18 Electron Rule: How To Count Electrons

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 14

18 

electron rule : How to count electrons
The rule states that thermodynamically stable transition metal organometallic compounds 
are formed when the sum of the metal  d electrons and the electrons 
conventionally considered as being supplied by the surrounding ligands 
equals 18. 

In general, the conditions favoring adherence to the 18 electron rule are, an electron rich  metal 
(one that is in a low oxidation state) and ligands that are good π‐acceptors 

The hapto symbol, η, with a numerical superscript, provides a topological description 
by indicating the connectivity between the ligand and the central atom. For example, 
if all the five carbon atoms of a cyclopentadienyl moiety are equidistant from a metal 
atom, we term it as η5‐cyclopentadienyl

Examples:
η1‐R, η1‐Ar  η2‐C2R4 η1‐allyl,   η3‐allyl, η4‐ Cb, η5‐Cp, η6‐C6H6 η8‐C8H8 η2‐C60, η5‐
R5C60.

The symbol μ indicates bridging;  normally we have μ2 and rarely  μ3 bridging

Examples: 
μ2‐CO, μ3‐CO, μ2‐CH3, μ2‐H, μ2‐Cl, , μ3‐Cl,  μ2‐OR, μ2‐PR2, μ2‐NR2
Methods of counting: Neutral atom method  & Oxidation  state method 

Ligand Neutral Oxidation state Ligand Neutral Oxidation state


atom atom
Electron Formal Electron Formal
contributi charge contribu charge
on tion
Carbonyl (M–CO) 2 2 0 Halogen ( M–X) 1 2 –1
Phosphine (M–PR3) 2 2 0 Alkyl (M–R) 1 2 –1
Amine (M–NR3 ) 2 2 0 Aryl (M–Ar) 1 2 –1
Amide (M–NR2 ) 1 2 –1 acyl (M–C(O)–R 1 2 –1
Hydrogen (M–H) 1 2 –1 η1-cyclopentadienyl 1 2 –1
Alkene (sidewise) η2- 2 2 0 η1-allyl 1 2 –1
Alkyne (sidewise) η2- 2 2 0 η3-allyl 3 4 –1
η2-C60 2 2 0 η5-cyclopentadienyl 5 6 –1
Nitrosyl bent 1 2 –1 η6-benzene 6 6 0
Nitrosyl linear 3 2 +1 η7-cycloheptatrienyl 7 6 +1
Carbene (M=CR2) 2 4 –2 Carbyne (M≡CR) 3 6 –3
Alkoxide (M–OR) 1 2 –1 Thiolate (M–SR) 1 2 –1
μ-CO (M–(CO)–M) 2 2 0 μ-H 1 2 –1
μ-alkyne 4 4 0 μ-X (M–X–M) 3 4 –1
X = halogen
μ-alkyl 1 2 –1 μ-amido 3 4 –1
(M–(NR2)–M
μ-phosphido 3 4 –1 μ-alkoxide 3 4 –1
(M–(PR2)–M (M–(OR)–M
neutral atom oxidation state
method method
CO Ru 8 6 (Ru +2)
PPh3
Ru η3- allyl 3 4
2 PPh3 4 4
PPh3
CO 2 2
charge -1 not required
16 16
Me
N Fe 8 6 (Fe +2)
Me
Fe 2 η5-Cp 10 12
18 18

Neutral atom method: Metal is taken as in zero oxidation state for counting purpose

Oxidation state method: We first arrive at the oxidation state of the metal by considering the 
number of anionic ligands present and overall charge of the complex

Suggestion: Focus on one counting method till you are confident
Easy way to remember ligand electron contribution for neutral atom counting method
Electron contribution
Neutral terminal :   CO, PR3, NR3 2 electrons
Anionic terminal :  X‐, H‐, R‐, Ar‐, R2N‐, R2P‐, RO‐ 1 electron
Hapto ligands  : η2‐C2R4 η2‐C2R2, η4‐C2R2 ,η1‐allyl, 
η3‐allyl, η4‐ Cb, η5‐Cp, η6‐C6H6
η7‐C7H7 η8‐C8H8 η2‐C60, η5‐R5C60 same as hapticity
bridging neutral μ2‐CO, μ3‐CO 2 electrons
Bridging anionic μ2‐CH3, μ2‐H ( no lone pairs) 1 electron

Bridging anionic μ2‐Cl, , μ2‐OR, μ2‐PR2, μ2‐NR2 3 electrons


(with 1 lone pair) 
μ3‐Cl( 2 l.p) 5 electrons 

Bridging alkyne 4 electrons

NO linear 3 electrons

NO bent ( l. p on nitrogen) 1 electron

Carbene M=C 2 electron

Carbyne M≡C 3 electron 
How to determine the total number of metal ‐ metal bonds 

Determine the total valence electrons (TVE) in the entire molecule (that is, the number of valence 
electrons of the metal plus the number of electrons from each ligand and the charge); say, it is A.

Subtract this number from n × 18 where n is the number of metals in the complex, that is, (n × 18) – A; 


say, it is B.

(a) B divided by 2 gives the total number of M–M bonds in the complex.

(b) A divided by n gives the number of electrons per metal. If the number of electrons is 18, it indicates 


that there is no M–M bond; if it is 17 electrons, it indicates that there is 1 M–M bond; if it is 16 
electrons, it indicates that there are 2 M–M bonds and so on. 

Molecule TVE (18 × n) – A Total M–M Bonds per metal Basic geometry of
(A) (B) bonds (B/2) metal atoms

Fe3(CO)12 48 54 – 48 = 6 6/2 = 3 48/3 = 16; 2 Fe Fe

Fe
Co
Co4(CO)12 60 72 – 60 = 12 12/2 = 6 60/4 = 15; 3
Co Co

Co

[η5-CpMo(CO) 2] 2 30 36 – 30 = 6 6/2 = 3 30/2 = 15; 3 Mo≡Mo

(η4-C4H4)2Fe2(CO)3 30 36 – 30 = 6 6/2 = 3 30/2 = 15; 3 Fe≡Fe

Fe2(CO)9 34 36 – 34 = 2 2/2 = 1 34/2 = 16; 1 Fe–Fe


Problem solving
The following organometallic compounds are stable and  has a 
second  row  transition  metal at its centre. Find out the  metal and 
its oxidation state
A few worked out examples

Understanding  metal –metal bond electron count become easier if you compare 
and  see how octet is attained by each Cl atom of Cl2
Exceptions to the 18 electron rule

• Square planar organometallic complexes of the late transition 
metals (16e). 

• Some organometallic complexes of the early transition metals


(e.g. Cp2TiCl2, WMe6, Me2NbCl3, CpWOCl3) [ A possible reason for
the same is that some of the orbitals of these complexes are too high in energy
for effective utilization in bonding or the ligands are mostly σ donors.]

• Some high valent d0 complexes have a lower electron count 
than 18.

• Sterically demanding bulky ligands force complexes to have 


less than 18 electrons. 

• The 18 electron rule fails when bonding of organometallic clusters of 
moderate to big sizes (6 Metal atoms and above) are considered. 

• The rule is not applicable to organometallic compounds of  main 


group metals as well as to those of lanthanide and actinide metals. 
OM  L2‐S1
Metal carbonyls

CO CO CO

CO OC CO
Ni OC Fe Cr
CO OC CO
OC CO
CO
CO CO

O
CO OC CO C CO
OC OC

OC Mn Mn CO
OC Co Co CO
OC CO OC CO
CO OC C
O

CO
OC
CO CO
OC CO Ir
OC
CO Os CO CO
OC
OC CO Ir Ir
OC CO
Os Os Ir CO
OC CO CO OC
OC CO
CO CO

Coordination number around the metal normally remains six or lesser.  17 electron 
species such as  Mn(CO)5, Co(CO)4 dimerize to gain 18 electrons
V(CO)6 does not dimerize. 
AJELIAS L2‐S2

Why study metal carbonyls ?

Simplest of organometallic compounds where M‐C σ bonding is well understood.  CO is one 


of the strongest  π acceptor ligands.  Back bonding       (π bonding) and variation in electronic 
properties of CO can be monitored very efficiently by Infrared spectroscopy

A range of metal carbonyls are used as catalysts in Chemical Industry

Hydroformylation Methanol to Acetic acid 
Alkene to Aldehyde Process
R
C CH 2
MeOH + HI MeI + H2O
H
CO H3C C I
CO, MeI
HCo(CO)4 H2 [Rh(CO)2I2] O
R H2O
H3C C I H3C C OH
CH CH 2
O O
H HC
O
AJELIAS L2‐S3

σ*
Molecular Orbital diagram of CO

Why does  CO bind a metal through its less  π*
LUMO
electronegative carbon atom  than its more 
electronegative oxygen ? What makes it a 
good π acceptor ? 2p
10.7 ev
σ
The highest occupied molecular orbital HOMO
(HOMO) of CO is weakly antibonding
(compared with the O atomic orbitals)
and is an MO which is carbon based.
Secondly, the π* antibonding orbital
2p
which is the lowest unoccupied 15.9 ev
molecular orbital (LUMO) is also of
comparatively lower energy which makes π
it possible to interact with metal t2g
orbitals for π bonding. There exists a σ*
2s
strong back bonding of metal electrons 19.5 ev

to the π * antibonding orbitals of CO


σ 2s
32.4 ev
C CO O
AJELIAS L2‐S4

Counting the electrons helps  to predict stability of metal carbonyls. But it will not 
tell you whether a CO is bridging or terminal 
AJELIAS L2‐S5

Infrared Spectroscopy‐ A spectro‐analytical tool in chemistry 

Infrared (IR) spectroscopy is one of the most common spectroscopic techniques used by organic
and inorganic chemists. Simply, it is the absorption measurement of different IR frequencies by a
compound positioned in the path of an IR beam. The main goal of IR spectroscopic analysis is to
determine the chemical functional groups in the sample. Functional groups are identified based
on vibrational modes of the groups such a stretching, bending etc. Different vibrational modes
absorb characteristic frequencies of IR radiation. An infrared spectrophotometer is an
instrument that passes infrared light through a molecule and produces a spectrum that contains
a plot of the amount of light transmitted on the vertical axis against the wavelength of infrared
radiation on the horizontal axis. Absorption of radiation lowers the percentage transmittance
value.
AJELIAS L2‐S6

Infrared Spectroscopy‐ Spectra of Metal Carbonyls  

CO OC CO
OC

OC Mn Mn CO

OC CO The range in which 
CO OC
the band appears 
decides bridging or 
terminal
terminal .

The number of 
bands is only 
related to the 
symmetry of the 
molecule

O O bridging
OC C C CO

OC Fe Fe CO
OC C CO
O

terminal

You might also like