Chapter 2B
Chapter 2B
Chapter 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
CHAPTER 2B
HIGHLIGHTS
*Source: FTB
**From the Governor's Proposed 2009-10 Budget Summary
________________________________________________________________________
Individuals who are residents of California are liable for the personal income tax on
income derived from all sources. Nonresidents of this state must pay income tax on
income derived from sources within California. However, nonresidents are generally
allowed a credit against their California tax for taxes they pay to their state of residence
on the same income.
In addition to individuals, partnerships, limited liability companies, estates, and trusts are
taxed under the "Personal Income Tax Law".
21
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
22
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
Taxpayers must compute their tax liability based on income earned during the year,
usually the calendar year. Generally, taxpayers must add up all sources of nonexempt
income and subtract the adjustments and deductions to which they are entitled to
calculate "taxable income". They then apply the appropriate tax rate to their taxable
income to arrive at a preliminary tax liability. After calculating their preliminary tax
liability, taxpayers may then apply tax credits, which reduce liability (i.e., every $1 in tax
credits reduces a taxpayer's tax liability by $1). In most cases, the tax liability remaining
after tax credits are applied is the actual tax liability. However, a few taxpayers are liable
for additional taxes under special circumstances.
The chart on the preceding page illustrates the steps involved in calculating final tax
liability. As the chart shows, the income that is actually subject to tax is much smaller
than a taxpayer's total income earned or received.
California's tax law largely conforms to federal income tax law. This allows substantial
simplicity for state tax forms. Today, a majority of the steps in computing income
subject to tax are done on federal Forms 1040, 1040A, or 1040EZ. California Forms 540
and 540A start with federal adjusted gross income (AGI). These forms then require
taxpayers to make adjustments to reflect differences in state law, apply state tax credits,
and compute state tax.
A third state form, without a comparable federal form, offers taxpayers a different,
simplified method of calculating their taxes. Beginning with the 1999 tax year, Form 540
2EZ ("too easy") replaced Form 540 EZ. Form 540 2EZ begins with the taxpayer's total
wages. However, the tax tables that accompany Form 540 2EZ already include the
standard deduction and personal and dependent exemption credits, thereby simplifying
the calculation processes required for other state forms.
For purposes of the personal income tax, income is measured or defined in four important
stages: (a) Calculation of exempt income; (b) Gross income; (c) AGI; and (d) Taxable
income (TI).
The major sources of income that are taken into account in computing tax liability
include the following:
° Gross Income. Gross income is the starting point for calculating tax on the
federal return. Gross income includes income from all sources, unless
otherwise exempt. Income that must be included in gross income for both
state and federal purposes includes salaries, wages, commissions, tips,
alimony received, dividends, interest earnings, annuities, pensions, net gains
23
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
from the sale of capital assets, net partnership and proprietorship income, net
farm income, and others. Losses from capital assets, partnerships,
proprietorships may be limited.
For some items, the amount of income entered on the tax return may be a
negative number if the taxpayer has incurred a loss.
° Exempt Income. Certain types of income are exempt from tax. In many
cases, taxpayers are not required to report this income on their tax return.
Some of these items are exempt in California but are taxable for federal
purposes. The most common income items that are taxable on the federal
return and exempt on the state return are California lottery winnings, a portion
of Social Security and Railroad Retirement benefits, unemployment
compensation, and interest from U.S. Savings Bonds and Treasury Bills.
Since California uses federal income as the starting figure, these items must
be subtracted from federal income before calculating California tax.
° Adjusted Gross Income. After totaling all items included in gross income,
certain deductions are allowed to compute AGI. These "adjustments" include
payments into certain retirement plans (IRAs, Keogh plans, self-employed
plans, etc.), alimony paid, penalties paid on early withdrawal of savings, and
the employer portion of Social Security that is paid by the self-employed (i.e.,
the self-employment tax). The remaining amount is AGI.
All taxpayers are allowed to deduct certain amounts from AGI. Most deductions are
intended to reduce the amount of income subject to tax to reflect certain living costs
incurred by all taxpayers. The rationale behind deductions is that these living costs affect
taxpayers' ability to pay.
The value of a deduction to a taxpayer (i.e., the amount by which the deduction reduces
the taxpayer's tax liability) generally may be estimated by multiplying the deduction by
the taxpayer's highest marginal tax rate (see Section 8 of this chapter for a discussion of
marginal rates). For example, the approximate state tax savings to a person in the top tax
bracket (9.3%) who deducts a $100 expense is $9.30 ($100 expense times the 9.3% tax
rate).
A taxpayer may reduce his or her AGI by the larger of either the standard deduction or
the total of his or her allowed itemized deductions.
24
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
Standard deduction amounts in federal law are different from those in California law. In
2008, federal amounts are as follows:
Single $5,450
Federal law also allows taxpayers to increase their standard deductions if they have
dependents, are over age 65, and/or blind.
Unlike federal law, California does not allow larger standard deductions for taxpayers
that have dependents and/or are over age 65 and/or blind. Instead, state law provides
exemption credits (see Section 7).
Itemized Deductions. As an alternative to the standard deduction, both state and federal
law allow various specific expenses (called itemized deductions) to be deducted from
AGI. The major itemized deductions permitted include the following:
° Home mortgage interest on first and second homes, subject to certain limits;
° Property taxes;
° Unreimbursed casualty and theft losses of over $100. However, only losses in
excess of 10% of AGI may be deducted; and
25
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
California's rules on itemized deductions are very similar to federal rules. The major
difference is that federal law allows an itemized deduction for state income taxes paid,
whereas California law does not.
Both state and federal law limit itemized deductions for high-income filers. For 2008, the
California phase-out affects single filers with AGIs in excess of $163,187, joint filers
with AGIs in excess of $326,379, and heads of household with AGIs in excess of
$244,785. The 2008 federal phase-out affects single taxpayers, married taxpayers filing
jointly, heads of household, and qualifying widowers with AGIs in excess of $159,950,
and married taxpayers filing separately with AGIs in excess of $79,975.
Once a taxpayer has an AGI that exceeds the personal exemption phase-out amount, he or
she must decrease the value of his or her exemption by a specified percentage for each
$2,500 (or fraction thereof) by which the taxpayer's AGI exceeds the applicable threshold
amount. The phase-out rate is 2% for single taxpayers, heads of household, and married
taxpayers filing jointly, and 4% for a married taxpayer filing separately. However, in
2008 each exemption can not be reduced to less than $2,333.
6. FILING STATUS
Taxpayers must file using one of five filing statuses: (a) Single; (b) Married Filing
Separately; (c) Married Filing Jointly; (d) Head of Household; or (e) Surviving Spouse.
Filing status affects tax liability because it determines which tax rate schedules and
personal exemption credits a taxpayer may claim on his or her return.
A head of household is generally a person who is not married at the end of the taxable
year and who has a child or other relative living with him or her for more than half the
year.
26
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
filing status generally permits use of tax rates, deductions, and credits similar to those
used by joint filers.
In general, California taxpayers must use the same filing status on their state returns as
they use on their federal returns. In certain situations where one spouse is in the military
or a nonresident, or the taxpayers are registered domestic partners (RDPs), California
permits a filing status different from filing status claimed on the taxpayer's federal return.
A taxpayer might choose different filing statuses at the state and federal level if he or she
could lower his or her tax liability by doing so. Effective for tax years beginning in 2007,
taxpayers registered with the Secretary of State as RDPs are required to use a filing status
of either married filing jointly or married filing separately for California purposes,
regardless of their federal filing status. [SB 1827 (Migden), Chapter 802, Statutes of
2006; SB 105 (Migden), Chapter 426, Statutes of 2007].
California taxpayers are entitled to personal and dependent exemption credits in addition
to their deductions. These exemption credits are intended to shelter a minimum amount
of income of each person in the household from tax. The federal government offers
similar tax relief through the personal exemption and increased standard deductions for
certain qualifying individuals.
The personal exemption credit can be claimed by all taxpayers, except those who can be
claimed as a dependent on another person's return. An example would be a college
student who earns enough income to file his or her own tax return, but who is also
eligible to be claimed as dependent on his or her parents' return.
A dependent exemption credit may be claimed for any relative of the taxpayer (child,
stepchild, parent, stepparent, sibling, etc.) whom the taxpayer supports for over half of
the calendar year. A non-relative who lives in the taxpayer's home and is supported by
the taxpayer can also be claimed as a dependent.
An additional exemption credit can be claimed for any person in a household who is
blind or age 65 or older on the last day of the taxable year. A person who is both blind
and a senior is eligible for two additional exemption credits in addition to the personal or
dependent exemption credit.
The 2008 personal, dependent, senior and blind exemption credits are as follows:
27
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
State exemption credits are phased out for taxpayers with federal AGIs that exceed a
threshold amount. The threshold amounts are $326,379 (married filing jointly and
surviving spouse), $244,785 (head of household), and $163,187 (single and married filing
separately). Like the exemption credits, the phase-out threshold amounts are indexed for
inflation annually.
Once a taxpayer reaches the phase-out threshold, he or she is required to reduce his or her
credits by $6 (if a single taxpayer, head of household, or married filing separately) or $12
(if married filing jointly or surviving spouse) for each $2,500 ($1,250 if married filing
separate) by which that taxpayer's AGI exceeds the threshold amount. For example, a
married couple with two dependents would have their total exemption credits reduced by
$24 (12 + 6 + 6) for each $2,500 by which their AGI exceeded the threshold amount.
Proposition 63, approved by the voters in November 2004, adds a 1% surtax on that
portion of a taxpayer's taxable income in excess of $1 million, effective for tax years
beginning on January 1, 2005. This tax surcharge raised $895 million in 2005-06, $939
million in 2006-07, and $1.5 billion in 2007-08, and is estimated to raise $981 million in
2008-09. Approximately 46,000 taxpayers were liable for the surcharge for the 2006
taxable year.
Revenue generated by the Proposition 63 tax surcharge will be used to expand existing
county mental health programs and create new programs.
California law provides for six progressive marginal tax rates applied to taxable income:
1%, 2%, 4%, 6%, 8%, and 9.3%. The term "marginal tax rate" refers to the rate applied
to the last (or highest) dollar of taxable income. As note above, for tax years beginning
on or after January 1, 2005, a 1% surtax is imposed on taxable income in excess of $1
million.
Under a system of progressive marginal tax rates (or "brackets"), each additional
increment of income a person earns is subject to a higher tax rate. Thus, for example, the
first increment of income is taxed at a rate of 1%, the second (next greater) increment is
taxed at a rate of 2%, the third increment is taxed at a rate of 4%, and so on. The
principle behind progressive marginal tax rates is that people with more income have a
greater ability to pay taxes than those with lower incomes.
28
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
The California tax rates and income brackets that apply for the 2008 year are shown in
Table 2 on the next page. Note that each filing status has the same rates of tax but the
amounts of income included in each respective bracket are different. Table 2 shows that
in 2008, the maximum tax rate of 9.3% applied to single taxpayers with taxable incomes
of $47,055 or more and to married taxpayers with taxable incomes of $94,110 or more.
The income brackets are indexed annually for inflation (see Section 10 of this chapter).
29
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
TABLE 2
30
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
TABLE 3
31
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
9. INDEXING
Many components of the Personal Income Tax Law used to calculate tax liability are
modified annually to adjust for inflation using a method called indexing. For example,
income brackets, exemption credits, the standard deduction, the joint custody head of
household credit, and many of the phase-out limits in the Personal Income Tax Law are
indexed annually. Indexing is intended to prevent taxpayers from being pushed into
higher marginal tax brackets by increases in income that just keep pace with inflation,
while the taxpayers' real buying power is not increasing.
The indexing adjustment equals the percentage difference between the California
Consumer Price Index (CCPI) in June of the current year and June of the prior year.
Each dollar value to be indexed is multiplied annually by this percentage change.
Indexing is illustrated below using one of the most important components of the personal
income tax – brackets. As noted above, annual indexing of income within the tax
brackets is intended to keep a taxpayer in the same bracket, as long as his or her income
increases no faster than the CCPI. For example, the effect of indexing on two
hypothetical taxpayers would be as follows:
Indexing of the tax rate brackets lowers the taxpayer's tax liability, consistent
with the taxpayer's decline in buying power.
Federal law began indexing tax rate brackets in 1985 and the standard deduction in 1989.
The federal indexing measure differs from California through use of the U.S. Consumer
Price Index and a different 12-month period (August to August).
Tax credits reduce tax liability on a dollar-for-dollar basis (i.e., $1 in tax credits reduces a
taxpayer's tax liability by $1). After the taxpayer computes tax due for his or her taxable
income, he or she subtracts the credits to which he or she is entitled, thereby reducing the
amount of tax due. Thus, credits have a greater impact than deductions, whose value in
32
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
reducing tax liability (as discussed in Section 5 of this chapter) equals the amount of the
deduction times the tax rate. Most state tax credits are not refundable if they exceed total
tax due. However, in some cases credits that exceed tax liability may be carried forward
and claimed against a taxpayer's future years' taxes.
Credits are usually provided to give tax relief to people who incur certain nondiscre
tionary costs, have limited ability to pay taxes, or to provide incentives to people to
engage in certain activities that are socially or economically desirable. Tax reform
legislation enacted in 1987 placed sunset dates (i.e., automatic repeal) on many credits in
the Personal Income Tax Law in order to give the Legislature an opportunity to evaluate
their impact.
The amount of the tax credits allowable in any taxable year may be limited by the
taxpayer's alternative minimum tax liability or by tentative minimum tax (see Section 14
of this chapter for further information).
Some of the tax credits allowed in state law are similar to credits offered in federal law.
However, in most cases the federal credits are larger.
The most significant credits allowed in state law are described below. The credits are
available to both full-time and part-time California residents, as well as to nonresidents
with California-source income. California residents are entitled to the full value of each
credit, as long as they meet all of the eligibility criteria for the credits. Nonresidents and
part-year residents are required to prorate the amount of each credit claimed using rules
specified in statute.
Renters' Credit. The Legislature enacted a "renters' credit" in 1972. In the first 20 years
following its inception, both the value of the credit and the income eligibility rules
applied to taxpayers that claimed the credit varied, but the credit was always available.
However, the renters’ tax credit was suspended when California experienced severe
economic pressures in the early 1990s. As part of budget agreements, the credit was not
available during the five-year period corresponding to the 1993 through 1997 taxable
years. The Legislature reinstated the renters' credit effective January 1, 1998.
Historically, the renters’ tax credit was also refundable. However, as reinstated, the
renters' credit is nonrefundable and is subject to income phase-outs. For 2008, married
taxpayers filing jointly, heads of household, and surviving spouses with AGIs of $69,872
or less may claim a credit of $120. Single taxpayers and married taxpayers filing
separately with AGIs of $34,936 or less may claim a credit of $60. See Chapter 6F
(Renters' Credit) for more information.
Senior Head of Household Credit. Taxpayers who are 65 years of age or older on
December 31st of the current tax year, qualified as head of household during either the
33
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
previous two tax years by providing a household for a qualifying individual who died
during one of the previous two tax years, and whose AGI for 2008 is $63,831 or less,
may claim a credit equal to 2% of taxable income. For 2008, the maximum allowable
credit is $1,203. The AGI cap and maximum allowable credit are indexed annually for
inflation.
Joint Custody Head of Household Credit. Taxpayers who qualify as joint custody
heads of household may claim a state tax credit that offsets a portion of their tax liability.
To qualify, the taxpayer must: (a) be unmarried at the end of the year; (b) have custody
of a dependent under a custody agreement for between 146 and 219 days of the year; and
(c) furnish over half of all household expenses. The credit is 30% of the net tax, not to
exceed $393 for the 2008 tax year. The maximum available credit is indexed for inflation
annually. The purpose of this credit is to allow divorced couples who share custody of a
child to share the benefits of the head of household filing status. A similar credit is
available to separated married persons who support a dependent parent.
Credit for Taxes Paid to Other States. In order to avoid double taxation, California
residents are generally allowed a credit for income taxes paid to another state on income
that is also taxed by California. The credit may not exceed the tax California would have
imposed on the income taxed by such other state. If the other state taxes this income at a
lower rate than California, this credit has the effect of allowing California to tax only a
portion of the income taxed by the other state.
Excess Employee's State Disability Insurance (SDI) Credit. Employees who work for
more than one employer and who earned over $86,698 during the 2008 tax year may have
paid more than the maximum State Disability Insurance through over-withholding. The
excess may be recovered by claiming a credit against the California personal income tax
on a Form 540 or 540A tax return.
Child Adoption Cost Credit. This credit is equal to 50% of the costs of adopting a
minor child who is a citizen or legal resident of the United States and is in the custody of
a California public agency or a political subdivision of California. The credit can be
claimed in the taxable year in which the decree or order of adoption is entered, even
though qualifying costs paid or incurred in prior years may qualify for the credit. Costs
eligible for the credit include: (a) fees for required services of either the Department of
Social Services or a licensed adoption agency; (b) travel and related expenses for the
adoptive family that are directly related to the adoption process; and (c) medical fees and
expenses that are not reimbursed by insurance and are directly related to the adoption
process. The maximum allowable credit cannot exceed $2,500 per minor child. This
credit may be carried over and is allowed for taxable years beginning on or after January
1, 1994.
34
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
Federal tax law also offers a child adoption cost credit. Taxpayers may claim a credit of
up to $11,650 for the qualified adoption expenses of each eligible child. Phase-out of the
federal credit begins for taxpayers with modified AGIs of more than $174,730; the
federal credit is completely phased out for taxpayers with modified AGIs of $214,730 or
more for the 2008 tax year. The limitation on eligible expenses and phase-out incomes
are increased for inflation annually. Qualified adoption expenses include reasonable and
necessary adoption fees, court costs, attorney fees, and other expenses directly related to
the legal adoption of an eligible child. The federal credit may be carried over for up to
five years.
Child and Dependent Care Credit. Beginning with the 2000 taxable year, taxpayers
that maintain a household within the state for a qualifying individual may claim a
refundable child and dependent care credit for employment-related expenses. The state
credit supplements a similar federal household and dependent care credit.
As defined by the federal law, a qualifying individual is a dependent of the taxpayer that
is under the age of 13 or a dependent or spouse who is physically or mentally unable to
care for himself or herself. Employment-related expenses are defined as those incurred to
enable the taxpayer to obtain or retain gainful employment.
The federal credit, which can be applied to a maximum of $3,000 in expenses for one
dependent and $6,000 in expenses for two or more dependents, is equal to between 20%
and 35%, depending on a taxpayer's AGI. Taxpayers with AGIs of $15,000 or less are
eligible for the 35% credit. The amount of the credit decreases by one percentage point
for each $2,000 by which a taxpayer's AGI exceeds $15,000. Thus, a credit of 20% may
be claimed by taxpayers with AGIs over $43,000.
California taxpayers may claim the state credit regardless of whether they have federal
tax liability.
Teacher Retention Tax Credit [Suspended in the 2004 and 2005 taxable years for cost-
saving reasons, SB 1100 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 226,
Statutes of 2004; again suspended in the 2006 taxable year, AB 1809 (Assembly Budget
Committee), Chapter 49, Statutes of 2006 ]. In 2001, California began offering a
nonrefundable credit to credentialed public school teachers based on their years of
teaching experience, allowing a credit of up to $1,500. Following several years of
35
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
suspension, the credit was repealed for taxable years beginning January 1, 2007. [SB 87
(Senate Budget Committee), Chapter 180, Statutes of 2007.]
Credits for Businesses. A number of other credits are available for business taxpayers
that file under the personal income tax, such as sole proprietorships and partnerships.
The total business credit allowed for taxpayers with net business income (PIT) greater
than $500,000 is limited to 50% of the total credit available for taxable years beginning
on or after January 1, 2008 and before January 1, 2010. Any credit amount in excess of
the limitation is eligible for carryforward. [AB 1452 (Committee on Budget), Chapter
763, Statutes of 2008.] Refer to the Bank and Corporation Tax chapter (Chapter 2C) for
a description of tax credits applicable to businesses.
Long-term care credit. For taxable years beginning in 2000 and ending in 2004, the
state offers a $500 credit to each taxpayer whose adjusted gross income is less than
$100,000 and for whom the taxpayer is an eligible caregiver for the taxable year. An
eligible caregiver is either the taxpayer, his or her spouse, or his or her dependent.
Anyone for whom the credit may be claimed must also be physician-certified as requiring
long-term care for at least 180 consecutive days, at least one of which occurs during the
taxable year. In order to be certified as requiring long-term care, an individual must meet
certain age-specific criteria provided in law.
In order to claim the credit, a taxpayer must include on his or her personal income tax
return the name and taxpayer identification number of the individual for whom care is
being provided and the identification number of the physician certifying that the
individual requires long-term care. When more than one person is an eligible caregiver
for the same individual, only one caregiver may claim the credit.
Capital gains are profits from the sale of property and other capital assets. They are
classified as a different type of income from "ordinary income," which includes wages,
salaries, and interest.
Capital assets are defined as all property except the following: inventories; property held
for sale in the ordinary course of business; depreciable business property; and real
property used in business. Capital assets include real property (land and buildings),
personal property, and intangible assets (such as stock).
Capital gains are measured as the difference between the amount realized when the asset
is sold and the asset's basis. Although an asset's basis is normally that asset's original
purchase price, basis can be adjusted to reflect improvements and costs of sale. Any
amounts invested in improvements are added to the purchase price to increase basis; costs
of sale are deducted from the sales price to reduce basis. Capital gains are generally
recognized in the year an asset is sold or otherwise disposed.
36
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
Through 1986, capital gains were accorded special tax treatment in California. During
that time, gains on assets held longer than one year were partially excluded from tax.
However, beginning in 1987, California began including all capital gains within the
measure of a taxpayer's income. California's tax treatment of capital gains is different
from federal treatment, because California applies the same tax rates to capital gains as
applies to ordinary income; the federal government applies lower rates to qualifying
capital gains.
Under federal (but not state) law, most types of investments held more than one year are
subject to capital gains tax at a top rate of 20% (10% for investors in the 15% tax bracket)
if the sale takes place before May 6, 2003.
However, individuals in the 15% tax bracket will pay capital gains tax at a rate of 8%,
instead of 10%, on profits from the sale before May 6, 2003 of investments held more
than five years.
For sales on or after May 6, 2003, and before January 1, 2009, the maximum capital gain
rate is 15% (5% for individuals taxed in the 10% or 15% tax bracket, or at a zero percent
rate for tax years beginning after 2007). For sales in 2009 and later, the rates return to
those that applied to sales before May 6, 2003.
These lower rates apply to most (but not all) types of investments. Among those
ineligible are collectibles with a maximum rate of 28%. Nor do the lower rates apply to
gains from the sale of investment real estate to the extent of depreciation deductions
previously claimed with a maximum rate of 25%.
Special enacted state and federal laws provide an exemption for 50% of the capital gains
realized from the sale of qualified small business stock. Qualifying stock must be issued
after August 10, 1993 and be held for a least five years prior to sale. For state tax
purposes, the company in which the investment is made must be located in California and
have assets of not more than $50 million. Certain industry and other limitations apply,
including industry growth in payroll, etc.
As under federal law, capital losses are fully deductible against capital gains realized in
the same year. In addition, up to $3,000 of capital losses in excess of capital gains are
deductible against ordinary income in any taxable year. If excess capital losses are
greater than $3,000, the unused portion may be carried forward indefinitely to offset
capital gains in future years and to deduct against ordinary income subject to the $3,000
annual limit. Federal law allows a three-year carryback of capital losses, but California
does not.
State law also conforms to federal capital gains treatment on sale or exchange of a
principal residence. Specifically, state and federal laws provide that a single taxpayer
may exclude up to $250,000 and a married taxpayer filing jointly may exclude up to
$500,000 of gain realized on the sale or exchange of a principal residence. The exclusion
37
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
is allowed each time a taxpayer selling a principal residence meets certain eligibility
requirements, but generally no more frequently than once every two years. To be eligible
for the exclusion, a taxpayer must have owned the residence and occupied it as a
principal residence for at least two of the five years prior to the sale or exchange. Federal
and state laws repealed the once-in-a-lifetime exclusion of $125,000 and the rollover of
gain from the sale of a principal residence provisions that previously existed.
Depreciation and amortization are allowed for property used in a trade or business or for
the production of income (investment). Depreciable property includes most kinds of
tangible property and improvements to real property, farm buildings, machinery, and
other physical assets. Intangible assets that may be amortized include copyrights,
licenses, franchises, goodwill, and covenants not to compete. Depreciation and
amortization are not allowed for property used for personal purposes, inventory and stock
in trade, land, and depletable natural resources.
Under the personal income tax law, California generally conforms to the federal
depreciation system for assets placed in service on and after January 1, 1987. This is
called the Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (MACRS). Under MACRS, all
depreciable assets are placed in classes. These class assignments determine the assets'
useful lives (i.e., the periods over which the assets may be depreciated) and the method of
depreciation that must be used. The amount to be depreciated is the property's basis or its
acquisition price. In general, MACRS allows shorter useful lives and more accelerated
depreciation methods than are allowed under other permissible depreciation systems,
thereby allowing larger depreciation deductions.
Under federal (but not state) law, a taxpayer is allowed to elect to take a bonus first-year
depreciation deduction equal to 30% of the adjusted basis of qualified property (including
New York Liberty Zone property) placed in service by the taxpayer after September 10,
2001. That percentage increases to 50% for property placed in service after May 5, 2003,
and before January 1, 2005. The additional first year depreciation deduction generally is
determined without any proration based on the length of the taxable year in which the
qualified property or New York Liberty Zone property is placed in service. The adjusted
basis of this property generally is its cost or other basis multiplied by the percentage of
business/investment use, reduced by the amount of any Section 179 expense deduction
and adjusted to the extent provided by other provisions of the Internal Revenue Code.
The remaining adjusted basis of this property is depreciated using the applicable
depreciation provisions under the Code for the property. This depreciation deduction for
the remaining adjusted basis of the qualified property or New York Liberty Zone
38
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
property for which the additional first year depreciation is deductible is allowed for both
regular tax and alternative minimum tax purposes.
In addition, in lieu of depreciation, existing federal and state laws (Internal Revenue
Code Section 179) allow a deduction to taxpayers with a sufficiently small amount of
capital expenditures for depreciable property. These taxpayers may elect to expense (i.e.,
to deduct immediately rather than depreciate over time) the cost of qualified property
placed in service for the taxable year and purchased for use in the active conduct of a
trade or business. Federal and state limits differ. The limit is $250,000 in 2008 under
federal law but remains $25,000 for California. However, starting in 2005, California
"C" Corporations are allowed to elect, in lieu of a maximum of $2,000 additional first-
year depreciation, a Section 179 deduction of up to a maximum of $25,000. The allowed
deduction is reduced (but not below zero) by the amount by which the cost of qualifying
property placed in service during the taxable year exceeds $800,000 under federal law
and $200,000 for California.
The MACRS system is not permitted under the California bank and corporation tax law.
However, California law permits S Corporations to compute depreciation under the rules
contained in the Personal Income Tax Law. For that reason, S Corporations can use both
MACRS and the Section 179 deductions referenced above. Refer to the Bank and
Corporation Tax chapter of this Reference Book (Chapter 2C) for a description of
depreciation deductions allowed for other corporate taxpayers.
Net operating losses (NOLs) occur in the course of a trade or business when deductions
exceed income. Under federal law, a net operating loss can be carried back for two years
(five years for losses arising in 2001 and 2002) and carried forward for 20 years.
California suspended taxpayers' abilities to claim NOL deductions during the 2008 and
2009 tax years. However, taxpayers were given two additional years in which to claim
NOLs accrued prior to January 1, 2009 and one additional year in which to claim NOLs
accrued during the 2009 taxable year. Beginning with the 2008 tax year the NOL
carryover period is extended to 20 years for NOLs attributable to taxable years beginning
on or after January 1, 2008. California allows a two-year carryback period for NOLs
attributable to tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2011. [AB 1452 (Committee on
Budget), Chapter 763, Statutes of 2008.] Prior to these changes, California did not
normally allow NOL deductions to be carried back. For taxable years beginning before
39
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
January 1, 2000, California allowed 50% of NOLs to be carried forward for five years.
Beginning with the 2000 tax year, the carryforward periods and carryforward amounts
were increased as follows:
In 2002, as part of the budget package, California suspended taxpayers' abilities to claim
NOL deductions during the 2002 and 2003 tax years. However, taxpayers were given
two additional years in which to claim NOLs accrued prior to January 1, 2002 and one
additional year in which to claim NOLs accrued during the 2002 taxable year.
Prior to the changes made in 2002, special NOL carryforward rules were available to
specific groups of taxpayers, including new businesses, small businesses, businesses
located in EZs, LAMBRAs, and TTAs, and taxpayers involved in bankruptcies and
certain bankruptcy reorganizations. Starting in 2004, virtually all businesses are treated
the same way under California's NOL laws. Specific details regarding these provisions
are described in Section 8 of Chapter 2C.
Noncorporate taxpayers who take advantage of certain tax preferences must calculate and
pay an alternative minimum tax (AMT) at a 7% rate if their tentative minimum tax
(TMT) exceeds their regular tax due. The purpose of the AMT is to ensure that taxpayers
who take advantage of special tax reduction provisions such as deductions and credits
pay at least some minimum amount of tax on their preferentially treated income.
California's AMT rules are patterned after federal law, which imposes the AMT at a
graduated rate of 26% on the first $175,000 of taxable income above the exemption
amount and 28% of the amount exceeding $175,000 above the exemption amount.
California's AMT replaced the add-on preference tax, which was a part of California's
personal income tax law until 1987.
California taxpayers that believe they may be subject to AMT must perform the
following steps to determine whether they owe any tax in addition to their regular tax
liability:
40
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
° Compare TMT to regular tax liability. If TMT exceeds regular tax, the
difference equals the taxpayer's AMT and must be added to the regular tax
and paid by the taxpayer.
For 2008, the exemption amounts are $80,017 for married persons filing jointly; $60,014
for single and head of household filers; and $40,007 for married persons filing separately.
These exemption amounts phase out to zero if alternative minimum taxable income
exceeds $300,065 for married taxpayers filing jointly; $225,050 for single and head of
household filers, and $150,031 for married taxpayers filing separately. The exemption
and phase-out amounts are indexed annually for inflation.
AMT has an important interaction with tax credits. Most credits can reduce regular tax
down to, but not below TMT. However, certain specific credits are not subject to this
limitation. These specific credits are:
41
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
For a further description of the AMT, refer to Section 12 of Chapter 2C, on the
Corporation Tax.
The tax treatment of pension and other retirement savings plans has two primary
elements -- treatment of contributions and treatment of withdrawals. With almost no
exceptions, California taxes pension and retirement savings (both contributions and
withdrawals) in an identical manner as does the federal government.
TABLE 4
Elective deferral plans $11,000 in 2002; $12,000 in 2003; $13,000 in $1,000 in 2002; $2,000 in 2003;
(401(k) plans, 403(b) 2004; $14,000 in 2005; $15,000 in 2006; $3,000 in 2004; $4,000 in 2005;
annuities, SEPs $15,500 in 2007 and 2008; indexed for $5,000 in 2006 and thereafter
(408(k)s)) inflation in $500 increments beginning in 2007
SIMPLE plans (408(p)) $7,000 in 2002; $8,000 in 2003; $9,000 in $500 in 2002; $1,000 in 2003; $1,500
2004; $10,000 in 2005 and 2006; $10,500 in in 2004; $2,000 in 2005; $2,500 in
2007; $10,500 in 2008; indexed for inflation in 2006 - 2008; catch-up contributions are
$500 increments beginning in 2006 indexed for inflation in $500
increments beginning in 2007
457 elective deferral $11,000 in 2002; $12,000 in 2003; $13,000 in $1,000 in 2002; $2,000 in 2003; $3,000
plans 2004; $14,000 in 2005; $15,000 in 2006; in 2004; $4,000 in 2005; $5,000 in
$15,500 in 2007 and 2008; indexed for inflation 2006 and thereafter
in $500 increments beginning in 2007 Plus, the limit is twice the standard
limit in a participant's last 3 years
before retirement.
42
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
Federal law provides taxpayers with flexibility to roll one type of plan into another type
of plan by allowing rollovers among governmental Section 457 plans and Section 403(b)
plans, rollovers of IRAs to workplace retirement plans, and rollovers of after-tax
retirement plan contributions (e.g., Roth IRAs). Those who have Section 457 plans may
use their plan funds to repay contributions and earnings previously refunded to them or to
purchase permissive service credits.
Federal laws prohibit states from taxing nonresidents on pension income received after
December 31, 1995. Because California enacted legislation that conforms to the federal
preemption, California does not impose a tax on specified pension income received by a
nonresident after December 31, 1995, as follows:
Passive Investments. California generally conforms to federal law (IRC Section 469) as
that section read on January 1, 2005. Both state and federal law limit the ability of
taxpayers to use passive investment losses to offset or shelter unrelated income. Passive
investments are trade or business activities in which the taxpayer does not materially
43
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
State and federal laws require the segregation of income and deductions into "active",
"passive", and "portfolio" categories. Portfolio income includes interest, dividends,
royalties, and gain or loss for the disposition of assets providing portfolio income.
Passive activity losses generally may not be deducted against other income, such as
wages, salary or portfolio income, or business income that was not derived from passive
activities. A similar rule applies to limit passive activity credits.
Current California law treats rental activities (including rental real estate activities) as
passive activities, regardless of the level of taxpayer participation. Federal and California
law permit the deduction of up to $25,000 of losses from rental real estate activities (even
though considered passive) if the taxpayer actively participates in them and certain tests
are met. This $25,000 amount is allowed for taxpayers with AGIs of $100,000 or less
and is phased out for taxpayers with AGIs between $100,000 and $150,000. Deductions
and credits suspended under these rules are treated as suspended losses or credits from a
passive activity and can be carried forward to years in which there is passive income.
Any remaining carry forwards is allowed in full when a taxpayer disposes of his or her
entire interest in the passive activity to an unrelated taxpayer.
Taxpayers must adjust the amount of California passive activity losses for differences in
other areas of state law (e.g., depreciation). Also, nonresidents and part-year residents
must make adjustments to passive activity items in computing California source AGI.
Other Special Provisions That Affect Businesses. There are other special provisions in
the Personal Income Tax Law that primarily affect business taxpayers. Several of these
are described in the Bank and Corporation Tax chapter (Chapter 2C).
Most corporations taxable by California are subject to a minimum franchise tax. This is a
specified dollar amount that businesses must pay even if their tax liability based on net
income is lower. See Section 4 of the Corporation Tax chapter for more information on
the franchise tax.
Personal income taxpayers are not subject to a minimum tax. However, certain entities
taxed under the Personal Income Tax Law are subject to an annual tax equal to the
minimum franchise tax. These include limited partnerships, limited liability partnerships,
44
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
certain limited liability companies, and real estate mortgage investment conduits
(REMICs).
A limited liability company (LLC) is a non-corporate entity, the revenue from which is
included as corporation tax revenue. A LLC provides its members with limited liability
and the option to participate actively in the entity's management. A LLC is formed by
filing Articles of Organization with the California Secretary of State. Although
exhibiting the corporate characteristic of limited liability, a LLC with at least two
members is usually treated as a partnership under the "check-the-box rules" used by both
the Federal Government and California
In certain cases, an LLC may "check the box" on Federal Form 8832 (Entity
Classification Election) to be taxed like a C Corporation. In addition, this C Corporation
could elect S Corporation status. California applies the same tax treatment elected for
federal tax purposes.
Under current state law, an LLC not classified as a corporation must pay the $800 annual
LLC tax and the annual LLC fee if it is organized, doing business, or registered in
California. Beginning in 2007, the annual LLC fee is based on the LLC's total income
from all sources derived from or attributable to California. [AB 198 (Committee on
Budget), Chapter 381, Statutes of 2007.] Total income is defined as the gross income,
plus the cost of goods sold, that are paid or incurred in connection with the trade or
business of the taxpayer attributed to California, determined by applying franchise and
income tax sales factor rules under current law to the total income of the LLC. Prior to
2007, the annual LLC fee was based on the LLC's total income from all sources
reportable to the state.1 Total income excludes the flow-through of income from one
LLC to another LLC if that income has already been subject to California's annual LLC
fee. The following chart is used to compute the fee under the new law beginning 2007:
1
Under prior law, total income was defined as gross income from whatever sources derived plus the cost of
goods sold that are paid or incurred in connection with a trade or business. The law lacked a definition for
"from all sources reportable to the state", but FTB and taxpayers had defined this term to mean worldwide
gross receipts without apportionment. However, this interpretation has been challenged.
45
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
California allows taxpayers to make voluntary contributions of their own funds to one or
more organizations listed on the state tax return by checking a box on their return. These
eligible activities are often called "check-offs", although they are not like the federal
check-offs that allow taxpayers to direct a portion of their tax liability to the selected
organization. These contributions allowable on California tax returns are deductible as
charitable contributions on the following year's tax return for taxpayers that itemize
deductions.
For the 2008 tax year, 15 check-offs will appear on the individual income tax form. The
number of check-offs on the tax form has grown in recent years to the point where the
form is very close to exceeding its current two-page length. Going to a three-page form
would be extremely costly for the state due to increased printing and processing costs.
Initially, the Legislature responded to the proliferation of check-offs on the tax form by
requiring check-offs to have sunset dates and to meet minimum annual contribution
amounts. The Legislature requires new check-offs to wait in line to be added to the form
until old check-offs are removed (so-called "queuing language"). The current rules
regarding the standards each check-off must meet in order to remain on the form are
summarized in the following chart:
46
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
_____________________
¹ The final tax return is subject to change if the fund does not meet minimum contribution test or legislation extends the repeal date. Dates and conditions of
application vary for each fund.
² The $250,000 test, initial test year, and the first year the minimum amount is adjusted for inflation are subject to legislative change.
³* The California Firefighters' Memorial Fund and California Peace Officer Foundation Memorial Fund are only subject to the $250,000 minimum contribution
amount if their repeal dates are specifically deleted in new legislation.
SB 1249 (Alquist), Chapter 645, Statutes of 2005, requires the FTB to make two determinations each year for voluntary contribution funds:
(1) The minimum amount requires to be received for the fund to appear on the tax return in the following year, rather than current year.
(2) Whether the amount of contributions estimated to be received will equal or exceed the minimum amount required.
This act also provided that voluntary contribution funds that were subject to a minimum amount in 2005 and appeared on the 2005 state income tax return were
subject to the same minimum contribution amount for calendar year 2006.
47
CHAPTER 2B
PERSONAL INCOME
TAX
20. REVENUE
The personal income tax is the largest single source of revenue for the State of California.
Revenues were $54.2 billion in 2007-08 (52.9% of state General Fund revenues).
Revenues are expected to be $46.8 billion in 2008-09.
21. ADMINISTRATION
The FTB administers the personal income tax. Returns are due annually on the 15th day
of the fourth month following the close of each taxable year (typically April 15th).
Individuals are automatically granted an extended filing period of six months for
submitting their tax returns but are not relieved of their obligation to pay the tax due by
April 15. Taxpayers who do not pay 100% of their tax liability by April 15 owe interest
and are assessed a late payment penalty. Similarly, taxpayers who do not file by the
extended due date (typically October 15th) are assessed a penalty for failure to file.
However, taxpayers who do file on or before the extended due date are not penalized for
failure to file.
The amount of tax due in excess of the amount withheld and/or paid as an estimated
payment is due on April 15th. If a taxpayer overpays during the year through
withholding and/or estimated payments, he or she can direct FTB to apply the
overpayment to the next year's liability or to refund the overpayment by check.
22. CODE
Revenue and Taxation Code, Division 2, Part 10, Section 17001 et. seq., and Part 10.2,
Sections 18401-19802
48