(PRINT) Root Cause Analysis CEFR Level Testing Progress Checking
(PRINT) Root Cause Analysis CEFR Level Testing Progress Checking
(PRINT) Root Cause Analysis CEFR Level Testing Progress Checking
On the following pages you will find a series of tools you can use for the
following purposes:
To identify the approximate CEFR level of your students so you can efectively
use the Remedial Instruction Toolkit
Use this process and series of tools to help you identify individual student
challenges
at the start of the academic year. The information you get about your students from
the Root Cause Analysis will help you know how best to support your students using the
activities in the Remedial Instruction Toolkit.
Student Data
From the students in your school. To include:
Year Use
Collect
3 performance
writing
the Speaking
samples
data
Use
and
(can
(mid-year
the
Listening
be
Reading
fromand
Rubrics
Year
Diagnostic
end
3 or
of
toproduced
year
further
Tool
assessments)
(where
understand
early appropriate;
in the
your
academic
students’
see CEFR
year)
CEFR
Level
andlevels
use
Testing
the
(appendix
Writing
Section)
1)
Ru
Use data from the Reading
SpeakingDiagnostic
and Listening
ToolRubrics
to establish
to establish
possiblepossible
root cause(s)
(see
root cause(s)
CEFR Level
(appendix
Testing 1)
Section)
Once you have collected samples of student work, use the writing rubric (appendix
1), to establish approximately which CEFR level your students are at for writing.
Try to arrange your students into 4 levels according to the writing rubric (Pre-A1,
Low A1, Mid A1, and High A1).
Students who seem to be writing at Mid A1 and High A1 level, are on track to be
able to follow the Year 4 curriculum with limited challenges. These are most likely
not your remedial students.
For students who are Pre-A1 and Low A1, proceed to use the Reading Diagnostic Tools
(see CEFR Level Testing Section) to further drill down into which CEFR level these
students are at.
2. Use the information from the Reading Diagnostic Tool to define student’s most likely CEFR
level for reading. If necessary, use the information from the student’s writing sample to help
you decide the most appropriate level.
1. Find time to interact with your students on an individual level over the first 2 or 3 weeks of
class. Make notes on their speaking and listening using the Speaking and Listening Rubrics
(appendix 1) to guide you.
Use the your
Approximate mid-year, end of CEFR
student’s year and anyusing
level other all
whole-school assessments
data sources to gauge
from Step 2
student progress.
Once you have identified the possible causes of low English proficiency for each student, you will be able to:
Understand Understand
what extra support your
what extra students
support need
your to be able
students needto toprogress (do
be able to they need
progress (do support
they in phonic
need support in phonics, phonemic awareness, reading comprehension, vocabulary,
grammar, speaking practice, listening practice, etc.?)
Know which level of activities students should do from the Remedial Instruction Toolkit
The Remedial Instruction Toolkit was developed using data from ELTC’s Training Needs
Analysis. You will find that solutions and activities for language specific root causes have
been designed to help you support your remedial students.
Assessment forContinue
Learning to use Assessment for Learning strategies throughout the Academic
year to evaluate whether your solutions and the Remedial Instruction Toolkit are
supporting student progress.
Whole-school Assessments
Midline
Use Tool tool to reflect on student progress halfway through the Academic Year (see Progress Checking Section
the midline
Endline Tool
Use the endline tool at the end of the Academic Year to summarise student
progress and establish efectiveness of your overall solutions, including use of the
Remedial Instruction Toolkit (see Progress Checking Section).
Use these tools for students who did not perform well in the written sample. These tools will help you understand:
Note: If a student does not perform well in the first 3 tools (recognising letters, recognising
sound patterns, & hearing individual sounds), there is no need to attempt the 4th tool
(reading comprehension).
2. Sound Recognition
Below 5 5-8 8-10
3. Individual Sound
Recognition Below 5 5-8 8-10
4. Reading
Comprehension Below 3 3-5 6-8
Tool 1: Recognising Letters
Children should be able to quickly identify all letters of the alphabet regardless of the font used
or whether they are capital letters. They should be able to do this without struggling and
without hesitation.
A hesitation shows that the child is not yet fully familiar with the letter, and that more
practice is needed.
A hesitation is when the child spends more than two seconds trying to identify a letter.
Instructions:
Student reads the full page of letters – capitals, smalls, diferent fonts, and other writing symbols (!, ?,
etc.)
For marking responses, there are 3 categories for the teacher to choose from as the child reads – Correct,
Incorrect, Hesitant
Tick the appropriate box as the child reads – left to right, row by row – can be done slowly
– no rush
Use this tool to check readiness and confidence e.g., able to decode letters, not confused by diferent fonts,
able to work out what is in front of them without too many instructions, etc.
If they do not have confidence in reading this page, these students are at the pre-reading stage and would
need to learn the letters and symbols of reading before proceeding further.
Record the student’s achievement in the Excel Spreadsheet.
Student Sheet –
print or show to your student to read
Teacher Answer Sheet
s k N
a Z L
U C Q
V b W
! u 4
O J j
H f m
q S i
r 8 y
T A t
B 2 G
p Y v
x _ a X
g K ?
E l c
n R P
w g D
F e h
6 I z
In this section of the Reading Diagnostic Tool, proficient students will get a minimum
of 8 out of 10 correct answers.
Instructions:
Each sentence in the list has two main words – some rhyme, some do not. Teacher
reads the questions about the rhyming words.
Students answer yes or no – they do or do not rhyme. Teacher takes note
of the response in the table.
Record the number of correct answers in the Excel Spreadsheet.
List A
List B
Total
Score
Tool 3: Recognising Individual Letter Sounds
Understanding that words are made up of individual sounds and that each sound has a
corresponding letter is an essential skill for reading proficiency.
In this tool, look out for when children appear to be guessing, or if the child responds “yes” to
every item or “no” to every item. This means that they are not fully comfortable with letter
sound recognition, and you should aim to discontinue the task.
In this section of the Reading Diagnostic Tool, proficient students will get a minimum
of 8 out of 10 correct answers.
Instructions:
Explain to students that words have sounds in them.
Ask ‘Do you hear the /k/ sound in the word KING? Listen ‘K – K – K – KING’ ‘Can
you hear the /oo/ sound in TOOK?’
‘Can you hear the /sh/ sound in TOOK?’
‘There is no /sh/ sound in TOOK. But there is in SHOOK.’ Proceed to
ask students all questions from list A.
Use List B later in the year when you are checking for progress. Record the
students’ answers in the related table.
Record the number of correct answers in the Excel Spreadsheet.
Prac�ce Items:
Do you hear /v/ in VAN? (Yes)
Do you hear /aw/ in THAW? (Yes)
Do you hear /h/ in GONE? (No)
Being able to understand the main idea of a text is essential for students to be able to access the
curriculum. On top of this, understanding specific information within texts is a foundational
literacy skill that all emerging readers strive for.
Instructions:
Ask the student to read the text to you.
You can help with pronunciation of unknown words.
When the student has finished, point to the questions and ask for verbal answers. Record the number of
correct answers in the Excel Spreadsheet.
This is My Family
Hi, I’m Sam. This is my family. I have a small family. We’re very happy because
we do lots of fun things together. We live in Kuala Lumpur, in Malaysia.
This is me. I am 10 years old. My favourite colour is green and I like riding my
green bike. Every day, I get up early and have a shower. I have bread for breakfast
and then I walk to school with my dad. In the evenings, I play badminton. At the
weekends, I always go to the park with my friends.
This is my sister. Her name is Aishah and she is 16 years old. She’s a student
in school but she wants to be a doctor. She does a lot of homework because
she needs very good grades.
This is my dad. His name is Ahmad. He’s an amazing dad. He’s a teacher in a
school, but he really loves cooking. Every day, he walks to school with me. In the
evenings, he makes pizza or plays the guitar with his friends. He wants to be in a
band!
Use this tool for students who were at the Pre-A1 level at the beginning of the academic
year.
To help you collect data to complete this for each student, you can:
Use this tool for students who were at the Low A1 level at the beginning of the academic
year.
To help you collect data to complete this for each student, you can:
Use this tool for students who were at the Mid A1 level at the beginning of the academic year.
To help you collect data to complete this for each student, you can:
Writing Rubric
Use this writing rubric to assess your students’ written work. If a student does very
well and scores High A1, this student is not a Remedial Student.
Source: Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah, Bahasa Inggeris, Dokumen Standard Kurikulum dan Pentaksiran,
Tahun 1, Tahun 2, Tahun 3, & Tahun 4
Appendix 1: Rubrics
Reading Rubric
The Reading Rubric shows which Reading Diagnostic Tools to use for students at
particular levels. Students who were a High A1 with their written sample do not
need to complete the Reading Diagnostic Tools.
Source: Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah, Bahasa Inggeris, Dokumen Standard Kurikulum dan Pentaksiran,
Tahun 1, Tahun 2, Tahun 3, & Tahun 4
Appendix 1: Rubrics
Listening Rubric
Use the Listening and Speaking Rubrics to assess the listening and speaking
levels of your students. You are also able to use Reading Diagnostic Tools 2 &
3 as they focus on listening skills, too.
Source: Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah, Bahasa Inggeris, Dokumen Standard Kurikulum dan Pentaksiran,
Tahun 1, Tahun 2, Tahun 3, & Tahun 4
Appendix 1: Rubrics
Speaking Rubric
Use the Listening and Speaking Rubrics to assess the listening and speaking
levels of your students.
Source: Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah, Bahasa Inggeris, Dokumen Standard Kurikulum dan Pentaksiran,
Tahun 1, Tahun 2, Tahun 3, & Tahun 4
References
Gilmore, A., Croft, C., & Reid, N. (1981) Burt Word Reading Test, Burt Books, NZCER Press, [Internet] Available at:
<http://www.burtbooks.com/BURTWORDRECOGNITIONTEST.pdf>
Jemaah Nazir dan Jaminan Kualiti (2017). Standard Kualiti Pendidikan Malaysia Gelombang 2 (SKPMg2).
Putrajaya: Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (2017) Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah: Bahasa Inggeris, Dokumen
Standard Kurikulum dan Pentaksiran, Tahun 1
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (2017) Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah: English Language Scheme of Work for
Phonics Primary Year 1
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (2017) Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah: English Language Syllabus Primary Year
1
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (2017) Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah: Bahasa Inggeris, Dokumen
Standard Kurikulum dan Pentaksiran, Tahun 2
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (2017) Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah: English Language Scheme of Work
Primary Year 2
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (2017) Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah: English Language Syllabus Primary Year
2
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (2017) Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah: Bahasa Inggeris, Dokumen
Standard Kurikulum dan Pentaksiran, Tahun 3
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (2017) Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah: English Language Scheme of Work
Primary Year 3
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (2017) Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah: English Language Syllabus Primary Year
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (2017) Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah: Bahasa Inggeris, Dokumen
Standard Kurikulum dan Pentaksiran, Tahun 4
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (2017) Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah: English Language Scheme of Work
Primary Year 4
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (2017) Kurikulum Standard Sekolah Rendah: English Language Syllabus Primary Year
4
Szabo, T. (2018) Collated Representative Samples Of Descriptors Of Language Competences Developed For Young
Learners: Council of Europe [Internet] Available from: https://rm.coe.int/collated-representative-samples-descriptors-
young-learners-volume-1-ag/16808b1 688
Wren, S. & Watts, J. (2002) The Abecedarian Reading Assessment, [Internet] Available from:
https://www.balancedreading.com/assessment/abecedarian.pdf