Get Popular Music Scenes: Regional and Rural Perspectives Andy Bennett Free All Chapters
Get Popular Music Scenes: Regional and Rural Perspectives Andy Bennett Free All Chapters
Get Popular Music Scenes: Regional and Rural Perspectives Andy Bennett Free All Chapters
https://ebookmass.com/product/popular-music-
scenes-regional-and-rural-perspectives-andy-
bennett/
OR CLICK BUTTON
DOWLOAD NOW
https://ebookmass.com/product/words-music-and-the-popular-global-
perspectives-on-intermedial-relations-1st-edition-thomas-gurke/
https://ebookmass.com/product/metal-on-merseyside-music-scenes-
community-and-locality-1st-edition-nedim-hassan/
https://ebookmass.com/product/popular-world-music-2nd-edition-
ebook-pdf-version/
https://ebookmass.com/product/cross-disciplinary-perspectives-on-
regional-and-global-security-1st-ed-edition-pawel-frankowski/
Popular Music, Critique and Manic Street Preachers 1st
ed. Edition Mathijs Peters
https://ebookmass.com/product/popular-music-critique-and-manic-
street-preachers-1st-ed-edition-mathijs-peters/
https://ebookmass.com/product/music-leisure-education-historical-
and-philosophical-perspectives-roger-mantie/
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-special-liveliness-of-hooks-in-
popular-music-and-beyond-steven-g-smith/
https://ebookmass.com/product/creative-autonomy-copyright-and-
popular-music-in-nigeria-1st-ed-edition-mary-w-gani/
https://ebookmass.com/product/popular-music-in-america-the-beat-
goes-on-5th-edition-ebook-pdf/
POP MUSIC, CULTURE, AND IDENTITY
Popular
Music Scenes
Regional and Rural Perspectives
Edited by
Andy Bennett
David Cashman
Ben Green
Natalie Lewandowski
Pop Music, Culture and Identity
Series Editors
Stephen Clark
Graduate School Humanities and Sociology
University of Tokyo
Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo, Japan
Tristanne Connolly
Department of English
St Jerome’s University
Waterloo, ON, Canada
Jason Whittaker
School of English & Journalism
University of Lincoln
Lincoln, Lincolnshire, UK
Pop music lasts. A form all too often assumed to be transient, commercial
and mass-cultural has proved itself durable, tenacious and continually
evolving. As such, it has become a crucial component in defining various
forms of identity (individual and collective) as influenced by nation, class,
gender and historical period. Pop Music, Culture and Identity investigates
how this enhanced status shapes the iconography of celebrity, provides an
ever-expanding archive for generational memory and accelerates the
impact of new technologies on performing, packaging and global market-
ing. The series gives particular emphasis to interdisciplinary approaches
that go beyond musicology and seeks to validate the informed testimony
of the fan alongside academic methodologies.
Andy Bennett • David Cashman
Ben Green • Natalie Lewandowski
Editors
© The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer
Nature Switzerland AG 2023
This work is subject to copyright. All rights are solely and exclusively licensed by the
Publisher, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of
translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on
microfilms or in any other physical way, and transmission or information storage and retrieval,
electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now
known or hereafter developed.
The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this
publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are
exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use.
The publisher, the authors, and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information
in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the
publisher nor the authors or the editors give a warranty, expressed or implied, with respect to
the material contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been made. The
publisher remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and
institutional affiliations.
This Palgrave Macmillan imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature
Switzerland AG.
The registered company address is: Gewerbestrasse 11, 6330 Cham, Switzerland
Acknowledgements
This book has been inspired by our work with the Regional Music Research
Group. We would like to acknowledge the support of our RMRG col-
leagues, Cary Bennett, Alana Blackburn, Alexandra Blok, Antonia Canosa,
Lachlan Goold, Ernesta Sofija.
We would also like to thank the Griffith Centre for Social and Cultural
Research for their provision of a small publication support grant to assist
with the editorial preparation of this book.
And a very big thank you to Sue Jarvis for her invaluable assistance in
the proofreading, copyediting and indexing of this book.
This book has taken shape during a period of great upheaval. We thank
all of our contributors for their sterling efforts in gracing us with such high
quality and deeply insightful chapters during extremely challenging times.
v
Contents
1 Music
at the End of the Land: Reflections on the
Pembrokeshire Music Network 3
Philip Miles
2 Diamonds
in the Backyard: Migrant Youth and Hip Hop
in Australian Regional Towns 19
Alexandra Blok
3 From
the City to the Bush: An Autoethnographic
Reflection on Australia’s Urban and Rural Music Scenes 35
Graham Sattler
4 Sounds
and Peripheral Places: Trajectory and Portrait of
the Rock Scene in Tâmega (Portugal) Over the Last Decade 53
Paula Guerra, Tânia Moreira, and Sofia Sousa
vii
viii Contents
5 Indian
Electronic Dance Music Festivals as Spaces of Play
in Regional Settings: Understanding Situated and Digital
Electronic Dance Music Performances 67
Devpriya Chakravarty
6 ‘Take
Me to Church’: Developing Music Worlds Through
the Creative Peripheral Placemaking and Programming of
Other Voices 83
Susan O’Shea
7 The
Creative Music Networks of Regional Recording
Studios: A Case Study of the Sunshine Coast and Gympie 99
Lachlan Goold
Part III Memory 115
8 Transactions
in Taste: An Examination of a Potential
Tastemaking Landscape Within Kent’s Blues Club Scene
and the Conception of a Local Taste Accent117
Phil Woollett
9 In
the Middle of Nowhere: Eisenach and Its Organically
Grown Blues and Jazz Infrastructure131
Nico Thom
10 ‘But
Do They Know How It Is in Pihtipudas?’ Rural and
Provincial Punk Scenes in Finland in the Late 1970s and
Early 1980s149
Janne Poikolainen and Mikko Salasuo
11 Building
Scene and Cultural Memory in the Weser Hills:
The Case of Glitterhouse Records and the Orange
Blossom Special Festival163
Robin Kuchar
Contents ix
12 Participatory
Belonging: How Tourist Music Workshops
Establish Trans-Local Music Scenes181
Leonieke Bolderman
13 Outsiders
in Outsider Cities? Expatriates in the DIY
Music Scenes of Nagoya and Fukuoka195
Benjamin Duester
14 Yogyakarta’s
Jazz Activists: From Regional Scene to Local
Stages209
Otto Stuparitz
15 Fragmented,
Positive and Negative: Live Music Venues in
Regional Queensland227
Andy Bennett, David Cashman, Ben Green, and Natalie
Lewandowski
Index243
Notes on Contributors
xi
xii NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS
research covers various topics related to music fandom, popular music and
youth cultures. In his doctoral dissertation, Janne studied the emergence
of popular music fan culture in Finland from the 1950s to the early 1970s.
He is co-editor of Katukulttuuri: Nuorisoesiintymiä 2000-luvun Suomessa
[Street Culture: Young People in Finland in the twenty-first Century]
with Mikko Salasuo and Pauli Komonen.
Mikko Salasuo is a docent in economic and social history and works at
the Finnish Youth Research Society as a leading senior researcher. He has
written and edited 20 books including Drugs & Youth Culture: Global and
local Expressions (with Philip Lalander), Exceptional Life Courses: Elite
Athletes and Successful Artists in 2000s Finland (with Mikko Piispa and
Helena Huhta) and Katukulttuuri: Nuorisoesiintymiä 2000-luvun
Suomessa [Street Culture: Young People in Finland in the twenty-first
Century] (with Janne Poikolainen). He is an adjunct Fellow of the Griffith
Centre for Social and Cultural Research. Mikko’s research topics include
subcultures, the history of youth culture, young peoples leisure time,
youth gangs and drug cultures.
Graham Sattler is a community music researcher/educator, practising
musician and arts leader who relocated to regional New South Wales,
Australia, from Sydney in 2001. Apart from two years in Melbourne,
Australias second largest city, Graham’s formative educational and perfor-
mance practice took place in Sydney, where he was mainly orientated to
the classical instrumental and vocal scene. With his move to the country
came a reassessment of performance, community attitudes to the con-
sumption of and participation in music, the place, value and valuing of a
local music scene, and the permeable boundary between professional and
amateur music-making. Graham holds a PhD, Master of Performance
(Conducting) and Diploma of Operatic Art and Music Theatre, all from
the University of Sydney, Sydney Conservatorium of Music. He is a mem-
ber of the Regional Music Education Research Group and was appointed
CEO of the Christchurch Symphony Orchestra, Aotearoa New Zealand,
at the end of 2021.
Sofia Sousa is a sociologist (MSc) from the Faculty of Arts and Humanities
of the University of Porto (FLUP). She worked as a research fellow under
the project CANVAS – Towards Safer and Attractive Cities: Crime and
Violence Prevention through Smart Planning and Artistic Resistance
xvi NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS
xix
List of Tables
xxi
Introduction: Popular Music Scenes in a
Regional and Rural Context
The concept of the music scene has been in use for many years as a means
of describing’ situations where performers, support facilities, and fans
come together to collectively create music for their own enjoyment’
(Peterson and Bennett 2004: 3). Throughout much of the twentieth cen-
tury, music scene was primarily in use as a vernacular terminology among
musicians, audiences and others invested in live music, such as music pro-
moters and music journalists. Towards the end of the twentieth century
and into the early 2000s, the music scene began to gain traction as a theo-
retical concept, initially in the work of Straw (1991) and later in studies by,
for example, Shank (1994) and Bennett and Peterson (2004). As illus-
trated in much of the scenes literature being published at that time, the
concept of the music scene has characteristically urban roots, with many
cities capitalizing on their strong association with the evolution of a par-
ticular musical style or genre and the crystallization of a distinctive local
scene around this. Although some of the musical genres now strongly
associated with urban scenes, notably blues, have origins in regional and
rural locations (see Guralnick 1977), it was the transition of these genres
to urban spaces that gave them global prominence. In other cases, the
defining characteristics of particular music genres are depicted as distinc-
tively urban, their style and sound bound up with particular aspects of city
life. Examples here include heavy metal’s dark and over-driven sound
being associated with its origins in the British Midlands city of Birmingham
during the industrial era (Harrison 2010) and hip hop’s evolution as part
of a do-it-yourself (DIY) street culture against a background of poverty
xxiii
xxiv INTRODUCTION: POPULAR MUSIC SCENES IN A REGIONAL…
and exclusion. Existing research on hip hop and local identity has estab-
lished how hip hop’s global reach is matched by its capacity for localized
forms of appropriation whereby its signature textures of rhythm and sound
and spoken lyrics take on new local meanings as young rappers adapt the
hip hop style as a means of engaging with local issues and challenges. Blok
extends this discussion to consider how young migrant rappers in regional
Australia are contributing to patterns of cultural transformation in their
regions, drawing on their trans-local connections and cosmopolitan
influences.
In Chap. 3, Graham Sattler offers a rich autoethnographic account of
his own transition from an urban to a regional music scene in New South
Wales, Australia. Sattler notes that such a transition can often result in
significant upheaval for the individual music practitioner, as the availability
of hard and soft music scene infrastructures with which to engage are sig-
nificantly reduced in a regional setting. This, in turn, impacts opportuni-
ties for participation in a local live music scene and presents difficulties in
securing a livelihood if one is coming into a regional music scene setting
as a professional musician or with aspirations to become one. Likewise,
Sattler notes other presenting challenges in terms of access to music edu-
cation and training, which are often a feature of regional settings.
Part II: Technology and Distribution focuses on the technologies and
forms of distribution that pertain whereby regional and rural popular
music scenes exist, and in many cases coexist, in forms of trans-local con-
nection with other scenes. In Chap. 4, Paula Guerra, Tânia Moreira and
Sofia Sousa consider the rock scene in the peri-urban Tâmega region of
Portugal, which includes a number of municipalities that together com-
prise one of the most densely populated regions of the country, with a
relatively young population. Despite a lack of economic and cultural sup-
port, local young people have developed a rock scene (which can be seen
as a patchwork of nano-scenes) with a significant degree of informality
and DIY logic. The authors draw on substantial ethnographic research,
including interviews and online investigations, to consider how Facebook
and other social media platforms have contributed to Tâmega’s musical
(re)affirmation of recent years, including as avenues for distribution and
advertising, without replacing local power and familial relationships.
In Chap. 5, Devpriya Chakravarty explores the regionally located
Electronic Dance Music (EDM) festival scene in India. Multi-day festivals
such as Enchanted Valley Carnival and Sunburn claim regional spaces for
ephemeral gatherings of mostly urban youth around the performance and
INTRODUCTION: POPULAR MUSIC SCENES IN A REGIONAL… xxvii
find themselves drawn to the scene later in life. Local identity is important
to the scene, with many passionate tastemakers running local clubs and
festivals. In contrast, musicians are routinely drawn from further afield
than just within Kent itself. Woollett finds that it is the consumers rather
than the producers who maintain control over the scene. They speak of
seeking an alternative to the perceived artifice of the X-Factor musical
generations in a scene grounded in earlier music.
In Chap. 9, Nico Thom considers the jazz scene of Eisenach, a regional
town in the state of Thuringia in the former German Democratic Republic
(GDR). Despite its small size, Eisenach casts a long shadow within the
history of German jazz. During World War II, jazz enthusiasts ran illegal
jazz jams, and the first jazz club of the GDR opened here in 1959, fol-
lowed by the establishment of the International Jazz Archive of Eisenach
in 1999. Thoms ethnographic work focuses on stakeholders and their
cross-generational interaction within this glocalized scene.
In Chap. 10, Janne Poikolainen and Mikko Salasuo examine rural punk
scenes of Finland in the late 1970s and early 1980s. These punk scenes
seemed a world away from the better-known scenes of London and
New York, but they are of particular interest as rural versions of urban
scenes. Their development coincided with the modernization of Finland
in the 1970s. However, this modernization was largely an urban develop-
ment; regional towns and areas were still conservative, sparsely populated,
under-developed and spread over large areas. Poikolainen and Salasuo
consider the social and cultural meaning and the national characteristics of
the first wave of Finnish punk culture in rural municipalities and towns.
Punks DIY aesthetic permitted the development of small local scenes com-
prising those seeking to reach out to the cities. It disconnected with the
conservative past and embraced modernist contemporary youth culture.
In Chap. 11, Robin Kuchar, noting the absence of academic study of
rural German scenes, seeks to contextualize the influential rural record
label Glitterhouse Records and the associated Orange Blossom Special fes-
tival within the German independent music scene. The former was a sig-
nificant mail-order house and record label launched in 1984 in Beverungen
in east Westphalia. It promoted both American independent music and
local artists, and has continued to gain significance within the German
scene. The Orange Blossom Special festival has been held annually in the
garden of the label since 1997, gathering an annual crowd of 2000–2500
festivalgoers. Glitterhouse is a significant German rural-based label, that
INTRODUCTION: POPULAR MUSIC SCENES IN A REGIONAL… xxix
has sought to build a community around music, shared attitudes and has
been in existence over three decades.
Part IV: Industry and Policy examines themes of industry and policy in
relation to culture and music, as these impact on the nature and identity
of rural and regional popular music scenes. In Chap. 12, Leonieke
Bolderman explores participation in music-making workshops and how
such workshops form their own trans-local music scenes. Based on ethno-
graphic research across three contemporary music workshops conducted
in Europe in 2016, Bolderman argues that although the workshops them-
selves are temporary, the scenes they create form long-lasting connections
between participants. Music workshops are a niche tourism product, gen-
erating interest and income for geographical areas that may otherwise
have been overlooked by conventional tourism. Perhaps unintentionally,
the workshops offer a unique entry point into a music scene that could
otherwise be unavailable to participants. Bolderman posits that, through
their structure and location, these workshops demonstrate translocality.
In Chap. 13, Benjamin Düster further extrapolates on this idea of trans-
locality through focusing on self-organized and grassroots musicians
around Nagoya and Fukuoka, Japan. Drawing on fieldwork conducted in
2018 and 2019, Düster recognizes that expatriates play an important role
in these smaller music scenes. By drawing on a Western DIY ethos, he sug-
gests that expatriate scene participants allow for the creation of overseas
tour opportunities and song and album releases for Japanese musicians
that may not be considered in the larger milieu of Japanese record labels.
As in Bolderman’s chapter, the role of the tourist is highlighted as an aid
to promote the scene, creating recognition and connection among scene
participants. Düster states that engagement with expatriate communities
in the Japanese DIY scenes, such as those in Nagoya and Fukuoka, pro-
vides meaningful connections between Japan and international indepen-
dent music scenes.
In Chap. 14, Otto Stuparitz also builds on this idea of translocal music
scenes in regional and rural areas. Stuparitz analyses how small jazz festi-
vals held in Indonesia present a way for nationally recognized jazz artists
to play in remote locations while at the same time providing opportunities
for local jazz musicians and organizers to interact with their metropolitan
counterparts. By tracing the establishment of Yogyakarta’s jazz commu-
nity, Stuparitz provides us with a further example of how a place can influ-
ence and serve as a guidepost for smaller and lesser-known music
communities. Similar to the communities discussed in Bolderman and
xxx INTRODUCTION: POPULAR MUSIC SCENES IN A REGIONAL…
References
Bennett, A., and R. A. Peterson, eds. 2004. Music scenes: Local, translocal, and
virtual. Nashville: Vanderbilt University Press.
Bennett, A., B. Green, D. Cashman, and N. Lewandowski. 2020. Researching
regional and rural music scenes: Towards a critical understanding of an under-
theorized topic. Popular Music & Society 44 (4): 367–377.
Frith, S. 1988. Music for pleasure: Essays in the sociology of pop. Oxford: Polity Press.
Green, B., and A. Bennett. 2019. Gateways and corridors: Spatial challenges and
opportunities for live music on the Gold Coast. City, Culture and Society
17: 20–25.
Guralnick, P. 1977. Feel like going home: Portraits in blues and rocknroll. London:
Omnibus Press.
INTRODUCTION: POPULAR MUSIC SCENES IN A REGIONAL… xxxi
Harrison, L.M. 2010. Factory music: How the industrial geography and working-
class environment of post-War Birmingham fostered the birth of heavy metal.
Journal of Social History 44 (1): 145–58.
Peterson, R.A., and A. Bennett. 2004. Introducing music scenes. In Music scenes:
Local, translocal, and virtual, ed. A. Bennett and R.A. Peterson, 1–16.
Nashville: Vanderbilt University Press.
Prior, N. 2015. Its a social thing, not a nature thing: Popular music practices in
Reykjavík, Iceland. Cultural Sociology 9 (1): 81–98.
Rose, T. 1994. Black noise: Rap music and black culture in contemporary America.
London: Wesleyan University Press.
Shank, B. 1994. Dissonant identities: The rocknroll scene in Austin, Texas. London:
Wesleyan University Press.
Straw, W. 1991. Systems of articulation, logics of change: Communities and scenes
in popular music. Cultural Studies 53: 368–88.
Waitt, G., and C.R. Gibson. 2013. The spiral gallery: Non-market creativity and
belonging in an Australian country town. Journal of Rural Studies 30: 75–85.
PART I
Philip Miles
P. Miles (*)
University of Bedfordshire, Luton, UK
e-mail: [email protected]
In the 1990s, a chance discovery by the late music industry manager Philip
Hall launched the career of Blackwood band Manic Street Preachers
(MSP)2 and consequently initiated an intensification of interest in rock
and eclectic material broadly labelled ‘Welsh pop’ (Owens 2000). A ‘scene’
transmogrified into a ‘national’ popular musical identity, despite having an
otherwise localized venue-driven focus, with Clwb Ifor Bach (Little Ivor’s
Club) in Cardiff and TJ’s in Newport being examples of urban live music
hubs that amalgamated the identity of bands. In areas in Wales that did
not have a notable vibrant, exclusive club dedicated to live rock music, a
local recognized (English language) scene did not develop sufficiently,
instead seeing bands drawn to urban hubs for recognition and exposure,
adding to the already colourful canvas onto which the ‘Welsh scene’ was
transposed, merging influences together in a variety of styles, genres and
languages (Hill 2007).
Embodying the eclectic, esoteric and psychedelic, Gorky’s Zygotic
Mynci (GZM) added Pembrokeshire to the litany of geographical origins
of those bands comprising the wider scene. In the 1990s, the band had
ostensibly emerged from a Welsh-language popular music scene (backed
by north Welsh record label Ankst) that had little cultural connectivity
with its native south Pembrokeshire, perhaps characterizing the county as
a place where music originates but does not remain, or produces
musicians (such as Jeremy Hogg of Automatic Dlamini, Grape and
1 MUSIC AT THE END OF THE LAND: REFLECTIONS… 5
John Lawrence (JL): We would go down and write tunes on the beach
with an acoustic guitar; something about being out
in the landscape … using that to nurture the song
writing process … down on the beach, recording
songs with a portable tape recorder and stuff, sea in
the background.
….
[Someone] organized a coach to go a Welsh
Language Society gig … so suddenly, … as we were
forming the band, we were amongst the Welsh music
scene bands like … Melys, Ffa Coffi Pawb, and that
was very exciting at the time, like real bands on stage.
While GZM was beginning its transition away from Pembrokeshire and
towards artistic and commercial recognition, some musicians were already
both in situ and happy to remain there. Discussing the origins and devel-
opment of a Pembrokeshire scene, or even a ‘Pembrokeshire sound’, The
Miracle Inn venue features heavily in recollections of participants. Richard
Lloyd, songwriter and guitarist with established local band Angelfish and
active in the creative musical community of the county for nearly five
decades, mentioned the Miracle Inn immediately. Dragging back his long
black hair and smiling, Lloyd summarized its importance as an otherwise
unremarkable ‘shack down in Freshwater East … we used to go down
there in the summer of ‘76 … a magical place in your memory you know?’
The Miracle, since immortalized in the title of Euros Child’s first solo
album post-GZM and recalled in Lloyd’s own song ‘What We Need is a
Miracle’, figures as a legendary place of communion among the older gen-
eration, encompassing detectable nostalgia and recognition of the shift
away from the ramshackle, make-do, happily rustic and unconventional
towards the myopic orthodoxy of the modern entertainments industry.
The Miracle – a ‘sort of nightclub’, as Richard Lloyd explains – existed as
an antidote to the lack of mainstream bands visiting the region and inter-
minable waits for the latest records and films to arrive in the locale in the
1970s and 1980s, functioning as a little escape pod from local
1 MUSIC AT THE END OF THE LAND: REFLECTIONS… 7
GZM played in the odd youth club – sans rock covers – accompanied in
performance by ‘the sound of ping pong tables and people playing pool’,
but the band’s interest lay predominantly in ‘the Welsh language pop scene’
rather than attempting to convert the locals to a form of pastoral psychede-
lia – later described by Mojo magazine as ‘crepuscular’ (Irvin 2000: 726) –
that arguably mixed the sophisticated jazz styles of Soft Machine and Gong
with the developmental innocence of a quirky DIY punk essence. This was
not de rigueur in Pembrokeshire; success lay elsewhere:
JL: I don’t think we wanted to dislocate, but I just think there wasn’t
anything in Pembrokeshire for us as a band … something to give the
band a bit of momentum … You wouldn’t have got us, at the time,
into some busy pub in Pembrokeshire that has bands on because no
one would get what we were doing.
8 P. MILES
If GZM’s manager’s remark that ‘very few people over 20 seem to go out’
in Wales was true, the die was cast somewhat conventionally in
Pembrokeshire (Thompson 1998: 50). A generational difference between
Richard’s material and the music being created by local singer-songwriter
Rob Parker’s contemporary alt-rock band Down With The Enemy
(DWTE) is possible, but it is also possible that a latent anxiety creates
conservatism, reproducing the scene in the image of the embedded con-
ventional audience taste.
Rob Parker (RP): Life is so much harder for your ‘originals’ bands … A
cover band … is going to pick up gigs easier than an …
originals band because venues want people to be enter-
tained … you can go along, get drunk and sing to
Oasis and Coldplay.
These days, venues are driven by the serving of food; in the past it was the
problems of licensing itself that limited performances to duos – usually
1 MUSIC AT THE END OF THE LAND: REFLECTIONS… 9
acoustic and adjustable to the venue – and created a strong foothold for a
continuing trend of light, occasionally folk entertainment that is sup-
ported by a vibrant Pembrokeshire folk network and associative online
community.4 It was harder for rock bands: the old Haggars Cinema on
Pembroke Main Street initially seemed to have the potential to challenge
the Narbeth Queens Hall or Tenby De Valence Pavilion, but the chance
was lost to more conventional nightclubbing (now Paddles), sending rock
back to the local pubs where it remains in places such as The George in
Pembroke, The Tiddley in Freystrop, The Lifeboat and The Lamb (both
Tenby) and the continually vibrant Eagle in Narbeth. This is pub rock by
necessity, the loudness and the audience shoehorned into bars away from
the more fertile commercial opportunities of folk, acoustic, duos, and
cover bands for hire. The ‘scene’ therefore has tended, over the years, to
concentrate on survival on its own terms. Nowadays, bands that wish to
play rock have split characteristics, forced out of Pembrokeshire for expo-
sure and experience like GZM before them, but also committed to their
own scene in parallel in a way that embodies a survival technique. With
rehearsal spaces temporal and scarce, the available venues limited and
recording facilities rarer still (Nick Swannell’s Studio 49 in Narbeth being
a notable success), a scene makes way for the necessity of exposure and
experience. Rob Parker of DWTE stated early in our first meeting that his
band had been forced to be creative with its self-identity, embellishing the
tag of its origins to be noticed:
The ‘Welsh scene’ has moved back from prominence to ordinariness and
periphery, and is engaged in a battle for survival as a distinct offering. The
10 P. MILES
RP: One of the main [problems encountered] with this area – and one of
the hardest things to keep a band together – is, once you get to an
age, you have a choice to make as a young man in Pembrokeshire,
and this is whether you stay local and try to make it in whatever you
want to do or you go to pastures new. We’ve … lost quite a few band
members to moving up to Bristol, Cardiff or further afield to go to
uni … We seem to have a never-ending conveyor belt of young talent
1 MUSIC AT THE END OF THE LAND: REFLECTIONS… 11
and when it gets to a point they move further afield and you are left
then with kind-of half a band.
RP: You start off … with an acoustic act, you build up then to some indie
and rock and then you end with quite heavy music … you would not
have a ‘headliner’ as the best, biggest band; usually one of the most
popular people there would be an acoustic artist opening or second
or third on.
RP: you can now access any music from anywhere in the world … we are
now not just influenced by the bands that we are watching … I think
that the music has evolved; we’ve almost lost a lot of our Celtic
roots … your musical gene pool is far greater and therefore the evo-
lution of your music knows no bounds.
Ian Davies (ID): Wales is the land of song … but I’m still waiting [for
suitable reactions] … it’s like the Pembrokeshire prom-
ise, isn’t it? There is fantastic talent here …
RP: … but no urgency.
ID: … they’re not coming forward …
PM: Is that insularity holding some people back?
ID: Yeah, they can’t see across the border.
established scene there so you’ve got to do what the hell you want or make
your own.’ This, however, does not make things easy:
JL: because you haven’t got that scene … it’s harder to make contacts …
it’s harder to find places to play, places to be heard, so yeah I think
initially, when you’re not established, it’s much harder – it’s like
you’re playing to no one … On the other hand, that’s a two-way
thing: if you’re in a city there’s a lot more people competing … you
have to be even better to stand out.
RP: Lots of bands, older people, still rockin’ – like the Penny Thousand
and Persona B – are more eccentric, more ‘Pembrokeshire’ … For
me, growing up with social media and the internet, … my influence
was changed and adapted by social media. For those older gentlemen
in bands, they have their influence ingrained in them … less influ-
enced by what they see from the outside.
Time passes, and music and geography remain constant while strategies
and methods of artistic creativity embrace the age of liquid modernity
(Bauman 2000). The rural ‘scene’ is gradually situated further away.
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
V.
(A második rovás.)