Enabling EV Charging in Condominiums
Enabling EV Charging in Condominiums
Enabling EV Charging in Condominiums
Charging in Condominiums
© 1986 Panda symbol WWF-World Wide Fund For Nature (also known as World Wildlife Fund).
® “WWF” is a WWF Registered Trademark.
Contents
Introduction ............................................ 4
APPENDIX 1 – Condominium
Act, 1998: Changes to Common
Elements and Assets: S97 & S98 ...... 17
Sources .................................................... 23
Introduction
1
Electric Vehicle Market Forecasts,
Navigant Reseach 2013
Condominiums in Ontario
For the majority of condominium residents, The Ontario Condominium Act, 1998 is currently
there are a number of legal and logistical under review by the Ministry of Consumer
hurdles that may hinder them from installing a Services and new legislation is expected soon.
charging station, and ultimately prevent them The Canadian Condominium Institute–Toronto,
from buying an EV or moving into the building. Plug’n Drive, World Wildlife Fund Canada and
While some newer buildings are being designed Zizzo Allan Professional Corporation have been
to support increased EV adoption with extra working to ensure that changes are made to the
electrical capacity being built into parking lot legislation that make it easier for condominium
infrastructure, the barriers to EV charging in owners and condominium corporations to
older buildings, and for many of the 1.6 million install EV charging infrastructure. Until these
Canadians residing in condominiums, need to changes are made, condominium corporations
be addressed. and condominium owners will need to navigate
existing barriers to EV charging on their own, a
This guide is a tool to help enable EV charging challenge this guide is meant to address.
in condominiums and has been developed with
the existing legal and development framework This document was made possible with the support
in Ontario, Canada in mind. However, the of the Automotive Recyclers of Canada. Previous
research and consultation was supported by the
information is applicable to other jurisdictions Ontario Ministry of Transportation
across North America as well.
Page | 5
1.0 Electric Vehicles
J-1772
Above: Battery Electric Vehicle (BEV) Above: Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicle (PHEV)
BEVs are 100% electric and powered entirely by a PHEVs are powered by an electric motor and
lithium-ion battery pack which is charged from the battery pack which, once depleted, switches to an
electrical grid. internal combustion engine and/or generator.
• BEVs use no gasoline and produce no tailpipe • PHEVs use both electricity and gasoline
emissions • Smaller battery packs result in reduced electric
• Range varies from 100km to 500km range but overall range is higher
depending on the make, model, weather, • Higher cost to drive and higher emissions than
driving habits, etc. a BEV due to gas use.
Models Available in Canada (July 2014) Models Available in Canada (July 2014)
- BMW i3 - Cadillac ELR
- Chevy Spark EV - Chevy VOLT
- Ford Focus EV - Ford C-Max Energi
- Mitsubishi i-MiEV - Ford Fusion Energi
- Nissan LEAF - Porsche Panamera S E-Hybrid
- smart fortwo ED - Toyota Prius Plug-In Hybrid
- Tesla Model S Page | 6
7
1.2. Electric Vehicle Charging Stations
Charging stations are available in different voltage and amperage combinations, allowing flexibility for drivers
to select a charger to match the specifications of their car. In general, there are two varieties of station that
would be considered in a condominium, both of which use the J-1772 standard nozzle. The Tesla Model S uses
a proprietary charging system but an adapter is available to allow for use with the standard J-1772 unit.
Level 1 (110/120V, 12-15 amp): Each EV has a have numerous varieties to fit the needs of specific
portable charger (cordset) that comes with the car. vehicles. A Level 2 charging station operating at
These cordsets plug into a standard three-prong 30 amps would be sufficient to meet the charging
household outlet and can be ideal for PHEVs which needs of all EVs today, though some configurations
have smaller battery packs, but is not ideal for BEV of the Tesla Model S can draw up to 100 amps
owners who may require more electricity. continuously. Typically, Level 2 stations are installed
by a certified electrical contractor, though they also
Level 2 (208/240V, 16-100 amp): Charge times are have the option of being plugged into a ‘stove plug’
minimized for both BEV and PHEV owners when (NEMA 6-50).
charging at this configuration and manufacturers
Portable / ~$500 -
Level one AC 120 15-20 1.4 – 1.9 5-60 Hours
Hardwire $1,200
Stove Plug ~$700 -
Level two AC 240 20-100 3.8 – 19.2 2-8 Hours
/ Hardwire $6,000
* Electrical code requires that EV charging stations be limited to 80% of their maximum load.
**Actual charge time depends on the vehicle model and the onboard ‘charger’ which charges the battery pack,
see car specifications in APPENDIX 2 – Electric Vehicle Charging Efficiency.
1.3. Installation Tips
Page | 8
2.0 Condominiums
Legal Considerations
In Ontario, The Condominium Act, 1998 is the main piece of legislation that governs condominiums and the
actions of a condominium’s Board of Directors. The Act is currently under review by the Ministry of Consumer
Services and new legislation and new implementation regulations are expected soon. While the review is in
progress, solutions must be found that fit under the current legislative framework. Some of the key sections of
the Act are Sections 97 & 98 which have been included as APPENDIX 1. The Act is available in its entirety at:
www.e-laws.gov.on.ca
Section 97: Changes Made by Corporation Section 98: Changes Made by Owners
The Board of a condominium corporation may Condominium Board approval is required for
make changes to the common elements, the any proposal by a condominium for an addition,
assets of the corporation or a change in service alternation or improvement to the common
that the corporation provides to the owners if the elements (either exclusive or non-exclusive use)
procedures in Section 97 are followed. Section 97 under Section 98 of the act. This will apply to
outlines how the Board may get approval and when owners who would like to pay all costs associated
owner notification and an owner approval vote are with installing a charger, as well as for Boards who
required. are interested in installing the infrastructure as an
amenity. To address this challenge, individuals and
It is possible that modifications to the common condominium corporations will need to recruit
elements may be required in order to install the support from other owners, clarify cost and
necessary electrical wiring for an EV charging payments, and likely involve a lawyer.
station. If the proposed modifications are sufficiently
expensive to the condo corporation, or if the Board Section 98 is triggered where owners wish to
chooses to treat the installation as “substantial” make changes to the corporation’s common
(as defined by the Act) and puts the issue to the elements. Owners must satisfy the following three
owners for their approval, a positive vote of 66 per preconditions:
cent of the unit owners will be required.
1. The Board must approve the proposed addition, into an alteration agreement under Section 98 to
alteration or improvement; the extent that the modification requires alteration
2. The owner and the corporation must enter into to the surrounding common elements.
an alteration agreement that sets out who pays
for the cost of the proposed addition, alteration Some jurisdictions, including California and
or improvement and who is responsible Colorado, have taken steps to introduce new
for maintaining, repairing and insuring any regulations making it easier to install charging
improvement; and stations in condominiums. WWF-Canada and CCI-
3. Notice must be given to the owners if the Toronto have worked together to recommend
change requires owner approval under Section similar changes to Ontario’s Condominium Act 1998,
97 had the change been proposed by the which would minimize some of these challenges.
condominium corporation. However, this notice
is not required if the change relates to an 2.1 Architecture & Design
exclusive use common element or if the Board
is satisfied that the change does not (a) have The design of the building and its parking
an adverse effect on units, (b) will not cost the infrastructure are primary considerations when
corporation and (c) does not detract from the installating a charging station. While a resident in
appearance of the building. a townhome may have access to a private garage
and have easy access to electrical capacity, there
The Section 98 alteration agreement does not take are many residents who live in buildings with
effect until the above-listed conditions are met and underground parking that are not well served
the agreement is registered against the title to the with electricity. In some cases, installation requires
owner’s unit. Once this agreement is effective, it is drilling through concrete to run conduit, trenching
binding on the unit and all subsequent purchasers. of landscaping or asphalt, as well as other aesthetic
changes.
In cases where the parking spaces are legal units
and not common elements, owners wishing to
install electrical wiring or EV charging stations in
their parking unit would likely be required to enter
Page | 10
2.2 Parking Configurations 2.3 Electrical Service
Flowing from building design, the parking layout and The electrical requirements of a charging station are
style of operation will affect how charging stations primarily dependent on the vehicle being charged
may be provided to residents. It is important to as it is the car’s internal controller that regulates
understand the legal status of the parking spaces the flow of electricity, not the station itself. The
which may impact decisions for the Board when charging station is somewhat poorly named and is
considering the merits of making charging stations actually more of a sophisticated extension cord that
a common element. can communicate with the vehicle to ensure that
the car’s on-board charger is safely activated.
2.2.1. Assigned Parking
In buildings where common element parking The amount of electricity that a vehicle will draw
spaces are assigned to residents for exclusive use, is dependent on the vehicle technology and the
EV drivers may prefer to install their own personal owner’s driving habits. Generally speaking, it may
charging station in order to have constant and require 4,000 kWh in a BEV and 3,000 kWh in a
reliable access (as opposed to relying on a shared, PHEV to travel 20,000km. At any given time, an EV
common use station). When installation is not can accept anywhere from 2 – 20 kW of electricity
feasible at the assigned common element space, during its charging session.
it may be possible for residents to swap spaces,
allowing the EV driver to use a spot with easier See APPENDIX 2 – Electric Vehicle Charging
access to electrical supply. Efficiency for a breakdown of currently available
vehicles and charging specifications.
2.2.2. Deeded Parking
2.3.1. Building Electrical Capacity
Where parking spots are owned by the resident and
assigned by deed, swapping with other residents A building’s ability to support charging stations
may be more challenging since changes may require depends on the original design of its electrical
a legal transfer of property. The condominium’s system as well as its remaining capacity to accept
declaration may restrict which parking units are additional loads. If capacity is available, the
assigned to which residential units. Also, the installation may be as simple as having an electrical
valuation of some parking locations may differ contractor install a second electrical panel from
based on personal convenience and preference, the main service which can be reserved for future
requiring negotiations amongst residents. installations.
Page | 12
3.0 Installation,
Operating and
Maintenance Costs
There are many installation solutions that can be deployed in any given building and with each solution comes
different configurations. To find the ideal charging solution for the given site and its charging needs, consider
the following options:
Estimated Materials
# of Units Cost per Unit Total Cost
Page | 14
15
4.0 Benefits of Charging
Stations in your Building
buildings of any size and multi-family residences
4.1 Tenant Retention / Attraction over four stories are eligible under the New
Construction (NC) Sustainable Sites Credit #4.3
The EV buying demographic is a growing segment
“Alternative Transportation, Low-Emitting and Fuel
who are passionate about their cars and their
Efficient Vehicles”. For existing buildings seeking
choice in property will inevitably come down to
LEED accreditation under the Existing Buildings
where they can charge their car(s). Newer buildings
(EB) program, there are between 3-15 LEED points
have started to prepare for the requirements of EV
under Sustainable Sites Credit #4.0 “Alternative
charging in their designs and some municipalities
Commuting Transportation” for installing one or
are building them into their city planning initiatives.
more chargers.
Page | 16
APPENDIX 1
Condominium Act, 1998: Changes to Common
Elements and Assets: s97 & s98
Meeting
(5) The vote shall be taken at a meeting duly called for the purpose of subsection (4). 1998, c. 19, s. 97 (5).
Cost of changes
(7) The cost of an addition, alteration, improvement or change that the corporation makes under this section
shall form part of the common expenses. 1998, c. 19, s. 97 (7).
Page | 18
(c) subject to subsection (2), the requirements of section 97 have been met in cases where that section would
apply if the proposed addition, alteration or improvement were done by the corporation; and
(d) the corporation has included a copy of the agreement described in clause (b) in the notice that the
corporation is required to send to the owners. 1998, c. 19, s. 98 (1).
No notice or approval
(2) Clauses (1) (c) and (d) do not apply if the proposed addition, alteration or improvement relates to a part of
the common elements of which the owner has exclusive use and if the board is satisfied on the evidence that it
may require that the proposed addition, alteration or improvement,
(a) will not have an adverse effect on units owned by other owners;
(b) will not give rise to any expense to the corporation;
(c) will not detract from the appearance of buildings on the property;
(d) will not affect the structural integrity of buildings on the property according to a certificate of an engineer,
if the proposed addition, alteration or improvement involves a change to the structure of the buildings; and
(e) will not contravene the declaration or any prescribed requirements. 1998, c. 19, s. 98 (2).
Below is an updated list of the specifications for all Electric Vehicles for sale in Canada as of April 1, 2014.
EV Specifications
Nissan LEAF BEV 24 kW 3.3/6.6 kW 16.5 hrs 4/7.25 hrs 3.5/7.5 hrs
smart fortwo ED BEV 17.6 kW 3.3 kW 12 hrs 5.25 hrs 5.25 hrs
Tesla Model S BEV 60/85 kW 10/20 kW 41/59 hrs 10.5/14.75 hrs 6/4.5 hrs
Ford C-Max Energi PHEV 7.6 kW 3.3 kW 5.25 hrs 2.25 hrs 2.25 hrs
Porsche Panamera PHEV 9.4 kW 3.6 kW 6.5 hrs 2.5 hrs 2.5 hrs
S E Hybrid
Toyota Prius Plug- PHEV 7.6 kW 2 kW 5.25 hrs 3.75 hrs 3.75 hrs
in
Page | 20
I Want to Buy An Electr ic Car…
And I Live in a Condo
EV users typically charge at their residential parking spots. This can lead to challenges for
condominium dwellers because of the special procedures they and their condominium boards need
to follow to enable a charging station installation. As a result, it’s a good idea for condominium
owners to ensure they will have access to charging in their building before purchasing an EV.
This checklist is intended to help condominium dwellers consider the viability of installing EV
charging equipment prior to purchasing an EV. In almost every case, installation of charging
equipment is likely to require approval by condominium board and, in some cases, a vote of unit
owners. Many installations will also require one or more legal agreements between the
condominium owner and the corporation.
Checklist:
Determine the type of charger you hope to install
R eview the legal status of your parking spot, which will help determine the type of condominium
board approval required (owned outright, exclusive use common element, or licensed from
condominium corporation or third party)
C heck the area around your parking spot: are there any standard outlets nearby that could be
adapted for Level I charging? W ill wiring cables need to be run through common element areas?
C onsider reaching out to other condominium owners to see if they have an interest in installing
charging stations
C ontact your local electrical utility to determine if it has any resources available for installation
and to ask if there are any known restrictions in your area
C heck with your condominium board on its requirements for the installation process, which
could include asking whether it:
Has an electric vehicle charging policy or is willing to form an electric vehicle working
group for interested residents
Has any questions or concerns from a technical or aesthetic perspective
Has a list of approved electrical contractors who you can consult on a quote for a feasibility
study
page 1 of 2
Ask a certified electrical contractor for a quote that considers:
Any installation restrictions from your condominium board
C urrent building electrical capacity
C ost of any installation, wiring and concrete removal required
C ost recovery options (like installation of a sub-meter)
B ased on the quote from your contractor, discuss the type of approval that will be required from
your condominium board and/or other residents
Trouble-s hooting
If the quote is too expensive, consider:
W hether it is possible to enter into (1) an agreement to change parking spaces with
another owner or (2) an agreement with the condominium corporation to use unused space
that is easier to access for charging
C onsider seeking the assistance of a condominium lawyer who has worked on E V charging.
C C I- Toronto has an online directory of local area lawyers who specialize in condominium law
C ha rging Agreement
C ommon issues to consider in an agreement to install charging equipment can include:
C ost of installation
C ompliance with applicable building codes and the C ondominium Act, 19 98, declaration/
bylaws, as well as reasonable aesthetic and technical requirements of the condominium corpo-
ration
Use of a licensed contractor for installation
C ost and metering of electricity consumed (either sub-metered, metered by charging equipment,
or a fixed access fee)
Maintenance and repair responsibilities (as applicable within the C ondominium Act, 1998)
R emoval obligations (for instance, if there is major maintenance of parking area or sale of parking
spot)
E V charging in condos can create a bit of a conundrum – so gather your facts, and explore your
options. For more information, resources are available through P lug ’n Drive, W W F C ana da and
the C C I Toronto & Area C hapter:
• www.ccitoronto.org
• www.plugndrive.ca/condo
• www.wwf.ca
Page | 22
page 2 of 2
A collaboration between the Canadian Condominium
Institute-Toronto and Plug’n Drive with contributions made by
the World Wildlife Fund Canada
© 1986 Panda symbol WWF-World Wide Fund For Nature (also known as World Wildlife Fund).
Sources:
® “WWF” is a WWF Registered Trademark.
Brookfield Residential Services Ltd. (2013). Electric Vehicle Plug-in Electric Vehicle Charging Infrastructure Guidelines
(EV) Charging Information Package. Toronto. for Multi-unit Dwellings. Los Angeles.
Building Owners and Managers Association of BC (BOMA Peterson, D. (2011). Addressing Challenges to Electric
BC). (2013). Electric Vehicle Charging Station (EVCS) Vehicle Charging in Multifamily Residential Buildings.
Information Package. Vancouver. UCLA , Luskin School of Public Affairs, Los Angeles.
California Plug-in Electric Vehicle Collaborative. (2013). Ontario Ministry of Transportation, Sustainable
Transportation Branch, Toronto
Written by: Josh Tzventarny