Ano-145 Cap
Ano-145 Cap
Ano-145 Cap
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
Facilities (145.A.25)
SNO. FINDINGS PJ REPLY 1/2/3/4 PCAA REMARKS 1/2/3/4
Plastic Container for storing rubber items being procured.
Satisfactory, Open.
Completion: 29th Feb.2016
Rubberized Items are not stored in a controlled Unsatisfactory, Open. Whole CAP to
1. SAT (CLOSED).
environment .They are placed in open racks be revised
Plastic Container for storing rubber items being procured.
Satisfactory, Closed. Verified.
Completion: 10th June, 2016
Separate containers for the items are being procured in Unsatisfactory, Open. No procurement
order to avoid mixing. Completion: 29th Feb,2016 done till date.
Binning is not proper. Binned items may get mixed. Unsatisfactory, Open. Whole CAP to
Being Purchased
Sample check of Oring AS-3209-110 carried out. Store be revised
2 record reflected that total quantity available is 25 Containers will be purchased and marked for ease of Satisfactory, Open. To be verified in
whereas total quantity actually available was 23. 02 O- identification. Completion: 10th June, 2016 audit
rings part no. AS3209-011 were found. Satisfactory, Open. To be verified in
Containers have been procured to prevent mixing of items audit
Satisfactory, Closed. Verified
Automatic Fire/Smoke detection system for the areas Unsatisfactory, Open. No system
identified will be installed. Completion: 29th Feb, 2016 installed till date.
Unsatisfactory, Open. Whole CAP to
Being Purchased
be revised
Fire detection system was not available inside technical Automatic Fire/Smoke detection system will be procured
3 Satisfactory, Open. To be verified in
record room of fixed wing and POL storage. and installed by first week of June
audit
Completion: 10th June, 2016
Satisfactory, Open: Installation shall be
Automatic Fire/Smoke detection system has been
verified in audit.
procured
Satisfactory, Closed. Verified
POL items are not segregated w.r.t HW and FW.
POL Store to be shifted as advised. Separate areas for
4. Furthermore POL items are placed within the office Satisfactory, Closed
FW and HW in new store Completion: 29th Feb, 2016
accommodation.
Signs of water leakage were observed on ceiling of Estimate being obtained for repairs, completion on priority
5. Satisfactory, Closed
technical record room of FW. Completion: 30th Jan, 2016
6. HW records are not placed in fire proof cabinet and are Actions to acquire fire proof cabinets initiated. Unsatisfactory, Open. Fire Proof
also not placed under lock and key. Completion: 15th Feb, 2016 cabinets still not available.
Page 1 of 13
Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
Page 2 of 13
Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
Page 3 of 13
Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
Page 4 of 13
Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
induction of Manager QA. Completion: 30th April,2016 still unavailable. GM QA not available.
Unsatisfactory, Open. Whole CAP to
QA related (In Progress)
be revised
Satisfactory, Open: The work hours as
mentioned in the man hour plan are
Plan attached (Completed)
unrealistic and need to be reviewed
seriously.
Plan already submitted vide CAP dated May 20th ,2016. Refer reply above
Work hours have been reviewed, fresh plan attached. Satisfactory, Closed.
Job descriptions for all nominated persons prepared.
Job descriptions are not as per the guidelines provided
15. Same for other persons being prepared. Satisfactory, Closed
in the user guide.
Completion: 30th Jan, 2016
Job descriptions were not available with the Under preparation and will be given to personnel , after
16. Satisfactory, Closed
maintenance personnel. signature by GM QA/CEs. Completion: 30th Jan,2016.
17. Competence Assessment for all maintenance personnel Unsatisfactory, Open. Amended
Para 3.14 of MOE amended as advised, amended PJ
not carried out and is not mentioned in MOE 3.14. procedure not submitted.
controller document prepared. Same will be used for the
Implementation of Competence
issuance of Certification Authorization. Completion: 29th
Assessment procedure could not be
Feb,2016.
verified.
Unsatisfactory, Open. Whole CAP to
QA Related (In-Progress)
be revised
Unsatisfactory, Open: Inclusion of
Competence Assessment was only one
Para 3.14 of MOE duly amended. Procedure attached.
part of the finding. Competence
Completed.
Assessment is to be carried out and
shall be verified in physical audit.
Para 3.14 of MOE duly amended. Procedure submitted Unsatisfactory, Open: Refer reply
vide CAP dated May 20th, 2016. above
Satisfactory Open. The procedure was
reviewed in the Verification Audit,
however it needs further improvement.
For example the QA Manager himself
cannot assess the Certifying staff. He
Competence Assessment has been carried out for both
needs to have Chief Engineer of the
(FW) & (HW). COMPLETED.
concerned department to be present as
the member. Furthermore, the
procedure must answer the four
questions given in the preamble of
MOE User guide.
Board will carry out competence assessment for both CS Satisfactory, Closed. Procedure
Page 5 of 13
Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
Page 6 of 13
Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
Page 7 of 13
Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
Page 8 of 13
Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
Page 9 of 13
Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
Page 10 of 13
Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
Page 11 of 13
Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
Para 2.16 of MOE amended as advised. Revised Unsatisfactory, Open. Whole CAP to
procedure and form to be submitted. be revised
Satisfactory, Open: Para 2.16.2.3
MOE para 2.16 amended, copy attached. should include minimum information on
CRS as described in MOE user guide.
MOE para 2.16 amended, copy submitted vide CAP dated Unsatisfactory, Open: Refer reply
May 20th, 2016. above.
Satisfactory, Open. Verified, MOE
procedure needs further clarifications
COMPLETED.
as discussed during the verification
audit.
CRS procedure has been modified and new form issued
Satisfactory, Closed. Verified.
which is common for both FW & HW. Completed.
Shifting and relocations of accommodation being made to Unsatisfactory, Open. Procedures for
have POL outside the main building Para 1.8.13(layout), maintaining Technical records for FW
being amended. Completion: 15th Feb,2016 and HW not revised.
Shifting and relocations of accommodation being made to
have POL outside the main building Para 1.8.13(layout),
During audit it was observed that FW and RW have Unsatisfactory, Open. Whole CAP to
being amended , procedure for maintaining technical
different technical record rooms, tools and equipment be revised
39. records for FW and HW not revised. UNSAT(OPEN)
and different procedures for maintaining records. Same Under Progress.
is not reflected in MOE. Unsatisfactory, Open. Procedures for
Shifting and relocation carried out. Para 1.8.13 amended .
maintaining Technical records for FW
Copy attached.
and HW are yet to be revised.
Shifting and relocation carried out. Para 1.8.13 amended . Unsatisfactory, Open. Refer reply
Copy submitted vide CAP dated 20th May,2016. above.
COMPLETED. Satisfactory, Closed. Verified.
Unsatisfactory, Open. Procedures not
Para 2.13 of MOE , being amended, Completion: 15th
amended. Kindly submit revised
Feb,2016
procedure.
Para 2.13 of MOE, being amended, Unsatisfactory, Open. Whole CAP to
MOE chapter 2.13 does not describe adequate QA Related (In Progress) be revised
40.
procedures for completion of maintenance document Unsatisfactory, Open To be reviewed in
MOE para 2.13 amended, copy attached
light of MOE User guide.
MOE para 2.13 amended, copy submitted vide CAP dated Unsatisfactory, Open. To be reviewed
May 20th ,2016. in light of MOE User guide
COMPLETED. Copy attached. Satisfactory Closed. Verified.
41. Quality Review meeting with the Accountable Manager One meeting per year carried out. As advised the Unsatisfactory, Open. Amended MOE
not carried out. meetings will now be twice a year. Next meeting planned Procedure and evidence of meeting for
Page 12 of 13
Pakistan Civil Aviation Authority
Airworthiness Directorate
Appendix ‘A’ to HQCAA/1046/051/AWAA/IV dated 27th April, 2017
Page 13 of 13