Child Health
Child Health
net/publication/50286795
CITATIONS READS
22 8,751
6 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Dimitrios Cassimos on 27 November 2017.
Abstract
Background Fairy tales have always been an integrated part of children’s everyday life. In our days,
they still represent important ways of helping the children share their desires and express their
agonies and inner conflicts. The present descriptive qualitative study aims to describe parents’
opinions and children’s preferences regarding storytelling.
Methods Four hundred and seventy parents took part in the study and were interviewed
following a semi-structured guide with open-ended trigger questions. Data were processed via
content analysis methods.
Keywords Results Three main themes were constructed. The vast majority of interviewees acknowledged
children’s preferences,
their strong belief in the power of fairy tales and stated that their children listen to stories at least
fairy tales, parents’
perception, storytelling, once a week. Most of them use storytelling as an instructive tool, in order to soothe their children’s
villains anxieties or set examples for them. Concerning children’s preferences, the majority of them choose
classic fairy tales over modern ones with Little Red Riding Hood taking precedence over other
Correspondence:
Pelagia Tsitsani,
famous stories. All participants acknowledged the fact that their children are amused and positively
Department of affected by storytelling, while young readers share their enthusiasm for fairy tales in many ways,
Paediatrics, General
mostly by talking about their favourite character. Finally, in relation to the villains, children seem to
Hospital of Didimoteiho,
25th May 152 Street, be satisfied or relieved when they are punished and only a small number of participants stated that
Didimoteiho PC 68300, the cruel punishment of bad characters creates feelings of fear to their kids.
North Evros, Greece
E-mail:
Conclusions The findings of this study emphasize the crucial role that storytelling plays in
[email protected] children’s life and normal development.
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Child: care, health and development, 38, 2, 266–272
268 P. Tsitsani et al.
Table 1. Semi-structured interview guide members of the research team in order to achieve the final
1. Do you believe in the power of fairy tales? matching and validity of categories. Data saturation was con-
2. How much time does your child spend away from you? sidered to have been reached when no new findings were iden-
3. Who is with your child during that time?
tified from manuscripts. Analysis of data was carried out
4. How often does your child listen to fairy tales?
5. Who is usually playing the role of the storyteller? manually and no software analysis package was used.
6. What method do you employ in order to tell a fairy tale?
7. Do you prefer reading or narration? Please justify your answer.
8. Your selections of fairy tales are based on which criteria? Results
9. What kind of fairy tales does your child listen to?
10. What kind of fairy tales does your child prefer?
11. What’s your child’s favourite fairy tale? Participants’ characteristics
12. Do you have a specific hour for storytelling?
13. Do you tell stories based on a specific schedule? The mean age of children whose parents participated in this
14. What do you think is the main purpose of a fairy tale? study was 4 years. Within this population, 51.8% were boys and
15. Does your child seem pleased when you are reading a fairy tale? If so,
48.2% were girls. The mean age of mothers was 33.6 years,
does he/she have a specific way of sharing his/her feelings?
16. What does your child think about villains? whereas for fathers it was 37.7 years. Forty-eight per cent of
17. What does your child feel when the villain is punished? interviewees had graduated from high school, and 38.4% held
18. Do you consider fairy tales instructive? Justify your answer. university degrees. Kos is a famous holiday destination, and
19. In what way do fairy tales affect your child?
20. When you were children, have you been listening to fairy tales? because of its touristic development, 20% of interviewees were
hoteliers, while 18% were freelancers, working in their personal
business.
why, it was explained from the beginning to parents that by the
term ‘fairy tales’ the researchers refer to classic and modern
children’s literature stories. Interacting with the parents Findings
expanded this spectrum to: western fairy tales, folk Greek lore
The results of this study are distributed in three main
and ancient Greek fables and stories out of Greek and universal
categories, as:
children’s literature. The contact invariably started with the
question ‘Do you believe in the power of fairy tales?’, aiming to
1 general topics about fairy tales related to family lifestyle
create a friendly environment and stimulate discussion. The
trends;
major issues covered in all conversations included parents’
2 parents’ opinion in relation to the use and usefulness of fairy
opinions in relation to the use of storytelling, children’s habits
tales;
and preferences, as well as general topics related to the function
3 children’s habits, attitude and preferences regarding fairy
of the family and modern lifestyle trends. All interviews were
tales.
carried out at the participants’ homes, lasting 35 to 45 min.
Dialogues were audio-recorded with the permission of all par-
The majority of respondents explicitly stated their belief in
ticipants and fully transcribed to written manuscript.
the power of fairy tales. According to one mother:
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Child: care, health and development, 38, 2, 266–272
Fairy tales: a timeless value 269
Table 2. Reasons justifying the choice between narration and reading Table 3. Roles of fairy tales in children’s life
Choice Examples of quotations from respondents Role Examples of quotations from respondents
Narration ‘. . . Narration enables your mind to create its own pictures. It Instructive ‘. . . I believe that fairy tales help him to realize who he is and
is more creative to use your imagination and through what he is capable of . . .’
improvisation promotes mental development . . .’ ‘. . . She seems to realize that even in fairy tales, heroes must
‘. . . My son loves it. He is actively participating in the plot of fight to get what they want . . .’
the story . . .’ ‘. . . While narrating, I always incorporate ideas worthy of
‘. . . I personally prefer narration. It is amazing to use your emulation . . .’
own skills to create a story . . . This makes the whole Relaxing ‘. . . Each night she lies in her bed, cuddling her favourite toy
process more personal . . .’ and listens to the stories of fairies, until she falls asleep . . .’
‘. . . We believe that narration is more amusing, both for us ‘. . . There is no better way to put her back to sleep after a
and our daughter . . .’ nightmare . . .’
‘. . . Definitely narration. You can improvise and create a story Exemplary ‘. . . When it’s impossible to persuade him do something, my
wherever and whenever you want . . .’ friend Peter Pan can always do that . . .’
‘. . . It costs nothing . . .’ ‘. . . When we tell them that there is no fairy tale for tonight,
Reading ‘Reading of course. It is the only way to cultivate a passion they always understand that they have done something
for words and teach your child to love books . . .’ bad . . .’
‘. . . Maria is thrilled to see all this colourful pictures. It is the ‘. . . If you are naughty the big bad wolf is going to eat
best way to draw her attention . . .’ you . . .’
‘. . . It is actually bizarre, but although our son does not read, ‘. . . Within fairy tales she finds a moral corrective to everyday
he seems to expect what is going to happen. Reading life. You see, all these stories represent a world in which
helps him follow the plot . . .’ the good is consistently rewarded and bad is consistently
‘. . . It is easier for me. I can read but I can not be Hans punished . . .’
Christian Andersen . . .’
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Child: care, health and development, 38, 2, 266–272
270 P. Tsitsani et al.
over other famous stories. Almost half of participants recog- eration of children is accustomed to multimedia-rich environ-
nized that they usually choose the stories their children listen to; ments. The advancing technology affected literature and with the
this fact was clearly depicted in the words of one mother who rise of the cinema, the fairy tale film became one of the most
quoted ‘. . . I know what is the best for my child . . .’ . Almost all popular cultural commodities worldwide (Zipes 1997). Nowa-
children ask for fairy tales on a daily basis, while half of them days, children are continually exposed to stories through reading,
prefer to hear the same story repeated several times. All partici- but fairy tale films seem to take precedence over literature,
pants acknowledged the fact that their children are amused and especially through television (Zipes 1997).
positively affected by fairy tales. The basic way for children to Concerning narration and reading, the majority of inter-
share their enthusiasm for fairy tales is to speak about their viewees considered them equally important, although most of
beloved characters and narrate parts of their favourite story parents preferred reading. The richness of the language and the
while they are engaged in other activities (90%). Following sto- enthusiasm of the reader are of great importance, while the
rytelling with devotion, participating actively and correcting method of storytelling does not affect any of these factors (High
mistakes of parents while reading their favourite fairy tales, are et al. 2000). Parents are now ‘grown-ups’, and through storytell-
frequently mentioned patterns used by children in order to ing, they rediscover hidden aspects and qualities of themselves.
express excitement. Concerning the villains of fairy tales, most Fairy tales hold the key to their forgotten world of truth and
of children do not seem afraid of them but are instead satisfied innocence: ‘I want to be what I used to be, when I was like
or relieved when they are punished; nevertheless, 30.4% of you . . . Most of all, I want to relearn how to laugh . . .’ (Once
parents stated that their children show sympathy for the even- upon a time, a poem by Gabriel Okara).
tual fate of wicked characters. Finally, 15.2% of parents moti- In relation to the purpose of storytelling, most parents put
vated by concern for their children claimed that the cruel emphasis on the use of stories as instructive tools. This is in
punishment of evil characters created feelings of fear to their agreement with the notion that the main purpose of the tale
children. No differences were observed concerning children’s from the beginning was to instruct, as fairy tales were intended
choices or preferences in any question, in relation to gender. to provide models of behaviour and implicit rules of pedagogi-
zation for the rearing of children (Zipes 1988). Concerning their
exemplary role, it is widely accepted that when a story includes
Discussion
a character that readers can relate to or admire, then the
This study offers a qualitative account of current trends regard- message communicated from the writer and the parent can be
ing fairy tales and highlights their great significance in chil- easily understood by the child (Fosson & Husband 1984).
dren’s life. Although few scientists argue whether traditional Finally, fairy tales are known for their ‘bedtime manner’ for
fairy tales still have any value or interest for modern children, centuries, and it is not surprising that many parents use them in
most researchers acknowledge that storytelling provides not order to relax and help their children deal with separation
only entertainment, but also a creative way to help children anxiety, which is at its peak before sleep (Lubetsky 1989).
form a clear picture of themselves in order to be able to under- Our results demonstrate that children prefer classic fairy tales
stand others and develop meaningful relationships with them over modern ones. Little Red Riding Hood was the favourite
(Noctor 2006). fairy tale in this study, although this particular story was dem-
The findings from this study support a dual notion: (i) that onstrated to appeal to school-aged children in previous studies
fairy tales are of great importance in a child’s life and (ii) that (Lubetsky 1989). In addition, a rather unexpected result of this
most parents wholeheartedly share this perception. This is clearly research was that no differences were found concerning the
depicted by the fact that the majority of parents read fairy tales to preferences of children in relation to gender, something that
their children at least once a week, while an important per cent of probably reflects a new trend, which is also obvious in modern
25% chooses to narrate stories on a daily basis. Regarding story- children’s literature. Modern stories do not use as much stereo-
telling, parents, although separated daily from their children for typed presentations as classic fairy tales do (Turkel 2002).
several hours, still play the central role, while grandparents seem Despite the fact that fairy tales have the purpose of giving life
to be less involved in the process. Grandmothers have tradition- to a child’s point of view, parents seem to impose their prefer-
ally been the main storytellers, a fact that was often captured in ences in relation to the choice of the theme. Storytelling is an
the illustrations of fairy tale books (Macnab & Langlois 2006). experience to be shared between parents and children; never-
Despite the reluctance of some parents, almost 40% of them theless, children should always play the leading role in choosing
seem to use audio-visual material, mostly because today’s gen- a story, as well as in determining the conditions under which
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Child: care, health and development, 38, 2, 266–272
Fairy tales: a timeless value 271
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Child: care, health and development, 38, 2, 266–272
272 P. Tsitsani et al.
Konz, M. (2006) Using fairy tales and narrative strategies with the Orbach, L., Vinkler, E. & Har-Even, D. (1993) The emotional impact
help of a sandpit with children suffering from conduct disorders. of frightening stories on children. Journal of Child Psychology and
Bulletin de la Société des sciences médicales du Grand-Duché de Psychiatry, and Allied Disciplines, 34, 379–389.
Luxembourg, 2, 281–295. Pope, C. & Mays, N. (2006) Qualitative Research in Health Care, 3rd
Krietemeyer, B. C. & Heiney, S. P. (1992) Storytelling as a therapeutic edn. Blackwell Publishing, Oxford, UK.
technique in a group for school-aged oncology patients. Children’s Pope, C., Ziebland, S. & Mays, N. (2000) Qualitative research in
Health Care, 21, 14–20. health care: analysing qualitative data. British Medical Journal, 320,
Lubetsky, M. J. (1989) The magic of fairy tales: psychodynamic and 114–116.
developmental perspectives. Child Psychiatry and Human Rustin, M. E. & Rustin, M. J. (2003) Where is home? An essay on
Development, 19, 245–255. Phillip Pullman’s Northern Lights (Volume 1 of His Dark
Macnab, A. J. & Langlois, S. (2006) Illustration of genetic syndromes Materials). Journal of Child Psychotherapy, 29, 93–105.
in the nursery. American Journal of Medical Genetics. Part A, 140, Stevens-Guille, M. E. & Boersma, F. J. (1992) Fairy tales as a trance
180–183. experience: possible therapeutic uses. American Journal of Clinical
Mazzeschi, C., Lis, A., Calvo, V., Vallone, V. & Superchi, E. (2001) Hypnosis, 34, 245–254.
Duss Fairy Tales: some data from a new evaluation form. Trousdale, A. (1989) Who’s afraid of the big, bad wolf? Children’s
Perceptual and Motor Skills, 93, 806–812. Literature in Education, 20, 69–79.
Megas, G. A. (1994) Ellhnik Paramqia [Greek Fairy Tales]. A′, Turkel, A. R. (2002) From victim to heroine: children’s stories
Bibliopwleon thς «Estaς» I.D. Kollrou & Siaς A.E, Aqna revisited. The Journal of the American Academy of Psychoanalysis,
[Bookstore ‘Estia’. I. D. Collaros and Company, Athens, Greece] 30, 71–81.
(Book in Greek). Zipes, J. D. (1988) Fairy Tales and the Art of Subversion: The Classical
Nicolopoulou, A. (2008) The elementary forms of narrative coherence Genre for Children and the Process of Civilization, 1st edn. Methuen,
in young children’s storytelling. Narrative Inquiry, 18, 300–325. New York, NY, USA.
Noctor, C. (2006) Putting Harry Potter on the couch. Clinical Child Zipes, J. D. (1997) Happily Ever After: Fairy Tales, Children, and the
Psychology and Psychiatry, 11, 579–589. Culture Industry, 1st edn. Routledge, New York, NY, USA.
© 2011 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Child: care, health and development, 38, 2, 266–272