Role of Artificial Lighting in Emphasizing The Entrance Approach
Role of Artificial Lighting in Emphasizing The Entrance Approach
Role of Artificial Lighting in Emphasizing The Entrance Approach
September 2020
Part of the Architecture Commons, Arts and Humanities Commons, Education Commons, and the
Engineering Commons
Recommended Citation
Youssef, Maged (2020) "ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE
APPROACHES," Architecture and Planning Journal (APJ): Vol. 26: Iss. 2, Article 3.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.54729/2789-8547.1041
ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE APPROACHES
Abstract
Building's entrance is metaphorically a threshold between two realms, the first is an outdoor exposed
to climatic change, hazards, and environmental factors, while the second is controlled, monitored, and
determined to certain functions. It plays an important role in enriching users' experience. Moreover, it is
the first impression a visitor takes to evaluate a whole building. Architecturally, the entrance is a very
special part in the elevation, distinguished and emphasized by different design approaches. One of these
approaches is using lighting. There is a direct connection between recognition of a space and light
assimilation in it. From sunset to dawn, the artificial lighting plays a role in drawing attention to texture,
colours, and forms of external elevations, which supports architecture to achieve its purpose. This paper
sheds the light on the problem of architects' failure to manage an entrance perception due to insufficient
light integration, over illumination, or weak transition from space to another. Many architects consider the
entrance as a challenging task, because they believe that it has a direct impact on visitors' perception. This
paper, therefore, aims to propose design methods to emphasize the entrance of buildings at night through
using the proper artificial lighting. To achieve this aim, the paper used a scientific methodology, based on
tracing literature review about design of entrances, investigating ideas of entrances' emphasis, and then
analysing four case studies trying to identify the different design approaches of their entrances and how
the location, direction, and intensity of illumination became a part of their nocturnal architectural elevation.
As a conclusion, techniques of lighting entrances contribute in perceiving architecture’s true purpose and
raise the aesthetic dimension of the building at night.
Keywords
Entrance Approach, Architectural Design, Artificial Light, Nocturnal Architecture, Transition, Perception
1. INTRODUCTION
A title to a book is what an entrance approach is to a
project; a golden key into the building. The circulation starts with
the outdoor environment and the entrance that leads users inside.
An architect can choose one out of the wild variety of the
approaches that construct an entrance and its path. These types
include frontal, oblique, and spiral geometrical approaches in
addition to the approaches of the different types of entrances.
Emphasizing the entrance is applied through choosing different
materials, colours, sizes, dimensions, and lights to construct a
flushed, projected or a recessed one. Particularly focusing on the
lights chosen for an entrance, this research discusses the various
deviations it can impact an entrance through. Light is a portion of
an electromagnetic spectrum that can be perceived by human eyes
where the wavelength ranges between 380 and 780 nm. The light
is either natural or artificial, and both types of light fit through
architecture. The delightful effect of light adds to the project as
links between space perception and the way light integrates with
and enters this space. It also enhances the objects and elements put Fig.1: Entrance approach
in the entrance and space. Once a person steps into the space, or showing direction and guidance
passes by through walking by the street, the light used gives an at MTY House, San Pedro
impression to what this person might see or discover inside this Garza García, Mexico.
building and predict its function. Architects use the lighting to Source: www.Archdaily.com
show rhythm or make the building feel as if flying for instance. Furthermore, the direction of lights
to the objects alters spaces and changes the feelings of people towards this particular entrance
(Waldman, 2002). Architects may face a challenge of how to affect a visitor’s perception through
lighting the entrance. This paper sheds the light on the problem of architects' failure to manage an
entrance perception due to insufficient light integration, over illumination, or weak transition from
space to another. Several buildings around the world have extraordinary form aesthetics, values, and
even high function efficiency, but unfortunately their architects miss-handled the proper design
approaches of entrances, neglecting the role of artificial light in emphasizing the buildings'
entrances. As shown in figure 1, a building's entrance can be emphasized through using certain
types of lighting.
This research aims to propose the proper design methods through a checklist of lighting units’
intensities and its emphasis on the entrance. The proposed hypothesis suggests that the external
lighting whether artificial or natural at an entrance and the path preceding has the main role in
determining what is inside and how this building functions. In order to achieve the mentioned aim,
this paper follows a scientific methodology, based on a desk-work method to introduce a literature
review about the design of building's entrance, its approaches, tools, and giving similar examples of
using artificial light in entrances. Then the paper concludes certain parameters of analysis to be used
in analysing four case studies; two of them are (local) - Lebanese - and the other two are
international. Respectively, these case studies are:
To support these analyses, the author used a field method by visiting the two local case
studies, captured photographs, and held interviews with users of these projects. Analysing these
case studies targeted identifying different design approaches of entrances and recognizing how the
location, direction, and intensity of the artificial light became a part of the architectural elevation at
night time.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
-Le Corbusier
-Thomas Fuller
The literature review depicts previous architectural attempts of designing an approach and
what architects, experts, and pioneers have said about the matter. Then, it will give a historical
background on the entrance approach emphasis and offer some examples where lighting was used
to emphasize this aspect. Previous practices of using light in architecture have shown its importance
and several advantages. When the right lighting is used effectively in areas heavily used by people,
such as doorways and bus stops, they feel safer for all kinds of users. Moreover, lighting an area
properly draws attention to its uniqueness and historical value if any. Using the right kind of light
can create a sense of drama depending on its intensity, brightness and color (Martin, 2019).
According to previous readings, one of the important articles tackled the topic of nocturnal
architecture. This article explained how the external light can change the perception of the outer
elevation of a building. It indicated that certain typologies of architectural projects can employ the
external light to draw a nocturnal image for their users (Nikoudel, F., Mahdavinejad, M., &
Vazifehdan, J., 2018). Other articles focused on clarifying the role of artificial light in the internal
spaces and studied its effect on users, function, and design efficiency. As an extension to such
studies, this paper concentrates on the entrance-approaches of buildings and tries to formulate
proper design methods to emphasize entrances through using artificial light. The literature review
therefore introduces firstly the definition of entrance approach, presents a historical background of
emphasizing the entrance-approach, explains its different geometrical types and ideas, and then
highlights examples of buildings used light in their entrance approaches.
https://digitalcommons.bau.edu.lb/apj/vol26/iss2/3
DOI: 10.54729/2789-8547.1041 2
Youssef: ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE APPROACH
Speer was professional in representing feelings of strength, power, and fear through
implanting spots of artificial light in the bottom of elevations and entrances in particular. He
employed these spotlights to embed the Nazi ideology of domination and control in all
surroundings. After a while, architectural design in the periods ranging from 1950s to 1960s
relied heavily on natural lighting by allowing large opening of fenestration with no further
consideration for artificial lighting. This focus on many openings created problems like
overhearing and uncomfortable period. In the post-modernist era of the 1970s, design changed
to focus on small openings that made interiors gloomy, but were contradicted by innovative
practices by architects like James Stirling, whose buildings had functional and environmental
problems but where preferred by users
(Mansfield, 2017). After that, lighting
research started going into a more
environmental approach by taking into
consideration factors such as energy
efficiency and overturning the uniformity
of lighting provision and pushing for
more variety lighting. These
developments were paralleled by
emerging projects in Germany in 1990s
after the collapse of the Berlin-Wall by
signature architects’ work like Norman
Foster’s Reichstag project that employed
innovative employment of natural an
artificial lighting design. New projects
like that in cities with an already existing
urban fabric and eventful history pushed
designers to think of how to emphasize
their work and make it stand out yet
remain respectful to its context. The
necessity for considering environmental Fig.3: Assessing flow of light through vector
considerations like energy saving also Source: Adapted from Cuttle
pushed designers to design considering
sufficient use of natural light during the day to save energy and use artificial lighting at night to
showcase what is important for the project’s typology and users’ comfort, thus focusing on the
building’s entrance approach as it is the project’s first impression by users. Scientific lighting
research joined by design considerations for architects also dictated the intensity of light used
as expressed in the following diagram, shown in figure 3 (Mansfield, 2017).
https://digitalcommons.bau.edu.lb/apj/vol26/iss2/3
DOI: 10.54729/2789-8547.1041 4
Youssef: ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE APPROACH
Thus, an architect can distinguish the entrance through making it different in size,
scale, volume, height, width, pattern, or even architectural style than the other parts of the
elevation.
2.4.7 Canopy
The canopy extended over the building’s entrance gives significance and
importance to the entrance and attracts passers to visit the building. As shown as in figure
12, a canopy can be static or kinetic, according to the function of the building, and its
environmental treatment.
described by the architect, the use of red light in the canopy aims to appear:
- Radiant; showing the brightness of the
staggering of the canopy elements at
different elements.
- Graphic; underlines the folds reflected in the
lower windows, emphasizing the effect of a
suspended staggered veil.
- Dynamic; Disturbing the regularity of the
facade by a vibration of the light to
deconstruct the drawing of the canopy. Fig.14: Galleries Elevation.
Source: ArchDaily
https://digitalcommons.bau.edu.lb/apj/vol26/iss2/3
DOI: 10.54729/2789-8547.1041 8
Youssef: ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE APPROACH
Light Units’
Finishing Light Units’ Colour of Color Entrance
Type of Light Location at
Materials Illuminance Light Temperature Approach
the entrance
3. METHODOLOGY
This paper tackles two topics: the lighting design and its emphasis on the entrance approach.
To achieve the previous mentioned aim, it depends on four research methods; the inductive method,
the analytical Method, the field method, and the comparative-analytical method. The first one was
used to gather data about the selected case studies, depending on reading a variety of sources,
providing images and necessary drawings and diagrams to enhance the explanation. The second was
used to analyse this data, and represented it in sort of diagrams and charts. The third was a personal
author experience in visiting two case studies in Lebanon, taking photographs and making
interviews with projects' users. The fourth method was used essentially to compare between the case
studies according to the parameters of analysis, mentioned in table 1.
In this context, the study uses these parameters in analysing the case studies, which were
selected according to certain criteria. There criteria of selection were:
- Diverse functions, locations, and target users
- Completed projects within the last ten years
- Having emphasis on the entrance approach
- Different finishing materials
- Diverse types of lighting light units' specifications such as illuminace and colour temperature.
Fig.16: Cluster-H-the-Backyard.
Source: Photo of İeva Saudargaitė
(a) Sketch showing (b) Sketch showing natural (c) Sketch showing artificial light
natural light on Entrance light on Axis of Movement on Entrance Approach
Approach
Based on the parameters concluded in table 1, the case study will be analysed detecting
these parameters one by one as follows:
https://digitalcommons.bau.edu.lb/apj/vol26/iss2/3
DOI: 10.54729/2789-8547.1041 10
Youssef: ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE APPROACH
Perception of Light
https://digitalcommons.bau.edu.lb/apj/vol26/iss2/3
DOI: 10.54729/2789-8547.1041 12
Youssef: ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE APPROACH
After experiencing this project and detecting the important role of artificial light in
emphasizing its entrance approach, the paper continues analysing the second case study as
follows…
3.2 Case Study Two: A. MUSE.UM / Nadim Karam+ Atelier Hapsitus, 2019
Project Title: A.MUSE.UM.
Date of Opening: 2019.
Architect: Nadim Karam + Atelier Hapsitus.
Location: Daroun, Lebanon.
Located in the villages of Daroun, architect/artist Nadim Karam placed his atelier in
order to reflect, create, and experiment. It is placed in between the landscape works in front of
his own traditional Lebanese stone family residence (Karam, 2019).
3.2.1 Type of light
The Atelier lighting was under
the supervision of Highlights SAL that
provided consultation about the lighting
used. Since the project is located in
between the landscape contour lines,
LED lights were used to emphasize the
approach given directly to the entrance,
shown in figure 23. Moreover, the LED
lights used among the project directly
Fig.23: Nadim Karam + Atelier Hapsitus 2019
give emphasis to the stairs located on
Source: ArchDaily Website
the roof of the Atelier that lead to the
traditional family residence house
(Karam, 2019). It is important to note that natural light has a direct link to the entrance in
which it has a direct visual connection with exploring space inside, shown in figs 24 &
25.
Fig.26: Plan
Source: ArchDaily Website with analysis of the author
Illuminated Pathway
https://digitalcommons.bau.edu.lb/apj/vol26/iss2/3
DOI: 10.54729/2789-8547.1041 14
Youssef: ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE APPROACH
After experiencing this project and detecting the important role of artificial light in
emphasizing its entrance approach, the paper continues analysing the third case study as
follows…
3.3 Case Study Three: OCT Shenzhen Clubhouse/ Richard Meier& Partners, 2012
Project Title: OCT Shenzhen Clubhouse
Date of Opening: 2012.
Architect: Richard Meier & Partners
Location: Shenzhen, Hong Kong
Sited on a prominent island in the middle of the
OCT harbor lake, the 118,400 sf OCT Shenzhen
Clubhouse consists of two buildings occupying an
artificial island on the southern edge of Shenzhen, a
waterfront financial center north of Hong Kong. The
Clubhouse provides a quiet oasis for guests and
members with a restaurant, a multi-purpose area, as
well as recreational facilities, a fitness center and a
small exhibition gallery (Meier, 2012).
Fig.28: The entrance
approach of OCT Clubhouse
in Shenzhen
https://digitalcommons.bau.edu.lb/apj/vol26/iss2/3
DOI: 10.54729/2789-8547.1041 16
Youssef: ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE APPROACH
Fig.33: The different color saturations of artificial light - Source: Larsen, 2017
After experiencing this project and detecting the important role of artificial light in
emphasizing its entrance approach, the paper continues analysing the fourth case study as
follows…
https://digitalcommons.bau.edu.lb/apj/vol26/iss2/3
DOI: 10.54729/2789-8547.1041 18
Youssef: ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE APPROACH
After experiencing this project and detecting the important role of artificial light in
emphasizing its entrance approach, the paper may hold an analytical comparison between
the case studies as follows …
From this table, the paper may reach to certain findings as follows…
4. FINDINGS
According to the previous analyses, the four case studies shared using LED lights as they are
environmentally responsible choices being both cost-efficient and energy-efficient signifying a
positive awareness by the architects while executing their projects. They took advantage of natural
light in their designs. All project installed floor-mounted lighting units to guide users through the
approach to the entrance and at the project’s entrance door. However, only project with an irregular
massing like The Backyard and OCT Clubhouse where were the architects used wall-mounted lights
to emphasize the different planes and shapes for users to enjoy the experience at night. Both of
these cases also integrated light with water elements to give a further dramatic approach and
journey for users.
As for light Units’ luminance, the degree differs depending on the typology of the project and
usage. In the OCT Shenzhen Clubhouse natural light was used to generate a specific spectrum of
time for the user and special artificial lighting was restricted to the entrance approach and
emphasizing its special features. Besides, in The Backyard and the Maina Headquarters are using
strong luminance light sources to give a cheerful effect on the users. While the A.MUSE.UM uses
low light luminance around the museum space to give the importance on the art that displayed
rather than the space itself. Strong luminance treatments were for users approaching the new
museum and the old building.
https://digitalcommons.bau.edu.lb/apj/vol26/iss2/3
DOI: 10.54729/2789-8547.1041 20
Youssef: ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE APPROACH
Warm light colours are heavily used in the projects OCT Shenzhen, A.MUSE.UM and the
Maina Headquarters to give a calming cosy feeling and enough significance for the project’s
function, while the Backyard used both warm and cool colours so that they give exciting effect by
showing the contrast. This difference showed a maturity of using the colours across different years.
The temperature differs from a project depending on the type of the zones, from exterior into the
interior in the project where it varies from cool to warm at close degrees.
5. DISCUSSION
Consequently, it is agreed that the supposed hypothesis that the external artificial lighting at
the entrance could hint at the building's internal purpose. This paper followed a research
methodology that began by describing the entrance approach with a thorough literature review
explaining the history and ways of highlighting the entry into a building. The appropriate design of
lighting joined by of meticulously using various materials, different colors, sizes and lengths and
adding some structural elements or ornamentation may be used to highlight the entrance. The
literature review also depicted previous light design attempts around the entrance and what
architects, experts, and pioneers have said about the entrance approach throughout different time
periods. Lighting is used for geographic orientations as lit focal points such as for major buildings
and bridges as light can the ability to emphasize the significance of a place and provide safety. The
first stage of the circulation system of a building is the path that always starts at the entrance
approach of the building. In brief, light plays an important role in emphasizing building and
building entrances through different methods. Each of type of light units, their location, color,
illumination and temperature play a vital part in how users perceive building’s approach. Each of
the above examples discussed above shows the importance each of the following characteristics
implies in different ways, whether in their presence or in their absence. Exterior artificial lighting in
a project either provides illumination for the entirety of it or it highlights specific elements
depending on the building’s typology and architect’s intentions. Tracking lighting is the perfect
example of positional lighting. The shown table concludes a proposal for the proper design methods
to emphasize the entrance approaches as follows:
Table 4: Proposed design methods to emphasize entrance approaches in different building typologies
Note: This table is a theoretical proposal for using certain architectural elements to emit artificial lighting to emphasize
entrance approaches on certain typologies of buildings
Proper Architectural Function of
Ideas to Emphasize Entrance Elements in Entrance A. L. in
Building Typology
Approaches Approaches to emit Artificial Entrance
Light
- Heighten the entrance remarkably, - In the high-class residential
artificial light, different materials, buildings, bright lighting Decoration &
Villas units can be fixed on or under
different style, water & landscape Security
canopies, beyond curtain
features
walls, over structural
- Frontal piazza, remarkable height, elements at the entrance, light Decoration &
Palaces different materials, artificial light, can be directed towards Security
water, & landscape features landscape, texture, pattern,
Residential - Decorative entrance, artificial light, crown of the entrance. Attraction &
Buildings Hotels different colours, different - In the middle and low class Entertainment
materials, & canopies residential buildings,
- Intimate scale, porch, different horizontal lighting units can Functionality
Houses colours, different materials, be fixed under the entrance & Security
artificial light, landscape elevation. Dim lighting can
- Intimate scale, colourful entrance, be fixed over the entrance.
Landscape elements can be Functionality
Orphanages soft surface materials, & artificial
functioned to emit light on & Security
light
the entrance.
https://digitalcommons.bau.edu.lb/apj/vol26/iss2/3
DOI: 10.54729/2789-8547.1041 22
Youssef: ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE APPROACH
According to these proposed design methods, architects can enrich users' experience, which
raises buildings' values and aesthetic dimension. Through using simple architectural and landscape
elements, sources can highlight a halo of light on users during their entering a building. From table
4, functions of artificial light in entrances are diverse according to the building typology. This paper
did not concern with the electrical information regarding the wattage of lamps, type of lamps, and
wiring system, while it focused on the design methods to emphasize the entrances using the
artificial light from a theoretical perspective not technical one. As mentioned, methods vary
between suspending sources of light from the ceiling, adjusting necks and lamps to be pointed at
specific items. Consider mounting them on the walls, also. Special picture and mirror frames also
have built-in lighting to highlight specific areas on a wall. Recessed lighting can be used in floors
and ceilings to create vertical beams of light as opposed to an overall glow from central light
fixtures hanging from a ceiling. Lighting needs to serve a purpose, and in every case study
mentioned in the both natural and man-made lighting help with the illusion of space and for every
type, colour, intensity, a new feeling arouses. The way in which a designer incorporates lighting
into their project helps shape the mood of the user of the space as it has a great impact on their and
perception and user experience. Employing good lighting can increase the brightness of a space and
create ideal mood sets. The right lighting helps in adding elegance, sophistication and style to any
project.
6. CONCLUSION
Upon completion of the study, this paper has arrived at the determination that applying the
used research methodology was important to fulfil the required aim. By studying the cadenced
examples of light, rhythmic patterns, their points and forms, their temperatures and colours, the
study was able to gain an understanding of how it cooperates with individuals and their everyday
rhythms, their realistic space requirements, and the essential physical treatment of space to promote
the best impact for each space. As a result of the research, it has been discovered that in spite of the
fact that the target for the task began as an effort to preserve a good physical link between man and
https://digitalcommons.bau.edu.lb/apj/vol26/iss2/3
DOI: 10.54729/2789-8547.1041 24
Youssef: ROLE OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING IN EMPHASIZING THE ENTRANCE APPROACH
light, in spots where this relationship is as strong, the designer has to find elective strategies to
preserve an advantageous interaction. The following points offer some guidelines for emerging
designers approaching the lighting design of a building’s entrance.
• Showing a beneficial use for illustrating the person's inherent interaction with rhythmic light.
• The approach to the building is clear to visitors and tourists throughout the day and night.
• The lighting should help people understand the function of a building.
• Different safety and weather protection must be taken into consideration.
• Different types of arrangements can be used to perceive different approaches.
• Lighting must distinct between exterior and interior spaces.
• Different elements can be used with lighting to emphasize a building’s approach like
landscaping.
Eventually, techniques of lighting entrances contribute in perceiving architecture’s true
purpose and increase the aesthetic dimension of the building at night.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The author would like to thank the architects who thought out side of the box to employ
artificial light in emphasizing entrance approaches, which eases accessibility of users. In addition, a
full gratitude and appreciation to the Lebanese architects Ms. Rayan Namro and Ms. Ghina
Kanawaty who cooperated in editing parts of this paper.
REFERENCES
− Caballero, P. (2019). A.MUSE.UM / Nadim Karam + Atelier Hapsitus. Retrieved from
− Ching, F. D. K. (2014). Architecture: Form, Space, and Order. London: Wiley, 4th Edition
− Chudinova, V. G. (2017). Modern Role of Architectural Style Category in Russian Practice. IOP
Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, Vol. 262, International Conference on
Construction, Architecture, and Technosphere Safety, pp. 21-22
− Crafti, S. (2015). Architecture: entrance ways that create a strong first impression. Financial
Review Magazine, Issue of 19 July, 2015.
− Grieco, L. (2012). Richard Meier Architects: OCT Shenzhen clubhouse now complete. Design
Boom Magazine, Issue of Sep. 04, 2012.
− Hesson, R. (2019). History - Artificial Lighting. Blog: Northern Architecture. Retrieved from
doi.org/10.1177/1477153517736803
− Karam, N. (2019). A.MUSE.UM. The official website of the architect Nadim Karam:
www.nadimkaram.com
− Larsen, R. S. (2017). A world of lighting: What is colour temperature? Lumega
− Mallat, B. (2016). Cluster H – The Backyard. The official website of Bernard Mallat Architects
- Mansfield, K. P. (2018). Architectural lighting design: A research review over 50 years. Lighting
Research & Technology, 50(1), 80-97.
− Martin, O. J. (2019). When light explores space and time. Advanced Photonics, 1(5), 050501.
− Meier, R. (2012). OCT Shenzhen Clubhouse. The official website of Richard Meier & Partners
Architects LLP.
− Nikoudel, F., Mahdavinejad, M., & Vazifehdan, J. (2018). Nocturnal Architecture Of Buildings:
Interaction Of Exterior Lighting And Visual Beauty. Light & Engineering, 26(1).
− Simes, S.P. A. (2018). Maina Headquarter: L’accento Della Luce Sull’ Architettura.
Lightblogazine-Simes
− Waldman, G. (2002). Introduction to Light: The Physics of Light, Vision, and Color. Dover
Publications.
− Weller, C. (2016). A haunting look back at the Nazis' most famous architecture. Business
Insider, retrieved from www.businessinsider.com
− www.archdaily.com