A Socially Inclusive Economic Transition For Mexico

WORKING PAPER
A socially inclusive economic

transition for Mexico: Identifying the
opportunities and benefits of enhanced
climate action
Andrés Flores Montalvo, Avelina Ruiz Vilar, Emilio García and Juan Carlos Altamirano
HIGHLIGHTS
CONTENTS
Highlights . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1
▪ Even though climate change poses a threat to development, and that
Mexico has expressed a commitment to address it, the country’s climate
Executive summary. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 policies lack ambition and clear implementation measures.
▪ Advancing
1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
a low and just carbon transition could help Mexico mobi-
2. Social and climate context in Mexico.4
lise investment, improve competitiveness, enhance development, and
3. System-wide transformation opportu-
address social vulnerability. Estimates show a potential gain on jobs
nities in Mexico. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
(763,455 jobs or 3.5 percent of the total formal jobs registered in July
4. Decarbonisation makes sense for the 2023) and additional 24.95 billion USD in Mexico’s GDP by 2050, equiva-
Mexican economy and society. . . . . . . . . 16
lent to 1.6 percent of 2022’s GDP.
5. Conclusions and next steps . . . . . . . . . 17
Appendices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 ▪ Policy levers that lie within the energy, cities, and land use systems offer
the greatest social, environmental, climate, and economic benefits.
Endnotes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
Acknowledgements. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 ▪ Inandthemethane
energy sector, more renewables, energy efficiency in buildings,
abatement, offer the greatest potential emissions abate-
About the authors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 ment as well as economic and social benefits.
Working Papers contain preliminary research, ▪ Incontribute

cities, curbing emissions from buildings, transport, and waste can
to both mitigation and socioeconomic goals.
analysis, findings, and recommendations. They
▪ Intauration
are circulated to stimulate timely discussion and
critical feedback, and to influence ongoing debate on the forest, agriculture, and land use sectors, measures such as res-
emerging issues. and sustainable management of ecosystems that support both
mitigation and adaptation are optimal, especially if they also benefit local
Suggested Citation: Flores Montalvo, A., A. communities and help conserve nature.
▪ Estimates
Ruiz, E. García and J.C. Altamirano. 2023. "A
socially inclusive economic transition for Mexico: state the level of investment needed for complying with NDC
Identifying the opportunities and benefits of commitments close to 100 billion USD, whereas associated efficiency
enhanced climate action". Working Paper.
gains and co-benefits could be set somewhere between 100 to 157 bil-
Mexico: WRI Mexico. https://doi.org/10.46830/
wriwp.22.00071
lion USD, avoiding as many as 26 thousand deaths by 2030.
WORKING PAPER | Version 1.0 | November 2023 | 1

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Around 100 million people live in cities, and these have
the largest potential for GHG emission abatement. In the
Climate change is one of the greatest threats to development. transport sector, measures to “avoid” the need to travel by
A growing ammount of evidence reveals the potential benefits motorized and polluting trips, “shift” to more sustainable
of enhanced climate action. The 2018 New Climate Economy modes and “improve” technologies to reduce emissions have
(NCE) report estimates that global benefits could reach an annual abatement potential of 86 percent of projected
26 trillion USD, compared to a business-as-usual (BAU) unabated emissions by 2050 and may save more than 75
situation, and according to the Global Commission on the thousand lives by improving air quality. Climate action
Economy and the Climate, more than 65 million green jobs in the transport sector would benefit mostly low-income
could be created by 2030, while saving close to 700 thousand, populations living in remote peri-urban areas, which tend to
lives worldwide. spend 15 percent more money and four additional hours per
day, and around 40 percent of household spending, while the
The effects of climate change on the population, productive nationwide average is less than half that figure.
sectors, and critical infrastructure, combined with the growing
evidence on the effects of the climate emergency on economic Mexico is the 11th largest country in agricultural production
growth, social inequality, and poverty, have become the main and the 7th largest global producer of livestock. However, in
drivers of climate action. As of September 2023, a total of 93 rural areas, 48.8 percent of the population lives in poverty
countries, representing 79.3 percent of global greenhouse gas –– 65.2 percent if only indigenous people are accounted, and
(GHG) emissions, have communicated net zero targets. 73 percent of indigenous women in rural areas. Achieving
net-zero deforestation could strengthen community resilience
In Mexico, there is compelling evidence that transitioning to and create new employment opportunities. Restoring and
a low carbon and climate-resilient economy can help reaching sustainably managing ecosystems can provide benefits that are
goals such as poverty alleviation, job creation, social inclusion, nearly 2.7 times greater than the costs.
energy security, and economic growth. The most promising
areas for the transition are renewable energy, construction, and The transition to a more sustainable, low-carbon and
the agricultural sector. resilient model of development needs to focus not only on
technological change, but also on closing structural social gaps.
Mexico’s potential abundant resources to generate renewable It is crucial and urgent for Mexico to integrate climate and
energy is 2,593 gigawatts (GW); this is an amount 26 times environmental objectives into its social development agenda.
the total generation capacity in 2023 and 76 times the energy Policy priorities and investments need to recognize climate
renewable capacity reported by Mexico’s Ministry of Energy change as a key factor that may worsen social inequality and
the same year. affect the country’s ability to develop in the future.
GHG mitigation measures in the construction sector are This working paper examines the question of whether Mexico
economically feasible and would have a positive impact in can achieve its sustainable development aspirations while
low-income households, where 58 percent live in energy advancing a climate agenda aligned with global commitments,
poverty. Twenty two percent of Mexico’s population still use and how. It identifies the sectors and policy interventions
firewood for cooking and more than 10 thousand deaths which offer the greatest opportunities, based on a review
are attributable to the use of solid fuels. Among them, of available literature, interviews with experts, analysis of
women and children are the most exposed. For social and available data, and existing results.
economic reasons, GHG emission-abatement measures
should be implemented anyway, independently of the climate Further analysis is needed about the specific conditions
change urgency. necessary to implement these policies and, their impact on
social development and on a multidimensional analysis on
human prosperity. This paper serves as a first step that requires
more in-depth analysis, which, along with an engagement and
communicational strategy, will be carried out in a next stage.
2 |
A socially inclusive economic transition for Mexico: Identifying the opportunities and benefits of enhanced climate action
1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Methodology

Mexico’s current federal administration has prioritized social This report relies on the review of the available relevant
development and poverty alleviation in the context of growing country-specific academic and non-academic publications,
social inequalities and economic hardship, exacerbated by the the analysis of data, new sectoral modelling, and inputs from
COVID-19 pandemic, the subsequent disruption of supply experts and stakeholders. The research approach combines a
chains and rising inflation, as well as the Ukraine war. Despite literature review, interviews and consultations, data compila-
growing evidence of the socioeconomic benefits of healthy tion, and scenario analysis using an economy-wide systems
ecosystems and low-carbon and climate resilient measures, dynamic model for Mexico. It applies the latest version of the
Mexico’s social development agenda does not yet integrate Energy Policy Simulator (EPS)1, as explained in chapter three,
climate and environmental objectives. which is designed to analyze the effects of climate mitiga-
tion policies quantitatively, accounting for interactions, and
By the end of 2022, the government announced an enhanced provides a series of co-benefits, including avoided deaths.
Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) with a new
non-conditional GHG mitigation target of 35 percent below In reviewing existing literature, the working paper attempts
BAU by 2030, up from the previous target of 22 percent below to provide an illustration of the results of analyses that have
BAU (SEMARNAT-INECC 2022). The government also responded the following two questions: first, which develop-
announced new investments to abate emissions in the energy ment challenges does Mexico have in terms of poverty and
and transport sectors and to slow deforestation and land de- social inequality that are exacerbated by the effects of climate
gradation, stating that the benefits of these investments would change? Second, where are are the main socio-economic
far outweigh the costs. opportunities for climate action?
However, these steps fall short of decarbonizing the economy The purpose of reviewing existing literature addressing these
at the pace required to tackle the global climate emergency questions is to get a broad perspective on the measures that
and keep global warming below the 1.5°C limit by the end have been identified for Mexico which would have a posi-
of the century (IPCC 2018). Mexico’s emission trajectory is tive impact on socioeconomic variables and climate change.
aligned with a pathway above 4°C of temperature rise and is The review includes both economy-wide as well as sector-
the only G20 country without a long-term net zero GHG specific analyses.
emissions target (WRI 2023). Despite structural socioeco-
Most of the publications consulted were peer reviewed and
nomic problems that are being exacerbated with climate
official documents. Estimations, nevertheless, are usually based
change impacts, Mexico has failed to integrate its develop-
on assumptions, so they should be taken with caution, since
ment objectives with an environmental and climate agenda
in most cases they are designed to guide policy making but
that offers great opportunities to close social gaps and produce
should not be taken as predictions.
higher living standards.
To collect insights from climate experts and stakeholders, nine
This working paper examines whether Mexico can advance
semi-structured interviews were conducted (see Appendix 1).
its sustainable development agenda while enhancing climate
Also, to get inout and recommendations, two meetings were
action, and what sectors and policy levers to focus on to
organized in 2023 with the members of the Advisory Com-
achieve the greatest impact. It summarizes arguments from
mittee for the New Economy for Mexico, integrated by key
existing literature and available evidence on whether more
actors in the national climate change agenda (see Appendix 2).
rapid decarbonisation would be compatible with develop-
ment aspirations. It addresses the Mexican context, the main Next steps from this work will cover the following topics: (1)
developmental challenges and existing policy priorities to sectoral and macroeconomic modelling; (2) political economy
confront the concurring social, economic, and climate crises. and distributional impacts analyses to assess the socioeco-
It explores specific shifts in the energy, cities, and land use nomic effects of climate and economic policy measures across
systems that would potentially achieve the greatest impact; various groups of the population; (3) analysis of potential
it also proposes some key policy levers that would be needed, feasibility and enabling implementation conditions; and (4)
and outlines next steps. an enhanced engagement with experts and relevant stake-
holders, including the advisory committee mentioned above
(see Figure 1).
WORKING PAPER | November 2023 | 3

Figure 1 | Scenario analysis using the Energy Policy Simulator
CLIMATE
Limit global warming to 1.5
degrees & support communities
in adapting to climate change.

Which development challenges Where are are the main
does Mexico have in terms of socioeconomic opportunities
poverty and social inequality - Literature review for climate action?
that are exacerbated by the - Interviews and consultations
effects of climate change? - Data compilation
- Scenario analysis using
Economy-wide systems dynamic
model for Mexico
PEOPLE NATURE
People are living in an equitable Ecosystem health is
society where they can meet protected & restored.
their essential needs.
Source: WRI
2. SOCIAL AND CLIMATE In Mexico, poverty and social inequality are major challenges.
36.3 percent of Mexico’s population is poor and in rural areas
CONTEXT IN MEXICO a greater percentage (48.8 percent) of the population lives in
poverty, increasing to 65.2 percent if only indigenous people
This chapter presents an overview of the Mexican social and
are accounted, and to 73.1 percent of indigenous women living
climate context, focusing on its main challenges, priorities, and
in rural areas (CONEVAL 2023). Mexico is one of the most
aspirations. The context provided is general, mainly because it
unequal countries in the world where, over the 21st century,
will frame the analysis and discussions that follow.
the richest ten percent of the population income share has
been at least 50 percent, whereas the bottom 50 percent has
2.1 Socioeconomic outlook not increased its share from ten percent (Chancel et al. 2023).
During the 2014-2019 period, Latin America and the Carib-
Even though the unemployment rate is relatively low (less
bean experienced the slowest economic growth recorded in
than three percent), Mexico is among the top ten countries
decades, with an annual GDP growth rate of 0.3 percent
in the world with the highest percentage of informal employ-
(CEPAL 2021b). The COVID-19 crisis only worsened the
ment, leaving a broad share of the population in a vulnerable
situation, causing the region’s economy to shrink by 7.6
situation; around 30.6 million people (INEGI 2022). 50 per-
percent which, coupled with an unemployment rate of 10.3
cent of the population does not have access to social security,
percent, exacerbated poverty and inequality (CEPAL 2022).
39 percent lack access to nutritious and good quality food, and
In the global slowdown that followed the pandemic, Mexico’s 28 percent cannot access medical services (CONEVAL 2023).
economy contracted 8.5 percent in 2020 (INEGI 2021a),
Throughout Latin America, the recession erased more than a
exacerbating vulnerabilities stemming from a sluggish
decade of progress in women's participation in the labor force
economic growth, social inequalities, and climate and envi-
(CEPAL 2021a). In the case of Mexico, women make up
ronmental crises. In 2021 the economy recovered slighly, with
most of the population but only 40 percent of the workforce.
a GDP growth of 5 percent (BANXICO 2022), and a 3.1
Women’s informality rate (55.5 percent) is higher than men’s
percent growth in 2022 when GDP values recovered to pre-
pandemic levels (INEGI 2023a).
4 |
(INEGI 2020), and their average pay is lower, 86 pesos for most of the cultivated areas suffer (INECC 2022) and will
every 100 that a man earns, on top of spending 2.5 times more increase pressure on revenues of a large portion of Mexico’s
hours in home duties per week (IMCO 2022). population which relies on climate-dependent agriculture
(i.e., 13 percent of Mexico’s employed population). These
The federal government has prioritized poverty alleviation, individuals will have to find different ways of earning a living,
boosting investments and regional development, particularly in many cases outside their places of origin. In fact, weather-
in the traditionally poor southern regions. Due in large part to related disasters uprooted more than 100 thousand people in
a wage policy aimed at increasing the real purchasing power Mexico during 2020 and 11 thousand in 2022 alone (IDMC
of workers and the formalization of employment (Quintana 2023). It is estimated that, between 2020 and 2050 in Mexico
2023), the most recent official data reveals that between 2018 and Central America, the number of internal climate migrants
and 2022, 5.1 million people moved out of the poverty line will double, reaching up to 3.9 million (World Bank 2018).
(CONEVAL 2023).
Climate change is one of the

2.2 Climate change impacts greatest risks to development,
and vulnerability
threatening the progress
Over the previous two decades, Mexico ranked ninth among
the countries suffering the greatest economic losses due to made over the past 50 years
disasters (UNDRR and CRED 2018). Between 1970 and
2019, there have been 202 disasters related to weather, climate, in global health and poverty
and water extremes, which led to over 6,500 deaths and 51.2
billion USD in losses (WMO 2021) and between 2000 and
reduction (IPCC 2022, WHO
2018, 83 percent of all municipalities have had a disaster
declaration for floods, extreme rains, cyclones, and droughts.
2021). It is crucial and urgent
Climate change will likely increase the frequency and severity for Mexico to integrate climate
of such events (INECC 2022).
and environmental objectives
During 2021 and 2022, Mexico suffered one of the worst
droughts in decades, and it is estimated that 31 of Mexico’s into its social development
32 states will suffer further from water stress over the next
ten years (Moody 's 2021). If this trend continues, it will limit agenda. Policy priorities and
the country’s capacity to generate hydroelectricity and achieve
its clean power generation targets (Moody's 2021). In terms
investments need to recognise
of domestic agricultural production, lack of climate action climate change as a key
could reduce the yield of major crops by up to 20 percent
over the next two decades, and by 80 percent towards the factor that may worsen social
end of the century (SEMARNAT-INECC 2018). Loss of
cropland can lead to food insecurity and malnourishment, inequalities and affect the
displacement, and permanent migration, especially for rural
families. The federal government has projected that by the
country’s ability to grow in the
end of the century climate change inaction would translate
to accumulated costs equivalent to somewhere between 50
future.
percent and twice the national GDP of Mexico from 2010
(SEMARNAT-INECC 2018).
Climate change impacts and environmental degradation have

added to socioeconomic stress, particularly of vulnerable social
groups including women, children, and indigenous peoples
(CONEVAL 2023). Changing in precipitation regimes and
increased temperatures will exacerbate the water stress which

2.3 The development case for This stems from Mexico’s recent economic troubles as well
as from a reduction on the use of oil and coal, more efficient
decarbonisation power generation, more renewable energy, and much more
There is a growing body of evidence about the benefits of reliance on natural gas (SENER 2019). Out of total GHG
promoting a more resilient and decarbonised economy. The emissions, 64 percent are related to energy use and generation,
2018 New Climate Economy (NCE) report estimates that and nearly 20 percent to agriculture, forestry, and land uses2.
global benefits could reach 26 trillion USD by 2030, compared
Mexico has recognized the need for action, and showed that it
to BAU (NCE 2018). To show a contrast, compared to BAU,
can lead change. In 2012, with the publication of the General
Brazil’s plans for a “new climate economy” are expected to add
Climate Change Law (LGCC for its acronym in Spanish),
535 billion USD to its GDP, with 3.7 billion USD in addi-
Mexico became the second country to pass comprehensive
tional agricultural production and 2 million additional new
climate change legislation. At the time, the LGCC positioned
jobs by 2030, (Romeiro et al. 2020).
Mexico as a leader in terms of formal legal and institutional
As of September 2023, a total of 93 countries, representing arrangements to address climate change.
79.3 percent of global GHG emissions, have communicated
In 2020 Mexico went on to submit an enhanced NDC. Its
net zero targets (WRI 2023). More than one thousand cities
mitigation target was deemed regressive by a federal court, and
globally have also established some sort of net zero emissions
therefore contrary to the Paris Agreement. For that reason it
goal, and over two thousand companies (21 of them Mexican)
was overturned. In 2022, at the 27th Conference of the Parties
have announced science-based emission reduction targets
(COP27), Mexico submitted a new enhanced NDC, empha-
(SBT). These are all signs of an economic and technological
sising adaptation to climate change as a national priority
transformation that will have significant impacts on world-
with additional lines of work in the areas of water crisis and
wide value chains, including in countries heavily reliant on
food security, as well as specific lines of action that were not
manufacturing such as Mexico.
contemplated in the mitigation component.
A growing body of research points out the fact that green
It terms of mitigation, the country deepened its pledged
investments generally create more and higher quality jobs.
emission cuts from 22 to 35 percent below BAU by 2030,
One study estimates that, globally, green investments will
with additional investments that would add up to 48 billion
generate between 1.1 and 3.7 times more jobs per 1 million
USD between 2022 and 2030. The statement explains that the
USD than unsustainable investments ( Jaeger et al. 2021). The
benefits of this substantial investment will outweigh the costs,
Global Commission on the Economy and Climate found that
and that they will allow Mexico to become part of the new
more than 65 million green net jobs could be created by 2030,
low-carbon economy, leading to the transformation of global
while saving close to 700 thousand lives worldwide (NCE
energy, food, and agricultural systems required in a net-zero
2018). The International Labor Organization and the Inter-
emissions world. It declared as well that this transforma-
American Development Bank determined that the transition
tion will allow the Mexican economy to become much more
to a net zero emissions economy will represent the creation
competitive (Gobierno de Mexico 2022).
of 15 million net jobs in Latin America and the Caribbean
by 2030, in sectors such as sustainable agriculture, forestry, Mexico is currently one of 27 parties to the United Nations
renewable energy, manufacturing, and construction (OIT Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) to
and IBD 2020). have a long-term Strategy (LTS) in place, which sets a GHG
abatement target of 50 percent below 2000 levels by mid-
It is estimated that, if no action is taken, climate change will
century (CAT 2023).
push up to 130 million people into poverty over the next ten
years, and could cause over 200 million people to migrate At the same time, despite substantive progress, particularly
internally by 2050 (Nishio 2021). Mexico has opportunities to in terms of building a comprehensive institutional and legal
leverage decarbonisation to achieve social development goals framework, Mexico is still falling short when implementing
and avoid the replication of structural inequalities. its commitments. Even with recent announcements and new
climate policies, Mexico is currently not on track to meet its
2.4 Mexico’s climate policy medium- and long-term climate goals, meaning its current
trajectory would not enable it to cut emissions even 22 percent
Mexico contributes with 1.3 percent of global GHG emis-
below BAU, let alone 35 percent below BAU by 2030 (CAT
sions and is currently the 14th largest emitter globally (WRI
2023). In regards to long-term commitments, even with its
2022). Over the last nine years, the annual GHG emissions
recently enhanced NDC, Mexico is currently the only G20
growth rate has deaccelerated, to 0.3 percent (INECC 2021b).
country without a mid-century net-zero target.
6 |
The contrast between current plans and what is at least techni- that are technically and economically viable (Flores Montalvo
cally possible is stark. An alternative NDC, presented by a et al. 2019). Some argue that Mexico could even reach the
civil society organisation at COP27, argues that Mexico could 35 percent target (ICM 2022), but only if the country acts
achieve, with available technologies and feasible policies, up up quickly and decisively, through a combined effort of all
to a 47 percent reduction in GHG emissions by 2030 below relevant economic activities and actors. The main climate
BAU. These efforts would require external financial support, change policies needed are spread among agriculture, waste,
reaching 256 billion USD between 2022 and 2030 (ICM fossil fuel production, and forests. To curb energy demand and
2022), which is roughly equivalent to ten percent of the total emissions, actions in cities and transport are likely the most
annual GDP in 2022. powerful mitigation tools (Elizondo et al. 2017).
Mexico’s current decarbonisation trajectory differs from the Recent WRI’s modelling analysis with the EPS-Mexico (EPS
goals enshrined in its commitments and laws. In addition to 2022) shows that a combination of 26 policy levers across dif-
aligning mitigation efforts with an emissions trajectory that ferent sectors would make it possible to abate emissions to an
achieves a 40 percent reduction in the country's GHG emis- annual 220 million metric ton of CO2eq in 2050 ––about one
sions by 2030, climate objectives and policies should consider third of current annual emissions (see Figure 2). Additionally,
the great potential they have to reduce the country's large this will bring gains in jobs (763,455 jobs or 3.5 percent of the
socioeconomic gaps of poverty and social equity. total formal jobs registered in July 2023) and additional 24.95
USD billion of Mexico’s GDP by 2050, equivalent to 1.6
percent of 2022’s GDP (World Bank 2023).
3. SYSTEM-WIDE Other analyses are roughly consistent with these findings.
TRANSFORMATION A study looking at decarbonisation pathways aligned with
OPPORTUNITIES IN MEXICO a 1.5 and 2oC limit global warming, finds that interventions
should focus on shifting from fossil fuel electricity to renew-
Despite slow implementation of commitments so far, it may ables as the main energy source before 2040. The same study
still be possible to reach Mexico’s initial 22 percent below the recommends adopting policies and building infrastructure
BAU target, through a combination of policies and measures that favors public transport modes and vehicle electrification,
Figure 2 | Emissions trajectories by sector in the energy policy simulator (EPS) mitigation scenario
800
700
600
million metric tons/year
500
400
300
200
100
-100
2020 2022 2024 2026 2028 2030 2032 2034 2036 2038 2040 2042 2044 2046 2048 2050
District Heat & Hydrogen Water & waste Agriculture Land use
Electricity Industry Buildings Transportation
Source: WRI 2022

and improving land use, agriculture, and forest management To decarbonise the energy sector, Mexico would need abun-
practices to reduce emissions and increase carbon absorption dant financial and technical resources. These would be needed
(Buira et al. 2021). Another analysis published by the INECC to design and implement an energy storage policy, increased
highlights transport, land use, and construction as the sectors penetration of utility-scale renewable generation plants and
offering the most cost-effective opportunities for achieving distributed generation, and to increase the flexibility of the
the mitigation target of Mexico’s 2015 NDC (INECC 2021a). electrical system. Large investments would also be needed to
modernize the transmission and distribution networks, oper-
In summary, the most cost-effective policies from our rated by the state-owned company, the Comision Federal de
mo-delling and the literature can be grouped into three major Electricidad (CFE).
systems: 1) energy; 2) cities, and 3) land use (including forests
and agriculture). These three systems have been identified In addition, policies at the national and subnational levels
as the primary drivers of rising GHG emissions and the need to ensure that all households have secure access to elec-
degradation of nature. Additionally, our model analysis finds tricity and meet their energy demands. Although almost 99
that pursuing these policies will not clash with Mexico’s percent of homes in Mexico have access to electricity (World
priority of fighting poverty and fostering development. Bank Data 2021), 36.7 percent of Mexican households are
Indeed, moving these sectors in a more sustainable energy deprived or lack at least one of the services or eco-
direction is key for achieving a socially inclusive economic nomic goods that are considered basic to satisfy fundamental
transition in Mexico. human needs (Sánchez and Graizbord 2016)3. Women are the
ones who suffer the most from this type of poverty, as they
3.1 Clean, affordable and reliable dedicate 2.5 more times to unpaid work than men, usually in
activities within the household.
energy
The energy transition in the electricity system needs to focus
Energy systems contribute roughly to 64 percent of GHG
not only on technological change, but also on closing social
emissions in Mexico (INECC 2021b), below their 76 percent
gaps by increasing access to energy goods and services for
share of global emissions (WRI 2022). Fossil fuels still make
households that are lagging, as well as for reducing poverty
up 87 percent of Mexico’s energy mix, above the G20 average
and generating jobs. The following sections describe some of
of 80 percent. Solar, wind, geothermal, and biomass account
the challenges and opportunities in renewable energies, energy
for 4.7 percent of Mexico’s energy supply. Their share in the
efficiency, and the oil and gas industry.
total energy mix rose by about 35.3 percent between 2015 and
2019 (Climate Transparency 2021). In 2019, the power sector
produced 171 MtCO2eq (million tonnes of carbon dioxide Renewables
equivalent), which roughly represents 23 percent of total According to the National Atlas of Zones with High Potential
national emissions (INECC 2021b). for Clean Energy (SENER 2016), Mexico has a generation
potential of 2,593 GW, which is 26 times the 2023 generation
Cross-model and policy scenario analyses have shown that capacity (SENER 2023) and 76 times the energy renewable
some energy decarbonisation pathways would rely more on capacity reported by Mexico’s Ministry of Energy the same
increased electrification and on the use of natural gas, while year. According to the Mexico 2050 Calculator, it would
others would be more dependent on efficiency improvement be technically feasible to achieve 100 percent of electricity
and increased use of biofuels, among other measures. How- coming from renewable sources by 2050, although the optimal
ever, in all cases the use of clean energy sources and a reduced mix of clean energy sources would change among scenarios
role for oil is required if the aim is to reduce emissions at (Elizondo et al. 2017).
least in half by mid-century (Veysey et al. 2016). Key policy
recommendations include a substantial ramp-up in renew- A decarbonised electric system in Mexico by 2050 is thus
able energies, energy efficiency, and further legal enforcement feasible, with renewables emerging as the cost-optimal
(Elizondo et al. 2017). technologies to achieve it (Solano-Rodríguez et al. 2018).
Electricity decarbonisation will be crucial to achieve eco-
Far deeper and quicker cuts may be possible than what is nomy-wide emission reduction targets, since several sectors
currently set in policies and commitments. One decarboni- will rely on access to clean power to meet their own goals
sation scenario analysis for the energy sector reveals that (Buira et al. 2021).
GHG emissions could be reduced by as much as 79 percent
below BAU by 2035 through a set of 36 mitigation measures Reaching Mexico's 2015 NDC target would require cutting
(Grande-Acosta and Islas-Samperio 2017). the electricity sector’s emissions 63 million tons below the
baseline (equivalent to nearly ten percent of Mexico's total
GHG emissions today). The NDC update, targeting a 35
8 |
percent reduction of emissions below BAU by 2030, would the 2020-2030 period, under the Mexico 2015 NDC scenario
require raising electricity capacity from photovoltaic (PV), (GGGI 2020). Economic and labor policies need also seek to
wind and geothermal sources, and promoting distributed increase the participation of women. In Mexico, only three out
renewable generation, to reach a total of 40 GW of clean of ten professionals of science, technology, engineering and
electricity capacity by 2030 (Gobierno de Mexico 2022), mathematics (which yield a better payment than other fields)
which would represent a growth of 15 percent of the 34 are women (IMCO 2022a), and women only held a quarter
GW of current installed generation capacity with renew- of total jobs in the oil state industry (Petróleos Mexicanos,
ables (INECC 2021a). PEMEX) in 2019 and 17 percent in the electric sector (Mexico
Evalúa 2021). Gender inequalities are underlying conditions
The Global Green Growth Institute (GGGI) developed an that challenge a just transition in Mexico (see Figure 4).
NDC scenario where total installed capacity reaches 156 GW
by 2030, with 90 GW of clean energy and retirements of 11 Improved transmission planning, coupled with the develop-
GW of conventional fossil fuel-based (GGGI 2020). Under ment of renewables, could deliver increased energy accessibility,
this scenario, the addition of renewables’ installed capacity stimulating economic development, and decreasing electricity
by 2030 will result in the creation of about 1.5 million total costs. Southern Mexico could emerge as a key hub for clean
job-years (GGGI 2020). The assessment estimates that utility- energy, enabling increased economic activity and potentially
scale solar photovoltaic, solar PV distributed generation, and becoming an energy exporter to other parts of the country and
onshore wind generate more jobs per GWh than a combined to Central America (DOE US 2022).
cycle technology, with onshore wind technology and solar PV
distributed generation producing the highest number of jobs The energy transition will also improve health conditions and
per unit of electricity output (see Figure 3) (GGGI 2020). will help communities currently exposed to pollution from
power facilities, leaks and spills of liquid and airborne pollu-
Mexico has a skilled workforce and the industrial capacity tants, and transport emissions. According to some estimates,
to absorb the substantial investments that would be needed fully implementing the 2015 NDC target could boost employ-
for an energy transition (Buira et al. 2021). Expanding ment in the electricity sector by 38 percent, and the benefits
solar PV and onshore wind capacity can increase at least 46 (avoiding social costs) from reducing PM2.5-related mortality
percent in direct high skill jobs and qualification levels for could reach 2.7 billion USD (Gioutsos and Ochs 2019).
Figure 3 | Landscape on green jobs potential in Mexico's energy sector
Mexico's abundant resource potential Large-scale solar PV, distributed solar PV generation
to generate renewable energy is 2,593 GW;an amount and onshore wind energy generate more jobs
26 times the total generation capacity in 2023 per GWh than more current combined
and 76 times the renewable energy cycle technologies
capacity reported by Mexico’s Ministry of Energy
1.2
1.0
Jobs - years/GWh
0.8
1.2 1.2
0.6
0.4
0.5 0.6
0.2
0.2
Combined cycle Onshore wind Solar PV distributed Utility - scale
generation solar PV
Fossil fuels represent 87 percent

of Mexico's energy mix,
above the G20 average of 80 percent.
Source: WRI with data from SENER (2023) and GGGI (2020)

Figure 4 | Women's unequal participation in Mexico's workforce
Mexicois amongthe ten highest ranking countries

in the worldwith the highest percentageof informal
employment. Inequality of laboral opportunities
Equivalent to
30.6 million
56.6 people in a vulnerable situation
percent
employed
in the informal
economy The informality rate of women Women constitute
is higher than that of men 55.5 percent 40 percent of labor's workforce
but their salary is lower:
Only three out of ten science $86 pesos
technology, engineering, and for every $100
mathematics professionals that a man makes
are women
Only a quarter
of total jobs in
the oil industry in 2019
Source: WRI with data from INEGI 2020, IMCO 2022 and Mexico Evalúa 2021.
Energy Efficiency Overall, demand-side measures are an integral part of any

mitigation pathway for Mexico (Veysey et al. 2016). The adop-
Globally, energy efficiency remains one of the most cost-
tion of energy efficiency targets in the construction, transport,
effective ways to reduce emissions (CUT 2019, IPCC 2021),
and industrial sectors provides an opportunity for enhancing
so it should be considered before other alternatives. Energy
Mexico’s NDC, with several co-benefits such as job creation.
efficiency is considered “the first fuel to achieve clean energy
Implementing industrial energy efficiency measures, aligned
transition in a secure manner” (IEA 2021).
with the NDC target of 22 percent abatement of emissions
The National Commission for the Efficient Use of Energy below BAU by 2030, could create nine thousand direct jobs in
(CONUUE) has led the way, with the publication of several industries and services that provide efficient technologies and
Official Mexican Norms (NOMs) and voluntary standards for solutions (Gioutsos and Ochs 2019).
energy efficiency. It has also built capacities among different
The residential sector, which comprises almost 25 percent of
economic sectors, and has fostered incentives to increase the
national electricity consumption, has a challenge for addres-
access and penetration of energy efficiency programs, tech-
sing its emissions (SENER 2021). GHG mitigation measures
nologies, and standards.
for the residential sector included in Mexico’s 2015 NDC
At the national level, the Transition Strategy to Promote the are economically feasible and would lower costs and save
Use of Cleaner Technologies and Fuels, the guiding instru- money, meaning that they should be implemented regardless
ment for clean energy and energy efficiency policies based on of climate change. They would also have the greatest positive
the Energy Transition Law, sets a goal of 1.9 percent annual impact in low-income households (INECC 2021a).
reduction of final consumption for the period 2016-2030 and
Despite its many advantages, energy efficiency policies are
a 3.7 percent per year between 2031 and 2050. This may seem
not highly successful. Political, technical, legal, and financial
ambitious but it is still below the four percent annual reduc-
barriers are largely to blame. Successful implementation of
tion proposed by the International Energy Agency (IEA) on
large-scale energy efficiency programs requires long-term
its net zero pathway by 2050 (IEA 2021).
commitment, but it is often difficult for politicians to plan
for the long term. In addition, financing mechanisms need to
10 |
be tailored to local markets and must be supported by appro- lung diseases, cause asthma attacks, increase rates of pre-term
priate policies, regulations, and incentives to phase out and birth, cardiovascular morbidity and mortality, and heighten
eliminate energy-intensive practices and technologies. stroke risk (Global Clean Air 2023).
Policies of increasing Mexico’s crude oil production, the lack

Methane emissions from oil and gas
of infrastructure to process gas, and the absence of incentives
Methane emissions represent roughly 33 percent of total and institutional capacity to ensure and monitor compliance
GHG emissions in Mexico. They grew 48 percent in the with their regulatory programs in the sector, are not allowing
1990-2019 period, with an average annual growth rate of 1.8 the country to advance in its climate goals.
percent (INECC 2021b). According to one recent study that
relies on satellite data, about 4.7 percent of gas produced in Decarbonisation pathways in key sectors of Mexico’s energy
Mexico is leaked into the atmosphere – a quite high figure system are technically feasible. However, these pathways face
by global standards (EDF 2021). Official government data political and social challenges. Firstly, politically, renewables
(INECC 2021b) report that the oil and gas sector contributes and electrification actions lack support and would need to
with only ten percent of total methane emissions, although show that these actions do not only benefit energy producers
this is widely seen as an underestimate, particularly regarding but the economy in general through the creation of green jobs
emissions from fossil fuels processing. Based on satellite and indirect economic positive impacts trough the value chain.
observations, other studies calculate that emissions average Secondly, lack of political will and support results in lack of
nearly 20 percent more than those officially reported in resources devoted to obtaining credible data that could pro-
national inventories (Lu et al. 2021). The largest discrepancy vide a certain guide on the reduction impacts from promoting
is in the oil and gas sector, with onshore facilities emitting low-cost abatement technologies such as those from methane.
ten times more than government reports say (Zavala- Thirdly, the reorganisation of the energy sector and its labor
Araiza et al. 2021). force needs to be carefully planned to ensure a just transition.
Those that may be left out in the process of a transition to a
Mexico signed the Global Methane Pledge at COP26, low-carbon future must be able to reap the benefits from it in
in Glasgow, committing to a 30 percent abatement of the terms of high-quality jobs and improved living conditions.
levels registered in 2020 for methane emissions by 2030.
Both the 2015 NDC and the enhanced NDC submitted at 3.2 Sustainable cities
COP27 set a 14 percent GHG mitigation goal for the oil
and gas sector by 2030 as compared to the BAU scenario. Worldwide, cities contribute with nearly 75 percent of carbon
It includes, prominently, pledges to reduce gas venting and emissions. Mexico is among the ten countries with the lar-
fugitive methane emissions (SEMARNAT 2020, Gobierno gest urban population in the world, with around 100 million
de Mexico 2022). In 2022, at the Major Economies Forum, people living in cities with more than 2,500 inhabitants. In
Mexico announced that methane emissions from PEMEX 1950, 43 percent of the population lived in cities; in 1990
would be reduced by 98 percent by 2030, but did not provide the percentage reached 71, and by 2020 it was 79 percent4
any specifics about how that would be achieved, except for the (INEGI 2020a).
fact that two billion USD would be invested in this measure
alone (SRE 2022). Cities can and must play a crucial role in strengthening and
meeting Mexico’s climate commitments. The largest potential
The civil society NDC presented at COP27 estimates that for GHG emission abatement among Mexican cities lies in
available technologies and policies could abate emissions from construction, transport and waste. The Coalition for Urban
the oil and gas sector by a little more than 50 percent by 2030, Transitions (CUT 2019) estimates that by adopting a bundle
three times the established goal in the NDC for this sector. of low-carbon measures in the construction, transport and
According to this proposal, reducing natural gas venting and waste sectors, Mexican cities could reduce their GHG emis-
flaring is the measure with the greatest abatement potential sions by 34 percent (98 MtCO2eq) by 2030 and by 87 percent
(11.9 MtCO2eq annually by 2030), followed by co-generation (284 MtCO2eq) by 2050, relative to a baseline scenario.
(5.3 MtCO2eq), and finally the curbing of fugitive methane Almost one-fifth (19 percent) of this abatement potential
emissions (4.5 MtCO2eq) (ICM 2022). stands in Mexico City alone; 28 percent in cities with between
one to five million residents, such as Monterrey, Guadalajara
Preventing methane leaks could also save money. One study and Puebla, and more than half in cities with less than one
estimates that 1.3 million tons or 200 million USD worth of million residents. Rapid urbanization without enough plan-
methane is wasted in Mexico every year (EDF 2021). Curb- ning exacerbates environmental degradation and reduces the
ing methane emissions could also bring health co-benefits, quality of life for urban dwellers (see Figure 5).
because it would reduce exposure to ozone, black carbon, and
criteria pollutant emissions, which damage airways, aggravate

Figure 5 | Climate opportunities in Mexican cities
Mexicoranks amongthe ten countries in the world

with the highest percentageof urban population
Almost a fifth of GHG emissions
168 Mexican cities reduction potential in Mexico City.
In would face a dangerous
ofandcitiesfive with

heat wave for over a month between one
million inhabitants

Close toone million people

living in cities.
ofonecitiesmillionwithinhabitants
less than
People that live in urban areas

are vulnerable to climate change
and poor air quality producedby
the burning of fossil fuels.
Source: WRI with data from Semarnat 2022, Carbonplan 2023 and Badillo 2023.
People living in urban areas are also highly vulnerable to The effectiveness of these strategies also depends on imple-
climate change and bad air quality, mainly produced by fuel menting cooperation and coordination mechanisms among
combustion of transport. In the last 15 years, the frequency national and subnational governments, the private sector, and
of heat waves in cities has increased (Semarnat 2022) and it civil society, as well as on developing an adequate capacity to
is estimated that in 2030, one million people living in 168 implement mitigation strategies (IPCC 2021).
Mexican cities would face highly dangerous heatwaves for
more than a month (Carbonplan 2023). Air pollution causes Buildings
around 48 thousand deaths per year. In Mexico City alone,
In Mexico, buildings consume nearly 18 percent of total
between January and August in 2023, just around 23 percent
power generated (SEMARNAT 2020a). They are also in the
of the days registered good air quality (Badillo 2023).
center of the climate agenda because of their close links with
There is a growing momentum among subnational enti- public health, air quality, poverty, and living conditions for the
ties, including both state and municipal governments, to get most vulnerable groups in Mexico (INECC 2021a). In deve-
ambitious and support climate action. State governments, loping countries, buildings have a lifespan of over 50 years, so
particularly, are showing their willingness to adopt climate any measure to improve them provides lasting benefits.
change mitigation and adaptation goals and programs. The
More than a third of households in Mexico live in energy po-
empowerment of states and municipalities, their growing
verty (Sánchez and Graizbord 2016), 58 percent of households
capacity to attract resources independently, and to establish
with incomes below the poverty line and 79.1 percent of the
their own financing schemes for mitigation and adaptation
indigenous ones live in housing deficit (CONEVAL 2019).
actions, could help them mobilize public and private invest-
28 million people (22 percent of the population) still use
ment, and to define decarbonisation routes according to
firewood for cooking (INSP 2021), which implies a significant
local circumstances.
health risk especially for women and children who spend more
One of the steepest barriers to more substantive progress time indoors and imposes significant pressure on forests.
includes the subnational governments’ need to increase capaci-
Developing energy efficiency measures alone provide more
ties to integrate climate policies with efforts to improve air
than half the abatement potential in cities globally (CUT
quality, promote sustainable mobility, and provide better access
2019). In addition to being cost-effective, decarbonisation
to green and healthy urban and peri-urban environments.
scenarios assume that energy efficiency can help build-
12 |
ings approach net zero GHG emissions by mid-century a local responsibility, and municipal governments have a
(IPCC 2021). Improving residential lighting alone could constant turnover of officials and legal limitations to access
cut emissions by 1.8 MtCO2eq annually, and in the com- funding, as mentioned before.
mercial and service sectors it could add an additional 0.3
MtCO2eq (ICM 2022). Transport
At the city level, construction codes and standards are the The transport sector is the second largest source of GHG
most common tool for promoting energy efficiency, but other emissions in Mexico. It represents 18 percent of total emis-
complementary options include efficiency-improvement sions and consumes 46 percent of final energy. GHG
targets, investments in retrofitting public buildings, incentives emissions from transport have grown faster than in any other
and finance, and performance information and certifica- sector in absolute terms, climbing at an annual rate of 1.7
tion (Becqué et al. 2016). According to the IEA, the global percent per year from 1990 to 2019 (INECC 2021b). Under
implementation of energy efficiency measures in the construc- the BAU scenario, they are projected to double by 2050 (ICM
tion sector could represent almost 5.8 billion tons of emissions and CT 2019). Road vehicles are responsible for more than
savings by 2050, and a reduction of GHG emissions by 83 90 percent of the energy consumption of the transport sector
percent below the BAU scenario (WRI 2016). in Mexico (SEMARNAT-INECC 2018), with an increase
of nearly 3.4 times in the total vehicle fleet between 2000 and
Improving energy efficiency can also help reduce air and water 2021 (from 15.62 to 53.12 million) (INEGI 2023).
pollution, and improve public health. In cities, construction
retrofitting has a great job-creation potential, offering huge Emissions, pollution and traffic congestion are some of the
opportunities for the sector, which employs a large share of main effects of urban models oriented to private car owner-
low-skilled workers (CUT 2021). ship and bad quality public transport. As urban mobility is
essential for urban dynamics, transforming urban transport
Major obstacles to decarbonise construction include insuffi- has the potential to improve living conditions for all citizens
cient knowledge and awareness from subnational governments (see Figure 6).
on incentives and benefits to promote energy efficiency
measures, and a lack of institutional capacity to promote Sectoral modeling carried out by WRI Mexico, using the
governance structures with the private sector to scale these EPS tool, refers to a potential annual abatement potential of
measures, among others (IPCC 2021). Policies are usually 30 percent by 2030, and 86 percent to reach 44 MtCO2eq by
Figure 6 | Why is it necessary to decarbonise the transport sector
Fugitive emissions & oil and gas

Waste Changing to more sustainable
Electricity and

heat production modes and “improving”
Industry technologies to reduce emissions
have a potential for annual
The transport sector is the second reduction of 86 percent by 2050.

AFOLU
source of emissions of GHG in Mexico
Other energy sectors
Air pollution
causes almost48 thousand deaths
a year in Mexico City alone.
The transport sector

consumes
of total emissions
of final energy
Source: WRI with data from INEGI, 2020 and IMCO, 2022.

2050 instead of 317 MtCO2eq within the BAU scenario, if needs an integrated and sustainable urban mobility system
it implements a comprehensive decarbonisation strategy in interconnected with an urban development planning through
the transport sector (ICM and CT 2019). The strategy would coordinated and efficient governance mechanisms that can
evolve around the “Avoid” (the need to travel by motorized ensure access to finance and enable environments to advance
and polluting trips), “Shift” (to more sustainable modes of towards equitable, connected, and competitive cities.
travel), and “Improve” (technologies to reduce emissions in
private, public and freight transportation) paths (Dalkmann Urban waste
and Brannigan 2007). Actions will be needed in all three areas,
Cities can mitigate GHG emissions and provide social and
from long-term land use planning and zoning regulations that
economic co-benefits by improving waste management,
promote connected streets, mixed uses, and compact develop-
both for municipal solid waste (MSW) and wastewater.
ment (avoid), to inducing and implementing public transport
In 2019, emissions from municipal waste amounted to 54
and cycling (shift), to fueling vehicles cleanly and efficiently
MtCO₂e, equivalent to 7.37 percent of Mexico’s emis-
(improve) to decarbonise the sector.
sions (INECC 2021).
These measures reduce the size of the vehicle fleet by eight
Almost 70 percent of countries in the world, including Mexico,
percent in 2030 and 40 percent in 2050. Under it, the penetra-
have created national institutions responsible for developing
tion of electric and hybrid vehicles would climb to 23 and 91
policies and supervising regulation of the waste sector, but
percent respectively for those same years. Vehicle efficiency
implementation differs by country and even by region. In that
would improve between 10 and 15 percent for off-road
sense, waste management operations are commonly handled
transport (vehicles that drive off paved roads or streets, such
locally, where capacities are often limited (Flores Montalvo and
as tractors, cranes, bulldozers, etc.), and more than double for
Loutfi Olivares 2020).
on-road vehicles. According to this analysis, by 2050 these
measures would lower transportation energy demand by 66 Mexico’s 2015 NDC included a specific measure to promote
percent and GHG emissions by 80 percent below BAU, which methane recovery and use in municipal landfills and water
would be consistent with a 2°C of global warming, although treatment plants. Under the unconditional target, this was
not enough to get to a 1.5°C trajectory (ICM and CT 2019). expected to cut methane emissions by 28.6 percent below
BAU by 2030 (SEMARNAT 2020). The 2022 updated NDC
It is estimated that, between 2020 and 2050, actions in the
includes a section on waste, enumerating measures that will be
transport sector of Mexican cities could contribute with
promoted, such as integral management of MSW, and better
around 29 percent of the emissions cuts needed nationwide
practices in treating municipal and industrial wastewater, reuse,
to be consistent with the scenario below 2°C (CUT 2021). A
recycling, composting, and bio-digestion (Gobierno de Mexico
scenario analysis that assessed the combined effects and costs
2022). It lacks specifics about implementation plans but does
of 21 measures, including structural changes in freight and
mention a National Circular Economy Strategy, which should
passenger mobility, new motor technologies, biofuels, price
be forthcoming. The civil society NDC, also present at COP27,
signals, transportation practices and regulations, and urban
proposed a mitigation target of 39.1 percent by 2030 for this
planning strategies, concluded that these measures could col-
sector, which could be achievable through the recovery and use
lectively cut emissions by 56 percent in 2035 compared with
of biogas from wastewater and MSW treatment plants, plastics
the baseline scenario (Islas-Samperio et al. 2019).
recycling, and waste-to-energy projects (ICM 2022).
The lack of access to transport is a leading cause of urban
This sector’s mitigation potential in Mexico has hardly been
inequality. It means that, for many, opportunities for employ-
studied, and a diverse array of models analyzing potential
ment, education, entertainment, and health services are out of
mitigation pathways pay scant attention to it, focusing
reach. In Mexico City, less than 19 percent of the population
instead on transport, energy or land use, where the largest
has nearby access to the mass transit system (Metro, BRT,
portion of emissions lies. The co-benefits of improved waste
suburban, and/or light rail), and almost 47 percent do not have
management and increased circular material flows include new
a vehicle. The mostly low-income population living in remote
business opportunities, jobs, and improvements on resource
peri-urban areas, tends to spend 15 percent more money
efficiency. Expanding wastewater treatment coverage and
and four additional hours per day on transportation than the
reusing properly treated wastewater would improve water
population living in urban areas. In 2020, transport repre-
quality, energy security, and human and ecosystem health,
sented 18.6 percent of household spending nationwide, but up
and would curb GHG emissions as well (Gioutsos and Ochs
to 40 percent among lower income households (WRI 2021).
2019). Technical barriers to advancing these policies include
To provide urban residents with a better quality of life and inadequate waste management facilities, and capacity and
health through equitable access to jobs and core services, financial constraints.
while addressing the climate crisis and air pollution, Mexico
14 |
3.3 Forests, agriculture, and land use financially supports 19 percent of households, and uses close
to 70 percent of the territory (CEDRRSA 2019). Despite its
Small producers, indigenous people, and rural communi- socioeconomic importance, there is a great gender inequal-
ties are the guardians of Mexico’s forests and its diverse ity in the population that works and depends on this sector
ecosystems, and their means of living as well as their social (see Figure 7).
and cultural systems depend on the products and ecosystem
services provided by rural territories, which makes restoring Labor informality of workers in agriculture reached an 84.1
and protecting Mexico’s forests and natural ecosystems not percent in 2023 compared to the 55 percent national rate, and
only a key element of the climate agenda but also the main only 11 percent of those formally employed are women (Sec-
mechanism to promote development and social equity. retaría de Economía 2023) as well as three out of ten people
with an ejido or communal land certificate (Inmujeres 2020).
Five of the Mexican states that are considered the most
biologically rich (Oaxaca, Chiapas, Michoacan, Veracruz, and Food production is especially vulnerable to effects from
Guerrero) are also those in which half of Mexico’s traditional, climate change. Almost 75 percent of the cultivated land in
communally owned “ejidos” and indigenous communities are Mexico consists of rainfed agriculture with high sensitivity
located (Toledo et al. 2001). In total, around 51 percent of the to shifts in rainfall patterns, and 60 percent of soils show
national territory (CESOP 2019) and 80 percent of the land some level of degradation (SEMARNAT 2022). The more
under forest use (CONAFOR 2019), are owned by ejidos and mechanised and water-intensive agriculture is located in the
communities, respectively. north, the region most susceptible to droughts and water
scarcity. It is estimated that the percentage of households
Mexico is the 11th largest country in agricultural production living in extreme poverty in rural Mexico would increase by
and the 7th largest global producer of livestock. However, 11 points because of climate change, and would lead to a rise
in spite of accounting for less than 4 percent of Mexico’s of more than 20 percent Gini index, the inequality coeffi-
GDP, agriculture employs 13 percent of the population, cient (CEPAL 2017).

Figure 7 | Ranking of agricultural production and employment by gender in the world

Note: Data from Gross Production Value of Agriculture per year in 1,000 USD. Employment percentages considered are based on the total country-level workforce. Data
disaggregated by gender considers only workforce in the agricultural sector. These percentages by gender do not add up to 100% because the World Bank statistics consider also
an entry for children who are part of the workforce.
Source: WRI with data from INEGI 2020, World Bank 2021 and IMCO 2022.

Food production remains a main driver of deforestation that remains for further analysis is whether it is possible to
and an important source of GHG emissions. In 2019, it affordably change agricultural and land management practices
accounted for 19 percent of Mexico’s total emissions, of which without making it harder to feed Mexico’s growing popula-
almost 80 percent was from cattle (INECC 2021b). Emis- tion, and how.
sions associated with land use change increased almost 122
percent between 2000 and 2019, due to land being converted It is relevant to stress that mitigation options exist in the agri-
from forest to pasture and agriculture, mainly in the tropics culture, forestry, and other land use sector (AFOLU) which,
(SEMARNAT 2022). Between 2001-2018, an average of 212 when sustainably implemented, could help deliver large-scale
thousand hectares of forest were lost every year (CONAFOR GHG emission reductions and enhanced removals. In that
2018), and although the annual growth rate of deforestation sense, they are complementary and cannot be expected to fully
has decreased since 2016, Mexico is still far from reaching compensate for delayed action in other sectors (IPCC 2021).
its NDC target of net-zero deforestation by 2030. On the
contrary, if food consumption continues growing, supported
by an agriculture model that keeps pushing for the expansion 4. DECARBONISATION MAKES
of cultivated lands, both biodiversity and ecosystems that keep SENSE FOR THE MEXICAN
land productive will be harmed.
ECONOMY AND SOCIETY
Achieving net-zero deforestation would strengthen com- The updated 2020 NDC recognises that Mexico has “a myriad
munity resilience and create new employment opportunities, of opportunities to undertake changes leading to the diver-
diversify incomes, and become an important driver of water sification of its energy matrix, and to lead transformational
resources protection, while it would also contribute to flood changes in its productive sector focusing on the population’s
prevention and drought alleviation (Gioutsos and Ochs 2019). welfare and in the protection and sustainable use of its cultural
Estimates show that steps to protect, restore, and sustain- and natural wealth” (SEMARNAT 2020, 9). Decisions over
ably manage ecosystems, including forests, provide benefits a climate and energy pathway for the country will have a
nearly 2.7 times greater than the costs (INECC 2021). For considerable positive and sustained impact on the economic
the agriculture sector, GHG mitigation costs are estimated and social development of the country (GIZ 2020).
to be in the order of 1.6 dollars/tCO2eq for 2030. Switching The WRI’s analysis (Flores Montalvo et al. 2019) is consistent
from nitrogen fertilisers to biofertilisers is the single measure with these findings. It shows that, by following a path aligned
that offers the greatest abatement potential, with co-benefits with its 2015 NDC mitigation target of 22 percent below
such as improving water quality (INECC 2018). This, due to BAU by 2030, Mexico could achieve several benefits. The
the mitigation of nitrous oxide emissions to the air, and to the policies it would need to implement are both technically and
reduction of nitrogen contamination in water bodies. economically feasible, and the average cost of implementing
The conservation and restoration of coastal ecosystems is them is 12 USD/ton of CO2- equivalent (tCO2eq), which
particularly important. In addition to preserving ecosystem is less than half the average social cost of carbon or the ave-
services, it also has great potential to contribute to climate rage estimated cost of damage done by each additional ton of
change mitigation and adaptation. Mexico is currently home carbon emitted. Besides, more than 60 percent of the policies
to the world’s fourth largest mangrove area (Simard et al. required would have negative costs, since the investments
2018), which stores an estimated 1.29 gigatons of CO2eq needed would more than pay for themselves in the short term.
(Global Mangrove Alliance 2020). Avoiding degradation and Implementing these measures would require investments
deforestation of mangroves could enable Mexico to reach an close to 100 billion USD between now and 2030, representing
estimated six to ten percent of the total mitigation target from about 0.8 percent of GDP annually. The returns would be
the Land Use, Land-Use Change and Forestry (LULUCF) greater, reaching almost 105 billion USD, counting only the
sector set in Mexico’s 2015 NDC (Adame et al. 2018). Pro- gains from improved efficiency and some health co-benefits
tecting coastal ecosystems would directly benefit 20 percent of from reduced exposure to air pollutants.
Mexico’s population who live in coastal areas, and who depend Much of the rest of the world is quickly moving along a
on the services provided by coastal ecosystems, such as fisher- decarbonisation pathway. If it lags or fails to move at the same
ies, water quality, firewood, recreational services, flood control, pace, Mexico could find itself at a competitive disadvantage
and protection from coastal erosion and saline intrusion. in the global marketplace. This could have repercussions
Projections show that Mexico can adopt a feasible land-use for the employment and could affect socioeconomic and
pathway that ensures food security, sets a limit to agricultural financial stability. For example, accelerating global efforts to
expansion, preserves natural ecosystems, and contributes to electrify transport could push down demand for oil by more
the mitigation of emissions (FABLE 2020). A key question than 70 percent by 2030 (Carbon Tracker 2020). Another
16 |
prime example is in the transport equipment industry, which of leadership. The next stages of our analysis will explore these
represents 3.5 percent of Mexico’s GDP, 25 percent of manu- obstacles further, looking concretely at the case of Mexico.
facturing jobs and 37 percent of exports. The industry will Clearly, more needs to be done to inform national and sub-
need to accelerate the adoption of more efficient, clean, and national authorities and decisionmakers across sectors, with a
climate resilient processes to widen its competitive advantages compelling narrative about the potential benefits and oppor-
in global and regional markets. It may do so in response to tunities for Mexico of investing in a low-carbon and resilient
market forces, but having the right policies in place would just transition, but also about the risks and disadvantages
make this transition much smoother. of not doing so.
Developing a decarbonisation pathway offers a platform This working paper contributes to this effort by reviewing
and opportunity to close social gaps and avoid replicating relevant evidence and identifying feasible and cost-effective
structural inequalities by reducing vulnerability to the effects interventions in terms of GHG emissions abatement and
of climate change of the most vulnerable groups. It can also the creation of jobs. It is a milestone towards a more com-
lead to the creation of jobs, including greater participation of prehensive analysis, building on the NCE approach, which
women, reducing energy poverty, improving levels of health will include original macroeconomic and sectoral modelling,
and wellbeing in cities, and lowering risks of rural commu- political economy and distributional impacts analyses, as well
nities to losses of agricultural and forestry income, among as a further assessment of enabling conditions and barriers to
other benefits. implementation. Our future research will include participatory
processes, with the collaboration of experts and relevant stake-
holders. It will provide new knowledge and evidence as well
5. CONCLUSIONS AND NEXT as a strategy to communicate information more effectively to
STEPS broader audiences, and to engage with policymakers.
Stronger climate action aligns with Mexico’s social aspira- Crucial decisions are coming. It is expected that enhanced
tions as well. Proving and demonstrating how this is possible climate action, decarbonisation and resilience will emerge
can help Mexico enact and implement policies needed to as key topics among presidential candidates and campaigns
reach its enhanced GHG mitigation targets and aim for even in the 2024 general election, and as an urgent matter for
higher goals. The government will need concrete evidence that many voters. This initiative will help inform the search for a
transitioning to a low carbon and climate-resilient economy path forward and will provide input for decision making at
can help achieve urgent priorities such as poverty alleviation, all government levels and across relevant sectors of society.
economic growth, social and gender equality, inclusion, and Furthermore, it can contribute to a new National Develop-
energy security. This is particularly necessary as Mexico copes ment Plan that prioritizes climate action to boost social and
with fiscal pressures, inequality and informality of employ- economic development.
ment, the provision of public services, climate vulnerability,
and economic difficulties.
Although there are still important gaps in our knowledge,

several existing robust analyses demonstrate the economic
and social advantages of pursuing decarbonisation in Mexico.
The federal government itself recognizes this, in its rhetoric,
policy statements, and legal framework. Yet it falls short in its
climate implementation. This makes it the only G20 country
without a net-zero emissions target. Thus, it is not complying
with commitments enshrined in its own laws or NDCs.
The analysis so far points to barriers that may thwart even

the most cost-effective, socially, and economically sensible
policies. Some of these have to do with who wins and who
loses, and the balance of power between them. Others may
stem from legal or institutional limitations, politics, or a lack

APPENDICES
Appendix 1. List of interviews conducted 9. Sarukhán Kermez, José. Personal communication between
Adriana Lobo Almeida, former Executive Director at WRI
1. Carabias Lilo, Julia. Personal communication between
Mexico, Carolina Campos Hernández, Advisor of the Executive
the author Andrés Flores Montalvo, former Climate and
Director at WRI Mexico, and José Sarukhán, former General
Energy Director at WRI Mexico, Adriana Lobo Almeida,
Coordinator of the National Commission for the Knowledge
former Executive Director at WRI Mexico, Carolina Campos
and Use of Biodiversity. August 11, 2021.
Hernández, Advisor of the Executive Director at WRI Mexico,
and Julia Carabias, Researcher UNAM. August 13, 2021.
2. De Buen Rodríguez, Odón. Personal communication between

Appendix 2. Members of the Advisory
the author Andrés Flores Montalvo, former Climate and Energy
Director at WRI Mexico, Carolina Campos Hernández, Advisor
Committee for the New Economy for
of the Executive Director at WRI Mexico, and Odón de Buen, Mexico
former General Director, National Commission for the Efficient 1. Adrian Fernandez, General Director ICM
Use of Energy. July 21, 2021.
2. Alejandra Navarrete, Government and Multilateral Liaison
3. Delgado Peralta, Martha. Personal communication between Officer, Ocean Foundation
Angélica Vesga, Public Affairs and Communications Director
at WRI Mexico, Carolina Campos, Advisor of the Executive 3. Eduardo Vega, Director, Faculty of Economics, UNAM
Director at WRI Mexico, and Martha Delgado, former Under- 4. Enrique Provencio, Coordinator of the University Program for
Minister of Multilateral Affairs at the Mexico’s Ministry of Development Studies, UNAM
Foreign Affairs. June 12, 2021
5. Ernesto Herrera, Executive Director of Reforestamos Mexico
4. Del Villar Alrich, Rafael. Personal communication between the
author Andrés Flores Montalvo, former Climate and Energy 6. Isabel Studer, Founder of the Global Institute for Sustainability
Director at WRI Mexico, author Avelina Ruiz, Climate Manager
7. Israel Hurtado, President of the Mexican Hydrogen Association
at WRI Mexico, Adriana Lobo, former Executive Director of WRI
Mexico, Carolina Campos Hernández, Advisor of the Executive 8. Jesarela López, Director of Analysis and Management, INEGI
Director at WRI Mexico, and Rafael del Villar, Chief Advisor to
9. Maria Eugenia Ibarrarán, Academic Researcher of the Ibero-
the Governor, Bank of Mexico. June 24, 2021.
American University Puebla
5. Fernández Bremauntz, Adrián. Personal communication
10. Mariuz Calvet, Director of Sustainable Finance for Corporate
between the author Avelina Ruiz, Climate Manager at WRI
Banking Mexico and Latin America.
Mexico, Adriana Lobo, former Executive Director of WRI
Mexico, and Adrián Fernández, Director of the Mexico Climate 11. Miguel Ruiz Cabañas, Director of the Sustainable Development
Initiative and former Director of the National Institute of Goals Initiative at Tecnológico de Monterrey.
Ecology. June 11, 2021.
12. Monserrat Ramirez, Director of Sustainability at ConMexico.
6. León Tovar, Rufino. Personal communication between
13. Sandra Guzmán, Founder, GFLA
at WRI Mexico, and Rufino León Tovar, President of the 14. Jorge Rickards, Director General, WWF
First Chamber of the Federal Court of Conciliation and
Arbitration. July 23, 2021. 15. Alejandra Navarrete, Government and Multilateral Liaison
Officer, Ocean Foundation
7. Medina, Carla. Personal communication between the author
Andrés Flores Montalvo, former Climate and Energy Director 16. Enrique Provencio, director of the university program for
at WRI Mexico, Carolina Campos Hernández at WRI Mexico development studies, UNAM
and Carla Medina, Corporate Affairs Director, Zuma Energía. 17. Andrew Rhodes, former manager of the ocean's agenda, SRE
August 13, 2021.
8. Pichardo Lechuga, Ignacio. Personal communication between

at WRI Mexico, Carolina Campos, Advisor of the Executive
Director at WRI Mexico, and Ignacio Pichardo, Mexican
Politician. July 14, 2021.
18 |
ENDNOTES Carbonplan. 2023. Modeling extreme heat in a changing. Avaiable

at: climate. https://carbonplan.org/research/extreme-heat-explainer
1. The EPS is open source and widely documented (Energy
Innovation 2023). Carbon Tracker. 2020. Nothing to lose but your chains: The emerg-
ing market transport leapfrog. Available at: https://carbontracker.
2. In a CO2eq comparison basis, 67 percent is carbon dioxide org/reports/nothing-to-lose-but-your-chains/
(CO2) and 24 percent methane (CH4). The remaining is nitrous
oxides and fluorinated gases. Centro de Estudios para el Desarrollo Rural Sustentable y la So-
beranía Alimentaria (CEDRSSA). 2019. El Sector Agropecuario en
3. Energy poverty is understood as lacking at least one of the el PIB. Mexico City: Palacio Legislativo de San Lázaro. http://www.
services or economic goods that are considered to satisfy cedrssa.gob.mx/files/b/9/47SectorAgro_PIB.pdf
fundamental human needs: i) electricity, ii) entertainment, iii)
water heating, iv) food cooking, v) food refrigeration, and vi) Comisión Económica para América Latina y el Caribe (CEPAL).
thermal comfort at home (García and Graizbord 2016). 2017. El cambio climático, la distribución del ingreso y la pobreza: el
caso de Mexico. Santiago: CEPAL. Available at: https://repositorio.
4. According to INEGI, a population is urban when it has more
cepal.org/server/api/core/bitstreams/eaa828bd-9ec1-46ec-a655-
than 2,500 inhabitants.
b2a90d376bc3/content
CEPAL. 2021a. The economic autonomy of women in the sustain-

able and equal recovery. Santiago: CEPAL Available at: https://
www.cepal.org/es/publicaciones/46633-la-autonomia-economica-
REFERENCES mujeres-la-recuperacion-sostenible-igualdad
Adame, M., C. Brown, M. Bejarano, J. Herrera-Silveira, P. Ezcurra, CEPAL. 2021. Social outlook from Latin America 2020. Available
B. Kauffman and R. Birdsey. 2018. The Undervalued Contribu- at: https://repositorio.cepal.org/bitstream/handle/11362/46687/8/
tion of Mangrove Protection in Mexico to Carbon Emission S2100150_es.pdf
Targets. Conservational Letters. ttps://www.cifor.org/knowledge/
publication/5000 CEPAL. 2022. Preliminary Balance of Latin America and the
Caribbean Economies 2021. Santiago: CEPAL. Available at:
Badillo, Diego. 2023. “Es necesario redoblar esfuerzos para mejorar https://repositorio.cepal.org/bitstream/handle/11362/47669/5/
calidad del aire: WRI.” El Economista, 7 September. Available at: S2100698es.pdf
https://www.eleconomista.com.mx/politica/Es-necesario-redoblar-
esfuerzos-para-mejorar-calidad-del-aire-WRI-20230907-0034.html Centro de Estudios Sociales y de Opinión Pública (CESOP). 2019.
La Relevancia De Los Ejidos Y Las Comunidades Rurales En La
Banco de Mexico (Banxico). 2022. Informe trimestral octubre- Estructura Social De Mexico. Mexico City: CESOP. Available at:
diciembre 2021. https://www.banxico.org.mx/publicaciones-y- https://www.ccmss.org.mx/wp-content/uploads/Relevancia-
prensa/informes-trimestrales/%7B9CE4F0BD-2CE1-0A7C-9A88- Ejidos-CESOP.pdf
7FBFC2411A53%7D.pdf
Chancel, L., Piketty, T., Saez, and E., Zucman, G. 2023. World
Becqué, R., E. Mackres, J. Layke, N. Aden, S. Liu, K. Managan, C. Inequality Report 2022. Paris: World Inequality Lab. Available at:
Nesler, S. Mazur-Stommen, K. Petrichenko and P. Graham. 2016. https://wir2022.wid.world/
Accelerating Buidling Efficiency, Eight Actions for Urban Leaders.
Washington D.C. : World Resources Institute (WRI). https://www. Climate Analytics. 2019. Decarbonizing South and South East Asia.
wri.org/research/accelerating-building-efficiency Country Report: Vietnam. Berlin: Climate Analytics. Available at:
https://climateanalytics.org/media/decarbonisingasia2019-profile-
Buira, D., J. Tovilla, J. Farbes, R. Jones, B. Haley and D. Gastelum. vietnam-climateanalytics.pdf
2021. “A whole-economy Deep Decarbonization Pathway for
Mexico.” Energy Strategy Review 33: 1-16. https://www.sciencedi- Climate Transparency. 2021. Mexico, Country Profile 2021. Available
rect.com/science/article/pii/S2211467X20301310 at: https://www.climate-transparency.org/media/mexico-coun-
try-profile-2021
Climate Action Tracker (CAT). 2023. Mexico Country Profile. Avail-
able at: https://climateactiontracker.org/countries/mexico Comisión Nacional Forestal (CONAFOR). 2018. Infraestructura de
Datos Forestales. Available at: https://idefor.cnf.gob.mx/

CONAFOR. 2019. El Sector Forestal Mexicano en Cifras 2019: Food, Agriculture, Biodiversity, Land-Use and Energy (FABLE).
Bosques para el Bienestar Social y Climático.Mexico City: 2020. Pathways to Sustainable Land-Use and Food Systems 2020.
CONAFOR. Available at: http://www.conafor.gob.mx:8080/docu- Available at: https://fablepathways.org/publications/pathways-to-
mentos/docs/1/7749El%20Sector%20Forestal%20Mexicano%20 sustainable-land-use-and-food-systems-2020/
en%20Cifras%202019.pdf
Flores Montalvo, A., J.C. Altamirano, F. Olea and A. Zafra. 2019.
Consejo Nacional de Evaluación de la Política de Desarrollo Social Choosing the Right Path: Low-Cost Policy Options for Enhancing
(CONEVAL). 2019. Principales Retos en el Ejercicio del Derecho a Mexico’s Climate Goals While Achieving Long-Term Social Benefits.
la Vivienda Digna y Decorosa. Mexico City: CONEVAL. ttps://www. Mexico City: WRI. Available at: https://www.wri.org/research/
coneval.org.mx/Evaluacion/IEPSM/Documents/Derechos_Socia- choosing-right-path
les/Dosieres_Derechos_Sociales/Retos_Derecho_Vivienda.pdf
Flores Montalvo A. and F. Loutfi Olivares. 2020. Policy mechanisms
CONEVAL. 2023. Medición Multidimensional de la pobreza en to reduce single-use plastic waste: Review of available options and
Mexico (Multidemensional measurement of poverty in Mexico their applicability in Mexico. Factsheets. Mexico City: WRI.
2022). Available at: https://www.coneval.org.mx/Medicion/MP/Pa-
ginas/Pobreza_2022.aspx García, R. and Graizbord, B. 2016. “Caracterización espa-
cial de la pobreza energética en Mexico. Un análisis a es-
Comisión Nacional para el Uso Eficiente de la Energía (CONUEE). cala subnacional”. Economía, sociedad y desarrollo 16:
2017. Hoja de Ruta de Eficiencia Energética. Mexico City: CONUEE. 289-337. https://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?pid=S1405-
https://www.gob.mx/conuee/acciones-y-programas/hoja-de-ruta- 84212016000200289&script=sci_abstract
de-eficiencia-energetica
Global Green Growth Institute (GGGI). 2020. Employment Assess-
Coalition for Urban Transitions (CUT). 2019. Climate Emergency, ment of Renewable Energy: Power sector pathways compatible
Urban Opportunity. Coalition for Urban Transitions.Washington DC: with NDCs and national energy plans. Mexico City: GGGI. ttps://
CUT. Available at: https://urbantransitions.global/en/publication/ gggi.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Employment-Assessment-
climate-emergency-urban-opportunity/ of-Renewable-Energy_Web_final.pdf
CUT. 2021. Zero Carbon Cities by 2050: Mitigation Potential by Global Mangrove Alliance. 2020. Global Mangrove Watch. Available
Sector and Level of Government in Six Key Countries. Available at: https://www.globalmangrovewatch.org
at: https://urbantransitions.global/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/
Summary-GCOM-SEI-CUT-paper-designed-07Oct.pdf Global Clean Air. 2023. How Methane Impacts Health. Available at:
https://globalcleanair.org/methane-and-health/
Dalkmann, H. and Brannigan, C. 2007. Transport and Climate
Change. Module 5e: Sustainable Transport: A Sourcebook for Gioutsos, D. and A. Ochs. 2019. Crunching the numbers: quan-
Policy-Makers in Developing Cities. Berlin: GIZ. Available at: tifying the sustainable development co-benefits of Mexico’s
https://www.scirp.org/(S(351jmbntvnsjt1aadkozje))/reference/refer- climate commitments. Mexico City: Deutsche Gesellschaft für
encespapers.aspx?referenceid=1112771 Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ). Available at: https://www.
gob.mx/agenda2030/documentos/crunching-numbers-quan-
Department of Energy of the United States (DOE US). 2022. Mexico tifying-the-sustainable-development-co-benefits-of-mexico-s-
Clean Energy Report. Washington DC.: US Department of Energy. climate-commitments
Available at: https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy22osti/82580.pdf
GIZ. 2020. Co-benefits: Contribution of the Energy Transition to
Environmental Defense Fund (EDF). 2021. Climate Scientists Sustainable Development in Mexico. Mexico City: GIZ. Available at:
Record Extremely High Methane Emissions Across Mexico’s Gulf https://www.cobenefits.info/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/CoBen-
States. 26 January 2021. Available at: https://www.ccacoalition. eficios-Espanol-200330.pdf
org/en/news/climate-scientists-record-extremely-high-methane-
emissions-across-mexico%E2%80%99s-gulf-states GIZ and Iniciativa Climática de Mexico (ICM). 2019. Presupuestos
de carbono: Una oportunidad para ampliar la ambición climática
Elizondo, A., V. Pérez-Cirera, A. Strapasson, J.C. Fernández and del sector eléctrico. Mexico City: ICM & GIZ. https://iki-alliance.mx/
D. Cruz-Cano. 2017. “Mexico’s Low Carbon Futures: an Integrated wp-content/uploads/CONECC_PresupuestoCarbono_Nov19.pdf
Assessment for Energy Planning and Climate Change Mitiga-
tion by 2050.” Futures 93: 14-26. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fu- Gobierno de Mexico. 2022. Contribución Determinada a Nivel Na-
tures.2017.08.003 cional. Actualización 2022. Mexico City: SEMARNAT and INECCC.
https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/NDC/2022-11/Mexico_NDC_
Energy Innovation. 2023. Energy Policy Simulator – Mexico. Avail- UNFCCC_update2022_FINAL.pdf
able at: https://energypolicy.solutions/home/mexico/en
20 |
Grande-Acosta, G. and J. Islas-Samperio. 2017. “Towards a Low- INECC. 2021b. Inventario Nacional de Emisiones de Gases y Com-
Carbon Electric Power System in Mexico.” Energy for Sustainable puestos de Efecto Invernadero 1990 - 2019. Mexico City: INECC.
Development 37: 99-109. Available at: https://www.gob.mx/inecc/articulos/presenta-inecc-
el-inventario-nacional-de-emisiones-de-gases-y-compuestos-de-
Health Effects Institute (HEI). 2020. State of Global Air: A Special efecto-invernadero-1990-2019-284532?state=published
Report on Global Exposure to Air Pollution and its Health Impacts.
Boston: HEI. https://www.stateofglobalair.org/resources?resource_ INECC. 2022. First Communication on Mexico's Adaptation to the
category=All&page=0 United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Mexico
City: INECC. Available at: https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/re-
ICM. 2022. NDC desde la Sociedad Civil. Iniciativa Climática de source/2022_adcom_mexico.pdf
Mexico. Mexico City: ICM. https://iniciativaclimatica.org/ndc/
wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Una-propuesta-desde-la-sociedad- Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geografía (INEGI). 2020. Pro-
civil-091122.pdf ducto Interno Bruto De Mexico Durante El Cuarto Trimestre De
2019. Available at: https://www.inegi.org.mx/contenidos/saladep-
ICM and CT. 2019. Rutas sectoriales de descarbonización para rensa/boletines/2020/pib_pconst/pib_pconst2020_02.pdf
Mexico al 2030 y proyecciones a 2050. Mexico City: ICM and CT.
https://www.iniciativaclimatica.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/ INEGI. 2020a. Encuesta Nacional de Ocupación y Empleo (Na-
PresupuestoCarbono_DOC-POL.pdf tional Survey of Occupation and Employment (ENOE). Available at:
https://www.inegi.org.mx/programas/enoe/15ymas/
Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (IDMC). 2023. Global Re-
port on Internal Displacement. Geneva: IDMC. Available at: https:// INEGI. 2020b. Censo de Población y Vivienda 2020 (Population
www.internal-displacement.org/countries/mexico and Housing Census 2020). Available at: Population and Housing
Census 2020: https://www.inegi.org.mx/programas/ccpv/2020/
International Energy Agency (IEA). 2021. Security of Clean Energy
Transitions. International Energy Energy Agency Report. July INEGI. 2021a. Producto Interno Bruto 2020 (Gross domestic product
2021. Available at: https://www.iea.org/reports/security-of-clean- (GDP) 2020). Available at: https://www.inegi.org.mx/contenidos/
energy-transitions-2 saladeprensa/boletines/2021/pib_pconst/pib_pconst2021_02.pdf
International Labor Organization (ILO) and Interamerican Develop- INEGI. 2021b. Cuantificación de la clase media en Mexico 2010-
ment Bank (IDB). 2020. Jobs in a future of zero net emissions in 2020. Available at: https://www.inegi.org.mx/contenidos/investiga-
Latin America and the Caribbean. Washinton DC: OIT. Available at: cion/cmedia/doc/cm_desarrollo.pdf
https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---americas/---ro-lima/
documents/publication/wcms_752069.pdf INEGI. 2022. Indicadores de Empleo: (Employment Indicators).
Available at: https://www.inegi.org.mx/contenidos/saladeprensa/
Instituto Mexicano para la Competitividad (IMCO). 2022.Monitor: boletines/2022/iooe/iooe2022_03.pdf
Mujeres en la Economía (Monitor: Women in the Economy). Avail-
able at: https://imco.org.mx/monitor/mujeres-en-la-economia/ INEGI. 2023. Total, nacional de vehículos. Economía y sectores pro-
ductivos. Available at: https://www.inegi.org.mx/temas/vehiculos/
IMCO. 2022a. En Mexico, solo 3 de cada 10 profesionistas
STEM son mujeres. Mexico City: IMCO. Available at: https:// INEGI. 2023a. Producto Interno Bruto Cuarto Trimestre de 2022.
imco.org.mx/en-mexico-solo-3-de-cada-10-profesionistas- Available at: https://www.inegi.org.mx/contenidos/saladeprensa/
stem-son-mujeres/#:~:text=Aunque%20entre%202012%20 boletines/2023/pib_pconst/pib_pconst2023_02.pdf
y%202021,minor%C3%ADa%20dentro%20de%20estas%20
INEGI. 2023b. Encuesta Nacional de Ocupación y Empleo. Avail-
%C3%A1reas.
able at https://www.inegi.org.mx/contenidos/saladeprensa/bo-
Instituto Nacional de Ecología y Cambio Climático (INECC). 2018. letines/2023/enoen/enoen2023_06_b.pdf
Costos de las Contribuciones Determinadas a Nivel Nacional
Instituto Nacional de las Mujeres (Inmujeres). 2020. Desigualdad
de Mexico. Mexico City: INECC. Available at: https://www.gob.
en cifras. Available at: http://cedoc.inmujeres.gob.mx/documen-
mx/cms/uploads/attachment/file/330857/Costos_de_las_con-
tos_download/BA6N05.pdf
tribuciones_nacionalmente_determinadas_de_M_xico__
dobles_p_ginas_.pdf Instituto Nacional de Salud Pública (INSP). 2021. Efectos a la
salud por el uso de fogones abiertos de leña y alternativas.
INECC. 2021a. Estimación de costos y beneficios asociados a la
Available at: https://insp.mx/assets/documents/webinars/2021/
implementación de acciones de mitigación para el cumplimiento
CISP_Humolena.pdf
de los objetivos de reducción de emisiones comprometidos en el
Acuerdo de París. Mexico City: INECC.

Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). 2018. Special Pew Research Center. 2021. The Pandemic Stalls Growth in the
Report: Global Warming of 1.5°C. Available at: https://www.ipcc.ch/ Global Middle Class, Pushes Poverty Up Sharply. Washington DC:
sr15/chapter/spm/ Available at: https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2021/03/18/
the-pandemic-stalls-growth-in-the-global-middle-class-pushes-
IPCC. 2021. Sixth Assessment Report. Mitigation of Climate Change. poverty-up-sharply/
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Available at: https://
www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg3/ Quintana, E. 2023. “Las dos caras del sexenio de AMLO”. El Finan-
ciero. 11 August 2023. https://www.elfinanciero.com.mx/opinion/
Islas-Samperio, J., F. Manzini and G. Grande-Acosta. 2019. “Toward enrique-quintana/2023/08/11/las-dos-caras-del-sexenio-de-amlo/
a low-carbon transport sector in Mexico.” Energies 13: 84-111.
Romeiro, V. A. Barros, A. Bassi, A. Lucena, A. Andrade, A. Szklo, B.
Jaeger, J., G. Walls, E. Clarke, J. C. Altamirano, A. Harsono, H. Mount- Pinheiro, B. Cunha, C. Genin, F. da Silva, G. Angelkorte, J. Feres, L.
ford, S. Burrow, S. Smith and A. Tate. 2021. The Green Jobs Advan- Garrido, R. Feltran-Barbieri, R. Garaffa, R. Studart, R. Schaeffer, and
tage: How Climate-friendly Investments Are Better Job Creators. S. Keneally, 2020. A New Economy for a New Era: Elements for
Working paper. Washington DC: WRI. Building a More Efficient and Resilient Economy in Brazil. Working
Paper. São Paulo: WRI. Available at: https://www.wribrasil.org.br/
Lee, Sangji. 2022. “Towards a just green economy transition.” The
publicacoes/new-economy-new-era-elements-building-more-
Journal of Field Actions 24: 38-43.
efficient-and-resilient-economy-brazil
Lu, X., D.J. Jacob, H. Wang, J.D. Maasakkers, Y. Zhang, T.R. Scar-
Saha, D., J. Jaeger, S. Rajpurohit, E. Said, and J. A. Laitner. 2023. A
pelli, L. Shen, Z. Qu, M.P. Sulprizio, H. Nesser, A. A. Bloom, S. Ma,
roadmap for Michigan’s electric vehicle future: An assessment of
J.R. Worden, S. Fan, R.J. Parker, H. Boesch, R. Gautam, D. Gordon,
the employment effects and just transition needs. Report. Washing-
M.D. Moran, F. Reuland, C.A.O Villasana and A. Andrews. 2021.
ton, DC: WRI. doi.org/10.46830/wrirpt.21.00171
“Methane emissions in the United States, Canada, and Mexico:
evaluation of national methane emission inventories and 2010–2017 Secretaría de Hacienda y Crédito Público (SHCP). 2021. Estadísti-
sectoral trends by inverse analysis of in situ (GLOBALVIEWplus cas Oportunas de Finanzas Públicas. Available at: http://presto.
CH4 ObsPack) and satellite (GOSAT) atmospheric observations.” hacienda.gob.mx/EstoporLayout/estadisticas.jsp
Atmos. Chem. Phys. 22: 395–418. https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-22-
395-2022, 2022. Secretaría de Economía (SE). 2022. Comercio Exterior, Países con
Tratados y Acuerdos firmados con Mexico. https://www.gob.mx/se/
Mexico Evalúa. 2023. Las mujeres en la economía: de este tamaño acciones-y-programas/comercio-exterior-paises-con-tratados-y-
es la brecha. Mexico City: Mexico Evalúa. Available at: https:// acuerdos-firmados-con-mexico
www.mexicoevalua.org/las-mujeres-en-la-economia-de-este-
tamano-es-la-brecha/ SE. 2023. Trabajadores en Agricultura. Available at: https://www.
economia.gob.mx/datamexico/es/profile/occupation/trabajadores-
Moody´s. 2021. Moody's: Las sequías y el estrés hídrico en en-actividades-agricolas
Mexico afectarán las industrias de alto consumo de agua. New
York: Moody´s. Available at: https://www.moodys.com/re- Secretaría de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Natutales (SEMARNAT)-
search/Moodys-Drough INECC. 2018. Sexta Comunicación y Segundo Informe Bienal De
Actualización Ante La Convención Marco De Las Naciones Unidas
New Climate Economy (NCE). 2018. Unlocking the Inclusive Sobre El Cambio Climático. Available at: https://cambioclimatico.
Growth Story of the 21st Century. The New Climate Economy. gob.mx/sexta-comunicacion/
Washington DC: WRI.
SEMARNAT-INECC. 2022. Contribución Determinada a Nivel Nacio-
Nishio. 2021. When poverty meets climate change: A critical chal- nal de Mexico. Actualización 2022. Available at: https://unfccc.int/
lenge that demands cross-cutting solutions. Available at: https:// documents/624282
blogs.worldbank.org/climatechange/when-poverty-meets-climate-
change-critical-challenge-demands-cross-cutting-solutions SEMARNAT. 2020. Contribución Determinada a Nivel Nacional de
Mexico. Actualización 2020. Available at: https://unfccc.int/sites/
OIT. 2020. Mexico and the COVID-19 crisis in the world of work: default/files/NDC/2022-06/NDC-Esp-30Dic.pdf
answers and challenges. Available at: https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/
groups/public/---americas/---ro-lima/---ilo-mexico/documents/ SEMARNAT. 2020a. Guía de eficiencia energética en el diseño,
publication/wcms_757364.pdf construcción y operación de hoteles en climas cálidos. Available
at: https://www.gob.mx/cms/uploads/attachment/file/565858/
Gu_a_de_eficiencia_energetica_hoteles__comprimida_.pdf
22 |
SEMARNAT. 2021. Programa Especial de Cambio Climático. 2021- Veysey, J., C. Octaviano, K. Calvin, S. Herreras Martinez, A. Kitous,
2024. Available at: https://www.gob.mx/semarnat/documentos/ J. McFarland and B. van der Zwaan. 2016. “Pathways to Mexico’s
programa-especial-de-cambio-climatico-2021-2024 climate change mitigation targets: a multi-model analysis.” Energy
Economics 56: 587-599. doi.org/10.1016/j.eneco.2015.04.011.
SEMARNAT. 2022. Tercer informe bienal de actualización ante
la convención marco de las Naciones Unidas sobre el cambio World Bank. 2023. Datos Banco Mundial Mexico. Available at:
climático. Available at: https://www.gob.mx/cms/uploads/attach- https://datos.bancomundial.org/pais/mexico
ment/file/747507/158_2022_Mexico_3er_BUR.pdf
Secretaría de Energía (SENER). 2016. Atlas Nacional de Zonas

con Alto Potencial de Energías Limpias. Available at: https://dgel.
energia.gob.mx/inel/
SENER. 2019. Balance Nacional de Energía 2019 . Available at:

https://www.gob.mx/sener/documentos/balance-nacional-
de-energia-2019
SENER. 2021. PRODESEN 2020 – 2034. Available at: https://www.

gob.mx/sener/articulos/prodesen-2020-2034
SENER. 2023. Sistema de Informacion Energética. Available at:

https://sie.energia.gob.mx/
Secretaría de Relaciones de Exteriores (SRE). 2022. Compromiso

del Gobierno de Mexico en el combate al cambio climático. Mexico
City: SRE. Available at: https://www.gob.mx/cms/uploads/attach-
ment/file/733833/20220617_MEF_PEUM._Vf.pdf
Simard, M., Fatoyinbo, L., Smetanka, C., Rivera-Monroy V., Casta-

ñeda-Moya E., Thomas N., and T. Van. 2018. “Mangrove canopy
height globally related to precipitation, temperature and cyclone
frequency.” Nature Geoscience 12 : 40-45. https://www.nature.
com/articles/s41561-018-0279-1
Solano-Rodríguez, B., A. Pizarro-Alonso, K. Vaillancourt, C. Martin-

del-Campo and G. G. al Dans . 2018. “Mexico's transition to a net-
zero emissions energy system: near term implications of long term
stringent climate targets.” In: Giannakidis, G., Karlsson, K., Labriet,
M., Gallachóir, B. (eds), Limiting Global Warming to Well Below 2 °C:
Energy System Modelling and Policy Development. Lecture Notes
in Energy 64, 315-331. Washington DC: Springer.
Toledo, V.M, P. Alarcón-Chaires, P. Moguel, A. Cabrera, M. Olivo. E.

Leyequine and A. Rodriguez Aldabe. 2001. El Atlas Etnoecológico
de Mexico y Mesoamerica. Mexico City: Etnoecológica. Avail-
able at: https://ccp.ucr.ac.cr/bvp/pdf/cambiodemografico/atlas_
etnologico.pdf
United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction (UNDRR) and

Centre for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters (CRED) .
2018. Economic losses, poverty and disasters 1998-2017. Geneva:
UNDRR. Available at: https://www.undrr.org/publication/economic-
losses-poverty-disasters-1998-2017

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ABOUT WRI
The authors are very grateful for the valuable comments and World Resources Institute is a global research organization that
advice provided by all organisations and individuals who gave turns big ideas into action at the nexus of environment, economic
feedback during the interviews and consultations that were opportunity, and human well-being.
carried out as part of the process of this report. Special thanks
Our challenge
to the reviewers for their very valuable insights: Itza Castañeda,
José Luis Samaniego, José Luis Santana, Thiago Guimaraes, Robin Natural resources are at the foundation of economic opportunity
King, Henrique Cervantes, Ashish Sharma, Miguel Ruiz Cabañas, and human well-being. But today, we are depleting Earth’s
Alejandra Elizondo and Alerto Carmona. We would also like to resources at rates that are not sustainable, endangering economies
thank Adriana Lobo, former Executive Director of WRI Mexico, and people’s lives. People depend on clean water, fertile land,
Angélica Vesga, Director of Public Affairs and Communications healthy forests, and a stable climate. Livable cities and clean
of WRI Mexico, and Carolina Campos, Advisor to the Executive energy are essential for a sustainable planet. We must address
Director of WRI Mexico, for their support in the preparation of these urgent, global challenges this decade.
the interviews that were used for the qualitative analysis of this
report. For the production process we thank Rivvy Eisenberg and Our vision
Anamaría Martínez; for revisions and comments, Jaime Reyes, Karla We envision an equitable and prosperous planet driven by the wise
López, and Erika Vilchis; for proofreading and copyediting Javier management of natural resources. We aspire to create a world
Toscano, and for design Nancy Rojas. where the actions of government, business, and communities
combine to eliminate poverty and sustain the natural environment
for all people.
ABOUT THE AUTHORS Our approach
COUNT IT
Andrés Flores Montalvo is a climate change and energy expert
with more than 20 years of experience. He is the lead author of the We start with data. We conduct independent research and
publication and was in charge of the research design and framing draw on the latest technology to develop new insights and
of the key concepts of the document. recommendations. Our rigorous analysis identifies risks, unveils
Avelina Ruiz is Climate Change Manager at WRI Mexico. Her opportunities, and informs smart strategies. We focus our efforts
contribution to this working paper was to lead the literature review on influential and emerging economies where the future of
and the production process. Contact: [email protected] sustainability will be determined.
Emilio García is Climate Change Coordinator at WRI Mexico. CHANGE IT

His contribution to the text was to develop the literature review,
elaborate the modeling scenario and to assist in the review We use our research to influence government policies, business
process. Contact: [email protected] strategies, and civil society action. We test projects with
communities, companies, and government agencies to build a
Juan Carlos Altamirano is Senior Economist at the Economics
strong evidence base. Then, we work with partners to deliver
Center at WRI. His contribution was to provide information
change on the ground that alleviates poverty and strengthens
on the national socioeconomic context and the benefits of
society. We hold ourselves accountable to ensure our outcomes
decarbonisation. Contact: [email protected]
will be bold and enduring.
SCALE IT
We do not think small. Once tested, we work with partners to adopt

and expand our efforts regionally and globally. We engage with
decision-makers to carry out our ideas and elevate our impact. We
measure success through government and business actions that
improve people’s lives and sustain a healthy environment.
Copyright 2023 World Resources Institute. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
To view a copy of the license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Cjon. Belisario Domínguez 8-Planta alta, Coyoacán, 04100 | Mexico City 2023 | ES.WRI.ORG

A Socially Inclusive Economic Transition For Mexico

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

A Socially Inclusive Economic Transition For Mexico

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

A Socially Inclusive Economic Transition For Mexico

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

WORKING PAPER

A socially inclusive economic

Working Papers contain preliminary research, ▪ Incontribute

WORKING PAPER | Version 1.0 | November 2023 | 1

1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Methodology

WORKING PAPER | November 2023 | 3

Climate change is one of the

Climate change impacts and environmental degradation have

WORKING PAPER | November 2023 | 5

Source: WRI 2022

WORKING PAPER | November 2023 | 7

Figure 3 | Landscape on green jobs potential in Mexico's energy sector

Fossil fuels represent 87 percent

WORKING PAPER | November 2023 | 9

Mexicois amongthe ten highest ranking countries

Energy Efficiency Overall, demand-side measures are an integral part of any

Policies of increasing Mexico’s crude oil production, the lack

WORKING PAPER | November 2023 | 11

Mexicoranks amongthe ten countries in the world

 ofandcitiesfive with

Close toone million people

People that live in urban areas 

Figure 6 | Why is it necessary to decarbonise the transport sector

Fugitive emissions & oil and gas

 The transport sector

WORKING PAPER | November 2023 | 13

     

WORKING PAPER | November 2023 | 15

Although there are still important gaps in our knowledge,

The analysis so far points to barriers that may thwart even

WORKING PAPER | November 2023 | 17

2. De Buen Rodríguez, Odón. Personal communication between

8. Pichardo Lechuga, Ignacio. Personal communication between

ENDNOTES Carbonplan. 2023. Modeling extreme heat in a changing. Avaiable

CEPAL. 2021a. The economic autonomy of women in the sustain-

WORKING PAPER | November 2023 | 19

WORKING PAPER | November 2023 | 21

Secretaría de Energía (SENER). 2016. Atlas Nacional de Zonas

SENER. 2019. Balance Nacional de Energía 2019 . Available at:

SENER. 2021. PRODESEN 2020 – 2034. Available at: https://www.

SENER. 2023. Sistema de Informacion Energética. Available at:

Secretaría de Relaciones de Exteriores (SRE). 2022. Compromiso

Simard, M., Fatoyinbo, L., Smetanka, C., Rivera-Monroy V., Casta-

Solano-Rodríguez, B., A. Pizarro-Alonso, K. Vaillancourt, C. Martin-

Toledo, V.M, P. Alarcón-Chaires, P. Moguel, A. Cabrera, M. Olivo. E.

United Nations Office for Disaster Risk Reduction (UNDRR) and

WORKING PAPER | November 2023 | 23

ABOUT THE AUTHORS Our approach

Emilio García is Climate Change Coordinator at WRI Mexico. CHANGE IT

We do not think small. Once tested, we work with partners to adopt

You might also like

Mexicois amongthe ten highest ranking countries

Mexicoranks amongthe ten countries in the world

ofandcitiesfive with

Close toone million people

People that live in urban areas

The transport sector