Movie Investing PDF
Movie Investing PDF
Movie Investing PDF
INVESTING IN THE
MOVIE INDUSTRY
Aug 2019
Conclusion 10
Bibliography 13
2 | An insight into investing in the movie industry 2019 © CoAssets International Pte Ltd
Introduction
A. INTRODUCTION
2. To understand investments in the movie industry, we need to understand the industry’s value
chain. This describes the whole process of movie production from development to consumer
consumption. In general, investments in the later part of the value chain have a more accurate
valuation due to a lower level of uncertainty once costs are finalized and distribution contracts
have been signed. For this reason, investments in the early part of the value chain generally have
higher returns and greater risk, while investments in the later part of the value chain have lower
returns and risk. The risk-reward ratio is project dependent.
3. The main factors determining the success of a film include public taste, aesthetic merit, compe-
tition from other films released at the same time, quality of the script, quality of the cast, and the
quality of the director and other parties.
B. SCOPE OF PAPER
II. Trends in the film & online video industry: A closer look into China
2019 © CoAssets International Pte Ltd An insight into investing in the movie industry | 3
I. FILM INVESTMENTS’ LOW CORRELATION WITH
EQUITY MARKETS
All investments inherently carry risk. Conventionally, Figure 2: S&P 500 index from 2005-2018
there are 2 broad categories of risk in the equity market –
Unsystematic risk, and systematic risk.
4 | An insight into investing in the movie industry 2019 © CoAssets International Pte Ltd
Due to the industry’s low correlation with equity markets,
investments in the movie industry can be considered ab-
solute return investments (as compared to relative return
investments).
This means that profits and returns from this industry are
largely dependent on specific film risks (e.g. script, produc-
tion costs etc.), and the ability of the producer or portfolio
manager to manage these risks, rather than market risks.
Such risks, and the areas that should be considered for
due diligence, will be covered in the later segments of this
paper.
As shown in Figure 4, U.S./Canada has the largest box Figure 6: Revenue of China’s online video market from
office market in the world, raking in a total of 11.9 billion 2009 to 2017 (billion yuan)
U.S dollars in 2018.
6 | An insight into investing in the movie industry 2019 © CoAssets International Pte Ltd
III. VALUE CHAIN OF THE FILM INDUSTRY
To understand specific investments made in the film indus- Development: This is the process of creating and de-
try, we look at the value chain of film entertainment (Figure veloping an idea for a film. This includes screenplay, as
7). well as securing funding for the writer. Films often spend
a long time in the development stage. This makes the
Figure 7: Summary of the film entertainment value chain investment at this stage particularly risky. One research
cites that only 18% of films developed in the UK reach
actual production. Funders of the development stage are
often separate from funders of the production and are
generally repaid out of the production budget rather than
from a share of proceeds of the completed film.
Slate financing: Hedge funds use slate financing to Factors to consider for due diligence before getting involved
manage risk and generate returns. This type of invest- in film financing include (but is not limited to):
ment is in a portfolio of films as opposed to a single pro-
duction. This reduces exposure to project risks (unsys- a) Investment structure
tematic risk) from a single film. As it is more diversified b) Return of principal (Escrow)
than the latter, the overall risk and return are more bal- c) Collateral
anced. The films included in the portfolio may depend on d) Cost of production
the fund’s co-financing efforts with the production and e) Ensuring a fair arrangement of the investment
distribution company. Portfolios are usually constructed
using a model or a few fixed criteria. The challenge faced Investment structure: Investors should consider the type
here is in conducting due diligence on tangled, opaque of financing (discussed in section IV) and the value chain
financial accounts to achieve greater transparency (Se- (discussed in III) in which he invests in, as this affects his
gal, 2018). projected nominal return and exit strategy. For investors
who invest early in the value chain, the time value of mon-
Crowdfunding: Partial funding via crowdfunding sets a ey is also important to monitor. Although many commercial
more realistic level of the funding target as it is easier films will continue to generate revenue for decades, the
to finance a specific production phase (e.g. pre-sales, present value of the revenue is diminished by time. Ancillary
post-production, distribution) rather than the whole (Mar- revenues (i.e. video-on-demand, pay TV, etc.) usually ac-
tin, 2016). Crowdfunding makes the film industry more crue to the studio that purchased these residuals (royalties
accessible to smaller investors who can now contribute paid to the actors/directors during DVD or online streaming
to projects which otherwise might have been shelved release) (HDTVNEWS, 2012).
(First, 2016). This also provides more security should an
investor pull out unexpectedly because the proportion of It is also important to consider how the investment will be
overall funds lost will be small, having a minimal impact repaid. For example, early-stage financiers would want to
on the continuation of film production and distribution. be repaid using the production budget, while late-stage fi-
nanciers would want to be repaid from actual profits. When
Because of the various ways crowdfunding can be used, different financiers are involved, there are also different re-
the risks for investments through crowdfunding are en- payment priorities. In such situations, it is also important to
tirely dependent on what the underlying financing struc- find out if existing financing has already been ranked pari
ture is, and where the investment lies on the value chain. passu, or if there is seniority tied to such debt. Senior debt
is normally considered to be lower risk than ’junior’ or subor-
V. RISK MITIGATION & CONSIDERATIONS dinated debt. In situations where debt is not directly present,
there are also structures that effectively mirror senior and
The creative factors which contributes to a film’s com- junior debt (see negative pick up example).
mercial success are (Litman, 1983):
Return of principal (Escrow): Investors should consider
a) Public taste in films especially in the territories of if there is an escrow account in the chain of financial trans-
distribution actions between the financing company and the production/
b) The artistic merit of the film distribution company.
c) Competition of other films released at the same
time in the target countries of distribution In an article by J.P. Morgan, it states that an escrow is a risk
d) Quality of the script and cast mitigation tool which allows two parties to set aside funds, to
e) Quality and accolades of director, producer and enable them to resolve various risk issues that might unfold
other parties during the transaction (Week, 2012). In film investments,
f) Production budget this addresses potential challenges like if the film distributor
g) Rating pays minimum guarantee for distribution rights, but the film
2019 © CoAssets International Pte Ltd An insight into investing in the movie industry | 9
delivery does not take place on time, or the materials a box office revenue of $500 million. In both examples, the
are not in line with conditions in the distribution agree- return on investment is 10 times. However, the movie with
ment (Zannoni, n.d.). the higher absolute cost of production and distribution runs a
larger risk of incompletion. This would also mean concentra-
An example of how an escrow account mitigates risk in tion risks for investments.
film financing is of a distributor who wants to buy distri-
bution rights of a film and the producer seeking to sell As such, judging the investment based on the ‘quality’ of the
such rights. Both parties run a financial risk of trans- movie produced may be misleading (see figure below); a
acting directly, as the distributor may not pay upon re- lower budget movie may make the same returns to the in-
ceiving the materials or the producer may default upon vestor as a blockbuster, depending on the investment struc-
receiving the money. With an escrow account, the pro- ture. This is also an added benefit to diversification via slate
ducer and distributor will enter into an escrow agree- financing (see section IV) when funding multiple movies with
ment with the account manager. The distributor will low production costs.
then pay for the royalties into the account, maintained
by a neutral third-party manager. After which, it is up to Figure 9: ROI for Hollywood movies in 2013
the producer to deliver the materials by a cut-off date,
meeting pre-agreed conditions. Once the conditions of Movie Studio Gross Cost ROI
the escrow agreement are met, the money will be re- Insidious:
FilmDistrict $160.4M $5M 31.1
Chapter 2
leased from the account (Zannoni, n.d.).
The Purge Universal $89.3M $3M 28.8
Collateral: According to Gallagher, Callahan & Gar- Warner Bros./
The Conjuring $316.7M $20M 14.8
trell, to serve as proof of value and collateral of the New Line
loan, the film package must demonstrate to the lender Despicable Me 2 Universal $918.6M $76M 11.1
the value of the project. If filming has not begun, the
Jackass Presents:
collateral can include the screenplay and story rights; Bad Grandpa
Paramount $142.2M $15M 8.5
legally binding commitments by the key personnel to Warner Bros./
We’re the Millers $269M $37M 6.3
participate in the film; the production budget – includ- New Line
ing a draw-down schedule for the use of the proceeds Gravity Warner Bros. $652M $100M 5.5
as they are paid to the filmmaker throughout produc-
Disney/
tion; and most importantly, legally binding guarantees Iron Man 3
Marvel
$1.2B $200M 5.1
for the territory sales, negative pick-up, or other financ- The Hunger Games:
ing arrangement. These contracts must specify the Lionsgate $774M $130M 5
Catching Fire
guaranteed minimum the filmmaker will be paid, and
Source: The Wrap (2013)
that amount can be used as collateral to be pledged
against the value of the loan (Ravgiala, 2009).
Other considerations: When assessing a film investment
Cost of production vis a vis returns: Investors opportunity, investors should confirm that the investment is
should consider the absolute cost of production and its a fair arrangement and structured in a way that ensures the
projected revenue. For example, an independent film agent and principal’s interests are aligned. Investors should
may cost $1 million to produce and distribute with a ensure that the parties are incentivised to execute their du-
box office revenue of $10 million. In contrast, a block- ties properly (Bloomenthal, 2019).
buster film may cost $50 million to make, and earn
VI. CONCLUSION
value chain is exposed to lower risks as compared to
This paper can conclude the following points. Firstly, investments early in the value chain. The risks associated
film investments as an asset class have a low with the various types of investments in this industry must
correlation to the equity market. This attribute could be factored into the investment decision making process.
be attractive for some investors due to the potential of
diversification when added to a portfolio of traditional Fourthly, there are different types of investments
investments. available within the film industry, including gap financing
and negative pick up financing. In this niche asset class,
Secondly, the global film industry has been steadily due diligence is crucial. Depending on the investment
growing for more than a decade. China is leading structure and the production stage at which the investor
the market in terms of growth, and is expected to finances, the investor should consider how he is repaid
eventually overtake the U.S. as the largest market in and how realistic the assumptions in revenue and cost
the world. projections are. For loans, lenders/investors should
consider how their financing is ranked, evaluating their
Thirdly, capital investment in the later part of the returns given the risk they are undertaking.
10 | An insight into investing in the movie industry 2019 © CoAssets International Pte Ltd
ANNEX A: LINEAR REGRESSION OF VARIABLES
Correlation
2019 © CoAssets International Pte Ltd An insight into investing in the movie industry | 11
ANNEX B: FILM PROJECT VALUE CHAIN
12 | An insight into investing in the movie industry 2019 © CoAssets International Pte Ltd
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Arnold, K. The Basics of Film Finance - HGExperts.com. Re- Organisation For Economic Co-Operation And Development.
trieved from https://www.hgexperts.com/expert-witness-articles/ (2008). Remaking the Movies: Digital Content and the Evolution
the-basics-of-film-finance-7309 of the Film and Video Industries.
Asset Class Correlation Map | Guggenheim Investments. (2019). Pearson, Kendall, & Spearman. (2019). Pearson’s Correlation
Retrieved from https://www.guggenheiminvestments.com/mutu- Coefficient - Statistics Solutions. Retrieved from https://www.sta-
al-funds/resources/interactive-tools/asset-class-correlation-map tisticssolutions.com/pearsons-correlation-coefficient/
Bloomenthal, A. (2019). Agency Costs. Retrieved from https:// Petrov, A., Hentov, E., & Zumbo, F. (2018). How Does Geopolitics
www.investopedia.com/terms/a/agencycosts.asp Affect Financial Markets? (p. Page 4). State Street Global Ad-
visors. Retrieved from https://www.ssga.com/investment-topics/
Bloore, P. (2009). Re-defining the Independent Film Value Chain. general-investing/2018/09/does-geopolitics-affect-financial-mar-
kets.pdf
Bramme, D. (2016). The different types of film funding. Retrieved
from https://www.danielbramme.com/blog/the-different-types-of- Ravgiala, J. (2009). Filmmaking 2.0: Equity and Debt Financing
film-funding - Film Financing. Retrieved from http://www.gcglaw.com/resourc-
es/entertainment/film_financing.html
Dogen, S. What Is Mezzanine Financing And How Does It Work?.
Retrieved from https://www.financialsamurai.com/what-is-mezza- Segal, T. (2018). How to Invest in Movies. Retrieved from https://
nine-financing-and-how-does-it-work/ www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0512/how-to-invest-in-
movies.aspx
Dutton, C. Bridge Loan VS Gap Loan: What You Didn’t Know.
Retrieved from https://privatemoneyutah.com/bridge-loan-vs- Week, L. (2012). The Role of Escrow in Mitigating Transaction
gap-loan/ Risk, J.P.Morgan. Legal Week.
Film industry in China | Statista. (2019). Retrieved from https:// What Is Mezzanine Financing And How Does It Work?. (2019).
www.statista.com/study/15709/film-industry-in-china-statis- Retrieved from https://www.financialsamurai.com/what-is-mezza-
ta-dossier/ nine-financing-and-how-does-it-work/
First, T. (2016). The rising popularity of movie crowdfunding – Yahoo Finance. (2019). Retrieved from https://sg.finance.yahoo.
Tribe First. Retrieved from https://www.tribefirst.co.uk/uncatego- com/quote/%5EVIX?p=^VIX&.tsrc=fin-srch
rized/the-rising-popularity-of-movie-crowdfunding/ Zannoni, D. Escrow Account for Film Business Transactions. Re-
trieved from http://zannonimedia.com/escrow-account-film-busi-
Global box office revenue 2018 | Statista. (2019). Retrieved from ness/
https://www.statista.com/statistics/271856/global-box-office-rev-
enue/ Deloitte, China. (2017) China’s film industry – A new era. Re-
trieved from
HDTVNEWS. (2012). Film Finance: What is a film Producer ? an https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/cn/Documents/
executive producer ?. Retrieved from https://hdtvnewschannel. technology-media-telecommunications/deloitte-cn-tmt-china-
wordpress.com/2012/09/11/what-is-a-film-producer-an-execu- film-industry-en-161223.pdf
tive-producer/
Robinson, J. (2016). Did you catch all the ways Hollywood pan-
dered to China this year? Retrieved from
Litman, B. (1983). Predicting Success of Theatrical Movies: An https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2016/08/did-you-catch-the-
Empirical Study. The Journal Of Popular Culture, 16(4), 159-175. ways-hollywood-pandered-to-china-this-year
doi: 10.1111/j.0022-3840.1983.1604_159.x
Dawtrey, A. (2008). Mezzanine financiers target indie films. Re-
Lotz, A. (2014). The television will be revolutionized (2nd ed.). trieved from
New York: New York University Press. https://variety.com/2008/film/global/mezzanine-financiers-tar-
get-indie-films-1117991715/
Martin, V. (2016). Crowdfunding: Eine Chance auf bessere
Filme? - Teil 1: Debütfilme. Retrieved from https://www.moviepi-
lot.de/news/crowdfunding-eine-chance-auf-bessere-filme-teil-1-
debutfilme-171970
2019 © CoAssets International Pte Ltd An insight into investing in the movie industry | 13
CoAssets Research Team
The CoAssets Research team delivers research on a wide
range of alternative investments and their related industries.
We aim to create data-driven reports to enable investors to
better understand macroeconomic and industry trends.
6 Shenton Way,
#36-01, OUE Downtown 1
Singapore 068809
Tel: +65 6532 7008
www.CoAssets.com