Jurnal

Full Paper
Teknologi
POTENTIAL OF NATURAL AND SYNTHETIC FIBRES Article history
Received
ON FLEXURAL PERFORMANCE OF FOAMCRETE 13 August 2015
Received in revised form
MORTAR 11 December 2015
Accepted
Md Azree Othuman Mydin* 6 March 2016

School of Housing, Building and Planning, Universiti Sains Malaysia, *Corresponding author
11800, Penang, Malaysia [email protected]

Graphical abstract Abstract

This research investigates the potential of natural and synthetic fibres on flexural strength of
foamcrete mortar. The are 7 different types of fibres had been used such as pulverized fuel
ash, wood ash, silica fume, palm oil fuel ash, polypropylene fibre, coconut fibre and steel
fibre. These natural and synthetic additives have different abilities that contribute positive
outcomes to the properties of foamcrete mortar. Pozzolanic materials and fibres were used
as additives to be included with control foamcrete mortar mixtures in order to enhance its
flexural properties. From the overall analysis, it has been confirmed that coir fibre recorded
the highest flexural strength in 7 days compared to other additives and the control sample.
Coir fibre of 0.4% reached highest strength in 180 days without allowing other additives to
overcome its overall flexural strength. It should be pointed out that, the more the addition
of fibres in the base mix, the higher the strength obtained due to its low cellulose content.

Keywords: Foamcrete, mortar, flexural strength, concrete, fibre

Abstrak
Kajian ini mengkaji potensi penggunaan serat semulajadi dan sintetik ke atas kekuatan
lentur konkrit berbusa. Terdapat 7 jenis gentian yang digunakan seperti abu lumat bahan
api, abu kayu, wasap silika, abu bahan api minyak sawit, serat polypropylene, serat kelapa
dan gentian keluli. Bahan-bahan serat ini mempunyai kebolehan yang berbeza yang
menyumbang hasil positif kepada sifat-sifat konkrit berbusa. Bahan pozzolanik dan serat
digunakan sebagai bahan tambah untuk dikaitkan dengan campuran konkrit berbusa
biasa untuk memperbaiki sifat mekanikal. Daripada analysis keseluruhan yang dibuat,
dapat dinyatakan bahawa serat sabut mencatatkan kekuatan lenturan yang paling tinggi
dalam 7 hari berbanding bahan tambahan lain dan sampel kawalan. Serat sabut
sebanyak 0.4% mencapai kekuatan lenturan yang paling tinggi dalam 180 hari tanpa
membenarkan tambahan lain untuk mengatasi kekuatannya. Semakin tinggi jumlah
penambahan serat, semakin tinggi kekuatan lenturan yang diperolehi atas faktor
kandungan selulosa yang rendah.

Kata kunci: Konkrit berbusa, mortar, kekuatan lenturan, konkrit, gentian

© 2016 Penerbit UTM Press. All rights reserved

1.0 INTRODUCTION porosity had significant effects on the flexural

strength of the foamcrete mortar [2]. The flexural
It has been observed that the high density of the strength of foamcrete mortar is directly proportional
foamcrete mortar produces high flexural strength, to its compressive strength because the same factors
while low density gains very low strength as observed that affect the compressive strength are expected to
in the compressive strength tests [1]. As expected, influence the flexural strength as well. Air voids, pores
the density of the foamcrete mortar influenced by its and matrix which attribute to the microstructure

78:5 (2016) 431–435 | www.jurnalteknologi.utm.my | eISSN 2180–3722 |

432 Md Azree Othuman Mydin / Jurnal Teknologi (Sciences & Engineering) 78:5 (2016) 431–435

normally will influence strength which is in relation to 3.0 FLEXURAL STRENGTH TEST SETUP
the density [3].
Flexural strength and splitting tensile force is similar Splitting tensile is a basic and important property of
to compressive strength when undergo tests at the concrete to determine its tensile strength. The test
age of testing. The ratio of flexural strength of was conducted according to the IS: 5816-1970. The
foamcrete mortar to its compressive strength is in the size of the foamcrete mortar sample used for the
range of 0.06-0.10. The decreasing densities and splitting tensile test is 200mm in height and 100mm in
increase in water cement ratio will reduce the ratio diameter. This cylindrical shaped specimen was
of flexural to compressive strength. The ratio is varies placed horizontally between the loading surfaces of
from 0.22- 0.27. Both compressive strength and the compression machine (GOTECH GT-7001-BS300
flexural strength show similar mechanical properties Universal Testing Machine) as shown in Figure 1. The
and behavior [4]. samples were taken out from curing process and
The strength will be differed when added with kept inside the oven to reach a dry density. These
other additives. Natural and synthetic fiber will be samples were also left to cool down to attain a
able to enhance the flexural strength. Higher fibers stable temperature. A uniform compression load was
inclusion (polypropylene and Kenaf fibers) leads to applied on the horizontally placed cylindrical
high flexural strength [5]. Fibers act as bridging sample. Finally, the sample was broken into half at
component in foamcrete mortar when cracks were the centre and considered as a concrete failure.
formed [6, 7]. Apart from fibers, fly ash also Assuming the foamcrete mortar samples act as an
contributes to the tensile strength of foamcrete elastic body, a uniform lateral tensile stress of ft acting
mortar [8]. The fineness of fly ash will influence the along the vertical plane causes the failure of the
tensile strength of a concrete because it get the samples [15].
filling rate of concrete increases [9]. A uniform pore
distribution occurs in a more dense and
impermeable structure [10].

2.0 MATERIALS

Natural fibers have been used to reinforce inorganic

materials for thousands of years. The compressive
strength decreased gradually due to the increase of
fiber volume percentage in conventional concrete
[11]. Lower density of foamcrete mortar caused the
strength to be lower and increased volume
percentage of coconut fiber also will lower the
density of concrete and produces low compressive
strength [12]. Strength of coir fiber can be varied in
terms of their diameters, strain rate, moisture
absorption, lengths and their chemical properties.
Natural fibers are strongly hydrophilic materials and
good moisture absorber, thus leads to a significant
deterioration of its mechanical properties [13]. Figure 1 Sample being tested by the compressive machine
In this research, the additives were selected
based on its behaviour and properties. These locally
available ingredients can be categorized as 4.0 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
pozzolanic materials and fibres (natural and
synthetic). Those additives were incorporated into High density of the foamcrete mortar produces high
the foamcrete mortar mix as cement replacement flexural strength, while low density gains very low
and total fraction volume. The fibres were associated strength as observed in the compressive strength
with the cement paste after the flow test and afore tests. As expected, the density of the foamcrete
the density of the mortar mixture is taken; meanwhile, mortar influenced by its porosity had significant
the pozzolanic materials were included together with effects on the flexural strength of the foamcrete
cement and sand before a flow test was performed. mortar. The flexural strength of foamcrete mortar is
These additives are pulverized fuel ash, wood ash, directly proportional to its compressive strength
silica fume, palm oil fuel ash, polypropylene fibre, because the same factors that affect the
coconut fibre and steel fibre. These additives have compressive strength are expected to influence the
different properties and abilities which contribute flexural strength as well. Air voids, pores and matrix
positive outcomes to the overall properties of which attribute to the microstructure normally will
foamcrete mortar [14]. influence strength which is in relation to the density.
In this section, the development of the flexural
strength of the foamcrete mortar specimens was
433 Md Azree Othuman Mydin / Jurnal Teknologi (Sciences & Engineering) 78:5 (2016) 431–435

observed to increase over the testing ages. However, would have prevented the cracks from widening.
it’s clearly seen that the foamcrete mortar mix Since coir fibre has a higher modulus, the higher
without any additives gave low strength as shown in concentration of fibres need more stress.
Table 1. Furthermore, the flexibility of the concrete will be
reduced by the inclusion of more coir fibre.
Table 1 The flexural strength of foamcrete mortar of different The addition of 30% of PFA in the foamcrete
densities mortar (PFA-30) produced a 90% increment in
strength compared to the control mix. Meanwhile,
Flexural Strength (N/mm2) 15% of PFA (PFA-15) gained strength by about 61% by
Samples Reference Density 7 28 60 180
(kg/m3) Days Days Days Days
180 days. From investigations, both PFA-15 and PFA-
NFC-1 700 0.27 0.34 0.40 0.40 30 gained very low strength at the early stage
Control because of the pozzolanic reactions. Large amounts
NFC-2 1000 0.85 0.88 0.93 1.10
sample
NFC-3 1400 2.01 2.17 2.56 2.84 of PFA will downgrade the flexural strength at the
early stage and need longer time to cure and reach
optimum strength [17]. PFA-15 showed enhancement
Due to the low strength of foamcrete mortar, in the flexural strength from the 28th day onwards but
different types of additives were used to observe the the strength of PFA-30 only started to rise up
changes in strength because these additives showed vigorously at the 60th day due to the different
positive responses in enhancing the strength [16]. The proportions of pozzolanic materials. In terms of the
results in Table 2 show that the different additives had physical condition of PFA, the increase in flexural
different effects on the flexural strength at each age. strength is attributed to the improved shear capacity
The development of flexural strength is similar to that between the particles of PFA and the paste phase.
of the compressive strength along the age and types PFA resulted in the highest reduction of porosity
of additives used. The ratio of flexural strength to compared to the other materials and led to the
compressive strength at 1000kg/m3 for the foamcrete refinement of pores, hence providing additional
mortar varied from 0.30 to 0.60 flexural strength. Besides pozzolanity, lower foam
requirement at this density also contributed to the
Table 2 The effect of addition of various types of additives strength development by decreasing the pore
on the flexural strength volume and providing an ease for uniform pore
distribution. Similar improvement was observed by
Dry Flexural Strength (N/mm2) the development of strong bonding between the
Samples Density 7 28 60 180 internal particles in concrete due to fly ash [18].
(kg/m3) days days days days
Figure 2 shows the cracks formed on the samples with
NFC-2 1000 0.85 0.88 0.93 0.96
POFA-25 1000 0.69 0.71 0.92 1.07
two different additives after reached failure mode.
POFA-40 1000 0.58 0.60 0.61 0.74 Coir fibres provide better shear force than PFA by
PF-0.2 1000 0.84 1.11 1.19 1.25 preventing the widening of cracks due to bending
PF-0.4 1000 0.88 1.16 1.36 1.43 stress as been shown on Figure 3.
SF-0.25 1000 0.83 0.88 0.90 0.98
SF-0.4 1000 1.00 1.01 1.07 1.21
SLF-10 1000 1.21 1.35 1.42 1.45
PFA-15 1000 0.87 1.32 1.37 1.55
PFA-30 1000 0.86 1.30 1.55 1.82
W5-P15 1000 0.86 1.31 1.35 1.42
W10-P15 1000 0.73 1.05 1.14 1.20
CF-0.2 1000 1.24 1.39 1.52 1.55
CF-0.4 1000 1.55 1.63 1.69 1.88
Figure 2 The cracks formed on the foamcrete mortar
samples with different additives

From Table 2, the inclusion of 0.4% of coir fibre

(CF-0.4) recorded the highest flexural strength
among the additives until 180 days. It dominated the
strength at each age. A significant increase of 82%,
85%, 82% and 96% in the flexural strength of CF-0.4
had been observed in 7, 28, 60 and 180 days
respectively. Coir fibre is a natural fibre that
contributes more to the flexural strength and also to
the compressive strength. The ratio of flexural
strength to compressive strength for coir fibres (CF-0.2
and CF-0.4) showed a decrease from age to age. Figure 3 The surfaces of the foamcrete mortar samples
The fibres would not cause the sample to break apart after breaking into two parts
but will react as an anti-micro crack agent which
434 Md Azree Othuman Mydin / Jurnal Teknologi (Sciences & Engineering) 78:5 (2016) 431–435

Figure 4 shows the effect of various additives on the reduce its strength due to low pozzolanic
flexural strength of foamcrete mortar at 1000kg/m3. characteristics. 10% of wood ash with 15% of PFA
From the overall analysis, least flexural strength was (W10-P15) by cement replacement obtained lower
recorded by the foamcrete mortar specimen with strength than W5-P15 at all the testing ages and
40% of palm oil fuel ash. The strength of POFA-40 in when compared to control mix.
180 days is not up to the strength of the control mix in
7 days. The flexural strength at the early stage is lower
and produced very little increment in strength which
was only 28% from day 7 to day 180 as it had a huge
cement replacement when compared to the other
additives. Based on the analysis, the flexural strength
will drop when the percentage of cement
replacement with POFA increases. As for compressive
strength, POFA-25 showed good response towards
flexural strength compared to POFA-40. In 180 days,
the foamcrete mortar with POFA-25 achieved 11.5%
higher strength than the control mix. POFA-40 took a
longer time to react with the cement during the
hydration process and to reach its optimum level of
strength. Since silica content gets higher when the
percentage of POFA increases, the time taken for
the hydration process will be longer, thus it reduces Figure 4 Effect of various additives on the flexural strength of
the early flexural strength of the foamcrete mortar foamcrete mortar at 1000kg/m3
[18]. Previous discussions have explained the
microstructure formation due to the additional
amount of C-S-H produced by the reactive silica in As a conclusion, the flexural strength has direct
pozzolanic reactions. The additional C-S-H enhances linear proportional correlation with the compressive
the shear resistance and flexural strength of the strength of the foamcrete mortar with wood ash.
foamcrete mortar specimens because the Analysis of the results concluded that if there is an
compound becomes denser and prevents the air increased level of cement replacement with wood
bubbles from merging with each other. Fine POFA ash, the magnitude of the flexural strength will
produced higher strength with cement replacement decrease gradually upon drying. Since wood ash is
of 20-30% than the control mix due to its higher less reactive than cement, it delays the setting time
pozzolanic activity. and reducing the bulk density of the hardened
In 7 days, 10% of silica fume (SLF-10) incorporated foamcrete mortar at a high proportion of wood ash
into the foamcrete mortar showed a good start-up in due to shrinkage. Based on the strength
flexural strength at the early stage, although it is a development, it can be concluded that the
pozzolanic material, due to the very low cement reduction of the formation of micro-cracks occurs
replacement. There was a 42% increase in flexural during the curing condition. Even a low amount of
strength by SLF-10 in 7 days compared to the control wood ash is used, the silica content should be
mix. The strength of the foamcrete mortar was sufficient to react with the calcium hydroxide from
observed to increase until the 180th day without a the hydration of cement. In comparison with mortar,
drop. Since the cement replacement was only about Mortar mixed with wood ash content of 10% showed
10%, the reaction during the hydration process was higher compressive strength in 28 days but lower
completed instantly to achieve a high strength. The flexural strength compared to the control mix [15].
size and shape of the particles of the silica fume are An increment of 49% in the flexural strength was
likely to react faster with the cement and produce obtained by PF-0.4 in 180 days compared to the
more C-S-H compounds during the hydration process control mix. When compared to 0.2% of
in order to make changes in the strength of the polypropylene fibres (PF-0.2), PF-0.4 showed better
foamcrete mortar. The pozzolanic reaction assisted strength at every interval of testing. Although
the pores in becoming uniform in sizes and polypropylene fibres resulted in poor compressive
distribution. Since the merged bubbles were strength, they slightly enhanced the flexural strength.
reduced, the bonding between the particles The fibres added into the concrete resisted the
became stronger, thus increasing the shear strength bending moment load and prevented it from cracks.
of the foamcrete mortar. Fibre acts as the bridging material in concrete and
Replacing cement with 5% of wood ash and 15% prevents the formation of cracks or breaking into two
of PFA (W5-P15) showed that the flexural strength of parts [6]. Polypropylene fibres provide additional
the foamcrete mortar increased about 48% bonding connection for each particle to remain
compared to the control mix at the 180th day and strong and connected due to the brittleness of its low
the result in 7days shows that the flexural strength of density.
(W5-P15) is similar with PFA-15. Increasing the Steel fibres also produced good strength from the
percentage of wood ash in the foamcrete mortar will age of 7 days until 180 days when compared to the
435 Md Azree Othuman Mydin / Jurnal Teknologi (Sciences & Engineering) 78:5 (2016) 431–435

control mix. It never showed any massive changes in [2] Othuman Mydin, M. A., Y. C. Wang. 2012. Mechanical
the flexural strength along the testing ages. When Properties of Foamed Concrete Exposed to High
Temperatures. Journal of Construction and Building
comparing between SF-0.25 and SF-0.4, the high Materials. 26(1): 638-654.
inclusion of fibres showed better compressive and [3] Awang, H., M. A. Othuman Mydin, A. F. Roslan. 2012.
flexural strength with some good additional effects Microstructural Investigation of Lightweight Foamed
because the lesser amount of fibres were not evenly Concrete Incorporating Various Additives. International
spread in the whole and later led to failure of the Journal of Academic Research. 4(2): 197-201.
[4] Soleimanzadeh, S., M. A. Othuman Mydin. 2013. Influence
fibre where it was unable to resist the load bearing at
of High Temperatures on Flexural Strength of Foamed
the very point of load. Due to the strong hold on the Concrete Containing Fly Ash and Polypropylene Fiber.
critical part by steel fibre, the samples never International Journal of Engineering. 26(1): 365-374.
experienced cracks or broke apart. The shape of the [5] Othuman Mydin, M.A., 2011. Thin-walled Steel Enclosed
steel fibres (hooked-end) holds the particles together Lightweight Foamed Concrete: A Novel Approach to
Fabricate Sandwich Composite. Australian Journal of
and prevents cracks from widening [11]. The
Basic and Applied Sciences. 5(12): 1727-1733.
specimens with fibres did not fail immediately after [6] Roslan, A. H., H. Awang, M. A. Othuman Mydin. 2013.
the initial cracks appeared. This is probably due to Effects of Various Additives on Drying Shrinkage,
the randomly spread fibres crossing the cracked Compressive and Flexural Strength of Lightweight Foamed
section, which resisted the widening of cracks and Concrete (LFC). Advanced Materials Research Journal.
separation of that section. 626: 594-604.
[7] Othuman Mydin, M. A., Y. C. Wang. 2012. Thermal and
Mechanical Properties of Lightweight Foamed Concrete
(LFC) at Elevated Temperatures. Magazine of Concrete
5.0 CONCLUSION Research. 64(3): 213-224.
[8] Mustaffa, W. E. S. B., Mehilef, S., Saidur, R., Safari, A. 2011.
From the results obtained, it can be clearly viewed Biomass Energy in Malaysia: Current State and Prospects.
Renewable & Sustainable Energy Review. 15(7): 3360-
that each additive produced different level of
3370.
strengths when incorporated with the foamcrete [9] Sahu, J. N., Abnisa, F., Daud, W. M. A, Husin, W. M. W.
mortar. Additives used in this study have shown 2011. Utilization Possibilities of Palm Shell as a Source of
higher flexural strength than the sample of the Biomass Energy in Malaysia by Producing Bio-oil in Pyrolysis
control mix while other variables were kept constant. Process. Biomass and Bioenergy. 35(5): 1863-1872.
As a conclusion, the investigation proved that coir [10] Johnson Alengaram, U., Al Muhit, B. A., Jumaat, M. Z.,
Michael, L. Y. J. 2013. A Comparison of the Thermal
fibre gave tremendous positive response on the Conductivity of Oil Palm Shell Foamed Concrete With
compressive and flexural strength of the foamcrete Conventional Materials. Materials & Design. 51: 522-529.
mortar by providing better shear stress to resist the [11] Othuman Mydin, M. A., 2013. Modeling of Transient Heat
bending moment load and act as a good reinforcing Transfer in Foamed Concrete Slab. Journal of Engineering
agent. Due to the pozzolanic reaction, PFA Science and Technology. 8(3): 331-349.
[12] Othuman Mydin, M. A. 2013. An Experimental
produced lower flexural strength at the early stages
Investigation on Thermal Conductivity of Lightweight
but the strength started to rise up enormously after 60 Foamed concrete for Thermal Insulation. Jurnal Teknologi.
days and its strength in 180 days was almost similar 63(1): 43-49.
with coir fibre. Furthermore, the strength of PFA is [13] Othuman Mydin, M. A., Y. C. Wang, 2011. Elevated-
expected to increase if the testing ages are Temperature Thermal Properties of Lightweight Foamed
Concrete. Journal of Construction & Building Materials.
extended
25(2): 705-716.
[14] Bouguerra, A., Laurent, J. P., Goual, M. S., Queneudec, M.
1997. The Measurement of the Thermal Conductivity of
Acknowledgement Solid Aggregate Using the Transient Plane Source
Technique. Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics. 30: 2900-
The author would like to thank Ministry of Higher 2904.
Education Malaysia for their funding of this research [15] Khan, M. I. 2002. Factor Affecting the Thermal Properties of
under Fundamental Research Grant Scheme (Grant Concrete and Applicability of Its Prediction Models.
No. 203/PPBGN/6711514) with research title: Building and Environment Journal. 37(6): 607-614.
Fundamental Study to Establish Thermal Insulation, [16] Demirbog, R., Gul, R. 2003. The Effects of Expanded Perlite
Mechanical Properties and Fire Retardant Aggregate, Silica Fume and Fly Ash on the Thermal
Conductivity of Lightweight Concrete. Cement and
Mechanism of Coir Fibre Reinforced Lightweight
Concrete Research Journal. 33(5): 723-727
Foamcrete. [17] Okpala, D. C. 1990. Palm Kernel Shell as Lightweight
Aggregate in Concrete. Building and Environment
Journal. 25(4): 291-296.
References [18] M. A. Othuman Mydin, N. S. Sahidun, M. Y. Mohd Yusof, N.
Md Noordin. 2015. Compressive, Flexural And Splitting
[1] Newman, J. B. 1993. Structural Lightweight Aggregate Tensile Strengths Of Lightweight Foamed Concrete With
Concrete, Chapter 2: Properties of Structural Lightweight Inclusion Of Steel Fibre. Jurnal Teknologi. 7(5): 45-50.
Aggregate Concrete. Chapman & Hall.