Chapter 1-5
Chapter 1-5
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Cytopathology is a branch of pathology that studies and diagnoses diseases on the cellular
level. Cytopathology is generally used on samples of free cells or tissue fragments, in contrast
sites, often to aid in the diagnosis of cancer but also in the diagnosis of some infectious
diseases and other inflammatory conditions (Kirkpatrick, 2022).. For example, a common
application of cytopathology is the Pap smear, a screening tool used to detect precancerous
Cytopathologic tests are sometimes called smear tests because the samples may be smeared
across a glass microscope slide for subsequent staining and microscopic examination.
Different types of smear tests may also be used for cancer diagnosis. In this sense, it is
The sample is collected, normally by a small brush, in the same way as for a conventional
smear test, but rather than the smear being transferred directly to a microscope slide, the
sample is deposited into a small bottle of preservative liquid. At the laboratory, the liquid is
treated to remove other elements such as mucus before a layer of cells is placed on a slide
Cytology has limitations such as potential sample errors, subjective interpretation and the
Results depend on the quality and representativeness of the sample obtained and errors may
Liquid based cytology while offering advantages, has limitations including increased cost,
technical complexity and the potential for artefacts that may affect sample interpretation.
1.4.1 Aim
The study is designed to evaluate locally prepared verse commercial liquid base cytology
1. To access the efficacy of locally prepared transport media for cytological samples.
2. To compare the efficacy of locally prepared and commercial liquid base cytology
transport media.
1. What is the efficacy of locally prepared transport media for cytological samples?
2. Does the efficacy of locally prepared transport media differs from commercial liquid base
At the end of this research and testing of hypothesis, the following null hypothesis (H0)
H0: Locally prepared transport media for cytological sample has no significant change
H1: Locally prepared transport media for cytological sample has a significant change with
2.1 Cytology
sites, often to aid in the diagnosis of cancer but also in the diagnosis of some infectious
diseases and other inflammatory conditions (Kirkpatrick, 2022).. For example, a common
application of cytopathology is the Pap smear, a screening tool used to detect precancerous
Cytopathologic tests are sometimes called smear tests because the samples may be smeared
across a glass microscope slide for subsequent staining and microscopic examination.
Different types of smear tests may also be used for cancer diagnosis. In this sense, it is
The following are the ultimate objectives from utilization of most cytological specimen:
This objective is the ultimate goal. Clinicians, patients, and pathologists are all interested to
reach a definitive specific diagnosis utilizing single diagnostic test. It is well recognized now
that the utilization of different cytological examinations from different organs provides
sufficient diagnostic information that drives treatment decisions (Caddy et al., 2005;
The success story of utilizing Papanicolaou smears in detecting early precursor lesions of
cervical cancer is well known in the developed word. Rates of cancer death due to cervical
cancer dropped tremendously after the 1960s when the Papanicolaou smears screening
establishing the initial diagnosis is a routine procedure. Sputum, bronchoalveolar lavage, and
bronchial brushings are frequent samples that are used as follow-up for patients with a
previous diagnosis of pulmonary carcinoma. Additional common samples that can be used
include: pleural fluid, peritoneal fluid, discharge samples, cerebrospinal fluid, and FNA from
any palpable or non-palpable deep-seated new lesions that appear during the follow-up
period.
The advantages of utilizing cytological examination over traditional tissue are well known,
2.1.2.1 Safe
The procedures that are used to get cytological samples are extremely safe. Complications are
very rare and when they occur they are relatively mild. Hematomas and pneumothoraces are
among those. The most serious complication that may occur and had been reported is the
development of pneumothorax during FNA of lung lesions. However, less than 5% of those
are serious and require insertion of chest tube (Shantaveerappa et al., 2002; Mullan et al.,
2004). In addition, if the procedure is done under image guidance, immediate evacuation
using the same needle is now recommended and had been successfully achieved. Paying
attention to the risk factors for the development of pneumothorax may decrease their rate.
Hematomas are observed more frequently in patients who have coagulopathies (Rios et al.,
2001). Prevention of such complications is easily achieved by applying gentle pressure for
longer periods after the procedure. It is also recommended to consult with the hematologist in
the institution to prepare those patients who suffer from bleeding disorders or are on
anticoagulation therapy. Pain and patient discomfort are relatively mild and can be prevented
Infections are extremely rare and can be avoided by following the international safety
guidelines and sterile techniques (Ryan et al., 2002; Lee et al., 2005).
2.1.2.2 Simple
It is well known that getting most cytological samples is simple. With increasing familiarity
of different sampling techniques, currently almost all institutions and health care providers
are aware of the technology and it is part of routine investigative and diagnostic patient work
2.1.2.3 Quick
The procedure is very quick and diagnostic answers can be provided immediately at the time
of procedure, if needed, or within the next 24-48 hours (Kramer and Groen; 2003; Nayek et
feature that is becoming very critical given the current high health care costs. Compared to
surgical biopsies, the amount of savings is substantial (Chaiwun et al., 2002; Nasuti et al.,
The samples represent cells that exfoliate from superficial or deep serosal or mucosal
1. Gynecological samples: Papanicolaou smears are the first samples that started the
exponential revolution of the cytopathology field. Recently, almost all health care providers
are moving away from the conventional Papanicolaou smears and moving to what is called
fluid-based technology that can provide more accurate interpretation and allows for
molecular testing for the Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) infection (Yarkin et al., 2003;
bronchoalveolar lavage, and bronchial brushing cytology. Those are commonly used to detect
3. Urinary cytology: Urine cytology, bladder washing, and brushing cytology. The urinary
chromosomal aberrations in urothelial neoplasms has been recently refined. Commercial kits
utilizing the Fluorescent in Situ Hybridization (FISH) are already available and in use
(Sarosdy et al., 2002; Degtyar et al., 2004; Mousa and Al-Abbadi, 2011).
4. Body fluid cytology: Common samples include pleural fluid, pericardial fluid, peritoneal
fluid, and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) cytology. Similar to respiratory samples, those are also
routine procedure during endoscopy. Brushing samples are used to detect viral and fungal
6. Discharge cytology: Discharge from any anatomic location can be easily examined to
investigate infections and malignancies. The most common sample is breast nipple discharge
that is used as a screening method for detection of mammary carcinoma (Mousa and Al-
Abbadi, 2011).
7. Scrape cytology: This technique is very simple and can be performed by either clinicians
or pathologists at the bedside or in the clinic. Detection of infections and cancer cells at any
surface (skin or mucosa) can be quick and accurate (Mousa and Al-Abbadi, 2011).
Different names are used to describe this expanding technique. The most famous ones are
FNA, fine needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB), and needle aspiration biopsy cytology (NABC).
All of them mean the same thing; aspirating cellular material using a fine needle to make a
diagnosis. This technique has been used from any lesion in the body which includes two
major areas:
least be available to confirm material adequacy are well studied in the literature.
2. Non-palpable lesions: The non-palpable lesions are usually done with the help of image
The initial smears are usually stained by a quick stain (stains, which needs approximately one
minute to perform) such as Diff Quick (DQ) stain, a modified Romanowsky stain.
This type of stain is done on slides with material after airdrying and this is why they are also
called air-dried based stains. The other set of slides are fixed in basic ethanolbased solution
(preferable 95% ethanol) for different type of stain, the Papanicolaou stain. In addition to the
previous smears which are prepared at the time of the fine needle aspiration, the rest of the
material is usually flushed in an ethanol or formalin-based solution after which the material is
centrifuged and a small mini biopsy is created from the concentrated cellular material at the
bottom of the tube; this is known as the cell block. The slides from the cell block are usually
stained by a regular Hematoxylin and Eosin (HandE) stain. These three types of stains are
commonly used in different laboratories. Each one of those has its advantages and
disadvantages (Mousa and Al-Abbadi, 2011). For example, DQ stain is good for
Papanicolaou stain is more superior for demonstrating the nuclear details, which are the most
important and specific in making the diagnosis of malignancy. The HandE stain combines the
advantages of both Papanicolaou and DQ stains and gives the pathologist a chance to
Different types of smear preparations are utilized in the cytopathology laboratory, which
includes:
concentrates the material and is especially advantageous when few cells are present in a large
amount of fluid, such as pleural or peritoneal fluids (Mousa and Al-Abbadi, 2011).
3. Centrifuge smears using membrane filters. This method utilizes the use of paper filter with
very small pores to trap contaminating material. It is becoming obsolete since the slide
4. Monolayer liquid-based cytology. This technology is now the standard method that is used
to prepare Papanicolaou smears. The smears are superior to their conventional counterparts
and also allow testing for Human Papilloma Virus DNA particles (Yarkin et al., 2003;
Matthews-Greer et al., 2004; Schiller et al., 2004). The cells are laid on the slide in a
5. The last groups of slides are those prepared using the Cellblock technique, as described
above. Those slides are prepared utilizing formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue. The
availability of such material provides the pathologist with material that can be used to do
special necessary stains. Microorganisms and immunohistochemical stains are the most
There is still no agreed upon standard for the best aspiration technique in cytopathology.
However, all FNA experts agree on one thing, every aspirator have to get comfortable with
one method and modify it as more experience is gained. The bottom line is to get enough
diagnostic cells from the area of interest. The gauges of the needles used vary, however, 21-
25 French gauge needles are the most frequent. Whether to use a gun (syringe holder) or not
when negative pressure is utilized, is left for the level of comfort of the aspirator. Some
believe that using the gun provides more control and more cells (Mousa and Al-Abbadi,
1. Aspiration using a fine needle (gauge range 21-25) without negative pressure or a syringe.
This technique is also known as “the French technique” and clinicians, radiologists and
pathologists who use this method believe that it is less traumatic than the others and yield
2. Aspiration using a syringe and needle without negative pressure. This method allows the
aforementioned capillary pressure to push cells in the hub of the needle avoiding the trauma
of negative pressure. It is believed that adding the syringe will allow collection of fluids if the
3. Aspiration using a syringe and needle with utilization of negative pressure. The amount of
commonly used. This is the method that the author uses without a gun and inserting the
needle in a circular way to sample the whole area of the lesion (Mousa and Al-Abbadi, 2011).
factors that vary depending on the tissue aspirated, the collection technique and the smear
make a final cytological diagnosis. The general features of malignancy in cytological slides
of nuclear chromatin, increased mitotic activity and specially the presence of abnormal ones,
nuclear membrane abnormalities, cellular and nuclear pleomorphism, and background tumor
necrosis (also known as tumor diathesis). Ultimately, we are all responsible for providing an
Problems can arise anytime anywhere from the time the patient is seen until the time the final
report is transcribed and faxed or sent to the clinician. Trouble shooting is very important to
identify problems, which can arise anytime (Mousa and Al-Abbadi, 2011).
Diagnostic pitfalls can still occur and are usually due to:
1. Poor collection technique: This can occur when the appropriate slides or containers with
appropriate fixatives are not used at the time of the procedure. This can be resolved by
consulting with the pathology/cytopathology department for help (Mousa and Al-Abbadi,
2011).
2. Poor fixation: This is sometimes seen when there is no experience with cytopathology
obscure cellular details and prevent appropriate interpretation. To avoid this problem, treating
4. Cellular changes related to radiation and/or chemotherapy: This issue comes up if the
patient had already been diagnosed with malignancy and was treated with chemotherapy
and/or radiation therapy. Certain changes are induced by these treatment modalities. To
decrease the pitfalls from these changes, appropriate and detailed history should be given by
clinicians and awareness of the changes by the pathologist should be taken into consideration.
Awareness of these changes by the cytopathologist is very helpful to prevent both false
positive and false negative diagnosis. Having a pathologist/cytopathologist at the time of the
procedure or performance of the procedure by a pathologist will help alert the pathologist to
The sample is collected, normally by a small brush, in the same way as for a conventional
smear test, but rather than the smear being transferred directly to a microscope slide, the
sample is deposited into a small bottle of preservative liquid. At the laboratory, the liquid is
treated to remove other elements such as mucus before a layer of cells is placed on a slide
For many years, efforts have been made to develop methods that would enhance the
sensitivity and specificity of the Papanicolaou smear (also called Pap History smear).
Emphasis has been placed on creating automated screening machines whose success depends
From this research and development, liquid-based gynecologic specimen collection has
evolved. Its proponents argue that liquid-based preparations outperform conventional smears
transfer. Proponents point out that, in direct smears, the cells are not transferred in a
representative fashion and that up to 90% of the material scraped from the cervix may be
discarded with the sampling device. With liquid-based collection, the sampling will be
representative and operator-dependent variation will not occur since processing is controlled
by the laboratory.
factors, and standardized cell transfer. In LBC, samples are collected by completely
immersing the sampling device into the company vial containing preservative fluid, whereby
the cells are preserved and fixed simultaneously unlike conventional smears where the
sample is smeared onto the glass slide and fixed separately (Manjiri and Prajakta, 2022). To
date, two major liquid-based preparation methods are known – ThinPrep and SurePath. These
two methods are different in their principles of cell harvesting but produce similar
sample is vortexed and strained to break the mucus and large cell groups and then is treated
through a density gradient centrifugation process to remove blood and debris. The cell pellet
is resuspended and is allowed to sediment onto a glass slide. This is followed by staining on
the PrepStain instrument (Manjiri and Prajakta, 2022). In LBC, samples are collected by
completely immersing the sampling device into the company vial containing preservative
fluid unlike conventional smears where the sample is smeared on the slide and fixed
ThinPrep or SurePath) and a smear representing monolayer cell sample with a clean
background is formed.
2.2.1 SurePath
cell/sample is vortexed and strained to break the mucus and large cell groups and then is
treated through a density gradient centrifugation process to remove blood and debris. The cell
pellet is resuspended and is allowed to sediment onto a glass slide (Manjiri and Prajakta,
2022).
2.2.2 ThinPrep
Principle
In this procedure, samples are collected in a vial containing a filter and methanol-based
preservative (provided by the company). The vials are placed one at a time on the semi-
automated ThinPrep machine. The filter within the vial rotates mechanically dispersing cells,
mucus, blood, and debris. This suspension of cells is passed through a filter made up of
neutral polycarbonate. The flow of this suspension is constantly monitored to get an optimal
quantity of cells. The cells trapped onto the filter surface are automatically transferred to a
The study was carried out in University of Maiduguri Teaching Hospital (UMTH), Borno
state. Borno State is located in the North Eastern geographical zone of Nigeria. Borno State
is the largest of the six states in North-Eastern Nigeria. The state lies on coordinates 11°30′N
13°00′E. It has a total landmass of 70,898 square kilometres and has a population density of
72 people per square kilometres. It shares borders with the Republics of Niger to the north,
Chad to the north-east and Cameroun to the east. Within Nigeria, Borno State shares
boundaries with Adamawa State to the South, Gombe State to the West and Yobe State to the
north-west. Borno State has an estimated population of 4,171,104 (2,163,358 males and
2,007,746 females). This accounts for 3.0% of Nigeria’s total population (NPC, 2006).
3.3 Sample Collection
The informed consent forms were distributed to the participants recruited for the study after
explaining the type and purpose of the research to them. After obtaining informed consent
from the participants, buccal swabr was collected from the participants.
3.6 Methodology
3.6.1 Papanicolaou stain
Papanicolaou stain is the most important stain utilized in the practice of cytopathology. It is a
polychromatic stain containing multiple dyes to differentially stain various components of the
cells
3.6.2 Principle
Papanicolaou stain includes both acidic and basic dyes. Acidic dye stains the basic
components of the cell and basic dye stain the acidic components of the cell. The
3.6.2.1 Hematoxylin
Natural dye hematoxylin is the nuclear stain which stains cell nuclei blue. It has affinity for
This is the first acidic counterstain (cytoplasmic stain) which stains matured and keratinized
This is the second counterstain which is a polychrome mixture of eosin Y, light green SF and
Bismarck brown. Eosin Y gives a pink colour to cytoplasm of mature squamous cells,
Stains blue to cytoplasm of metabolically active cells like parabasal squamous cells,
3.6.3 Procedure
3. The smear was stained with Harris hematoxylin dye for 2 minutes
CHAPTER FOUR
4.0 RESULTS
4.1 Analysis of Study Population
This study was designed to evaluate locally prepared verse commercial liquid base cytology
transport media for cytological sample preservation analysis. The results were displayed in
Table 4.1 shows the socio-demographic data of the participants. Ten (10) study subjects
whose informed consent has been obtained were recruited into the study and it consisted of
6(60%) females and 4(40%) males with a mean age of 29.53±9.79 years.
Five buccal smears were immersed in locally prepared transport media and commercial liquid
base cytology transport media each. The results were displayed in photomicrographs
Table 4.1: Socio-demographic data of study subjects
Male 4(40%)
Plate 4.1: Photomicrograph of Pap stained buccal smear after preserving in commercial liquid
based cytology transport media. The picture shows poor cytoplasmic details and background.
Plate 4.2: Photomicrograph of Pap stained cytological buccal smear after preserving in
locally prepared liquid based cytology transport media. The picture shows better cytoplasmic
CHAPTER FIVE
5.1 Discussion
The sample is collected, normally by a small brush, in the same way as for a conventional
smear test, but rather than the smear being transferred directly to a microscope slide, the
sample is deposited into a small bottle of preservative liquid. At the laboratory, the liquid is
treated to remove other elements such as mucus before a layer of cells is placed on a slide
The study aimed at evaluating locally prepared verse commercial liquid base cytology
transport media for cytological sample preservation analysis. The study shows that pap
stained cytological buccal smear had poor cytoplasmic details and background when
preserved in commercial prepared liquid based cytology. The study also revealed that better
cytoplasmic details and background were obtained when buccal smear was preserved in
5.2 Conclusion
This study demonstrated that better cytoplasmic details and background was obtained when
pap stained cytological buccal smear was preserved in commercial liquid based cytology
transport media. Locally prepared liquid based cytology transport media can effectively
preserve cytological samples which may provide a valuable and cost-effective tool for
diagnostic cytopathology.
5.3 Recommendation
It is recommended that further research should be carried out using a larger sample size of
buccal samples to determine the efficiency of locally prepared liquid based cytology transport
media.
References
Caddy G, Conron M, Wright G, Desmond P, Hart D, Chen RY. (2005). The accuracy of
EUS-FNA in assessing mediastinal lymphadenopathy and staging patients with
NSCLC. Eur Respir J;25:410-5.
Chaiwun B, Settakorn J, Ya-In C, Wisedmongkol W, Rangdaeng S, Thorner P. (2002).
Effectiveness of fine-needle aspiration cytology of breast: Analysis of 2,375 cases
from northern Thailand. Diagn Cytopathol; 26:201-5.
Degtyar P, Neulander E, Zirkin H, Yusim I, Douvdevani A, Mermershtain W, et al. (2004).
Fluorescence in situ hybridization performed on exfoliated urothelial cells in patients
with transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder. Urology; 63:398-401.
Eedes CR, Wang HH. (2004). Cost-effectiveness of immediate specimen adequacy
assessment of thyroid fine-needle aspirations. Am J Clin Pathol; 121:64-9.
Han J, Kim MK, Nam SJ, Yang JH. (2004). E-cadherin and cytokeratin subtype profiling in
effusion cytology. J Korean Med Sci; 19:826-33.
Kontzoglou K, Moulakakis KG, Konofaos P, Kyriazi M, Kyroudes A, Karakitsos P. (2005).
The role of liquid-based cytology in the investigation of breast lesions using fine-
needle aspiration: A cytohistopathological evaluation. J Surg Oncol;89:75-8.
Kramer H, Groen HJ. (2003). Current concepts in the mediastinal lymph node staging of
nonsmall cell lung cancer. Ann Surg; 238:180-8.
Lee LS, Saltzman JR, Bounds BC, Poneros JM, Brugge WR, Thompson CC. (2005). EUS-
guided fine needle aspiration of pancreatic cysts: A retrospective analysis of
complications and their predictors. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol; 3:231-6.
Liptak, Peter; Barnetson, Robert James (2012). Liquid-based cervical cytology in the United
Kingdom and South Africa. Continuing Medical Education. 30 (2): 45–48.
Matthews-Greer J, Rivette D, Reyes R, Vanderloos CF, Turbat-Herrera EA. (2004). Human
papillomavirus detection: Verification with cervical cytology. Clin Lab Sci; 17:8-11.
Mazza E, Maddau C, Ricciardi A, Falchini M, Matucci M, Ciarpallini T. (2005). On-site
evaluation of percutaneous CT-guided fine needle aspiration of pulmonary lesions. A
study of 321 cases. Radiol Med (Torino); 110:141-8.
Mousa A. Al-Abbadi (2011). Basics of cytology; Avicenna Journal of Medicine; Vol 1 | Issue
1
Mullan CP, Kelly BE, Ellis PK, Hughes S, Anderson N, McCluggage WG. (2004). CT-
guided fine-needle aspiration of lung nodules: Effect on outcome of using coaxial
technique and immediate cytological evaluation. Ulster Med J; 73:32-6.
Nasuti JF, Gupta PK, Baloch ZW. (2002). Diagnostic value and cost-effectiveness of on-site
evaluation of fine-needle aspiration specimens: Review of 5,688 cases. Diagn
Cytopathol; 27:1-4.
Nayak S, Puranik SC, Deshmukh SD, Mani R, Bhore AV, Bollinger RC. (2004). Fine-needle
aspiration cytology in tuberculous lymphadenitis of patients with and without HIV
infection. Diagn Cytopathol; 31:204-6.
Rader AE, Avery A, Wait CL, McGreevey LS, Faigel D, Heinrich MC. (2001). Fineneedle
aspiration biopsy diagnosis of gastrointestinal stromal tumors using morphology,
immunocytochemistry, and mutational analysis of c-kit. Cancer; 93:269-75.
Rios A, Rodriguez JM, Martinez E, Parrilla P. (2001). Cavernous hemangioma of the thyroid.
Thyroid; 11:279-80.
Ryan AG, Zamvar V, Roberts SA. (2002). Iatrogenic candidal infection of a mediastinal
foregut cyst following endoscopic ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration.
Endoscopy; 34:838-9.
Sarosdy MF, Schellhammer P, Bokinsky G, Kahn P, Chao R, Yore L, et al. (2002). Clinical
evaluation of a multi-target fluorescent in situ hybridization assay for detection of
bladder cancer. J Urol; 168:1950-4.
Schiller CL, Nickolov AG, Kaul KL, Hahn EA, Hy JM, Escobar MT, et al. (2004). High-risk
human papillomavirus detection: A split-sample comparison of hybrid capture and
chromogenic in situ hybridization. Am J Clin Pathol; 121:537-45.
Shantaveerappa HN, Mathai MG, Byrd RP Jr, Karnad AB, Mehta JB, Roy TM. (2002).
Intervention in patients with pneumothorax immediately following CT-guided fine
needle aspiration of pulmonary nodules. Med Sci Monit; 8:CR401-4.
Taylor LA, Sorensen SV, Ray NF, Halpern MT, Harper DM. (2000). Cost effectiveness of
the conventional papanicolaou test with a new adjunct to cytological screening for
squamous cell carcinoma of the uterine cervix and its precursors. Arch Fam Med;
9:713-21.
Turkistanli EC, Sogukpinar N, Saydam BK, Aydemir G. (2003). Cervical cancer prevention
and early detection--the role of nurses and midwives. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev; 4:15-
21.
Wilbur, David C.; Bibbo, Marluce (2008). Automation in Cervical Cytology, Comprehensive
Cytopathology, Elsevier, pp. 1021–1042,
Yarkin F, Chauvin S, Konomi N, Wang W, Mo R, Bauchman G, et al. (2003). Detection of
HPV DNA in cervical specimens collected in cytologic solution by ligation-dependent
PCR. Acta Cytol; 47:450-6.