Ch6 19rare
6.
Priority diseases and reasons for inclusion
6.19 Rare diseases
See Background Paper 6.19 (BP6_19Rare.pdf)
Background
In the EU, a disease is considered to be rare when the number of people affected is less
than 5 per 10 000. There are between 5 000 and 8 000 rare diseases, most of them with a
genetic basis. 1 A very rough estimate would be that one out of 15 persons worldwide
could be affected by a rare (“orphan”) disease – 400 million people worldwide, of
whom 30 million are in Europe and 25 million in the United States.2 Rare diseases are
serious chronic diseases, and may be life-threatening.
In recent decades, considerable attention has been paid worldwide to efforts to
stimulate the research, development and marketing of medicinal products for rare
diseases, including the use of various regulatory incentives in both the EU and the
USA. In the United States, over 400 products have been approved as therapy for more
than 200 rare disease indications and in the EU, over 70 products for about 45
indications. 3,4 In addition, the establishment of various (research) programmes and
networks has also helped advance understanding and diagnosis of rare diseases.5 The
International Rare Diseases Research Consortium (IRDiRC) was launched in 2011 at the
initiative of the European Commission and the U.S. National Institutes of Health with
the aim of fostering international collaboration in rare diseases research. However,
despite these positive developments, the burden of rare diseases continues to persist
for a number of reasons.
Rare diseases present fundamentally different challenges from those of more common
diseases, such as asthma. This is most apparent during the clinical development stage
when rarity significantly complicates the task. Problems include the small number of
patients, the logistics involved in reaching widely dispersed patients, the lack of
validated biomarkers and surrogate end-points, and limited clinical expertise and
expert centres.
1
Priority Medicines for Europe and the World 2013 Update
Remaining challenges
For many rare diseases, basic knowledge such as the cause of the disease,
pathophysiology, natural course of the disease and epidemiological data is limited or
not available. This significantly hampers the ability to both diagnose and treat these
diseases. To address this challenge, public funding of fundamental research into the
disease process remains necessary both at the national and global level.
Rare disease patients are scattered across countries. As a result, medical expertise for
each of these diseases is a scarce resource. Fragmented disease knowledge means that
it is critical that investments in fundamental research go hand-in-hand with
investments in dedicated infrastructure and international networks (biobanks,
registries, networks of expertise). Where needed, these networks can also provide
opportunities to train health professionals on rare diseases.
Equally important is the availability of an internationally recognized rare disease
classification system which can help generate reliable epidemiological data. Such a
system would provide a useful basis for further research into the natural history and
causes of rare diseases, and enable monitoring of the safety and clinical effectiveness of
therapies and assessment of the quality of care.
Ongoing fundamental research into the disease process will result in the discovery of
more targets for drug development for a specific rare disease. In particular, public
funding of translational research, including proof of concept studies, might act as a
catalyst to translate rare disease research into the development of new medicines.
Making a disease easy to diagnose at an early stage will allow the development of
prevention strategies that, even in the absence of an underlying treatment, can have a
significant positive impact on a patient’s life.
Clinical trial funding programmes remain essential for orphan drug development,
especially for rare diseases that appear less attractive for the pharmaceutical industry.
Of critical importance for marketing authorization and reimbursement is the
acceptance of the evidence generated during drug development for rare diseases.
When the medical need is great, a treatment can become available at an early stage
where evidence is robust, but limited. However, this represents a substantial hurdle for
some methodological assessments and the development of alternative methods of
evaluation in small and very small populations is desirable. Large multidisciplinary
networks should be funded to stimulate collaboration and bring together medical
experts, reference centres and patients’ groups. This infrastructure is necessary for
performance of clinical trials and subsequent monitoring of newly authorized
products.
A new generation of more targeted therapies (such as stem cell therapies, gene
therapies or therapeutic gene modulations) is in development and new products are
becoming available. To allow these targeted therapies for smaller patient groups to
2
6. Priority diseases and reasons for inclusion
become more common practice, it is critical to continue funding the research and
development of these highly innovative therapies.
The use of optimized delivery methods (such as controlled or site-specific delivery)
could entail improving the pharmacokinetic profiles of existing orphan drugs with
improved efficacy, safety profile, or convenience for the patient.
Another opportunity for research in pharmacological intervention for rare diseases is
to pursue the development of molecules developed for one indication that have also
demonstrated potential with a favourable benefit/risk ratio for treating a different rare
disorder and could be developed for other indications, a practice known as “drug
repurposing”. The advantage is that more is known about these molecules and that
knowledge can be leveraged in a new development programme.
Research needs
In the area of rare diseases, there are many opportunities for the EU to build on the
successful programmes and networks that have been supported so far. The most
important ones that should continue to be supported are:
Networks of excellence that focus on research infrastructure as well as provision of
disease-related information at EU level and beyond (for example, patient
experience)
Initiatives that focus on rare disease classification
Fundamental research into the disease process to increase understanding of rare
diseases
Incentives for the development of therapeutics (such as clinical trial funding
programmes)
Assessment methods adapted to small and very small patient populations.
In addition, more support is needed for:
Translational research to increase the translation of disease knowledge into drug
development or health care innovation
Innovative diagnostic methods for rare diseases to enable early intervention
Research, infrastructure and implementation of guidelines for medical and
psychosocial care for rare diseases
Incentives for the development of preventive strategies and validated diagnostic
techniques
Incentives to leverage existing knowledge and optimize the use of existing drugs
(innovative delivery systems and drug repurposing)
Finding methods to provide easy access to available health care for patients,
regardless of where they live.
3
Priority Medicines for Europe and the World 2013 Update
References
1Orphanet website: About rare disease. Available at: http://www.orpha.net/consor/cgi-
bin/Education_AboutRareDiseases.php?lng=EN Last accessed 10 March 2013.
2 EURORDIS. What is a rare disease? http://www.eurordis.org/about-rare-diseases. Last
accessed 20 January 2013.
3 Braun MM et al. Emergence of orphan drugs in the United States: a quantitative assessment of
the first 25 years. Nature Reviews Drug Discovery, 2010, Vol 9, 519-522.
4 Committee for Orphan Medicinal Products. European regulation on orphan medicinal
products: 10 years of experience and future perspectives, Nature Reviews Drug Discovery, 2011,
Vol 10, 341-349.
5 Aymé S, Rodwell C eds. 2012 Report on the State of the Art of Rare Disease Activities in Europe of
the European Union Committee of Experts on Rare Diseases, 2012.
