Catalysts 12 01191 v2 1 3

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 3

catalysts

Article
Insights of Selective Catalytic Reduction Technology for
Nitrogen Oxides Control in Marine Engine Applications
Pierpaolo Napolitano 1 , Leonarda Francesca Liotta 2 , Chiara Guido 1 , Cinzia Tornatore 1, * ,
Giuseppe Pantaleo 2, * , Valeria La Parola 2 and Carlo Beatrice 1

1 Istituto di Scienze e Tecnologie per l’Energia e la Mobilità Sostenibili (STEMS-CNR), Via Marconi 4,
80125 Napoli, Italy
2 Istituto per lo Studio dei Materiali Nanostrutturati (ISMN-CNR), Via Ugo La Malfa 153, 90146 Palermo, Italy
* Correspondence: [email protected] (C.T.); [email protected] (G.P.)

Abstract: The international shipping industry is facing increasingly stringent limitations on nitrogen
oxide (NOx ) emissions. New solutions for reducing NOx emitted by marine engines need to be
investigated to find the best technology. Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) is an advanced active
emissions control technology successfully used in automotive diesel engines; it could be applied to
marine engines with ad-hoc solutions to integrate it in the exhaust of large engines. In this study,
a commercial SCR was tested at the exhaust of a diesel engine in inlet gas conditions typical of a
marine engine. The SCR system consisted of a custom monolith (provided by Hug-Engineering AG)
that enabled seamless integration for a broad range of engine sizes; the active phases were V2 O5
(3 wt%)-WO3 (7 wt%)-TiO2 (75 wt%). The monolith was studied at the laboratory scale for its in-depth
chemical/physical characterization and by means of an intermediate-scale engine, reproducing the
exhaust gas conditions of a full-scale marine engine. The system’s effectiveness in terms of NOx
removal for the selected engine operating conditions was evaluated in a wide range of temperature
Citation: Napolitano, P.; Liotta, L.F.;
and NOx emissions values and for different quantities of the reduction agent (AdBlue or ammonia)
Guido, C.; Tornatore, C.; Pantaleo, G.;
added to exhaust gases. The investigated technological solution resulted in efficient NOx emission
La Parola, V.; Beatrice, C. Insights of
control from a marine engine.
Selective Catalytic Reduction
Technology for Nitrogen Oxides
Control in Marine Engine
Keywords: extruded monolith; V2 O5 -WO3 -TiO2 ; SCR; ammonia; marine engine
Applications. Catalysts 2022, 12, 1191.
https://doi.org/10.3390/
catal12101191
1. Introduction
Academic Editor: Zhaoyang Fan
Marine diesel engines have always used heavy fuel oil, a poor-quality fuel that con-
Received: 2 September 2022 tains a high concentration of sulfur; therefore, among the pollutants produced, sulfur
Accepted: 5 October 2022 oxides (SOx) are of great importance, together with nitrogen oxides (NOx ) and particulate
Published: 8 October 2022 matter (PM) [1]. Nitrogen oxides have a major impact on air pollution. They can damage
Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral the human respiratory system, promote secondary organic aerosols, acid rain and haze
with regard to jurisdictional claims in photochemical smog and contribute to ozone depletion [2]. NOx emissions from marine
published maps and institutional affil- engines have been recently taken into consideration by the Tier III standards of the Interna-
iations. tional Maritime Organization (IMO), introduced on January, 1st 2016 (MARPOL Annex VI).
These regulations require an 80% reduction in NOx emissions compared to Tier I, and they
apply in selected sea areas called “NOx Emission Control Areas (N-ECAs)” that comprise
the coastal waters of the United States and Canada, the North Sea and the Baltic Sea. In
Copyright: © 2022 by the authors. addition to the IMO conventions, other maritime organizations such as the United States’
Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. Environment Protection Agency (EPA), the European Union and the Chinese Ministry of
This article is an open access article
Environmental Protection have also established maritime regulations for the reduction in
distributed under the terms and
exhaust emissions [3].
conditions of the Creative Commons
Exhaust gas aftertreatment devices can efficiently remove pollutants from internal
Attribution (CC BY) license (https://
combustion (IC) engines’ exhausts without a penalty in engine power and fuel economy.
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/
Among them, selective catalytic reduction (SCR) systems are widely adopted in road
4.0/).

Catalysts 2022, 12, 1191. https://doi.org/10.3390/catal12101191 https://www.mdpi.com/journal/catalysts


Catalysts 2022, 12, 1191 2 of 18

applications for effectively reducing NOx . SCRs can operate as a standalone technology;
they show high levels of reliability and durability, and they do not require major engine
modifications. This technology includes an injection of urea water into the exhaust gas;
taking advantage of the exhaust gas heat, ammonia (NH3 ) is produced through urea
thermal decomposition. NH3 reacts with NOx on a catalyst to convert NOx into molecular
nitrogen (N2 ) and water (H2 O). The main global reactions occurring in a SCR are presented
in Table 1.

Table 1. Main global reactions occurring in an SCR.

NOx Reduction Reactions Undesirable Oxidation Reactions


(a) 4NO + 4NH3 + O2 → 4N2 + 6H2 O (d) 4NH3 + 5O2 → 4NO + 6H2 O
(b) 6NO2 + 8NH3 → 7N2 + 12H2 O (e) 4NH3 + 3O2 → 2N2 + 6H2 O
(c) NO + NO2 + 2NH3 → 2N2 + 3H2 O (f) 2NH3 + 2O2 → N2 O + 3H2 O
(g) SO2 + 1/2O2 → SO3

Reaction (a) represents the overall stoichiometry of the SCR process; it occurs rapidly
in the presence of catalysts when the temperature is between 250 and 450 ◦ C and oxygen is
in excess. Usually, NO2 concentration at the exhaust is very low (only 5% of the NOx ), so
reactions (b) and (c) play a minor role in the process.
As for the undesired oxidation reactions, those indicated with the letters d-f involve
NH3 consumption and determine a reversal of NOx removal and the formation of N2 O as
a by-product. These reactions can take place on SCR catalysts when the feed is low in NO,
but they are negligible in the presence of NOx .
Ammonia has been chosen as reducing agent in the SCR process due to its capability
to selectively react with NOx in excess of oxygen. This property is not observed in other
simple reagents such as hydrocarbons and carbon monoxide. Reaction (g) is the oxidation
of SO2 , responsible for the formation of salts such as ammonium sulfate [4].
The core of the SCR technology is the catalyst system that has the role of improving
the reaction efficiency by decreasing the activation energy and reaction temperature of NOx
decomposition, increasing N2 selectivity in NOx reduction products and preventing the
incidence of side reactions. Selecting the appropriate catalysts is critical when designing an
SCR; its main characteristics should be high deNOx activity, strong anti-poisoning ability,
high mechanical strength and a suitable operating temperature range [5]. Many catalysts
have been demonstrated to be effective in SCR reactions. Noble and transition metal oxides
are the primary active components, with TiO2 , Al2 O3 , SiO2 , zeolite and carbon serving as
carriers.
For low- and medium-speed marine engines, SCR technology is derived from power
plant systems using diesel engines. While ammonia water can be used in power plants as a
reducing agent, larger ships only use urea water solutions [6] for safety and storage reasons.
The size of the urea–SCR system can also be an issue; the SCR urea consumption is estimated
to be 8.5% of the diesel consumption [7]; this undoubtedly adds size and weight to the
ship. Furthermore, the vibration resistance of urea tubes should be carefully considered.
Pumping and dosing systems, as well as urea feed pipes, use welding connections whenever
possible to avoid urea leaks [8].
Furthermore, the main challenges for marine SCR applications are low temperature
sulfur resistance and low temperature activation. The latter issue is also a problem for cars,
trucks and off-road applications and can result in the catalyst not working, for example
at startup and during maneuvering [9]. In marine engines, the turbine downstream tem-
peratures are generally below 150 ◦ C, making catalytic exhaust gas treatment impossible.
For this reason, the SCR catalyst is usually placed on top of the turbocharger close to the
engine to allow the highest possible temperature for an efficient NOx conversion and to
avoid the formation of ammonium sulfates. In this case, the system is called high-pressure
SCR (HP-SCR) and it is mostly used for two-stroke low-speed diesel engines. HP-SCR
is characterized by a compact layout and high exhaust gas energy utilization rate, but it
Catalysts 2022, 12, 1191 3 of 18

has a significant impact on the working performance of diesel engines and turbocharg-
ers. Conversely, an SCR arranged after the turbocharger is referred to as low-pressure
SCR (LP-SCR). This system has high adaptability and a lower impact on the engine and
turbocharger but its denitration efficiency is inadequate for low-speed two-stroke diesel
engines because of the low exhaust temperatures. For this reason, an exhaust gas heating
device is usually installed before the SCR reactor [10]. In the frame of the above literature,
it emerges that the investigation of NO SCR catalysts for marine applications and the issues
related to on-board installation deserve further efforts. Some numerical investigations have
recently been performed to predict the denitration efficiency, ammonia flow rate and other
parameters of SCR systems for marine applications [11,12]; less effort has been made for
experimental studies.
Most catalysts for marine SCRs are V2 O5 –WO3 –TiO2 -based; vanadium and tungsten
oxides coated on a titanium substrate [13]. V2 O5 is the active component (1–3%), which is
usually impregnated on an anatase TiO2 support together with WO3 (~10%) to stabilize the
vanadia and increase thermal durability. The typical maximum NOx conversion range is
between ~250 ◦ C and ~450–500 ◦ C. Above this temperature, selectivity is reduced because
NH3 is oxidized by O2 instead of reacting with NO [14]. A V2 O5 –WO3 –TiO2 SCR is
commonly used as a stationary catalyst, but it has not been commercialized for vehicles due
vanadium toxicity. Conversely, this type of SCR catalyst is appropriate for ships because of
its high light-off efficiency, good sulfur resistance and low cost, so its demand in the market
has increased.
It is worth noting that zeolite-based catalysts can also be effective in catalytic exhaust
gas aftertreatment systems because they are characterized by a high specific surface area
and thermal stability. In recent years, many studies have improved the de-NOx performance
and durability of Cu-zeolite catalysts that show excellent low temperature activity [15–18].
Fe-zeolite has great durability toward high temperature and poisoning; thus, it can be
successfully used in after-treatment catalysts for heavy-duty diesel engines even if it shows
a high activation energy, causing low light-off performance.
Some researchers have compared V2 O5 –WO3 –TiO2 catalysts [19] with two kinds of
Fe-zeolite (Fe-zeolite (1) and (2)). Their physicochemical characteristics were examined
according to hydrothermal aging, sulfur poisoning and HCs co-existence. The results
showed that V2 O5 –WO3 –TiO2 SCR was the least susceptible to sulfur poisoning because of
Brønsted acid site effects and its NOx conversion rate was relatively higher at ~350 ◦ C. It
resulted in being the most suitable for the reduction in exhaust gas from ship engines.
Magnusson et al. [12] investigated how sulfur, water and low temperature affect
NOx the reduction activity of a commercial SCR V2 O5 –WO3 –TiO2 catalyst in marine
applications using urea as a reducing agent. The authors proved that for temperatures
higher than 300 ◦ C, NOx reduction could be greater than 90%. Japke et al. [20] tested
the performance of vanadia-based SCR catalysts obtained using the incipient wetness
impregnation method. The study demonstrated that the preparation process had a strong
effect on the catalyst’s NOx removal efficiency with ammonia and on the oxidation activity
of soot and hydrocarbons. Zhou et al. [21] studied the catalytic activities of an extruded
commercial monolithic V2 O5 –WO3 –TiO2 catalyst at low temperatures according to the
working characteristics of marine diesel engines. The authors reported that for temperature
below 150 ◦ C, the SCR reaction was mostly influenced by internal chemical reaction kinetics,
and when the temperature was above 200 ◦ C, the most relevant mechanism affecting the
SCR reaction was the reactant diffusion rate. The parameters that can improve NOx
reduction were found to be space velocity, NH3 consumption and O2 /NO2 concentration
in the gas mixture.
Recently, Lai et al. [22] and Zhang in collaboration with some authors of the present
paper [23] have pointed out that the catalyst’s preparation method, the titania surface
area and crystalline structure, the vanadium and tungsten loadings and the calcination
treatments strongly affect the morphological, structural, acidic properties and NO SCR
performance.