Facilities Strategic Asset Management Plan Template
Facilities Strategic Asset Management Plan Template
Facilities Strategic Asset Management Plan Template
Facilities
Strategic Asset
Management
Plan
2015-2025
Table of contents
Foreword .................................................................................................................... 7
1 Introduction ......................................................................................................... 8
1.1 About this plan .............................................................................................. 8
1.2 Key principles ................................................................................................ 8
1.3 What this plan covers .................................................................................... 9
2 Why this plan was developed ............................................................................ 10
2.1 Fit with the Long-term Plan ......................................................................... 10
2.2 Purpose ....................................................................................................... 11
2.3 Challenges and opportunities ...................................................................... 12
Identified risks, issues and improvement initiatives for this section ...................... 14
3 The assets this plan covers ............................................................................... 15
3.1 What the assets provide .............................................................................. 15
3.2 Overview of the assets ................................................................................ 16
3.3 Critical assets .............................................................................................. 16
3.4 Our current and changing network .............................................................. 16
Identified risks, issues and improvement initiatives for this section ...................... 24
4 Current and future demand ............................................................................... 25
4.1 Factors that affect demand ......................................................................... 25
4.1.1 Population............................................................................................. 25
4.1.2 Demographics ...................................................................................... 25
4.1.3 Sustainability ........................................................................................ 26
4.1.4 Urban infrastructure .............................................................................. 26
4.1.5 Resilience ............................................................................................. 26
4.1.6 User expectations ................................................................................. 27
4.1.7 Other factors ......................................................................................... 27
4.2 Current use ................................................................................................. 27
4.3 Barriers to use ............................................................................................. 30
4.4 Future provision .......................................................................................... 31
4.4.1 Parks depots and utility buildings ......................................................... 31
4.4.2 Toilets and Changing Rooms ............................................................... 32
Identified risks, issues and improvement initiatives for this section ...................... 33
5 How we measure asset performance ................................................................ 34
5.1 Levels of service ......................................................................................... 34
5.1.1 Challenges with level of service statements ......................................... 34
5.2 Asset performance criteria .......................................................................... 35
5.2.1 Functionality ......................................................................................... 35
5.2.2 Use ....................................................................................................... 35
5.2.3 Condition profile .................................................................................... 36
5.2.4 Financial performance .......................................................................... 36
5.3 Proposed baseline service standards ......................................................... 37
Identified risks, issues and improvement initiatives for this section ...................... 38
6 How we manage our assets .............................................................................. 39
6.1 Decisions we make about assets ................................................................ 39
6.1.1 Optimising return on investment ........................................................... 39
6.1.2 Delivering agreed levels of service ....................................................... 39
6.1.3 Meeting anticipated demand for service ............................................... 39
6.2 Key considerations ...................................................................................... 39
6.3 Approaches to managing assets ................................................................. 40
6.3.1 Asset acquisitions and major upgrades ................................................ 41
6.3.2 Asset renewals ..................................................................................... 41
6.3.3 Maintenance activities .......................................................................... 41
6.3.4 Asset disposal ...................................................................................... 41
6.3.5 Lifecycle management by asset type .................................................... 41
6.4 Optimisation project .................................................................................... 51
Identified risks, issues and improvement initiatives for this section ...................... 52
7 Financial implications ........................................................................................ 53
7.1 Projected 30 year expenditure .................................................................... 53
7.2 Forecast capital spend for the next 10 years............................................... 54
7.3 Capital spend by local board ....................................................................... 58
7.4 Strategic CAPEX funds ............................................................................... 59
7.5 Maintenance and repairs: 10-year operational budget ................................ 60
Renewals .......................................................................................................... 61
7.6......................................................................................................................... 61
I am pleased to present the first Community Facilities Strategic Asset Management Plan 2015–2025.
Creating strategic asset management plans for Community Facilities has provided the opportunity for
Auckland Council to develop integrated and coordinated asset planning across departments allowing
us to form an overview for the Parks Community and Lifestyle theme.
Why is it important?
The Community Facilities Strategic Asset Management Plan 2015–2025 outlines our direction and
priorities for building and land assets that play a significant role in delivering a vibrant and attractive
city, which competes as a visitor destination on the world-wide stage while promoting a sense of
identity, pride and belonging in our local communities.
What’s different?
Working together to develop the plan has allowed us to gain greater knowledge and understanding of
our assets, and has provided an opportunity to better leverage the scale of our asset network, with the
aim of producing the best outcomes for Auckland.
This strategic asset management plan has been an ambitious task, which is not only a first for
Auckland Council, but for New Zealand.
By creating one strategic asset management plan rather than 10, as in in previous years, this
Community Facilities Strategic Asset Management Plan 2015–2025 helps the council to continue to
develop and optimise its asset management capabilities in a way that aligns to international best
practices, in an effort towards making Auckland the world’s most liveable city and delivering
Aucklanders great value for money.
Ian Maxwell
Community Facilities Strategic Asset Management Plan Owner
General Manager- Parks, Sport and Recreation
8
• disposing of under-performing Overviews the assets covered by this plan,
assets that are no longer meeting and the outcomes they provide for Auckland.
community needs (see Section 5.3 Also outlines the current number, location and
Proposed baseline service state of these assets, and the projects we
standards for more information)
have planned with respect to them, for the
• recognising spatial prioritisation future.
areas
Section 4: Current and future demand
• improving the value realised from
assets by using a whole-of-life Describes the key factors that affect demand
value approach. for our community facilities assets and the
3. Focus investment on developing fit-for- current levels of use. It also identifies barriers
purpose, integrated and connected to use and frameworks for future provision for
community facilities by: our assets.
• ensuring assets are fit for purpose
Section 5: How we measure asset
for their defined activity, including
lifting levels of service (where performance
required to allow greater use) Outlines how levels of service have been
• identifying opportunities to provide defined for community facilities assets in the
flexible, integrated and connected past and proposes a new approach based on
facilities, where possible. establishing a baseline standard for each of
4. Consider non-asset solutions and our community facilities asset types.
partnerships by:
Section 6: How we manage our assets
• exploring opportunities to leverage
and support partnerships with other This section considers the information
providers presented in the previous sections and
• developing service solutions that do outlines the approaches we use to manage our
not require assets, where possible. assets accordingly.
These principles are consistent with the Section 7: Financial implications
objectives in the Community Facilities Network
Plan, and with the council’s Asset Describes the financial implications of
Management Framework (2011) and Asset investment in capital projects within the current
Planning Standard (2014). financial constraints and identifies priorities for
asset renewals, levels of service and meeting
1.3 What this plan covers growth.
The plan is organised into the following Section 8: Major projects comparison
sections. Together, they describe why the plan
Compares the major growth & levels of service
was developed, what assets it covers, why
projects identified in the Long-term Plan 2012-
these assets are important, and how we will
2022 and the Long-term Plan 2015–2025.
manage them for the future to help achieve the
council’s vision and strategic outcomes for Section 9: Improvement Plan
Auckland.
Presents the full improvement plan for the
Section 2: Why this plan was developed document. The initiatives have been identified
Explains how this plan sits within the council’s throughout the document and are also
Long-term Plan, its purposes and principles, presented at the conclusion of each section,
and the challenges and opportunities we face where they are linked to the relevant risk or
in managing community facilities assets. issue (see Appendix 2 for risk & issues
registers) and the four key principles of this
Section 3: The assets this plan covers
plan (Section 1.2).
2.1 Fit with the Long-term Plan For asset management planning purposes,
this theme is split into two areas: community
In its Long-Term Plan 2015–2025, Auckland facilities, and open space.
Council divides its business activities into
seven broad themes: The Community Facilities Network Plan and
the Open Space Policy provide high-level
• Auckland development strategic direction for managing assets in the
• economic and cultural development two areas. Below these sit this Community
Facilities Strategic Asset Management Plan
• environmental management and
regulation 2015–2025, and the corresponding Open
Space Strategic Asset Management Plan
• governance and support
2015–2025.
• parks, community and lifestyle
These strategic asset management plans set
• transport
principles and priorities for how we will
• water supply and wastewater. manage these assets, and how they change
Taking a theme-based approach supports over time. They are also used to inform and
different council departments to work together guide our renewal and maintenance
to provide integrated and coordinated programmes.
planning. This hierarchy of plans, and the relationships
Community facilities sit within the parks, between them, is illustrated in Figure 1.
community and lifestyle theme, which
incorporates community services, libraries,
parks, recreation and leisure activities.
10
Management Plan 2015–2025 include:
At a higher level, this Community Facilities • the asset demand implications
Strategic Asset Management Plan 2015–2025 flowing from special housing areas
is one of a number of plans, policies and
• the growth impacts of the Forward
strategies that have been developed to Land and Infrastructure Programme
support the Auckland Plan, as shown in Figure
• the Community Facility Network
2.
Plan, in particular the actions
Key strategic documents that inform this plan identified for the first three years,
include: 2016–2018, which will inform the
next long-term planning round
• Arts and Culture Strategic Action • the 30-year Infrastructure Strategy.
Plan
• Thriving Communities: Community 2.2 Purpose
and Social Development Action
The purpose of this plan is:
Plan
• Auckland Libraries: Te Kauroa – to improve strategic alignment and provide
Future Directions 2013–2023 a coherent and integrated approach to
• Housing for Older Persons: managing building assets to realise
Property portfolio review opportunities from efficient and improved
asset performance.
• Public Open Space Strategic Action
Plan 2013 In particular, this plan:
• Auckland Sport and Recreation
• covers community facilities assets
Strategic Action Plan 2014–2024
from all of the council’s
• Parks and Open Space Acquisition departments
Policy
• identifies limitations with the content
• Sport NZ National Facilities of this plan, and initiatives to
Strategy for Aquatic Sports address them, through the
• Pools and Leisure Renewals improvement plan
Strategy • signals the risks and consequences
• State of the pan. of current financial and planning
constraints
Community facilities play a significant role in
achieving the outcomes detailed in the • is intended to be a current, living
document – to remain accurate,
Auckland Plan.
reflect business activities and
Other influences that have shaped this promote progress on the identified
improvement initiatives
Community Facilities Strategic Asset
12
Challenges Opportunities Relevant section
Improvement initiatives to address these issues and risks are itemised in Section 9.
Key principle
Risk or issue identified
Improvement initiative
Key principle 2:
Take a holistic, coordinated and evidence-based approach to planning
14
3 The assets this plan covers
16
Table 3 Community facility asset types current state & planned projects
Total 32 Average 9
Provision Changing rooms are customer-facing facilities, which the council provides Growth and levels of service projects for changing rooms are:
Changing rooms
Total 69 Average 6
18
Facilities Current state Planned projects (long-term plan)
– number, size and location
Provision Community centres and houses vary in size and age, from small • Construct Westgate library and community centre.
Community centres and houses
Total 50 Average 16
Provision The council owns 176 sites and facilities, of varying size, age and No major projects.
Community facilities leases
Total 176
years. This includes facilitating ownership (through ordinarily ground a cost of $45,000 per unit.
Albert-Eden - -
Devonport-Takapuna 274 38 leases) of 150 own-your-own units.
Franklin 99 16
Great Barrier - - Approximately half of these units are one-bedroom bedsits, with the other
Henderson-Massey 91 10
Hibiscus and Bays 18 1 half being one bedroom units (single and double bedrooms in equal
Howick 71 6
Kaipatiki 148 19
portions). The configuration of the units differs across the region.
Mangere-Otahuhu 151 32
Manurewa 126 24 There is uneven distribution across the region with no rental provision in
Maungakiekie-Tamaki - -
Orakei
the areas of Central, Rodney or Waiheke and Great Barrier.
- -
Otara-Papatoetoe 167 29
Papakura 72 17 The average age of the units is 45 years with a higher proportion of rental
Puketāpapa - units in the North above this average age.
Rodney - -
Upper Harbour 18 5
Waiheke - - The majority of the Housing for older persons villages are well located
Waitakere Ranges 64 19 close to amenities and public transport.
Waitemata - -
Whau 113 14
Provision The council manages and operates 55 libraries, providing a total library Build new libraries at:
Libraries
20
Facilities Current state Planned projects (long-term plan)
– number, size and location
Provision Parks depots and utility buildings include: Growth and levels of service projects identified in the long-term
Parks depots and utility buildings
Total 200
Provision The council currently provides: Projects we are already committed to include:
Pools and leisure centres
Total 164
Provision Toilets are customer-facing facilities that have been split into two Growth and levels of service projects for parks toilets are:
Number of (sqm) per
Toilets (parks and streetscape)
Local Board facilities 1000 people categories, based on which council group has management responsibility
for them: • Piha Domain, toilet and camp ablution block – $73,368
Albert-Eden 23 7
Devonport-Takapuna 27 22
Franklin 62 26
• Greenslade Reserve, combined toilet and changing room -
Great Barrier 14 95
• parks toilets – 588 scheudled for completeion in 2016
Henderson-Massey 22 3
Hibiscus and Bays 45 22 • streetscape toilets – 96. • Matakawau Domain toilet refurbishment - scheudled for
Howick 27 6
Kaipatiki 26 7 The average size of toilets is 30sqm and the average age of the portfolio is completeion in 2016
Mangere-Otahuhu 11 4
Manurewa 10 6 21.3 years. Renewals projects for parks toilets are:
Maungakiekie-Tamaki 26 15
Orakei 21 9 The overall condition of the network is very good with approximately 97
Otara-Papatoetoe 15 5 • Browns Bay Beach, toilet refurbishment
Papakura 15 4 percent of assessed components in moderate to very good condition.
Puketāpapa
Rodney
20
61
18
36
• Wenderholm Regional Park, main entrance toilet
Upper Harbour 20 6
Waiheke 25 44 • Mahurangi Regional Park, information centre toilet
Waitakere Ranges 28 18
Waitemata 60 12 These renewals are scheduled in the 2015/16- 2024 programme.
Whau 18 6
Regional 108 33
22
Facilities Current state Planned projects (long-term plan)
– number, size and location
Provision The council’s venues for hire range from small one-room facilities to larger • Build a new hall in Stillwater – scheduled for completion in
Venues for hire
Improvement initiatives to address these issues and risks are itemised in Section 9.
Key principle
Risk or issue identified
Improvement initiative
Key principle 2:
Take a holistic, coordinated and evidence-based approach to planning
Lack of data for some asset types • Complete network assessments for asset types within
limits the application of consistent existing scope of the Communities Facilities Network
planning practice across the Plan (24)
portfolio • Address issues with inconsistent or missing base data to
Issue 2 improve its accuracy and analysis (6)
24
4 Current and future demand
In this section we discuss the key factors that There are patterns to where older people
affect demand for the council’s community reside across Auckland, with the highest
facilities: population, demographics, proportions of elderly in the Orakei, and
sustainability, urban infrastructure, resilience, Hibiscus and Bays local board areas. These
user expectations and other factors. patterns are likely to continue as the
population ages.
We also look at the current levels of use of
these facilities, the barriers that may prevent A corollary to this is that some local board
people using them, and how we intend to areas have, and will continue to have,
manage future growth in demand. relatively youthful populations, for example
Henderson–Massey and Manurewa.
4.1.1 Population
Auckland is also highly ethnically-diverse with
Auckland’s population grew by approximately approximately 35 per cent of the 2013
400,000 people between 1995 and 2013 (from population born overseas.
1.1 to 1.5 million), and is expected to grow by
a further 500,000 between 2013 and 2031 (to As with age distribution, there is also
2 million). While some of this growth is due to significant variation in ethnic distribution
net migration into Auckland (both internal and across the region as illustrated in Figure 3.
external to New Zealand), the main driver of These demographic factors will have
Auckland’s growth is natural increase, implications for the quantity, type and location
particularly as a result of greater longevity. of community facilities that will be sought
throughout Auckland over the long term.
Figure 3 Auckland’s population breakdown by ethnicity
26
4.1.6 User expectations retrofit current community facilities to
accommodate these technologies.
Use of the council’s community facilities
depends to a large degree on whether those • Māori outcomes – Auckland Council is
committed to working with Māori and to
facilities meet users’ expectations. To assess
valuing te ao Māori. Responding to
this, we monitor the performance of our Māori communities’ needs and
community facilities, and user satisfaction (see aspirations, by providing appropriate
Section 4.2). assets, is a means of lifting their social
and economic wellbeing. This
4.1.7 Other factors commitment is likely to have
implications for future use of the entire
Other factors that affect demand for
community facilities network, particularly
community facilities, and how we provide those facilities located in areas with
them, include the following. relatively high Māori populations.
• Economic factors – economic factors 4.2 Current use
affect demand for council services in a
number of ways. For example, demand Table 4 summarises who uses the council’s
for libraries typically increases when community facilities (the user profile), and their
services such as the internet become current levels of use and satisfaction with the
more expensive.
facilities.
• Technological factors – community
facilities in the future will need to be able The results given are based on a 2014 survey
to cope with and cater for changing of the council’s community facilities.
technology (for example, Wi-Fi
capabilities). We may also need to
Art facilities 71 per cent are female. 48 per cent of respondents Visitor satisfaction is high –
had used an arts facility over 80 per cent for most
40 per cent are aged over 55 between one and four times facilities surveyed, although
years. in the six months prior to the levels were lower for Asian
68 per cent are New Zealand survey. and other ethnicities.
European. There is demand for more
All other ethnicities are under- opportunities to participate in
represented. other art forms (music, film,
photography, literary arts),
and for access to affordable
studios and rehearsal space.
Community 77 per cent are female. 69 per cent of respondents Satisfaction is high and most
centres and had not used a community have been visiting for a long
38 per cent are aged over 50 centre in the six months prior time.
houses years. to the survey.
63 per cent are New Zealand
European.
All other ethnicities are under-
represented.
Housing for People over the age of 60 years Consistently high occupancy Data unavailable
older persons with limited income and assets rates (97 per cent), with a
waiting list of approximately
340 people in 2013.
Turnover is generally low,
but does vary between
villages.
Libraries 60 per cent of members are 41 per cent of respondents Overall satisfaction with
female had used a library five or library facilities is high, with
more times in the six months 89 per cent of users
Age profile is similar to the prior to the survey. satisfied.
Auckland age profile
26 per cent of respondents
Ethnicity unknown had used a library between
one to four times in the six
months prior to the survey.
Parks depots Internal and external staff. No usage data is available. Agreed service levels are
and utility achieved.
Ethnicity unknown.
buildings
Leisure centres
57 per cent of respondents
50 per cent are male, and 50 per had not used a council
cent female. leisure centre in the six
45 per cent are aged between 20 months prior to the survey.
and 50 years. 24 per cent of respondents
There is a slight over- had used a council leisure
representation of Maori, Pacific centre five or more times in
and Asian users. the six months prior to the
survey.
28
Asset type User profile Levels of use Satisfaction
Toilets (parks Casual parks visitors. No usage data is available. No satisfaction data is
and available.
Formal and informal recreation
streetscapes) parks users.
Age profile is similar to the
Auckland age profile.
Ethnicity unknown.
Venues for hire 67 per cent of hirers are female. Overall, venues for hire are Hirers are generally highly
used between 30 to 40 per satisfied with their facility
74 per cent of hirers are aged cent of their available and have been booking the
over 40 years. bookable time. facility for a long time.
69 per cent of hirers are New The total number of visits
Zealand European. varies significantly between
venues, from hundreds to
over 20,000 per month.
Peak use times are between
9am and 11am, and in the
evening between 6pm and
8pm.
Figure 5 Why survey respondents did not use each type of facility
30
It is important to note that, while different
4.4 Future provision
criteria apply to each type of space, our
Section 4 of the Community Facilities Network intention for the future is to provide integrated
Plan sets out provision frameworks for and connected community facilities (refer
community facilities. The frameworks outline principle 3 Section 1.2). This may involve
the objectives, functions and provision building new facilities, or changing the purpose
approach needed for the council to deliver fit- and optimising the use of existing facilities.
for-purpose facilities. They also identify the
For the financial implication of our future
types of spaces required in the community
provision see Section 7.
facilities network and how we will fill an
identified gaps. 4.4.1 Parks depots and utility buildings
Some community facilities assets do not fall Objective: To support agreed service delivery
within the scope of the Community Facilities levels through a combination of externally and
Network Plan. Provision frameworks for three internally focussed buildings, such as service
of these asset types are outlined in this centres, depots, glasshouses and farm
section. Frameworks for the remaining assets buildings.
groups have yet to be developed.
Functions Full facility levels of service are Full facility levels of service are Full facility levels of service
maintained. maintained. are maintained.
Provision Limited number of facilities to Limited number of facilities to Limited number of facilities to
approach serve catchments up to 5km. serve catchments of 10km plus. serve the region.
Ideal Use affordable facility design as a Use affordable facility design as Design determined by
schedule of base, customised in accordance a base, customised in evidence of need and
space with a needs assessment of the accordance with evidence of assessment of viability.
service delivery required. need and assessment of
Must be of a standard
viability.
sufficient to meet agreed
levels of service.
Approach for Use existing facilities. Use existing facilities. Use existing facilities.
filling
Assessed on case-by-case Assessed on a case-by-case
identified
basis, based on clear evidence basis, based on clear
gaps
of demand and a viable evidence of demand and a
business case. viable business case.
Toilets
Provision Network to serve local Limited number of facilities to One to three facilities to serve
approach catchments of up to 5km. serve catchments of 10km plus. the region.
Ideal Use affordable, standard facility Use affordable, standard facility Use affordable, standard
schedule of design as a base, customised in design as a base, customised in facility design as a base,
space accordance with a needs accordance with a needs customised in accordance
assessment. assessment. with a needs assessment.
Approach for Recognise other providers in Use existing facilities. Assessed on a case-by-case
filling areas outside the catchments of basis, based on clear
Assessed on a case-by-case
identified existing facilities. evidence of demand and a
basis, based on clear evidence
gaps viable business case.
of demand and a viable
business case. Recognise national facility
policies.
Recognise national facility
policies.
Changing rooms
Provision Network to serve local parks. Network to serve destination Network to serve region-wide
approach parks. parks.
Ideal Use affordable facility design as a Design determined by evidence Design determined by
Schedule of base, customised in accordance of need and assessment of evidence of need and
Space with a needs assessment. viability. assessment of viability.
Approach for In areas outside catchments of Use existing facilities. Assessed on a case-by-case
filling existing network. basis, based on clear
Assessed on a case-by-case
identified evidence of demand and a
basis, based on clear evidence
gaps viable business case
of demand and a viable
business case. Recognise national facility
policies.
Recognise national facility
policies.
32
Identified risks, issues and improvement initiatives for this section
Risks and issues that we have identified for this section have been linked to our key principles as
outlined in Section 1.2.
Improvement initiatives to address these issues and risks are itemised in Section 9.
Key principle
Risk or issue identified
Improvement initiative
Key principle 1:
Effectively maintain, improve and optimise our existing portfolio in the first instance before acquiring
more assets
Key principle 2:
Take a holistic, coordinated and evidence-based approach to planning
Risk A11
Some asset types do not have • Review current provision frameworks for all community
provision frameworks facilities asset types and develop new where necessary
Issue 9 (29)
Libraries 9
Facilities in parks 9
34
• quality – well-maintained, safe and
5.2 Asset performance criteria provide an enjoyable customer
experience
Asset performance determines how well a
facility accomplishes a given delivery • sustainable – balance the needs of
present and future generations, minimise
requirement. Measurements of performance are
their impact on the environment, and
qualitative or quantitative, and are based on deliver value for money for ratepayers
actual performance against a set standard or and users.
target. With regards to community facilities, these
The overall performance of an asset is attributes need further development. In
measured using four key criteria, as shown in particular, we need to be able to set appropriate
Table 8. targets and measures for each asset type, so
that we can measure functionality improvements
Table 8 Performance criteria
over time. However, at present, they offer
Performance Descriptor guidance on what is required of a facility for it to
criteria be considered functional and therefore fit for
Functionality Ability to meet service delivery purpose.
and customer requirements
Use Frequency of customer usage 5.2.2 Use
Condition Physical state of the asset Usage data for community facilities ranges from
Financial Cost to operate, maintain and good to poor. For example, collecting and
performance renew modelling usage data about unstaffed public
toilets requires a different approach to that taken
for leisure facilities where staff are onsite and
In this section we discuss how we collect data multiple activities take place at the same time.
about and measure these criteria for the
council’s community facilities assets, as well as Lack of consistent usage data is a risk. The
current issues in relation to them. improvement plan for this strategic asset
management plan outlines initiatives that we will
5.2.1 Functionality take to address this risk, as part of improving
Functionality measures how well an asset is our asset management planning.
performing against service delivery and
customer requirements.
The key attributes that describe and measure an
asset’s functionality are:
1200
70%
Pools and Leisure
1000 Toilets
Libraries
Number of facilities
800
Housing for Older Persons
400
17%
200 9%
4%
0
Very Good Good Good to Average Poor to Very Poor
(CGI <1.5) (CGI 1.5-1.9) (CGI 2.0-2.5) (CGI >2.5)
Condition Grade
36
• the level of investment required to reach
and maintain target levels for each asset
type.
5.3 Proposed baseline service Using a consistent approach and language
standards across the asset types will also enable us to
prioritise and consider trade-offs across the
We are currently developing a new entire network, in line with the council’s strategic
performance-based approach for how we objectives.
manage and allocate resources for community
The standards will also enable us to critically
facilities assets – the Baseline Service
analyse our community facilities asset portfolio
Standards Framework. This will initially focus on
to answer questions such as:
renewals, but over time will be further developed
for use in all aspects of asset lifecycle planning. • What assets are fit for purpose in our
network?
The purpose of the framework is to simply and
clearly articulate how we need our assets to • How well suited is the asset to the
perform in order to deliver services. activities and services it supports?
• What is the current functional capability of
In the first instance, we will develop a baseline
our asset portfolio?
standard for each of our community facilities
• Has the asset exceeded its use-by date?
asset types, in order to understand those assets’
current position. • Which assets only require minimal spend
if there is no longer strategic alignment?
We will then appraise the assets’ performance
• What is the best way to optimise the value
against four overarching criteria (see Section
of individual and portfolio assets through
5.2). renewal investment?
The focus will be on how well the assets are • Where are the trade-off, divestment and
performing their intended use based on service disposal opportunities?
delivery and functionality requirements. It is also proposed the Baseline Service
The Baseline Service Standards Framework will Standards Framework will help address some of
clearly define the target level of functionality, the challenges the community facilities portfolio
usage and condition required from our assets. faces for example:
This will be done by asset type, based on key • What does fit for purpose look like?
asset attributes that determine whether a
• What is the performance level of our
community facility is fit for purpose.
network of assets?
By developing specific targets and measures for • What underperforming assets do we have
assets we will improve our understanding of: and where are they in the network?
• individual community facilities • Which of our assets are unlikely to be
financially viable in the short and long
• the current level of service they provide to term?
the community
We will retain our current levels of service as a
• the overall performance of the community
measure of performance for our community
facilities portfolio
facilities until the Baseline Service Standards
Framework has been formally adopted.
Improvement initiatives to address these issues and risks are itemised in Section 9.
Key principle
Risk or issue identified
Improvement initiative
Key principle 1:
Effectively maintain, improve and optimise our existing portfolio in the first instance before
acquiring more assets
Key principle 2:
Take a holistic, coordinated and evidence-based approach to planning
38
6 How we manage our assets
Optimising the council’s return on its investment In addition, the network plan requires the
involves: investigative phase of asset planning to
consider the possibilities for community
• considering the total costs of providing and provision of assets (by others) and non-
maintaining an asset over its entire asset solutions.
lifecycle
c) Managing risk – the council uses a
• achieving the best outcomes from assets,
in the context of long-term funding consistent risk identification process across
constraints. all its activities and asset types (refer
Appendix 2). While the council is generally
6.1.2 Delivering agreed levels of service risk adverse, in some instances a low level
It is difficult to deliver the optimal programme of of risk across an asset portfolio is
services from the council’s community facilities appropriate and acceptable.
assets in the current constrained financial d) Project prioritisation – Section 5 of the
environment. Community Facilities Network Plan outlines
To manage this, planners and decision-makers a multi-criteria project prioritisation
share information, so that the implications of framework, which will ensure that all
delivering a lesser programme are understood projects align with the council’s strategic
and managed. outcomes.
We also plan holistically across all the different The framework will ensure that projects are
groups of community facilities, and aim to ensure funded based on evidence and transparent
decision-making.
40
required for the future. The associated Action The rest of our planned and response
Plan contains recommended investigations, and maintenance programmes are managed by our
associated prioritisation results, to indicate those preferred contractors.
actions that should be advanced in the short
term. 6.3.4 Asset disposal
Section 4.4 provides further information on the A number of factors trigger decisions about asset
provision frameworks for community facilities. disposal, such as:
Asset type Asset capacity and performance Asset condition Asset acquisition
Art facilities Measured by: Condition survey for all facilities (ideally every three Additions to the network are normally new
years), including an estimate of the components that asset builds, based on evidence-based
• floor space per capita
need replacement. identification of provision gaps or business
• visitor numbers
• visitor satisfaction need.
Condition assessments are yet to be undertaken.
• renewals required to maintain levels of However, it is estimated that only 60 per cent of the A business case outlining whole-of-life
service.
facilities are in good condition. investment costs and benefits is required.
Data is saved in the SPM asset management system and Development contributions are not available
maintained by the Property department. for growth investment in this asset type.
Changing rooms Measured by: A condition survey is ongoing for the parks component for Additions to the network are normally new
this asset type. asset builds, based on evidence-based
• service delivery required to maintain
identification of provision gaps or business
levels of service Data is saved in SPM and maintained by the Property
• renewals required to maintain levels of need.
department.
service.
A business case outlining whole-of-life
investment costs and benefits is required.
Chapels, Measured by: Condition surveys are required for this asset type. Additions to the network are normally new
crematoria and asset builds, based on evidence-based
• service delivery required to maintain Data will be saved in the SPM asset management
parks public identification of provision gaps or business
levels of service system.
buildings • renewals required to maintain levels of need.
service. Data will be updated and maintained by the Property
A business case outlining whole-of-life
department, in a way that is consistent with community
investment costs and benefits is required.
facilities data, wherever possible.
Development contributions are not available
for growth investment in this asset type.
Community Measured by: Condition surveys are required for this asset type. Additions to the network are normally new
centres and asset builds, based on evidence-based
• floor space per capita Data will be saved in the SPM asset management
houses identification of provision gaps or business
• health and safety incidents system.
• renewals required to maintain levels of need.
service Data will be updated and maintained by the Property
A business case outlining whole-of-life
• customer satisfaction surveys. department, in a way that is consistent with the
investment costs and benefits is required.
community facilities data already available.
Development contributions are not available
for growth investment in this asset type.
42
Asset type Asset capacity and performance Asset condition Asset acquisition
Community Under review. Condition survey for all facilities (ideally every three Additions to the network are normally new
facilities leases Assessment of these assets needs to years), including an estimate of the components needing asset builds, based on evidence-based
consider the nature of the services replacement. identification of provision gaps or business
provided as these are not council- need.
Data is saved in the SPM asset management system and
operated facilities.
maintained by the Property department. A business case outlining whole-of-life
investment costs and benefits is required.
Housing for older Measured by: Condition survey for all units (ideally every three years), Typically, new sites can be built, based on a
persons including estimate of the components needing business case outlining their initial Capex and
• use of units
replacement. ongoing consequential Opex requirements.
• tenant satisfaction
• renewals required to maintain levels of Data is saved in the SPM asset management system and
service. maintained by the Property department.
Libraries Measured by: Condition survey for all facilities (ideally every three Additions to the network are normally new
years), including an estimate of the components needing asset builds, based on evidence-based
• service delivery required to maintain
levels of service replacement. identification of provision gaps or business
• renewals required to maintain levels of need.
Data is saved in the SPM asset management system and
service.
maintained by the Property department. A business case outlining whole-of-life
investment costs and benefits is required.
Parks depots and Measured by: Condition surveys are required for this asset type. Additions to the network are normally new
utility buildings asset builds, based on evidence-based
• service delivery required to maintain Data will be saved in the SPM asset management
levels of service identification of provision gaps or business
system.
• renewals required to maintain levels of need.
service. Data will be updated and maintained by the Property
A business case outlining whole-of-life
department, in a way that is consistent with Community
investment costs and benefits is required.
Facilities data already available.
Development contributions are not available
for growth investment in this asset type.
Rental Measured by: Condition surveys are required for this asset type (ideally Additions to the network are normally new
accommodation every three years). asset builds, based on evidence-based
• service delivery required to maintain
identification of provision gaps or business
levels of service Data will be saved in the SPM asset management
renewals required to maintain levels of need.
system.
service. A business case outlining whole-of-life
Data will be updated and maintained by the Property
investment costs and benefits is required.
Department, in a way that is consistent with community
facilities data already available. Development contributions are not available
for growth investment in this asset type.
Toilets Measured by: A condition survey is ongoing for the parks component for Additions to the network are normally new
(parks and this asset type. asset builds, based on evidence-based
• health and safety
streetscapes) identification of provision gaps or business
• provision agreements. Data is saved in the SPM asset management system and
need.
maintained by the Property department.
A business case outlining whole-of-life
investment costs and benefits is required.
44
Asset type Asset capacity and performance Asset condition Asset acquisition
Venues for hire Measured by: Condition survey are required for all facilities (ideally Additions to the network are normally new
every three years), including an estimate of the asset builds, based on evidence-based
• floor space per capita
components that need replacement. identification of provision gaps or business
• usage rates – peak and off peak
• visitor numbers need.
Data is saved in the SPM asset management system and
• hirer satisfaction maintained by the Property department. A business case outlining whole-of-life
• revenue/return on expenditure
investment costs and benefits will be required
renewals requirements to maintain levels
for consideration.
of service.
Development contributions are not available
for growth investment in this asset type.
Asset type Asset prioritisation Renewal strategies Renewal programme Building risk
Art facilities For new works and major Depending on funding levels in Developed in conjunction with the • Infrastructure not capable of
refurbishments, as prioritised each year, priority may need to be Property department to: supporting future requirements.
in the Communities Facilities given to renewals to cover health • Heritage buildings not designed
• deliver maximum value for investment
Network Plan. and safety and compliance issues, for current or future planned use.
• reconcile within envelopes for the
and to allow continued service • Condition of the structure
For renewals, as determined governing body and local boards
provision. degrades, as insufficient funding
by the Action Plan and the • only set minimum levels of renewals
renewals prioritisation criteria. Comprehensive renewals will be is available to deliver the
investment for those assets with an
undertaken where funding and refurbishment programme.
associated priority investigation in the
priority allow. • Earthquake compliance.
Community Facilities Network Plan and
draft Open Space Policy
• maintain a minimum level of service.
Changing rooms For new works and major Developed to deliver infrastructure Developed in conjunction with the • Infrastructure not capable of
refurbishments, as prioritised renewals in a timely manner, and Property department to: supporting future requirements.
in the draft Open Space Policy refurbishments as part of a regular • Heritage buildings not designed
• deliver maximum value for investment
and Community Facilities cycle, depending on the levels of for current or future planned use.
• reconcile within envelopes for the
Network Plan. funding available through the • Condition of the structure
governing body and local boards
planning cycles. degrades, as insufficient funding
For renewals, as determined • only set minimum levels of renewals
by individual business cases Needs assessment is based on is available to deliver the
investment for those assets with an
and renewals prioritisation condition, performance and network refurbishment programme.
associated priority investigation in the
criteria. capability. • Old infrastructure systems being
Community Facilities Network Plan and
overloaded.
draft Open Space Policy
• maintain a minimum level of service.
Chapels, For new works and major Needs to deliver infrastructure Needs to be developed in conjunction • Infrastructure not capable of
crematoria and refurbishments, as prioritised renewals in a timely manner, and with the Property department to: supporting future requirements.
parks public in the draft Open Space refurbishments as part of a regular • Heritage buildings not designed
• deliver maximum value for investment
buildings Policy. cycle, depending on the levels of for current or future planned use.
• reconcile within envelopes for the
funding available through the • Condition of the structure
For renewals, as determined governing body and local boards
planning cycles. degrades, as insufficient funding
by individual business cases • only set minimum levels of renewals
from operating staff and Needs assessment is based on is available to deliver the
investment for those assets with an
renewals prioritisation criteria. condition, performance and network refurbishment programme.
associated priority investigation in the
capability. • Old infrastructure systems being
draft Open Space Policy
overloaded.
• maintain a minimum level of service.
46
Asset type Asset prioritisation Renewal strategies Renewal programme Building risk
Community For new works and major Depending on funding levels in Developed in conjunction with the • Infrastructure not capable of
centres and refurbishments, as prioritised each year, priority may need to be Property department to: supporting future requirements.
houses in the Communities Facilities given to renewals to cover health • Heritage buildings not designed
• deliver maximum value for investment
Network Plan. and safety and compliance issues, for current or future planned use.
• reconcile within envelopes for the
and to allow continued service • Condition of the structure
For renewals, as determined governing body and local boards
provision. degrades, as insufficient funding
by the Action Plan and the • only set minimum levels of renewals
Property department’s Comprehensive renewals will be is available to deliver the
investment for those assets with an
renewals prioritisation criteria. undertaken where funding and refurbishment programme.
associated priority investigation in the
priority allow. • Earthquake compliance.
Community Facilities Network Plan and
draft Open Space Policy
• maintain a minimum level of service.
Community For new works and major Depending on funding levels in Needs to be developed in conjunction • Infrastructure not capable of
facilities leases refurbishments, as prioritised each year, priority may need to be with the Property department to: supporting future requirements.
in the Communities Facilities given to renewals to cover health • Heritage buildings not designed
• deliver maximum value for investment
Network Plan. and safety and compliance issues, for current or future planned use.
• reconcile within envelopes for the
and to allow continued service • Condition of the structure
For renewals, as determined governing body and local boards
provision. degrades, as insufficient funding
by the Action Plan and the • only set minimum levels of renewals
Property department’s Comprehensive renewals will be is available to deliver the
investment pending a network review
renewals prioritisation criteria. undertaken where funding and refurbishment programme.
of assets, with the flexibility of
priority allow. • Earthquake compliance.
addressing reactive maintenance
requirements.
• maintain a minimum level of service.
Housing for For new works and major A full 10-year renewal schedule is in A full 10-year renewal schedule is in • Infrastructure not capable of
older persons refurbishments, as prioritised place, based on site refurbishment place, based on site refurbishment plans supporting future requirements.
in the Social Housing Action plans. • Condition of the structure
Plan. degrades, as insufficient funding
is available to deliver the
refurbishment programme.
• Earthquake compliance.
Parks depots For new works and major Needs to deliver infrastructure Needs to be developed in conjunction • Infrastructure not capable of
and utility refurbishments, as prioritised renewals in a timely manner, and with the Property department to: supporting future requirements.
buildings in the draft Open Space refurbishments as part of a regular • Heritage buildings not designed
• deliver maximum value for investment
Policy. cycle, depending on levels of for current or future planned
• reconcile within envelopes for the
funding available through the use.
For renewals, as determined governing body and local boards
planning cycles. • Condition of the structure
by individual business cases • only set minimum levels of renewals
and renewals prioritisation Needs assessment is based on degrades, as insufficient
investment for those assets with an
criteria. condition, performance and network funding is available to deliver
associated priority investigation in the
capability. the refurbishment programme.
draft Open Space Policy
• Old infrastructure systems
• maintain a minimum level of service
being overloaded.
48
Asset type Asset prioritisation Renewal strategies Renewal programme Building risk
Pools and As part of the Leisure The Leisure Renewals Strategy, As of 2015/16, the prioritisation Although no facilities have a rating
leisure centres Renewals Strategy, each of aims to: framework has informed renewals of 5, those rated as 4 are outlined in
the 40 facilities has been given planning so resources are directed to the Community Facilities Network
• prioritise work in one facility, do it
a rating from 1 (highest highest priority facilities. Plan and require further
once and do it right, with only one
priority) to 5. A draft closure, minimising any disruption investigation and action in the short-
prioritisation framework (also to operations to-medium term.
part of the strategy) then • review the renewals needed
determines an individual across the programme to identify
opportunities to maximise
renewals project rating. This
purchasing power.
priority ranking is then cross-
referenced against a facility The strategy categorises projects as
ranking, which is based on the follows:
facility’s community
• comprehensive upgrades – over
participation and revenue.
the course of the long-term plan
each facility receives a
comprehensive upgrade
• strategic renewals – strategic
replacement of key assets to
bring long-term energy and
maintenance savings and enable
strategic procurement
• return on investment initiatives –
specific funding for projects that
have a strong return on
investment.
Rental For new works and major Needs to deliver infrastructure Needs to be developed in conjunction • Infrastructure not capable of
accommodation refurbishments, as prioritised renewals in a timely manner, and with the Property department to: supporting future requirements.
in the Communities Facilities refurbishments as part of a regular • Heritage buildings not designed
• deliver maximum value for investment
Network Plan and the draft cycle, with the duration depending for current or future planned
• reconcile within envelopes for the
Open Space Policy. on levels of funding available use.
governing body and local boards
through the planning cycles. • Condition of the structure
For renewals, as determined • only set minimum levels of renewals
by business cases from Needs assessment is based on degrades, as insufficient
investment pending a network review
operating staff and renewals condition, performance and network funding is available to deliver
of assets, with the flexibility of
prioritisation criteria. capability. the refurbishment programme.
addressing reactive maintenance
• Old infrastructure systems
requirements
being overloaded.
• maintain a minimum level of service.
Venues for hire For new works and major Depending on funding levels in Developed in conjunction with the • Infrastructure not capable of
refurbishments, as prioritised each year, priority may need to be Property department to: supporting future requirements.
in the Communities Facilities given to renewals to cover health • Heritage buildings not designed
• deliver maximum value for investment
Network Plan. and safety and compliance issues, for current or future planned
• reconcile within envelopes for the
and to allow continued service governing body and local boards use.
For renewals, as determined
provision. • only set minimum levels of renewals • Condition of the structure
by the Action Plan and the
investment for those assets with an degrades, as insufficient
Property department’s Comprehensive renewals will be associated priority investigation in the
renewals prioritisation criteria. undertaken where funding and funding is available to deliver
Community Facilities Network Plan and
priority allow. draft Open Space Policy the refurbishment programme.
• maintain a minimum level of service. • Earthquake compliance.
50
finalise a programme of governance, processes,
6.4 Optimisation project
roles and business rules that will guide and
The council’s current organisation-wide improve non-service asset sale processes and
optimisation project aims to expand, direct and service optimisation activities.
accelerate the council’s non-service asset sales;
The aim is for the programme to become a
and where appropriate, enable service property
business-as-usual way of operating for all council
optimisation. For the purposes of the
departments, which will ensure:
Optimisation Project non-service refers to
properties where no funded service is involved. • non-service assets are identified and
dealt with in a timely and efficient
The project has come about as a result of a manner
critical review of the council’s expenditure, with
• long-term plan asset sales targets are
the intention of materially reducing its costs. This collectively planned for and met
is to be achieved by, among other measures,
• the optimisation philosophy is developed,
making efficiencies, reducing Capex and
formalised and adopted across council
divesting non-strategic assets. businesses
The Long-term Plan 2015–2025 has indicated • underperforming service assets are
that asset sales of around $66 million a year will optimised to deliver suitable levels of
occur over the life of the plan. service, thereby maximising their value,
use, efficiency and realising their wider
As part of the project, the council is exploring a strategic value
new method of dealing with service property, • optimisation activity supplements the
called optimisation. potential costs of future demand for
service activities, and the implications of
Essentially, optimisation seeks to deliver optimal
these on affordability and council
levels of service from the council’s property budgets
assets (including community facilities) by
• a programme is available to assist
releasing strategic and commercial value from
decision-makers prioritise asset sales,
underperforming properties, for direct
optimisation and investment decisions,
reinvestment into other service properties or
ensuring that these decisions are well
activities (rather than, as at present, being
informed.
directed to general council revenue).
At present, a number of cross-council teams are
contributing to the project. Together they will
Improvement initiatives to address these issues and risks are itemised in Section 9.
Key principle
Risk or issue identified
Improvement initiative
Key principle 2:
Take a holistic, coordinated and evidence-based approach to planning
Key principle 3:
Focus investment on developing fit -for-purpose, integrated and connected community facilities
52
7 Financial implications
Please note: the graph above includes all capital costs associated with the assets (e.g. library collections, technology and arts assets).
54
Table 10 and Figures 10 to 18 show the proposed 10-year spend on Capex growth, level of service
improvements and renewals funding by asset type.
Table 10 Ten-year capital funding for growth, level of service improvements and renewals for the community facilities asset
types
Level of
Community facilities asset type Growth service Renewals Total budget
Art facilities $386,170 $5,113,905 $7,469,772 $12,969,847
Community centres and houses $12,479,217 $4,014,752 $7,251,826 $33,745,795
Community facility leases $18,447,103 $18,447,103
Housing for older persons $36,267,979 $36,267,979
Libraries $20,818,770 $40,902,704 $61,721,474
Other parks facilities $72,479,886 $1,507,577 $36,109,194 $110,096,657
Pools and leisure centres $33,169,050 $30,055,951 $64,078,998 $127,303,999
Toilets and changing rooms $89,744 $9,871,619 $9,961,363
Venues for hire $2,236,337 $15,746,326 $17,982,663
Total $139,333,093 $53,018,266 $236,145,521 $428,496,880
Note:
• ‘Other parks facilities’ includes chapels, crematoria, parks public buildings, parks depots and utility buildings, and rental accommodation.
• A number of capital projects are a mix of growth, renewals and/or levels of service investment. Where this is the case, we have allocated the
full spend against the main investment driver.
56
Figure 15 Ten-year spend on toilets and changing rooms (uninflated)
Note: Other Parks Facilities includes Chapels, crematoria, parks public buildings, Parks depots and utility buildings and rental accommodation
58
Table 11 Top 12 growth and level of service projects for community facilities
Figure 20 Scheduled (proactive) repairs and maintenance funding over next 10 years
Figure 21 Responsive (reactive) repairs and maintenance funding over next 10 years
60
7.6 Renewals
Figure 22 shows the amount and proportion of
renewals capital expenditure by asset type.
The total of $236 million over 10 years equates to
55 per cent of all capital expenditure for
community facilities (see Figure 23).
Figure 22 Ten-year renewals budget by asset type (uninflated)
Note: ‘Other parks facilities’ includes chapels, crematoria, parks public buildings, parks depots and utility buildings, and rental accommodation.
Section 7.8 explains the gap between the renewal model and the LTP
approved budget for each asset type.
Figure 24 Condition and renewal cost for Housing for older persons
62
Figure 25 Condition and renewal cost for Libraries
Renewals are funded from a mix of borrowing • Asset optimisation – seeks to deliver
optimal levels of service from community
and depreciation reserves, which are paid for
facilities assets, by releasing strategic
through rates. In the current economic climate,
and commercial value from
we need to make efficiency savings, in order to
underperforming assets, which can then
help reduce the costs of new capital works and of
be reinvested directly into other service
maintain and renewing our existing asset
assets or activities. This will include
portfolio. This has resulted in a reduction in
reviews of clusters of community
renewals funding for seven of the nine
facilities, which could lead to asset
community facilities asset types, with an overall
divestment, or divestment to fund level of
reduction of 6 per cent: see Table 12.
service improvements or new multi-
Table 12 Renewals funding gap by asset type purpose facilities (see Section 6.9 for
more details).
Asset type Reduction
• A dedicated Parks, Community and
Community houses and
-19% Lifestyle Capex Fund worth $120 million
centres
Venues for hire -18% (see Section 7.4).
Community facility leases -23%
Some of the reductions in renewals funding for
Art facilities -13%
specific assets are linked to asset reductions
Libraries -13%
made through the optimisation initiative.
Pools and leisure centres No reduction
However, a number of other factors could also
Toilets and changing
-20% influence funding requirements, as we implement
rooms
Other parks facilities -20% some of the improvements covered in this plan,
Housing for older for example by:
No reduction
persons
• improving asset information and
Combined funding gap -6%
condition data
The reductions in funding relate to the cumulative • introducing a star rating for facilities
10-year renewals budget for each asset type, • developing baseline service standards
and will total $11 million across all the types. (see Section 5).
To ensure the most urgent renewals are carried Figure 27 Process for addressing the funding gap
out within the first four years, funding was
increased for the early years, and allocated using
asset condition data – in particular for art
64
Figures 28 to 37 provide a 10-year overview of
the renewals funding gap, including any related
.
impacts that might occur.
66
Figure 35 Other parks facilities renewals (uninflated)
68
8 Major projects comparison
Asset type Long-term Plan 2012-2022 Long-term Plan 2015-2025 Gap Impact of gap Action to address gap
Description Cost Description Cost
Building Albany Northern $21.6m Project due for Funding Demand arising Implications: Provide a 25 metre swimming pool
Aquatic Centre - completion value from growth • Underserved population facility; with learn to swim and
planned for 2015 2016/17 same as • Inequitable access to children’s water play and social areas,
stated in facilities for population and the addition of fitness facilities,
catchment
LTP 2012- subject to available funding to make
22 both a wet and dry leisure facility
Benefits of progressing:
Caters to demand arising from growth
Building Multi-use $4m Start delayed until Original No major gap – town Project need will be satisfied in
community facility 2017/18 budget centre (by external 2017/18
in Flatbush - $4m contractor) has not
planned for 2014- been built yet
2016 Change in
budget
+$0.4m
New
budget
$4.4m
Building New library in $11.7m Start delayed until Funding No major gap – town n/a n/a
Flatbush - 2016-2018 value centre (by external
planned for same as contractor) has not
2015/16 stated in been built yet
LTP 2012-
22
*Building Aquatic facility in $18.6m Planned for 2020 Original Demand arising Implications: Development of new library, multi-use
Flatbush - budget from growth, gap in • Underserved population community space, and pools and
planned for 2015- $18.6m the network • Impact on existing network leisure space
2017 of facilities Benefits of progressing:
Change in • Inequitable access to Caters to demand arising from growth
facilities for population
budget catchment
+$6.4m
Options:
New Change (decrease) levels of
budget service, timing
$25m
Building Massey North $6.1m Start delayed until Original No major gap – Project completion expected in 2015/16
Community 2015/16 budget urgency to build this
Centre - planned $6.1m has dissipated
for 2013-2015
Change in
budget
+$1.6m
New
budget
$7.7m
70
Asset type Long-term Plan 2012-2022 Long-term Plan 2015-2025 Gap Impact of gap Action to address gap
Description Cost Description Cost
Building Leisure centre in $7.7m Leisure centre in Original Demand arising Implications: Investigate options for pool and leisure
the north-west the north-west budget from growth, current • Impact on existing network space in the north-western area to
corridor (Whau) corridor (Whau) - $7.7m gaps in provision of facilities address potential gap in provision and
planned for • Inequitable access to population growth, recognising
facilities for population
2020-2025 Change in opportunities for co-location with other
catchment
budget community and sport facilities
+$12.3- Options: Benefits of progressing:
17.3m • Change (decrease) levels of • Caters to demand arising from
service, timing growth
New • Addresses current gap in provision
budget
$20-25m
Building Otahuhu $24m Works nearing Funding Demand arising Implications: Development of new aquatic centre as
Recreation completion, value from growth and fit • Underserved population part of the wider precinct development
Precinct - planned opening mid same as for purpose • Inequitable access to
for 2015 2015/16 stated in facilities for population
catchment
LTP 2012-
22
Building Pool and leisure $8.8m Not proposed in NIL Demand arising Implications: Investigate need for aquatic and leisure
centre in new long-term from growth, current • Impact on existing network space in the wider Pukekohe area
Pukekohe plan gaps in provision of facilities
• Inequitable access to Benefits of progressing:
facilities for population
Address demand arising from growth
catchment
• Underserved population
Options:
Change (decrease) levels of
service, timing
Building New library in $5.5m Start delayed until Original No major gap – n/a n/a
Takanini - 2018-2019 budget works will still align
planned for $5.5m to projected growth
2015/16 in the area
Change in
budget
+$0.3m
New
budget
$5.8m
Asset type Long-term Plan 2012-2022 Long-term Plan 2015-2025 Gap Impact of gap Action to address gap
Description Cost Description Cost
Building New library in Albany $8.3m Deferred beyond 2025 Original Library service provision Library is a leased Investigate provision of
- planned for 2019 budget does not meet agreed level building with lease expiry library services in this area
$8.3m of service date of October 2019. giving consideration to
Growth is also a contributing Beyond the lease’s tenure and suitability
Change in factor to provision expiry, future service Negotiations required to
budget requirements in this local provision will not be met. address lease expiring in
-$8.3m board Decrease in LOS due to 2019
this library serving the
New budget highest head of
$0m population per sqm in the
library network (AB or RB
– standardisation of
library hours)
Building Community centre $2.8m Start delayed until Original No major gap in service Project and need will be
development in 2020/21 budget provision as a result of delay satisfied in 2020/21
Meadowbank - $2.8m
planned for 2017/18
Change in
budget
+$0.3m
New budget
$3.1m
72
Building New community $2m No change in delivery Original No major gap in service
house at Hobsonville timeframe budget $2m provision as a result of delay
Point - planned for
2015/16
Change in
budget
-$0.5m
New budget
$1.5m
Building Museum and arts $3m Deferred beyond 2025 Original No change to existing None. However, future Could be mitigated by a
facility in Papatoetoe budget $3m provision or service levels. arts and culture provision non-asset solution
- planned for 2015- in the Papatoetoe area
2017 could potentially not meet
Change in needs
budget -$3m
New budget
$0
New budget
$5m
New budget
$2.5m
74
9 Improvement plan
Associated references
Community
Regional &
Related
Specialist
Facilities
Libraries
strategic
Pools &
Local &
Leisure
Sports
CFNP
Asset asset
Parks
Parks
AMP
AMP
AMP
management management Person Timeframe Resources Associated
No. attribute plan section Improvement required Comment or explanation Action responsible Priority for action required risk/issue
1 Capability Section 2 Deliver integrated planning Requires development and Monitor, promote and support Jane Taylor High 3 months To confirm Strategic Issue 4,
across all types of community implementation of internal establishment of internal Kataraina through Improvement Issue 5
facilities processes, most critically steering group to guide Maki delivery of 2
coordination of effort and integrated planning action
shared information
2 Process Section 6 Implement processes for Through partner project of Determine appropriate Jane Taylor High 3 months To confirm Strategic Risk A17
Capability investigating the potential ACPD and ACPL, defined participants to realise Kevin through Improvement
optimisation and divestment of process for divestment and optimisation and divestment Marriott delivery of 3
facilities that are no longer optimisation should be objectives Allison action
meeting community needs approved and implemented Dobbie
as a priority
3 Capability Section 6 Develop an agreed approach Dependent on development Consider appropriate Kevin High 12 months To confirm Strategic Y Risk A17
for establishing sustainable of best practice approaches participation in development Marriott through Improvement
partnerships with community from Community & Social and promote progress delivery of 4
and private organisations to Policy action
provide community facilities
4 Process Section 3 Improve network analysis of Will provide evidence base Consider appropriate High 6 months To confirm Strategic Y Issue 7
Data community facilities to inform for advancing needs participation in development through Improvement
planning assessments for Community and promote progress delivery of 6
Facilities action
5 Process Section 4 Consider standardisation of Will provide evidence base Consider appropriate High 12 months To confirm Business Y Issue 8
Systems methods for capturing and for advancing needs participation in development through Improvement
recording utilisation for assessments for Community and promote progress delivery of 116
community facilities Facilities action
6 Data Section 3 Address issues with Will improve asset based a) Identify key participants ADBS - PSR High 6 months To confirm Y Y Issue 2
Systems inconsistent or missing base planning to inform renewals b) Identify key information through
data to improve accuracy and planning and long term sources (present) delivery of
analysis planning c) Identify key requirements action
d) Explore options for
enhancement
7 Process Section 5 Participate in prioritisation of Will advance required Consider appropriate Medium Ongoing To confirm NEW Risk A9
Data seismic remedial work towards remedial work for the participation in development through
the optimisation of community portfolio and promote progress delivery of
facilities action
8 Process Section 5 Develop and implement Requires significant a) Identify key participants High 9 months NEW Risk A13,
Data Baseline Service Standards modelling and stakeholder b) Identify key information Risk A5
Capability methodology engagement to understand sources (present)
and measure implications of c) Identify key requirements
implementation (stakeholders)
d) Explore options for
enhancement
e) Seek feedback and
endorsement
Community
Related
Regional &
Specialist
Facilities
Libraries
strategic
Pools &
Local &
Leisure
Sports
CFNP
Asset asset
Parks
Parks
AMP
AMP
AMP
management management Person Timeframe Resources Associated
No. attribute plan section Improvement required Comment or explanation Action responsible Priority for action required risk/issue
9 Data Section 5 Develop timeframes for Condition surveys are still a) Identify key participants High 6 months NEW Risk A13,
Capability surveys to assess the current required for some facilities b) Identify key information Risk A14,
condition and performance of and need updating for others. sources (present) Risk A15
assets to support the Baseline Before new surveys are c) Identify key requirements
Service Standards approach undertaken a thorough (stakeholders)
review of process and data d) Explore options for
captured needs to be enhancement
completed to ensure it e) Seek feedback and
supports the Standards of endorsement
Service approach in a robust
manner
10 Capability Section 2 Ensure there is integrated Streamline inputs and co- a) Identify key participants Medium Other related NEW Issue 5,
planning within the parks, ordinate approach to b) Identify key information SAMPS's Risk A16
community and lifestyle theme, planning to ensure all asset sources (present) and AMP's
as articulated in the community types are captured, aligned c) Identify key requirements within Parks,
facilities and open space and optimised (stakeholders) Community
strategic asset management d) Explore options for and Lifestyle
plans enhancement theme
e) Seek feedback and
endorsement
11 Process Section 4 Use the updated growth model 3.0 Growth 10.3 Key Issue 1
Data (once available) to analysis and Demand Improvements Risk A11
future network requirements for Recreation
Facilities 3.1
12 Process Section 4 Undertake further research into The value of particular 2.0 Issue 8
Data the use of services and the clients, and what that means Managing
value or importance our for service provision should Performance
customers and stakeholders be strengthened and well-
place on our community articulated. The role of
facilities community facilities in the
service offer for customers
should be clear.
76
Associated references
Community
Related
Regional &
Specialist
Facilities
Libraries
strategic
Pools &
Local &
Leisure
Sports
CFNP
Asset asset
Parks
Parks
AMP
AMP
AMP
management management Person Timeframe Resources Associated
No. attribute plan section Improvement required Comment or explanation Action responsible Priority for action required risk/issue
17 Process Section 6 Review of the Optimisation This new process arising out Identify key participants from High Risk A17
Project’s execution plan to of the Long Term Plan will theme in the identification and
identify any implementation need to be well understood, prioritisation of opportunities
opportunities, issues and risks in particular the implication of being considered.
for the community facilities Local Board assets that
portfolio serve a catchment beyond
their local board boundaries
23 Capability Section 2 Define roles and expectations Participate in the Operations Issue 5
for asset planning functions divisional reshape project
within departments and across
divisions
Term Definition
Acquisition The process of engaging the use of an asset, from identification of needs through to hand-
over. Acquisition includes ensuring an asset is ready for service, as well as documentation
and protocols around record keeping and management. Acquisition is not solely about
outright purchase, but also encompasses alternative methodologies such as construction,
leasing, vesting, and partnerships with external parties
Annual Plan The plan that sets out what the council will be working to achieve in a financial year, how it
will spend its money, the level of service provided, and the level of rates and other revenue
sources required to fund that spending
Area (Spatial) Plan Spatial planning at a more local scale that translates Auckland Plan directions and local
board aspirations into local spatial outcomes and intended land uses. In turn, it gives
direction to the Unitary Plan, previously referred to as a District Plan or some other name
Art facilities Provide opportunities for the community to learn, experience, create and appreciate arts
and culture. They also provide opportunities for art-making at community, emerging artist
and professional artist levels. They include facilities for visual and performing arts, literature,
and for cultural activities (both cultural expression and cultural heritage). These facilities
have on-site staff, coordinated programming and some have performance and exhibition
spaces, teaching facilities, studio spaces for hire and maker spaces.
Asset An item of value, usually of a physical nature and that has future economic benefits.
Infrastructural assets provide the basic facilities, services and installations needed for a
community or society to function, such as stormwater drainage pipes. Non-infrastructural
assets are those that provide either administrative or operational functions, such as
computer software, office equipment, etc
Asset Condition The physical state of an asset, which determines its ability to deliver required services
Asset Management The Asset Management Framework is the overarching document, as defined in the Long
Framework Term Plan, that articulates the council's commitment to ensure that asset management
(AM) is undertaken in a structured and coordinated way across the organisation
underpinned by core principles
Asset Management Plan An Asset Management Plan (AMP) is a medium to long term (10-50 years or more) plan
(AMP) that outlines the asset activities and programmes for each service area, as well as the
resources to be applied to provide a defined level of service in the most cost effective way.
It supports Council's Long Term Plans, the Auckland Plan, CCOs' Strategic Plans and Local
Board Agreements
Asset Management This document sets out the high-level, long-term approach to asset management, including
Strategy asset management action plans and objectives for the management of assets. It also
includes information about capability enhancement projects
Auckland (Spatial) Plan A spatial plan for Auckland as mandated in S79 and S80 of the Local Government
(Auckland Council) Act 2009. Now called the Auckland Plan (see also Masterplan)
Asset Register A record of asset information, typically held in a spreadsheet, database, or software system,
including asset attribute data such as quantity, type, and construction cost, primarily for
asset management purposes
Asset Value The assessed value of an asset, which may be either the amount for which an asset could
be exchanged between knowledgeable, willing parties in an arm's length transaction, or the
amount at which an asset is recognised after deducting any accumulated depreciation and
accumulated impairment losses
Capital expenditure (Capex) Expenditure used to create new assets or to increase the capacity of existing assets beyond
their original design capacity or service potential. Capital expenditure increases the value of
an asset.
Catchment The geographic area that the facility serves. This can be specified as a local, destination or
regional catchment.
Changing rooms Facilities usually on or near a beach or sports park. They often include a toilet facility. Their
purpose is to serve as a changing area for sports and recreation activities.
Chapels, crematoria and Grandstands, Cafe/Restaurants, Kitchens, Public Display/Education Buildings,
parks public buildings Shade/Shelters, Sports Facilities, Visitor/Information centres, chapels, crematoria and parks
public buildings
Community centres and Provide opportunities for social interaction, arts and recreation, events, programmes and
houses interest-based groups or activities. These facilities generally have meeting spaces which
can be booked, coordinated programming and are often staffed by an on-site manager.
They may also include other associated amenities like early childhood education centre,
Cititzens Advice Bureau or Plunket.
80
Term Definition
National Facilities Strategy Developed by Sport New Zealand to provide direction on the international, national and
for Aquatic Sport local facility requirements for aquatic sports. For Auckland the strategy indicates:
• International requirements will be met by the development of the Millennium Institute of
Sport and Health (MISH) in Auckland and a proposed facility in Christchurch.
• National requirements – prioritise access to existing facilities, especially those with
spectator capacity and specialist amenities.
• Local – benchmark estimates for community pools in Auckland at 70 people per square
metre of pool (equivalent to 35,000 people for standard 500m2 pool).
National Facilities Strategy Developed by Sport New Zealand to provide direction on the international, national and
for Indoor sports local facility requirements for indoor sports, including volleyball, gym-sports, badminton,
basketball, futsal and netball. For Auckland the strategy indicates:
• There is sufficient supply of international facilities in New Zealand.
• There is a requirement for additional national and regional competitive facilities in
Auckland, as an extension of community level provision
• Local – benchmark estimates of one indoor court for 9,000 people (including school
and public provision). On this basis there is significant shortfall of indoor courts in
Auckland.
Operational Expenditure Operating expenditure refers to the costs incurred in running and managing assets, such as
(Opex) administration support (e.g. staff, contractors, consultants), occupancy costs (e.g. rent,
rates, insurances), regulatory and compliance costs (e.g. WASSA, BWOF, accreditation,
etc.), and other costs relating to performance (e.g. cleaning, customer surveys, feasibility
studies, condition assessment, etc.)
Optimisation Improving the delivery of community facilities to achieve better financial and community
outcomes, for example selling an asset(s) to reinvest in the upgrade or development of new
asset(s), repurposing an asset for a different use or taking advantage of commercial
opportunities to generate funding that can be invested into asset(s).
Parks depots and utility Council Office/Service Centres, Farm buildings Horticulture/Glasshouses, Pumphouses and
buildings Works Depot/Utility Buildings
Pools and Leisure centres Buildings or fenced outdoor areas, incorporating indoor and/or outdoor swimming pools for
swimming for fun, learning, sport or relaxation. These facilities have on-site staff and require
user supervision and management of water quality in accordance with national standards.
They may also include a fitness suite, programme rooms and other associated amenities
like a café, physiotherapy and early childhood education.
Rental accommodation Camp/Hut/Lodge Buildings, Laundries (usually in Holiday Parks), Camp/Hut/Lodge
Buildings, Commercial/Investment Buildings, Community Facilities, Residential houses and
Residential Garages (usually for Park Rangers), and Baches.
Housing for older persons The provision of rental or owner-occupier units for older people provides safe, secure,
accessible and affordable housing to low income older people supporting them to be active,
healthy, safe, and independent allowing older members of the community to stay close to
friends and family. Although the provision of social Housing for older people is a
discretionary activity it is a recognised as a significant activity under the Local Government
Act 2002.
Special Housing Areas Locations identified for growth in the Auckland Plan and the Proposed Auckland Unitary
Plan where fast-track development of affordable housing can take place
Toilets (Parks and Provided as a public amenity. Management of the Auckland Council public toilet network
Streetscapes) falls under the responsibility of two distinct and separate departments of council. In their
capacity as ‘manager’ they act as owner on behalf of Auckland Council.
- Parks, Sport and Recreation (PSR) – toilets and change sheds located on parks, reserves,
esplanades, beach or sports grounds and that service users and visitors to these locations.
- Auckland Council Property Department (ACPD) – toilets that service users and visitors to
business town centres and are not located on a park, reserve, esplanade, beach or sports
ground. These are commonly referred to as streetscape toilets.
Underperforming assets An asset’s overall performance is measured by its functionality, utilisation, physical
condition and financial performance based on the service delivery requirements of the
business and community. These requirements are generally described in levels of service
statements or service standards.
An underperforming asset does not meet these criteria either in part or full.
Venues for hire Spaces available for hire on a regular or casual basis for public and private meetings,
activities, programmes or events. These facilities have no on-site manager or coordinated
programming. In most cases users hire and access the spaces through a centralized
booking system.
Risk register
Risk Status
(After treatment)
Risk
Ref ID #
Additional Control(s)
Treatment Open /
Consequence
Plan Closed
Risk Score
Likelihood
Summary Relevant SAMP
(RAG)
section
A1 Failure of climate control systems (including drying Damage to Library heritage and Art Back-up climate control 2 2 4 Libraries: Senior Dept specific 2016 Closed
equipment and cold storage facilities) collections systems will be able to protect Library Management
heritage and art assets Art facilities: Facilities
Managers
Failure of heritage and art facility security system Damage to Library heritage and Art Back-up security systems will 2 2 4 Libraries: Senior Dept specific 2016 Closed
collections be sufficient to protect Library Management
heritage and art assets Art facilities: Facilities
Managers
A2
A3 Referral of customers to 2 2 4 Libraries: Library Dept specific 2016 Closed
alternative library with internet Administrators/ Library
services intact. Secondary Staff/ Information
power source services staff
Failure of internet services Not able to operate internet service
C1 Operational services could 1 2 2 Libraries and Council-wide 2016 Closed
Inability to respond to, or effectively still be provided off-site Community Centres:
manage and recover from disaster or Operations managers
emergency; Inability to operate council
Unavailability of normal workplace resources for council business under normal conditions; Poor
personnel public perception / Negative image
A4 Refer improvement plan initiative Continue to form a robust end 2 2 4 Asset management Section 6: How we will 2016 Closed
23 to end process of information planning and manage community
management e.g. Operations staff facilities for the future
standardised data entry
forms; Improve use of filing
systems; Define
responsibilities more clearly;
Operational loss; Financial costs; Failure Provide appropriate training
to meet compliance requirements (e.g. for staff; Protocols for update
asset inventory and condition information, and ongoing auditing;
unable to forecast renewals Ongoing customisation of
requirements); Poor public perception / Asset Management systems
Loss of asset information Negative image to meet needs
A5 Refer improvement plan initiative 3 3 9 Operational Lead Section 5 Regular Open
8 Teams
Ensure asset descriptions and
condition data is accurate
prior to valuation exercise;
Annual Plan budgets to be
based on condition data;
Improved asset planning
Decline in integrity and service capacity of processes linked to project
assets due to under-funding of renewals; delivery and asset
Failure to secure renewals funding - funding constraints Insufficient depreciation funding replacement
82
Risk Status
(After treatment)
Risk
Ref ID #
Additional Control(s)
Treatment Open /
Consequence
Plan Closed
Risk Score
Likelihood
Summary Relevant SAMP
(RAG)
section
A10 Physical safety of staff, users and contractors Injury or harm to affected persons 1 3 3 Property operational Council-wide Annually Closed
staff
A11 Under or over provision due to growth and demand Under of over provision in particular areas Refer improvement plan initiative Organisational buy-in and 1 4 4 RIMU staff, Financial Section 4 Quarterly Open
predictions being too high or low, if actual patterns differ of Auckland 11 resourcing (underway) Policy and Planning
from projected growth model staff
A12 Provision frameworks don't specifically reference the Demand may differ from past trends as a Refer improvement plan initiative Organisational buy-in and 2 2 4 Operational staff Section 4 Regular Open
potential impact of technology on changes in use of result of changing behaviour 14 resourcing (underway)
physical assets
A13 Exposure due to lack of asset information and disconnect Refer improvement plan initiative Organisational buy-in and 2 2 4 Asset Planning Section 5 Regular Open
with renewals planning [Visitor Centres, Ancillary Buildings, 8, 9, 15, 16 resourcing (underway)
Holiday Accommodation] Decline in integrity and service capacity of
assets due to under-funding of renewals;
Insufficient depreciation funding
A14 Lack of overall building condition grade creates reliance on Inconsistency in knowledge could give Refer improvement plan initiative Organisational buy-in and 1 2 2 Asset Planning Section 5 Regular Open
individual knowledge to assist in prioritisation inputs. inaccurate results 9, 18, 19, 21 resourcing (underway)
A15 Lack of current building condition information creates Inconsistency in knowledge could give Refer improvement plan initiative Organisational buy-in and 2 2 4 Asset Planning Section 5 Regular Open
reliance on modelling to inform planning of some asset inaccurate results leading to under- 9 resourcing (underway)
types funding of renewals
A16 Lack of cohesion between Open Space and Community Gaps or duplication in asset information Refer improvement plan initiative Organisational buy-in and 1 2 2 Asset Planning Section 2 Regular Open
Facilities SAMPS 10 resourcing (underway)
A17 Inadequate internal and external stakeholder and Delays in delivering project outcomes Refer improvement plan initiative 2 4 8 Section 6 Open
governance engagement through implementation of Dissatisfaction may prevent realising 2, 3, 17
property optimisation and disposal process project outcomes
A18 Decline in integrity and service capacity of Support requests for 2 3 6 Section 6 Open
Failure to secure adequate operational funding - funding
assets due to inadequate maintenance additional funding as required
constraints
Issue
Ref ID #
84
86