Water in Permaculture - Pamphlet XI - Page 1.

XI
WATER IN PERMACULTURE
BY BILL MOLLISON
Pamphlet XI in the Permaculture Design Course Series
Edited from Transcript of the Permaculture Design Course,
The Rural Education Center, Wilton NH USA, 1981

PUBLISHED BY

YANKEE PERMACULTURE
Publisher and Distributor of Permaculture Publications
P.O. Box 52, Sparr FL 32192-0052 USA
Email: Y a n k e e P e r m @ a o l . c o m
http://barkingfrogspc.tripod.com/frames.html
or
http://www.permaculture.net/~EPTA/Hemenway.htm

These pamphlets have been placed in the public domain. Reproduction is free to all and is encouraged. Credit to Yankee Per-
maculture is appreciated. Contact Yankee permaculture for a list of other permaculture publications. Please send us transla-
tions of these pamphlets into other languages.
 This is the eleventh in a series of 15 pamphlets based on the 1981 Permaculture Design
Course given by Bill Mollison at The Rural Education Center, Wilton, New Hampshire, USA.
Elizabeth Beyor, without compensation, undertook the transcription of tape recordings
of the course and subsequent editing of the transcripts into 15 pamphlets. Thelma Snell
produced the original typescript for all pamphlets in this series and Lisa Barnes drew il-
lustrations for some pamphlets, including this one, again without compensation. Later,
Meara Culligan entered the text to computer disk. I have lightly edited this pamphlet for
readability. In deference to the monumental task of love represented by Bill's assembly
of the Permaculture Design Course, and by the subsequent volunteer efforts leading to
this pamphlet, Yankee Permaculture has placed it in the public domain. The reproduction
of is free to all and highly encouraged.
Translations of a few pamphlets into some other languages are available. Order per-
maculture paper #27 from the Yankee Permaculture order form for an up-to-date list.
Volunteers are now needed to translate these pamphlets into other languages. And Yan-
kee Permaculture continues to depend on volunteers for all of our publications. If you
want to help, contact us at the address on the cover.

For Mother Earth

Dan & Cynthia Hemenway, Sparr, Florida USA. July, 2001
Fourth Edition

The minimum order, before computing p&h, is $10. Postage & handling is an additional US5 + 10% in the US, +20%
elsewhere. Prices subject to change without notice.
We regret that we can accept payment only in US funds by postal money order or checks drawn on a US bank.
See our regular order form for more details.
 Water in Permaculture - Pamphlet XI - Page 3.
WATER IN PERMACULTURE
Almost all of the water on the earth is not moving. It is in the moated islands with trees--maybe hundreds of islands. The hy-
oceans or it is in the ice caps. I think 75% of all fresh water is dro-electric commission dammed it, flooded it up. It is now a
unavailable. Of that fresh water in the world, there are only tiny sheet of clear water. Official vandalism! That area was not
amounts in lakes, ponds, soils, rivers and in the atmosphere. In meant for storage. It was a beautiful habitat.
total, less than 1% of that water moves. That's the amount that Intertidally, or between levels, there is another set of plants.
we have to work with. They have certain characteristics. They die down, either in sum-
The world mean average rainfall is 33.8 inches. Of the at- mer or in winter, depending on the sort of pond. They then rest
mospheric water, 77% falls on the oceans, 23% on the land. Of as rhizomata or tussock systems.
the 23% falling on the land, 16 parts transpire or evaporate,
leaving seven parts to run off and end in the ocean. Of the 7%
runoff, 84% goes into the ocean and returns to the cycle.
The land, in addition to the rainfall, gets seven parts of its wa-
ter from horizontal advection. That is where forests intervene.
This is a very simplified, generally accepted sort of model. The
one real application we can make locally is in providing surface
storage and soil storage of water. If we establish forests, we
store a lot of water in the forests, too.
We can't do much about the rivers; and we can't do much
about the atmospheric water. But, to me, it is clear that most of
the world needs much more surface storage at greater heights
than usual, not just in the low valleys. We need to reduce runoff.
We can store water in soils that have been treated with the
Wallace plow, and by constructing swales. Throughout urban ar-
eas, swales seem very appropriate.
It is the water available to us that decides what sort of plants
we grow. While the average is 34 inches of rainfall, such figures This is a very rich area and therefore difficult to manage. If a
are really meaningless, particularly during a plant's establish- plant gets out of control there, there is nothing worse than to
ment. We must buffer extremes, particularly those drought ex- try to eradicate that plant from the situation. You want to be
tremes that seem to be happening more and more. very careful about what edge plants you put in.
It is simply no good recommending plants to people, or de- When I talk to you about this edge effect, I want to instill in
signing orchards, unless you have cared for the water supply. you that you can maximize edges by creating islands and penin-
Give them the ability to water at least twice in the summer. You sulas. As you design a pond, decide what sort of edges you will
must make absolutely certain that you have designed water put in it. If there are trees to be planted, plant them as a buffer,
storage so they can get water--either off site, somehow, or on so that rushes are blocked from extension on to lawn. Decide
the site--in the plant's establishment phases. upon your edges and put them in. If you get them in fast enough,
then you won't get a completely rush-ridden pond of one
Seaweed and seaweed concentrates do a lot for water stor- species.
age, working as jell in the soils. In the very dry soils, you can rec-
ommend the use of dried seaweed, powders and seaweed con-
centrates, to greatly assist water storage and plant resistance
to wilt. Basically, it works on the surface film itself.
In our previous discussions of water storage, including the
keyline system, we simply regarded it as reserve water supply.
While in most places, ponds are made for cattle and stock wa-
tering, we design the water storages in themselves as highly
productive systems.
We can get books on fish culture, but there are very few, if
any, books on plant aquaculture. Do you know of any? Plants
that grow in water are just a neglected part of aquaculture.
Yet, as on land, we are going to get more yield out of those
plants than we get from animals.
The water level of lakes and ponds changes from summer to
winter, furnishing a variety of sites for aquatic plants that run
from the water surface to rooted vegetation to marginal vegeta-
tion. Quite a few swamp trees can live here. In fact, they must
not live more than 20 feet from the edge of water, yet never in
the water. One of those is bamboo. Bamboos won't take sod-
den conditions. They live up on fairly well-drained soil, but they
will send feeder roots down to water. Many such tree species
grow well in wetland margins.
Within the water there are hummocks which are either ex-
posed or not exposed. Many plants, like the bald cypress in Flori- Different species of rushes and reeds serve varied uses.
da, live on hummocks or even develop hummocks. How they de- From these you get real heavy crops. That is where papyrus
velop them, nobody is quite sure. Plants on these big bogs grow grows, and a whole group of things that are good for paper and
in little islands, too. The weight of the trees depresses the bog fodder. That is where the reed for mats and the cattails grow.
so that they become moated. My advice to the ordinary small homeowner is to put those
Whole sets of plants, including trees will grow out reed mats. cattails in the annual garden in a tiny little pond, and to cut off
We had a lake we called the lagoon of islands. It was just many the tops to stop them from seeding. Keep them out of the main
water storages. However, their seed can blow in at any time, This is where the lotus lives. Some of the lotus have popcorn
and you have to pounce on them as soon as they start. Other- seeds. You may gather the seeds and pop them. There are
wise, they close off that marginal surface. Chinese water chest- many things that are good for popping, but we don't pop them.
nuts, which are fairly hardy, grow there. They form large tubers, However, other people often do.
and so does the earth nut. This, again, is a Here, which may be only three or four feet out, you also have
rush [sedge]. the most important floating species, , which runs from
Certain trees grow here where the water table is very shal- very cool to equatorial climate. The Chinese water chestnut lives
low. The water table on these banks is only three or four feet here as a mud rush. The Indian water chestnut is a floating
down. This is a poplar spot or a willow spot. chestnut with an anchor, anchoring the stems. The chestnut
Some swamp trees produce the most durable woods in the floats. It is a beautiful sight in India to see ladies floating big
world, and some of them are the lightest woods in the world. I bronze bowls along in front of them, picking the water chest-
think , the American genus, is the world's lightest wood,
much lighter than balsa. They hold water in the stems. A lot of nuts. You need skilled people, because you can't walk through
them have air cells throughout their stems and root systems. the rows; they have to walk rather slowly through the stems, so
This is how they manage to live in water. They store oxygen as they don't tear them off. It is a graceful and pleasant summer
air in the plants themselves. occupation. But no splashing and kicking about in there, be-
Other plants that you know very well are the arrowheads, the cause it will knock the stems to pieces. No hanky-panky or mon-
duck potatoes, an important wildfowl food. The come key business.
up and lie along the surface, bearing heavy seed heads. These Beyond that, and beyond six to nine foot depth, the only thing
are eaten rather like leeks. They look like leeks, and you can we are much interested in is either a continuation of our good
treat them like leeks. , the duck potato, has at least old fern or duck weed. on the surface. and duck
80 species and a wide climate range. It grows way up past here weeds are both useful. The dreaded water hyacinth can be
and way south of here. used, and used well, in restricted locations to clear up pollution.
Wild rice is a very important plant, if not for you, at least for In warm climates, this plant is bad in large slow rivers. Here we
all of your ducks. You have to put that seed into mud balls and want algae production, which practically ceases at 12 feet
throw it into your ponds. The seeds do not have a long air- deep. The only reason we would want a space 12 to 15 feet
storage life. Water plants often have seeds that are fat, deep in a pond is to allow fish to escape low oxygen, and high or
squashy things, that fall from the plants, sink, and take root.
Some are different, though, and will blow for miles like thistle. low temperature conditions.
They bob around in the water. A few get eaten by ducks. They We are interested in algae bloom out here. When a white
sink before the winter, and then take root in the bottom in painted disc disappears at a depth of about two and a half feet,
springtime. (wild rice) is one of those. There are also a obliterated in a soft green water, you have a really well-manured
tropical grows from the coast of Florida way up pond. If the disk blacks out at about a foot, the pond is over-
to central Canada. It grows in still lagoons, slow flowing rivers, manured. If the disk can be seen at five feet, the pond is not
oxbows--that sort of situation. It doesn't like fast water, but it well-manured--you need to throw in more chicken manure to in-
likes a bit of movement through the water, either wind induced crease the bloom. If we are interested in the production of
or flow induced, and it likes a depth of 18 inches to three feet. shrimps, prawns, yabbies, fish, or whatever, we want a well-
You would probably do best to choose your seed from a situa- manured pond with a soft green bloom.
tion that approximates that which you are going to be planting. Certain fish browse algae. Even the rainbow trout has gill rak-
I see no reason at all why, instead of thinking ponds, you
shouldn't think bogs, and create a hundred square yards of bog, ers that enable it to collect algae and zooplankton. The brown
and go into a special crop like the distillation of for oils. trout lacks this feature.
Forget about the pond, just fill it up with . With trees and bee plants, we use 200 species across all cli-
is the super, plu-perfect thatch. Thatch of mates. I have no doubt there are 2,000 species that are of
lasts 40 to 60 years. It is as good as any roof. The only great use to us, many of them not entering into any catalog of
one that would last longer is a turf roof. Slate roofs always plants because it just is not our habit of recent years to go
crack, scale off and piddle down. splashing around in water getting our food. I guess the reason
Close to the water's edge, in soaked soils, there will be fly might be that most gardening ideas come from Britain. The Brit-
catching plants--venus fly trap plants, pitcher plants, sundews, ish never get wet. If they get wet, it is to mid-shin, their trousers
picking tiny little things out of the air and fastening them into the rolled up. That is probably the reason we never evolved these
plants. When you come out into the water, you can have a few systems.
plants which root, come up, and float on top. They include all If you want a productive pond, you might very well incorporate
your so-called water lilies. The best way to plant those is to take it as a normal part of the garden. Further, I would say that a
a bag of manuring materials, tuck it into a good old tire, punch
the tire in two or three places, and push it out with the water lily very small area, six feet in diameter, is well worth having as a
root buried in the bag inside the tire. It will come out of the tire production pond, with these elements in it. These are as good
and be out of the bag and constrained by the tire. You can al- vegetables as any land vegetables. Watercress and cattails are
ways get it out again as a pond plant, and harvest it easily. That two good examples.
works well.1 In Australia, we have concrete tanks anywhere from five to
Many of these deeper rooted species can be planted by put- 25,000 gallons. You buy them off the shelf. We have stock
ting them in clay balls containing as much nutrient as you wish ponds of all sorts, little concrete ponds. The most handy one
to wrap with them. Just drop them in. Weight them with a only costs $40. It is a very good little production pond. I got a
stone if you want to: clay ball, stone, and a bit of horse manure sheet metal mold and rolled two molds for a six foot pond, two
with your seeds. feet deep.

1. Because tires contain cadmium, an extremely toxic element, we usually delete Mollison's reference to various uses he finds for them. In this case, we
left the reference in, assuming that the reader can find another way to do the same job.
2. In my experience in North American greenhouses, toads (Buffo spp. ) control slugs and cut worms well as all these are nocturnal. Bull frogs were of lit-
tle value, probably because they feed in daylight when those pests are not active.
 Water in Permaculture - Pamphlet XI - Page 5.
I am becoming convinced that you need frogs in your glass- human food. The little arthropods that we are talking about, the
house because I think they are going to deal with a lot2 of those phreatocids, are harmless to plants. They eat the decaying mat-
slow moving things. They are plu-perfect slug eaters. ter from the plants, and keep the stems clean. They don't chew
I am going to repeat some things that I have been throwing the stems. They don't eat green plants, nor do shrimp. There
out offhand. The pH in ponds is between 6 and 8, that is, it is are some mollusks that we don't want in there: the spiral mol-
100 to 200 times lower in acid than most garden soils. Good lusks eat plants. On the other hand, some are large enough to
garden soil will go from pH 5 to 6.5. It is common to lime ponds. eat. If you want to go into snail production - God forbid! - you
Lime them when you make them. Lime the whole base of the would go into those. Otherwise, exclude spiral mollusks. If they
new pond. Then, just check the pH of the pond. Most things in get on top of you, the dry land cycle and the ducks will finish
the pond like lime. It is quite different from land culture in that them.
respect. So keep checking on this pH. It is good in this climate to Don't let children bring snails into your ponds because they
water your plants with limey pond. eat green plants, and they can wipe out a pond. The crawfishes
The ideal structure for a pond is a sloping floor or a step usually don't compete with fish and don't harm them. Try to get
floor. You should be able to fully drain it. It is even better if you crawfish with restricted burrowing capacity. We have one called
are able to drain it into another pond and take it through a dry- the yabbie. He is a long tunneler. He may go 25 feet. He might
land cycle. After a few years as a pond, it will carry dryland start on the inside wall of your dam and come out on the out-
crops three to four years without further manuring. One rea- side wall! Surprise, surprise! He comes out with great speed.
son for this is the fantastic ability of the mud and the mud sur- But we have other crawfish, and so do you.
face to fix passing nutrients from the water. One of the ele- One of them that makes a restricted burrow. In fact, the best
ments in those nutrients is the diatoms, which you can't see, habitat for these species is beer cans. So we throw in a clutch
The other one is fresh water mussels. Mussels pump nitrogen of the beer cans tied to a cork or a ping pong ball. Throw out
and phosphorus into the mud. They will filter about 200 gallons the ping pong ball. Draw 20 beer cans and take out 20 large
of water per day per mussel. The mussel draws from the water size crawfish. Then sink your beer cans again. That's a slow way
all of the little living forms and particle and shoots them out and to do it. A fast way to make a little trap is with a ramp and slope.
buries them. It lives there on the mud surface and just has it's They go up the ramp and hop into the trap. In Australia, the cul-
top lip out. It injects these nutrients into the mud floor of the tivation of crawfish is becoming rather common, and some hun-
pond. It lowers phosphorus in the whole system. Of all other dreds of acres of flat, previously non-productive land is under
plants, animals, seeds, anything, the mussels are the superior aquaculture.
phosphorus fixer. So I consider it a valuable part of the pond to The crawfish is a fantastic inland resource. They have them in
be harvested only modestly for chicken grit. Chicago. You should have them here. I don't know if anybody
When you drain the pond for the dry cycle, shift most of the grows them here. We worked it out. A Scotch biologist figures
animals into another forage pond. Don't go to dry land culture that 30 quarter-acre ponds in marine culture would keep a fam-
unless you have at least one other pond to transfer your old ily, supplying an income of $20,000 to $30,000.3
pond waters into, together with your critical species. Crawfish like ponds that are about three feet deep, and they
It is good for intensively cultivated ponds to go through a dry like brush piles. Piles of limbs in the water can save them from
stage. In the dry cycle, grow the heavy feeders in the first year, getting eaten by predators. The traditional way that the Hawai-
then taper off and finish with a modest crop. Then roll it down ians and the Japanese fertilize their ponds is by doing exactly
and re-flood it. Once your pond is held in gley, the gley itself goes what the beaver does, letting bark and limbs rot in the ponds.
down in the soil quite a ways and perpetuates itself. You have to You don't spread it over your pond, just put it on the edge where
start that fermenting process, but you don't have to continue it. you are not cultivating.
If I had a delicate pond sitting on top of a sand dune, in no way Another real good thing to do around ponds is to strew bales
would I play on it after I had gleyed it. Just use your sense. of hay around the edge, both to seal ponds and to get diatoms
It is possible to go out into a perfectly stable lagoon, dig a working. Strew it half in and half out around the edge, kick it in if
couple of post holes, and your lagoon runs out. Just punch the it rots off. Diatoms like hay. Often you can feed little fish by hav-
gley in a sufficient number of places to a sufficient depth and ing a bowl of hay and water, and dipping the water out of the
the whole thing drains. Ponds do obliterate in time. The ponds bowl and feeding it to the fish. What you are actually putting in is
that most commonly obliterate are shallow ponds, made from little flagellates and diatoms. They drift around in the air. There
fairly loose fill material. There are ponds, however, that don't is no need to put them in there. They are in all water. Just scat-
obliterate in a millennia. Most of the operating ponds we would ter the hay around the edge, and kick a little more in. Ducks will
put up here on this site would be there many, many years later, add manure to it.
and the ponds in our hills would also be there. You can figure on eight ducks to a quarter acre. But the
You will never see a pond obliterate, though, in your lifetime. more ducks you put on, the more manure you get. Ducks give
The only way you will see that is to make a barrier dam in the you an additional crop, and they greatly assist the turnover of
desert. As soon as you fill a watercourse in a dessert, it will per- the energy in the pond. It is possible to make provision for the
colate nicely as a sand dune. A lot of the ponds built in Arizona ducks somewhere in that food cycle. Wild rice is good in this sit-
are barrier ponds across water courses. They simply fill up with uation because it comes up in the vegetative stage, and it grows
detritus. With the sort of ponds we are making, if there is any well above the duck. You harvest what you want. It has a three
risk of that , what you do is use your pond as your source of ma- week dropping period. You gather it for four or five days, and the
nure. Cut the muck out and spread it on your fields. That is often rest of it falls. It is superb duck food.
done. These ponds are great places for trapping all of those We have a lot of foxes and dogs that chase ducks. If you
things that are good to throw on the ground. [It is also possible haven't got a pond big enough for an island, put a fence into the
to build silt traps to harvest these materials before the water water; top net it--that is essential. Put your duck shed back of
enters the pond, prolonging its life. - DH] that. The ducks will come out of this shed into the water and
Mussels don't hurt plants nor do shrimps or prawns. We swim and browse and go back there to sleep. They know to do
have fresh water shrimp that are very good harvesters of al- this from night one on. They don't want foxes either. Islands are
gae, including diatoms. They are a prime step from diatoms to good, though. But if it is murderous to ducks where you are,
fish. As you get sub-tropical, these shrimp are big enough for maybe you can't keep ducks.

3. 1981 dollars.
 As large a yield as anyone knows of for the home farm is
from blueberries and mulberries on the edge of the pond. Mul-
berries are great feed for stock in water, as well as on land.
White mulberries are used extensively throughout the ponds
and paddies of Asia for their leaf and fruit as feed. We want
careful adjustment of maybe 20 species of plants and small ani-
mals low on the trophic ladder. That includes the shrimps, yab-
bies, crayfish, catfish, edge plants, pond plants, and ducks.
You can do little pond designs at home, with perhaps ducks
for their eggs, and wild rice. Always include those mussels as
decomposers.
There is a whole group of American grain plants that are
ideal for ponds, marsh grasses with heavy seed yield for ducks.
Wherever you build your pond, don't forget its other func-
tions: barrier functions, fencing functions. Often a long pond in
the valley saves you a half a mile of fences. The pond has reflec-
We have a lot of foxes and dogs that chase ducks. tion functions and fire protection functions. It's a heat store. It
usually becomes a recreational area. Put a big rock by the side
Pond edges are good blueberry areas. Mints are invasive, but of a deep area where children can safely dive. The pond has wa-
very productive. Another purpose for the pond might be to grow ter cleaning functions. It efficiently collects in its mud essential
mints, particularly black mint. You don't need many acres of nutrients. I believe the Chinese would say that the main value of
that. Two or three could bring you $70,000. You distill mint to their canals and ponds is for manuring their fields.
menthol. It is good to grow mint if you are dairying and have Sewage should be turned out into a marsh, not a pond. In
dairy outwash. From that, you get powerful blooms of mint. So that marsh, grow your mints, your bog plants. They have phe-
you might try a mint marsh for that black peppermint and do nomenal sewage demand. But in this climate, send your sewage
simple steam distillations. Mint is such a strong growing plant into a holding pond. Then let it seep through a marsh that can
that it quickly exhausts even ponds. It will get pretty woody after grow into trees. When it has passed through that, it has no sol-
a few years. In cold climates, it has a rest period, and you can ids left at all. It still holds a lot of dissolved nutrients, mainly phos-
re-manure. You can put it on edges; but because it is laterally in- phates and nitrates. You can let that go into your pond. You
vasive, I would put a couple of bushes on either side of where I need a holding pond, because in winter the marsh plants are
was going to put mint--dense bushes to keep it in its little patch. dormant and cannot purify water.
A good place for bamboo is back from your ponds. They look There is a Swiss study which might interest you. One of the
great. plants which they mention is rush, They found
I won't go into a discussion of the fish you might place in your this to be the most efficient water cleanser. One of my designs
pond, because you have to know your local laws about fish. Cat- was for a town of 8,000 people, for which I did a sewage dispo-
fish look like an obviously good pond fish because they are very sal, saving $30,000 a year in engineering work, and about the
low on the chain feeders, way down on the trophic ladder. And equivalent amount annually for fuels. The town is pleased with it.
they are good eating. I wouldn't go past them to trout, unless I turned it into an industrial base for the town, an employment
you are real keen on trout. system, through mint and bamboo. This was originally done on
If you are in the happy opportunity where you spot a hundred 50 acres; but the town has purchased an additional 1,500
acres with a 15-foot wide outlet, land that used to be marsh, acres and turned it into further raw materials. Also, I allowed for
and somebody is selling it cheap, grab it. Stock it with trout. You water fowl, and put underwater shelving into it. It has been so
can retire instantly, because just by net fishing, not manuring or successful, that when I last heard of it, it had vast numbers of
anything, you will have a continual trout supply. black swans and teal. While up in Canberra, they put in a
A man bought a cattle property. That land was jumping with $700,000 sewage cleaning plant which produces poisonous
grasshoppers, absolutely covered with grasshoppers. He was in water. They make no apologies or anything for doing this.
a grasshopper that erupts annually. He was pretty despondent Just give me a bulldozer and a sloping site. As for San Fran-
about growing cattle. The grasshoppers would remove every- cisco, I could do their whole town. As it is, all they are doing is
thing. He built a pond. I said, "What's in your pond?" covering the sea floor with silt. It is horrible!
He said, "Let's have a look." He threw in a net and pulled out If we are just dealing with water culture, I believe that what
an eight pound trout. we should do is set up single culture systems that flow one to
I said, "How long have these been here?"
He said, "Twelve months."
I said, "You are nutty! You have bulldozers and this great val-
ley, and you're going to grow cattle?"
He said, "Now I got you right!"
I said, "Hills covered with grasshoppers!"
He put over a hundred acres into a big trout pond, and he
just simply retired. He doesn't have to figure around feeding
those trout and adjusting them. He has a hundred acres of this
trout pond.
Trout are in beaver ponds. As long as they have that escape,
shaded by a few trees, they don't demand a lot. They can take it
a bit warmer or a bit colder than you think. They are optimal
over 60 degrees Fahrenheit, but lower than that, they are still
pretty active. Trout are an extensive fish. So if you have an exten-
sive area under water, grow trout. But intensive trout are a
curse, because you have fine adjustments to make, and it is a
nuisance.
 Water in Permaculture - Pamphlet XI - Page 7.
the other, and we should design for them. Make a duck marsh which is why most people think they don't work. When you go to
with mussels, perhaps, and wild rice, an 18-inch deep flat pond. look at them by day, there is often not much left in them, but at
From there, we can go to ordinary rice crop, or paddy crop. night they are often full of fish.
From either of these, we can go to shrimp ponds that don't con- Another good thing to do is to make a pond two or three feet
tain trout, or to a pond with any invertebrate that trout like. We deep in this tidal area, because fish otherwise will strand and
are enriching the water, using some of it in crop, turning some turn into sea gull food. You will often find a client whose land in-
of it into shrimp, and these ponds trickle to the trout pond, inevi- cludes some salt flat, even if the government has struck off a
tably carrying shrimp on migration. hundred foot tide reserve, above the high tide mark, as they fre-
In Australia, there is a place that has an enormous clay base. quently do. You will often find that back from that, for hundreds
It doesn't breed trout. Every year they stock thousands of trout of yards, you have salt marsh. You can put a simple channel
and they grow well. Those trout eat a little fish called smelt. The through that reserve area, if a channel doesn't already exist,
smelt is found at one site, a quarry in which it can breed. The just by driving backwards and forwards with your tractor for a
main food of the trout is the smelt which lives in this tiny quarry. while. The tide runs into these salt marshes in any case. It is
If we get production of tiny things that continually flow into a possible, between tides, to dig inland ponds. There are only a
trout pond, we could greatly relieve the need to feed the trout, few rules. They must have about a three-to-one side slope, a
and maybe abolish it. real gentle side slope. Then the rocks fall, and you can throw
You have a lamp that attracts a lot of bugs, an ultraviolet them up on the tide side to stop the sea winds coming in. Put
lamp, the patio light. Place a lamp of this sort over the pond, some salt-resistant shrubs around your pond, and lead your wa-
with a little fan in it, so that when insects come flying to it, the ter in through the channel. You could fill a pond with the next
down draft hits them and they go straight into the water. With tide, if you wish. Then, depending on how deep that channel is--
that sort of setup, you could do without manure input for crops. and you can regulate it by shifting a board up or down--you can
Have a few small ponds at different pH's, which suit small for- give it a three inch, or six inch, or one foot tide range twice daily
age animals, some of which, in this case can be snails. These over that pond. It is the cheapest swimming pool you can build
ponds would have trickle systems into the main pond where we anybody, and self-flushing. It is always warm. It is inland. You can
harvest trout. Meanwhile, from the other ponds we take wild shelter it. The tide brings only a few inches of water over the
rice, rice, duck eggs. warm water.
It is polyculture, but not in the sense that we have it all in to- A variety of organisms, particularly oysters and mussels,
gether. Some crops may not, in fact, grow with others, because grow best when their location is at 60% air exposure. For any
we are adjusting totally different pH's. We might find a little kind of oyster, your local fisheries guide will tell you what air to
phreatocid, or something--a real good trout food--that will go in a water exposure is ideal. Broadly speaking, above that exposure
low pH. Meanwhile, we might heavily lime another pond for mol- you get much less meats, while below it, immersed, you get
lusk production. With their food flowing to them, the trout are much more shell. But at the ideal exposure you get a modest
perfectly happy. Maybe a few forage ponds around fish are the amount of shell with a lot of meat. So if you have an oyster en-
way to feed fish. There is no way the trout can come up the thusiast, you can actually set him up with a situation in which he
trickles, which are through little grilles. So what is coming down, can raft or support oysters inland, which is much easier than
they get, but they can't get at the sources. having them out in the tide land, and which is self-governed to
Some little fast breeding fish, like stickleback, breed by mil- give them all ideal exposure. It is possible for a client to make a
lions, and, given certain high algae conditions, can be converted lot of money breeding oysters, selling off the spat.
into trout. If you put them into a total polyculture, they would If he has access to a lot of broken pot, he can set up a lobster
short-circuit the whole system. I think we've have many skilled city. Lobsters will not tolerate another lobster in the same hole.
games to play in aquaculture, interesting games too. They will lose legs and things. Often you find that there is some
There were a lot of hippies at a conference. They had colored fish processing somewhere, usually with waste product that you
tents all over the place. I noticed that there were a lot of grass- can feed to lobsters in these stacks. It amounts to the growing
hoppers on the yellow tent. So I figured it would be good if you of a marine animal inland.
could float a big yellow balloon out here in the pond, just beyond Another thing you can grow there is sponges. You can also
the normal grasshopper's leap. They can see yellow and they will grow flounder, if you can feed them. Lobsters and oysters are
leap for it.4 pretty immune from predation. But with the flounder and other
fish, you might strike cormorant problems. Cormorants can be
Now, folks, we are going to take permaculture right out into converted to fish food by hanging a five and a half inch net well
the sea. We don't stop permaculturing at the shore lines. Down off the bottom. It will drown them and fish will eat them. But you
we go into the tide, the rocky main shore line, the main marsh- only do this when you are into intense fish production. Ponds in
land, and the tidal marsh. these areas offer no protection for fish. If you have any shelter,
Tide ranges can run from two to 27 feet. The tide range that as soon as a cormorant hits the water, the fish takes for shel-
we need is really less than one foot. In some cases tides may oc- ter. The cormorant might get one, but he doesn't get many. But
cur only once a day. Tides are real weird things. Around the in an open pond situation, he will murder a lot. You can bring the
coast of America, you will be able to determine your tide ranges, growth of lobsters to a standstill in dense populations, so that
and there are also tide tables. Twenty-seven feet--something like none will exceed three and a quarter inch carapace, simply be-
that--for the Bay of Fundy, Darwin, and many other places. cause the density of lobsters is enormous.
Those mud traps, of which you find many in Tasmania, are Let's look at the inlet. You can bring the tide in, maybe with
very ancient. Nobody has any record of them ever being built. banks supported by concrete. You can slide boards in, adjusting
They are quite possibly aboriginal. The Maoris have many. The your tide range. You can also have funnels leading in so the sea
other Polynesians also built them. They are simple tide traps, comes in through funnels at night. A lot of small fish enter.
stone walls that don't quite reach the surface at high tide. They Small round fish can't get back out again. You can bring a lot of
are about six inches below the surface. Fish swim over them at fish into your ponds continually, with every tide. If you have a
high tide. The tide drops six inches, and they are still quite happy predator fish or lobsters in there, you can just keep them in
in this lagoon. When they try to swim out, they find the tide has food. Now I'll give a couple of instances of the human brain at
gone out through the rocks. These traps work best at night,
4. Not all yellows are created equal. Insects use prismatic eyes to see colors, including yellow, as bands of the spectrum. People do see this "spectral
yellow" as yellow. We also see mixtures of the red and green portions of the spectrum as yellow, whereas insects would see red plus green, not a com-
posite color. For insect traps, use either a known "spectral yellow" or perform tests with insects. Seeing the trap as yellow is inconclusive.
work. They want a sea pond for the breeding of oyster spat. So Another thing about these little sub-tidal fences and screens
what do they do? They go 50 feet above sea level, dig out dams, for collecting long-shore drift is that other things arrive here:
and pump sea water up 50 feet. They are doing that in Tasma- broken up shell, sometimes by tons.
nia. Or they go into the sea and build a wall out at tremendous I was on an island recently that was originally very low pH and
maintenance cost. has an acidic soil. They have been carting limestone onto it by
If you get hold of these saltings, and there are thousands of boat for I don't know how long. They built a jetty with stone base,
acres of them, you have the best goose grazing areas you ever and they are still carting limestone in on this jetty. Yet I looked
saw. over the side of this jetty, and by my best estimate, there might
Now what do you have in the way of plants for here? For salt be 1,100 tons of broken shell there, which is just limestone.
flat tidal range, you have front line plants, the mangroves, if you Shell, itself, is salable in 50 pound bags to any responsible chick-
are in a hot enough climate. On these salt marshes, you have en keeper. It is quite expensive. It is a continually renewable re-
various little fat plants at your grass roots. is a great source of good lime for fields.
goose fodder. This is real goose country, where I think a lot of These little longshore drift traps can collect many things. If
our domestic geese breeds come from. If you want to go into a you look closely at natural things in this tide range, like a log
very small industry, you can make pickles, which sell that washed ashore, or an old wreck, or an old boat moldering
well in England. A host of little plants out here are quite useful. away there, and you walk around and study it, you find that the
You can plant here salt marsh honey plants. Sea lavender is a tide comes in and out, and the longshore drift builds up. A deep
very good honey plant. There is an interesting plant, . It and permanent pond forms there, and a shallow permanent
is called cord grass, used for weaving those fancy seat chairs. pond in front of it. Nobody had to dig those, and nobody has to
The old timers made cord from it. But it is far more important maintain them. All you have to do is to direct the tide into these
than that. Spartina is a heavy seed producer, and it is also a scour-hole situations. They are excellent growing ponds.
great forage crop for geese, and the base food for most of the Again, if you have the right title, or lease title, you can put in
cool water fish. No , no bluefish. It is a nurse ground for simple barrier systems, which may be fences or logs, or any-
the young and their food. The bluefish industry depends on the thing you can drag there. You can produce permanent ponds.
and the depends on there never being an oil You don't have to dig or maintain them. One thing that grows in
spill. So I advise you to collect some Spartina seed and send it there is octopus. If you simply provide the pots for them, they
down to me as rapidly as possible. After the next oil spill, I will are occupied. At low tide they are ponds; at high tide, they are
send you back some seed, at a very minimal cost. It is slightly flooded. Octopus have no place to rest in this whole situ-
a northern hemisphere plant. That environment is totally unoc- ation, and it is full of little mollusks. They can't dig caves in there.
cupied in the southern hemisphere. It doesn't have a plant in it. They would like to be there because they eat mollusks. When
Without , you don't have quahaugs either, because your you give them a pond, they have a place to breed. If you put pots
quahog zone comes in here. We don't have quahaugs because in there--ordinary clay pots--each pot has an octopus in it. When
we don't have . the tide comes in, these hundreds of octopus come out of their
When we come down into the sea grasses, it is very interest- pots and go out and eat shellfish. They come home and go back
ing. They are the and the , the eel grasses. into the pot at low tide.
These are basic sea foods. They absorb nutrients quickly. I think They will do this as soon as you provide pots. I don't know
it has been calculated that if you put a bag of super-phosphate where they come from. They apparently have just been swim-
out to them, in three days they will have absorbed all of it. When ming all over those browsing lands, looking for somewhere to
composted for about 10 days, they are the best insulation ma- live. It is a good octopus growing situation. It is also a very good
terial you can get. They shed all their upper part, which comes place for growing sponges.
ashore by the tons, either in autumn or early summer, depend- Now you can start to play around. There can be barrier fenc-
ing on what variety they are. They heat up like fury when you pile es, drift fences, pond scour holes. We can design for ourselves
them on your carts. The composting process burns out a lot of a complicated system which scours water and is self-
things that are on sea grasses that otherwise stink, while it maintaining, and brings in broken shells. You just combine a se-
leaves the frame of the sea grass. It is a chocolate color, fi- ries of fairly natural drift events into a complex of fish trap,
brous stuff. As an insulation material, it doesn't have any of the scour hole and growing situation.
risks of the mineral fibers. And they last forever. You can use It is enjoyable working around down there. We do a lot of it in
that for garden mulch, but not where there are cattle, because miniature to start with, taking little logs down and watching the
they eat it. Put it straight on and forget about salt, unless you effect, building little fences. Then when you feel as though you
are in a location with below 20 inch rainfall. Put it on sopping are getting it right, scale them up. Always be looking along the
wet. shoreline at what is really happening. Observe when something
Possibly, in this whole estuary the eelgrass will only blow happens--where a reef runs out, or a log strands--because there
ashore at one place. This is probable. But it is easily caught on are lots of forces at work, and lots of material on the move all
fences. the way along here. You can bring it to where you want it.
It will be necessary to investigate your client's title. Ancient I believe also that it would be very productive to run the same
grant titles extend to low tide. There are still some in the United thing that we would run in large dams, what I call sub-surface
States. Titles which are not grants, but freehold--they are not dams. This would permit some of the waters, just for a while, to
Crown charters--will go to high tide. Modern titles may be set remain as quite water. I believe we could create large
back 100 or so feet from the beach which has been converted fields intertidally. The condition required for is a period
into beach reserve. At the same time you can get, under lease, of still water, not too much run of tide. I think that we could
access to the intertidal zone. It is not difficult, and is very cheap. greatly increase the productivity of intertidal sand flows by in-
At least in Australia, everybody has the right, no matter who stalling shallow still-water systems. This I do know: in a tidal river
leases the area, to take a single eelgrass load. It is real good that fills at high tide, where a natural barrier occurs in it, like a
stuff and it is free to you. If you don't collect it, it either blows in- stone dike, that area will be full of and full of fish. It is
land or wisps out, a silica skeleton that just helps to build up the very simple to duplicate that system by constructing leaky walls,
beach plants a bit, while the rest of it breaks up and returns as just rubble walls. These are not dams. On open coastlines, you
mud into the channels and goes back to the sea. It probably fer- don't find . When the get mussels attached to
tilizes the sea further out. We have enough of this stuff in the them, and shrimp move into there, a whole series of events
world to insulate the world, safely. When you convert it to insula- start to take place. It is a fascinating area to play with, that salt
tion you have put it to permanent use, at a big energy savings. marsh to low tide.
 Water in Permaculture - Pamphlet XI - Page 9.
We don't stop there; and we don't stop at this intertidal place, You can do large scale transfer of sea birds in nesting cycle,
because certainly the Hawaiians kept on gardening right out by keeping adults until the nesting cycle begins on part of the
into the reefs. So did the Irish. The Irish set out what they call coast. A mutton-bird is a critically important food of the Tasma-
fields. The fields are simply rows of stone across hard bottom. nians. You can keep the adults like chickens until they nest.
You can handle very large boulders in the sea. You come in When you release them, they return to the nest, and then you
along side of them, draw them on to boats, float them out, and start a whole new colony. To some degree, you can do the same
roll them off. You can place them easily in the sea. They grow with seals. You have to kidnap the young seal, before they can
enormous quantities of desirable seaweeds on those fields. swim, when they are not being fed, and they all start a new seal
Many of those Irish fields are not harvested any more; but some colony, too. So it is possible to colonize an abandoned area.
are. They are visible from air, enormous acreages under water. Seal are critically important to inshore fisheries. The loss of seal
I went to Donegal and poked around on the barrens. I saw dropped the inshore fisheries right down. What apparently hap-
some very interesting things there. They make tiny little stone- pened was that the seals ate mainly spiny and whitefish, which
walled fields. I said, "Why don't you enlarge these fields?" have a high manurial turnover on the bed which, in
They answered, "Because the smaller field produces more turn, supports high quality food fish. When you kill off the seals,
than the larger one." you kill off your manurial system. There are connections there
I said, "Why?" that nobody ever made. They simply killed the seals for fur, and
They said, "It is warmer." destroyed the inshore fisheries.
You could feel the radiant heat from those walls. Another thing that nobody has made much use of except one
They deliberately made their fields smaller and increased man I know is the sea as a source of phosphate. Phosphate is
their productivity. carried by birds. Sea birds like islands, and specific roosting
places. Look at a flock of gulls and cormorants roosting on an
They also used the tide a lot. They cut the kelp, tie a big rope old bridgework. You will see quite species-specific roosts. You
around it and pull it up, 10 or 12 tons of kelp on the move. They can make very attractive roosting systems by creating roosts
bring it in on the tide, right into the bog channels. When the tide on platforms in the sea or on islands. Well, this man built a plat-
goes out, there it is, right on the shore. They load donkeys and form with multiple roosts on a desert coast off west Africa. The
and away they go with the kelp. They can handle great weights platform was the size of a football field, with concrete pylons.
in the water. All over the coast, you will see little hollow mounds. He spent a lot of money doing it. And he was the subject of
They fill these with kelp stems, which they stack and dry like fire- great laughter. He's gathered so much phosphate off that area
wood. They fire them with peat, and get the potash from the that he's annually a millionaire, and he's laughing. He gathers it
kelp stems for their fields. The fronds they lay down as mulch. It both as a liquid when rain falls, which he pipes ashore and evap-
is a marginal existence, the only way they can exist, but it is orates on the shoreline, and as a solid which is shoveled into
quite enjoyable actually. They eat a lot of dulse and other sea- bags. Basically, he has reconstituted a phosphate island.
weeds chopped in their porridge.
There are many phosphate islands in the world that are being
You can extend your aquaculture systems into estuaries. You mined, but very few that are being created. The potential for
can do beautiful swap-offs in estuaries, too. You can take cold creating a small phosphate island serving a small village is a
water, fresh water, warm salt water from them. In estuaries, in very simple affair, providing you look at your roosting situation.
adjoining ponds with totally different salinity grading, you can Two hundred terns always roosting in the right place will entirely
grow everything from trout to grey mullet to eels, because you supply maybe an island or a village. Phosphate is one of the criti-
have an intake of fresh water up there, as well as twice daily in- cally lacking minerals in the Third World. Wherever you can get
take of warm salt water. So we can continue to design even on- that organized, in a lake, or by the sea, or on the land, it is a
ward and outward. good thing to have done. The Dutch build specific bat roosts
Another thing that I have seen working very well is very large throughout their fields, which control mosquitoes and give them
raft culture. When the Irish salmon runs were good, they didn't a critical manure. You will see those bat roosts in the flatlands
worry about culturing salmon. Now two things have happened. in Holland, slatted like racks for drying towels. These are ideal
Their authorities "improved" their rivers. Their idea of improving bat roosts. The insectivors hang from them. Their manure is
rivers was to get a bulldozer down the bed of the river. That de- carefully collected and carefully distributed. So the sea and
stroyed all the old salmon weirs. Now salmon weirs are little log lakes are good places for collecting phosphates. If you can
and rock constructions across the river. They oxygenated the achieve something like that, you will be making a better strike
water. The engineers did away with them, and the oxygen levels than anybody else for local self-sufficiency.
dropped. The salmon were wiped out. The Japanese got effi- You know now about , the hippie food additive.
cient with their gill nets at sea. They would catch nearly all the is an algae. It can be simply produced in tanks under continu-
salmon bred in Ireland. So the Irish, not to be outdone, bring the ous production system. desalinate water. A modest
salmon inshore and release them into giant floating rafts, plant will desalinate 10,000 gallons of water a day, producing
moored in quiet tidal areas behind islands. They produce an that much fresh water from salt or brackish water. Once it
amazing amount of salmon there in big flooded nets. starts to produce fresh water, you can mix it with hyper-saline
So you can go into rafting. I should mention at this point that water coming in and put it back again through the tanks. It has
rafts are applicable across the whole of the aquatic systems: a higher BTU than coal, if you want to use it as a fuel. It is about
tiny little ones on tiny little ponds for insect attractants; larger 86% total protein, of which 68% is a complete protein. It has no
ones to grow plants at a fixed root level, including pot plants. cellulose, so it is almost entirely digestible. In summer, it will give
Water culture is highly developed in southwest Asia. A raft re- three crops a day. It is presently greatly over-priced, selling for
mains constant and level, and you can set pots in rafts so that about $30 a pound, dried. It should cost one and a half cents.
your plants are at the same depth at all times. One thing you It will clean up sewage water; it will clean up grey water. You
can grow well on rafts is daffodils. You can set them out on can feed it to your ducks and pigs, or turn it into a powder and
chicken wire. Each little space holds a daffodil bulb,and its roots eat it yourself. There is no need to eat the stuff. I merely pro-
are just in the water. If it is a high nutrient water, you get a lot of pose this as part of aquaculture. It is very promising, I think. But
daffodils. Vegetable crops could be grown on rafts, and they can I'm not going to do it. It is not my style of garden.
grow rock cultures, mussels, oysters, and algae. It would be a In places where you will be designing in arid lands, perhaps
good way to grow algae. You can make a ring, and a big net, and just summer arid lands, you will find people who are short of
grow fish within the sea in that net system. The Irish had very garden water and who have showers and sinks going into un-
large rings, and they walk boards around them, with four foot derground drains. Shunting systems can be installed, using a
fences so the salmon couldn't jump out.
simple standard double mouth fitting, and gray water can then would push more than four trees down in a row. And they go on
be run directly into mulch. This has been done successfully in growing. The fifth tree usually has the full upright height of the
dozens of places with summer arid areas where I have de- tree. , willows, poplars, all withstand flood.
signed. Shower water is immediately taken up by plants. You can plant in two ways. In both cases, you start at right an-
Grey water can be recycled through glass houses. It releases gles to the bank and do a nice taper towards the river. That
its heat in there. A sensible thing to do is to put your shower in way, you will create a scourhole lagoon in the river, which is a
the glass house. You can shunt this relatively clean water direct- very handy thing, providing a low water area for fish. If you can
ly to the gardens. pick a place where it is not rocky, you can create a permanent
I previously described for you that half-pipe open on one side, lagoon. You can bring in detritus, collect firewood, also collect a
designed to lead water from toilets directly to tree crop, and substantial amount of mulch. You can have a place that doesn't
which won't become blocked by roots. I think this is really a sane collect anything, but which does give some silt. So floods can
and safe way to dispose of sewage. While I think there is noth- provide you with a lot of wood, a lot of mulch, and a lot of silt.
ing at all wrong with the flush toilet, I do think there is something This silt is a good place for a crop like asparagus. It likes an
awfully wrong with Los Angeles--a crazy excess of everything, in- annual dressing of silt. In Australia, it is a channel weed--it grows
cluding the flush toilet. in the irrigation channels. It is four feet down with its roots.
This tile drains useful where we can get sufficient domestic In Australia, poplars grow to 90 feet high. Saw them off at
water from uphill to run a flush toilet, and where we can grow the butt, dig an eight foot hole and lay them straight in position.
trees on the outrun. I think it is an extraordinarily safe system. It A 90-foot hedge. It works. You grow your willows to sort of 30
has been on a long trial. It is now produced from standard plas- feet high, saw them off, and plunk them in a hole. As long as you
tic material. What size? If you use a lot of water, make a big have them anchored, they'll grow. There are nurseries that will
drain. It falls at the normal drain-fall. About every four feet it has sell them to you at about 60 or 80 feet. Canadians would be
a two inch piece that fastens the bottom of the sections togeth- transplanting at least 50 foot poplars, wouldn't they? No roots,
er. These act like little dams that slow the water, so that little just saw them off. Then you get another one that comes from
ponds form continually behind them. This half pipe is placed up- the roots. That's why you run that nursery. You can take a 90
side down in an earth trench. It is buried in earth, but it is open foot poplar and make two 45-foot poplars. You could take a 90
on the bottom. It doesn't have stone on it or under it. It can even foot poplar and make three 30-foot poplars.
be laid in clay. You then plant trees beside it, even invasive trees, Now a word on very large dams such as the Aswan or any of
and away they grow. The man who made it originally made it out those dams. They are mostly negative in their effect. All studies
of half pipe and molded those little dams in it. Put it down below show that they reduce the fertility of the river below them by
the frost line. It holds the water up as it goes along until absorp- trapping the silt. They often sharply increase disease, and partic-
tion takes it out. ularly in tropical lands, because the country is not scoured by
floods. They always change the fisheries below. In Australia, for
instance, they completely wipe out some species of fish for
miles downstream because of the cold water released from the
base of these dams. They have a very low biological use. They
give rise to centralized power systems and, inevitably, to pollut-
ing industries at the other end of the usage chain. Generally
speaking, they are a disaster.
So we are mainly in favor of reasonably small impoundments.
There is always a nuisance damming the waterways. You
have to pay a lot of attention to your spillway systems, and those
dams may flood. But they have their uses. However, it is the
last place to go for a dam.

It works. Round pipes don't work, because they

get invaded by roots. They will fill up with poplars
and eucalyptus root. Leach fields work for a while,
but these devices seem to work indefinitely.
The more you play with water, or walk on land-
scape where you can play with water, the more
fascinating things you'll see that you can do. I do
believe that if we really studied what the beavers
are doing, we would already see some very smart
work, just on flatlands. They are not building just
one dam, they are building several dams, for all
different reasons, and they are building little ca-
nals and bog places, and they are doing water
control--pretty good little fellows!
Here is something we have done on flood
plains. If you have a row of trees along a river
bank, which you often do have--willows and pop-
lars, you will notice that there is seldom more
than four trees tilted over, until the next one is up-
right. I have not seen many flood plains that