Tensile Behavior of Pre-Stress Corroded and Post Hydrogen Embrittled Spring Steel
Tensile Behavior of Pre-Stress Corroded and Post Hydrogen Embrittled Spring Steel
Tensile Behavior of Pre-Stress Corroded and Post Hydrogen Embrittled Spring Steel
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCC) and Hydrogen Embrittlement (HE) are two major degradation phenom-
Received 13 June 2021 ena experienced by spring steel. The consequences of these phenomena have an impact both on the
Received in revised form 15 August 2021 mechanic response, sufficiency, and life of the mechanical system. The susceptibility to premature failure
Accepted 19 August 2021
is never the same and is unique for different environment combinations. There will be a combined effect
Available online 31 August 2021
of these phenomena. Here in this experimental investigation, an attempt is made to understand the ten-
sile behavior of combined treatment. The pre-stressed specimens were corroded and post-treated with
Keywords:
the HE process. Traditional tensile testing was used to investigate the combined effect of corrosion and
Tensile loading
SCC
post-treated HE. From the test results, it can interfere that the post hydrogen charged specimen exhibits
HE ductility loss, but recover in the ultimate strength, and increase in yield strength. The dominance of
Anodic dissolution recovery was also shown by an increase in fracture strength and toughness. The scanning electron micro-
Crack closure scope was used to assess the mechanism and to characterize it.
Fractography Ó 2021 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Selection and Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the Global Conference on
Recent Advances in Sustainable Materials 2021.
1. Introduction works have been carried out to understand the failure mecha-
nisms. The various mechanism by which Environmental assisted
Corrosion of steel is one of the main degradation problems in cracking occurs like anodic dissolution, film rupture during general
the industrialized world. In many service conditions, where the corrosion, hydrogen influenced hydrogen enhanced assisted crack-
prevailing stresses are combined with a corrosive environment, ing or adsorption-induced dislocation is still debated in engineer-
the degradation phenomena intensify. There is considerable inter- ing alloys, particularly for different material and service
est in material degradation at present, which is partly responsible environment combinations [3–5]. The deleterious interaction of
for failures and shortening of the service life of the mechanical sys- the operating environment and mechanical loads influences the
tem. Material degradation affects the performance of many indus- performance and life of engineering alloys. Even though structural
trial engineering steel components due to exposure to in-service steel alloys were selected and intended for long-term use, they fail
conditions. Material degradation affects the performance of many due to various factors such as overuse, overloading, an unfavorable
industrial engineering steel components due to exposure to in- oxidative, corrosive environment, residual strains, and poor main-
service conditions such as overloading, overutilization, corrosive tenance. The components, which are subjected to deleterious aque-
environment, and improper maintenance. The consequences of ous conditions, lead to corrosion and subsequently decrease the
these in-service conditions lead to fatigue, corrosion, and wear life and load capacity. Spring steel is one of the widely used carbon
damage, are of considerable technological significance. Materials steel in the industrial world because of its properties such as
degradation problems are in particular important in naval, petro- toughness, strength & hardness. Under extreme service conditions,
chemical; energy generation, and conversion industries, including EN47 spring steel will undergo two major phenomena Stress corro-
nuclear [1,2]. In response to these challenges, extensive research sion cracking (SCC) and hydrogen embrittlement (HE). This con-
ceptualization raises the scope for the investigation of the failure
behavior of spring steel. The integrity of the material relies on
⇑ Corresponding author. the material behavior under complex service conditions such as a
E-mail address: [email protected] (H.K. Basukumar). high rate of loading, environmental conditions, and material. The
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2021.08.156
2214-7853/Ó 2021 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Selection and Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the Global Conference on Recent Advances in Sustainable Materials 2021.
H.K. Basukumar and K.V. Arun Materials Today: Proceedings 49 (2022) 2000–2006
Table 1
Chemical composition of test specimen material EN47/SAE6510.
consequence of conjunction action of the escorts environmentally utes exposure. The nitric acid exhibits the most aggressive corro-
induced crack initiation and propagation results in impulsive fail- sive nature in most of the metal, especially in steel. Therefore,
ure [6–8]. nitric acid is considered for the simulated laboratory condition.
A comparative study of tensile behavior of EN47 spring steel, The nitric acid with 20–22% concentration is used for passivation
over the corrosion environments, has been examined. The conjoint below and beyond which acts as a corrosive media. This typical
action of loading rate, corrosive environment, and material leads to solution exhibits corrosion behavior by anodic dissolution, which
a sudden and catastrophic failure. The term SCC is used to describe is one of the mechanisms for SCC, a cracking phenomenon caused
service failures in engineering materials that occur under the influ- by the combined effect of tensile stress and a corrosive environ-
ence of slow environmentally induced crack and its propagation as ment. In the laboratory experiment, stress-corrosion cracking of
a consequence of the working stress. This can lead to unexpected low-carbon steels occurs in specimens, which experience some
sudden failure of normally in ductile material subjected to tensile plastic deformation due to applied working stresses. As a necessary
stress. SCC is selective and specific to a certain chemical environ- condition, an initial plastic deformation was induced (about 70
ment. The specific environments along with very small concentra- percent of the ultimate stress) by pre-stressing the samples. In a
tions of certain highly active chemicals are needed to produce simulated corrosion environment, these pre-stressed specimens
stress corrosion cracking, often leading to devastating and unex- were subjected to general corrosion before being put through a
pected failure [9,10]. Hydrogen damages are one of the most com- tensile test until the final fracture. Defects caused by corrosion spe-
plex occurrences as material failure compares to the other type of cies will act as stress raisers and cause catastrophic failure when
failure in the hydrogen nonexistence. This type of material degra- combined with the applied working load.
dation is the result of various unknown physical and chemical
kinetics. Hence the study of HE of steels is a particularly significant
issue in many industrial applications, since a fully developed and 2.2.2. Post hydrogen embrittlement
practically applicable predictive physical mechanism-model, still The specimens were submerged in a 35 percent aqueous solu-
does not exist [11,12]. HE is one of the common degradation pro- tion of ammonium thiocyanate at room temperature for 120 hours
cesses which can happen in a room or slightly above room temper- for hydrogen charging. The test solution was replaced with fresh
ature with or without applied stress. Unfortunately, just solution every 48 hours. The test solution for the immersion test
determining that a failure is due to HE or SCC is seldom lending was prepared by diluting with distilled water to concentration of
a hand to the customer unless that determination is put together 35%w/vol at room temperature. The laboratory immersion experi-
with references that provide some ways to avoid such damage in ments were carried out in compliance with ASTM guidelines. By
future applications [13]. The combined effect of corrosion caused immersing the pre-stressed corroded specimens in hydrogen, a tra-
by dissolution and embrittlement caused by a cathodic reaction ditional laboratory immersion approach was used to charge hydro-
can still cause the unexpected failure of relevant materials. The gen. The experimental study involves mechanical testing of stress
susceptibility of spring steel to stress corrosion and embrittlement
was studied simultaneously. The overall corrosion process in
spring steel under the influence of pre-stress condition, as well
as post-hydrogen embrittlement (SHE), were studied to investigate
the failure mechanism of spring steel.
2.1. Material
2.2. Methods
2001
H.K. Basukumar and K.V. Arun Materials Today: Proceedings 49 (2022) 2000–2006
load is applied. As a result, plasticity occurs ahead of the crack tip that the material was able to withstand a greater load before
and crack grows through the plastic zone during tensile load before deforming. The chemical reaction at the surface has caused work
final failure. hardening. The uniaxial tensile properties of the treated and
untreated EN 47 steel specimens were represented graphically in
Fig. 5a and 5b. As schematically illustrated in Fig. 5, the yield
3.1. Stress/strain behavior of treated and untreated material
strength was higher in both the treated specimens. Higher strength
means an increase in hardness and lesser deformation. The excep-
Fig. 4 depicts a typical tensile curve in terms of engineering
tion to this, in the stress-corroded specimen test, the yield and
stress–strain variations with engineering strain in a simulated cor-
elongation both increased indicating the formation of the shear
rosive environment at a nominal strain rate of 0.3 mm/minute. The
band. A higher strength means increase in the hardness and lesser
tensile properties such as the yield strength, ultimate strength
deformation. Exception to this, during stress corrosion process the
were obtained. The ductility parameters such as the percentage
yield and elongation both increased indicating towards intense
of elongation and the area reduction of treated EN47 samples were
shearing strain. After post hydrogen treatment, the yield strength
evaluated at ambient temperature. The engineering stress–strain
of the specimen increase with a decrease in the percentage elonga-
curves of the EN47 spring steel Untreated, stress corroded, Pre-
tion pointing towards the recovery of the material properties of an
stress corroded post HE (SHE) are presented in Fig. 4. Typically,
untreated specimen, the same can be substantiated in the stress–
the corrosive environment affects the engineering tensile curve.
strain curve behavior. The behavior of stress–strain curves reveals
The untreated specimen had yield strength of 385 MPa, a 26 per-
a certain work hardening has taken place in the SCC test specimen
cent elongation, and an ultimate strength of 650 MPa . The SCC
by virtue of process which can be depicted as a decrease in UTS.
behavior of the test specimen yields results of 416 MPa and ulti-
The increase in both yield strength and percentage elongation;
mate strength of 506 MPa. The yield strength (YS) and ultimate
decrease in ultimate strength substantiate chemical reaction and
tensile strength (UTS) of the SHE sample were found to be
failure due to stress corrosion cracking. Further, the increase in
434 MPa and 585 MPa, respectively. In comparison with the
yield strength and decrease in percentage elongation indicates loss
untreated specimen, the yield strength was increased by 13 per-
of ductility pointing towards the effect of HE. The curve of the post
cent and the UTS decreased by 10 percent. The elongation was
hydrogen charged material indicates that it had become harder,
increased by 37 percent in stress corroded specimens and 17 per-
revealing embrittlement; that is can withstand far higher loads
cent in post-HE specimens. The increase in yield strength indicates
before they deform. There is a small increment in the load-
carrying capacity which is indicated by an increase in the ultimate
strength of the SHE specimen compared to the SCC specimen. The
stress–strain curve in Fig. 4 corroborates the recovery process that
occurred due to the post-HE process. This further shows the recov-
ery of plastic deformation, leading to an increase in toughness.
Fig. 5. Mechanical Properties of tensile test untreated SCC and SHE treated specimens of EN 47; (a) % elongation and yield strength, (b)) % elongation and Ultimate strength.
2003
H.K. Basukumar and K.V. Arun Materials Today: Proceedings 49 (2022) 2000–2006
show that the fracture origin is at the point indicated by the arrow. 3.2.2. Micro-mechanism failure analysis
The flat fracture surface indicates that the stress that caused the During slow strain rate tensile load failure, the formation of the
failure was tension, as there is no shear lip. The absence of a shear void, coalescence of voids, initiation of crack, crack, and rapid fail-
lip indicates that the fracture began at a free surface. The lack of ure has occurred in the untreated specimen. The formation of mul-
deformation indicates that the fracture is primarily brittle. The tiple cracks, at the circumference act as triggering site, will
radial lines are attributed to the direction of crack growth penetrate the material at a rapid speed; finally, fail as bulk shearing
upstream. The fracture surface is approximately normal to the of the material. The pre-crack originated by the virtue of the stress
applied tensile loading direction, and a shear lip is present around corrosion, are more and dense on the circumference of the material
the fracture. The fracture surface of the untreated specimen reveals as compare to untreated, but the depth of these dense cluster
a typical cup and cone morphology, which is reminiscent of glob- cracks are very less. The fracture facet of the untreated specimen
ally ductile failure; Macro brittle changing to macro ductile with (Fig. 6a) reveals elongated fracture whereas pre-stressed brittle
loss of constraint. This indicates a possible site for fracture initia- failure for treated specimen surfaces. Untreated specimens have
tion, as well as a bright central region and shear lips formed during a flat fracture surface with shallow radial marks associated with
the final stages of the fracture process. The fracture surfaces appear a cleavage mechanism, whereas the bright fibrous center region
brittle-ductile as a mixed-mode. There was a uniform distribution has dimples associated with a nucleation-growth-coalescence
of cracks around the circumference of the SCC specimen. These mechanism. The microstructure of the stress corroded specimen
were induced and originated by the virtue of the process. The uni- (Fig. 6b) shows pre-existing cracks that resulted in a mixed mode
form shear band formation can be seen on the fractured surface. of brittle and ductile cracking inferred by the presence of cleavage
There was a less and uneven distribution of cracks was observed and micro void coalescence at the microscale, as evidenced by the
on the circumference of the post-HE treated specimen as shown presence of shear lips. The macro and micrograph images show
in Fig. 7(a). Careful observation reveals of the gouge, possible crack that the central region is the result of void nucleation, their growth,
initiation site formed due to the corrosion phenomenon whereas and coalescence process; while the surface observed a formation of
closed crack on the surface formed due to embrittlement. Shiny the shear lip zone shows elongated dimples in the radial direction.
Fracture surface indicates cleavage likely failure whereas the rough Hence, it is presumed that, because of the decohesive process, a
matte surface stipulates ductile failure. quasi-brittle fracture failure occurred. This failure suggests that
Fig. 6. a) Macro and micrographs of Fractured Untreated Tensile Specimen; b) Macro and micrographs of Fractured stress corroded Tensile Specimen;
Fig. 7. Macro and micrographs of fractured pre-stress corroded post hydrogen embrittled Tensile Specimen; a) flat fractured surface b) Overall Micrograph of fractured
surface; c) Magnified image near the surface.
2004
H.K. Basukumar and K.V. Arun Materials Today: Proceedings 49 (2022) 2000–2006
the mechanism of plastic deformation localization induced by ano- The SCC behaviour of the spring steel is influenced by crack tip
dic dissolution was dominant in the SCC. The SCC behavior of the blunting due to anodic dissolution and because of decohesive
spring steel is influenced by crack tip blunting due to anodic disso- process, a quasi-brittle fracture takes place, which indicates,
lution. Well-documented literature enumerate crack closure the mechanism of localized plastic deformation induced by ano-
mechanism have a significant effect on the threshold behavior, dic dissolution.
especially in fatigue failures. With reference to the available infor- The effect of simulated chemical treatments of pre stress corro-
mation, the crack closure can be related to environmentally sion and post HE was noticed in-terms of change in yield
induced closure resulting from the corrosion product [19]. In this strength, ultimate strength and ductility under the influence
case, due to post hydrogen charging, the deposit also acts like a of tensile load. The stress-strain curve corroborate the recovery
trap allowing corrosive elements to enter but not to leave, leading process occurred due to post HE process. This further shows
to stationary propagation process of an external surface to the cre- recovery of plastic deformation, leading increase in toughness.
vice, anodic dissolution, internal cathodic reactions, and repassiva- Although recovery in the mechanical properties, there is mate-
tion [8,20]. The fracture surface in Fig. 7 (a) presents a nearly flat, rial degradation phenomenon involving overall loss of material
identifying as a macroscopically brittle failure, however, the which will affect the service life.
appearance of the microstructure stays quasi-brittle (Fig. 7c).
Microstructural examination shows a course ridged pattern, with
a reduction in area and a fibrous zone. A ridge pattern is visible
Declaration of Competing Interest
on the fracture surface of a material that shows limited ductility
during fracture. The dotted circle represents the fibrous zone of
The authors declare that they have no known competing finan-
overload fracture; finally, in the treated specimen the ridge pattern
cial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared
has disappeared, the reduction in area is large, and the fracture
to influence the work reported in this paper.
surface consists of a central fibrous region and a smaller shear
zone. Fig. 7(b) depicts the fracture morphologies of specimens at
the failure area. On the fracture surface, there are signs of cleavage Acknowledgements
facets and ductile tearing. The distinctive fracture features, inter-
granular cracking characterized by cleavage and river pattern, All persons who have made substantial contributions to the
and microvoid coalescence during ductile failure were observed. work reported in the manuscript (e.g., technical help, writing and
Base on careful analysis of fracture surface images in Fig. 7c, the editing assistance, general support), but who do not meet the cri-
shear lips are indicated by the dark grey shaded area at the speci- teria for authorship, are named in the Acknowledgements and have
men’s extreme surface. By virtue of the applied load, in the mid- given us their written permission to be named. If we have not
region of the fracture surface, the treated specimen has ductile nat- included an Acknowledgements, then that indicates that we have
ure of failure with deep and uniformly distributed dimples as seen not received substantial contributions from non-authors.
in the typical untreated specimen. The increase in the yield
strength of the treated specimen maybe because of the solution
treatment for a longer duration and impurities might have precip- References
itated, impeding dislocation movement and hardening the mate-
rial. This could be the cause of the increase in yield strength, [1] T. Nam, M. Kwon, J. Kim, Mechanism of Corrosion Fatigue Cracking of
which needs to be investigated further. The crack is initiated by Automotive Coil Spring Steel, vol. 21, no. 6, pp. 1–8, 2015.
[2] M.A. Yar, Y. Wang, X. Zhou, C. Soutis, Corrosion behaviour of an industrial shot-
the dissolution of the material ahead of the crack tip, and the prop- peened and coated automotive spring steel AISI 9254, Corros. Eng. Sci. Technol.
agation is a mechanical brittle fracture. Cathodic reaction supports 53 (8) (2018) 564–573.
anodic dissolution at the crack tip. [3] M. Kurzydłowski, K. J., Lewandowska, M., Świe˛szkowski, W., Lewandowska-
Szumieł, Degradation of Engineering Materials–Implications to Regenerative
Medicine, Macromol. Symp. (Vol. 253, No. 1, pp. 1-9). Weinheim WILEY-VCH
Verlag., vol. 253, no. 1, pp. 1–9, 2007.
4. Conclusion
[4] L. G. Bland, J.S.W. Locke, Chemical and electrochemical conditions within stress
corrosion and corrosion fatigue cracks, npj Mater. Degrad., no. July, pp. 1–8,
Here both SCC and HE are detrimental to the material perfor- 2017
mance. The degradation differs in both the environmental condi- [5] J. Woodtli, R. Kieselbach, Damage due to hydrogen embrittlement and stress
corrosion cracking, vol. 7, pp. 427–450, 2000
tion and corrosion species. The environment susceptible to the [6] T. Suzuki, S. Kozawa, T. Yoshioka, M. Kubota, H. Miyamoto, and Mi. Aono,
cracking for every metal or alloy is limited because not all environ- ‘‘Low-alloyed High-strength Suspension Spring Steel‘‘, Nippon Steel Technical
ments promote the SCC. So, it’s a mechanical–chemical process Report, (122), 2019.
[7] H.K. Basukumar, K.V. Arun, Failure of spring steel by stress corrosion cracking
leading to cracking at stresses below their tensile strength. During and hydrogen embrittlement-an experimental investigation, GIS Sci. J. 7 (12)
this environmental degradation process, the crack tip blunting (2020) 847–858, ISSN NO 1869–9391.
plays a vital role as an important variable, which influences the [8] R. W. Neu, Initiation and Propagation of Stress-Assisted Corrosion (SAC) Cracks
in Carbon Steel Boiler Tubes, (2007): 559-566., vol. 129, no. October 2007, pp.
development of the SCC. The anodic dissolution changes the crack 559–566, 2015.
shape and thus the crack tip radius. Because of these changes, crack [9] J. G. Parker, Initiation of Stress Corrosion Cracks in a Low Alloy Steel, vol. 0599,
tip blunting can affect the SCC resistance of the material. While in no. May, pp. 6–10, 2016.
[10] A.U. Malik, T.L. Prakash, I. Andijani, Failure evaluation in desalination plants –
the case of hydrogen charged specimens, embrittlement might some case studies, Desalination 105 (3) (1996) 283–295.
have led to the loss of ductility and harden the material. This might [11] M.B. Djukic, V.S. Zeravcic, G. Bakic, A. Sedmak, B. Rajicic, Hydrogen
be the reason for an increase in the yield strength which needs fur- embrittlement of low carbon structural steel, Procedia Mater. Sci. 3 (2014)
1167–1172.
ther investigation. But in the process of SCC followed the HE pro-
[12] H.K. Basukumar, K.V. Arun, Experimental investigation on Hydrogen
cess, hydrogen entering into material changes the crack surface embrittlement of EN47 Spring steel, IOP Conf. Ser. Mater. Sci. Eng. 1126 (1)
energies inhibiting dislocation motion and hardening the material. (2021) 012077.
Anodic dissolution at the crack tip is supported cathodic reaction [13] M. R. Louthan Jr., Hydrogen embrittlement of metals: a primer for the failure
analyst, pp. 289–307, 2008.
for the failure of the material. Based on the results of the tests, [14] J. Toribio, E. Ovejero, Role of crack tip blunting in stress corrosion cracking of
the following conclusions can be drawn: high strength steels, Int. J. Fract. (1999) L31–L36.
2005
H.K. Basukumar and K.V. Arun Materials Today: Proceedings 49 (2022) 2000–2006
[15] A.F. Liu, Mechanics and mechanisms of fracture: an introduction, ASM Int. [18] B.P. Somerday, L.M. Young, R. Gangloff, Crack tip mechanics effects on
(2005). environment-assisted cracking of beta-titanium alloys in aqueous NaCl,
[16] H.K. Basukumar, K.V. Arun, Experimental approach to study the effect of Fatigue Fract. Eng. Mater. Struct. 23 (2000) 39–58.
hydrogen embrittlement on structural steel under the influence of impact [19] J. M. Barsom and S. T. Rolfe, Fracture and fatigue control in structures:
loading and wear characterization department of mechanical engineering, J. Applications of fracture mechanics, Third Edition. ASTM International, 1977.
Int. Technol. Sci. 3 (04) (2016) 108–113. [20] N.A. Vu, A. Castel, R. François, Effect of stress corrosion cracking on stress –
[17] A. Pundt, R. Kirchheim, Hydrogen in metals: microstructural aspects, Annu. strain response of steel wires used in prestressed concrete beams, Corros. Sci.
Rev. Mater. Res 36 (1) (2006) 555–608. 51 (6) (2009) 1453–1459.
2006