2 Lateef
2 Lateef
2 Lateef
1Faculty of Economics and Management Sciences, University Sultan Zainal Abidin (UniSZA)
2Faculty of Social Science and Humanity, Kwara State University Malete, Nigeria
3College of Business, University Utara Malaysia
*Corresponding Author:
Email: [email protected]
ABSTRACT
The objective of the study is to investigate the knowledge, skills, and ethics from the
perception of Professional Accountant on fraud prevention in the Nigerian public sector. The
primary data was collected from a Professional Accountant in the Office of Accountant
General and Auditor General for the Federation in Nigeria through a self-administered
questionnaire. Five hundred questionnaires were distributed, out of which 312 were retrieved
from respondents. This study employed the Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS) as
statistical analysis tools. Three hypotheses developed in the study were tested through the
correlation and regression analysis regarding their relationships. The results obtained from
the analysis provided support for the hypothesized relationships. Furthermore, it is apparent
that the significant positive influence of skills and ethics of a professional accountant
indicated that the variables are essential requirements in enhancing fraud prevention in the
Nigerian public sector. The study concluded that auditors in the public sector environment
should develop more interest in enhancing their capabilities in fraud prevention.
Introduction
The bane of public sector organization financial mismanagement in Nigeria since the oil
boom years has created a variety of loopholes and a near total absence of skills, ethics,
and accountability in the conduct of public affairs which tend to facilitate and sustain
corrupt practices in the country (Ademola, Ayoib & Popoola, 2017; Adewusi, 2016). To
the extent that fraud has had a severe negative impact on Nigeria economic activities and
national image. Transparency International’s (TI) Corrupt Perception Index (CPI) ranked
Nigeria as one of the most corrupt countries. Despite the efforts of the government to
get rid of fraudulent practices, the country was ranked 136th out of 176th corrupt nations
(Adewusi, 2016). It was also reported that Nigeria was ranked 143th out of 182 nations in
the world (Akosile, 2011). Corruption accounts for 20% of the GDP of Nigeria (Akosile,
2011).
10
© Department of Agribusiness Management
Lateef et al. /Applied Economics & Business, 2019 3(1) 10 - 21
In Nigeria, reported cases of fraud are many, which have resulted in the abject
poverty of the citizens (Mefor, 2013). For instance, the major source of Nigeria’s revenue,
which is Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC), was reported to over-
deduct wrongly to the tune of $79.3 million on subsidy claim on local petroleum
consumption (Oboh, 2012). Earlier in 2009, the case of the aviation fraud of $15.6 million
was reported. The incidence of fraud is not limited to the federal level alone; states are
also affected. An illustration is the case of Bayelsa State on a salary of workers where the
sum of $5.56 million was not accounted for in 2010 (Oboh, 2012).
Similarly, salary fraud of $5.29 million fraud was also reported in Kogi State
(Osawe, 2014). In addition, the capital market (Nigeria Stock Exchange) has not been
immune from fraud incident (Ojeme, 2010). According to Gbegi & Adebisi (2014),
EFCC report 2015 stated that from 2012-2014, Nigeria had lost $138 billion to various
financial fraud on the NSE. Accordingly, all these tend to reflect the unabated fraud in
the Nigerian public sector. The non-compliance with the government accounting policies
has been argued to be a reason for the failure to control fraudulent practices in the public
sector, making the accounting system in the public sector porous with the potentials for
corrupt and fraudulent practices (Popoola, 2014).
Because of the above issues, several scholars in Nigeria have mentions many
factors that contributed to the frequent occurrence of fraud and corruption in Nigeria.
It is believed that knowledge, skills, attitude, trait, ethics, and professionalism should curb
fraud and other irregularities in the Nigeria public sector. However, it has been
established by previous studies that auditors in Nigeria have failed to prevent fraud in the
public sector because they lack the required skills and knowledge to function effectively
(Ademola et al., 2017; Imam, Kumshe & Jarere, 2015; Popoola 2014). Similarly, low
ethics practice is one of the major issues that are affecting Nigerian public services most
especially the public sector accountants who are responsible for the receiving, custody
and disbursement of the public fund (Ademola et al., 2017; Omisore & Adeleke, 2015;
Inyang & Akaegbu, 2014; Casimir et al, 2014; Eketu & Nwuche, 2014; Osawe; 2014;
Adesopo, 2013; Fatile, 2013). For instance, the level of accountability and transparency
of public officers in the office of accountant general has been adjudged very poor and
insufficient of all the good attributes of quality and timely information about government
financial activities for the use by citizens to assess the performance of the government
(Chi-chi & Ebimobowei, 2012). This study desires to examine the capability requirement
(Knowledge, skill, and ethics) of Professional Accountant on fraud prevention in the
Nigerian public sector.
Literature Review
Public Sector
The public sector is an organization created, managed, and funded through taxpayers'
money by the government agent to get good leadership and expertise to enhance the
integrity, effectiveness, and efficiency (Okoduwa, 2007). It is a non-profit making
organization (government owned) that provides social amenities to the citizens (IPSASB,
2012; ICAN, 2009; Hassan, 2001). The public sector in Nigeria is administered by the
11
Lateef et al. /Applied Economics & Business, 2019 3(2) 10 - 21
Fraud Prevention
Fraud prevention involves identifying and reducing actual fraud. It encompasses policies,
procedures, training, and communication (Brooks et al., 2006). In addition, Fraud
prevention involves a vigorous and iterative process for identifying and assessing risks to
the achievement of organization objectives (COSO, 2011). As revealed from the previous
studies, billions of Naira are lost every year in the public sector through one fraudulent
means or the other in Nigeria. Appah and Appiah (2010) argue that cases of fraud are
prevalent in the Nigerian public sector that every segment of the public service, would
seem to be involved in one fraudulent act or the other. To prevent fraud, controls are
needed to be put in place as mentioned by Committee of Sponsoring Organization
(COSO, 2011) such controls include; control activities, control environment,
information, and communication; risk assessment and monitoring. Furthermore, Sengur
(2012) carried out a study on auditors’ perception of fraud prevention measures in
Turkey. The study categorized the fraud prevention measures into three, in compliance
with SAS 99: creating a culture of honesty and high ethics; evaluating anti-fraud processes
and controls, and developing an appropriate oversight process. These three fraud
prevention measures also sub-divided into fourteen (14) items. The study revealed that
the mechanism has effectiveness on fraud prevention.
12
Lateef et al. /Applied Economics & Business, 2019 3(1) 10 - 21
13
Lateef et al. /Applied Economics & Business, 2019 3(2) 10 - 21
Competency Theory
The competency theory is a predictor of human performance, which was developed by
McClelland (1973). It describes the specific knowledge, skills, and other characteristics
needed to effectively perform a task in an organization and is used as human resource
tools for appraisal, selection, training and development and succession planning (Lucia
& Lepsinger, 1999). The competency approach, as framed by McClelland (1973) suggests
that competencies are ideal for determining the potentials for the effective performance
of individuals, which ultimately affect organizational outcomes. In this study,
competencies are the capabilities (skills, knowledge, and ethics) of the Professional
Accountant in the Nigerian public sector required for the prevention of fraud. The
capabilities are key and crucial for the Professional Accountant in the performance of
their respective responsibilities, particularly the prevention of fraud.
Conceptual Framework
A conceptual framework, a set of ideas organized in a manner that is easy to communicate
to others (Rayan, et al. 2016; Yearwood, 2011). The purpose of the conceptual framework
formulated in this study is to define how a professional accountant in the Nigerian public
sector can prevent fraud given the capabilities of potential fraud perpetrators in the public
sector to commit fraud. The framework is as presented in Figure 1.
Knowledge Requirement
Hypotheses Development
The theoretical linkage in the research framework explains the factor of capability
element of a Professional Accountant on fraud prevention. Capability refers to the quality
possessed by individuals that give such individuals the opportunity to perform. This
attribute is recognized as knowledge, skills, values, ethics, and attitudes necessary for
14
Lateef et al. /Applied Economics & Business, 2019 3(1) 10 - 21
H1: There is a positive relationship between knowledge (KR) and fraud prevention (FP)
in the Nigerian public sector.
H2: There is a positive relationship between Skills (SR) and fraud prevention (FP) in the
Nigerian public sector.
H3: There is a positive relationship between Ethics (ER) and fraud prevention (FP) in the
Nigerian public sector.
Methodology
As this study targeted respondents that are Professional Accountant in the Nigerian
public sector, the respondents consist of forensic accountants, accountants, and auditors
in the office of the accountant general of the federation and auditor general for the
federation who are the main users of the professional accountant in the Nigerian public
sector. The study used the cross-sectional design and a survey method. The questionnaire
requests the respondents on their capabilities about fraud prevention. In total, 500
questionnaires distributed, 312 questionnaires were returned that represents a 63%
response rate. Out of 312, 14 questionnaires were declared unusable due to
incompleteness and ineligibility; and outliers of 31 (6.2%), while usable questionnaires
267 (54%) constitute the effective response rate. According to Linus (2001), the 50% is
considered as the acceptable response rate for any social science studies in Nigeria. This
indicates that the study met the response rate requirement of 63% and an effective
response rate of 54%. All the measurement instruments for the four constructs (KR, SR,
ER, and FP) in this study were adapted. The Dependent variable instruments of Fraud
Prevention (FP) were adopted from Sengur (2012) with 14 items based on five point
Likert scales. The independent variables measurement instruments of Knowledge (KR)
with 7 items were adapted from DiGabriele (2008) and Davis et al. (2010); Skills (SR)
with 9 items were adopted from Davis et al. (2010) and Ramaswamy (2005); and lastly,
Ethics (ER) with 28 items were adapted from Aidaros (2012). All instruments were
measured on a 5 points Likert scale ranging from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly
agree) on the average result to the ordinal values for all four variables.
15
Lateef et al. /Applied Economics & Business, 2019 3(2) 10 - 21
Reliability Test
It is expected that the reliable instrument reduce the measurement error largely. The most
common test of inter-item consistency reliability is Cronbach’s alpha coefficient. Hence,
the Cronbach’s alpha coefficient was used to measure the internal consistency of the
instrument in this study. Table 1 indicated the reliability result of the latent constructs.
After running the data, it was found that all the measures possess a high-reliability
standard ranging from 0.743 to 0.916. This is by the standard that an instrument with a
coefficient of 0.60 is regarded to have average reliability; whereas a coefficient of 0.70
and above shows that the instruments have a high level of reliability (Sekaran & Bougie,
2010).
16
Lateef et al. /Applied Economics & Business, 2019 3(1) 10 - 21
Table 3: Multiple regression result between skills, knowledge, ethics and fraud
prevention
Unstandardized Standardized
Coefficients Coefficients
Model B Std. Error Beta t Sig.
(Constant) .784 .174 4.513 .000
H1 Knowledge .069 .053 .085 1.302 .194
H2 Skills .480 .056 .494 8.606 .000
H3 Ethics .286 .065 .281 4.387 .000
R R2 Adj. R2 R Change
2 F-Change
.789 .622 .618 .622 144.504
Note: Two hypotheses (H2 & H3) are accepted based on their t-values (t-value ≥1.96). ** p-value @
5% significant level.
The significant F-test (144.504, p< 0.000) shows that there is a overall significant
prediction of independent variables to the dependent variable but did not explain the
relative contribution of each independent variable to the dependent variable. Among the
three predicting variables, skills are the variable that best predicts the criterion with the
following values (β =.480, t= 8.606, p<.000).
17
Lateef et al. /Applied Economics & Business, 2019 3(2) 10 - 21
The next vital predictor in order of importance is the ethics (β = .286, t= 4.387,
p< .000). However, Knowledge (β = -.069, t= 1.302, p< .194) is not significantly related
to fraud prevention. Two out of three independent variables affected the directional
hypothesis. Therefore, hypothesis H2 and H3 are supported, whereas H1 is rejected.
As indicated from the result of the analysis, the skills requirement variable is a
predictor for Fraud prevention with the following figures (β =0.291, t= 4.988, p<.000).
Hence, the Hypothesis H1 is supported. As such, the result indicates that the skills
requirement is significantly related to Fraud prevention in Nigerian public sector. This is
in line with the Competency Model, which explained the skills of professional accountant
towards the prevention of financial fraud and other irregularities. Scholars such as
Albrecht et al. (2009); and Ahmad (2008) agreed that prevention of fraud and other
irregularities depend on skills of the professional accountants such as forensic
accountant, auditors, financial accountant among others. In addition, the ethics
requirement variable found to predict fraud prevention with the following figures (β =
0.286, t= 4.387, p<.000). Hence, the Hypothesis H1 is supported. As such the result
indicates that the ethical code of conduct is constantly and most important for the
forensic accountant, auditor and the users of the accounting information within and
outside the organization (Mohammed, 2008). With the ethics of the accounting
profession, the practitioners are protected not to derail from the codes of conduct
emphasizing transparency, accountability, and professionalism. However, the
relationship between the knowledge requirement and fraud prevention indicate
insignificant. This revealed that knowledge requirement is not predictor to the effective
fraud prevention in the Nigerian public sector.
Conclusions
The findings of the research work have provided insights on the capability requirements
of a professional accountant on fraud prevention in the Nigerian public sector, which are
considered as a contribution to the body of knowledge in the area. The knowledge, skills,
and ethics of a professional accountant are in agreement with the competency theory
(McClelland, 1973; Cohen et al., 2010). In essence, the competency theory refers to the
expectation of a Professional Accountant about the degree to which they are capable of
controlling fraud be it external or internal. The theory refers to the combination of
knowledge, skills, abilities, and other characteristics needed by the Professional
Accountant to prevent fraud and other irregularities (Lucia & Lepsinger, 1999;
McClelland, 1973).
Empirically, this study has provided evidence to support the argument that skills
and ethics are significantly related to fraud prevention in the Nigerian public sector, most
especially the office of the AGF and AudGF. If Professional Accountant has the required
capabilities, fraud will not only be curbed but prevented in the Nigerian public sector.
Hence, it deserves more attention by the authorities concerned through constant
updating and raising the standard of those capability requirements to be attained by a
professional accountant.
18
Lateef et al. /Applied Economics & Business, 2019 3(1) 10 - 21
References
Ademola, L. S., Ayoib, B. C., & Popoola, O. J. (2017). The Forensic Accountants' Skills and
Ethics on Fraud Prevention in the Nigerian Public Sector. Academic Journal of Economic Studies
3(4), 77 – 85.
Adesopo, A. (2013). Consolidating Nigerian Democracy: Time to Enhance Ethics and
Accountability Systems of the State Bureaucratic Institution. International Journal of Humanities
and Social Science, 3(15) pp 191 – 203.
Adewusi, A. O. (2016). Motivation and Ethics: Essential Factors for Sustainable Public Service
Delivery in Nigeria. Journal Of Organizational Studies And Innovation, 3(1), 19-33.
Ahmad, S. N., (2008). Developing Expertise in Forensic Accounting, Forensic Accounting
Courses in Malaysia. ADB/OECD Anti-Corruption Initiative for Asia and the Pacific.
AICPA. (2002). Statement on Auditing Standards (SAS) No. 99: Consideration of Fraud in a
Financial Statement Audit (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, Durham).
Aidaros, A. H., Idris, K., & Shamsudin, F. (2011). The Accountant’s Ethical Code of Conduct
and Moral Reasoning From an Islamic Environment: Case in Yemen. Journal of Global
Management, 2(December), 98-123
Albrecht, W. S. Albrecht, C. O., Albrecht, C. C., & Zimbelman, M. F. (2009). Fraud Examination.
South Western.
Akosile, A. (2011). Nigeria drops 9 Steps in 2011 corruption index. This Day Live.
http://www.thisdaylive.com/articles/nigeria-drops-9-steps-in-2011-corruption
index/104108
Bammeke, S. A. (2008). Public Sector Accounting and Finance for Decision Making. SAB &
Associates Limited, Lagos.
Bay, D. (1997). Determinants of ethical behaviour: An experiment. Unpublished doctoral thesis,
Washington State University.
Brooks, L., & Labelle, R. (2006). CAP forum on forensic accounting in the post-Enron world
education for investigative and forensic accounting/formation ET Juri capability. Canadian
Accounting Perspectives, 5(2), 287-306.
Casimir, K. C., Izueke, E. M., & Nzekwe, I. F. (2014). Public Sector and Corruption in Nigeria:
An Ethical and Institutional Framework of Analysis. Open Journal of Philosophy, 4, 216-224.
Chi-Chi, O. A. & Ebimobowei, A. (2011). Fraudulent Activities and Forensic Accounting
Services of Banks in Port Harcourt, Nigeria, Asian Journal of Business Management 4(2): 124-
129.
19
Lateef et al. /Applied Economics & Business, 2019 3(2) 10 - 21
Chui, L. (2010). An experimental examinationof the effects of fraud specialist and audit mindsets
on fraud risk assessments and the development of fraud-related problem representations.
East Eisenhower Parkway, USA.
Cohen, J. (1988). Statistics Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences, (2nd ed). New Jersey: Lawrence
Erlbaum Associates.
Cohen, J. Ding, Y., Lesase, C. & Stolowy, H. (2010). Corporate Fraud and Managers' Behavior:
Evidence from the Press. Journal of Business Ethics.
COSO (2011). Internal Control Framework: Committee of Sponsoring Organizationsof the
Treadway Commission. New York, NY.
Davis, C., Farrell, N.,& Ogilby, S. (2010). Characteristics and skills of the Forensic Accountant.
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants FVS section.
DiGabriele, J. A. (2008). An Empirical Investigation of the Relevant Skills of Forensic
accountants. Journal of Education for Business. p. 331-338.
Durkin, R., & Ueltzen, M. (2009). The Evolution of the CFF Credential, The Practicing CPA,
July/August.
Eketu, C. A., & Nwuche, C. A. (2014). Unethical Behaviour in Personal Service Delivery in
Nigeria: A Case Of The Hospitality Industry.
Fatile, J. O. (2013). Ethics and Performance in the Nigerian Public Sector. International Journal
of Advanced Research in Management and Social Sciences, 2(10) pp 132 – 151.
Gbegi, D. O., & Adebisi, J. F. (2014). Forensic Accounting Skills and Techniques in Fraud
Investigation in the Nigerian Public Sector. Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences.
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2014.v5n3p243
Grippo, F.J. & Ibex, T. (2003). “Introduction to Forensic Accounting,” The National Public
Accountant, Vol. 4, 4-8.
Hair, J., Anderson, R., Tatham, R. & Black, W. (2010). Multivariate Data Analysis, Upper Saddle
River, NJ: Prentice-Hall International.
Hassan, M. M. (2001). Government Accounting, Lagos, Nigeria: Malthouse Press Limited. Nigeria.
IFAC. (2006). International Education Standard No. 8, Competence Requirements for Audit
Professionals. International Federation of Accountants. New York.
Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nigeria. (2009). Code of Conduct for members.
Immam, A., Kumshe, A. M., & Jajere, M. S. (2015).Applicability of forensic accounting services for
financial fraud detection and prevention in the public sector of Nigeria. University of Maiduguri, Borno
state Nigeria.
Inyang, B., & Akaegbu, A. (2014). Redefining the Role of the Human Resource Professional
(HRP) in the Nigerian Public Service for Enhanced Performance.International Journal of
Business Administration, 5(1) pp 90 – 98.
IPSASB. (2012). Handbook of International Public Sector Accounting Pronouncements.
International Public Sector Accounting Standards Board. International Federation of
Accountants, IFAC. New York, NY. Vol. 1.
Lucia, A. D., & Lepsinger, R. (1999). The art and science of competency models: Pinpointing
critical success factors in organizations. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass/Pfeiffer.
McClelland, D. (1973). Testing for competence rather than intelligence. American Psychologist,
28, 1-14. doi: 10.1037/h0034092.
Mefor, L. (2013). Ghost workers’ racketeers. Punch. http://www.punchng.com/ opinion/ghost-
workers-racketeers.
Mohammed, A. (2008). Accountants’ ethics in Yemen. Unpublished Master dissertation, Universiti
Utara Malaysia, Malaysia.
20
Lateef et al. /Applied Economics & Business, 2019 3(1) 10 - 21
Nik Muhammad, N.M., Jantan, M., & Md Taib, F. (2010). Moderating effect of information
processing capacity to investment decision making and environmental scanning.Business
Management Quarterly Review, 1(1), 9- 22.
Oboh, A. (2012). “Probe of the Oil Sector”. Daily Independent Vol.11 No 22230.
Ojeme, S. (2010). Forensic Accounting “LL Reduce Fraud in Financial Industry. Retrieved on 5/9/2010
from http://www.gaflbcstocwrLcom.
Okoduwa, R. (2007). Combating corruption in the public sector and the role of the ICPC.
http://www.cenbank.org/out/publications/transparency/ 2007/transparency.
Omisore, B. O. & Adeleke, A. O. (2015). Work Ethics, Values, Attitudes and Performance in the
Nigerian Public Service: Issues, Challenges and the Way Forward. Journal of Public
Administrationand Governance,5(1) PP 157 – 172.
Osawe, C. O. (2014). Reengineering Professionalism in the Nigerian Public Service Towards
Service Delivery. Review of Public Administration and Management 3(6), pg 63 – 75.
Pallant, J. (2007). SPSS Survival Manual: A step – by step guide to data analysis using SPSS for Windows
(version 15). Australia: Allan and Urwin.
Payne, D., & Landry, B. (2005). Similarities in business and IT professional ethics: The need for
and development of a comprehensive code of ethics. Journal of Business Ethics, 62(1), 73-85.
Popoola, O. M. J. (2014). Forensic accountants, Auditorsand Fraud: Capability and Competence
Requirements in the Nigerian Public Sector. Doctor of Philosophy, Universiti Utara
Malaysia September 2014.
PWC, (2011). Fighting Fraud in the Public Sector. Retrieved from whatwouldyoulike
togrow.com.au. 22/09/2012. Quality in the post-SOX UK regulatory environment.
Accounting and Business.
Ramaswamy, V. (2005). Corporate Governance and the Forensic Accountant. The CPA Journal,
(75), 69-70.
Rayan, B., Samsudin, S. R., Che-ahmad, A. B., & Popoola, O. M. J. (2016). Capability Component
of Fraud and Fraud prevention in the Saudi Arabian Banking Sector. International Journal of
Economics and Financial Issues, 6 (7), 68 – 71.
Sekaran, U. and Bougie, R. (2010). Research methods for business. A skill building approach(5th ed.).
UK: John Willey.
Sengur, E. D. (2012). Auditors' perception of Fraud prevention Measures: Evidence from Turkey.
Annales Universitatis Apulensis: Series Oeconomica, 14(1), 128.
Wolfe, D., & Hermanson, D. R. (2004). The fraud diamond: Considering four elements of fraud.
The CPA Journal, 74 (12), 38-42.
Yearwood, L. (2011), A Conceptual Framework for the Prevention and Detection of
Occupational Fraud in Small Businesses. Research Paper Concordia University College of
Alberta.
21