Jigl Notes ch-2
Jigl Notes ch-2
Jigl Notes ch-2
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
Preamble
The preamble declares India as a Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, and Democratic Republic,
emphasizing justice, liberty, equality, and fraternity. The constitution is considered the prime
source of laws, reflecting the nation's principles and ideology.
Structure
The Indian Constitution is described as federal but with certain unitary features. It incorporates
dual government, distribution of powers, supremacy of the constitution, an independent
judiciary, a written constitution, and a rigid amendment procedure. While having federal
characteristics, both the Union and States collaborate to achieve the ideals in the preamble.
Fundamental Rights
Part III of the Constitution guarantees fundamental rights to secure liberty, equality, and
fraternity for the people. These rights are influenced by the idea of universal and inalienable
rights, with a focus on preserving human liberty and promoting democratic life. The
Constitution originally included the right to property, which was later removed. Fundamental
rights are subject to reasonable restrictions in the interest of the state through valid legislation.
Definition of State
The term "State" includes the government and parliament of India, government legislatures of
states, and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the
Government of India. Fundamental rights are generally available against the State, with a few
exceptions.
Laws existing before the Constitution came into force are subject to review.
The court must declare the invalidity of pre-constitutional laws inconsistent with
fundamental rights.
Definition of 'Law':
Constitutional Amendment:
Doctrine of Severability
Invalid parts of a law inconsistent with fundamental rights are severed, keeping the
valid parts intact.
Doctrine of Eclipse
Existing laws inconsistent with fundamental rights become dormant but can be revived
if the constitutional prohibition is removed.
Waiver
Generally, citizens can't waive fundamental rights. Knowledge of rights and voluntary
waiver are essential.
Guarantees equality before the law or equal protection of laws to every person.
Legislative Classification:
Must have a reasonable basis, and the differentia must have a rational connection to
the law's purpose.
Evolved Dimensions:
Article 15(2): Forbids citizens from being subjected to any disability, restriction, or
condition regarding access to public places like shops, restaurants, and educational
institutions, funded either wholly or partially by the State.
Article 15(3) and (4): Allow the State to make special provisions for women and
children, and for the advancement of socially and educationally backward classes,
scheduled castes, and scheduled tribes.
Article 15(5): Allows the State to make special provisions for socially and educationally
backward classes or scheduled castes and tribes concerning their admission to
educational institutions, both aided and unaided by the State.
Article 15(6): Introduced by the Constitution (One Hundred and Third Amendment) Act,
2019, enables the State to make special provisions for economically weaker sections in
educational institutions, subject to a maximum of ten percent of total seats in each
category.
Article 16(2): Prohibits discrimination based on religion, race, caste, sex, descent, place
of birth, or residence.
Article 16(3): Allows Parliament to make laws stating that residence within a state or
union territory is an essential qualification for certain employment.
Article 16(4): Permits the reservation of appointments or posts in favor of any backward
class not adequately represented.
Article 16(5): States that a law requiring a person in certain religious or denominational
institutions to profess a particular religion is not invalid.
Article 16(6): Introduced by the Constitution (One Hundred and Third Amendment) Act,
2019, enables the State to make special provisions for economically weaker sections in
public employment, subject to a maximum of ten percent of posts in each category.
Article 19(2) to (6): Allows for reasonable restrictions on grounds of sovereignty and
integrity, security of the state, friendly relations with foreign states, public order,
decency, morality, contempt of court, defamation, and incitement to an offense
Guaranteed Freedoms
Freedom of association
Restrictions:
Reasonable Restrictions
Must be reasonable.
Must be imposed for achieving specific objectives in respective clauses of Article 19.
Factors for Reasonableness:
Onus of Proof:
State must prove to the satisfaction of the Court that the restriction is reasonable.
Restrictions:
Restrictions:
Restrictions:
Restrictions:
Subject to reasonable restrictions in the interest of the general public or the protection
of Scheduled Tribes.
Right to Acquire, Hold, and Dispose of Property (Article 19(1)(f)) [Deleted by 44th
Amendment in 1978.]
Citizens have the right to practice any profession or carry on any occupation, trade, or
business.
Restrictions:
State can carry on trade, industry, or service, to the exclusion of citizens if necessary.
Protection in Respect of Conviction for Offences (Articles 20, 21, 22)
Protection against Ex-post facto laws (Article 20(1)):
No person shall be convicted of any offence except for a violation of a law in force at the
time of the act.
Ex-post facto laws, punishing acts that were lawful when done, are prohibited.
No person can be prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once.
If a person is let off after prosecution without being punished, they can be prosecuted
again.
Extends to those formally accused, suspects, and even witnesses fearing exposure to
criminal charges.
States that no person shall be deprived of life or personal liberty except according to the
procedure established by law.
Gobind v. State of M.P.: Right to privacy should be denied only when an important
countervailing interest is shown.
Originally, A.K. Gopalan held that it means the procedure enacted by a law made by the
state.
Later clarified in Maneka Gandhi's case that Article 21 does not exclude Article 19, and
the procedure must be fair, just, and reasonable.
Right to Privacy:
Gobind v. State of M.P. emphasized the need for careful examination and case-by-case
development of the right to privacy.
Safeguards for persons arrested, including informing them of grounds, right to legal
consultation, and production before a magistrate within 24 hours.
Preventive Detention
Detention without trial to prevent a person from committing prohibited acts.
Parliament and State Legislatures can pass laws for preventive detention.
Rights of persons detained, including being informed of grounds and the right to make a
representation.
Supreme Court can issue writs like habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, quo
warranto, and certiorari.
Guarantees the right to move the Supreme Court directly for the enforcement of
fundamental rights.
Allows individuals to bypass other remedies and directly approach the Supreme Court.
This power can be assigned to other courts by Parliament without affecting the Supreme
Court's authority.
Extends not only to challenging the validity of a law but also to executive orders issued
under the authority of the law.
The Court sees itself as the protector and guarantor of fundamental rights.
Article 32 can be invoked against private individuals for violations of rights under
Articles 17, 23, and 24.
Habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, quo warranto, and certiorari can be issued to
remedy violations.
The right guaranteed by Article 32 shall not be suspended except as provided in the
Constitution, such as during a state of Emergency.
Limits Parliament's power to amend the Constitution - Parliament cannot alter the basic
structure or framework of the Constitution.
The Directive Principles of State Policy are a set of guidelines provided in Part IV of the Indian
Constitution (Articles 36 to 51). These principles are not enforceable by any court but are
considered fundamental in the governance of the country. It is the duty of the state to apply
these principles while making laws.
Not Enforceable in Courts: Unlike Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles are not
enforceable in courts, and they do not create justifiable rights for individuals.
No Justiciable Rights: Directives do not confer justifiable rights, and courts cannot
declare any law void on the grounds that it contravenes Directive Principles.
Just and humane conditions of work, maternity relief, and living wage (Articles 42 and
43).
Free and compulsory education for children up to fourteen years (Article 45).
Governor's Powers
Article 213 grants similar powers to Governors for the states. The Governor can issue
ordinances under certain circumstances, and they need approval from the state
legislature.
State legislatures have the power to make laws for the whole or any part of the
territory of the respective states.
Union Territories are administered directly by the Central Executive, and Parliament has
plenary powers to legislate for Union Territories.
Union List includes subjects of national importance, State List includes local or regional
subjects, and Concurrent List includes subjects needing both national and local
attention.
Tax subjects are enumerated in the Union List and State List, but not in the Concurrent
List.
Both Parliament and State legislatures can legislate on Concurrent List subjects, but in
case of conflict, the central law prevails.
Parliament has residuary legislative power for matters not covered in any list.
In certain situations, Parliament can legislate on State List subjects, but these situations
are limited and subject to specific conditions and timeframes.
The exceptions mentioned highlight that while the general rule is the distribution of
legislative powers between the Union and the States, there are specific circumstances
where the central government can intervene in state matters.
Harmonious Construction:
The Constitution aims to prevent conflicts and not render any entry nugatory.
If a law falls within an item where the legislature has the authority, it is valid even if it
incidentally touches another subject.
Courts consider the overall nature and character of the law to determine its true
essence.
Colourable Legislation:
Legislation with the color of constitutionality but aimed at achieving something the
legislature could not do is invalid.
The motive of the legislature is irrelevant; the focus is on the actual effect and purpose
of the law.
State legislatures can impose restrictions in the public interest and tax goods from
other states.
Laws creating state monopoly in trade are valid despite restricting freedom.
The Judiciary
Consist of the Supreme Court, High Courts, and subordinate courts, civil courts, criminal courts,
special tribunals.
Article 32 grants the Supreme Court similar powers for the enforcement of Fundamental
Rights.
High Courts have wider jurisdiction but limited to their territorial boundaries, while the
Supreme Court can issue writs across India.
Concurrent Jurisdiction:
Both High Courts and the Supreme Court have concurrent jurisdiction to issue writs.
The Supreme Court plays a special role as the protector and guarantor of Fundamental Rights
under Article 32.
High Courts can enforce rights other than Fundamental Rights if there is a public duty.
Types of Writs:
Habeas Corpus:
Example: X detained wrongfully by Y; X's family can file a writ of habeas corpus.
Mandamus:
Applicability: Articles 226 and 32; not against the President, Governor, or private
individuals.
Prohibition
Certiorari
Jurisdiction: High Courts can issue it throughout their territorial jurisdiction; Supreme
Court under Article 32.
Quo Warranto
Delegated Legislation:
Classification:
Executive Legislation
Judicial Legislation
Municipal Legislation
Autonomous Legislation
Colonial Legislation
Principles:
Recent Amendments:
102nd Amendment (2018):
Separation of Powers:
Three categories: Legislative, Executive, Judicial.
Legislative Functions:
Bill:
Types: Government Bills, Private Members’ Bills, Original Bills, Amending Bills, etc.
Procedure: Ordinary Bills, Money Bills, Financial Bills, Constitution Amendment Bills.
Expiring Laws (Continuance) Bills: Extend Acts that would otherwise expire.
Procedural Classification:
Ordinary Bills
Financial Bills:
Joint Sittings:
Permitted under Article 108 in certain scenarios.
Effect of Dissolution:
Bills, except those in Rajya Sabha and pending, lapse after Lok Sabha dissolution.
First Reading:
Publication in Gazette:
Second Reading:
Third Reading:
Joint Sitting:
Types of Committees:
Ad hoc Committees:
For specific purposes and dissolve after completing the task.
Other Committees:
Committees on Subordinate Legislation, Government Assurances, Estimates, Public
Accounts, Public Undertakings, and Departmentally Related Standing Committees
(DRSCs).
Watchdog Committees:
These legislative functions and parliamentary committees are integral to the functioning of the
Indian Parliament, ensuring thorough scrutiny, expert analysis, and public participation in the
legislative process.