Leadership Vs Management
Leadership Vs Management
Leadership Vs Management
DIFFERENCE?
“Leadership, he wrote, is the creation of positive, non-incremental change, including the
creation of a vision to guide that change—a strategy—the empowerment of people to
make the vision happen despite obstacles, and the creation of a coalition of energy and
momentum that can move that change forward,” Koehn said.
Fuller, who teaches the online course Management Essentials, relayed his thoughts on
how management compares.
Watch the full keynote discuss While these definitions draw parallels between the roles of
leaders and managers, they also allude to some key contrasts. Here are three differences
between leadership and management. on between Nancy Koehn and Joe Fuller below:
“I think of management as working with other people to make sure the goals an
organization has articulated are executed,” says HBS Dean Nitin Nohria in an interview for
the online course Management Essentials. “It’s the process of working with others to
ensure the effective execution of a chosen set of goals. Leadership is about developing
what the goals should be. It’s more about driving change.”
In the book, On Becoming a Leader, scholar Warren Bennis presents a list of key
differences between managers and leaders, including:
and more on Leaders, on the other hand, are less focused on how to organize people to
get work done finding ways to align and influence them.
“Your central function in a position of leadership is to mobilize others so they can execute a
set of individual and collective tasks,” says HBS Professor Anthony Mayo in the online
course Leadership Principles.
eaders can learn how to empower their employees and inspire them to both believe in and
pursue imBy developing a personal leadership style through self-reflection and honest
feedback, lportant organizational initiatives.
The title “manager” often denotes a specific role within an organization’s hierarchy, while
referring to someone as a “leader” has a more fluid meaning.
“Manager is a title. It’s a role and set of responsibilities,” says leadership coach Doc Norton
in Forbes. “Having the position of manager does not make you a leader. The best
managers are leaders, but the two are not synonymous. Leadership is the result of action.
If you act in a way that inspires, encourages, or engages others, you are a leader. It
doesn't matter your title or position.”
For seasoned and aspiring managers alike, possessing strong leadership skills can not
only lead to better job performance, but an improved knowledge of how to influence the
context and environment in which decisions get made.
Also called the “authoritarian style of leadership,” this type of leader is someone who's focused
primarily on results and team efficiency. Autocratic leaders often make decisions alone or with a
small and trusted group and expect employees to do exactly what they’re asked.Autocratic leaders
typically have self-confidence and are self-motivated. They communicate clearly and consistently,
are dependable and follow the rules. They value highly structured environments and are
proponents of supervised work environments.The benefits and challenges of an autocratic
leadership style include:
Benefits: Autocratic leaders can promote
Challenges: Autocratic leaders are often prone
productivity through delegation, provide clear
to high levels of stress because they feel
and direct communication and reduce
responsible for everything, plus their lack of
employee stress by making decisions quickly
flexibility can lead to team resentment.
on their own.
Read more: What Is Autocratic Leadership?
Bureaucratic leaders are similar to autocratic leaders in that these leaders expect their team
members to follow the rules and procedures precisely as written. The bureaucratic style focuses
on fixed duties within a hierarchical system, where each employee has a set list of responsibilities,
and there's little need for collaboration and creativity.This leadership style is most effective in
highly regulated industries or in departments like finance, health care or government. This style
may fit your leadership approach if you're detail-oriented and task-focused, value rules and
structure, are strong-willed and self-disciplined and have a great work ethic.The benefits and
challenges of a bureaucratic leadership style include:
Benefits: This style can be efficient in Challenges: This style doesn't promote
organizations that need to follow strict rules creativity, which can feel restricting to some
and regulations. These leaders separate employees. This leadership style is also slow to
work from relationships to avoid clouding the change and does not thrive in an environment
team's ability to hit goals. that needs to be dynamic.
Related: 23 Leadership Characteristics To Be a Good Leader
A coaching leader is someone who can quickly recognize their team members’ strengths,
weaknesses and motivations to help each individual improve. This type of leader often assists
team members in setting smart goals and then provides regular feedback with challenging projects
to promote growth. They set clear expectations and creating a positive, motivating
environment.The coach leadership style is one of the most advantageous for employers as well as
the employees they manage. Unfortunately, it’s often also one of the most underused styles—
largely because it can be more time-intensive than other types of leadership. Coaching leaders
are supportive and value learning as a way of growing. They're self-aware, offer guidance instead
of giving commands and ask guided questions.The benefits and challenges of a coaching
leadership style include:
Benefits: Coaching leadership is positive in Challenges: While this style has many
nature and promotes the development of new advantages, it can be more time-consuming
skills, empowers team members and fosters a as it requires one-on-one time with
confident company culture. They're often seen employees which can be difficult to obtain in a
as valuable mentors. deadline-driven environment.
Read more: What Is Coaching Leadership? (And When To Use It)
The democratic style (aka the "participative style") is a combination of the autocratic and laissez-
faire types of leaders. A democratic leader asks their team members for input and considers
feedback from the team before they make a decision. Because team members feel their
contributions matter, a democratic leadership style is often credited with fostering higher levels of
employee engagement and workplace satisfaction.Democratic leaders value group discussions
and provide all information to the team when making decisions. They promote a work
environment where everyone shares their ideas and are characteristically rational and flexible.The
benefits and challenges of a democratic leadership style include:
Benefits: Working under the democratic
Challenges: This leadership style has the
leadership style, employees can feel
potential to be inefficient and costly as it takes
empowered, valued and unified. It has the
time to organize group discussions, obtain
power to boost retention and morale. It also
ideas/feedback, discuss possible outcomes
requires less managerial oversight, as
and communicate decisions. It also can add
employees are typically part of decision-
social pressure to members of the team who
making processes and know what they need to
don’t like sharing ideas in group settings.
do.
Read more: What Is Participative Leadership?
The laissez-faire style is the opposite of the autocratic leadership type, focusing mostly on
delegating many tasks to team members and providing little to no supervision. Because a laissez-
faire leader doesn't spend their time intensely managing employees, they often have more time for
other projects.Managers may adopt the laissez-faire style when all team members are highly
experienced, well-trained and require little oversight. However, it can cause a dip in productivity if
employees are confused about their leader’s expectations, or if some team members need
consistent motivation and boundaries to work well.
Benefits: The laissez-faire leadership style Challenges: This style typically doesn't work well
encourages accountability, creativity and a for new employees, as they need guidance and
relaxed work environment, which often hands-on support in the beginning. Other
leads to higher employee retention rates. employees may not feel properly supported.
6. Pacesetter leadership style
The pacesetting style is one of the most effective for achieving fast results. Pacesetter leaders
primarily focus on performance, often set high standards and hold their team members
accountable for achieving their goals.While the pacesetting leadership style can be motivational in
fast-paced environments where team members need to be energized, it’s not always the best
option for team members who need mentorship and feedback.The benefits and challenges of a
pacesetter leadership style include:
Benefits: Pacesetting leadership pushes Challenges: Pacesetting leadership can also
employees to hit goals and accomplish lead to miscommunications and stressed-out
business objectives. It promotes high-energy employees as they are always pushing toward a
and dynamic work environments. goal or deadline.
Related: How To Demonstrate Leadership Skills at Work
Servant leaders live by a people-first mindset and believe that when team members feel
personally and professionally fulfilled, they’re more effective and more likely to regularly produce
great work. Because of their emphasis on employee satisfaction and collaboration, they tend to
achieve higher levels of respect.Servant leaders motivate their teams and have
excellent communication skills. You may find this leadership style a match for your own style if you
tend to encourage collaboration and engagement among team members and if you commit to
growing your team professionally.The benefits and challenges of a servant leadership style
include:
Benefits: Servant leaders have the capacity
Challenges: Servant leaders can become burnt
to boost employee loyalty and productivity,
out as they often put the needs of their team
improve employee development and decision-
above their own They may have a hard time
making, cultivate trust and create future
being authoritative when they need to be.
leaders.
Read more: Servant Leadership: Definition, Tips and Examples
Visionary leaders possess a powerful ability to drive progress and usher in periods of change by
inspiring employees and earning trust for new ideas. A visionary leader is also able to establish a
strong organizational bond. They strive to foster confidence among direct reports and colleagues
alike.Visionary style is especially helpful for small, fast-growing organizations, or larger
organizations experiencing transformations or restructuring. Visionary leaders tend to be
persistent and bold, strategic and open to taking risks. They're often described as inspirational,
optimistic, innovative and magnetic.The benefits and challenges of a visionary leadership style
include:
Benefits: Visionary leadership can help Challenges: Visionary leaders may miss
companies grow, unite teams and the important details or other opportunities, like
overall company and improve outdated recognizing their teams, because they’re so
technologies or practices. focused on the big picture.
1. Experiment. Try out varied approaches in different circumstances and pay attention to
the outcome.
2. Seek a mentor. Consulting a leader with more experience than yourself can offer great
insight into how they developed their style and what worked for them.
3. Ask for feedback. Constructive feedback helps you grow into a successful leader. Seek
feedback from individuals you trust that will give you an honest answer.
4. Be authentic. Trying to perfect a leadership style that's in opposition to your personality
or morals will come across as inauthentic. Try to choose a leadership style that’s in
alignment with your strengths and work to improve it.
While a certain leadership style may be impactful in a specific job—for example, autocratic leaders
tend to do well in military settings—the best leadership is using a blend of styles. Knowing what
style to enforce in workplace situations comes with time, practice and through emotional
intelligence.While you may have excelled in a past role using one style of leadership, another
position may require a different set of habits to ensure your team is operating most effectively. By
understanding the different leadership types, and the outcomes they’re designed to achieve, you
can select the right leadership style for your current situation.
Simply put, effective leadership isn’t one size fits all—people within
an organization differ from one another. While some might need more
support and direction, others may need the exact opposite. At various
stages in a person’s career, or even in smaller situations, different
types of leadership are needed.
Summary
Servant leadership is a leadership model developed by Robert K. Greenleaf. Servant leaders
display characteristics such as strong listening skills, empathy, self-awareness, and the desire
to create a healthy work environment. Read our tips on becoming a servant-first leader and
find out what the pros and cons of this leadership style are.
Finding the right leadership style is no easy feat. It has to feel natural to you, be accepted
within your organization, and effective with your team members. To discover the best way to
lead your team, try learning the ins and outs of different leadership styles to become the best
leader for your team.
Kurt Lewin (authoritarian, democratic, and laissez-faire), Daniel Goleman (emotional
leadership theory), and Bernard M. Bass (transformational leadership) are all well-known
leadership researchers. Perhaps a lesser known but nonetheless interesting approach to
leadership was developed by Robert K. Greenleaf in the 1970s: servant leadership.
What is servant
leadership?
Servant leadership is a leadership approach that puts serving others above all other priorities.
Rather than managing for results, a servant leader focuses on creating an environment in
which their team can thrive and get their highest-impact work done.
The biggest difference between traditional and servant leaders is where their motivation
lies. While traditional leaders care mostly about their own advancement, servant leaders want
to see their whole team grow and succeed.
A traditional leader will measure success through results and prioritize shareholders over their
customers and teammates. A servant leader puts their team first, customers second, and
shareholders last. While this may not be the fastest way to success, it can be more
sustainable.
Finally, a traditional leader will use their authoritative rank to stand above others, which
reflects in their communication style as well. Servant leaders view leadership as an
opportunity to serve others, so they’ll focus on listening and understanding their teammates
versus speaking to and commanding things from them.
Regardless of what communication style you use, your team can benefit from clear
communication and dedicated 1:1 time. Make sure you’re giving team members a space to
build trust and be heard, no matter which leadership style you practice.
Origin of servant
leadership
The idea of servant leadership came to Robert K. Greenleaf, a retired AT&T executive, after
reading Hermann Hesse’s novel Journey to the East. The storyline is simple: A group of men
head out on a mythical journey accompanied by their servant Leo who sustains the group with
his song and spirit. After Leo disappears, the group falls apart and the journey is abandoned.
Years later, the narrator of the story finds out that Leo was in fact the head of the order that
had sponsored the journey. He wasn’t just a servant—he was the guiding spirit, their great
leader.
As romantic as this may sound, Greenleaf saw parallels to the corporate world.
In 1970, he used the inspiration of Hesse’s story to write an essay that coined a new style of
leadership: “The Servant as Leader.” Greenleaf believed: “The servant-leader is servant first
[...] Becoming a servant-leader begins with the natural feeling that one wants to serve, to
serve first. Then conscious choice brings one to aspire to lead.”
In 1964, he founded the Robert K. Greenleaf Center for Servant Leadership to advance
the awareness, understanding, and practice of this leadership style by organizations and
individuals.
Characteristics of servant
leadership
Former president and CEO of the Robert K. Greenleaf Center for Servant Leadership, Larry
C. Spears, defined the 10 characteristics of effective, caring leaders. They’re based on
Greenleaf’s essays and writings and can help you better understand how to be a servant-first
leader.
inline illustration] The first P: Product (infographic)According to Spears, you can learn
and develop these 10 characteristics with practice and patience. Here’s how to get started.
1. Listening
Servant leaders prioritize active listening. Communication and decision-making skills are
important aspects for all good leaders to practice, but a key characteristic of servant
leadership is to listen to their team and gain a deep understanding of what they’re saying.
Robert K. Greenleaf accredited a leader’s listening skills as crucial to an innovative work
environment.
Example: When a team member comes to you with a problem, listen to them and make them
feel heard. This way, they’ll always feel comfortable reaching out to you.
2. Empathy
Empathy is another skill Spears deemed important to become a servant leader. He writes:
“The servant-leader strives to understand and empathize with others. People need to be
accepted and recognized for their special and unique spirits.”
Example: Always assume that your team members are doing their work with the best
intentions. Keep an open mind to foster creativity and courage in the workplace.
3. Healing
Servant leaders recognize the negative experiences and habits their team members have
developed to cope with unpleasant situations.
Greenleaf talked about “understanding the search for wholeness” as something servant
leaders and led teams have in common. By prioritizing a healthy work environment and
guiding teammates through their healing process, you can create a culture that strives toward
this wholeness.
Example: Create an environment that serves your team by providing resources and support
such as weekly 1:1 meetings, a mentorship program, or access to mental health care.
4. Awareness
A servant leader’s awareness includes self-awareness and general awareness of their own
strengths and weaknesses, as well as those of their team. It allows servant leaders to
understand ethics and values from a more integrated and holistic perspective.
Example: To increase your self-awareness, implement an honest and frequent feedback
loop where your team can let you know what works for them and what doesn’t. Keep track of
your personal goals and plans. You can also take psychometric tests to gain new perspectives
on your personality and reflect on how others see you.
Read: How to lead by example, according to one Asana leader
5. Persuasion
Servant leaders persuade others instead of using their authority to make decisions.
Convincing their teammates of something rather than coercing compliance is one of the
clearest distinctions between the servant leadership style and the authoritarian approach.
Using persuasion also helps in building consensus and a level of trust within a team.
Example: Next time your team is making a decision, try using the word “we” instead of “you”
when presenting your strategy to make everyone feel more like it’s a team decision and not
just you calling the shots.
6. Conceptualization
Thinking beyond day-to-day realities requires discipline and practice. However, the ability to
look at a project, team, or organization from a conceptualization perspective allows servant
leaders to keep dreaming of great things.
Example: Share dreams and aspirations with your team. Short-term goals are important,
but with one eye on the horizon, you can continue to inspire your team members even on
difficult days.
7. Foresight
A servant leader is able to anticipate future events and the impact they’ll have on their team.
This characteristic isn’t as magical as it may sound but rather a skill that’s developed over
time through experience and intuition.
Example: Use tools like a SWOT analysis to help you better understand past events,
manage upcoming projects, and predict future outcomes.
8. Stewardship or accountability
Stewardship is “the careful and responsible management of something entrusted to one’s
care.” In his book on stewardship, Peter Block urges his readers to “act in service of the long
run” and in service “to those with little power.”
Inspired by Block’s words, Spears included stewardship as one of the 10 characteristics of
servant leadership. It helps servant leaders acknowledge the importance of their
responsibilities.
As a servant leader, the stewardship characteristic can help you uphold the trust and
confidence given to you by your organization.
Example: If you make a mistake, share the story with your team. Prove that you’re holding
yourself accountable, and show your team the steps you took to resolve the issue.
1. Lead by example
A servant leader will always walk alongside their team members and lead by example.
Teams of servant leaders notice that their managers are willing to put the same time and
effort into projects as they do and appreciate it. This will encourage teams to work hard and
with integrity.
However, leading by example goes beyond working hard together. Servant leaders can also
encourage their team members to take time off and recharge by doing it themselves. Teams
are more likely to benefit from paid time off or mental health days when their leaders do the
same.
Example: As a servant leader you may offer to lend a hand with a task that’s not necessarily
part of your job description to support a teammate. This will allow your team members to
focus on more important initiatives without worrying that their work isn’t getting done.
3. Encourage teamwork
Servant leaders know that teams are stronger when they’re putting in a combined effort. They
will encourage collaboration by giving each team member space to grow, a place to shine,
and a group they can rely on. Creating this sense of community will benefit the individuals and
the organization.
Example: You can promote teamwork by frequently scheduling team building activities.
Whether that’s through a virtual call or an in-person event, spending fun time together will
strengthen your team’s relationships.
Pros
Fosters strong team culture: Servant leaders give ownership to their team members to
increase their motivation, courage, and creativity.
Creates people-focused culture: Servant leaders establish a people-focused culture by
fostering deep, trusting relationships with and between their teammates. This level of trust
and connection allows teams to make decisions in the best interest of the organization and
everyone involved.
Boosts team morale: A team that feels seen and valued by their leader tends to have
stronger integrity and show a higher level of pride in their work. Servant leaders can
boost team morale across teams and help develop future leaders by giving them
opportunities to shine.
Cons
Formal authority may be lost: Because servant leaders get down on such a personal level
with their teams, their formal authority is easily lost. This can become difficult when individuals
take advantage of their leader’s transparency. It can also cause confusion when other leaders
in the organization take a different approach.
Time intensive leadership style: Servant leadership requires a lot of time, energy, and
experience. Servant leaders have to know their team members on a professional and personal
level so they can support them to the fullest.
Team members may struggle with decision making: By giving their team members
opportunities to prove themselves, servant leaders also risk overestimating and
overburdening their teammates. Individuals that don’t have the courage or confidence
for data-driven decision making on their own yet may feel discouraged and lost in a work
environment that provides them with this much executive power.
Finally, keep in mind that the servant leadership style may not align with your corporate
performance management or incentive systems, which are often focused on short-term goals.
However, you can still implement the servant leadership approach by leading with
authenticity, providing direction for your teammates, giving them opportunities to grow and
develop their skills, and building a strong community within your team.
You likely already know about several people who have practiced
transformational leadership. For example, Henry Ford was a
transformational leader who not only made the automobile more
affordable through innovation but raised wages, cut down working
hours, and provided health benefits.
Ford was not alone in his transformational leadership style. Others such
as civil rights movement leader Martin Luther King Jr., advertising
legend David Ogilvy, and technology magnate Steve Jobs,
demonstrated the powerful effect transformational leadership has.
Over time, leaders who guide their followers this way have become
synonymous with innovation, progress, and modernity.
Transformational leadership is a leadership style that empowers people to accomplish positive change through big
vision, inspiration, and a call to action. Leaders enable change by emotionally connecting with their audience and
inspiring them to achieve something greater than themselves. By communicating a positive vision of the future, they
motivate and encourage their followers to keep pushing forward. The end result is collective action that leads to
innovation, massive transformation, and the betterment of society.
During the 1970s and 1980s, scholars began solidifying the transformational leadership theory. Sociologist James V.
Downton coined the term “transformational leadership” in Rebel Leadership: Commitment and Charisma in the
Revolutionary Process. Afterward, the idea attracted attention from James MacGregor Burns and Bernard M. Bass,
two additional key players in the development of this leadership style.
Burns analyzed political figures such as Franklin D. Roosevelt and John F. Kennedy to identify the characteristics,
traits, personalities, and goals of transformational leaders. One of his biggest contributions to the study was
qualifying transformational leaders as people who also transform their followers into leaders. However, Bass focused
more heavily on the impact transformational leaders have on their followers through The Four I’s listed below.
Idealized Influence: The leader serves as a role model for others to follow. They also demonstrate established
organizational values, setting an example so followers understand expectations. Leaders who have connected with
followers through respect and trust can create this influence easily.
Inspiring Leadership: A transformational leader can passionately communicate an exciting vision of the future,
inspiring people to action. The leader can also encourage followers to keep pursuing the overall objective no matter
what challenges or obstacles they may face.
Intellectual Stimulation: Transformational leaders always support followers’ learning, growth, and development.
They firmly believe that it is their duty to help others become the best version of themselves.
Individualized Consideration: When a transformational leader acts, they don’t just do it to large groups. Instead, they
work with individuals, showing concern for their progress as a person. These leaders act as a mentor or coach who is
genuinely interested in working with each person in the group.
Top Attributes of
Transformational Leaders
Over the last 50 years, leadership experts have identified several traits
that transformational leaders share. The following list is just some of
those leadership qualities, though leaders may exhibit other
valuable traits and leadership skills.
Clearly define a collective vision and shared mission.
Unite people through a common cause.
Emotionally connect with their followers.
Lead with influence rather than authority.
Ensure that team culture is ethical.
Serve as an example for those they guide.
Change their approach when circumstances necessitate it.
Establish organizational values.
Practice innovative leadership.
Motivate and inspire others to take action.
Eliminate self-interest and practice servant leadership.
Create positive outcomes.
Benefits of Practicing
Transformational Leadership
Transformational leadership isn’t just some buzzword employed by PR
departments. It has real, lasting effects. Many people can benefit from
this leadership style, including leaders themselves. The following are
just some of the benefits.
5 Ways to Be a Transformational
Leader
1. Create a Positive Vision and Mission
Whether it’s for a business or simply for your own life, creating a vision
and mission are two important aspects of the transformational
leadership style. Be precise in your vision statement and
communicate it with others. You can start with why, defining the
purpose behind your vision so others will know why their work
matters. As you center all your actions around your vision and
mission, people will see your sincerity.
4. Set an Example
Many people will only listen to a transformational leader if that leader
practices what they preach. Ensure that you are living the philosophy
you are sharing. Show people how to create the change you want
them to create. It’s far easier for people to act when they have a
blueprint they can follow. Otherwise, your message can come across as
empty words.
5. Think of Solutions
Anyone can talk for hours about problems, but transformational leaders
seek to solve them. It takes someone with a transformational mindset
to come up with creative and effective solutions that will get
results and change the world. People are naturally drawn to those who
present solutions because they offer a remedy to a perceived ill.
Best Examples of
Transformational Leaders
Martin Luther King Jr.
“Not everybody can be famous but everybody can be great, because
greatness is determined by service.”
Martin Luther King Jr. is one of the most influential leaders in American
history. As a leader during the civil rights movement, MLK fought for
the rights of people who had long been oppressed. His leadership
provided a positive vision of the future, encouraging people to fight
for a better tomorrow alongside him. King’s message was one of
love and fair treatment for all, believing everyone could make a
difference no matter their station in life.
Mother Teresa
“Small things done with great love will change the world.”
Mother Teresa devoted her life to caring for sick and impoverished
people who were often overlooked. She won the Nobel Peace Prize in
1979 thanks to her selfless work all over the world. Mother Teresa
believed that one could help the world by easing others’ suffering. She
was willing to give up personal comfort to show kindness and
compassion for unhoused people, addicts, the poverty-stricken, and
more. In this, she provided an example others could follow,
establishing a blueprint of how to help heal the world one person at a
time.
Richard Branson
“There is no greater thing you can do with your life and your work
than follow your passions—in a way that serves the world and you.”
Reed Hastings
“Be brutally honest about the short-term and optimistic and
confident about the long-term.”
Elon Musk
“When something is important enough, you do it even if the odds are
not in your favor.”
Anyone can incorporate this leadership style into the way they lead. All
you need is a big vision, effective communication skills, and a desire
to connect along with the strength to motivate and inspire
others, even during tough times.