Gis-Based Suitability Mapping of Banana in The Philippines
Gis-Based Suitability Mapping of Banana in The Philippines
Gis-Based Suitability Mapping of Banana in The Philippines
net/publication/333135714
Article in Journal of the International Society for Southeast Asian Agricultural Sciences · December 2018
CITATIONS READS
3 2,945
1 author:
Victorino Bato
University of the Philippines Los Baños
15 PUBLICATIONS 36 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Victorino Bato on 14 August 2019.
Victorino A. Bato
Division of Soil Science, Agricultural Systems Institute
College of Agriculture and Food Science
University of the Philippines Los Baños
Corresponding author: [email protected]
ABSTRACT
A banana suitability map shows various areas with different levels of suitability for banana
growth: high, moderate, marginal, and not suitable. Suitability levels may be regarded as potentials for
successful banana cultivation. This research sought to generate a banana suitability map covering the
whole Philippines using Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and the most recent sensor-based data.
The following spatial data were used to generate the suitability map: digital elevation model,
topography, slope, soil series and texture, monthly minimum temperature, monthly maximum
temperature, monthly rainfall, and 2010 land cover/land use. These various spatial data were processed
within the GIS using series of recoding, map algebra, and cross-classification procedures. The resulting
banana suitability map for the Philippines was published in static PDF or JPEG format and interactively
in the World Wide Web.
Key words: SARAI, land use, ASTER GDEM, soil, slope, Landsat, interactive map
INTRODUCTION
For a country to be progressive, agricultural production should improve and contribute to food
security and the national economy. Land resources should be utilized optimally for different land uses,
especially crop production. Different crops have different growth requirement for soil, temperature, and
rainfall. The challenge is to match these crop growth requirements to areas where they can be met. Crop
suitability assessment addresses this challenge. There have been crops suitability maps generated in the
past, but these maps were of a national-scale and are only suitable for national-level planning purposes.
There is a need to create newer suitability maps that are usable at municipal and provincial-levels and
of much higher spatial detail and accuracy. Such higher accuracy is now achievable through the use of
the latest remote sensing products and the use of Geographic Information Systems (GIS). These newer
crop suitability maps will contribute to the country’s goal of increasing agricultural production and
sustaining food security.
Creating a suitability map for banana involves integrating various types of information like:
soil, temperature, rainfall, topography, and slope. The complexities and details of the input varies, with
data on soil sometimes including very detailed information on pedology, physical, and chemical
properties. But such information are very difficult to obtain or even unavailable, especially for the entire
country of the Philippines. Nevertheless, a suitability map for banana could still be generated in the
1
GIS-based suitability mapping of banana in the Philippines
absence of very detailed level of soil-survey information. Other data such as finer resolution digital
elevation models, slope, rainfall, temperature, and land cover/land use maps, together with soil series
and texture data adds to the overall accuracy and usability of the suitability map. In the end, a banana
suitability map could be generated and used as guide in banana cultivation. The success or failure of the
crop would still depend on fertilizer, pest, and water management and the prevailing weather.
Bananas (Musa spp.) are of great importance to small-scale farmers in the developing countries
of the tropics and sub-tropics (Frison et al. 2004). In 2016, the Philippines produced 8,903,684 metric-
tons of banana (PSA, 2017). The Philippines is the largest exporter in the region, which accounts for
some 90% of the total export volume from Asia (FAO 2017). Bananas prefer freely drained, deep and
fertile loamy soils, but [can be] cultivated on a wide range of soil types following proper agro-
management. Swelling clay and high bulk density appear to pose drainage problems, thereby lowering
crop yield. Banana grows well in pH range of 4.5 to 8.2 (Kadao et al. 2003). The potential for bananas
to produce year round is best expressed when water is abundant and the daily temperatures are in the
range of 20-30 degrees Celsius (Van den Bergh et al. 2012).
A GIS-based land suitability assessment for banana was performed for Bang Kratum District,
Phitsanulok Province, Lower Northern Thailand (Boonyanuphat et al. 2004). Five environmental
factors were used in the generation of the suitability map: soil property, topography, climate, availability
of supplementary water, and market factor. Each factor, was given a weight, depending on its
importance on the growth of banana. The end product banana suitability map features four suitability
classes: highly suitable, moderately suitable, marginally suitable, and currently not suitable.
Soil characteristics for the growth of banana in Hainan Island, China were studied by Zhao
(2018, 2005). The SOTER (Soil and Terrain Digital Database) database was utilized as source of soil
and terrain information. An expert model for physical land evaluation was created in ALES (Automated
Land Evaluation System), which was used to separate the potentially suitable AEU (Agricultural
Ecological Units) from the unsuitable ones. The following parameters were considered during the
modeling process: soil depth; surface horizon depth; texture, structure; bulk density; CEC (Cation
Exchange Capacity); pH; total nitrogen; total phosphorus; exchangeable calcium, magnesium, and
potassium; growing period; and rainfall and typhoon occurrences. A GIS-based land suitability analysis
for rice cultivation was also performed in Morobe Province, Papua New Guinea (Samanta et al. 2011).
A spatial multi-criteria decision-making approach, where geographical data is combined and
transformed into a decision, was utilized in the overall process. ArcGIS 10 and ERDAS Imagine’s
model builder was used to construct the index model for rice land suitability analysis. Shuttle Radar
Topography Mission (SRTM) data was selected to generate the digital elevation model (DEM) where
topographic information was extracted. It also utilized climate data, soils data (texture, depth, N, P, K,
and pH), and market access data (or travel time and distance from village to market). The final rice
suitability map has three classes: suitable, moderately suitable, and unsuitable.
Remote sensing and GIS were utilized to map and evaluate the land suitability of the Northern
part of the Nile Delta, Egypt (El Baroudy 2016. Remote sensing data can be used to delineate various
physiographic units together with site-specific soil and climate data. When coupled with soil survey
information it can be integrated in a GIS to assess crop suitability (Abdel Rahman et al. 2016).
Physiographic map units were identified based on Landsat ETM+ satellite data and the DEM. Land
suitability was based on the interaction of soil fertility, chemical, and physical factors. Each factor is
computed based on the interactions of several sub-factors. The result of the modeling are various classes
with weighted-index according to its significance to land suitability for crop production.
The land capability classification by Mary-Silpa and Sowshaja (2015) made use of GIS as the
platform for assessment. Aside from utilizing slope, soil depth, soil texture, and permeability in the land
2
J. ISSAAS Vol. 24, No. 1: 1-13 (2018)
assessment, the research also considered soil erosion. Input soil erosion map was obtained using the
RUSLE (Revised Universal Soil Loss Equation) model.
A combination of an expert system and GIS for land suitability evaluation was developed by
Kalogirou (2002), resulting in the LEIGIS (Land Evaluation using an Intelligent Geographical
Information System) software. This utilizes the FAO 1976 framework for land evaluation of crops. The
evaluation process has two main parts: the physical evaluation, which features a new interpolation
function that maps values to scores of land characteristics, and the economic evaluation that includes
income-maximization while taking into account market restrictions. The GIS functions help in
managing the spatial data and visualizing the result. The software was developed using Microsoft Visual
Basic (VB) programming language. The GIS functionality was implemented using MapObjects
ActiveX Controls developed by ESRI (Environment Systems Research Institute) (Kalogirou 2002).
Land suitability evaluation for different crops is heavily anchored on numerous soil-related
information that are mostly available at a regional scale. Utilizing such a generalized data at a local-
scale or planning-scale land evaluation will be one of the “weakness” of the resulting suitability map.
However, soil attributes could be predicted through models that utilize terrain attributes from digital
elevation models (DEM) (Ziadat 2007). Furthermore, the accuracy of the suitability classification
derived from predicted soil attributes compares favorably with the accuracy of classifications derived
from traditional soil maps.
This study sought to utilize GIS to generate the suitability map for banana in the Philippines.
Specifically it sought to develop a framework for banana suitability mapping that uses GIS and various
spatial data, create various thematic maps needed as input to the suitability map, and publish the
suitability map as static and interactive web-based maps.
Study area. The study area covered the entire Philippines. Map outputs vary in scale from country-
level to provincial-level.
Identification of criteria. Criteria for suitability are based on the growth requirements for banana
(PCARRD 1988) which are the following:
1. Rainfall: 20 – 22 centimeters per month, evenly distributed
2. Temperature: 15 – 36 oC
3. Soil: deep and friable loam soil
4. Topography: flat terrains are highly desirable, but ravines and hilly lands may also be used
5. Drainage: banana is sensitive to standing water
Data collection. Table 1 shows the sources of data utilized for generating the banana suitability map.
Hardware and software. The suitability mapping of banana was performed on a 64bit IBM
(International Business Machines) compatible PC (Personal Computer), with an Intel® Core(TM) i5-
4210U CPU (4 cores) running at 1.70GHz, a RAM (Random Access Memory) of 12GB, and an
operating system of Microsoft Windows 10.
3
GIS-based suitability mapping of banana in the Philippines
Various software were used in this study. GDAL (Geospatial Data Abstraction Library)
utilities were used in repetitive tasks that required script programming, such as the re-projection and
mosaicking of ASTER GDEM (Advanced Spaceborne Thermal Emission and Reflection Radiometer
Global Digital Elevation Map) tiles. PCRaster Software (April 16, 2015 version) was utilized in the
quick visualization of maps and in non-complex map algebra. IDRISI Selva Software was utilized in
the cross-tabulation of constraint maps. ArcGIS 10 was utilized in map layout creation and printing.
Table 1. Source of data for various layers used in the banana suitability map.
Data characteristics of the output. The technical characteristics of the data output are described below
(Table 2).
Parameters Description
Pixel size (minimum mapping unit) 100 by 100 meters (10,000 squared-meters or one hectare)
Projection UTM, WGS84 datum (Universal Transverse Mercator
Projection, World Geodetic System of 1984 )
Image dimension 10,749 x 18,350
Formats Raster: GEOTIFF
Vector: Shapefile
Database generation
a. Rainfall. Banana requires 20 to 22 cm. of rainfall per month. From the gridded monthly
precipitation data of the Philippines, a Boolean map was created per month with areas having
20 to 22 centimeters of rainfall getting a value of one, while the rest was zero. The process of
creating the Boolean map requires recoding or re-classing the pixel values. The monthly
rainfall Boolean maps were combined together using map algebra through the multiplication
operation and the output is the rainfall constraint map.
b. Temperature. The optimum growing temperature for banana ranges from 15 to 36 oC. The
gridded monthly minimum temperature maps of the Philippines were used to create a minimum
temperature Boolean map. Areas with temperatures equal-to and above 15 oC were given a
value of one while zero was set for the rest. A maximum temperature Boolean map was created
by utilizing the gridded monthly maximum temperature maps. Areas with temperatures equal-
to and below 36 oC were given a value of one, and the rest, zero. The individual minimum and
maximum monthly temperature Boolean maps were combined together using map algebra
4
J. ISSAAS Vol. 24, No. 1: 1-13 (2018)
through the multiplication operation. This process resulted to the creation of the temperature
constraint map.
c. Elevation. The source of the digital elevation model (DEM) is the ASTER GDEM. To cover
the entire Philippines, 95 ASTER GDEM tiles were required. The ASTER GDEM data is
natively in angular reference units (longitude and latitude), with a WGS84 datum. This data
had to be re-projected to UTM, a linear reference system (units are in meters), also in the
WGS84 datum and under Zone 51, North. After re-projecting, the individual ASTER GDEM
tiles were mosaicked together to a single DEM covering the whole Philippines and resampled
from 30-m-resolution to 100-m-resolution. The DEM was resampled to 100 meters to achieve
a minimum mapping unit of one-hectare and to reduce computing load.
The task of re-projecting, mosaicking, and resampling the ASTER GDEM tiles was performed
using the GDAL utility (gdalwarp.exe). Using GDAL requires creating batch scripts, which runs in the
MS DOS (Microsoft Disk Operating System) console, to automate repetitive tasks. The batch script
minimizes error and increases the speed of various GIS operations.
Prior to using the mosaicked ASTER GDEM as an input to an operation, low-pass filtering
was performed to smoothen-out the roughness and remove artifacts inherent in the data. From the
mosaicked ASTER GDEM, an elevation map was created by recoding ranges of elevation based on the
BSWM (Bureau of Soils and Water Management) elevation categorization (0-100m1, 100-500m2,
500-1,000m3, and >1,000m4). Figure 1 shows the digital elevation model from the ASTER
GDEM, while Figure 2 shows the categorical elevation map.
d. Slope. Slope was computed in PCRaster using the mosaicked DEM as an input. The output of
this operation is a slope map image with a continuous data type. Slope ranges were recoded
into categories in accordance to BSWM’s slope categories (0-3% 1, 3-8% 2, 8-18% 3,
18-30% 4, 30-50% 5, and >50% 6). Figure 3 shows the categorical slope map.
e. Soils. The soils data that came from the BSWM was in vector format (Shapefile format) and
had to be converted to raster. The raster version of the soil map has a resolution (100 meters x
100 meters) and image dimension similar to the categorical elevation and slope maps to enable
overlay within the GIS. The soils map of the Philippines is shown in Figure 4.
Banana requires deep, friable and well-drained loam soils. The soil map was recoded according
to the preference of the crop. Soils that are highly suitable for banana were assigned a value of one,
those that are moderately suitable a value of two, and those that are not suitable, a value of zero. Thus,
6
J. ISSAAS Vol. 24, No. 1: 1-13 (2018)
soils with textures of clay loam, loam and loamy sand were assigned a value of one; clay, sandy clay,
sandy clay loam, sandy loam, silt, silt loam, silty clay, and silty clay loam were assigned a value of two;
and the rest, those that are not suitable for banana cultivation (bogs, filled-up, gravel, hydrosol, lava
flow, mountain soil, peat, river sand, rock land, rough broken terrain, rough mountain, rough stony,
rubble land, sand, sand dune, and undifferentiated soils), were assigned a value of zero. Potential soil
fertility-level as a function of the soil’s cation exchange capacity, inferred from the clay content of the
soil, was also considered in the categorization of the different soil series and textures. The output of this
process is a soil constraint map.
f. Land cover/land use. The 2010 land cover/land use map (Fig. 5) from NAMRIA is based on
image classification of medium-resolution Landsat data. The land cover data was in vector
format and had to be converted to raster format to enable overlay and map algebra within a
GIS. The image dimension and resolution of the raster land cover map is similar to that of the
rasterized soils map.
GIS suitability modelling. Geographic Information System (GIS) is a very powerful tool in
agricultural research and natural resource management (Samanta et al. 2011). In suitability modelling
IDRISI Selva Software was used. Cross-classification of the categorical elevation and slope maps
yielded a preliminary physical constraint map. The result of this process are combinations of values
shown on Table 3. Cross-classification of the preliminary physical constraint map with the soils
constraint map yielded the preliminary biophysical constraint map, with the possible combination of
values and their explanations shown on Table 4. Intersecting the preliminary biophysical constraint map
with the land use, rainfall, and temperature constraint maps yields the final banana suitability map.
Figure 6 shows the flowchart of process used in the suitability modelling.
7
GIS-based suitability mapping of banana in the Philippines
Table 4. Cross-classification values of preliminary physical constraint map and soil constraint map.
8
J. ISSAAS Vol. 24, No. 1: 1-13 (2018)
The banana suitability map that was generated by this study have two versions: the static map
and the interactive map. Figures 7 and 8 shows the output suitability maps (static maps) for banana for
Laguna province (sample provincial-scale map output) and for the entire Philippines (Philippine-scale
map output). The static maps were generated in JPEG (Joint Photographic Experts Group) and PDF
(Portable Document Format) formats. Such formats could be easily downloaded, printed on paper, or
viewed using a computer or smartphone. The static maps are designed for easy viewing and distribution
and are suited for users who have limited access to technology. The banana suitability maps for all 81-
provinces of the Philippines and an overview banana suitability map showing the entire country are
available for download from the SARAI Website (http://www.sarai.ph).
9
GIS-based suitability mapping of banana in the Philippines
The interactive, web-based version of the banana suitability map (Fig. 9) can be accessed
through the SARAI Maps Website: http://maps.sarai.ph/suitability-maps or through the Philippine
Geoportal Website: http://www.geoportal.gov.ph/viewer/. The interactive version of the suitability
map is designed for more advanced users who have computers with moderate to fast Internet
connections. The user interface of the interactive map enables the user to zoom-in-and-out of an area of
interest, perform drill-down attributes query with a mouse click, perform name-place search, make use
of various base maps, and overlay thematic maps from various sources. Tools, such as distance and area
measurements, are also available in the interactive map user interface.
A clear advantage of the interactive suitability map for banana over the static version is that
the user interface enables the use of the most recent, high-resolution satellite data from Google Maps
as a base map. The Google Map enables users to easily locate areas of a certain suitability class due to
the easily recognizable landscape features on the base map.
10
J. ISSAAS Vol. 24, No. 1: 1-13 (2018)
This study also computed the area for various suitability classes for the different banana
suitability classes for the Province of Laguna (Table 5). It is just a sample area computation for one
province, area computations for suitability classes have been done for the various provinces in the
Philippines. This tabular information complements the map and is needed by decision makers in the
local and national government and bureaus.
Table 5. Area computation for different suitability classes of banana for Laguna province.
11
GIS-based suitability mapping of banana in the Philippines
Limitations of the suitability map. The banana suitability map that was generated in this study is
partly a product of the reconnaissance soils map of the Philippines made by the Bureau of Soils and
Water Management (BSWM). The digital soils map is a compilation of digitized, provincial-level,
paper-based soils maps which vary in scale from 1:250,000 to 1:500,000. The level-of-detail in the
soils map limits the precision of the suitability map to only the provincial-level.
CONCLUSION
This study dealt with the GIS-based suitability mapping of banana in the Philippines. Using
GIS, together with the most recent sensor-based data on elevation, temperature, rainfall, and land use,
a banana suitability map covering the entire Philippines was generated in a very short period of time.
Sensor-based data enabled the creation of a spatially accurate suitability map, something very difficult
to generate in the past. Also, advances in hardware enabled faster computing of large datasets. The
availability of advanced software enabled the automation of repetitive tasks, generation of professional-
level output, and distribution of data through various media (Internet and print). The method developed
in this study that utilized GIS and satellite-based data serves as a generic framework for suitability
mapping of banana. Such method can also be applied to the suitability mapping of other crops. This
study also generated various thematic maps that were utilized in the generation of the banana suitability
map. Finally, the banana suitability map is published online in the SARAI website in both interactive
and static versions.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The author acknowledges the Philippine Council for Agriculture, Aquatic and Natural
Resources Research and Development (PCAARRD) – Department of Science and Technology (DOST)
for providing the funds to the SARAI (Smarter Approaches to Reinvigorating Agriculture as an
Industry) Project, which made the conduct of this work and the writing of this manuscript possible.
Acknowledgement is also due to the following people who contributed to the conduct of this work: Mr.
Roel L. Fucio who made the layout of the static maps. Professor Concepcion Khan and her group of
students who worked on the interactive, web-based version of the suitability maps, Dr. Artemio Salazar
and Dr. Ma. Victoria O. Espaldon, and the entire SARAI Team.
REFERENCES CITED
Abdel Rahman, M. A.E., Natarajan, A. and Hegde, R. 2016. Assessment of land suitability and
capability by integrating remote sensing and GIS for agriculture in Chamarajanagar district,
Karnataka, India. The Egyptial Journal of Remote Sensing and Space Sciences. 19: 125-141.
Ceballos-Silva, A. and López-Blanco, J. 2003. Delineation of suitable areas for crops using a multi-
criteria evaluation approach and land use/cover mapping: a case study in Central Mexico.
Agricultural Systems. 77: 117-136.
El Baroudy, A. A. 2016. Mapping and evaluating land suitability using a GIS-based model. Catena.
140: 96-104.
FAO [Food and Agriculture Organization]. 2017. Banana market review 2015-2016. Food and
Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Rome. Retrieved from http://www.fao.org/3/a-
i7410e.pdf.
12
J. ISSAAS Vol. 24, No. 1: 1-13 (2018)
Frison, E., Escalant, J.-V. and Sharrock, S.L. 2004. The Global Musa Genomic Consortium: a boost for
banana improvement, pp 341-349. In Mohan Jain, S and Swennen, R. (eds.). Banana
Improvement: Cellular, Molecular Biology, and Induced Mutations. Science Publishers, Inc.
New Hampshire, USA. Retrieved from http://www.fao.org/docrep/007/ae216e/ae216e0u.htm.
Kadao, S. H., Prasad, J. and Gajbhiye, K. S. 2003. Characterization and classification of some typical
banana growing soils of Wardha district of Maharashtra. Agropedology. 13: 28-34.
Kalogirou, S. 2002. Expert systems and GIS: an application of land suitability evaluation. Computers,
Environment and Urban Systems. 26: 89-112.
Mary Silpa, T. J. and Nowshaja P.T. 2016. Land Capability Classification of Ollukara Block Panchayar
Using GIS. Procedia Technology. 24: 303-308.
NASA [National Aeronautics Space Administration]. 2016. Aster Global Digital Elevation Model.
https://asterweb.jpl.nasa.gov/gdem.asp.
NAMRIA [National Mapping and Resource Information Authority]. 2010. Land cover/land use map
2010. Digital vector data. Retrieved from http://www.namria.gov.ph.
PCARRD [Philippine Council for Agriculture, Forestry and Natural Resources Research and
Development]. 1988. The Philippine Recommends for Banana. Department of Science and
Technology. pp 11.
Samanta, S., Pal, B. and Pal, D. K. 2011. Land suitability analysis for rice cultivation based on multi-
criteria decision approach through GIS. International Journal of Science & Emerging
Technologies. 2(1).
Van den Bergh, I., Ramirez, J., Staver, C., Turner, D. W., Jarvis, A. and Brown, D. 2012. Climate
change in the subtropics: the Impacts of projected averages and variability on banana
productivity, pp 89-99. In Acta Horticulturae 928 XXVIII International Horticultural Congress
on Science and Horticulture for People (IHC2010): International Symposium on Citrus,
Bananas and other Tropical Fruits under Subtropical Conditions, Lisbon, Portugal.
Zhao, Y. G., Zhang, G. L., Wen-Jun, Z. and Gong, Z. T. 2005. Soil characteristics and crop suitability
of sandy soils in Hainan, China. In Management of Tropical Sandy Soils for Sustainable
Agriculture. Retrieved from http://www.fao.org/tempref/docrep/fao/010/
ag125e/ag125e03.pdf
Ziadat, F. M. 2007. Land suitability classification using different sources of information: Soil maps and
predicted soil attributes in Jordan. Geoderma. 140: 73-80,
13