C O Agbata, Corporate Law Practice Note-1
C O Agbata, Corporate Law Practice Note-1
C O Agbata, Corporate Law Practice Note-1
com 07035406532
DISCLAIMER:
This note is a compilation by Chris Ozo Agbata on the NLS Yola Campus 2021/2022, using
NLS handbook, class slides and notes. It does not represent NLS official opinion; it is not
for sale and it is for exam preps only.
Any observations, reservations and comments should be directed to Chris Ozo Agbata
using the contact info provided at the header. This is only the first draft, so, such will be
appreciated.
1
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
TABLE OF CONTENTS
An Overview of the Legal Framework & Regulatory Bodies on Corporate Law Practice in
Nigeria............................................................................................................................................. 3
Choice of Business Organization and Formation (I) .................................................................... 19
Business Name/Partnership and Incorporated Trustee ................................................................. 41
Pre-Incorporation Matters ............................................................................................................. 70
Post-Incorporation Matters ........................................................................................................... 83
Foreign Participation in Nigerian Business Sector ..................................................................... 126
Corporate Governance (I) ........................................................................................................... 151
Corporate Governance (2): Officers Of Company- (Directors and Secretary) ........................... 175
Corporate Governance (3): (Membership, Meetings & Resolutions) ......................................... 198
Corporate Governance 4: Financial Statements, Audits and Annual Returns ............................ 218
Corporate Governance 5: Majority Rule, Minority Protection and Investigation Of Companies
..................................................................................................................................................... 228
Company Securities 1 (Shares & Debentures and Enforcement of Securities) .......................... 239
Company Securities 2: Floatation of Securities & Collective Investment Schemes .................. 255
Corporate Restructuring 1, (Internal Options) ............................................................................ 275
Corporate Restructuring 2 – (External Options) ......................................................................... 283
Company Proceedings and Investment Disputes Resolution...................................................... 302
Corporate Insolvency, Company Voluntary Arrangement, Adminisration And Receivership .. 316
Winding Up and Dissolution of Companies ............................................................................... 339
2
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
3
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Commission
22 Standard Organisation of Nigeria Standard Organisation of Nigeria
Act
23 Nigeria Deposit Insurance Nigeria Deposit Insurance Managing Director
Corporation Act Corporation
24 Stamp Duties Act
25 Land Use Act
26 Companies Income Tax
(Amendment) Act
27 Export Incentives & Miscellaneous
Provisions Act
28 Food Drugs & Other Related
Product Act
29 Nigeria Minerals Mining Act
30 Petroleum Industry Act 2021
31 Petroleum Profit Tax Act
32 Infrastructure Concession Infrastructure Concession
Regulatory Commission Act Regulatory Commission
33 Nigeria Maritime Administration & Nigeria Maritime Administration
Safety Agency Act & Safety Agency (NIMASA)
34 Nigeria Export Process in Zones Nigeria Export Processing in
Act Zones Authority (NEPZA)
35 Nigeria Export Promotion Council Nigeria Export Promotion
Act Council
36 National Automotive Council National Automotive Council
(Amendment) Act
37 Financial Reporting Council Act Financial Reporting Council
38 Mortgage Institutions Act Federal Mortgage Bank
39 Capital Gains Tax Act
40 Education Tax Act
4
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
a. administer this Act, including the registration, regulation and supervision of—
i. the formation, incorporation, management, striking off and winding up of companies,
ii. business names, management and removal of names from the register, and
iii. the formation, incorporation, management and dissolution of incorporated trustees;
b. establish and maintain a company’s registry and office in each State of the Federation
suitably and adequately equipped to perform its functions under this Act or any other law;
c. arrange or conduct an investigation into the affairs of any company, incorporated trustees
or business names where the interest of shareholders, members, partners or public so
demands;
d. ensure compliance by companies, business names and incorporated trustees with the
provisions of this Act and such other regulations as may be made by the Commission;
e. perform such other functions as may be specified in this Act or any other law; and
f. undertake such other activities as are necessary or expedient to give full effect to the
provisions of this Act.
Pre-action notice and restriction on levy of execution S17 CAMA:
A suit shall not be commenced against the Commission before the expiration of 30 days after a
written notice of intention to commence the suit is served upon the Commission by the intending
plaintiff or his agent.
(2) The notice referred to in subsection (1) shall clearly state the—
(a) cause of action;
(b) particulars of the claim;
(c) name and place of abode of the intending plaintiff; and
(d) relief sought.
Form MISC 01 Companies Regulations 2021 - Application for Accreditation of
Professional/Agent
Accreditation is required in respect of matters relating to companies (Part B CAMA). The
professionals authorised to transact business with CAC relating to Part B are:
i. Legal practitioners
ii. Chattered accountants
iii. Chattered secretaries
iv. A firm of any of the above professionals
The procedure for accreditation is as follows:
1. Fill the Application Form for Accreditation online (pre.cac.gov.ng)
2. Gather the following accompanying documents and upload;
i. Passport photograph
ii. Electronic Signature
iii. LL. B certificate
iv. National Youth Service Corps discharge certificate or exemption
5
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
6
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
7
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
FOR LP
1. CAC/LP 01 – Application to Register a Limited Partnership (LP)
2. CAC/LP/2 – Notice of Change in Principal Place of Business or Branch Address
3. CAC/LP 03 – Notice of Change in Name of Limited Partnership
4. CAC/LP 04 – Annual Return of Limited Partnership
5. CAC/LP 05 – Notice of Change/Correction in Particulars of Partner of a Limited
Partnership
6. CAC/LP 06 – Notice of Change in Objects of Limited Partnership
7. CAC/LP 07 – Notice of Cessation of Limited Partnership
FOR BN
1. CAC/BN 01 – Application to Register Business Name
2. CAC/BN 02 – Notice of Change in Principal Place of Business or Branch Address
3. CAC/BN 03 – Change of Name
4. CAC/BN 04 – Notice of Change in Objects of Business Names
5. CAC/BN 05 – Notice of Change/Correction in Particulars of Proprietor
6. CAC/BN/6 – Annual Return of Business Names
FOR IT
1. CAC/IT 01 – Incorporated Trustees Application Form
2. CAC/IT 2 – Change of Name of Incorporated Trustees
3. CAC/IT 03 – Replacement/Appointment and Change in Particulars of a Trustee
4. CAC/IT 4 – Incorporated Trustees Annual Return
5. CAC/IT 5 – Bi-Annual Statement of Affairs of Incorporated Trustees
6. CAC/IT 6 – Notice of Merger of Incorporated Trustees
7. CAC/IT 7 – Notice of Alteration of Constitution of Incorporated Trustee
8
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
jurisdictions; in furtherance of its role of protecting the integrity of the securities market
(after seeking court order to that effect)
d. Enter and seal up the premises of persons illegally carrying on capital market
operations;
e. Public companies’ securities registration
f. ICT linking facilitation of all markets in securities
g. Cross-border securities transactions authorisation and regulation
h. Nationwide system for securities trading in the Nigerian capital market establishment
facilitation, in order to protect investors and maintain fair and orderly markets;
i. Integrity protection of the securities market against all forms of abuses including insider
dealing;
j. Compensate investors (by establishing a nationwide trust scheme) whose losses are not
covered under the investor’s protection funds administered by securities exchanges and
capital trade points, as an act in the public interest having regard to the protection of
investors and the maintenance of fair and orderly markets
k. Mergers, Acquisitions, Takeovers and all forms of business combinations and affected
transactions of all companies as defined in this Act; to review, approve and regulate
them.
l. Agencies and intermediaries’ registration and regulation (e.g.: securities depository
companies, clearing and settlement companies, custodians of assets and securities, credit
rating agencies)
m. Training programmes organisation
n. Investor education
o. Capital Market Operators (corporate and individual) registration and regulation
p. Business of investments and securities in Nigeria regulation
q. Exchanges registration and regulation (e.g.: securities exchanges, capital trade points,
futures, options and derivatives exchanges, commodity exchanges and any other
recognised investment exchange
r. Guideline preparation
s. Advise the minister
t. Disqualification of unfit persons in the securities industry
u. Assistance rendering (as may be deemed necessary) to promoters and investors wishing
v. Establish securities exchanges and capital trade points;
w. Foreign Portfolio Investment register to be kept and maintained
x. Other necessary functions not inconsistent with the ISA
y. Relate effectively with domestic and foreign regulators and supervisors of other financial
institutions including entering into co-operative agreement on matters of common
interest.
z. Venture capital funds and collective investments schemes (in whatever form) registration
and regulation
aa. Information calling, inspection, inquiries and audit of securities exchanges, capital
market operators, collective investment schemes and all other regulated entities;
bb. Research into all or any aspect of the securities industry
9
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
cc. Unfair and fraudulent trade practices (relating to the securities industry) prevention
dd. Self-regulatory organisations promotion and registration (including securities exchanges,
capital trade points and capital market trade associations to which it may delegate its
powers)
REGISTRATION WITH THE SEC
A. Concept
To operate in the Nigerian capital market as a CMO/CMC, one must be registered by SEC. this
is because S38(1) of ISA provides that no person shall operate in the Nigerian capital market as
an expert or professional or in any other capacity as may be determined by SEC; or carry-on
investment and securities business unless he is registered in accordance with ISA and the rules
and regulations made thereunder.
They can register as firms or persons carrying on business in their names or as a corporate body
Rule 178 SEC Rules 2013. The professionals allowed registration are:
1. Legal Practitioners,
2. Accountants,
3. Auditors,
4. Engineers,
5. Estate Valuers,
6. Property Manager, and
7. Others as determined by SEC.
For individual Partners, they must possess 5 years post-call experience to qualify to be registered
while for sponsored individuals it is 2 years post-call that is needed r178 SEC Rules 2013.
Registration by SEC is totally different from accreditation by CAC SEC v Prof A. B. Kasunmu
SAN
B. Procedure for Corporate Bodies (S178(2) SEC Rules)
1. Send an application to SEC by filling SEC Form 3
2. Pay the application fees of:
i. Firm - N20, 000
ii. Principal Partner - N 5,000
iii. Sponsored Individual - N1, 000
3. Submit the application Form with the following documents:
a. Two sets of duly completed form SEC 2 to be filed by at least two sponsored
individuals, one of whom shall be a principal partner
b. CV of the sponsored individuals including details of activities stated in order of time
from secondary school till date
10
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
11
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
C. Revalidating Accreditation
Revalidate accreditation at SEC every 5 years S38 of the ISA, 2007; R. 178 SEC Rules 2013.
C. FEDERAL COMPETITION AND CONSUMER PROTECTION COMMISSION
Established by S3 of the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Act, 2018
Functions: S17: The Commission shall -
a. be responsible for the administration and enforcement of the provisions of this Act and
any other enactment with respect to competition and protection of consumers;
b. initiate broad based policies and review economic activities in Nigeria to identify anti-
competitive, anti-consumer protection and restrictive practices which may adversely
affect the economic interest of consumers and make rules and regulations under this Act
and any other enactment with regards to competitions and protection of consumers;
c. advise the Federal Government generally on national policies and matters pertaining to
all goods and services and on the determination of national norms and standards relating
to competition and consumer protection;
d. report annually on market practices and the implications for consumer choice and
competition in the consumer market;
e. carry out investigations or inquiries considered necessary or desirable in connection with
any matter falling within the purview of this Act;
f. advise the Federal Government on any matter relating to the operation of this Act
including making recommendations to the Federal Government for the review of policies,
legislation and subsidiary legislation as considered appropriate or as may be requested by
the Federal Government or any of its ministries, departments or agencies for the
eradication of anti-consumer protection and anti-competitive behaviour;
g. eliminate anti-competitive agreements, misleading, unfair, deceptive or unconscionable
marketing, trading and business practices;
h. resolve disputes or complaints, issue directives and apply sanctions where necessary;
i. give and receive advice from other regulatory authorities or agencies within the relevant
industry or sector on consumer protection and competition matters;
j. create public awareness · through seminars, workshops, studies and make available
information with regard to the exercise of its powers and performance of its functions to
the public;
k. authorise, with or without conditions, prohibit or approve mergers of which notice is
received;
l. protect and promote consumer interests;
m. regulate and seek ways and means of removing or eliminating from the market,
hazardous goods and services, including emission, untested, controversial, emerging or
new technologies, products or devices whatsoever, and cause offenders to replace such
goods or services with safer and more appropriate alternatives;
12
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
n. publish, from time to time, list of goods and services whose consumption and sale have
been banned, withdrawn, restricted or are not approved by the Federal Government or
foreign governments;
o. organise or undertake campaigns and other forms of activities capable of promoting
increased private and public consumer awareness;
p. encourage trade, industry and professional associations to develop and enforce in their
various fields quality standards designed to safeguard the interest of consumers;
q. cause all imported goods to be registered for traceability whenever the need arises;
r. collaborate with consumer protection groups and associations for consumer protection
purposes;
s. ensure that consumers' interests receive due consideration at appropriate fora and provide
redresses to obnoxious practices or the unscrupulous exploitation of consumers by
companies, firms, trade associations or individuals;
t. ensure the adoption of appropriate measures to guarantee that goods and services are safe
for intended or normally safe use;
u. collaborate with international organisations and agencies, firms, organisations, groups or
persons for the purposes of exchange of information to locate the source of substandard
goods;
v. undertake regular research, study and analysis of consumer product standards and
services rendered to the consumer and publish relevant observations, findings and
recommendations in journals or other forms of publications for the benefit and general
information of consumers;
w. collaborate with government agencies or professional bodies in establishing and using
laboratories, testing facilities, common procedures in ensuring or enforcing standards of
consumer goods or in assessing the quantum of loss or damage;
x. act generally to reduce the risk and injury which may occur from consumption of certain
consumer items and other services rendered to consumers which action may include
restriction or prohibition;
y. ensure that all service providers comply with local and international standards of quality
and safe service delivery; and
z. cause an offending company, firm, trade, association or individual to protect,
compensate, provide relief and safeguards to injured consumers or communities from
adverse effects of technologies that are inherently harmful, injurious, violent or highly
hazardous;
13
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
a. Co-ordinate and monitor all investment promotion activities to which this Act applies;
b. Initiate and support measures which shall enhance the investment climate in Nigeria;
c. Promote investments through effective promotional means;
d. Collect, collate, analyse and disseminate information about investment opportunities and
sources of investment capital, and advise on request, the availability, choice or suitability
of partners in joint-venture projects;
e. Register and keep records of all enterprises to which this Act applies;
f. Identify specific projects and invite interested investors for participation in those projects;
g. Initiate, organise and participate in promotional activities, such as, exhibitions,
conferences and seminars for the stimulation of investments;
h. Maintain liaison between investors and Ministries, Government departments and
agencies, institutional lenders and other authorities concerned with investments;
i. Provide and disseminate up-to-date information on incentives available to investors
j. Assist incoming and existing investors by providing support services
k. Evaluate the impact of the Commission in investments in Nigeria and make appropriate
recommendations;
l. Advise the Federal Government on policy matters designed to promote the
industrialisation of Nigeria or the general development of the economy
m. Perform such other functions as are supplementary or incidental to the attainment of the
objectives of this Act.
14
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
NB: Any remedy to the above? Within 60days from the date of the notice of refusal or
cancellation, file a notice of appeal to the Governing Council of NOTAP S9 NOTAP Act.
Effect of Non-Registration
• No repatriation of funds through the official market S7 NOTAP Act; STANBIC IBTC
v. FRCN & NOTAP
NOTABLES
• Agreement between countries is not compulsory but necessary.
• The CEO of the NOTAP is Director-General of NOTAP
15
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Features of OSIC
• The participating agencies will maintain their existing mandates and responsibilities
within the structure of OSIC
• Only statutory provisions will be administered at OSIC and not special applications
• Agencies will establish their presence at OSIC in phases
• Approval time for business entry approvals is 24 hours
• OSIC covers investments into all sectors of the economy
• It is mandatory for all foreign investors to register with OSIC to facilitate foreign direct
investment tracking/investor tracking as provided in the NIPC Act.
16
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
6. Protect, enhance, or realise the value of the eligible bank assets that the Corporation has
acquired
7. Perform such other activities and carry out such other functions which in the opinion of
the Board are necessary, incidental or conducive to the attainment of the objects of the
Corporation.
17
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
reports, legal opinion or similar instruments or processes or file any such document for
his employer. Rule 8(2) RPC.
7. A director of a registered company shall not appear as an advocate in court or judicial
tribunal for his company. Rule 8(3) RPC.
8. A lawyer must devote and dedicate to the cause of his client. Rule 14 RPC.
9. A lawyer must represent his client within the bounds of the law e.g., if his client instructs
him to incorporate a company whose objects is to manufacture arms and ammunition or
produce police uniform, it is the duty of the lawyer to advise him against embarking on
such venture. Rule 15 RPC.
18
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
(d) disqualified under sections 281 and 283 of this Act from being a director of a company.
TYPES OF COMPANIES S21
• a company limited by shares S21(1)(a)
• a company limited by guarantee S21(1)(b)
• an unlimited company S21(1)(c)
• A company of any of these types may either be a private company or a public company
S21(2)
By implication, the types of companies include:
1. Private company limited by shares (Limited, Ltd)
2. Public company limited by shares (Public Limited Company, Plc)
3. Private company limited by guarantee (Limited by Guarantee, Ltd/Gte)
4. Public company limited by guarantee (Limited by Guarantee, Ltd/Gte)
5. Private unlimited company (Unlimited, Ultd)
6. Public unlimited company (Unlimited, Ultd)
NB: the names of the companies are provided for in S29.
FACTORS THAT MAY DETERMINE THE CHOICE OF BUSINESS
ORGANIZATIONS
1. Nature of Business.
2. Available Capital
3. Number of members
4. Desired extent of liability of members
5. Commercial expediency.
6. The scope of operations.
7. Position of the Law/statutory requirements e.g., commercial banks/chambers of
commerce.
8. The cost of registration and expenses.
9. Speed of processing and completion of registration.
10. Post registration compliance issues.
11. The desire of the client himself
PRIVATE COMPANY S22
1. Private company is one which is stated in its memorandum of association to be a private
company S22(1).
A private company may;
2. S22(2) provides that a private company may restrict the transfer of its shares and also
provide that—
o shall not, without the consent of all its members, sell assets having a value of
more than 50% of the total value of the company’s assets.
20
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
o a member shall not sell that member’s shares in the company to a non-member,
without first offering those shares to existing members.
o a member, or a group of members acting together, shall not sell or agree to sell
more than 50% of the shares in the company to a person who is not then a
member, unless that non-member has offered to buy all the existing members’
interests on the same terms.
3. The total number of members shall not exceed 50, except employees presently or
formerly employed by the co who are not included in the count S22(3).
4. Where two or more persons hold one or more shares in a company jointly, they shall, for
the purpose of subsection (3), be treated as a single member S22(4).
S22(5), A private company shall not, unless authorised by law, invite the public to—
(a) subscribe for any share or debenture of the company; or
(b) deposit money for fixed periods or payable at call, whether or not bearing interest.
5. Minimum issued share capital: minimum issued share capital is N100,000 S27(2)(a).
6. Name: Limited, Ltd S29
7. Statutory meeting: not required to hold SM within six months after incorporation or
file statutory reports S235.
8. Written resolution: all resolutions shall be passed at general meetings and are not
effective unless so passed, but in the case of a private company a written resolution
signed by all the members entitled to attend and vote are as valid and effective as if
passed in a general meeting S259.
9. Age of Directors to be Appointed: No age restriction on the appointment of persons
over 70 years as Directors for private as public companies require special notice for a
special resolution S282.
10. Number of Directors appointed by a motion: Can appoint two or more directors at a
single GM by a resolution S287.
11. Qualification of Secretary: the company secretary need not have certain professional
qualifications such as being a chartered secretary/administrator, legal practitioner,
accountant, a firm of any of these or a person who has practiced as public co’s secretary
for three of the five years immediately prior to CAMA S332.
12. Removal of Secretary: the removal of the CS does not require special procedures such
notice, 7 working days period for defence or 7 working days option to resign S333.
WHEN RECOMMENDED
1. Where the capital available to start off business is relatively small probably less than
N2m
2. Where small and medium scale business organizations need to acquire incorporated
status
3. Where family and friends want to engage in business expected to last over a long period
4. Where a SME seeks to acquire an incorporated status
5. Where there is intention to control the company
21
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
PUBLIC COMPANY
1. Definition: any company other than a private company shall be a public company and its
memorandum of association shall state that it is a public company S24.
2. Membership: it is unlimited S22(3).
3. Public Issue: it can invite members of the public to subscribe to its shares and debentures
S22(5), S67 ISA.
4. Minimum Share Capital: the minimum issued share capital is N2m S27(2)(a).
5. Name: Public Limited Company, Plc S29.
6. Statutory Meeting: must hold SM within six months of incorporation S235.
7. Additional Notice of GM: In addition to the notice required to be given to those entitled
to receive it in accordance with the provisions of this Act every public company shall, at
least 21 days before any general meeting, advertise a notice of such meeting in at least
two daily newspapers S246.
8. Written resolution: all resolutions shall be passed at general meetings and are not
effective unless so passed S259.
9. Appointment of Directors over 70 years: where a person who is above 70 years is to be
made a director, it requires a special notice for a special resolution and the age must be
disclosed S282.
10. Number of Directors appointed by a motion: cannot appoint more than one director at
a single GM by a resolution S287.
13. Qualification of Secretary: the company secretary must be professionally qualified,
such as being a chartered secretary/administrator, legal practitioner, accountant, a firm of
any of these or a person who has practiced as public co’s secretary for three of the five
years immediately prior to CAMA S332.
11. Removal of Secretary: the removal of the CS requires special procedures such as notice,
7 working days period for defence or 7 working days option to resign S333.
WHEN RECOMMENDED:
1. Where the capital available to start off business is relatively large, at least N2m and
above
2. Where the business organization desires to have access to public funds through offering
shares to the public for subscription
3. Where membership is not limited or restricted
4. Where there is intention to control the company
5. Where an SME has grown and needs corporate expansion
6. Where a large number of people, up to 50 desire to incorporate a company
7. Where large expansion is anticipated and the incorporators do not wish for a later
conversion into plc
8. Where any law requires the company being formed to be a plc
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN LTD AND PLC
SN DETAIL LTD PLC
1 Definition Its memo must call it private Its memo must call it public S24
22
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
S22(1)
2 Membership Shall not exceed 50 except for Unlimited S22(3)
employees S22(3)
3 Issue of shares Article may restrict transfer of No such provisions
shares, right of pre-emption,
can’t sell more than 50% of
shares to a non-member S22(2)
4 Issue of shares Unless can’t issue shares to the Can issue shares to the public S67 ISA
public S22(5)
5 Deposit of Money Shall not deposit money for No such provision
fixed periods or payable at call
S22(5)
6 Minimum issued N100k S22(2)(a) N2m S22(2)(a)
share capital
7 Name Limited, Ltd S29 Public Limited Company, Plc S29
8 Statutory meeting Need not SM within 6 months Must hold SM within 6 months of
of incorporation S235 incorporation S235
9 Additional notice No such requirement shall, at least 21 days before any general
of GM meeting, advertise a notice of such meeting
in at least two daily newspapers S246.
10 Written a written resolution signed by All resolutions shall be passed at GMs and
resolution all the members entitled to are not effective unless so passed S259.
attend and vote are as valid and
effective as if passed in a GM
S259.
23
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
24
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
10. If the Commission is satisfied that the MEMART have complied with the provisions of
this section, it shall cause the application to be advertised, in the prescribed form, in
three national daily newspapers S26(8).
11. The advertisement shall invite objections, if any, to the incorporation of the co and the
objection shall state the grounds on which it is made and shall be forwarded to the
Commission within 28 days of the date of the last publications in the newspapers, and, if
the objection is made, the Commission –
(a) shall consider it and may require the applicant to furnish further information or
documentation; and
(b) may uphold or reject the objection as it deems fit and inform the applicant
accordingly.
12. Where no objection is made and all requirements have been complied with, the
commission may withhold or grant assent and issue cert of incorporation accordingly
S26(10).
13. If it carries on business for the purpose of distributing profits to its members, all officers
and members who are cognisant of the fact that it is so carrying on business shall jointly
and severally be liable for the payment and discharge of all the debts and liabilities of the
company incurred in carrying on such business, and the company and every such officer
and member shall be liable to penalty as prescribed by the Commission for every day
during which it carries on such business S26(11).
14. The total liability of a member to contribute to the assets of the company in the event of
its being wound up shall not at any time be less than N100k S26(12).
15. If a member’s liability is not up to N100k, the articles may provide that he can retire or
be removed from membership by a special resolution duly filed with the Commission
S26(13).
16. If the total liability of the members at any time less than N100k, every director and
member of the company who is cognisant of the breach is liable to a penalty as prescribed
by the Commission for every day during which the default continues S26(14).
17. Subject to section 117 (4) (d) of this Act, if upon the winding-up, there remains, after the
discharge of all its debts and liabilities, any property of the company, the same shall not
be distributed among the members but shall be transferred to some other company limited
by guarantee having objects similar to the objects of the company or applied to some
charitable object and such other company or association shall be determined by the
members prior to dissolution of the company S26(15).
WHEN RECOMMENDED
1. Where the company’s object is for the promotion of commerce, art, science, religion,
sports, culture, education, charity.
2. Where the company’s profit is not to be distributed to members as dividend.
3. It is a subsidiary company set up to render corporate social responsibility, obligations for
the parent company.
25
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
26
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
(2) For the purposes of subsection (1), the composition of the board of directors of a company is
deemed to be controlled by another company if that other company by the exercise of some
power, without the consent or concurrence of any other person, can appoint or remove the
holders of all or majority of the directors.
REGISTRATION OF COMPANIES
Steps taken towards registration:
1. Taking instruction
2. Create account on CAC Company Registration Portal (CRP)
3. Search for availability of proposed name
4. Pay for reservation of name
5. Reserve name
6. Complete the pre-reg form on the CRP
7. Upload the required docs e.g., signatures and ID of directors and shareholders
8. Pay the filing fee via online payment portal (e-transact)
9. Pay stamp duties online
10. Download and print the electronic and certified extract of reg after approval from your
portal
TAKING INSTRUCTIONS
Client Interview Questionnaire
1. Proposed Name of Company/ Alternative
2. Registered Office Address/ Head Office
3. Nature of Business
4. Location
5. What is the proposed sphere of coverage?
6. How many members/shareholders/proprietors will you have for a start?
7. What is the maximum number of members?
8. Ages of the persons forming the company
9. Who are the Proposed Directors?
10. Any known legal disability
11. Proposed minimum share capital
12. Shareholding structure – Ratio
13. Expatriate employees
14. Control and Management / Leverage on investment
15. Public Issue of Shares and Prospectus
GTE
1. What would be the extent of members undertaking to contribute?
2. Name of the Company
3. What are the objects of business?
4. Are the objects for promotion of commerce, art, science?
27
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
5. Details of Subscribers
6. Permits and Approvals
7. What is the proposed NAME of the business?
8. Control and Management
9. Raising and Borrowing Power
10. Registered Office Address.
11. Company Secretary
12. Directorship
THE QUESTIONS IN DETAILS
1. Personal details
• Name in full
• Nationality
• Gender
• Age
• Residential address
• NB: Essentially to answer the question of capacity under S20.
2. Shareholders/ownership
• How many persons to start up the business.
o membership
o Details of such members
o Nationality
o Age
3. Details of Directorship
• Who are to be Directors?
o Age
o Qualification = expertise
o Mental capacity
o Number of Directors
o Contact address
4. Sphere/dimension of Business
• Need for registered office address in Nigeria
• Leveraging on ECOWAS Protocol, WTO/GATT, etc
• Incentives - manufacturing and rural location
5. Shares
• Share Capital
• Shares Allotment
• Types/Classes of Shares
28
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
29
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
30
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
31
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
32
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
33
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
34
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
8. Borrowing
9. Meeting of the company- Types (SS235, 237, 239)
10. Notice of meetings
11. Proceedings at Meetings (SS238, 242), Quorum (S256)
12. Chairman (S265)
13. Voting (S248)
14. Poll (S250)
15. Proxy (S254)
16. Written Resolutions (S259)
17. Number of directors (S271)
18. Appointment of first directors and other directors (S272 and 273)
19. Casual vacancy (S274)
20. Share qualification (S277)
21. Life Director (S281)
22. Vacation of office of Directors (S284)
23. Tenure of directors (S285)
24. Removal (S288)
25. Proceedings at meetings (S289)
26. Written Resolutions of Directors (S289(8), Quorum (S290)
27. Notice of meeting of directors (S292)
28. Remuneration (S293)
29. Managing Director
30. Duties of Directors (SS305-309)
31. The Secretary
32. Appointment and removal (S333)
33. Duties S335
34. Common seal –custody
35. Authority to use
36. Signature of documents
37. Official seal
38. Dividends and Reserve
39. Declaration of dividends and interim dividends (SS426) Reserves (SS430)
40. Payment of dividends
41. Capitalisation of profits (S430(2))
42. Accounts-Directors to cause proper books of accounts to be kept (S374)
43. Audit- Appointment of auditors (S401)
44. Stock Exchange if the company is to seek listing of its shares on a Nigerian Stock Exchange,
the articles must comply with the regulations of the exchange
45. Note: Second tier Securities Market (SSM)
46. Notices (S244)
47. Winding up
48. Indemnity
36
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
REGISTRATION DOCUMENTS
S36(1) The memorandum of association shall be delivered to the Commission together with an
application for registration of the company, the documents required by this section and a
statement of compliance.
• Memo
• Application for reg of the co
• Docs required by S36 (Statement of initial issued share capital and initial shareholdings,
statement of Co’s proposed directors, statement of proposed registered office, a copy of
articles of association)
• Statement of compliance
(2) The application for registration shall state—
(a) the company’s proposed name;
(b) the registered office address and head office address if different from the registered office
address;
(c) whether the liability of the members of the company is to be limited and, if so, whether it
is to be limited by shares or by guarantee; and
(d) whether the company is to be a private or a public company.
(3) If the application is delivered by a person as agent for the subscribers to the memorandum of
association, it shall state the name and address of that agent.
(4) The application shall contain—
(a) in the case of a company that has a share capital, a statement of initial issued share capital
and initial shareholdings;
(b) in the case of a company that is limited by guarantee, a statement of guarantee;
(c) a statement of the company’s proposed directors;
(d) a statement of the proposed registered office of the company; and
(e) a copy of the proposed articles of association to the extent that these are not supplied by
the default application of model articles.
Statement of capital and initial shareholdings
S37(1) The statement of initial issued share capital and initial shareholdings required to be
delivered in the case of a company that has a share capital shall state—
(a) the total number of shares of the company to be taken on formation by the subscribers
to the memorandum of association;
(b) the aggregate nominal value of those shares
(c) for each class of shares—
i. prescribed particulars of the rights attached to the shares,
ii. the total number of issued shares of that class, and
iii. the aggregate nominal value of issued shares of that class; and
37
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
(d) the amount to be paid up and the amount (if any) to be unpaid on each share (whether
on account of the nominal value of the share or by way of premium).
(2) The statement of initial issued share capital and initial shareholdings shall—
(a) contain such information as may be prescribed for the purpose of identifying the
subscribers to the memorandum of association; and
(b) with respect to each subscriber to the memorandum—
i. the number, nominal value (of each share) and class of shares to be taken by him on
formation, and
ii. the amount to be paid up and the amount (if any) to be unpaid on each share (whether
on account of the nominal value of the share or by way of premium).
(3) Where a subscriber to the memorandum is to take shares of more than one class, the
information required under subsection (2) (b) is required for each class.
(4) The total fees payable to the Commission in connection with the filing or increase of a
company’s issued share capital under this Part of this Act shall be as the Minister may by
regulation specify.
Statement of guarantee.
S38(1) The statement of guarantee required to be delivered in the case of a company that is
limited by guarantee shall—
(a) contain such information as may be prescribed for the purpose of identifying the
subscribers to the memo; and
(b) that each member undertakes that, if the company is wound up while he is a member, or
within one year after he ceases to be a member, he shall contribute to the assets of the
company such amount as may be required for—
i. payment of the debts and liabilities of the company contracted before he ceases to be
a member, payment of the costs, charges and expenses of winding-up, and
ii. adjustment of the rights of the contributories among themselves, not exceeding a
specified amount.
Statement of proposed Directors.
S39(1) The statement of the company’s proposed directors required to be delivered to the
Commission shall contain the required particulars of—
(a) the person who is, or persons who are, to be the first director or directors of the co; and
(b) where applicable, the person who is, or persons who are, to be the first secretary or joint
secretaries of the co.
(2) The required particulars are the particulars that are required to be stated in the case of a—
(a) director, in the company’s register of directors and register of directors’ residential
addresses; and
(b) secretary, in the company’s register of secretaries.
38
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
(3) The statement shall also contain a consent by each of the persons named as a director, as
secretary or one of joint secretaries, to act in the relevant capacity but if all the partners in a firm
are to be joint secretaries, consent may be given by one partner on behalf of all of them.
Statement of compliance
S40(1) The statement of compliance required to be delivered to the Commission is a statement
by the applicant or his agent that the requirements of this Act as to registration have been
complied with.
(2) The Commission may accept the statement of compliance as sufficient evidence of
compliance.
(3) Nothing in this section prevents the Commission from accepting declaration of compliance
which is signed by a legal practitioner and attested before the commissioner for oaths or notary
public.
NB: the difference between subsection one is that the applicant or his agent submits the SoC in
(1) but in (3), the LP does a declaration of compliance not signing the SoC, he’s somewhat
attesting or guaranteeing that they’ve complied in a separate doc and not necessarily signing the
SoC.
Grounds to Refuse Registration
S41(1) The Commission shall register the memorandum and articles unless in its opinion—
(a) they do not comply with the provisions CAMA;
(b) the business which the company is to carry on, or the objects for which it is formed, or
any of them, are illegal;
(c) any of the subscribers to the memorandum is incompetent or disqualified with respect to
capacity
(d) there is non-compliance with the requirement of any other law as to registration and
incorporation of a company; or
(e) the proposed name conflicts with or is likely to conflict with an existing company,
trade mark or business name registered in Nigeria.
Notwithstanding the above explanation in line with S36, the fact is that albeit, registration can
now be completed online and certificate of incorporation printed but for the purpose of Bar
Finals, the checklist of docs (filed online) may include:
i. Form CAC 1 for availability of name (no longer in Reg 2021)
ii. Form CAC 1.1; application for registration
iii. Identification documents for every subscriber and secretary (international passport
needed if a foreigner is involved)
iv. MEMART filled online
v. Original receipts of reg fees, stamp duties and statement of compliance or a declaration of
compliance by a LP sworn before a commissioner for oath or notary public
vi. Residence permit, if an alien
39
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
vii. Electronic signatures of the subscribers, directors, secretary and legal practitioner or
agent incorporating the company
viii. Affidavits where any alterations are made to the application forms
ix. Birth certificate or photo-page of international passport where a minor is involved
x. Board resolution and certificate of reg, where a corporate body is involved
NB: the purpose for the above list it that, in Bar Finals, the question maybe couched in a way
that will require the students to list forms and other docs aside from those listed under S36, thus,
these in conjunction with those in that section will suffice. Better to err on the side of surplusage
until NLS releases the official updated CLP modules operandi.
Documents required to register company limited by guarantee
i. CAC 1- Availability Check and Reservation of name (fill online)
ii. CAC 1.1- Form for Company Registration (to be adopted online with little alteration
allowed)
iii. Memorandum and articles of association (fill online) dully Stamped.
iv. Approval of Attorney General of the Federation
Other documents:
v. Residence permit (where foreigner’s residential address is in Nigeria) (uploaded online).
vi. Recognised means of identification for every director, subscriber and secretary in the
company (uploaded online)
vii. Electronic signatures of the subscribers, directors, secretary and legal practitioner or
agent incorporating the company (uploaded online)
viii. Other documents required by the Commission to satisfy the requirement of any
law relating to the formation of a company (uploaded online).
ETHICAL MATTERS
• Duty to act in good faith
• Duty to take full instruction.
• Duty to Disclose Conflicting Interest Rule 17 RPC.
• The money collected must be disbursed in accordance with client’s lawful instructions.
• Preserve Confidential Information - S192 EA
• It is the duty of the lawyer to devote his attention, energy and expertise to the service of
his client in accordance with Rule 14 (2 - 5) RPC 2007.
40
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
41
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT
• Oral
• Written
• By Deed
• Legal Implication
NECESSITY FOR FORMAL AGREEMENT
• Prevention of presumptions of law
• It forms a benchmark for reference time of crisis
• Easy enforceability of the terms
• Avoidance of bad faith, cheating and oppression
• Makes the terms easily ascertainable
RULES FOR DETERMINING EXISTENCE OF PARTNERSHIP S4 PLL
In determining whether a partnership does or does not exist regard shall be had to the following
rules -
(a) Joint tenancy, tenancy in common, joint property, common property or part ownership
does not of itself create a partnership as to anything so held or owned whether the tenants
or owners do or do not share any profits made by the use thereof.
(b) The sharing of gross returns does not of itself create a partnership whether the persons
sharing such returns have or have not a joint or common right or interest in any property
from which or from the use of which the returns are derived.
(c) The receipt by a person of a share of the profits of a business is prima facie evidence that
he is a partner in the business, but receipt of such a share or of a payment contingent on
or varying with the profits of a business, does not of itself make him a partner in the
business; and in particular -
i. the receipt by a person of debt or other liquidated amount by instalments or
otherwise out of the accruing profits of a business does not of itself make him a
partner in the business or liable as such;
ii. a contract for the remuneration of a servant or agent of a person engaged in a
business by a share of the profit of the business does not of itself make the servant or
agent a partner in the business or liable as such;
iii. a person being a widow or child or a deceased partner and receiving by way of
annuity a portion of the profits made in the business in which the deceased person
was a partner is not by reason only of such receipt a partner in the business or liable
as such;
iv. the advance of money by way of loan to a person engaged or about to engage in
any business on a contract with that person that the lender shall receive a rate of
interest varying with the profits or shall receive a share of the profits arising from
carrying on the business, does not of itself make the lender a partner with the person
or persons carrying on the business or liable as such:
42
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
43
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
44
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
iv. The LLP if it decides to have a common seal may have one; and
v. The LLP may do and suffer such other acts and things as bodies corporate may lawfully
do and suffer.
NAME OF LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP S757 of CAMA
RESERVATION OF NAME S758 of CAMA
PUBLICATION OF NAME OF LLP S760
i. The invoices, official correspondence and publications of the firm to bear the name,
address of its principal office and registration number of the LLP; and a statement that it
is registered as LLP; and
ii. Display of the certificate of registration conspicuously in its principal place of business
and in all its branches where it has branch offices.
ELIGIBILITY TO BE PARTNERS S761
• On the incorporation of a LLP, the persons who subscribed their names to the
incorporation documents shall be its partners and any other person may become a partner
of the LLP in accordance with the LLP agreement.
RELATIONSHIP OF THE PARTNERS S762
CESSATION OF PARTNERSHIP INTEREST S763
i. By agreement with the other partners of the firm;
ii. By giving 30 days’ notice in writing of his intention to resign as a partner of the firm to
the other partners of the firm in the absence of agreement;
iii. Upon the death of the partner;
iv. When a partner is declared to be of unsound mind by a competent court;
v. Where a partner has applied to be adjudged or declared as an insolvent; and
vi. Upon dissolution of the partnership.
REGISTRATION OF CHANGE IN PARTICULARS OF PARTNERS S764
PARTNER AS AGENT S765
• A partner of a LLP is, for the purpose of the business of the LLP, the agent of the LLP,
but not of other partners.
EXTENT OF LIABILITY OF LLP S766
UNLIMITED LIABILITY IN CASE OF FRAUD S769
FORM OF CONTRIBUTION BY PARTNERS S770
MAINTENANCE OF BOOKS OF ACCOUNTS, OTHER RECORDS AND AUDIT S772
i. Register of members.
ii. Books of account.
45
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
46
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
47
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• A limited liability partnership may be wound up either voluntary or by the court S789.
• If it is winding up by the court, the application to the court is by way of petition S786.
CIRCUMSTANCES THAT WILL WARRANT WINDING UP OF THE PARTNERSHIP
BY THE COURT S790
i. Where all the partners decide that the LLP be so wound up by the court;
ii. Where for a period of more than six months, the number of partners of the partnership
falls below two;
iii. Where the LLP is unable to pay its debts;
iv. Where the partnership has acted against the interests of the sovereignty and integrity of
Nigeria or against her security or public order;
v. Where the partnership has made a default in filing with CAC, the statement of account
and solvency or annual return for any 10 consecutive financial years; or
48
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
vi. Where the court is of the opinion that it is just and equitable that the LLP be wound up.
DISCLOSURE OF SIGNIFICANT CONTROL IN A LLP S791
• Where a partner becomes a person with significant control over a LLP, he shall within 7
days of becoming such a person, indicate to the LLP in writing the particulars of such
control.
• Upon a LLP receiving or being in possession of the information that a partner has
become a person with significant control, the partnership shall within 1 month from the
receipt of the information or any change therein, notify CAC of that fact.
BUSINESS TRANSACTIONS OF PARTNER WITH LLP S792
• A partner may lend money to and transact other business with the LLP and has the same
rights and obligations with respect to the loan or other transactions as a person who is not
a partner.
POWER OF CAC TO STRIKE OUT DEFUNCT LLP OFF REGISTER S793
• CAC can strike out a defunct limited liability partnership off the register if the
Commission has reasonable cause to believe that the partnership is not carrying on
business or operation.
POWER TO MAKE RULES S794
• CAC is mandated to make rules or regulations in respect of fees, forms, duties or
additional duties to be performed by CAC and generally, the conduct and regulation of
registration under this part and any matter incidental thereto.
RELEVANT CAC FORMS UNDER PART D OF CAMA
1. Form CAC/LLP 01 – Application to Register a LLP
2. Form CAC/LLP 02 – Notice of Change in Registered Office or Head Office Address of
LLP
3. Form CAC/LLP 03 – Application of Change of Name of LLP
4. Form CAC/LLP 04 – Notice of Change in Particulars of Partner of LLP
5. Form CAC/LLP 05 – Appointment of Partner of LLP
6. Form CAC/LLP 06 – Termination of Appointment of Partner of an LLP
7. Form CAC/LLP 07 – Annual Return of LLP
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP (LP) PART D, SS 795 - 810
S795 (2) A LP shall not consist of more than 20 persons.
(3) A LP shall consist of one or more persons called general partners, who shall be liable for all
debts and obligations of the firm, and one or more persons called limited partners.
(4) Each limited partner shall at the time of entering into the partnership contribute, or agree to
contribute, thereto a sum or sums as capital or property valued at a stated amount and shall not
49
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
be liable for the debts of obligations of the firm, beyond the amount so contributed or agreed to
be contributed: Provided that a limited partner is not under obligation to contribute any capital
or property to the partnership where the partners have so agreed in writing.
(5) Unless otherwise agreed in writing by the partners, a limited partner shall not, during the
continuance of the partnership, either directly or indirectly, draw out or receive back any part of
his contribution and if he draws, out or receives back any such part, is liable for the debts and
obligations of the partnership up to the amount so drawn out or received back.
Capacity to form LP S796, any person including body corporate can form LP except a person
of unsound mind or undischarged bankrupt can from LP.
Mandatory Registration S797
1) A partnership carrying on business as a LP must be registered.
2) A partnership not registered shall be deemed to be a general partnership and every limited
partner shall be deemed to be a general partner.
Application for registration S798
798(1) An application for registration as a limited partnership shall be in the form as prescribed
by the Commission and shall—
(a) specify the name under which the limited partnership is to be registered;
(b) be signed or otherwise authenticated by or on behalf of each partner, and
(c) include a statement containing the details listed in subsection (2).
(2) The application for registration of a limited partnership shall include a statement signed by
the partners which shall contain —
(a) the name of the limited partnership;
(b) the general nature of the business;
(c) the principal place of business;
(d) the full name and address of each general partner;
(e) the full name and address of each limited partner;
(f) the term if any, for which the partnership is entered into and the date of its
commencement;
(g) a statement that the partnership is limited and the description of every limited partner
as such; and
(h) the sum contributed, or agreed to be contributed by each limited partner and whether
paid, or to be paid in cash or in another specified form.
DOCUMENTS REQUIRED FOR REGISTRATION OF THE LP
i. Availability and Reservation of Name Form;
ii. Form CAC/LP 01 – Application to Register a Limited Partnership;
iii. Partnership Agreement;
iv. Recent passport photographs of all partners;
50
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
v. Copy of recognised and valid photo identification that is: either data page of International
Passport, Driver’s License, National Identity Card, Voter’s Card or Birth Certificate (in
case of a minor) must be submitted for every individual partner; and
vi. Evidence of payment of filing fee.
REGISTRATION OF LP S797
• A partnership carrying on business as a limited partnership must be registered as limited
partnership failing which, it will be deemed to be general partnership
NAME OF LP S802
• The name of a LP must end with the words "limited partnership" or the abbreviation "LP"
RESERVATION OF NAME AND CHANGE OF NAME OF LP S803.
APPLICATION FOR REGISTRATION OF LP S798.
Application for registration of the partnership is made using Form CAC/LP 01 – Application to
Register a LP and other registration documents namely:
i. Availability and Reservation of Name Form;
ii.Partnership Agreement;
iii.
Recent passport photographs of all partners;
iv.Copy of recognised and valid photo identification that is: either data page of International
Passport, Driver’s License, National Identity Card, Voter’s Card or Birth Certificate (in
case of a minor) must be submitted for every individual partner; and
v. Evidence of payment of filing fee.
CERTIFICATE OF REGISTRATION S799
Upon fulfilling the requirements of incorporation and delivering the registration documents to
CAC, CAC shall register the LP and issue certificate of registration of the LP.
REGISTRATION OF CHANGES IN PARTNERSHIP S800.
NOTICE OF CHANGE IN STATUS OF GENERAL PARTNER OR ASSIGNMENT OF
SHARE OF LP S801
A general partner can become a limited partner if such an arrangement is agreed upon by the
other partners and a notice of the arrangement or transaction specifying the change from general
partner to limited partner is filed with CAC within five days of the change.
COMMISSION TO KEEP REGISTER
CAC must keep at its registry in respect of limited partnership the following books:
i. Register of limited partnership; and
ii. Index of limited partnership S805.
51
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
52
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
53
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
(h) the date of commencement of the business, whether before or after the coming into
operation of this Act.
815(2): Where the registration to be effected is that of an individual or a firm, some or all of
whose partners are individuals, there shall be submitted to the Registrar copies of the passport
photographs of the individual certified in a manner required by the Registrar.
815(3): Where the registration to be effected is that of a firm or individual carrying on business
on behalf of another individual, firm or corporation whether as nominee or trustee, the statement
required by subsection (1) to be furnished shall contain the following particulars in addition to
the particulars required by that subsection;
i. the present forenames and surname,
ii. any former forenames or surname,
54
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
iii. the nationality and, if that nationality is not the nationality of origin, the nationality of
origin and
iv. the usual residence of each individual on whose behalf the business is carried on; and
v. the name of each firm or corporation on whose behalf the business is carried on.
(4) Where the registration to be effected is that of a firm or individual carrying on business as
general agent for any concern carrying on business outside Nigeria and not having a place of
business in Nigeria, the statement required by subsection (1) to be furnished shall, in addition to
the particulars required by that subsection, state the name and full postal address of each such
concern, provided that in the case of a firm or individual carrying on business as general agent
for three or more such concerns, it shall be sufficient to state the fact that the business is so
carried on and the countries in which the concerns carry on business.
(5) A statement furnished in accordance with subsections (1) - (4) shall in the case of a;
(a) statement furnished by an individual, be signed by him;
(b) statement furnished by a firm, be signed by each individual who is a partner and by a
director or the secretary of each Corporation which is partner; and
(c) corporation, be signed by a director or the secretary:
Provided that, if the statement is accompanied by a statutory declaration made by any person to
the effect that he is a partner of the firm or is a director or the secretary of a corporation which is
a partner of the firm, the statement may be signed by that person alone.
(6) A statement furnished in accordance with subsections (1) - (4) by an individual who is a
minor or by a firm of which one of the partners is a minor shall, in addition to the requirements
of subsection (1), be signed by a magistrate, legal practitioner or police officer of, or above the
rank of Assistant Superintendent of Police.
(7) If an individual, firm or corporation makes default in complying with the provisions of this
section, the individual, corporation or every partner in the firm commits an offence and is liable
on conviction to a fine prescribed in the Commission’s regulations for every day during which
the default continues, and the Court shall order a statement of the required particulars to be
furnished to the Registrar within such time as may be specified in the order.
PROCEDURE FOR REGISTRATION SUMMARY:
Instruction to be taken in respect of the following:
1. The Firm name or names
2. The general nature of the business
3. Full postal address of the principal place of business and of any branches.
4. The full names of the partners or individual proprietor, presence of minors to be noted.
5. Where the business is to be carried on as nominee, trustee or general agent, full
particulars of the principals should be taken.
6. Date of commencement of business.
55
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
56
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
registration and must be lodged at the office where registration was effected S818, CAC/BN 05
– Notice of Change/Correction in Particulars of Proprietor/Partner.
Publication of true name in all trade catalogues, business letters, etc S820. Searches and Copies
of Entries S820.
DEFAULT OF REGISTRATION
• Penal sanctions S815 (7) Civil Remedies
a. Bar to action to enforce partnership rights Alowonle v Bello.
b. Effect on Contracts: contracts entered into during default are not void but merely
unenforceable and application may be made to a high court in which any such
contract would otherwise be enforceable for relief from the disability section 821.
The high court may grant relief if it is satisfied that the default was as a result of any
of the following grounds:
i. That the default was accidental or due to inadvertence or some other sufficient
cause; or
ii. That on other grounds, it is just and equitable to grant relief.
NB: The other party or parties to the contract are free to enforce their right against the party in
default but the defaulter will be free to counterclaim or otherwise enforce his rights against that
party in that action.
ANNUAL RETURN
To be delivered not later than 30th June in each year except the calendar year in which the
name was registered S822.
REMOVAL OF NAME FROM THE REGISTER S819
• On notice by proprietors within 3 months of cessation of business.
• At the instance of the Registrar where he has reasonable cause to believe that a business
is no longer being carried on, send a later and if no response after two months, the name
may be removed.
CESSATION OF BUSINESS NAME AND DISSOLUTION OF PARTNERSHIP
• BN and partnership can only be brought to an end by cessation and dissolution as
opposed to winding up in the case of companies.
• Upon cessation of its business, either by the death of a sole proprietor or by consents of
the partners or formal dissolution by the courts, the BN is deemed dissolved and the name
is removed from the Register of Business Names at the CAC S819.
• Any of the partners should within 3 months notify the CAC of the dissolution and the
fact that the firm has ceased to do business.
FILING OF NOTICE OF CESSATION OF BUSINESS
• Notification to the effect that the BN has ceased to carry on business to CAC.
57
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• The notification is by the proprietor or the personal representative of the proprietor or the
personal representative of the proprietor in the case of death of the proprietor and it has to
be within 3 months of such cessation S819.
DISSOLUTION OF PARTNERSHIP
Partnership can be dissolved:
i. By act of the general partners
ii. By operation of law
iii. By the Court
Relevant CAC Forms under Part E of CAMA:
1. CAC/BN 01 – Application to Register Business Name
2. CAC/BN 02 – Notice of Change in Principal Place of Business or Branch Address of
Business Name
3. CAC/BN 03 – Change of Name of Business Name
4. CAC/BN 04 – Notice of Change in Object(s) of Business Name
5. CAC/BN 05 – Notice of Change/Correction in Particulars of Proprietor/Partner
6. CAC/BN 06 – Annual Return of Business Name
INCORPORATED TRUSTEE (IT) PART F, SS 823 - 850
Regulation 27 of the Companies Regulations 2021 provides that the following classifications
shall apply to incorporated trustees;
1. Religious
2. Educational
3. Literary
4. Scientific
5. Social
6. Developmental
7. Cultural
8. Sporting
9. Charitable
10. Others
S823(1): Where two or more trustees are appointed by any community of persons bound together
by custom, religion, kinship or nationality or by anybody or association of persons established
for any religious, educational, literary, scientific, social, development, cultural, sporting or
charitable purpose, they may, if so authorised by the community, body or association (in this Act
referred to as “the association”) apply to the CAC in the manner provided for registration under
this Act as a corporate body.
Method of application
S825(1) application shall be in the form prescribed by CAC and shall state the:
58
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
(a) name of the proposed corporate body which must contain the words “Incorporated
Trustees of”;
(b) aims and objects of the association which shall be for the advancement of any
o religious,
o educational,
o literary,
o scientific,
o social,
o development,
o cultural,
o sporting or
o charitable purpose, and
o shall be lawful; and
(c) names, addresses and occupations of the secretary of the association, if any.
(2) There shall be attached to the application;
(a) two printed copies of the constitution of the association;
(b) duly signed copies of the minutes of the meeting appointing the trustees and authorising
the application showing the people present and the votes scored; and
(c) the impression or drawing of the proposed common seal, if there is one.
(3) The application shall be signed by the person making it.
(4) The Commission may require such declaration or other evidence in verification of the
statements and particulars in the application, and such other, information and evidence, if any, as
it may deem fit.
(5) If any person knowingly makes any false statement or gives any false information for the
purpose of incorporating trustees under this Part, he commits an offence and is liable on
conviction to imprisonment for one year or to a fine as the Court deems fit.
PROCEDURE FOR REGISTRATION S825
1. All applications should be submitted to CAC electronically. Form CAC/IT 01 – Application
to Register IT must contain, among other things: -
i. The name of the proposed corporate body which must contain the words, “Incorporated
Trustees of _____________________”
ii. Registered office address
iii. Publication details
iv. Aims and objects of the association
v. Trustees’ details – trustee personal information, residential address and service address
vi. Secretary’s details – personal details of secretary and service address
vii. Impression of common seal (if any)
viii. Enclosures
ix. Details of chairman
59
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
60
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
(2) If a person disqualified under subsection (1) (c) or (d) acts as a trustee, he shall be liable to a
penalty for every day during which he so acts, the penalty shall be determined in accordance
with regulations made by the Commission from time to time.
Constitution
S827 The constitution of the association shall in addition to any other matter—
(a) state the name or title of the association; e.g., “Incorporated Trustee of ………….”
(b) the aims and objects of the association; and
(c) make provisions, in respect of the following—
i. appointment, powers, duties, tenure of office and replacement of the trustees,
ii. the use and custody of the common seal, if there is one,
iii. the meetings of the association,
iv. the number of members of the governing body, if any, the procedure for their
appointment and removal, and their powers, and where subscriptions and other
contributions are to be collected, the procedure for disbursement of the funds of the
association, the keeping of accounts and the auditing of such accounts.
The checklist may include
1. Name clause
2. Aims and objects
3. Trustees’ appointment, powers, duties, tenure and replacement
4. Common seal (if any)
5. Meeting clause
6. Governing body number, appointment, removal, and powers
7. Source of income
8. Disbursement of fund
9. Keeping of accounts
10. Auditing of accounts
11. Constitution amendment clause is a mandatory provision in the Act (S832, 833 and 835)
no need to include it
Advertisement and objections.
S828(1) If the Commission is satisfied that the application has complied with the provisions of
CAMA, it shall cause the application to be published in a prescribed form in two daily
newspapers circulating in the area where the association is to be situated and at least one of
the newspapers shall be a national newspaper.
(2) The advertisement shall invite objections, if any, to the registration of the body.
(3) The objection shall state the grounds on which it is made and shall be forwarded to reach the
Commission within 28 days of the date of the last of the publications in the newspapers.
61
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
62
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
63
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
(2) The grounds on which the body corporate may be dissolved are that:
(a) the aims and objects for which it was established have been fully realised and no useful
purpose would be served by keeping the corporation alive;
(b) the body corporate is formed to exist for a specified period, that period has expired and it
is not necessary for it to continue to exist;
(c) all the aims and objects of the association have become illegal or otherwise contrary to
public policy;
(d) it is just and equitable in all the circumstances that the body corporate be dissolved; and
(e) the certificate of registration of the association has been withdrawn, cancelled or revoked
by CAC.
(3) At the hearing of the petition, all persons whose interests or rights may, in the opinion of the
Court, be affected by the dissolution shall be put on notice.
(4) If in the event of a winding-up or dissolution of the corporate body there remains, after the
satisfaction of all its debts and liabilities, any property whatsoever, the same shall not be paid to
or distributed among the members of the association, but shall be given or transferred to some
other institutions having objects similar to the objects of the association:
Provided that the institution shall be determined by the members of the association at or before
the time of dissolution.
(5) If effect cannot be given to the provisions of subsection (4), the remaining property shall be
transferred to some charitable object.
64
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
ASSIGNMENT
ANSWERS TO SCENARIO: CHOICE OF BUSINESS AND NONBUSINESS
ORGANIZATION AND FORMATION (PARTNERSHIP AND INCORPORATED
TRUSTEES)
Nathan Abayomi and Jeriel Uchendu just got enrolled for the mandatory National Youth Service
Corp where they met at Sokoto state, their state of posting. During the service year, they started
collecting and recycling plastic waste out of their passion for a clean and healthy environment.
They eventually made a business out of it when they started supplying their recycled plastic to a
plastic company in Kano and they want to run the business themselves with much ease because
of their little resources. Still in pursuit of their passion for a clean environment, they started
teaching people on how to properly dispose waste and creating awareness on the use of
biodegradable materials for packaging goods and other products, they want this campaign to be a
continuing one and to reach other parts of the country.
65
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
66
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
6. Three (3) presumptions that can be made as a result of their joint business are as follow: (15
marks)
a. Partnership Capital: It will be presumed in the absence of a provision for capital
contribution in the Partnership Agreement that the partners contributed the capital equally
and must share the profit and losses equally.
b. Remuneration/Salary: It will be presumed in the absence of a provision for payment of
salary/remuneration in the Partnership Agreement that the partners will not be entitled to
receive salary/remuneration.
c. Profit and Loss Sharing: It will be presumed in the absence of a provision for profit and
loss sharing in the Partnership Agreement that the profit and loss will be equally shared
by the partners.
d. Expulsion: It will be presumed in the absence of a provision for expulsion in the
Partnership Agreement that the partners lack the power to expel any partner. If they
attempt to expel any partner, the partnership stands dissolved.
e. Partnership Property: It will be presumed that the partners have equal rights to the
partnership property if nothing is provided on the contrary in the Partnership Agreement.
f. Dissolution of Partnership: The partnership will be presumed to be partnership-at-will
which can be dissolved at the instance of any of the partners (notice). Death, incapacity,
expulsion or resignation of a partner may also signify the dissolution of the partnership if
there is no provision in the Partnership Agreement for continuation of the partnership
after such occurrences.
7. Five clauses that will be included in the agreement that will regulate their joint business are as
follow: (5 marks)
a. Parties
b. Name and style
c. Place of business
d. Nature of business
e. Commencement
f. Duration
g. Capital
h. Property of Partnership
i. Profits and drawings
j. Bankers and signatories to bank account
k. Salary/Remuneration
l. Accounts
m. Powers, rights and duties
n. Retirement
o. Expulsion and Suspension
p. Dissolution
q. Arbitration
67
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
8. The appropriate form of registration for their campaign on a clean environment is to register
Incorporated Trustees under Part C of CAMA. This is because the aims and objectives of the
organization they want to form is to educate the entire people of Nigeria on how to properly
dispose waste and creating awareness on the use of biodegradable materials for packaging goods
and other products, as well as the organization being a non-profit organization falls under Part C
of CAMA.: (3 marks)
S. 590 of CAMA: (1 mark) provides that, “where one or more trustees are appointed by any
community of persons bound together by custom, religion, kinship or nationality or by anybody
or association of persons established for any religious, educational, literary, scientific, social,
development, cultural, sporting or charitable purpose, he or they may, if so authorized by the
community, body or association (in this Act referred to as “the association”) apply to the
Commission in the manner hereafter provided for registration under this Act as a corporate
body”.
9. The steps involved in getting the body registered are as follow: (15 marks)
a. Taking instructions
b. Holding of meeting of the body where the trustees are appointed and the Special Clause
adopted
c. Writing of letter authorising the person handling the registration
d. Conduct availability check and reservation of name
e. Publication in two (2) daily newspapers of which one must be circulating in the local area
and the other one circulating nationally, calling for objection within 28 days
f. Preparation of incorporation documents (filling of application form, constitution, Trustee
Declaration Form, obtaining passport photographs of trustees, etc)
g. Preparation of the Common Seal of the body
h. Formal application addressed to the Registrar-General, of the Corporate Affairs
Commission requesting for his consent/approval for the registration of the body by the
person registering the body
i. Payment of filling fees
j. Filing
k. Obtaining the certificate of incorporation and CTCs of the constitution and application
form (CAC /IT FORM I) of the body.
10. The person that may join in the registration of the body must be: (5 marks)
a. An adult
b. A person of sound mind
c. A person who is not bankrupt
d. A person who has not been convicted of an offence involving fraud or dishonesty within
five (5) years of his proposed appointment. See S. 592 of CAMA.
11. The minimum number of person that is registered for the body to have corporate personality
is one person. CAMA provides that one or more trustees are required for registration of an
Incorporated Trustees.: (2 mark) See. S 590 of CAMA.
68
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
12. The documents required for registration of the body are as follows: (14 marks)
a. Form of approval of name Form CAC 1
b. CAC /IT FORM I -Duly completed set of Incorporation Form
c. Trustees Declaration Form
d. Formal application letter for registration signed by the chairman and secretary
e. Extracts of minutes of general meeting appointing trustees and adopting special clause in
the constitution signed by the chairman signed by the chairman and secretary
f. Two printed copies of the constitution
g. Trustees declaration from duly deposed to by each trustee in the High Court
h. Impression of the common seal of the association on the application form
i. Payment of filing fee
j. Evidence of newspaper publication of advertisement of trustees
k. Impression of common seal
l. Evidence of land ownership
m. Two passport photograph of each Trustees
n. Letter authorising the Solicitor handling the registration
13. Five (5) provisions that must be contained in the constitution of the body are as follows: (5
marks)
a. Name
b. Aims and objectives
c. Common seal
d. Special clause
e. Trustees
f. Governing body
g. Meetings
h. Accounts
69
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
PRE-INCORPORATION MATTERS
B. Promotion of Companies and Pre-incorporation contracts
WHO IS A PROMOTER?
By virtue of S85, a promoter of a company is any person;
• who undertakes to take part in forming a company with reference to a given project and
set it going and
• who takes the necessary steps to accomplish that purpose, or who, with regard to a
proposed or newly formed company, undertakes a part in raising capital for it, is deemed
a promoter of the company:
• Provided that a person acting in a professional capacity for persons engaged in procuring
the formation of the company.
Erlanger v New Sombrero Phosphate Co, Lord Blackburn defined promoter as “a short and
convenient way of designating those who set in motion the machinery by which the Act enables
them to create an incorporated company.”
BECOMING A PROMOTER AFTER INCORPORATION?
• YES
• It is possible to become a promoter of a company already registered if for example a
person assists a newly formed company to raise capital, manpower etc.
CAN A CORPORATE BODY BE A PROMOTER?
• YES
• An existing company except the one in liquidation may be a promoter of another new
company if they do the activities of a promoter for the newly formed company S20(4).
CAN A FOREIGN OR ALIEN COMPANY BE A PROMOTER?
• YES
• An alien or a foreign company may join in forming a company S20(5).
WHAT ARE THE PROMOTER’S ACTIVITIES?
• For a company to come into existence, there must be persons who would promote and
float it. Promotion activities usually involve:
i. Fund raising
ii. Obtaining requisite permits
iii. Packaging of incorporation documents
iv. Land acquisition
v. Personality Shopping/Employment/Staffing etc
71
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
LIABILITIES OF PROMOTERS
Where there is a breach of the duties imposed on a promoter, the company can take any of the
following actions for redress
i. Action to render account of money or property received in the course of promotion
activities
ii. Action to account for secret profit made
iii. Action for damages for wrongful exploitation of confidential information
iv. Refusal to ratify pre-incorporation contract tainted with conflict of interest
v. Action to refund.
vi. Rescission (strongest tool)
REASON FOR RESCISSION
• A promoter is in a fiduciary relationship to the company; thus, any breach of this duty
entitles the company to rescission from such contracts S86(3).
IS THE RIGHT OF RESCISSION OF A COMPANY ABSOLUTE?
• NO
• The court may in its equitable jurisdiction stop a company from rescission. For instance,
a company may not rescind where there is full disclosure of material facts known by the
promoter and the contract has been ratified on behalf of the company:
• Where rescission not possible, the company may take option of RECOVERY OF
PROFIT
• Where it is not possible for the company to rescind the contract, the company may
recover the profit made in the transaction.
• Sometimes, recovering profit only may not be sufficient thus company is entitled to sue
for damages for the breach of the fiduciary duty.
• Also, a subscriber has a right to sue for damages where relied on the false information
given to him by the promoter subscribing for the shares.
IS THERE LIMITATION OF TIME IN ACTION AGAINST A PROMOTER?
Action against a promoter by a company is not limited by time S86(4). But the court has the
discretion to relieve a promoter in whole part from liability considering the circumstances and
lapse of time.
RATIFICATION OF CONTRACT ENTERED BY PROMOTER S86(3)
i. By the company’s Board of directors independent of the promoter
ii. By all the members of the company; or
iii. By the company at a general meeting at which neither the promoter shareholders of any
shares in which he is beneficially interested shall vote on the resolution to enter into or
ratify the transaction.
72
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
REMUNERATION OF PROMOTERS
• A promoter has no right against the company for payment of services rendered before
incorporation.
• The law is that unless the company’s Articles of Association permits the Directors to pay,
a promoter is not entitled to remuneration for services secured as a promoter.
• Where the promoter enters into a contract with the proposed company, he can recover his
fees and preliminary expenses where the contract is ratified by the company.
ISSUES OF REMUNERATION GENERALLY?
i. Promoter
ii. Executive director
iii. Managing director
iv. Non-executive
v. Trustees
vi. Company secretary
See the case of Gluckstein v Barnes.
Erlanger v New Sombrero Phosphate: Frédéric Émile d'Erlanger was a Parisian banker. He
bought the lease of the Anguilla island of Sombrero for phosphate mining for £55,000. He then
set up the New Sombrero Phosphate Co. Eight days after incorporation, he sold the island to the
company for £110,000 through a nominee. One of the directors was the Lord Mayor of London,
who himself was independent of the syndicate that formed the company. Two other directors
were abroad, and the others were mere puppet directors of Erlanger. The board, which was
effectively Erlanger, ratified the sale of the lease. Erlanger, through promotion and advertising,
got many members of the public to invest in the company.
After eight months, the public investors found out the fact that Erlanger (and his syndicate) had
bought the island at half the price the company (now with their money) had paid for it. The New
Sombrero Phosphate Co sued for rescission based on non-disclosure, if they gave back the mine
and an account of profits, or for the difference.
The House of Lords unanimously held that promoters of a company stand in a fiduciary
relationship to investors, meaning they have a duty of disclosure. Further, they held, by majority
(Lord Cairns LC dissenting), that the contract could be rescinded, and that rescission was not
barred by laches.
Lord Blackburn decided that delay did not bar rescission. As a general "condition to a
rescission there must be a restitutio in integrum." There was a question over this, since phosphate
had been mined, and it was not so easy to put the phosphate back. He observed it would "be
obviously unjust that a person who has been in possession of property under the contract which
he seeks to repudiate should be allowed to throw that back on the other party’s hands without
accounting for any benefit he may have derived from the use of the property… [or] making
compensation for that deterioration." In this case, however, adequate compensate could be paid.
So, there was no impossibility in counter restitution.
73
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Gluckstein v Barnes: Mr G and 3 others formed a syndicate and bought a property for
£120,000, but claimed they were paying £140,000. They also promote a company of which they
become the directors and buy the property (for the company) for £180,000. In order to fund the
purchase, the company invited members of the public to buy shares, for which a prospectus was
issued. However, a £40,000 profit was disclosed, whereas the promoters had actually made an
additional £20,000 secret profit. This was not disclosed to the prospective shareholders but was
instead written in with a vague reference to ‘interim investments’. 4 years later the company
went into liquidation and the extra £20,000 was discovered. The liquidator brought an action to
recover part of this amount from Mr G.
Held: The action succeeded. As promoters they were under a duty to make explicit declarations
of the profits already made.
Lord Macnaghten said that: ‘Everybody knows that sometimes half a truth is no better than a
downright falsehood.’
Lord Macnaghten: there are two things in this case which puzzle me much, and I do not
suppose that I shall ever understand them. I mention them merely because I should be very sorry
if it were thought that in these two matters the House unanimously approved of what has been
done. I do not understand why Mr. Glusktein and his associates were not called upon to refund
the whole of the money which they misappropriated. What they did with it, whether they put it in
their own pockets or distributed it among their confederates, or spent it in charity, seems to me
absolutely immaterial. In the next place, I do not understand why Mr. Gluckstein was only
charged with interest at the rate of 3%. I should have thought it was a case for penal interest.
In these two matters, Mr. Gluckstein has been in my opinion extremely fortunate. But he
complains that he may have a difficulty in recovering from his co-directors their share of the
spoil, and he asks that the official liquidator may proceed against his associates before calling
upon him to make good the whole amount with which he has been charged. My Lords, there may
be occasions in which that would be a proper course to take. But I cannot think that this is a case
in which any indulgence ought to be shown to Mr. Gluckstein.
Lagunas Nitrate v Lagunas Syndicate: The L. Company was promoted and formed by the
directors of the L. Syndicate for the purpose of purchasing part of the property of the syndicate,
consisting of nitrate works. The directors of the syndicate prepared and signed the memorandum
and articles of association of the company, the articles nominating them as directors and stating
specifically that they were also the directors of the syndicate. They also prepared the company’s
prospectus and purchase contract and affixed the seals of the syndicate and of the company to the
latter. The company’s solicitors and secretary were also the same as those of the syndicate. Two
years after the date of the contract and the completion of the purchase the shareholders of the
company, believing that their property had been purchased at an over-value and that there had
been misrepresentations in the contract and prospectus, appointed an independent board of
directors who, after investigating the facts and with the sanction of a general meeting of the
shareholders, brought an action against the syndicate and the directors for rescission of the
contract and damages on the ground of misrepresentation, misfeasance, breach of trust, and
74
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
concealment of material facts, but not alleging fraud. From the date of the contract and down to
and also since the commencement of the action the company had, first by its original directors
and afterwards by its independent board, carried on business and worked the property the subject
of the contract. At the trial Romer J. dismissed the action.
On appeal by the company: -
Held, by Lindley M.R., and Collins L.J., that the company was not entitled to rescission or
damages, for
1. at the date of the contract the company had, by its memorandum and articles, notice that
its directors were also the vendors or agents of the vendor syndicate, and the mere fact
that its directors did not constitute an independent board was not a sufficient ground for
setting aside the contract;
2. there had been no misrepresentation made to, or any material fact concealed from, any of
the persons who were members of the company at the date of the contract, those persons
being the directors themselves;
3. although the contract and prospectus were, on the evidence, misleading in certain
particulars which would have entitled the company at the time to repudiate the contract,
yet through the subsequent alteration of the property consequent on its being worked by
the company, the position of the parties had been so changed that they could not be
restored to their original position; and
4. the defendants, the directors, had not been guilty of such negligence or breach of trust as
to render them liable in damages in law for the loss occasioned to the company, or in
equity to make good the loss.
PRE-INCORPORATION CONTRACTS
S96(1) any contract or other transaction purporting to be entered into by the company or by any
person on behalf of the company prior to its formation may be ratified by the company after its
formation and thereupon the company shall become bound by and entitled to the benefit thereof
as if it has been in existence at the date of such contract or other transaction and had been a party
thereto.
S96(2) prior to ratification by the company, the person who purported to act in the name or on
behalf of the company shall, in the absence of express agreement to the contrary, be personally
bound by the contract or other transaction and entitled to the benefit thereof.
Pre-incorporation contracts entered into by person on behalf of a company before its
incorporation:
i. promotion agreements,
ii. preliminary agreements formation agreements,
iii. shareholders agreement,
iv. memorandum of undertaking,
v. Pre-incorporation agreements etc
75
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
76
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
where the terms of the original agreement are changed. Howard v Patent Ivory Manufacturing
Co, Touche v Metropolitan Railway Warehousing.
Also, in Edokpolo & Co Ltd v Sem-Edo Wire Industries Ltd (1984) 7 S.C. 119, the SC
unanimously upheld novation being a valid ground to make a pre-incorporation contract valid
and binding. Per Nnamani JSC “it seems to me with greatest respect that these conclusions
arise from the fact that the CA didn’t give due consideration to the case of the appellant which is
that there is a new contract between it and the 1st respondent (Sem-Edo Wire) subsequent to its
incorporation. The court’s whole consideration of the case appears to have been limited to the
pre-incorporation contract.” Per Bello JSC “the facts averred in the statement of claim which are
deemed to be true for the purpose of the objection taken in limine show that the appellant and the
1st respondent company entered into a new contract in the terms of the pre-incorporation
contract after the 1st respondent company had been incorporated. In the circumstance, the rule of
company law that a company is not bound by a pre-incorporation agreement entered into by its
promoters and that the company cannot ratify such agreement after its incorporation is
inapplicable to the facts of the case as pleaded in the statement of claim.”
Thus, in Nigeria, novation could not be unilaterally effected by the new corporation all by itself,
the third party must also give his assent until the decision in Edokpolo vs Sem-Edo Wire
Industries Ltd. Therein, on 27th October 1975, Edokpolo had executed a pre-incorporation
agreement with SEM Nigerian Holding GHBH and Company Hamburg, (a German company) to
create Sem-Edo Wire, i.e., that Edokpolo and the German Company would own 40% and 60%,
respectively in the new Sem-Edo Wire company. The agreement was incorporated into the
memorandum of the new company. The company was incorporated on 5th December 1975. On
27th February 1976, in breach, the new company after formation, allotted part of Edokpolo’s
40% to the chairman and the solicitor, despite a post-incorporation adoption of the share
allotment agreement by Sem-Edo Wire’s Board of Directors, i.e., that a new contract had been
created between Edokpolo and Sem-Edo Wire after incorporation on the same terms as the pre-
incorporation contract. Upholding the novation, Justice Nnamani, JSC, held that there was
nothing to prevent the new corporation from ratifying the pre-incorporation after its later
registration: But there is nothing preventing the company after incorporation from entering into a
new contract to put into effect the terms of the pre-incorporation contract. This new contract can
be in express terms or can be implied from the acts of the company after incorporation as well as
from the minutes of its general meetings and board meetings
In Newborne v Sensolid (Great Britain) Ltd, Mr Newborn was selling goods on behalf of the
Newborn company that was not incorporated. The contract was signed – Newborne (London)
Ltd and underneath was the name of the future director – Leopold Newborn. Held: Leopold
Newborne never purported to contract to sell nor sold the goods either as principal or agent. The
contract purported to be made by the company, on whose behalf it was signed by a future
director, and in as much as the company was non-existent at the material time, the contract was a
nullity.
77
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Parker J. The principle laid down in Kelner v. Baxter is that if a person contracts ostensibly as
agent for a non-existent principal . . . he can be held to be himself personally liable. . . It is plain
that this principle, that the agent is personally liable, . . . is based on this principle, that it is only
by holding him personally liable that any effect can be given to the contract.
Court of Appeal interpreted the finding of Kelner v Baxter in a different way and developed
the principle further. In this case an unformed company entered into a contract, the other
contracting party refused to perform his duty. Lord Goddard observed that before the
incorporation the company cannot be in existence, and if it is not in existence, then the contract
which the unformed company signed would also be not in existence. So, company cannot bring
an action for pre-incorporation contract, and also the promoter cannot bring the suit because they
were not the party to contract.
In the Nigerian case of Caligara vs Giovanni Sartori & Co Ltd., the Court followed the ruling
in Newbourne vs Sensolid Ltd. In December 1956, Giovanni had obtained a loan of £800.00
from Caligara by a cheque cashed on 24th January 1957, but Giovanni had obtained the loan in
the name of the proposed corporation. Honourable Justice Sowemimo, relying on Paragraph
824, Page 425 of Volume 6 of the Halsbury’s Laws of England, (3rd edition), held that the loan
transaction was a nullity and so rejected the argument that the later corporation was liable since
Mr. Sartori had not acted as an agent. Further, the court also held that the corporation could not
ratify the loan, since it had no legal capacity to confer any authority on the borrower: As I earlier
mentioned at the time the cheque was cashed, the defendant company was not in existence and it
could not be said to have taken the benefit of this contract. In the result, the Plaintiff’s claim
must fail. He has his remedy which he can enforce against the proper person
Societte Generale v Societte Generale Bank Nig Ltd 1997 4 NWLR 8 In 1976 three Nigerian
gentlemen entered into an agreement with the appellant to establish a bank in Nigeria, the
Societe Generale Bank (Nigeria) Ltd, the respondent in this matter. In December 1976, the
respondent was duly incorporated under the Companies Act, 1968. The appellant was to act as
manager of the respondent.
In July 1976, five months prior to the bank's incorporation, its founding members entered into
another agreement ("the July agreement"). On 8 March 1977 this agreement was ratified by the
respondent's board of directors.
The July agreement contained a clause that any dispute between the parties would be referred to
arbitration.
The relationship between the appellant and the respondent later started deteriorating, the
respondent accused the appellant, in its capacity as manager of the bank, of mismanagement and
negligence. As a result, the respondent terminated its contract with the appellant and in
December 1989 instituted action in the High Court of Lagos State for the recovery of more than
N190 million as well as the equivalent in Naira of an additional FF20.75 million from its former
manager.
78
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Thereupon the appellant, invoking the arbitration clause contained in the July agreement, applied
for a stay of proceedings. The matter was heard in January 1990 and in April 1990 the High
Court ordered a Stay of Execution.
The respondent successfully appealed to the Court of Appeal and the appellant now appealed to
this court against the latter ruling. In a cross-appeal, the respondent appealed against the Court of
Appeal's finding that the July agreement constituted a "pre-incorporation contract".
The appellant contended that the July agreement, and hence its arbitration clause, was binding on
the respondent. In support of that it relied upon the provisions of Sections 624 and 626 of the
Companies and Allied Matters Act ("CAMA") which make Section 72 of that Act have
retrospective application, clearly overriding Section 6 of the Interpretation Act as well as the
common law on retroactivity. The provisions of Section 624 make Section 72 apply not only to
companies formed under the Act, but also to existing companies, as was the case here.
Against this, the respondent argued that the relevant sections in CAMA should only apply to
ratification of an earlier agreement if the ratification took place after CAMA came into
operation, in January 1990. In this event, the July agreement was ratified in March 1977, and
after the respondent had been incorporated in December 1976. Nothing, it is contended, shows
that the legislature intended that after 1990 a company should be bound by ratification in 1977 of
a 1976 agreement
The appeal upheld and cross-appeal dismissed.
OGUNDARE, JSC: "Any contract or other transaction purporting to be entered into by Societe
Generale Bank (Nigeria) Limited or by any person on behalf of the company prior to its
formation and ratified by the company after its formation, the company shall become bound by
and entitled to the benefit therefore as if it has been in existence at the date of such contract or
other transaction and had been a party thereto."
WHAT IS THE LEGAL REGIME UNDER CAMA?
• By S96(1), a company upon incorporation can ratify all the pre-incorporation contracts
entered on its behalf. Thus, the company becomes bound and is entitled to the benefits
and obligations thereto.
• However, before such ratification, the person (or promoter) who purported to act in the
name or on behalf of the company shall be personally bound by the contract or
transaction and entitled to the benefits and obligations thereof S96(2).
CONFLICT BETWEEN PROVISIONS OF MEMART & PRE-INCORPORATION
CONTRACT
• Where there is a conflict between the memo and articles on one hand and the pre-
incorporation contract on the other hand, the provision of the memorandum & articles
shall prevail.
79
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Even where a “Supremacy clause” is inserted into the pre-incorporation contract, it would
still not go to erode the clear provision of the CAMA which in S46(1) describes the
memo and articles as superior contract of the company.
EFFECTS OF PRE-INCORPORATION CONTRACT ON THE MEMO AND ARTICLES
• The inclusion of the terms of a pre-incorporation contract in the object clause is the
intention to carry out such objects.
• NB, the inclusion of a pre-incorporation contract in the MEMO of a COY does not
impose extra liability on the COY, but amounts to no more than a serious desire by the
promoters that the proposed coy after its formation should execute the terms of the
contract Edokpolor & Co Ltd v Sem-Edowire.
• Provisions made in the Articles of Association on rules of management of the company,
the mgt and members of the company are bound to observe them.
INDICATIONS FOR PRE-INCORPORATION CONTRACTS
a. Payment of promoters’ expenses
b. Shareholder's agreement - need to secure interests of corporators
c. Takeover of business, or purchase of property
d. Joint - Venture especially between Nigerians and aliens
e. Conversion of partnership to registered company
f. Promoters/Directors' service contracts
TYPES OF PRE-INCORPORATION CONTRACTS
i. Joint venture agreement
ii. Shareholder’s agreement
iii. Contract for payment of promoter’s expenses
iv. Directors’ service contract
v. Contract for conversion of partnership into incorporated company
vi. Contract for acquisition of property
vii. Contract of Transfer of Technology
viii. Employment agreement
ix. Procurement agreement
x. Loan agreement
xi. Formation agreement etc.
CONTENTS OF SHAREHOLDERS’ AGREEMENT
1. Commencement (parties and dates)
“This Shareholders Agreement (or Joint Venture Agreement or whatever type) is made this
…………….. day of ………………. BETWEEN Chris Ozo Agbata of 15 Edupal Drive, Ikoyi,
Lagos, Gabriel Odii of 14 Johnso Drive, Manchester and Hafeez Yusuf of Simeon Close,
London.”
80
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
81
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
“Mr ……………….shall not either during or after the termination of the said appointment
divulge or communicate to any person or persons except to those of the officials of the company
whose province it is to know the same, any of the company’s secrets or any other information
which he may receive or obtain in relation to the company’s affairs or to the working or any
process or invention which is carried on or used by the company or which he may make or
discover while in the service of the company.”
20. Dispute Resolution
21. Pre-emptive rights
22. Winding up
23. Shareholders consent etc
JOINT VENTURE AGREEMENT
• A joint venture Agreement is more specific and formal than the memorandum of
understanding. Binding and enforceable terms.
• At this stage, parties are certain as to the terms of the venture.
• This also contains consideration or contributions.
• It is not unusual to find clauses in the MOU also in the JVA.
CONTENT OF JOINT VENTURE AGREEMENT
1. Parties and their description
2. Date
3. Recital
4. Nature of business
5. Registered office
6. Dividend policies
7. Financing accounts
8. Confidentiality
9. Restrictive covenants
10. Directors
11. Secretary
12. Winding up
13. Consideration
14. Dispute Resolution
15. Applicable law
16. Capital contribution
17. Admission of new partner
18. Transfer of technology, etc
82
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
POST-INCORPORATION MATTERS
PRELIMINARY STEPS BEFORE COMMENCEMENT OF BUSINESS
Three main activities that follow after incorporation are:
1. Trading from Registered Address/Head Office
2. Publication of Name
3. Keeping Statutory Books
4. Make Statutory Filings
REGISTERED AND HEAD OFFICE OF A COMPANY S728
• After registration, a company must trade or operate from its registered address and if any
change should occur, it must notify the CAC in writing within 14 days. Even it was
already operating prior to the commencement of CAMA 2020, it must within 14 days
comply and the address must be a physical address not an online one. Failure to comply
attracts a penalty of fine, the amount of which is to be prescribed in the regulations
periodically.
CERTIFICATE OF INCORPORATION
• Upon registration, a certificate of incorporation will be issued. The certificate must be
displayed conspicuously by the company in all its offices.
PUBLICATION OF NAME BY COMPANY S729
• Every company, after incorporation, shall—
a. paint or affix, and keep painted or affixed, its name and registration number on the
outside of every office or place in which its business is carried on, in a conspicuous
position, in letters easily legible;
b. have its name engraved in legible characters on its seal, where the company has a
seal; and
c. have its name and registration number mentioned in legible characters in all business
letters of the company and in all notices, advertisements, and other official
publications of the company, and in all bills of exchange, promissory notes,
endorsements, cheques, and orders for money or goods purporting to be signed by or
on behalf of the company, and in all bills or parcels, invoices, receipts, and letters of
credit of the company.
• Failure to comply attracts fine penalty, to be prescribed by the regulations.
SUMMARY:
1. Publication of name in name plate
2. Publication of name in common seal
3. Publication of name in official documents and bill of exchanges
4. Publication of name on invoices and receipts
5. Publication on letterheads
83
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
84
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
85
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
distinguishing each share by its number so long as the share has a number, and of the
amount paid or agreed to be considered as paid on the shares of each member
• date on which each person was registered as a member
• date on which any person ceased to be a member
• entry shall be made within 28 days of the conclusion of the agreement with the company
to become a member or, in the case of a subscriber of the memorandum, within 28 days
of the registration of the company
• if the person ceases to be a member, entry is also within 28 days or if not at the instance
of the co, within 28 days that it got to co’s knowledge.
• Where a co defaults, it shall be liable to a fine as may be prescribed in the regulation
• Time limitation to enforce action for entry or removal is 20 years.
• Usually kept at the registered office of the company
• Can be kept at another office of the company or where it is made up, but must be within
Nigeria and CAC must be notified.
• CAC must be notified of any change in location of the reg within 28 days, failure
attracts fine to be prescribed in the regulation.
86
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• The entry required under this section shall be made within 30 days of the conclusion of
the agreement with the company to become a debenture holder or within 30 days of the
date at which he ceases to be one.
• The register except when closed shall be open to debenture holders, members of the
company and the public.
87
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
11. REGISTER OF SECRETARIES (MUST FOR PUBLIC COS); S336, 337 and 338
• Every public company shall maintain a register of secretaries which shall contain;
• in the case of an individual—
i. full name and any former name or names;
ii. address; and
iii. email address.
• For the purposes of this section a “former name” means a name by which the individual
was formerly known.
• The register may not contain particulars of a former name where the former name—
88
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
i. was changed or disused before the person attained the age of 18 years; or
ii. has been changed or disused for 20 years or more.
• The address required to be stated in the register is a service address which may be stated
to be the company’s registered office.
• in the case of a body corporate, or a firm—
i. corporate or firm name;
ii. registered or principal office; and
iii. email address.
• If all the partners in a firm are joint secretaries it is sufficient to state the particulars that
would be required if the firm were a legal person and the firm had been appointed
secretary.
• If the business of the company involves dealing in goods, the accounting records shall
contain—
i. statements of stocks held by the company at the end of each year of the company;
ii. all statements of stocktakings from which any such statement of stock as is mentioned
in paragraph (a) has been or is to be prepared; and
iii. except in the case of goods sold by way of ordinary retail trade, statements of all
goods sold and purchased, showing the goods and the buyers and sellers in sufficient
detail to enable all these to be identified.
• Each public company shall keep its audited accounts displayed on its website.
• It must be kept at the registered office of the company or any other place within Nigeria
as approved by the directors.
• It shall at all times be open to inspection by the officers of the company.
89
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
8. The company after the change of name has been approved by the CAC will:
90
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
i. Alter the common seal, certificates, letter heads; etc of the company;
ii. Alter the memorandum and articles of association of the company; and
iii. Advertise the change of name in a daily newspaper circulating nation-wide
NB: if its compulsory change of name, then the procedure may include;
1. Amendment request letter by the company whose name is infringed to the erring
company to change its name voluntarily.
2. Protest letter from the existing company to the CAC where the erring company doesn’t
act accordingly.
3. Investigation by CAC
4. Direction by CAC, the erring company may be directed to change its name within 6
weeks or such other period as CAC may direct if it found that it infringed the name of the
exiting company.
CAC REQUIREMENTS/DOCUMENTS FOR THE CHANGE OF COMPANY NAME
a. Availability search and reservation of new name
b. Notice of change of the name of a company (Form CAC 3) - to be authorised by a
director, secretary or any other appropriate officer of the company
c. Special resolution stating the change desired, duly signed by director(s) of the company
d. Surrender of the original certificate of incorporation for cancellation
e. Payment of filing fees
f. Up-to-date annual returns
g. The company’s memorandum and articles as proposed to be amended
h. Compliance with S733 (where applicable)
NB: Does a change of name affect the rights and liabilities of the company? S30 (6) CAMA.
91
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Dear Sir,
APPLICATION FOR CONSENT TO CHANGE THE NAME OF EDUPAL NIGERIA
LIMITED PURSUANT TO SECTION 30(3) OF THE COMPANIES AND ALLIED
MATTERS ACT, 2020
We are members of the Board of Directors above Company instructed to apply for approval of
the Commission for the name of the above company to be changed to GOD’S FAVOUR LTD.
Please find enclosed, all the documents legally necessary to effect the change.
The circumstances which make the change of name desirable are as follows:
1. to make the name of the company reflect the true nature of the business of the company
as a public company.
2. to make the company easily identifiable.
Thank you.
Yours faithfully,
________________
Chris Ozo Agbata Esq
Company Secretary
Enclosed:
1. Special Resolution dated 15th of August, 2022
92
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Dear Sir,
PROTEST AND REQUEST TO COMPEL EDUPAL BEST NIGERIA LIMITED TO CHANGE
ITS NAME PURSUANT TO SECTION 30(1)(4) OF THE COMPANIES AND ALLIED
MATTERS ACT, 2020
It has come to our notice that a certain company has been registered as EDUPAL BEST
NIGERIA LIMITED, on the 19th day of March, 2022 with RC number 458540, a name which
infringes on our corporate name. As a company we came into existence on the 13th day of
March, 2020 with RC number 151025 and have so carried on business in that corporate name till
now.
It is pertinent to state that our business goodwill is likely to be endangered should both
companies be allowed to co-exist. The public will likely be deceived as to whether we are now
operating under a new name. It is therefore imperative that the Commission compels the new
company to change its name.
We have attached a copy of our Certificate of Incorporation as evidence of incorporation.
Please compel EDUPAL BEST NIGERIA LIMITED, to change its name or we may be forced to
take necessary legal actions.
Thank you.
Yours faithfully,
________________
Chris Ozo Agbata Esq
Company Secretary
Enclosed:
Certificate of Incorporation of EDUPAL NIGERIA LIMITED
93
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
……………… …………………
Director Director
94
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
……………… …………………
Director Director
95
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
96
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
ii. a certified true copy of the order, in the case of confirmation of the resolution together
with a printed copy of the memorandum as altered; and
b. no application is made with respect to confirmation to a Court under this section, the
company shall, within 15 days from the end of the period for making such an
application, deliver to the Commission a copy of the resolution as passed.
(8) If the Commission—
a. is satisfied, a printed copy of the memorandum as altered by the resolution shall forthwith
be delivered to it;
b. is not satisfied, it shall give notice in writing to the company of its decision and an appeal
from its decision shall thereafter lie to the Court at the suit of any person aggrieved and
such appeal shall be made within 21 days from the date of the receipt by the company of
the notice of rejection, or within such extended time as the Court may allow.
(9) The Court may at any time extend the time for the delivery of documents to the Commission
under subsection (7) (a) for such period as the Court may consider proper.
(10) If a company defaults in giving notice or delivering any document to the Commission as
required by subsection (7), the company and every officer of the company who is in default is
liable to such penalty as the Commission shall prescribe by regulation, and for every day during
which the default continues.
(11) The validity of an alteration of the provision of a company’s memorandum with respect to
the business or objects of the company shall not be questioned on the ground that it was not
authorised by subsection (1) except in proceedings taken for the purpose (whether under this
section or otherwise) before the expiration of 21 days after the date of the resolution in that
behalf, and where such proceedings are taken otherwise than under this section, subsections (6),
(7), (8) and (9) of this section shall apply in relation thereto as if they had been taken under this
section, and as if any order declaring the alteration invalid were an order cancelling it and as if
any order dismissing the proceedings were an order confirming the alteration.
(12) For the purpose of this section only, any reference to “member” includes any person
financially interested in the company within the context of subsection (2) (b).
SUMMARY OF S51: this applies mutatis mutandis to all alterations except change of name
which must be in line with S30 and alteration of capital which must be in line with SS128 – 130.
1. Board of directors resolution proposing the alteration (in whole or in part) in the
object of the company
2. Secretary to issue notice (in writing) of GM – 21 days is to be given to all members of
the company and debenture holders secured by floating charge
3. Holding of general meeting and passing of special resolution for alteration of the
business or objects of the company as contained in the memorandum of association.
4. all the members and debenture holder have the right to object only if they voted
against and they have 28 days to do so.
97
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
5. the objectors must old 15% of share or be 15% of members in Ltd and Ltd/Gte
respectively
6. application to alter the memo must be made within 28 days following the resolution
either all of those entitle or by those they shall appoint in writing on their behalf
7. the co shall forthwith apply to court for confirmation of the resolution
8. the co shall within 15 days deliver to CAC the court order whether confirming the
resolution or not
9. the co will file a CTC of the court order if denied but if confirmed or granted, it will
file a CTC of the court order and a copy of the altered memo.
10. if the co defaults in delivering the docs in time, it shall be liable to a fine to be
determined by regulation.
11. if CAC is satisfied, the co should deliver a copy of the altered memo to it
12. if the CAC is dissatisfied and declines, the co has 21 days to appeal to court
13. the validity of the alteration of the memo can be question in any proceedings before
the expiration of the 21 days following the special resolution for the alteration.
14. The court may make any of the following orders:
i. An order confirming the alteration either wholly or in part and on such terms and
conditions as it thinks fit;
ii. An order for an arrangement to be made to purchase the interests of dissenting
members of the company; and
iii. Give such directions and make such orders as it thinks expedient for facilitating or
carrying into effect any such arrangement.
15. If the appeal succeeds, within 15 days from the court order deliver to Corporate
Affairs Commission, a certified true copy of the court order and printed copy of the
memorandum as altered
CHANGE OF REGISTERED ADDRESS OF A COMPANY SS 50 & 51
S50(5) provides that subject to section 54, any other provision of the memorandum maybe
altered in accordance with section 51, or as otherwise provided in this Act. In other words,
change business name (by virtue of S27) being a content of the memorandum will be amended or
changed following the procedure laid down in S51. The procedure is outlined and summarised
above, but below is what is obtainable in practice;
• Board resolution
• Convene general meeting where special resolution will be passed
• Deliver to Corporate Affairs Commission:
i. Form CAC 3 duly signed by a director and company secretary; and
ii. evidence of payment of Annual Returns
• Upon approval by the Corporate Affairs Commission, the company will publish the
change of its registered address to its customers and the rest of the public
98
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Issued at nominal value: this means same thing as issued at par above but issued at
nominal value is the term used in CAMA. By ss 38(1), 39(1), 154(1) and 158(1) a share
may be issued at nominal value or at premium. So, if its issued at par or face value, it
may be said to be issued at nominal value.
ii. Issued at premium: By s145(1) Shares of a company may be issued at a premium. This,
as explained above is when it is issued above the face value. The rise in price of the
shares is subject to market forces of demand and supply usually influenced by the
99
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
reputation of the company and financial projections. See SEC Act and Investment and
Securities Act on the regulations and fixing of prices of various shares.
iii. Issued at discount: By s146 It is unlawful for a company to issue shares at a discount.
This means that a company is not allowed to issue its shares below the face value.
iv. Issued redeemable preference shares: By s147 (1) No company limited by shares shall,
after the commencement of this Act issue any preference shares which are irredeemable.
But subsection (2) provides that A company limited by shares may, if so authorized by
its articles, issue preference shares which are liable to be redeemed subject to such
conditions as may be prescribed in the terms of issue or in the articles of the company.
Section 868 provides that a "preference share" means a share, by whatever name
designated, which does not entitle the holder of it to any right to participate beyond a
specified amount in any distribution whether by way of dividend or on redemption, in a
winding up, or otherwise. A share which entitles the holder to a fixed dividend, whose
payment takes priority over that of ordinary share dividends (Equity holders) and the
shares usually do not carry voting rights. Preferred shareholders have prior claim on a
company's assets if it is liquidated, though they remain subordinate to bondholders.
NB: redeemability means that the company can repurchase the shares.
v. Equity Share Capital: s868 "equity share" means a share other than a preference share.
In other words, any share that’s not a preference share is an equity share.
There are two subvariants of issued capital which are Subscribed and Unsubscribed.
i. Subscribed: this includes the shares that are offered to the public for subscription and
actually subscribed by the insiders of the company or outsiders. It may be paid up,
calls-in-arrears, called up or uncalled. There are three variants of subscribed
capital.
➢ Called-up: By s 158(1) Subject to the terms of the issue of the shares and of
the articles, the directors may make calls upon the members in respect of any
money unpaid on their shares (whether on account of the nominal value of the
shares or by way of premium) and not by the conditions of allotment of the
shares made payable at fixed times.
Provided that no call shall exceed one fourth of the nominal value of the share
or be payable at less than one month from the date fixed for the payment of
100
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
the last preceding call, and each member shall (subject to receiving at least 14
days’ notice specifying the time or times and place of payment) pay to the
company at the time or times and place so specified the amount called on his
shares, so however that a call may be revoked or postponed as the directors
may determine.
Flowing from the above, this refers to the part of the uncalled capital that the
company has actually requested or demanded (called) for the subscribers to
pay for. When this happens, it becomes a debt (call-in-arrears) on the
subscriber and as long as it lasts may be paid with interest. Allen v Gold
Reefs of WA.
There are two variants of Called-up capital viz: paid-up and calls-in-
arrears.
o Paid-up: This is the part of the issued shares that have actually been
paid for by the subscribers or holders. Most of the times when a
company issue shares especially at incorporation, they are usually not
all paid for immediately or they may be paid for in part. Thus, the parts
that are fully paid for are referred to as paid-up shares. Ss 131(2),
145(3)
o Calls-in-arrears: the company has made calls for the shares to be paid
up but the holder has not paid. E.g., Allen v Gold Reefs of WA.
➢ Uncalled: Flowing from the above, the part of the issued shares which have
neither been paid-up nor called to be paid-up are referred to as uncalled
shares. In other words, they are still not paid for by the subscribers who are
owing the company, so until the company requests or demands (calls) for the
shares to be paid for, they are called uncalled shares.
101
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
ii. Unsubscribed: this is a part of issued capital that is not yet subscribed by either the
members of the company or the public.
2. UNISSUED
This is the part of a company’s capital that is not yet issued or offered to either the members or
public for subscription. Other variants of unissued share capital include:
i. Share premium account: NB: refer to 1ii above
By s145(2) Where a company issues shares at a premium, whether for cash or otherwise,
a sum equal to the aggregate amount or value of the premium on those shares shall be
transferred to, “the share premium account”
(4) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in subsection (2), the share premium
account may be applied by the company in:
(a) paying up unissued shares of the company to be issued to members of the co as fully-
paid bonus shares;
(c) writing off the expenses of, or the commission paid on any issue of shares of the co;
or
(d) providing for the premium payable on redemption of any redeemable share of the co.
102
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
ii. The capital redemption reserve account: NB: refer to 1v above for meaning.
(4) Where shares are redeemed otherwise than out of the proceeds of a fresh issue, there
shall, out of profits which would otherwise have been available for dividend, be
transferred to a reserve fund, to be called “the capital redemption reserve account”, a
sum equal to the nominal amount of the shares redeemed, and the provisions of this Act
relating to the reduction of the share capital of a company shall, except as provided in this
section, apply as if the capital redemption reserve fund were paid-up share capital of the
company.
iii. Reserve funds: This is generally the amount which by the discretion of the directors may
be removed from the profits made by the company to be reinvested or ploughed back into
the business in any manner to yield profit for the company but cannot be deployed into
purchasing of the company’s shares.
(1) The directors may, before recommending any dividend, set aside out of the profits of
the company such sums as they think proper as a reserve or reserves which shall, at the
discretion of the directors, be applicable for any purpose to which the profits of the
company may be properly applied, and pending such application may, at the discretion,
either be employed in the business of the company or be invested in such investments
(other than shares of the company) as the directors think fit, and the directors may
without placing the same to reserve, carry forward any profits which they may think
prudent not to distribute.
(2) The company in general meeting may upon the recommendation of the directors
resolve that it is desirable to capitalise any part of the amount, for the time being,
standing to the credit of any of the company’s reserve accounts or to the credit of the
profit and loss account or available for distribution.
iv. Fixed capital: s868 "fixed capital" means that capital which a company retains in the
form of assets upon which the subscribed capital or other sum has been expended, and
which assets either themselves produced income, independent of any further action by the
company, or being retained by the company are made use of to produce income or gain
profits.
2. NON-CASH ASSET
s868 "non-cash asset" means any property or interest in property other than cash and for this
purpose, cash includes foreign currency.
103
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
3. LOAN CAPITAL
According to Abugu, this refers to debt instruments and securities issued by the company,
particularly debentures (being that portion of a company’s capital that is raised through
borrowing). The term is widely used by businessmen but it is legally inappropriate as the holders
of the debt instruments e.g., debenture holders are creditors of the company, not members. Loans
whilst considered as part of the trading capital of a company, in determining ‘net worth’, they are
classed on the side of liabilities and not as part of capital.
ALTERATION OF SHARE CAPITAL SS 128 – 130
Under sections 125
Section 125: Alteration of share capital by consolidation, etc.
125. A company having a share capital may in general meeting and not otherwise, alter the
conditions of its memorandum to —
(a) consolidate and divide all or any part of its share capital into shares of larger amount than its
existing shares; and
(b) subdivide its shares or any of them, into shares of smaller amount than is fixed by the
memorandum, but in the subdivision the proportion between the amount paid and the amount
unpaid on each reduced share shall be the same as it was in the case of the share from which the
reduced share is derived.
Based on CAMA 2019, there are only 2 principal ways to alter a share, which are by
Consolidation/Division in 125(a) and Subdivision in 125(b). Both Conversion and Cancellation
in the old CAMA 1990 have now been expunged and also the removal of the proviso to section
83(1) in the old CAMA on adding stocks in the register in its equivalence of section 109(1)
CAMA 2019 confirms this.
Consolidation and Division into Shares of Larger Amount: by virtue of s 125(a), a company
may consolidate and divide all or any of its shares into shares of larger amount than its existing
shares. However, this can only be done by the alteration of the conditions in the MOA in a
general meeting.
Subdivision of Shares into Shares of Smaller Amount: this can occur by virtue of s 125(b)
where for instance a company with N1m shares of N1 each subdivides into N2m shares of
50kobo each but in the subdivision the proportion between the amount paid and the amount
unpaid on each reduced share shall be the same as it was in the case of the share from which the
reduced share is derived.
INCREASE OF CAPITAL
S127: Increase of issued share capital and notice of increase.
(1) A company having a share capital, may in general meeting and not otherwise, increase its
issued share capital by the allotment of new shares of such amount as it considers expedient.
104
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
(2) Where a company increased its share capital, it shall, within 15 days after the passing of the
resolution authorising the increase, give to the Commission notice of the increase and the
Commission shall record the increase.
(3) Where, in connection with the increase of shares, any approval is required to be obtained
under any enactment other than this Act, the company shall give notice of that fact to the
Commission within 15 days after the passing of the resolution authorising the increase, together
with an affidavit sworn to by a director of the company to that effect, and upon receipt of the
notice and affidavit by the Commission, the period of 15 days stated in subsection (2) is deemed
extended, for a period terminating no later than 10 days after receipt of the approval is required
to be obtained by the company under an enactment other than this Act.
(4) If the company has not obtained the required approval under an enactment other than this Act
within 48 days of the date on which it notified the Commission under subsection (3), the
company shall file another notice and affidavit to that effect with the Commission, and shall do
so for every successive period of 48 days that elapses after the date on which it first notified the
Commission under subsection (3).
(5) If the Company fails to obtain the approval that is required to be obtained under an enactment
other than this Act within nine months from the date on which it first notified the Commission
under subsection (3), the resolution increasing the company’s issued share capital becomes null
and void.
(6) The notice to be given under this section includes the particulars prescribed with respect to
the classes of shares affected and the condition subject to which the new shares have been or are
to be issued and the notice shall be accompanied by a printed copy of the resolution authorising
the increase.
(7) If default is made in complying with the provisions of this section, the company in default is
liable to such fine as the Commission may prescribe by regulation for every day during which
the default continues.
(8) Where a company increases its share capital, it shall be by an ordinary resolution and shall
amend its memorandum and articles of association to reflect the new issued share capital.
Section 128: Increase of issued capital on increase of shares.
128. (1) Where a company allots new shares, thereby increasing its issued share capital, the
increase shall not take effect unless —
(a) at least 25% of the share capital including the increase has been paid up; and
(b) the directors have delivered to the Commission a statutory declaration verifying that fact.
(2) Where a company fails to comply with the applicable subsection, it shall be liable to such
fine as the Commission may prescribe by regulation for every day during which the default
continues
105
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
106
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
107
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
which N25 has been paid, the company may reduce them to N25 fully paid-up shares and thus
relieve the shareholders from liability on the uncalled capital of N25 per share.
(b) either with or without extinguishing or reducing liability on any of its shares, cancel any
paid-up share capital which is lost or unrepresented by available assets, or
Example- if the shares of face value of N50 each fully paid-up is represented by N25 worth of
assets. In such a case, reduction of share capital may be effected by cancelling N25 per share and
writing off similar amount of assets.
This is also known as capital loss or loss of capital reduction which occurs probably where a
company’s asset e.g., a building that is uninsured is gutted by fire or where there is diminution in
value e.g., for whatever reason it is now worth less than the original value or it is disposed or
sold at a lesser value. The company can cancel shares in order to ensure that its shares are
represented by its available assets to cover up for the capital loss in the lost asset.
If reduction is to be effected because of the loss of capital or because the capital is not
represented by available assets, evidence of such loss and that the capital is not represented by
available assets must be given. A reduction may be confirmed where capital has been lost but
still represented by available assets Sugar Refineries Ltd Petitioners, Re Hoare & Co Ltd.
(c) either with or without extinguishing or reducing liability on any of its shares, cancel any
paid-up share capital which is in excess of the company’s wants,
Example- shares of face value of N50 each fully paid-up can be reduced to face value of N25
each by paying back or cancelling N25 per share.
This occurs when a company has more paid-up shares than its needed. The company can arrive
at this decision by financial projections. This may also include buying back such shares section
132 (2) (b) i.e., paying the owners of the shares the money they initially paid to purchase them
from profits it had made.
and the company may, if and so far as is necessary, alter its memorandum by reducing the
amount of its share capital and of its shares accordingly.
(3) A special resolution under this section shall in this Act be referred to as “a resolution for
reducing share capital”.
S132: Application to Court for Order of Confirmation
(1) Where a company has passed a resolution for reducing share capital, it may apply to the
court for an order confirming the reduction.
(2) If the proposed reduction of share capital involves either—
(a) diminution of liability in respect of unpaid share capital; or
(b) subject to subsection (6), the payment to a shareholder of any paid-up share capital, and in
any other case if the Court so directs, subsection (3), (4) and (5) shall have effect.
108
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
It is apparent from the (a) and (b) that they both involve diminution of capital as the former is
direct diminution of liability of unpaid shares while the latter is repurchasing of paid-up shares
which further depletes the company’s capital albeit it’s done from profits that is supposed to
serve as dividend Section 185, Payment for share buyback: Where a company buys back its
shares, payment for the share buyback shall be made from the distributable profits of the
company. It was held in Poole v National Bank of China that where the reduction does not
involve a diminution of the liability in respect of unpaid capital, the creditors are not concerned.
Where the creditors aren’t concerned, the court would consider the following questions;
a) Should the court refuse its sanction to the reduction out of regard to the interest of those
members of the public who may be induced to take shares in the company?
b) Whether it is fair and equitable as between the shareholders as it must provide for
uniform treatment of shareholders with similar rights.
c) Is the reduction fair and equitable as between the different classes of shareholders?
(3) Every creditor of the company who, at the date fixed by the court, is entitled to any debt or
claim which, if that date were the commencement of the winding up of the company, would be
admissible in proof against the company, is entitled to object to the reduction of capital.
(4) The Court shall settle a list of creditors entitled to object, and for that purpose—
(a) shall ascertain, as far as possible without requiring an application from any creditor, the
names of those creditors and the nature and amount of the debts or claims; and
(b) may publish notices fixing a day or days within which creditors not entered on the list are to
claim to be so entered or are to be excluded from the right of objecting to the reduction of
capital.
(5) If a creditor entered on the list whose debt or claim is not discharged or has not been
determined does not consent to the reduction, the Court may, if it deems fit, dispense with the
consent of that creditor, on the company securing payment of his debt or claim by
appropriating (as the Court may direct) the following amount if the company —
(a) admits the full amount of the debt or claim or, though not admitting it, is willing to provide
for the full amount of the debt or claim; or
(b) does not admit, and is not willing to provide for, the full amount of the debt or claim, or
if the amount is contingent or not ascertained, then an amount fixed by the court after the like
enquiry and adjudication as if the company were being wound up by the Court.
(6) If a proposed reduction of share capital involves either the diminution of any liability in
respect of unpaid share capital or the payment to any shareholder of any paid-up share capital,
the Court may, if having regard to any special circumstance of the case it considers proper to do
so, direct that subsections (3) - (5) shall not apply as regards any class or classes of creditors.
It was held in Poole v National Bank of China and followed in Re Meux’s Brewery Co Ltd
that where the reduction does not involve a diminution of the liability in respect of unpaid
capital, the creditors are not concerned and thus cannot object except they can show a strong
109
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
case. Ashbury J in Re Meux’s Brewery held “I think it is quite clear from s 49(1) that there is
power in the court to permit a creditor to object to a reduction where no such diminution of
assets is about to take place, but from the framing of the section, and after considering the
observations of Lord Macnaghten in Poole v National Bank of China., I think that I am at
least right in saying that prima facie creditors are not supposed to be concerned in these
questions of reduction of capital where no diminution of unpaid capital or repayment to
shareholders of paid-up capital is involved; in other words, if the court is to allow a secured
creditor in particular to object to a reduction which does not involve such a diminution of assets
as is referred to in s 49(1), it is at least incumbent on him to make out a strong case before such a
direction would be given.”
S133: Court order confirming reduction.
(1) The Court, if satisfied—
(a) with respect to every creditor of the company who under section 132 is entitled to object
to the reduction of capital, that either—
(i) his consent to the reduction has been obtained, or
(ii) his debt or claim has been discharged or determined or secured; and
(b) that the share capital does not by this reduction fall below the minimum issued share
capital, may make an order confirming the reduction on such terms and conditions as it deems
fit.
(2) Where the Court so orders, it may also—
(a) if for any special reason it considers it proper to do so, make an order directing that the
company shall, during such period (commencing on or at any time after the date of the order) as
is specified in the order, add to its name as its last words “and reduced”; and
(b) make an order requiring the company to publish (as the court directs) the reasons for
reduction of capital or such other information in regard to it as the court considers expedient with
a view to giving proper information to the public and (if the court deems fit) the causes which led
to the reduction.
(3) Where the company is ordered to add to its name the words, “and reduced”, those words
shall, until the expiration of the period specified in the order, be deemed to be part of the
company’s name.
ALTERATION OF MEMORANDUM OF ASSOCIATION SS 49, 50 & 51
Other clauses in the memorandum of association can be altered like the object/business clause.
Alteration of the memo is in line with SS50 & 51, explained above. Note the difference between
conditions and other provisions as provided in S49 and also the entrenchment principle in
S52(2).
110
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
111
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
……………… …………………
Director Director
112
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
……………… …………………
Director Director
NB: you have to choose either of the body paragraphs for the purpose of bar finals, depending on
how the question is framed, first extinguishes liability of the unpaid shares, second reduces
shares unrepresented by available assets and third, reduces shares in excess of company’s wants.
Thus, they apply mutatis mutandis.
113
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
114
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
iv. If share has been issued for consideration other then money, it shall have been
performed or discharged or the co can enter a contract not exceeding 5 years from
resolution date with that holder.
v. There is an exception of shares issued to employees but the shares will not count
as issued shares and should not taken up more than 1/10 of the entire issued
shares.
8. Requirements as to assets in line with S58, must obtain the following
i. Balance sheet of not more than 7 months from the date of application
ii. unqualified report by the company’s auditor on that balance sheet
iii. a written statement by the company’s auditor that, in his opinion at the balance
sheet date, the amount of the company’s net assets was not less than the aggregate
of its called-up share capital and undistributable reserves.
iv. After tendering the balance sheet, before re-registration, there shall be no change
to make the net assets be less than the called-up capital and the undistributable
reserves
9. Recent allotment of shares for non-cash consideration S59
i. This applies to the shares issued between the date balance sheet was prepared and
passing of the resolution
ii. as fully or partly paid up as to their nominal value or any premium on them
otherwise than in cash
iii. CAC shall not accept the co for re-registration except the conditions in S57 above
have been met on allotment of shares
iv. Shares held by the Co’s nominees, nominee of the holding co, nominee of the
subsidiary co, or nominee of the subsidiary of the holding co shall be disregarded
10. Application for reregistration as a public company S60, the app shall contain;
i. a statement of the company’s proposed name on re-registration; and
ii. in the case of a co without a secretary, a statement of the company’s proposed
secretary.
The application shall be accompanied by;
i. a copy of the special resolution that the co should re-register as a public co
ii. a copy of the company’s memart as proposed to be amended
iii. a copy of the balance sheet and other documents referred to in s58 (1); and
iv. if s59 applies, a copy of the valuation report (if any) under subsection (2) (a) of
that section.
v. Statement of compliance that the co has complied with CAMA
11. Issue of certificate of incorporation on reregistration, this is if CAC is satisfied that the co
has met all the conditions and complied with CAMA.
12. NB: for this and all the re-registrations below, you must include the following docs;
i. Evidence of availability
ii. Annual returns
iii. Filing fees
iv. Certificate of re-registration issued
v. Form CAC 4, for re-registration notification
115
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
9. A person who consented to or voted in favour of the resolution for alteration cannot bring
an application for cancellation of the resolution to the court.
10. The applicant will give notice of application to court for cancellation of the resolution to
Corporate Affairs Commission and also to the company
11. The court on getting such an application can make any of the following orders:
i. make that order on such terms and conditions as it deems fit
ii. if it deems fit, adjourn the proceedings in order that an arrangement may be made to
the satisfaction of the Court for the purchase of the interests of dissenting members
iii. give such directions, and make such orders, as it considers expedient for facilitating
or carrying into effect any such arrangement.
12. The company shall within 15 days from the date the court made the order deliver a copy
of the order to CAC
13. Default to notify CAC as stated will attract a penalty of fine to be state in the regulation
APPLICATION FOR REREGISTRATION AS A PUBLIC LIMITED COMPANY S66
1. An application for re-registration as a private limited company shall contain a statement
of the company’s proposed name on re-registration.
2. The application shall be accompanied by a copy of the—
i. resolution that the company should re-register as a private limited company; and
ii. company’s memorandum and articles as proposed to be amended.
3. The statement of compliance required to be delivered together with the application is a
statement that the requirements of this Part as to reregistration as a private limited
company have been complied with.
4. The commission may accept the statement of compliance as sufficient evidence that the
company is entitled to be re-registered as a private limited company.
5. If satisfied, CAC will issue certificate incorporation altered to meet the circumstances.
116
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• The Commission may accept the statement of compliance as sufficient evidence that the
company is entitled to be re-registered as an unlimited company.
• If satisfied, CAC will issue certificate incorporation altered to meet the circumstances.
• NB; the numbers 1 – 6 above under S63 apply
• NB: you must include the following docs;
117
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
i. Evidence of availability
ii. Annual returns
iii. Filing fees
iv. Certificate of re-registration issued
v. Form CAC 4, for re-registration notification
REREGISTRATION OF UNLIMITED COMPANY AS LIMITED S71
An unlimited company may be re-registered as a private limited company if—
• a special resolution that it should be re-registered is passed;
• an application for re-registration is delivered to the Commission in accordance with
section 72, together with—
i. the other documents required by that section, and
ii. a statement of compliance.
• The condition is that the company has not previously been reregistered as unlimited.
• The special resolution shall state whether the company is to be limited by shares or by
guarantee.
• The company shall make such changes—
i. in its name; and
ii. in its memorandum and articles, as are necessary in connection with its becoming a
company limited by shares or, as the case may be, by guarantee
118
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• If satisfied, CAC will issue certificate incorporation altered to meet the circumstances.
• NB; the numbers 1 – 6 above under S63 apply
• NB: you must include the following docs;
i. Evidence of availability
ii. Annual returns
iii. Filing fees
iv. Certificate of re-registration issued
v. Form CAC 4, for re-registration notification
REREGISTRATION OF PUBLIC COMPANY AS UNLIMITED S75
A public company limited by shares may be re-registered as an unlimited company with a share
capital if—
• all the members of the company have assented to its being so reregistered;
• an application for re-registration is delivered to the registrar in accordance with section
76, together with—
i. the other documents required by that section, and
ii. a statement of compliance.
• The condition is that the company has not previously been reregistered as —
i. limited; or
ii. unlimited.
119
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
ii. if any of the members has not authenticated that form himself, that the directors have
taken all reasonable steps to satisfy themselves that each person who authenticated it
on behalf of a member was lawfully empowered to do so.
• If satisfied, CAC will issue certificate incorporation altered to meet the circumstances.
• NB; the numbers 1 – 6 above under S63 apply
• NB: you must include the following docs;
i. Evidence of availability
ii. Annual returns
iii. Filing fees
iv. Certificate of re-registration issued
v. Form CAC 4, for re-registration notification
CORPORATE SEARCHES
• Corporate search is conducted at the CAC to ascertain the profile or status, legal
compliance of a company to legal requirements and standing of a company
• It is necessary in the following circumstances:
1. Opening of bank account
2. Application of loan facility from bank or other financial institutions
3. Conducting due diligence/ legal auditing
4. Verification of profile of a company
5. Ascertaining whether a company is registered or not
6. During investigation of a company
PROCEDURE FOR CONDUCTING CORPORATE SEARCHES
1. Complete CAC prescribed form for search and CTC of documents
2. Write application to CAC to conduct search
3. Payment of search and CTC prescribed fees
4. Payment of AR(annual returns), where requested
5. After the search, prepare the search report attaching the CTC of relevant documents
CONTENTS OF CORPORATE SEARCH REPORT
1. Clients Name:
2. Address of Client:
3. Date of Search:
4. Place of Search:
5. Name of Company:
6. Change of name (if Any):
7. Registered Office address:
8. Registered Certificate Number:
9. Date of Incorporation:
10. Business/Object:
11. Directors and addresses:
12. Share Capital:
120
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Dear Sir,
APPLICATION TO CONDUCT CORPORATE SEARCH ON EDUPAL NIGERIA LIMITED
We are the external solicitors to ALLS Bank Plc which intends to open and operate an account
for Edupal Nigeria Limited. Thus, we kindly seek your permission to conduct a corporate search
on Edupal Nigeria Limited which claim to be a Nigerian company registered under the
Companies and Allied Matters Act, 2020.
Please find enclosed evidence of payment of search fees, fees for CTC and evidence of annual
returns filed.
Thank you.
Yours faithfully,
________________
Chris Ozo Agbata
(Principal Partner)
For: C O Agbata LP
121
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Enclosed:
1. Receipt of search fees
2. Receipt of CTC fees
3. Updated annual returns
122
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Dear Sir,
COVER LETTER FOR SEARCH REPORT
We are Solicitors engaged in the corporate search of Edupal Nigeria Limited, carried out at the
Corporate Affairs Commission, Maitama, Abuja.
We are pleased to inform you that the said corporate search has been successfully carried out as
instructed.
Please find attached a search report of Edupal Nigeria Limited.
Thank you.
Yours faithfully,
________________
Chris Ozo Agbata
(Principal Partner)
For: C O Agbata LP
123
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Dear Sir,
CORPORATE SEARCH REPORT ON EQUATOR INVESTMENT LIMITED
We, Solicitors of the above name address hereby give details of the instruction received from
your office in respect of the above subject matter.
Find below the report in respect of the instruction given to our Law Firm on the 15th day of May,
2021.
1. Date of Search: 15th day of August 2021
2. Place of search: Corporate Affairs Commission
3. Name of company: Edupal Nigeria Limited
4. Previous name and date of change: nil
5. RC Number: No 152021
6. Registered office of the company: 15, Edupal Drive, Ikoyi, Lagos.
7. Date of incorporation: 13th March, 2020
8. Business/object of the company: Schooling and Research
9. Particulars of Directors (name, address, occupation): ABC of 12 Johnso Avenue, Ikeja,
DEF of 83 Imam Street, Lagos Island, Lagos.
10. Share capital: N5,000,000 divided into 5,000,000 ordinary shares of N1 each issued and
paid-up shares.
11. Encumbrance: (Encumbered, Not Encumbered)
12. Annual Return: The annual return of the Tropical Investment Limited is up to date.
Comment/ Advise: ALLS Bank Plc can go ahead with view to banking with Edupal Limited.
Thank you.
Yours faithfully,
________________
124
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
125
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
126
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
127
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
128
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
o Registered Companies
o Exempted Companies
PORTFOLIO INVESTMENT
• It means an investment in shares or other securities traded on the Nigerian Stock
Exchange S31 NIPCA.
• A person whether citizen of Nigeria or not, resident in Nigeria or not may invest in
securities traded on the Nigerian capital market or by private placements in Nigeria
S26 FEMMPA.
• Thus, by virtue of the FEMMPA provision, it is not only securities traded on the NSE but
also by private placements because that would’ve excluded private since they’re not
quoted on the NSE as public companies.
• FPIs should be registered with the SEC S13(l) ISA.
• FPI can be effected with foreign currency imported through an authorised dealer and
converted to Naira at the official exchange rate S15 FEMMPA.
• The Authorised Dealer through which the foreign currency or capital for the investment
is imported shall, within 24 hours of the importation, issue a Certificate of Capital
Importation to the investor and shall, within 48 hours thereafter, make returns to the
CBN giving such information as the CBN may, from time to time, require S15
FEMMPA.
• The CBN may appoint a bank or non-banking organisation or any other corporate body
which is well equipped to operate as an authorised dealer.
PROCEDURE FOR FPI
i. Application for allotment of shares by the foreign investor to the Nigerian Company
ii. Application for allotment of shares can also be done through a capital market operator
iii. Approval of allotment of the shares to the foreigner by the BOD of the issuing company
iv. Importation of capital through authorized dealer
v. Obtain certificate of capital importation
vi. Obtain share certificates
vii. Apply to SEC for registration of security
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT
• S868 CAMA defines an alien as a person or association, whether corporate or
incorporated, other than a Nigerian citizen or association.
• Subject to the provisions of any enactment regulating the rights and capacity of aliens to
participate or undertake in trade or business, an alien or a foreign company may join in
the formation of a company S20(4) CAMA.
• Direct Investment by foreign investors who invest in Nigeria by establishing a company
for that purpose.
• Here, a foreigner may on his own or in conjunction with other Nigerians, incorporate a co
in Nigeria.
129
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• In a narrower sense, it includes building a new facility and a lasting management interest.
• In a broad sense, mergers and acquisitions, building new facilities and reinvesting profits
earned from overseas operations. This may include participation in management, joint
venture, transfer of technology and expertise.
• The company established must be registered unless it qualifies and obtains an exemption
from registration
SUMMARY OF PROCEDURE FOR FDI
i. Apply for and obtain business visa “Subject to Regularisation” (S.T.R.) from the
appropriate Nigerian Diplomatic Mission S9 Immigration Act.
ii. Secure an address in Nigeria for service of documents and other matters preliminary to
the incorporation of company S78(1) CAMA.
iii. Prepare a joint venture agreement (JVA) and any other pre-incorporation agreement that
may be necessary if it involves a Nigerian partner.
iv. Register a company with the CAC S78 CAMA, S19 NIPCA.
v. Apply to register the enterprise with NIPC S20 NIPCA.
vi. Register the investment with SEC S13(l) ISA.
vii. Import capital through an authorised dealer S15 FEMMPA.
viii. Obtain certificate of capital importation S15 FEMMPA.
ix. Apply for necessary permits.
x. Apply for the applicable reliefs and incentives.
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN FPI AND FDI
SN POINT FDI FPI
1 Nature of Participation Active Passive
2 Nature of Biz Direct participation like est a co Securities such as shares
3 Management Partakes in management Doesn’t partake in mgt
4 Physical Presence Needs physical presence Need not be present
5 Registration Both CAC and SEC Only SEC
6 Mode of Entry Must be reg or exemption Needs neither
130
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
131
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• If they carryon business with complying with S78 CAMA both company and officers
will be criminally liable, and the officers or agents will be liable whether or not the
company is convicted S79 CAMA.
• However, while it cannot carryon business, FC has the right to either sue or be sued in
Nigeria S84(b) CAMA, Ritz GMBH & Co KG v Techno Continental Engineers Nig
Ltd, Watanmal (Singapore) v Liz Odofin.
EXEMPTION FROM REGISTRATION S80 CAMA
S80(1) CAMA provides that a FC may apply to the Minister for exemption from the provisions
of S78, if that FC belongs to one of the following categories, that is FCs which are;
a. Are not among those specified in paragraph (d) (engineering consultants and technical
experts), invited to Nigeria by or with the approval of the FG to execute any specified
individual project;
b. In Nigeria to execute specific individual loan projects on behalf of a donor country or
international organisation;
c. foreign government-owned companies engaged solely in export promotion activities; and
d. engineering consultants and technical experts engaged on any individual specialist
project under contract with any of the governments in the Federation or any of their
MDAs or with any other body or person, where such contract has been approved by the
FG.
Summary:
a. FCs which are neither engineering consultants or technical experts invited by FG or with
FG’s approval to execute specified individual project
b. FCs in Nigeria to execute loan projects on behalf of the donor country or IO (world bank,
IMF etc). Since Nigeria is owing China, this can be a Chinese a company, e.g., there was
a recent news that Chinese company will join in running in running Nigerian customs.
c. FCs owned by foreign govts which are solely for exportation
d. Engineering consultants and technical experts under contract with a govt in Nigeria or
with any other person approved by the FG. I wonder why this was excepted from one
above; the only difference seems to be that the former is to execute (like one time or
short period project) while the latter is to be under contract and engaged in it (for a
longer period of time), otherwise, it seems to be verbose separating the two.
Excluded under paragraph a and included under paragraph d.
PROCEDURE FOR APPLICATION FOR EXEMPTION S80(2) of CAMA
An application for exemption shall be in writing addressed to the Minister and shall set out;
a. the name and place of business of the FC outside Nigeria;
b. the name and place of business or the proposed name and place of business of the FC in
Nigeria;
c. the name and address of each director, partner or other principal officer of the FC;
132
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
d. a CTC of the charter, statutes, or memart or other instrument constituting or defining the
constitution of the company and if the instrument is not written in the English Language,
a certified translation thereof;
e. the names and addresses of one or more persons resident in Nigeria authorised to accept,
on behalf of the FC, service of processes and any notice required to be served on the
company;
f. the business or proposed business in Nigeria of the FC and the duration of such business;
g. particulars of any project previously carried out by the company as an exempted FC; and
h. such other particulars as may be required by the Minister or SGF.
Further Points in S80 CAMA.
• Granting of the exemption is at the discretion of the minister and he may impose
conditions as he deems fit, S80(3) CAMA.
• Every exemption must state its duration or (projects) when it shall lapse S80(4) CAMA.
• The Minister may at any time revoke any exemption if he is of the opinion that the
company has contravened any provision of CAMA or has failed to meet any condition
contained in the exemption order or for any other good or sufficient reason S80(5)
CAMA.
• When exemption is granted, the minister shall publish in the FG gazette; the duration or
projects and if it has been revoked, when such revocation occurred S80(6) CAMA.
• The exempted co has 30 days after payment of prescribed fees to deliver notice of
exemption as Form CAC 21 to CAC S80(7) CAMA.
• Failure to comply with the delivery of notice of exemption, it shall be liable to the
penalty as the CAC may specify for everyday of default S80(7) CAMA.
STATUS OF AN EXEMPTED COMPANY S82 CAMA
• The exempted company has the status of an unregistered company S82 CAMA.
LIMITATIONS OF EXEMPTED COMPANIES
i. There is no absolute right to the exemption, it is at the discretion of the Minister
ii. Period of exemption is shown in the order, the exemption is not indefinite
iii. The exemption is only for the specific project/business applied for and does not cover all
businesses carried out by the said foreigner
iv. The Minister may revoke the exemption at any time if he is of the opinion that the
company has contravened CAMA or has not fulfilled any condition of the exemption
order or for any good or sufficient reason
PROCEDURES FOR APPLICATION TO NIPC
Application to NIPC is on NIPC Form 1 for
i. Business Permit and Expatriate Quota; and
ii. Pioneer Status, Technical Assistance Agreement and in case of other fiscal incentives a
separate Form is to be completed.
133
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
A non-refundable deposit of N10,000 naira is payable for each application in bank draft to the
nearest NIPC office. The application should be forwarded to the NIPC Headquarters, Abuja or
State Ministries of Trade and Industries for onward transmission to NIPC Headquarters, Abuja,
along with two (2) copies of the receipt for purchase of the Form.
PROCEDURE FOR FDI (EST OF BIZ)
i. Prepare JVA or other necessary pre-incorporation contracts (where needed)
ii. Obtain Business visa
iii. Secure address for service of documents in lieu of registration
iv. Register company with CAC or obtain Letter of Exemption (whichever applies)
v. Import capital
vi. After incorporation as a Nigerian company but before starting business, he must register
with the NIPC- S20 NIPCA.
vii. Register security/investment with SEC S54(1) ISA.
viii. Obtain necessary permits
ix. Apply for necessary incentives
REGISTRATION WITH NIPC
• Compulsory by virtue of S20 NIPCA.
• NIPC has 14 working days from the date of receipt of complete reg forms to reg the
enterprise all relevant documents for registration have been duly completed and
submitted or otherwise advise the applicant, accordingly S20(2) NIPCA.
ONE STOP INVESTMENT CENTRE (OSIC) see week one above for details
• OSIC is a brain child of the NIPC established for the following reasons:
i. Eliminates delay in dealing with multiple government agencies in several
locations
ii. Removal of abuse of discretion and lack of transparency in granting permits,
approvals and licenses.
iii. Substantially reduces the cost of establishing a foreign direct investment
iv. Provision of investment information
CHECKLIST OF DOCUMENTS (ATTACHMENTS)
1. 1 copy of completed NIPC Form 1.
2. A bank draft for the payment of the prescribed sum (N10k)
3. 1 copy of (JVA) partnership joint venture agreement where applicable
4. 2 photocopies of payment receipt for application form
5. Certificate of incorporation of the applicant company.
6. CTC of the Memart of the applicant company.
7. CTC of the returns of allotment and particulars of directors.
8. Evidence of Capital importation from an authorised dealer.
9. Tax clearance certificate of the applicant company.
134
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
10. Receipt for payment of stamp duties on the authorised share capital of the company as at
the date of application.
11. Feasibility report and project implementation programme of the company for its proposed
business.
12. Title deeds of land evidencing firm commitment to acquire requisite business premises
for the company’s operations.
13. Training programme for Nigerian staff or personnel policy of the company, incorporating
management succession schedule for qualified Nigerians.
14. Names, addresses, nationalities and occupations of the proposed directors of the
company, including non-resident directors which should be marked “NRD”.
15. Job title designations of expatriate quota positions required, and the academic and
working experience required, and the academic and working experience required for the
occupants of such positions.
16. Information brochure, if any, on the foreign partner.
REGISTRATION OF FDI WITH SEC
• S13(l) ISA provides that the SEC is required to keep and maintain a register of FPI.
IMPORTATION OF CAPITAL
• Having obtained the requisite NIPC registration, the FC (now a Nigerian company, if
registered) must then import its foreign equity through any of the following ways:
i. Through an authorized dealer
ii. By bringing in equipment
iii. Through the debt-equity conversion scheme
CAPITAL IMPORTATION THROUGH AN AUTHORIZED DEALER
• An authorized dealer is a bank or other body recognized as such by the CBN pursuant to
the FEMMPA and obtain a certificate of Capital Importation from the bank (dealer).
• The Authorised Dealer through which the foreign currency or capital for the investment
is imported shall, within 24 hours of the importation, issue a Certificate of Capital
Importation (CCI) to the investor and shall, within 48 hours thereafter, make returns to
the CBN giving such information as the CBN may, from time to time, require S15
FEMMPA.
• The certificate evinces the importation of capital through the said Authorized dealer
Advantages of CCI
• Entitles the foreign investor to:
i. Open a foreign currency Domiciliary Account with any authorized dealer S17
FE(M&M)PA.
ii. Open a special non-resident Naira account
iii. Buy shares in Nigerian companies out of the naira account.
iv. Repatriate the capital, dividends and incomes at autonomous market rates after taxes
135
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
v. Nobody is required to declare any foreign currency at the port of entry into Nigeria
excess where such exceeds US $5,000 or its equivalent and even then, the amount
that is declared is for statistical purposes only- S12 FE(M&M)PA.
DEBT-EQUITY PROGRAMME
• Capital can be brought into the country through the debt-equity programme of the FG,
whereby Nigeria's debt instrument is bought at a discounted value from any stock
exchange anywhere in the world. This enables the foreign investor to get the naira
equivalent of the face value of the debt instrument.
• It is a feature of the deregulation programme introduced by the federal military
government in 1988. If for e.g., a foreigner needs to invest $30 million but he has only
$10 million, he can take his $10 million to any stock exchange anywhere in the world to
buy Nigeria’s debt instrument at a discounted value, i.e., he could pay $10 million for a
debt instrument with a face value and not the discounted value, the certificate is brought
into Nigeria, taken to a bank as proof of their capital importation into Nigeria, he can
obtain the naira equivalent of $30 million.
• It must be pointed out that the repatriation of part of the profits derived from the initial
capital outlay i.e. ($30 million) is postponed until after a minimum of five years, while
the capital proceeds cannot be repatriated until after 10 years, even then only 20 per
cent per annum of such capital outlay can be repatriated.
• It is implemented by the Debt Conversion Committee (DCC) in CBN but now taken over
by the Debt Management Office regulated by DEBT MANAGEMENT OFFICE
(ESTABLISHMENT) ACT, NO. 18 2003.
• The minimum amount of debt to be considered under the Scheme shall be $250,000.
136
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Dear Sir,
APPLICATION FOR EXEMPTION FROM REGISTRATION AS A NIGERIAN COMPANY
PURSUANT TO SECTIONS 80(1) AND 80(2) OF THE COMPANIES AND ALLIED
MATTERS ACT, 2020
We the above-named foreign company having been invited to Nigeria by the Federal
Government of Nigeria to execute a solar energy project hereby apply for exemption from
incorporation as a Nigerian company.
Please find attached the necessary documents as stipulated by section 80(2) of the Companies
and Allied Matters Act, 2020 for your kind consideration.
Thank you.
Yours faithfully,
________________
Chris Ozo Agbata Esq
Company Secretary
Enclosed:
1. Particulars of EDUPAL INC as the Parent company outside Nigeria.
2. Proposed name and place of business of our company in Nigeria
3. Particulars of the name and address of each Director, Partner or Principal officers of
EDUPAL INC
4. Particulars of persons resident in Nigeria authorised to accept services of any process/
Notice on the foreign company
5. Duration and proposed business of EDUPAL INC in Nigeria
137
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
138
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
o Certificate if incorporation
o Memart
o Feasibility report (should certified or registered with CAC)
o Form CAC 1.1
o JVA for partnership venture between Nigerian and foreigners (original to be
presented for sighting)
o Tax certificate (original for sighting)
o Title deeds (lease agreements or C of O) for opening premises (original for
sighting)
DRAFT: APPLICATION FOR RELIEFS/APPROVALS
C O AGBATA,
LEGAL PRACTITIONERS, SOLICITORS, AND CHARTERED ARBITRATORS
15 EDUPAL DRIVE, IKOYI, LAGOS
07035406532
([email protected])
Our Ref: 2304______________________________________ Your Ref: _______________
15th August, 2022
The Director General,
Nigerian Investment and Promotion Commission,
Plot 256 Maitama,
Abuja.
Dear Sir,
APPLICATION FOR RELIEFS/APPROVALS FOR EDUPAL NIGERIA LIMITED
We write as solicitors of Edupal Nigeria Limited (“our client”) on whose instructions we make
this application. Our client is a private company limited by shares with RC NO: 315415 with
registered office at 15 Edupal Drive, Ikoyi, Lagos state incorporated under Companies and
Allied Matters Act, 2020.
Two aliens, Mr Peter Pan and Mr John Lewis are undertaking different values of share capital in
the company. Mr Peter Pan seeks to bring in 100,000 Euros as a loan from an American bank to
expand the company’s capital base.
We therefore apply for the following reliefs;
1. Rural investment allowance under CITA, CAP C21, LFN 2004.
2. Repatriation of capital through an authorised dealer
3. Tax relief of interest on foreign loans
Thank you.
Yours faithfully,
139
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
________________
Chris Ozo Agbata
(Principal Partner)
For: C O Agbata LP
EXPATRIATE QUOTA
• This is the official approval granted to a company to enable it employ individual
expatriates to specifically designated jobs and the quota must state its duration.
• S8(1)(a) IA provides that no person other than a citizen of Nigeria shall accept
employment, not being employment with the Federal or a State Government, without the
approval of the Chief Federal Immigration Officer. The approval is what is known as
“Expatriate Quota”.
EXPATRIATE QUOTA BY BUSINESS CAPITALISATION
• Capitalization of N15m and above = 2 automatic quota positions.
• Capitalization of N30m and above = 4 automatic quota positions.
• All others on merit.
TYPES OF EXPATRIATE QUOTAS:
• Permanent Until Reviewed (PUR), and
• Temporary Quota (TQ).
PERMANENT UNTIL REVIEWED
• This is usually granted to the Chairman of the Board of a company or the Managing
Director. As the name implies, it is permanent until there is a supervening circumstance,
which will necessitate its review.
TEMPORARY QUOTA
• This is usually granted to the directors or other employees of the company. The
maximum time usually granted is 5 years subject to renewal for another term of 2 years.
NATURE OF EXPATRIATE QUOTA
• The quota position attaches to a particular post hence different persons can be covered by
the same quota. It is the duty of the company to apply for the quota and not that of the
employee Oil Fields Supply Centre Ltd v Johnson.
APPLICATION
• Application is made on Immigration Form T/2. It is the duty of the company and not
that of the employee, to apply for expatriate quota.
o Should be accompanied by the following documents
o Completed Immigration Form T/2
140
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
o Certificate of Incorporation
o Memorandum and Article of Association
o Feasibility Report (should be certified or registered with Corporate Affairs
commission (CAC)
o Particulars of First Directors or Changes Thereof
o CAC 5 - Return of Allotment (Post Incorporation) Minimum N10 million
o Company’s Current Tax Clearance Certificate (Original to be presented for
sighting)
o Lease agreement for C of O for opening premises (original to be presented for
sighting) in respect of each Company.
o Proof there is need for an expatriate e.g., Evidence of imported machinery
ENTRY PERMIT/VISA S9 IA
• Generally, everyone needs visa to visit Nigeria but there are exceptions of countries that
Nigeria may have a bilateral or multilateral agreement with. Thus, the citizens of those
countries may not need visas to enter Nigeria, likewise Nigerians not needing visas to
enter those countries e.g., ECOWAS member states, some commonwealth countries and
any other country that has enter such a treaty with Nigeria.
• In some cases, it can be a visa on arrival wherein the person is issued a visa on point of
entry (POE). However, such a person must have applied either online or in-person at the
Nigerian embassy to acquire a letter of approval that he will present at the Nigerian
airport in order to receive the visa on arrival (VOA).
• An employee who is coming into Nigeria must possess a visa to legally come into the
country.
TYPES OF VISAS
• Ordinary, this further categorised into 3:
o Transit: issued to applicants passing through Nigeria with the exception of
ECOWAS citizens
o Single Journey: may be issued as:
▪ Short Visit Visa (SVV): this is usually for a short period e.g., concerts,
conferences etc
▪ STR Visa: This is subject to regularisation obtained from the Nigerian
foreign mission in home country. It is then regularised into residence
permit upon arrival in Nigeria and upon application. This is within 90
days.
▪ TWP: Temporary work permit, usually to those workers who will not stay
long e.g., maintenance, repairs, installation etc.
o Multiple visit
• Diplomatic
• Gratis Courtesy
141
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
142
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• CERPAC is valid for two years, after which application for revalidation must be made.
• Foreigners relocating to a different part of Nigeria must inform the nearest Aliens Office
of the move.
• Also, if a foreigner holding an Aliens Card leaves Nigeria permanently then the card has
to be handed over to the Aliens Office.
• The fee is US$350.
• On payment and submitting of the completed application form, a temporary receipt is
given.
• This receipt should be carried at all times as proof of residence.
• Applicants will then be told when and where to collect their cards.
• In conclusion, a foreigner doing business in Nigeria is required to have
o business permit,
o residence permit,
o alien registration card and
o business visa (3 types).
• Only residence permit and alien registration have been combined.
ECOWAS CITIZENS
• Citizens of ECOWAS under the protocol are entitled to:
i. Free entry within 90 days
ii. Right of residence
iii. Right of establishment of business
• To enjoy the free entry, the ECOWAS citizen must possess valid travel documents like
passport or ECOWAS travel certificate and admission through approved point of entry.
• To enjoy right of residence which is valid for 5 years subject to passport validity, there
must be:
i. Valid travel documents
ii. Admission through approved port of entry
iii. Procurement of residence card
iv. Registration of business with CAC in accordance with CAMA
TRANSFER OF TECHNOLOGY S5(2) NOTAPA
• Every contract or agreement entered into by any person in Nigeria with another person
outside Nigeria involving the transfer of foreign technology to Nigerian partners shall be
registered with NOTAP in the prescribed manner, that is, not later than 60 days from
the execution of the agreement S5(2) NOTAPA.
WHAT CAN BE REGISTERED
• According to S4(d) NOTAPA, an agreement involves transfer of technology if its
purpose or intent is, in the opinion of NOTAP, wholly or partially connected with any of
the following matters:
143
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
144
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
11. where the transferee is required to appoint the supplier of technology as the exclusive
sales agent or representative in Nigeria or elsewhere;
12. Where the contract or agreement is expressed to exceed a period of ten years or other
unreasonable term where this is less than ten years;
13. Where the consent of the transferor is required before any modification to products,
processes or plant can be effected by the transferee;
14. Where an obligation is imposed on the transferee to introduce unnecessary design
changes;
15. Where the transferor, by means of quality controls or prescription of standards, seeks to
impose unnecessary and onerous obligations on the transferee;
16. Where there is provision for payment in full by the transferee for transferred technology
which remains unexploited by him;
17. Where there is a requirement for the acceptance by the transferee of additional
technology or other matter, such as consultancy services, international subcontracting,
turn-key projects and similar package arrangements, not required by the transferee for or
in connection with the principal purpose for which technology is to be or has been
acquired by him;
18. Where the transferee is obliged to submit to foreign jurisdiction in any controversy
arising for decision concerning the interpretation or enforcement in Nigeria of any such
contract or agreement or any provisions thereof.
EXCEPTIONS
• The council may direct the direct to issue the certificate in national interest S6(3)
NOTAPA.
• Following the director’s advice, where the parties make the necessary adjustments to the
agreement, the certificate may be issued S6(4) NOTAPA.
REGISTRATION PROCEDURE:
1. Complete NOTAP prescribed form
2. Attach CTC of the company’s memart
3. Certificate of Incorporation
4. Two CTCs of the agreement to be registered
5. Two copies of duly completed questionnaire
6. A copy of the relevant feasibility study
7. Annual audited accounts (if not a new company) and if a new company, a copy of the
Statement of Affairs of the company accompanied with the Certificate of Incorporation
8. Payment of prescribed fees
EFFECT OF NON-REGISTRATION S7 NOTAPA
• Non-registration of a contract does not render the contract void or unenforceable between
the parties but merely frustrates transfer of any fees or payment due under the contract to
the account of the aliens outside Nigeria because they will not enjoy the benefits of
repatriating their fees, profits and royalties through CBN unless there is a Certificate of
145
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
146
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• 25% of incomes in FX collected by a hotel shall be exempt from tax provided that such
income is put in a reserved fund to be utilised within five years for the expansion of new
hotels, conference centres and new facilities for the purpose of tourism development: S37
CITA Note also that Development of holiday resorts, hotels, sporting and recreational
facilities is a pioneer industry so no tax.
• Interest on any loan to a company engaged in agricultural business, the fabrication of
local plant or machinery or as working capital for any industry established under Family
(Economic Advancement Programme Establishment, Etc.) Act is exempt from tax
S11 CITA.
• Foreign loans to Nigerian companies S11 CITA minimum of N150, 000, the loan
agreement must be approved by the Federal Ministry of Finance and copies deposited
with them and Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS).
INVESTMENT TAX CREDIT
• Companies that are engaged in R&D activities for commercialisation are allowed 20%
investment tax credit on their expenditure
PETROLEUM INVESTMENT ALLOWANCE
• A coy in Production Sharing Contract with the NNPC is entitled to petroleum investment
allowance – 50% of chargeable profit
INVESTMENT TAX CREDIT
• A company, which purchases a locally manufactured plant, machinery or equipment for
use in its business, is allowed 15% investment tax credit on such fixed asset S30 CITA.
• Where a company buy a new machinery to replace an obsolete plant and machinery, there
shall be allowed to that company, 15% investment tax credit: S26 CITA.
RURAL INVESTMENT ALLOWANCE
• Provision of electricity, water, and tarred road telephone, located at least 20 kilometres
away from such facilities, - rural investment allowance: S34 CITA.
LABOUR INTENSIVE MODE OF PRODUCTION
• Tax concession for five years. The rate is graduated in such a way that an industry
employing one hundred will enjoy only 6%, while those employing two hundred will
enjoy 7%, and so on.
EXPORT FREE ZONE
• Onne and Calabar
• The, profit of a 100% export-oriented undertaking established within and outside an
Export Free Zone shall be exempt from tax for the first three consecutive assessment
years
• Unrestricted remittance of profits and dividends earned by foreign investors in EPZs
148
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Though called EPZ coys are allowed to sell 100% of total production in the domestic
market
• No import or export licenses required,
• Sale of up to 25% of production permitted in domestic market
• No quotas on products from Nigeria exported to the European Union, (EU) and the
United States of America
• Made-in Nigeria goods are entitled to preferential tariffs in the EU.
CONDITIONS
i. New business
ii.New plants and machinery
iii.
Export proceeds form 75% of its turnover;
iv.Company repatriates at least 75% of the export earnings to Nigeria and places it in a
dorm account
v. To enjoy exemption from taxation is the profit of a company for the first N6,000 S42
CITA.
Other reliefs:
• Relief is also available where a Nigerian company is liable to pay a Commonwealth Tax
S44 CITA.
• There is relief from payment of double taxation if there are bilateral agreements with
other countries S44 & 45 CITA.
• There is also tax exemption for foreign loans not less than N150,000 granted to a
Nigerian company when it is not repayable within 10 years and is not repaid in less than
8years S9(1) CITA.
• Interests payable on bank loan granted for agricultural trade and business also enjoy tax
concession.
• Bank loan granted to a company engaged in agricultural business and fabrication of local
plant and machinery also enjoys concession.
• Deposit accounts or domiciliary accounts of a foreign non-residence company are also
exempted from taxation provided that the account consists mainly of foreign currencies
imported into Nigeria on or after 1st January 1990 through the CBN or any other
authorised bank.
• Bank loans for manufacture of goods for export are also tax-free.
• Please note that stocks and shares of any description have been removed from the list of
assets liable to Capital Gains Tax (CGT).
DUTY DRAWBACK AND SUSPENSION SCHEME
• The Customs and Excise Management Act and also the Customs Duty Drawback
Scheme/Regulation provides for the refund of import duties on:
o all imported goods used in manufacturing goods meant for export. In such cases,
100 per cent refund of import duties is granted.
149
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
150
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
151
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
152
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
AGENCY/SHAREHOLDER THEORY
• The agency/shareholder or stock holder theory posits mainly that the shareholders are the
principal while the directors are their agents.
• The shareholders or the stock holders provide the equity or money with which the
company does business and they bear the risk of the business.
• The directors are appointed by the shareholders to bring in their skills and expertise and
provide a high return on the investment of the shareholders.
• This theory therefore watches for the best interest of the shareholders which is basically
maximisation of profit.
• The theory posits that the officers of the company are its agents who are to carry out the
wishes of the company.
• Under the shareholder theory the main organs of the company are the General Meeting
and the Board of Directors as the decision-making organs of a company S87 CAMA.
• The importance of the interface between members and Directors on the platform of the
GM is sacrosanct and underscored by the principles under part C of the NCCG 2018.
STAKEHOLDER THEORY
• This theory recognizes that there are other persons in the company structure outside the
directors and members that impact meaningfully on the performance and sustainability of
the company.
• These are all referred to as the stakeholders viz: the shareholders, the management, the
employees, the creditors, the society, the government S305 (4) and (5) CAMA.
• These persons could include long term employees who have acquired valuable skills over
time. They might even have benefitted from some trainings from the company and they
are valuable to the company as much as the company is valuable to them.
• As a result, the interests of all these individuals or classes of individuals need to be
protected and a good framework needs to be created to ensure same.
• They bring in ethical considerations into the business of the company and may prompt
the company to perform certain CSR (e.g., oil spillage and flaring issues in Ogoni land).
• Part F of the NCCG is relevant here.
IMPACT OF CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY (CSR) ON CG
• Society and businesses are interwoven:
• Some of the ingredients required to make the organisation successful are derivable from
the relationship which the organisation has with society.
• For both to co-exist, there must be harmony.
• Hence the need for corporate leaders to transform their businesses by being socially
responsible
• CSR requires that modern business should help find innovative solutions to solving social
and environmental problems regardless of whether or not these organisations created the
problem in the first place.
153
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
154
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
155
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
ii. All private companies that are holding companies of public companies or regulated
entities.
iii. All concessioned or privatized companies.
iv. All regulated private companies being private companies that file returns to any
regulatory authority other than the FIRS and the CAC.
AIMS AND OBJECTIVES OF THE NCCG, 2018
i. Institutionalising corporate governance best practices in Nigerian companies
ii. Promoting public awareness of essential corporate values and ethical practices that will
enhance the integrity of the business environment
MONITORING METHODS
• The FRCN is the authority responsible for monitoring the implementation of the NCCG
• This may be done through the sectoral regulators and registered exchanges, who are
empowered to impose sanctions based on the specific deviations noted
• Review of implementation methods of the code, by the FRCN, in response to recurrent
cases of deviations
STRUCTURE OF THE CODE
• 7 (parts) in general but 6 operative parts and 28 Principles together with the practices
recommended for implementing the code.
• The parts are:
i. Part A. Board of Directors and Officers of the Board
ii. Part B. Assurance
iii. Part C. Relationship with Shareholders
iv. Part D. Business Conduct and Ethics
v. Part F. Transparency
vi. Part G. Definitions
156
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
157
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
159
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• The MD/CEO may be appointed an NED in any other Company, provided such
appointment is not detrimental to his responsibilities and is in accordance with Board-
approved policy.
Principle 5: Executive Directors
• Executive Directors support the Managing Director/Chief Executive Officer in the
operations and management of the Company.
Recommended Practices
• EDs should have a broad understanding of the Company’s business in addition to
possessing such other qualifications as may be needed for their specific assignments or
responsibilities.
• EDs should support the MD/CEO in the proper implementation and achievement of the
Company’s strategic imperatives, as well as prudent management of the Company’s
finances and other resources.
• EDs should declare any conflict of interest on appointment and annually thereafter. In the
event that they become aware of any potential conflict of interest at any other point, they
should disclose this to the Board at the first possible opportunity. Actions following
disclosure should be subject to the Company’s Conflict of Interest Policy.
• An ED may be appointed NED in any other company, provided such appointment is not
detrimental to his responsibilities as an ED and is in accordance with Board-approved
policy.
• An ED should not be a member of the committees responsible for remuneration, audit, or
nomination and governance.
• The responsibilities and authority of EDs should be clearly set out in a contract of
employment.
Principle 6: Non-Executive Directors
• Non-Executive Directors bring to bear their knowledge, expertise and independent
judgment on issues of strategy and performance on the Board.
Recommended Practices
• NEDs should be chosen on the basis of their wide experience, knowledge and personal
qualities and are expected to bring these qualities to bear on the Company’s business and
affairs.
• NEDs should constructively contribute to the development of the Company’s strategy.
• NEDs should not be involved in the day-to-day operations of the Company, which should
be the primary responsibility of the MD/CEO and the management team.
• NEDs should have unfettered access to the EDs, Company Secretary and the Internal
Auditor, while access to other senior management should be through the MD/CEO.
160
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• To facilitate the effective discharge of their duties, NEDs should be provided, in a timely
manner, with reasonable support as well as quality and comprehensive information
relating to the management of the Company and on all Board matters.
Principle 7: Independent Non-Executive Directors
• Independent Non-Executive Directors bring a high degree of objectivity to the Board for
sustaining stakeholder trust and confidence.
Recommended Practices
• An Independent Non-Executive Director (INED) should represent a strong independent
voice on the Board, be independent in character and judgment and accordingly be free
from such relationships or circumstances with the Company, its management, or
substantial shareholders as may, or appear to, impair his ability to make independent
judgment.
• An INED is a NED who:
o does not possess a shareholding in the Company the value of which is material to the
holder such as will impair his independence or in excess of 0.01% of the paid-up
capital of the Company;
o is not a representative of a shareholder that has the ability to control or significantly
influence Management;
o is not, or has not been an employee of the Company or group within the last five
years;
o is not a close family member of any of the Company’s advisers, Directors, senior
employees, consultants, auditors, creditors, suppliers, customers or substantial
shareholders;
o does not have, and has not had within the last five years, a material business
relationship with the Company either directly, or as a partner, shareholder, Director or
senior employee of a body that has, or has had, such a relationship with the Company;
o has not served at directorate level or above at the Company's regulator within the last
three years;
o does not render any professional, consultancy or other advisory services to the
Company or the group, other than in the capacity of a Director;
o does not receive, and has not received additional remuneration from the Company
apart from a Director’s fee and allowances; does not participate in the Company’s
share option or a performance-related pay scheme, and is not a member of the
Company’s pension scheme; and
o has not served on the Board for more than nine years from the date of his first
election.
• The above-mentioned criteria for establishing the independent status of an INED are not
exhaustive, but should be considered as examples of some of those relationships or
circumstances which may impair, or appear to impair an INED’s independent judgment.
• The Board should annually ascertain and confirm the continued independence of each
INED of the Company.
161
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Reclassification of an existing NED into an INED on the same Board is not desirable.
Principle 8: Company Secretary
• The Company Secretary plays an important role in supporting the effectiveness of the
Board by assisting the Board and management to develop good corporate governance
practices and culture within the Company.
Recommended Practices
• Without prejudice to the provisions of extant laws, the Company Secretary should be a
person with relevant qualifications and competence necessary to effectively discharge the
duties of his office. The Board should ensure that the person appointed has the gravitas
and objectivity to provide independent guidance and support at the highest level of
decision-making in the Company.
• Where the Company Secretary is an employee of the Company, he should be a member
of senior management and should be appointed through a rigorous selection process
similar to that of new Directors.
• The Company Secretary should be properly empowered by the Board to discharge his
duties and responsibilities.
• The Company Secretary should have both functional and administrative responsibilities.
The functional responsibility is to the Board through the Chairman, while
administratively, he reports to the MD/CEO.
• The Board should approve the performance evaluation of the Company Secretary.
• In addition to his statutory functions, the Company Secretary should carry out the
following duties and responsibilities:
o Provide the Board and Directors individually, with detailed guidance as to how their
responsibilities should be properly discharged in the best interest of the Company;
o Coordinate the induction and training of new Directors.
o Assist the Chairman and MD/CEO in coordinating activities regarding the annual
Board plan and with the administration of other strategic issues at the Board level;
o Notify Board members of upcoming meetings of the Board and its committees as well
as other matters that warrant their attention;
o Compile Board papers and ensure that the Board’s discussions and decisions are
clearly and properly recorded and communicated to relevant persons in a timely
manner;
o Provide a central source of guidance and advice to the Board and the Company on
matters of ethics, conflict of interest and good corporate governance.
• Under the direction of the Chairman, the Company Secretary’s responsibilities include
ensuring good information flow within the Board and its committees and between senior
management and NEDs.
• Subject to the provisions of extant laws, the appointment and removal of the Company
Secretary should be a matter for the Board.
162
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
163
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• To facilitate adequate oversight, the Board should establish committees responsible for
nomination and governance, remuneration, audit and risk management.
• The Board may combine any of the responsibilities mentioned in Section 11.1.6 on Board
committees, taking into consideration the size, needs and other requirements of the
Company.
• The chairmen of Board committees should be appointed by the Board.
• The Board should ensure that, in appointing members of the Board committees, there is a
balanced distribution of power in respect of membership across committees so that no
individual has the ability to dominate decision making and undue reliance is not placed
on any individual.
• The Company Secretary, or any other officer in the office of the Company Secretary,
should be the secretary of all Board committees.
• The agenda for the meetings of Board committees should be developed in consultation
with the respective committee chairmen.
• The timing of committee meetings should be well coordinated for the effective discharge
of their duties.
• At board meetings, the chairman of each Board committee should present a written report
of the key recommendations made at all the meetings held by the committee since the last
Board meeting.
• Members of Board committees should devote sufficient time to the committees’ work.
• Board Committees may engage a consultant at the expense of the Company for the
purpose of obtaining independent external expertise in carrying out their responsibilities.
This should be done in line with the Company’s policies.
• Board Committees should be accountable to the Board for their own activities and
performance.
11.2 Committee responsible for Nomination and Governance
• The Board should consider assigning the responsibilities for nomination of members and
oversight of governance matters to a stand-alone committee, or to any other committee
capable of combining it with their existing functions, as is appropriate.
• Members of the committee responsible for nomination and governance should be NEDs,
and a majority of them should be INEDs where possible.
• The chairman of the committee should be a NED.
• The committee should meet at least twice a year or such number of times as may be
appropriate to discharge its duties.
• Among other things, the committee should have the duty to:
o Review the structure, size, composition and commitment of the Board at least
annually and make recommendations on any proposed changes to the Board;
o Establish a formal and transparent process for Board appointments, including
establishing the criteria for appointment to the Board and Board committees,
reviewing prospective candidates’ qualifications and any potential conflict of interest;
164
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
165
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
166
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
12. Discuss the interim or annual audited financial statements as well as significant
financial reporting findings and recommendations with management and external
auditors prior to recommending same to the Board for their consideration and
appropriate action;
13. Maintain oversight of financial and non-financial reporting.
14. Review and ensure that adequate whistle-blowing policies and procedures are in place
and that the issues reported through the whistle-blowing mechanism are summarised
and presented to the board;
15. Review, with the external auditors, any audit scope limitations or significant matters
encountered and management’s responses to same;
16. Develop a policy on the nature, extent and terms under which the external auditors
may perform non-audit services;
17. Review the independence of the external auditors in line with the policy referred to in
Section 11.4.7.9 above prior to their appointment to perform non-audit services to
ensure that where approved non-audit services are provided by the external auditors,
there is no real or perceived conflict of interest, or other legal or ethical impediment;
18. Preserve auditor independence, by setting clear hiring policies for employees or
former employees of external auditors;
19. Ensure the development of a Related Party Transactions policy and monitor its
implementation by management. The Committee should consider any related party
transaction that may arise within the Company.
20. At least once in a year, the committee should hold a discussion with the head of the
internal audit function and the external auditors without the presence of management,
to facilitate an exchange of views and concerns that may not be appropriate for open
discussion.
11.5 Committee responsible for Risk Management
• The Board should consider assigning the responsibilities for oversight of matters relating
to risk management to a stand-alone committee, or to any other committee capable of
combining it with their existing functions, as is appropriate.
• Members of the committee responsible for risk management should include EDs and
NEDs, a majority of whom should be NEDs.
• Where the committees responsible for audit and risk management are separate, the Board
should consider for one or more members to have joint membership of both committees
for more effective functioning as this will enhance the discussions at meetings of both
committees – the risk implication of audit matters will be discussed more extensively,
and a knowledge of findings from the Company’s internal audit activities will bring a
unique perspective to the discussion of risk issues.
• The chairman of the committee should be a NED.
• The committee should meet at least twice every financial year or such number of times as
may be appropriate to discharge its duties.
• The committee should:
167
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
1. Review and recommend for approval of the Board, the risk management policies and
framework, as well as assist the Board in its oversight of risk management strategy;
2. Review the adequacy and effectiveness of risk management and controls in the
Company;
3. Exercise oversight over the process for the identification and assessment of risks
across the Company and the adequacy of prevention, detection and reporting
mechanisms;
4. Review the level of the Company’s compliance with applicable laws and regulatory
requirements which may impact the Company’s risk profile;
5. Periodically review changes in the economic and business environment, including
emerging trends and other factors relevant to the Company’s risk profile and those
trends which may threaten the Company’s business model, key strategies, future
performance, solvency and liquidity and make recommendations to the Board as
appropriate;
6. Review and recommend for approval of the Board, at least annually, the Company’s
Information Technology (IT) data governance framework to ensure that IT data risks
are adequately mitigated and relevant assets are managed effectively. The framework
may include:
a. Development of IT strategy and policy;
b. Proactive monitoring and management of cyber threats and attacks as
well as adverse social media incidents;
c. Management of risks relating to third-party and outsourced IT service
providers;
d. Assessment of value delivered to the Company through investments in
IT; and
e. Periodic independent assurance on the effectiveness of the Company’s
IT arrangements.
7. The person charged with the responsibility for risk management should be a member
of senior management of the Company, a professional with relevant qualifications
and experience and should be in attendance at meetings of the committee. The direct
reporting line of this person should be to the MD/CEO and there should be an indirect
reporting line to the committee responsible for risk management.
Principle 12: Appointment to the Board
• A written, clearly defined, rigorous, formal and transparent procedure serves as a guide
for the selection of Directors to ensure the appointment of high-quality individuals to the
Board.
168
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
PART B. ASSURANCE
Principle 17. Risk Management
• A sound framework for managing risk and ensuring an effective internal control system is
essential for achieving the strategic objectives of the Company.
Principle 18: Internal Audit Function
• An effective internal audit function provides assurance to the Board on the effectiveness
of the governance, risk management and internal control systems.
Principle 19: Whistle-blowing
• An effective whistle-blowing framework for reporting any illegal or unethical behaviour
minimises the Company's exposure and prevents recurrence.
Principle 20: External Auditors
• An external auditor is appointed to provide an independent opinion on the true and fair
view of the financial statements of the Company to give assurance to stakeholders on the
reliability of the financial statements.
169
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
PART E. SUSTAINABILITY
Principle 26. Sustainability
• Paying adequate attention to sustainability issues including environment, social,
occupational and community health and safety ensures successful long term business
performance and projects the Company as a responsible corporate citizen contributing to
economic development.
PART F. TRANSPARENCY
Principle 27. Stakeholder Communication
170
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Communicating and interacting with stakeholders keeps them conversant with the
activities of the Company and assists them in making informed decisions.
Principle 28. Disclosures
• Full and comprehensive disclosure of all matters material to investors and stakeholders,
and of matters set out in this Code, ensures proper monitoring of its implementation
which engenders good corporate governance practice.
PART G. DEFINITIONS
Principle 29. Definitions
171
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
iv. The NED’s bring in their business experience and expertise to help the Board make
critical decisions.
v. The INED should have little or no interest in the coy and should be able to bring
dispassionate view into the Boards decision making process.
BOARD STRUCTURE AND COMPOSITION
• This should be organised in such a way as to ensure a balance of skills and diversity
(including experience and gender) without compromising competence, independence and
integrity.
• It is not advisable for a director to be on several Boards although it is not prohibited,
there should be disclosure- reason effectiveness.
CRITERIA FOR THE APPOINTMENT OF THE INED
• The criteria for the appointment of the INED are broadly contained in S7.2 NCCG and
they include some of the following:
i. Should not hold more than 0.01% of the shares of the coy.
ii. Should not be a representative of a substantial shareholder of the coy.
iii. Should be in the employment of the company or group and should not have been within
the past 5 years.
iv. Not a close family member to a key decision maker of the coy auditor etc. (Brainstorming
on requirements)
CODES ON CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
• Essentially, the various codes of corporate governance were initiated to check the
recurrence of corporate financial failures otherwise known as corporate collapse.
CODE OF CORPORATE GOVERNANCE FOR FINANCIAL COMPANIES IN
NIGERIA (CCGFCN) 2019
• The code is made pursuant to the CBN Act and the BOFIA and aimed at encouraging
investment, access to finance (especially to SME’s) and growth of the economy it is not
only applicable to banks, but to all licensed Financial Companies as well.
• Some key provisions of the code concerning the BOD include the following:
i. Size and composition of the BOD- the minimum size is 5 while the maximum size is
9 and more than 50% of them should be NED’s.
ii. It limits the number of family members that can be on the Board to 2.
iii. There must be one INED on the Board that has no relationship with coy or any
subsidiary, someone completely dethatched from the coy.
iv. At least 2 members of the BOD shall be experienced in Banking.
172
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
i. Right to receive information on a timely and regular basis from the FC, e.g., in
newsletters, websites and other media in addition to the General Meetings.
ii. Dealing with the Shareholders Association shall be in strict compliance with the Code
of Conduct for Shareholders Association issued by SEC.
HIGHLIGHTS OF OTHER PROVISIONS IN THE CODE
• Rights and duties of stakeholders are entrenched.
• Prevention of insider from insider trading and other unethical practices.
• In the event of malpractices in the FC stakeholders are to comply with the Guidelines for
Whistle Blowing for Banks and other Financial
• Institutions in Nigeria for raising alarms.
• Stakeholders also include customers.
• Emphasizes good corporate governance for stakeholders including the host community.
• Provisions on disclosure and transparency.
• Auditing and reporting to CBN on an annual basis.
• Semi-annual report on compliance with the code to be filed with the CBN.
• Non-compliance is sanctioned under S64 of BOFIA.
HIGHLIGHTS OF THE CCG FOR BANKS AND DISCOUNT HOUSES
1. The Board shall act in the best interest of the bank’s employees and other stakeholders
(employees are therefore recognized as stakeholders).
2. There must be in place a succession plan for the CEO, ED’s and other top management
staff.
3. The size of the Board should be between 5 and 20.
4. Banks shall have 2 INED’s while discount houses shall have 1 INED.
5. Not more than 2 members of the same extended family shall be on the Board at the
same time.
6. No 2 members of the same extended family shall hold the positions of CEO and
Chairman at the same time.
7. NED’s can only serve for a maximum of 3 terms of 4 years each only.
8. The maximum term for a CEO is 10 years which may be broken into two tenures of
5years each.
9. No director can serve as a member of the Board of the Bank and a holding company
within the group at the same time.
10. The remuneration of the ED’s is determined by a committee constituted of only NED’s
11. Other remuneration committees are to be constituted by NED’s alone.
12. The Chairman shall not be a member of any Board Committee.
WEEK 10 ASSIGNMENT
Tantaloom (Nigeria) Plc was incorporated in October 2018. Later, it was as a listed public
company. Since incorporation however, it is yet to hold an AGM (Annual General Meeting) or
173
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
even a statutory meeting. As contained in the Memorandum of Association, the objects of the
company are as follows: Haulage, Warehousing, production of palm kernel cake (PKC), Palm
Kernel Oil (PKO) and Palm Kernel Sludge (PKS).
Led by Mr. Onyemere Onuku, the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, the company has not
kept a proper record of its substantial shareholders. There is also no indication that an internal
audit function has been established, even though an annual report is ready to be filed on behalf of
the company.
As a result, many shareholders are aggrieved with the way the affairs of the company is being
managed by the four-man Board of the company. Some have also argued that the family ties
between Mr. and Mrs. Jaiye Owopo, makes them ineligible to serve on the Board of Tantaloom
(Nigeria) Plc.
Answer the following questions:
1. List the codes of corporate governance applicable to the company and the issuing
authority for each code.
2. What are the applicable laws on corporate governance in the present circumstance?
3. Assuming that Tantaloom (Nigeria) Plc is an insurance company, what additional laws on
corporate governance will apply?
4. Comment on the following:
a. The absence of the internal audit function in the company; and
b. The relevant time frame for holding the statutory meeting of the company.
5. What would be your answer in respect of the following matters:
a. The propriety or otherwise, that Mr. and Mrs. JaiyeOwopo are ineligible to serve on
the company’s Board; and
b. The composition of the entire Board of Tantaloom (Nigeria) Plc.
174
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
175
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
2. Secondary actors
The latter are officers and agents s87(1) but the former are MIGM and BOD (and MD by virtue
of s89 which used the three in the same pedestrian). The primary can also act through the
secondary.
Division of powers between members in general meeting and board of directors.
87. (1) A company shall act through its members in general meeting or its board of directors
or through officers or agents appointed by, or under authority derived from, the members
in general meeting or the board of directors.
There are two main organs identified here which are members in general meeting and board
of directors and the law also recognises that they can also allocate such powers to agents to
act on their behalf. NB: it must be BOARD OF DIRECTORS and MEMBERS IN GEENRAL
MEETING and not otherwise as the law clearly states. The purport of this provision is that the
other two organs (officers or agents) cannot act until they derive the authority from either of the
Board of Directors or Members in General Meeting.
But how do the powers function? How do they relate?
On how and what powers are exercised by the primary actors, it is in s87(2) but while drafting
the AOA, regard must be had to s723 as the Act supersedes where there’s inconsistency.
S87(2): Subject to the provisions of this Act, the respective powers of the members in general
meeting and the board of directors shall be determined by the company’s articles.
There are two instruments that determine the allocation of powers and functions to the Board of
Directors and Members in General Meeting, which are the Act and AOA (subject to the
provisions of the Act). If the two conflicts, it is section 723 that will apply and the Act will take
precedent.
(3) Except as otherwise provided in the company’s articles, the business of the company shall
be managed by the board of directors who may exercise all such powers of the company as are
not by this Act or the articles required to be exercised by the members in general meeting.
(4) Unless the articles otherwise provide, the board of directors, when acting within the powers
conferred upon them by this Act or the articles, is not bound to obey the directions or
instructions of the members in general meeting provided that the directors acted in good faith
and with due diligence.
(5) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (3), the members in general meeting may—
This subsection seeks to be taking away from subsection 3 but it has stringent conditions
(a) act in any matter if the members of the board of directors are disqualified or unable to act
because of a deadlock on the board or otherwise; what can make the board to be disqualified?
176
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Deadlock is for example when there is a tie in vote among them and they cannot move forward.
Then the “otherwise” means other similar instances. Section 291, Failure to have a quorum:
where the board is unable to act because a quorum cannot be formed, the general meeting may
act in place of the board and where a committee is unable to act because a quorum cannot be
formed, the board may act in place of the committee.
(b) institute legal proceedings in the name and on behalf of the company, if the board of
directors refuse or neglect to do so; you must note that this will only be the case wherein the
AOA so provides. See s346 for derivative action.
(c) ratify or confirm any action taken by the board of directors; or It is only when the board has
acted where it doesn’t have the power so to do that there will be need for ratification and for
confirmation, why confirm what someone already has the power to do?
(d) make recommendations to the board of directors regarding action to be taken by the
board. While making recommendations may be weak as the board can ignore (subsection 4
above) but the MIGM can also remove the board, so it is in their best interest to obey the MIGM
as they also have the power to remove them.
(6) No alteration of the articles invalidates any prior act of the board of directors which
would have been valid if that alteration had not been made. This clearly clears the air with
regards to alteration of AOA under section 53(2), also because 53(2) stated “subject to the
provisions of this Act”.
DIRECTORS
WHO IS A DIRECTOR?
In Re Marseilles Extension Railway, 7Ch. 161, Mellish L.J. defines a company director thus,
“A director is simply a person appointed to act as one of a board, with power to bind the
company when acting as a board – but having otherwise no power to bind them.”
S269 defines directors in terms of what they do. Also, see the definition in s868.
S868 "director" includes any person occupying the position of director by whatever name
called; and includes any person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors
of the company are accustomed to act
S269. Meaning of Directors. (1) A Director of a company registered under this Act is a person
duly appointed by the company to direct and manage the business of the company.
S270. Shadow director.
(1) Without prejudice to the provisions of sections 269 and 276 of this Act, and for the purposes
of sections 279, 301 and 307 of this Act, “director” shall include any person on whose
instructions and directions the Directors are accustomed to act.
177
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Bolton (Engineering) Co Ltd v Graham and Sons Ltd: Per LORD DENNING "A company
may in many ways be likened to a human body. It has a brain and nerve centre which controls
what it does. It also has hands which hold the tools and act in accordance with directions from
the centre. Some of the people in the company are mere servants and agents who are nothing
more than hands to do the work and cannot be said to represent the mind or will. Others are
directors and managers who represent the directing mind and will of the company, and control
what it does. The state of mind of these managers is the state of mind of the company and is
treated by the law as such."
Lord Haldane in St Lennards Carrying Co v Asiatic Petroleum Ltd “a corporation is
abstraction. It has no mind of its own any more than it has a body of its own, its active and
directing will must subsequently be sought in the person of somebody who for some purposes
may be called an agent, but who is really the directing mind and will of the corporation, the very
ego and centre of the personality of the corporation.”
PRESUMPTION OF DUE APPOINTMENT AND LIABILITY FOR HOLDING OUT AS
A DIRECTOR
Section 269 (1) A Director of a company registered under this Act is a person duly appointed by
the company to direct and manage the business of the company.
(2) There is a rebuttable presumption in favour of any person dealing with the company that
all persons who are described by the company as directors, whether as executive or otherwise, is
duly appointed.
(3) Where a person not duly appointed acts or holds himself out as a director, he commits an
offence and is liable on conviction to imprisonment for a term of two years or a fine as the
Court deems fit for each day he so acts or holds out himself as a director or both and shall be
restrained by the company.
(4) If it is the company that holds him out as a director, it is liable to a fine in such amount as
the Commission shall specify in its regulations for each day it holds him out, and he and the
company may be restrained by any member from so acting until he is duly appointed.
LEGAL STATUS OF DIRECTORS
1. Directors as Trustees: Directors occupy a position of trust. Hence, they are accountable
for all company’s money and properties that is entrusted to them. They are to exercise
their powers in the interest of the company rather than gratifying their personal interest –
section 309 (1) provides that “Directors are trustees of the company’s money, properties
and their powers and as such shall account for all the money over which they exercise
control, refund any money improperly paid away, and shall exercise their powers
honestly in the interest of the company and all the shareholders, and not in their own or
sectional interests.”
178
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
2. Directors as agents: section 309(2) “A director may, when acting within his authority
and the powers of the company, be regarded as agents of the company under Part III of
this Act.”
NUMBER OF DIRECTORS
• Except for small companies, S271 (1) CAMA puts the minimum number of directors,
upon registration to be two (2)
• Except for small companies, if the number falls below 2, the company must fill that
vacancy within one month of such development or else the company shall not carry-
on business after the expiration of the one-month period, as specified in S271(2)
CAMA
• Any director acting without filling the vacancy after 60 days shall be personally
liable for all the debts incurred by the company within that period S71(3) CAMA
TYPES OF DIRECTORS
Three Types of Directors
There are basically three types of directors but with several subcategories especially for de-jure
director.
1. De-facto Director
2. Shadow Director
3. De-jure Director. This may be further subdivided into:
i. First directors
ii. Subsequent directors
iii. Executive directors
iv. Non-executive directors
v. Independent executive directors
vi. Independent non-executive directors
vii. Life directors
viii. Alternate directors
ix. Assignee directors
DE-FACTO DIRECTOR:
This is the type of director who holds himself out to act as a director without necessarily being
legally appointed as such. However, he still acts in that capacity as a director by performing the
kind of functions that someone in the position of a director will ordinarily perform.
S868 provides that "director" includes any person occupying the position of director by
whatever name called; and includes any person in accordance with whose directions or
instructions the directors of the company are accustomed to act
179
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
From this provision, there is no mention of being duly or legally appointed but simply that “he
occupies the position of director by whatever name called.
In the case of Re Hydrodam (Corby) Ltd, Millett J held: “I would interpose at this point by
observing that in my judgment an allegation that a defendant acted as de facto or shadow
director, without distinguishing between the two, is embarrassing. It suggests – and counsel’s
submissions to me support the inference – that the liquidator takes the view that de facto or
shadow directors are very similar, that their roles overlap, and that it may not be possible to
determine in any given case whether a particular person was a de facto or a shadow director. I
do not accept that at all. The terms do not overlap. They are alternatives, and in most and
perhaps all cases are mutually exclusive.
A de facto director is a person who assumes to act as a director. He is held out as a director by
the company, and claims and purports to be a director, although never actually or validly
appointed as such. To establish that a person was a de facto director of a company it is
necessary to plead and prove that he undertook functions in relation to the company which could
properly be discharged only by a director. It is not sufficient to show that he was concerned in
the management of the company’s affairs or undertook tasks in relation to its business which can
properly be performed by a manager below board level.
A de facto director, I repeat, is one who claims to act and purports to act as director, although
not validly appointed as such.
SHADOW DIRECTOR
This is the type of director that lurks in the background but dictates the tune and the directors of
the company dance to it. The directors of the company are accustomed to follow his directions
and instructions. He does not hold himself out to be a director but rather hides himself, despite
this, his instructions and directions are still followed by the directors of the company.
S270 (1) on shadow director, provides that; without prejudice to the provisions of sections 269
and 276 of this Act, and for the purposes of sections 279, 301 and 307 of this Act, “director”
shall include any person on whose instructions and directions the Directors are accustomed to
act.
Similarly, shadow director is also well captured in latter part of the definition in S868 "director"
includes any person occupying the position of director by whatever name called; and includes
any person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors of the
company are accustomed to act,
However, where a person gives advice in professional capacity, even if the directors are
accustomed to act or follow such directions and instructions, such as person will not be regarded
as a shadow director.
180
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
In Holland v HM RC, Lord Hope explained that “In relation to a company, ‘shadow director’
means a person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors of the company
are accustomed to act. However, a person is not deemed a shadow director by reason only that
the directors act on advice given by him in a professional capacity.”
DE-JURE DIRECTOR
These types of directors are those who are legally and duly appointed whether at incorporation as
first directors or subsequently as subsequent director, whatever name they are called, provided
that they occupy the position of directors and are duly and legally appointed, they are de-jure
directors.
S269(1) on the meaning of directors provides that, “a director of a company registered under this
Act is a person duly appointed by the company to direct and manage the business of the
company.”
• Types of De-jure Directors: (this is not sacrosanct as any of those may still fall under
de-facto director)
1. First directors: These are the directors at the time of incorporation of a company who
may be appointed by the subscribers or a majority of the subscribers or provided in the
articles of the company.
• S272 provides that the number of directors and the names of the first directors shall be
determined in writing by the subscribers of the memorandum of association or a majority
of them or the directors may be named in the articles.
2. Subsequent directors:
• These are the directors appointed after the company has been incorporated and
become a going concern. This is usually done in the AGM wherein such directors
may be re-elected or rejected.
• S273(1) provides that the members at the annual general meeting may re-elect or
reject directors and appoint new ones.
• NB: where all the directors die at a time: S273(2) provides that; In the event of all
the directors and shareholders dying, any of the personal representatives apply to the
Court for an order to convene a meeting of all the personal representatives of the
shareholders entitled to attend and vote at a general meeting to appoint new directors
to manage the company, and if they fail to convene a meeting, the creditors, if any,
may do so.
• NB: subsequent directors may also be appointed to fill causal vacancy created in the
case of death, removal, resignation or retirement of directors. S274(1) provides that
the Board of directors may appoint new directors to fill any casual vacancy arising
out of death, resignation, retirement or removal.
181
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
3. Executive directors are involved in the day to day running of the company and are
normally paid salaries Longe v FBN
• An executive director holds his office as an alter ego as well as an employee of the
company and is entitled to the payment of salary.
• The MD/ CEO and all other directors of the company who are also employees and are
entitled to the payment of salary are therefore subsumed under the platform of
executive directors
• Officers holding service contracts of the company appointed to the board.
• Executive directors are responsible for the day-to-day running of the company and
their powers are usually circumscribed by the articles.
• He is entitled to be remunerated.
4. Non-executive directors: appointed pursuant to the CAMA and not regular salaried
employees of the company.
• In public companies, the Chairman of the BOD is a non-executive director
• S269(2) of CAMA also stipulates that a person described as director of the company
may be appointed in the capacity of an executive director or a non-executive director
• A non-executive director is a director that attends board of directors meeting and is
not entitled to be remunerated apart from re-imbursement of his out-of-pocket
expenses in attending company’s matters.
• But non-executive directors can be remunerated where the articles of association of
the company provides for it.
5. Independent Directors:
• S275(1) provides that a public company shall have at least three independent
directors.
• S275(3) in this section, “independent director” means a director of the company who,
or whose relatives either separately or together with him or each other, during the
two years preceding the time in question—
o was not an employee of the company;
o did not—
▪ make to or receive from the company payments of more than N20m,
or
▪ own more than a 30% share or other ownership interest, directly or
indirectly, in an entity that made to or received from the company
payments of more than N20m or act as a partner, director or officer of
a partnership or company that made to or received from the company
payments of more than such amount;
o did not own directly or indirectly more than 30% of the shares of any type
or class of the company, and
o was not engaged directly or indirectly as an auditor for the company
182
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
6. Life Director:
• By virtue of S281, a person may be appointed a director for life, usually in a private
company, but such person shall be removable under S288 by an ordinary resolution.
• Being a life director simply means he is not subject to retirement by rotation S281.
8. Alternate Director:
• Where the articles of the company permits, a substantive director may appoint an
alternate director to act in his place during his absence. Such temporary delegation of
functions subsist pending the revocation of power by the appointing authority.
• In Baffa v Odili the court made a distinction between a director under S269 and an
alternate director is that the latter is appointed by a substantive director where so
enabled under the AOA of the company and the alternated director sits in for his
substantive director when the substantive director cannot attend the meeting.
• Also, S11(1)(b) Interpretation Act on the fact that he who appoints can also remove.
9. Assignee director:
• This is a director that has been permanently assigned to manage particular activities
of the company e.g., a director of operations. Flowing from the position above in
Baffa v Odili, the difference is that, the alternate is on temporary while assignee is on
permanent basis.
183
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
treated as the act of the company itself and the company is criminally and civilly liable to the
same extent as if it were a natural person.
RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE MANAGING DIRECTOR/ CEO
1. Day-to-day management of the Company;
2. Proper implementation and achievement of the Company’s
3. Strategic imperatives to ensure the sustainable development and growth of the Company;
4. Ensuring prudent management of the Company’s finances and other resources;
5. Providing the Board with complete, accurate and timely
6. Information and documentation to enable it make sound decisions;
7. Promoting and protecting the interests of the Company; and
8. Being the Company's leading representative in its dealings with stakeholders
APPOINTMENT OF DIRECTORS
This will be discussed under the following headings:
a) Appointment of fist directors
b) Subsequent directors
(a) APPOINTMENT OF FIRST DIRECTORS S272
• The number of directors and the names of the first directors shall be determined in
writing by the subscribers of the memorandum of association or a majority of them or the
directors may be named in the articles S272 CAMA
• The names of the first directors of the company, at the time of registration are usually
filled in the space provided for the particulars of first directors in the pre-incorporation
forms.
• This is appointed by all or majority of the subscribers or the name of the directors will be
provided in the AOA of the company.
Sample Draft:
THAT Chris Ozo Agbata of 15 Edupal Drive, Ikoyi Lagos and Theo Uguru of
16 Robinson Close, Victoria Island, Lagos, being adults of less than 70 years of
age, having being nominated, are hereby appointed as first Directors of
EDUPAL NIGERIA LTD, by the Subscribers to the Memorandum and Articles
of Association of the within named company.
184
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
185
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
……………… …………………
Director Director
NB: drafting of other resolutions follow same format, the relevant sections and purpose of the
resolutions apply mutatis mutandis.
7. APPOINTMENT BY DIRECTORS SUBJECT TO AOA S274(3).
• The directors may increase the number of directors if it does not exceed the maximum
allowed by the articles,
• But the GM may increase or reduce the number of directors generally
• The GM may also determine in what rotation the directors shall retire, but that such
reduction shall not invalidate any prior act of the removed director.
186
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Advantage:
o Means of exercising control in the company
o Not subject to the rule on rotation.
187
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
(d) a person disqualified under S279 (insolvency), S280 (fraud), S284 and
(e) a corporation other than its representative appointed to the board for a given term.
188
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• But compare with S276 above, where it is the officer who holds himself out, although the
act will be valid but he would be personally liable.
• Albeit actual knowledge vitiates any claims of any person against the company SS92 &
93(d)(ii), British Roya Bank v Torquand, Onwuka v Taymani.
MODE OF VOTING ON APPOINTMENT S287
• private company- single resolution for all directors.
• public company- separate resolution each director.
• unless a resolution that it shall be done has been agreed at the meeting without any vote
against it (unanimous resolution).
• a motion for approving a person’s appointment or for nominating a person for
appointment is treated as a motion for his appointment.
REMOVAL OF DIRECTORS S288.
(1) A company may by ordinary resolution remove a director before the expiration of his period
of office, notwithstanding anything in its articles or in any agreement between the company and
him.
(2) A special notice is required of any resolution to remove a director under this section, or to
appoint some other person instead of a director so removed, at the meeting at which he is
removed, and on receipt of notice of an intended resolution to remove a director under this
section, the company shall immediately send a copy of the notice to the director concerned and
(whether or not he is a member of the company) and is entitled to be heard on the resolution at
the meeting.
(3) Where notice is given of an intended resolution to remove a director under this section and
the director concerned makes, with respect to it, representations in writing to the company (not
exceeding a reasonable length) and requests their notification to members of the company, the
company shall, unless the representations are received by it too late for it to do so—
(a) in any notice of the resolution given to members of the company, state the fact of the
representations having been made; and
(b) send a copy of the representations to every member of the company to whom notice of the
meeting is sent (whether before or after receipt of the representations by the company), and if a
copy of the representations is not sent as required in this section because it is received too late or
because of the company’s default, the director may (without prejudice to his right to be heard
orally) require that the representations are read out at the meeting:
Provided that copies of the representations need not be sent out and the representations need not
be read out at the meeting if, on the application either of the company or any other person who
claims to be aggrieved, the court is satisfied that the rights conferred by this section are being
abused to secure needless publicity for defamatory matter and the court may order the company’s
189
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
costs on an application under this section to be paid in whole or in part by the director,
notwithstanding that he is not a party to the application.
(4) A vacancy created by the removal of a director under this section, if not filled at the meeting
at which he is removed, may be filled as a casual vacancy.
(5) A person appointed director in place of a person removed under this section is treated, for the
purpose of determining the time at which he or any other director is to retire, as if he had become
director on the day on which the person in whose place he is appointed was last appointed a
director.
(6) Nothing in this section is taken as depriving a person removed under it of compensation or
damages payable to him in respect of the termination of his appointment as a director or of any
appointment terminating with that as director, or as derogating from any power to remove a
director which may exist apart from this section.
• The articles of association or directors service contract (if any) may spell out the manner
of removing directors, in absence of which recourse is made to the CAMA, U.O.O.
Nigeria Plc v Okafor & Ors, per Peter-Odili JSC, Longe v FBN, Oni v Cadbury,
Iwuchukwu v Nwizu, Omenka v Morison Ind. Plc.
• A director may be removed before the expiration of his tenure by an ordinary resolution,
regardless of the provisions of the article or agreement to the contrary S288(1).
• The articles or contract must not just state that a director can be removed, but it must state
HOW (procedure) before it will apply, if not, CAMA shall apply Longe v FBN per
Oguntade JSC.
• This is known as alternative removal scheme (ARS) provided in the last phrase of
S288(6) “Nothing in this section is taken as depriving a person removed under it of
compensation or damages payable to him in respect of the termination of his appointment
as a director or of any appointment terminating with that as director, or as derogating
from any power to remove a director which may exist apart from this section.”
• ARS is also provided for in S46(3).
PROCEDURE FOR REMOVAL OF A DIRECTOR
1. Check the articles for ARS or any agreement between the co and the director.
2. Special notice of 28 days is given to the company by the person who wants the director
removed
3. On the receipt of such a resolution to remove the intended director, the company sends a
copy to the director concerned and also issue a notice of meeting at least 21 days before
the date of the meeting.
4. Director may make written representation which shall be given to members attached to
the notice of the meeting sent to them.
5. Where such representation is received late by the company and it was not attached to the
notice, the director pursuant to his right to heard can make oral representations at the
meeting by having the representation read out at the meeting.
190
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
191
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
192
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Where remuneration has been fixed by the articles, it is alterable only by a special
resolution.
• A co is not bound to pay remuneration, but where the co agrees to pay, the directors shall
be paid such remuneration out of the fund of the co.
• The amount of remuneration is a debt from the co so that if directors take office on the
basis of the articles, they shall be able to sue the co on account of the debt or prove it in
liquidation.
• A director who receives more money than he is entitled to, is guilty of misfeasance and is
accountable to the co for such money.
• The remunerations of directors is apportionable.
DUTIES OF DIRECTORS SS 305, 306, 308, 278
Directors are in fiduciary relationship with the company, all their duties therefore flow from the
fiduciary duty that they owe the company S305(1)
1. Utmost good faith: since directors are in a fiduciary relationship with the co, they must
always observe utmost good faith towards the company in any transaction with it or on its
behalf S305(1)
2. Duty to act in the best interest of the company: a director must separate his personal
interest from the interest of the company. The test is subjective which depends on each
circumstance, but the director must have displayed faithfulness, diligence, carefulness
and ordinary skill S305(3).
3. Duty not to fetter discretion: discretion will be fettered when for example the director
uses the right to vote for a collateral reason S305(6).
4. Duty to avoid conflict of interest: personal interest must not conflict with duties as a
director (especially in making secret profit) S306 (1) and (2).
5. Duty to account: a director is accountable to the company for any secret profit made by
him or any benefit derived by him S306(3)
6. Duty not o misuse corporate information: this duty still binds him even after resigning as
a director and can be bound by injunction to not misuse the information S306(5)
7. Duty of care and skill: simply means a director must not be negligent in the discharge of
his duties S308 (1).
8. Duty to give notice: notice of interest in contracts, loans and/or shareholding.
9. Duty to disclose age and Multiple directorships in case of public company:
i. Age: Any person who is appointed or to his knowledge proposed to be appointed
director of a public company and who is 70 or more years old shall disclose this
fact to the members at the general meeting S278(1)
ii. Multiple Directorship: Any person who its proposed to be appointed a director
of a public company shall disclose any position he holds as a director in any other
public company at “the meeting in which he 1s proposed for appointment as a
director S278(2).
193
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
194
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
195
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Draft:
EDUPAL NIGERIA LIMITED
RC:151025
15 EDUPAL DRIVE, IKOYI, LAGOS
07035406532
([email protected])
Our Ref: 2304______________________________________ Your Ref: _______________
15th August, 2022
Mr Chris Ozo Agbata,
15 Edupal Drive,
Ikoyi, Lagos.
Sir,
NOTICE OF BORAD OF DIRECTORS’ INTENTION TO REMOVE YOU AS THE
COMPANY SECRETARY PURSUANT TO SECTION 288 OF THE COMPANIES AND
ALLIEDMATTERS ACT, 2020
You are hereby given Notice of the Board’s intention to remove you as the secretary of the
company for failing to file statutory returns to the Corporate Affairs Commission for a period of
six months now.
You are given a period of seven (7) working days to make your defence or alternatively to put in
a Notice of your resignation to the Board.
Thank you.
Yours faithfully,
________________
Chairman
By Order of the Board
196
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
3. Rendering proper returns and notifications to the CAC. (Note the various returns)
4. Carrying out other administrative activities directed by the company or directors.
5. Can only exercise powers of the board with authority of the board.
RETURNS TO BE MADE BY COMPANY SECRETARY
1. Court orders e.g., S51(7)(b); S65(3); S115(4).
2. Notice of change of particulars of directors or secretaries SS 321(1) & 339.
3. Registration of charges S222
4. Registration of certain resolutions S262
5. Annual Returns S421. Note concessions granted to small companies, S419.
6. Return of allotment S154
7. Returns on the alteration of share capital SS 126, 127, 131, 134
8. Statutory Reports S235(6)
9. Statement by Banks, Insurance Companies, etc. S733
RETURNS TO BE MADE BY A COMPANY AND THE PERIOD WITHIN WHICH:
1. Final return of accounts of co being wound up by liquidators within 7 days of meeting of
members and creditors.
2. Notice of appointment of liquidator within 14 days of appointment
3. Notice of change of director within 14 days of such change
4. Notice of change of secretary within 14 days of such change
5. Notice of removal of an auditor within 14 days of passing resolution.
6. Order of court sanctioning reduction of share capital within 15 days.
7. Special resolution within 15 days of passing same
8. Notice of increase of shares within 15 days.
9. Returns of allotment within one month of making allotment.
10. Annual returns within 42 days of holding AGM
11. Registration of charges within 90 days of its creation
RESOLUTIONS TO BE FORWARDED TO CAC S262(4)
The following resolutions are enumerated to be sent to CAC within 15 days of passing the
resolution for registration.
1. Special resolution
2. Unanimous resolution on issue which requires special resolution
3. Unanimous class resolution
4. Resolution requiring a company to wind up voluntarily under S620
CLASS EXERCISE
1. Outline the procedure for the appointment of a chairman.
2. Outline the duties of the company secretary before during and after the General Meeting.
NB: To answer this question, it will not suffice to merely re-state S335.
197
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
1. SUBSCRIPTION S105
• A person can agree to become a member by subscribing to the Memorandum of
Association at incorporation S105(1). Thus, subscribers automatically become members
Martins v Ogungbadero; Ezeonwu v Onyechi.
• Can a person who agreed to be a subscriber but left out as such maintain an action to have
the register of the company rectified by inserting his name as a subscriber? NO Starcola
(Nig.) Ltd v Adeniji
• All persons mentioned above (except subscribers) do not actually become members until
their names are entered in the register of members. Thus, apart from subscribers, all other
members must have their names in the register of members to be referred to as members.
198
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• A subscriber of the memorandum who holds the whole or any part of the shares
subscribed by him in trust for any other person shall disclose in the memorandum that
fact and the name of the beneficiary S27(3)
• With respect to a co having a share capital, each member shall be a shareholder of the co
and shall hold at least one share. In such a co, the term “members” and “shareholders”
may be used interchangeably.
• However, in companies limited by guarantee, membership is acquired by subscription
and by an undertaking under S27(4)(b) followed by registration by the company.
• A person who undertakes to make a contribution, in the event of the winding up of a co
limited by guarantee, becomes a member of the co when his name is entered in the
Register of Members.
• All subscribers must together subscribe to shares amounting in value to at least N100k
for small co and N2m for big cos of the authorised share capital S27(2)(a).
Sir,
LETTER OF ALLOTMENT
I am directed by the Board of Directors to inform you on your allotment pursuant to your
application dated.............. day of............................ 2022. The Board has approved the allotment
of a total number of 2000 shares in the capital of the company.
199
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Please find attached the original Share Certificate and allotment mode.
Please accept my warmest congratulations.
Thank you.
Yours faithfully,
________________
Theo Uguru,
Company Secretary.
Sir,
LETTER OF REGRET
I am directed by the Board of Directors to inform on the above subject matter.
The Board regrets to inform you your application for 4000 number of shares in the capital of the
company was not approved.
Please find attached enclosed cheque in your favour in the sum of N200,000.00 which you paid
for the purchase of the share.
We regret any inconvenience this might cause you.
Thank you.
Yours faithfully,
________________
Theo Uguru,
Company Secretary.
200
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
5. ESTOPPEL
• Where any person has his name in the register of members with his knowledge. Such a
person cannot afterwards deny his membership, and in such an instance becomes a
member by estoppel.
201
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
202
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
iv. the particulars of any pre-incorporation contract together with the particulars of any
modification or proposed modification;
v. any underwriting contract that has not been carried out and the reasons therefor;
vi. the arrears, if any, due on calls from every director; and
vii. the particulars of any commission or brokerage paid or to be paid in connection with
the issue or sale of shares or debentures to any director or to the manager.
• The report shall contain an abstract of the receipts of the company and the payments
made from them up to a date within seven days of the date of the report S235(4).
• The statutory report must be delivered to the CAC within 14days S235(6).
• Failure to deliver the report to CAC or holding of SM is a ground for winding up the
company S571.
• The members have a right to discuss at the meeting, any issue in respect of the formation
of the company and commencement of business or any matter arising out of the statutory
report S235(8).
• Any member who wishes a resolution to be passed on any matter arising out of the
statutory report shall give further 21 days’ notice from the date on which the statutory
report was received to the company of his intention to propose such a resolution, in which
case, the statutory meeting shall not be held until the expiration of the 21 days’ notice
given to the company by the member S235(9).
• There is a penalty of fine for everyday of default in holding the meeting S236.
• SM must be held in Nigeria S240(1).
ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING S237
• Every company shall in each year hold a general meeting as its AGM, in addition to any
other meeting in that year and shall specify the meeting as such in the notice calling it
and not more than 15 months shall elapse between the date of one AGM of a company
and the next.
• The only exceptions are; a small company or any company having a single shareholder.
Essential features of AGM
• A company must hold its first AGM within 18 months of incorporation.
• The co need not hold its first AGM in the 1st or the following year of its incorporation
S237(1). For example, if a company was incorporated on 1st November 1995, it need not
hold AGM in 1995 or 1996 but must hold it at least in April 1997.
• Except for the first AGM, for the subsequent AGMs, CAC may extend the time for
holding the meeting by not more than 3 months S237(1)(b).
• If a company fails to call AGM, a member can apply to CAC which will give directives
on calling the meeting and such directive will include the power for one member to apply
to court to make an order that such member shall take decisions that will bind members
of the company S237(2).
203
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• If there is a default in carrying out the directive of CAC, there is a penalty of amount as
the CAC may determine on the co and every officer at fault S237(5).
Business Transacted at AGM S238
• Two types of businesses are transacted at the AGM of a company
i. Ordinary Business
ii. Special Business.
Ordinary Business of AGM
i. Declaration of dividend
ii. Presentation of the Financial Statement and the Report of Directors and Auditors
iii. Election of directors in place of those retiring
iv. Appointment of Auditors
v. Fixing of remuneration of the auditors
vi. Appointment of members of the Audit committee
vii. Disclosure of remuneration of managers of a company
Special Business of AGM
• Any other business not listed as ordinary business of AGM is deemed a special business.
• Examples Of Special Business
i. To alter the object/ memart
ii. Change of Name
iii. Re-registration of all types
iv. Reduction of capital
v. Removal of auditor before expiration of tenure etc
EXTRA-ORDINARY GENERAL MEETING S239
• EGM is the GM held at any time to transact business that cannot comfortably wait for the
next AGM.
• The board of directors may convene an extraordinary GM whenever they deem fit, and if
at any time they are not within Nigeria, sufficient directors capable of acting to form a
quorum, any director may convene an EGM.
Who can convene an EGM? S239
i. Board of Directors
ii. Requisition by members holding not less than 1/10 of the paid-up capital of the co,
carrying voting rights Pedley v Inland Waterways Association Ltd.
iii. In case of limited by guarantee or in the case of a company without a share capital,
members holding 1/10 of the total voting rights of all the member.
iv. Auditors can requisition EGM for the purpose of directors receiving and considering his
explanation as to the circumstances connected with his resignation S413(1).
204
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
205
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
206
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• A notice may be given to the joint holders of a share by giving the notice to the joint
holder first named in the register of members in respect of the share S244(4).
• A notice may be given by the company to the persons entitled to a share in consequence
of the death or bankruptcy of a member S244(5).
FAILURE TO GIVE NOTICE S245
• Failure to give notice of meeting to a person entitled to receive it shall invalidate the
meeting.
• The exception is where such failure is an accidental omission on the part of the persons
giving the notice FBN v Longe.
• Failure to give notice to a person entitled to it, due to a misrepresentation or
misinterpretation of the provisions of CAMA, or the articles, shall not amount to an
accidental omission.
ADDITIONAL NOTICE S246
• In addition to the normal individual notices sent out, every public company shall, at
least 21 days before any GM advertise such meeting in at least two daily newspapers.
COURT ORDERED MEETING (COM) S247
• S247(1) provides that the FHC can suo motu or upon an application, by director or
member who is entitled to vote in the case of GM or a director in the case of a BOD
meeting order a meeting in any of the following circumstances;
o If for any reason it is impracticable to call a meeting of a company in the
prescribed form or
o To conduct such meeting in any manner prescribed by the Articles or CAMA
ORDERS COURT MAY MAKE
i. That the meeting be called, held and conducted in any manner it deems fit S247(1).
ii. Where any such order is made, may give such ancillary or consequential directions as it
deems expedient S247(1).
iii. That one member of the company present in person or by proxy in the case of a meeting
of the company, and one director in the case of the board may apply to the Court for an
order to take a decision which shall bind all the members S247(2).
iv. Any COM is for all purposes deemed to be a meeting of the company or of the board of
directors duly called, held and conducted.
In case of death of all Directors & Shareholders S273(2)
• In the event of all the directors and shareholders dying, any of the PRs may apply to the
Court for an order to convene a meeting of all the PRs of the shareholders entitled to
attend and vote at a GM to appoint new directors to manage the company, and if they fail
to convene a meeting, the creditors, if any, may do so S273(2).
207
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
208
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
iii. making ineffective a demand for a poll on any such question which is made by any of
the persons mentioned in section 248.
• The instrument appointing a proxy to vote at a meeting of a company is also deemed also
to confer authority to demand or join in demanding a poll, a demand by a person as proxy
for a member is the same as a demand by the member
• There shall be no right to demand a poll on the election of members of the audit
committee S249(3).
Voting on a poll S250
• On a poll taken at a meeting of a company, or a meeting of any class of members of a
company, a member entitled to more than one vote, if he votes, need not use all his votes
or cast all the votes he uses in the same way S250(1).
• If a poll is duly demanded, it shall be taken in such manner as the chairman directs, and
the result of the poll is deemed to be the resolution of the meeting at which the poll was
demanded S250(2).
• The exceptions are; a poll demanded on the election of a chairman or on a question of
adjournment which is taken immediately not on chairman’s direction S250(2) & (4).
• In the case of an equality of votes, whether on a show of hands or on a poll, the chairman
of the meeting shall be entitled to a second or casting vote S250(3).
PROXIES S254
• Proxy means a person nominated by any member to attend a meeting on his behalf, he
takes part in the voting and can exercise the same right as the member appointing him
S254(1).
• Only a member who is entitled to attend and vote at a meeting can appoint a proxy
S254(1).
• Proxy is not allowed in company without share capital unless its articles permit S254(1).
• Meeting notice must provide for members right to appoint proxy, breach of this
constitutes on offence and attracts penalty of fine as may be determined CAC S254(2).
• There shall not be more than 48 hours during which to appoint a proxy and if the co’s
articles provides otherwise, it is void S254(3).
• The instrument appointing a proxy shall be in writing, under the hand of the appointer or
his attorney duly authorised in writing and, if the appointer is a corporation, either by
deed, or under the hand of an officer or attorney duly authorised S254(6).
• The proxy instrument shall be deposited at the registered office or head office of the
company or at such other place within Nigeria as is specified for that purpose in the
Notice of the meeting S254(7).
• The instrument shall be deposited at least 48 hours before the time for holding the
meeting or adjourned meeting, at which the person named in the instrument proposes to
vote, or, in the case of a poll, at least 24 hours before the time appointed for the taking
of the poll, and if defaulted, the instrument of proxy shall not be treated as valid S254(7).
209
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
210
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
RESOLUTIONS
• Resolutions refer to decisions taken at the company meetings, arrived at through voting,
or unanimous agreement by members entitled to vote.
Types of Resolution
There are two types of resolutions provided for in S258(1) and (2) respectively:
i. Ordinary Resolution
ii. Special Resolution
Other types may include:
i. Unanimous Resolution
ii. Written Resolution
iii. Resolutions Requiring Special Notice
ORDINARY RESOLUTION S258(1)
• A resolution is an ordinary resolution when it has been passed by a simple majority of
votes cast by members of the company as, being entitled to do so, vote in person or by
proxy at a GM S258(1).
• Ordinary resolution is presumed when the Act simply requires the passing of a resolution
by the company, without saying which (ordinary or special).
SPECIAL RESOLUTION S258(2)
• This is a resolution passed by not less than ¾ (three-four) of the votes cast by such
members being entitled to vote either in person or by proxy; of which 21 days’ notice,
specifying the intention to propose the resolution as a special Resolution has been duly
given
• Shorter notice may however be given if agreed to by majority holding not less than 95%
of the nominal value of the shares or by members representing not less than 95% of the
total voting rights in case of company not having share capital.
• A declaration of the chairman that the resolution is carried is, unless a poll is demanded,
conclusive evidence of the fact without proof of the number or proportion of the votes
recorded in favour of or against the resolution S258(3).
Examples of matters requiring special Resolution
1. Change of Name S30
2. Alteration of objects S51
3. Alteration of the Articles S53
4. Reduction of capital S127
5. Re-registration of LTD as PLC S56(1)
6. Re-registration of PLC as LTD S63(1)
7. Re- registration of ULTD as LTD S71(1)
211
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
212
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
213
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
ii. has effect as if agreed by the company in general meeting, he shall provide the
board with details of that decision
• The book is to be kept at the co’s registered address or head office and open to the
members without charge for at least 6 hours a day during business S267(1).
• Any member is entitled to be furnished within seven days after receipt of his request in
that behalf to the company, with a copy of any such minutes certified by the secretary at a
charge not exceeding N100 for every page S267(2).
CLASS MEETINGS S268
• This is the meeting held by classes of shareholders where a company has different classes
of shares.
• S68 provides that the provisions of CAMA relating to meetings shall apply to any class
meeting except if expressly excluded by CAMA itself.
DRAFTS OF NOTICES:
IN THE FEDERAL HIGH COURT OF NIGERIA
HOLDEN AT LAGOS
SUIT NO: FHC/L/C/15/2022
IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION UNDER SECTION 711 OF THE COMPANIES
AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, 2020
AND
IN THE MATTER OF EDUPAL NIGERIA LTD
IN RE: EDUPAL NIGERIA LTD-----------------------------------------------------------APPLICANT
COURT-ORDERED MEETING OF THE HOLDERS OF THE FULLY PAID ORDINARY
SHARES OF EDUPAL NIGERIA LTD
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that by an Order of the FHC holden at Lagos (the Court) dated
the 15th day of April, 2022 made in the above matter, the Court has directed that a meeting of
the holders of the fully paid ordinary shares of Edupal Nigeria Ltd (the Company) be convened
for the purpose of considering and if thought fit, approving (with or without modification), a
proposed Scheme of Arrangement pursuant to Section 711 of the Companies and Allied Matters
Act, 2020. The Scheme is explained in detail in the Explanatory Statement on Pages 15 to 20 of
the Scheme Document.
The meeting will hold at the Edupal’s Main Hall at No 15 Edupal Drive, Ikoyi, Lagos State,
Nigeria on Wednesday the 15th day of May, 2022 at 11am at which place the above mentioned
shareholders are requested to attend.
The following resolutions will be proposed and if thought fit, passed as special resolutions at the
meeting with or without modifications:
214
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
1. The holders of the fully paid ordinary shares hereby agree to surrender ten (10%) percent
of their fully paid ordinary shares to the preference shareholders who have agreed to take
fully paid ordinary shares in lieu of their dividend which is cumulative and in arrears, by
way of a Scheme of Arrangement and Compromise pursuant to section 711 of the
Companies and Allied Matters Act, 2020.
2. The company be and is hereby authorised to effect the transfer of the designated fully
paid ordinary shares to the preference shareholders who have agreed to take fully paid
ordinary shares in lieu of their dividend which is cumulative and in arrears, by way of a
Scheme of Arrangement and Compromise pursuant to section 711 of the Companies and
Allied Matters Act, 2020.
By the said Order, the Court has appointed Mr Stephen Agbata, a director of the Company or
failing him, Mr. Theo Uguru, also a director of the company or failing them both, any other
director so appointed in their stead, to act as Chairman of the meeting.
A member of the company entitled to attend and vote at the Meeting is entitled to appoint a
proxy to attend, speak and vote instead of that member. A proxy need not be a member of the
company.
Any member of the company entitled to attend and vote at the Meeting who is unable to attend
the meeting and who wish to be represented at the Meeting by proxies, must complete and return
the attached form of proxy in accordance with the instructions contained in the form of proxy so
as to be received by the Company Secretary at the Registered Office of the Company at 15,
Edupal Drive, Ikoyi, Lagos, not less than 48 hours before the date of the meeting.
The Register of Members will be closed from 10th day of May, 2022 to 15th day of May, 2022,
both dates inclusive, for the purpose of attendance at the Court Ordered Meeting.
Dated this 15th day of April, 2022
________________
Chris Ozo Agbata Esq
For: C O Agbata LP
(Solicitors to Edupal Nigeria Limited)
15 Johnson Drive, Ikoyi, Lagos.
[email protected]
07035406532
215
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Ordinary Business:
1. Appointment and fixing of the remuneration of the auditors
2. Appointment of the members of the audit committee
Special Business:
1. Fixing the remuneration of Directors.
2. Increase in share capital
Proxies Attendance
A member of the company is entitled to appoint a proxy to attend and vote instead of him. A
proxy need not be a member. A form of proxy is enclosed and if it is to be valid or the purpose of
the meeting, it must be completed, stamped and deposited at the Registered office of the
company at 15, Edupal Drive, Ikoyi, Lagos not less than 48 Hours before the time fixed for
holding the meeting.
ENCL:
1. Proxy Form
216
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Proxies Attendance
A member of the company is entitled to appoint a proxy to attend and vote instead of him. A
proxy need not be a member. A form of proxy is enclosed and if it is to be valid or the purpose of
the meeting, it must be completed, stamped and deposited at the Registered office of the
company at 15, Edupal Drive, Ikoyi, Lagos not less than 48 Hours before the time fixed for
holding the meeting.
ENCL:
1. Proxy Form
217
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
218
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• S374 provides that, every company must keep accounting records that will be sufficient
to show and explain the transactions of the company, so as to
i. disclose with reasonable accuracy, at any time, the financial position of the
company;
ii. enable the directors to ensure that financial statements comply with the
requirements of the Act.
CONTENTS OF ACCOUNTING RECORDS S374(3)
• It must specifically contain;
i. entries from day to day of all sums of money received and expended by the company;
ii. the matters in respect of which the receipt and expenditure took place
iii. a record of the assets and liabilities of the company; and
• If the business of the co involves dealing in goods, the accounting records shall
contain;
i. statements of stocks held by the co at the end of each year of the co;
ii. all statements of stocktakings from which any such statement of stock has been or is
to be prepared; and
iii. except in the case of goods sold by way of ordinary retail trade, statements of all
goods sold and purchased, showing the goods and the buyers and sellers in sufficient
detail to enable all these to be identified.
• Each public company shall keep its audited accounts displayed on its website S374(6).
PLACE, DURATION AND FORM OF RECORDS S375
• The accounting records shall be kept at the company’s registered office or such other
place in Nigeria as the directors think fit and will be open at all times to inspection by
officers of the company S375(1).
• The company is required to preserve the accounting records for a period of six years
though subject to any direction with respect to the disposal of records given under
winding up rules S375(2).
• A company may, in addition to original hard copies, keep electronic copies or registers
of any document or record it is obliged to keep or maintain under this Act, and where a
company chooses to maintain electronic copies or registers of its documents or records,
the company shall give sufficient consideration to the quality of the hardware and
software to be used, and technical specifications such as protocol, security, anti-virus
protection or encryption S375(3).\
DIRECTORS’ DUTY TO PREPARE ANNUAL ACCOUNTS S377
• The directors of a company must yearly prepare financial statements S377(1).
• CONTENTS OF FS S377(2)
a) statement of the accounting policies (not for ltd, only plc).
b) balance sheet as at the last day of the year;
219
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
c) P&L account or, for a co not trading for profit, an income and expenditure
account for the year;
d) notes on the accounts;
e) auditors’ report;
f) directors’ report;
g) statement of cash flow (not for ltd, only plc)
h) changes in equity (not for ltd, only plc)
i) value-added statement for the year;
j) five-year financial summary;
k) group financial statements for holding cos
l) other matters required by accounting standards (not for ltd, only plc).
• The FS of a private company need not include (a), (g), (h) and (i) above S377(3).
• At the first board meeting of a Company, the directors must determine the date each year,
when financial statements shall be made up and notify CAC within 14 days of the
determination S377(4).
• In the case of a holding company, the directors shall ensure that, except where in their
opinion there are good reasons against it, the year of each of its subsidiaries shall
coincide with the year of the company S377(5).
DIRECTORS’ REPORT S385
In the case of every co, there shall be prepared in respect of each year, a report by the directors—
i. containing a fair view of the development of the business of the co and its subsidiaries
during the year and of their position at the end of it; and
ii. stating the amount, if any, which they recommend should be paid as dividend and the
amount (if any) which they propose to carry to reserves.
iii. state the names of the persons who, at any time during the year, were directors of the co,
and the financial activities of the co and its subsidiaries in the course of the year and any
significant change in those activities in the year.
iv. Report matters contained in Parts I, II and III of the Fourth Schedule.
v. Failure to comply attracts penalty of fine as may be prescribed in the regulation by CAC
but it will be a defence to prove that reasonable care and skill were deployed to comply.
SIGNING OF BALANCE SHEET AND DOCUMENTS TO BE ANNEXED THERETO
S386
• A co’s BS and every copy of it which is either laid before the co in GM or delivered to
CAC shall be signed on behalf of the board by two of the directors of the co.
• Failure to comply, attracts penalty of fine to be determined by regulation.
PERSONS ENTITLED TO RECEIVE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AS OF RIGHT S387
• A copy of the co’s FS for the year shall, at least 21 days before the date of the meeting
at which they are to be laid be sent to the following persons—
i. Every member of the company;
220
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• If copies of the FS are sent less than 21 days before the date of the meeting, it is,
notwithstanding that fact, deemed to have been duly sent if it is so agreed by all the
members entitled to attend and vote at the meeting S387(4).
DIRECTOR’S DUTY TO LAY AND DELIVER FINANCIAL STATEMENTS S388
• The directors shall lay before the co in GM, copies of the FS of the co made up to a date
not exceeding nine months previous to the date of the meeting:
i. Directors must at a date not later than 18 months after the incorporation
ii. For subsequent years, once every calendar year.
• The auditors’ report shall be read before the co in GM, and be open to the inspection of
any member of the co.
• In respect of each year, the directors shall deliver with the annual return to CAC
i. a copy of the balance sheet,
ii. the profit and loss account and
iii. the notes on the statements which were laid before the GM.
SHAREHOLDERS’ RIGHT TO OBTAIN COPIES OF FS S392
• Any member or debenture holder of a co, whether or not entitled to have copies of the
co’s FS sent to him as of right is entitled to be furnished on demand and without charge
with a copy of the co’s last FS.
• If after 7 days of the demand, the co fails to comply, it shall be liable for a penalty of
fine as may be specified in the regulation.
MODIFIED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS BY SMALL COMPANIES S393
• A small company may deliver to CAC, modified financial statements in accordance with
Part 1 of Schedule 6.
• The modified balance sheet shall be an abbreviated version of the Full balance sheet. In
this circumstance, the profit and loss account, director’s report and auditor’s report need
not be delivered to CAC as annexures to the balance sheet.
221
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• The “balance sheet total” means the aggregate of the amounts shown as assets in the
company’s balance sheet S394(5).
• The “number of employees” means the average number of persons employed by the
company in that year S394(6).
PUBLICATION OF FINANCIAL STATEMENTS S398
• This means the publication by a company of full individual or group FS required by S388
to be laid before the company in GM and delivered to CAC, including the directors’
report.
• That is laying the account before the general meeting of the company, reading auditor’s
report before the company in general meeting and
• Delivering to CAC,
i. a copy each of the balance sheet,
ii. profit and loss account and
iii. notes on the statements laid before the company in general meeting along with
iv. annual return of the company.
• S398 deals with publication of full FS while,
• S399 deals with publication of abridged FS.
AUDITOR
• An auditor is a person appointed and saddled with the responsibility of examining
company’s books and accounts, and making a report to the members on the accounts
examined by him including every BS, P&L account and all group accounts, laid before a
company in general meeting, during his tenure of office.
APPOINTMENT OF AUDITORS S401
Every company shall at each AGM appoint an auditor or auditors to audit the FS of the co, and to
hold office from the conclusion of that, until the conclusion of the next, AGM S401(1).
APPOINTMENT OF AUDITORS BY DIRECTORS S401(5)
• The first auditors may be appointed by the directors at any time before the company is
entitled to commence business and auditors so appointed hold office until the conclusion
of the next AGM, provided that—
a) the company may at a GM remove any such auditors and appoint in their place any
other person who has been nominated for appointment by any member of the
company and of whose nomination notice has been given to the members of the
company at least 14 days before the date of the meeting; and
b) if the directors fail to appoint, the co may, in a GM convened for that purpose,
appoint the first auditors.
222
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Members at AGM can also appoint auditor(s) under the following circumstances;
i. where the directors fail to exercise their power to appoint the 1st auditor(s)
S401(5)(b);
ii. Subsequent appointments of auditor(s) are made by members at each AGM with
the exception of filling casual vacancies S401(1).
iii. At any AGM, a retiring auditor however appointed, shall be re-appointed without any
resolution being passed unless S401(2);
a) he is not qualified for re-appointment; or
b) a resolution has been passed at the meeting appointing some other person instead
of him or expressly providing that, he should not be reappointed; or
c) he has given the company written notice of his unwillingness to be reappointed.
EXEMPTION FROM AUDIT REQUIREMENT S402
• A company is exempt from audit of accounts in respect of a financial year if—
i. it has not carried on any business since its incorporation; or
ii. it is a small company within the meaning of section 394.
• A company is not entitled to an exemption if it was at any time within the financial year
in question
i. an insurance company,
ii. a bank or
iii. any other company as may be prescribed by the Commission.
QUALIFICATION OF AUDITORS S403
None of the following persons is qualified for appointment as auditor of a company:
1. an officer or servant of the company;
2. a person who is a partner of or in the employment of an officer or servant of the co;
3. a body corporate.
4. persons who in respect of any period of an audit were in the employment of the co or
were connected therewith in any manner.
5. a person disqualified from being an auditor of a holding or subsidiary co
6. a debtor to the co or related co, in an amount exceeding N500,000
7. a shareholder or spouse of a shareholder of a co whose employee is an officer of the co
8. a person who is or whose partner, employee or employer is responsible for the keeping of
the register of holders of debentures of the co
223
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
9. an employee of or consultant to the co who has been engaged for more than one year in
the maintenance of any of the co’s financial records or preparation of any of its FS
10. a firm is qualified for appointment as auditor of a company if, all the partners are
qualified for appointment as auditors of the company.
AUDITOR’S REPORT AND AUDIT COMMITTEE S404
• The auditor(s) of a co, shall make a report to the members on the account examined by
him and on every BS and P&L account and on all group FS, copies of which are to be
laid before the company in a GM, during the auditor’s tenure of office.
• The auditors’ report shall state the matters set out in the Fifth Schedule in addition to the
report made under subsection (1), and the auditor shall in the case of a pub co, make a
report to an audit committee which shall be established by the pub co
• For a pub co, the report must be subject to the scrutiny of an audit committee.
DUTIES AND LIABILITIES OF AUDITORS
1. Utmost good faith (full disclosure of financial malfeasance)
2. Duty to exercise reasonable care and skill (S415) implying that he could be liable for
negligence. In Re Kingston Cotton Mill No2, Lindely L.J. said an auditor is a watchdog
while Lord Denning in Formento Sterling Area Ltd v Selsdon Fountain Co Ltd said
that, though auditor is not blood bound, he must approach his work with an inquiring
mind suspecting that someone might have made a mistake.
3. Duty to certify only what he believes
4. Duty to make exhaustive investigation
5. An auditor is liable in damages if he is found to be negligent and the co suffers loss.
Directors are to sue in such situation, but if they fail, any member can sue after notice of
30 days has been given to the directors
6. An auditor can be liable to an investor who invests and suffers loss due to information
given by the auditor Hedley Bryne & Co v Hellers & Partners Ltd.
REMUNERATION OF AUDITORS S408
• in the case of an auditor appointed by the directors, the remuneration may be fixed by the
directors; or
• be fixed by the company in GM or in such manner as the co in GM may determine
• “remuneration” includes sums paid by the company in respect of the auditors’ expenses.
REMOVAL OF AUDITORS S409
• An auditor may be removed by ordinary resolution of which special notice was given
notwithstanding, any agreement between them, before the expiration of his tenure
provided S409(1)
• The company shall within 14 days give notice in the prescribed form to CAC and failure
attracts fine penalty to be specified by regulation S409(2).
224
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
225
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
auditors to liaise and defraud the company and questioning the directors on the findings
of the auditor(s).
COMPOSITION OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE S404
• It shall consist of five members comprising of
i. three members and
ii. two non-executive directors,
• Remuneration? the members of the audit committee are not entitled to remuneration,
• Tenure of office: they are subject to election annually.
• The AC shall examine the auditors’ report and make recommendations thereon to the
annual general meeting as it may deem fit.
• All members of the AC shall be financially literate, and at least one member shall be a
member of a professional accounting body in Nigeria established by an Act of the
National Assembly.
• Any member may nominate another member of the co to the AC by giving written notice
of such nomination to the secretary of the company at least 21 days before the AGM
and any nomination not received prior to the meeting as stipulated is invalid.
OBJECTIVES AND FUNCTIONS OF AUDIT COMMITTEE 404(7)
Subject to such other additional functions and powers that the company’s articles may stipulate,
the objectives and functions of the AC are to—
1. ascertain whether the accounting and reporting policies of the co are in accordance with
legal requirements and agreed ethical practices;
2. review the scope and planning of audit requirements;
3. review the findings on management matters in conjunction with the external auditor and
departmental responses thereon;
4. keep under review the effectiveness of the co’s system of accounting and internal control;
5. make recommendations to the board with regard to the appointment, removal and
remuneration of the external auditors of the co; and
6. authorise the internal auditor to carry out investigations into any activities of the co which
may be of interest or concern to the committee.
ANNUAL RETURNS CAP16 from S417
• Every company shall, once at least in every year, make and deliver to the Commission an
annual return but the company needs not make a return in the year if the company does
not hold a meeting in that year under review S417.
• CAC Form 19 (Annual Returns Form) while
• CAC Form 22 is Annual Report of Exempted Company (unregistered company).
FORM OF ANNUAL RETURN
• The AR shall be in the following form;
i. Schedule 7 – Company having share capital other than small company S418
226
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• If a balance sheet after laying it before the general meeting is amended, it must be stated.
• In the case of a private company whether small company or limited by guarantee, the
annual return will be accompanied by the following;
i. a certificate by a director and the secretary of the private company, to the effect that,
the company has not since the date of its incorporation or last AR, as the case maybe
issued any invitation to the public to subscribe to any of its shares or debenture;
ii. where the AR discloses the fact that the number of members of the company exceed
50, also, a Certificate signed by a director and the secretary that the excess number
consists wholly of persons who under S.22(3) are not included in reckoning the
number of 50 i.e., employees of the co.
• A small company shall in addition to the certificate, send with the AR a certificate signed
by a director and the secretary that:
i. it is a private company limited by shares;
ii. the amount of its turn-over for that year is not more than N120,000,000 or such
amount as may be fixed by the Commission;
iii. its net assets value is not more than N60,000,000 or such amount as may be fixed by
the Commission;
iv. none of its members is an alien;
v. none of its members is a government, a government agent or nominee; and
vi. the directors among them hold at least 51% of the equity share capital of the
company.
227
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Majority rule is a principle that in the context of corporate law, the logical principle is
that the majority will always prevail. This is because decisions are based on votes. The
majority can then become overbearing as most times instead of acting in the company’s
interest, they act in their own interest against the company or minority.
• There is the indoor management, historically the court has been of the view that the court
is not the manager of the business or managing the squabbles within the business. The
attitude of the court is that even when there is an issue, the court would consider if it is
what the majority can solve and if so, the court would not intervene.
• The court or law however, tries to equilibrate the situation to contain the overbearing
influence of the majority. However, the court won’t allow the minority to always turn to
it at every single action taken by the majority. So, it is usually when there is fraud.
CORPORATE SOVEREIGNTY
• The rule of corporate sovereignty was laid down in the old English case of Foss v
Harbottle (1843)2 Hare 461; SPDC Nigeria Limited v. Nwawka (2003) 6 NWLR (Pt.
815) 184 SC; Elufioye & Ors, v. Halilu & Ors. (1993) 6 NWLR (Pt. 301) 570;
Abubakri v. Smith (1973) 6 SC 31; Yalaju-Amaye v. Associated Registered
Engineering Contractors Ltd (1990) 4 NWLR (Pt 145) 422; Edokpolor& Co Ltd v.
Sem – Edo Wire Industries Ltd (1984) 15 NSCC 553, Mariner Nominees v FBIR.
• The rule is codified in S341: where an irregularity has been committed in the course of a
company’s affairs or any wrong has been done to the company, only the company can sue
to remedy that wrong, and only the company can ratify the irregular conduct.
• As explained by Jenkins LJ in Edwards v Halliwell [1950] 2 All ER 1064, it has two
limbs:
i. The proper plaintiff in an action in respect of a wrong done to a company is prima
facie the company itself.
ii. Where the alleged wrong is a transaction which might be made binding on the
company and all its members by a simple majority of the members (ordinary
resolution), no individual member of the company is allowed to maintain an action in
respect of that matter ‘for the simple reason that, if a mere majority of the members of
the company…is in favour of what has been done, then cadit quaestio (in other
words, the majority rule)
RATIONALE FOR CORPORATE SOVEREIGNTY.
• Prevents multiplicity of suits over one or similar incidents or arising from the same set of
facts.
• Members in a general meeting can ratify the wrongful acts of the directors.
228
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
229
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
230
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• The basic feature and uniqueness of this domain of action is that it is an action which the
company, alone, ordinarily is empowered to maintain S346.
• However, the Act empowers a shareholder to, with leave of court, bring an action in the
name or on behalf of the company or intervene in an action, or to intervene in an action to
which the company or the company’s subsidiary is a party, for the purpose of
prosecuting, defending or discontinuing the action on behalf of the company or the
company’s subsidiary S346(1).
GROUNDS UPON WHICH THE COURT MAY GRANT LEAVE S346(2)
• No action may be brought and no intervention may be made, unless the Court is satisfied
that:
i. a cause of action has arisen from an actual or proposed act or omission involving
negligence, default, breach of duty or trust by a director or a former director of the
company;
ii. the applicant has given reasonable notice to the directors of the company of his
intention to apply to the Court;
iii. the directors of the company do not bring, diligently prosecute, defend or discontinue
the action;
iv. the notice contains a factual basis for the claim and the actual or potential damage
caused to the company;
v. the applicant is acting in good faith; and
vi. it appears to be in the best interest of the company that the action be brought,
prosecuted, defended or discontinued.
• A DA may be against the director or any other person (or both).
• In any DA, the plaintiff shall have the right to obtain any relevant documents from the
defendant and the witnesses at trial, and may in pursuance of that right request categories
of documents from such person without identifying specific documents.
ORDERS THE COURT CAN MAKE UPON A SUCCESSFUL DA S347(2)
The Court may make an order;
i. authorising the applicant or any other person to control the conduct of the action;
ii. giving directions for the conduct of the action;
iii. directing that any amount adjudged payable by a defendant in the action is paid, in whole
or in part, directly to former and present security holders of the company instead of to the
company; and
iv. requiring the company to pay reasonable legal fees incurred by the applicant in
connection with the proceedings
WHO CAN INSTITUTE A DERIVATIVE ACTION? S352
“applicant” means;
i. a registered holder or a beneficial owner and a former registered holder or beneficial
owner, of a security of a company;
231
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
232
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
6. varying or setting aside a transaction or contract to which the company is a party and
compensating the company or any other party to the transaction or contract;
7. directing an investigation to be made by the CAC;
8. appointing a receiver or a receiver and manager of property of the company;
9. restraining a person from engaging in specific conduct or from doing a specific act or
thing; or
10. requiring a person to do a specific act or thing.
NB:
• where an order that a company be wound up is made under this section, the provisions of
the Act relating to winding up of companies shall apply mutatis mutandis, as if the order
had been made upon an application duly filed in the court by the company S355(3).
• where an order under this section makes any alteration or addition to the memart of a
company, the alteration or addition supersedes provisions of the Act, and shall have
effect as if it had been duly made by a resolution of the company, and cannot be altered
without the leave of the court S355(4).
• a CTC of the order shall, within 14 days of the making of the order, or such longer
period as the court may allow, be delivered to CAC for registration by the co S355(5).
INVESTIGATION OF THE COMPANY BY CAC S357
• This section applies to where the co itself or its members applies for such investigation.
• The Commission may appoint one or more competent inspectors to investigate the affairs
of a company and to report on them in such manner as it may direct.
• The appointment may be made:
i. in the case of a co having a share capital, on the application of members holding
at least 1/10 of issued share capital;
ii. in the case of a company not having a share capital, on the application of at least
1/10 in number of the persons on the company’s register of members; and
iii. in any other case, on the application of the company.
• The application shall be supported by such evidence as CAC may require for the purpose
of showing that the applicant(s) have good reason for requiring the investigation S357(3).
• Where a co’s employee, in compliance with an inspector’s request, provides the inspector
with any information concerning the co’s affairs, the co shall protect the employee from
any form of discrimination or other unfair treatment S357(4).
• Any employee relieved of his employment without any just cause, other than for reason
of disclosure made pursuant to the provision of this section, is entitled to a compensation
which is calculated as if he had attained the maximum age of retirement or had served the
maximum period of service, in accordance with his terms of employment or conditions of
service to the co S357(5).
233
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
234
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
235
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Someone can bring action to wind up under just and Equitable Grounds, the remedy wasn’t
readily available. If there was some form of other remedy, the court won’t grant it.
The remedy was readily available in the context of small family companies or quasi partnerships.
It’s what happened in Ebrahimi v Westborn Galleries Ltd as it’s a co of father and son and the
applicant. The father and son ganged up and removed him as director from the co and they
followed the correct procedures of passing ordinary resolution while removing him making it
legal. Being hard-done by the removal and very unhappy brought action to wind up the company
under “winding up on just and equitable ground”, lost at TC and CA but won at HL based on
equitable grounds.
It is immaterial whether the act is in the interest of the co, provided it is inequitable per Lord
Wilberforce. This was given the initial understanding that all three of them would be directors,
the HL held it to suffice and because that was the only remedy available in the 1948 act, it was
wound up. But now, there are more remedies like unfair prejudice, so the court wouldn’t grant
that now but likely follow other remedies. It would amount to using a sledge hammer to kill an
ant. You cannot be closing up companies that create employment just like that when millions are
unemployed, such public interest is usually considered by the court.
If at all it would apply today, it would be in very small companies and there must be evidence
that like in Ebrahimi, there was a pre-agreement between them and the would-be directors. The
phrase is legitimate expectation. This was expressed in O’Neil v Phillips where Lord Hoffman
referred to the phrase as an unruly horse that won’t be allowed to dent the smooth process of
corporate operations. So, even the legitimate expectation based on the pre-agreement may not
now suffice in all circumstances.
The remedies now are numerous, so this winding up under just and equitable grounds, though
still in the statute books is highly unlikely to be granted.
236
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
In Fasakin v Fasakin, an application on the ground that there was reckless spending by the
director and treating the company as his personal property was refused with the CA overruling
the TC which had earlier granted it.
DRAFT: APPLICATION FOR DERIVATION ACTION
IN THE FEDERAL HIGH COURT OF NIGERIA
HOLDEN AT LAGOS
SUIT NO: FHC/L/C/15/2022
IN THE MATTER OF EDUPAL NIGERIA LIMITED
AND
IN THE MATTER OF COMPANIES AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, 2020
BETWEEN
EDUPAL NIGERIA LTD----------------------------------------------------PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT
AND
PETER PAN --------------------------------------------------------------DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT
MOTION ON NOTICE
BROUGHT PURSUANT TO RULE 2(2) COMPANIES PROCEEDING RULES 1992,
SECTION 346 COMPANIES AND ALLIED MATTERS ACT, 2020 AND THE INHERENT
JURISDICTION OF THE COURT
TAKE NOTICE that this honourable court shall be moved on the 15th day of August, 2022 at the
hour of 9 O’clock or so soon thereafter as Counsel to the Applicant may be heard praying the
court for the following reliefs:
1. AN ORDER FOR LEAVE of court to bring an action in the name or on behalf of the
company to which the company is a party for the purpose of prosecuting the action on
behalf of the company.
2. AN ORDER directing an investigation to be made into the approval of a new
remuneration for the Managing Director of the company by the Corporate Affairs
Commission.
3. AN ORDER varying or setting aside the resolution of the Board of Director approving a
new remuneration for the Managing Director pending the investigation by the Corporate
Affairs Commission.
4. AND FOR SUCH FURTHER OTHER ORDERS as the honourable court may deem fit
to make in the circumstances.
Dated the 19th day of April, 2019.
____________________________
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT
Chris Ozo Agbata.
C. O. Agbata LP
237
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
238
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
239
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Some of the rights attaching to shareholding include; the right to attend and vote at a
meeting S138(a) and (b).
• A share is a chose inaction and is property transferable as provided in the articles S139.
See Okoya v Santili.
TYPES/CLASSES OF SHARES
• Please see as from page 86 infra on construction of share capital.
PROHIBITION OF NON-VOTING AND WEIGHTED SHARES
• S140 abolished and prohibits the issue of non-voting and weighted shares with the
exception of preference shares in certain circumstances.
• S168 provides for the circumstances where preferences shares are permitted to carry
more than one vote per share are as follows, upon any resolution;
(a) during such period as the preferential dividend or any part of it remains in arrears and unpaid,
such period starting from a date not more than 12 months or such lesser period as the articles
may provide, after the due date of the dividend;
(b) which varies the rights attached to such shares;
(c) to remove an auditor of the company or to appoint another person in place of such auditor; or
(d) for the winding up of the company or during the winding up of the company.
(2) Notwithstanding the provisions of section 140, any special resolution of a company
increasing the number of shares of any class, may validly resolve that any existing class of
preference shares shall carry the right to such votes additional to one vote per share as is
necessary in order to preserve the existing ratio which the votes exercisable by the holders of
such preference shares at a general meeting of the company bear to the total votes exercisable at
the meeting.
This subsection is to the effect that even when the share capital of a company is increased, the
company may through its article provide for increment of the votes of preference shares to
maintain the ratio that hitherto existed. Even more controlling power, because if they were
already majority may be by virtue of subsection 1 of this section, increase in shares that would
have provided opportunity for the ordinary shareholders to reduce preference shares majority
through the backdoor as happened in Greenhalgh v. Ardene Cinemas Ltd. (No. 1) per Lord
Green, White v. Bristol Aeroplane Co, Ltd per Romer J and Cumbrian Newspapers Group
Ltd v. Cumberland and Westmoreland Herald Newspapers and Printing Co. Ltd per Scot
J has also been scuffled by this subsection.
(3) For the purposes of subsection (2), a dividend is deemed to be due on the date appointed in
the articles for the payment of the dividend for any year or other period, or if no such date is
240
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
appointed, upon the day immediately following the expiration of the year or other period, and
whether or not such dividend shall have been earned or declared.
ISSUE OF SHARES
• Please see as from page 86 infra on construction of share capital.
MODES OF ACQUISITION OF SHARES
i. Subscription S105
ii. Allotment S149
iii. Transfer S175
iv. Transmission S179
SUBSCRIPTION S105
• One can become a member of a company by subscription. By subscription we mean the
members who signed/subscribed to the memorandum and articles of association of a
company. They are known as the subscribers and are the first members of the company.
• The subscribers must together subscribe to all the shares amounting in value to the
authorised share capital as provided in S27(2)(b).
• At incorporation, the amount of the share capital stated in the memorandum to be
registered shall not be less than the minimum issued share capital S124(1).
• At least 25% of the share capital must be paid up S128(1)(a).
ALLOTMENT S149
• It is the allocation of a specified number of shares of a company to an applicant.
• Upon receipt of an application, a company shall where it wholly or partially accepts the
application, make an allotment to the applicant and within 42 days notify the applicant of
the fact of the allotment and the number of shares allotted to him S150(1)(c).
• The notification is by way of letter of allotment or a letter demanding payment for the
shares allotted.
• An applicant shall have the right at any time before allotment, to withdraw his application
by written notice to the company S150(2). This is known as renunciation.
• The company will subsequently enter the name of such allotee in the register of members
thereby, making him a member of the company.
METHOD OF APPLICATION FOR ALLOTMENT S150
• This depends of the type of co (whether is private or public)
o For a private co or pub co where the issue is not public, an applicant applies in
writing stating the number of shares he wishes to purchase.
o For a pub co where the issue is public, the application is made by the applicant
completing, signing and returning the form of application to the co.
• The BOD will have to pass a resolution to decide on the application
241
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Notification of allotment of shares forms a contract between the co and the applicant with
effect from the date of the allotment S151
• Sending a letter of regret, where the whole shares applied for cannot be granted
• In the event where a letter of regret is sent, part of the money representing the shares not
issued to the applicant should be refunded Dangote Ind Ltd v Bank PHB, it was held
that when issuing letter of regret, the money or part of it should be refunded, not merely
to increase share capital to issue.
• Return of allotment is done by filing Form CAC 5 within 1-month S154.
• There is also, pre-emptive rights with respect to allotment of shares S142.
PROCEDURE FOR ALLOTMENT OF SHARES (PLC)
1. Issue a prospectus.
2. Open a subscription list.
3. Receive applications and record in Application and Allotment Sheets.
4. Convene board (or Allotment Committee) meeting to pass a resolution of allotment.
5. Issue letters of allotment and letters of regret as appropriate and applicable.
6. Deal with letters of renunciation if any.
7. Prepare share certificates to be issued within 2 months S171.
8. Enter allottees’ names in the register of members.
9. File Return of Allotment (Form CAC 5) within one month of allotment.
NB: shares maybe paid for in cash or non-cash consideration S160.
10. If consideration involves capital investment of N20,000 or more, apply under the
Industrial Inspectorate Act for approval.
11. If shares are issued for a consideration other than cash; have the consideration valued and
by an independent valuer and obtain particulars of valuation.
12. Prepare and file along with Form CAC 5;
i. Particulars of valuation (valuation report);
ii. Agreement for sale of property or for services or other consideration;
iii. Agreement constituting the title of the allottee to the allotment.
iv. BOD resolution approving allotment by non-cash consideration
RETURN OF ALLOTMENT S154
• Every company within one month of allotment of shares must file with CAC Return of
Allotment that is, Form CAC 5.
CALL ON SHARES S158
• This is a demand made by a company upon a member to pay an amount outstanding on
his partly paid shares.
242
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
243
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• A person may become a member of a company by having the shares of that company
transferred to him by the holder of those shares and entering his name in the register of
members.
METHOD OF TRANSFER OF SHARES S175
• Transfer of shares shall be effected by delivery of a proper instrument of transfer to the
company and the subsequent registration of the transferee in the register of members
S175(1) & (2).
• The transferor is deemed to remain a holder of the share until the name of the transferee
is entered in the register of members in respect of the shares S175(3), Ferris George &
Son Ltd v Khoury; Starcola Nig Ltd v Adeniji.
• The directors may refuse to register any transfer of shares and notice to that effect must
be given to the transferee within 2 months.
PROCEDURE OF TRANSFER SS 175, 176 & 181
• The procedure varies depending on whether the transferor is selling all his shares to one
purchaser or only part of his shares or all his shares to different purchasers.
• Where he is selling all his shares, the procedure is:
1. The transferor completes and signs the instrument of transfer under seal and delivers
it with the share certificate to the transferee.
2. The transferee completes and signs the instrument and delivers it with the share
certificate to the company for registration.
3. The transferee becomes the holder once his name is entered in the register of
members.
4. The company issues him a new certificate within 3 months and cancels the old one.
5. Alteration is effected on the register.
6. Notice to CAC as in Form CAC 5 (return of allotment).
• If what is transferred is part of the shares or all the shares but to more than one
purchaser, the procedure is as follows: S181
1. The transferor executes the instrument of transfer and delivers it together with the
share certificate to the company.
2. The company on receipt of the instrument and the certificate endorses on the
instrument the words “certificate lodged”
3. The endorsed instrument is delivered to the transferee in exchange for the price.
4. The transferee executes and sends the instrument to the company for registration and
issuance of share certificate.
5. Old certificate is submitted and a new certificate is issued to the transferee within 3
months.
6. Alteration is effected on the register.
7. Notice to CAC as in Form CAC 5 (return of allotment).
• This process is called certification of a transfer.
244
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
TRANSMISSION S179
• The vesting of shares in the personal representatives on the death of a shareholder is
known as transmission of shares.
• On the death of a member, the survivor(s) where the deceased was a joint holder or the
personal representatives of the deceased where he was a sole holder, shall be the only
persons recognized by the company as having any title to his interest in the shares
S179(1).
• The PR may decide to elect another person in whose name the shares will be registered
but the co reserves the right still refuse to register it as it would have had was it
transferred by the original owner in his lifetime S179(2).
• The means to claim title to the interest in shares is the production of probate of the will or
letters of the administration of the estate S173. See Tika Tore Press Ltd v Abina.
• A personal representative may himself validly transfer the share or other interests of a
deceased member even though he is not registered as a member S178.
PROCTECTION OF BENEFICIARIES S180
• Any person claiming to be interested in any share, dividend or interest on them, may
protect his interest by serving on the company concerned a notice of his interest.
• The company shall enter, on the register of members, the fact that such notice has been
served and shall not register any transfer or make any payment or return in respect of the
shares contrary to the terms of the notice until the expiration of 42 days’ notice to the
claimant to the proposed transfer or payment.
• In the event of any default by the company in complying with this section, the company
shall compensate any person injured by the default.
• The interests of a beneficiary under a will are equitable only until the shares are
transferred to him and he has been registered as a member of the company.
DIVIDEND WARRANT
• This is the instrument used for paying dividend due on profits to members.
• It is now regarded as a negotiable instrument.
• Stamp Duty on Dividend Warrant.
• Currently, dividend warrant is no longer in use. What is presently in use is E-dividend.
MORTGAGE OF SHARES
• Shares are property transferrable as security for an advance.
• In other words, it can serve as a collateral for grant of facilities.
• The mortgage may be legal or equitable.
ATTACHMENT OF SHARES
• Shares held by a judgment debtor in public company or corporation may be attached and
sold by the judgment creditor.
245
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• This is made possible by the Judgment Enforcement Rules (Order V Rule 1) under the
Sheriffs and Civil Process Act.
DEBENTURES
• A company may borrow money for the purpose of its business or objects and may charge
or mortgage its undertaking or property and issue debentures S191.
• Debentures are instruments issued to lenders to acknowledge indebtedness by a company.
• The instrument is often, but not necessarily, by deed Union Bank of Nig. Ltd. v Tropic
Foods Ltd.
• A debenture is a legal document which states the terms on which a company had
borrowed money that is; a written acknowledgement of debt.
• Put differently, debenture is a loan agreement by which the lenders provide money to a
company to be repaid at a later date while bearing interest at an agreed rate.
• Debenture is usually secured on company’s property though, it need not always be so, as
there are unsecured debentures.
• Unlike shares, debenture is an external source of capital of a company for a company’s
business or objects. See General Auction Estate Co. v Smith; Inter-contractors (Nig)
Ltd v N.P.F.M.B and Union Bank of Nig. Ltd v Tropic Foods Ltd.
• Debentures are transferable securities and the normal conditions require the company to
maintain a register of debenture holders (except bearer debentures).
• The co can only borrow to the extent that the AOA allows but if it exceeds, it may be
ratified by MIGM.
• Co can issue debentures beyond borrowing limit, even outside of its authorised business
objects and it shall be valid S44(3), SS 92, 93, British Royal Bank v Torquand.
• Debentures may generally be of two forms:
o simple debenture or
o series of debenture (debenture stock) covered by trust deed
• Holder is entitled to a certificate within 60 days of creation and it can be reissued when
lost S192.
• Statement on a debenture is prima-facie evidence of title of the debenture by the person
named on it S194
• Every co must keep a register of charges SS 215 – 216
• Registration with CAC as in Form CAC 9 within 90 days of creation, non-registration
makes it void against a liquidator S222
• Form CAC 10 is for satisfaction of charge.
TYPES OF DEBENTURES
1. Perpetual Debentures; S196
2. Convertible Debentures; S197
3. Secured and Unsecured (Naked) Debentures; S198
4. Redeemable Debentures; S199
5. Registered Debentures;
246
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
6. Bearer Debentures
7. Syndicate or Loan Debentures
PERPETUAL DEBENTURES S196
• These debentures are made irredeemable or redeemable only on the happening of a
contingency, however remote, or on the expiration of a period, however long.
• Such contingency maybe winding up of a company, takeover bid etc.
CONVERTIBLE DEBENTURES S197
• These are debentures issued with a proviso that at a determinable future date and at the
option of the debenture holders shall be converted into ordinary shares.
• But no debenture so converted into shares shall appear as if the shares were sold at a
discount. This is because of the ban on issue of shares at discount S146.
• The conversion is in lieu of redemption or repayment.
SECURED AND UNSECURED (NAKED) DEBENTURES S198
• Secured Debentures:
o A secured debenture is that which is secured by a charge over the company’s
property and it may be so secured by a fixed charge or by a floating charge.
• Naked Debentures:
o While a naked debenture is one which is not secured by a charge also called an
unsecured loan note.
• Debentures may be secured by a fixed charge on certain of the company’s property or a
floating charge over the whole or a specified part of the company’s undertaking and
assets, or by both a fixed charge on certain property and a floating charge.
• A charge securing debentures shall become enforceable on the occurrence of the events
specified in the debentures or the deed securing the same.
REDEEMABLE DEBENTURES S199
• A company limited by shares may issue debentures which are, or at the option of the
company are, liable to be redeemed.
• These debentures at the time of issuance are said to be redeemable at an agreed date.
• Redemption of this type of debenture is out of the profit of the co or from a Sinking
Fund, which is a fund set aside for redemption of debentures at a future or agreed date.
REGISTERED DEBENTURES
• These are debentures registered in the register of debenture holders and payable only to
the registered holders.
• It can be transferred and the transfer becomes effective after registration in the register of
debenture holders.
• It cannot be used as a negotiable instrument.
247
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
BEARER DEBENTURES
• These are negotiable instruments and payable to the bearer.
• It is in succession and payable to the last endorsee.
• Bearer debentures do not require the company to maintain a register of debenture holders.
SYNDICATE OR LOAN DEBENTURES
• It is a successive or series of debentures on the same property with not right of priority of
one after the other, they rank pari-passu but asset mut cover borrowing
ISSUE OF DEBENTURES
• Debentures are issued in accordance with the provisions in the memart of association.
• If debentures are issued to the public, apart from complying with memart, they must also
comply with requirements, of S71(1) ISA i.e., a prospectus must be issued.
• A prospectus is the basis of the contract between the company and the public.
FORMS OF DEBENTURES
• There are two forms of debentures
i. Simple debenture and
ii. Debenture stock.
• Simple Debenture:
o This type is used where the loan is from one or few people.
o It is an agreement stating the sum borrowed, signed, sealed and delivered on
behalf of the lender/holder and the borrower/company
o The conditions of borrowing are endorsed at the back.
• Debenture Stock:
o Where the loan is from a large number of people, debenture stock is used.
o A debenture stock is a securitised loan stock by which loans are made by way of
securities, which are alloted in the same way shares are allotted except that
debenture stock holders are creditors to the company.
o Debenture stock must be issued under a trust deed between the company and the
trustee of the debenture holders appointed by the deed S208(1).
o No debenture trust deed shall cover more than one class of debentures, whether or
not the trust deed is required by this section to be executed.
CONTENTS OF EVERY DEBENTURE TRUST DEED S209
Every debenture trust deed, whether required by section 208 or not, shall state;
a) the maximum sum which the co may raise by issuing debentures of the same class;
b) the maximum discount which may be allowed on the issue or reissue of the debentures,
and
• the maximum premium at which the debentures may be made redeemable;
248
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
c) the nature of any asset over which a mortgage, charge or security is created by the trust
deed in favour of the trustee for the benefit of the debenture holders equally, and
• the identity of the assets except where such a charge is a floating charge;
d) the nature of any asset over which a mortgage, charge or security has been or will be
created in favour of any person other than the trustee for the benefit of the debenture
holders equally, and,
• the identity of the assets subject to it except where such a charge is a floating
charge.
e) whether the company has created or will create any mortgage, charge or security for the
benefit of some, but not all, of the holders of debentures issued under the trust deed;
f) any prohibition or restriction on the power of the co to issue debentures or create
mortgages, charges or any security on any of its assets ranking in priority to, or equally
with the debentures issued under the trust deed;
g) whether the co has power to acquire debentures issued under the trust deed before the
date of their redemption and to re-issue the debentures;
h) the rate of, and the dates on which, interest on the debentures issued under the trust deed
shall be paid and the manner in which payment may be made;
i) the date or dates on which the principal or the debentures issued under the trust deed shall
be repaid or redeemed, and unless the whole principal is to be repaid to all the debenture
holders at the same time, the manner in which redemption is effected, whether by the
payment of equal instalments of principal in respect of each debenture, or by the selection
of debentures for redemption by the company, or by drawing, ballot, or otherwise;
j) in the case of convertible debentures, the dates and terms on which the debentures may be
converted into shares and the amounts which may be credited as paid up on those shares
in the right of the debentures held by them;
k) the circumstances in which the debenture holders are entitled to realise any mortgage,
charge or security vested in the trustee or any other person for their benefit (other than the
circumstances in which they are entitled to do so by this Act);
l) the powers of the co and the trustee to call meetings of the debenture holders and the
rights of debenture holders to require the co or the trustee to call such meetings;
m) whether the rights of debenture holders may be altered or abrogated and if so, the
conditions which shall be fulfilled, and the procedure which shall be followed, to effect
such an alteration or abrogation;
n) the amount or rate of remuneration to be paid to the trustee and the period for which it is
paid, and whether it is paid in priority to the principal, interest and costs in respect of
debentures issued under the trust deed; and
o) provisions for the replacement of the trustee if required.
CONTENTS OF DEBENTURE COVERED BY TRUST DEED S210
• Every debenture covered by a debenture trust deed shall state, either in the body or in a
note forming part of the same document or endorsed therein:
a) the matters required to be stated in a debenture trust deed by section 209 (1) (a), (b),
(f), (h), (i), (j), (l) and (m) above;
249
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
b) whether the trustee of the covering debenture trust deed holds the mortgages, charges
and securities vested in him by the trust deed in trust for the debenture holders
equally, or in trust for some only of the debenture holders, and if so, which debenture
holders; and
c) whether the debenture is secured by a floating charge vested in the trustee of the
covering debenture trust deed or in the debenture holders.
CHARGES SECURING DEBENTURES SS203, 204
• Debentures may be secured by
i. Fixed charges
ii. Floating charges
• A Floating Charge means an equitable charge over the whole or a specified part of the
company’s undertakings and assets, including cash and uncalled capital of the company
both present and future, but so that the charge shall not preclude the company from
dealing with such assets until:
a) the security becomes enforceable and the holder thereof, pursuant to a power in that
behalf in the debenture or the deed securing the same, appoints a receiver or manager
or enters into possession of such assets; or
b) the Court appoints a receiver or manager of such assets on the application of the
holder; or
c) the company goes into liquidation.
• On the happening of any of the events mentioned above, the charge shall be deemed to
crystallise and become a fixed equitable charge on such of the company’s assets as are
subject to the charge, and if a receiver or manager is withdrawn with the consent of the
chargee, or the charge withdraws from possession before the charge has been fully
discharged, the charge shall thereupon be deemed to cease to be a fixed charge and again
to become a floating charge.
• A fixed charge on any property shall have priority over a floating charge affecting that
property, unless the terms on which the floating charge was granted prohibits the
company from granting any later charge having priority over the floating charge and the
person in whose favour such later charge was granted had notice of that prohibition at the
time when the charge was granted to him:
o Provided that a person is deemed to have notice of such prohibition in a floating
charge where a notice indicating the existence of such prohibition is registered
with the CAC S204.
250
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
251
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
principal and/or interest which, as a debt, will be ground for winding up under
S233(b)(ii).
4. Sale
The power of sale may be exercised in the following circumstances:
i. If there is power in the debenture or trust deed. Where there is a single debenture, it
will normally contain power of sale to be exercised by the receiver. Even where there is
no express power, the implied power of sale by a mortgage may be exercised. Where
there is a trust deed, there will normally be an express power of sale and a sale of the
company's business operates to determine the contract of service of employees.
ii. On the order of court following a debenture holder's action. When an order is made,
the sale is generally carried out under the direction of the court and the purchased money
paid into the court. The court may in special circumstances, authorise sale out of court.
5. Foreclosure
• Foreclosure may be claimed and granted in a debenture holder's action S233(2)(b)(i). The
effect of the order is the same as for any mortgage, and the foreclosure may extend to
uncalled capital of the co. An order will not be made unless all the debenture holders of
every class are parties to the action, but the court may order sale instead of foreclosure if
it considers it just so to do.
253
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
254
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Primary Market: In this part of the capital market fresh securities are issued by
companies, for the purpose of raising capital.
• New securities in this regard may be traded by way of:
o Initial Public Offer
o Subsequent public offer
o Hybrid issue
255
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Secondary Market: Here, investors can buy shares and other securities that have been
previously issued and traded.
CAPITAL MARKET OPERATORS AND CONSULTANTS
• Capital market operators
• They are to be registered with SEC. These include:
i. Issuing Houses
ii. Securities Dealers
iii. Stock Brokers
iv. Trustees
v. Portfolio Managers
vi. Underwriters
vii. Custodians
• Capital Market Consultants
• They offer expertise service in the capital market.
• To operate in the capital market, they must be registered with SEC.
• Examples of capital market consultants:
i. Solicitors
ii. Accountants
iii. Valuers
iv. Investment Advisers
v. Rating Agencies
vi. Engineers
REGISTRABLE SECURITIES R279 SEC Rules 2013.
NB: Security offers by the following entities must be registered with SEC R279 (1) (a) & (b)
SEC Rules:
• All securities of:
i. Public companies
ii. Collective Investment Schemes
iii. Investment trust companies
iv. Government and its agencies
v. Supranational bodies
NB: securities arising from conversion of a private company to public limited company shall be
registered by the SEC R279 (1)(d) SEC Rules.
METHODS OF PUBLIC OFFER OF SECURITIES R279 (1)(c) SEC Rules
All securities subject to registration may be offered through the following methods:
1. Initial public offer
2. Offer by Introduction
3. Direct offer to the public (offer for subscription)
256
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
2. Offer by Introduction
• By this method, the shares of a company can be listed without the conduct of an initial
public offer (IPO).
• The company will usually have raised capital, prior to the initial listing of the company’s
shares on the trading board
257
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
5. Placing
• Involves the issuance of the securities of public companies, not to the public at large but
to an issuing house, which then sells to clients or institutional investors (e.g., banks,
pension funds, etc) Placement (also known as private placement by public companies)
• The company pays brokerage (commission) to the issuing house.
• This is a means by which an unquoted public company may arrange to offer its shares to
the public
• By R340(2) SEC Rules there are conditions that must be satisfied foe private placement:
• No public company shall offer securities by way of private placement without the prior
approval of the Commission.
• Private placement by public companies shall be subject to the following conditions:
a) The company shall show evidence of dire need of fresh funds or technical expertise
and shall satisfy the Commission that private placement remains the only viable
option to achieving its objective.
b) The securities shall not be offered to more than 50 subscribers.
c) The resolution of the company authorizing the placement shall be Special as defined
in the CAMA, and shall state the number of shares to be offered and the price.
d) The notice of the GM authorizing the placement shall be published in two national
daily newspapers and evidence of the publications shall be filed with SEC.
e) The aggregate number of shares to be offered through private placement by a public
quoted company shall be 30% of its existing issued and paid-up capital prior to the
offer: Provided that where the company is ailing, it may offer a higher number of
shares, subject to the approval of SEC.
f) The price of the securities of the company, if quoted, shall be on technical suspension
during the period of placement.
g) The offer shall be for a period as proposed by the issuer and approved by SEC but
not exceeding ten (10) working days: Provided that SEC may extend the period
under special circumstances.
h) All subsequent capital raising shall be approved only upon satisfactory account of
utilization of previous issue proceeds.
• Private Placements shall not be advertised, mentioned and/or discussed in the print and
electronic media. Approval of a private placement may be suspended or withdrawn for
violation of this rule. Any Capital Market Operator engaged in an advisory role on the
private placement may also be sanctioned.
6. Rights Issue
• An invitation to existing shareholders to subscribe to new securities being issued by the
company, at a special price and in proportion to their existing holdings. E.g., The
issuance of 2 new shares for every 10 shares held in the company.
• It requires prospectus but an abridged prospectus may be sufficient
258
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
7. Bonus Issue
• The proportionate issuance of new shares to the existing shareholders of the company
at no cost to the shareholders by the capitalisation of accumulated reserves from the
profits earned in the previous year
• NB: No need for the issuance of prospectus
9. Debenture
• A debenture is a medium or long-term debt instruments used by companies to borrow
money.
10. Bonds
• Bonds are tradable security issued by the following authorities:
i. Governments at the Federal (sovereign bonds)
ii. states, local governments and government agencies (revenue bonds)
iii. cities within a local government (municipal bonds)
iv. Public Companies
• FG, SG & LG bonds are tradable securities issued by the govt to raise funds for particular
projects authorised by the issuing authority SS 222 – 223 ISA.
• They can issue registered bonds or promissory notes cumulative loan outstanding shall
not be more than 50% of its revenue for the preceding year.
11. Sukuk
• It is an Islamic financial certificate that is similar to a bond.
• It represents aggregate and undivided shares of ownership in a tangible asset, as it relates
to a specific project or specific investment activity.
• Investment certificates issued as evidence of undivided ownership of tangible assets,
usufructs and services, or some investment activity, based sharia principles, approved by
SEC, R569 SEC Rules.
• The difference between bond and sukuk: the sukuk holder receives, on a periodic
basis, a portion of the profit generated by the associated asset while the bond holder
receives periodic interests, arising from the debt obligation owed to him by the bond
issuer
259
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• The minimum price is fixed but the maximum price is determined by the prices tendered
in the applications.
• Allotments are made to the highest bidder.
260
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
261
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
1. Full prospectus
• Contains a full or detailed description of the offer
2. Abridged Prospectus
• It is a summarised version of the prospectus, containing the key requirements of a
prospectus
• Takes the place of a full prospectus, which is bulky and contains many documents
• It usually issued in restricted invitation S79 ISA where the invitations are:
i. made solely to the existing shareholders of that company; or
ii. in all respects is uniform with its existing listed shares
iii. made under S79(3) and (4).
iv. involving the exemptions under S76(a) and (b).
262
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
3. Deemed Prospectus
• It does not bear the title “prospectus”, yet, it contains the basic requirements of a
prospectus which are relevant to a public offer.
• Where a statement in lieu of prospectus is issued, the company shall at least 3 days
before the first allotment of the shares deliver to SEC for registration, the statement in
lieu of prospectus signed by every person who is named in it as a director or a proposed
director of the company or by his agent authorised in writing.
• Statement in lieu of prospectus shall be in the form and contain the particulars set out in
part 1 of the 4th schedule to this Act, and in the cases mentioned in part II of that
schedule, set out the reports specified therein, and the said parts shall have effect subject
to the provisions contained in part III of that schedule., S84 ISA.
CONTRACT IN PROSPECTUS, etc., NOT TO BE VARIED WITHOUT LEAVE S81 ISA
• A company limited by shares shall not, before the statutory meeting, vary the terms of a
contract referred to in the prospectus or a statement in lieu of prospectus, except with the
approval of the statutory meeting.
• Observations: could it be that this provision refers generally to all the meetings provided
for in CAMA (SM, AGM and EGM) as statutory meetings? This is because, according to
CAMA SM is held once in a company’s lifetime which is 6 months after incorporation
but public issue of shares is done limitlessly, so how can the variation of terms in the
prospectus or statements in lieu of prospectus be only in a SM? There’s definitely a legal
coordinate dissonance and lack of concomitance between the two.
CIVIL AND CRIMINAL LIABILITY FOR MISSTATEMENTS IN THE PROSPECTUS
(OR STATEMENT IN LIEU)
• Civil liability S85 ISA
• Subscribers who suffered loss, as a result of the untrue statement or misstatements in the
prospectus shall be compensated by:
o The issuing house and its principal officers
o Employees of the company and directors who facilitated or participated in the
issuance of the prospectuses R292 SEC Rules, 2013.
263
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
o Any director or officer who authorised the issuance of the prospectus commits an
offence and is liable on conviction to:
▪ A fine of not less than N1, 000,000,000 (one billion naira); or
▪ To imprisonment not exceeding 3years; or to both fine and imprisonment.
▪ But if it is summary conviction, although, the fine penalty is same but the
prison term is three months.
▪ Exception: unless he proves either that the untrue statement or mis-
statement was immaterial or that he had reasonable ground to believe and
did, up to the time of the issue of the prospectus, believe that the
statement was true.
o It is same liability for misstatement in statement lieu of prospectus but it is
provided for in S87 ISA not S86, all the elements and quantum are same.
Other liabilities:
• Liability for Non-Issuance of Prospectus: N500,000 (body corporate) and N100,000
(individual) S67(2) ISA.
• Liability for Issuing Application Form without Prospectus: N100,000 fine S71(4)
ISA.
• Non-Registration of Prospectus: N25,000 for company & N5,000 for individuals for
each day of default S80(6) ISA.
PROCEDURES FOR THE FLOTATION OF SHARES IN THE CAPITAL MARKET
1. Preparation of a Draft Prospectus (or statement in lieu of prospectus)
2. The Issuing House submits the prospectus to the SEC, along with Application for the
Registration of the Securities
3. Printing the final copy of the prospectus, as approved by SEC
4. Obtaining the consent of experts whose reports or statements are contained in the
prospectus
5. Having the final copy of the prospectus duly signed by every person named in it as a
director
6. Submission of the printed prospectus to SEC for registration
7. Sending the Approved and registered prospectus to NSE and CAC for record purposes
8. Publishing the prospectus which contains the invitation for the public to subscribe to the
securities of the company
FLOTATION OF BONDS
• Bonds are fixed income securities issued as debt instruments with low interest yield but
guaranteed return on investment over time.
• Bonds may be floated by the govt or a corporate organisation in order to raise funds
264
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
FEATURES
• Interest is paid at periodic intervals but the principal sum is paid at specified maturity
dates.
• It is traded at the NSE like debentures, shares
• It is a means by which the govt raises money to finance projects.
• A corporate body can also issue bonds, in order to raise the capital needed to fund its
business objects
CLASSIFICATION OF BONDS
• public bonds may be issued by the government or a public company
i. if issued by the govt or any of its agencies, they are referred to as govt bonds
ii. if issued by a company, they are known as corporate bonds
• In both situations, all public bonds are regulated by the SEC
i. Government bonds: Issued by government at all levels (FG, SG, LG). It is:
a) Sovereign bonds – Issued by the Federal Government
b) Revenue bonds – Issued by the SG, LG and government agencies
c) Municipal bonds – Issued by cities within local governments
265
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
c. Two (2) copies of the board resolution authorising the issue of the bond or special
resolution if needed
d. Two (2) copies of the Memart (CTC) of the Issuer
e. A copy of certificate of incorporation of the issuer certified by the company
secretary;
f. A signed copy of the issuers latest audited accounts for the preceding three (3)
years, with the latest account not more than nine (9) months old at the time of
filing with SEC;
g. Reporting accountant report;
h. Consent letters of the parties to the offer;
i. Two (2) copies of the draft vending agreement between the issuer and the issuing
house;
j. Draft underwriting agreement (where applicable);
k. Rating report by a registered rating agency;
l. A letter of “No Objection” from the relevant regulatory body (where
applicable);
m. Two (2) copies of draft trust deed;
n. A draft prospectus, right circular, placement memorandum or any form of
information Memorandum with specified contents in R567(n)(i-xi) SEC Rules
o. Declaration by the issuer on compliance with all requirements of the Act;
SOME CONDITIONS FOR ISSUANCE OF GOVERNMENT BONDS
1. A law passed by the National Assembly, State House of Assembly or Local Government
authorising the issuance of bonds.
2. It must be registered S223(1)(b) ISA.
3. The total amount of out-standing loan and the bond of the issuer should not exceed more
than half of its actual revenue for the preceding financial year S223(1)(b) ISA; R565(2)
SEC Rules.
4. The bond issue must be in accordance with ISA S224(1) ISA, R564 SEC Rules.
5. The fund shall be managed by a corporate trustee registered by SEC S224(5) ISA.
6. The principal monies and interest shall be charged on and payable out of the general
revenue and assets of the body concerned and of the assets of the appropriate authority or
project which is the beneficiary of the proceeds of the loan S225 ISA.
7. The particulars of each loan to be raised shall be published in the Gazette or any other
official document by the body raising the loan S226 ISA.
8. Redemption date shall not exceed 25years from date of issue of the bond S226(2) ISA.
9. No person shall be entitled to any registered bond unless he is registered as a bond holder
in respect of the bond S230 ISA.
10. The bond holders must pay full purchase price before registration S231 ISA.
11. Bond Certificates must be issued to bondholders by the registrar within 2 months of the
issue S232 ISA; R565(5) SEC Rules.
266
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
12. The bond instrument must bear crest of the govt body and be signed by the minister,
commissioner or chairman or other appropriate officer of the body raising the loan
S241(1) ISA.
13. Registered Bonds may be designated in any denominations approved by SEC S241(2)
ISA.
14. A separate sinking fund shall be established for each loan raised S251 of ISA.
15. Letter of authority of guarantee by the Accountant General of state or federation stating
that the bond shall be paid and to deduct at source from the statutory allocation due to the
issuer in the event of default or failure to meet its payment obligations.
PROCEDURE FOR THE REGISTRATION OF GOVERNMENT BONDS R565(1) SEC
Rules; S224(3) ISA.
Fill Application Form SEC 6 with the following attached:
1. A copy of the Law authorising the issue of the bond by the State Government, etc. or a
Resolution of either the House of Assembly (or the Senate if it is by the Federal
Government) or the State (Federal) Executive Council in lieu of a formal Law.
2. Copies of the draft trust deed, where applicable
3. An irrevocable Letter of authority issued by the Accountant-General of the State to the
Accountant General of the Federation to deduct at source from the statutory allocation to
it (the issuer) into the sinking fund(note-waiver)
4. Evidence of technical agreement (if any) reached between the issuer and technical
partner(s), advisers/consultants;
5. A feasibility report on the project to be financed
6. Copies of the draft underwriting agreement and sub-underwriting agreement
7. A copy of a rating report by a rating agency
8. The latest audited accounts shall not be more than twelve months old for states, local
governments and Federal Government agencies and supranational bodies.
9. Publication of annual financial statements in 2 daily newspapers.
10. Details of sinking fund
11. Evidence of payment of registration and filing fees
FLOTATION OF GLOBAL DEPOSITORY RECEIPT (GDR)
• It is a type of investment by a foreigner, whereby the foreigner buys the shares of a
foreign company in his home country and in the local currency
• Dividend on GDR is paid in the local currency of the foreigner
• No share certificate is given
• Only listed companies can enjoy the issuance of GDR.
267
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
268
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
2. Holder: means any investor or beneficiary who has acquired units of a collective
investment scheme and is entitled to a pro rata share of dividends, interest or other
income of the securities comprised in the unit
3. Custodian: means a person who has custody as a bailee of securities or certificate issued
in the investor's name with the investor's name appearing in the issuer's register as the
beneficial owner of the securities
4. Trustee: under a unit trust scheme or such other arrangement, means the person in whom
the property for the time being subject to any trust created in pursuance of the scheme is
or may be vested in accordance with the terms of the trust
5. Issuer: means the person performing the duties of a manager pursuant to the provisions
of the trust deed or other agreement under which the units or securities are issued
6. Auditor: means a member of a body of Accountants, from time to time, recognised by an
Act of the National Assembly and appointed as Auditor of a company or trust by
managers with the approval of the trustees
TYPES OF CIS S154 ISA.
1. Unit Trusts Scheme
2. Investment Trust Scheme (investors can decide the type of investment to be made with
their money)
3. Real Estate Investment Schemes (REIS)
4. Community Savings Scheme (esusu, adashe, ajo)
5. Open-ended investment schemes (different classes of investment/portfolios with differ
investment plans)
6. Other CIS that may be published in a gazette.
DISTINCTION BETWEEN CIS AND INVESTMENT IN SHARES
1. A person who owns shares in a company is called a shareholder but participation in a
CIS makes the investor a unit holder
2. A shareholder is a member of the company in which his money is invested and is
entitled to Exercise the rights of membership but a unit holder is not a member of the
company in which his money is invested and is not involved in the running of the
company
3. The Board of Directors manage the company in shares investment but a CIS is managed
by the fund manager
4. For their investments, shareholders are rewarded with dividends but a participant in the
CIS is entitled to pro rata distribution of profits, liabilities, interests and dividends.
UNIT TRUSTS
• "Unit trust scheme" means any arrangement made for the purpose, or having the effect, of
providing facilities for the participation of the public as beneficiaries under a trust in
profits or income arising from acquisition, holding, management or disposal of securities
or any other property whatsoever S152 ISA.
269
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
270
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
8. SEC may refuse to authorise a scheme if in the opinion of SEC, it fails to comply with
ISA and shall so notify the manager, trustee or custodian under the scheme stating its
reasons for refusal within sixty days of filing the application.
CONTENTS OF THE TRUST DEED
1. Definition of terms
2. Provision as to certificates
3. Provision as to holders (of units),
4. Register of holders,
5. Transfer & transmission
6. Constitution of the trust
7. Issue of Units
8. Realisation of Units
9. Investment of property held on the trust
10. Distributions
11. Voting right on assets held on the trust
12. Interest upon deposited cash
13. Remuneration of Trustee and Manager
14. The trustee and the Manager
15. Accounts
16. Retirement of Trustee
17. Removal or retirement of Manager
18. Termination of the trust
19. Notices
20. Reconstruction and amalgamation
21. Meeting of holders
REGISTRATION
• Units are registered by the SEC under ISA, S160(1) ISA.
• Application for registration of units is made on Form SEC 6A in duplicates and made
along with the application for authorisation of the scheme.
• An application for registration of units shall become effective on the 60th day after
“filing thereof or such earlier dates as SEC may determine.
ALTERATION S162 ISA
• It is unlawful for any manager or trustee to make any alteration in the trust deed or in the
name of the authorised scheme without the prior approval of SEC.
• A manager or trustee under a scheme who defaults, is liable to a fine of N100,000 and a
further sum of N5,000 for every day the contravention continues.
271
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
272
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
273
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
7. Certify or obtain certification of compliance with all statutory requirements by the issuer
and other parties to a transaction;
8. Make all statutory filings and provide confirmations (legal opinion) as to the
enforceability and effectiveness of transaction documents;
9. File necessary applications in court in support of transactions; and
10. Any other roles ancillary to any of the above.
274
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
1. Internal Options
i. Arrangement and compromise
ii. Arrangement on sale
iii. Management buy-out
iv. Reduction in share-capital
v. Share reconstruction/consolidation
2. External Options
i. Merger and amalgamation
ii. Take over
iii. Acquisition
iv. Purchase and assumption (agreement)
v. Management Buy In
vi. Cherry picking
vii. Other forms applicable under the law
REGULATORY BODIES AND LAWS
SN BODY LAW
1 Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) Companies and Allied Matters Act, 2020
2 Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Investments and Securities Act, 2007
3 Federal High Court (FHC) Federal High Court Act
4 Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) Central Bank of Nigeria (Establishment) Act
5 Nigerian Investment Promotion Commission Nigerian Investment Promotion Commission
(NIPC) Act
6 Nigeria Deposit Insurance Corporation (NDIC) Nigeria Deposit Insurance Corporation Act
7 Nigerian Exchange Limited (NEL) Investments and Securities Act, 2007
275
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
276
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
277
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
case may be and also on the co and in the case of a co being wound up on the liquidator
and contributories of the co Re Lipton of Nig. Ltd. (Unreported) Suit No. FHC/ L
/M2185 at 9.
8. Delivery of CTC of the Court Order for Registration: An order sanctioning the
scheme shall have no effect unless an office copy of the order has been delivered by the
co to CAC for registration
9. Annexing Copy of Court Order to the Company Memo: A copy of the order must be
annexed to every copy of the memorandum of association of the co issued after the order
has been made.
ARRANGEMENT OR COMPROMISE BETWEEN TWO OR MORE COMPANIES S711
• Where under a scheme proposed for a compromise, arrangement or reconstruction
between two or more companies or the merger of any two or more companies, the whole
or any part of the undertaking or the property of any company concerned in the scheme
(in this section referred to as “the transfer of company”) is to be transferred to another
company S711(1).
PROCEDURE S711
1. Preparation of Scheme of Arrangement & Compromise: The cos involved prepare the
scheme.
2. Application to the FHC for a Court Ordered Meeting: Any of the cos involved in the
scheme may apply to the court for a court ordered meeting of each of the cos involved in
the scheme.
3. Issuance & Service of Notice of the Court Ordered Meeting: Following the court
order, a notice of the meeting is sent.
4. Approval of Scheme of Arrangement & Compromise: A majority representing at
least ¾ in value of the share of members being present and voting either in person or by
proxy at each of the separate meetings agree to the scheme.
5. Sending Approved Report to the FHC: If approved at the various meetings, an
application may be made to the Court by one or more of the cos, and the Court shall
sanction the scheme.
6. Court Order Binding on all Parties: When the scheme is sanctioned by the Court, it
becomes binding on the companies.
ORDERS COURT MAY MAKE S711(3) & (4)
Court may, by the order sanctioning the scheme or by any subsequent order, make provision for:
1. the transfer to the transferee co of the whole or any part of the undertaking and of the
property or liabilities of any transferor co;
2. the allotting or appropriation by the transferee co of shares, debentures, policies or other
like interests in that co which under the compromise or arrangement are to be allotted or
appropriated by that co to or for any person;
278
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
279
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• The transferee co shall pay or transfer to the transferor co the amount or other
consideration representing the price payable by the transferee co for the shares which that
company is entitled to acquire, and the transferor co shall thereupon register the
transferee co as the holder of those shares.
• Any sum received by the transferor co shall be paid into a separate bank account, and
such sums and any other consideration so received shall be held by that co on trust for the
several persons entitled to the shares in respect of which the said sums or other
consideration, were respectively received.
DISSENTING SHAREHOLDERS S713
• This section applies where at least 9/10 of the shares in transferor co is transferred to the
transferee co
• The transferee co shall, within one month from the date of the transfer (unless on a
previous transfer in pursuance of the scheme it has already complied with this
requirement), give notice of that fact in the prescribed manner to the holders of the
remaining shares or of the remaining shares of that class, as the case may be, who have
not assented to the scheme.
• A holder may, within three months from the giving of the notice to him, require the
transferee co to acquire the shares in question.
• If a shareholder gives the notice, the transferee co is entitled and bound to acquire those
shares on the terms on which under the scheme, the shares of the approving shareholders
were transferred to it, or on such other terms as may be agreed on as the Court hearing
the application of either the transferee co or the shareholder deems fit.
ARRANGEMENT ON SALE UNDER S714
A co may by special resolution resolve that the co be put into members’ voluntary winding-up
and that the liquidator be authorised to sell the whole or part of its undertaking or assets to
another body corporate, in consideration or part consideration of fully paid shares, and to
distribute the same in specie among the members of the co in accordance with their rights in the
liquidation S714(1).
SUMMARY OF THE PROCEDURE
• The members in general meetings pass a special resolution for members’ voluntary
winding up and appoint a liquidator. For the procedure on members voluntary winding
up, SS 620- 633 CAMA.
• The liquidator to give effect to the resolution.
• If no objection or dissent, the MVWU is carried by selling in part or whole of the co’s
assets and distributed among the members pro-rata as if would have been in liquidation.
• If within one year from the date of the passing of the special resolution an order is made
under SS 353 - 355 CAMA, relief on the grounds of unfairly prejudicial and oppressive
conduct or for the winding-up of the co under a creditors’ voluntary winding-up, the
280
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
arrangement for the sale and distribution shall not be valid unless sanctioned by the
Court.
o Thus, these two conditions constitute the only instances under which there
must be an application to court to effect a valid AFS:
i. Where there is a court order that the MVWU is unfairly prejudicial
or oppressive conduct or
ii. Order for creditors’ voluntary winding up
• If any member, within 30 days, by writing addressed to the liquidator and left at the
registered office or head office of the company, dissents in respect of any of the shares
held by him, the liquidator shall either abstain from carrying the resolution into effect or
purchase such shares at a price to be determined by agreement if a private co without
foreign participation but if a priv co with FP or a pub co by SEC.
• Any member who fails to signify his dissent is deemed to have accepted the resolution.
• If a liquidator elects to purchase the shares of a dissenting shareholder, the price shall be
determined by agreement if it is private co without foreign participation but if either a
private co with FP or pub co, then by SEC.
• This formula for determining prices applies to all other instances where the co undertakes
to sell part or whole of its assets.
• Nothing contained in this section authorises any variation or abrogation of the rights of
any creditor of the company.
MANAGEMENT BUY-OUT (MBO) R449, SEC Rules.
• Management buy-out is the acquisition by a management team of a company, of
controlling shares of that company or its subsidiaries with or without third-party
financing.
• It concerns a deal when the existing management team of a business purchases all or part
of that business from its current owners.
• Management Buy-In (MBI) conversely, is where all or part of a business is purchased
by an external management team, albeit it is an external restructuring option to be
discussed below.
PROCEDURE
Management team to apply to SEC for the approval of the scheme accompanied by prescribed
documents:
i. resolution of the shareholders of the co approving the MBO;
ii. resolution of the management team to undertake the MBO;
iii. a copy of the certificate of incorporation of the co;
iv. a copy of the memart of the co;
v. two copies of the Prospectus which shall contain the following, among others:
a) profile of the co;
b) profile of the management team buying over the co;
c) objectives of the MBO;
281
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
d) five (5) years audited financial statement of the co (or if less than five (5)
years, the statement of affairs for the number of years in existence);
e) claims and litigation;
vi. sale agreement between the co and the management team which shall contain the
following terms amongst others:
a) terms and conditions of sale;
b) indemnity against contingent liabilities by the seller to: -
1. third-parties;
2. pay tax not provided for in the account;
c) if employees of the target company operate a pension scheme, the agreement
should have a clause on the continuation of the scheme;
d) sale and purchase of assets;
e) contracts and creditors;
f) employees: the liabilities and obligations under the existing contract of
employment will pass to the buyer with accrued contractual and statutory
rights unaffected;
g) debtors: the agreement should reflect that monies owed the seller by its
debtors should be paid to the seller unless assigned to the buyer. The purchase
price must reflect the fact that the debts are assigned;
h) name: the agreement should state whether the buyer or seller would like to
carry on the business under the existing name. Where a new name would be
used, it should be so stated and copies of relevant documents shall be filed
with SEC;
i) Trust Deed (where applicable);
j) any other document that may be required by SEC from time to time.
282
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
MERGERS/AMALGAMATION
283
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• S165 FCCPA which is the principal legislation on mergers has now repealed SS 118 –
128 ISA which hitherto governed mergers, thus for the purpose of mergers, the only
relevant legislation is FCCPA alongside rules and regulations made pursuant to it, such as
o FCCPC Notice of Threshold for Merger Notifications, 2019
o Merger Review Regulations, 2020
o Merger Review Guidelines, 2020
o Merger Review Amended Regulations, 2021
o Amendment to the Rules on Mergers, Takeovers and Acquisitions, 2021
• Merger is a contemporary restructuring tool that has long being deployed in corporate
law practice to resolve liquidity problems, leveraging on economies of scale, desire for
growth, profitability and increase in market share, sectorial survival strategy etc.
• A merger occurs when one or more undertakings directly or indirectly acquire or
establish direct or indirect control over the whole or part of the business of another
undertaking S92(1) FCCPA.
• S92(2) FCCPA provides that a merger may be achieved through;
i. the purchase or lease of the shares, an interest or assets of the other
undertaking in question,
ii. the amalgamation or other combination with the other undertaking in
question, or
iii. a joint venture.
JURISDICTIONAL APPLICABILITY OF MERGERS Reg 3 FCCPC Merger Review
Regulations (MRR) 2020
Merging Parties for the purposes of S92 FCCPA, FCCPC shall consider an undertaking to be
involved in a merger if it–
a. is being acquired directly or indirectly by another undertaking;
b. is directly or indirectly acquiring another undertaking;
c. establishes direct or indirect control over the whole or part of the business of another
undertaking by way of acquisition of either shares or assets;
d. is involved in an amalgamation or other combination with another undertaking or is the
product of that amalgamation or combination between the undertakings; and
e. is entering into a joint venture with another undertaking or is the product of an
understanding to create a joint venture between two or more undertakings. The JV that
operates on a regular or lasting basis.
WHAT DOES HAVING “CONTROL” MEAN? S92(2) FCCPA
An undertaking has control over the business of another undertaking if it:
a. beneficially owns more than one half of the issued share capital or assets of the
undertaking;
b. is entitled to cast a majority of the votes that may be cast at a general meeting of the
undertaking or has the ability to control the voting of a majority of those votes, either
directly or through a controlled entity of that undertaking;
284
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
285
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• a "small merger" means a merger with a value at or below the threshold stipulated by the
Commission by regulations;
• a "large merger" means a merger with a value above the threshold stipulated by the
Commission by regulations.
• The FCCPC is saddled with the responsibility of prescribing the upper and lower
thresholds on combinations of turnover and or assets in Nigeria S92 (4) (a) & (b)
FCCPA, 2018.
FCCPC Notice of Threshold for Merger Notification 2019 which is the only regulation or
notice where FCCPC has made provisions for the threshold provides in Reg 1 that:
• Notice shall be given notice of a merger before implementation if, in the financial year
preceding the merger:
a. The combined annual turnover of the acquiring undertaking and the target
undertaking in, into or from Nigeria equals or exceeds N1,000,000,000 (about
US$3,267,974); or
b. The annual turnover of the target undertaking in, into or from Nigeria equals or
exceeds N500,000,000 (about US$1,633,987).
It is clear that there are two ways of determining threshold for the purpose of notification: first is,
cumulative turnover value of N1bn or more and the second is the turnover value of the target
undertaking of N500m or more, check out SS95 and 96 FCCPA below and attempt the posers
that follow.
In terms of who should notify the commission before a merger, FCCPA has the following
provisions:
• S95(1) FCCPA provides that a party to a small merger is not required to notify the
Commission of that merger unless the Commission requires it to do so.
• S96(1) FCCPA provides that a party to a large merger shall notify the Commission of the
merger in the prescribed manner and form.
The questions now are:
286
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
What exactly is the threshold for a small merger? If it is N1bn and below as the provisions
suggest, does it mean that, if its cumulatively N1bn which from the provisions of the act is at the
threshold and ought to be a small merger, it should now require notification contrary to the
express provisions of SS 95(1) & 96(1) FCCPA respectively?
Submission: The Act will always take precedent over the regulation made pursuant to it, so
clearly, the threshold for small merger should be N1bn and below and notification should be only
for cumulative turnover above N1bn. Varied views are very welcomed.
SMALL MERGER
• Please refer above for the meaning and threshold
• Parties to a small merger are not required to notify the Commission and may even
implement without an approval from the Commission, unless it expressly requires the
notification S95 FCCPA.
• However, S95(3) FCCPA, provides that the Commission may within six months after a
small merger is commenced require the parties to notify it of the merger where it forms
the opinion that the merger could substantially prevent or lessen competition or cannot be
justified on the grounds of public interest.
DEEMED APPROVAL OF SMALL MERGER
• If at the expiration of the 20 working days period provided in S95(6) FCCPA or the
extension thereof contemplated therein, the FCCPC has not notified the parties of its
decision, the small merger shall be deemed as having been approved subject to subsection
7.
LARGE MERGER
• Please refer above for the meaning and threshold
• The procedural step for large merger is contained in SS96 and 97 of FCCPA, 2018 and
MRR.
• Also note the additional requirements for merger of associations in Reg 35, Companies
Regulations, 2021.
PROCEDURE FOR LARGE MERGER S96 FCCPA
1. A party to a large merger shall notify FCCPC of the merger in the prescribed manner and
form.
2. The notification of the merger shall be published within five business days after receipt
by FCCPC.
3. The primary acquiring undertaking and the primary target undertaking shall each provide
a copy of the notice to -
a) any registered trade union that represents the employees in the acquiring and target
undertakings respectively; or
b) the employees or representatives of the employees of the acquiring and target
undertakings, if there are no such registered trade unions.
287
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
4. The parties to a large merger shall not implement the merger unless approved, with or
without conditions, by the FCCPC.
5. Any action undertaken by any party to implement the merger without approval is void.
6. FCCPC may exercise any of the powers available to it to render void any merger
implementation that fails to notify its employees as stated in no3 above void.
7. An undertaking that implements merger without FCCPC’s approval, commits an offence
and is liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding 10% of turnover of the undertaking
in the business year preceding the date of the commission of the offence or to such other
percentage as the court may determine having regard to the circumstances of the case.
Procedure after compliance with FCCPC S97 FCCPA
8. Within 60 business days after the parties to a large merger have fulfilled all notification
requirements, FCCPC-
a) may extend the period in which it has to consider the proposed merger to 120
business days and issue an extension notice to all parties to the merger; or
b) after having considered the merger, issue a report in the prescribed form -
i. approving the merger,
ii. approving the merger subject to conditions, or
iii. prohibiting implementation of the merger.
MERGER OF ASSOCIATIONS Reg 35 Companies Reg 2021.
The requirements for merger of association shall include the following –
1. Similar aims and objectives
2. Resolution passed by 75% of members of each of the associations
3. Publication of application for merger in two daily newspaper circulating in the area
where the associations are situated, one of which shall be a national newspaper.
4. Display of notice of the proposed merger conspicuously at the headquarters and branches
of each of the associations for at least 28 days.
5. The publications and notices shall call for objections to the application which shall state
the grounds for objection and be forwarded to reach the Registrar-General of the CAC
not later than 28 days of the last publication or notice, whichever is later.
6. Scheme of merger sanctioned by the Federal High Court
FOREIGN MERGERS WITH NIGERIAN COMPONENT REG 9 MRR
1. An undertaking in Nigeria that comes within the control of a foreign undertaking will be
subject to merger review if:
i. it attains the turnover requirements under the Threshold for Merger Regulations 2019
or
ii. its acquisition affects the market structure by preventing or lessening competition in
Nigeria.
288
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
2. In any event where a merger will occur purely as a result of a transaction involving
undertakings wholly domiciled outside Nigeria, the Commission will nonetheless assess
the merger if it has a local component.
3. The Commission will only assert jurisdiction over a transaction in subregulation (2) if the
foreign enterprise has a local component materiality, such as having subsidiaries in
Nigeria or having attained the turnover requirements for large mergers as provided under
the Threshold Regulations.
4. Parties outside Nigeria shall appoint local legal representatives to notify the merger to the
Commission on their behalf in accordance with the laws of Nigeria.
REGULATORY BODIES INVOLVED IN MERGER TRANSACTIONS
1. Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC)
2. Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN)
3. Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC)
4. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)
5. Nigerian Exchange Limited (NEL)
6. Federal High Court (FHC)
7. Court of Appeal
Other sector specific regulators such as
8. Nigerian Electricity Regulatory Commission (NERC)
9. Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC)
10. National Insurance Commission (NAICOM)
REGISTERED MARKET OPERATORS INVOLVED IN MERGER TRANSACTIONS
1. Financial Advisers/Issuing Houses
2. Solicitors
3. Auditors
4. Reporting Accountants
5. Registrars
6. Stockbrokers
DOCUMENTATIONS IN MERGER TRANSACTIONS
In the build up to the consummation of a merger transaction, the preparation and execution of
certain agreements are very important. The agreements are as follow:
1. Exclusivity Agreement;
2. Memorandum of Understanding;
3. Confidentiality Agreements; and
4. Scheme of Merger.
PRELIMINARY STEPS TO A MERGER
1. Due Diligence
2. Preparation of Merger Scheme (Merger Agreement)
289
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
290
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
291
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
292
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
iii. The continuation by or against the transferee company of any legal proceedings
pending by or against any transferor company
iv. Provision for dissenters to the scheme
v. The dissolution, without winding up, of any transferor company
vi. Othe incidental or consequential matters necessary for the reconstruction or merger to
be fully carried out.
POST-APPROVAL REQUIREMENTS Amendment to the Rules on Merger, August, 2021
After the approval given by the Commission and the court-order sanctioning the scheme, the
following requirements shall be complied with by the applicant:
1. file a copy of the court-order sanctioning the scheme within seven (7) days of the court
making the order;
2. file a copy of the newspaper publication of the court-order;
3. file an application for the registration of the securities to be issued as consideration for
the scheme where applicable, accompanied by the following (where applicable);
a. evidence of payment of the processing fee
b. relevant SEC form for the registration of securities
c. evidence of increase in share capital of the resultant company to accommodate the
share exchange
d. amended copy of the memart of the resultant company
4. file summary reports of the scheme within three months in respect of the following:
a) Arrangement relating to employees of the acquired company;
b) Settlement of shareholders;
c) Utilization of monies injected into the company, if any.
d) Treatment of dissenting shareholders;
e) Submission of gazetted copy of the court sanction;
f) Evidence of allotment of shares;
g) Evidence of settlement of severance benefits of employees (where applicable).
h) Statement of the actual cost of the scheme
REGISTRATION AT CAC
• Resolution of the companies
• Merger scheme as approved by FCCPC
• Formal approval by SEC
• Court orders.
• Evidence of publication of Court order in Gazette and 1 newspaper.
• Original certificate of incorporation of companies dissolved in the merger for
cancellation.
• Updated Annual Return
SALIENT CLAUSES IN A MERGER AND ACQUISITION AGREEMENT
1. Introduction
293
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
294
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
295
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
12. Share purchase agreement and any other relevant agreement executed between the
acquirer and the acquiree (where applicable);
13. Payment of N50,000 being application fee;
14. Payment of processing fee based on the value to be acquired on the graduation fee.
15. Annual report and accounts of both companies for the proceeding period of five (5) years
or a shorter period of three (3) years for private companies and those that have been
operating for less than five (5) years;
16. Source of fund to finance the acquisition must be clearly disclosed and backed by
documentary evidence;
17. Report of valuation shares/assets (where applicable);
18. Publication of the acquisition in at least two national dailies after consummation.
POST ACQUISITION REQUIREMENTS BY SEC R437 SEC RULES
The following docs shall be forwarded:
a) Executed share/asset purchase agreement
b) Evidence of settlement of purchase agreement
c) Evidence of settlement of severance benefits of employees who may be affected by the
restructuring exercise.
POST- ACQUISITION INSPECTION R439 SEC RULES
• Post-acquisition inspection by SEC, three months after the approval and consummation
of the exercise.
EXTERNAL RESTRUCTURING R440 SEC RULES
• External restructuring includes restructuring of a group of companies and other related
party transactions.
Procedure for obtaining approval for External Restructuring R441 SEC RULES
Companies proposing for external restructuring shall:
1. File with CAC an application for external restructuring;
2. Upon clearance of the application, the companies shall file an application in the FHC
seeking an order to convene a court ordered meeting;
3. Following the resolution of the shareholders at the court ordered meeting approving the
scheme and sanctioning of the transaction by the court, the applicants shall file with CAC
a formal application for approval of the external restructuring.
Requirements for External Restructuring R442 SEC RULES
An application for external restructuring shall be filed by submitting the following documents:
1. Shareholders resolution of the companies approving the external restructuring;
2. A copy of certificate(s) of incorporation of the entities certified by the co secretary;
3. CAC CTCs of particulars of directors and allotment of shares of the affected companies;
296
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
297
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
b) A takeover bid must be made by such a person or group of persons or through the
instrumentality of a market operator to the shareholders of the target company.
c) Where a takeover bid is made by a corporate body, there must be a resolution of the
board of directors approving the bid and also accompanying the bid.
d) The bid must be made to at least 20 shareholders representing 60% of the
membership of the target company or such other members as may be prescribed by SEC.
e) A bid must not be made where the shares to be acquired are shares of a private company.
TAKE OVER BID R445 SEC Rules
1. The takeover bid shall be made through the agents of the person/corporation to the target
company R445(1) SEC Rules.
2. The agent who dispatches the bid must be a registered CMO R445(1)(b) SEC Rules
3. The take-over bid must be made or dispatched to at least twenty (20) shareholders
representing sixty (60%) percent of the members of the target company or such other
number as SEC may provide from time-to-time R445(3)(a) SEC Rules. This can also be
to members holding aggregate of 51% of the paid-up shares S133(3)(a) ISA.
4. The bid must be to acquires shares of a pub company not a private company R445(3)(b)
SEC Rules, S133(4) ISA.
5. If the bid is by a corporate body, it must be accompanied by a resolution of the company,
signed by one director and the company secretary approving the bid R445(2) SEC Rules.
6. The bid must be advertised in at least two (2) national dailies R445(4) SEC Rules
7. The bid must be dispatched within three (3) months from the date the authority to
proceed with the bid was granted, or if a renewal is granted, then within the renewed
period.
8. The bid must contain the requisite contents of a take-over bid set out in R446 SEC Rules
and S136(1) ISA.
9. The bid must be registered with SEC in accordance with R448 SEC Rules and S135 ISA
CONTENTS OF A TAKEOVER BID R446 SEC Rules
A bid, being an invitation under a takeover bid must be in a document that states as follows:
1. The name and address of the offeror,
2. The maximum number and offer particulars of the shares the company proposed to be
acquired during the period specified in the invitation to bid.
3. The price and other terms on which those shares are proposed to be acquired.
4. The number and other particulars of the shares in the offeree company to which:
i. the offeror; and
ii. any company in the same group of companies as the offerors, is or are entitled
immediately before the date of the take-over bid
5. State whether it is going to acquire the shares of dissenting members at the fair market
value.
6. Such other matter as may be prescribed by regulation from time to time.
298
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
299
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
300
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
ETHICAL ISSUES
1. Duty to disclose the true state of the company in preparation for the scheme of merger.
2. Duty not to allow conflict of interest under R17 RPC 2007.
3. Duty to act with care and skill as required under R14 RPC 2007.
4. It is also the duty of the solicitors to the scheme of merger to devote their attention,
energy and expertise to the course of the newly merged company and minimize post-
merger conflict
SOME ETHICAL ISSUES INVOLVED IN MBO AND PURCHASE AND ASSUMPTION
1. Duty to disclose the true state of the company in preparation for the management Buyout
and Purchase and Assumption.
2. Duty not to allow conflict of interest and insider trading on the part of the managers in a
MBO under R17 RPC 2007.
3. Duty to act with care and skill as required under R14 RPC2007.
4. It is also the duty of the solicitors to the P&A transaction to devote their attention, energy
and expertise to the course of the financial institution assuming liabilities and minimise
post assumption conflicts and undisclosed liabilities.
301
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
302
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
303
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
304
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
PARTIES
The parties to the proceedings before the Committee shall be:
a) In a matter initiated by the Commission:
i. the Head of Department responsible for investigation in the Commission;
ii. the person or institution against whom an allegation of violation of the Act or Rules
has been made;
iii. any other person required by the Committee to be joined or joined by leave of the
Committee.
b) In any other case:
i. the Complainant;
ii. the Respondent;
iii. any person considered by the Committee to have an interest in the proceedings or
joined by leave of the Committee.
POWERS OF THE COMMITTEE
The Committee shall have jurisdiction in respect of:
1. disputes between investors and Capital Market Operators;
2. disputes between Capital Market Operators;
3. disputes between Securities Exchanges, Capital Trade Points and other Self-Regulatory
Organizations (SROs);
4. disputes arising from public offers by companies;
5. disputes between Investors and Issuers of securities;
6. disputes between Investors;
7. disputes between SROs;
8. violations or probable or threatened violation of the provisions of the Investments and
Securities Act, the Rules and Regulations made there under and the Code of Conduct for
Capital Market Operators and their Employees;
9. violation of the Code of Corporate Governance for public companies;
10. activities and dealings of public companies and their employees;
11. issues relating to the registration of Market Operators and SROs;
12. public sale or trading in unregistered securities;
13. dealing in securities or sale of securities to the public;
14. unethical and unprofessional practice, manipulations and use of deceptive devices or
contrivances in securities transactions;
15. denial of registration;
16. non-compliance with orders, guidelines and directives of the Commission;
17. any other matter which the Commission may direct it to hear
INVESTMENT AND SECURITIES TRIBUNAL
• Established under S274 ISA
305
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• The Tribunal was established to provide an efficient dispute settlement mechanism with
fairness, flexibility and transparency for the capital market investors, public companies,
capital market operators, self-regulatory organisations and other market participants IST
Procedural Rules 2&3(1) 2003.
COMPOSITION OF THE TRIBUNAL S275 ISA
• The Tribunal shall consist of ten (10) persons to be appointed by the Minister as follows:
o a full time Chairman who shall be a legal practitioner of not less than 15 years
with cognate experience in capital market matters;
o four other full time Members, three of whom shall be Legal Practitioners of not
less than 10 years’ experience and one person who shall be knowledgeable in
Capital Market matters who shall devote themselves to issues relating to
adjudication and shall not exercise any administrative function;
o five other part time members who shall be persons of proven ability and
expertise in corporate and capital market matters.
• The Chairman shall be the Chief Executive and Accounting Officer and shall be
responsible for the overall control, supervision and administration of the Tribunal.
CONSTITUTION OF THE TRIBUNAL S276 ISA
• The Tribunal shall be duly constituted if it consists of not less than 3 members of the
Tribunal
• The Chairman of the Tribunal may constitute a panel of three (3) from its membership
whenever he deems it necessary for the purpose of exercising the jurisdiction vested in
the Tribunal by this Act or any other Act provided that:
o a member presiding as chairman of any panel shall be a legal practitioner; and
o the sitting of any of such panel shall be deemed a sitting of the Tribunal.
JURISDICTION OF THE TRIBUNAL S284 ISA
The Tribunal shall, to the exclusion of any other court of law or body in Nigeria, exercise
jurisdiction to hear and determine any question of law or dispute involving-
1. a decision or determination of the Commission in the operation and application of this
Act, and in particular, relating to any dispute-
i. between capital market operators;
ii. between capital market operators and their clients;
iii. between an investor and a securities exchange or capital trade point or
clearing and settlement agency;
iv. between capital market operators and self regulatory organisation;
2. the Commission and self regulatory organisation;
3. a capital market operator and the Commission;
4. an investor and the Commission;
5. an issuer of securities and the Commission; and
306
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
307
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
309
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Decisions of the Committee are subject to confirmation by the governing board of the
Corporate Affairs Commission.
• Parties dissatisfied with the decision of the Committee may appeal to FHC.
Note:
i. The venue of the sittings of the Committee unless otherwise indicated is the head office
of CAC.
ii. The chairman presides over the meetings of the Committee and at any meeting the
chairman is absent, the members present will appoint one of their members to preside
over the meeting.
iii. The quorum at the sitting of the Committee is four members present.
iv. The Committee regulates its proceedings subject to the provisions of S851 of CAMA.
v. The proceedings of the Committee shall be guided by the provisions of the Evidence Act
SANCTIONS THAT THE ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS COMMITTEE MAY
IMPOSE
i. Imposition of administrative penalties;
ii. Suspension or revocation of registration; or
iii. Recommendation for criminal prosecution if matters brought before it reveals any
criminal act or conduct S851(10) CAMA.
BETWEEN
JOHN WEST
SMART STEVE
(Administrators/Personal representative of the Estate of Edwin John-Deceased) ---------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------APPLICANTS
AND
EDUPAL NIGERIA LIMITED
PETER PAN (DIRECTOR)-------------------------------------------------------------RESPONDENTS
ORIGINATING MOTION
310
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
311
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
BETWEEN
JOHN WEST -----------------------------------------------------------------PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT
AND
EDUPAL NIGERIA LIMITED
PETER PAN (DIRECTOR)-----------------------------------------DEFENDANTS/RESPONDENTS
ORIGINATING SUMMONS
BROUGHT PURSUANT TO RULE 2(2) COMPANIES PROCEEDING RULES 1992 AND
UNDER THE INHERENT JURISDICTION OF THE COURT
Let Edupal Nigeria Plc whose registered address is at 15 Edupal Drive, Ikoyi, Lagos within
jurisdiction to within 7 days on or after service of this summons on it inclusive of the day of such
service cause an appearance to be entered for it to this summons, which is JOHN WEST
(Plaintiff) whose registered address is situate at 12 Yahaya Street, Lagos, and who will seek for
the determination of the following questions:
QUESTIONS FOR DETERMINATION
1. Whether or not the takeover of the plaintiff by the defendant is legal?
RELIEFS:
AND after the determination of the issues, the Plaintiff/Applicant prays as follows:
1. AN ORDER declaring its take-over by the defendant as fraudulent, illegal and void
2. AND FOR SUCH FURTHER ORDER OR ORDERS as the court may deem fit in the
circumstances.
Dated the 19th day of April, 2019.
____________________________
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT
Chris Ozo Agbata.
C. O. Agbata LP
12, Johnson Street, Asokoro,
Abuja.
[email protected]
07035406532
312
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
NB: these processes are supported by affidavits drafted in the general format; thus, they
apply mutatis mutandis with those in Civil Litigation.
BETWEEN
CHRIS OZO AGBATA-------------------------------------------------------PLAINTIFF/APPLICANT
AND
BAD NIGERIA LIMITED--------------------------------------DEFENDANTS/RESPONDENTS
PETITION FOR WINDING UP OF BAD NIGERIA LIMITED
The humble petition of Mr. Chris Ozo Agbata (Petitioner) of 15, Kaba Street, Lagos is presented
for filing based on the following facts:
1. The Petitioner is a Legal Practitioner with his office at 15 Edupal Drive, Ikoyi, Lagos.
2. The Respondent is a company incorporated in Nigeria in accordance with the provisions
of the Companies and Allied Matters Act, 2020, with registered office at 14, Imam Street.
3. The Respondent agreed to pay 2 million dollars as professional fees to the petitioner.
4. The Petitioner has demanded for payment of his professional fee and the respondent has
failed pay for over six months.
THE PETITIONER PRAYS AS FOLLOWS:
1. AN ORDER for the compulsory winding up of the company by this Honourable Court
2. That a Liquidator be appointed by the court to effect the winding up and settlement of the
sum owed the petitioner.
Dated the 15th day of August, 2022.
____________________________
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT
Chris Ozo Agbata.
C. O. Agbata LP
12, Johnson Street, Asokoro, Abuja.
[email protected]
07035406532
313
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Respondent’s Counsel
Theo Uguru Esq
56 Madison Close,
Abuja.
ADR OPTIONS
• Negotiation
• Mediation
• Conciliation
• Arbitration
• NB: the Disadvantages of litigation and advantages of ADR
ADR PROCESS UNDER S26 NIPC ACT
• S26 NIPC Act applies where:
o The dispute involves any level of government in Nigeria (Federal, state or local)
or its agency
o The dispute involves the business enterprise
o The dispute involves a local or foreign investor
ADR Process:
Step 1: Mutual discussion via Negotiation or mediation
Step 2: where step 1 fails, the parties will resort to arbitration.
• The applicable arbitration rule will depend on if the investor is a local or foreigner
• Where the investor is a local (national), recourse will be had to the provisions of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act.
• Where the investor is a foreigner, recourse will be had to any bilateral or multilateral
treaty to which the Federal Government and the country of which the investor is a
national are parties
• In the absence of any such bilateral or multilateral treaty, recourse will be had to any
other national or international machinery for the settlement of investment dispute agreed
to by the parties.
• Where they fail to agree, the parties must adopt the International Center for Settlement
of Investment Disputes (ICSID) Rules.
IST – ADR CENTRE
• It is an ADR centre of the IST
• Provides sessions for the various ADR options
• Such as mediation, negotiation, arbitration and other hybrid processes
314
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• R34(1) IST Procedure Rules issues directive for effective management and resolution
of disputes
• More so, IST is empowered to promote reconciliation among parties to an action and
encourage and facilitate amicable settlement of disputes
GUIDES IN DRAFTING AN ADR CLAUSE
Sample
“If at any time disagreement or dispute or question shall arise between
the parties in connection with this agreement or its validity, construction;
or performance, then the same shall be referred to an Arbitrator
nominated by Settlement House upon request on the request of any of
any party and the decision of the Arbitrator shall be binding on all the
parties.”
ETHICAL ISSUES INVOLVED IN COMPANY PROCEEDINGS
1. Duty not to forge documents in relation to the proceedings involving companies in
consonance with R1 RPC 2007.
2. Duty to ensure that the right originating process is applied to client’s action R16 RPC
3. Duty of confidentiality
4. Duty to appear in litigation on behalf of client corporate or individual.
5. Duty not to aid unauthorized practice of law.
315
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
316
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
317
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
318
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
b. if, in his opinion, such meetings should be summoned, the date, time and place
that he proposes for the meetings.
2. For the purposes of enabling the nominee to prepare his report, the person intending to
make the proposal shall submit to the nominee;
a. a document setting out the terms of the proposed VA; and
b. a statement of the company’s affairs containing;
i. particulars of its creditors, its debts and other liabilities and of its assets as
may be prescribed, and
ii. other information as may be prescribed.
3. The Court may, on an application made by the person intending to make the proposal, in a
case where the nominee failed to submit the report, direct that the nominee be replaced as
such by another person qualified to act as an insolvency practitioner in relation to the co.
SUMMONING OF MEETINGS S436
A proposal may also be made where the nominee is;
a. not the liquidator or administrator, and it has been reported to the Court that such
meetings should be summoned, the person making the report shall (unless the Court
otherwise directs) summon those meetings for the time, date and place proposed in the
report; and
b. the liquidator or administrator, he shall summon meetings of the company and of its
creditors to consider the proposal for such a time, date and place as he thinks fit.
c. The persons to be summoned to a creditors’ meeting under this section are every creditor
of the company of whose claim and address the person summoning the meeting is aware.
DECISIONS OF MEETINGS S437
• The meetings summoned shall decide whether to approve the proposed voluntary
arrangement with or without modifications.
• However, it shall not make modifications:
i. by virtue of which the proposal ceases to be a proposal such as is mentioned in
section 434.
ii. which affects the right of a secured creditor of the company to enforce his security,
except with the concurrence of the creditor concerned.
iii. any preferential debt of the company is to be paid otherwise than in priority to such of
its debts as are not preferential debts
iv. a preferential creditor of the company is to be paid an amount in respect of a
preferential debt that bears to that debt a smaller proportion than is borne to another
preferential debt by the amount that is to be paid in respect of that other debt provided
that the meeting may approve such a proposal or modification with the concurrence
of the preferential creditor concerned.
• After the conclusion of either meeting, the chairman of the meeting shall report the result
of the meeting to the Court, and, immediately after reporting to the Court, shall give
notice of the result of the meeting to such persons as may be prescribed.
319
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
321
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• If any of the company’s creditors or any other person is dissatisfied by any act, omission
or decision of the supervisor, he may apply to the Court, and, on the application, the
Court may;
a. confirm, reverse or modify any act or decision of the supervisor;
b. give him directions; or
c. make such other order as it deems fit.
• The supervisor may apply to the Court for directions in relation to any particular matter
arising under the voluntary arrangement, and is included among the persons who may
apply to the Court for the winding-up of the company or for an administration order to be
made in relation to it.
• The Court may, whenever it is;
a. expedient to appoint a person to perform the functions of the supervisor, and
b. it is inexpedient, difficult or impracticable for an appointment to be made without the
assistance of the Court,
make an order appointing a person who is qualified to act as an insolvency practitioner in
relation to the company, either in substitution for the existing supervisor or to fill a vacancy.
ADMINISTRATION OF COMPANIES
• Administration is a statutory insolvency procedure introduced by the CAMA, 2020 with
the primary purpose of rescuing instead of liquidating an insolvent company.
• It is an alternative regime to receivership in which the receiver is primarily concerned
with the interest of the creditor who appointed him as against the collective interest of all
creditors.
• Administration unlike CVA affords a moratorium on other legal process in that no step
can be taken to enforce security or repossess goods in the company’s possession under a
hire purchase agreement without the consent of the administrator or presentation of court.
APPOINTMENT OF ADMINISTRATOR S443
• By S443(1), a person may be appointed as administrator of a company by:
i. an administration order of the Court under s.449
ii. the holder of a floating charge under s. 452
iii. the company under s.459, or
iv. its directors under s. 459
• Where an administrator is appointed out of Court, if it is an administration that has a
cross-border element, an application shall be made ex parte to the Court for approval
S443(2).
PURPOSE OF ADMINISTRATION S444
The administrator may perform his functions with the objective of:
a. rescuing the co, the whole or any part of its undertaking, as a going concern;
322
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
b. achieving a better result for the co’s creditors as a whole than would be likely if the co
were wound up, without first being in administration;
c. realising property in order to make a distribution to one or more secured or preferential
creditors.
• According to subsections 4 and 5, the functions rank in the order of importance, B is
performed when A is impracticable, and C is performed when neither A nor B is
practicable.
• Notwithstanding (b) - (c) above, the rescue of the co is the primary objective of the
administrator in the performance of his functions, except
o where he is of the opinion that it is not reasonably practicable or
o a better result can be achieved for the co’s creditors by pursuing some other
course in order of priority i.e., secured or preferential creditors.
• The administrator shall, within 60 days of his appointment prepare a detailed schedule of
assets and submit a copy to the person by whom he was appointed.
STATUS AND STANDARD OF PERFORMANCE EXPECTED OF ADMINISTRATOR
S445
• He shall perform his functions as quickly and efficiently as is reasonably practicable.
STATUS OF ADMINISTRATOR S446
• He is an officer of the Court, whether or not he is appointed by the Court.
GENERAL RESTRICTIONS ON APPOINTMENT OF ADMINISTRATOR S447
1. A person may be appointed as administrator only if he is qualified to act as an insolvency
practitioner in relation to the company.
2. A person shall only be appointed as administrator of a company which is in
administration, subject to the provisions of sections 525-534 and 537-541 about
replacement and additional administrators.
3. A person shall not be appointed as administrator of a company which is in liquidation by
virtue of;
a. a resolution for voluntary winding-up, subject to section 475 (2) (b) of this Act; or
b. a winding-up order, subject to sections 474 and 475 of this Act.
4. A person shall not be appointed as administrator of a company which;
a. has as a liability in respect of a deposit which it accepted in accordance with
relevant banking laws; and
b. is not an authorised deposit taker within the meaning of banking laws and
regulations.
5. A person shall not be appointed as administrator of a company which effects or carries out
contracts of insurance except with the leave of the insurance regulator.
APPOINTMENT: WHO CAN APPOINT?
• court S448
323
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
324
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
325
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
327
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
328
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
329
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
a. a proposal for a voluntary arrangement under Chapter 17, but this section is without
prejudice to section 435 (procedure where nominee is not the liquidator or
administrator) and
b. a proposal for a scheme of arrangement and compromise or reconstruction.
4. The administrator shall send a copy of the statement of his proposals to—
a. CAC;
b. every creditor of the company of whose claim and address he is aware; and
c. every member of the company of whose address he is aware.
5. The administrator shall send the proposals before the end of 30 days beginning with the
day on which the company enters administration.
6. The administrator is deemed to send proposals if he publishes in the prescribed manner, a
notice undertaking to provide a copy of the statement of proposals free of charge to any
member of the company who applies in writing to a specified address.
Creditors’ meeting (ICM) S487
1. The administrator shall summon a meeting of the creditors to be known as “creditors’
meeting”;
a. in the prescribed manner; and
b. giving the prescribed period of notice to every creditor of the company of whose
claim and address he is aware.
2. The period of notice may be varied in accordance with consent of the creditors.
3. A creditors’ meeting shall be conducted in accordance with the prescribed rules.
Requirement for initial creditors’ meeting (ICM) S488
1. Each copy of an administrator’s statement of proposals sent to a creditor shall be
accompanied by an invitation to creditors’ meeting (an “initial creditors’ meeting”).
2. The date set for an initial creditors’ meeting is 42 days beginning with the date on
which the company enters administration.
3. An administrator shall present a copy of his statement of proposals to an initial creditors’
meeting.
4. A period specified in this section may be varied with the consent of the creditors.
5. An administrator commits an offence if he fails, without reasonable excuse, to comply.
Restrictions on summoning of ICM S489
1. No need to summon ICM where the statement of proposals states that the administrator
thinks that—
a. the company has sufficient property to enable each creditor to be paid in full;
b. the company has insufficient property to enable a distribution to be made to unsecured
creditors other than by virtue of the provisions of CAMA; or
c. neither of the objectives specified in section 444 (1) (a) and (b) of this Act shall be
achieved.
2. The Administrator shall summon an ICM if it is requested—
a. by creditors whose debts amount to at least 10% of the total debts of the company;
330
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
331
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
333
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
334
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• Where such is the case, he is replaced by the appointing authority pursuant to SS 529-535
RECEIVERSHIP
• Among the remedies of the debenture holder as provided under S233 is the appointment
of a receiver.
WHO MAY NOT BE A RECEIVER OR MANAGER? S550
• The following persons cannot be appointed a receiver or managers of any property or
undertaking of any company: -
i. An infant;
ii. Any person found by a competent court to be of unsound mind;
iii. A body corporate;
iv. An undischarged bankrupt, unless he shall have been given leave to act as a receiver
or manager of the property or undertaking of the company by the court by which he
was adjudged bankrupt;
v. A director or auditor of the company;
vi. Any person convicted of any offence involving fraud, dishonesty, official corruption
or moral turpitude and who is disqualified under section 280 of the Act.
APPOINTMENT OF RECEIVER AND MANAGER BY THE COURT S551
• Where an application is made to the Court to appoint a receiver on behalf of the
debenture holder or other creditors of a company which is being wound up by a court, an
official receiver may be appointed.
LEGAL STATUS OF A RECEIVER APPOINTED BY THE COURT S552(2)
• A receiver or manager of any property or undertaking of a company appointed by the
Court is deemed to be an officer of the Court and not of the company and shall act in
accordance with the directions and instructions of the Court.
RECEIVER AND MANAGERS APPOINTED OUT OF COURT S553
• A receiver or manager of any property or undertaking of a company appointed out of
Court under a power contained in any instrument is, subject to section 554 of this Act,
deemed to be an agent of the person or persons on whose behalf he is appointed and, if
appointed manager of the whole or any part of the undertaking of a company, he is
deemed to stand in a fiduciary relationship to the company and observe the utmost good
faith towards it in any transaction with it or on its behalf.
POWER OF A RECEIVER OR MANAGER APPOINTED OUT OF COURT TO APPLY
TO THE COURT FOR DIRECTIONS S554
• A receiver or manager of the property of a co appointed under a power contained in any
instrument, or the persons by whom or on whose behalf a receiver or manager has been
so appointed may apply to the Court for directions in relation to any particular matter
335
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
arising in connection with the performance of his functions, and on any such application
the Court may give such directions or make such order declaring the rights of persons
before the Court or otherwise, as it deems just.
Notice and Statement of Affairs of the Company s.559
NOTIFICATION TO THE COMMISSION THAT A RECEIVER OR MANAGER HAS
BEEN APPOINTED S555
• Where a receiver or manager of the property of a co has been appointed, the receiver or
manager shall within 14 days give notice of his appointment to CAC indicating the
terms of and remuneration for the appointment, and every invoice, order for goods or
business letter issued by or on behalf of the company, receiver, manager or liquidator of
the company, being a document on or in which the company’s name appears, shall
contain a statement that a receiver or manager has been appointed.
DUTIES AND POWERS OF RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS S556
• A person appointed a receiver of any property of a company must, subject to prior
encumbrances, take possession of and protect the property, receive the rents and profits
and discharge all out-goings in respect of it, and realize the security for the benefit of
those on whose behalf he is appointed but unless appointed manager, he will not have
power to carry on any business or undertaking.
• A person appointed manager of the whole or any part of the undertaking of a company
must manage it with a view to the realization of the security of those on whose behalf he
is appointed (this is the major difference with administrator who acts in the interest
of all creditors albeit in priority).
• Without prejudice to subsection (1) or (2), where a receiver or manager is appointed for
the whole or substantially the whole of a company’s property, the powers conferred on
him by the debentures by virtue of which he was appointed are deemed to include (except
they are inconsistent with any of the provisions of those debentures) the powers specified
in the Eleventh Schedule to this Act (NB: they are ipsissima verba with the powers of
administrators stated above contained in the Tenth Schedule to CAMA).
• From the date of appointment of a receiver or manager, the powers of the directors or
liquidators in a members’ voluntary winding-up to deal with the property or undertaking
over which he is appointed, shall cease, unless the receiver or manager is discharged or
the security is realised.
• If, on the appointment of a receiver or manager, the company is being wound up under
the provision relating to creditors’ voluntary winding-up, or the property concerned is in
the hands of some other officer of the Court, the liquidator or officer shall not be bound
to relinquish control of such property to the receiver or manager except under the order of
the Court.
336
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
337
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
so ceasing, and the aggregate amounts of his receipts and payments during all preceding
periods since his appointment.
3. Where the receiver is appointed under the powers contained in any instrument, this
section has effect with the —
a. omission of the references to the Court in subsection (1); and
b. substitution for the references to the Court in subsection (2), of references to CAC
and in any other case references to the Court shall be taken as referring to the Court
by which the receiver was appointed.
4. Subsection (1) does not apply in relation to the appointment of a receiver or manager to
act with an existing receiver or manager or in place of a receiver or manager dying or
ceasing to act, except that, where that subsection applies to a receiver or manager who
dies or ceases to act before it has been fully complied with, the references in paragraphs
(b) and (c) to the receiver shall, subject to subsection (5), include references to his
successor and to any continuing receiver or manager and nothing in this subsection shall
be taken as limiting the meaning of the expression “the receiver” where used in, or in
relation to, subsection (2).
5. This section and section 560 of this Act, where the company is being wound up, apply
notwithstanding that the receiver or manager and the liquidator are the same person.
ETHICAL ISSUES
338
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• NB: If a co passes a resolution for voluntary winding up before the presentation of the
petition, the winding up would be deemed to have commenced at the time of the passing
of the resolution – S578(1).
LIABILITY AS CONTRIBUTORIES OF PRESENT AND PAST MEMBERS S565
• In the event of a company being wound up, every present and past member is liable to
contribute to the assets of the company as provided in section 117.
339
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
• S117 provides that every member is liable as a contributory but not where;
i. he has ceased to be a member for a period of one year or upwards before the
commencement of the winding up;
ii. unless it appears to the Court that the existing members are unable to satisfy the
contributions required to be made by them in pursuance of this section;
iii. in the case of a company limited by shares, no contribution is required from any
member or past member exceeding the amount, if any, unpaid on the shares in respect
of which he is liable as a present or past member;
iv. in the case of a company limited by guarantee, no contribution is required from any
member or past member exceeding the amount undertaken to be contributed by him
to the assets of the company in the event of its being wound up; and
v. any sum due from the company to a member or past member, in his capacity as
member, by way of dividends or otherwise shall not be set-off against the amount for
which he is liable to contribute in accordance with this section but any such sum is to
be taken into account for the purposes of final adjustment of the rights of the
members and past members amongst themselves.
DEFINITION OF CONTRIBUTORY S566
• The term, “contributory” means every person liable to contribute to the assets of a
company in the event of its being wound up, and for the purposes of all proceedings prior
to the final determination of the persons who are to be deemed contributories, the
expression includes any person alleged to be a contributory.
COMPULSORY WINDING UP BY THE COURT
Jurisdiction as to Winding-up S570 CAMA & S251(1)(d) CFRN
1. The Court having jurisdiction to wind up a company is the FHC within whose area of
jurisdiction the registered office or head office of the company is situate.
2. Registered office or head office means the place which has longest been the principal
place of business of the company during the six months immediately preceding the
presentation of the petition for winding-up.
Circumstances in which companies may be wound up by Court S571
A company may be wound up by the court if:
a. the co has by special resolution resolved that the co be wound up by the Court;
b. default is made in delivering the statutory report to CAC or in holding the statutory
meeting;
c. the number of members is reduced below two in the case of companies with more than
one shareholder;
d. the company is unable to pay its debts;
e. the condition precedent to the operation of the company has ceased to exist; or
f. the Court is of opinion that it is just and equitable that the company should be wound up.
340
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
341
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
name, for at least six months during the 18 months before the commencement of the
winding-up, or have devolved on him through the death of a former holder.
• the Court shall not hear a winding-up petition presented by a contingent or prospective
creditor until sufficient security for costs has been given, and a prima facie case for
winding-up has been established to its satisfaction.
• A contributory is entitled to present a winding-up petition notwithstanding that there may
not be assets available on the winding-up for distribution to contributories.
WINDING UP ON JUST AND EQUITABLE GROUNDS S571(f)
Pursuant to this section, the following must exist:
a. The company is formed for fraudulent purposes;
b. The co is a “bubble” i.e., where a going concern does not have any business or assets;
c. Unfairly prejudicial or discriminating acts against the minority or other members;
d. If it is a small going concern, ground employable in the dissolution of partnership is
enough to dissolve the company.
The remedy was readily available in the context of small family cos or quasi partnerships. It’s
what happened in Ebrahimi v Westborn Galleries Ltd as it’s a co of father and son and the
applicant. The father and son ganged up and removed him as director from the co as director and
they followed the correct procedures of passing ordinary resolution and removed him legally.
Being hard done by the removal and very unhappy brought action to wind up the co on winding
up on just and equitable ground, lost at TC and CA but won at HL based on equitable grounds.
It is immaterial whether the act is in the interest of the co, provided it is inequitable per Lord
Wilberforce. This was given the initial understanding that all three of them would be directors,
the HL held it to suffice and because that was the only remedy available in the 1948 Act
(England), it was wound up. But now, there are more remedies like unfair prejudice so the court
wouldn’t grant that but likely adopt other remedies. It would amount to using a sledge hammer to
kill an ant. You cannot be closing up cos that create employment just like that.
If at all it would apply today, it would be in very small cos and there must be evidence that like
in Ebrahimi, that there was a pre-agreement between them and the would-be directors. The
phrase is legitimate expectation. This was expressed in O’Neil v Phillips where Lord Hoffman
referred to the phrase as an unruly horse that won’t be allowed to dent the smooth process of
corporate operations. So even the legitimate expectation based on the pre-agreement may not
now suffice in all circumstances.
The remedies now are numerous, so this winding up under just and equitable grounds, though
still in the statute books is highly unlikely to be granted.
In Fasakin v Fasakin, an application on the ground that there was reckless spending by the
director and treating the co as his personal property was refused with the CA overruling the TC
which had earlier granted it.
342
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
343
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
LIQUIDATOR S585
The Court may appoint a liquidator or liquidators for the purpose of conducting the proceedings
in winding-up a company and performing such duties in reference to it as the court may impose
and where there is a vacancy, the official receiver shall by virtue of his office, act as liquidator
until such time as the vacancy is filled.
At any time after the presentation of a petition and before the making of a winding-up order, the
appointment shall be provisional and the Court making the appointment may limit and restrict
the powers of the liquidator by the order appointing him.
Powers of liquidator S588
1. The liquidator in a winding-up by the Court shall have power, with the sanction either of
the court or of the committee of inspection to—
a. bring or defend any action or other legal proceeding in the name and on behalf of the
co;
b. carry on the business of the co so far as may be necessary for its beneficial winding-
up;
c. appoint a legal practitioner or any other relevant professional to assist him in the
performance of his duties;
d. pay any classes of creditors in full;
e. make any compromise or arrangement with creditors or persons claiming to be
creditors, or having or alleging themselves to have any claim, present or future,
certain or contingent, ascertained or sounding only in damages against the co, or
whereby the co may be rendered liable; and
f. compromise all calls and liabilities to calls, debts and liabilities capable of resulting in
debts, and all claims, present or future, certain or contingent, ascertained or sounding
only in damages, subsisting or supposed to subsist between the co and a contributory
or alleged contributory or other debtor or person apprehending liability to the co, and
all questions in any way relating to or affecting the assets or the winding-up of the co,
on such terms as may be agreed, and take any security for the discharge of any such
call, debt, liability or claim and give a complete discharge in respect of it.
344
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
d. draw, accept, make and indorse any bill of exchange or promissory note in the name
and on behalf of the co with the same effect with respect to the liability of the co as if
the bill or note had been drawn, accepted, made or indorsed by or on behalf of the co
in the course of its business;
e. raise on the security of the assets of the co any money requisite;
f. take out in his official name, letters of administration to any deceased contributory,
and to do in his official name any other act necessary for obtaining payment of any
money due from a contributory or his estate which cannot be conveniently done in the
name of the co, and in all such cases the money due shall, for the purpose of enabling
the liquidator to take out the letters of administration or recover the money, be
deemed to be due to the liquidator himself;
g. appoint an agent to do any business which the liquidator is unable to do himself; and
h. do all other things as may be necessary for winding-up the affairs of the co and
distributing its assets.
PROCEDURAL STEPS IN COMPULSORY WINDING UP BY THE COURT
1. Filling of the petition with the affidavit verifying the petition;
2. Service of the petition (file affidavit/proof of service);
3. Obtain leave of court to advertise the petition;
4. Advertisement of the petition;
5. Filing of memorandum of compliance;
6. Filing notice of intention to appear, affidavit in opposition and affidavit in reply by the
respondent;
7. Appointment of provisional liquidator;
8. Filing and leaving of summons for costs;
9. Filing of list of persons appearing;
10. Hearing of the petition;
11. Making of the winding up order;
12. Service of winding up order;
13. Delivery of statement of affairs;
14. Official receiver’s preliminary report;
15. First meeting of creditors and contributories;
16. Appointment of liquidator;
17. Advertisement of appointment of liquidator;
18. Appointment of committee of inspection;
19. Winding up by the liquidator; and
20. Dissolution order.
A winding up proceeding, could be stayed after a winding up order has been made in the interest
of justice S601(1).
Reg 43 Companies Reg 2012 (not in the 2021 regulations but in the handbook, so this is
strictly for bar finals) sets out the requirements for winding up by the court. The steps are
as follows:
345
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
346
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
15 days after passing the resolution and it should embody a statement of the co's assets and
liabilities as at the latest practicable date for the making of the declaration. Where this is not
done, the statement will have no effect.
Any director(s) who makes this statement carelessly and the co fails to fulfil the declaration
commits an offence and on conviction liable to punishment as the court may prescribe or 3
months imprisonment.
A winding-up in any case where this type of declaration has been made and delivered, shall be
referred to as “a members’ voluntary winding-up” and a winding-up in any case where a
declaration has not been made and delivered as aforesaid shall in this Act be referred to as “a
creditors’ voluntary winding-up”
NB: all costs, charges and expenses properly incurred in the winding up, including the
remuneration of the liquidator, shall be payable out of the assets of the co in priority to all other
claims.
SUMMARY OF PROCEDURE FOR MEMBERS VOLUNTARY WINDING
1. Statutory declaration of solvency duly signed by majority of the directors and embodying
statement of the company's asset and liabilities, to be filed at CAC within 5 weeks
preceding the date to pass winding up resolution and filed with CAC within 15 days
of passing the resolution.
2. A GM is convened to pass the winding up resolution.
3. Special resolution for voluntary winding up signed by a director and secretary or two
directors, to be passed within 5 weeks of making of the statutory declaration of
solvency, and filed with CAC within 14 days of its passage.
4. Publication of notice of appointment of a liquidator in the Gazette or two daily
newspapers.
5. The co ceases to carryon business except those that will benefit the winding up.
6. The co in GM shall appoint one or more liquidators for the purpose of winding-up the
affairs and distributing the assets of the co, and may fix the remuneration to be paid to
him or them.
7. If a liquidator is appointed, all the powers of the directors shall cease, except so far as the
co in GM or the liquidator sanctions the continuance thereof.
8. Resolution for appointment of liquidator.
9. Notice of appointment of liquidator to be filed with CAC within 14 days of the
appointment.
10. Liquidator's notice of his appointment.
11. Return of final meeting and account of liquidation as laid before and approved by the
meeting, to be filed with CAC within 7 days after date of the final meeting.
12. Original certificate of registration (or CTC where applicable) to be delivered to CAC for
cancellation. See also SS630 and 631 (2) CAMA
347
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
349
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Dear Sir,
STATUTORY NOTICE OF DEMAND TO REPAY N50, 000, 000. 00 LOAN PURSUANT TO
SECTION 572 OF THE COMPANIES AND ALLIED-MATTERS ACT, 2020
Edupal Nigeria Limited (our Company) seeks to bring the debt in the sum of N50,000,000.00
(Fifty Million Naira) only which BAD Nigeria Limited owes our company to the notice of BAD
Nigeria Limited.
The said sum is hereby demanded and BAD Nigeria Limited is given three weeks, from the date
of receipt of this letter, to pay the said sum mentioned above.
TAKE NOTICE that upon failure to pay the said sum after the expiration of three weeks from
the date of receipt of this letter, our company shall proceed to apply to the Federal High Court to
compulsorily wind-up BAD Nigeria Limited.
Thank you.
Yours faithfully,
________________
Chris Ozo Agbata Esq
Company Secretary
350
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
Dear Sir,
STATUTORY DECLARATION OF SOLVENCY EMBODYING A STATEMENT OF THE
ASSETS AND LAIBILITIES OF EDUPAL NIGERIA LIMITED PURSUANT TO SECTION
625 OF THE COMPANIES AND ALLIED-MATTERS ACT, 2020
We, ABC and XYZ, being the Directors of the above-named company, solemnly declare as
follows:
1. That we have made a full enquiry into the affairs of this company
2. That having done so, we have formed the opinion that the company will be able to pay its
debt in full within a period of twelve (12) months from the commencement of the
winding up, and we append a statement of the company’s assets and liabilities as at the
15th day of August, 2022 being the latest practicable date before making this declaration.
3. And we make this solemn declaration, conscientiously believing the same to be true by
virtue of the Oaths Act.
…………………
1. ABC
…………………
2. XYZ
Deponents
Sworn to at the Federal High Court Registry, Lagos
This 15th day of August. 2022
BEFORE ME
.......................................................................................................
COMMISSIONER OF OATHS
351
Chris Ozo Agbata [email protected] [email protected] 07035406532
352