposed
to development of active infections with Toxoplasma gondii, and a number of case reports indicate
that similar complications could occur in dogs treated with immunosuppressive drugs due to
Survival curves constructed from data from dogs with IMHA show curves with similar slopes
reflecting the fact that most deaths occur in the first two weeks after diagnosis.13,24,47 Problems arise
when immunosuppressive regimens are instituted and there is either no control of the haemolytic
process or no regenerative state is achieved. In these circumstances clinicians often look to increase
the breadth of the immunosuppression by adding other agents. Most dogs achieve initial control using
prednisolone +/- another agent, usually azathioprine or ciclosporin. When there is a less than optimal
response to treatment, other agents are added including azathioprine and ciclosporin to increase to two
immunosuppressive agents or three depending on whether the dog was on mono or dual therapy to
begin with. If this does not alter the disease process there are a number of options for clinicians, none
Several studies have looked at the role of hIVIg for this purpose. As far back as 1997, Kellerman and
Bruyette suggested that hIVIg would be a good option for dogs that did not respond to prednisolone
therapy within 7 days.48 This was reiterated by a later study49 but better long term survival was not
proven.50,51 In the one published prospective study, again hIVIg did not alter response to treatment or
survival23 although the survival data compared favourably to other studies (24/28 survived to 2 weeks,
86%). The question that has not been answered by these studies is whether hIVIg is able to alter
prognosis and survival in a dog that would not otherwise have responded to standard medication i.e.
one that would be expected to have a poor prognosis based on our current understanding of prognostic
markers. For this to be answered clinicians would have to have at their disposal a robust prognostic
scoring system that could reliably pick out dogs that may benefit from more intensive drug regimens.
In the human literature a strong case is made for the role of splenectomy in IMHA patients with
survival rates encouragingly high.52 The idea that splenectomy may be helpful is decades old in
veterinary medicine too with reports dating back to 1985 reporting 100% survival in 3 dogs with
IMHA.53 More recently a retrospective study evaluated 10 dogs that were splenectomised as part of
their treatment for IMHA.54 This study showed a 90% survival at 30 days with PCVs rising
significantly 3 days after the procedure and a reduced requirement for transfusion. These studies
appear to suggest that IMHA could be managed successfully by splenectomy and that this technique
between 3 and 6 months and are rarely standardized, though some authors55 have found it helpful to
use standard protocols within their institution with the result that retrospective studies become more
meaningful and data collection is easier. The treatment regimen described at Utrecht follows a 69 day
gradually tapering course. Relapses prompt a return to the beginning of the regimen. Too rapid
tapering has been associated with an increased incidence of relapse but strong evidence for this is
Classically, IMHA is diagnosed when an animal has a regenerative anaemia associated with
autoagglutination, Coombs’ test positivity and spherocytosis and in the absence of any recognisable
underlying disease pathology. The regenerative response does not happen immediately however, and
3-5 days are required before an adequate reticulocyte response is recognised after acute haemolysis. If
there is no appropriate reticulocyte response after 5 days then it is still possible that immune mediated
disease is the cause and animals may have either pure red cell aplasia (PRCA) or non-regenerative
IMHA56. PRCA is diagnosed when erythroid aplasia results from presumed immune-mediated
destruction of precursor cells within the bone marrow.56,57,58 Non-regenerative IMHA appears to be a
related disorder in that immune-mediated red cell destruction takes place within the marrow and
maturation arrest of the erythroid lineage at different stages of maturation can be recognised. In
addition, some forms of non-regenerative IMHA are associated with bone marrow erythroid
and haemophagocytic syndrome. Dogs that have similar haematological changes peripherally can
therefore have very different bone marrow profiles varying from PRCA to erythroid hyperplasia.
Although the names PRCA and non-regenerative IMHA have been given to these conditions based on
the cytological evaluation of the bone marrow, from a purely clinical perspective it would appear that
PRCA is just one end of a continuum of immune-mediated disease that begins as destruction of early
precursors and ends with destruction of mature circulating cells. These diseases all have the same
feature of immune-mediated cell lysis and should all respond to immunosuppression, albeit to different
degrees. Giving a specific disease name, such as PRCA suggests it is a separate disease entity and
somehow is unrelated to peripheral IMHA. We would argue that these diseases are closely related and
are only separated by the stage of maturation of the cell type that is the specific target for auto-
The prognosis for dogs with PRCA is reported to be fair within the available literature with survival
rates of 72-79%.56,59 However, numbers are low and the authors’ perception is that these diseases are
more difficult to manage. In one study,59 dogs with non-regenerative IMHA and erythroid hyperplasia
were shown to have statistically significant lower 60 day survival rate (56%) when compared with
dogs showing maturation arrest or PRCA. Again, low numbers make this information open to
interpretation. Many clinicians would choose a more aggressive multi-drug form of therapy from the
outset for these cases or would ramp up therapy after treatment with steroid alone fails to resolve the
disease within a reasonable timeframe (10-14 days). The evidence for such choices is lacking however
and as much of the literature is 8 or more years old, it does not include information about newer drug
Thromboembolic disease: Formation of thrombi is one of the major complications suffered by dogs
with IMHA47,60, and the pathophysiology of this process has been reviewed elsewhere.61 Pulmonary
thromboembolism (PTE) is reported most commonly, but vessels in other locations, including the
brain, spleen, portal vasculature and kidneys may be affected.22,24,62 One of the major challenges
involved in managing PTE in dogs with IMHA is the difficulty in diagnosing this complication ante
mortem. Formation of a thrombus does not result in reliable changes in the radiographic appearance
of the lungs,63 nor does it consistently cause hypoxemia in all cases.64 A recent study indicated that
computed tomography with pulmonary angiography, which is considered the gold standard imaging
modality for diagnosis of PTE in people, might produce greater diagnostic accuracy,65 but this form of
imaging is expensive and not readily available in clinical practice. As a result, PTE is often suspected
if there are consistent clinical and laboratory findings, such as acutely increased respiratory rate and
effort, hypoxaemia and increased alveolar to arterial oxygen gradient,66 but it may be difficult to
establish whether these changes could have a different aetiology, such as secondary bacterial
pneumonia, acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) or increased respiratory drive due to cerebral
hypoxia.
There has been frequent speculation that development of thromboembolic disease is predictive of a
poor outcome in dogs with IMHA,22,62 but definitive proof of this hypothesis is lacking, partly due to
the difficulty in confirming the existence of the problem in live animals. Paradoxically, greater
maximal amplitude values obtained by thromboelastography in dogs with IMHA were associated with
a poor prognosis.
Due to its importance as a possible cause of additional morbidity and mortality, there has been
extensive discussion of the use of anticoagulant therapy, either for symptomatic animals or as
prophylaxis for those recently diagnosed with the disease.61 These discussions are somewhat
state and increased risk of clinically detectable thromboembolic disease, and by the lack of concrete
risk of death.
Among the drugs evaluated in clinical practice, some inhibit platelet activation (aspirin, clopidogrel)
and some limit the activity of coagulation factors (unfractionated and low molecular weight heparin).
form of anticoagulant therapy,5 and it is likely that requirements will differ widely between individual
regimens that were administered to dogs with IMHA shortly after diagnosis and alongside a
standardized immunosuppressive protocol that included prednisone and azathioprine.60 This study
demonstrated that administration of aspirin at an ‘ultra-low’ dose of 0.5 mg/kg twice daily resulted in
improved survival compared to dogs that received no anticoagulant drug, heparin alone or a
combination of aspirin and heparin. A smaller prospective and randomised study evaluated the use of
clopigogrel alone, ultra-low dose aspirin alone or a combination of the two drugs, but did not reveal
any significant difference in survival between the three regimens.69 Whilst apparently not supporting
the use of clopidogrel in dogs with IMHA, this study is likely to have been underpowered, recruiting
just six cases per group. There is suspicion that a proportion of dogs with IMHA will also have
platelets that are relatively resistant to the action of aspirin, as has been reported in people. In this
situation, it may be of benefit to consider the use of an alternative anti-platelet drug if platelet function
Use of heparin for management of thrombi has several theoretical advantages because venous
cascade, rather than abnormal platelet activity.61 This class of drug is also used widely in people that
have similar diseases, including deep vein thrombosis and PTE related to recent surgery or cardiac
disease.70 Both unfractionated and low molecular weight heparin have been administered to dogs with
IMHA in an attempt to reduce the frequency and severity of thromboembolic disease, but the regimens
and the studies used to evaluate their effects have varied widely.5
Helmond and others71 performed a randomised controlled trial to compare the effects of administering
unfractionated heparin at a conventional and fixed dose from the point of diagnosis, with those of in
which the dose of heparin was adjusted on a daily basis according to the results of repeated factor X
assays. The latter group of dogs had significantly improved survival and required a wider variety of
different heparin doses to achieve the desired reduction in factor X concentration. This study
heparin, limiting its use outside of the hospital environment.72 Whilst possibly representing a valuable
addition to therapy in dogs in which PTE or similar disease is suspected, some forms of heparin are
expensive and access to factor X assays is limited to a small number of veterinary institutions. Similar
assays are available at many human hospitals, so monitoring may be feasible if a good working
Bilirubin encephalopathy: There have been two case reports of dogs suffering neurological signs that
appeared to be related to increased serum bilirubin concentrations,73 one in a dog with primary
IMHA.74 This phenomenon, properly termed bilirubin encephalopathy and occasionally kernicterus,
has been described most commonly in human neonates and rarely in adults with deficient activity of
the hepatic enzyme uridine diphosphate (UDP) glucuronyl transferase, which is responsible for
conjugation of bilirubin.
Bilirubin encephalopathy is suspected in people with excessive total serum bilirubin concentrations
(usually in excess of 500 umol/l) that begin to show neurological signs. In the dog with IMHA in
which it was suspected, magnetic resonance imaging of the brain revealed increased intensity in T2
weighted images of the basal ganglia and other central nuclei,74 and post mortem examination of both
adult dogs diagnosed with the disease showed yellow pigmentation of the thalamus.
In clinical practice, the majority of dogs will not develop hyperbilirubinaemia that is so severe as to
result in bilirubin encephalopathy, but we believe that this condition should be considered in icteric
Distal renal tubular acidosis: A case series published in 2009 described distal renal tubular acidosis
in three dogs with IMHA.75 In all three cases, the diagnosis was based on the presence of metabolic
acidosis with normal anion gap and inappropriately high urine anion gap and bicarbonate excretion.
The acidemia was treated in all three dogs with infusions of sodium bicarbonate but all were
acquired distal renal tubular acidosis in people,76 particularly in association with systemic lupus
erythematosus, rheumatoid arthritis, and Sjogren’s syndrome, in which it may affect up to one quarter
of patients.77,78,79 It has been suggested that the phenomenon develops due to production of
autoantibodies that interfere with the action of ion transporters in the distal tubule.80
It is not known how frequently distal renal tubular acidosis develops in dogs with IMHA or other
autoimmune diseases, or whether it has any impact on the outcome in affected dogs. In people, the
acidosis is usually treated with potassium citrate rather than sodium bicarbonate, as this will treat the
Haemoglobin-related acute kidney injury: Experience gained from treating human injuries during
the Second World War suggested that excessive circulating concentrations of myoglobin and free
haemoglobin could cause acute kidney injury, and the same syndrome was produced experimentally
by injecting haemoglobin into dogs in 1947.82 More recent studies suggest that haem proteins cause
damage to the kidneys in several different ways, including oxidant damage to cellular molecules and
It would appear that azotaemic acute kidney injury is not common in dogs with IMHA as it has not
been reported frequently in dogs with this disease, although increased serum concentrations of both
urea and creatinine have been associated with decreased survival in affected dogs.14,50,10,7
Interestingly, a study of dogs at high risk of haemoglobin-induced nephropathy (including dogs with
IMHA, dogs infected with Babesia canis rossi and dogs that had been injected with large amounts of
haemoglobin) reported serum creatinine concentrations within normal limits in all groups.84
Glomerular filtration rate was also measured in all individuals and was reported to be ‘normal’, but it
was not clear whether these values were standardised to breed and age group reference intervals.
In conclusion, while release of large amounts of free haemoglobin into the circulation could increase
the risk of acute kidney injury, this phenomenon has not been reported frequently in the veterinary
literature. Furthermore, in patients with greatly reduced blood oxygen-carrying capacity and systemic
inflammation, it may be difficult to establish whether azotaemia has developed due to the effect of
There have been anecdotal reports that recent vaccination could be associated with development of
IMHA in dogs, and a study produced in the United States suggested that dogs with IMHA were much
likely to have been vaccinated in the month prior to onset of clinical signs than a group of control dogs
presented for management of other diseases.19 The results of this study were not duplicated by
another, larger investigation, which found no relationship between timing of vaccination and onset of
clinical signs.22 While there does appear to be a consistent relationship between some vaccines and
development of immune thrombocytopaenic purpura in people,86 there are only sporadic reports of
A topic often raised by owners and veterinarians is whether continued vaccination will induce relapse
of IMHA but, to our knowledge, there have been no published studies reporting the frequency of this
phenomenon in dogs with IMHA. While there is no evidence to suggest that vaccination will cause
relapses, it is possible for serum antibody titres against canine distemper virus, parainfluenza virus and
adenovirus 1 to be measured to guide the decision to vaccinate. Protective antibody titres against
Leptospira organisms are unlikely to persist beyond one year, so we usually counsel owners and
veterinarians that the decision to administer this vaccine should be based on a consideration of risks
and benefits for the individual animal. For example, there may be little indication to vaccinate a dog
that lives mostly indoors in an area with a low prevalence of Leptospira infections, whereas
vaccination may well be indicated in working dogs, or in dogs that have exposure to waterways.88
5. Future directions and comparative aspects
IMHA throws up many challenges for the small animal physician and it remains a disease that may
respond unpredictably or poorly to medication and may still be fatal in a significant number of cases.
Treatment of canine patients relies almost solely on immunosuppression, with splenectomy not
universally employed as a reasonable alternative. The situation is similar in human medicine where
steroids remain in use as first line agents with or without cyclophosphamide.89 In people, there has
been an attempted movement away from immunosuppression towards the use of therapeutic
monoclonal antibodies though these remain rather non-specific and therefore of mixed efficacy.89 In
children particularly, treatments such as rituximab, a monoclonal antibody against the CD20 molecule
that causes B-cell depletion, are used to avoid high doses of steroids or splenectomy, both of which
cause significant and severe side effects.90 The search for more specific ways to treat autoimmune
haemolytic anaemia in people continues and relies on the need to define the origin of the stimulus to
mount an immune response against red blood cells, so that the stimulus can be removed and the
immune dysregulation corrected. However, this approach may still be some way in the future in
concentration
concentration
Season Warm 1
concentration
STEROIDS
STEROID-
SPARING
DRUGS
Azathioprine 2 mg/kg/day PO Thiopurine Hepatotoxicity (28), Inexpensive
for no more than analogue bone marrow (25 and 50-mg tablet).
14 days; then suppression, Other doses have to
decrease to 1mg pancreatitis. Most be reformulated. Do
/kg PO every day side-effects follow not split tablets
or 2mg/kg EOD using 2mg/kg daily
Not licensed for use in
depending on dosing for > 2weeks
dogs in UK
ease of dosing unless in
susceptible
Or, 50mg/m2
individuals
every other day
RESCUE
THERAPIES
History: This dog had a history of immune-mediated thrombocytopenia that had been previously
treated with prednisolone and azathioprine. The treatment had been tapered off and had stopped
The dog had a 3 week history of lethargy and inappetance. He was identified as having a regenerative
anaemia at his primary practice (PCV 25%) and began treatment using prednisolone at a dose rate of
1mg/kg/day initially that was increased to 2mg/kg/day 12 days before referral because the initial
response to treatment was poor. Although the response to the dose increase was positive at first (PCV
increased to 42%), the dog again deteriorated, the PCV dropped and he was referred to the Queen’s
Clinical examination: The dog was lethargic but reasonably bright. He had a normal temperature and
respiratory rate and a heart rate of 80bpm. His mucous membranes were pale and icteric. His
Investigation: Blood work showed a moderate anaemia (PCV 25%) with evidence of regeneration
and spherocytosis. There was a mild thrombocytopenia (platelet count 109 x 109/l, range 175-500 x
109/l). Total protein was 74g/l (60-80g/l). Bilirubin was mildly increased (56µmol/l, range 0-
12µmol/l). Coombs’ test was negative. In saline agglutination test was positive.
Survey radiographs of thorax and abdomen revealed no abnormalities and abdominal ultrasound was
unremarkable.
Diagnosis: The history, clinical examination and laboratory findings were compatible with a diagnosis
of IMHA.
Management: The dog continued on prednisolone (2mg/kg/day) and azathioprine was added
(2mg/kg/day). Over the next 24 hours the dog’s condition deteriorated significantly and he became
pyrexic, lethargic, pale and tachypnoeic. His PCV was found to have dropped to 11%. He was given
one unit of packed red cells and his post-transfusion PCV was 25%. He also received 10g of human
The dog was sent home with a PCV stable at 20% and receiving prednisolone (2mg/kg/day),
The dog returned to the hospital for reassessment after 3 days, by which time his PCV was 25% with a
strongly regenerative response. Ciclosporin caused persistent diarrhoea in this dog and was tapered
and discontinued over two weeks. After 2 weeks, the prednisolone dose was decreased to 1mg/kg/day.
A recheck after one month showed that the PCV had increased to 44% and the dog was doing well.
Medication was maintained at immunosuppressive levels for 3 months then a tapering regimen began.
Discussion:
This case shows that in dogs with a predisposition for immune-mediated disease, different diseases
can present either at the same time or, as in this case, serially in a dog’s lifetime. When therapy with
prednisolone was started to treat IMHA, it began at the fairly modest dose of 1mg/kg/day. Although
this was increased after 7 days, response was transient. The dog then deteriorated rapidly having been
relatively stable for a period of about 3 weeks. Treatment intensity was increased using azathioprine
but this drug is thought not to have a rapid onset in action and probably did little to prevent the
hemolytic crisis that the dog entered. Human IVIg was chosen at this point because of its perceived
rapid onset in action. This patient responded well both clinically and also haematologically and was
Case example 2
Signalment: 8-year-old, male, entire, Irish setter dog, 42kg
History: This Irish setter had a history of reduced exercise tolerance, disorientation and collapse on
exercise and tachypnoea. He was hypothyroid and had been receiving thyroid supplementation.
Clinical examination: The dog was bright and appeared normal in attitude. He had a normal
temperature; respiratory rate was 56 and heart rate 150bpm. His mucous membranes were pale with a
normal capillary refill time. His abdomen appeared to be pendulous with suspected cranial abdominal
organomegaly
Investigation: Blood work showed a marked anaemia (PCV 14%) with no evidence of regeneration.
There was a marked leukocytosis with a neutrophilia (31.56 x 109/l, range 3-11.5 x 109/l). There was a
marked thrombocytosis (platelet count 2275 x 109/l, range 175-500 x 109/l). Total protein was 70g/l
(60-80g/l). No spherocytosis or in saline agglutination was seen. Bilirubin was normal (3.1µmol/l,
Survey radiographs of thorax and abdomen revealed no abnormalities and abdominal ultrasound was
unremarkable.
Bone marrow aspiration and core biopsy were suggestive of pure red cell aplasia (PRCA) as there
were few to no red cell precursors identified. The majority of cells were myeloid with evidence of
Diagnosis: The history, clinical examination and laboratory findings were compatible with a diagnosis
of PRCA of presumed immune-mediated aetiology in the absence of any other pathological changes.
Management: The dog was treated with prednisolone (2mg/kg/day) and ciclosporin (2.5mg/kg BID).
He remained non-regenerative and was transfusion-dependent for the following 3 weeks. At this point
lithium carbonate (10mg/kg, BID) was added to his dosage regimen. Three weeks later, when again
the dog required transfusion, ciclosporin was withdrawn and mycophenolate mofetil added (10mg/kg,
BID)
Outcome: No improvement was seen in the red cell parameters and no indication of regeneration was
seen. In addition, the dog developed a skin lesion on the bridge of his nose that cytologically was
found to contain fungal hyphae. Lithium carbonate dose was decreased to 10mg/kg/day following
some adverse effects. The dog continued to do badly however, made no response to mycophenolate
and was euthanased due to there being no response to treatment and due to the development of
Discussion:
This dog illustrates some of the frustrations encountered with bone marrow-centered disease. There
were few indications of the aetiology of the anaemia in this Irish setter and the disease was presumed
to be immune-mediated in the absence of any other drug, toxic, neoplastic or inflammatory disease.
The dog was supported with transfusions and was immunosuppressed. When there was no response,
other additional therapies were used including lithium carbonate and then mycophenolate mofetil.
Lithium has a small body of literature to support its use and was not helpful in this case (see Table 1).
Mycophenolate has been reported in small numbers of canine IMHA cases and was reported to
provoke few side effects in canine patients when used in conjunction with steroids. It may prove
useful as an alternative agent in the management of this disease (Wang et al., 2013). Unfortunately, it
also was not helpful in this case and the dog was euthanased.
References
3. Kisielewicz C, Self I, Bell R (2014) Assessment of clinical and laboratory variables as a guide
to packed red blood cell transfusion of euvolemic anemic dogs. J Vet Intern Med 28:576-582
4. Kiesielewicz C, Self IA (2014) Canine and feline blood transfusions: controversies and recent
5. Swann JW, Skelly BJ (2013) Systematic review of evidence relating to the treatment of
6. Mason N, Duval D, Shofer FS, Giger U. (2003) Cyclophosphamide exerts no beneficial effect
over prednisone alone in the initial treatment of acute immune-mediated hemolytic anemia in
immune-mediated hemolytic anemia: treatment outcome and prognostic factors in 149 dogs. J
8. Gregory CR, Stewart A, Sturges B, DeManvelle T, Cannon A, Ortega T, Harb M, Morris RE.
diseases of dogs that are unresponsive to conventional therapy. Transplant Proc 30:4143-4148
cyclosporine vs. prednisone alone for treatment of canine immune-mediated hemolytic anemia
10. Swann JW, Skelly BJ (2011) Evaluation of immunosuppressive regimens for immune-
mediated hemolytic anemia: a retrospective study of 42 dogs. J Small Anim Pract 52:353-358
11. Wang A, Smith JR, Creevy KE. Treatment of canine idiopathic immune-mediated haemolytic
anaemia with mycophenolate mofetil and glucocorticoids: 30 cases (2007 to 2011).J Small
12. West LD, Hart JR (2014) Treatment of idiopathic immune-mediated hemolytic anemia with
mycophenolate mofetil in five dogs. J Vet Emerg Crit Care (San Antonio) 24:226-231
13. Klag A, Giger U, Shofer F. (1993) Idiopathic immune-mediated hemolytic anemia in dogs: 42
14. Goggs R, Dennis SG, Di Bella A, Humm KR, McLauchlan G, Mooney C, Ridyard A, Tappin
S, Walker D, Warman S, Whitley NT, Brodbelt DC, Chan DL. (2015) Predicting outcome in
dogs with primary immune-mediated hemolytic anemia: results of a multicenter case registry.
15. Swann JW, Skelly BJ (2015) Systematic review of prognostic factors for mortality in dogs
16. Whelan M, Rozanski E, O’Toole T, Crawford S, Holm J, Cotter S. Use of the canine
haemolytic anaemia objective score (CHAOS) to predict survival in dogs with immune
Evaluation of prognostic factors and establishment of a prognostic scoring system for canine
18. Ke SS, Anderson GA, Connolly SL. Evaluation of prognostic indicators for canine primary
1996;10:290-295.
20. McAlees TJ. Immune-mediated haemolytic anaemia in 110 dogs in Victoria, Australia.
outcome in dogs with idiopathic immune-mediated hemolytic anemia: 173 cases (2003-2006).
22. Carr AP, Panciera DL, Kidd L. Prognostic factors for mortality and thromboembolism in
2002;16:504-509.
23. Whelan MF, O'Toole TE, Chan DL, Rozanski EA, DeLaforcade AM, Crawford SL, Cotter
SM. Use of human immunoglobulin in addition to glucocorticoids for the initial treatment of
dogs with immune-mediated hemolytic anemia. Journal of Veterinary Emergency and Critical
Care 2009;19:158-164.
24. Reimer M, Troy G, Warnick L. (1999) Immune-mediated hemolytic anaemia:70 cases (1988-
25. Rozanski E, Callan M, Hughes D, Sanders N, Giger U. Comparison of platelet count recovery
with the use of vincristine and prednisolone or prednisolone alone for treatment of severe
26. Barcellini W. (2015) Current treatment strategies in autoimmune hemolytic disorders. Expert
30(3):517.e5-10.
28. Wallisch K1, Trepanier LA. Incidence, timing, and risk factors of azathioprine hepatotoxicosis
infections in dogs treated with ciclosporin and glucocorticoids: eight cases. J Small Anim
31. Trehy, M., Whitley N, Battersby I. (2011). The Use of Lithium Carbonate in the Treatment
of Pure Red Cell Aplasia in Dogs: 5 Cases (2006-2010). British Small Animal Veterinary
32. Sontas H., Dokuzeylu B, Turna O, Ekici H. (2009). Estrogen-induced myelotoxicity in dogs:
33. Crump KL, Seshadri R. Use of therapeutic plasmapheresis in a case of canine immune-
mediated hemolytic anemia. J Vet Emerg Crit Care (San Antonio). 2009 Aug;19(4):375-80.
34. Peterson AL, Torres SM, Rendahl A, Koch SN. Frequency of urinary tract infection in dogs
with inflammatory skin disorders treated with ciclosporin alone or in combination with
35. MacNeill AL, Steeil JC, Dossin O, Hoien-Dalen PS, Maddox CW. Disseminated nocardiosis
caused by Nocardia abscessus in a dog. Veterinary clinical pathology / American Society for
36. Paul AE, Mansfield CS, Thompson M. Presumptive Nocardia spp. infection in a dog treated
37. Siak MK, Burrows AK. Cutaneous nocardiosis in two dogs receiving ciclosporin therapy for
453.
and squamous cell carcinomas in situ in a dog following chronic treatment with prednisone
39. Kronbichler A, Jayne DR, Mayer G. Frequency, risk factors and prophylaxis of infection in
41. Watson PJ, Wotton P, Eastwood J, Swift ST, Jones B, Day MJ. Immunoglobulin deficiency
carinii pneumonia. The Journal of Veterinary Medical Science / the Japanese Society of
2000;12:39-45.
44. Hoon-Hanks LL, Regan D, Dubey JP, Carol Porter M, Duncan CG. Hepatic neosporosis in a
dog treated for pemphigus foliaceus. Journal of Veterinary Diagnostic Investigation : official
2013;25:807-810.
45. Galgut BI, Janardhan KS, Grondin TM, Harkin KR, Wight-Carter MT. Detection of Neospora
46. Bernsteen L, Gregory CR, Aronson LR, Lirtzman RA, Brummer DG. Acute toxoplasmosis
following renal transplantation in three cats and a dog. J Am Vet Med Assoc 1999;215:1123-
1126.
48. Kellerman D, Bruyette D. (1997) Intravenous human immunoglobulin for the treatment of
206:1825-1900
human immune globulin in dogs with immune-mediated hemolytic anemia. J Am Vet Med
Assoc 210:1623-1627
51. Grundy S, Barton C. (2001) Influence of drug treatment on survival of dogs with immune-
Haematol 61:98-102
immune-mediated thrombocytopenia and hemolytic anemia in the dog. J Am Vet Med Assoc.
187:617-619
dogs with immune-mediated hemolytic anemia: ten cases (2003-2006). J Vet Emerg Crit Care
19:254-261
55. Piek C, van Spil W, Junius G, Dekker A. (2011) Lack of evidence of a beneficial effect of
56. Stokol T, Blue JT, French TW. Idiopathic pure red cell aplasia and non-regenerative anaemia
57. Abkowitz J, Kadin M, Powell J, Adamson J. Pure red cell aplasia: lymphocyte inhibition of
58. Weiss D. Antibody-mediated suppression of erythropoesis in dogs with red blood cell aplasia.
59. Weiss D. Bone marrow pathology in dogs and cats with non-regenerative immune-mediated
haemolytic anaemia and pure red cell aplasia. J Comp Path 2008;138:46-53
60. Weinkle TK, Center SA, Randolph JF, Warner KL, Barr SC, Erb HN. Evaluation of
prognostic factors, survival rates, and treatment protocols for immune-mediated hemolytic
61. Kidd L, Mackman N. Prothrombotic mechanisms and anticoagulant therapy in dogs with
2013;23:3-13.
62. Scott-Moncrieff JC, Treadwell NG, McCullough SM, Brooks MB. Hemostatic abnormalities
in dogs with primary immune-mediated hemolytic anemia. Journal of the American Animal
63. Fluckiger MA, Gomez JA. Radiographic Findings in Dogs with Spontaneous Pulmonary
64. Johnson LR, Lappin MR, Baker DC. Pulmonary thromboembolism in 29 dogs: 1985-1995.
65. Goggs R, Chan DL, Benigni L, Hirst C, Kellett-Gregory L, Fuentes VL. Comparison of
66. Goggs R, Benigni L, Fuentes VL, Chan DL. Pulmonary thromboembolism. Journal of
67. Sinnott VB, Otto CM. Use of thromboelastography in dogs with immune-mediated hemolytic
2009;19:484-488.
2012;191:347-53
69. Mellett AM, Fenimore AC, Nakamura RK, Bianco D. Prospective Evaluation of Clopidogrel,
Ansell J. Guidance for the treatment of deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism. J
72. Hylek EM, Regan S, Henault LE, Gardner M, Chan AT, Singer DE, Barry MJ. Challenges to
73. Sangster CR, Stevenson CK, Kidney BA, Montgomery DL, Allen AL. Kernicterus in an adult
74. Belz KM, Specht AJ, Johnson VS, Conway JA. MRI Findings in a Dog with Kernicterus.
75. Shearer LR, Boudreau AE, Holowaychuk MK. Distal Renal Tubular Acidosis and Immune-
2009;23:1284-1288.
76. Caruana RJ, Buckalew VM. The Syndrome of Distal (Type-1) Renal Tubular-Acidosis -
77. Pessler F, Emery H, Dai L, Wu YM, Monash B, Cron RQ, Pradhan M. The spectrum of renal
78. Ter Meulen CG, Pieters GFFM, Huysmans FTM. Flaccid paresis due to distal renal tubular
Transpl 2001;16:2328-2336.
80. Bae EH, Han CW, Lee JH, Park JW, Ma SK, Choi KC, Kim SW. The Case. Hypokalemia
associated with nephrocalcinosis. Distal renal tubular acidosis associated with Sjögren's
Everything you need to know about distal renal tubular acidosis in autoimmune disease.
82. Harrison HE, Bunting H, Ordway NK, Albrink WS. (1947) The pathogenesis of the renal
83. Deuel JW, Schaer CA, Boretti FS Opitz L, Garcia-Rubio I, Baek JH, Spahn DR, Buehler
PW, Schaer DJ. (2016) Hemoglobinuria-related acute kidney injury is driven by intrarenal
oxidative reactions triggering a heme toxicity response. Cell Death Dis Jan 21;7:e2064
84. Lobetti R. Changes in the serum urea: Creatinine ratio in dogs with babesiosis, haemolytic
85. Lobetti RG, Reyers F, Nesbit JW. The comparative role of haemoglobinaemia and hypoxia in
Lupus 23:554-567
88. Schuller S, Francey T, Hartmann K, Hugonnard M, Kohn B, Nally JE, Sykes J. (2015)
European consensus statement on leptospirosis in dogs and cats. J Small Anim Pract 56:159-
179
89. Salama A. Treatment options for primary autoimmune hemolytic anemia: a short
90. Miano M. How I manage Evans Syndrome and AIHA cases in children. Br J Haematol
2015;172:524-534