Theme 11
Theme 11
Theme 11
Civil Procedure
Introduction
A private-law dispute arises when one party violates the subjective right of another or
threatens to do so.
If the parties cannot solve the dispute themselves, they must make use of the
prescribed civil procedure in order to solve their dispute.
The solution will be given by the court.
Section 34 of the Constitution – Access to courts:
‘Everyone has the right to have any dispute that can be resolved by the
application of law decided in a fair public hearing before a court or, where
appropriate, another independent and impartial tribunal or forum.’
The law of civil procedure does not only assist a legal subject in the case of violation
of subjective right.
It can be used for the following purpose:
To obtain a declaratory order
To prevent damage or injury
To make damage or injury good
To claim specific performance
The rules of the law of civil procedure are found in common law, rules of practice,
legislation and in the Uniform Rules of Court laid down in terms of legislation.
The most important legislation is the Superior Courts Act 10 of 2013 (complemented
by the Uniform Rules of Court – called the High Court Rules) and the Magistrate’s
Court Act 32 of 1944 (complemented by the Magistrate’s Court Rules)
Map of civil procedure
STAGE 1
Before Litigation
STAGE 2
Litigation
STAGE 3
After Litigation
STAGE 4
Additional Procedures
General principles
Action proceedings
Fundamental differences between parties with respect to the facts of the case.
Parties are the plaintiff and the defendant.
The plaintiff initiates the case (dominus litis) and institutes action to claim
performance
Defendant is the person against whom the action is instituted and who may raise a
defence against the action
The procedure is more time-consuming and expensive than the application
procedure.
Example: Payment for damages.
Application proceedings
No Fundamental differences between parties with respect to the facts of the case.
Parties are the applicant and respondent.
Applicant is person who initiates the case and approaches the court for a particular
kind of relief.
Respondent is the person against whom the relief is sought.
Application proceedings are also used to obtain a declaratory order.
Example: X and Y are involved in a car accident. Both feel aggrieved and blame each
other for the accident.
Applications before court in form of affidavits
Ex parte application: application without notice to respondent
On-notice application: application with notice to respondent
Stages of proceedings
Pleading stage
In the hands of the parties and their legal representatives.
Pleadings are documents that parties exchange
These documents contain the facts of the case and not applicable to legal principles.
Purpose of pleadings:
To reduce dispute between the parties to a condensed and abbreviated version.
To prevent parties from surprising each other in court.
To make the judge or magistrate familiar with the case beforehand.
Trial
Pleading stage is followed by the trial.
Proceedings are accusatorial and not inquisitorial.
Accusatorial system: two parties oppose each other. The parties collectively
decide on which documents and witnesses to present to the court. The judge
acts as a referee and supervises the court.
Action proceedings: Oral evidence is presented.
Application proceedings: No oral evidence is needed.
The judge or magistrate applies the relevant legal principles to the facts and gives
judgement.