Mixing Sunda Strait
Mixing Sunda Strait
Mixing Sunda Strait
Adi Purwandana
Research Center for Oceanography - National Research and Innovation Agency (RCO-BRIN),
(RCO
Jakarta, Indonesia
Jl. Pasir Putih I Ancol Timur, Jakarta 14430
*e-mail: [email protected]
Abstract
The characteristics of mixing properties in the Sunda Strait waters were revealed using indirect
method, employing the archived CTD datasets of the RCO RCO-BRIN. The mixing properties represented by
turbulent kinetic energy dissipation (TKE) rate and vertical eddy diffusivity were inferred using an improved
Thorpe Method from gravitationally unstable density profiles measured by CTD in July 2001. This study is
aimed to reveal the rate of water mass mixing quantitatively. Vertically, the region was characterized by
three distinctive regimes of TKE dissipation rate rate, i.e. 8.2×10-8 W/kg in the near-surface
surface and upper
thermocline layer, 2.6×10 W/kg in the lower thermocline layer and 9.1×10-9 W/kg in the intermediate and
-7
deep layer. The spatial variability of the dissipation rate is likely related to topography roughness pattern
where enhanced dissipation rate mainly occurred in the steep topography region. No specific regime can be
clustered from the vertical diffusivity value due to its intermittent pattern, possibly due to the impact of
topography roughness and stratification variability in space and time. The maximum enhanced values
reached 3×10-4 m2/s. It was suggested that that strong shear due to interaction between sharp changing
topography, the strait throughflow and tidal currents controls the mixing rate in this region. This indirect
estimates need to be validated against microstructure measurements via a continuously pro profiling which
covers at least one tidal cycle to investigate possible temporal variability.
Keywords: vertical mixing, Thorpe Method, dissipation rate, vertical diffusivity.
diffusivity
Abstrak
Percampuran vertikal di bagian perairan dalam Selat Sunda, Indonesia. Karakteristik propert properti
pencampuran massa air di wilayah perairan dalam Selat Sunda diungkap dengan metode tak langsung dari
arsip data CTD Pusat Riset Oseanografi BRIN. Properti percampuran yang direpresentasikan oleh laju
disipasi energi kinetik turbulen dan difusivitas eddy vertikal dihitung menggunakan Metode Thorpe yang
telah diperbarui, diidentifikasi dari ketidakstabilan profil densitas secara gravitasi dari data CTD bulan Juli
2001. Studi ini bertujuan mengungkap laju percampuran massa air secara kkuantitatif
uantitatif di wilayah perairan
dalam Selat Sunda. Secara vertikal, wilayah perairan ini dicirikan oleh tiga rezim lapisan laju disipasi yang
berbeda, yakni 8,2×10-8 W/kg pada lapisan dekat permukaan dan lapisan termoklin atas, 2,6×10-7 W/kg pada
lapisan termoklin bawah dan 9,1×10-9 W/kg pada lapisan menengah dan dalam. Variabilitas spasial disipasi
tampak mengikuti pola kekasaran topografi, nilai yang tinggi umumnya terjadi pada topografi yang curam.
Tidak ada rezim difusivitas secara spesifik yang dapat ddikelompokkan
ikelompokkan karena peningkatan nilai yang tidak
beraturan, yang dapat diakibatkan oleh pengaruh kekasaran topografi dan variabilitas stratifikasi secara
spasial dan temporal. Ditemukan nilai maksimum difusivitas hingga 3×10-4 m2/s. Diduga, sesar arus yang
Purwandana
kuat akibat interaksi antara topografi yang berubah drastis, aliran selat dan arus pasang surut mengendalikan
laju pencampuran di wilayah ini. Estimasi tidak langsung ini perlu divalidasi dengan pengukuran
mikrostruktur dengan metode profil secara kontinyu yang mencakup setidaknya satu siklus pasang surut
untuk menyelidiki kemungkinan variabilitas temporalnya.
Keywords: percampuran vertikal, Metode Thorpe, laju disipasi, difusivitas vertikal.
N is the buoyancy frequency, 1×10-10 W/kg is the 3 cph are the canonical Garret and Munk
lowest resolved dissipation rate in the Indonesian dissipation rate and buoyancy frequency
seas (Bouruet-Aubertot et al., 2018; Koch- reference, respectively. Then, the vertical
Larrouy et al., 2015); ɛ0 = 7×10-10 W/kg and N0 = diffusivity is calculated as:
𝜀 (2)
𝐾 =𝛤
𝑁
Г = 0.2 is the mixing efficiency (Osborn, 1980). The CTD stations were irregularly in
The ε and Kρ from all stations are presented in space, where there were two stations located at a
Figure 1e and Figure 1f, respectively. relatively close distance, separated by less than
45
Purwandana
o
0.05 (Figure 1a). Therefore, the spatial pattern of m (thermocline layer), 300-500
500 m (intermediate
the mixing properties are inspected in a gridded layer), and 500-1000
1000 m (deep layer), and are
horizontally maps over 0.05°. This setting averaged by the density ranges to assess their
produces
ces 11 gridded stations as shown in Figure values related to the water mass characteristics,
2a.
a. Hereinafter, the station mentioned in the text and are presented
sented in the temperature
temperature-salinity (T-S)
refers to this gridded station. Vertically, the values diagram.
are also averaged with depth intervals of 50 50-300
Figure 1 (a) Map of Sunda Strait waters with topography inferred from ETOPO. The CTD casts sampled in
July 2001 are presented in red plus signs. The measurements were conducted using the CTD SBE
911 on board of RV Baruna Jaya VIII; (b) density profiles inferred from salinity and temperature
measurements, (c) stratification represented by buoyancy frequency profiles from all CTD cast casts,
(d) Thorpe length identified from instabilities in the density profiles, (e) turbulent kinetic energy
dissipation rate (mean-bold
bold line, minima and maxima-thick
maxima thick lines), (f) vertical diffusivity (mean-
(mean
bold line, minima and maxima
maxima-thin lines).
Gambar 1 (a) Peta perairan Selat Sunda dengan topografi dari ETOPO. Penurunan CTD dilakukan pada
bulan Juli 2001, disajikan dengan tanda plus merah. Pengukuran dilakukan dengan menggunakan
CTD SBE 911 Kapal Riset Baruna Jaya VIII; (b) profil densitas yang diturunkan dari d data salinitas
46
Oseanologi dan Limnologi di Indonesia 2022 7(1): 43-51
dan suhu, (c) stratifikasi yang direpresentasikan dengan nilai frekuensi apung, (d) skala panjang
Thorpe yang diidentifikasi dari ketidakstabilan pada profil desnitas, (e) disipasi energi kinetik
turbulen (rerata-plot
plot tebal, minimal dan maksimal-plot
plot tipis), (f) difusivitas vertikal (rerata
(rerata-plot
tebal, minimal dan maksimal
maksimal-plot tipis).
Table 1 Mean and standard deviation of the dissipation rate (ɛ, ( ρ, m2/s)
( , W/kg) and vertical eddy diffusivity (K
3
for specified density anomaly range (σθ, kg/m ).
Tabel 1 Rata-rata
rata dan simpangan baku disipasi energi kinetik turbulen (ɛ, ( , W/kg) dan difusivitas eddy
vertikal (Kρ, m2/s) pada berbagai rentang anomali densitas (σ
( θ, kg/m3).
Figure 3 Grid averaged T-S S diagram in 0.5 oC × 0.1 psu space involving all CTD stations with overlaid
colors: (a) turbulent kinetic energy dissipation rate (in log10 scale, W/kg),, (b) vertical eddy diffusivity (in
log10 scale, m2/s).. The JSW, NISW, NIIW and NIDW denote the Java Sea Water, North Indian Subtropical
Water, North Indian Intermediate Water and North Indian Deep Water, respectively.
Gambar 3 Grid rata-rata 0,5 oC × 0,1 psu diagram suhu-salinitas (T-S) S) dari semua stasiun CTD dengan
tumpang susun warna: (a) disipasi energi kinetik turbulen (dalam skala log10, W/kg) dan (b) difusivitas
vertikal (dalam skala log10, m2/s). JSW, NISW, NIIW dan NIDW berturut-turut
berturut adalah adalah
dalah massa air Laut
Jawa, massa air Samudera Hindia lapisan pertengahan dan massa air Samudera Hindia lapisan dalam.
48
Oseanologi dan Limnologi di Indonesia 2022 7(1): 43-51
Discussion relationship hence the deeper layer is potential to
have elevated diffusivity even with a small
The water masses in the Sunda Strait have amount of TKE dissipation rate, as long as the
a typical Indian Ocean characteristics in the stratification is low. Therefore, it is common that
thermocline and deeper layer, with less influence enhancement of the diffusivity value will increase
of fresh water masses in the mixed layer from the in the elevated dissipation rate area such as above
Java Sea throughflow. Although featured by less the steep topography, as can be confirmed in
influence of Java Sea water in the mixed layer yet Figure 2d-f. Intermittency pattern showed in the
a relatively high dissipation rate and high vertical vertical diffusivity also suggests the importance of
diffusvity in this layer (σθ < 22 kg/m3) are continue measurements which covers at least one
potential to freshen the upper layer. In general, tidal cycle to look over the temporal variability of
high dissipation rates in the order of 10-8 to 10-7 stratification as well as current shear.
W/kg observed in the waters are not surprising A low salinity in the upper layer of σθ <
since the stations are located in the narrow 21 kg/m3 in the southern Sunda Strait as shown in
passage/strait. Another possible mechanism the T-S diagram in Figure 3 indicated the
occurred is the hydrolic jump that is often existence of shallow water throughflow from the
occurred down stream in the narrow passages, the Java Sea. This low salinity contributes to the
same mechanism as working in the Lifamatola ‘pseudo’ pycnocline layer formation in the upper
Passage (Tan et al., 2020). However, the values 50 m depth hence producing highly stratified
are lower compared to the maximum values layer. Three different regimes of TKE dissipation
observed in other straits, i.e. Ø [10-7 - 10-6] W/kg rate clustered in the T-S diagram as shown in
in the Halmahera Straits and Ombai Strait Figure 3a indicate the most dissipative layer is in
(Bouruet-Aubertot et al., 2018; Nagai et al., the lower thermocline layer (σθ = 23-26 kg/m3),
2021), the Lombok Strait (Purwandana et al., followed by the upper thermocline layer (σθ < 23
2021a) and Maluku-Talaud waters (Purwandana kg/m3), and the lowest dissipation rate occurred in
et al., 2021b). the intermediate and deep layer (σθ > 26 kg/m3).
As can be indicated from vertical profiles This trend, i.e. dissipative in the thermocline layer
shown in Figure 1e, an enhanced dissipation rates and near surface layer is related to high shear
occurred in the upper layer, which is likely related instability formed due to stronger current
to the active circulations, as has been suggested structures there. Less dissipative in the deeper
from observation and modeling of surface layer is occurred due to less strong current shear
currents study by Mujiasih et al. (2021) which and less stratified water column, a typical
indicated strong mainstream currents of ~0.7 m/s condition in the deep layer.
in the observation area. Spatially, a closer look to
each station as shown in Figure 2a-c, indicated Conclusions
that there is a spatial trend horizontally of the
enhanced dissipation rate in the steep topography The typical values of dissipation rate
stations (~high bottom roughness, i.e. the standard observed in this study is 1-2 order higher than the
deviation of the bathymetry over a specified cell typical deep sea dissipation rate such as in the
size); and also vertically, decreasing trend towards Banda Sea yet compared to other narrow
depth. Enhanced dissipation values were also passages, such as to those in the Halmahera Straits
observed in the intermediate layer at Station 2, and Ombai Strait, the dissipation rate in the deep
and in the deep layer at Station 4 and 6, where region of the Sunda Strait is one order lower. The
located in the non steep topography (~low bottom CTD stations involved in this study are located in
roughness). Basically, the pattern of dissipation the narrow passage/strait, the place where
rate can be variably not only in space but also in barotropic tidal currents will be converted into
time (Purwandana et al., 2021a; Purwandana et internal tide and generate local mixing. High
al., 2020). As we do not have a daily station from dissipation rates occurred in the upper 300 m
the archived datasets to investigate the temporal layer, which is a clear evidence of enhanced
variability of the dissipation rate in this area, we values related to shear instability due to possibly
put a possibility that there can be the influence of strong currents. This study highlighted the
tidal variability. importance of comprehensive project in the future
There is an intermittent pattern of eddy which involves more parameters, such as current
diffusivity vertically as can be seen in Figure 1f, measurements and microstructure profiler and
yet still can be observed a decreasing trend also involves other aspects such as
towards depth. The vertical diffusivity is sensitive biogeochemistry hence the impact of vertical
to the stratification through inversely proportional
49
Purwandana
mixing to the oceanic productivity can be directly 10.1016/j.dsr.2015.09.007
assessed. Koch-Larrouy, A., Lengaigne, M., Terray, P.,
Madec, G., & Masson, S. (2010). Tidal
Acknowledgment mixing in the Indonesian seas and its effect
on the tropical climate system. Climate
The author thanks the Crew and Captain Dynamics, 34(6), 891–904. doi:
of the RV Baruna Jaya VIII for helping the data 10.1007/s00382-009-0642-4
acquisition during the observations, Pak Law, C. S., Abraham, E. R., Watson, A. J., &
Hadikusumah and all staffs of Laboratory of Liddicoat, M. I. (2003). Vertical eddy
Physical Oceanography for preserving the diffusion and nutrient supply to the surface
archived CTD datasets processed in this study. mixed layer of the Antarctic Circumpolar
Current. Journal of Geophysical Research,
References 108(C8, 3272), 1–14. doi:
10.1029/2002JC001604
Bouruet-Aubertot, P., Cuypers, Y., Ferron, B., Mujiasih, S., Hartanto, D., Beckers, J., & Barth,
Dausse, D., Ménage, O., Atmadipoera, A., & A. (2021). Reducing the error in estimates of
Jaya, I. (2018). Contrasted turbulence the Sunda Strait currents by blending HF
intensities in the Indonesian Throughflow: a radar currents with model results.
challenge for parameterizing energy Continental Shelf Research, 228, 104512.
dissipation rate. Ocean Dynamics, 68(7), doi: 10.1016/j.csr.2021.104512
779–800. doi: 10.1007/s10236-018-1159-3 Nagai, T., Hibiya, T., & Syamsudin, F. (2021).
Dillon, T. M. (1982). Vertical overturns: A Direct Estimates of Turbulent Mixing in the
comparison of Thorpe and Ozmidov length Indonesian Archipelago and Its Role in the
scales. Journal of Geophysical Research, Transformation of the Indonesian
87(C12), 9601. doi: Throughflow Waters. Geophysical Research
10.1029/JC087iC12p09601 Letters, 48(6), e2020GL091731. doi:
Egbert, G. D., & Erofeeva, S. Y. (2002). Efficient https://doi.org/10.1029/2020GL091731
Inverse Modeling of Barotropic Ocean Osborn, T. R. (1980). Estimates of the Local Rate
Tides. Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic of Vertical Diffusion from Dissipation
Technology, 19(February), 183–204. doi: Measurements. In Journal of Physical
https://doi.org/10.1175/1520- Oceanography (Vol. 10, Issue 1, pp. 83–89).
0426(2002)019<0183:EIMOBO>2.0.CO;2 doi: 10.1175/1520-
Frants, M., Damerell, G. M., Gille, S. T., 0485(1980)010<0083:EOTLRO>2.0.CO;2
Heywood, K. J., MacKinnon, J., & Sprintall, Park, Y. H., Lee, J. H., Durand, I., & Hong, C. S.
J. (2013). An assessment of density-based (2014). Validation of Thorpe-scale-derived
finescale methods for estimating diapycnal vertical diffusivities against microstructure
diffusivity in the southern Ocean. Journal of measurements in the Kerguelen region.
Atmospheric and Oceanic Technology, Biogeosciences, 11(23), 6927–6937. doi:
30(11), 2647–2661. doi: 10.1175/JTECH-D- 10.5194/bg-11-6927-2014
12-00241.1 Purwandana, A. (2019). Turbulent Mixing in the
Galbraith, P. S., & Kelley, D. E. (1996). Indonesian Seas. Sorbonne University.
Identifying Overturns in CTD Profiles. Purwandana, A., Cuypers, Y., & Bouruet-
Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic Aubertot, P. (2021a). Observation of internal
Technology, 13, 688–702. doi: tides, nonlinear internal waves and mixing in
10.1146/annurev.fluid.39.050905.110314 the Lombok Strait, Indonesia. Continental
Gargett, A., & Garner, T. (2008). Determining Shelf Research, 216. doi:
Thorpe scales from ship-lowered CTD 10.1016/j.csr.2021.104358
density profiles. Journal of Atmospheric and Purwandana, A., Cuypers, Y., Bouruet-Aubertot,
Oceanic Technology, 25(9), 1657–1670. doi: P., Nagai, T., Hibiya, T., & Atmadipoera, A.
10.1175/2008JTECHO541.1 S. (2020). Spatial structure of turbulent
Koch-Larrouy, A., Atmadipoera, A., van Beek, P., mixing inferred from historical CTD
Madec, G., Aucan, J., Lyard, F., Grelet, J., & datasets in the Indonesian seas. Progress in
Souhaut, M. (2015). Estimates of tidal Oceanography, 184(March), 102312. doi:
mixing in the Indonesian archipelago from https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pocean.2020.10231
multidisciplinary INDOMIX in-situ data. 2
Deep-Sea Research Part I: Oceanographic Purwandana, A., Iskandar, M. R., Edikusmanto,
Research Papers, 106, 136–153. doi: Zheng, W., Fadli, M., Dwi Santoso, P.,
50
Oseanologi dan Limnologi di Indonesia 2022 7(1): 43-51
Corvianawatie, C., Muhadjirin, & 52. doi: 10.1175/JPO-D-19-0326.1
Wattimena, M. C. (2021b). Percampuran Thorpe, S. A. (1977). Turbulence and Mixing in a
vertikal di Perairan Laut Maluku dan Talaud Scottish Loch. Philosophical Transactions
pada bulan Februari 2021. Oseanologi Dan of the Royal Society A: Mathematical,
Limnologi Di Indonesia, 6(2), 97–106. doi: Physical and Engineering Sciences,
10.14203/oldi.2021.v6i2.363 286(1334), 125–181. doi:
Silubun, D. T., Gaol, J. L., & Naulita, Y. (2015). 10.1098/rsta.1977.0112
Estimasi intensitas upwelling pantai dari Voris, H. K. (2000). Maps of Pleistocene sea
satelit Aquamodis di perairan Selatan Jawa levels in SoutheastAsia : shorelines, river
dan Barat Sumatera. Jurnal Teknologi systems and time durations. Journal of
Perikanan Dan Kelautan, 6(1), 21–29. Biogeography, 27(5), 1153–1167.
Stansfield, K., Garrett, C., & Dewey, R. (2001). Wyrtki, K. (1961). Physical oceanography of the
The probability distribution of the Thorpe Southeast Asian waters. Scietific Resultas of
displacement within overturns in Juan de Marine Investigations of the South China
Fuca Strait. Journal of Physical Sea and the Gulf of Thailand, 2, 195. doi:
Oceanography, 31(12), 3421–3434. doi: 10.1017/S0025315400054370
10.1175/1520- Xu, T., Li, S., Hamzah, F., Setiawan, A., Susanto,
0485(2001)031<3421:TPDOTT>2.0.CO;2 R. D., Cao, G., & Wei, Z. (2018).
Susanto, R. D., Gordon, L., & Zheng, Q. (2001). Intraseasonal flow and its impact on the
Upwelling along the coasts of Java and chlorophyll-a concentration in the Sunda
Sumatra and its relation to ENSO. Strait and its vicinity. Deep-Sea Research
Geophysical Research Letters, 28(8), 1599– Part I, 136, 84–90. doi:
1602. 10.1016/j.dsr.2018.04.003
Tan, S., Pratt, L. J., Yuan, D., Li, X., Wang, Z., Yang, Q., Zhao, W., Li, M., & Tian, J. (2014).
Li, Y., Corvianawatie, C., Surinati, D., Spatial Structure of Turbulent Mixing in the
Sandra, A., & Bayhaqi, A. (2020). Northwestern Pacific Ocean. Journal of
Hydraulics and mixing of the deep overflow Physical Oceanography, 44(8), 2235–2247.
in the Lifamatola Passage of the Indonesian doi: 10.1175/JPO-D-13-0148.1
seas. Journal of Physical Oceanography, 1–
51