IB Extented Essay

‘’When Edgar Allan Poe's ‘’The Black Cat’’ is analyzed from a psychoanalytic point

of view, can we find traces of the author in the work? Did the author's lifestyle affect

the flow of the book?’’

Subject : English B – Group 2

Word count : 3890

Candidate number:

Table of Contents
Introduction--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------1

Narrator's Character ………………………………………………………..……………………………………7

Symbolism and Imagery ………………………….…………………………………………………………….12

Superego ……………..………………….……………………………………………………………………………18

Conclusion …………………………………………………………………………………………………………….20

Referances …………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 22
Introduction

Brief overview of Edgar Allan Poe and his literary style Edgar Allan Poe, a

luminary of 19th-century American literature, stands as an enduring figure within the

Romantic movement. His literary prowess, characterized by a unique blend of Gothic

elements, atmospheric darkness, and profound psychological exploration, distinguishes

him as one of the preeminent voices of his era.

This extended essay examines the research question ‘’When Edgar Allan Poe's

‘’The Black Cat’’ is analyzed from a psychoanalytic point of view, can we find traces

of the author in the work? Did the author's lifestyle affect the flow of the book?’’

Furthermore, due to the gothic elements and atmospheric darkness of the work, as well

as its interest in psychoanalysis, I chose to pursue this type of analysis. The profound

approach it offers in understanding the inner worlds and motivations of the characters

drew me to write this essay. When gothic literature's dark and mysterious atmosphere

is examined through a psychoanalytic lens, it provides a profound understanding of the

complexity of the human psyche and the dark abyss of the unconscious. Among the

books I've read, The Black Cat seemed to best fit this theme and offered the most

potential for exploration.

 Poe emerged against the backdrop of the Romantic movement, a period marked

by a fascination with individualism, emotion, and the sublime. While his

contemporaries explored the expansive landscapes of nature, Poe delved into the

uncharted territories of the human psyche.

Atmospheric darkness is the hallmark of Poe's literary realm. Shadows acquire a

life of their own, enveloping characters and readers alike in an immersive experience.

His ability to create an ominous atmosphere heightens the emotional impact of his

narratives.

Death, a pervasive theme in Poe's works, is not merely a conclusion but a

constant companion. The inevitability of mortality serves as a canvas upon which he

paints intricate tales. Madness, too, becomes a landscape to explore the fragility of the

human condition.

Poe's impact extends beyond his lifetime. His innovative approach to

storytelling and thematic exploration influenced subsequent generations of writers,

shaping the trajectory of Gothic literature and horror fiction.

Edgar Allan Poe's contributions to literature extend far beyond the confines of

his era. Through the lens of Romanticism, he unearthed the complexities of the human
experience, leaving behind a legacy that continues to captivate and inspire readers

across generations.

The story is narrated by an unnamed man who, in an attempt to prove his sanity

while on death row, recounts his descent into madness and the horrific acts he

committed. The narrator begins by describing his love for animals, particularly his

fondness for his pets. However, as the story progresses, he becomes increasingly

abusive toward them, especially after becoming addicted to alcohol.

The turning point occurs when the narrator adopts a large black cat named

Pluto, whom he initially adores. However, as his alcoholism worsens, he becomes

increasingly violent, eventually gouging out one of the cat's eyes in a fit of rage.

Despite feeling remorseful afterward, his cruelty only intensifies, culminating in a

gruesome act of violence in which he hangs the cat from a tree, killing it.

Shortly afterward, the narrator's house mysteriously burns down, leaving only

one wall standing, on which an image resembling the outline of a cat with a noose

around its neck appears. He soon adopts another black cat, eerily similar to Pluto,

except for a white patch on its chest. Despite his attempts to love and care for this new

cat, the narrator's guilt and psychological torment continue to torment him.

As the story progresses, the narrator's mental state deteriorates further,

exacerbated by his growing dread of the second cat. His descent into madness reaches

its peak when he murders his wife, entombing her body within the walls of his house.
However, the authorities, who had been investigating his wife's disappearance,

ultimately discover her corpse, along with the unearthly cries of the second cat

emanating from within the walls.

The narrator confesses his crimes, attributing his downfall to the malevolent

influence of the second cat. The story serves as a chilling exploration of guilt,

obsession, and the descent into madness, with the black cat symbolizing the narrator's

inner demons and the consequences of his actions.

"The Black Cat" is significant within Poe's body of work for several reasons.

Firstly, it explores themes that are recurrent in Poe's stories, such as madness, guilt,

and the macabre. The story delves into the psychological complexities of the human

mind, showcasing Poe's fascination with the darker aspects of the human psyche.

Overall, "The Black Cat" is a quintessential Poe story that encapsulates the

author's thematic preoccupations and narrative techniques, making it a significant and

enduring piece within the context of Poe's oeuvre.

Psychoanalytic criticism is a literary theory that analyzes the psychological

motivations of the characters in a literary work. This approach seeks to uncover the

unconscious desires, fears, and conflicts that shape the characters' behavior and the

events of the story. Psychoanalytic critics often focus on the role of the author's own
psyche in shaping the work and may draw connections between the characters and the

author's personal experiences.

Within Edgar Allan Poe's macabre story, "The Black Cat," the narrator's

harrowing journey into madness is propelled by the interwoven threads of

psychological trauma, the corrosive effects of alcoholism, and the haunting specter of

guilt. Through the symbolic metamorphosis of the black cat, the escalating pattern of

the protagonist's actions, and the inevitable tragedy that unfolds, Poe crafts a narrative

that delves into the darkest corners of the human psyche, unraveling a tale that

transcends conventional horror.

Poe's adept use of symbolism is evident in the transformation of the black cat,

originally a cherished companion, into an ominous symbol of the narrator's unraveling

sanity. The feline's mysterious reappearance and the grotesque alteration of its physical

features become a mirror reflecting the protagonist's descent into moral decay, creating

an atmosphere of psychological terror that lingers throughout the narrative.

The insidious influence of alcoholism becomes a central force, fueling the

protagonist's descent into madness. Poe skillfully portrays the toxic relationship

between the narrator's consumption of alcohol and the exacerbation of his violent

tendencies. The blurred boundaries between reality and the distorted perceptions

induced by intoxication add layers to the psychological horror, highlighting the

corrosive impact of substance abuse on the protagonist's mental state.

 Guilt emerges as a palpable presence, haunting the narrator with increasing

intensity as he grapples with the consequences of his actions. The transgressions

against the black cat and, ultimately, the horrifying murder of his wife serve as

manifestations of the protagonist's moral degradation. Poe invites readers to navigate

the murky waters of the narrator's conscience, blurring the lines between perpetrator

and victim in a psychological dance of horror and remorse.

The progression of the narrator's actions traces a chilling trajectory, showcasing

the deepening darkness within his soul. From the impulsive mutilation of the cat to the

grotesque climax of spousal murder, Poe crafts a narrative arc that intensifies the

horror, emphasizing the inextricable link between the narrator's psychological torment

and the external manifestations of his deteriorating mental state.

The narrative's denouement unfolds as a tragic consequence of the narrator's

descent into madness, with incarceration and the spectral reappearance of the black cat

serving as poetic justice. Poe masterfully concludes the tale, leaving readers with a

lingering sense of unease and a profound contemplation of the destructive forces that

lurk within the human psyche.

Edgar Allan Poe's "The Black Cat" transcends conventional horror, unraveling a

narrative that explores the delicate interplay of psychological trauma, alcoholism, and
guilt. Through rich symbolism, a chilling progression of actions, and a haunting

denouement, Poe invites readers into the shadowy realms of the human mind, leaving

an indelible imprint of the destructive power that lurks within the recesses of the soul.

Analysis of the Narrator's Character

 Description of the narrator's personality traits and behaviors

American writer Edgar Allan Poe is often defined through his literary works

and personal life. Poe frequently adopts a dark and melancholic tone in his writings,

exploring themes of death, despair, and the macabre, which mirror his inner struggles.

Poe is generally known to be an introverted and reserved individual, often

preferring solitude and introspection to express his thoughts and feelings through

writing. His intellect is widely recognized, as he had a broad range of knowledge

through extensive reading in various fields like literature, science, and philosophy.

This intellectual depth is evident in the complexity of his works.

Poe possessed a vivid imagination, allowing him to craft unique and often

surreal stories and poems. His ability to create compelling atmospheres and evoke

strong emotions in readers is a testament to his creative talents. In both his writing and
personal life, Poe displayed a passionate and intense nature, with his love for literature

intertwining with his complicated personal relationships, contributing to the depth of

his work and personal experiences.

Poe's life was marred by tragedy, including the early loss of his parents, the

death of his beloved wife Virginia Clemm, and financial difficulties. These personal

tragedies undoubtedly influenced his writing, contributing to the prevalent themes of

death and loss in his works.

In summary, Edgar Allan Poe was a complex and enigmatic figure known for

his dark and imaginative literary creations, as well as his troubled personal life. His

personality traits and behaviors are often intertwined with the themes that permeate his

iconic works, making him a fascinating and enduring figure in American literature.

 Examination of the narrator's subconscious desires and conflicts

Edgar Allan Poe, the renowned American writer of the 19th century, is often

defined by his literary works and personal experiences. Understanding his

subconscious desires and conflicts requires delving deep into his writings and the

tumultuous events of his life.

Edgar Allan Poe's subconscious desires and conflicts were profoundly shaped

by the personal tragedies he endured throughout his life. Losing his parents at a young

age, the death of his beloved wife, Virginia Clemm, and constant financial struggles
cast a long shadow over his psyche. These experiences manifested in his writings,

often exploring themes of death, loss, and the fragility of human existence.

Poe undeniably harbored a fascination with fear and horror. His keen interest in

the darker aspects of human nature is evident in his tales of murder, madness, and

supernatural occurrences. These narratives often delve into the depths of the human

psyche, pushing the boundaries of morality and sanity. Poe's own inner conflicts found

an outlet in these stories, allowing him to confront the darker corners of his mind.

A recurring theme in Poe's works is guilt and the torment it inflicts upon his

characters. This theme appears to mirror Poe's own inner conflicts and guilt over his

perceived inadequacy in protecting and supporting his loved ones. Characters in his

stories incessantly question themselves, mirroring Poe's introspective nature as he

grappled with the consequences of his own actions and personal failures.

Amidst the darkness of his narratives, Poe's subconscious desires also

encompassed a quest for redemption. Many of his characters, despite being drawn into

the abyss, carry a desire for salvation or atonement. This pursuit of redemption mirrors

Poe's own quest for meaning and solace in the face of personal tragedies. It reflects his

ongoing struggle to reconcile his inner conflicts.

 Edgar Allan Poe's subconscious desires and conflicts are intricately woven into

the fabric of his literary works. His personal tragedies, fascination with fear, guilt,

redemption, and romantic idealism all found expression in his writings. Poe's

exploration of the depths of the human psyche continues to captivate both his own

inner world and readers, inviting us to peer into the enigmatic depths of his

subconscious.

 Discussion of the narrator's defense mechanisms, such as denial and projection

Certainly, "The Black Cat," penned by Edgar Allan Poe, is a renowned short

story that delves into the depths of human psychology while masterfully crafting a

dark narrative atmosphere. It particularly addresses psychological defense mechanisms

such as denial and projection with great finesse.

Denial takes center stage in this narrative. The protagonist initially defines himself as

an animal lover and a virtuous individual who holds a special affection for his black

cat. However, as the story progresses, under the influence of alcohol and the haze of an

undefined internal decay, he ruthlessly kills the black cat and sets his own house on

fire. Despite these horrifying actions, the narrator begins to deny his guilt vehemently.
Instead of confessing to his wrongdoing, he tends to attribute his actions to external

factors or others. This is recognized as a psychological defense mechanism.

Projection is another prominent feature of the protagonist's character. He

engages in projecting his inner turmoil onto the black cat by blaming it and accusing it

of harboring his own inner evil. In reality, the accusations against the cat are

reflections of his own inner darkness. By blaming the cat, he attempts to externalize

his guilt and negative aspects of his own character, thus evading direct confrontation

with his guilty conscience.

Symbolism and Imagery

 Analysis of the symbolism of the black cat

Poe often explored the theme of perversity in his works, referring to the

inexplicable desire to engage in actions that go against one's best interests. The

narrator's mistreatment of the black cat, Pluto, becomes a manifestation of this

perversity, a precursor to his further moral deterioration.

The black cat takes on symbolic significance as a representation of the narrator's

guilt and remorse. The white patch on the cat's chest, resembling a gallows, becomes a

haunting reminder of the narrator's culpability. The narrator attempts to escape the cat,

but its reappearance underscores the inescapable nature of guilt.

 In psychoanalytic terms, the black cat can be seen as a manifestation of the

narrator's unconscious mind. Its reappearance after being walled up in the cellar

symbolizes the return of repressed guilt and the narrator's inability to suppress the

darker aspects of his own psyche.

The second black cat that mysteriously appears, nearly identical to Pluto but with a

distinctive mark on its fur, can be interpreted as a doppelgänger. This symbolizes the

narrator's inability to escape his own actions and the inevitable consequences of his

moral decay.

The black cat serves as a tool to highlight the unreliability of the narrator's account.

The narrator attributes the cat's transformation and reappearance to supernatural

forces, adding a layer of ambiguity to the narrative. The cat becomes a symbol of the

blurred line between reality and the narrator's distorted perceptions.

The mutilation and ultimate killing of the black cat symbolize the narrator's descent

into violence and cruelty. The cat becomes a canvas upon which the narrator projects

his inner turmoil, and its mistreatment becomes a reflection of the narrator's moral

deterioration.
 The reappearance of the black cat in the final scenes of the story can be seen as a

symbol of fate and justice. It becomes an avenging force, exposing the narrator's

crimes and sealing his tragic fate. The cat, with its association to superstition, serves as

an instrument of cosmic justice.

In The Black Cat, Poe skillfully employs the symbolism of the black cat to enrich

the narrative, infusing it with layers of meaning related to guilt, psychological torment,

and the consequences of moral decay. The cat becomes a complex and multifaceted

symbol that adds depth to the exploration of the narrator's troubled mind.

 Examination of the imagery of the narrator's dreams and hallucinations

In Edgar Allan Poe's short story The Black Cat, the imagery of the narrator's

dreams and hallucinations plays a crucial role in portraying the psychological descent

and unraveling sanity of the protagonist. Poe, a master of macabre and psychological

horror, employs vivid and disturbing imagery to delve into the darkest corners of the

narrator's subconscious. Here's an examination of the imagery within the narrator's

dreams and hallucinations:

A recurring image in the narrator's dreams is the white patch on the second black

cat's chest, resembling a gallows. This image serves as a symbolic representation of

the narrator's guilt and foreshadows the cat's role in the tragic events. The gallows

imagery suggests an impending reckoning for the narrator's actions.

The narrator experiences a hallucination in which he sees the image of the cat

hanging on the wall, revealing the depth of his psychological torment. This

hallucinatory vision blurs the line between reality and delusion, portraying the

narrator's increasing inability to distinguish between the tangible and the imagined.

The narrator hears hallucinated screams during the walling-up of his wife. This

auditory hallucination intensifies the horror, creating a chilling and disorienting effect.

The screams echo the psychological torment and internal conflict within the narrator's

disturbed mind.

In a hallucination, the narrator sees the apparition of the second black cat sitting on

the scene of the murder of his wife. This haunting image reinforces the supernatural

element of the story and serves as a manifestation of the narrator's guilt haunting him.

Poe employs the imagery of dreams and hallucinations in The Black Cat to plunge

readers into the disturbed psyche of the narrator. These vivid and unsettling images

serve as a narrative device to explore the themes of guilt, remorse, and the

consequences of moral decay, creating a chilling psychological landscape that lingers

in the reader's mind.

  Discussion of how symbolism and imagery reflect the narrator's inner conflicts

and desires

In Edgar Allan Poe's The Black Cat, the intricate interplay of symbolism and

imagery becomes a psychological tapestry, unraveling the depths of the narrator's inner

conflicts and desires. Each symbolic element and vivid image serves as a mirror

reflecting the profound transformation of the protagonist's psyche.

Initially, Pluto, the black cat, is a symbol of innocence and companionship. The

narrator's affection for the cat represents a connection to morality and decency.

However, as the narrator descends into alcoholism and moral degradation, he mutilates

Pluto, signifying the destruction of his own moral compass. The cat's transformation

becomes a visual metaphor for the narrator's internal corrosion.

The white patch on the second black cat's chest, resembling a gallows, is a

powerful symbol reflecting the narrator's escalating guilt and his subconscious

acknowledgment of impending punishment. This image serves as a psychological

projection, an externalization of the internal conflict between the narrator's desires and

the weight of his conscience.

 The narrator's dreams and hallucinations, filled with spectral and supernatural

elements, provide a window into his tortured psyche. The fiery eyes of the cat and the

haunting apparitions symbolize the narrator's internal demons. These images are not

merely fantastical; they are manifestations of the narrator's guilty conscience, visual

echoes of his deteriorating mental state.

The black cat's persistent return, despite the narrator's attempts to eliminate it,

symbolizes the resilience of guilt. The cat becomes an ever-present reminder, an

external manifestation of the narrator's own sins that refuses to be eradicated. Its

survival echoes the enduring nature of the narrator's internal conflict and the haunting

persistence of remorse.

Poe expertly utilizes auditory and visual symbolism to delve into the narrator's guilt

and moral decay. The exaggerated heartbeat represents his heightened guilt, while the

cat's transformation mirrors his moral descent. These elements combine to create a

haunting exploration of the human psyche, showcasing Poe's mastery of psychological

narrative.

Superego
 In Edgar Allan Poe's The Black Cat, the psychological dynamics of the

narrator's mind can be analyzed through the lens of Sigmund Freud's psychoanalytic

theory, which posits the existence of the id, ego, and superego as components of the

human psyche. In the story, these psychological elements contribute to the unraveling

of the narrator's sanity and the moral degradation he experiences.

The id, representing primal instincts and impulsive desires, is evident in the

narrator's descent into alcoholism and violent behavior. His id-driven actions, such as

mutilating Pluto and later killing his wife, reveal a lack of control over his base desires

and a surrender to destructive impulses.

The narrator's aggression towards the black cat, Pluto, and his ultimate violent

acts can be seen as manifestations of the id's unrestrained energy seeking immediate

gratification, regardless of moral or social consequences.

The ego, which strives to balance the demands of the id and the constraints of

reality, is strained in the narrator's psyche. His attempts to rationalize his actions, such

as blaming the cat for his misfortunes, demonstrate the ego's function of managing

conflicting desires while maintaining a connection to reality.

 The ego employs defense mechanisms, such as denial and projection, to shield

the narrator from the full weight of his guilt. This is evident when he denies any ill will

toward Pluto and projects his own aggression onto the cat.

The superego, representing internalized societal and moral standards, is at odds

with the narrator's actions. As guilt intensifies, the superego attempts to assert control,

leading to heightened anxiety and internal conflict. The white patch on the second cat's

chest, resembling a gallows, serves as a symbolic representation of the superego's

judgment and the anticipation of punishment.

The narrator's descent into violence and cruelty results in a moral condemnation

by the superego. The superego, acting as an internalized moral authority, becomes a

source of anxiety and fear, reflecting the psychological consequences of violating

societal norms.

Throughout the story, the id, ego, and superego engage in a struggle for

dominance. The narrator's actions oscillate between impulsive desires (id) and

attempts at rationalization (ego), while the superego's influence intensifies with the

growing weight of guilt and the fear of impending punishment.

The psychological deterioration of the narrator, marked by hallucinations,

nightmares, and a fragmented narrative, reflects the disintegration of the ego under the
overwhelming influence of the id and the superego. The boundaries between reality

and the unconscious blur, leading to heightened anxiety and fear.

In The Black Cat, Edgar Allan Poe presents a psychological portrait of a

character whose id-driven impulses, ego defenses, and superego judgments clash in a

tumultuous internal struggle. The narrative unfolds as a psychological thriller,

exploring the consequences of an unbalanced psyche and the pervasive fear that arises

from the conflict between primal desires and societal norms.

Conclusion

Edgar Allan Poe's short story The Black Cat offers a compelling exploration of

the complexities of the human psyche, delving into themes of guilt, morality, and the

consequences of unchecked impulses. Through the lens of Freudian psychoanalytic

theory, the narrative becomes a vivid portrayal of the internal struggles faced by the

protagonist as he grapples with his primal instincts, societal norms, and moral

judgments.

Poe's masterful use of symbolism, vivid imagery, and psychological depth

elevates The Black Cat beyond mere horror fiction, transforming it into a thought-

provoking examination of the darker aspects of human nature. The interplay between
the id, ego, and superego within the narrator's psyche serves as a poignant reminder of

the complexities inherent in the human condition, as well as the profound impact of

internal conflict on individual behavior and mental well-being.

Furthermore, The Black Cat continues to resonate with readers today,

highlighting the enduring relevance of Poe's exploration of the human psyche and its

intricacies. By peeling back the layers of the narrator's consciousness, Poe invites

readers to confront their own inner demons and contemplate the universal themes of

guilt, morality, and the consequences of our actions.

In essence, "The Black Cat" stands as a testament to Poe's enduring legacy as a

master of psychological horror, challenging readers to confront the depths of their own

subconscious and consider the profound implications of the human psyche's darkest

recesses.

References

“The Black Cat Summary.” Sparknotes, SparkNotes,

www.sparknotes.com/lit/poestories/section8/. Accessed 21 Feb. 2024.
Reeder, Roberta. “‘ “the Black Cat” as a Study in Repression ,’ Poe Studies, June 1974, Vol.
VII, No. 1, 7:20-22.” Edgar Allan Poe Society of Baltimore - Poe Studies - Poe Studies
- The Black Cat as a Study in Repression,
www.eapoe.org/pstudies/ps1970/p1974104.htm. Accessed 21 Feb. 2024.

The Detailed Analysis of the Black Cat by Edgar Allan Poe In ...,
dergipark.org.tr/tr/download/article-file/992690. Accessed 21 Feb. 2024.

Mehruz, Rasna. “Psychological Analysis of Edgar Allan Poe’s ‘The Black

Cat.’” Academia.Edu, 23 June 2016,
www.academia.edu/26445785/Psychological_Analysis_of_Edgar_Allan_Poes_The_Bla
ck_Cat_.

A Psychoanalysis of Edgar Allan Poe’s Black Cat,

mjajo.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/The-Black-Cat-A-Psychoanalytical-
Approach.pdf. Accessed 21 Feb. 2024.